Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
AL-14ASA,lLt
BY AL-
(d. 538H-/1144)
IV
Thesis presented
for
ST. AMMM
the
to the University
degree
of Doctor
of Sto Indrews
of n2llosoplW
JANUARTs1977-
-1-
DECLARATION
I hereby
research
work
declare
that
carried
out
and that
own composition,
presented
St.
for
any other
Andrews,
16th.,
December,
the
by me; that
it
is
following
has not
the
a -record
thesis
is
previously
degree.
A. H. B. Muhammad.
1976.
of
my
been
j
-
CERT
I CERTIPY-MT
completed nine term
of St., Salvatox
II
IFICAT
ION
has
the conditions
Court*
of St. Andrevaq
of Resolution
and that
College
No. 1
be in qualified
in application
J. Burton (Mr.
(supervisor)
for
ill
-
TAI.
W&CIV =-IlSTTTfWLlflj
in
tm.
. %.
&-
t
th
cl
kh
k
d
.
dh
1r.
1
m
* ta
4.r
eh
0
zu
40
L;
4. e
.h
,v
Z
2=
fgell
Hamza 9
ei
u
tatha + vav
latha
+ allt
+ ra
iv
-
ABBREVIATIONS
After
A. H.
Hijra.
Before
Hijra.
b.
Son of.
bint.
Daughter
Of.
Compare, confer.
d.
Died.
ed.
Edited.
fo.
Folio*
ff,
Folios.
H.
Hijra.
Ms
Manuscript.
MSS
Yanuscripts.
n. d.
No date.
no,
Note#
rM,
Numbers.
pe
Page.
pp.
Pages.
suggest.
Suggestion.
Vol.
Volume.
Vols.
Volumes.
of.
number.
Note:
t[II
T -
Represents
an insert
within
an insert.
-vACKNOWLMM.MENTS
of this
thanks for
thesis.
It
his scholastic
during
is my duty to offer
guidance and his
of this
the pre-
him my sincere
My
encouragement.
his valuable
suggestions
Dublin,
Ru3iis al-Yasq'ils
in
their
providing
and for
Museumt Londont
League,
and the
for
sending
the
subject,
National
this
of
staff
and for
a microfilm
me access
to
of
other
the
Text
materials
the
of
staff
the
staff
the
Library
the Library
Egyptian
Library,
National
me to use other
are
of
the
of
MSS which
of various
allowing
of
the
Arab
Cairo,
relevant
materials
to
available
libraries.
I also
University
operation,
the
me microfilms
Pinally,
the
giving
due to
are also
British
their
me with
library.
My thanks
in
wish
to thank
of St.
Andrews
and to the
Universiti
University
research.
for
of Malaysia)q
the
their
staff
of
assistance
the
Library
and
Kebangsa! an Malaysia
for
sponsoring
of
co (The
me to undertake
I was admitted as a
October 1973*
00
Abdul Bolin
STe ANEREWS
Deoembove1976*
000000****
bin Muhammad
CONTENTS
Pages
Declaration
Certification
Transliteration
ill
table
Abbreviations
1V
Acknowledgments
Contents
Abstract
to
one :. Introduction
1-
and orthography
2-
The NS used in
2-
The copyist
this
and date
4 - Critical
Chapter
edition
1-
3 - Purpose
of composition
5 -6
7 -8
apparatus
two : Author
His
1,
nameg kunyal
nisbahs
and
9-
titles
2-
His
Family
3-
His
education
11 -
13
and his
teachers
13 - 16
4-
His pupils
16 - 17
5-
His
literary
6-
His
7-
His
18 -
30
travels
30 -
34
death
34
output
Chapter
three
: Place
in
literature
1-
Compositions
2-
Authorshi
of
3-
Comparison
of Ru"s
with
works
other
of RuTs
the
present
Chapter
four
: Development
1-
Ikhtilaf
2-
Birth
in
of
of
The (scope
five
38
legal
42 - 43
thought
43 - 46
literature
47
48 - 53
science
of al53 - 57
of application
theory
of UZI
of
0
Ikhtil7af
literature
The classical
of
36 -
the work
Xhilfi
Chapter
36
39 - 42
general,
the
35 -
al-Masa'il
Ikhtil7af
of
work
of Ikhtil7f
a) The significance
b) Zamakhshalls
al-Masa'il
of)
jurisprudence
theory
The application
3-
Conclusion
to
the
of UZ-1
7-
jurisprudence
2-
classical
58 - 59
of
the
theory
59 - 68
68
69
70 - 85
Bibliography
PART TWO
Textq
appendix
and notes.
ABSTRACT
This thesis
an introduction
and the
work
death
is
in
title.
also
its
showing
author
A historical
and the
in
Finallyt
and its
and in
dealt
with
survey
of
the
of
chapter
of composition
copyist
the
of
explained.
and outlines
briefly
the author's
namep family,
and his
other
the
The date
works.
conclusion.
place
of
the
Ru'is al-Maia"il
I
of works of similar
of
the
present
similar
works
illustrating
the
work
, and
in
results
of
attitude
the
on Figh.
the
development
science
of al-Khil;
of
literature
Ikhtiiaf
fiZZat
have
been
four.
five
chapter
application
by a brief
of a review
other
work with
beginnings
discussed
the
with
significance
on matters
involves
the authorship
of
this
chapters,
apparatus
authorship
and consists
Confirmation
of
critical
deals with
part
ascertained.
literature,
comparison
five
information
his pupils
deals
three
Chapter
type
teachers,
his
educationg
the
The discussion
career.
The first
and purpose
and the
two concerns
Chapter
into
general
The date
discussed,
also
author's
divided
one provides,
orthography.
is
of his
is
which
Chapter
of two parts.
consists
in
the
deals
Ikhtil7af
with
the classical
literature
which
theory
is
of Usul
followed
0
The second
under 62 titles
from
ranging
food
part
family
Text.
This
407 ralings-
contains
different
law to the
ralings
subjects
on
and drink.
The separate
development
vided
the
presents
aiming
on Fioh
of the
notes
Sh-aft'Ite
to illustrate
doctrines.
the
in
order
An appendix
development
to show the
is
also
of Zamakhshari's
proideas
PART ONE
INTRODUCTION.
CHAPTER ONE
I-
The M
The present
-1, J. Arberry
other
edition
present
is 17 x 13-1 cm-
The following
the
middle
of this-folio
the
of
same page,
who studied
is
is
is
hand corner,
on the rest
no
consisting
the
first
first
the
page of
the Shah; da
is the title
in
written
twice
s; ra
left
of
la Tge writing,
the
the
and also
of
the
top
in
of
the
The first
same title.
Qur3an appear
are written
At the
the IM.
in
names of
and
the middle
several
of
persons
book.
The t!astey-w,and %,
estevnnumbers appear together
left
that
author
written
and on the
this
Ireland.
folio
same title
second verses
work,
on the right
again
stated
it
in Dublin,
the book
Library
on the unique
of 107 folios,
based
has briefly
the work
to be recorded.
The measurement
is
al-Masglilw
who described
copy appears
altogether
this
of "Rufus
edition
in
used
recto
from folios
2 to 75, but
The MS is well
except for
preserved,
is humidity
damage on folios
5b,
29a
and 106.
.1
1,
A. J.
Arberry,
P- 41-
A Handlist
of
the Arabic
IISS, Dublin
1955, vol- 3,
-2-
The transcription
that
is
of
in
years
nine
Rajab,
the
after
576 H.,
death
its
of
authoT.
2 -, The copyist
of the Dublin
The copyist
folio
and orthography
105a. as Shibli
b.
graphical
on the basis
of the present
had insufficient
Imowledge
in the opinion
both
No bio-
known figures.
language
the Arabic
he
that
and juris-
prudence.
He stated
this
work as Rajab,
he lived
during
this
His orthography
writing
is mostly
supplied
transcription
completing
576/December, 1160.
This indicates
simply
that
period.
is generally,
provided
with
points
and occasionally
but
seems that
with vocalisations.
He applied
the
usageg
form. -
the recognised
in three
Arabic
classical
follow
not consistently
different
it
49
ULZ
1.
2*
Ibid.
3.
Ibid.,
fo.,
llb.
15b.
-ski
he does
Thisphonomenon can be
lal-Sh3fi5i'
2
Ill
ILOW-11
forms I 41
and
,
written
of
jW
I
and
which was
4-
Ibid.,
fo. 16a.
5.
Ibid.,
fo.
l9a.
6.
Ibid.
fo-
14a.
-3There
forms
hamza is
Generally
where hamza is
many words
in various
appears
fox
are
depending
omitted
long
alif
comes in
when it
Similarly
4
for
is
for
and
other
words
wrong
place
such as
I Ot
Lr'
JI,
10
he puts
word
For
them in
some
the
for
for
1.
and
of the
but
as required,
k41 I
for
beginning
6
I for
J,
occurs.
L.S" 12 for
the
in
it
suchas-I
like
middle
or when it
such as
the
The writing
in which
on the place
final
after
involved.
and
'9 for
Occasionally
Ld
Y91 replaces
P-: Ill
the hamza as in I
\-: ,
such as in
or conversely
15
while
in
other
1.
Cf.
2.
alif
for
13
for
instead
for
>-ik,.
He also
of
alif
cases
Lvt14
as t.
ha instead
16
instead
alif
other
of hamza alone
and
1! ', pS
'.
112 for
In
he used tg3maft;
as
S 110 for
L-J
I
such as
and I Cjj
together
and occasionally
Lmartu-ta such as
the
of
t9
for
maqsura
used abbreviations-for
ms, fo.
12b.
10.
Ibid.,
fo.
23b.
Ibid.,
fo.
83a.
11.
Ibid.,
fo.
12a.
3.
Ibid.,
fo.
Ilb.
12.
Ibid.,
fo.
2a.
4-
Ibid.,
fo.
12a.
13-
Ibid.,
fo.
8a.
5-
Ibid.
14-
Ibid.,
fo.
llb.
6.
Ibid.,
fo.
4a.
15-
Ibid.,
fo.
17a.
7.
Ibid.,
fo.
2a.
16.
Ibid.,
fo.
85b.
S.
Ibid.,
fo.
3a
17.
Ibid.,
fo.
102a.
g.
Ibid.,
fo-
48-
such
some
-411 for
words such as
On the
critical
in
points
3
II
hand,
other
some letters
for
which
Misairangement
occurs
on several
headings7 or rulings8.
10
repeated some others
*
in
gives
these
us the
idea
that
this
copying
for
transcript-
he misplaced.
occasions;
been made in
the
, L)Lz
or
as
have also
corrections
dia-
with
II
either
Several
I.
provided
for
He does not
not
are
and
16 for
12 for
and 1
and 1
ion.
II
the
is
to
himself,
copyist
to the
copyist
It
Text.
original.
it
again
and made
corrections.
He has applied
vaxious
he simply
the
places
thing
incorrect
to
similarly
methods
correct
for
out
crosses
words.
If
in
the margin,
words
When a word
corrections.
one of them;
is
the mistake
sometimes
this
or
applies
he
crossed
out
without
crossing
any-
out.
He uses various
missed
out,
margin.
the
techniques
correct
Usually
in
words
to
are
cross
placed
If
out.
between
tis
some words
the
lines
are
or in
in place
sign
1.
2.
7.
Ibid.,
fo. 77a.
3.
Ibid.,
fo.
12a.
8.
Ibid.,
fo. 65b.
4-
Ibid.,
fo.
88b.
9., Ibid.,
fo- 4b.
5.
Ibid.,
fo.
6b.
10. Ibid.,
fO. Ba.
Ibid.
the
of
-5the missing
but
words,
''(i.
not
in
word
Ie
ally
he uses'this
sign
On the other
hand, there
e.
the line
cases,
at the
correct)
no obvious connection
all
he writes
and sometimes
the
end of
with
.0
,2
1,
such as
Occasion-
correction.
the
for
a full
stop.
the passage.
)O'
and 1
appear between
They normally
like
in
the
or
margin
,
, -**
Grammatical
and unusual
peculiarities
in
occur
expressions
were almost
often,
very
who had
due to
certainly
the
copyist.
The contents
of the HS appear
to
end on 105a-
105b consisting
is an addition
of two sections
'while
belong
b
to
to
the
Kit;
al-Da6w,
of which appears
seems to belong to the Kit; b al-Hiba
These have simply
been reproduced
this
Following
the first
the second
according
to their
in
position
work.
in the HS.
idea
about
that
it
the
purpose
either
the contents
of
this
composition.
in the present'work
us encourages
to declare
late
in.
his
Hanafite
rite
of'the
0
spending most of his life without showing his attachment
1.
Cf. ms fo.
22b.
2a
Ibid.,
fo. 55a.
3-
Ibid.,
fo.
l9a.
or others.
to people
period,
to any one
-6-
It
of legal
school
particular
thought.
be presumed
may also
that
the
is
composition
intended
as a
dedication
highly
in this
argument presented
the
on defending
produces
further
madhhab which
argumentation
on the
scholars
because
transcription
the
Even so,
sumed that
the
author
based
ideas
present
of the
author.
his
a particular
other
present
contained
he
cases
giving
is
in both
whereas
ideas
528 H. in which
This
show that
in
is
suegestion
lil.
al-Kashsh3f
the
thirty-nine
to be pre-
the year
al-Kashshaf.
f do not
is
and it
original,
work
al-Kashsh;
madhhab,
in
without
equally
not an original
the
present
in most
subject.
idea-contained
completed
on the
The ideas
in
the
sides
of his
support
of
death
the
after
both
NS is obviously
The present
lyears
in
he has followed;
for
and evidence
cases
Hanafite
0
he was interested
lil
in
different.
the
Hanafite
are
completely
views
adopts
0
to be placed
is most likely
Thus the composition of ROUs al-MasPil
which he entirely
after
the year
528 H.
ZamakhsharilIs appreciation
can be found
in
his
of Sh7afi"i's
al-Kashshgf,
Cairo
in Arabic
ability
1946,
Vol.
lt
language
P- 376,
and
mentioned in his
of Ab Hanirfats knowledgels
0
Naw9bigh al-Kalim. in Amthal al-Sharq wa al-Gharb, 'Cairo 1960-61,
his appreciation,
pp. 198,223,
by Yi7suf al-Bustgniv
al-BustEni.
-7Critical
The critical
MS.
apparatus
is to preserve
edition
appearing
the
in
Modern Arabic
the
several
is
as this
a matter
letters
because
points
for
Ot'3
This
it
quotations
in the MS have
t and I
of orthography.
have no diacritical
words which
to mention
only
have been
which
except
LJtZ I to I
notes
of
the words
as not conforming
to
Dublin
reading
this,
B_A..
64.
P-31
i to ,
gjl III
1
instance,
the original
had to be altered
the
with
footnotes.
orthography
to deal
In order to achieve
Text
apparatus
the
critical
to
also
applies
be impractical
would
them all.
has been made to
An attempt
incorrectly
--peculiarities,
corrections
by the
and between
the
limit
copied,
copyist,
the
unusual
footnotes
to
unclear
spellings,
in
appearing
the grammatical
writing,
the margins
lines.
The vocalisations
interest.
special
References
for
the
and the
rulings
evidence
supporting
have been
by the editor,
ist's
inverted
Qurlgn
corrections,
and Hadith,
indicate
and stars
th3t
the
* indicate
angle brackets
direct
quotations.
indicate
commas ""
and other
square brackets
connection
end of -eac--foli0e'
/,
]indicate
> indicate
evidence
copyfrom
the
Round brackets
with
the
passage,
-8-
in
this
Punctuation
in the present
situation
suggestions
and paragraphing
edition.
-9-
CHAPTER TWO
AUTHOR
1-
(a)
Zamakhsharl"s
Qiftiv
it
that
, Ibn Khallikan
Ibn
said
with
that
it
Mahmud Ibn
Tmar
2
'Umar Ibn Muhammad
it
accounts
3
'Umar Ibn Muhammad Ibn Ahmad ;
and titles
it
that
SuyW,,
Yaqut
name.
nisbahs
,
name
who deal
Biographers
of his
name, kunya
Zamarkhsha: rlts
Tmar
and
Ibn Muhammad
5Umar4.
and Ibn
Suyuti
parental
to
much attention
in
appears there
this
problem,
probably
point,
and they
The others
to avoid
have simply
2.
Qiftir,
3-
Tgr"lkh al-Hukam33,
in that
themto mention
2, P- 940-
1903, p. 293-
Leipzig
wa al-Nuha-t,
1968-72,
5-
vol.
Wafay9t
al-Agygn
wa Anbgl
Abn; al-Zamgn,
Tahdh*ipbal-Ans9b,
6, P- 315, and
Ans5b,
Leiden,
Beirut
5, p. 168.
Among biographers
have not
involving
been satisfied
1.
was disagreement
of biographers
majority
selves
but it
great-grandfather,
between them.
paid
both
Khallikan
al-Dubab fi I
10
-
his
father's
(b)
name because
was unanimously
Zamakhsharl's'kunya',
Beside
different
full
his
agreed.
titles
nisbahs'a'nd
he has a kunya,
name above,
various
nisbahs
and
titles:
He was called
in Zamakhsha: t!;
Khwarizm,
a province
which
last
nisba'
the Multazilite
that
showing
His
indicating
Zamakhshar;
contains
to
indicates
which
he belonged
shows that
kunya
-2
al-Zamakhshari
al-Khwarzim713,
as his
Ab; al-Casim
he was called
various;
simply
it
nisbahs
that
that
were
he was born
he originated
14,
eta,
i,
al-M,,
,
madhhab;
he belonged
to
from
which
and finally
the Hanafite
sect.
in many subjects;
He specialised
68
ILalhEIF (gTammarian)',
therefore
(philologist),
al-Lughawf
0
(commentator of the Qprlgn),
al-Mufassir
(a man of letters),
and finally
(theologian).
al-Ilutakallimlo
lo
Ibn Khallik9n,
2.
Ibid.
3.
loco
opo cit.,
al-Nujgm
cito
al-Z3hirs
5, p. 274.
'op.
4-
Ibn KhalliOn,
5-
Ibn TaghrI
6.
qift11,
cit.,
7.
SamIgn1i,
8.
Ibn
9.
Ygqt,
10.
op.
op.
cit.,
loc.
f-ImZd, ShadharEt
op.
cit.,
loc.
59 P. 170-
loc.
cit.
cit.
loc.
cit.,
Vol-
cit.
al-I)hahab,
Cairo
1350,
VOL
4,
P- 118.
cit.
al-K-utub
al-
- 11 -
Moreover
intellectual
his
'Sheikh
al-gArab
(neighbour
known as J9rulIJ
(pride
of
of
(professor
al-Dunia
of Khwarizm).
because
of God),
for
there
and stayed
Ustadh
2 (a
teacher
Ajam
il-f.
wa
and Fakhral-Khwarizm3
non-Arab),
to him in'recognition
he was called
reputation;
of the World),
times
titles
sIeveral
the Arab
and
He was also
Mecca several
he visited
years.
Zamakhshar-1"I s family
2-
5
Zamakhsharl, was born on Wednesday 27th Rajab, 467'11. /Bth. March, 1075.
6,
This date was accepted by most of his biogra'phers
except that a few
of
The birth
occurred
village
at that
closely
linked
on 17th.
fell
it
them said
time,
although
2.
it
later
the
or at
in Zamakhshar, in Khwarizm.
,a
end of Rajab8.
comparatively
unknown
was
with
He was of Persian
Cf.
467, H.
Rajab,
Zamakhsharl,
descent
Maq7u;t,
10
but
his
2:325,
Cairo
fa'Mily
was not
introduction
p.
well
known.
2.
Ibid.
aj
3-
Ibn
4-
Ibn Taghrl'
5-
Ibn Khallik3n,
6.
Other biographers
Qutlubugha,
7jim,
Tai_:
al-:
Birdl,
op.
cit.,
OP- Cit-,
Baghdad i962,
volvol-
al-Nuh3t,
al-Alibb3l
9.
Ibn Taghri
10.
Cf.
op.
cit.,
Vol.
2,
Bxockelmann,
273-
are Qirti",
vol-
71-
5, ' P- 173.
OA19 Inb9t
8.
5, p.
P.
al-Ruw-at
-Inbgt
3, p. 266.,
Anbgrl,
4, p. 121.
279.
p.
Joe. cit.
Al-Zamakhsharl,
4, p. 1205.
in Encyclopaedia
of
Islam,
ITuzhat
12
-
This
the
has resulted
in
biographical
statement
a lack
have not
works
showed that
which
there
Nevertheless
more information
family;
his
about
IM7Mn al-Adabl,
learned,
cultured
lost.
his
dealt
it
is
in
suffering
in
for
in
Zamakhsharl"
therefore
al-Mulk
and according
6
moral character
1.
2.,
Cf.
3-
Ibid.
4-
Ibid.,
5-
Ibid.
6.
Cf.
that
to secular
his
he
death
h, Mift;
the sake
matterS3.
father
his
was
realised
that
his
family
was left
in
to rectify
this
situation
order
the release
that
had many
father
while
poverty,
of his father5.
is not clear;
Zamakhsharig' occasionally
knowledge,
TFshkubri-ZZda,
vol.
of his
it
political
As a student
for
of his father
the, imprisonment
of gaining
comparative
situation,
he asked-Muayyid
was a
Zamakhsharl explains
devotion
prison4.
a difficult
com-
poetic
as a result
children
Zamakhshar
his father
that
life,
spiritual
On the other
except
20
greatly
in fact
it
with
Zamakhsharills
and pious
and even
another
subject,
was an Imam in
father
where he mentions
of piety,
on the
sufficiently
is available
position
himself
of information
father
left
died
The reason
was perhaps
was 2 man of bad
his family
for
the sake
Cairo
home.
(n. d. ),
2, p. 100.
Zamakhsharl,
fo.
Dlwgn,
MS Egyptian
National
Library,
No- 529,
97b.
Ibn Ath1m,
Tgrlkh
al-Kamil,
Cairo)92,1-3g,
vol.
8, p.
197.
(adab),
13
This
continuous
was often
by the
separation
saddened
death
he was not
He also
He explains
by separation
of his
father
mentions
his
that
the
about
went into
and it
mother
the
1,
severe
he
grief
caused
especially
since
consciousness.
its
he pulled
leg.
and as he did
out,
and said,
but
family,
fact
a hole;
its
cut through
incident
his
In
and grief.
occurred.
but it
so the thread
death
that
he followed
from
was comparatively
with
him sorrow
caused
leg
the
off
and upset
of
the
treacherous
they
respected
leg'
as he cut off the bird's
I
In regard to his family
as a whole
and that
teaohings
religious
Zamakhsharl"s
Tracing
up in a cultured
His
father
indicating
fore
it
background
that
is
uncertain
from
education
his
father.
father
1.
cf.
zamakhshari,
op. cit.,
2,
Cf.
Yaqut,
Irshad
was imprisoned;
Kitab
this
tragedy
ff.
al-Arib
Cf. Zamakhsharl,
OP- Cit-,
fo-
his
There-
primary
given
caused
no information
his
separation
from
72a, 72b.
ilg
vol. 7, P. 147.
3-
as
he was
activities.
any educational
But a statement
is
there
Zamakhshari I received
whether
his
in
that
family
environment.
and religious
he was involved
and his
parents
indicates
them, certainly
was a learned
known3.
Zamakhsharl's
of
that
was well
attitude
education
as he has described
a whole,
brought
the
their
he dec lares
85b.
Macrifat
al-Ad-ib,
Cairo
1925,
14
-
his father,
there
and certainly
for
opportunity
them to
indication
in Khwarizm
studied
of his
Nany remarkable
which,
scholars
by him.
later,
he appears to have
consulted
is that
education
Under
brought
in various
who specialised
them he studied
different
him up to a position
sciences
branches
of
as a famous scholar
were
science
of his
time*
He became a pupil
Khwarizm.
his
time,
According
the
who followed
it
authority
the blultazilite
ZamakhshaT!
Y5qt,
in
doctrine
studied
al-Dabbl'
a, -NahW14
1 in
philology,
Cf. Y-aq;t,
2.
Maqdisi
describes
pp. 284,285
loc.
op. cit.,
him-both
for
bringing
6
grammar
and
teacher
cit.
as follows:
-** -
Nil
ces\lt
.!
3-
4-
Cf. Ygq5t,
5-
Ibid.
6.
P- 391.
7.
cit.
8.
op. cit-,
op. cit.,
Vol-
Joe. cit.
fo. 91,
5t P- 170.
in
78
by
his
the
he
time
and
at
same
was
sponsored
,
1.
k U
...
to the biographer
acknowledged
to Khwarizm5.
literature
of Ab Mudir b. Jarl'r
Cut,
15
-
in Baghdad
While
According
from
him.
but
it
is
impression
if
was cut
he studied
This
off3.
this
read
some philology
any particular
alsubject
Zamakhsharli,
with
occasion
was the
gives
us the
between
relationship
him
between
relationship
and pupil.
time4,
al-Jawgliqll'.
there
that
clear
twice
leg
and Zamakhsharl,
teacher
not
However,
Ab ManOi
2C
'ooks to him and gave him ijaza .
Dgmighanil',
al-
'gAbd-ull;h al-Ygbirl
r
(usull),
law
al-AndalUsi,
cAll
He read to him*Kitgb
Sibawaih,
Ibn Hazm5.
Ibn Zaid,
some
(faqlh).
and a jurist
of
I
b. Wahhs for
6.
,.r
al-E3rithi
1.
Cf.
cit.,
loc.
cit.
2.
vol.
3# p. 270.
3-
op. cit.,
loc.
4.
Brockelmann,
5-
6.
Cf. Suyiitir,
YgqUt,
op.
op. cit.,
loc.
cit.;
Librum de InterpTe
1839t P. 41.
Cf. Ygqt,
op. cit.,
cit.
-loo.
r7
He studied
jurie-
cit.
see also Qifti,
op. cit-,
Vol.
Tibus Korani,
Lugduni Batavoriurii,
3, p. 268.
16
-
al-Kbayygtl
-2
Muha=ad
Rukn al-Din
al-Usuli
0a
On the other-hand, Ygqt states that Ab'Al_1 al-Hasan b. al3
He was
teachers
Muzaffar al-NaisbUri was one of his literature
0
4.
a man of letters,
a, poet, and an author, who died in 442 R.
However,
this
the
death
Nais5brills
is
statement
latter
in
It
therefore.
doubt,
to become his
course
of his
intellectual
instruction
career
the
al-Balldil,
for
impossible
pupils
was highly
capacity
field
academic
in
to many people
Among his
Ja9far
in
was obviously
was born;
pupil.
Zamakhsharils
Zamakhshazirts
Zamakhsharl
occurredrbefore
different
he appears
In
to have given
b.
"Ill
famous figures
b. Muhammad b.
6
in literature5.
Barjuk,
al-Ifr9b
Cf.
2.
Ibid.
T9shkubri-ZEdah,
op.
7-
I's
Zamakhsharl
among
cit.,
loc.
learned
b,
'Ilm
and
Moreover,
1.
the
subjects.
pupils-were
regarded.
vol. 2, p. 100.
cit.
loo.
vol.
Ibid.,
vol.
5, P- 412.
Ibid.,
vol-
7, p- 77.
-cit.
79 P- 304.
friends
and pupils
17
-
to these
(ijgza
authority
b. Abdul
Sa=3n
In addition
was a learned
pupils,
Zamakhshari
agreed
Among his
b.
Barak3t
asking
who obtained
from
authority
authorit,
al-DIn
al-Watwat,
and poet
who were both
were those
fIS3 b. Wahh3s
1.
Cf.
2.
SamcgniE. op.
b.
cit.,
p.
his
teachers-and
who studied
pupils.
gIlm al-
278.
op. cit.,
vol.
2, P. 344-
5, P. 170
4.
5.
02- cit-.,
OP- cit-,
loc.
cit.
al-Nahwiyya
Cf. Tashkubri-Zadahlop.
Qifti,
his
3.
him4.
Ta.rsir'from
Be
scholars,
Ahmad b. Muhammndal-
him for
Mahmud al-Us3ll,
Cf. Yikt,
She
there
vol.
of celebrated
Ab T3hir
Ibid.,
their
by Zamakhsharl".
a group
b. Muhammad b. Abdullh
Malik
a man of letters
Finally
Also H3fiz
and others
derived
scholars
authority
under
and authorised
pupils
IbighiM
b. Abdul
her
from Alexandria
twice
wrote
of Khwarizm
of Samarqand
r
b,
Zainab
example
al-ShOr, # Who
for
jurist
a number of
was given
r2
them
Zamakhshar,
among
Salafi
Ahmad b. MahmUdal-Shati
Malik,
) from him;
Ibn Khallik5n
authoxised
Jal'ill
al-Simr
Ab
vol,
vol.
7, p. 92.
cit.,
loc.
3, p. 268.
cit.
wa al-Lughawiyya
finda
18
-
The liteTary
Zamakhsharils
very
linguistics,
had a great
Therefore
numerous
poetry,
life
to knowledge
a family
himself
works
was
on grammar,
commentary
as a source
he chose a priestly
way of life,
people
on the
Quil9n,
interest
because
of problems
it
he felt
1
and difficulties
this
although
in
attitude
was
way of life
the
Perhaps
and his
and children
potential
opposed by his
lo
his
literature,
most of his
He denied
was great.
it
in
reflected
literature
and Islamic
etc.
He devoted
that
is
lexicography,
jurisp--udence
in Arabic
achievement
This
great.
of Zamakhshari
outDut
he had chosen
which
so many books.
produce
This
Mawlawis
Khadin
Husain
for
Hay,
work
1,
fo.
2.
Ibid.,
3-
Ibn KhalliOn,
4.
Brockelmann,
5.
The detailed
Khalfa;
fo.
Calcutta
1859,
4
1307,1308,1318
and Cairo
on this
The commentaries
6
been published
time
first
the
and Abdul
at Bul7ak 1291,
4
published
an haq; 3iq_al_-tanzi,
al-Kashshaf
later
it
was
and 1948-
are variOU35;
26.
9.
op.
cit.,
Op- cit-,
Kashf
p. 1205-
4,
vol-
commentaries
in his
p. 168.
Vol--59
on this
al-Zun;
have
been mentioned
work
Leipzig
n,
1835-58,
Vol-
by II; jI
0
5, PP- 155-157,
182-198.
6.
Two commentaries
the
margin
by al-Jurjani
of al-Kashsh3f
in
and al-Iskandari
Cairo
edition
1948-
were printed
on
.- 19 -
al-Mbfassal
The above work was published
1879,
with
Delhi
1891,
Shawahid
glosses
by J. B. Broch,
by Mawlawi
and appendices
by Hamzah Fathallgh,
commentary
Alexandria
1859,
Christiania
Ab FirEs
al-NaOZnj
al-
Halabi -2
Several
commentaries
on the
work3;
some of
3-
al-Umdhaj
1269,
1275,
Tabriz
Different
f" al-nahW5
0
by Broch, Christiania
1289 and Stambul
Cairo
main work,
Kazan 1901,
fi
ShaTh al-Anm7udhaj
1.
Ibn Khallikan,
op.
cIsg
loc.
vol.
vol.
'Askar,
Cairo
al-Fairgdhaj
1289,
4, P. 1206.
work are mentioned by Hajil
0
1882,
and Cairo
Ibn Khallikan,
op.
Brockelmann,
op. cit.,
cit.,
and tUmdat
cit.
commentaxies on this
The
two commentaries'are
by Muha=ad
MajZPa
and another
cit.,
1299
commentaries on this
in
1867, printed
6
by Go Jahn,
(n. d. ).
loc.
loc.,
cit.
cit,
in Brockelmann,
op. cit.,
loo.
cit.
- 20 -
al-S;
rl
by Ibiahlm
b.
Savad al-Khususi,
1312
Bulak
fl
al-Muhgj3t
wa mptammim maham arVa*b al-h-Wt
i-2
al-ahaji
wa al-gh3z
I
Bahijah
by Dr.
al-Hasan!
0
University
Baghd3d 1973-
of Baghd9d,
It
it
for
by 'All
by Iir
published
f!
al-V53iq
was published
was edited
in 19674.
al-5Ir9ql*,
6-
the first
Ygqt,
al-Mustaqsa fi
amthal al-r'Arab
by Majlis
dalirat
Later
Ibrah-im,
1945.
Cairo
al-'Arabiyya,
dit-,
op.
Cf.
Majalla
but
'-'.
Ris3la
cit.,
al-malarif,
Haiderabad,
vol.
loc.
cit.
7s P. 151;
but
al-Muhajat
bi
Maimagal-1, ilm"I
ZaiCanpTZrIkh
Al kalimat
4-
See MaJalla
5-
Y5qt,
loc.
op.
5t P. 168 mentions
vol3-
1324
1962.
Brockelmarn,
2o
time in Haiderabad
al-Bij3W71
al-hadith5
gharib
ihyg-lal-kutub
7-
al-shah; da3
by Majm al-$ilml
by
and published
al-adab
vol.
mentions
6.
Brockelmann,
7.
Ibn Khallik3n,
al-masalil
op.
al-nahwiyya.
al-vArabl,
vol-
cit.,
15,
7,
P- 150,
al-P33iq
o]2. cit.,
op.
al-vIraq_i,
cit.,
loc.
loc.
but
vol.
Ibn
Xhallik3n,
fl-tafs1ral-Had"Eth.
cit.
cit.
15,
p. 1210
3, P. 50 mentions
al-shah3da.
Majmac al-cilm!
OP- cit-,
cit.
al-rIraqi,
Ibn Khallikan,
p. 121.
op.
cit.,
21 -
A selection
from
in
al-Gallipoli
it
entitled
999 with
Persian
8-
Kit3b
Zubdat
al-amthal
and Turkish
commentary
fi
al-mufmad wa al-mulall-a-f
Asas al-Bal;
glosses
al-nahw
published by Majmalal-
gha
Cairo 1972*
10 - Aljab al-tujub
1300, 'Cairo
lgmiyyat
al-Arsb
sharh
1'324,1328
1966, with
Damascus
,
by Abdul
notes
Mut'J[n al-Maluhil.
Kitab
It
by'M.
was published
9.
Leiden 1859
1.13mockelmarm,
2.
Ibn
P-
op.
Qutlubugha,
151
Cf.
Muialla
4-
Ibn
Khallik3n,
5-
BTockelmann,
6.
Ygq5t,
7.
Brockelmam,
80
But
9.
brockelmann,
op.
Yaq-ut,
cit.,
cit.,
op.
op.
loc.
loc'.
loc.
cit..
cit.
loc.
OT). cit.,
cit.,
cit.,
al-tlriql,
cit.,
cit.,
(auspice
Grave
De
but
loc.
loc.
T. G. Juy-nboll),
Ygqt,
wa al-muTakka_b__fi
Majmagal-tilml
op.
b3l wa ai-miyah
cit.
loc.
al-Mufrad
op.
wa al-j
Salverda
loc.
cit.,
op.
mentions
3-
al-amkina
Vol-
Vol,
al-tArabi37a.
15,
P-
100-
cit.
cit.
cit.
cit.
states
cit.
Kitab
al-jibal
wa al-amkina
22
-
fl
12 - Atwaq al-dhahab
According
to
al-NasPih
by which
,
the
mentioned
could
Halsbander
Goldene
scharis
by G. Weil,
1876.
translation
in 1286, Beirut
Qalglid
I
1772;
Z,,
Vi-,
text
ed.,
Ygqt,
2,
Brockelmann,
op.
3-
Zamakhsharil,
al-Keshsh-af,
cit.,
Joe.
Leiden
op
Les Pensees de
de Meynard, in J. A. ser.,
cum scholiis
lith.
vii.,
4t p.
Vol-
1,
vol.
1960 - 1961.
atwaq al-dhahab
1207.
P- 368.
fl
al-mawa? iz wa al-khitab,
1876, P. 176.
5a, B:rockelmann,
op. cit.,
loc.
Zamakhshax"l, al-Kashsh-af,
cit.,
Bxockelmann,
mentions
op.
cit.,
al-Kalim
loc.
cit.
but YgqZt,
1, p. 297;
vol.
al-naw7a-bigh
cit.
f!
al-mawaciz.
vol.
Stambul 1866.
cit.
cit.,
Zamakhsharl', Kit9b
loc.
H. A. Schultens);
Beirut
.-
1.
6.
commentary
by H. A. Schultensq
of.
in Cairo 1287,1305
Paris
Turkish
with
sententiamum arabicarum
llustravit
par C. Barbier
arabe,
op.
Istanbul
and illustrated
(Anthologia
vertit,
P. 3Usqq.;
Printed
by C. Barbier
and edited
1314,
Leipzig
Fleischer,
al-kalim
Nmiabigh al-kalim
Zamachsjaxii
und deutsch
arabisch
by H. L.
Beirut
1293,1322
13 - Nawabigh
work
in
(Samach
al-adab
This
al-Kashsli5f3;
Atwaq al-dhahab,
translated
Printed.
in
in Atwaq al-dhahab4.
translated
1863,
Stuttgart
Paris
m,entioned
Keujahrsgeschenk
als
de Meynard,
is
known as
and published;
1835),
name it
be found
This
the
de Meynard,
C. Barbier
-2
al-sighar
phrase
al-mawagiz
op. cit'.,
23
-
on this
The commentaries
are various
work
14 - Mcjaddimat al-adab
This
1844
is
3,
another
al-Kutub
under
al-Misriyya,
in HS form
work
edited
15 - KhasPis
It
was edited
by Dr.
is
in
preserved
272 and 58
no.
Tehran
al-fasharatal-kir3m
Bah-ijah
in
Leipzig
which
al-lugha,
majmat
'published
and
information
According-to
of this
volume
by J. G. Sipaphansalar
Tehran 1342.
4.
in
Dgr
It
was also
1963 - 1965-
al-baTaTa5
al-Hasan'll,
in
and published
Baghd5d
1968.
16 - al-QistZs
Baghdad 1969
Ibn Khallik9n,
op.
3-
Brockeimann,
4-
Cf.
Joe.
cit.,
al-HaSanl
and published
loc.
al-adab
f!
cit.
loc.
ghat
op.
cit.
cit.,
op.
Muqaddimat
states
al-ar;
Brookelmann,
2.
Bahijah
cit.;
but
Y; qt,
op.
loc.
cit.,
al-lugha.
cit.
fi
al-qurGniyya
tafsl'r
al-Zamakhshari,
(nd,. ), P. 47.
Cairo
5.
6.
cf.
asani
loc.
Khasg3is
al-Zamakhsharl,
salsila
7-
Ibn Khallik9n,
o_p. cit.,
8.
Printed
by Maktabat
cit.
al.! asharat
kutub
loc.
al-andalUs,
al-kirgm
al-turath,
al-barara
Baghdad 1968,
cit.
Baghdad 1969.
li
rio.
10.
cit.,
24
-
17
al-Durar
al-dPir
istV;
This
Baghdad 1968
Bgh-ijah
al-Hasan'l,
1
in
and published
al-mawa-ciz3
in Cairo 1313,1325-
zux Maqamenliteratur,
Beitr'ge
19 - Sharh
It
al-gArab
wa
18 - Maq; mt f!
0. Rescher,
al-muntakhab
r; t wa tashbih3t
by Dr.
Ci kinayat
fasc.
It
6, Greifswald
1913.
al-kibaT4.
al-maqmgt
was published
by
was translated
1313,
13255.
of this
states
that
1. -Brockelmann,
0
work is
the
preserved
work
is
being
Sibawaih
in Ahmad 37,
edited
Geschichte'der-Arabischen
Istanbul.
Dr.
Litteratur,
Leiden 1937-42,
suPPl- 1, P- 511.
2.
See 14aialla
Majmat al-tilml
al-EIT3q!,
1968, vol.
16.
yaqut,
5.
Ibid.
6.
Ibn Khallik3n,
7.
See YAjalla
8.
Ibid.
op. cit.,
Ylajma sl-ilm'
loc.
cit.
31Trg al,
Vol.
15, P- 91.
25
-
21 - Nukt
Dr.
Mr.
Bahijah
also
al-j'crib
22 - Rabirt
Ph. D.,
al-itT9b
gharib
al QuT35n)-l
the
that
mentions
(fi
is
work
above
gharlib,
being
by
edited
-2
DarwIsh
, Abdull7ah
This
fi-
al-abr;
r3
by Dr.
Bahijah
for
al-Hasan!
the
degree
of
Cambxidge4.
wa nuzhat al-
6
The M of this work is preserved in the Ayb Sofia q no. 4331
1
24 - Mlw-an al-shitj
in MS form
al-Masriyya,
clear
naskhi
529 (adab).
no,
is
which
The M
in
preserved
DFr al-
of 120 folios,
consists
writing.
25 - Ru)s al-masglil
is
1.
Ygqt,
2.
See Majalla
3-
Ibn
Qutlubugha,
cit.,
mentions
4-
Cf.
5-
Brookelmann,
states
6.
loc.
op. cit.,
in
op.
Rabl$
cit.
al-11raqi,
vol.
', loc.
cit.,
to
theses
loc.
cit.;
Fuzhatal-m-usta-Inis.
Ibid.
Ibn Khallikin,
op. cit.,
but
cit.;
f3i al-adab
al-abrgr
Index
op.
thesis.
cit.
YajmaO al-film-i
Paterson,
this
pTesented
loc.
cit.
Vol.
15,
P- 94-
Ygqt,
op.
va al-muh5dar;
15,
but Yaq; t,
p.
cit.,
loc.
t.
23.
op.
cit.,
loc.
cit.
in
26
-
fl 11 al-us9l
26 - al-minhgj
Brockelmann states
that
in the Library
of Ahmad Timor4.
28 - al-Qasidat
is Preserved
al-batudiyya.
6
in Berlin
29 - MasPil
al-Ghaz;,,:,
30 - al-Kashf
The above work is
in Berlin
fl
al-qir;
in
preserved
8.
'; t9
Medina,
Maktaba
Rib9t
Sayyid
'UtImign".
1,
Ibn Khallik3n,
op.
der Arabischen
Litteratur,
loc.
cit.,
but
cit.;
supp.
Brockelmann,
1, P. 513t
Geschichte
el-Ifinhaj
mentions
fi
us; 1 al-din.
2.
Brockelmann,
3-
Ygqt,
ot-
Brockelmann,
loc.
op. cit.,
cit.,
loc.
cit.
al-Zamakhsharl
5.
6.
Ibid.
7.
Ibid.
B.
Ibid.
9.
Brockelmann,
10.
Ibid.
cit.
in Encycloppedia
of Islam,
vol,
4, p. 1207.
P. 56.
Geschichte
der Arabischen
Litteratur,
EUPP1- 1,
P- 511-
27
-
31 - Jawahir
Unknown
al-lugha
2.
3
32 - al-Am; 11:
Unkno, m4.
33 - Hashiya
falg
al-mufassal
6
Unknown
34 - Kit; b al-ainas7
v
8.
Unknown
35 - Kitab
Casm3l al-=wgt9-
mutashabih
10
Unknown .
tilm al-farglid
36. - al-Ra'Jid fl
12
Unknown .
1.
Yaqut,
2*
3.
op.
cit.,
loc.
cit.
P. 49-
5, p. 169, states
cite
Joe. cit.;
f,
al-Amall
fI al-nahw.
5-
mentions al-Amall
Ab5 Musa, OP- cit-,
P- 50loc. cit.
Ygqt, op. cit.,
6.
See Majalla
4-
7.
Yajmal al-9ilmTal-Ijr9j,
loc. cit.
YgqUt, op. cit.,
8.
AbU Isg,
9.
YaqUt,
10.
11. YZqUt,
12.
op.
op.
Ab M5sg,
OP* cite,
cit.,
cit.,
loc.
P. 49.
cit.
P- 57.
loc.
OP- Cit-,
cit.
P- 49-,
'
kul fan;
Vol.
op. cit.
15, P. 94-
loc.
28
-
17
37 - Sarnimal--farabiyya
2.
Unknown
38 - Mulljam al-hudUd3
Unknown4.
39 - 191lat
Unknown
al-nashid
6.
41 - Biwan khitab
Unknown
10
.
42 - Diwan al-tamthil
Unknown
12
.
loc.
1.
Ygq5t,
2,
AbU IlUsE,
3-
ygq5t,
4-
op.
cit.,
op.
loc-
7.
YaqUt,
8.
Abu Mus;,
g.
Ygqt,
10.
AbU ISs3,
11. Yzq5t,
op.
op.
loc.
op.
loc.
cit-9
loc.
cit.,
op.
loc.
cit.,
cit.
cit.
P. 56.
cit.
loc.
cit.,
ED. cit.,
cit.
P. 50.
OP. cit.,
cit.,
cit.
cit-
loc.
loc.
cit.,
OP- cit-,
6.
cit.
cit.
cit.
loc.
cit.
29
-
43 - Tasliat
al-dariTr
.0
2.
UnImown
44 - Ris3lat a_asr; r3
Unknown4.
45 - al-Risalat
al-n3siha5
Unknown 0
46 -, Sawa-lir aj_amtj-aj7
I-8
Unknown
10
.
48
Unknown
takl
Ritab
-
al-kul
12
1.
y9qutj
2.
3*
Ygq5t,
4-
5-
YaqUt,
6.
Abu Musa,
7.
YaqUt,
8.
AbU Mgsg,
90
Y_aqUt, op.
10.
AbU 1,':'usg,
11.
YgqUt,
op.
loc.
cit.,
op.
op.
loc.,
cit.,
loc-
OP- cit-,
op.
loc.
op.
cit.
loc.
cito,
loc.
cit.,
cit.,
cit.
cit.
loc,
loco
cit.,
cit.
loc.
cito,
cit.
P. 56.
OP- cit-,
cit.,
cit.
citloc.
cit.,
cit.,
op.
cit.
cit.
cit.
P. 57.
- 30 49 - Shaq; liq
haq; liq
al-nucm-an fl
al-nufm3n
fi
2
Unknown
travels
Zamakhsharllp
Khwarizm.
him confidence
intellectual
seems that
and skill,
so that
abilitY5.
He felt
he was being
that
scholars
material
rewards.
In order
were.
kingg-and
in
of his
become proud
eventually-he
in
good positions
to be in
He was eager
he tried
this
to attain
members of-the
some notable
when he looked
slighted
the
to
the
at
contemporary
and
goverment
same position
ingratiate
as they
himself
with
by celebrating
government
them
poems.
Among those
Yaq5t,
cit.,
power by Malik
absolute
op.
loc.
cit.,
mentions
ShaqPiq
3--
Zemakhsharir, al-Rashsh3f,
4.
cit.,
but
cit.;
2.
This
loc.
loc.
al-nugmanfl
Shah to run
Ibn Rhallik5n,
haq; 3iq
Nizam al-Mulk,
0
6
the country
oR. cit.,
loc.
al-nulman.
cit,
vol.
1, P. 376.
cit.
can be found
in what he says
in
his
elw3n,
ff.
8a,
78b, 79b.
Cf. Houtsma, Malik
Shah, in Fncyclopaedia
of Islam, vol-3,
p. 212*
31
He praised
could
not
him,
satisfy
obtain
a reward
Vizier
was not
hoping
it
but
had gained
in
posts
it
that
if
he arrived
him,
him to attain
his
to obtain
there
Isfahan,
where
Shah for
his'good
from
service
Malik
in
to
verse
Islam,
theZaljuk
but
he was
2.
Ibid.
3.
Ibid.
fo.
37b.
4-
Ibid.,
fo.
13b.
5-
Ibid.,
fo.
23b.
6.
Ibid.
fo.
97b.
7.
Ibid.
ff
86a.,
95a,
-ff.
,
9
Diwan,
fo-
in
his
although
the
appeared
mind.
'5
As he was not
to
When
govermentgamong*
leave
Khurgbn
and
succesfor
to
ask for
13b.
95b.
86b.
to obtain
him7.
1.
who
he had to
Shah al-Ardastnl
decided
he eventually
those
country.
remained
b. Nizam al-Mulk
he honouxed
to him,
ever
inevitably
some members of
Ab al-Fath
MLfayyid al-Mulk"Ubaidul27ah
Khui-as-an either,
his
for
sful-in
in
the
in Kharizm failed.
country
him4
to
only
that
than
capable
a position
the
for
in
less
leave
he had no position
was not
by accusing
purpose,
his efforts
difficult
it
doing
he got
which
he made a complaint
of being
to
reward
As he realised
goverment
Khwarizm in frustration,
He left
position,
in
was very
because
it
aim in
as well.
and decided
He was frustrated
The material
his
a position
help
Unfortunately
accept
because
much interested
would
he felt
Malik
anything
32
-
In the
512 H. he suffered
year
which. he called
al-mundhira
own behaviour'during
his
understand
Remembering
position
indeed,
this,
and material
members of
the
so far
that
from his
After
his
he felt
suffering
guilty
about
sin
about
himself,
valuable
opportunity
After
sin
for
and some
if
he were
there4.
and Amirs
in, poetry
in Mecca,
birthplace7that
and within
in Mecca,
he did
by him,
and prose5.
several
some years
and repentance
hospitality
was given
he lived
to go to Mecca,
in worship
not
this
period
he had the
as he said,
01 have
he was so affected
by the
places in Arabia,
6
the dust of ArabiaO
spending
memory of his
families
compositions
to visit
stepped in all
while
two years
his
he decided
met
He stayed
greed
suffering
several
him to
and needed to be
to repeat
not
devoting himself
where he could stay quietly
1
3.
Ibn Wahh; in Mecca,
He
to
of
his
kings
of praising
he had co=itted
and promised
discovery
his
God
caused
career.
previous
as a result
reward
so he repented
released
This
of disease
goverment.
He realised
cleaned,
(-warning).
a kind
from
severely
have the
patience
to
stay
p. 6.
1,
2,
'Ibid.
3-
4-
Ibid.,
5-
0.
7.
42a, 42b.
fo. Ia.
vol.
5, p. 287.
Cairo 1972t vol.
1, P- 78-
and
33
much longer;
His
therefore
dream of getting
old
had returned
mind to leave
he made up his
to Khwarizm.
a high
In ordet
position
the
for
and science
brated
by Zamakhsharl
his
respect
the
comnnnd of Atsij.
It
for
scholars
2.
during
that
appears
his
for
interest
He also
the
in
not satisfied
benefit5.
He was repentant
brated
TFj al-Mul
hospitality
three
years
from
leaving
it
Mecca for
Cf.
2.
Cf. Zamakhsharl,
3-
Ibid.
4-
Cf.
5.
Ibid.,
Ibid.
Ibid.
Zamakhshari,
completing
Zamakhshaxll,
41a.
Liwan,
his-famous
ff.
ff.
son
where he cele7
who succeeded
him
He received
under
his
patronage
for
107b.
107a,
41a,
at
as nothing4.
al-Khashsh3f.
there
Muqaddimat al-adab,
Iffy9n,
al-adab
1.
fo.
his
and
in Mecca for
He arrived
he spent
and also
died
and cele-
again.
time,
and science
a book Muqaddimat
of Xhwarizm
reign
for
blamed himself
So he bitterly
literature,
to
governor
with
when he
at that
the
After
wrote
Atsiz,
him again
struck
of Khwarizm
governor
who later
he was replaced
place.
praise
the
41b.
1, p. 2.
34
the
second time
It
1.
was reported
he had travelled
by a wooden leg
Zamakhsharir suffered
that
a great
deal;
spending
1144
period
3.
eighth
of his
Ibn
several
to his
life
BaGta
says
was replaced
years
birthplace
and died
death
in
Khawarizm,
Jurjaniyya
he had visited
that
of the
where he spent
in
his
parts
the
year
tomb there
World,
the
537 H. /
in
the
century4.
1.
Cf. Zamakhsharf,
2.
4-
because
2*
Zamakhshari, r returned
last
it
Zamakhsharl's
After
from frostbite
S7jtl,
2, p.
BuRhyat
vol.
ff.
79b, 80a.
7, P. 147.
al-wucZt
ri
tabaq-at
al-lughawiyy:
in wa al-nulait,
280.
IjiwEn,
2,
- 35 -
CHAFTER THREE
PLACE IN LITERATURE
1-
'Ru'Us
enjoyed
Compositions
scholars
in
mentioned
the
according
to him,
authors
they
Hahm3d.
Ibn
AbU
al-Q7asim
.-and
oa
composed with the same title.
On the
scholars
schools;
that
the
Hanafite,
Haj!
2.
Cf.
Ibn Rajab,
Cf.
authors
2,
H8ji
(d-
447 H. ) (d-
that
out
the
Shfililte
cAbdul Kh3iiq
al-
(d.
?a
latter
307 H. )
-
both
who
-
Hanafite
-a
Khalifa
'Rulas al-Mas7a,3ill
entitled
538 H-)
Malikite,
Khallia,
Kashf
al-D)--il
information
provide
of the
Cf.
3-
title;
points
this
under
Shanqitl3e
0
these statement
1.
vol-
this
however,
only,
was
by Shilikh
Therefore
appears
under
which
Various
many centuries.
works
5Umar (d-
a Hanbalite
composed works
title
other
an interesting
one volume,
two volumes,
-'in
is
for
al-Masg'il
Cases'
literature
Islamic
- who wrote
" Sh7afiglte
Ru'Us
apparently
" Sh3filte
'The Basic
al-T-Tas3ill
popularity
of
of
works
bearing
one or other
cola
of the
title
it
subject.
were eminent
four
legal
orthodox
and Hanbalite.
Shafiirte
al-Zunun,
this
on the
Istanbul
Tabaqat
1941-1946,
al-Hanabila,
vol.
Cairo
1,
p.
1952,
1, P. 17ha-ikh
Shanqitl,
Asm; 3 ashhur
al-kutub
al-CArabiyya,
P. 17.
910.
- 36 -
Generally
prudence,
the
speaking,
but
conflicting
I have just
title
mentioned
Rul; s al-masa2il
dealing
statements
the
present
work
authors
of
Nevertheless
these
juris-
as a theme.
bearing
the works
with
is
works
were many;
such a title
work under
of the
that
these
of
matter
rulings
Authorship
,
subject
Several
author.
show that
the
he wrote
have to be
statements
examined.
Study
showing
Ition
is
of
that
mainly
shown on the
front
also written
in large
Second:
In addition
in
There
sixty
This
in
confirma-
writing,
same is
folio
uvo-"v
cases
conflicting
are jointly
are about
dealing
discussed
eighty-eight
with
in his
such cases.
'are
Ab-u Han1fa and Slzfifi:
0
of them agree with the present work3.
are sufficient
distinguished
with
to indicate
that
Zamakhsharl was
of
the
legal'schools.
3-
'and
the'two
Beirut
2.
number of
results
in the following
writing
These points
separate
clear
of his
his.
6. "
the NS in
al-Kashsh3f.
separately,
interesied
points;
1.
page of
work
indeed
II 6PLiL c-Lo
A considerable
differences
treated
is
following
on the
The title
First:
discussion
work under
based
us and another
cit.;
masPil.
Cf. Appendix.
37
-
Third:
In
Zamakhsha: ri7ls
-fact
al-Kashshf,
that
appears
the
, b. al-Hasan,
before
scholar
frequently
ha-lik
or after
in
applied
of
literature.
Ikhtilgf
is
Ikhtil5f
it
presented.
are
frequently
mentioned
al-Auzg6i,
in
obvious
Muhammad
al-Nakhal-i
etc.
>-l
word which
as a standard
field
r-ulings
scholars:
al-Tahiwil,
al-Zahirl,
00.
Fourth:
The word-'
work
the
cases he also
various
following
the
in
the
concerns
of dissimilar
in handling
name of
DMd
inteest
a lot
where
discussion
of
presentation
the
present
the name of a
precedes
the
each ruling,
when the
al-Kashsh3f
throughout
conflicting
same word
cussed.
it
Moreover,
cases
which
and points
as example
seems that
following
the
a) The following
it
show the
is
ruling
would be useful
between
similarities
the
two works;
taken;
in
appears
vol.
al-Kashshaf,
1,
pp.
21,22:
ji
4Z
II
4---:.
This ruling
as below
\j jL, i 1 &. ji
is also mentioned
gl ji; gi%
...
in the Ruls al-masalil,
I:
; k-ji U,. rj I C)
!; j
1.
Cf.
Text,
p. 25.
CAL
LJU-j (-f
-le
Li clx-ji
to
fo.
l4b
38
-
b) This
tradition
is
517: 11
P.
al-Kashshaf,
be found
can also
1, p.
vol.
283,
The interesting
in
this
in the
six
point
the majority
read
in
the
Rul5s
al-masa3il
in
the
provided5.
is
the
work fo-
Indeed,
the
expression
in
of the tradition,
collections
al-fath
he reads
present
, 3
? 12
4b,
reading
Zamakhsharl prefers
with
where the
a reason
vowel
has been
point
applied'in
vas
for
is
This reading
al-kasr.
mentioned-
Kashsh7af too,
tradition
the word
read differently
4 but
with
anoth er reading;
this
alhe says
choice;
CX
ok;
jJI
3.
Oa
g.
&)-"i'
,,
"
&J 6I.-P \j
is presented
expression
(reciters)
2
Al-Qurr;
c)
Al
ccA\!
vol.
27b
found
in
6--M%
Cy
I
%-ro
f
-
found
'
Ju
Qj
%IrALC
1. Ibid.,
2,
Cf.
P. 54.
Tirmidhi",
Jgmial-Sal7ih,
Cairo
1937-1965,
1961, vol.
information
on this
point,
1, pp. 208,209.
Cf. Text,
Cf. Zamakhsharl,
op. cit.,
loc.
cit.
4,
(n. d. ), Vol-
al-Kashshi; f,
Vol.
c
see Marl,
p. 196.
4, p. 196.
1, P- 448al-ImlP,
For
Cairo
2,
39
-
discrepancy
sixth
the
Fevertheless
on the
Ir
dates
of the
jurist,
Qaddurit
comparatively
early;
therefore
on the
points
we have obtained,
which
fites).
It
is
which
works;
of
it
is
the
of the
subject
is concentrated
who wrote
scholars
The death
it.
about
in
we face
can be traced.
origin
several
and.
the
year
428 H.,
to be presumed
that
his
year
the works
among the
405 H1. is
Hanafites
undertaken
mostly
fifth
the
its
occurred
between
of differences
The comparison
of
deaths
which
in
he dictated
which
a pioneer
no indication
of a Hanafite
0
Rl-TajrId
,
Several
during
enable
subject
of
points
grew extensively
because
some difficultiesq
with
introducing
in
but
on the
c to write
Shafifites.
others
some were Hanafites,
0
This kind of literature
centuries,
Ikhtil9f
Ite.
the
Sh3fil"I
school and
before
authors
first*autho:
the
of
works
with
here
book
first
work
and Sh3ficites.
is
limited
to the
materials
of Sh9fitites
of rulings
and on the
by several
scholars.
Different
of rulings
in their
on the quantity
is
and approach.
I
The quantity
of rulings
evidence
Works of
authors
Ikhtil3f
were written
produced different
quantity
jurists
f Juwainir introduces
which consists
of 234 folios
1,
2.
Cf.
MS British
op. cit.,
Shirgzl
p-
museum,no- 7574-
presents
works.
in the field
of
- 40 -
entitled
al-Nukt,,
whereas
Ibn
Mukhtasar
Farh
600 rulings
only
and producing
about
are
Partly
in
three
there
of
al-Simanaml)whose
It
we have,
seems that
is
that
on the subject,
is
volumes:
217 folios
of
jurists
only
whose works
al-Sarakhs-i,
entitled
volume
three
is
5,
65 rulings
about
of 124 folios#
consists
are bigger
this
is
the
than
smallest
This
1 and volume
2 are
MS Ahmad 3, no.
0-
1080.
preserved
of several
in Salim
come to light.
volumes;
MS of
Agha,
278.
3.
Cf.
4-
Cf. NS Egyptian
National
Library,
(fiqh
1523
no.
5.
Cf. MS Egyptian
National
Library,
(fiqh
238
no.
6.
of
has been
work'which
2.
that
407 rulings.
and contains
and
The only
al-Khi5fiyyt.
al-Jinay9t,
of 107 folios
volume
several
consisting
containing
mentioned
1.
work
al-Dirn
unfortunately
YlasPil
the works
to be presumed
written
Radi
work
Tariqa*in
about
47 rulings
of about
consisting
us,
and producing
two Hanafite
only
221 folios,
Kam3luddIn
which
has reached
but
volumes,
consisting
of it
composed his
are
They are
available,
part
of 338 folios
entitled
83 xulings4.
hand,
other
1570 rulings
and containing
I
Baihaql
al-Khil7fiyy5t
of
work
consisting
one volume
available.
al-Tariq
the
Q7541 al-Husain
unfortunately
On the
309 folios
of
summarised
al-Khil7afiyygt
consisting
19
no.
Shgfi"1)
Hanafl)
41 -
The evidence
and approach
Examination
of the
works
of writing
on the
subject
trend
for
evidence,
of
fifth
the
and sixth
for
the
centuries.
the
different
(consensus)
ljmgc
Cadl
ShirizI,
in
the
al-Hus
from
the
and the
sin,
Qiygs
of Sh; fitite
works
rest
the
any of
the
providing
in providing
from
ruling,
from-various
evidence
may be found
a single
identify
groups:
evidence
us to
enables
variety-of
Surma,
Zamakhshar"17 is
but
item
three
tendenoy
This
the
Qur2En,
such as Juwainli,
alike,
in
Works containing-a
the
jurists
into
mentioned
only one
recognised.
sources.
Works contain
Second:
(Q=39n,
fox
Sunna),
filliftes.
Sh7a.
Third:
any points
trend
This
exclusively-the
of
evidence
al-Simana-111".
is
observed,
generally
on the
reliability
writers
argue
is
produced
school
against
for
opponents point
the
of
both
they
But Zamakhohar,
such a fanatical
than -others.
between
evidence
provided
ShAfilte
writers
and then
parties,
This
jurists
and
and is
all
sources.
they
argue
is
intended
centred
Hanafite
The evidence
and vice-versa*
polemic
al
as we have
two madh3hib
from
Qiy; s.
Radl al-Yin
literature,
this
polemic
by point.
which
in
appears
Hanarites
from. the
exclusively
by the Hanafite
which
the Text
by Baihaql.
The approach
between
conflict
was adopted
Works producing
from
evidence
against
mainly
their
to
defend
follow.
appears
argument.
in
his
work not
Thus on this
to
point
become involved
he is
in
more objective
42
-
As we have observed,
in
this
from
is
period,
tradition
by all
the production
Zairfakhshari
previous
in
their
of their
conflict
frequently
the
with
This
our view).
in
fact,
is
which
argumentv
are
forward
put
rebuttal
a negative
producing
them equally
he agrees
attitude
a remarkable
in
is
achievement
the
with
But
works.
toward
attitude
for
either
both
in
sides
and
He emphasises
(i. e.,
his
work,
present
in
Zamakhshari
Taqlid
in
the
expression
when the
period
their
case,
in
and argument
evidence
evidence.
reflected
of
a single
rulings
by the
only
which
the
by the
They are
subject.
the
of
'Rul; s al-Masglil
for
theme in
takes
work
work
on the
evidence
a central
by simply
field
the
of
among
prevailed
The selection
paratively
selected
of
reasonable
is,
indeed,
cases which
a result
expressions
selected
which
include
This
rulings.
of its
On the
kind
in
the
he presents
Moreoever
amount.
first
of
or in
is
This
literature
Ikhtil9f
ecIDlars
a variety
views
which
producing
contemporaries
I
accompanying
view
his
Zamakhsharl'
such a situation
of
in
with
opponents.
issue
rulings,
existing
of the
objective
of providing
support
the
f literature
Ikhtil;
and fresh
of new evidence
The significance
and his
writers
habit
the
is
he breaks
which
of the
concerned.
a)
in
for
and Qiy9s
parties
common feature
the
of careful
the
the
presentation
this
evidence
observation
in
recognised
is
work
which
a comis
and speculation,
of evidence
is
to fit
probably
the
the
subject.
a new idea
about
the
application
of
43
-
from
of evidence
that
is
the
by the Hanafites
authorised
is
application
hardly
The present
achievement
does not
scholar
the method
found
ever
work
by any particular
or in
in
the
of his
but serious
Jelthough
works in Islamic
and literature...
Two important
It
through
and wide
legal
subject.
out yet,
What follows
is an attempt
to understand
subject.
al-Yashsl7af
and Ws
us with
al-
information
stages in this
Zamakhsharl passed
first
respect;
when he became
which
of the existing
3..
original
says,
I keep silent;
His
his
on the
reading
two different
Zamakhsharl.
evidence
is
thought
jurisprudence
Zamakhsharl
angry
The work
and evidence
thought.
seems that
a mujtahid
Shgfiltes.
the materials
materials.
of Zamakhsharl,
works
are, relevant.
Such
rulings.
selecting
effort
evidence
Masg3il
of
the
studies
such studies
linguistics
ShafVite
that
b) Zamakhsharl-ts
Several
the
the works
suggest
either
of arranging
as a result
to
in
He applies
Sunna.
attitude
'If,
they
ask me about
my silence
shows that
legal
Cf. Zamakhsharl,
on it
is
Zamakhshari I did
schools
on this
as a =, tahid
my madhhabo I do not
safer'
not
commit
This
is
himself
clear
to
in his time.
al-li-qliq,
1.
when he expresses
1, P-9-
get
any
44
-
his
Sb
al-Kashaf.
about
in
view
In regard
the
with
is
to
the
According
Qur2an,
Sunna,
he expresses
Qur19n_,. His
of the
QUr3Ea,.
QurlEn
Eknaff
'is
and the
Qiyas_or
on the
; that
the
interrupted
in
believes
application.
the
subject
Qurl5n
of
_Qiy-as
transmitters3.
but
On the
verses
verses
not
the
of
both
by the
by the
Ijm7a"
hand he
other
4
of 11L, Irac, and equally
the validity
In
origin.
be abrogated
transmitters,
law
(anology).
of abrogated
abrogated
agree
of Shariva
root
and
subject
could
seems to
of Qur3Bnic
are
on the
Sunna of uninterrupted
Sunna of
strongly
fact,
attitude
theory
that
(consensus)
Ijm3c
in
its
and
law Zamakhsharl
considers
sourcesi
his
theory
of Sharlita
which
to him these
addition
opposes
the
of
He produces
and for
case,
a great
the views
provides
His
idea
on various
neither
1.
Cf.
2.
Schacht
in al-Kashsh;
many rulings
of different
himself
he inclines
on this
is
rulings
scholars,
-to
are presented.
Sh3fil
and with
in
f.
Frequently
he
in
each
as much as possible
take
in
seen clearly
67
in nost--cases
with
theory
legal
theory
classical
fourfold;
idea
the
his
if
anindependent'view
f where his
al-Kashsh;
He appears
to agree
some , but
in
possible.
decisions
Ab Han-ifa
with
he agrees
others
Zamakhshar1l
al-Kashsh.;
has discussed
Jurisprudence,
this
Oxford
Zamakhshari, 7
1967t
f,
subject
Cf.
4.
Ibid.,
vol.
2, pp.
5-
Ibid.,
vol.
2, pp* 232,252,298.
6.
For detailed-rulings
7.
An example
for
this
ruling
8.
An example
for
this
case see,
cit.,
2, PP- 158,214,
in his
1,
vol-
The oTiginsof
Pp. 446,539-
Muhammadan
P- 1-
3-
op.
vol.
vol.
2, p.
217.
233,252.
on this
point
see note
see Zamakhshari,
Ibid.,
vol.
of
op.
1,
the
text
cit.,
P- 526.
1,
p.
274.
45
-
Zamakhsharils7
idea,
well-documented
idea
primary
528 H.
is
1,
clear
during
idea
therefore
on this
it
when the
author
evidence
for
had reached
the
suggestion
that
the
Zamakhsharl
*The brilliant
)f Ab Han1fa
th
of the
are
and others
scholars
water,
age of
Zamakhsharl
only
his
indeed
in
the
year
This
sixty-one.
work
IJtih9d
practised
as a Mugallid
the
Earth
are Hanafite
I
of Islam
scholars
to
like
the
religion
a bubble
sincere
of
science
joined
"They
...
- they
true
are
on the
disappears
which
with
by the
as the Hanafite
A,07 Hanifa,
is
this
f was completed
Zamakhshar, ir says,
2.
that
presumed
his
life.
most of his
-scholars
is
Al-Kashsh;
subject.
is
in al-Kashsh3f
of jurisprudence
surface
4.
1)
These statements
followers,
but
they
a follower
of the
appear
do not
entail
Hanafites.
of AbU Han1fa
to be in favour
the
that
conclusion
and his
Zamakhsharl
The statements
was
the
author
composed al-Xashs1raf5.
Moreover
that
of the
This
Hanafite
0
rite,
is
enough to
because
his
show
idea
1,
Ibid.,
2,
Cf. Zamakhshari,
3.
Ibid.,
4-
5.
in al-Kaphsh9f,
vol.
1, p. 297.
(Atwgq al-Dhahab)
in al-Kashsh-af,
vol.
1, P- 368.
vol.
3, P. 371.
Nawabigh al-Kalim,
Cairo 1960-61,
p. 223.
p. 198.
p. 88.
- 46 -
in
this
in
attitude
we try
this
favour
to'fix
the
is
presumed
it
c ompleting
because
idea
of the
Hanafite
only
this
it
is
scientific
academic
research
field.
preference
because
is
the Hanafites.
the
when he changed
time
some difficulties
arise
In
change occurred.
the
after
impossible
does not
year
before
show that
Thus he changed
late
that
when
of
spite
of his
year,
in favour
attitude
period.
either
to be presumed
His
satisfaction.
It
madhhab.
in his
of
change happened
528 H.
We have no information
although
about
when this
in al-Kashshaf
in a particular
ested
idea
the Hanafites,
time
that
al-Kashsh3f,
the
information
of
exact
the
to
similar
as we lack
Even so,
his
is
composition
that
for
about
this
the motive
was*a
the. Hanafite
Zamakhshari r devoted
for
question
view
this
of
is
change,,
intellectual
based on
most of his
life
to
the
47
-
CHAPTER FOUR
DEVELOPMM
literal
The original
It
on the
Prophet4
and as the
will
exclude
It-is
of the
Cf.
science
of
opinion
deal
with
two parts;
schools
Thus it
dis-
of this
is
that
claimed
is
the
(ummatl)
is
the
of the
as defined
half
second
six
century
among the
Prophet's
1) Ikhtil;
f in
of
above,
the
of Hijra
companions.
general,
and
Backgroun4,
London
3, P. 138,11.
1971,
al-lslZmiyya,
p.
Cairo
Wehr,
258(n. d. )p
vol.
19 P- 41-
in Encyclopaedia
of Islam,
vol.
2, P- 458.
(n.
Tabarli,
Ikhtilgf
',
d. ), P- 4 (Introduction),
Beirut
al-Puqaha
0
N. J. Coulson,
A History
Law, Edinburgh
1964, p. 102.
of Islamic
Cf.
Cf. SuYWI,
6, p. 102, FairU*za-
1966, vol.
Benghazi,
T; rl: kh al-Madh;
Ikhtilgf,
subject
of al-Xhil3fiyya-t.
al-Muh-it,
0
Pxe-Islamic.
from
opinion
of Modern Written
Goldziher,
legal
among my people
the
limited,
of
of principles
in which
to refer
2.
The authority
tradition
'difference'
jurisprudence
or between
question
few decades
TFj al-Ar3s,
Ab7u Zahra,
Schacht,
first
into
*s
al-Qam;
Dictionary
is
differences
Cf. Zubaidl,
badhi,
2o
the
classified
2) Birth
will
involved
to
Islamic
is
of God%5.
here
period
century
the
"Difference
The discussion
second
from
bounty
the
of
in
(consensus).
the. U-3
had said,
sense
on the
not
was derived
of
LITERATURE
among jurisprudents
opiniori
cases,
with
agreement
a sign
of
detailed
contrasted
1.
meaning
to differences
it
OF IMILAP
cairo
(n. d. ) vol.
1, P. 13-
2, P- 78
48
1The term
Islamic
the
title,
is
is
on rkhtilaf
jurist,
Cairo
1357.
to himself
Sh3ficir
uses
quoting
his
that
composed by Shgfifl
a work
Cairo 1902
But Ab5
work under
wa-I-bn-Ab"
Lailg,
Both works
seem to me to resemble
by Ab al--
edited
each
of AbU Y5suf
Hanafite
jurist
account
indicates
that
Muhammad during
and copied
Kitab
whereas
to Abu Hanifa
0
referring
after
Cf. Goldzihert
had for
Sh3fill
his
the
in
stay
former's
vIr9q,
works
fihi
in
Cairo
1968 with
The Zhiris,
wa
Ibn
close
this
Therefore,
certainly
Abu Hanifa
been in
and during
4.
A biographical
of Sh3fiti.
a time
published
ma Ikhtalafa
works
by Muhammad b. al-Hasan
and
00
3.
Muhammad was a
as well
and a contempomary
the present
was transmitted
latter's
among the
leading
sumed that
in
r
Hanifa,
Ab
of
view.
was counted
studied
the view
quoting
after
(i. ee he agrees)
The work
it
contact
time
is
to be pre-
from Muhammad,
originated
al-Umm bearing
Abi Laila
he had
the
an Abi
Abu Zahrat
OP-cit.
jvol.
2, p. 245.
title
Yusuf.
3- Cf. SarakhJ,
4.
believes
Goldziher
old.
in
particularly
it
referring
2,
comparatively
Abi Hanifa
Ikhtilgf
expression
1.
literatureq
Islamic
in contents,
other
with
in
as used
famous Hanafite
the
general
12
-r
49
Ira-qlyyln
Kern,
F.
al
ed.
,
Wafa al-Afghani,
it
f in
known treatise
Ikhtilgf
entitled
the
Ikhtilgf
jurisprudence,
oldest
Ysuf,
Ikhtil;
49
-
and is
later
legal
Sh7afi? ils
his
than
re markable
that
of Ab YUsuf.
activities
mostly
work
in Egypt,
was completed
Ikhtil9f
the
second
During
the
These legal
produced
a vast
amount of legal
human activities,
lived.
(of
ment of
this
Madh; hib
Madhahib
rulinkpwhich
individuals.
of
half
second
)a
great
of
Syria
by various
out
to all
relating
number
and devoted
studies
such as 'Iraq,
on the
their
aspects
decisions
for
and
scholars
of
were in
in which
and environment
place
became materials
had not
yet
develop-
the
it
point
differs
in
been established
by jurists
were produced
On this
from
were the
this
period,
achievement
a-later
period
Ikhtil7af
in
the
of the
.
The following
and the
first
1.
KhaddGri,
half
are the
of the
OP- citop
second
third
works
century
and the
first
half
century
composed during
third;
P- 15.
the
second
of
when the
were established.
Works of
Cf.
beginning,
oldest
literature.
The several
and the
the
legal
on many points
fact,
in
is
the
Hijra
in
decisions
course,
These views,
of Ikhtil3f,
forms.
were carried
depending
to each other,
contrast
they
and of
the
the
onwards
centuries
which
studies
particular
subject
of AbU YUsuf
about
the
about
appeared
various
and third
second
learn
period
taking
multiplied
in
literature.
which
From this
that
was reported
Egypt
contains
the work
us to
enable
in Islam
century.
increasingly
Islamic
in
place
partly
so evidently
known in
on Ikhtil9f
work
took
al-Umm which
it
Moreover.
century
50
1)
(d.
182 H. ),
by Ab5 al-Wafal
edited
2) Al-HuJaJ
Kufa
wa Ahl
Only the
first
it
Earlier
al-Madina,
in
1326/1908
Muslim
(d.
Kull
his
with
short
Minhum,
FarIq
annotation
al169 H. )
in Haiderabad.
the
Anwar Ahmadi"I
ma Yahill
f al--UlamVfl
Kit; b Ikhtil;;
wo Yah-rum wa Tluija
from
was published
Lucknow
press,
part
(d.
been published
of this
Al
al-Shaibani
al-Hasan
1357.
Cairo
Ikhtilaf
fi
or al-HuJja
b.
by Muha=ad
in
published
al-Afghani,
al-14iibina
by AbU Ysuf
Ab! Lail;,
Ab'i"__Hanifawa Ibn
lkhtilgf
min al-AshTiba
by Ab Muhammad Abdull;
h b.
213 H. )2.
f1hi
b ma Ikhtalafa
4) Kit;
Ab; Hani-fa
wa Ibn
Abl Lail7agan
Abl' Y5suf.
Kit3b
Ikhtilgf
Kith
Siyar
7) Kit3b
8) t9b
lCalik wa al-Sh3fili
al-AUZ351.
ca13 Muhamad
al-Radd
al-Urasiy
9) Wa Turiam
fl
min Ikhtilaf
Siyar
Ibn
al-Hasan.
al-fIrgqiyy-in.
Usba thumma
al-Sabiy
al-Auzg"I
Yam7ut.
10)-Wa Turjam
fir
Ikhtil;
f M-alik
Al
Ikhtil;
al-$Iraqiyyln
IRhtil;
al-6IrZqiyyin'fi
wa al-Sh-afill
-ab al-
Hanb-dh'.
1.
Cf.
Matsumi,
11)
Wa Turiam
12)
Wa Turjam-_fi
13)
fli
Wa
Ikhtilgf
Qabl
an Yabd;
2.
Cf. Brockelmann,
al fuqahal
Bay"'
in Islamic
8, p. 215-
op. cit.,
Salah-uha.
Tah7MVs Ikhtilaf
f-iBab
al-lIrgqivyi-n
B3b al-Salam.
s"pp.
1, p. 120.
Studies,
51
14)
-Wa
f-i B; b al-Bacw;
min Ikhtilgf
al-rTr;
f!
al-rIra-qiyyln
wa al-Kafala
7'n.
qiY3r,
BEb al-Hiw7ala
wa
f-i al-Kafala
al-glr3qiyy-in
wa al-
Hamm3la wa al-Dain.
17) Wa Turiam fl
Bab al-Sharika
al-Iraqiyyin
wa Ghsirihi.
wa al-$Itq
18) Wa fl
Ikhtilgf
f al-OIr;
Ikhtil;
fli
qiyy-in
Bab al-fAria
wa
Akl
al--Ghila.
,
19) Wa fl
min Ikhtil;
Bb al-Ghasb
20) Wa fl'
B9b al-Sadaqa
f al-Ir3qiyyIn.
min Ikhtilgf
wa al-Hibba
al-
cIrqiyyln.
21) Wa flIkhtilaf
alLIr3qiyyin.
22), F-i:'
B; b al-Ajlr
al-$'Irgqiyyln
-Ikhtilaf
23) Wa fl' Awwal Ikhtil;
wa al-lj;
ln.
f al-tIx3qiyy:
(d. 204 H. )
seems that
the trend
of writing
Malik
mentioned in this
Zufar
Islamic
number of eminent
During
prudence.
the
The
literature
were Ab
al-Auzgtl,
of the
many parts
period
scholars.
Muhammadb. al-Hasan,
changing
in Cairo
mostly
scholars
a large
concentrated
Hanifa,
;
h3ficit
in his remarkable
Ta.
this
than
in
previous
studies
world,
which
scholars
period
the
the
of
in
resulted
extended over
the
in
who specialised
divergence
previous
trend
increasingly
period.
Ikhtil5f
of
production
Islamic
opinions
This
literature,
of
juris-
became wider
tendency
which
causes
mostly
the
52
-
concentrated
Instead
more ideas
it
with
Ikhtilaf
al-Puoah7a2.
the
than
other
Ab Bakr,
Iy3s
second
half
b.
al-Rabirg,
of the
title
third
Ahmad, Ishaq,
Ibn
Abl
Ikhtil;
f literacentury,
Tthm7an al-
Ibn
al-Hay,
used was
fourth
above were
b.
Jacfar,
of
and the
century
ZlYadj
Ibn
scholars.
was currently
in works
mentioned
b.
Rabila,
which
al-Hasan
b.
al-Hasan
different
mentioned
al-Hasan,
cUbaidull3h
b. Mutgwiya,
Thaurl,
10
Fiqh
those
gUbaidullah
Butti,
and the
appear,
two or three
the
Scholars
in
to
related
occupied
tuTe
between
on comparison
Shabrama,
Ibn Abil
Zanad,
Yal*-a
al-Layth't
b. Sac-ld,
alTbaid
Ab;
Works of Ikhtil3f
third
The following
century
and the
1) Kit;
second
in
written
half
fourth
the
of
century
second
f al-F*uoah; l al-Kabir,
Fuqah3: 3 al-Saghir,
half
Ikhtilaf
(d.
third
of -the
by Ahmad b. Nasr
al-Fuqahal,
Kit;
b Ikhtilaf
310 H. ).
al-Khiliifiyv;
shed by Schacht,
Parts
Leiden
1.
7
Ibn Nadim,
2*
3-
al-Fihrist,
Cairo
1933,
1929,
P- 327.
of this
p.
al-
al-Marwazll
2
'Abdul
b.
Zakariyya
Yahya b.
Rahm3n al-S3jll'
o0
3) Kit7ab ikhtil7af
by Ab Jafar
b.
al-FuqaI03
Tabarl
the
century;
b Ikhtil;
2) Kit3b
the
and the
century
are works
fourth
in
by Abu Yahya
,
(d.
307 H. ).
Jarlr
al-
and by F. Kern,
Cairo
299.
2, p. 226.
1902.
*
..
53
-
4) Kit3b
baina
al-Ikhtilgf
by the
published
Kit9b
b.
Islamic
(d.
This
f alUlamP,
Ahmad
6
Institutet
Research
fl *:' Ikhtil;
al-Ishrg-f
al-Mundhir
321 H. ).
(d.
b. Muhammad al-Tahgwi
bv Ab; Ja9faT
al-Puash3l'.
Islamabad,
1971.
by Ab Bakr Muha=ad
0
310 H..)
3
the science
Birth'of
During
the
as I have just
increased.
of its
second half
third
century
development
the
mentioned,
Islamic
of the
of al-Khil9fiyy-at
jurisprudence
of Ikhtil7af
as a whole
tendency
activities
Polemic
schools.
followers
which
of
they
2.
and for
justify
which
cit.,
Vol.
2, p.
they
the
zenith
came into
of Taqlid
ideas
later
being.
development
of the
began.
schools
their
argued
their
against
of
recognised
these
The
hib
oppcnenis.
al-Khilgf,,
his
Kashf
al-
Cf. Schacht,
126.
'
by
HZjl: Khalfacin
was used
lal-Khilafi377at'
Zunun, vol-.
Ibn
had to
had reached
on the
on the
of
literature
period
followers
century,
had an effect
only
fourth
p. 292.
The term
between
followed
Ibid.,
Thus the
centred
each school
1.
819;
5.
certainly
which
legal
only four
Consequently
century
and the
op.
cit.,
vol.
vol.
, P. 79.
1, pp.
818,819.
op. cit.,
loc.
1,
cit.
54
-
beginning
Thus the
Islamic
of the
literature
of
the root
is
by either
in
of founders
present
important
Wsls
kind
on this
the works
the
the views
their
This
analysis
work has
its
therefore
of al-Khilgf'
than others
in this
the
present
period,
but
or Hanbalites,
no longer
period
although
schools
b.
Malikites,
Shgfi'Itesq
his
subject;
science
of
being'in
al-Nazar.
contain
among jurists
of the
as a founder
work
which
sections
of its
and Hanafites
0
The ideas
by tlbdullEh
L--Ois
first
the
Hanafites,
Sha-ficites
was introduced
his
eight
divergence
regarded
A great
into
divided
been considered
author
430 H. ) in
(d-
of
came into
of al-Khilafiyygt.
al-Dabsll
book is
This
of, al-Khilefiyyat
The science
Tmar
science
respect4.
direct
view
but
they
the ITadhghib.
of
1. --lbid. 9 p. 819.
:1
2.
Cf.
DabEsl, Talsis
3-
Cf.
Ibn qutlubugha,
Flilgel
accepted
this
al-Nazar.
op.
der Hanefitischen
al-Khilgf
was established
loc.
al-Nazar
cit.
).
C1 Ikhtil;
(n. d. ),
P. 36.
cit.,
view
Klassen
Ta2sIS
Cairo
which
Goldziher
was mentioned
in
his
ber
'This
(see
vol.
1, p. 819.
that
mentions
P- 301,
Rechtsgelehrten,
--
pp. Sg.
Goldziher,
die
gilm.
with
op.
cit
his
55
-
Works of
The following
centuries
Ikhtil3f
in
the
fifth
and sixth
composed during
are works
the
centuries
fifth
and sixth
(A. H. );
Works of Shafi-Cites
1) Kit;
b al-Khilafiyyat
by Ahmad b. Husain
(do 458 H. )
BaihaqI
2) Mukhtasar al-Khilgfiy-vat
This
al-
work
is
gAbdullgh b. Farh.
by
Abu
,
of the
a su=ary
work
of al-Baihaqi,
al-KhiliTfiyyat.
Al-wasg"il
al-Shgfif!
(d- 480 H. )
Kit3b
Khil;
al-Durrat
f baina
f!
al-Mudivya
al-Shaficl
(d-
ra Waqafa fihi
4
3-yya wa al-Hanafiyy
cAbdul Malik
Abil al-Ma911
by Ibn Jam; ga
alby
b. Ahmad al-Juwa-4n-i,
Imam
445 H. )
al-Haramain
o
5) Kit; b al_Nu, %t5, by Ab; Is4; q Ibr; h-im b.
cAll
al-
nakhtasar
by
al-K
al-Abdgr'i
fii
sl-Sh;
le
2.
3.
4-
Cf. Subkl,
6.
Cf.
.0
7.
Ibid.
Tabari,
op. cit-,.
op.
cit.,
vol-
vol.
loc.
al-Puqahg7,
al-sh7afitl
3, P- 4-
1, p. 673-
3, P. 88.
cit.
by Abu Bakr
(d.
507 H. )
56
-
8) TarTqat
f baina
al-Khili;
fiyya
al-Shi7ficiYYa
b. Mhammad al-
al-Husain
462 H. )
(d-
Maruruzi
wa al-Hana-'
Works of Hanafites
1) Kit9b
Kitab
al-Tajrld,
f
Khil;
2,
fi
al-Taqrib
Ylasa3il
al-
(d. 428 H. )
Tbaidullah
2) Ta3sTs al-Nazargby
by "A19 al-17in
3) lfiikhtalaf
4) Al-Tariqatal-Ridawivya
(d-430
al-Dab-sii
Muhammad b.
0
by Red, al-Diln
,
'Abdul
al-Sarakhshl
544 H. )
5, .
5) ManziTma. by Najm al-bln
6) Ru3Us al-Masa3il,
(d.
Tmar
(d- 552 H. )
Hamid
al-Samarqandli
.
(d.
b.
al-Nasaf'l
(d- 537 H. )
538 H. )
Works of I-Talikites
1)
Ru2us
6,
al-Y. asg3il
1.
Cf.
2.
34-
6.
Cf. Tabarl, op. cit.,
p.
0
Cf. ITS Egyptian National Library,
5-
Ibn Qutlubugha,
6.
Cf.
Sh&ikh
Cf.
Ibn.
MS Egyptian
National
Xhaldn,
Library,
op. cit.,
op. cit-,
Shanqitl7,
op.
IFUyUn al-Adille,
op.
cit.,
no.
1523 (Fiqh
7,
by
Ibn
sh7afit'i
P.
(Fiqh
)
1165
Hanaf-l,
no.
P- 72.
loc.
cit.,
vol.
1,
cit.
p. 820.
al-Qasgr
0
H. )
57
-
2) Mukhtasar
3) Kii-ab
al-Talkhls
1,
by Ibn
al-Saggt'i
al-
4) Al-Ishr3f
9A112'al-Baghdadi(d.
b.
in Tunis
(n. d. ) in
al-Khil5f,
by ".Abdul
422 H. ).
It
Wahh; b
was published
two volumes.
Works of Hanbalites
1) Kitib
by Ab al-lqafg
al-Puun,
'All
b.
9Aqll
al-
Baghd7adl (d-
(n. d. ), edited
431 H. ).#Beirut
by G. Maqdisle
3
by gAbdul laa7aliq al-Hgshiml
al-Mas3li,
2) RulUs
(d.
470 H. )
Al-TOliq
I
fi
al-Kablr
Mas; 3il
al-Khilafiyyat
al-Pimma4,
baina
(d.
526 H. )
Oa13 Madh; hib
4) Al-Ishrif
5Awn al-DIn
1.
Ibn Rhald5n,
2.
Ibid.
3-
Cf.
Ibn Rajob,
4-
Cf.
Mavsu-m'11',op.
5.
Ibid.,
p.
op.
217.
Yahyg b. Hubaira
op.
cit.,
cit.,
al-AshT;
1, p. * 820.
loc.
vol.
cit.
8,
p. 218.
(d-
f5
by AIZ al-Muzaffar
j
555 H. )
56
CHAPTER FIVE
1--
are in
Most jurists
Law into
four
Schacht
and the
that
habit
the
of
by Sh7aficl
the
the
jurisprudence
the
Qurlgn,
This
in his
sources
the
classical
of
theory
Islamic
the
Sunna,
theory
of the
essentials
of
dividing
(analogy).
Qiy3sl
introduced
claims
of Usul
or sources;
principles
(consensus),
originally
theory
The*classical
LITERATURE
were created
Ijm7ac
was
2,
and
by
Shfitjr3.
But this
tive
for
There
one.
the
classification
laws
are
at
regulating
least
as fully
life
the
in
faithful
of the
or authorita-
all
its
canonical
different
aspects4.
These f our sources,
QuIr6n, were
subject
definition.
flicting
to
detailed
Cf.
Abdul
2.
Cf.
Hamidull7ah,
Wahh7ab Khall;
Sources
Islamic Quarterly,
Cf. Schacht,
Cf. Schacht,
of
their
and even
indicating
the co-n-
on these. principles5.
UEZ1 al-Piah,
Islamic
validity
accounts
schools
cIlm
f,
Law -A
Kuwait#1972,
p.
new approach,
in
12.
The OriginSof
Cf. Hamidullah,
as to
controversy
1.
3-
op. cit.,
An Introduction
MlihammadanJurisprudence,
Oxford 1967, P- 1.
p. 205.
to Islamic
59
-
We are not
to'discuss
going
here
is
to
these
discuss
in
principles
their
detail,
because
to the
application
Ikhtil;
literature.
2This
legal
Their
recognised
attitude
to this
is
theory
where
of the
is
theory
classical
schools.
writings
Theapplication
accorded
to these
tendency
certainly
resulted
on the
case.
This
schools
in rulings
variety
of
on the
To illustrate
this
is
subject
in
they
from
each
individual
between
We find
the
within
the following
the
or on the
adduced.
rulings
orthodox
seen in
differ
dissimilarity
problem
of the
clearly
principles,
at and evidence
arrived
evidence
by most jurists
Nevertheless
applied.
priority
other
theory
are
legal
also
same school.
as
selected
examples:
Different
the
of
Performance
is
wine)
dition
that
minor
valid
then
2.
valid
of the
take
the
for
grounds
to the
yourselves
Cf.
Text,
Cf.
Baghd3di,
pp.
(wuda")
Qurlan,
clean
with
5.6
this
it
...
for
from
a tiahis
performing
minor
ifye
(date
nabldh
who derive
Hanafites,
Prophet
of the
pTinciples
ablution
The Malikites
ablution
on the
recognised
minor
according
one night
on the priority
considerations
is
ablution
find
not
no water,
The Sh;ifiOlites
and
1,2.
al-Ishr3f
lalg
Yasg3il
al-'Khilgf,
Tunis
(n. d. )q
vol- 1,
3.
Translation
Cf. Text,
A. YUsuf
All,
The Holy
p. 2.
0
Our3gn,
Beirut
1965,
vol-
1,
p. 242.
6o
1
Hanbalites
of
them appear
a liquid
it
have the
is
to base it
is
which
not
valid
as the Malikites
same view
not
for
either
to the
on reasoning
for
valid
use during
a journey
of the
minor
but
case,
both
'7dh
is
as nabi
that
effect
the
performing
interpretation
Different
on the
at home
ablution
2.
same principles
a) Qur3gn
person
(qadhf);
then
(shaha-da)
"And
is
those
four
(to
and reject
4.
verse
I...
to the Hanafites,
their
support
their
against
Sh7afitltes
on the
-Unless
ever
they
for
consider
that
Qurln,
them., with
24-4
not
eighty
his
is
evidence
24.4,5)
but
(their
and mend
adduce
conduct);
1.
Cf.
Egshiml,
ROUs al-MasaJil,
Damascus,
no.
2744,
fo-
1, ES al-
Zghiriyya.
2.
Cf.
Text,
p.
3.
Cf.
Text,
p.
230.
4-
Cf.
A. Yusuf
gAll,
5-
Cf.
Text,
p.
230.
6.
Cf.
A. YUsuf
vAll,
7.
Cf.
Baghd3dI,
op.
8.
Cf.
Hashimi,
op.
cit.,
OP- cit-,
Vol.
1, P. 897.
op.
loc.
cit.
cit.,
cit.,
vol.
2,
Cairo
p.
loc.
cit.
289.
1351,
vol.
9,
(Qurlan
thereafter
repent
evidence
after:
same evidence
his
on the
flog
-
allegation)
evidence
But the
chaste
intercourse
of unlawful
accusation
valid.
a charge
valid.
a false
According
in future
not
who launch
transgressors,
for
he repented.
witnesses
stripes
the
was flogged
PP- 431.
61
-
b) Sunna
The last
Zuhr) is
0
the view
moment of the
prayed
when the
length
of the
Malikites
opinion
that
their
half
the
the
with
sun passed
the
2
,
the
shadow of
last
on the
opinions
is
each thing
and the
Hanbalites4
0
afternoon
prayer
day he
day when the
itself
thing
are
is
thing.
as that
of the
when the
length
They also
base
mentioned.
in
pTeferences
on the
evidence
first
as the
is
"Gabriel
that,
second
al-
This
shadow.
the
and the
as long
tradition
Different
two days;
was as long
the
moment of
its
of
(waqt
prayer
on a traditio
meridian,
the
afternoon
length
prophet
But the
the
of the
who base it
the Hanafites,
of
of
is
time
choosing
same principle
a) Qur3gn
A person
the
ground
seriously
consider
to repeat
ye turn,
of
Ijtihgd;
the
it;
is
in
the
completing
it
he realises
the
direction
is
performed
valid
base this
they
there
deciding
prayer
facing
prayer
after
in
mistaken
that
his
performs
the
1.
Cf.
Text,
2.
Cf.
Baghd3dil",
3-
Cf.
Text,
4-
Cf.
t5ashiMll,
op.
5.
Cf.
Text,
22.
6.
Cf.
A. Yu-suf
on the Qurlgn
6
Presence of God... I.
and its
2.1155:
vol. 1, p- 57-
p.
gAll,
fo.
OP. cit.,
ZO.
vol-
1,
that
on
he was
The Hamfites
0
is not
performer
"oo., whithersoever
The Malikites
p. 18.
cit.,
of Qibla
of Qibla.
p.. 18.
op. cit.,
dire6tion
P- 49-
express
required
62
-
the
The former
the
as the Hanafites
same view
add other
from
the
Qiyas
anafites,
but
Qiyas
is
base this
forth,
not
and the
valid,
Qur39n 2.150
face
thy
whencesoever
in
the
and the
ruling
a tradition
a prayer
by the Xalikites
on the
turn
the
evidence.
indicates
which
circumstances
that
and
mentioned,
The Hanbalites
are also of the same view as the
0
they appear to base this
on the tradition
and the
mentioned
performed
from
evidence
had approved
prophet
on both
in
the
turn
ye are,
OF=
direction
thou
whencesoever
the
of
thither
face
it;
has to repeat
performer
3:
your
say the
The Sh9fi5Ites
Sacred
prayer
they
startest
Mosque;
and
#4.
....
b) Sunna
Performance
the
SalZm,
that
the
performance
additional
action
this
from
ofprayer
The Hanbalites
0
1.
Cf.
BaghdgdI,
2.
Cf.
Hi; shiml,
op.
3-
Cf.
Text,
22.
4-
Cf-
A. YZsuf
5-
Cf.
Text,
6.
Cf.
Baghd3d-1r' op.
p.
'Alli,
that
cit.,
op.
after
the
prophet
cit.,
26.
Vol.
1, p.
P- 31cit.,
take
Vol. 1, P. 70.
fo.
Vol.
lt
P. 98.
on the
should
during
the
of
performing
for
SujTTd al-Sahw
as the Malikites
same view
op. cit.,
the
tradition
The Malikites
be performed
unintentionally
tradition
have the
of
as required
should
occurred
the
be after
the performance
Sal; m, -but
the
-performing
derive
that
opinion
should
such an instruction5.
had given
prophet
incomplete
al-Sahw
the Hanafites,
to
according
the
express
of SujZd
60.
the
place
the
before
Sal; m if
They
sal3t.
had practised
on the
it
ruling
and
63
-
the
evidence
the
Sal6m;
it
1.
But the
they
say it
Sli-afi$ltes
base this
on the
be performed
should
that
tradition
the
before
had done
prophet
C) Qiys
Two persons
(option)
of Xhiygr
Condition
that
the
the
ground
that
tract
for
himself
during
object
the
ship
of
that
moment,
the
they
that
contract
is
dition
basis
are
the
the
that
that
if
the
on
fails
Xhiy3r
the
of
the
permit
belongs
it
Therefore
the
making
does not
seller
an object
The Hanafites
say
0
belongs to the seller,
on
during
of Xhiyar
of
the
same view
in
with
the
as the
the
conowner-
to him at
object
offer
returns
the
contract
have a different
buyer,
and therefore
without
the
Cf.
2.
Cf. Text,
P- 31-
3-
Cf. Text,
P- 75-
4-
Cf. Baghd3dl,
5-
Cf. Text,
Rgshimll-,
on the
ownership
op.
cit.,
op. cit.,
P- 75-
but
basis
that
should
not
that
view;
the
1, p. 249-
their
if
there
complete,
the
case,
of
performance
is
contract
The Hanbalites
a con-
because
its
in the future..
is
ownership
be transferred.
fo-'43.
vol.
the
of the seller
of RjZar.
a condition
1.
if
is
offer
on this
formulating
and acceptance,
to the
Hanafites
in
expression
can be transferred
ownership
completed
transferred
a contract
parties.
of KhiyFr
period
to use a different
The Sh9fill'tes
valid
both
of
purchase
of Xhiygr
decision
the
to be transferred.
on the
appear
argument
the
condition
The Malikites
but
for
indicates
object
to him without
for
make a contract
pexformed
It
is
are
is
like
of the
'4
64
-..
same opinion
-C-1 ites
Shafi
as the
on the
Different
is
same legal
enough to
school;
in
choose
a ruling
of the
by tanning.
are
dissimilar.
He says that
alive,
by tanning
is
that
Qi3; ah,
but
its
skin
if
licked
he says
is
not
On the
of
the
fifth
hand Ibn
prophet
said,
another
tradition
'The
a dirty
It
wicked
earnings
he said,
H-ashimir,
op.
2.
Cf.
ShEfigl,
al-Umm,
Cairo
3.
Cf.
Shirgill,
al-Nukt,
fo.
are
...
1967,
vol.
price
1, Pe Be
6a.
Ibn
Farh,
Mukhtasar
s1-Yh. il9fiyyat,
5. Cf.
Ibn
Farh,
a
op.
loc.
cit.
F
fo.
it
is
live,
a dish
since
also
traditions
126.
fo.
case on
same as a pig3.
of a dog is
4- Cf.
cit.,
the
alive
this
while
Baihaq11,
the
this
a dog and
is
it
a pig,
the
drawn
can be purified
bases
like
is
case from
OThe price
Cf.
cit.
this
is
not
bases
with
that
animal
that
FaTh mentions
derives
century,
is
is
school,
also
is
skin
ruling
associated
century,
as an example:
a dog's
this
it
problem,
school
while
this
produce
the
Shgfiite
clean
nrast be washed it
animal
other
it
is
by tanning.
purified
by this
which
because
that
which
of an animal
fifth
the
of
from
of the
skin
of an ahimal
a jurist
shlrazi,
that
uncleannessis
the
whereas
to
legal
consider
sources
founder
Shafifl,
case on Qiy5s.
a pig*while
But the
the
demonstrate
SlZfivite
unanimously
scholars
school
a position
to
order
evidence
same ruling
on the
in
not
every
ShNfivite
purified
same legal
evidence
We are here
school.
evidence-from
is
the
amount of
a vast
on the
evidence
in
There
6a.
a jurist
that
of a dog,,
vicious
the
(KhalTith)lk
65
-
Moreover
Zamakhshari
on the
that
reports
Qpr3gn 5-4
the
to you (for
"Forbidden
of the rule
the
works
of
the
works
of Ikhtil3f
from
the
the
writings
the solution
of
of Usiil
science
legal
I,
Shfi,
to this
ritual
'Umra,
across
the
on the
and applied
chosen for
are
and b) A person
tiaditiorn
basis
theory
our
discussion;
in
originated
and Qiyas.
that
its
who is
back to the
he was a pioneer
in
properly
handling
of
the
The performance
that
tradition3,
on the
it
is
whereas
gro-und of
a state
of. major
the
of
impurity
walks
interpretation
5Umra
wUmra is
ritual
the Hanafites
recommended
the
latter
and the
(sunna)
our text,
that
from
-arises
the
r
Sh3fivites.
basis
it
Cf.
Text,
2.
Cf.
A. Ysuf
Cf. Text,
ff.
p.
op.
cit.,
1, p.
vol.
66.
p.
66,
-67.
0
obligatory
from
originally
66.
tAlli,
is
2399
The former
of Prophetic
Prophet4.
of tradition.
1.
of different-
a point
on the
consider
tradition
another
in
as appears
Ibid.,
of the
between
consideration
consider
in
a) Performance
mosque.
a) Performance of a ritual
4.
from
which
as a model,
to
applied'properly
rulings.
Two rulings
here,
was not
a number of rulings
to be derived
dead meat....
are
This
in which
food)
ruling
rulinps
of Usul
period.
Qur3gn appear
To find
the
later
Shafitites
(wajib)
The problem
conflicting
66
-
in
The problem
arose
from
originally
Scholars
the
Quilln,
Some interpret
'Umra
and the
interpretation
complete
indication
of
the EEL
in
fact,
includes
he is
inclined
to
say that
plete
is
in
on the
record9d;
L3sj5l
imposes
that
ported
is
which
the
J.sexcluded
and the
from
the
is
the
recommended
gUmra
0
....
is
the
0;
...
also
other
me-
pilgrimage
Mmra
therefore
the
and-thus
......
theme is
It
comis,
reading
and the
unless
and
command to
a variant
to it...
of the Haij,
category
The command to
IU-=a
has no
Haii
alone
effect
that
is
obligatory
Sh3ficl
meaning
said
that
the EEL
0
duties
obligatory
effect
it
and recommended,
Perform
a different
prophet
(effort)
jihd
'Umra is
gives
recomis
evidently
obligatory
basis
first
injunction
case of Q 2,196,
the
a command to perform
evidence
the
rUm
Umra , but
duties
the
'Umra is
or recommendation.
both
4Perfomm both
as,
the
of
word
"Umra
and the
who prefer
analysis,
and the
obligation
either
it
interpret
performance
to Zamakhsharl's
command to
complete,
the
of the
the IaL
The scholars
that
consider
According
mended.
as "Complete
....
examination,
interpretations
different
our
2.196:
it
to
according
4 and others
them ....
fact,
to have offered
appear
tg
in
question
prefers
of
second
on the
obligatory,
the
the
Qur3; n,
3n,
ground
and it
is
"as
I know...,,
1.
Cf.
Qurtubli,
2.
Cf.
Zamakhshari,
al-Kashshaf,
3-
Cf.
Sh3fici,
cit.,
Shaf1ti,
Jamic li
op.
in
that
it
preferred
is
Vol.
to the
literal
scholars
(ahl
has adopted
Caixo
1, p.
2p P- 113-
the
near
by the
other-words,
Ahk; ni al-Qurlan,
Vol.
to
interpretation
261.
1964,
the
al-lilm)
a particular
Vol.
2, P. 365.
67
-
of the veise.
exegesis
Whatever
the
Qux'3n
from
and not
the
that
to have agreed
appear
the
impurity
.
a state
Hanafites
a person
prohibited
a'state
it
is
that
is
prohibited
who is
in
a state
'But the
the
conflict
arises
here
The question
reference
basis
on the
permitted
again
tion3
of
interpret
it
the
in a state
He who lacks
adopt
believe,
of
approach
text
is,
ceremonial
let
water,
this
of prayer
view.
not
different
sources.
except
those
who merely
Cf.
Text,
p.
walk
Q=3Znic
impurity
it
*
except
Adcording
approach
those
interpretation
in
of prayer....
2. Ibid.
0
"
This
interpreta-
as OprayerO
not
first-
prayertravelling.
9&*0
The Hana-
becomes,
10 ye who
a state
is
and others
to the
who are
26.
the
origin,
different
arisesfrom
...
consider
z
_e.;
00 ye who believe,
across
the
in
that
opinion
seems to
prophet
or who is
the
in
The
the
The text
of
who,
IJ
(mosque).
The second
places
of
'
him perform
that
impurity
are
Some interpret
as d Places
interpretation,
fites
a question
The conflict
the word
a person
basis
ruling.
mosque
on the
from
-Ar- ') 1
Y-'
L
is
a Qur3; nic
the mosque.
Sh3fi5Ites
from
originally
across
of major
of Qiyas
essentially
is
concerns
problem
walks
is
sides
of major
the
across
walks
of menstruation
Tmra
in a state
it
that
consider
who is
(junub),
impurity
of
both
subject,
Thus it
on a similar
ruling
of major
institution
tradition.
b) A person
The other
on the
conclusion
of
ceremonial
the view
of
the
impurity
68
-
Shafitites
The scholars
the
ruling
to walk
also
it
is
reports
who is
And he says,
to
Zaid
in
the
of
the
which
rulings
fifth
of
are
to the
impurity
of major
Qurlan
4.43
(la
permitted
to walk
Malik
balsa)
across
the
to
mosque. "
0.
Ikhtil3f
to hand, reveals
I
been developed before
which
are
had mostly
were produced
they
above
conclusion
Therefore
that
except
is
impurity
of major
the works
century.
respect
"It
Examination
the
with
a state
of the
grounds
b. Aslam said,
a state
in
that
consider
a person
3-
that
interpretation
has no connection
prefers
permitted
that
first
involved
across
a person
here
But Sh7afill
that
effeot
is
which
injunction.
the
who prefer
no new achievement
in
reproduced
a new-and
this
more concise
m6nner,
In
in
active
producing
for
and others
and develops
source
this,
of
spite
at
evidence,
particular
It
which
new evidence
existing
for
is
le
Cf. Qurtubi,
0
2.
Cf.
Shl; figli',
Cf. Glik,
legal
derived
from
In fact
such rulings;
as a rule
the
principles
evidence
mentioned
which
mostly
it
supplementary
to
support
is
the
view
appears
original
of the
opponents.
the
op. cit.,
vol-'5,
op.
vol.
cit.,
the
were very
as the
designed
polemically
schools
be considered
can no longer
Madhhab against
seems that
of all
rulings.
time
that
or evidence
jurists
the
Usill
in
this
period
no longer
carried
p. 202.
1, P- 46.
al-Mudawwanat al-Kubrg,
1, p. 32.
69
-
its
function
original
or solve
further
Madhhab.
of
for
function
existing
rulings
We have also
applied
where
Its
new problems.
evidence
deciding
seen that
the
here
is
in favour
discipline
objectively.
to
create
of the
a new ruling
and develop
particular
of -the theory
of
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1)
A.
Yu-suf
'Ail
Yusuf
Abdullah
Translation
cAbdul
The Holy
and Commentary--,
Printing
2)
Ali
Beirutt
Productiong
Text,
Qur'gn
2 vols.,
1965-
TWi
k1uharnmadReEd Abdul Baqi , al-Mu " Jam ale
f
Maiabi
Mufahras li Alfz
alal-Qqr"in,
1378-
Cairog
Sha'b,
u-suf
AuKitab
Ibrahim,
Ya qub b.
Abu- al-WaCa
ed.
1355-
Hanifa
Au_ al-WaCa
WaCa
5)
Abi
Ikhtilaf
al-Istijaaa
al-AfglZnlt
Pressp Haiderabad,
4)
ed.
al-Athar,
wa Ibn
Laila,
Abi
al-AfghZ_io
Matba'at
al-
1358-
Cairop
9
AU_ ITa-Zd
b. al-Ash'ath
SulaiuZn
Sunan AJi
IAIT,
Cairo,
I; adq
Matba'a
al-SijisGli
2 vols.
Mustaf
al-Babi
al-Halabi,
1371/1952s
Au_Mua
i;
?
A_u
a_, al-Balghat
Muhammad Husain
Qurliniyya
al-Fikr
Ci TafJr
ar
al-Zamakhshaji,
Cairo
al.: Arali,
al-
(n, d. ).
Au-Ya' i7a
Muhammadb, A6-u Ya:"17a,
Al;u- al-Husain
0a
Tabaat al-lTaabila,
2 vols. (in
MuhammadHan7id al-Paji,
al-Muammadiyyat
Cairot
1. ),
ed.
Matba'cat al-Sunnat
1371/1952.
71
8)
Abu Zahra
Muhammad Au- Zahra, fa7r7ikh al-Madl7ahib
al0
Fl
fa7rTkh
Isl7amiyya,,
two,
part
al-Yladla-hib
Dar al-Fikr
al-Fiqhiyyai
Au- Hayyan
0
fu'suf
Mahammad b.
Andalusi.
al-
b. Ail
b.
Hayyan
MusamZ' bi
al-
al-Kabir
al-Muhit
98 vols.
00.0
(n.
).
Riy7ad
d.
Nasr
al-.
al-HaJithaq
10)
al-Bahr
al-
Matba'at
9
Arberry
J. Arberryp
Arthur
A Handlist
Dublin,
11)
(n. d. ).
Cairo
Ara-it
of
Beatty
The Chester
the Arabic
Library
Manuscripts,
8 vols.,
1955.1
Baihaj
Au- Bakr
Ahmad b.
10 vols.
al-Kubra
Malrifv
12)
Platbaa
Kitab
al-Sunan
Yajlis
irat
I)7a!
al-
1344-
Raiderabadq
Ahkam al-Qur'an
li al-Imam al-Miiazzam wa al=_
0.0
MuJtahid
Muhammad b.
al-Muqaddam AV"Abd'illah
ld-is
2 vols.
al-Shafi'-i
GharZ Abdul
Beirut,
13)
al-Husain
Khaliq
(in
Dar
al-Xutub
9
1. )q ed. cAbdul
al.! Ilmiyya,
1395/1975.
al-Xhil3fiyy7a*tp
vols.,
Salim Agha.
14) Bagh(fa-J
a9c
Abdul WahlTab b. AIT al-Baghd7ad7it
Maa'il
Tunis
al-Khilaf,
(nd.
).
2 vols.
al-Ishr7af
Matba'at
al-Ix;
al7a
daj
72
15)
Brockelmann
Carl
Litteratur,
16)
Brillt
suPP-9 E-J-
3 vole-p
Leideng
der Arabischen
Geschichte
Brockelmarmg
al-Zamakhsha.
in
of Islam,
Encyclopaedia
Leyden, Luzacj
vols. p E. J. Brillp
London,
1924 - 1927.
17) BuklZil
Au- cAbdulla
b. Isnigll
al-Buklait
Mustaf: a- al-IZli
Coulsont
F,dinburghg
Islamic-Law
A HistoMof
1964.
b.
al-Na7n
,
00
'Umar al-Dau-Jq
Matba'at
al-Iu7amv
Ta'sls
Cairo
(n. d. ),
17araqutyri
4AIT b.
'Umar
Sunan al-
al-IraraqutnYt
4 volsDaraqutni,
0/
..
shim Yamanit Sharikat
2. ).
Fanniyyat
Cairop
9
(in
21)
Dai
cUbaidalZi
20)
Cairo
al-Halalip
Coulson
N, J,
19)
M.
137 - 1378/
18)
( in
9 vols.
Sahih
,
000
Matba4a
al-Bukhar-i
Fabzabadk!
\Au_
Taik
al-Muttahida
Muhammad b.
4 vols-9
al-Muffit,
W-1Cairo (n. d. ).
ed. Abduliah
al. -Tiaat
Ya'(ubq
Matba'at
0
al13a6/
1966.
al-Q-zum-us
al-Sa'*Zda,
73
22)
F, Sayyid
Y%?ad Sayyid,
3 vols.
23)
Fihrist
pDar al-Riyad
al-Musawwara,
al-Makhtutat
li
00
Cairo,
al-Nashrp
al-Tag'wa
GhaZIT
Au- 117midMuhammadb. Muhammadal-Gha317i,
al-Mustasfa
min
al-Muthanna,
24)
cIlm
2 vols. 0 Maktabat
al-Usul,
1970.
Baghdad
Goldziher
The ZahiriS,
trans,, p and ed.
0
Leiden, 1971Wolfgang Behn, E. J. Brill,
Ignaz Goldzihert
26) ajl
of Islam
in Encyclopaedia
Ikhtil7aft
25)
Khalae
Xashf alKhalfa
ajl
Ylustaia- b. cAbdullap
9
oe
'an Asr.q-;" al-Kutub
7 vols-s
ZuZn
wa al-Fun-un
1835 - 1858-
Leipzig,
27)
MustaCa
Ua
b. ,AbdullZa
al-Zuin----'an
2 vols.
wa al-Fun7un,
al-Xutub
1360 - 1362/
Kashf
1941
Istanbult
9
1943-
28a) MamidullZa
Muhammad HamidullZi
A New Approachq
in
of Islamic
Sources
Islamic
-L
uarterly
Law -
9 vol.
London, 1954.
28b)
Houtsma
M. Th. Houtsma,
of Islara .
Malik
Shah 9 in
Encyclopaedia
1,
1954-60.
74
29)
H. Wehr
of Modern
Arabic,
London,
1971-
J. Milton
ed.
Cowan,
30) asa'Z
Bahijah
al-Hasani,
ri
Muoallaf
Majalla
Kitab
al-Mufrad
li
al-Zamakhshari
al-Nahw
0
- Majma" al-"Ilrj-
al-'Ir7a
wa al-
ovol-
in
.
15t,
Baghdad, 196731)
Kha-V'is
li
al-Klrari
al-'Asharat.
Kutub al-Turialtho
Salsila
al-Zamakhshalq
al-Barara
32)
lGshii'
Abdul
Xhaliq
Mas7a"il,
fa-r
MS no.
al-Kutub
Ia
b.
Ru"Us
al-TGshirZj*
2744 (al-Fiqh
al-iairiyyap
0
al-
al-Hanbal-i),
0
Damascuse
vols.,
irif
al-Me
b. HiamudCin.
Sunan al-Aqwal
Matba"a Jamiyya
al-Uthmaniyya,
Haiderabadl 1364-
34) nall7af
Abdul WahhabKhallaft
ar
al-Qalam,
Ilm
Kuwait,
Usul
0
al-Figh,
1392/1972.
75
c
35) Ibn Abd-ul - --,Ba=
"Umar
Abube Abdul
400
Matbaa
a0
ad
Ma'rifat
al-lstT43brii-
, A17i k1uhammad
al9 ed.
4 vols.
al-Asl7ab,
BijWit
Barrg
be IIuha=.
be Abdulia
)uuf
1380/1960.
Nahdap Cairog
fi
al-Tarikh
Cairo#
al-Isti6maq
37)
al-Luab
Maktabat al-QudJit
vols-9
1357.
Au- Abdulla
Muhadhdhab Rihla
al-AZmiri
Ibn Bai-uta,
ed. 'Ahmad
al-Au7iAyyaq
Cairo, 1937.
39) Ibn Parh
Au- Abdullah
Muhammadb. Farh,
Mukhtasar al-Khilafiyyat,
0
1080,
MS
no.
t
Ahmad3.
0
40) Ibn Hajar
Abu al-Fadl
'Al7i
b. Hajar
Ahmad b.
al-Tahd-ibq
1968.
12 vols. 9
76
41) Ibn Hanbal
0
Ahmad b. Hanbal,
Musnad al-In7am
6 vols.,
Hanbal,
al-Maktab
17teirut,
lir dadir
1969.
,
0
Ahmad b.
al-Islami,
-
b. Ahmadj, al-Muhalla,
9 vols.
Ahmad
Muhammad
Sla-kir,
ede
t
Iat
al-Tiacat
1347 - 135; /
Cairo
al-Murilriyyat
1928 - 1933-
Abdul
OR
al-I)hahab
Ray b. al-Imad,
0
Ci Akhar
man
Dhahaba, 8 vola.
Maktabat
al-Qudsi,
9
Ibn
KhalCun
li
al-Ti-Vat
0
al-Lubriani
wa al-NashrgBeirut
1961.
Muhammad b. AJ
Wafa; a't al-A"3ran
Zan7anq 8 vols.,
far
S7adir,
0
Beirut,
Bahr b. Khallian,
wa Ana"' Abr; a-'aled,
Ihsan Abbas,
0
1968 - 1972,
77
46)
Ibn l9ja
Muhammad b. Yazidq Sunan
0
Zid
dAbdul
l7aj,
Fu!
ed. Muhammad
Abu Abdullah
2 vols.
Dar Ihya.
al-Kutub
al-Halabit
Cairog
Ia
alArabiyya
al-17ali
1952 - 1953-
Muhammad b.
al-Faraj
eL
Matba at
al-Fihrist,
Ishaq
al-Nadimo
al-Rahniniya,
Cairot 1929.
48)
Ibn Qutl7ubugha
Zain al-ITIn
(5sim b. Qxtl7ubugha
Taj al-Tarajimp
Matba"at
al-
;iq Baghdadq
1962.
49)
Ibn Rajab
Zain
al-Din
b
b. - Shil;
al-ffing
TabaSat
Abdul
Abu al-Faraj
ab
Ki;
aL-HanLbila,
al-Dhailal7a
2 vols.
al-Sunnat
Rahman
( in
1. )
Matba'at..
-.4--
Cairot
1952 - 195350)
Ibn Taghri
Birdi
Yusuf
Zahira
b,, Taghri
ri
Birdi#
Mul7uk Misr
al-Nujum-alwa al-Qahira,
Cairo
12
(nd,
).
78
51) JuwairdAu-
e
17i Abdul
al-Ma";
Kitab
al-Durra
al-Juwainl,
ma Vlaqea
fihi
wa al-Hanafiyya,
6
al-ShafiTyya
Ahmad
al-Mudiyya_fi
baina
al-Khilaf
b.
Malik
Museum.
Khadd7ul
Majid
Islamic
Khadduriq
JohniHopkins
The
9
Risala
Slraff-fls
Jurisprudence,
Pressq
1961.
Baltimoret
53) Kala;lla
'* Jam al-Mu'allif-in,
Mu
9
49
Umar Rida KahlZa
00
0
Damascusq
54) YZ!
Au- Bakr
Tarilib
b. XaS"'dq
-Bada'i*
Matba 4 at
9 vols.,
al-Shwal'i`
(n. d. ).
al-Ima-mq Cairo
55)
al-SarVi*
il
Glik
?
Ylalik
b, Anas . al-Mudawwanat
6 vols.,
56a)
Haktabat
al-Muthanna,
al-Kubra,
Baghdadq 1970.
al-Halabig
0.
Cairog
1951-
56b) MaqdiJAu-
Abdull7ah
Bakr,
Ahsan
al-AqRl'fri,
E. J.
Brill,
f!
" rifat
IMa
Leiden,
1906.
79
-
57) IllarqrUJi
al-Husain
Tariga,
Egyptian
58)
Ma sumi
0
b. Muhanmad zLl-Maruruzi,
Abu Ali
Libraryt
al, -SI;a-fi'-f
Calros
MuhammadHasan Ma sumig
Tahawils
Ikhtilaf
Studiesp
Vol.
in Islamic
al-Fuqaha,
8,
19 69.
Islamabad,
59) Muslim
Muslim b. Hajjajt
Abu al-Husain
Muslim,
Sahih
al-Kutub
al-Arabiyya
Cairop
al-lialabig
'Isa
1374
1375/1955-1956.
T
murZ;
4Abdul
flthe
Relf
Had7ith
Khair
margin
Matba'a.
YunUz' al-Haa'iq
.0
2 vols.
al-Khal7a"iqp
9 on
al-MuriJq
of
Ylustafi
by
al-Saghir,
al-Tami'
(n. d. ).
Cairo
al-Halabiq
al-Babli
Suyuti,
61) muzarE
Illl
Isn:
Abu IbrRjm
5 vols-,
al-Muzani,
by Sh3fi"179
b.
Yahyl
al-MuzarF, Mukhtasar
on the margin
Maia-bi
0
al-Sha'
bt
of al-Umm,
Cairo,
1388/1968.
i62) Nawa,
Au_ Zakariyya
YhihyidTin
al_Majm7u'*q* 21 vols.,
YlutiTt
0
Maktatat
ed.
Sharf
al-Nawa%Fq Kit*ab
Muhammad NajFb
al.! Xlamiyyal
Cairo
al-
(n, d, ),
80
I
63)
Paterson
G. M. Patersont
to Theses, t Vol.
Index
1964 - 1965,
London,
Jamal al-Din
Abu al-Hasan
0
159
1967.
lnat
al-Qifl,
3 vols.,
Ali
b.
I; a-r al-Kutub
Yusuf
al-Misriyya,
0
qairo
Ibrahim,
1369 - 1377/
1950 - 1957.
65) Qurjuli
Au- Vdull7ah
al-Jaml li
al-Q. urtubi,
(in
20 volt',.
al-Misriyya,
AhGm gl-Qur7nl
:
far
)s
Matba at
io.
al-Xutub
1; 69 -. 1385/ 1950
Cairo,
1965-
66) SarakhJi
Abu Bakr Muhammadb. Abu SuhailtKitab
(in
al-MlabZut, 30 vols4'Edaq
Calrog
al-Sa.
67)
1324/1906.
SarakhJi
Radi
al-Din
al-Ridawiyya,
al-Hanari),
6s)
15. )p Matba'at
al-Sarakhsiq
volEgyptian
al-Tariqat
3, MS no.
National
238 (al-Fiqh
Library,
Cairo.
samamVT
Fadil
Salih
al-Samarra
it
al-Dirasat
al-Nahwiyya
wa al-Lur, -,hawiyya'inda
FLI-Zamakhsh&ji,
:
Matba at al-IrshZd,
Baghdads 1390/1971.
81
-
69)
Schacht
Joseph
Schacht,
Jurisprudence,
Oxford,
70)
An Introduction
71)
Theolqgy
Law in
Otto
72)
Pre-Islamic
ed. Majid
l#
Theolopy
and
in
1971.
Law in
The Middle
KhadCu_i and H. J.
CShafi i
A-ccbu Abdullah
11uhammad bo Idris
(in
al-Umt
7 vols.
Cairop
1388/1968.
4-)p
ip
al-Shafi
Maiabi"
bs
al-Sha
Shaii
Muhammad b, al-Hasan
0a-4
1, ed, Shafiq
vol.,
rami'Lat
75)
in
Wiesbadeng
Backgroundq
Liesbesnyg
74)
fiarrassowitzg
East,,. vol,
73)
1967.
to Islamic
Islamp
Muh.ammadan
The originsof
al-Cia-hirap
al-Shalbanit
Shahltag
Cairo,
al-Asl,
Matba'a
1954-
Sh-'Ukh ShancCiiiMalua7udb.
-mmad
44".
Asma
al-Shanqiti,
g0
Kutub
al-Arabiyyaq
Asbaniyya
Arab League.
al-Talamidh
Ashhur
Maktaba
photocopy
is
al-Tirkizi
alMadrid
preserved
al-Amma,
in
the
82
-
76) SbTa'Ji
Abu Ishaq
Kitab
Ibrahim
al-Nukt,
b. Ali
al-Fairuzabadhi,
1154,
no.
Ahmad 3
77)
Au- Ja,"far
Vil
Ma,
fi
al-Jinayat
lramaint
78)
Muhammad b. Ahmad
MS no.
al-Siman-&-4-i
baina,
al-Xhilaf
6510P British
al-
Museum.
Subj
c).
Taj al-17in ACul Nasr bdul Vlahlab'b. TacjudJin
al-Subkit
6 vols.
Tabagat al-Shafi"Tyyat
al-Nubra,
0
(in M.
Matba'at al-Husainiyyat
00
Coro, 1906.
79) suy;!'Ci'
Jal7al
al-17ineAbdul
Bughyat
il
al-Wli"Et
Tabaqat
(in
6 vols.
Suyuti,
Sharh Sunan al-NaZT,
00
17ar Ihja_3'al-Tu3:;; th al_Araliq
80)
al-
3eirut
(n. d. ).
al-Nuhat
2 V018.9
lbrahimg
ed. Muhammad Au_ al-Fadl
0-0
'is-a
Matba'a
Cairo,
al-B-ab-i al-Halabi,
10
0
1384 - 1385/ 1964 - 1965.
81)
al-ja-mial-Saph-fr
;
nl-Nadlrir,
vols.
iaVi
al-HalaJ#
ii- AlaVith
al-BasIJ-r
Matbaa
p
MustaCa
Cairo
(n. d. ).
al-
4. ).
83
-
82)
de Interpretibus
Sojutii_Librum
Exhibens
Meursingeq
Korani,,
ed. v Albertus
Batavorump 183983)
Lugduni.
Ti=idl7i
Muhammad b.
Isa
Au-
Isal
al-jami
al-Safrih
wahuwaSunan
5 vols.,
Matba c a.
Cairo,
Mustara
al-Tirmidhi,
al-aJi
al-Halalig
1937o
84) TabaAl
0
Aju
Ja" far
Ikhtilaf
A3eirut
Iluhammad b.
Jajir
al-Tabaji,
ed. F. Kerng
al-Fuqahag
(n. d. ).
85) Tali; i
u_ Ja" far
Ahmad b. 14uh.
-ummadal-Taliii,
0000
2 volo,
Matba4at
Sharh Mat;T7i a1-1t17ar,
9
00
1348Delhi,
al-Asfiyyaq
86)
Ikhtilaf
al-Puqaha
Hasan Ma
Islamabadp
87a)Tlshkubri
sumig
19
Muhammad
vol.
ed.
9
Islamic
Research
Institutep
1391/1971.
ZZIah
Ahmad b. MustaCal Mift7ah al-Se7da,
2 vols.,
Dar al-Kutub
al-Haditha,
Cairo
(n. d. ).
84
-
876JUkbari
Au- al-BaqV
Imla
I'
b.
Abdullli
ma Manna bihi
2 vols.
(in
Matba'a
1. )t
lIU8tafg
fT
ed,
jaij-4
Ibim
al-Bab-i
al-Ukbari,
al-Rahman
Z7t
77ab wa al-Qiz;
al-Rusain
al-QurZi,
Utwa4Iwad
Cairo,
al-Halabil
1380/1961.1(
88)
Wensinck
indices
A, J, Wensinckq Concordance et
la
Tradition
Musulmane97 voleg , E. J.
Leiden,
1936 - 1969.
faVu tb.
cAbdullli
de
Brillg
YaVu
89)
t
if
Yla 4 rifat
al-Hamalj
Uf bi
4
7:
al-Ma
al-Adib
Aw Tabagat
al-Uda-a"
Irsl, 3d al-ATb
7 vols-9
al-Uda-a',
ed.
B. S. Margolioutho
Mu c lam
E. J. W.Gibb Memorial.
Wstenfeld,
91)
6 vols,,
ed,
1965-
Zamakhshail
Au- al-(gsim
MaluZd
al-Kashst7af"an
fi
al-Aqawil
Matba"a
.0
b.
HaQ7 3,in
Wujuh al-Ta'
MustaCa al-faVi
.00
1367/1948.
1
4"
4Umar
al-Zamakhshar-i,
al-Tan7.
Tl
%A-1,3
al-Halali,
wa UZn
vols-9
Cairo,
- 85 92)
al-
fa"iq
ed. All
2. ).
Muhammad al-Bijawi
04
4cIsa,
Matba, a
al-Babi al-
al-Fadl
Ibrahimt
Halabi,
0
Cairo 9 19F45-.
2 vols.,
Muqaddimat al-Adab,
.-,
93)
(in
4 vols.
fT Gha_Fb al-Hadith,
ed. Saiyed
MohammadKazem,Emamt Tehrant
1342 - 1343/
1963 - 1965.
94)
ri
95)
ed. C. Barbier
AZas al-Bal7aghat
f.iz
al-Maja
wa al0
de Meynardg Paris,
2 vols, q Matbaa
e
al-
SaM
ed,
,
e0
NwZbigh
al-Kali
BasG7i,
in Amtl7al al-Sharg
fu"suf
by
al-Busill
al-ITn
al-
wa al-Charb,
Ma; rat,
98)
99)
Xatbaat
Cairo,
al-TauFi'qv
1325-
National
Egyptian
.
Cairo.
Zubaidil
fa'j
Benghazi,
al-Nashr
va al-Tau-,,
1966.
100) Zairan
Juri-i. Zald7an, aih
(in
al-Adab
2. ). IZr Maktabat
alArab-i
al-Ilajat,,
0
Beirut,
,4
vola
1967.
PART
TEXT
7vto
APPF-NDIX
NOTES.
TMT
238
a
L: 4
L.
ZAJI
c3k:
cill
9LZ
Ou
OVT>
CAe;
.0
ki-I
C.A6
ce
cob-; J.
00)
Ut-L
ZN
C-)k--Ll
&
%:
L-S;
ek; -p
Ll q
L&C
01)
kp
i5Ji
&%
dIL.
(12)
4.21
t (L
C'.
\. 4t'.
'-
A
C
(13)
-4
s1
'
10
*--
-'
JU
jL]
(4J(
d-, J
ckj
d
(15)
OP.Aj C-t
zu
14.
(.
41
.
Lf.
-r,& ,=,.
cs
ct
f o. 105b.
-L, >Lai
a) Cf. above P- 40
line
sug5est.
11,
9.
Lrk, %31
04--ji
1:A
c) Cf,, above
f) ms,CA-;p -
ms
h) irs
15
13
p. 9,
line
13-
237
-
L
le
'13, Aj, (3,
.tj,
1
L3)j5:
D--33
J):
L-)
::s1
UJI
jj
b
-'
z--5
01C.,
<:
> (
--
--, t-U) L2 ,
-4..
fo, 105a.
(AC
a) ms
W J9
b) ms
L.;J1
(J crossed
0) ms
d) above the line
out.
c*i
S9
236
/
JI
J>
r
(x,
u,>\j
%,:.
U, >
7
- e>,
''
rj
t, G, k. v. t
-9
Uv
U5
C., J-
-UZ -: e.
&-; Lii
So. 104b,
. _Z.
(J_J
L9i
t3
__i
It
;
ce
4-A; IIi
>
..
(8)
4(J
d-*
ul
I Ll I Ls Yl
L.
10
ZG,-a I ut.
6[
*r it
i)
b)
outer
Cf.
,
left
hand margin
above p. 2 7,
0) M841!L-k'. V,%.
line
f)
&
crossed
out.
h) ms c-4Wo -
d) ms
e) Df.
g) above tha
9.
ms Lp-;V:j I.
above p. 99 line
13-
line.
U-j
.1
235
-
*I-*
>-
fo-104a.
J4i
'r
.
2u
ccG
c:,
_;,
.1,u.
du
G,
>e4
1
cci
gj
4
_,
C-A
ju
b
14.
14-)1
c,;;
J,
(Jul
JLq
d;
LIU%
jL41
'I
Ajk; L3j
-;
UW
10
C.\J
Ls
&.:: i
r'-'
3\.
t. d.
bJ
4- cU UA ttt
_>
a) ms
b) i, e,
i.
C)
e. ...
AJ: d
W-4;
J
J\;
ctI
"04 du
1
q
-.
15
234
-
N
ju
13,
4L,:
c
c-
a-S-1.;
-0.4 au
(11)
xi ,1
z'JL-J% tUc,
c5
61
Ci
3,
LsciII
>b o,
\J-51 1
c
t,>i
10
ou
ut
l 61w,
1
-. -
czl
15
a)
Ms
L:.Jl >p
b) ms 0,0& *
C) ms >j .
233
(6)
10
eGi%
cJ
-'
cx
)5
cd
-*j I
"\4
Uj
z
(-;
j
-- $
\j
Ck-p
-i
ul"I
dA
(p
Z; C4. d
Jl
161
J;; >i
&1
aj
(;:--11
u (.I;,
10
>
6.
(ju
LP
-Ajl
Zi
OLP
Y,
'k-5i)
-Jl
(. c
Li
V-9
00)
%:.,
fo-103b.
Li
Ll
>-c,
..
a)
ms
b)
ms
b-. (. -
%a0
15
232
-
W0-s
b-:!.
U-P
-%
-0
a 0
cvc U-A-) ,, - kjk-. Jl
IJ
k:
>
-U,
Li
1, ol"
11 J -\-:..
J
_,
Uej
(1)
Le
"'t.ou ZI
5
e
6
'31
4f
(h>'
"
(3)
I C.
GIA-0
...
".
10
Ak 61!.
a-s-
103a
jt;
L-IJLZ-jl
u-P
k-lo
.
Lp
cyc
4--
C-A-4-i
6.
>
a)
b)
(sic)
ms
suggesi.
m3 *A% Ljl -
c)
d) mo
6)
ms
f)
ms
6,
cf.
d.
La;.
above
1
(F-r.
p. 16,
Ce
"
JL;
Zl
kxc
linell.
dl; l -
g) i. e. *
h) ms
above the line.
outer
k) ms
right
hand margin.
15
231
-
,.A ...
u; j% ;kk,.
O-Av.
L
(13)
Li
it
a-tf- <s.
P!. p u3j,
L9-111
-- cy"-'
GG- v i Z1
-.
jj
-to
cxD
bu,
Lju-,
-OL11
;Ajl
-- %-
Li
-k-6
4351 L>-LC-r
o. 102b LS,
104)
GU L; Jl
_>J
4-4
'As
10
(15),
Is
JJJI
L3 \.:. u,
>
(16)
'():
'-
15
0 8)
ff,
297bo 298a
230
-
Ls
a
ci
tit;
1.
Lya)
fo. 102a.
(r
tit;
13"b-9
C4
0-a
"->-6m
L,
..
JO
4al
ZZ1
c. juz
(Y.Z>31.2
c.
10
01)
po---Ut
(i
WL05
UJI
-->I
CS,
Let,
b) ms
0) ms
d) cf.
e) ms
f)
ms
4-
L4
229
-
(33)
: ijL-j
t%
(34)
C-vc
cxt
(35)
(4z,
qt
14fIII
Gk:ji
U-Ij
d-Ml
'00"I
::L, ((J
d) ms
0)
:>-
;. I
C) ms Z!, L
f)
Lsjl
%
ms I t d -%j
)
-!
(sic)
M3
j; ) Cf.
suggest
h) ms ew
.
e.
I-
t of . above
1.
>
io
',:, u.
p. 16 t line
228 -
Li 10L-up
tit,
(26)
(27)
.01a
1bU42tX4.,
c*L
A:
JI
Ngl
'-4)
>
CC,
cC,
(28)
Liu
E) 14
.7%.
(29)
1
6m
.
1
..
61
C-.
0a, 'suil
3-1
aA-
\1
Li3x-
41
C-,
(30)
10
Ll
(Akll
lip
(32)1
ro. 101b.
-'I
*U4V
a) ms
&-\Jl
DL%-t'
64
f) ms CA4-
b) ms
9) MIS
C) ms
h) ms
i)
kp >.-I
lower
V\; left
hand margin.
15
227
-
040,
C3"
(20)
.
L.i
G- lJ,
-j
-. .
(21)
ja,
(22)
(23).
lu
Z31
ci I
ul
(24)
10
AL
C-
.
I.
(-4
lola.
*'I--o'LO
ro.
:
1,,>
\J
&-"*
(25)
JLJI
OV
V QI-9
L?
'"
19
(
IJ
'
a) ms %f;,>
b) ms
c) ma
d) ms e-41 kj-A
e) Cf. above p. 9
f)
MS
bj4l
line
13.
crossed
out.
tcV
LO
EN
-6
.)
tv
o ->.
, -G
Aj--t
15
226
-
ul
&A-DI
d-m.:) okei
a
&Stj
CiD wi
u-jl
lAu -o (je* L-i-;
9
LSLC
rl6: j
f
ItA
Luo
;uL-11
(15)
h
r: Ju;
Iu
ro. 100b.
<dj >I
41coeil
'U
di
:
(: ot >.
Ole
10
k,
01;
J,
'i
&I C-ju u Ib
Cj-;J. LP-P,
L;Lc
15
a) ms
b) ms CZAVs
-
ms
j)
ma cxpus -
11.
1) ma
14--
hand margin.
d) ms
f)
line
6.
225
\ji4.
I,
'r
'-"
DU
6, -4-
Cl
jl
tj,
(JJI
4J, [Z)" i
Jlgl
.'UJA;
-t"
C(
\Ji
'.
e-d
jj'
\fl
"
g-ii
fo*100ao
0e;
pl*. uL-A
Li
Li
01)
Uu
;;j
10
1 -
Li
(
)'ji
;.J%>.9j'
I
U:'
Uj
(13)
Ejj
(12)
C',
W.
6U.
uw
a) ms
b) Cf. above P-212P line
0)
3-
ms
d) ms .YQ"
0) ms d1v f) ms cit
9) upper
riCht
h) above
the
hand margin.
line.
15
224
-
a
6
wIlI
f0-:
VD-9
t.
11.>UC
CAa
Jlr.
\) C7uil
(1)
CiPUM
D)}
'1
\j
U&; 3I1
61C.,
'6
-U ,
-,- j
\J,
C
'-
(:4
LJ%
UO
bi
\-,
U
NjIt&t
(!.)i
>
fo. 99b*
U: I
CA
A-
e
CA
cm
bsl: "r-
uj I
io
csjl
11
;
L:.U, >
cs
64
15
14".
9 a-": Ou
a) ms
vil -
b) ms VoWl
U- d) ms k,,(, %.
I
e). upper
ms
0) ms C,; f)
right
hand-mar'ginj
&3-41crossed'oiat.
13-
223
(12)
4#
fQ,
Nl
Lckl
Liv
Li
JLP
dL
(14)
fo. 99a.
9$
(q,
06'A
a
-5!-
j4
u
it
V
-"I.
-. j
L-JI
-vApt
10
W.
5.
d) Cf.
16.
b) Cf.
above P-41t
13.
e) Cf.
1.
0) ms
t;.
line
f)
ms
222 Qw
w
..
\j
\,
rjj
; JL..,
Q--
ozs
_li\&"
VI
(9)
ba
6 UU, > 16.GL%
. )
JLJ
ail
(:j-!>Giiv,ztj
z)-?
-9t
&,>4 PZIL.
9,
&)'-'J'
c*Th
DWI]
-*
z
>;,:
j9\&.
(jJ
s16
U'
cv
LL. il
--1
oz
00)
LP
04
Up
r--'
(L)9p
J%
(;
It
>;. c
10
U.
(?
cJ
t,,
d'%
,.
a) ms
b) ms
e) i. e.
C) ma ,61. AA,
9,I.
d) ms
L;
f)
ms
-..
221
-
&; LE31 %,
zc 4[L xc 3 4,--
b
ek
14.:
iJal
-
u
it-ii
V--3L.
)
C(4)
(: j 1A
Z>s-(3
c- (10,1
(JL;
ot3
jo
(3)
b
ce
u3j 19
01,
cAr.
djo,
L:,rc
..,
X;,l
[1
10
OV DJL-,
2% UU.)
(7)
Uzi
fo. 98be
Cij
(:.er
&--t
cci
ij
b) ms
-;
"'-
l-i
-.,;
h) ms
ms
u-
ms
'ms
e) me .d
c:k-u
-*"1"' -
C)
Cp
9.
ms
cii,
15
220
-
u.:j I
LJ
*dL
L
ffi Ci qu; e-lu
>c
t-. 41
(15)
JLII
Lu
N-
fo. 93a. *
L)
uI
(20)
6Z
ob;
I os
j
lo
(21)
v L; j
I;
,-!
J.
;izJ
13-
b) ms
C) ms
d) ms
lau U.;.'
ms-Oewl
g)
h)
outer
left
hand margin,
crossed
ms ALI -
9.
ms
out.
A.
%J-j
c
,.
4>
-t--
219
-
c:A: i
(1).
.
-.
: -L.- (-g
0,11b
:
Z,
q
x;z. '
L&,
Z,
o
*0
it;
4,4-ca-m
LAa
NJ
-4-
1, JL-jl
V.;Jl &
(3)
1"
(:.Yc
(4)
fo-97b.
[J,
(5)
W
>.
3-eie.V
CL9.51
(6)
le>>m
1.
i
0
g
(
-.
10.
(82
,.obN).
'1&,
5
je-
iii(-3-*9
xu
-9
Ic:
eO
t. t,
->"
ds
au4 9 d. t
a
ZJLb
i1
ug
t 3 ct:i %-u
j
(11)
&
(10)
aj&
(12)
i
QAS
ms
11,
-51
15
218 -
cye--i
44a
w.
:J;:). )
-'
r-'5
<c>"
(13)
V
;4; \4
c"'
. "
(141
)
cje.
:
)Lb
g)
V,
-.
20.
c4jJ
GtC.
--e >
L
ue.)
jk-.
ms
a)
-b) above the linel
C) ms
d) below the line.
e) above the lines ms (sic)
0
ms
.;. -
Ub Iz
>,
>3
cI
_q
6.1>-
uzu
2% *Z%
suggest.
v?. JLJ%
10
217
-0
cu
Z:-4 -I (.9
-j
0'. 0
Oaji 6
".,
k&L-4
&
4D ct c;-.Jl
4.4
CLJ
ociv
L"i
uqi
Git
(.:
t
c-x%ZJLa,
A>i L- 9 jg
t.
D%
,
uxc
-3'
fo. 97a-
v
(ye.
1*%xb.
C--3Qlt
, rivi
a) ms
;,*
f) mg
b) ms
0)
",
-
mg
ms
h)
me j ;U.
i)
M,9 a'..
d) ms
e) ms eK,-
je..
10
216
$-I
L>-j
(p91
IM
C-.)Ufl,
; mgs
At,
(2X
&etz,
g>
t
log
czL9
' i*i
J-,
uuz
4
-I
06
tL
ok-3 LjL-j
I-4t
'-
'o
af_
I-
Cul
__
LAC
.L
_jj
ju
(4)
f o. 96b.
J L4
C-A;
j
otI
b-, i L
u2
10
dg
Uj
3xi
Yi
ck
15
a) ma o-il-i .
0) lower left
b) ms
&>
.
-*.
hand margin.
d) Ms
0) upper right
f)
Ms
9) ms
h) ms
hand margin.
215
CL.
a<
(2)
j
U,: >
b4
k
P1
1-1313
6r- li:,3ZL?
(3
UO
c6li Lskr.
jo
9f
fo. 96a.
;JLJI
0-!"
-L
(4)
&ALI
Lt
10
(5)
(6)J
(7)
I
LIA
k
C;
-Jl
(8)
LIJ,
cv,
0 0)
aj"I
j% C-.
LS,.:
Vr01)
n1
outer
c) ms
d) Cf.
right
hand margin.
i)
16.
g) Ms ( -
.0
k)
J) Cf.
MS
line
J,>
above p. 27, line
(9)
h) ms
15
ins
M8
99
above
p. 27slineq
m) Cf. Shafi'190P.
vol-4,
n)Cf.
0) ms
Citot
P-101
'I %.w
J&
tt-etj
above no. m.
214
.I
W.
d--U
LjqL%
6L-Lk
'A
LA, &
6L.,
\j
V--216
,-. k4x
cujlp
6: )
AAU
-400
OL)!l
06
611
61
JL.
&
LJL;--*JI
o--Ml
UJI
(3)
CA---j
J
L)6; -A--vj
oJk,,O_q c J
(2)
3- V
Io
\j
cx: >3rf. su
L)O)
let
b) ms
C) Cf. above p. 18p line
P-1334
1.
t.,%
10
213
-
(i'
cJ
ZL
r
(2)
LV
J,
zu
c Ls, I
a-:0
(9)
ic
oc
(7) b
e2-,
oap
lo
Lst.. >
J'L.21 L3 Lu. ) .
ob
U'l
fo-95b,
Li
6ul
d
Lis,
up
_AO-flij
fe
a) Cf* above P-389 line
5-
b) ms
0) Cf. above p. 279 line
d) ms
e) above the line.
9.
f)
ms ;, -.: j
15
212
-
EN
6-,.,
qL
-
VL
uu
L;
131
21
61-ab
C
fo-95a.
Le 4,,
II,
I
ll
61 ,
..
10
-51
hdl:
a) ma
b)
C) ms
d) ms
0) ms
f) ms
E) Cf& above line
h) ms S-Z)I
3-
J'
1
,qt
;a d=
11
t
211
-
(Yj1i
a
:!
(J
LID I
5,lc
I,
L
zo
(2
Lb
L)
': >
'C,
2i
'-I
Ci
93
..
P-31
ivl
*-I ,
JVI -I
10
7u cv -
ua
Llu
q.
-;
V,
e
o
a) ms
b) ms
0)
ms
d) ms
e) ms
15
210
-
*Iou
i
I \-- I] e.)Ij,
tiL.,
It-A-:
j.
-*C-jr, -- I- ulb
Li
ci
LO
;, j
CAr \4; -D
(24)
-ca,
b
L--.. b
;,j L
(25)
1C1 jz AJ
.
46
.1
k:.u
, LL
r
C-3
c
(26)
fo-94b
OLAC C-D-
U9
lo
(27)
a)
zi 1A4,
MS Lf>:.
c .
c..zy
3t6;j
v, c.
ti
(.4
209
.s
12LIJ.
(is)
6 ci
". oz-,.
BL9 a-. (
-,
-l
.
Lj
fo-94a.
.
Z.
ovs
a.,
QL
5
cU A-U
Al
C.3
bjpp
(2q)
(2? )
101
6,12
Ae
;, J
(23)
a3
Liu
lj
Ujo
\4"
.
du
Z43
JU
Cy.
ZN
G
-.,,
a) ms
lil ; ,Il
't.
b) ms e-p-
c) Cf. Stiafi'f,
d) ms
e) ms
f)
ms kvJka
g) ms a."o.
op cit.,
6,
p. 138;
vol.
10
208
-
-, LZJ 1
out
5
4U
lx;lc,
1XIC
ro. 93b
uu
1;
LDI
ul _AJ
\jl
Cf
4., jr. J
71
)JI
Jul
LAX L!
(A'xz
10
LAC
)Lc
ZL!JU-
&-;;
6-s
(17)
15
Li
Cf
ms
b) upper right
hand margin.
9) ms
h) Cf. above P- 4p line
C) ms
d) outer
no. e.
right
i)
hand margin.
10.
ms tol
J) ms
k) ms
3.) ms
V!, j I
11.
207
(Jul
cckiII (jI'
Qo'(. -,
j--
lJ,
ul;
&C-.
Ut
c).
..
-I
-..
eA
2-;
tj
2b
lj,
>
iv,
'
QI
I1,
c-ce. e I.
.
C41.9
IL
L-tL--
Gb
I.
%ILI
10
64-!
kj
UJ
1 6"*:.
U9
c
.j(:
)k;
jlt
4l
k0
L3..
OX--:
Jl
4)
L
.a) ms
g) ms o.-. 9
b) ms
h) ms >,D,
-
0) ms C;"7.
d) Cf, above line
S) ms
f)
ms
MS
1.
J) ms
k) ms
206 -
Lx:.
4
c
t>
ce
el;
Lye-)
(5)
CP
DIU 6-m,
y
'4jd
ZJt
2;
10
tuo
C-&.
41
Uj i
00)
1
c
ziL..
fo-93a.
UI
b) ms Oto -
a) ms.
0) lower
right
hand margin.
15
205
-
5VLEJ,
&3(
(S323
&
LX3
);
c}'
r--C
(3o)
'>-,
,0.
jo
Zt4b
ZL4G?
$I
jj-
-12;
(32)
k". ,
.
d
ul
k3l
uu'fwj
fo. 92b,
6 W, >
10
cy
tjtr*eO
9f
AJ
(33)
ILI
15 ',
b) ms
wul
*
d
b
0,
(34)
4.
e) ms
f) above the lineg
6) ms
d) ms
cu-kio-vt'.
1;.V-
h) ms
t;.
204 -
(>
( 28)
k; s
f o. 92a.
ci
7L
L-c, ti zL4%
vu,
(29)
>
Ev, LE. )
f
10
C,
a) ms
b), above the line.
c) i. e. ... tu
d) ms
e) ms
f) ms
g) ms
h) ms
Of
203
-
6 OL)J
'>--
it
\R4
.a
\32%
t;:
c
UO
't
t,
Z)
d
t
cx
''
(4-
"J C*Wj
(23)
dig>
C--.
k*v
f
6'a
jqJ I
C-A: I.l
(j
(25)
.0
(U\Jl
U!
Ls
1-13.3 1
L&J
10
kjL-b
(26)
h
(27)
Z
C:
a) ma U-J.
b) ms 1,*.
d) Ms.>.!.ot
e) ma A4, > .
f)
ms
9) ms
h -) ms
Ms
C) msV.A%
15
220
0
GW-:ig &
->t
",
;;.
C.
),
(3---)
(.
(2
D
_IL
ca, )r-,.
e.,xu ju
t-NI
(19)
c:, u-2-.
Z1u.
axu-
v,
(20)
-
lleUlj
tbl-lb
61,
i
(22)
01
10
-[
; $iit
_%.;
4J
c-Ax--i
fed
1b)L-3I
fo. 91b.
C-)U.
Bl,
L-b
%b
\U
&
f.
-p
j'331
second
b) outer
left
hand margin.
left
hand marcino
Cjs.,,A3crossed
out.
d) ms
f)
Cf.
line
g) above the
12,
linel
ms (sic)
lq-
15
C) ms
e) outer
16<
suggest.
3ctj*,.L.
201
-
0
;JLjl
-X9
JL2%:
r'-
c) o-i'
G
'
C,
'ci
cb
"-
'
-'
ail
1
-
L-j
(-skc
10
)4P
fo. 91a.
ci
J"
);
P)'
6t4 ':
(17)
S
Ar
Zo-pul
CAS.
l3dl
wic
b) above the
cil
d) ms
->--.,I
e) ms
C. IL4
6b
J41
15
a) CL. above p.
0) ms
A.
%Qz
859 line
line.
.
13-
200
-
ba
4-k*l-c> elk
Lf, U31
\j
jg:,
01%
(10)
fo. 90b.
-k-N tM
Ao-U
cy.
v.;>
<,
14
.G
2.1
C.-,14,
tic--ei
a--u
"L,
*.
41
JLO
L.
ju
",
..
0-;
31
1.1
t
-t
u
o.)2;30. e;91
x.,
Lko
1"
o-4
-.
.
(13)
2j
au
ov'u
\i
4
li
-e rt.
c -:A
10
-I
; ijLj
Li
.r-.
a) ms
b) above the line.
c) upper right
d) ms
e) ms
f)
Ms
hand margin,
Z :
15
199-
(4)
b
(-, b
ILI
ce
ctj
ID c-;-Nu \J-.
9
%J
U-31
5iA;
'16 OU;
4
4,
a;
ZI
le,;
4.; S
cu
(5)
6
DI
**
sj
%-u I
cs,
<(; X)
0p
0-111
10
(4)
1
&-c
('-I
NJ I
.
6,
>Sq
47),
Lp
(8)
(9)
.01w--
a) ms
e) 'Cf.
b)
ms .
-0.
f)
0)
ms
d)
ms (; *J:>
me
-above P-39
line
14.
198
-0-
al
Lv
a
JLji
--
(5)
.b
ic
1
JL (-:.
so,
L-)
(JU
-*
otezi
Jowl
&.
jU
(1)
e
burol Ob-.. 91
Liu
cike-, 61
A-. bA
! A;
6Ls
C&-
31;
10
1;
ID:
>A, c--"L-fi
fo. 90a.
g---I
44
ju;
zk ij
f)
a) ms 0-0>6. b) i. e. .,.
C)
- kA; %icLi3uj,
jvi3
d) ms Ce4%
NIP )tcrossed
h) ms 01s out,
(-+j- ; LL
J) ms
>
(S-;.,
271;
J%
z;
gfo.
Sh7IrEzI,
op.cit., fo. 269b;
g) above the line.
M3
e) ms
h
el
CS-1:
j
197
-
cJ
I
tx:
\)
'c
-3
c i'
Cd
Luc
cyb
k.
v.
e;.:
(.
Ly-Al
(2)
(3)
-b
o. 89b. -
Ol
Vdl
,
e
10
0.9 10
1
WIll
LP
a) outer
left
hand margin,
$ mj3
15
f)
ms
b) ms
g) ms
o) Lee*
h) ms
d) ms
0
xbove
the line.
196
bL
d<.
.
'* I
k-
Lj
L:
UL.
;
I Z>
6b.., UA-r- -
e
(20)
(22)
v.
wi.
Zi
b;
--.
u5
94 za.
-
.4
z4%9
*.
.4
cu't
-9,1
a) ms
b) i. e.
C) ms OAe
d) above
e) mscu-At
f)
Cf,
the
4,
line.
e-:4;.
above line
4.
S) ms
h) ms
i)
outer
left
J) ms Xbkp
hand marging
ms
4;,;
%
xz
Z-*
10
195
k-
ul
but
Lvu.
IJ2J
'w,
O.
69,
)l
uujl
L4
Z*-Uut
ZuiUlz
L-z
10
C.
e
sc%
\j-x
-0
0).
ccil
(17)
0--mt& 4kc-
il
d-l,
&;?;
10
;. k. 3,1% ju,
rc
f o. 89a.
/d-
( (.Y6V,,-,.;wt.-,(.ut4-"
NN
6JI
(i
Zi
rle-c
(e--c
a) ms
b) ms
(sic)
c) ms
d) ms
suggest.
cf.
above
p. 16,
line
11.
15
194
-
&%
('
,
-e
)-'-,.,
Cs-
's2_9
CP
>S41
%
d>
")D
&'
-'-,
(
ju.
Iu
o'c
aN
A3
ONJ
LAC.
''
(il
CAS.
10
00)
f o. 88b.
13 1
.
*IJ
15
a) ms
c)
d)
i. e.
ms
e) ns
f)
ms
b) ms 6&
9) ms 1j; x h)
lower
MS
left
L"4AU31
hand margin.
193
b>o
:.
< GL19
(: k
a
I>-,
.3)
) o",
or. 3).
ux-OD
k. c;x-, cc-il
t;
(Alz
_3I_,
ou
ol-Al
* ; %
Or-
iJ
A-jl 4
YAJ
U' '&DU (3 I
L-
A
oks:
Ou
t C,"LAI
5'
c4vjl
LA. 0
(4)
(5)
f o. 88a.
t)
L>:..c
t
;
d'
q3
1-'L'J%1e.
..
h/9
Uj
(6.
Lnl
Ou.>
L)J.
C;, j)
-..
Ou cuil
io.
34%
uu
CP
15
a) above the'line.
b) ms Ls
g) ms
ms
C) ms
d) ms
e) ms
f)
ms
j)
Cf. Sjj'raj,
op. cit.,
fo. 262b;
- 192 -
dz;ilt
kt31
-,
Ajo
Uu
s;
fo-87b*
4p,
tfd::;
cJ,
f
(2)
4,
-g
)'
u)
t
\J
(DP
r-
'
io
-iiGMi
i*-
-''L9
L.
6a-,'%
(6
,
i;
Gi
>z
z-tuI -
%
cLe.
9),
a) ms
f)
b) ms C%,
g). ms
0) ms 1, ..
h) ms
d)
upper
e) ms
right
hand margin.
i)
ms
J) ms
k) ms
13-
15
- 191 a
1-5
do.
\j I
(45)
ct-p Uji
(p,
ul
(471.
foG87a.
(46)
Utz
0i
1
(:
')
d1I;
&)
b4)"
(48)
k:,
I(.
r-p-
(
-5v
I.:
L >Iuu
p-41
b
&-.
9 'r UP
. AJ
C-M:>s,,Lv-; J..
-J
ck-
10
(49).
ckL
J1(
JT
)
Z;
(50)
-,
1'5
WIC. )j :-
L:KA. 9
JI
a) Cf* Zamakhshail,
Ru b
oP-cit-,
vol-19
L9
b) ma
C) Cf. above p. 189 line
1.
P-337
190
i
t;
-;
LV
; 31
A.
UtI. &, ZL;(1:
141
I
(40)
5111
bk,
k4;
Lc-C,
ZM
--j
6
c
-L
'
4.6
-- uril
kf
4r
UPL42;
Ve
C,
(
1;
6c
"
6-9---
uu, >
(42)
14
du ZI
yl
10
k.? j
(43)
(44L
z)t .I di
61ji
( (3'P-"
z.
15
a) i. e.
b) ms
t,,: jcj
.
L-,U
0) ms
d) ms
e) outer
right
hand marging
ms
j,.
o: jt crossed
out.
189
-
\J
a<L,
J%>
c*J
c
iftGip---i
-,-b
.i
cy.
11
Cs--
4 -tJ
1 0,;
-5-b
U L--S31
4t
tA2-;
-;
t"4,
4.3..
ur6
c
3,
ZL;
C*
o
JS
ub.
(J-ZZ31 (it
G-JUJI
10
(38)
cos
ro. 86b.
ul
r6
d-li
le
42;
dj: i
2 L..
h>,
ZIJUJL
b>
(39)
Lu, > 4-L:g
-
t
,
z;
15
z
0-
a) ms
g) m8
b) ms
C) ms
i)
d)
J) ms
e.
e) ms
f)
ms
ms
188
-
(36)
L;
CAo
c4
tL)4
sj
ci
C,
JU
'cJ\)
(L
(37)
L6
W.
lp
L; j I
10'
cc
yu, >: o
EN
(3
LA.
-*JI
-Jt
L
9
iZ.
e4
Co
Gr'
(kj
U*'U,
&XO
a) ms
b) Cf. above p*61o line
C) above the line.
d) ms
e) ms
'Z.
%,l;
4 leui
)->l
15
187
-
Lo
LV
I-W
,;
61 (J-V.U., c,.c
It--')Jl
I
CL)k;., 9
A-c
1!3 (]-,
d-;,
I
(34)
fo-85b.
a'a
'10
Lp
t
(jt
4:4zJt'
I
(>4
c:4:;
*JjL"
u0 0-
%0
4a)t
Zi
a) Le.
-,
k-Z-
i,.
-i
j1
(.
e
(sic)
e) ms
cf.
e) ms
zuggest.
sug,>9est.
b) me
d) ms (ic)
cC1C
c*!
above p. 16,
line
11.
15
le6
rUDI
a
-6
Cj!
EN
(30)
L, -
*"
fo-85a.
(31).
)A2))
2d
LJ
cj,;
Ll
(32)
61 LAC.
\1
c LJ
10
31ul
ZjLji o t4, >- ;Lez-.
C;\j "
ijl
CA 3a .4
av]
10e0...
a)
b) ma
C) ms
d) ms
e) ms
5"--*
D
61-.
-
f) ms ILA,
-
6) MS
h) ms
E;,j
-'185 Li, I
f 0.84b,
.f
cL
-'
>-
(28)
L
_j'
(29)
10
oo
U411*
'(_s_
-'
.0..
N1
d
up
a) ma
b) ms
0) ms
d) ms
1'
15
184
cy--
s.:.;
fto
I-a
61
-
U-11-9
%6
C-N
c (79
; A---.
cAr-
LAC
QVN
(25)
bsL
LeJ)
-)
up
Z'
te;
up ii >-L-
A
(26)
-
. 0.
2Lii
cffi-.
p Giio'\ji um-,
-2)
10
(27) e
LAS.
0,10j,6:;
Z-, i
a%
opug;
k-,
j
15
(sic)
ms
a)
b) MS L,
C) i. e ...
d) ms
e) ms
f) ms
suggest.
Etjw%jv)
183
'7J
a"
'.
b
Cj
a;
(21)
cx,Aj
9
(22)
CAA >t;
i
Vll
E)l
%,
:
4%
D
:
-,
'
I.
6,
CIA-:
; LA,
q
LA-C.
(23)
10
a-lew
fo-64a.
Lyv..::, c
4
(24)
k1C:.;
a) Cf. SArazl,
II JU-1 I
06;A ue,e-A:
>
b) ms
P, -
C) Cf . no. a.
d) ms C)6.
e) ms L;j I
f) ms
"4
1,
C);W.%J*
&:.
0.tp!.J.> &
urzlu
"
ms
ms
Q ms
182
-
d L4r3
-b-
-.
ZJ
-'
Jt
(3J%(J
C)l
OkiILL
J!
61,9OIDLO-Jf
JLJI
\D
(-J
d.
J6 ILL
(15)
uu,
ci
(J'L,,U
> - auc.
UI
cJs
J
(16)
1Ji
cj, j
gout
cys
ZL-U.
Al
kfi, \J q
(:
.e
e-j-.
j->l,
gjj,
J% Lila)
c Ly-.:
Z,
.6 ,.
10
Qr
c>D
(20)
'Z30
Ut
>31
c(e
.
Gb
g',
top
0
64,4
Ut,
a) ma
L>U;
(I
$
ckIC
fo. 255a;
f) 'ms ms
0) ds
d) m3
h) ms
ce.. -4
aL3.
e) ma
fticrossecl
out.
CJ.
'.
i)
ms
j'o
15
lal
-
>
oj.
W> u;e
(i
(9)
b
-u
1
9
-ts -.
10)
(>P
\j
cut
c
<S
>
Lv
%b
fo-83a.
"0
L), O L6J
U.
-A
w-
a-P Cjjl
u 1w < \j I>
70
10
f
Liz U
U.
61e 1)1;
-9
.003)
651
15
9
110.0
3-
19
d) Cf . Sh9f J!
o2. cit.,
a) outer
left
C..
-e- I
f)
Ms C,
9) Ms Q"I
vol. 6, P-5;
hand margin.
180
-
tj
lw. > <
jui
Ou
b
<
LZP
(3)
(4)
u-tUil
82b.
-"%.
4.0"-tc
Lj
t;
-4,
rA-J
_;
ILJ I
3
(: J?.
(6
up
La
10
6
11-0
LI.. 's &Z;
JIU.
LS
\___
;;
0 CSm
(Lb)
".i
Mi
Mt
15
uD
left
hand margin.
b) lower left
hand margin*
a) outer
C) ms
d) ras ccbk; -
Le;
j i
179
1
"11;
.)UII
7, ,.J(4)
it <V,
-;
LA-C
bull
(5)
0-
fit;
LAP
J.
b
'C)o'
(6)
L2)I
c.
O-Jk4L-
94-IJ;
C-A.;
uo
10
l
(j-v
9.3 bi- N
(V
\-b
bo
1.
.
00
ut'p
(8)
etd
(4-551
.
DIA,
15
'
-4,
au
-ul
C. 4]
.4.
d.
a) ms
4pu -b) above the lines
C) M6
e) outer
f)
df.
left
hand margin.
13.
178
-
co
L13
-.:
Jk,
3j
Uu-
),:X ,
LyoLe:
Jl
U'L;
t)L4?,
(2)
up
c
Ux
"i
bC:,
UpLejl
-b
P
\.
1. tj-,dj ;\) 01
10
ci
1-0
%, Jl
LA;
L:,
U,
_J1111
ak--;,
ble
(ZDI
f o. 82a
15
v
Ui.
a) ma
0,0
b) ma
0) ms b-4W%
.
d) ma
0) me
A ms
177'-
cL
6 dv-Lm
4?.
L:
I
ill C-A
cl,
U4.,
g-
Z
; k.:;
LL%
LJ
CYC
ul
Ail
c-L.
LOY,
fo. 8lb.
k:tq,
"-,
I, Ul Z-9
10
2
i
-.
j
1'.
e
11
j\)
%
s
x.
_
-,
1:Ul
6c
cl
4) c)
(tJ
Ja
jJI
c?-1
"e
...
cA,
ou
c
ZJLJ
a) Cf. linell).
d) ms
b) ms
e) outer
0) ma
f)
10 LNb E Cj c
right
omission
hand margin*
in ms.
15'
176 b
C: --,
li
t cyj
ilv-
29 V*
.
4-- ti Lk.
(Y3> %,
t1c:.
-
e
dj
a) ms
b) ms
second
d) i. e.
d) Cf. above line
;>%
t%
\j cz , (y 4-*0*
.
.. -i
rj
yj
C) ms
4.
6J crossed
Zt-
out.
64
175
-
U.)x
"
WWI
Jul
C;jj i oll
4
"". u
t,
A
..
CA-
CE),
b
Jl
C...:
a--: 9
i
4c..
CUAI
Z: 9
&>3
Li
r
1..
u;
fo. 81a.
10
43--iii
,
-A
.
lt: >l
--
UU
euD
LskA
IiGil
(V LZJ I
"OLjl
; Lj,
L:
C>- N L'4% ,
11.
13.
' ;k.
15
174 -
Qx*r
Qfrd.
c*
(J
(2)
U)
iL2
(3)I_
t.
'I
1:
(.r
dLj
40
LIU
10
"u
o. 60b.
1j,
a) me
b) me
c) me : d) mg ye..e
.
15
ce:
L;t4%%
zi%
-4
&..
173
-
C)i 4
>9
A, iI
V"N:,
AC)
1,> Ok-,a-, 31 ,J'L_o
,
a
-5
w
Gl.
-4
a-XI
5
(5)
Ce (3-c. 6: \, Jl 6',
-"
6d
;
JL-jl
xq
-.
d
tuo
OA;.
%,
>Zz
-
LAX(7)
10
%A.
fo.
80a.
>>Ill
-Ck-e.
4-
\1lx
LP
k.
Ekil
15
00)
a) ms Z?z;;i -
9) ms
b) ms 6; 4
h) ms_tA)D
c)
MS631-%>"j
crossed out.
MS
d) =690, i,.,Z
J) ms
e) ms U,;,, t
k) ms
t -;k"
w
_q,
f)
1)
above p. 18t
ms
Cf.
M) ms
line
1.
172-
C-)u
oz
ji
vt
cA 1.I
\j
Z,-Z%
*iLii
LAO*
fo-79be
---
(e
C;
Up
j! ( -,; Ai
&
&I :J.
10
p'.-0
US
-1
.6
15
ts;
ILI
a) ms
>:& .
1.
171
LZI ,b
ool+Dl
0oo
r"A,:
-A
a) ms
b) ms
C) ms
d) ms
I
&z
170
ar
Mutz
>';i
IA
4-111
aiL-.. "
L; -,>
-t;
ILI
, t331
Ut
A-:
C.
1. I
--A
: l>
G>Gil
\j
2kj. L.
2%
b$
:1.
1
>Jl
Vtj
sj
>L
d-u
I
L5
I
C-M
(-iLz
Ce"
40
o. 79a.
A
.60 e
(3
Lju.
L'C'
Lrsji,
Ci4a
&-Ji
6A
10
6A
--b-s
(4)
Jj.
otj;
1
; JL. Ji
Ltj
.0e.
a) Cf.
Sldr7azl#
79
4 x ,r6
op.
cit.,
'm
3J%
jx>i L)%j
fo. 275a
b) ms
13-
d) ms
0) ms ; J1.
f)
ms
C4-- -
g) ma
53
h) ms
lp;
; JI.*,!qcrossed out
- 169 4-LP
7)
k;U, >
fo-78b
Le
ur
:76,,,
%3s>
1 uc
-- 3 %
ile,
i-%,
u-;
k:) t
CX4J
:'it uk al
LLP
ZI
i cjv-owl 6(ju
outz--.
uu Ct'-'Ml &.j I& qv 1,
P]
Ic
a) ms
b) ms
C)
XI crossed out.
first
i)
M13
point
d) ms
arranged.
e) ms
in E ]supplied
799., line
at this'point
supplied
from
fo-79al
5.
line
h) ms
in
9.
J)
from
fo.
10.
This
section
from
line
k-) This
at
supplied
8.
section
appears.
be incomplete.
to
168-
Uj
C
aL,
_
ALI
cr
x-;
i j
V
CAiil
Lj
Z,
4'
>;
u : -
10
b"oki'Lltsoll
(5)
cys
a) ms
-*A
uq
4.
b) ms 1.* :,
'j
167 baa
J
p33i
-s
C3
I.;
1431
;uL
1,Liu
fo-78a,-
10
L3
2L' ,6
\j
bit
qt)
T
c,;-,
jl%Jl
a) MS O-a
b) ms
d) ms
C) ms
e) ms
f) ms
1; pj
_,
9) lower right
hand ma gin.
13-
6-,-"Jl
--
166 -
bta
9J
Z>-V
I*
Lp
<
(8)
Bal
.
'
',I aJ"L---,
b
\ac1,
k::
"I*1
t
&- -,,
fo. 77b.
EN
A-.
wo
Ji
L3
Li
4VI
.
..
uL J>!
-0,1
OL,
JI
"Sl
t;;
U'
LT
01)
Ij
AJ
a) ms
d)
outer
ms
e) Cf.
lztUk
f) ms jp
-
b) ms
c)
hand margin.
io
00)
Z) ldv-, 3 :,1
tc \j
Jul
fe
91
Ok
c3
Pf.
ma
13-
ms
no.
165 a
-*
-
ll x-rl>
C.All-, Iii
i-
1z( (:)
53.61
C.5
i o
uL..
CJL;
&-ml
1 L3U1
LLP
w,
l.,
1
L-11,
;-
>
c-..,c
(50at
(3)
I'.
fo. 77a
(4)
C,;L/")
L
cv
! 'jI
Li! )
_9J
.: iIaJ,
'
C-..
911
%'k
ml
6t
co
4-.
---
". 1 (3;s1,
I
j
LJ
>b
(6)
'
>.
&
"44
c-,
tj\.;
io
zf-.
c
j%
'15
int
at
this
Isupplied
b) ms
c) ms dVi d6
d) ms
e) ms
f) ms
point
became disarransed.
Wj%crossed
,
out.
>.-
h) ms., oj,,L%
.
i)
ms
J) ms (sic)
cf.
above
suggest.
p.
16,
line
Ile
164
[,kj
f o-76b
* t.
e:.
-k-jl-;
Jl-
4I. J11
C. YU %
du;
I. (o
CIS
loe
61
LOU
#.
(8)
.
.0..
.
&x>
....
(9)
L
00)
j J;
-..
L4
01)
9 :; j
ul
9) The section
a) ms ok&
fo-77ap
b) me
,
C) me IAJO
h)
d) ms
ms,
e) ms x>5
f)
outer
ms
right
hand margin.
J)
MS
k)
Ms
line
in E]supplied
11.
from
163 -
(i)
-.
'_)-
'>--,
:f'
(,
jjl
(\i>
ib
iil
L.ZtjLii
I
U C,
:>
-)
Ci'
-.
4,0
d
)5
61
(3)
'
JJI
C;;?
C-m:>g"
'\4JI, 4aml
-ALI
lo
(4)
C4
k;
%,
L.O: >_9 1 ;
Cj
-01
L'
a.,::Lbwl
a) Cf.
above p. 161,
b) above
the line.
c)'outer
left
d) ms
C-wj-
e) ms L". tzj f) ms
9) Ms
line
hand margin.
14.
f
162 -
AsI
%j
aL,.
.-.I..
Ju
.
1,
6:
A6
IL
(je,
Gy
sb
-&
ue.
Litz
11
a.
(3)
d--u
u 1.;j)
fo-76a.
lo
JL;
Lv
J13
a) ms ;. >'l
b) Cf. ZamakhshaA's op. cit.,
vl
c) ms
d) ms
-q6
vol. 19 p. 276
Col. u. 's
U0,
cip
lo-A,
161
-
a-
(3
(3
__
JI1
600
&lu
6..
LAC,
J. uz>A%
UL,
Lilt
(i XJ IsIVI
e-go. uIC;
1)" ;)
0;,
r- &-p
a'.
tj
"fec
".
1, i)
Ln
c:A:
AJLJ
(4)
10'
Z.
fo-75b
-a
11.1p,
-,j
15
CAC
L3
Ati
I>
L4:j
(6)
,
a) ms
o Im.
b) ms A!)I
c)
e) ms
f)
Cf.
ms
d) ms Li 1!
ms
Hishiml,
op.
cit.,
fo. 235;
16oa
V,,
C. 5Az--z
bc,:,
xa.
U
t,
(33)
C)OU
&\.
L!
e
6't
fO-75a
C,--,
-,
(34)
U!,t
9-D-1
; JLJI
(35)
10
a) ms
b) ms
Ax -
c) above
d) ms
the line.
(sic)
e) ms
f) V's
g) ms
, -Uj.
suggest. F%6%
159-
t,
(3
jJ I
(2
(9LJI
fo. 74b
C.. jq
-,
i=e
Lim
jL.. A
-;,
Q.6)
CVLjl
611
G.,- Y-Aj
L
c: 4
tu
Vv
ULP
(27
66
-9
(28)
ci
CA'LA up--Ib
t.
c
>:,
c (
(29)
c916
':4
i 3,ri,,
cy.C? , >, j, -,
't_''
&-.
>
i,
(JA
A'
15
(32)
&t5jl
a) ms
b) ms *.A.cs ep%daziaged.
ms -b!'ll ; ,, it
d) ms
158
kk;
(231
US
I16a,
fo - 74a.
14
lip
&u
G)
k!o
I
_9
d I--
-1
1.;
>
Gi up
7
-..,
:, I
(J, [4'4,
).
((.& U0
0; i :>
!... ,W
111% kjo
)
( %,
, ju.
Ir
:.
A9
c;
Lj
t-
".
wi
U.
,
Z.3
cUP
;kidLit
61
dt,
24)
CA
-l
Uo
JL.
-r-
-%s 9
(.
ctl
G >-
Cil
U-1--il
ut
-11
ou -; tu
JL4
ex
j:
Gl'
%>!;
6c
a) ms
b) ms
C) ms
(sic)
suggest.
10
157-0
ZX:
.
kp,
:. aA
>
oixbk--
'%
iz>j
),
4jL--..
(21)
k.!
:fo-73b.
b
ci
e
--
\J
h.
Z
11
1 ..
.0
931
10
m
;
3-9
1.$3
CAC
n.
,3
>
ckskej
ms
\eV4I
ms
J) ms
above the line.
b) ms
0
]]is
Crt!. q 9 c7z
crossed
out.
1) ms
Va'I"I
n) ms
A
)
e. ms (sic)
o)
suggest.
ms
ms
me
q) ms
Cf
13-
M) ms
156
-
tr
;J ! J) :
OLC ),>.!I
-.
c
0,1
tA
fo-73a.
IJ
d2-'
;
I LA---
Ls'l kj-);,
-4,
C-21u
>j)
ui.
:i
cy -cov
ci
6dQ1 6^: p
Ii
c-s)
6s
ju
15
oa%
(20)
;jL.
10
UY
fe
4pk
6Ajl
a) ms
g) ms
b) ms
h) ms ZtM-
0)
Cf.
above p. 9, line,
d)
outer. -left
e)
Cf.
MISk p -
13-
below-line
14.
i)
outer.
left
15
hand maraln.
J) ms
k)
Cf.
ms
3.
155
t3
_.
I
jl
LJL.
,;
-*
'I
up
q
C.:
Lit,
&4; J
fo-72b.
olup
c--u I
U,
93
LS
uj, - - fclj-Ul11-11"t
- -0LLI
V
6
>,
4
o
I cu (J.,
'r
C-Ao
tN;
-Q
CL,. U-
tit;
Ge
,4
63A, C(59zl
ej.
\j
L; Ajl
lo
b
&,Liu
-0>
--gj
.6
&J I
ci-si-t
ci
\4
0 ZI)
ck.
-?
L
_.
,
j
I
;OJ
t3G
-fI
b-'u
a) ms
b) above the line.
66,
L;
C) ms
G Ajl
(3-09ALLI
15
15401)
ar.! p U3
&u -.31
,V
k,,
, Zr
"*I,
G2.,
0'4
t
C3Ab
f 0.72a
U3
ju
zal
e.
i'
uji
ti'!,
'
4I
th
cp
-,
10
(13)
ju
u; j 1.I,
6-9
L.-Iji
0 -OjI IJ,.i
7'
Us
h
>_4I
J'
>5s',
':?
(3
CA:. b
(sic)
a) ms
suggest.
tj'
b) ms I.:Kb
C)
ms
4.
d) outer
e) ms
jg) ms
left
.
_
f-) ms (.r .
tp .
h) ms \,,j, So
hand margin.
1,;.4N.
15
153-
We
iL-le
't
V_;
Lp
cseAJ
)Z-a-3
, Zk.it
-Alp
c: ju412;
(6)
fo. 71b.
"' e(
*
91
fe
*, bJ+ < &Wl
I>
CAC
in
ey-z,-k-4 , -,;i
CA
uv
**'I
Q0
a-..
,
-.-.
c;
ii;j , (-)
-9-b-9 t2
i (
LAW
I-
j-s
`4
CJLO: j
dL-W
CAAlul
CA
(7)
U,
j
L3.AL, 451I&V.
ou,
.g
.9
lz
A-zr-It
G, kzl
CAJ-
it
ib
b-o
4-12
e
1.31;
ci-.3.
A.
etLk;
10
Z; %)eZL4;jl
ZI
1., b
&e.: e. eu
(9),
15
6j
"
S.
CjLq C;
>
00)
.
6)mS
Ltc
L&
C51
ms
first
Ii,
ms
UIX.
I
Lou
,
-AP
crossed out.
1.
152
-
fo - 71a.
4 &110.
b >, D
Qv--
LIL;
. 'r it
: oL.
J1 6
V-U, 5
-VI
'd'
vb
f
96
> 3,e
C.31f
10
-*
41
JA1P 13-L-3 'L. g14.01
N it;
1,
(3jk.
c-
c: -k-i
',
'
ci,
G, 4,du ii 2eiN ,
->i
ji
,
10-
1-4;
j
1
d'.
Z
C-Aj
a) ms (3%wtl
b) ms
C)
MS
d) ms
0) ms
f)
ms
0 msciik7wh) ms
L;.., 4LJ*
- 151 %.
61
JI
(2).
'1
(P
(it
'3&
OL
(3)
10
f
(3
_LI
<C-'*
U, 2! 2.e 11.3
. -91
ei-gL1
-,
t,
Li
15
a)
MEI
i) ms
-c/
w6&;
I Lf,;%zjIJ1.1j)
1.
11,
J) ms
Q ms
ms
150
-
"t
\)
ti.
(172
.
ba
Z-tew
C--!!,
-p--ol
fo - 70b.
a) me
b) me
c)
lower
left
land
ma gin.
149-
uJI
C31!,
'"":
fo-70a
-,.
c C.)c
46
c33kl,;,Ck':,
b
<
> k6-
64"
(15)c
I,.
4-IL;
c1>.;. jt
&>-
e.
(16)
a) ms
b) outer
ZY0
P-
C) msz-;:A
d) outer
e) ms
-t'
left
15
hand margin.
<'J'>
'"
65t
UN
left
Oku E3;Jl
___
GJI
lo
_-4'
IV
ti,;i
&
e6
V
_5Xk.
)'
146-
CIO
-j
b
ck-XA
4-M
JP
Z*j7%
c, (3)
E
ep! -oj
(2)
tju
CUE
e
fo. 69b
(5)
OA
V-9
CA
(6)
7 -
; Lj L--)I
LAW
h9
;j1,.
01
>
-x-P,
6, r;
-1--I-
10
(8)
(91.
ajL.
J1
,
uw
15
00)
m
a) ms
b) ms
(sic)suggest.
IFaraquIniq
Cf.
C)
6, cf. above
p. 16, line 11.
qunansvol-3, p. -245;
y
4) Cf - P. 146, line
15-
e) Ms.
h) ms
i)
ms
J) ms
L& C4 L;;.,
I U.>-
ms
(sic)
9) ma
Suggest.
J.
M) ms
147-
Co
3u.
it
xis C.;!
a
c..
(92)
ZJ
Ui
rg
C-
(93)
6L
-c
(94)
c
J-0
(95)
'5
d
fo. 69a.
6184
>
ul
(96)
&,L 31 r
-\:,
I-,
L\:
.
S
01
.
I_,
r,
-
,,
' ti-/>
10
(97)
(98)
>
(99) k
CA
: %? (JI
(c. L
r-'
(
15
000)
f)
a) ms -Ci
b) ms (Sic)suggest,
line
C) ms U
d) above
e) lower
the line.
right
hand
%.
P, cf.
11.
above p. 16,
9) ms
b)
ms
-*
&PI
ms
J) ma -k
-Q
9
ms
crossed
.;
L:41
out.
1) Me
I.
Lf > -
146
-
; Lj
(87)
6
-*
\1
LLJI
Lj
ZVnl
-01
ae
Ly
fo. 68b.
<-; !)>
(_J
U,
'j I%
-
%J *
t. -J.
19
c;; oi
:; Cb)
1o__
\j Ci
it
f
6.! A%
Im
lo
(89)
ul
t1116
I
4
I...
(-:,
Ul
uj
I V.,
(90).
<
(91)
a) i. e.
b) ms
0)
M13
d) upper
ms
e) ms
t-leill
right
f)
Cf.
g)
above
shlirZzl,
op.
hand margin,
crossed out.
the line.
209a;,
fo.
cit.,
"
r-U-51 r"'t
15
145
-
(82)
ell
I'azx
tL41
.10
d
N-!t--xj N-! L),*. Il
-
fo. 68a.
-0
b,
kjl
(:41.: s jri
..
J1
q
*C
Xr ; t-; ; J1
S%j
6
-Z
k:,b U,
33
6!
*,
1
Y-
VA. C-,
C---Ol
-,
LPL.: Jl
6,
f
Alla
-;
Jl c
(83).
R
84)
9
J-
- --%
-10
ul
<
ON;
(85)
Li
LVL=i
olc
d--Ul
l
L, o
Q. ;,jLjl
(86)
a) ms
e) ms
b) ms
f)
c) outer
d) ms
right
hand margin.
above
C) ms
the
(sic)
line..
suggest.
IOAr-j.
h) ms
i)
ms IbAl,
it
crossed
out*
'15
144(73)
.1
L-,bu-. 5
*e
b
..
t_
fo. 67b.
y:
'
(je 3
(75)
5
(76)
(77)
t:, jt
u4 J- Cre-j N C-vo
; jLjl
jai
cL
-A;
-;.
-
(79)
lt.
eg:,
a) ms
b) ms
60
10;
(.
-.
-1
(78)
143
L:
4. JJt!
-bLk
'-,
t)
#J'
a-: v
(69)
(70)
ULI
c3*3
-,
i
1,
. it
10
aW
ZL.Ik
t
72
0
v>131,!"%
>
--3-92.3,1;;:
Ub
c-L
C-L 34
md
ms
f)
M13
>1-9
ZL"\Jl
13,
142
-
,L
-4
iIA, Z. 9 ', ju
-3-z
(64
je, 1c
01-,
. np
LA
4>19
Xz
(66)
2Le ,.i
B-; j I
V
%.
LAc
Z> ;, w
",
1. 4 eu U 1)1.1
6'
Ci
L\lj
_94
>L;
p
G-4L-;-- ea..:
JU-
Lb I >-- 1, t
cr Et;
!'41
ul
"-,
I
611"
1.
d! -11I-ILJI e- NA-21
SQ1C.
Y, 0-\:-c
10
(67)
r !)]
]uu
91I.
-J-
a-j,
?,
D
I
L-4i
Cu s Z,6j
Ij I
e
k
Nj
(68)
M
6j.
fo. 67a.
[63
6.2
CIL.11
a) ms
h) ms
b) ms
L.:,;jI-
Z,
ms
kIL; C)
AL-ji
d) ms
-
J) ms;> 63.)
e) ms
S;
59
Skraft'l,
Cf.
P.
1) Cf. Qur"in 4 . 25
vol.
cit.,
op.
f)
ZV;
t-Z.:
g)
W% 6%?.
-jI
GI. N4.
Vj*50
CLA
6-1 C.IVJ.J%CAIL4.3d%ZI.
-
no.
It.
lower
right
hand margin.
17"
141
cy
jl
1z)l;jL,
;:'$; 'c., t
'
U'.
uj,
Jt
e:'
(58)
10D,
%"
'g"
(59)
6-L::aU, n2lz
C-)
Ii
(6o)
4.
P;
cut
-;-:
10
<:
_u,
Jr>
c'
AJ'L
c'
(62)
Ztj
.1 Ljj
-V
Ut
(631.
-,
CAj
LJO,
15
a) ms
Z14I
9) ms
b) ms
C) ms
i)
d) ms
J) ms
e) ms
k) ms
f) ms
outer
left
cj. X
hand margin.
140
-
bit
rtiL--0
(55)
iN i
-,
LLI
49
0
1-P,
4*cla
EN
_.
dIcC:.
-
-U
cz
_;;
-g-p-:
(57)
&
%..
zu ',' -5,9--9
a.
.
h_
CL,
i
a) ms
b)
outer
right
hand ma gin.
f)
MS
g)
ms
L5;a,.I.
1145A.W%
0) ms
h)
ms
d)
i)
e) ms. L):>l
point
at
this
became disarranged*
The section
in[
]supplied
1.
139
-
Z4
il
(.t
6 u;
914
C)-'>,cy::.
Iflel
(50)
(51)
&
$I X
u-n. UIPU3
;;,
: L...
)I
L
JL
%
_;
;. i L
(52)
-f*
(53)
C,
I
'A
.
4AL;
T*6C!,
fo. 65b.
l) :>
-,
61
(54)
ubI
a3i
LJU LJL; j
ij
u,
qGt;
1,
cuz,
i
'c
r.
t1
10
ti>
Ail
L2J
LP
4,1t)
tob.
C--,
J;
b
z
pl
.
tj
b) outer
right
hand ma gin.
,;,
>I'll
15
138
P3t
iA
iU'
)&)1
; 5;;
a
b
'.
I C.:,?..
-4
6\3 i ov!
4J
oA,
Sb4...
C)
6, >Lo
-.
II5
t
C.
c3
d<,
6J
"I
';.
to
wIe
[aiL
10,
(48)
j
(49)
1:ii
ci uAj
'i
ms
-a)
b) above the
line.
0) pas
i)
d) lower right
no, h .
k) ms
L:..
e) Ms
hand-maygin.
IJJGO.
f)
Cf. no. h
.
Ms
point
66bj
became disarranged.
M) ms ! SZOj
The section
137
-
3e
&
c:
Z
-)c
(J,
ut
\f
(44)
.
%-ib
64b.
1
'.
\J
'4V.
(45)e
f
. ZI
63u.
\1
-A;,
Cl
CLJ
\)
>l
vt;
I-
I"
46
(47)
.0.0
:0
Li
bsk-0
a) ms
Nil
b) ms
c) ms
d) ms
e) Cf. Sidriailt
f) ms
207a
10
136
wi
\j
-CA
JUJ.
ccilt
co
14 <Z\j
>
dS'-I
u'u.
u. c,->
b
o:>.
6--i' ;,jLji.
(39)
ILU.
Li
> -( -r *q
611
CkAr
ul
cf-
tj
(41)
-10
(42)
i.
(43)
cgs
a) upper
left
b) above
the line.
C) outer
left
hand margin,
hand margin
supplied
e) ms
s
cj_,
f)
I -D
':
ms
MS
at
, ms
this
from
fo.
point
became disarranged
65b., line
3-
h) ms N>I-qj
i)
above
J) ms
The section,
the
line.
135
-
(33)
.0
(35)
q'a
cf
VU
C-.,
Cj IL
(36)
(34)
;LJLJI
do
t4)J cA4aJ) c
cJ
ck
CAP
cut
(37)
8,91
t;,:
10
(38)
e
c: 45
9f
A
Lo.
2y'Y )1 e-U
(-il
.
hs
Jql
a) Cf. above P-859 line 13.
b) Cf* above P-1339 line
10.
A.91
UP N.
Cj
r) ms
MS
fo. 202b,
Ms
U31-
15
134
(29)
b
a
LCi1
&1-! e5
w CA
(30)
e1
U,4-1
c,
c>
Lt
. le
G.
M-
19
jl,
O
,
t
. -5) _;_,:
t>
T"
4 >v -3.
61
M-
Uu
V.
Ul
ir
-,ju*
lo
a'a C.P
fo. 63b.
CILr.
(V
6"
c ZLIOI
(32)
U'l
Jj
;;, jL...
)i
t.:.u,
ZN
a) ms
f) MS
b) ms
0) ms AO I
9) ms
12)ms
i) ms
line
Cf..
P9-85
13
above
e)
9
15
133(22)
ju
**0
%Ubt,
(23)
6s(24)
Ls
'd.
I.
';
CAL
.9
uL
;
ig!
4Ni
i
b
%:
>i c;\jl &
,
j
q9
-- lD1> Lt>:,c c' eg-:;
z)
-,
25)
lo
(27)
fo- 63a.
CU
J V9Oj
cy)
up
cu
m
>S.
CjI
,U
t-,
(28)
T,.
-"
10-9 :
ul
Nit.,
43%
15
23
yvol-79p.
ms
IAA -
h) ms (sic)
b) ms
i)
ms
ms
rCj*U-jl
UD
JL]
io
e
M) ms
C..:
11.
- 132
II
-IC.
,.
CY,.
'&, '
w,
ZA;
-;
b\
e Ol
'Jh
\j
I cs-, \j I
I \Jj-
I
\JJ
ALJ
(18)
\i
fo. 6U.
fi
'! 9b
1 AIL
I & j
DI
** V., -o
ul
"z
U
oc,
%,
>I
*I
.0
, LAI-A
U-
1"
It"
""
U1
"
I
'10
(20)
LV
ed
Glj I
(, \. c
U"-l
-b
tL (xc
1-9
%.
4ig
"i
k-LU
&Lki
U-9-i
Jp
a) me
k---- -
b) me "14
C)
me
d) ms
e) Ms
ib
'
131
-
UJI
QV
Uu
uji
'j
-A-..
"
Gd
.09
5
(14) b
LA;
fo.
62a.
CA
CLILD
L>-.
ql
10
Li
lrL;
U-4j
-.
6jl
";
D,
15
1.
130
if
-7
1
a
UJI
L4
C::tl
g--m
--
fo. 61b.
(8)
zo.
utla--u
Uxc
>:-
e:
jL--.
b
.r41
YL4 &
'3
(34i
Ul
)\
>; JF
cr
0002.
61)
Lj
J>uol
L3 Jljxl
a) ms
f) ms
b)
g)
ms
M15
-Pk'Ol! -
0) ms
h) ma (sic)
d) ms
me
0) ms
Joj--A
suggest.
10
- 129 -
&4; J
%0
to,
fo. 61a.
"' &
(6
'W.
ci
LiJI
.1*"1,
v
Q; 4-t
0
CA4P
U*gl
YLA
LJ
(3)
JL; OSI
WO
; JL.... )l
LAJI
6"%
o
.I-;,
(Ac
is
:>4
-'
-4
w
2;4AJ
o3ii
(5)
Ii
a) ms
b) ma co i
C) Ma
Lw-
ms
e) ms
.
-5
f) ms (sic)suggest.
__
L4;j I
f
d)
lo
to j cf.
11.
128
-
-)I.
> (: %
boll
li
"Ad'
kl
( a-W, --
e-.!
) C;--^jII, b
(DI),
I; q,
P&
O'. j
60-
e-Wl
-.
-j
J'
I,
I&
f-UN
-4A'. .,
c33
,1
-? >.; -1>--,p)%,
C-A
C-7-9
*r $
ul
CQl
ul
C's,
(23)
b
k1)
(24)
(25)
-I")
4J
10
i,.,
ci,
(26)
o
&l.t Gc(27) te
ZPL7-11
--1.
(28)
u
,.
suggest.
L4
Gi(
,-,
4...
%_q
c!112
3
el.:
.i
127
-
fo. 60a.
Qr U31
UI
ZI LfAlill
Zp"-51c>.
c
(17)
06.
wo
..
ul
>--
'
"c
(2.0)
.L
10
21)
&; UJI
jt;
ii
: Lj
(22)
.0
LD
15
(01
fo.
60b,
a
k.U
Cj-tX
i
-h
L. <..))
10.
'no.
)
b. Cf
a.
.
g) ms &I'>6
h) ms (sic)
ms (sic)
13.
ip
suggest. %,
126
-
fo.
ao. j
59b.
Lp
\! A
LJ
(?y#a)
<
WO
lq
AJI
4d.
UL.
cr..q
WWI
<
10
OR
U\j
oa
ou'l C-S
-Ole,
"wn,
k
Li
a) mis
h) ms
b) ms
i)
0)
ms
;,
p
top
d) above
the line.
e) above
the line.
f) ms
I .
>;..
g) ms
CA; -
outer
J) ms
k) ms
(sic)
right
suggest.
Ill
A.: -
hand margin.
125
L)I
ji
16
kLc.
b3 1
uI
(L)L6
ck-s
CJL; j
La),
4-jil
UID,
xo
1.14
cp
IL>
(J]
(8)
g-V
Ujl
Z:
Lx
ka
(9)
ks-
o3j
ju,
Cy
-clkj I
LA. -O
; %>u
LAI
uka
\: a'-)
(10)
10
r-.; L! ctsUwl
9
Lsj,
>
g.)
L;,.,
OLAI
(1 2aJ
h
Lj
r
(12b)
15
a) ms
b)
ms
c)
Cf.
above
Pi389
line
5-
9)
d)
Cf.
above
p. 4,
line
it-
h)
e) ms(.*
f)
Cf.
ms
i)Cf.
Zamakhshar7i
LJ UI
L&
op.
cit.,
vol.
2,
V. GI
Z=akhshar7i,
p.
op.
cit.,
loc.
cit.;
16
vuV-4A
uls
)
(J!;
124ac
C-'
is
"I
sX\
::
4JJ%
&'
Q if c I ju qvo
-,:
5
oj
_J_,
'L
1j,:;
Tj
(3)
at'
10
WA
0,1r.
6 -V
IId
X
11
d- lj
L?"p
d"
-c
f
L6
(7)
V-U, >
(6)
-pi
u z.,
ciol
ft0- 59a,
i
a) ms
b) ms
0) ms
d) ms
e) ms
f)
ma
t, I
(sic)
suggest.
;ONJI..
15
123
-
b
>u:ciq oulie
CeUA?%,
Ak,-.
c
',,6p
.
I,
I,
Ll
tjv
.o
111
\j
>IN I*Z;
-. IW
10
'J
ctD
(--
-"
\!
Zj
L;
C.
--Vo -0,
fo.
j
OLP-;:
C
ook-,
l
UL.1
58b.
a) ms
b) m.
8
f) ms
9) ms
C) ms
h) ms
d) ms
i) ms
e) ms
J) ms &
k) ms
ms
122
__
(3)
i: >
&'
V
J'Ld
%Xb
b
41
C,
t5
jq
uaie
0,
9
01
..
j194x
,`e
6%.
vxAg
fo. 58a.
C-A:
>'Q
10
Ws
.
a) ms
b) ms
rjc
C) ms
Ow
..
d) m's
c6
line
13.
121
-
cf'
cj
L; L)l
9
-.
(j;; J
C)
c. JUy
a'
3L
". r
/
IG5
AAr-
ajj
; JLJI
57b
.
64w,
C.6
10
a. 1.0%C.
%:
>I
'u->
"U,
Ll
.wjW
f
C4!,g>
IXO
9
),
OK.
zt:
mp.
-si
%j
oil
.
LV
*
.&
82ki
15
..
(2)
ubIb
0
a)
b) upper
ms
right
hand margin,
*1 crossed out.
e) ms
f) above the line.
g) Cf. above p. 189 line
h) ms
0) ms
ma
OV
q ,o1..
i)
J)
M8
A3;;
1.
120 -
(26)
(27)
JU(28)
c-Li
Ec
01
CAJ
(C44;
'-,
b1
01.0
"9
fo. 57a-*Illlb
d-JJI
'X - - --5
>.j I
Jl
ozc
IJM
j,
6c-..) al-2:
Cjl
L
).
,
6x- "0e;
Z;
3ke
V"5
64.
-;
10
L9-9
rc
C-,P L;j I
(301
LV
Lj
C)tr.
.
C
15
0) ms
d) ms
0) ms U-1>411),
-
119
-
61
OU
uzi >'
&oNo'll
014; ZLA,
JuLp
(22)
AGJ ooil
zj
uL
&'
a
fo.
56b.
ue:;:; %
1 .10
CWI
d
UJI
(23)
Ape..
(24)
o-5.3%
; LjL., D
(25)
f
6uo
I
YU,
;4C.,
a) ms
o
_, _,
b) ms
L:.,!
C)
-c
ms
d) :Lee*
e) above
f)
ms
9)
M3
the line.
ig
10
118
-
fo.
0..,
35
6k.:,
ky,
56a.
LJ
L:
LO
"
a,,
.
\J
4:
LAP"-
"UN
OLP.:., p
(20)
u;
LA
cw
j
-P.;.
0 ltltj
Ly
LV
>i
f-
ty4'0--
i-ej
>3jl
t>bj
$,
,,j
,t, 5N1
9c:
G>
10
.&i
du
a) lower. -right*hand
margin.
b) ms
crossed out.
C) me ZjI, )VI d) ms
Ms 6-e>-VIj -
117
W5
b
tw
dtll*
6.9
ciw.
k, 6t)
C; A,
6jr,
kk,
LV
5
Og
CP
vjooi
(17)
(18) 1.
-L:.
p
-j)
u-T.,
JL.,
1,
4,61
;
zau
%
,
,
-,
>i,
%l
c-:--p W,
dxs
'>-'
'>-,
C'
k<0)
1
(
JL.2
t:,
9J
a) ms
b) ms,
fU
0) ms
10
6--tc
l)
(:)i
h)
13.
MS
m5 6X. -bA I
(p
crossed
out.
- 116 \I
(:)14a
'&Jj;
CM;
:j9'-fl
'>-'
(13).
1
__
t
CJLV.
:A,. p
daq
659
QA
J?
-)p
_-bjq,
U9
V,zk.o-.g
0.
-: 0
C,:
't-.i t (i ji
-z
]
g
u
,
LLI
-.
A;
e
c-m
.10
%.
U4
6
5-1>
.,;,
-,
.i,.
1:I
91.
Ck
j1
611
9j
t>
60
e:g. ,bi
e, 4y lo c-.
4
'U
zJ
`7
L:U 1
c--, * W,
ukr-
4t,
a)
b) ms
0) MSAI
ms G-' --
d) ms.
ms
e) ms
i. e.
ms Jj"k
-4
g
55b, -5
%" 3u -1.4
'j
.
'.
%0
Uji
9
,
10
115
a,
CQ
uL_
b
01)
sx-41
i
W1e
1.u 1 ( c.....,
0
C.,
* -'
ta
,%1,
zz )
ue-"
juji
c-
eiL
:'
:, I
cu
),ke
*
--
Ut
; L.:
cy -Li%
10
cLirz
j%
sw,
ejk:
out
'Z s
c)
ul
j
'Ai
I-b
.u
h
ejlj
fo. 55d.
m
4
..
L-,
15
C-Awu
a) msko.31b) ms A.:,c
C) va
al %I
d) ms
CV;
e) ms
ms
ma
h) ms
I-
114 -
urb oW
k4e-)it3k34;&I
c
(-,,.
A-L
IN
Mut
ex.
*'c.
C.
cit
->->-pi -" cu i,G
-t-L
Jh
6e4p-
L,
>: x
L5
t-u, >
L L3
JX;
61A 131,d-ij
Ct;j
Ull I:xv.
V-il
j
(3>
-;
Li
Cj
lo
ZA"Juj
CA-
c, Uk'Alj%
fo- 54b.
(10)
d
c-, ug: D.- U%
u%
tV. C-P
Ue. C-JU,
J%
),, D
Vj;
6L
a)
MS
k;
L..o jl
second
b) ms
C) ms
d) ms
i ,"
crossed out.
113 -
A-P-L
, cly->j Zia;
lj>u >-ti1
(i)
1.1,
CAJ -t-,ei
*.
Zi
csA
. Ls;
Az.'; uM1b1&1
-q1
14
tv 16ZI
!)a.,
-,
alo
Lo
;S
(3
to
h-.
4b,
>L40-J
(3)
0
Ly
C"p
kd v
U6
10
Jto
dIA
(4)
Uzi
e-6 (31
-ccL3
fo- 54a.
114
tit
u
15
(6)
CD UJ I
k,;D
a) ms
e) ms
b) ms
f) ms 6
C) ms
Li-- -
g) ms
d) ms
1,
h) ms
-A-0 -
112
-
S7)
j
Ul
S
th
bb
Aq
Lit,
.0
'J
i
a
LV
-.
a
Li
J3
Ljj
a 'o
too
yj
fo.
UbLb
53b.
vv
4:r
Lp
L3
Q-x
L31a
aa
LA Li Lb
Li
'
6!,
d,
-Jtc
6,1
lo
L:.
Jl-e
(-0*
jUL.
16.;
2
Jll (:.)A
a
Lk-&0\41
15
a) ms
9)0-e.
b) ms
f) msLmk:
"
c) me
g) ms
h) ms t: #V"
8.
ms
-111-
(i)
"x
-'
*
l%
,ve
.
3u
Aur.
,
b
t
(5
'x
c:
-4c,
JJ
0-
cut
:,.
(5)
-0
ul
I
10
U'
C)
"
'ci
'-
>i
G4
-J
CC
(JAM\JI
1;
%:
>Ibig
a) me
b) ma
ma
d) ms
er)
f) i
'-,
'l
, me
Lpe-;.
15
110-
bwxI2
A; D
I,
L,
; U'Ll-b
-;
(7)
0-9, ZJLt
CLAIO-
-LA
jk,
(JQI
(a)
fo.
52b.
ew
'031ol
(9)
&Jl
1\V.
10
Z4 v Zv
'L. J1
ai
.0
6*
LIJ,
-I-?.
.i
'l,
CU
(.0.;A
ul
CLJ.
L&
OL,.
f
I<
15
ul
>%e) mslp%.
f)
L'A
1.
16.
ms
9) ms
Ij
d,:,j_.Ojb_ja,:)%crossed out*
log
t--i
'
eee
u-ll
>
.
-'-
:; 31lf
di
-.
/, u>
>>
JL;
Q
lu
6
c
d4l
dL;
'G
_J
CJJ
5
-
uz lb dij,
(5)
>-p 4
L'->,3
fo-52a.
.7j
ul
&., >:i
>
Lv-.
OUIV
yj:
Al
10
ul
e
-ul ar- o
15
a) ma
d) ms
b) ma
e) ms vj,)
is
e *. 009
C)
Ljvjj J\; ]
f)
ms !,; I
108
-
C--Ujooo,
*)
f..
Ei
il tI, <j]-Q> ) *.>
11ziu ii
2,
i
-9
U'l
oJ-
14't
.:
Z
6t;
i
,r, f
ul
"I
ky
rz
%
c-j; p-7J (.
; A-A
--"
U--j
to-
51b.
quel
-9 eIL: , r..XA
\J
ck
10
. -0
Li
<1>
Zl
tit;
Li
t.
JL-A
zstc
J6
od
06
J;
.
il*-
UO
. i,L; -'A9r0
A
JL;
b) ms
ms
db I
fo.
PWils'al-MasVilt
a) Cf. HishimIt
0)
OL-A-Z-A
right
crossed out.
ms .0):;j -
*.
,;
Z--j g) ms
-
9 ms
hand margin
ms
A..
160
Lr
A.;
-\AA
15
io7
-
oalul
L3
LP
IA
.I..
"I
fo- 51a.
Ve
(J2
.
(9i ct
c,
9.10
e,. Lji)
t-&
.,
lineS
the
a) above
b) ms
e) above the line.
d) ms
C4jI
e) ms
f) ma jkjju-
uu
lo6
-
lol
w9k
Co-,
12
;
9,
>WO*
&.
t.
.
; LD,
4;
-'-!
_)I
c?-e
I c5
fo. 50b.
.
ti
c-,
..
I,
1:
ZL-0
g
G
't
ea2,
-
(t
I,
(1O)f
mI
.,
c-2
-
L. Ji j.
((J
.-e31 19
'c&J
10
J, 21
; LA_JI
oJ
0 1)
b)-outer
cJ
d) ms
a) ms
c)
.,
left
hand margin.
1.
(sic)
e) ms
f)
suggest.
ms j;, O;. %
Ov.
crossed out.
105 491
oG
Cj_.-y.>>
-A...D-LP
F1
ut
a, %,c
co
6A
j I
yl;
">:
i.
a-,
"4)_9
('
uo.
r.
61,
;j >;
fo-50a.
.s
,g
34 \-?
(J9v(0
ci
il
(-,
s
p
:
(J-3 &x>%"t2>-tmcui
10
-42JI
W9U
UNVNV.
d. X
UUI,
l c..>
Le-,:
15
(-) 1
U
).
Cb
.
Le:-
i
(
e) Cf.
b) outer
f)
right
hand ma gin.
c) lower right
hand margin.
d) upper left
hand margin.
i. ee
,
-%kz
above p. 189 line
>o
>
-.
1.
\I
- 104-
bj:x
Ul
Z? uu
.i&..
( ci,.x 3 ti zrei
4
-j)-4
dJ J I
Cyr-
fo. 49b.
-tj
L;
ttji
eu
10
10
(4)
CiA.
.
,6
It
6l :#jL,
9t
wl
wI
Ij
Q.
15
ih
Ij,
27
line
Cf.
above.
p.
a)
,
b) Cf.. above p. 8, line
16.
13.
ms\ZD\SW
IfA
...
g),
ms
one above
the
linp
--:
crossed out*
-
C) ms
d) i. e.
f)
JXX3
13.
103 -
zt
(5)
fo. 49a.
UM
cja
d,
6
L>- li
Z,
j2,331
_,
GI,
ut
I LPAC
1,
'.
>,o
kA-" -ku
L$'--,i
IX0
ullJ-9
-*
C-9
LIJI
Uo
1 1.
lo
Th
u_u!,
, i:
1j
uL
a) ms
b) ms
(sic)
0) MS
d) ms
e) ms
f)
M15
g)
h
ms
ms
suggest.
lpjv -
102
-
(1)
ajj, , z
q-4
.
.0a
0b
(j
fo-48b.
LD I
7i
cjk,. a-vi
X-C
bZ
J'
&'
a(frJ
c
Z)t C1A.
uC)A
LV
ovi
151
J,
ulb";
T,swI
UI-
.,
tA
5
JJ'
OuI
Ul
(2) 'h
10
;JI
IC
LL-'
T,i
Lit
L55-Sle
6VUJI
Li
c>. 91 (34j, (i
v,
(y
c-p-
\! Cu
a)
M13
-*,
" Ut
b) me 1I
C) ms
Q%
d) ms
e) ms
f)
suggest,
ms owl Cv. .
g) ma
%:;
h)
ma ck:z.(Atiz-Al
i)
ma
J)
ms
t:, i
2>gt.
ZY0
-
15
101
-
Lo
tv
Ep
_
!.
1.6,,;
1
L,
9
LAS
a) Ms C)vI: t. ) .
LAC
(J jj
t:, c
100-
-0
60
1,
Wu-i
muh
3b
"0
L (j3j
; L"-L-,
(J5,P
Dt
uu
koj)k?UA-l
I
--u 2pzi,
5
u"i
Gf-
fo. 48a.
c-.
e>jb
f
9.
(,
2
I 0,>JN
o-.;i -k, :4jum
;kid
"t
VbUNe-m,>,
j
LL)l
up
1 ))
1
'4
-a
10
ulwo
Ce Lit
uj Lo
lz>t
I
(5) hIs
ar
a)
ytq
11.
b) ms-:L? C) ms
1
* 4311
k. I CA...
eW-,
1-e9)
,
ms
crossed out.
d) ms
e) ms
f) Me
MG
k)
99
a
[ZiU161-A
(I)
&L'Iji
ceur
-*UA-l
tluo
too
CJL,:P-jl
Wr
C--t3.
(2)
Llb kb d..)J:>
f
ul;
c-A-D
a) The ms clearly
b) ms
C) Ms
&All.,
a) Ms L-U Cel:> to
e) ms Cj,, b%Cf .
f) i. e.
at
this
The section
point became disarranced.
from fo- 48b# line
8, ms
supplied
in
ga
-
L:jr
zull C-.?
b
a.,
rust
):,. cj
J1
61
6L4
cd
?.
ul
5.1
.
D
Zuz
UIA
L6
(;,
C'6b
fo-47b.
d_j
Li
al
a) ms
b) Cf. Sblriaili 9 OP- cit-tfo-158a
A
e-j
c)
ma
ov,
d) ms
e) ms
f), isee
r LIV31
]
tju;
Ls
lo
97
-1
up
tpj
X.J.zq
Y-tj
(3)
C)v %,
i
!A
,'
d-1ct.;
2)
Vj
e-
2
-!
O-47a.
l
Lzp-?
(-) 1
IrI
jk;
52>
ZN)
U 0-,
Il-e;Ljl
;;jUi
Z WU
>O
EN
*0
\j k:,
i
i
Lij i
ri
-OPIP
a)
10
1-9
-SD
e ez,
(5)
L,
e->-;L31e.. Lt
...
i*
uI
LcILb
X?
4,
t.9 >i
(sic)
ms
b) mig
d) ms
suggest.
0) upper left
f)
ms
hand margin.
15,
96
-
NJI
tTi tGC,
V.9 t&[
1.2xz.
?'
(9)
00)
Ls Uu, > Al
-
fo. 46b.
JA
Ac
01)
''
Ul
-* c-I-
Uo L: , i
volp"
"4dk-tu ;LfL
L-,p---jj" A--:il 3-.
-&
-eqe
&
--.-p
(14)
31
41
U!
'D
6
-k>L-) z:
,
Ju
(13)
>-l; 1-
cJJ)j
cS'-4"
(12)
31
a) ms c-;pW, -
V--f
io
95
-
-.
le ct
1z>I .00.
J,
--2
--91
1.
Cz
&i
_A
i [;zthp)
>u
,
'511
ZU\)-41
a-4-a
C-L-i
(.
yk;
-.
--
e, i 1
q LD 11.
cl,
5
fo-46a
(6)
Jl
EN Jul
E41
I cy
q;pu')l
CI;
(7)
jL.
L11
h
LP
tiv
Zu\j
31
di
U3J
h
CjC
_j,
kjLj
C,.
Lb Lp
(8).
ap uj I LAC C,
a) The section in
I suPplied
from fo. 46al line-2,
b) MS
9) 2"
C) Ms,
h) ms
d) mo
i)
0) Cf.
above
P-85P line
13.
MS
J) ms
Cyt
PC)c crossed
out.
10 -
94ba
lor
A;
I
L,
1;l
je
I. S.
-t.
c-ewl
_--
-I cy
cc.
I :>I
To
a-NJ
U4? --9
.
-LAPC-W
pLp-
U'll,
UU 1>
.
;;L)L-. Jl
st, ;ou
--iLe
v1
[41>
;iL. 41 ci
-'
L; eA_
L-bl
ua;
U'j. uU
4 6D; J
c-.,.,.
0
a) Cf.
HEshiml,
op.
cit.,
fo.
c) i9ee
148
.0.0
b)
point
from
became disarraneed.
fo.
46a,
line
10
93-
(i)
CL-Ul
LI!
L,
J-IIV z
10
3u;
du;
,
Lzt
dLtu
(2)
b.
a_u
u2,gi c,.i
(3)
44
0.
1
- -*--oi (I -,-b
-3,3
fo. 45b. V
cGt;
LA>
o
_jL.
6: >
_31
AfZ, - Lj ,
_
10
92
C,
Ul
1:)l
zLil
U,kl;o
(15)
Lu)
-
cyp
C>P>
ul
a) M13
b) ms C-:pl; jl
C) ma
d) ma
e) ma
(sic)
suggest.
!
t
\J
C33L.
L31
91 -
e-j-x
ur
:
).
o)
&
)Z-
1.
eAAt
Ut
Z),
\1
cre
t %
Ar
fo . 45a.
-'
!PL (ArA
4>i-
;e
310 j-5:0.9 z5
bU.
Cr4.j
ji
.!;
k; z
01
I
OU.
': 6L
-'Il
(i
'r A
16'
04
10
90
6
.
) b"
U.
--c-"a
CIJ
__43 _41
e-uJ
b
_qp
>
-9
(5)
[sk-JIM
-V- \j
I Sl
5
331 LAr.
CY,
6--4
tz--j\j
(6)
cr
ckc
10
ul
LAC
UN
I
fo-44b. *
w.
eL,
SU.tz--\Jl
1-
>. CL2
L<tc(;0
cc4-,
6". au t
lZ
ck'.
ii
15
utc r-. j I d",
rA : il
U u?
a) ms
e) ms
b) ms
f) ms
c) ms
d) Cf.
jj crossed out.
Sh7afi'l,
op. r-it.,
9)
MS
LA-C_S 9!,jicrossed
out.
vol-5, p. 63;
Wil
4-A
Ujl
UJI (3U`
-89 -
(i)
_Ji)
uuo
aw
Ss
otq, Vl
6u I
J'
C
e.
'i
-'.
m e>
i-..
&z>h
Ntw
oci.
,
:4),
,i
h9
fo. 44a. *91
L$79 1.I
10
Gel". 21
<l>Z.,
r, '421
<
-I
tJ;
"-I
__
'LDU)
a) ms
L. >Ic
f)
b) ms
g) ms
C) ms
i)
d) above the
e) ms
line.
h)
ms C-*Vl -
ms
J) upper left
hand margin.
k) upper left
hand margin.
15
88
-
LS Lu, >
tj
CJ
fo-43b-**J-Ab
crUji
'i-?
r&
6
(7)
a)
ms
b) ms
87
-
LJJ c
LIL
-'
C. A1'M
1Ljt
(1)
LAa
4--rj&C
_Lkc
i''.:
Lli
t.MA rM3t
d'
Xc
(-3&.
fo-43a-".
Jul
LV
10
Ul
Lyd
-UWI; 9 coUji
-"
r-'
i.
e..
i%
a) above--*the-line
b) ms 'Sz, c;,Ajl crossed out.
C) ms,
(sic)
d) ms
e) ms
ms
6V-
suggest.
o-ii
cA
[
Lt. 0
Zj \J
15
86(62)
->b-
b (63)
;;JL-jl
-Li*
l',
17e
(3
0-)
-
c,
..
oL
Z' I,4,-.
i
r
Z,
- -.te%., &
tefo. 42b.
(64).
10
(65)
Ju
(66)
a)
b)
ms
85
-4
e-;
631
46>
-,.
tsm
1>
-
"
6,
-o
1
V.
Ls.>7,V..
c
Lw
I<
4,
(60)
%
.
fo-42a.
44
rk
(61)
I--e
(Sj)
Uc
ti5
10
1:w
Sul
a)
ms
b)
C)
MS
d)
ms
e)
M3
fir3t
-30
crossed
not clear.
out.
- 84 :,
$1
I
u
! -J
&
0-*L:
31
(56)
j.
CIAJ
-- -
(57)
di
--,;;
3 V.
1.
j,
-e)
--p
ql-ejl
&k..
,
ii
ua, Vul
I
tLi
; )3l
C-
61I1
'1
c-)j
1 Cr
4
,.
fo-41b.
$'
Zp
LJ) I
C:)
)% (>
A
"
-u
, Xamil
at
-i
10
(58)
LP
ll
lli
U
Clb
V---Ju
cy&Pv (:O)yu,;YL,
(59)
1
6-q
O-A at
ms
>:x crossed
out.
15
83
-
(49)
LI),
>
A-9
,-re
je
[b
1 tej 1 Ju: c-.q ll
c
0
CLO,
(50)
LAC
dAA0%1)U-.
-.:
Lt-jl
Swl
LAC
fo-41a.
Liii
ZL4- Vai
t.
19 Gl
52)
Cewi
(53)
io
(A
.IJ.,
4-Al
(3x-:
* k.,,
cjc
Jl
(54)
&,
*1
V,
(-s,
(55)
41.. j 1 ( uu a_>j-9
15
L3*AWLs
a)
b)
Cf.
ms
d)
above p. 2791ine9.
e)
ms
f)
(sic)
ms
cf.
ms
3A,
out.
sug
2, p. 239;
Gj
g)
ms
82
-
VL&%
ou,
LA
C.
: JL-jl
LIJI
al
(42)
1 , o
&41
.
dj.
113,
AtU
(I)
-ko-, J.
d,
31 JL-,
.
>, t; )l
(43)
c!.Jlj% >- NJ
a
Gel.3
ul
4-to-9
fo., 'Ob.
jl;.,
&
-JI
Ul
IUI
_.
Di
i
JIL-Ji
;
L.
V
C.
L---!
-J At
CAL.
"
GUL;
b
js
(44)
cr---j
10
-Nis
(45)
Ad
ow,
(46)
ue
4-j 1
ch
CIL-:
jitip
15
d
<
a)
ms
b)
Cf. below
P-89p
line4
C)
US
d)
ms
above
p.
18,
line
1.
81
.. '
a-f
ly ii
i 54 aG >k;c. tu :
uO
rkx
(35)
5
v-ell
(36)
"**
Ui';
1>.r
Li
;i,
g,
-D
%:
dx.
>.
-u.
(37)
&%-U
.,.:
bY
&Z
-%j->
_
U-Jle
LL
-i
\i
ul
>,
(38)
SO.40a.
lo
l
>-:
(39)
(31JI
ctc'i
(40)
.
t,
-x.
-; -5xt
>: c
L0
L,
e. . D
'--
15
'U
a)
b)
ms
'
13.
-'
L)L-J!
-3
80
17
&
b
(281.
fd
f
Us
L&,
9L..:
ILI
(29)
Ul
30)
L'tail? *
fo. 39b.
4J
&., \j 3; k-Dl
10
(31)
(32)
L;
< LO,
LAC
I-A
>
(33) J
Lp
k: ?
4J
AJ-
15
a)
b)
h)
ms
ij
ms
Cf.
d)
f 0- 139-1;
e)
f)
ms
g)
ms
xv
0'-L3
79I
__
(22)
Ul
f-
LA
A-- XZ
IL.
"o,
k; I
-3J
f 0-39a.
ok,:.
-
%:C-1 (- t>, c
7:
IJL-,
(23)
ul
uu
(24)
ur_4
&C
ti.
(25)
10
;jL ..21
(26).
h
JL,
(27)
16L.
_u )-
..
_V.
'J
-
a)
=s
9)
0)
zz
h)
jraziqcj,
S'%-,
Cf.
r 0-
C) - mz
0)
T)
1)
ms
*2ctt*q
15
1.
78
-
uI
L,
Vu co* -LII=
CI
L),: 2
kj.>
cj
(17,
,<
(is
c
00
.
Li
(20)
W\Jl
.
w-hb
A:
131
ct., O
U-0
U--
Le;,!
10
btfAb
-
C-5
as uj, a)
113,c=--33ed
1b) - Mzq---U; t C)
d)
ms U.
-J
e)
ms
.A
out.
mz
Cf-
P- 77,
line
0 -CIA
ms
ms
.t: s
-I
4-
77
-
c. 39a.
lj
(15)
A.
11
__
J-0
dip
%f
o1
Sh
Z;
zoal
OAb-0
\j
r<A
Ji,
)
)t?
:
l:
Ji,
)u,
)kj
1 J6
CPA;
SO-33b.
[CA
--I!
a)
ms
b)
ms-
. 0)
- ms
-t, -
d)
-el
ms
ms (sic)
above
tle
h)
Cf.
i)
ms 0,Z3
suggest.
line.
above line
12.
t, >L .
15
76
fo. 37b.
91
19
a
a.,p, 1
ceI jLA
1a
cr
d
(, i
phil
-g
AI
-
k;
i>
tut
*
.
lo's
'r
6
U"J
19
ooo
L-631
&
10
V;j V-eC9.14'.
.6V6 qp- -t
zL
uII,
4.1
z,
-
:', J% 1b
4C
a)
b)
outer
=s
d)
e)
f)
mz
ms
t. 1,.ard raar,-in,
--i&.
g)
h)
4ij
rLs
- =z
15
-75
(6)
U"
J4jt.
tL)
<C)')
(7)
jo
-
cJI
0t4> cl
<
C-e -*fl
CU
Zeefil
)Yl
-.,
>; OjI
(8)
Lu. >
10
a
iL;, j
Ls
ICUI
-6k
LVIIQ;,
a)
d
L!
ms
b)
C)
msZA;-U%f,not clear.
d)
outer
left
outer
cn the
0)
left
left
heandma--,,
--;n crossed out.
15
hand ma--,,
-in.
i)
h)
hand =arjin.
Cf . p, S, , 'line
Jul
J)
msj;;.
rubbad
out.
13,
-74-
NJ
I1
(1)
V-U, >
AJI:
0-
run, C3,
. -
ce
LJL;
Zl
L., u
(2)
Ull
U Litt,
Ls
J-91
\I
___
ZL5
L3 VU, >
7a
6631
10
I Git
. ->
1"Ks
w6e
-f
f0.37a.
.
uLbt
: c--3 (*
a)
b)
s
z.z
titu
K
lbs> jugl
JL21
-..
A:.
u
043.
b (
'.a'
d) ms
e)
outer
41
right
hand margin.
-73-
(74) d
Tg
ul
I >
.:
"
5
;U_;43
JL
(75)
1
l
u7,
LAr(76)
.I
:4
CLP
(77)
10
Li
t-L:
ro. -k6b.
.,
NO
lt
C.
(80)
0.-
JAZZil
a) - ms vl: x b)
MS
c)
ms
d)
ms
0)
f)
9)
MS U,5%"Jl
4-O.At
13.
uu..)
-72-s
-.
(65)
6, A; h dob,,
(66)
-5 L
5
I
L;
(67)
IL
(68)
JtZ
L:. q,
>
el
&
(VUji
,-
(69)
10
fo-36a.
(72)
1 xzr.
LZJ
_D
-q
.
v
(73)
a)
outer-right
hand marcin.
b)
:Is
C)
d)
e)
lower
ms
hand
right
10
15
margin.
.0
71
-
---t zip ii
&q--e,
o
LL.
6%j
i
L. Lji
5;
(62)
CM
<
?
OUD,
-- 'i
vrlo-30,4
d.1L7. f
UP
t.Ji .t14,
(63)
&; Lii,
b2
fo. 'zo.
55
ib.
.
".
L>:
c
u',
--";
,'
kVL
'J
i-
iI
e
>--.:
-
ul (0)
0#
*, t.
js
J;
a-e--e%i
-.:, L -
-tl
66k.:
Ju
A;
Njj
I
>
e.
O-U,
. -,.
AJ)
j
Z.
0:xv.
L;Xjl
OL I--
((A
(64)
CA
a)
the
line.
above
-
b)
ms
0)
ms
d)
ms -. Jks, cuter
lellt
e)
=z
2.e.,,
". hand ra--, -,in,
f)
ms k,
g)
ms
ev, outer
h:---id =a=gin.
11
14jt
10
70
16
uSp3l
%.!"jI
_0
c4c
sL-D I
(56)
fr)%
A
A31 :.
L: *
I
cy--l
j"I
(57)
-L,
ull
.w(
9'1
-.,
e-9j.
a;
,
10
Lj
Ir
foi 35a.
(58.)
"! 0
ul
zt-c
jq, e-v-.
b-
I'
kJ)
dD
LfJ
(59)
.(
15
(-, Vdl
(60)
..
; Lj
ms
ms
ms
1
i
, -;
A
.a
69
(46b)
V,q
4,,
(47)
1. X-G u %
iox:
(48)
ant
-
'U!
D
0:
l
>,
CJ
b
C os
f
I
U,
Ul
(49)
Ll j,
(50)
i; Aji
f
cy.
L)--j
10
f 0.34b.
(52)
(53)
CIS
Ii
'L
61:,C---Ir
(54)
cxq
06
46
Lot
(55)
J
I
ue-eJ u--,.
a)
ms 0:>a
v-u.)
MS (sic)
cf.
suggest.
Slarzzl,
ms
I
ms xvop:.
MS 'OLP
ms *_9
irms
15
on. oit.
ffo.;
68a
cx, -b L-- -:L-u I
ex, J,
(37) b
Li
II
e-
5
(38)
(39)
6-APL? )
(40),,,.
40
Aji
cjz 0-
ctv
f
ip,
fo-34a.
1. Cjtt
L-:
Jl
! 42)
CLJ
L3
(41)
C-A-'p-*D-
C=4.1
(43)
(44)
k
%.
(45)
(46a)
15 -
L4; oul
a)
b)
0)
d)
, ms
e)
the line.
-above
K>:.
&
ms
ms
f)
a-it
r-S
9)
ms
h)
mm
Cf. below
p. 2239 line
2.
67
-
3,01,
..
a.
..
_a;
b
,P,
; LjL... )i Li
ij.
.t
CC; "; j
(26)
Ujl
IL
.0.0
Z;
4..
JU
(271.
Za
6
.; - I
1'
ZLJ
fo. 33b.
-$-D-1
(30)
-(
28)
d,
4A
LA tu.
>
(29)
ul
L;
j
(31)
(32a)
4-1
10
(32 b)
e
<>4,
JL;"JL,
rAzj
I
LAS
(DA
Li
: Lj
Lu, >
U,
C-3"
a)
(34)
35)
-21 J,
6-Ajl &
d)
ms
The hadith
CYR (L; L; j
-
; LJL-. Jl
ms 6
appears
to be missing.
o)_
Cf,
Zamalchshari,
Mcit,,
vol. 1, p. 265
j.
2,
li
z,
ti-J2,
z;g
>...
s &
e)
mztVt,
p, it
11"irsta'Ji
crossed
out.
15
66
-
-toil
(17)
L
b
(18)
-4,
(20)
-fo-33a.
%:
LVO->
>
C
. -L-0
&a
4f
,
C-,
cf
4JU
ci
c3L-ii
1-
4-igit cu c'
l>
10
'Lre.
(23)
-r
ji
ZAil
1-,,> s jul
(24)
kle13
; w-t Gr4-tit- s.
(j
--
0
1-.2j,
(25)
JL;
a)
b)
msW.. >.
Cf. above P-389 line
3-,
I
ms b 0d)
above the
ms bt4; -
line.
A-: Jl
15
65
-
-.
ul.; 1
0.32b.
L-9JA
7: >
u
-5,
tp-lr-
Lill
ed
';:
j; '
-'
zdt
<I "v)
Ul
us'r,
x,
I
&.;
(J,.
1
e ui>%
-(ju U4J
e'
02-92
a,:.
c
ox,, ,
(14)
211
-
d)
a')
-4<
lo
a--c
U"
cti,
cLt
kj
0 6)
(A)
ms
b)
C)
d)
1--e-
-ma
above the line.
1.
h)
outer
i)
J)
Ms
k)
Ms
1)
outer
M)
right
right
hand margin.
ha,-Id r-argin.
MS -J Voutar
margin.
11o
64
fo.
32a.
(6)
'I
CYN,
6-A
CN
Lstc el
LIU
Li
LI..
I (Jt
u'L.
Ji
00)
JL;
-k; A
L1
lplll
i-,
-ut-L-
'I
10
. O.-P L. 61
6tL
fe
\1
iT
15
cut
a)
b)
ms
nner left
hand margin
5.
ms
ms
Cf. Muslim
!
P-
X--z
_;
$abib
vol.
2. p. 977
ae.
4p
Las
63
-
J
4;
it
ug
-t
'jj'
Cc
ia
>i
wo,
JQ
jZ
:
vp
1:q rL-o
10
! 4) c
Ly
U,
jg,
a)
a bove the
b
a)
d)
ms -ko;h
ms
.i
1q: -
line.
62
-
cba
6 tL
&; i, '
\j
JL..
Q>I
2>:
>
gVie
b
jI
..
39
k 4Gv.:.
c \i 1
X,
i 1
9 6 p..
uz
\i 1, j
kr
6. G
A3
6D
10
Li
00)
)J
JI
fo-31b.
a)
ms
b)
ms
C)
MS
&V
9)
ms
ise,
h)
ms
d)
ms
i)
e)
MS
-J
(-Wlcrossed out.
61
(37)
C.)r
tjj;
&-5
U10
zi
5L:
0 c)'
(38)
ft
G!. LSL-
5
(-)
'
)AI
JI
LU. >.
-ep-ft
I-
I-.
L.
LJ
Li
uej
I Sb-, g
(21
(JU
jq;
C-*;
v-,rP 0-iI A--
j -5j
10
Li
LV
fo-31a.
"Lac
(5)
Uj(
Ljr
15
a)
b)
ms U,A 'JI;
C)
i. e.
5.
ia
Jj
V3
#X;
L
the line.
60
S
JJ
LJL--b
le
(-*
(32)
5
(33)
f
-#.
apI
Ib
jLji
>i.
LJI
LaiI
(35)
:>-S
e-)j:>Z
(.
..,
-OVA
&JI
OS
Ll
6
ck9
If
10
(36)
ed
fo - 30b
17
-ULb
15
a)
ms UJI .
b)
outer left
C)
,
ms -A69outer
d)
lower left
e)
ms
L:2; j i
hand margin.
left
hand margin.
hand margin,
ms 11 crossed out.
59
(i
* Irt
bI
J +A-,
-ii,
Cr-?:
I11:
L; aJL.; j
L-U I
L)--
(24)
;,
c Nr,
-5
(25)
c%
-1
44C
-0
LAC.
(26)
uu, >
I
9
W-'o
;
)I tj
ul
C-31-01
ula
):;
/
1
_.
C:
r--;!
40
Ll
f (27).
L-ij
t>-; 11'
as
[J]
t
JU
1
28)
CJJWI yj
:>
(ZD
j
10
e
(29)
fo , 30a.
<w, > *
-,
J%j
1h
-sp-z
->-,
(30
15
h)
i)
ms
ms t-q
J)
lower right
d)
ms
k) - ms
e)
ms W6
11) MS.
f)-
a)
ms
b)
above
-Cf.
C)
9) - ms t: tA& I.
189 line
1.
3.
M)
cf.
hand margin.
above no. b.
58
-
04t.
r, \JL-t
k
9im_.
-1
>..
e-9
ul,
"4-r-'-
Ci
k'
J4:1
L;eJ, e4
yw
X.,j
Lp
(22)
L:j,
10
L)
uJI
Ze
fo. 29b.
X-P
(23)
34J
a)
ms
outer
b)
ms
C)
ms
d)
abov6 the
e)
ms
f)
left
hand marb-in. g)
MS
X
A-P-.
15
cr9lvL,
11.
.
cr.
Y-:Aj-line.
ms -Ale, 9, outer
hand margin.
A;
C! .
ms
90
. -
right
57-
:-A JI
Zi ; 1-LI iz..ozE9
i>le b: >b L',
(17)
tU
Jis)
5
:.
.w,
1:>.z LAC
cu
(20)
'1
k3i
%,21 :,
',
'Je .
%ic
j3L;;)
10
LAC
fo. 29a.
clul
Lt
--".
9. WJ%
'
>0
e4;
jJ)
'9
th
6>Yq
a) ms
uy
>,;
g) -. ms damageds
b)
Cf.
0)
above
d).
ms
9)
ms damaged.
ms damaged.
"_,
15
___
f)- ms
"4
1.
line.
56
-
jpl
-
wJ, !
V,
(--
Z-c -, Ou!
-.
&I
scs)2,1
-Af
II
L-b
-j
.0
,r Ip.
VAL
C
SteA31
Ul
OL
e- 4:
e-g
ul -+Jlj
10
f o. 2 Ob.
1:>,b
3:e !,jl
4Ad
LAC
jd
V-J
-t40 -o I -;
msujl
g)
ms
b)
ms
h)
ms
C)
ms
d)
ms
J)
ms
e)
ms
k)
ms
f)
ms
ms
15
55
cii
C2)'
3'
.
Ia
Al
ar&
ul
Jb,
3U
L
4
,o0
-(.: )Qu
4p
C2--M I
19 *
C.:, jj-b
'-;
C-A3, !. 9,
L)
jL
:> Lp
'6142
'!
a-aa I ju
Li
I
"(i2)
&1L
LJU
v.
ju
; c'
J4t
rA. Zi1
Ir
%1
I
:
k
a-u'l
-
>,
-o
U.9
c
1.0
.
10
.
OLX I
ro
eb" 1
fo. 28a.
JU;
4
-;
-,
il
U'
a..
LfLp
-I
"I
L3LS.
r--o ---
Cyj
*k
um ut e.-,.>l >.,I
gjuj
a)
ms
b)
C)
d)
e)
.
ms
'G
AG
-I
4j,
A-
Z, )
lo
-.4r.
15
-54
(6) t
Lp
(L. 0
5
uy,
,r.
fo. 27b.
,
':
z
L:.
>.
-
.g
6L)'-:,
il
>
\1('oA;s t. 6
(9)
U-. A,. Jl 6 Zr
L;
r-UI eA: Jl
L)
00)
b
YJ--j,
OJAI'>
d
10
uu, )
LAP1,?
a)
ms
b)
lower left
C)
ms
d)
e)
ms
f)
outer
hand margin.
]O:,.
7-
9
-:
right
hand margin.
cut;
&*
15
53
-
L__,
':
)i'
jP
Z)i ZiUj,,
cy
LJ!A3j
czk
VI
'4.
JI
fo. 27a.
U
Uu
\j
o"i
4;,j
ju; '2'z>-ltc
0
pp.(te,
41
131
1.0
:...
Mus
;JL----JtLi CT
a)
ms Vy. - ,
-b)
ms(sic)
C)
lower right
d)
Ms
bjl
suggest.
hand margin.
e-* Li Lj 66-
- 52 fo. 26b>L-%4-c'
%(5)
>
ZJL---,
0%9
C--IU2; 11
ba
U>--l 0*->z ull
(6)
o
Lo
L;
P
L:; j
'
U-)
uq, >
00)
Lp
a)
I
ms
b)
1!8I
ms
4-,& C
ms &, , .
1.
no
U-11
10
-51 _,
(45)
(46)
3il
&5jl
j-D
tle-
(47)
Lou(48)
(49)
D% 3. p.
Pat;
-,
di
LJ
ULJ
b >
1946V, I
0-
Lk--.tj ql
A; cl,, a;
-.
(50)
j,
c-jL6
(51
cy
lo >j.
J-
I Jj crj
10
(1) d
10631
CA-*
ul
;
)l
DLP
LJL-.
,
-.
b)
ms
C)
ms
a-,Qj.
4
ms
M 13 JU
UsLiji
U3
3)
-
a)
L-V up
LAC
1.
CJL21
e LSLA- 15
CLI,
50UL
(40)
a
tit
of.
rL-b
utc
LAC C
C-.--Lp
ul
(42)
'9
cd.
cD
(11)
()1i
10
(43)
k
ce
D:
>
C-,
fo. 26a.
Jej
F-Ip
ct_u
(44)
15
ms
a)
ms
g)
ms
b)
ms
h)
0)
above
Ms -Ako, outer
margin,
i)
Cf.
the line.
d)
ms --Xb , outer
e)
T'S 4--Lpc:
rieht
hand mar6in.
J)
Q
Ms
ms
above
p.
right
19,
line
hand
4.
49
(28)
(29)
Ce : >w
Ce
JL;
uI
(30)
C-,
le,.
;
:XDC:
0)t,
-Yb
>_p
"Lp
Z,
J-o
d44
0--Ul
Cut
il
l
1--9
c:
(33)
(34)
6d
JIA)l
fo. 25b. -
<LJ\.
-)I>
Lf C-r-.l (3-
dJ
e
Y-W
1"
1, b
10
LA
(35)
; JL
(36)
(37)
1) <
-All
Lyq
left
; A21
<J>kj, 1:>J6 Ul
hand margin.
f)
a)
outer
b)
ms
CP -
g)
ms
0)
h)
above the
d)
lower left
e)
ms (sic)
hand marCin.
suggest.
Lop cf.
15
11.
line.
48
(23)
(24
k;
jl
c
&)*1
(251
V-Y.
- U42--W
fo. 25a.
b)
-L"(}
AM
%j
..
p C
-".
I(
q"
.
LUb
-k.;.
IA; 1 J6
't
11u
j!
74
f
wsd
(26)
.w
Li
10
(27)
-t
,
ne
-Io
ul
"4$-
3Ae
s11 G-c-
. %.
tu
outer
t
hand margin.
upper right
d)
e)
ms
ms
hand margin.
right
0)
f)
IIi
15
ms
ms
z-9
1.
-47-
cj'
fo-24b.
0 '1-
trALJIILY
4Ar-
dd
I
(fd)
c7J% JU j
(18)
ti-o
lo
Ul
Lj i
(20)
15
a)
lower left
b)
Ms
C)
ms
d)
ms
e)
ms
hand margin,
46-
4
cuL'
>c
.
12;
. (ii)
(A
a--a
(jg
-.
g--1 -
wo
k; -:, i C.:.
e; cJ_c- u-; )l
IV$
cul
5,5
-:
je
,1
a>
6z
-f
lo
p.
jul
L-. j. ut3,
ci
,.
9
C:- u"'Ll,
11I
U,
I
g
Ni
;,
>;
C,:
->
-C
1634A--,
k99
UL.,L_jIa
a)
IRS
b)
Ms
d)
6 MSCL,,,
e)
f),
inner-left
9)
ms
ms
%,Xgi.
ms
ms %it
hand margin.
.
;.)
I,
0)
&6
Z.it
0'.
k)
15
7.
45
-
00
CY CM
Jt4,
C-
(-)i
i2
CCr)u2m
&
(ju
10
(8)
"kj L.
-.
)
CAI
f
Fv I
CX.,
L'T
)
(9).
fo. 24a.
a)
ms
b)
ms
C)
ins
d)
ms
e)
ms
f)
ms
I , b
-44-
5ii cA. j
LAC
b
Lp
ul
da;
fo. 23b*
UU
>391
cj
-''
ms
ms
Ai
U: )
J-
tJ
-43(26)
6
lo. 27a.
JI;
\J_,
-L. A (27)
(28)
uo
a)
ms
b)
d)
=6>JiLop
C.,
j crossed out.
-42V
czu,
Lb UU
L)
09)
V
uto
jw
Lp
*L2-il
d..; Jl
CA
-10
(20)
A.
-,.
J1
Oei
J-LU
iL
-tx
L13
LID
xs-9
((r,.
cb
Lp
au sr.
(22)
uI
-A.,
& UjI-I-
Z 1 1; L;
.
g;
-k;
-j
(23)
10
d
ul
4-
CAO-.
)
f
(25)
< 141)
(24)
uI
V-wo
j.
651
a)
ns
e)
ms
Uj
Clue,
ja-
s1
b) m& a-Jk
Ins
0)
outer
ms
ms
6)
ms
A.x
right
hard
margin.
15
-41
(5).
(6)
Tis.0.4.;,
4U I
<;; AX
4.. M I
L---
CJ
c-4
.. r
(9)
00)
03)
.
bA-:
Li
J1 -,
12)
e-,-e
LA C-
(-Zp -uI
Ji
) te,; ul
4.
-tj
b
10
c
ZP
ezj
(16)
&I
: LJLJI
uI
9e
6; Vt
fo. 22b. * -
a)
MS
b)
ms
0)
ms (V.,sto-)
d)
ms
e)
ms
f)
ms
g)
h)
ms,
ms
>91
_9'.
ot; >91
YPI
L--Jl
&;
L
6-3j
-40-
CAL.
UD I
6 elfl:> UU.>
LP
4-a-r-
4.: )l
C:k-. Mi
Lxo
O-ul
CL)
A-A
'L'
iN
&''
i"
(4)
lJL(i)
(}
10
d-
_uI
-
''-,
JL
\J
((3
__
Le
o. 22a.
&''
__fr
': +u
a)
ms
!.0 -5, -
b)
ms
Ail
ms
d)
ms
C)
ms (; JI ju
f)
9)
h)
(text
i)
ms dj -
J)
k)
msZ.,
s501
corrupted)
hand margin.
ms
lin6-1.
13-
M)
ms
n)
lower right
hand margin.
39-
Qx%
g/
U' t
6JAp
(3 CA-a-,
k
&
Uuo
9,
(: jk..
jks-q-"-
fo. 21b.
10
L .
-.
C.iln AZ-31 (N,
15
-
ms
ms
g) cf.
blx,Jk!a-m
:)L.
sidrazi,
op. cit.,
fo. 66a;
0' ms
h) ms
d) ms ;i
e) ms Zj-sL--# f)
Cf
Qur3Zn
4.
2@
203
&
r9l
k)
1)
ms 1.,p
msz, jm
38
C;!
jL
C2'
(L
c.'j
___
(201.
ba
-P
(2
ql
SAI)
1
01-UI> I
(4fo. 21a.
(21)
> V,a dJw
Iv
z-jl
JN9,
* )L..
(23ij
i
e(,
I'L
<
C:L,,.Oj
CI& 1,u
et\
.0,
. rktzl
('
%A% k_p
cy. >
(J
>
Z,
"
10
&j4
'c-s
CJN
Ls
h
J%tx:
;
eZ,
15
(3)
-- a) inner
right
b) outer-right'
c)
outer
right
d) Cf. ShIrizi,
hand margin,
hand margin.
hand margin.
op. cit.,
fo. 63b;
(2)
-j
Cf . Shaf iL
j
&
tk3%
ce
outer
h) ms
ms
e) upper
left
hand margin.
J) ms
left
al
vol. l, p. 209;
hand margin
with",
ms
37 -
00)
(11) d
LA
5
9
U"l
j
tPA
fo. 20b.
04
k
>
3-b
10
4iL,
(14)
L3
tit;
-ul
Ltis,
4-41
(17)
(18)rn
15
a)
ms
b)
inner
0)
ma
d)
ms
e)
r. s
ms
ms
h)
left
hand margingms
outer
left
hand
ms
OW -
j)
MS
4: 4
Ms.
k)
(sic)
suggest -6LO-2j,
line 1*
360 6s)
...........
LAC
ev;
0
(i)
.S
LA
1D
'I
(2
a<,.,
JtC.
94U
L; j
fo. 20a.
cv-11
Ls,.>
10
Li
`ju
1
l
Uil
bl>.
CS3
j-*
G-.
-*
ziLii
1-*,
10 3,
a)
line.
the
above
b)
ms
k -,
35
X.0 *E
11
bv.;
(161
Z, r--
cv,L. L31
-4"
-6
NA
c'6
uc
-13
(162)
rt;
U-A
14J
b--LS'
0e \-2-;
fo. lgb.
w-)
(163)
\-O \:.u.. > - k..j
1,i
rx
(165)
''
(164)
dJ
r'
? (P)t
10
66)
(167)
Li
a)
(sic)
'0104ol,
ms
suggest. -C.
b)
0)
ms
d)
ms
e)
ms
-Ako, outer
left
f)
MS
g)
Ms
h)
ms
i)
MS I
1.
hand margin.
15
34
-
I
;!..
)'
': )I
js 1('L-ZLiz,
L.S
LP
",
-L. 4
Lp-. , -A-a-ft'd
B-L,-o I
C!.;
-,
VV-Z\i
4r.
LC
JVJ
fo. 19a.
ZAI>
011-9-
60 diaA
db
L*t
I
0, >U
e-.u: > e
(157)
<
"luil
10
(158)
(159)
Li
(160)
'15
-Ms
b)
ms
C)
inner
d "I
;
3VI
ms
0)
outer
f)
ms
ms
right
hand margin.
left
hand margin.
33
(146)
A
(147)
Cj I &C
ec-jk, p
xu
<G>
Ljz
-,
sou
IZA
CL-ar.
4-)Jl
! I,
-,
CIO
(148)
.
4-11-t
..
-),,
(149)
-.
JL;
(150)
(151)
fo. 18b.
uL;
W-LLi
P 1;
6
d-Ul
(154)t.
0,
L)->-ei
(153)
(152)
10'
kjpk-16
JL-J
u--,
15
D-9
Powl
Ul
,
-3,
IC
i
1
C.;
--k-,
Uu. >
p ZJL-, b
(155)
(156)
LV
15'
a)
outer
b)
ms
left
hand margin.
-. -Du 9 outer
right
hand margin.
32
-
cci U: e.
(137)
I OLIO :>j
;;j L-., O
6p
6%Aji
el
u9
(139)
cL(140)
(141)
f
18a.,&u-4
D
C
<.,
9
-XA.
-6
Z;
9
sJt
Z-,9,.
j \I
ci.
cij Cb u::,
10
d
(142)
(143)
-t-jjI, q dJL; -6t o
C,,.
.1& -C
-,
(145)
6 uu, )
(144)
ue-i
4
a)
ms
b)
ms
0)
ms
d)
ms
e)
ms
ei
`i
2t cu
JLC
i,
>.i
L;
-9
15
31
-
- .0U0-,
-#
(129)
4: >Lp
L
Ll J'9'
L)
%ju oull
u, u,
t.9.
(130)
-tj
-5
'74
m;
--j,
u-,5 , eLe;ijo, ,
-.
cjj
fo. 17b.
U%
C4b.
132)..
. A. &t
Li
&; z
&
A;
10
(J
?:
'ji
C1aJ
Zil
CXtu
(133
1
(135)
(134)
e.
:Jbj
(136)
*eAzil
a)
ms
b)
me;
0) ms
4, i
15
30
tz"
1.9
C->-
--99
..
J-P
f4o. jb
(126)
P.
t; 41
1.,l
r
--,
L
\1
cv
cl
(6--
; YLZJI 'U"I
IV.
L-J I
Cjt
CA
41
(&:
1%
4'J
t,
%i
9.
(127)
fo. 17a.
(-:o.--1i;il &-..- %
>
1,-Ici;9i
zi \j a-.xc; %AI k.
\If
LJ
10
ILI
(128)
4
;
Ul 'SLy jLjl
ue
uu')
ci
Jk; CC,)>ue
\j
dj I
ci-;.
ms
C) . ms t
15,
29
-
6k
018)
tl-
V-1
,
;
jj
L
-JJ
_142.0-J
(120)
CCJ
(121)
d
fo. 16b.
<
10
(123)
(122)
65,
Le
Ce
(J"ol)
Ljk.;
-*
Z'I
Liu
pLD
(124)
(125)
LI
a)
ms
b)
ms -J
0)
outer
left
d)
outer
right
0)
f)
MS
L"-! )
hand margin.
hand margin.
15
28
-
Cut
-.,k"
Oll)
Ear. ) J-1: 3
-.
*A.
"ic
.I-0
.0
fo. 16a.
10
. -A
4k4'
s) II,.,
b po 1.) 1,
_
ci
(115
Cv.Jul
> Lp*
u-,;I;-D
(116)
21
>
Ly
Q'I
15-
cr
jL;
a) . ms
r ight
hand margin.
b)
outer
0)
Cf. above M,
d)
outer right
e)
f)
V%-Pms 4-2,
12. -
9)
hand margin.
h)
ms Pt Z?v.
line
9.
27
-
'
(:!
(100)
10
j -U"
LjOOQ
.0.,
ju
e.
.61-.
Ul
L3
(103)
55
(ICL2)
.0
b-.4b
-Uo
(104)
fo-15b,
(105)
10
e. lp lip
,j(107)
d
ul
'j,
(108)
3kD J
.
(109)
WI
4-IC-
wo
15
.
CJ ju;
LJ
ms
ms
ms
-ms
(3--d
26
. 0.
op
.0
6ju
LO
1,
(68)
L.
bv, q: >Jl
(89)
(P
Z-"
(91)
1;
6--' 0 Q C;--) I
(90)
"' c
-
I (
(93)
Ul
fo- 15a.
ol
(92)
le %,
0.,,
Lo
'LU. >, C
(95)
10
(97)
96).
"I eA-:Jl
l
&C q
-Llr
(99)
(98)
; ul-v
a)
b)
-JU,
>
e)
Cf o W7 DZVrad
V 6?
2u-nan,volol,
P-52;
15
3-
25
Zjj--b
ct-, C-p
LA.,o wi cyc
. 6"1
lo,
j 1146,1
(78)
>j9..
-. -
a4
(77)
D%
uu, >- 6-; IW.&I I
\..
)
i>
tb L -z,
>
,
(79)
(80)
st
_Y.
.d
cv
-*
L-ii -i.
zlI
-5
.0s
(82)
fo. 14b.
> rt-I
(83)
c: -4J
'60cj;
61,
(84)
.. J.
(u
Lj"
LLi
Jj
4-. ->'
U9
10
cu<
c.; -42,
h
5
0-..,
-Out
'r
u
L;
j"
(86)
CIS
15
a)
ms
b)
ms
C)
ms
Cf.
d)
ms
op. cit.,
e)
ms
f)
6)
ms
ms -61-s
Zamakhshari,
vol. l, pp.
21-22;
24
(64)
ba
uL..
)i Li
(65)
-u
>j.
LA-'
-,
(67)
jv-;
.
(66) "
.0.0
(.jL4laj
J- Lu.) --
1.11:
(68)
Jx
5,
LI6
(69)
(70)
4.01,
fo-14a.
Jl
tu,
> 4. v,; Jl
Go
b,
4 b.
(72)
tZ
Lj
10
6u.
(73)
(75)
(74)
Jl
%_1OJL; A:
-'Jl
i. C:,01..
(76)
U
.0C.
a)
MSZ-.A6 j'. 6
b)
ms
C)
ms
d)
ms
e)
ms
f)
ins,
-;
15
2314:
)t
ii
:Ma
"1Ii
C56)-
5
(57)
*'
'O-reuJ, -G-t
:ro 'l 3b.
dj;
(58)
5u1
ew,
ct_ul
LJ
(59)
t.: u
Jj
10
; Ij
(61)
(60)
\J1
- -Ai
aj
(62)
(63)
15
a)
ms 1L-;;
b)
C)
ms
e)
ms
f)
ms
g)
ms
b)
ms
d) ms (sic)
suggest.
22
-
ri
uI
144),
LAC J, >
-I1.
--*
bi,
bi
CA-5,
(45)
g u
(46)
0
%-4--L7
3a.
(48)
(49)
J1
_-7
4j
(50)
6,)uv
(4T
(51)
(_7
tjL,
C,
(52)
10
MY
fe
;, IkAD
k I Ud;
iz'stap-)l<
cd
v
44-c
LGI ci
> (-;4
GjI
0,,
CT)
Ul
A-U.> eL;e;,Jl
6
166(;
(54)
15
a)
ms
e)
b)
ms
f)
ms
C)
lower
right
d)
rds ":
Xs.-I-.
hand margin*
9)
ms
h)
Cf.
(sic)
Sldia-zlp
>. r, 1;
suggest.
o2-cit-9
fo-36b
ul d-eAl
40
21
-
CA
J-P
'3t
Or-
IA;
4:
-Al
(3,7)
41
(:
ty-ujl
L), c
L;
6-c
:7
fo. 12b.
(39)
au
(40
d-A
I LSLP
10
tit;
L4
Lj
Le
15
a)
ms
b)
ms
C)
outer
left
hand margin
20(26)
(27)
(28)
29)
(30)
fo. 1 2a.
uI
>-,>-I
-j"
t bG-:,
i- ( U.
o
U1
[ocl
Lit
f
(32)
e
I
cl
-kit;
j-)
1A,
I-J,
i CL..
"o, --
6&-,ic
,1
Lr.
Ij
10
CS1L
;UL
(34)
(35)
(36)
I ukc
A;
a)
f)
b)
ms
9)
ms
0)
h)
ms
above the line.
ms 6 9 -
13
d)
ms clj., j .
i)
e)
TS
J)
9-A5
-,
ba
15
19 -
(6)
.L-.Ul
fo. 11b.
L)
Ul
(8)
00)
(9)
Ui
(13)
`- I l
"..Ll*-t
OUP
Lp
zZil
4j,
ul
c:0-&c yw
L)
(17)
,c
L:j
jl;
(19)
18)
(22)
10
(21)
(20)
JL;
(23)
(25)
(24)
D-Jj
.
-upper
right
hand mar-gin.
b)
upper
right
hand margin.
C)
ms 341 L.;,Z
d)
a)
too I'l
4.
caulC&Oa-At
bl,.-
15
18 (22)
(23)
C
ul;
1f6.
u3r-
--0
ft
Pe
.-
(2)
ul
zj%
-,-XI
d
VLL;
Lo>
.9.0P,
(,
(3)
6
L0,01,1
A
IC
b)
'0
3431;
-k
(4)
a)
e
<
[(ja3
61"
k-t"JI
e.. ...
vol. 1, p. 62;
tj-t
6;
LV
cit'. 7, -VI
d)
... "Iji,
-Llio
above the line
e)
f)
ms vj, -
9)
ms
1.
12.
- 17-
03 )
4&
JA
15)
:,
ijL;9 4-A (-Jl
L
6uez;
Jl
6;.
Cvkl)
bLa;
bk-42-;
,
U3
Lc-,
J,,
tjL; -ul ow -, 4-31
-U
(14)
.nl
tila-
Iv
LAX
vu,
>
)
L.
LJ
L; e
C9
i o''
CA
0.1la.
9 zu
sjr4i
L-- e.5' e ti
ul.Z
I.;zi
(20)
-(I
ei
4
d-I I
'
j>
-..
Z,
J-P
15
a)
outer
b)
ms
C)
ms
e)
MS
f)
ms
ms
right
hand margin.
Zv
d)
ms
16
b
(9)
a
4,
LJ4
&1%,
[JUj)
-)i
(a).
(C.
<-
fo. I Oa.
C-A3
JN
'-4)
C9
2'
z'
ILI
(5)
Ls'
(Ac
(4)
10
f
1&1
[-ju Zi 3
C-V.
UZIC-rc
U-tj6 VU,.
5
alsj,
ua..
v,
B,j
-ql
as.
os
C-0
00)
03
ILLY
t,
(12)
fo. 10b
--qj
-rL'I
C.c Y-Sj
>:, C
Ge jI
3-
15
jA
;kjL-l
01)
e) ms
Cf. below P. 17, line
b) ms
f)
C) lower right
)
(sic.
h) ms
suggest.
hand margin.
fo. 23b;
of.
above line
11.
1. g) msLr, *.-t
X.Pj
15
I.
Cjj\:
fol
Ls
fo. gb.
C2J%2
--i
rea-.
Z
1.
.
IL-i
ei
it> i:;, yt
Gib-
-6L;
S's
car-
(6)
$ m,
f-I:.
4x
t4..
Ls&c JII
Wut
a)
above
the line.
b)
upper
right
0'
Cf.
d), -
e)
ms
hand margin.
above P- 71 line
3.
lo
14
-
"i
(42)
a
(43)
CIj I
(44)
&,
^,
su
1510
1.
Ai
jl-,
WU
4J_j
lit
(45)
JI
0.9 a.
(46L
1-l
-tit
1,
-, I
jj
d---
c__,,
Q)2)I
()
(. )
J'
L5
e
(48J.
(47)
(49)
CA -Co v
(C.
.9f
U 6-
(L
-1 wh
s-
1:
< L>-t
(I
15*
13-
Cf.
SAr7aA,
b) ms
C) ms
d) ms
e) ms
f)
ms
O.D. cit.,
't. - % ,u
h-,) ms
i)
above
the
line.
fo. 21a;
su-1
2-j
13
-
(32)
0,
(33)
(34)
-4c
C
I-
&'
\iW.,
So. 8b.
t.,
, -x:,c
q
-.
cr
(36)
(37)
u-'>
5,
(38)
%v
U-lCU
-Ji
39
10
VL,11,
! 1,6
_-b
i tj
I..,P Ila
(40)
(41
a)
(sic)
ms
b)
ms illegible.
C)
outer
siiggest.
_Con,
outer
f)
ms
9)
ms
h)
Mis
ms
Zamakhshari,
!)I4: tp
left
hand
left
hand margin.
margin.
Ms
e)
cf.
vI
12
-ta -
JL,
(26
'LA-e-9
i t
--t
z>i
L--.
i
(25)
ikse?'. at Ual
CLWI
I-
27
U;
L.;j
Li
LAC,
LP
AL-
fo. 8a.
*-
w
A-,
gut
-41
6 Is
j>-I
7-
&
(28)
f
uuu
lo
(29)
uu.
j-
61. Lo
I
41
cx
(30)4
L99
L:.
j 1
1.50
. ur
a)
M3
b)
C)
upper left
d) - ms
e-)
Ms
f)
Ms
g)
Ms Gua:;.. -
4A
du
0,
hand margin.
joo";
U.
..
A-Ail
-11-
(15)
a0
Cio
Lit;
CL-W
lfi
LY,
(17)
uu
-;(18)
cu
20)
(je
fo. 7b.
tj1
4.
j
- yjX!
'ju c j-ii ji
zt
gl
r?
UL,
8, Lj
10*
ej a Y-. oj
ul
(21) f
U-, )
(-u
Lit
V,
(22)
A--
24),,
(23)
"
a)
ms
b)
ms
? 66 -
(sic)
C)
ris
d)
lower left
e)
outer. right
ms
ms
suggest,
. Jl
below
line
?!;
cf.
P-149
4t
9
hand marcin.
hand margin.
th
'A)'
rc
>Jc
15
10 -
(7)
"
Iaj,
q;
CJ
>C
OJU
-Pk-
e
410L.
J
(9).
01)
f <.
J>
el
fo. 7a.
4A.
(1 2a)
a
JL
ca-j
(12b)
IA;
(13)
LA,
(14)
,,
I-. - !.9
a)
ms ? 61; .
b)
ms
0)
mS
d)
ms
e)
r, S
9)
outer
;3,>
crossed out.
left
hand mari; in
ms
crossed out.
L&
-5
"'x"ua: b
-9-
(82)_.
LJ
'
L)
.I
ba
(8)
(84)
L
Lit
;:
f. Lit;
L; --o
(jIL
4-ml
cuut
Lb
UUI>
(2)
d
tA-l
>
. 1--IJL;
*A
d..
10
too-Ili
kI
Li
;
fo. 6b,
r,,:j IU
uta
(6)
-:
.
6, V. (3"Puil
a)
UA-lp-I
. . )#
- Cil,
ej,
ms
b)
outer
0)
ms
d)
X:LPr
ms
left
hand margin.
rubbed
two dots
=4"I,
crossed out.
ms -.: A
out:
(3ic)su,,,,, Cest.
y1plt
e)
ms
f)
3.
on
Ut
.
J)
lovror left.
hand marCin.
-8-
(70)
0."
L,
.015,. >Lc0.
uis
cj
4,
(72)
(74)
Glj:. &.
w
-b
swad
J;;
f
< -t
JI;
(76)
c
&
(78)
qAj
OWL
JLO
ju
(75
LA
(77)
0111
cy. L4
10
Le
(79)
0-.Arj
c;e;L
(80)
(81)
0: 310ul "Le
fo. 6a.
)_)4'
a)
ms
b)
ms
641 damaged.
At4
(.,
c)
ms
d)
e)
ms e3k-J
31
f)
g)
ms
61& -
h) - Irls L;e;.!-. -
5.
ms 'JI
15
-7dL;
b. >J
(L: Jj
(61)
(62)
JL
eX,0,9
e_
-a"-U
Af eAmcil
(63)
eyL.,:)I
L4
)j
&C
;aw,
LU;4P-P;-L
,,
uu, >
A;
C6
j.
LJ
>_-
LV,
, dt
(64)
f 'I'
Jj
L;
LS
(681
(67)
(66)
(65)
u-c-p
JNJ
10
cy,
L;e;;,.
h9
(69)f
du
.*4'-
\j
-*
fo-5b.
15
a)
b)
dazaCed.
C)
Ms L,
d)
ms
L,,;
g
!.di damaged.
e)
ms
f)
m8
9)
MS
outer
ms
left
(52)
J-p
zml
A,
(54)
(53)
-"
Lij)
jl, 93
(55)
14.
fo -
4b.
;j
(56)
(57)
L:
_tj
xtp.
JA
1I 4L
Si,
cul
(58)
-, -1U-i
U
(59)
10
C-1
: tjL-..
(60). ee
15
a)
Cf.
below
b)
MS
6)
outer
d)
Mi
6)
- M3
P- 79 line
riht
3.
hand mp gin.
-5 -r
(39)
(40)
CJ
-IJL;
b
(41)
(42)
--p
S9
slilb
-,.,
I?
V-.
Llj:
CY
>
Ir
L; --
.
L:
j
I
C-V
J43)
juz
JLZ
J6
Aj
ck.
CJJ
(45)
(44)
(46)
fo. 4a.
10
6-
; LA
(47)
d--Ul
-Lr,
(48)
Al;
'CAI
(50)
(49)
atk
C-)s
15
(Lk
Mi
(51)
-; 1,6;.
ms $6-A
--,
e)
ms
0)
ms
Cf.
Cf..
J?, .
;
ms j\. s -
Shlr-Zz'17,-
above
the line.
Al..
al-
:0
(28).
(27)
C,. -j
I(Y
(29)
(3%)
O;
N;
O.
U,
Litz
(32)
(31)
zj
L)L;
Y-,j L.
(A-Di
(33)
4-1 '.
(34)
WL11
fo - 3b.
'
%1-9
-'
(35)
Z,l?
t u>:.c-
(37)
4
e5
-..
gL3uj
10
AJ
L--.
k.
5.
>
P)i c.--21
u-.
(36)
*,
ic
d.
kj
JIZ
--Jl
b
bi
L,:
cr
C-- 6;
Jkb
LZ
Tj
(38)
0
l
.
J,
5
J-95".
64U!
4.
-15
a)
ms
b)
ms
0)
ms k"Nt
d)
outer
right
hand margin
-3-
-'I
(16)
));
3'-
0,Ao
ZLJt
Mk
JJ
j
>;
(19)
5
ea
?, ii
(20)
(22)
, . (x,.it
j>
L zits L-,
.e.
e u; si 1&jt;
(24)
-udjLz
--10
i (cag i >
1
--.. -,
(23)
-(25)
j; jo
0,3a.
(JU
Ct-'UL;
%
idl
931
.
Lk1aI IL;..j,-4;
a)
ms
b)
ms
C)
ins
d)
ns
n,s
(26)
Li
16
),
--
15
2
cis,
L-Ijl
fo. 2a.
JL;
b
1:>D'ou; LVLII
LAI. 4J..)
&11CL?
tLACl
:>%,
:>6w.
k
e5-s.
>j
ji J- -d% I k
I C!.
IZ,
uJI
," il CtAACu
Q,
eI-*"
cj" JQI
Ljk;j
1;
SLI
(10)
rt;
&3UJI
ijLo
NAt
cvl
0-
JLj
w%
c-,
-41ai ->
d
JL < e-u :>a>
fo. 2b.
10
(12)
04)
15
Cf. below p. gp line
the
13-
line.
b)
above
e)
6U
ms
-I
d)
outer
left
hand margin.
e)"
outer
left
hand margin,
f)
upper
right
hand margin.
I
LsL-
(1)b
b-
b 4-'.
)i
j1j
%10
U,
d :,
d0j;
<66> ALZA
6c3uj
J
O'XI
JLZ
L;
10
6-4-j
Jul
LoUil
h
dt
ti
b)
Di
-,.
Ic
U,
a) - Cf.
61
j
4JjQ
contents
ro.
t
JOT.
g)
ms
above
C) - ms -X.
-
outer
d)
J)
ms
k)
ms
f)
ms
outer
line.
ms
i)
e)
the
'i
right
hand margin.
right
hand ma gin.
L.
C-4
-Il
TEXT
APPENDIX
32-
sk
cD)
C)"
US
"!
- 31 't.
o>o
;,Q.\,
CJ
bl,
&2zel
( --5
c>Cj\A
--'0, c
G-IL ul
00
i k-
J'9
sa
1-:
C, >a-
0J-4.9
r1)
C',
.-
ka
Kit7ab al-Mukatab
Utz
cfzl!
-A;
Q4
O-M
VU
14c
cli
14
ti,
bti
.(7zi
-30
Kitab
Adab a! -Q-ada7
t41
"(1)
c:.c
4Aaj
Kiiab
4141
al-Da'awa
&Atoll
-\; -c
\.!
-Z
iqt li--
0-3it
6411
<,-- 0-mi
-, -Il
>:z-! ) Ic
- -
cc.
03,
.
ci
4r.
(.
41
;,. l
cl
L9
c cyZ3,dk:,.Z,k6, L4
> aJmlN:,
C)Z')
29
-
Kitlb
b,
..
r-
al-Aymin
3a
wa al-Nudhur
%2LJ%
(1)
jc3%
-A-9,
iL5,3
;9
y'
oe
QjiU
I\4.
ai
\j
tjj.;
JS
16
$S)
-.
6u
.001
cj\Ll
-/
28
-
Qe
Kifa-b
al-Adhiya
43
40
QA,
e..
/..
AI3
4,
(2
J2p
(2)
"
Ls
>-9
dL
o
)
27
C-e ol
01c
L'S
Lv
oj
Kit7ab al-Sayd
va al-I)haba'ih
ul
L-Vvj
a-ml
k)
0\4
'e-4'
26
-
ce
(c--m
de
LAX.
CAJ
C
1X*A`9
Kitab
al-Jizya
616
1
Z:.
(S4j%j
.
k2.
CY
25
-
Kitab
... -I
-)1>51219
al-Sariqa
ji17j1-9(1)
:i
(
-
Gb
Ce
a-A-t->
e_;j I
C-P
,
41if-lo
ei
ub
(
,3t*G,
.
-1
Li
ck
(2)
uaulz-
'&-.,
C,-epi
0--m
i>.
ttb
G-Al
Ki-fab
al-Ashriba
-I
-'Ii
'-L3
C.
'
()
(Jl
(:3'
&-. ot'j"..-EjIr
C; JfrJI
Vte I
24
-
Kitab
I'
li,
al-Hud7ud
G,
ei
wi
-.
-9
(i)
-\x,
Zilt U,.r.
-91,
LIJ I
'.
ft
--9,
du
eu-
. aLJj
i
c.
eu--o
t,>:.c
GJ I
Cki
k;
(1z.
uf,
i
9.
%J-g
L,:q
- -->-ge,(ju
>4
;&!,,
-.
(2)
c)v
loop
!'.
6; oj 56
\.,
z4t!
->Z
(3.t
U
C-,
C,
Cx-O->%j
?PI
I-,
CL)")
LW
Uc
=po.
4.
j4_b
C,e
(-;
(J4
"
23 -
Kitab
QitRl
Ahl
al-'Barhy
;;k
OUP
1-9
J, 3
1 100
L? t
Jl
CU,
LS6
Zl
L' 1-1,
CA.
(-Aa- (3-b-b
L>,NA
-. 1.
22
-
-91
4
c% e-.
Z.k:e- Le-pI.
Ic
-5j
U'.
(i-
Kitib
. Ck
ii
-.
Twl
-51
,
-1" "
l: ' t 6t<
4. > G'
v,
al-Diyya
'J9
21
-
",
Bab al-Rad
12-
AJLi_
-I-I
>D-'
4iL
-'
(i)
-L
a-:-
cj\j
4?
'I
_-
C'.
&UpA
Kit7ab al-Qiga,
Ci I
3'
:)
(>_c
k: II rj;>v. i
j9-.
9
& 9
(jPNe
't
(2)
21
%
t>\, L -,
Gd'
-u
mit
iLZ-Zai
DS
ap
...
q. ILI
19,
U;
-03
a-ckp.
20
-
KitRb al-Aym7an
Bib
al-Li'Kn
cv
Ju
'Ar-r-gi.
ZA.
"%
4: -c
19
Ia'b al-JIR'
"o
ac
O-M,
k4AI
(2p
JT
33::
U
L;
Nib al-ZihEr
& . -t-
ull
Ls-
Ull
js
ug
ue
:jb
18
**-J ok;
-
oil
64
'I
U
jcJ%t
0q-:
*-I
t,
(j
LUO)
sc' C)c
C--tj
a3ml
', ) ju;
',
&->
el-e-Xjl"l e-X:..
fe
c;
b
\.
)i
!
1:
Z)
,
o'
%91,
t
-i
Lp
,
431
tz.
(-"33 i (:j
-j>.
Lj
awa
.(.
70-c
Li
V-i
-Nk.
&.
17
'
(4)
I
_l
kv-hUkAi51
>
(b
I: >
(: -5
ktt:,
Nb
i>. -,.
-l
137abal-Sadiiq
(5)
Kifab
al-Taliq
; 0112(6)
4C:
-.;
im
-P
( I. -21 czil>
,
(;
(
pljaj.
ULu
z-.
-u
; >3,z
G-; t>L,;
cau, L.,
0-)
(.)-, -; 91
.
69,176
40
-1
on
cij\P9
4.
-
&
)
--.
YP
16
-
Kitab
al-Nika-h
0
ul
9
(J1,21
. ipX; -z
.0
4-721
AG ZUGIv.
16>
ck.-j
Ir
Jl
a-s
ull
6u ;41
--#-
-I
40
ff.
cul
11"
-'
>:
,7'e
L-: y ''(
(at -
"
C7O
15
-
Kitilb
al-Siya
'tiiPt
'j"
k--.
C. J%.XP'
(i)
.0
.0w
vp,.)
41
le
LY. "y
"I'
L::
f
C. 1;
)
40
'00
%J
.
*
(1
- ..
C=A;
Ac
)
U-0.
U-.e
LY
CiIx
-l
--t
IL3
d;
Ift *
CUD-)
Ll 1 L,;"!
-)P
-
J--,
(
1: 1
.&-ui
--4
sw
03))
j
1-:
cy.
9,
'? j
uU.-N,
(V"--l
(J.? 1 (: 5>
1
-; ::
Ziitziii
-p
14
...
-S
(u)
%)-.
(j
-oj
l>
("
G'
>
9-(:
,
L "ut
Lu)
--A
9-LM
&M%
ii% li,
.
j1
4&
14
-
KitRb
al-Iflas
wa al-VaJar
JL;
It
*
dl
;
Vj
;j
Cto.
Xit9b
>-j
% 1.
*'-
al-Ghasb
U4%.9
cti%9
AM
""
p
liL
',
'-Ij
9vuG, w1
13
-
Ov -A
-..
cat
.
".
l_)';
_,
Cu
-"b
6,
I
-
(-'I
QJ
4M
(P
_i_,
cJ'
(S
'm
c: ,
kA)
cL,
ZPI Gr
', '
J>V
c!
L
-*
1_,
i
r>
lq
c
>
1,
>-*i
N
C.
2i
j:.
z.
-*..
-5
_J,
3-.
u&y,
34
CSU
CL.
i-z.-,.g -.qg
t-9
: A-9
t%,'- uc
Jxk
.
j UU-,
(8)
12
JJ
c(.: 4t
(5)
A-LIU
Aj
&Ae-
L,. P;_
11
L31
-ALV4
*i,
0-
ul
ia
31;
>&
pl
Lip
'k4"
Cj
-.
W,
&
(}4;
Go
",
?
-4.
'i
il
cius
Gu.
x;
c:.
e- M1
"xb
j-
tA.
*.
j.
.0
ti;
-*&',
r-O
C-0
V9
jg
& (ju
-,
-a-ul
a4WA-? 4-S
ul.
Ls
k;;,
U;
;;
I
b
.
_0
. .
C,
Zj, -
Ski
",
Cki
Lf....;
11
-
(iI
(j
A-cL*-;,u WJ dmi -a
d-,.
()
c "t
c%.
'4"
-9
cci,
c4ij
Bq,.Jj ce
14;
Ly,
*32
L2->-e;
g
ZiJ
a--ul
u-i4
a-!
--bj
- '9 d.
21
kv-l;
C),
r('>] e-.)j :j -
9
__
-'
...
ci
0 it
G.x'.
J__,
2i
'a_:
(J"4))
di
LP
"c'
'-
rL
.'
()
- 10 -
Ki'Fabal-HaJA
14-c-t6l-
vj
tb
->D
.'
tc
l'
c.,
C-Jj
!,; &DAlt.
i
W"AL,
5o %i
"&
j,
CAL 3&Jl >
0-ii,
jt;
clu
&-U:
> jj
1; 12 Lk-pL;
1>
!
--#
Of
oks.,.
CJL;
vie.
JL;
cul
14
Z1
cJ.
(-.L-
ct
JL.
Izu
-2 ,
w9-24.iV9
..
Ba-b al-Aikaf
v ev. %
>egz >eI
..w,
jo
\J-gtuo-ie..i
"-gi-i
(JI
,r,
A .-
-4
cu
zul,
b-
-8-
Kititb
CA
Z4IP
al-Zakit
0, >,, LAr-
(gl5
tf
32'
Li
co,
116.
Kit7ab al-5iyln
44
Lit
Y5
cjl
-"I
rL,; Jl
jj(2)
CJ
JLO.
o
I(P.
.
., .1-.
7
Ljj
Lou
L?%C -OUL..
Pl.
I? cl,&
.
V.
L4
-q
Lu
-
'.
,
c
Lb
-I
k A
&0511-9
;Iu?41csa-'.
Nu II
LAS
.j---
>a
II
I-
-6ct. A
t%. B
16',
M
-;
A-1c
CA I-I-I
S, A.,.
4
d-Ju
U----'-
Lx L-A
LaiI cis
JLq., j tA
j
L;
C-, kc
. wo
.1
Ug
4ti
ju;
C-41
J,c-.q
O-Ac
(:J Li
(J
JAQ"
z4
(a
-.
;6
-d
C)Z)
)Id
(
Kitib
al - Jumca
.0
-j
tJ'
J42%9
..
p
_.,
".
&1,0
a 1"
:qC:,
),z
c J-; Aj OLA
JLP
sj
cAl
cp.
_Ipl
)u
k),
-11
If
-5G
C.--u
Ilo. (i \j t
l; a)i U. '
'JAS
A;
&
-
-,
1
cZ
-11(6)
6,41
ajkZi
Us.
u-rsi
Cj
(II
---
Aj
du
J. N-L-J-
ILY"Oli
o., Ub
(2;), *,**
le'i
aj,
j
v'
-A
CL-1 i
91
'42,5
3ei
j>JU
-LtU
J'
6 L-. J
_JU.
, >U
)%
-19
c-JI
Cr,
j t
G;-z-uc ui e-.
k
Lp
ou.,
4.
JI,
d'
t
5.9-zi
6- lu
ex-e
e-..,11%:>I -: I j
.,
cA
G.
,
a.:
--
g-s
-,
41.
-MI -., ---III. jI
.j-,
6 5-Al
1 -:.; td(4-b
-II
I
4E
'..
-4I--.
AP
(4)
Jo
ia
o
CetmlLAS
Zol
Cis
cy-z!
j
4A
Lug
IL-0
(5)
1
U-b
sV
6-5
OL-A
N-....
* le
lxra
11
-3-
Kitab
al
Salat
-
aj,
1 czj_, &:, i
.
Je--9
I
Li GC ci-tYL U \i 1 jgulmi,
, V? li
GI---U
i
'i
C-Y. >,
c4.0
x;_c c,;
%l
L, 31
",eeIL
ZG0
Wi Ls"
CL.:;-, i4-
6D
LA4
;.;
C,
iti v,.>
C,
iI
t*J:
C,
"(3)
Ai
j ( t-PJ,: tj:? V
tv. s
>!
II.,
!):.
LAc.
.v
-U-M4""
"ILP
u-3--e
iu
zi14),zi, 1Z1
-2B-ab al-
.c,
...
Tayammum
(i)
Ia
6:! A
'-'
cJ
-'
Jj
'4_%
-;
(3
l
w
16
0, celz Y: -0:
3,
'(Jft
"
(2)
Jl
UU
'I
'>: '
4.
99
Le
.jUIc
63-1,
cv
ICU
Lyu
cp
Le
c>c
b
__
1r
)'
. C2-)j >r
LA
"u-P
CLr
Z-3t.
Cy3s,
t:
cyb
d-3JI
-'
CL.
-'
--,
U--tj
L-
":
')
:D
LV-.3.
-APPMIX.
KASHSHIF
,V. X
t, rpU
I-..
LS.
&A
(1)
691
( 4),
Lj
C6.
X
u-!
-s
t4l
GLail
>!,.Jl
44-c- 4' cs
co
I-
4-11- J
APPENDIX
I,
NOTES(_
'N 0TF.
THE
TM.
Kit"-5b al-Talrara
(1)
Sjjfrjzi
cf.
, al-Nukit,
J L;
4 Z- a-:.. -,
And
Ru-us
Mshiml'q
SAUlls
of.
4;
al-Nhiriyya,
Cairo
al-'Umm
a1-IIa. -A'ilMS
statement
L;
"V,
tj
P.
,
4-1-9
a---
-,
see
But
L?
4a
1154 pfo.
HS Apad 3, no.
....
A:: Z; 5j
cedl
(2) But
'.
ju ... U-
Sh7a-fit'lls
cf.
'>
cit.
op. cit-oloc.
evidence
jj
L"-^*O. AI-11
Moreover
ina
with
"'16
X; r C:
(),
Muzarri
1, al-Mukhtasar
that
n of al-Umm I mentions
water
On which
A
Shifl'!
has argued
Z--makhsbari
in his
Cy
9 PA-Kashsfraf,
This statement
is
CU
shows
"
11unless
_j-JUP
that
it
L;
.,
Zamakhshari's
that
J1
.(
! 01
&U
6P
,6
Cairo
IIIL
4-' C U
to mean
39. )
ablution
4 ".
C>c.
I
>
word 11 ,t,030"
the
had based
Q7ar"'Zn 25-48,
on the
&
p vol.
on the
19 po 2j
4,
..
U,
intepretation
is supported
Lz
of the
by verse 8-11;
means
-2I
Shiia-ZI
Cf.
loc.
p op-. cit.,
ocit.
fo.
4b
Jl
.
And see HishirAig
Bat
that
cf.
ShRf ill
cf.
Mas'ad
d, 32 A*H. )
Cf. Shirizi
For his
Beirat91968,
vol.
biography
6,
pp. 27#28. vol.
19 P- 135-
19 p. 2,
said
BUt
0 f.
oloc-
, op. -cit.
q0P. qcit.
Cit-
di
h'
ruling
cit-
plOC*qCito
that
Sli-afi'l
cit.
2
itp.
ovol.
on the Qurlin
that
Shafiol
had based
25,48-
had
oloc.
MuZan!
differently.
Skafi'l
that
C;!
SIdliAzi
see
25,48
Qur-Zn
the
case on
-
Cit,
OP.
,
Cf.
ovol.
19P-39
-C
al-tahdhib,
qTahdh-ib
Ibn Pl9ja
But
cit.
;.; j
-k
Ibn Hajar
9 op.
statement
had said
(5) cAbdulliai b.
loc. cit.
op. cit,.
Muzard's
Li,
op.
-eit.,
op.
ro. 6a ;
-cit.
glocateites
d.4
-3But
SIL;fi"Ils
cf.
statement
;
-8
#OP-_cit-pvol-l#PP-7,
Ut Ul
(13) Hindi
(14) But
Wanz 9 Haiderabad
of. Slia-fe'lls
1945tvol-
evidence, ",
9t p. 247l,
B
vol.
p,
,
git
a-'j-Lisuj I
114,
fo. 6a.;
0..
But.
op.
statement
cfe Strafi4'lls
gloo.
1
(21) Cf, Zamakhsharl,
op. citi,
64-V
6",
16>
...
VVI U, >
AjIg
ku
- (See
2tP-595.
gvol,
Sidiras-i
loc. cit..,
loc..
-cit.,
ovol-loPP-7,8
90P. -cit.
cit.
-cit.
5p p, 6.
1969, Vol.
U`k`
OPS cit.
pop. -citploco
evidence
C U'>)
(20)
cite
1.4Fj
I.-Y
I -%
2.
gfo.
-cit.
Sh-aft"I's
cfe
--,
0-.
%0-
But
cit,,
Bv,>Jr>V1az-,
I
I!
appendix p. 1, no. j. )
'.
6b
0
cit,
1".
1
-fo.
'IF
of.
Sb7afigils
statements
l, p. e
gvol.
L; ---
&.
.
)
L*4
.
(22) Tirmidall-.
(23) But
it;
of.
-A%>
Cairo
-Rimet
Sh7afills
Cy
4.1i>A
k:
evidence
Ls-V f&I
evig
-b
(24) 1Gshimic2p,
cit
19379vol.
#loc.
f14.
top up..
-tie
-4i
P-74-'
9 op. citooloco
CA.
V-4
6L,
y
cite
CP-N
>J)
ul
cit.
Cy
O.
Lc--,
UL4
I
f
cit.
iU'.
j tz Oj ; tj-
Cf.
lLishiid,
op.
cit,
cit,
ploo,
A.
ju
But
that
cf.
Muzan7ls statement
-P,
, oP, cit-,
Vol-ltPP-495.
'
Nu,
ji;
cf.
that
Muzanipop.
-cit-9vol-ltP-5s
below;
case on the tradition
based this
6 "f
AIV- O-VIU..'a
-Cit.,
4b;
Sl;a-fi'l
LAC
had
ZA-1
vol-5. p. 213-
tff.
13a. 13b
Of Sli-afifTs
Jj
C;
t >Iut >,
.c
4w
-6
61
4.
J-1.,
tpmp6.
>.
i
X-I&
P-.
(32)
(d.
)
Mal'ik b,
Anas
O'D- cit-tvol-10,
cil-svol-19P-35
statementgop.
179 A. H.
.!
L&Z Oul -. ev
C:
UJI
cs; jt;
sli
a--4
U
I
A-C;
-It--i
Ibn Hajar,
his'biographygsee
For
.
PP-
_Sbifi'lls
evidence
lb
L4-,
t
ou-
gop. cit-qvol-loP-33
')4
ut; citz 4-Ul
).)L;
e..
(35) See
2,
11.
no.
above-p.
(36) Cf. Stdrizi,
op. cit.
8b
vfo.
4
And see*IlEr-Mm7itoP--cit-,
fo-4,
.4 NZO
JL;
LrUjl
tau
-5But
Shafi'-Ils
cf,
statement,
vol. lqp*26
2.L., cit,,
ul
lu%
C;2 cy P'l6 (J
-,
j 00
A4,, j -.t't
Ocl.
U: A
(37)'Qur-'grl 9.60.
(38)
SirL2ipo'P--eit-Ploc-.
cit
vol. 1, p. 25-
oj2.. cit.,
0
and he explains
the majority
"al-fath"
with
"al-kasr"
with
the word
his
in al-KashAafg
reading
;aW
cz
vl
ql
But Sh7afi"I
This is
4;yz..,
c:;Ib; Ivy
LAC,
reads it
according
in his
mentioned
_--
clearly.
to the reading
in
statement
of
the majority
he says
UJI
U;
,,,
'j,
31
The text
reads
For detailed
information
on this
point
Tkbiiil
psee
21
pal-Iml7a:
Cf.
But
Zamakhsharl'
AA
cf.
tvol-l*P-449-
>
i t.
loo.
sidirizi,
cit,
op.c
-cit.,
0-1-Al
Sliifi'lls
-%-
p. 1, no. 2
'por.
statement
ziv
eu:
(See appendix
CYA
A,
-.,
-A,
q0P., cit.
jvol.
fo. 8a;
6
lqp, 22
4 %.::
aI ju
61 'LL
4.;.
ZAP-?
-
tII
Je
pi
!
i10).!
Lo
:4 #1.0
-6(43)
1955, vol-
evidence
pop.., eit.,
21
L,
(.ju
Z,--i
JI
d
L>.
-cit.
oloc.
cit.
I -A1,9J,
,, -O.
Lj
o]2.
4L
OU
SA4Z
kz.
ci.
Imw
>-9
-A,
u.
e',
L4
(.d-g
ri -,
).k51
-ii
s
0.
".
A-L'
33ut
(48)
cf.
Ti=idhYt
(49) But'
8a
fo.
t
, opcit.
0)
#...
Ll
.0
'0
ShIfi"i's
92.
statement
cit-ovol-19P.
cf. Slafills
ak-'A
vol. ltp.
gop. -cit.,
ji
"%'61
23,;
49
evidence
du
CA;
&.
L
>.
)
'%'>
Lb -Sj'ujl
Ck"-j
LAC
a-Ml
'x4-j
te
U. 0
Ce
5
Li-!
cj
Crip.
Lit
I, \4v.
6
U---'
:>
I havb not-found-this
in
traditiori
but-the
1'
, &. q)
following
the-collection
VA
U1
qlal
OU
(See Suyt-jthrh
Sunan,, Beirut
(-n,.cl.), voi..
1. p. 88.)
-S
--
.0
6 vi
tradition
exists
cit,
fo.
8b;
9
IV
But
Shaft"I's
cf.
statement
cit.
top.
cit,,
9loc,
UL
56
(53)Tinaidhl: '
(54) But,
this
(55)
9 op. cit-tvol-19P-53-
ofe SICaft'lls
evidence
PoPo
-SIdia-z-i
citotloco
cite
C.$A 13.
LY-91
cf.
loo.
op.
cit.,,
t
Ox Ov
.:
u,
Ilp. 9.
And see Muzani pop.
-cit. pyol.
(56) Cf. Sidiazi
fo.
10b
op.,
cit.
,
0
But
op.
of. Shifiils
fo. 7.
-cit.,
statementp op.
l.
18
p.
9vol.
-cit.
-A
Lt..
(57) Ibn MEja
9 op. cit.,
(58) SITafel
op-scit.
,
(59) IbnkL; ja
Shifi'lls
cf..
114.
fo. 10a
OU-961t41a.
tvol-19P.
, op. cit.,
jk'41
ploc. -cit.,
9 op. -cit.
vol. l, p. 121.
cit.
op.
tloc.
statement
"Jl
-'..
geit.
t oR. cit.
20
lgp.
pvol.
JU
UJI
(61) Ibn ?9ja
(62)
But
op.
cf.
Z0
loc.,
cit..
_cit;,
Shafe its
evidbnce
LAO
p op.
cit.
'19p. 19
tvol,
ULt,:p I
6%
Jq;
4: -4
Cuo.)
V-91
'*
-8-
(C
_g
Slaffells
ou 9cs-;
jo
(j
Mukhtasar
(31
MS
3,
Ah.
1080,
26afo.
mad
no.
,
statement
lq
P-14 ;
qvol,
p qjQ.cit.
.j...
CA CA-9(LN Ls>
Slaifills
evidencep
op. cit.,
vol. 1, P-156.
loc. cit.
u
C).
(66)
cy
Nar,
oD. cit.
cf.
it
from
see Ibn
gfo.
26b
(k..c o-
Baihaq-igqMan
mentions
biography,
4.
(6s)
For his
pp. 276-279.
OP-cit-ovol-5,
..q
(3k4. % Ci o-til
b. Abbas (d. 68 A. H. ).
Abdull3h
ju
1344t Vol.
Haiderabad
.,
Ibn
..
JJ
lt
P-1419 who
XaScad.'
And see'Hgshimliq
vol. l,
op. cit.,
oP. cit-ofo.
P. 18
(C1.D';
.
(70) Cf. Hindi,
op. cit.,
SlEfi'Llls
Qyl lq
'4-9-
But cf.
"Low
p
axP
Shafi
i's
statementl
OJAA.,:oulUj% ju,
-l
-9
61-9
r JW
Joc,,cit,,;
c-e
8
Ls
7.
AW
I Q_9
A,,
CA: > j
'J-. q
-9-
oP.
-Cit-9100--cit-
Ji
.0.
op.
'
follb;
902- cit-,
.
66,
&0-
'o,
OU9460Lot
t>
-9il
;
NJ,
I
L
(, .,
Bat
6.
fo.
cit.,
J$
-ou
u"
D'>
%: >, I
ua-41
O-V
d"
'.
ju
-.,
0-tIr
Ibn Hajart
02-011-PvOl-89
PP-398 9 399-
vol-19P-101.
(d. 40 A. H. )
334
339.
ajarp 'o]2.
pvol-79PP--cit.
(77) Hindi
30
it
59who
vol-999P.
mentions
op.
.
-cit-t
Ibn
from Hudhaife. .
4-4A
c,
-X
see HAhimit
Ad
opo
-cit.
L40
o-m
loc.
cit.
L;. Jl
at
SK&I
I
o it-
Cf.
Saia-zll
op. cit.,
fo. llb
OU
But
cf.
L) I
Sh-afells
statementg
OP--Cit-tvol-ltP-13
-"
iI
j
it;
-i
A
L;e-OA 41." I (j I
t3
44&
SUA-le.
'k4c
oj2.
ow
cit.,
-eit..
vol.
loo. cit.
9 op. -citeg
lip.
133
;1v
vol, l, p. 12.
10
-
al-Umm,
on various
readingtof
The text reads,
(84)
states
his
has various
See above p.
For
-reads
this word
04.01
,,
2t no,
tkbarliq
p see
detailed
op.
cit.
information
lvol.
i. p. 182.
11.
ta'b al-Tayammum
-OP.
,
-cit,
9fo-14b
J#j
Lp
But
Sb7afi"Ils
cf.
fo. g.
. op. -cit.,
statement
9 OP- cito*tvolol#Po39
Af
liP
ul
(2) Cf. Suyall
9 oP. -cit-9
9 opo-cit.,
vol-lop.
171.
loc., cito.
9 op. -cit.,
fo, 17&
V J'j
But
that
vol-1, Po36
had said
zvgo
(6) But
Shifi-i
4, #'.
-CPp
that
this
case on the
following
C'I Cjs
T.
LskaYt-&A
See above p. 29 no.
fo.
op.
jk.
Va
ow
athar
_cit. tfo*ll
- 11 -
But
Saft"I's
cf.
statementt
OP-cit-tvol-lt
P-42
'A.'44
ou
C2-j 11
,,
G.
\it
,."b
,
Q.
*- Ouc
A-19""L
4--A%
(L'
Ji9i%
But cf.
Sja-fi'-jt
following
Ioc. -cit.,
op. cit;,
where Rabl'
provides
the
-
--k,
statement
Gel-i
e V. d--:Ck-101,
.I&V
Cf.
llgshili,
op. cit.,
loc. cit.
i'vi
(11) See above p. 29 no. 11.
1(12a)
Cf.
Zamakhshar-i, OP-cit-tvol-1,
P-399-(See
02-cit-9fo-14a
0%
OP-cit-tvol.
appendix
)
29no.
l,
p,
it
P-43
cel; - -J
fo. 8
op. cit.,
jj
"J
cf.
. -But
Shafi
i's
'j-,
af
-Jj
ew
,*,
statement,
%"
But
ef.
ShZfi'lls
op. cit.,
evidence,
100. cit.
-Lt
'SUP
(15)
OP-cit-,
'vol-1,
fo-14b
op. cit.
P-33 that
M.
pfo.
Shifi'l
But cf.
.
Muzan-i's
had said
statement,
%9 jf ju
'
- 12 (18)
(19)
Cf. Muzarri
op.
cit.,
Joc.
--it.
pp,
fo-15a
_cit, t
JU !R
I-le
02--cit-9,
vol-19P-40.,
l, P-39-
OP* cit-ovol.
fo-15a
%U
But.6,0,2jl t)zz-
(26) But
'efo Shiifili's
ul-I
CI
xr.
,
cf,
Sh9figils
9 op. cit-tvol-IPP-41
statement
'e
$I)
(.
evidence
**
"'16
6j
J/'
op.
.
-cit.
gloc.
;
lj'J
cit.
UV
96
'4,
&'
-'
'4. D
jjlD
Uj
j
(it
dj
ZA; CXY-10
LAC
Ibn
(29)
%i\;
TI.ia-.bit
-Nad7im9 al-
L; cu
aN
W 340%
A Sjk
3w%I OjY.. 4!0tj
X4
0- 150 A. H. )
Fihrist
. op. cit-t
Cairo
9
-284.
fo-41a
%.,
ul;
0,:
tk
-,
9
,
j,
eV
-9
,
cj:>11JVI
see
Al
- 13 But
Sh9fic!
cf..
Ia statement
3;
l,
p.
top. .-cit. tvol..
L- s Lp
CP
uI
I A-f-b
(30) Alu-Daw-udq
Sunan
( 31) But,
cf.
Cairo
Sb7aft"I's
19529 Volelp
evidence
9 o32.-cit.
L.:
-e
-v-
P-17.
I; PP-394 ;
lvol.
Z* e. i >v
zu%
j;
-.
fo- 43a
22-
6f.
cji,
e-u.
>
>?
cf.
39a
I.. # ce!;A,
Cc.'k.,
But
SIGXi'lls
.
J-L.
Vll
ze
O
Wl
C--,
ILIP, t0
--:
statement
ql
ja
Oj edI
t 02- cit-ovol-ItP-5
qA-t
L%e t-Nv-4b.
,I'
$I
.
6jbv-.
;
a
v% CJL
Jul
(36)
9who mentions
61 v1
A
d-j>
La--
-0
6PL-.
Io
9 OP. -C-it-oloc-
%
Ji
,
-4
AI
,..
, op. cit.,,
ou
14
(38) Muslim
, op. cit.,
(39) Cf.
1
Hishi
vol. l, p. 234.
ON cil-fo-14
Ap
ui
Uj
%
LJ4
I
6
L)
-tie.
But
cfq Shift"I's
ci
statement
vol. lp,
9 op* cit.,
C,
O'A.C. tj I o,,, wj%-
*'-'
Uk;,
(
...
-,
LY-4--pci-kll -1.0
61
, u ,e
u-.
evidence
Lit
# op. -cit.
t40.
e-u
I
&O-VI
t OP. -cit.
tfo-15a
I-t
And see Hishimf
But# cf.
k!)%
ju
fi
Ljl ju
gloo., cit.;
Ofj
I C-AL
Slaft'lls
ULC
CA
u"I
(43) See above p. 10, no. 2.,
(44)
Cf. ShKfi'l
loc.
j op.. cit,,
loc.
citog
-cit,,
'Cit.
(46)'Cf.
shlirizi
t oR. -cit.
of. Sli7afic'lls
But
21a
ofo.
statement
#OP--cit-9vol-19P.
J%
L:
cis
u-J
47
But
Cfo Sfafi"Ils
evidence
C*5p sI,
# op.
II
cit.,
loc,,
cit,
Cy, f, )71t
L",
--
C-P
4
-A
lb
ce
11$
dL; -
i,IuI
\.
6aWI
j
LSLO
D-j 1,121
LA
15
(49) Qur'gn 17
. -70Bab al-Masb
.ic
Cf.
Ibn
Farh
t,,
Al
fo-
9'OP. -Cit-o
al -Rhuffain
43b
b,,
...
vol, ljp. 28
,o L;
U%
LACLi
.9
(2)
Rat
cf o
..
U-A*>
bkt;
I
---
&-Cato)l
1.
Ck
-x>
to 10C cite
;
op.
ci
0
t
o9
J"C
LOW I
''
wl
o
CQV
evidence
",
A)
L&
lt
44--U%
at;
-!
')
Dj
Cf* ShIriz!
But,
Cl.BILO I
op.
-cit.
cfp -ShTLfi'lls
SarakhJi
-
I"
cf.
op. cit.
statement,
I u(c e
Cairo
9
, al-Mabsilt
Shgfi'Ils
bases this
22a
ljk X, oj
*
e-11 o-:,.
Cf
fo.
9
evidence
case on tradition
1906
op.
-,
vol. l, p. 29
Z)1.j
vol.
vgL;
Jwl
1, p.
JU jo
102.
28
who
tvol. qlgp.
I
-cit.
(See above no. 2
),
.
,
, op. cit,
23a
vfo,
6-
di
But
cf.
Muzadlls
that
Shfel
statement
had said
Y-O-
63A;
(L. ek-ol
902---cit-'9vol-l9P-5i
;
'
"V)
16
(8 )I
(9 ) But
cf.
thia
Muzanlls
that
tradition.
statement
ShL-ri'l
p OP.-cit-t
had based
this
following
case on the
evidence;
C;J-%L41
Ig
-j
-,
Ake e>
Bab al-Hayd,
( 1)
Zamakhsharli
Cf.
9 op,
Cf. Zanakhshar: l
cit.,
op.
ly
vol.
Sli7i37a2it
op. cit.,
gloo. cit.,
-cit.
- kf
JVJ
ok; )
-! Lv-Jl
page 2, no*2*)
fo. 23a
J: - e
fo. 16 .
op.
.
-cit.,
Shfjl'lls
statement I 02--cit-ovol-19P-50
of,
.
je
r
_e12:
.m..
G(;
>2
re
xg Z.)-,
t>
i
u--- ui?
,
c",-V,
", UAo.
1-9
-0
fit
'o
43,
jtJ,
L;
- -.
JUQ)%
Z"
C16
. _qb;
(3)
cf.
shIrTz!
op.
loc.
cit
cit.
_,
cf,
IGshirj-
vol-19P-51
; op.
9who says
Shifi'li
Ioc.
cit.,
9 oR.
_citogand
cit.
;
lb
; wt
-,
Ai
JC
l3at
C_,
u
JLO
A
ex,
..
-:.
3L;e,.,
Gt?
ci-3b
>
dj
qUil jl;
bU
;
61
At)p
ul4
Ly'e-iUl t..
(4)
Al-Qurr-V
gives the
I ..
ujfl;
)I
%:,
64Zdl
Cf.
read differently
following
AP
e, >
jtk.:
al-KashshFf,
%
-J-01-..
'Yo'?
vol. 1, p,
't
But
Shgfil
reads
Yk oto-"A.
3\
Zamakhshar-i
on this
statement
%V,
OAU. "*
cj-4L.
k-t
274.
01
A. *
Q-; P"
-His
statement
on this
is
- 17 in
available
al-'UM
vol-1,
P. 51# as below
J, J.; O
d-Ul
The text
For
reads
see Ukbari
further
information
on this
t OP--cit-tvol-19P-94-
Qur"gn 2_*222.
24b
tfo.
6.),
ju
tfO-18
ej,
L;
_9
Shfi'l
9
OP,
cit-,
9
, oR. cit.
cf.
Sh9fells
who base's
OR--cit-9vol-la-55
evidence-p
evidence
ot;
40
-1
AXI
Lit
&j
b.
it
GC-3
)-.
u
Gke.
&
(),,
Nx
L
.e
4
IG
Hgshim7i
op.
cc
Cf. SIdniz!
(,, 3u)
.A..
jj
;
16 ',
cit*
I.U
V41
Lj
---b
%>'I
p-: j I CA
V-Y
-)
jj
JJ
9)
9 op.
and also
u-j
G4.,
3
-A,
1,
U4V
-91r,'j%
>;
loc.
I 4L.
-za
1L9
24b
. op. ci
44
vol-IPP-58
-Cit.,
LJ,
OJ
Uili
tiri u- u%Lk--i
1,9
e
u;
C-41---&
li
L:
9
L;.
.
Cf,,
58.
vol-pliP.
cit.,
locopcitop
Juwaini
Shifi'Y
'op.
cit.,
al-Dur
MS British
ihtvol-&P-55
"o
t
(1
(14) But
cf.
SAfi'lls
evidencet
bases
18
-
this
dif f erent
case on
, op. cit.
UL'aa;
But
below
ct. ,P.)
ON cit-,
15b
jj
%U'>
e3k-jI -k.-kr-A
16a
Vol-1vP-83
Oj
txl
10-1-
ff.
t o]2. cit.,
]Buklia-3:1
cf.
CA
9 ).
P- 17 o note
cit.
9loc.
v uL'f L;-6
u-!'o
(See above
evidence.
JU
mentions
as
qv. g
IA
OVA
L.,
.
JL9---"
r.
Jj
CC
# & (53.,;;
%?.
jdi
..
0.
1
06%.,
01
I C-A
,,,
LIS
&A -U%
jj
uu
1>9
i
cy
(17) Cf.
Sblia_i
op.
ju
ciu
25a-;
ifo.
-cit.
e-ji
Jj ...
(18)
SarakhEri
si
kY
22- cit-9
vol-39-P-153-
Cf,
Shlrgz-i
9 op. -cit.,
fo. 25b
to, -, L)Li.
"d
(21 ) Hind
Tirtaidh-il
(2-3 ) Cf
Shlrgzl
-
oi
,
udhaifa.
Abli Umaiyya
biography
(22)
L)
-cit.
gvol.
, op. _cit.
.ai>
9 op. , cit.
ilp.
256.
loc,
cit.;
(d. 61 A. H. )
For her*
120
PP. 455 - 457.
9vol.
ct:Jj
tu Ji
19
-
XitRb
op.
-cit.
al-Salat
f'o.
26a
p
o
L3
j;
Lv
And see H9shim7i,. op.
-cit.
20
qfo.
-"ko
Shlfil
9 op.
cit,. #
'I,
62.
vol.
p.
(2) Cf. Shlx7az-i
0 op. -cit.,
4du
26a 9 26b ;
ff.
U . e>il f-A0-9,
Lr--o"9
t
And see Illshim!
(3) AbaDMd
# o2. --cit.,
loc,
Shlfll
cit.,
, op. cit.,
loc.
cit..
fo. 27 ;
. op. cit
C,
lPPP-93 s 94.
tOP--cit-tvol.
Cf. Shlrzl
LN:
op.
-cit.,
Cf- Shlr7azl 9 op. cit., Ioc.
64-
vol. lp.
;
cit.
U-0
9 op. cit*plOC*tcite
.,.
j....
cit.
p
op. cit-9fo.
21.
it
(See appendix
Shlx;
zli,
,
P. 3, no-
op. clt.
28a
;
qfo.
Iv
20
But
ShFift'lls
cf.
statement
p op. -cit.,
vol. lp.
64 ;
4,
Laeb
4kki:
61
kw
-10)
-P
Cf.
ShZfi'*Ils
this
evidence,
case on the
a'
'11
(11)
Cf.
U-
loc.
cit.,
4".
(U-61 ul
l, p. 62
bases
who
,
below,;
tradition
op.
cit.,
22.
4-511
Sh-ir-azi
**vol.
43k;
1, op.
cit.
cit-;
cup)
am%. X4
Cairo
. al-Mwatta"q
cit.
910c.
Uu
I6raqun!,
P- 13
1951, vol-19
op. cit,
vol. l. p. 269.
tradition
(14) CA HINZ!
t "211-00-32a
But'
cf.
op.
Shafi'lls
cit.,
.I
;
fo. 24
statement
op.
,
-cit.
9 vol-lop-72
13
Jl
ul-0 c.
-xV
cP.
C)ls
32a 932b ;
L(-2.j Lp
(up)
I
4Ou
And see Shif i"I
(16) BilRl
ajar
b.
op. cit,
'
Raah (d. 25 A. H. ) . For his bio graphy
9,02--cit-ovol-19PP.
(17) Muslim
9 op. cit.
(19) cAmr b. Qais (d,
02- cit-,
vol-8tP.
100,
cito o
.
Ibn
see
.
502 9 503-
29P.
768.
ovol.
?
34.
Ibn
Hajarq
see
t
I
21
-
(19) ! have
not fourid*this
following
bxit
haCith
adFth_is
available
the collection
-in
UP. ) d! UI t3 '-J
C: A 4J-
JIMI
29P-768 v MIik
vol.
(Y. A-4
4
U; d:!,)
_J,
>tC
t op, cit,
1,
pvol.
74.
(20)
Cf. Slrirazli
But
Slaft"I's
cf.
32b
;
Ifo,
, op. cit.
p OR- cit-,
statement
WO
U-i
W
(-5,
/(21)
Cf. Shiraz!
-DUP\J"9
Cy
>Ql
A-ml
_j,
And
Slafi4l'
see
(22) Aus b.
0 op,
vol. 12
(. ujwt
ji
4--va
Joe,
cit.
Oj
-W..
OW: X9 j I Liu's
6
-.
to W
cit,,
(d-59 A. H. )
his
biographyv
For
.
Ma'lr
op. cit.,
%, >99
JO
..
32b 9 33a
41
A
.0
I, P-73
UL>
cP-0
ci't-iff(L)P)
vol.,
a
(23) For/complete text of this hadith
_cit.,
'
p, 235,
vol, l,.
(24)gAbdullgh
b.
Zaid
al-Ansari-
text
63 A. H. )
(d.
For
biography#
his
5, p. 223-
of this
Abil
Diw;
dt
OP.
see
9
-citep
hadith
Bat
cf.
Sliaifllls
statement
Slaft"I's
evidence
4,
p op. -cit.
gloo.
(see
cit,
abov6
)
20.
no .
(27) But
0-41
cf.
J, V
--'.
*&DqL,d)%
VI
Jto,
I ,,0-IJ I
JIJ
/,I
1,0.0
A-M
...
'o
,0j
"JI
UA4
ILA
d0j,
'JJ
UA
I du
-V
22
-
ff-
op. cit-,
33a 9 33b
(32)
Bat
that
op.
-cit.
20.
tfo.
had used
the'following
1975, vol-l
the mentioned
P-59
for
verse
'mehUos
evidence
of
ruling,;
u.
(3 3)'Qar" 7a,,17.78.
.
('34) Cfo Sldria'Ji op.
29b
j
-cit. gfo.
6A
But
6.e I"'.
-,
Shlifi'Ll's
' cf.
G"--3 I
.
(55)'Ammir
Nar
, OP--cit.,
(36) Baihaji
(37) But
UA.C &A,
b. T; sir
9 oRp
statement
(d. 37 A. H. )
LAS,
, %uq -'ic
cj,
(3kz
0--ul
vol-79PP-408
uJUJI OU
Ibn
see
9
410.
-
Sunan
.
9 vol-19P-388.
of.
Shafi'*Ils
evidence
, op. -cit.,
Ioc.
cit.
05%
6L>
23
(38)
AbiDgwild, OP. cit.
1
2p.
29PP'.
45'2,453.
vol,
9
loo.
cit.,
cit.
;Fu C
4L
>-,
I
,
Shai"E's
statement # opo cit. tvol. l, p. 61
i%
CJLZ
.
4
4.
Jj
6vi"l
, ..,,
A,Aoij%
But - of.
&P cw.,: 4. )
1
du0'.
-v
-A)
I L>V I
Jj
Vp'l
L;
(40) Buklar-i
'I
A-:4 N..q
0'P2-11-9"1-10-146,
p
gop. 011-9fo-31a
4`1
Ly
tv
But
Shaft"I's
cf.
statement
op. cit.,
vol. l, p. 65
C
(42)TirmidhE
(43)
But
I q2. -cit,
cf*
Sh9figils
jvol.
l, p, 28q,
evidence
vol.
op.
.
-cit.,
l, pp. 65,66
V4.1
0--9,
!
-9
VO
LC4.C
uo
LskyA
16t ....
fo-35b
012cit-,
;
,
.4
Farh
PON ciLtfo-71a-
- 24 -
But
Shaft"its
of.
6%:
statement,
l,
82
p.
;
ovol.
cit.
qg
>4
op,
4)1
OA.
CAW"
e4l
JI;
*tp
cj$
6,
%4d%
C),.
LAC
LO
L&
-p%l
44 ,) ut. 0
...
cf. SITaft"I's
U-
l.
81.82
evidence p oP,
pp.
-cit, pvol.
U
;
_'
I U!, -'
-'
4511 ou
Ue
e
ail
p (49) Qur"En 2.150--A
(50) Cf- SI;h7! z-i 012- cit-tfo-30a
9
em J
I, S.%"
%q e;
But
cf.
Shgfi!
(51) But
cf,
ShIfit'li's
%>9
Is statement
IjuI
, op. cit.
0,
..
toik.p
43
71
19P.
tvol.
Ioc. teit.;
>
y--ol
OP--Oi+--tvol-ltP-1159
p.
Cr-.4A
379.
40
25
-
cf. Sliifiils
%JA-.
statement
; A
j10
79
02- cit-ovol-ltP.
..
V-4
ono
I lj
Ji i Uz
63UJI
4-4%
Ju
L;
V, u
But
cf*
Shaft"I's
statement
0 op.
cit.
tvol.
i, p. 67
ff
ICUAp
Utc Liao
*k;,
Lb-,!
Li
S
S>->
"I
U;:
>
;
;
-q
a:.;1; &,
It 6v %.,
uj 0-.
t
16 ttolt,
l>j
)-
e:
:>
X-b
L;*UJI %JU
0
-Jj
Lp
(56) ihat
cf.
Sh7afirl's
evidence-, pp.
6796s -9
ltpp.
-cit. ovol.
(UP)
3kp
I Le(, o
Z\j
C",
9.,.w I
Q.,J
_j, -,
D Cjjl,
P..,
Pj -)Aj*
-P:
m;. c
Byoil
>o L-4-,
p CLU
61,5
ul
W-41
ft
IU
.
C"o
t: 9. $A
,j
26
(58) Cf- Sarakhs-i
9 02- cit.
'in
the collection,
154
but
the
tradition
tVol-19P.
9
as below
W,&Ig
op.
(59)
OP--cit-tvol-ltP-334
-cit.
.#i
t-9
L&
95,
...
But
cf.
SICaft"I's
statement
But
of.
SICaft"I's
evidence
Cy.ykg. 6:
thd
this
(A4;
dt.
"d
t -, ii -e-z,9,ot
9 op. cit-tvol-IPP-87
o]2.
jloc.
-cit.
"0
U%10-3
jcit.;
C>S
%Wordlngjt
appears
&";
j,
d;
1>11
ai ;i
Cuo)
&L
(l
d-M
CA,
zo
jb 0.4"g, (AP3
wo.) OJUI
ek-vty" Z>vl
(Cf. suyd
-t-i, 613. cit.
C:A
- Qur"in 17-110.
(64)
(65)
)
2.
Po3pno.
as below
collection
e..;
(See appendix
, 032--oit-tfo-38b
;
&x
!,*A U14.., j %
(63)
tradition.
9 OP--Oit-ovol-39P-331.
1 t, Lxe;,
(62)
APXJ
%I%
Zamakhshari. t
9 ana cf.
2,
297.
p.
tvol.
43
W
bo;
.1
See TirmidId-9
exists
Cf.
Zamakhsharli
IShirazl
(66) cf.
ioo.,
, oj2. cit.,
cit..
-9
But
of.
t op.
Sh9fi"I's
"Umakhsharl
statement
(68)Qur'in
87-14
, op. -oit.
15.
,
dri
L-WI CY
fo. 27
cit.,
1, A-w I
(67YU.
)
2.,
P-3#no.
39b
9 02- cit-ofo-
(See appendix
J""3k;
op.
L4-
gloc.
cit..
cite.
loc,,
cit*;
uz
Lit
du
jj
27
(69)
But
Slaft'lls
of*
this
op.
ligshini-i
(71) Cf-Hlshirl
cit.
op.
cit..
tloo.
30
op.
;
9
tfo.
-cit.
k,-A
4,,j 's ,1
Slrafills
-0
vot 6,
(-,P--A'31; -
-cit,,
bases
who
p
cit,
cit.;
tloc.
t op. --cit.
;, I
But
loc,
(See p. 26
62).
no.
g
tradition.
case on
And of.
evidence
fo. 106b
statment
P-93
9 012--cit-ovol-1,
L.;
LAC,
y
C-f-:
Lew
OW
16L.
op.
-cit.,
Ioc.
cit.;
JJI
I
,, "I
Lv
ce :4"
(d-34
b. 41-Qlmit
ajar
t oP. cit.
-cit.,
A. H. )
For
Ibn Farh
U.
cit
biography
his
ofo-107a.
Ibn
see
.
9 02--cit-tvol-59,
(75) Bukhi: A
10c-, cit-,
OP--Cit-,
l9p.
192.
jvol,
.
vol. ltp. 188,
40 ;
ov
t (.;,0
Cp Iq
"
j.
-4
VP
kv
-).!
ip.
p
k-,
CUP
-.
But
Shaft"I's
of.
staterient
t op.
cit-tvol-ltP-15'D
;
A--j
41 Z-, O
L&
(78)
Cf.
by
(79)
But
1.4.0
j!
(LW) KN%
-s-
0,.. -. A)
?...
Murraiiii
-
C4">.
Kurruz
Suyjj
C-1. Shlift"I's
""tcuv
a&
Zt.\, g Gf.
of
al-JEMi4
d-)
tOP-0i't-,
vol-IM-150051
f chz..
Z"
.
1.
A
C-u
(11,9
%
x
%ly
dL4ju
28
-
(80)
Sag d b.
ljajar
(d. 74 A. 11.)
For
his
.
MZik
, OR- cit-tvol-39PP.
biography
Ibn
see
I
that
4 U2J",
j%
i-,
0,
_G)
Z, cr-q -,.!
this
L3
L.
(82) Cf. Zamakhsharl
0 op. -cit.
( See appendix
21.
ltp.
qvol.
op. cit.
Jbn
ploo. cit..
aZa
P-39no-3)
Farhp OP-cit-tfo-74a
"UJI
O
A-.
opi
4.
LV
But
cf.
Sh7afi"I's
k;
statementgop.
cit-,
vol-19P-94
it I
(85) But,
J,
O-Al
(66) Zamakhshail
loc,
in the complete
("i
-0t,(is u.1%
43U
eit.
, o]2. -cit.,
loc.
cit9q
and of.
( JU
6%j
&-.
1.3
t
4
Gli
:
i
&,
u
%wv
10
us
i
(it.; cwp.
(r'LA.- , ( eu O--Ajii
2t.> -,
Ajca4
LiIji
UII
-29
(87) Cf. Ibn Farh 9 op.
-cit.,
"L')
J.,
v
cc.
fo. 86b
-Ij
cit-ovOl-19P-76
01;
%l
6'.
that
Muzaxi-i's statementt
had said
Slfaf: ll
AO
euT 6-
(88)
Cf.
(89)
(90)
Cf.
Ibn 14!ja,
. op.
Farh
vol. l,, p.
cit.,
op.
cit.
top.
cit.,
itp.
tvol.
ju...
Cf.
Buklia-il'g
(92)
Cf.
Zamakhshail
(93)
Cf
Zamakhsha: l
II.
V.
Imt
. -..
cf.
op.
190.
loc. vcit.
6A.'o .I -v
k4w
.
192.
voj. j,
cito.
(See appendix
o'
ou
-,,,
Slafllils
&
statement
6v-!
V,
LL'
L?
1: 11,4
--o
6-
fo-42a;
eWjl--w--
vol-ItP-95
, op. -cit.,
dl;
uv.,
A;
(A
00
P-49no-4-)
OP-cit.,
gloc. qittShirazi,
JU
ok.
16
C.
'P
C)1-9
0
"...
(94) But
(06
276.
c-,
(91)
cy
oa-
(%,
Ibn
But cf.
p who mentions
6-1, A),
fo-42b.
cf.
Shkills
evidence
,-
t jl
9 oP'-_cit-9vol-IPP-94
&x
>Za..
a'
tU
4t-?
od
30
(96) Cf. ZamakhshaA'
(See
appendix P-49no-5-)
9 OR.. Oit-ovol-1, P-398-
c-41
(98)'Cf.
(99)
But
Sh7afe i's
statementt
z
L Lj%,
...
PP-5 3.
tvol-I
-cite
Shifi-ils
cf.
CA u -k?
-'a.
Bat, cf.
9 op.
evidence
cito,
loc,,
cit,
;
W%
(Az
-M
...
Utp!
4.5,
it
U-Aa "
3-
ot;
6 !- L;;>
L \1--q
J
OV61.11.
Muslim-,
(102)But
, cf.
V_"I
LA
But
of.,
Slaifi'lls
statement,
qo
(10.1)Cf.
1,4
28.
OP-_cit-#*fo.
'-,'
OP---rAt-9VOl-I9P-32?.,
SICaft"i's
CJL;.,
X^r'
4J1.
89990
OV01.19PP.
pp
evidence
1 01;
P Wj
Lt
I(
U1
UO)
0_11
jc.
9 op. cite,
3, e-m
10c., Cito
cy'>-
P-5
nn .
C'-%.
t P-436, # Vol-. 3tPolo-
61.7. )
. op. -cit.
. op. cit-,
27
pfo.
But
cf.
Shafli's
vol-19P-93
IL;
C., OV,
4-01
above p. 2. no-
(110)
Cf.
Ab7a Yasuf,
alZthgr
But
cf.
at4ar
is from Abi'Darda
.
But
cf.
1355v
Ilaiderabad
Zamakhsharli t 02--cit-vvol-30-110',
Shafi6l's
evidence
C.j%4jt
&
i>LC
9 op. _cit,,,
who mentions
Gur)in
(112)
that
;
>
c-p. ci %
Z->C * --
..
C
"'
I
%.
-P ejL;
!J;j
(111)
P-44.
12.-2.
JL
fo-84b
But
cf.
ShFfirl's
statement
U,
J<4
(113)
cAbdullh
cPic%(d.,
b.
Cf.
Bukl-aili
(115) But
(116) Iut
cf.
p qM. -cit.
cf. Stafi"lls
11L, 4 -,
Soo
1j
JV jU, CiotLilij
JG kV--.-A k4V
)
'57'A. H. )
9 op. cit.
Sh9fi4l's
Zue I c6
0-1-J5
k;!
C-
JXP
9 OP--Oit-ovol-19P-97
ki,'
12tpp.
ovol.
262 - 267
ljpo2Ol;
ovol'.
statement
I op. -citotvol*l,
p, 108
LLJ
cis
ZY-P
Cii
C-ru
->-q
evidence p OP--cit-9Vol-I#P-107I
(:.c
cy
I
&.xt.
U-Z
jkl;
161.
this
32-
vol. 2tP-530
op. cit.,
4&
cy C.)
..,
&
t OP.-cit-ofo-46b
%4.
A#
A ju
., . ..
i's
e.
Shift
Cf.
But
statement
3w 64 L4
J..."
(119)
9 op. cit-tvol-lPPP-1319132
tv
:r
xO
0-3,
0:
>
appears.
i-.
as below
61%
)
2750276.
l.
pp.
gvol.
(120) Bat
L-A
"j,
cr-
u'j
cf* Shafif'lls
cite
evidence'v op.
-cit*tloco
N;
't JL--,#C).
r wvz% U. ow ou ol 4,
I &, Ps .
u L.
Ls I Lstp-
hadi-th.
A
(122)
9; 0-49
Cf. lashiiJ
cc
-
9 02- eit.
!.
IPI
And see Sidriz!
(123)gAmr
b.
OP- cit-,
Shiiaib
c-A
L,
u::,
k;
x>
JL; -Y,
j) Ic
D,
9 oP-'-cit-9fo-48b
(d. 118 A. H. )
For
,
his
biography
Ao
Ci "I
"%-,
q
,
SP
a-z'-;Zol
Ib'n
Hajar,
see
9
33
(1.24) This
fo-
adlth
by Shirazi
was mentioned
49a . 'But
the
hadith
existd-in
as below
the
in his
collection'.
6A-, a
, 9-
j3I
_;
as well
W
jZXA
>0
Lg
40% L;
(Cf.
(125)
But
DErdqunl*
cfe
, op.
Sh7afigils
2, p. 30
gvol.
cit.
evidence
9 OP. oft-ovol-7tP.
189
U"
(126)
Cf.
'Sh-iraz-i
op.
fo-53a
cit.,
A---j
But
cf.
Shifills
statement
9 op. -
ICit-tvol-19P'048;
60
'cc.
A0..
(128)
(129)
100a
gfo.
9 op. -cit.
lp
..
op. cit-ovol-liPA47;
Z. A ttt
it
-t
And"
cf.
SAft"I's
statement#
ZY J
(130) Cf- Ab7l ])ZwGdt OP.
-cit-9
(131) Cf. Zamakhsharl'
g o]2. cit.
v?l-ItP-135(See appendix
29p.
15
gvol.
..
)
8,
P-5pno.
OP--cit-ofo-30a
li dL;
Shafi'lls
And cf.
C.,bLOJ I Cy- ,,
-g
statement'.
;v)
(-Nk,
But
I
-J
LA*I,
6,
0a
5
ts
XI
Shaft"I's
cf.
6,
&
13
.
(138) But
-Vol-19P-114
o
331)236.
oPfo-50b;
4$ (
(4^, r
I.
.
60
4,"
t OP- cit-ovol-lop-148
Lo,,
6 L
L_
SITafis
cf
.
cit
>l
statement
L. j
&
p
ouk,
9 22-
(A
%,!
tA
_)A
9 OP- cit-ploc-peit.
'1
But
4e-
Ju
JUJ
statement
zAu
6L
-....
VLA_-
>,. Oi.
Slafills
of.
4, j
(jq
0.
cr
61
lop.
vol.
cit.,
(C.
14;
(.11,
W.
41.
C, ...
k4 %it;
X-L
GAO
U\jt
>41-9
fA
O.
(,
(& -P,
La 1,LP
evidence , op.
cit.
oloc*,
-cit.
ut
>1,
Co
ut_,r
(140)
Cf.
Muzarri
Shafi'l
, op.
cit-tvol-19P-95
who mentions
had said
Lj!
Lfkz
Rp. cit.
19
vol.
P-46.
9
>
that
35
(141)
0 C A. A. --""
&-_4
And see Slrafilj
(143)
fo-49a
o]2.-cit.,
,",.,
C-.*p
lgp.
op.
) %0_:
j, ..
p e
&'
'
123-
-cit. qvol.
5'
See above p. '2
t no.
*-
I.
9 OR. cit-
U%
&
0--M
t5
-'Id%
*1
'4
61
L&
ShEfe i's
&\;;o'-Al-j
L,
-tTadition.
evidence
WV
100.9cit9;
ci+..
op..
t
9
Ji
-1
--
k:tk C)V
I-z;
%)I;- or(:.>11
(CLAA.
U-s%
rv&
vol-19P. 478-
UJI ou
"
Ul
zy.,4jI (:"
61
j>
01). citelloc.
C-4!.t
toit.
, OR.-cit-tff-54955.
;
o2.,
cit.
,
tfo-56b
Cj
...
36
But
Slafills
cf.
statement
op.
f-Y," 'I,,
(153)
-cit.,
J4).
vol. -l,
'P. 164.;
jj
Q Ut-. *P
e-.
..
.1
-cit.,,
..
-'
&
(Jt:
vol. lp.
163
4:
cy
(156) Cf. Muslim
232.
lpp.
op.
cit.,,
vol.
,
(158) But
9 op. -cit.
9 op. -cit.
cf.
Muzani's
that
oloc. qcit.,
But
cf.
Mizani's
cf
128
lgp.
gvol.
l,
12j
op,
vol.
p.
,
j
_cit.,
based this case on the following
statement
ShafiThad
evidence
US
u-
ztt
.
tk
-C-G
cit.;
0
o%j---uj
11
37
(160) Cf. SlRrali
fo-56a
, OP--cit-9
SlCafi'lls
Butq cf.
OP- Cit-P55-
statementl
But
(162)
Cf.
of,.
Sh7afi9ils
Sarakhs .17,
op.
the
in
appears
Cf, Tirmidhi
cit.,
cit.;
the lollowing.
op.
tfo-37b;
-cit.
,j
A,tj L;
0
Ir
-1
And 8ee Eksh&r. op. cit",
(164)
above-P-17s
-See
LD;
fo-51-
2.
2#p.
tvol.
51952. '
op,. a-it-pff.
v OP.-Cit-ofo-36a
ilo
-V
--zr
Shifi
A)j
no-7--
9 op. cit.
statement
g op.
cit.
tvol,
11-0
Q-;* C-
o'q,
\";.
y
\j
fw-,-) o-J.;-4%
juu
Cf.
Sh7afi f. r's
I op. -cit.
evidence
0-*
'a
cit.;
gloco
eJ
...
I-Z
9L,--)
'6
A
j
3"t,
Co
ov
Q
CA96
%-.
;
-,
A6
a.,
C.
,
to
-'s
0,!,v
L-Oxp
AAt2->C
00-".. C.
Y,">-a. -,
LS (UP) A-lal
L)-rt"
wI
...
P-85;
ow I
cIk:
L"
l,
%j
Ord
ullpol
(168)
Q 4%) lu
tradition
collection
16Jj
cf.
loc.
cit.,
ops-cit-tvol-10-334-
I 3lit
(163) Cf. shh!
But
9 op.
evidence
(169) cf.
Ioc,
cit.;
38
ab
(1)
Cf.
Zamakhshwl
al
, op.
JuTn"a
cit-vol-3,
230
pp.
(See appendix
231
0
.
9 OP. cit-fo-57b
914 4, A
.. -V
cAc ; -i
Cit-ofo-57
, op.
',
6,
j.
no.
p.
but
of.
9
Shgfllls
statementt
vol-19P. 170
O'P- cit.,
Al
9
06.1:
>Z
Cf. Baihajil
9 op. cit-tvol-39P-179
Zamakhshwi-
'eit.,
, op.
vol. Ilp.
, op.
loc.
cf.
Sh7afi"F
cit.,
231 -
cit..
Cf.
ZamakhshaA
9 op.
Cf . ZamakhsharI7.
C, .A-..
u >4."
cit.,
, op. cit.,
Ip
vol. lp.
cit..
loc. oitp
)
6,
l.
p.
no.
(See appendix
ShlxZ7zli, 012,cit-,
,.
cit..
gloco
fo-58a;
""V
J
Ie
t,
..
Joc.
W\$%-
i's
statementl,
169
14,
Shlfi
e i's
tradition
evidence
9 22.
cit.
gloc.
cit.;
ji
cup)
0%;
i,:. a
("-D
b,
O-A,
C.:o k-!.
0110
41-
4,
loc.
cit.
; -4,
9 op. cit.,
19
*v
loo.
But
of,
*
cit.
Sh9fi'l
, OR- cit-t
11-14,
-,
0sa
1-9 Sul
1-9
4L
\\
ZA
C-)
*_I
4L (3
cit.
op.
p
cit.
'
But cf-
Shlift"I's
evidence
9loc.
But cf.
_..
_,
KC
-Q
,"-.
(See appendix
Cy>A
Shlfills
statement
ol).
-eit-svol-19P.
LAS.
SarakhJi
Zamakhsharl
9 op.
9 op.
cit.
cit.
L,
gvol.
gloo.
cy
.-v
29p. 24
6jk4j
1V-,
L
:.
-
cit..
z)Q-P-q
a.;
ei
s,
#., ,
9 OP. cit.
170;
cit.;
aul
)
6,
i.
p. no.
i0o
LDA. 0
0-
(16) Cf.
bases
this
who
9
no-3-. . '-
(..
4,
4tL
Ckj
Ut
59b
;
tfd.
11
kk
L:j
40
(19)
cf.
siAlr7azl
to, ls*
.
But
(20)
But
, op. cit.,
j6
U-4
cf . Sb7af1 iIs
this
statement,
Slafit'lls
of.
fo. 60a ;
evidence
op.
isha
cit.,
bint,
Abi
(d-58
Bakr
..
bases
who
i
vol-lip-176
i"r
Zi
IJIIV
(21)
177
cit-tvol-ltP.
62-119
on the Quriin
ruling
op.
uk;;
A. H. ) For
her
-1
6- jj
v6
biography
see Ibn
ajar
436.
op.
cit.
PP-433
9
9vol.
(22) Cf* SIir; d
1000
Cite
op.
citet
t
I
ak;
0-0
b
F
ek;
, cP,., -, OG,
4.OL;"a
(23) 1 have not found this
but
it
in
exists
athar
books
the
X
U';
>-',
L"O'A
- ..
in the six
of
collections
jurisprudence
transm: Ltt6r*;
cit
it
. mentions
".. k'
jurists
mentions
A; cL. Ji
(tQ
(I
the
In Kitib
Cairo
-Rawawi .
9 where
of 4adithg
Bab SalEt'al4Idain
Cf.
Sh7ir7azY
But cf.
, op.
Shifit'lls
cit.,
fo. 63b;
oR. cit.
statement
Bq-,
209
ltp.
pvol.
Olo
vvl
L-Lt-
U-J
V
(2
Yeq7tib bIbn
Irlim,
Nad7im
Mular=ad b-
oZ.
al-Hasan
9p.
his
biography
see
286.
41
(4)
Cf.
HiZshiml
fo. 65 ;
op. cit.,
; j, c
r-'
tj
um
But of.
&
ea)l
Ul
Sh7afl'fls
statement
1.:5L ul al
k,
, op. cit.,
cy
5y.,p
-4)%
'%6
"'
&
I
P-U'
-t-31f,
pi
--Jl
IL
vol. l, p. 213
zm%
. 00
,
ov
oR. cit-ofo-140b
eA
J\01
5
Cf. Ks7anli
But K; &d
Visuf
(6
Bada7j
Cairo
that
mentions
this
case
is
ascribed
only
to Abil
and M"ammad.
Qur'2!ri 2.203.
(7
Zamakhshar7i
interpretation
(1)
Cfe Shirazi,
tju
in
his
a1-KashsI; a'f
on the
Qqr'an
2.203-
Bab al-Kusi
66a
fo.
oD. cit.,
Cju L;
Cjug..;
-q
'Ir
Cu
op. cit.,
'-Ij
Sh7aff"i's
statement,
i tt. >5
du
-?
W%
ti.. i e J
La3%
NA2,b U L;
U;
z.
'
i-9.
t
1;
1;
%ep
D
> --9,3Ub
( ( -%e- (
j'%
tc 9)L)
""
.
Z-5
1-x-A5
42
-
Cf.
I
Shlrazi
P'op-
cit.
tfo.
67a
JUJ)
But cf.
Slia'fills
statement
op. cit.,
1. p. 225
vol,
W% (JU
JLZ
(.
Q-.,, "Jo 6.1-9C, > 11e3 W;
VIU,
ev
3) But of.
Sh7afiils
evidence
op.
cit.
9
VI
0-1k
41
cit.
flit
It ivg ( _0
))
v
Cy.
co-,
ILA;
- a-tu(ilmp
J ko
; I. oil UAS
oloc,
vzj I ju
k; s
joi
-J
I have not
found this
athar.
t-ab al-Jaria*l'iz
2) Cf
Ab7i D&,md
- 43 -
Shift"I's
cit.
gloc.
CjA
j
CUP)
0-t1i
J-;;
1;
c
UA-Ccpl C.,
(C.
P)
&C
Urok:
CiN
JJ
t
(4)
Cf,
Shirazi
o]2. eit.,
cit.
fo. 68
cit.,
b!,
0'6
i, p. 242 1
tvol.
Sb7afil
, op.
68b
fo.
. op,
cit.,
vol
But of.
.
Slia-fells
62-'
1151,4P1
L-A-%-p
242
pp.
*19
statement
"I
ILA
-(.: I
243-
(7)Pa-tima
Ibn
(8)
bint.
Hajar
. op.
ul;; I 0--"
cit.,
loc.
,
cit.
. op.
cit..
fo. 69
cit.,
%&;
I C,'t'-j
b. Abdul WJalib
see Ibnlbdul..
(13)
But cf.
S137afills
But. cf.
.
Bar-r,
Ibn ?Igja
Slafill
(d.
statementg
9 02- ci
-svol-li
s evidence
du-JI JU -
pp. 61,62.
3 A. H.
al-Isti"&b
4,
Ck-V
"'. Uti,
t 02- cit-9101-4t
Cf.
440 - 44?.
(10) Cf-
(12)
g, see
'
(11)=za
69a
fo.
;
or.
eit.,
,
12
pp.
gvol.
r,
cit.
9 op.
Cf. -Shgfi"I
(d. 11 A. H.
Ra:;u'lllliih
9 op.
Cairo
biography,
For
his
0)
1960,
vol.
1, p. 36go'
P- 485.
cit.
vol.
. -9
1, p.
(y
237
`-
'
du
.*
44
(14)
I..
But cf.
Shifi'lls
statement
t op.
j
e-p"
ue;it
o-a
Ls
evidence
LA;, 4-41
,
(1
CA; q bjd\J%
Li
5, p. 290.
, op. cit.,
vol.
du
i
CU-
Litz
>-,I
-1
ceci-a
&
. ..
(P4
cjt kk^.
*c
(16) cr.
jj
""
236 ;
vol, ltp.
cit.,
b.
H=a
Ibn. 'AbdQlBarr
fo. 69b
3 A. H. ) For
(d-
al-Rihib
his
biography9see
cit-ovol-19P-381
OP9
(19) Ibid.
(20) Cf. Juwaird
. op. cit.,
loc.
cit.
9loo.
cit.
st".
(21)
Cf.
Shirazi
9 op.
cit.
4,
&
OP. citoovol.
op.
cit.
Ifo.
69
But cfo
.
SiCafig-its.
statements
19, p. 237 ;
1.0
UJI, ju
. -Y
J
(22)
But
cf.
Sb; Xills
6s
up)0-14v
(23) cr-. sliAii
evidence
9 op.
cit.
ploc.
cit.
L4
loceitorr-it-,
,
40
('t
..
45
-
70a
%J*9Z.
L"
Sh7afl'Ils
Jj
(25)
LA. O
d. $j
-01
CA""
ju_
Ukj&
-%j
L-Yl
statement
*"
op
70b
;
p
9"1
U &-r uO
op. cit.
29P-53gvol,
% ov-9
-V.,
4: -t4l
L;eOu
ee
.
But cf.
S64-fllls
L).. QUI
(-; eoj
ShiZfills
Lym!
t.
1.
-0
L&
19p.
238
;
ovol.
L4
U-1)
LAC
evidence
L$kAo
toR. -ci
otloc*
cit.;
.I-- -w
6%>.:. r
41
U-?
uk'C'
a. ".
Ap
Lso
6eoi,
>
e,,
o,
c&
L; oj
; ut
ZN
C)v
46
-
it
al-Zak;
Kitab
t vol.
% ,
Z6U
LSU
j
-10,
0\)%
-V
(::ol) lzj
:.
J;.
;
(
yz--..,
But
Slaftils
cf's
-
9 OP. cit-974
statement,
29 P. 41
ul
it;
k,
d)*
6,0
(2) Cf. SbIr7a27i
Lk
loc.
-cit.;
9
op. cit.
ju
&A, UA"p
A*u
"cit.,
fo,
op,
t
V,
-.
4k, 4. r.
SICafiTs'statement
But cf.
U
L-
C,
75 f Slfaifll
2p P-
vol.
t op. -cit.,
2t P-146 .
9 vol.
ul
(.,
Lv
And see Ilishind
-".
k Cy LJA-,
;
>.
t.
ok
cit.
9 op.
kio
:,,
Ll
CeW,
9vol.
29 P.
UJI
4u
-A
`cit.,
And see 119shiiJi
9 op.
OP.
it.
o vol.
29 p.
fo-U-But
Slafi'-Ils
statementg
10 ;
- i o-o to
Lj I.
cf.
ci.
.I...
J. )"al ot CA
V-,
61.1
1w
C6. .6f
L,!i I it;
u6
- 47 -
Cf*
Shlfills
evidence
. op.
cit,
G')'41
e-Av.
(7)
Cf.
lashimli
op.
O. J.
(13) cf.
shlraJ',
loc.
cit.,
LA
op-. cit.
-V
cit.
UU. ) '0
d-O'
up-
etaOf6 U-c,
cit,
9100,
-,
'c
0,
77b
pfo.
v-,
e:,y 91 Looav
..,
I".
But of.
W1
's statement
Shafi!
91
)
>-i
1>9-;
t.
Cf.
Sh-afills
evidence
loc.
cit.,
66t!
-lis,
(10)
Cf.
SlAr7aii
9 op.
cit.
gloco
cit*
(11)
Cf.
Hashimi
9 op.
cit.
sloc.
cit.
But
cf.
SlCafi'lls
statement
cit.
JL; cis
\4
oR. cit.,
vol. - 2, p.
I1".
C-Aast-A
j
->;
6
V,;
)
%iu
-!
2. p, 16;
-6
U1.0 -5,6 L;
Jd
op.
9vol,
l
S-;
*Lll tl
9
X.V (.
(9)
op. cit.
13
:VUJI jk;
41
Q6
(12)
Cf.
HishiTd
op.
cit.,
10c.
cit.
zu>
But cf.
o-
4j
Slafi4'116
statement
01,
C.Ax.
.
9 op.
cit*ovol,
2, p, -18
C.S>G jjdl
\12$1
48
-
OP-- cit-',
Shlrizlo
o
o OP--cit-91OC-cit
4#
06
And see 119shirA
op. cit.
(
)
Bpno.
See
l.
3,
11.
Pappendix p.
vol-,
z'
ff.
cit.,
op.
OP-cit-ofo-77b;
77
78
Sb7afi . l's
But
cf.
.
statement,
2.
9vol.
A
CA
VA
k4.
wI
LAC,
(16)
But cf.
Sh7aft"i's
evidence,
o)2.
gloo.
-cit.
cit,
63
This hadlith
(17)
The full
is also part
text
can be traced
hadith
this
Cf - sl liraili
And-see
fo.
, op. cit.,
Wishind
op.
statement
,i
SICafi
Maja
9 op.
cit.
Shlirazli
op. cit.
op. cit.
(it 6--.0
80
ofo.
But
Slafills
cf.
2. p. 22
svol.
had
79b
ofo.
cit.
Shafil
evidence
*I _A
C.0; Ul
op.
cit,
gloc,
06.6
1, p. 210 that
cit, vol.
t'op.
statement,
had said
'Cit,
,
OP
Muzani's
But cf.
JN9-Ahll
Cf.
Ibn
78b ;.
cit.
vol.
(20)
in
It P. 578.
vol(18)
of
statement,
W-) 3k;
;
W)
AA I
&
j,
.,
A:
%j 4)
'.
sij.
9, wt
1-1!ul
dzo
C-Ael
kxw
d-,
, &.; I
L. -
lb-s.
ts
is
49
(22)
But of.
Shafells
4,
evidence
9 op.
cit.
gloo.
cit.
J.
Jo
or-
04P o-ll
Uko
(23)
Cf.
Hishind
cit.
. op.
ploo.
cit.
6,
176.
vol.
p.
.,
op.
ofo.
-cit.
82 ;
op.
cit,,
,
(31,>,Wl
twl
Lp
fo,
81 . Bu cf.
Sblfills
statemento
2,
21
P.
tvol.
kA
OU
loo.
op.
cit.
,
6it.;
6-
--! 3
4. A"
fo-79a
op. cit.,
okjcull
vi -Ij
oj
And see Ibn Farh
. op. cit.,
(28)
Cf.
Ibn
Farh
, op.
cit.
fo-
153b.
cit.
Iloo.
44
CXS
1-7ul
IAILIA!
(b
(29)
(d, 18 A. H.
_
.
lo, pp. 186 - 188.
Muclidh, b. - Jabal
op. cit.,
vol.
02--cit-,, volfo.
. o]2. cit.,
ibn ajart
see
p
It P- 580-
80a
dio
And see H;;shim-i,
OP* cit.,
vol.
cit-ofo-
op.
2, p,
84
But
-
26
'!'1
A-U
cf.
Slia-fi6l's
statement,
50
(32) Cf. Hindi
, o]2. cit., vol.
(33) Cf. Sb7afi'lls
evidence,
J9
."
6, p. 175.
op, cit,
j % C)3-
'P
-,;
9vol.
2. p, 25
LiA
G--A
Cj
\"-*
-')
U-'j
4- 0U
dvo Li ; G-;
Cl
i's
&
Sha-fi
But cf.
106)
statement,
2, p. 29
vol.,
6
C-4:
See above page 49
no.
44f"
LN
dij,
29.
T
hadith.
0
op. cit.,
evidence,
loc.
op. cit.,
cit.;
jo
; j; 5h
OU
4.
op.
cit.
cit.
gloo.
op.
-cit.
OP* cit-9vol-
:;
.0...
a
v
82
tfo.
ju A:o t5
41 L;pt)' Li
.;
And see Shirazi,
CA
op. cit.,
fo,
Bla
statement,
3, p. 240
V-t: Al
u
; jljl
51
(41) Cf. SldFaA
, o]2. cit.
tfo.
"
L& zt,
1.4
-
(42)
cit.
81b ;
loc.
#
cit-,
jv.(
fo-83
But
cit.
--
'6lVtWj
,
UW
-9
cit.,
, op.
fo.
84 . But
cf.
Shafi'T's
had-ith
found this
not
-have
available
Ikil
statement,
29 Po 35
oPo citotvolo
(44) 1
II:,.
82b
I'-I
And see Egshimi
statementt
40. )
.0.11
vfo.
ShEafills
cf.
hadith
is
in the collection
J,. ,
Q'ij-PI
OU
O-e
C-Ae
'k w,
al 641
OL4
L,
-.. Gvj
See Tinnidhi
kA
"ou
)"
299
30.
't
3
pp.
ovol-
9 02- cit-
) OL-mi
"-N,
W 43W- jl;
SK-*. 4
c>C
,.%
VJ1
LAO
LAh
k:10
(46) CLHEshiad
loc. cit,;
cit.
op.
.,
U
J#
\j
Oki,
J-
:
C's
0::
...
di.
&
dl
j
LA
'ue
ZY
>Al
C-A4
A-il
I>e.-
And cf,
I
SkIrazi
op.
9
cit.
cite
gloce
83a
cyj
But cf.
Sli7afi'*Ils
statement
op. cit.,
CJI&
U. &j
"6
1,
lo
vol.
Iz
2, P- 43 1
I
LIAl
Ju -9
52
-
. o12. cit.,
6, P- 156.
.
vole
al
t v
u,\1
CiA.
(51) cf-
shlraZI
Ioc-
9 OP- cit.,
4.11
cit-
,61
137abZak3t
(1)
Cf.
Sjj'r7ai I
op.
cit.,
lj
, -
fo.
"-,
- -s-,
'7
And see Hishi m1p
OP- cit-,
op. cit.,
But
cf.
fo-87
Imt
cf-
evidence,
op.
loc.
cit.,
VL'O
L4
op. cit.,
fo.
Ly
cit.
dxu...
ut
statement,
LAXeL--- LAC,
Slaifi'lls
Cf. Sldrazli
Straft4l's
29 P-55
vol.
o' Lj-'tUl
(2)
al-Fitr
-;
VLP
cit.
86a ;
loc.
cit.
But
cf.
.
Sh7afi'lls
Ult
st4tement,
53
(5) See text page 46
.0
(6) Cf. Shl: &'zli , op. cit.,
fo.
86b
I
-K:
', fo. 88
op.
cit.
Cf.
Cit.
910C. cite
SldriJ
p op.
-ajI
ut &-j
1.9
And see Hgshimli,
op.
cit.,
(8)
Cf.
D-artlquln-i
9 op. -'cit.,
(9)
Cf.
ShIlAzI
op.
6.
(10)
-V1. ** --
cit-ifo.
'I ju
op. cit.,
Yol.
loc.
cit.
29 p.
150-
87a
Okz"-)
- -V
a-At-,
loc*
Q'U'95
LAC
cit.
CjU,
d-o"
54
-
Xifaibal-$iyam
(2)
Cf.
Zamakhshail
Cf.
SlrbTaA
4P
cit.
op.
So.
cit.,
kz -'-e
v
2, p.
vol.
\1 1,6
a..
P
LASI
(See appendix
)
89
2.
no.
p.
90a
oR.
cit.
9fo.
q
Aj :
, JU-P
k.
2581;
p.
gvol.
NJ -V .
6')% C-1
fo.
cit.,
91
But cf.
Slrafills
statementg
81
'
v
A.
C' GL
LAa
O%
(AL6
_44
LAC.
(3)
Cf-
Muslim,
vol-
8,
OP- Cit-tvol-
Sh7afi'l's
Lo I &r I CY
(5) Cf. Zamakhsharl,
,
(6)
Cf.
ut
op. cit,
I
OP
ci
I
Shlraili
loc.
'Cit.,
o2.
gvol. -l,
4
p. 263p 2t 517.
S6lyp
fo.
OP-cit-ovol-49
90b ;t
N
CA,-V
And see 119shimig
fo. 92
cit.,
op.
p. 196,
108.
vOl -39P,
9 op. -cit.,
cit.
LA.
(7) Cf Tirmidlil
(8)
Hind7i#
796
P.
411.
PO
2,
But
cf.
ShRfilils
statementg
vol. 2, p. 82
OP.
Aa
N JU cj
6.4-:
0 &o\
(A
o',
'
--k,
Cf. ShRfit'lls
(10)
614>
-
evidenceg
t; j 1 'k
e--,
OP. cit-9100.
Cf.
Bukh7wl,
Cf-
op.
cit.,
volol,
c
And see IlEshimlis op. cit-ofo.
.rL.
u! j; 4.6
-J-
1
cit.
(See no. 4
-Aj
)
above.
po 2.
jo I ju-! ) i &. e
94 - But cf.
-&,a,
ShRfelils
statements
55
-
vol. 20 p. 85
OP* cit.,
A
>0_'>
A: em:
v'A
U-Ul
U"
w'
r
'J_
\J-9 &k. -
b-;
-,
L
(12)
Cf.
Sh7afi"i's
evidence,
op*
cit.,
ckt.
ktt)
"
L;:
-.
jA'_q
L41
II
-AV-"
(UP)
e-..
6`0
0_3
ct-11
-1-i
Z%Jl"
Li -J,
6.
\
I
'!
>
dAvl
ml)o
-,
_".,
the
But
71
adlth
"'.
CJL-
o;;
4OG
LA-P
dJul
"L
collection
as_below
exis-ts in
;
do
iv
1,
84;
9'p
2s P-
vol.
J6
"L. ok--q
"Id, %;
JA% u1c. C
N
1w
-1
-V
'o'
It
U-911410k;
O-Z
130--..)
Of
-10
oool
Lo
(See Muslim,
(14)cf.
Shirazit
But cf.
Op. cit.
2g PP-7819 782.)
lvol.
op. cit.,, fo. glb
Slia-fills
statementg
op. cit.
. 11,)U
jb: >I""
.:.
2p
P-85 ;
gvol.
LAC
.jC.;
:,
(d)LOI
Cf.
on the'adlth.
Shri-all,
V9
L,
>
u:
lo
c,
op.
cit.,
%Ie-We
9 op. cit.,
vol.
2, p. 84
cit.
6
l
llo
4;
e-Vk,, -0
t
N UU...
ak.:.
Al
dal
&b
jo
2. p.
Volo
But of.
tfo-93
SfZfii'S
s*atementq
80
Ab UU
J
ajAP
-Aul-V:
ju
J'
(18)
Cf.
Cy:xb
Sli&fills
IJ Ab
evidence,
-t-sI uc
CA-b-v
eLs
t,
Y- -AM
(19) Cf.
c-A c Y-
i
L,
H9shim-i,
J-VLb
OL:,
cit.
ok. 74
e.
cit.
ce
loc.
0-ml
LtA
>JA-
>; s
ios4jut
jv-j,%
Aj?
(it;
97
9 OP. Cit-9fo.
But cf-
Sh7aficrls
statementg
vol,
j.,
LAS.
-cit.,
loc.
C)kir,
*op.
-t'i
LA&
cit.,
op.
doxp
SlGafills
3A;
dk
evidenceg
op. citooloc.
cit.
3k;
JW
LL
032- cit.
jvol.
z)%ztv-jix!, p
cit.,
29 P. 452.
vol.
91a
;
ofo-
op. cit.,
29 -pp. 84
85
9
G--
Sh&fills
statement,
63,,
t
e l--ejJir
zjj
--u
-%i
L16. o. *
ay-
0#
57
-
Slafi'lls
evidence,
op. cit.,
vol.
2. p. 85 ;
jj
.t,...
c:.u -. - ("zaui
-*
a44
.0,1
u(
0 p). .c;\j 6--,
au
11
A.
_J.
k4:'
t>->! cS4JUP11
_0
cl. c>t;
(26) Cf. Slir-azi-,
G
)
L3%;
-.,
A, $31
416.
P-
ovol.
2, p.
cit.
95 - But cf.
tfo.
88
t; tjj
evidence,
op. cit.
ULp,
>
9loce cit.
i.
'v4
ik;
6!; A6 Q %,S-jUf -Al
k.pjj
Cf. -H; 7shiaE,
statementt
"'
%l
L),
1,l
1:>49p--40%
(28)
Slaft'"I's
op.
cit., fo. 96
CL
Al
op. cit. ifo. 92a.;
Li
jol
cit.,
fo. 96.
39 P. GO.
cit.
o]2. cit.
#loc.
*. 'I Z)kzp-u 4y
ou-I
58
-
95a
op. cit-ofok;,
JU
(I..
VA; \j
(33)
A':
_-b
2,, p.
vvol.
cit.
:
i's
Slia-fiila
statemento
_ox
uq
Cf-D9'374qutnLop-
pfo.
But
cf.
.
42:;
L)t
2, P. 88
9vol.
U'C
99
);
op. cit.
evidence,
177-
ploc.
cit.
; L:taCyI
CA-C
1:Jl'ju
%,>I
U. Z:
".
a
I
o ...
(35) Cf. Slilrazli, op. cit., fo. 95b
ouv
...
(36)- cf.
slliia-Jiv
statement, OP.
fo. 94b
OP-' cit.,
-cit.,
-eit-,
or.
(38)
98
99
fo.
eit.,
op. cit.
ff,
Vol. 79 p. 263
zso
And Ibn Farh,
ta;
99 ;
e
9fo.
.-See-above P-5.69i-n6,22i
:>-t L;-1
171a
cl;a;
ap
c;..:o
- 59 -
Bab al-Iti.
op. cit.
cit.
op.
tfo.
JG
96a
cit.,
cf.
Slaflils
statement,
29 P-93
9vol.
ji
e-.,p
(2) Cf. Abil DZwGds
op. cit.
vol.
op . cit.,
lt
P. 575.
tv
Ca;
...
-V6
v ob1 A. 0j
;k
CkAlls
pi
cit.,
vol.
OA-'
.>-,.
Jl
''b
2,, pp.
90 9 91
bljl
cjm-6
cy
V%
...
6tz;
%J-l
'-e-\Jl
...
(yo
LA
-bumcappears in the
-*j
tL6.
PJ>
; dL;
"-j"
below
;
as
collection
statemento
Cil
Lx-w
cjk5
Ioc. cit*
vol.
op. cit.,
Sh7afi'-IIs
bJ\)
>d'
op.
statement,
<'
'-
'
loc.
j
-cit.
Ci
-'I
F.
cit.
)
g,
l,
p. no.
6o
-
(8)
Cf.
Muzanlls
evidence,
op.
20 PP. 35-37.
citst3rol.
IA
6-9, >
od
06. Cy-t: 3 p
(9)
I.
Cf Shdfi-fls
statement,
op.
cit.,
vol.
CL..
(10) Cf.
Abu- Dgwild,
op. cit.
(-
2. p.
I..
2p P-346.
ovol.
93
J.;
dJ
61
-
Ki-CFtb al-Hal
a
(1)
Cf.
Ibn
Fa*t
op.
fo,
cjt.,
C?
176a
;
OkA
u
%,
',
0%-4
x>I,
u-,
'i,
(C.
'21
eit.,
op.
2, p.
vol.
-cit.,
k. Z>
CA a
fo. 101
But cf.
.
tiol
J;
SlZfells
statementg
105
zit
q
-%-. -e c:e-9 ... L
4
Gtpekee%
.', _.,
_)
3,3
v
..
Cfe FSshiurit
Joc.
oj2. cit.,
cit.
(5) qurlin
L>j
Cf-
Slj3:;
op.
cf,
cit.
cit.
gloc.
ce
keu;
V.,
-i'-ji t( toU-I -i-,-L. e-0Zl,
oR.
V.0
But
39 . 65-
SldlrgAp
cf.
4EQ
loc.
cit.,
cit.
tc i-J!
jv-. 4 as UZ),
--)I
...
Sh7aft"Is
I
op. cit.
statemento
910c,
cit,
JJ
j
evidence,,
op. cit-9foI
_,
&,,.. -):
,
.11
1
C, m
0%,
op. cit-9
loc.
'
cit.
_9
97b
40
_q
4C.
Ou
CO
.1
J%f
62
-
(10)
Cf-
Cf.
259
Zamakhsharl
9
Shlr7azl,
op.
cit.
cit.,
118b ;-
tfo.
Plf
JU-9 & e,
;L
But cf. Sb7aft'lls
i
, op.
2, p. 230
-
vol.
(11)
2, p.
2, p.
#vol.
loo
Zi
25
6
%,.
,
6
-
- ( L)o)C;-3%
Z.
)c-
cf-
**ol
A
-,.,
uit
du
L;,
4%
,. aj
>9% N
zem
%J
(12) Us Ilislim,
22. cit.,
vol.
29 P. 977.
loc.
cit.
jj
Cf.. Shirazi,
98b
op.
2, p.
9 vol.
loc.
cit.,
cit.
But cf.
Shrift
i's
statement,
98
I
ali
eu,
-Ae.
Iw ev',94 UtzO-ml
CY GOOJ "-I'
Shifills
evidence
9 op. cit*q
10cs cite
;
do
I m,
-)o
1-0
-pig
U-,
ey. I.
P
c
C Lei
d-'-
c--i
'Lul
Q-.
*4-,
04,. W
y1-9
cu.j ;j , C,\,001
63
(16)
Cf.
Egshimlip
op-.
fo.
-oit.,
102 ;
UA;- &(puil
And see Ibn Farh
op.
cit.
t op.
2, p.
9 vol.
C)p
-J.
L)L;
176 . But cf.
cit-,
43 that
Sh7afi'-i
Muzairils
had'said
jo
statement,
;
"'
"
J,
t. cis U!j
C'
(17)
But cf.
Up)
Sh7afllils
pv
t'-
evidence,
"'t ju
C.'L
'U-t-
op.
cit.,
:
(Ll
2p p.
vol.
,O'IOU
105
Utz
dLA% ot? -j
4%
Cj-'A;Cyctjzo d 0-;
cup.) Q"j I
A;
ZY'SaY-11oc
aA'O:
%-:c C-P % vi U;
q -1,41
U.
'.
0-
- 44-0-)l -,A US
T
And see Muza6iq
OP. cit.,
op. cit.,
'
CA tj
A'
%4
Ly-
cy 1 Z-4-
'. ol;
cit.
(jot
V..
cir"
pl
Ul
U-MUP
eA-. J% A--Ir.
,,
2p P- 44-
vol.
joc.
40
6
-fit
va.
40
k.,
'ju;
op. cit.,
loc,
cit,
Dawu-dlop. cit.
(21)
Far
Cf.
Ibn
9 op.
cit.,,
9vol.
fo.
of this
It
person.
P. 421.
177b ;
1, ujt4
6i cjjrG-Cou-;.
But cf.
Shgfi , i's
statements
op. cit.
.1u
Ce LACceo01
L,d; e;,, )
61(22)
Dat
cf.
Shafills
ovol.
2, p, 101 ;
evidence
op.
-A
'I Ojs
j
-J-Ut
..
cit.,
loc.
cit.
JI;
CC,
64
-
o2. cit,
(See
261.
p.
appendix pp. 10olltno.
It
tvols
100b
tfo.
Sh7afells
statementl
2, p. 113 ;I
u%
u-exi
aj%
.b6
op.
Ioc.
cit.,
2, p. 995 9
vol.
cit.
op. cit.,
evidence,
loc.
cit.
CL
ul
Zamakhshari,
(28)
Cf.
oR. cit.
Shirazli,
cit.
eit.,
pvol.
vol.
gfo.
op. cit.,
p. 26.5.
it
101a
fo.
state'mentg
2, p. 173
1c:
Sh7afe its
9
>
51, P. 83-
7*
P-17P
no.
above
-see
Lt svol- 3t P- 183.
_jQ;
(32a)But cf.. Sb7afit'i's evidencet op. cit., loc.
.0.
.P
IA-"-Jko
(32b)Cf.
ShTiazig
s.
6C...
"I
bp. cit.,
A.
U.wl Ul
cit.
j
41Y
6,)OJ
fo. 101b
Oj
Ov
o, l
4>>
uj
t .0) jl;..
lou
'Jt4fov 6
L-u
&-a:- ,.>;
4 Ljkz
1s)
65
(33) 1 have not found this
had7ith..
J.4
SlTafills
d-,
C-0
;
Zll
CA e
jr.
'o
**
(36)
-%->
ds-,
Li
Cf.
Zamakhshari,
op.
-cit.
j0u-P-1.7 4LU.. 21 -k
b AJ..
%e
S--J
\.
Lj%
L L91-: L)G.l
w6
!A
a6k; -
-,,
cit.
tloc.
-V.
2,
123
p.
tvol.
Lit,
jj
CJ"
"
But cf.
)
2.
11,
p.
no.
But of.
loc.
cit.
loc, cit
op. cit.,
'1 ou
--'3
SlTafills
qR. cite,
statement,
11
A.; L44J
)
119
p.
no-3.
2. p.
183
ju
-,
jl
(See appendix*
-sj.
Cf-
Zamakhshai-iq
Rit
of.
op.
Shafi'lls
cit.,
loc.,
statemento
cit.
op.
cit.,
d'i,-"
Cy" t?:.jU-'6j
(See appendix
vol.
2,
.f
L$ 0
p.
p.
11. no. 1. )
162 ;
Al I
%I 01;. jQ
(3 ; Sjl
tjk;
OLAI,
(let
'
(j rk, J I.
al
,
Lou- UP, 6-14 CA,
(.P)
co (Y
6't.
Q
C)%
CY
6
1
JN.
4
%.
0'.,
>
LSU
C-114j%
lt.
(Jly
-Al: -0.1 ..
-A
Lei
0--l I
LA. s
Y-vp
Jl
66
(46a) Cf. Hunain, al-T Egyptian
tional
Na.
qrEj2aq-MS
'JI
(46b)Cf,
Tahawli,
Sharb Meai
N,
%4.
; q?U%I
Ij I
CCA-J%
..
Dellti
13489 vol-lt
P-429.
(See
1,
263vol.
p.
appendix,
oR. cit.,
-**.
loc. cit
ov;
"J
Shlrzl"p
.i
op. cit.
tfo-104a
,4
4.0
op. cit
't
aljt1rar,
Lib=ryg
op.
cit.
Zt3l Z
I?
!
A-P
;
4"
;%
I
-q
-;,
Slrafills
v--y>-
I
tfo-103
But efe
-
2, p. 132 ;.
vol.
all
statement,
9
us
6-.
'I
A.,
ukc
'-*-A
Ij
C'>jo
Slia-filils
*J
(--s% C>-Sj
(I-*-. v
(50) Cf-
' op.
Sldx7ai,
cit.,
-V
S%
jj
'6tV:,
'sk;
cit.
al.
OP. cit-9fo-105b
"Pj
.
But
cf.
Shafi'Jlls
statement,
o2.
i. "j
':
cit.
29 pp.
9vol.
1279
;jU.
U*"l C)
172
it
.. -4
LA
(52) Cf.
Sldia-2710
106a
op. cit.,
'
-Q
4;
;
&010-V-1)
U-1
t
L4
>
iJ
0-Ic
-&
. "-: Oz
-'
And see Hishi71, op. cit.,
op,
cit.
2, p.
vol.
172
fo.
%-Jjzk.,v
ShZfi'lls
c*i4?
(53) gAbdull7ah b.
ajar,
op.
r-'
cUmar
vol-
clt-
But cf.
J. ,
-Z%
ShZafiils
4". e-
Jj
iL)
IIU
JA
...
cY
(d. 73 A, H, ).
-
JV
&,% Lk-A.,V
'C..
'---'
statementp
soe Ibn
59 P- 328 - 330vol.
evidenceg
29 P. 835op.
cit.
gloo.
'cit.
'
.I...
So.
67
-
;
u-j
3v;
cit.,
vol.
loo4cit..
op. cit.,
2,1.31
L;e,.
;,tc,ctt:oj
.4
ql
LWJ
But of.
Slaifi"Ils
:>"
statementv
(i-OUJI dl;
(56) But cf.
Sh7afif"Ils
op.
evidence,
cit.
lloc,.
_cit,
"J
S 01.1
tit;
(q)
CfOll;. .ia")
kt. op-ov
2p* citooloco
I.,. C::
-
rvl
7
SZirziq
And see
Cito
op.
100*
cit.,
Cit.
fo. 106b
CjLJ
9,
Shafi
Bu.t cf.
I. -
i's
statement,
P. 70.4'*u
w>'
ezi'l -'%
..
129
J,
%-A
j
lb --,-&A:ka
..
v4
oa;I oj
29 p.
vol.
cit.,
op.
107a,
*
;
OP.
eit.
9
#fO*
J%;
-..!.
But
.0
cf.
It.
Slia-fills
tl;
op,
statementp
C>
cit.
C,::
40
*A!
q vol.
%'
) 1"
0.
al;
-*,
2, P- 184 ;
i IL!
jt al;
gut -Z,
...
-o
V 4:.j
-z
16
And see Hishim7i,
032. cit.
loc.
cit.
op.
cit.,
fo.
116.
But
of.
1C41
Sh7afilils.
+#%
.
statement,
jodk
C4'.V4
SG
6a
-
(64)
Cf.
SilrEzi,
op.
10c.
Cit.,
Cit.
fo. 98b ;
&I
oAgj
And see 19shind, op. cit-, fo. 114. But cf* Shlfi'61's
OP. cit.,
2. p.
vol.
statement,
94 ;
(3t,cA s, -,k.9
Ooa
%
0:
LO
'-e
OLo cy
w,;j
Y:>3%
civ-9 v-ac
tf wv' kv. C.
)
\O
zp--J%
cit.
lvol.
(See
483.
19
Pop. Cit., VOI.
appendix
op. cite# locecit
op.
2, p.
fo,
cit.,
Ila
Shirazi, r
But
cf.
,
p. 12, no
OP-cit-tfo-114a
Slafilils
statementt
160
6
0-1
Ul
!,O\;
111
41 U"
(jov
A,
ji %31;
O-j
(69) Qur "in 5-95.
(70) But cf. Sh7afills evidenceg op.
'Ji
Via, ou
"\:
4\,
ev'si,
(71)
Cf.
Zamakhsha3; i-,
op.
2.
170
p.
-cit. ovol.
ju
eeil
op.
cit.
9100,
cit. 9foo
ou
LiJUJI
01
cit
115b
120
But cf.
Muzan-i'8 statement,
6. )
69
-
op. cit.
29 p. lilt
jvol.
ShUigl
that
had said
0.1
',
(
e6
-9
115b ;
top
And see HgshirJ,
or.
eit.,
op.
Iooo
cit.,
But cf.
.
cit.
Slafills
statementp
vol. 2, p. 175 ;
0
(75) But cf- SlGafills
20
ul
'LAI
"' J-;#!uuzi
bI,b -I-.
el & d.,;u YL,,
-,
4-I
LAr.
loo,
Cf - Zamakhshar-i
cite
9 vol.
loc. cAt.
OP- Cit-,
012 "06
-cit.,
vol.
or.
cit.
OP-cit-tfo.
jj
JJ.I
Shafl!
pfo.
Is statements
2, P. 140 ;
1 6.1 Ly--v .I
Lis
cy.
(79) But Cf. Sh9fi'cl's
Ce-Al-
I j ?4
,
4>1
6\
ZI
V!
I
j;
Vol. 2, P. 139
.
I
U
1
4-M
4.
-Q
!j1;
vI
'.
OU
21
\;;
"A
eQ
011
&I ';'fj5
'z". 0 Z.; 'y- cAr.
--v
(80)
Cf.
Shlrgzl,
op.
cit.,
loc.
cit.
00
4; I
C"I
117a
. ..
70
-
Ki-Cab al-Buy7if'
cf.
shlia-zliq
fo. 1271-Y
o]2. cit.
ou,
:p
(I D-b
-
(2)
Cf. Dluralii'
vol.
OP.
-p
-cit.
Cf, Sh7iiazi,
DU- ei't-910c-
*,
ov
Muzani's
had said
ci't-
;.;.
e
wi>.
0"
J-93,
zc
>.
%
A.
.-.
JI
But cf.
29 P-. 97-
u-
4a-
fo-
130b
Zt4
vvol.
2, p. 134 that
Luu
Cf.
SbIri2lo
OP-- cit-*.
loc.
(6)
Cf.
Egshiml,
op.
fo.
cit.,
> Y.C-U:
...
>
-j
126
"I
1J.
-O
C.4
Lis
statementg
iw
op. cit-ovol-
it;. ::I
611,
39 PP- 34 s 35
CJj
_Jc
Wl
U16,
Zm
'o]2.
Cf. ' lli'shimalg
cit.
(8)
Cf.
Ibn
Farht
op.
.4.P-110
cit.
II vjp I
>
&-A:
_A
_
Shafi'lls
Sh!afli
'r
(5)
But cf.
ti 4
16444.
oR. cit.
statement,
--b
V4-! Jl
(-. I do'l
:L-r
LA
0,.
3p P- 33
ploco cit*
citooffe
197a p 197b I
44f
.0-9
(f.
e
tea,
71
-
But of.
Shgfi'lls
statement,
op.
cit.,
J,
-k
(up)
Wi7st (d.
(9) Va'b-anb.
op. cit.
cf-
(11)
33ut cf,
zu".) &-%I
I CAW
_01
(10)
3p P. 59 ;
vol.
9vol.
?
ce
(L.
Oj
? '. l OL:
Jvl
Ok -t
For his biographyg see Ibn Hajar,
10'JI
?
suYUM19 OP-cit-9vol-7t
Shafi4T's
t_
p. 252.
evidencet
op.
cit.
L.L; -4%
cit.
floc.
dJ:;
the traditiorA
traditionpbut
t-.
jrV
131a
appears in the A,
", (L)p)
-o Li
1% OLs,
.
0%;
PI
-!
. L,
But cf.
Slaft'lls
statement,
3t' P- 13 ;
op. cit-9vol-
L4
(14)
But
Sh9fil'i's
cf.
J.
,0V4
up.) a-uI
evidencet
I >...
CiI C:4 Wj I Cy.BAx Cre--- C-ekoj
G4\
L9
'&
3v PP- 12
13
9
vol-
OP. cit-t
tt
(A3%
_J
_)Ji'
I
jiv
51
k:
(;,.
c>%
'
-f
_)
Cf.
Muhammad al-Shaiban-iial-Asl
d,
But
I
the hadith
appears
in
Cairo.
,
the, collection
a; a;o. L diz
": >31,46JU(QP) vWI of- C,Lg)%Cy &A& 6F
4I?
-- ZJ 5(d! -t A- P.
Ij - dte. AVLg &Oz!W.,4u.
d!
--ri
-31 '0
,.
(See Ti=midhTpop.
cit. vvol-39P-5419
72
-
(18)
Z,-&
See above
fo- 131b ;
op. cit.,
P-12,
(19) Cf-Shlrazli,
; 41 (A
LfA. ) .. -W
no. 28.
OP-cit-,
fo-132a
-9
But cf.
(20)
See text
Shafi
i's
40
statementl
OP-cit-,
vol-3p
A."
P-13
P- 77.
132a
OP- cit-ifoju
-2
V-9
tAle
ewl
But cf.
Muzanirls statementl
Cit-tvol.
29 P-140 that
vol.
op.
cit.
fo. 128
But
.
had said;
Sh-afills
cf.
statement,
7, P- 326
160
ul
_jl
J%;
JLZ
av
ur
av
.e
Lu
LO ;l'u
4 CO
I
I
'Iy
-.
V-.
ju
3, P-71
Lf
L--O.
!;vIjk; L.u_;
I
*i
Ivil
ju
fo. 134a
%J-
I
1
Y.
>,;
g
-. -v,. ''4
22---cit-,
Sliaftl
op. cit.,
gfo.
130
But cf.
Slaftlls
statement,
73
-
in the collection
exists
as below ;
ce)
cit..
2. p. 224. )
Slafilils
cito,
;
4)
61
(26) Cf. Shliai,
loc.
op. cit.,
S00
CAP
'31;
cit.
Aj
t-Y &
-e
j%;-S C
-tit
C;A
ovol-
129
But
cf.
vfo.
.
Sh-afills
statementg
3t P. 16 ;
6
%j
lk::
0141%
(28) But cf.
133b
&I ty-tte
ShEfi-Ila
LAC ci ll
evidence,
oD. cit.,
Q" Le V, IO.
J..;
4(
NO--O j4
11
&L-J.
vol.
Q6
tit;
39 P- 15.;
U"itou
*Q-j
Cyr- Lo Uj
qk
*jat
j
Lo
op.
cite
citeploc*
L)eo--- "gj
(30) Cf- sqrgz-io
But cf.
4
C.
OP- cit-ifo-
138b
8.
Sb7afi F's statementv
"
k-
vo..
Ok
OR- cit-P
VOL 39 p. 60
Jl-
Q
LP
I UJIdu
74
-
(31) But-cf.
al
Xz:
S,,
\moj
3W%
e
c31
6V,
s"I
Shaft"I's
d.j:
loc.
evidencep
op. cit.,
Q3L Ut-
At
43
wI
6'
kpe:WA.V -10P
1
---
aoat
,,
L. Lo:O W)
6VW)
cit.
;,
3v
OL.
- L) cj
-9Lb
op. cit.
(4
...
cit.
tl'oe.
'
('I
cLM'U
1"
ti
y
(34) Cf.
Shlira-zl,
06 ^3 A> '-J
.
loc. cit.;
op. cit.,
clo
(35)
Zamakhsharl,
Cf.
Utz.
cit.,
op.
2,
vol.
6o le.;
lk; 9 C..:9
p. '211.
(See
vj
p.
appendix
13p no.
.f
'to
l
I
&M,
(
op. cit.
statement,
9 vol-
5p P- 38
L9
(37) Qur'an 16.75', ' 76.
(38) But cf-
Sla-fi-ils
o]2. cit.
evidenceg
PlOc- cit-
.t%4
di
(39) Cf- SIJ:a-zit or- eit-Ploe&i,
eilt-
.i
op. cit-tfo.
'0
143b
Jul
And see HEshimip
ON
cit*qvol.
op.
cit.,
ZPFP-j9%jqzthat
fo.
134.
Shlfil
c
:w-j, ---
But
cf-
Muzarri's
had said
statement,
8. )
75
-
Muzard's
SbZfi'l
(42)
Cf.
statementq
had based
H98hirA,
op.
u.
Shei
kluzan7i"s
this
op.
cit.,
cit-9fo1L
135
fo.
143b
cit.,
op. cit.,
fo.
vol.
2,
following
p.
193 that
evidence
135
statementp
op.
vol. 2, p,
cit.,
203
i had said
CAUL-; kqto:
g; %jt
that
Ut>
..
b4'
(45) cf, Juwainli, op. cit-9fo.
But cf.
J;
Shgfi"lls
'-
''t"-
I_3$'
...
t: j"
140b
39 P. 78
op. cit-tvol.
statementt
jt;
no. 12.
(47) Wt ch
evidence 9,"cit.,
SANI's
%
loot cit.
d'
(JI
(48) Cf-
Juwairili,
op.
cit.
oloc.
Al
Cit.
dl
3I
'Oii
op. cit-9vol.
0
t>.
>
il>zj
t>
.,
Sh7afel's
4, P. 168 ;
%>c V A%aUi t
,
GA,
,
du
1:)q utz
4..v
(t
76 -
I-
Shafi"I's
evidence,
loc.
oR. cit.,
cit.
ul
9.1
&'5
v
C'xo
(Y
ou
<x
G'j
I O-L.
* brjq
:
X;
U&
0'x1%'p '6>b
j;
op.
cit.
fo., 144b ;
I.
0 :
(53)
Cf-
OP. Cit.
see 11;shimi,
(54)
Cf.
k
c,ito
gloce
(_)cCup.)
C.
And
statementg
%J Gl
dive
%:
>I-.t
?
'11,9
ML)l %3
"V,
Sla
4Shafi i's
3, P. 9
vol.
aaj cy%
fo.
02- cit-i
cit.
tloc.
cit.,
Shlia'Ii,
fo..
cp .0uA;..
But cf.
Muzan7i's statementg
Sh7afil
had said
OP. cit.
100,
cit,
140
2-9'po' 239-
vol.
LO
N6
-** C
CA
64c
1
(.Y-
ch
OP- bil.,
Al
105
vj,
>:x CPA.
'.
op. cit.
204'that
p.
-29
tvol.
;
low
ow
11
6;
<..A;.J,
77
-
13ut cf.
Shafi'lls
statementq
22-
cit-,
3, p,
vol-
209
Ct
6Ls' U-O I Ow
%:.
Z>
B., L31
OJ Oj
(58)
Cf-
But
cf.
no-
57
ShUi"T's
op.
loc.
cit.
fo.
162b
statementp
op.
loc.
-cit.,
cit.
loc.
9
Cfi
Sarazli,
ow
cit.
fo.
cit.
uz.
_SllrJt
-op-cit.,
1 41
:
I
U10
cf__4_9
14
's,
bO.
to..
fo. 162b. ;I
t-P-Ap
-'s
--*
op. cit-9fo.
Vj
162a
0
Z- -: ou-54U-.,A, -. 4-,
(62) Cf.
(See above
cit.
(61)
A'OU
k; U.
uV
144b
41 g
(64)
-Cf.
loo. cit.
iI
40
N
_A
L16
OV-1
cc
fo.
129
4j%
61-s
X.
s-j
.6
aj.
>
78
-
Sh7afi'lls
But cf.
statementp
02- cit-9
31 pp. 62 t 63 ;
vol-
.iiL'.
63
3t**p.
ovol.
U:>Ik; ...
cy
owl
"u
LI
tp
-o J"A
Bab al-Salam
(1)
Cf.
But cf.
Is statement,
Shifi!
39 P- 83 ;4
fL-jl
Q0 J,
0..
16
oP. cit-9vol-
oal
#.;.:
cit.,
zu-0i
4t-A;
loc.
39 P-81
cit.
t
dk-
()
'k-e-4
&X%j (jw
cf.
&A
Is statementp
SI:afi4'!
CJI a;, v
02-
cit-9
vj,;
a-b
; .
(JA
&I
evidence,
,is
(*j
"
oR. cit.,
1
'".
(I---
39 P- 83
Vol61
t: e. C
SSaifills
tA
0
-. .
Lo.
(5) But cf-
Ir
cit.
jo
But
Aj
tOWI et"
loc.
cit.
6j-A\
40
VUj
CJLZ
a4tail tjL;
79
-
16
But cf.
Sb7aft"I's
G,
tp -e*r.
... >.,
statementg
6
0.;
GI. j
-P,.
Pot
qp. cit.,
fo.
3t P. 84
22- cit-tvol-
147b
!A
L--(,
6)
9 ...
Z)l
-Y
ciqk3%
--Pejl
ju
.-
Kitqb
(1)
Cf-
SIA'3a-ilit 02-
80 -
al-Rahn
150a ;
cit-ifo-
ju
foe 145
But cf,
Sh9fi'I's
8tatementp
3t P. 168 1
OR. cit-9volG. 42
-9
But cf.
up
Sh7afikils
6'P--eit-tvol-
evidbncep
3 , PP- 168
169
cy
U11
juq:; (P-+-cy:
And Muzanip
op.
(L
cit.
2t p.
vol.
the
210 gives
following
information;
;Jujl
AJoj
CL.
'e'v
'op.
And see HgshinE,
cit. 9 loc.
(4) Cf. sa7a2ds oP. cit-#
fo. 152b
sLbL-
CA9)
4". j
-All
,>h
-"
r.
vol-
cit.
op. 'eit.
pfo.
SlZafllls
atatement,
3# P- 128 ;,
uL->, ;ev,
Z>tg
%Z>3-9
...
I-
ZA
it;
81
-
OP- cit-ploo-
cit%:
j
CA
kk;
'
%6b
JO
VJ
CX-4--
lb
a
(6) cf.
up"
.,
fo.
t4
sh7l77Ez37,,
op. cit.
44
cip
aoj-
'l
S; %-
153b
C)V_)
_p
LAC
(7)
ul cikz di
0-
loc,
cit,
Cy 6>
And HEshirid,
,
Cf,
Dgrdqunlrq
(9)
Cf.
Shirazit
loc.
cit.,
op.
cit.,
fo.
tu
'
a.
-As
-;
cit.
39 P.
vol-
OP. cit-9
(10)
Cf.
Sldia27i,
,ji
cit.
L.
cj. $O
*C
, w
Lu
0%:,
jA
6L5
4.4%
jl-tA
tlocs
op. cit.
.,,
1 6
pvol.
3v P- 139
cit.
9-...
Lou 64,
-a
I uz
Cit.
33-
;;
statement,,
op.
!J%A;
151b
*J.
'%A-P-q
Sh9fi'lls
Lis
Sb7ir-aZIq
op* eitoplOC.
9
cit.
63 6u-*11 ; ot C3
cf.
statementt
22,
(8)
Dit
Slafi`Ils
'V,
,
*
%xvq
e-.:pi,
.I
k.
Ow X,
Sh:afigli',
Cf
J,
3, P. 147
vol.
-rZrl
fo.
9
J)
-j
_; 'g,
Sb7afells
!, j I L),
150b
-001
statement#
op.
cit.
tvol.
3v P. 148
A
(13)
cf* Sb7afi'll
(14)
See text P. 90 .
O'D-Oit-ovol-3i
P' - 147.
82
-
fo- 152a ;
6Lo
C-. -Owl
-Pl
C: 4,10W
>! 'C
Ce,
6J%
CA)
;
CA &. 0" 0, l
G%60
But cf.
Muzard's
UA
statement,
4-4:
op.
cit.
cite
ploc.
Af
loc.
6.,.
Cit.
j Jul
au.
wl-
*that
014-
1
Sb7afr
83
-
Kifib
al-Ashriba
W,
L
13-
Bowl
84
Kitab
(1)
Cf-
SlrirR7,19
ons
al-IflAs
fo-
wa al-Hajax
154a ;
CA,
yl
But cf.
CjL4 Ls
0, 3%
Slafi'Tls
ON cit-9
vol-
3t P- 177
% U-aAl
aAao- 6
statementp
U-; Ll
Sla-fiflls
BL5-11 C)A.
-I
vol,
oft
39 P. 176
t UP iu
Q. 1%04
Ul
85.
"
-
O'D.cit.,
op.
cit.
foe
..
-,
But cf-
150
40
2r.
ShFfel's
..
-.
statement,
lj,
($Oj
_93
LJ1';
(J
c"*-14...
u
e.
op. cit.,
evidencep
vol-
3,
q ou.
L;01-.
('-- C.
1..
>
41
.
P- 194 i
UJI
(t:
. & ju
O-U
bu
I
f
0a
I*
Jl
"--o
!
rl( Vi,."ol;
I
Cf. Shirazil't
o]2. cit.,
loc.
cit*
a
jtlo 1j:
I have not found this
Cf- Shirazil
op. cit
Aw
to U's I
e
-,.
v.
JY
tradition.
fo.
9
154b
OJU
3t P- 189
ano.
148
But
Shallls
Cf.
sfoo
statement,
86
-
(8)
But cf,
Shgfills
evidenceg
op.
cit.,
k4,> cs>
w-)
vfo.
-PO
155b j
-,
c
And see Hgshind,
fo-
oR. cit.,
(11)
But cf.
Slj7afjjls
evidenceg
150
Uj*-
op.
cit.
T
a-I
Slaft'lls
JUC'-.0% AJV
4:
9 vol.
1, p.
A &}
JjI
no.
28.
no. 5.
no. 4.
cDj,,
...
statcment,
"
(Ju%
60 ;
. ..
...
iAi
But cf-
L)
4
oG
(12)
;;,
4.1
4L.k., 4
op. cit.
#vol,
31 P- 179 ;
vol.
C (Y)
-'
4'L
fjv
87
-
Kitab
NO=
fo.
op. cit.,
156b
IJ)
But-Cf.
Sirafit'i's
statementg
kp. p
(2)
dlx
Cf. Sliifi_il,
(3) TirmidhTtop.
op.
cit.
LAS-
3, P- 197
t vol-
6359 p.
LAC-
-9
statement,
;
0, dk;
J,
Ls )r%
Lou
L4;0
%J
(5) But cf-
Sh7afills
evidence
op. cit.,
JI;
Cj'C Y-V
ZkZj
tL'
Cf.
JuwainT,
-ou
op.
cit.,
loc.
cit.
l oc. cit.
(4L41
ou
-88
Kitab
al-13iia'la
158a
d\, J
S, rjl
E.4
N-,-
44C
But
cf.
Shifi'ils
statementt.
o]2.
'.
19",
u-%:
it;
ol'
u
L;q
03510 4
&J)\.. JU I.-
.0
",
But of.
ov
Sh7afi"Is
-U
evidenceg
-I --j
1 6.
op. cit.
dtA I
Lit-&
loc.
v
cit,
04
(,-.
'C%UC4
C'
89
-
Kitab-al-7)amiZn
(1)
Cf.
ShlirEzF,
wa al-KafFLIa
op.
Oul
]at cf.
i's
Slrafi
op. cit-P
statement,
vol-
3, p. 204
*,
dsuj%
1,5%
OVO
jw
dItAi
...
I-D
tN;
OWM
IIca,
Lot>a'
fo.
10co cite;
159b
jvj
But
cfo
Sla-fi4lls
statementg
op. cit.,
fo.
op.
_cit.
cit.,
loc.
cit.
Ul
LO-A)
Cf. Shirgili,
op.
Joe,
158b
focit,
CY?
Shift"I's
- go -
Cf-
Sldra'zli,OP - 2-11-9
loc-
low
'L
, k,.
-
And see
vol.
.010 01;
4
e4
L
Hgshimlij pn.
it.
0,
cit-
!p4C UU
40
0-: p
cit.
6W
-1
P-m
loc.
cit.
MuzanIp
#
op.
cit.
.0
uto
2, p. 227.
no. 76
OP- Cit-tvol-
op. cit.
gloo. cit.
3t P- 3131
ll
91
-
Kitab
al-Sharika
fo. 160a ;
Al
jo
(2)
Cf.
Shlrazliq
Lp
LAS,
-Of. -S9razl,
(4
.6A
fo. 160b ;
\j
'I j L;I( ;kl%p
;"
fo.
op. cit.,
vit :
statement,
3, p. 206
IUJ%
sA
VI
lw
dw, IA--
Sh7afi'i-Is
evidencet
Nil
But
cf.
Mazax;Iils
statement,
_jkPI
P.
. 61 Lpwl
(L.
vpy'>\' I"
fo.
cit.,
2. p.
vol,
230
dL
tit;
Vt
dxi.
N>.!.
o
v*l:-A?
-
160a
&I; z31 %
tlut
le
V-A-i v geW,
9..
, (
v-g-I
s
'c3uI
%J-:
- ..
92
-
Kitab
(1)
Cf.
19shiml,
op.
'al-Wala-la
fo.
cit.,
187 ;
6-
0.04
't;p
Bu cf.
Shaft"I's
OP- Cit-s
statementp
(2)
ZamakhshaAg
op.
-;o
L4
((..
10 p,
vol,
evidencet OP--cit-9
%%-up
Oj
6,0-0.
ra,
Y9,4% LA&
U,
119shioris
cit.,
oP. cit.
jo
3p p,
vol-
207 ;I
Ull
--;
259-
loc--cit-t
vol- 79 P- 109 ;
'401;gis Lj-%.!
'o,
jv*
%,
b
\J-v WV,:
4:,
'j
j)l
ea:
...
'Ooxt!
G-4;
C.
- tZm .'c,
\s
j%
*--
),>t; b.
;
cit.
tloc.
J,
C-A,
V.U. )
&A.:A cy
q Ik 6%-.
' %:>s "g--
&. X;g
Cf. Sh7ir;;zl,
u
_..;,
J)
C)Y,
ur
J
ty-1,
-.,
fo. 165b ;
op. cit.,
-Olt
4..
"Ld..
(6) cf.
sh! rEzl,
op. cit.,
loc. cit.
s.. "
;
4.: p
ff.
158 9 159 ;
'
)L1
.
Cl" (
,
But of, Sh-afi i's
4.
(C
a--
z& wa:
> cy.
vol.
7t P- 108
.
4"
Xl
O..
L.XC
at,
93
-
(8)
But
cf.
Shifel's
.?
Cf. -Ilgshimit
evidencet
Id k2G -, iii
op. eit.
op.
G
--,
cit.,
t)
0.15e
9
fo.
-Of..
"-.
Hshiii,
op. cit,
cit.
., v ....
Q (aGuit
du, "
QI
157
4"=1
I
ov..
1
0
1
*p
v
...
-P
-.
-.
69
(11)
loc.
e
,.,
(I
ploc. Cite
b. ., \....
94
-
Xitab
al-Iqr
fo.
p
160
A7
I,
-0',
j'k;
,
i's
Sh7afi
But of.
%V
q.
Ls
4 ,,1
statementf
op.
%-...
)&
O
%.
0-41
q41 .e>
6
12A-*4
&,0%C
. >U
Sh-afi-ils
209
O-M% ck2*J
%0!, 4u
Ch:&r,
evidence
3P p,
cit-svol-
6jk
JA
...
j6:
it. .. Ck;
'O'
-A
209
Cu
C.P
OLdI
>I
GO,
64 \A I
D"',
kj J % LI1,
dtp
Aj
j&V;
J% J%P
op.
cit-9
,
5
4. P
61"AI
z'." 9i'%j
Ia
..
Ow,
.1-P -
LJp
And see Hgshiml,
statementv
02- cit-9
Cf. ShIrEzI,
loc.
012. cit.,
Shgfi'lls
39 p. 211 ;
vol-
A--t--I,
Lo
%
>!
op. cit.,
But cf.
cit.
loc.
'a
Y,.;---VsI \...
cit.
'!I
And see HEshim-i,
op.
-cit.
OP. cit-t
loc.
cit.
&,
--I'
fo. 306
du
\j
And see Hishim-it
op. cit.
gloo.
cit.
But cf.
'ou
Sb7af? lls
(itz oL
L)IU
J-94-kj
\J
uji
L:
95
-
Cf.
SbIriazip
op,
cit.
loc.
cit.
j
o..
op. cit,
'V.
308a
it
-4.5
fo.
op. cit.,
7, P. 110
vol.
ou
-;;;
op.
o%--C3
cit.,
o'.!
Joc.
IL-A*Av
But' ef -Shiifi'j!
0
- Ao
rw"'
cit,
-03
OL,
s statement,,,
Shgfe'lls
Z> I
A.
("
wt
cit,
C-4
Cf, HL'UME,
ZA 0,3:wi
'j
OP. cit-9
tip
J.31 Cj,
tjoc,
fo-
op. cit.,
Cit
'.
t3k;
"jo
a
b-p
6u-.
(I) ( ;4 .1"I&. 1.
op,
cit.
vol.
-
7. p.
0:;%
k'. 4
111
cit
statementg
- 96 Kifab
(1)
Cf.
Slilrazi, I
op.
oo- cit-,
fo,
cit.,
alKria
172a
fo.
op. cit.,
Shifit'lls
statementg
3, p. 217 ;
vol.
Jlj
(2)
6-,
--x-s
u-, -9
Cf.
Dgrdqunli
Zamakhshari,
Cf.
op.
Shiifi"Iq
-cit.
Vajarp
op.
Sldrwd,
p
*f
op.
064
.
zj4t6
e-e.cjlt; r k4j.,
cit,
cit.
vol.
loc.
cit,.,
op. cit.,
Shlia-zYq
op.
tloc.
UziI
; eaks
see Ibn
29 p. 265-
vol.
loc.
cit.
aLl
cit.
(7) Cf.
218
op.
Jv--
3p p.
vol-
-cit-9
Af
3#-P--419
19 P- 358-
p vol.
OP-
(4) afwiain b.
Vol-
OP-eit-i
A.
ou qvj
op.
cit.,
cit.,
loc.
oT. cit.
L40 0--A
du ckj., %)
loc.
cit.
cit.
loc.
9
cit.
e & 'i I
5-1
'A
t
Li
11, *
cit.
AOju;
.e
- 97 -
Kit7ab al-Ghasb
fo. 173b
op. cit,
GO
CJ%
fo.
o.
166
But cf.
-cit.,
3, pp, 218 9.219 ;
vol.
'. >4
Shafe-i's
b >J_
statemento
LUjl
(ju
x
(2) But cf.
ShZfi"I's
02-
evidence,
Cil-9
(AC
U'l
eA.
u4
42%
Il
a\;
*A
0\.
.
"-it
(V
dW
1A
--
*'u.
L4 x>"%
219
ly.
do',
39 p,
Apt
C"C
L;P!.:,
, z,
b
,
vol-
L, 4, ul
Cf. Sh-irazip
op. citoploc*
81%J%,
Gic
J
>
(:
y
>--j%
cp
i
o:
cit*
QJI-9
yu
&-i
ci
cy.
k--21
'-p
i
%
>
>-4
-----j 2l, 334 ( See
-4. -sx;
op. cit.,
t 1- ye,
-
But cf.
'j-VI
>
""
4 >;,
P-,
9,
)
149
2.
p.
appendix.
no.
fo. 174a
o
-..
91
S137afi'*Ils siatementt
1*4-3% C.
ax.,
%SU-2
-e->'
o2. cit-ovol-
91
39'-P,. 223
'
98
-
Sh7afi-Ils
evidenceg
-t-x
..
4.
-) )-tj
op.
loc.
0
cit.
ly. ; 11
Cit.
aw
&
J%-!
a-;
pU'>%
6:>
upLAu XLq4!.
q
'jp
CA
Gv
k'k;
A.
Cf.
SIIraili,
op.
loc.
cit.,
tot
cit.
CAJ
6XA
L't
W%
J.
%J>A%
ct
ct. 4,
Ab
("C
J-;..
A;
fo.
Shlfi Ii
vol-39PP-45,46that
had said
-I
-.
93-,
Qur"gn 5
(9)
But cf.
Shafilhad
jUAP
Muzan-i's
based
statement,
this
op.
cit-9
case on the
volt
following
39 P. 46 that
evidence;
*
C'. c?
)(10)
Cf.
Skd3aizl,
loc.
9
op. cit.
'wI
...
4k.;
cit.
%: j L4
And see Hashimig op. cit.
(il)
Cf.
Sh-ir-azli,
op.
Cit.
pfO.
loc.
, ,
cit,
176a
...
I't
AV! Dgwiid,
op.
cit..
OP. cit.
169
9 vol.
2, p.
259.,
I"
99
-
But of.
Muzan-i's statement,
...
029 cit*9
t>j.
9,t-,
vol-
39 P. 43 that
j
-0:
ds
um
u
0--41
-eLe
ou
\j
175a
sk;
-AC.,X .
-, -41
1, .:4 Lot
e-:.,o V--i3
(18)
Cf.
Stdr7azig
op.
(19)
Qur'in
15 - 78.
(20)
Qgr'a
39.42.
(21)
Cf.
Slrir7azliq
op.
fo.
cit.
op.
cit.,
cit.
174b
fo.
loc.
166
cit,
-V
(22)
Cf.
ShIxTa'zli,
op.
cit.
loc.
"- ()
cit.
I
:
U
I,
t
-A
fo,.
167.
And see lashim-T# op.
-cit. 9
at;
ps%
.
- 100 -
cit.
j
%:
statement,
o2.
cit,
no. 28,
fo,
op. cit-9
loc*
op, cit#9
op.
cit-,
;2
175b
cit.,
loc.
vol-
3o p.
%J
Bat
.
cit.
222 ; A. 40
I Cm-,, W%. O
4.4 t
...
lo;.
#
cit.
(29)
Hindi,
But. cf.
op.
op.
-cit.,
Sh7afi'lls
cit.
ploc*
Vol.
10t
statementg
cite
c.. 1 `q---tu
P. 422.
OP- Cit-t
Vol-
3t-p.
239
"',
JU
'J'
%
'4;
'A
(See p.
2. )
WO
""
Cf.
U2.
re
ll
(28)
Shaft"I's
cf.
vol-
39 P. 219
101 -
KitTLb ai-wad7i%
4,:
'
JU
-5-11%
fo.
OP- cit.,
54
CJV%J
CY
173a
10'.U,
CJI'A. 4%
CJ,;;
"
"'toi
(: &
ZA
Ls -"%
I
statement,
op. cit.
9 Vol,
4v O-t4u.-,3 G. ul,
'Shli-ail,
(2) Cf.
ali
LjL,
op. cit.
uu u*L
G,;a
a:ii
6V4 .. Av.
Lq
cte
ke.%A
&tl
:>G
Joe, cit.;
LOU
(4) "cf.
j
C;
A
I
I_,;
g-vi
*0
G5>,,
vI
I?
j
db,
k-r
ov-z---j
shfrgz-i,
x"
OP.Cit.,
-%,
",
0: LY, C-,
Joe.
cit.
9
"-*,
I -
dU
49 p. 60.
0,71
t>.P--0
)U
"et;
JOC.Cit.
owl
CY CA' L:Ulv
C'. !JUt
102
-
Kitab
Ibn Far,
Cf.
op.
sjj7jr&'zj
228a
ff.
op.
228b
4t
cit-tvol.
3v p.
vol-
cit-9
cit.
op.
. 1,
op.
statementp
Zamakh8hari,
Cf.
ci
Shafi4i's
But cf.
(2)
al-Siyar
218.
p.
202
(See appendix
P-159nool,
2s6a
9fo.
J6
But cf,
Muzanils-statementp
Sh-afi'*l
had said
oP. cit-s
5t P- 189that
vol-
O-ZI
(3)
5) Cf- Shlia-I,
OP- cit.
cit
V-IY
269b
fo.
9
(4,
And see H; shim-il
op.
statementp
%'L'or'vis
0
-.
op.
cit.,
vol.
cit.,
6t
Sli&fi4l's
fo.
149
p.
LA
A.
CC,
\&
(6)
sz
b.
El7alid
Ibn
Hajarl
(7)
Cf.
Ibn
(8)
Cf.
Sl&fi'llp
loc.
cit.
al-Walld
op. 'eit-t
Mgja
op.
op.
21 A. H. )
(d.
vole
cit.,
cit.
For his
biography,
see
3P P- 124vol.
16c.
29 P- 948cit.
lashimli,
op,
cit.,
t; c: %i:;j & WC
eJL-j, A-)i oj
-grz
(9) Cf. Abri Dawilidt
vol.
29 P. 440-
KasEnI,
But cf*
(See
29
16
vol.
p.
appendix
#,
.
op-cit.
9, P- 4361
vol.
,
SI)7afi'! 's statement,
op. cit-,
vol-
49 PP- 719 72
du
Ls
ozaj j; _5
0-)41
1-9
UA
CdA
OX-11
Slaft"I's
loc.
9
cit.
no, 28.
'op.
evidence,
cit.,
loc.
cite;
UV
U. 5
1:
C-Lki,
lk;
Y-.
d%
CY
kL--
-. Q'I
ru
fo.
9
op* cit.
ee
Cjjj
't-0 But cf.oA-t
'I's
Sh7afi
Lt.
C;A%
k3k
(. CU-0)
. *Al
tju'
(4
...
290
4
statementg
111
k>AtA;
op. cit.
jV01.4t
P-70-
:
C-A.
I
- )%
104
-
Muzar;i-'B statementg
had said
OP- cit
P, 183 that
v vol-5p
Shgfil
;
Oo
(17)
(19)"Umar b.
Hajarp
.
(20)
1 have not
(21)
found
P-105-
statementg
op. cit.,
vol.
4, P. 145
(d. 23 A. 11.)
For
his
biography,
.
al-Khatlab
o2. cit.,
...
JU J,
see Ibn
vol-7.
this
athar.
op* citot
evidencep
10C* Cite
;
0#
*ji
l#
Z
'
t. au
-ip.
--0.
.;.j,
ci
e-
J.
"I JU
-0
--. b
ul
291a
fo.
4: 0.
L5 I
'
%- u%
no. 'I%
loco
cit.
ju,
V;
J,
105
-
But cf.
Shiifi'lls
ou?-.5 W.
statement,
012. cit-9
vol.
4, p. 65
'w
6L4 6u
ShEft"I's
op. cit
evidencet
CL.O.)
L; t4--q
loc.
.
cit.
a-u:),j
LAX
aiD
.oo
OP-cit.,
op. cit.
vol-9t
P-4353.
tioc. cit.
106
-
Kifab
(1a)
Cf. Zamakhshali,
(lb)Cf.
Abazlt
al-NiAb
lt
pvol.
op. cit.
op.
cit.
fo.
Ir
It
JP I
dl;.
cf.:
Sliafi4lls
statementg
59 P- 11;
But
P-392.
)
169
l.
p.
no,
193a
(2)
(See appendix
C-o
O-P. cit
loc.
cit.
Cxr
Cj'j Li,. C Cjkz
-j
a-
loc. cit.
up.
uv
'op.
fo.
9
rz,. Wil
ou-P
cit.
199b
cstg
a;
-0.1
cit,,
this
evidencet
OP. citelfoo
(9)
Cf.
'Jul
..4
cit,
But cf,.
op. cit.
av.
100. Cit.
fo.
41
-41
199a
statementt
200a
cj-w
op. cit.
16.1 -W
vol.
ShBfills
(iquil
Lic
ShIrEzI,
op, cit.,
-; -ie-
4adlth.
0'1Jjk-
loc,
Am
5,. P. 15
kky
L4,
k3
vol. 5,
-p. 225-
op. cit.
T*%
loc.
cit.,
) 4FA IuI
t..
C$4
Skrafi4l's
statement,
11
",
0
.
atz 0.1j,Aj." UAL
6
G-J,>.g
11
tL4: oa;
du
? LAjl>A
107
-
s eyidencep
"'e
op.
loc,
9
cit,
Gst;:
Jtul;,u
Y%'Cvc
JL;U-%:
-cit.
loc.
#
cit.
cv. "
op. cit.
3, p. - 260*
vol.
fo.
op. cit.,
U'V
199b
CL-A: ZV,;Jl
loc.
op. cit.,
cit.
loc. cit.
'-:p owl
JN
(** *,
cit*
-b
3
%1u.
_9'l
loc.
o]2. cit.,
ZAJ
10
UALe>-. 9
(15) Cf. Sldazlp
a.
op. cit.
loc.
9
But cf.
cit.
ShIfi'E's
statement,
vol-, 5, P. 6
; 0"J
ioc.
op. cit.,
cit.
jj
6e zk4;
Z'V;
GSLtAl JU J,
V .r zj'l %;
-
&
fo. 199a
"a, JV
JA
q-%JA-kZjj. VI 0;
.
cit.
op.
fo, 251b
loc*
CUO) "
t 1,,,W,
-x- 1,1,
N
(19) See
above p. 106, no-4-
Q; . k; Ujo
cit*
J,
6
..
$
Cl
4,
'b-t"ou ov ky--t-A
108
-
(20)
Cf.
siTir-azi,
Z.-u;
op.
,t
cit.
fo,
200 b;
c7--.
-01 tjk;-,
But cf.
Shfills
tiki140-b1b1Ilu
1,) u53
i y,
5p P. 16';
vol.
op. cit-o
statementp
-q
-i;
,
U.
jl*,
&
L.
11
4
-.
ll
ii.
(21)
(22)
Cf.
i's
Slafi
gU
7p p.
'Vol-
23-
op. cit-
evidence,
1
0-N ,tG,
*Z
g
u cV --.
5p P- 15 ;
vol-
ei
Z.
1.
cy.
,
4t
) --- e-,
u. -t-
L>*i
i,jU
t--. , (.;4%.:
't
il du
e*.,
Y.' G.
(
4.
ZA;
Cf.
ShIrazli,
op.
1;
3s,
foe
a
J_,
>71
. Cl.
cit.
oP. cit.,
91
Y,
vol-
JG
in the
exists
-
0,,j\; avo)"i
Cj
: A
(Muslim,
C.;,
op. cit
CA
'j..
)
vol. 2, p. 10'56.
's
59 P- 12 ;
Sh7
afi4l's
evidence,
op. cit.
910c. cit.
(4 *,
.
(29)
Cf.
Sld3aJiq
op.
cit.
t;
:>
op. cit.,
loo,
cit.
_tm
e I LAO
op. citso
statement,
"4
C.P
4jbv
2011),l
-4
log
-
oR. cit.
tfo.
J
202b ;
I
%
_j.
OV-9
But cf.
Sh-afills
statementt
OP- cit-i
vol-, 5# p. 62 ;
4F
U.
SITafi"I's
loc.
J1
cit.
Nj
(32) cf.
w'. -Odk#
146,
"",
W
"i
C"'V.
-j
fo. 203a
41LAC
, )I
PLO-, Al
OP* cit-p
(33) Cf-
But cf,
fo.
198.
But cf.
Slaifills
statement,
vol-
ShIr7azit
op., cit.
OP-
op. cit.
SIrafi4l's
100-
cit-9
fo.
p
;.
-cit-
201a
statementg
OP- cit'otvol.
59 p. 12
CJt
(35) See
above p-.9,9*no. -76*
Jv
110
-
(36)
OP.
cit.
-Cit-ploc.
AO
ce
(38)
Cf.
SIiTazi,
OP. cit.
fo. -202b
9
cit.
statementg
vol-
Liu
C.?
d-u:
02--cit-,
>
loc.
p
cit.
But
cf.
.
Is
59 P- 13 ;
40
611.1
121-
Shlfi!
J.P
VW
(39) Cf- Sldriazli',
op. cit.
4.
lut
Shafi
cf.
(-r 8U.N
205b
fo.
9
JV
.$d
G-
i's
statementg
op.
-9
5v p,
vol-
cit-9
22
tj,
Ul;
4A-(,:Kt.tt5ot(, z
(40) Cf Sh7afi"I's
-
11C.
%N
vv.
59 P. 136 ;
-1
doj
c: Z.
ew du
f
wo
.
lI
d.
Pl
ii!
(>
(,
j)
ze: '-I zM:
.
(41) Cf Muslim
-
9 ON Cit-9
(42)
op.
Cf.
Sqrgz7ig
cit.
VOI* 29 Pe 1081.
loc.,
cit.
01
ill
-
Sli&fills
But cf.
Z
I;
S-,. -
31% ",
e. m,
ukg
Sliaft"Its.
Cr
Vp
Aj
ui
0-0- cit-9
statement,
;
-,
jG
o;
_!
C, k';..
te)
4_0
-'j ... *e
1P-Vbl... 5p P. 8
A.
ut. &
_"
5t P- 9
vol.
4j
t;
411
C., LZ
-,
loc-
22- cit-P
cit-
CAJ'f'
C-u
_)_O
See aboye p.
(48)
See above p.
(4 9) BA
cf.
'LAA4
Ar
(50)
Of.
(52)
Cf.
110 . no-
Sh7aft"I's
38
evidenceg
op.
cit.
SldiTazlit
op.
cit.,
fo.
'-.
I
Zamakhsharip
OP. cit.
5t P.
p vol.
01V
Lle'oj
C-t': t
(51)
13
'f
202b
-fisv%
9 vol.
r"i
%,.
29 P- 545-
loc,
Cf. *Zamnkbshar-i, op. cit.
cite
94 ... .8
JLWv tee-. k; 3Ij r
C'
&I
u
-o
(See appendix
pShirazit
op. citatfo.
p. 16,
203b;
JO
33
50OP. cit.,
JX;
6-l. ) cu-P) Ja J!,., j
100. cit.
no.
di;
1. )
- 112 -
But cf.
Shafllls
statement,
ak-q I
e-40
(56) Bit
fo. 2056;
'cf.
Sh7aft"I's
J..-4
UJ.
P
'a
OP-cit-,
234;
vol-5tp.
*to-ul
olrj
4.1di%,,
%
!,.k
oloo. cit.
OU
j%
LjL!
is J,>
ukc
C-Av
(57) qur"Rn 25
54.
fo. 207b ;
op. cit.,
40
And see H57shimlq op. cit.,, fo. 201. But cf.
I
Nl
A-L o" x.
k.-W. co:
(59) Ct. Shafi"E,
ce
Atj
c4a
,*1
j4j-
(60)
'0 (kw)
I,
U:
Ghail. Tn b.
4Abdul
Barr
A%
ju;
1,
L01,
-,
Salama (d.
9
Slii'rgzTg
op. cit.,
9
(L. I
Ioc.
0. u
-)
OP-cit-ovol-39
*&.v%.
bOzj-ciA..
-,.
*.
?
statement,
be,
U,
1;
to*
UU
0
z:.0-A
'mol
. -"Vl
loc. cit.
op. cit.,
oLp-.,..
Shgfi'lls
Cit.
to tj
.0
see Ibn
P. 1256.
628.
l,
p.
svol.
fo. 204b
j-,
661
*
#J
go!
Wtll"
a-sj,..
'-Ol
a
%)
113
-
But cf.
Sha'fi'"ils
A. CA
Y-Ij
I
-l-VP
(63) But cf-
Sliifills
P-3 ;
OP- Cit-ovol-5,
statementp
Pl
6w
;
;
W-16
4-:
I
XJca;
f-Al
evidence,
-4
ope cit.,
ivol-3,
in
the collection
available
ij
-4y I
M-,
OL;
\I
%
1,
.
vi'l
is
40
f Liu
ju
Ail
pp. 2,3 ;
OP-'cit-, Vol-5,
40
(JI;
b-'3z-t
PP-129791298. But
zw ev-e-
the tradition
as below;
Lj.PO-m
tit;
'JQI
(Ac
L44
%J-
uu.'Ml uk;
-%
LJL41
'W'b
P-476t Ti=idh
op.
cit.,
vol-3, P-433-')
(65)
Cf
(66)
Cf. Zamakhsharl
Zamakhshm4it
But cf.
op.
Shlifti's
(See appendix
100'. Cit.
cit.,
op. cit.,
loc. cit.,
statement,
OP-cite,
'j
ShIrEzIg
vol-59
Sh-ira-z-i-,,
lococitt#
g
op. cit.
P-8
F-kA;
(68) qur'in
tj(A
C-WI
CrZO,
4.250
Cia
oj.
4j-;
oloo-cit.
OP*citoovol-59
op. cit.,
(.
3%
6Q3
\J.. P
qloc,
cite
;
.6
Cou;
Jl
ji
(See appendix
.
But
p. 169 no. 3. )
fo,
207a
:5a.;%,Z)6:.(L--q
Shjr3-J,
t
*t
1 'ju -s ,
fo. 201.
X.
CA6
cf.
op. cito,
Shafi
P-7 9
4; 3
tt. OLoj-,
C.:wl ok J_tWi
t;
op'. cit..
L--.
Z:
CubZ!
-,
206a
#fo,
op. cit,
Z.;, j IZ
.'6
)
16,
2.
no.
p.
i's
stateinentg
41. LjLA
CN
L-t
JI:
.1-,
114
-
Shafi4! qs evidenceg
P. 5
-9P-ci't-tvol-59
cm
j-. i, A1
mat ;;,>t
ZV4;e
cy >vat'
Muzani's
based this
hadlith.
statementg
Cf.
Juwainlo
op. cit.
evidence
had
-Ip
glococit.;
Shafi'l
"VY C::,
Vv ..., o
Li
ci
I
%
-AP -t-lo 15J
(77) Cf-Shlrzl,
that
op. citegloOscito
1;,
e-;
()I
...
(75)
oe 9-9
CJI
(73) 1 have
not found this
(74) But cf.
yi, ull
U.
o"J,
Z%
Lite
I
I
-j
201,
But
Sh9h"T's
cf.
gfo.
4'
statement,
o-1.4
--Pj 91
Lit;
Cj&
Ji-,.
crt.
>
115
-
lo'o. cit.
evidenceg
op. cit.
6! 6\-
Lp -V
oloo. cit.
4-
j'. ) %eL
cto
tv; A% ukc ckr-)
V.,;
01%
>,;,A 'e;l
-c..;
cy. 6L;-"-o
\P-Y
Lp
.j
(81)
Cf.
Shl r7azli
op. cit.
(82)
Cf.
Sl; i-r3zrg
op. cit.
-P
(83)
Cf-
Shlir7al,
oito
fo. 208a
0-5'
Ci
de"
do,
JA
ZW
floc,
fo. 202.
op. cit.,
OP-cit-oloc-cits;
op. cit.,
fo. 204b
;
_4
02-cit.
statement,
&A))
p'vol-5t
t
XJI
(1, .
P-157
d3l
0
.. i
(85) Cf. Sh9fi"Tt
oP.cit-ovol-59
op-cit-,
vol-7v
a
-*-.:
I &b u1j.
P-15.
ii6
-
t_''
op. citot
Shgfills
statementg
j'-,
(J3
A
ty.;
(88)
But of.
.6
JIA-L rW
ok;.?
fo, 201.
Slaifil'lls
evidence,
op. clt.
b)
6)..,
gloc. cit.
JU
(89)
Cf.
Ilashimi,
ol), cit.,
Ioc. cit.
41,
But
cf.
Shlfills
A, cj", li-A
P-75
OP-cit-ovol-5t
statementt
Cy 'j I V, >: 4
6
VO-Zx
6
xo
0
b1p
-: ---u
L-.a%d-Oup.
&i.-
(90)
But
cf.
&its
Shafi
evidencet,
'Vt%
op. citetloc.
gloo. cit.
U- t'I... 1
'>'^0 ...
op. cit.
'I **
J.
ju
cito';
-'
op. cit.
Vol-5o
209b
ofo.
oy. cit.
P-109
gloc. cit.
).
OA"
But
v
L-,
cf. Sl7afills
,, '9 tIW
tike
statement,
"
117
-
(93)
Hajarp
op. cit.
For
biography,
her
.
ofPisha
12p P-403-
tvol.
p. 292.
OI!-r-it-pvol-3p
op. cit.
evidence,
C:A;
oloo. cit.
Co-
(S
Mvi
ul
le
1.,
o i .i 4 ----0-
G4
G)i
(:>ce-,
z, C;P2
i-j
o.
-r,
-",
'%ju-j. , 6-k:h ul
-o.
But
109
cf.
.
gfo.
Shafi
4-Z23.
i's
69p7O;
pp.
>:.5 C-,4-
mcit-tvol-5t
Shgfit'lls
evidenceg
o]2. cit.,
loc. cit.
do
t4
A* 9-3
(_
Nb
%j
)
e-.,
ue.
kh
,
cA5.
ju--.' JU4
A;x
J-3
*'
C-u ...
Z\-41-4
,
(100) Cf. Shirazit
oD. cit.
oloc.
cit.
of*
118
'Bgb- al-Sadgq
(1)
Cf. Zamakhsharlt
(2)
Cf.
Shlraiq
(See
284.
1,
p.
appendix
tvol.
op. cit.
fo. 210a
op. cit.,
I d; I
dUu.
op. cit.
Shafi'lls
205-
Ifo.
statement,
Sh7afills
du
t
p. 245.
gloo. cit.
JI
jut
N
a.
t-m%
12 G;
J>m-,
U_x
-%x41
Shirazi,
op. cit.
Cf-
Zamakhsharl
IVr-
&Ll
op. cit.
1.7. >l
1,J,
",
cki-IU-01
lvol.
eA-, e- GO
(See appendix
29 P-471-
t.
.
OP-cit-ovol-5t
Q=-in *4
)
2.
no.
210b;
#fo.
Ja
-
QI.
Btateiento
UJI
du
(.J
UL, OL-N
I
(3
P-144
'ef.
Strafili's
But
Ioc. cit.
op. cit.,
CLA
P-170
gloc. cit.,
op. cit.
4 (k-q
cit,
tloc,
et.
Cf. Zamakhshalq
14. G"t
, (k-;
'64
%J--
CAS.
jI
X.
t
j,: -- -%
Cf.
p. 52
02-cit-tvol-5t
)
P-17p no. 5.
6,
YJA
24.
e; o%,
4A
C.
0 CA;
...
*4
6
4A2
Shafi"I
92.2-cit-tvol-7t
P-40.,
- 119 -
-q
op. cit.
gloc. cit.
0-;3
C)
op. cit.
212
fo'.
a;
,
'4.
c_._ u
statementt
p. 61
vol-5,
02-cit-,
Z
U:
U
atz
0.
C,k; (:, t
07)
3,jb
.>-
*"'(,OU
"W
0 It. 1; I
U4
evidenceg
ft
op. cit.
iq v
_
tloc.
cit.
U41j LW
c:
4,
j,,
\-v
jA;;
ej.
\:
C.
o-j
t.
s
,
L,
.
L;,: c.:,o-tij 4*,, ..,
0
4
\j I
cl.
qu
_;;
I vjj
L;, %.
- 120
Bab al-'Khal"
(1)
Cf. Sh-irazig
5,
vol
Aj-10
But cf.
Gpl
3%;
I
I
-t
_p
" (,
_AjN
ee CjAk6
(2)
fo. 214b
op. cit.,
220
op. cit.,
Shafi4T's
to
But
ShiWl's
cf.
o
P- 18 1
2uu
X34 ( j--;
.0
statement,
UV.
Cue,
evidenceg
op. cit.
oloc. cit.
04
W.
gloo.
cit.
ci
Lk;
\j
.
e-.:,
-54
v; - (i
".
L?
" \j ,-,
v-,
JI
Ir
fo. 223- But cf. SEafi'!
'o statement,
Osw%
op.cit* 9loc.cit.
(5) But cf. Slaifi`lls
N
5;
1
6
'Ay.
Vo!o
&
&-I
lrI,
Cf. Sl;
evidencet opicit.
ete%
op. cit.,
gloc. cit.
ki "-J.2
a--j.
(3u
Ioc. cit.
43-N
>!
wg
;
U
40
- 121 -
KiGb
al-Tal'gq
I
(1)
Cf. Shir7azi,
216b ;
gfo.
op. cit.
j
Sh9fi ,1
the
provides
following
statement
1
4
t
2"j
6,
13
L5
ZY
WI:44
ou; e
(39,
',
1114
j%
4*
449
(2)
Cf. Shirazig
4 ZMA
loc. eit.
op. eit.,
u-gcm L31%
(:e%
( 3) Cf Ibn Mija,
.
20p.
vol.
9
op. cit.
Cf - Zamakhahari
(-,, 4
op. cit.
(See
)
2406.
p,
appendix P-17f no.
SArEzlo
loo. cit
j
)I j U.. , p:?
-,t-lb
vol-3t
660.
-A
L.4
C.
.
p. 162*;
op-cit-9vol-5p
statementg
OP-cit-. 9fo-217a
6100
L:! j
.4 .1-
W.
J%;
Ju.
GIXWI
N_q
Cjo
C,
)%:
j*l
(6) qur'lin 65 1.
(7)
as
4adith,
'I
yj I L; 2)IJ
.;
; %V 0.MlU 1.%3
fOllOW3
ZV, kj
3.!
blal
01
*w 17,'I
k
&-tj
3
04,
tr-
zOJp
(L
in the
V)
Z
4 Mi
z)i
cu
Gb
p "
(10) Cf. Sjirazi,
04. >. 0.)%
om-eit.
CZ'e,
-Ut -t-21
oloc. eit.
o-':p cilg
Cpj
t::Jj ju
AP
122
-
(11)
Cf. ShlrEzY,
op. cit.
ifo.
218a 1
*,
Is
Z;
p
.9!.
OP-cit, ovol-4#PP-73974
012V
thit
Shafi'i-
had said,
j
.0.0
6- o'LA
(12)
(13)
I
Cf. SldrLi,
op. cit.
op. eite,
Aeil
Jqoa)l
u-
ou
..
&uo
JA
ei
J
','
eit.
ZG up 1 t6
->-%, -41
U0
-bb
-, fo. 218b
-ft; _0
cf. Shafi4l's
loc.
(3yb),
op. cit,
ou-,
But
o-p-cit. iloc-eit.
6
ciL.
#Ioc.
te
Sljirazi,
ou
69. I
-Y
Biatement,
I Gill,
"i
ou
(::;, I
p. 124
OP-cit-tvol-59
av IV
C.001
(17) Cf-WrQ,
Mcit-tloc-
cito ;
ci
;j
li -A
ml
- *-r-..c; ve C:,
-Y
(18) MASS,
"it.
190a
tfo.
had said
ji
-IN
P-74 Ahat
123
-
(20)
Cf.
llgsh-iri,
fo. 229
op. cit.,
vol-79 PP-'145046
'I,
A
a.
V-
t eCj!.
-O-'j
Cd
XV
A.
J-;.,.
'; j"I
69Vw
OV
P-NIout,
I
C;,
-. 0''%, !.P &\I,
%
'>j
La4
Nk..'
SICaft"I's
-W,
&\; -L% a
or.Gou
.
9110c#cit,
op*cit.
evidence,
I>w . 01
222a
;
gfo.
o2. cit.
-U
pus.
t (.
Bat of. 1-luzwils statementg
4e--3
49 p. 82
oP. eit-tvol.
(.At.
0. (; 2.0j O, >
;
iv. &a: J_>. zf%->bwU
L;,> j1
(25) U. Stdrazlit
statement,
ot
op-cit.
A-0-41
%C
, 6AM cy-A u
-*,
4CU--"
op. cit.
tfo.
233.
But cf-SIEfi
239
59
p.
tvol.
&
'.
-P
A6
CA
!d&,:
>. g
%&
%
-0
4.
Cr-GV'c
..
Lfluil du
(up)
-,
%
ILL6 (:.kA>
-A
6Xj
124
-
(28)
or-cit-,
Cf. ShlrI,
3t P. 488
-,
vol-
fo. 223a
op. cit.,
;
CYJJIj
t.-';
(29)
statementg
OP-cit-tvol-79
6
CLY.
Z'>-'
Bxr -j'c -I'I
Abdul RahrZn
9
b.
P-149
biography,
Lis
W%
see Ibn
Cf, Tirmidll,
op. cit.
Sh7afills
loc.
cit.
9
#loc, cit,
op. cit.
evidencet
j
CAJ
lp
4
&"q
C,
cy
j
cjt>J1
4""
1%
e
k
1
LrA Z.-Itjj (. 0.,
-P
d...-P ZI&21
; cttjl
t GjxW1c-ii,
(33)
cit.
; L-f
222a ;-III.
gfo.
#Ioc, cit.;
pp. cit.
statement,
(34)
1>>5a.x
(35) Cf. Sldrzlv
",
evidenceg
Uu
OP-cit-ovol-79
(il.
Lik) C.
Iii21 -.li
op. cit.,
IN:
Cp
fo. 222b
0-99
'0
%,
>u
(Jua
0.3, v
PP-1499150
ji
I
ji
;-2... utu
125
-
M7abal-Raj4a
223b
f
pfo.
Jo
-4
But
cf. Shiifills
.C
lp
" Y.6
k:.t C- U%
ut
Cy.
(2)
But
p. 223;
OP-Cit-ovol-5p
statement,
0-.U
oj
ef. SYCafi'lls
'
-J-J-
op. cit,
evidence,
4
43U
cit,
tloo,
AP
*,
J0
Q -C.?
k.; Ls% 6v
cit".
k.0
e.:. A
ov
Cf-Shliazis
OP-cit-oloo-cit-
Cf-SldriaAs
OP-cit-iloc-cit-
\.V.
IS-. ) du
p, 225
OP-cit-tvol-5t
I L>.Jt 611
CAJI"I
^lit
Ui
Vj
I OU
;
C:.
6--A
A;
",
u
O-j
69 ouk'si
ez
UA.
LL;
\.V.eg;. t3)mo
v it
($ZVI
Ioc. cit.
'14
"',
;
't. > 0..r '% GP
41
%JU
--(
%S>
-3.
->
_>s,
.
Cf. SijirZzi, op. eit., ff. 223b, 224a
du
LAC
126
-
B9b
(1)
Cf. Zamakhshailv
(2)
Cf.
OP-cit.
(See appendix
OP-cit-glococitptHgshimll
OP. Cit.
u
6.0o
CIL,
: U.5--, 4-11-11
IV,
I
4 C-
pol9p
)
l.
no.
236;
gfo.
:>
V,
jzerP
ji (U. %c-->
t Gtbi. Kt4
--i
statementg
42 *,
c.,.;
Pj
,d.
Gil,
%G
OP-cit-9vol-59
p. 256 ;
Z, 5, %G. d. ),
-11
C-b 61;
X;
-J
Ai L;
p. 276.
Zamakhsharl: "-i
dr.
tvol.
it
P-107 states
that
I-e
J.
t)(3) Qur'gn 2.226.
But cf. Shafills
evidence,
op. cit.,
Ioc. cit.
;
Lai
%.
Lio
jjc
6%
uke
it
..
VC1.0Jk>
kt
L; AW % C6
ot,14
GXS2
us,. I'
(.3.ku 1 (4
V
%%
Zzs
%u
Lgb
A$, L4 XL
oy. eit.
oloo. cit.
.)`
up
(5) Cf, Mshinrig
a\; Al
Ct
0
co >aAt
127
-
Fa-b al-gihar
(1)
Cf. Hashiiil,
op. cit.
e, jav
Ifo.
237
A.
ou
clUjl
qal
-Y-3
*kl);
.
ob
4 zJ e1;4
v j12,
j".
1,
xx
m
--..
_A
_A
-Aj%
%.ZJ%
JU
is
L4
.
(2) Qur'&' 58 39 4.
(3) But cf. Sliafi"i's
e-':LAC
0-%
ok;;j &-)A
QI
6941-,)1
4L.
&
U
61
L
Cb
CY% (Ivl
vo.,
kB-A;
d-Z, OU
"V,.,
O-J4%
&
'ju
".
(4) Qur'iin 58
"I
Y-5,
d3w%
%b
"; -L.u-,
(t.-O-5
6--.
L4
2.
C;--.jkw
ov"
43 aj
*c
LIP
pp#1210122
. 1cjla
0%.et-,; C.,
(7) But cf. Muzani's statementp
122 that SkCafel
U-Clt-svol-49'p.
had based
on the
following
evidence
',loc.
cit.
;9
128 -
(See
208.
p.
appendix
OP-0-11-tvol-3t
OP-cit-tlooocit*vShlr7azlq
0-cit, tfo, 234a
C k;, Wl atAl Y.:" *.j .0
...
'I dk;,.g ,
statement,
But
..
OP-011-9vol-59
's evidenceg
Cf*Slia'fi4!
op. cit.
II*
p, 266
OP. Cit.,
fo. 234b
Kit;
Cf*Zamakhshar-ip
(2)
Cf .- Zamakhsbarl-9
op. cit,
-5,1
(see
gloo, cit,,
OP-cit-tvol-59
LVj
But
4
of. SIG-fi i's
Cf-Shlr7ali,
evidence#
op. cit*gfo.
op. cit,
235a I
appendix
Shlirazli,
loo.
cit.,
9
statementv
u
(4)
b al-Aym; n
op. cit.
cy.
)
oloc, cit.
JAje V
_;,
(1)
NJ
-I
-"6
'r.,
(3)
)
2,
no,
Cf*Zamakhsharl
Ill &-
(11)
pol9t
#loc. cit.
op-cit.
p. 267
p. 20, no. l. )
234b
o.
ff
129
-
Cf. Shi-razi-,
loc. cit.
op. cit.,
y-e 6
r.,
And see Hgshiird,
:L4Lz
S.LS
4.
c-
op. cit,.,
.
G i eeu GZ-. b u
cf*Sh7afi"I's
statement,
'
4>.
cx-, -%eu4: p )-s .-- wWt au
L
Z>
s
cez.- %L.zu\., ile... aw.> 45,zgI&.q , %
%j-s
(8)
Cf. Shir7azig
iiial
op. eit.
gloc. eit,
,
zc
(3,.
t -..
til
(10)
But
ef. Shafi'gils
(ii) c:r.siirizfi
V,
'4,
'
M;
?
%.
o;,
>eL;jt! it
1CI-j
l
evidence,
op. eit.,
statementg
loc. eit.
236b,
237a
eit.
or.
pff.
va
0'0.rit,., vol. 5,
1;;
oD. eit.
gloc. eit.
pp2699270 ;
Gib 3v
t>-y
c
6.
c:
Abt
p
-e4
u
s-q
-b
.
)
-.
1%3-1%
But cf*Slrafl
cxG
*t
ils
statement,
ju
i
m
(; j %. 1
U x> !.s -p
-,
130
-
evidencei
Vol-5,
(14) Cf-shlrEzlt
OP-cit-,
6.A."
>u-
B,qb al-Ll'n
(1)
Cf. scir3zlit
-9p.
: k
'6
W12-D
e-O.
fo. 238b
--0
-1,
op. cit.
242.
gfo.
Q4
CJW'
ac,
evidenceg
o2. cit.,
Z etit
G) a.%
C:J">\s.
-t 4- >tei1& i
1
da-,
e-X>%
op-cit-, 10c-Oit-
Cf. Slirizit
op. cit,
ii;
gloo, cit,
Jut
cf, Sh7afills
statement,
P. 274
.0
od
(aW-9 vtl
%3%;,
-9
_JA
And see HishiA-9
ji
UU...
, c;itzit
cf-sldrali,
4k-m%
cjl
Iococit,
J,
atz
9
(Xi.
e-y
li)
0'P-eit-tvol-59
statement,
p. 273
OP-cit-ovol-59
Nl
cit.,,
&--,
,- 9y
131
-
evidencet
Qur"Rn.
(See P-130t
loc.
OP-cit-ovol-5.
)
2.
no,
cit.
U"
G'
;a
..:; A%
Z. l
But
(8)
cf-. Slia'fi!
's statementt
'But cf-Sh7afi4lils
op. cit.
evidence,
5, p. 273
*(See
OP-cit-svol.
(See P-1309
olooocit.,
2t P-376.
tvol,
P-130g
(See appeadix
)
j.
no.
)
2.
no.
)
20t
2,
p.
no,
(10), See,
above p. 40t no, 21 ,
(11)
bkA%
'3 ,
ov ->l
.r. e., 41 it) b%A%
BUt cf. SlGafills
OP-cit -Pvol-59
statementp
%J,
31
'L
6
Y:>f
41AJ
Xe Z':
I
C,.
p. 280;
6'>\.l
J!;
ez-10
kii, swo
61;
-Aj
Cup)
U'l
JLI-.
d51
)
CI;
10
ak
0
(13)-Cf.
Sh7lrR2lq
op. citotloce
cite
0-111
v
VoI-lp
P-521.
132
-
Kiiab
(1)
Cf. ZamakhshaA0
(2)
op. cit.
op. cit.
pfo.
ILadd al-Qadhf
tloo.
(See appendix
o
cit.
275a
G-
VS'
(3)
Cf. S17irEzip
op. cit.,
d
9;
p. 209 no-3-)
loc.
cit.
Vol
a-!
-.-t ,
statementf
p. 286 I
OP-cit-ovol-59
Lit
(1) U. Stdia-zit
op. cit.
25a
ifo.
Ct
statement,
'vol-5p
OP-cit-,
..
p, 202 I
At
ot. cit.,
fo. 245a
Y-P
cy-,
,
vi"J
3u.;,
>Q
(5,
"
.
-4
zr--:
But cf. Shgfi'lls,
statemento
I
C:
-
to
t.
.j
4?A G)IO
Z.4k-s%ce C)
e >
,e16*
G--%II ->..
%
%
;%
>
e
%xall
-,
,It-; swj \.oj6
(;-. -,V
.%.:
133
-
p. 205
evidencet 02-cit-ovol-5,
C4
*'
'o
ZZIIl
tj-j\
skz
(! W-
u: >I\
cjy.
--
,
oz;
6,; k.;
evidenceg
CA Qx,
statement,
'it
3.9
s
OU
A
\,6, 1>-Vo IA!
L&
p. 214 I
OP-cit-tvol-59
4
CY.
J%
yv,
-.
k4Z,
e,.
ovlo, ,
tea
ShEfi"Els
l'
Cr
ShEfillo
'04.54C.
W
;;
%A%
cr
>,
c
7,
14 cr. L-J.
op, cit.,
p, 215
IDP-cit- ovol-5,
6361%>`
4
),
"'
-O,
U-,
y
1 u;
\-A W-
6?.
W4'
C'.t,>
\A e?
CjU>
loc, cit,
Cf. Sldia-Ti,
ol. cit.
tfo.
247a
-4/
But
Sla-fills-statemeritq
cf.
,
CAK---%
\"s
cAp
a
(9)
,
2%
p. 200
OP-cit-ovol-5,
C-' "I
%:>io
U-10
evidence,
Cl
e% 6\.;
'dl
oR. cit.
40
I q02JI
JV
%I A-k
gloo. cit.
I C%6% tt
CA cuk4"L
ovo
I.,
- 134 -
(10)
Cf.
Shirizig
or. Cit.
plocoeite
tju
(J)
op. cit.
247b
gfo,
Ly-,.!,
j. )l
op. cit.
#fo.
251
i's
Shafi
But
cf,
.
statementg
op-r-i't. 9 vol. 5p p, 23
,.
"->
cy
it
c' -> Sldrizlij f>-
, (i
2Zcitgloce0it
OP-cit-PIOC-cit,
9.
,
A. (,;0, -., %,
c :, u vi
4
ow
0.
.
43-;
011
C'kkA.
L)-;,
-t
0-11
loc. cit.
vol. 21 p. 1075
4 uUJI
-e
cup)
du
op. cit.
(See
121,
p.
appendix
p. 219 no. l. )
248a
pfo.
Cc.
And see 10shimil
op. cit.
gloo. cit.
-But
i's
cf-Shafi
statement,
.4
O-M%
a.>\ I,
(5) Qur"a
40
Lo
46 . 15.
evidence,
OIA C>1G'4w
(7)
VA aV
'su
uw
'248b
Cf.
Sldia-zlt
op. cit.,
fo.
4
ol!. cit.
jk
vol- 5, P. 25,
-,
,g
Gm,
But
cf.
,
gloo. cit,
3
(A
<Ub
SlEfigTlo
statementl
924
&j
-l& &v
1
#,
cx; (3s &. q %1 js
au
- 135 -
Cf. rardqulnr
But cf.
this
(10)
Vol-
9 O'P-cit-o
Sh7afllls
evidence# OP-cit-ovol-5,
who bases
IOCCite
op. eit.,
10
p*23t
case on tradition,
Cf. Sjj-jr7aZjt
4p P- 173-
02-011-svol-59
loe. cit.
op. cit.,
evidencej
P-27 ;
Bab al-Nafagit
250a
;
ofo.
et
012-cit*tfo.
*,
j%
\*tl&-
evidence,
op. cit.
; 'Ju
G".
tioc. cit,
$)P--)%
athar.
?
- -z-t-
pp. cit.
%:g
oloocit.
%I .1i
statement,
v01-5pP. 81 ;
& i's
Li3ultjuv
136
Kit7ib
(1)
Cf. Shlrazliq
al-lkr;
fo. 250;
op. cit.,
1&
But cf.
Muzard's
Shgft!
had said
OP-cit-tvol-59
statement,
40
Vr
no. 2-.
255a
gfo.
op. cit.
I
&
%
ywO?,
'J">1. AL;.
%NIL
-&. wI
qA
%!
3
LA
-v
">"A\
,
,
_*,
no. 2
no-32,
SIrEJ,
ShF-fi"I
L4
-1
0-.,jmi
3
Aw
\) --;
(3
i.
t OP-cit.
statementv
D-X-
c(isvi'l
-AlU
4_. j
%1\;
adlth.
tloo. cit.
Cf - Ibn klJa
Muzan-i's
had said
op-cit.
(10)
that
P-81
(9) Cf.
op. cit.
A,
lk. di"
Al:
c'.
(8)
fo. 221a
o vol.
19 p. 660.
0-41 Ut, -o
UJ
137
-
Xifib
(1)
Cf-
(See
218p
p.
appendix
Zamakhsha3::179 OP-ci+--tvol-3#
Sldr7azig
op. cit.
pfo.
4*4
ci -> (P; 1:
6, P-33 ;
45-
)
l.
no.
252
QL='iLn 5-
P-15,
Shafit'lls
rloc. cito
20.
(See
252.
1,
p.
appendix
lvol.
loc'. cit.
Shirrazio
9
op. cit.,
Cc
But cf.
Shafills
(10)
statementg
op. citvol.
d-ml
J,;
6-#r.
6z
(C...r,,>-w I s-;..
CA
\1
Ur
i
Cf*
Sld3a-zlq
6, p. 21
opocit.,
94
60
e
--- o-,:
-;
loc, cit,
A;
V-P
)
21,
2.
p.
no.
fo. 253b;
138
-
(11)
Cf. Shlralit
254a
;
tfo.
op. cit.
CS
cv-
Ov
jol
-9,
285a
But
cf,
tfo.
,
op. cit.
Shifells
statement,
k
U31IN
ZA--A!
U34%
-N
%
\A
lk>l 1>1,
1.9
Ic
G-t-.
\.
J.
%
D
d-.; -9
t ey-,
J.31* %Z>%
>v%
: %-.
(13)
9 22. eit.,
Cf-
o]2. cit.
Ibn Far4q
29 P-678
9285b
"-ovo
ai
04)
vol.
op. cit.
.-0.
CYJ
89
P-43,
ovol.
255a
fo.
9
40
-%a
LS d.., .
41
Jr I
cy
",
Lp
-r_v
uo_al
du_.
Vp
&\Jl
.
op. citegfo,
;;%j"Al u-L
us
_*f
286a -But cf, Safi i's statementl
194.
(17) Qur'Fm 42
40.
But ef.
( IL.
W)
...
SIOafftils
't
\V.
5x-,
--.
Uj\ 6v
op. eit,
evidencep
'
it
gloc, cit,
di
(jA
t
GA
Iv.
--ii 1..
> ILU--.
d-
139
-
(19)
Cf,
ze
Ibn rarh,
op-CittslOC-Cit-
t xet
-9
;, k-
JK_N
q! % Gt
t
(20) Cf.
Ti=idhi"
q OP@Citetvol
-49
p. 21
fo. 261a ;
op. cit.,
-'
oe-wd.)4z>
And see lashimli,
op. cit.
(Sk
213
But
of,
gfo.
.
Sh7afi'lls
statementp
L.,
%,
kt
M: p 6-L.
-tix;.
4,
akz
no*
Slalfiils
evidenceg olD.cit.
loo.
cit.
9
I.
(24)
fo. 261b
OP-cit.,
e-A
(25)
X.-v
Cf. Sldra-zl,
OP-cit.
9fo.
('0L. 6il
256b
Uki
But cf. Sligfi"Els
4`0
ty;
(26) cf,
statemento
oT. cit.
69 P-34
ovol.
e-l
O.OJ 4. W
-5
rc.; w, - ViLA
sidrazip
'lj
C..
-:
49
(27) Cf-Hgshirilt
f4,.
(28)
6f'. Hsh&d,
4"'.
op. cit.,
Vl
fo. 255;
....,
lu oy-9
(-4
op. cit,,,
Va\64%uke.o_;,
01
_0
gloc.
cit,
.1
(U1
.)
140
-
(29)
Cf.
Sllrazl,
op. cit.
op. cit.,
tfo.
op. cit.
256a
gfo.
256.
But cf.
SlGafills
taiementt-
6,
vol.
p. 19 ;
OvIi
ou
ai
.'
ji-e
(30) Qur"Zn 2
237.
(31)
Cf-
Sji2aii
OT).r-it.,
;
-V
:
ca
Q-.
3u-,
e
ou
t,
-oj
cs
4
- cu-!
V
u-t;
C-'-.
e:,
-%Jtt
)
si
-,
.
* j%
And see Hashimit
loc-cit-
op. cit
ploo. cito
op. cit.
fo. 256 ;
O-sp
Bat cf.
Sl;a-fi'lls
...
zu
statementrop.
it
aA%.
ks;
r. >>!..
p
;
citojlococito
Ue.
-9
GO-0
IV
4: ) 1
_91%
ukg
Cf. Dgraqulnl
no. 19.
, OP-cit-o
shifjlls
vol,
3. p. 202
6p
vol.
P-103 ;
statementg o]2.cit.,
lec).b
2;
wt
C-Itz--
C.i jxj,
w(
4!,
\4j
a.
0%
%>
,i
Cu") (J% (
o-vi
f
>.
x
fkk
A
IV.
- 141 -
no. 22.
fo. 258b
op. cit.,
j?
And see Hshirdq
op. cit.,
19 tjot&% ;;ule-
%YL
fo. 257-
op. cit.,
loo. cit.
258a
lfo.
op. cit.
lee;
4
N,
ol-aj Cko--
4,4b;oj .0
-VI
Bat cf o Muzan! 1s- stat ement
that
Sh7afi"I
op. cit.
51
vol.
p JJ. 1.139 114
,
had said
Al
(41) Cf.
ShIrEzI,
vfo.
257b
Dat cf.
4-1: -D
(42) Cf
oR. cit.
1. j
Ibn Mij a.
Cy
-11
Okt
61
vol. 29p.
op. cit.
'I,
ca
.
ak;
(isvit
889.
U*
(a
iJ
(jQ)
(jt
I,-. bu. L;
(44) See
above p. 138, -noA4.
c-u-,
...
C.
P-5Oka--p-
440
Qu-r"iin 3-- 97. -
142
-
op. cit-ploo-cit.
;
c?
k;
- ** :
,M-q -. - ill
k:
&"
691
4dv
?Q&
LA,
(50) But cf.
Slafills'evidence,
opecit.
#loc. cit.
;
jj
LQ-.
&
-9
tAl
m;-:,
-c-4p
Kifab
k-,
a-'
ZLI
'>,
(.
22. cit.,
statement,
fo. 259b ;
OU
,
And see-HXshimiq
't
Zka
aJ
o. cit.,
op. cit.,
--. t'
al-Diyya
*16
tp
1>
--aC
'
(.
Shifili's
6,
p. 99 ;
vol.
tI
(2)
But cf.
Shlfills
C; i
evidence,
9 to
10-4-A!
on-cit.,
vol.
6, p. 91
ja% Z'4 0;
C3 Ut -411Q
-*
143
-
262a
;
gfo.
2
But of.
k49
__4,
Sh7afi4i's
statementp
(A
oR. cit.
>; o
">(D,
\J cp. o'
o9
But cf.
ShRfi'lls
Iococit,
Jj
.4
Isj
14.
_j%Lg
jo; .i
(6) Cf. Tirmidhis
-Precit.,
o-P.cit.,
o-D.cit.
L-
1-4
-Y
61C
31
Vol-39
fo. 262b
or. eit.,
P-195-
oloc. cit.
J
>3
Y. >11-9
; 4,1
G-C
61A
14%
S,; u
op. cit.
264b
Ifo.
U. OL"I
But cf.
Shfiflls
bjo
statementg
okp
C3, >4jl
d;,; l
as; u
CJ-A; &
',
&; 4%
a&
01V
er.
14 r-; c
k;
p. 296
OP-cit-pvol-L
djua%
3k;
&
-Al
144
-
(10)
But
Shafi
cf.
i's
evidence,
oloc.
606
CJL4 %Z>1
Wl
op. oit.
cit.
.0
t0j,
4: j
jA
ul
w..
; 4>Sl
al; wl
(: 6JIe
Sld3;
C,
Zl,
0 I'l,
(12)
06
o:,, >
&> ;,Wl
65
Cf.
Cf.
O-N
L4
;, Uwl
LAX
aj
Op. eit.
A4
Z=akhshajlij
0A.9
910C. Cit.
I
kk%
,
,I,
Xjk?
LAC
y,,
6V,
o]2. cit.,
PP-416P 417.
vol. jj
(See appendix
)
4.
22,
no.
p.
k
s-,-b-.
-v
u;
- wi
But cf.
(14)
But cf.
(15)
Cf.
Shafllls
(3Q,
Z";
Slafills
ai'lC.
'-
loc. cito
op. cit.,
evidence,
statementv
op. cit.,
no.
Shafi7l's
6,
p. 92
vol.
dx
:
L-U
>
L..
'_'
'A
76.
athar.
evidence,
o-o. cit.
joc.
cit.
oil
Cy.
6k43
Cy.
-"f
pv
)
g.
no.
fo. 261a
(17) 1 have
not found this
But cf.
910C*Cito
>
(16) See
above p.
(18)
op. cit.
statement,
But cf.
Ul
Sla-fi'lls
(See P-143,
145
-
09)
loc. cit.
;,
uu
6v.;
Qo)
Cf.
Stdrazig
statement,
b>su-!
a-OA
But
of.
.
Slialfllla
vol. 6, P-94 ;
k
(;.!
), % i -
u-u
1 b "r. er6 G. Ll
-9
Iv
j
VC.;
fo. 265
op. cit.,
OP-cit.,
e. "
fo. 265a ;
o. cit.,
"""Au
I Nviq
$1
AI&O-N
L9
69
evidencep oR.cit. ovol.
P-93
ShEft"I's
cso-;
((Y.
)
L
,
'i
--%,
.
(22)
1 have not
collection
found
this
'
3;
(. ()C cl,
-Ill
I-.., 63.
al
hadith#,
b4t. the
hadith
: -V
as below
*
...
C-4 1.00
uu, 1.
OU;
LW
6L
op. cit.
)
2t
P-497.
Ovol.
in
exists
&
the
146
-I
Kifa'b
(2)
1 have not
appears
in
op. cit.,
found
the
fjZj-at
al-Xaf
fo. 267a
this
hadlith
but
the
following-hadith
collection
u
Cie.
4. (3m.
(See SuyUjiq
(3)
But
cf.
had said
)
2,
7.
vol.
p.
ILIq
Muzarri's
statementp
P-153
OP-cit-tvol-59
Cf.
Slia-fi!
;
J,
(4)
that
Sldrazip
opscit.,
loc.
ju
(ua%
cit,
...
't,
And see-HEhiulj
op. cit.
269
gfo.
cit.
C,
(.
.0
- 147 -
Oit; il
Kitab
(1)
Cf. Zamakhsharig
(2)
Cf. Sb7ir&zl#
OP-cit-tvol-3o
op.
al-Baphy
P-152*(See
appendix
268'a;
tfo.
-cit.
Ahl
statementt OP-cit-tvol-4t
ou-l
-011,
V, -.,
J Li
O-ul
Litz
01--
dm!.,,
LILZ,
eke%
6
eo
z-z
ds
&
0
d.A,j%&b ,I
!P.LAVO
"'. jl C-0 4,
&1
j; u, oul
cy.
di
chffl 'XI C;
-S:
-;
("LA;
-9
4
C">->!
VA,
q
Cr3,
..
45.
L9
4c. to-;
CIO
t;
(:. cjlo
ul
4!.;
'll
adlith.
evidence,
oR. cit.
plooscit.
&;
(Jowl
U>' IPuU
;,. u
C;'u
Vujl
'11;
kjaz; I
146
KitFtb
(1)
Shirazi,
Cf.
op. cit.
al-Ridda
lfo.
269b
m. 0;; 5 NJ w
But cf.
statementp
ul.
cu''
(2)
Slafells
Cf.
Sh-afils
29
P-948gvol..
gloo. cit
op. cit.
1(.. asu
Abu- Dg"dt
FlEshili,
'i
o]2. cit.
#loc. cit,,
pl
j,
.
vol. 2p P-440-
op. cit.,
Kitab
al-Jjudud
(1)
Cf.
ZamakhshaAig
op. cit,
(2)
Cf.
o]2. cit.
0-
k-.
ko"-
cit.
tloc.
tSldia-zliq
op. cit.
statement,
: >'%
ce
(A
-o'.,
-b
% ci \--
% ut
lp
Y-",:
no. 19.
02-cit-ovol-99
P-4163,.
See above p. -9 ,
cf.
KjsjCj,
Shlfi'Ll,,
no-76.
op. cit.,
cit.
_pp.
SkZficils
1
tj
. .I
loc. cit.
oloc. cit.
evidencet
"-9
(JI
op. citeplococite
01-4. )
ull%
Qe
p. 24,
#fo.
>a.. %
j
*
c. LP
>., y
L; '-)l
O-t'!
no*io)
270b
P-150
tvol-79
kA.
vim
*a,;;
a%-;
- 149 -
(8)
Cf.
Sarizit
op. cit.
910c. cit.
40
>I-
GO
And see Zamakhaharig
opeciteglococito
fo*273a
ol!. cit.,
ac-A
-!I
But
Sh2fi"I's
cf.
YlViz
ou..
c"
q
-$A
a
.-Abdul
(13) Ut
For
Barrp OP.-cit-ovol-39
cf.
SANI's
6-,, J,
-A
vol.
his
6t p. ilg
biograp'h*yg'*see
#Iocicits
V1A114C3%Oii
vxb
C.
d-N%
0,>
)c ...
Lkc
, Ae
4:,
6-9
*9%.!
at j\;
I-s-b
ULC
Liu
4"
&
.
(14) Cf. Sh-irazi,
P-1345
evidence, "it.
vol.
op. cit.,
statementt
(d.
b, Y:slik
--ou
wo
a; c , I
';
C-A
I
(31- O.J.'i ...
150
-
OU-9 C,O-Oyl
-VII
>e_
**
,,
Z>
%
%
>,
**
e >--!q
But cf.
Muzard's
SITafi"I
had-said
ti'l
...
(16) Cf.
statementg
ovol-5.
\:'
272a
gfo.
op. cit.
6--a
It.
p. 167 that
"
C)%Lq
LLiu
4
0,:
--,
Sidrazi,
PP-cit,
0,
.
>j
eu-; %:
%
-,
v, 4-;
".
kA,, \V.
0\;..
q
C,
>--SO
IL -P
But cf,
.
Sb7afi
i's
statement,
op. cit.
69
P-144 ;
gvol.
$ut
(17) Cf.
SIir7azij
loc.
op. cit.,
-,
cite
"I
jXp
(18) Cf. Sljirzlt
fo, 273b
OP.cit.,
qj%
4-
But cf,
Slaft"I's
.,
>dl
loc,
cit,
9
OIL
vol. 6, p. 121
4,Litz
A-Al
ppt! j) avit"
-1
te; am
ju
11
(20)
Cf.
Shlirgzljq
o, -,, &
utc
is
op. cit.
tloo.
e"
cit.
V-)'A %4'
;
At
xjxk;
j%
4.
151
-
271b
;
gfo.
cM
cJ
,c
But of.
41Shafi i's
4f--r-.
9,3.
jo. 3%
%I
(22) Gur'iin
(23) But cf-
24
-g
p. 169
OP-cit-tvol-7p
statementg
dk;
41
:>_V,
2-
SITaft"I's
cit.
6P.
-O
Uz
)c
a - GeV
t->3,6
%e
(3
bc,
2
>3
-, %C-ke
0
stilr7ailig
%j
(N
no. 2 ?,.
op. cit.,
(29) Cf,
(30) Cf -
(31) cf.
Sljz7al,
th18
o2. cit.
athar.
272b
;
tfo.
4P
Sq35-zli, On-cit-oloo-cit-
But cf.
Sh7afi"I's
C-.O. UW
''.
29
3'73-(See
PP-3729
appendix
pvol.
Stdrizi,
op-cit-oloo-cit-9
statementg
OP-cit-9vol-7#
"
a.
A.
m-40
1-,
lcl-";
j
-61
P-1*50
O. N
.. 6
C.
oD. cit.,
-Ift,
'Li
fo. 271a
152
-
op. eit.,
eit.
cy,
V% , ,'
(34) Ilusiim"o
Kitab
a.1-Sariqa
Zamakhsharli,
Cf.
>
).
tp2.
.1.
But cf.
SITafi"i's
The WIth
But cf-
Sh7afi'-Ils
. 1,id up
ec
...
from . All.
op. cit.,
vol. 6, P-1331
G.%l1) jj
k
GK---
Zu%
(,Lp)
loctoite
o2. eit-Ploc.
1.
jAI-5kh
>
,c
cf.
a
Zu
JJ
u
\j z>Z,...
;1.
z
e.
0-c..
(8) U-Tirmidlliv
-z
cit-;
>t.:ii
S113fi'lls
statemento
op-cit.
&
ctltj
,
ei-b
(J,
3kt
. ". -9
tO
op. cit.,
01;ji -
(t-
1Uli
>
a.
&
t\-
uI
(3u
(imt Z.!
Cf. Shlriziv
lut
crx.Zii -u
p. 245-
evidencel,
opseit..,
277a
vol. 6, P-134
op. cit.,
Sia2r-iii,
it*gfo.
op*c!
9
vol. 4# P-51is
mentioned
appendix
tu
statementg
op. cit.,
Slla
OP-cit-tvol-39
Cf,, TirmidhF,
Cf.
44 -i
P-459-(See
100*Citot
OP. Cit.,
%
it
vol. lt
( -;j i
6, P-134 ;
ovol.
%.,
9
A40,
&-.
V-9-.
vol. 4# P-53.
4
C.
...
ei
o2iNtIG
v
-;
153
-
Cf.
evidencet
Sl; ir7azi,
op. cit.,
on tradition.
case
op. cit.
Cf. ZamakhshaAit
S4razi,
Q
-;
P-302t(pee
OP-cit-tvol-39
op. cit.,
no-5-)
Ilococito
4c
*-JI
L31*;
(11)
6t
vol.
P-133 who bases
)
25p
2.
p.
no.
appendix
fo. 278b
L9
But cf.
ShZfills
4.
-Y.
** Ia4
t--7
IA3
L;
&%
z: >%
F's
Sh7afi
evidence,
"-
%l
L"
Vj%
op. cit.
...
40 Lj U41
au
gloc. cit.
",
-&
(ijvj%
%
(
C&j
--.
-
as
av;
loccito
.9
IAIJ
t-1
(14) But cf.
Sh7aXi'Fls statementg
Shifills,
evidenceq
22. eit.,
s'
t.
6,
vol.
P-139
op. citollococite
Cf.
Sjirazi,
olD. eit.,
fo. 280a
4;
-&hL"9 1,
c. -.* ji , du-9
But cf. SlZafllls
statementg
no. -76.
oR. cit.,
vol. 6, P-138
Pj
154
-
(18)
1 have not
(19) Cf.
Shifi"19
found
this
athar
Shlir7ailip
loc. cit.,
op. cit.,
opocito#loc,
cit,
*
.I"I-L;
C"jozoozc "I Lg
UI
--L2
>* uts
DOJ
((-.0.>,
(20)
e.-A _-c-.*)%
12,
PP-398-99tvol.
PP-cit.
(21) 'Abdull7ah
b. -f'UtIman
Ibn 4ajart
(d. 13 A. H. ),
Por his
bio'graphy,
see
PP-3159 316.
OP-cit-tvol-59
or. eit.,
fo. 279b
,; libx> v1 ',"
"j
-x--i
G-s- %h1
64
IL.
1-.!)
-Avano'j,
BUt ef o StrafITS.
6P Lj., Ilyj
statement,
6-)-i
el"!
ccp%-Cf
op-cit.
.9AL-,
JV
1:>%,
-Up
11
au
A; ---j.., - k&i
oc V% LoL,,
OR-cit. 100-cit,
;I
0.4A-",
't
>35
.
QpP'l
ZA,;
Q..
ovol-6 P P- 139-
op. cit.
277b
;
ofo.
-9
(1
::
tKll
- 155 -
But
4-i's
Shaf'Al.
-
of.
6%3 k,
(26)
6,
vol.
cite,
op.
P-134
statement#
: >j
But cf.
this
Shfills
Aj
evidenceg
ZOO.
43
%A
vol. 6, P-133 who bases
op. cit.,
case on tradition.
Kitab
(1)
Cf.
Shlr7aJi,
fo.
op. cit.,
Q:qt: Ca al=Tariq
281a
jp I
But
ef,
Shiiff'ills
op. cit.,
statements
(-,& 61 e 61
vol.
6,
P-140
S
-,
Sla-fi'Llls
evidenceg
op. olt.,
Is
4
i,
. ju
ou
6,
vol.
P-139
41 A'-
c C.3%
.Q14,
.
ju
; jv
916.
(3)
Cf.
cow,
;
I
(6) Cf.
But cf.
Shafill's
Ioc. cit.
op. cit.
statementt
>jzo &u
v
L.
6, P. 140
ovol.
q
A :W, (yo-eam
6atA*;,
ji
..
-6
'Ob
6v
e.
I
CD
>j
-,
j
-)*,
156
-
Cf,
Shlraziv
op. cit.
cit.
ploc.
(4
Kitab
(See
Cf.
appendix
pp.
Zamakhshwilj,
25,26p
vol. 1, p. 272t
1,
Cf . ZanakhshaAig
op. qit.
(4)
1 have
this
not
it
found
ty"
2,
qvol.
hadIth.,
Cr
Cf. Tah-awl,
op. cit.
.q
lvol.
2t
ci,,
q *tau
0,2-cit-ofo-3o6b;
P,,131 ;.
the
hadith
'as below
exists
Cf
4,
"'OvLy-%
&c
c
->,:
-.
-, lococit.
k,-- -;it
41
P-324 , Zamakhshailij
op. cit,
evidencep
tv
op. cit.,
"4 6\;
coc : A-v
4-l
C.u,
c34
40.,tu, )
j%
ey.
Ltu
Cie"
69
P-130 ;
vol.
"
cj'l
-A,
"IA%
U*%
u
P-)-s
o>k
b;
6.>Ij
'PI
x.!.
%c;s
p. 209.
but
-i
Y!. r
Sliaft"I's
Far,
(C.
(5) But cf.
Ibn
x
\..
-6,
op. cit., vol.
statementg
(3)
..
no-3-)
op. cit.,
il
al-Ashriba
(2)
: j
2-13
o't
Aet
...
m!.
-lj
t.
i,
157
-
(7)
Cf.
(8)
1 have not
found
this'ad-ith.
(9)
1 have not
found
this
(10)
Cf.
Slilrazlo
op. cit.
lvol.
29 p*294.
adlth.
gfo.
284a
Kit7ab S; l
op. cit.,
al-Pabl
fo. 269a
0-4s.
But cf.
Muzard's
P-178 that
OP-cit-tvol-5#
statement,
Sb7afe 1
had said
UA-C
Mluzalils statementp
had based
this
case
on the
tloc. cit.,
op. cit.
below
evidence
.
'L
.3u
V -o,j,-, ->
%,
that
Shfi'l
I 0-5,
3\;
.
...
aJll
158
-
Kitab
(1)
Cf.
Zamakhsharll,
(2)
Cf.
SIral.
But cf.
al-Jizya
oD. cit.
)
26,
l.
p,
-no.
292a ;a
pfo.
op. cit.
Shgfi'E's
lvol.
(See appendix
20 P-35-
statementt
49 P-105
02-bit-tvol.
616,0
(3)
Our'Zn 9,29.
P-97
evidencev op-cit-tvol-49
4b
is
6-i-jk
0-
cob k
r,
14p-,
O-U%
ov;
% %-P-
CA
Li,
u-4\
&
c,
-;
(7)
Cf.
Sfdrait
Cf.
Zamakhshar7i#
op. cit,
Cf. Zama*khsharit
gloo.
oT. cit.
op. cit,,
I
ov,
cit*
qloc. eit..
(See appendix'p.
10c, cit,
ShIrEzit
13U
op. cit,
27p no. 2. )
ofo,
291b
9 I
LjkC
-W-
-)L49:,;,
P-101
cj
u Lpf
Sq'i
\.
e
A. a,: >)% So',
+"q A
,
(JU
-AJ>Ivp
(8) Bat cf.
,
i's
Sh-afi
evidencet
ZLA
0.2--Citotloo*cito
10,
lou
\j
Lv
ul
to
4LP)
zy- (`l
- 159 -
(9)
Ibn
Cf.
j
>uk
Parhv
\i
Ul wo)
(10) See above P- 49, no.
1.9.
(11)
vol.
29 P-149.
(1)
Cf.
Zarnakhshalq
opocitoovolelt
(2)
Cf.
Zamakhshalt
op. cit.,
loc. citt.
4F
lut
PP- 525t
p
Shlrailit
I
526. (See appendix
op. cit.
tfo.
)
27,
3.
p.
no.
123b ;
i92
2,
p.
op. cit. gvol.
Jj
J., >J
Gur"iln 6 -121.
(4)
(5)
Cf-
Sldr7m]iv
Cf.
OP-cit-tl0c-cit-
A#
124a
(.
')
But cf.
Sli-afi'lls
statementg
But cf.
Slia-filils
ovidencet
02---cit-svol.
OP-cit.,
2s'P-197
vol. 2, p. 198
tio j
LS
Cf. Sldrazliq
In .
op.cite ploc.cit.
11
9v
k.,
15
1 0' w :) "'L44--
1.
111 LAO lb.;
UJI a\;"
A.,k
vi "I
16o
-
29
P-93ovol.
124b
tfo.
inc.
And see Ibn Farht
OP-cit-ovo-1-5t
-J -7
14Ct.
q
But
Muzarills
efo
.
OP-cit-tfo-318a
06
CkLo,-)
CY AJ% a
Shafi'l
had said
V-z
;
aj
4,
UIZ
LV-!3
A:o du-z-\j
statement,
ou
I A-st) Uk
Old
Ai
Cf.
Mazardt
2p P-322.
tvol.
Ibn Farh,
loo. eit.,
op. cit.,
op. cit.,
loo, eit,;
j>
(12)
Cf.
Ab7u DWidqop.
1q P. 19.
qvol.
cit.
-':
But of.
Shafi'lls
qp. cit.
statementt
>3'
2t
200
p.
I
9vol,
j:
4
-9
1
ij 0-.;G; v' c-" -9'%
Z;.2
4--
-,
.,
u
W
ce
1 r- i -Uz-9 -9 <-Z- j1 ti--;.
ec
op. cit.
1
4411
-3
%
it
e!,
o-ju,
4.
-t.'
20
gj
-: - . -*bit
..
di
(iii
29
Sldia;
198
it
p.
9
gvol.
OR.Citelloo,
cit,;
''
*
1.
VJ.,
(UP
f>JI
uu
i
j-i
-X>q
(15) Cf, Ab-u Da-wildq op. cit.
2'khi,
OP-cit-ovOl-'79
29 p. 921
ovol.
pp, 1209 121.
161
-
Y.itF. b al-Adhiya
But of.
(2)
Cf,
SlTafills
statementy
SYafills
2, p. 84.
#vol.
But cf.
29
189
p.
gvol.
op. cit.
evidenceo opocit.
gloo. cit.
Zi
.. &
L3
uz
t"
'!;
cl,.
I
(S-M e),;! kAIA
(1)-;
V&
Ls
0-M 64
-4-9
k-0 V71i
C"
C,
%
UL- ".
41
(4)
1 have not
found
collection
as below
this
adlith
but
the
adlthappears
the
in
Vj
Al-.
-')
-.,-o
(See
I
Hindi,
vol-5t
012-cit-,
op. cit.,
P-51-)
fo. 124a
A du-!
j..
o
t;
But cf.
Slia-fills
statement,
(5",
oP. cit,
'2, p. 203
ovol.
4%
>
%LA
u
.
C,
i
S.
a-z' 01> 4-M:
>
.
..
(6) But cf. SkTafi"I's evidencet 22. cit,
cit,
ploc,
.
; l
k,
"i U Gl du 'G %.
te..j>9(-J c4! q ;,ut Ct iiu: >3%
bt
U-.,
(JU
... (t
- 162 a
(7) Cf Shir7azll-
oD-r-it.
't
(8)
(9)
9loc-cit.
"Ij
iut the h.
hadith,
ad7ith appears in the
6 V-'% ,,
,&
UA-r- CP) Cis, a. --7tP. l2l. )
awl
tvol.
(See
)
198.
28t
op. cit, qvo112, p.
j.
appendix
p.
no.
(io)
cf. shlr7a-Iiqo-n.cit.,
fo. 125a
k.
But cf.
SITafi'lls
Z%;
,
(11)
(12) Qur'in
03)
But cf.
statement#
ot,.,W!.q
Cf. Zamakhshar-ig
Shgfills
op. citoplococit,
evidenceg
vleb
19.
athar.
zamakhshailt op-cit-ovolilt
op. cit.,
'L
i's
Sga-fi
21
.
Z,- Cis
P-533-(See appendix
statementg
il-k
09
C',
or. cit.
'-
2p
225
p.
gvol.
(sL
D.lut,Lw,.qt 01 e, c
Zamakhsha34,
(19) qur-in
6-
op. citeploo.
(21) Qur"Fm5-3-
cite
145.
-Y
4S
CiI clkt"4_0
A.
4-9
Cf.
)
289
2.
p,
no.
fo. 125b
(18)
au'
16 - 8.
But cf.
y "6
loc. oit.
op. cit.,
a ut>
cf.
2. p. 223 I
op. citelvol.
cy OL21r% -U-01,
b,
(%)
ou
ok-
60-0a-A7,3
%.
40
163
-
Kitab
(1)
Cf.
Zamakhshwl,
(2)
Cf.
Sl: iraz-lg
But cf.
vol, l, pp,
op. cit.,
op. cit.
Shgfills
al-Aym7; n-wa,
al-Nuclhur
p. 290 no. j. )
224b
lfo.
statement,
oP-cit-p-vol-7#
P-56
_9
1-9
But cf.
SIraff"E's
. 14
JKY
evidenceg
0,9;
-ut
(5)
Cf.
Sh! Az-i,
Ct
>V.
-9.
;
dj
U
tj
04,
b%
UG1.:
't...
c:>%\cJ, (-ob)
A,
Ioc. cit.
oD. cit.,
't
Gc
op-cit-ploo-cit.
6
(6) Cf. Muzan-i's
oPscit-tvol-59
statementg
4Shafi-i
had said
w4r twail
6
But cf.
bases
Muzan-i's statementv
this
case on the
op. cit.
following
gloc. cit.,
that
C
Shgfi4:
evidence;
L
I
\,
d--
&..
u:
O
j,
'Au
jl%l
Cy.
jo
"?.
%
0/1
&,,
-j
..
.
(-,
fC
3V
164
-
Cf.
SId-razig
(li)
Cf.
Slilira2lt
But cf.
4,
ev
-j
-
&
loc. cit.
op. cit.,
126a
gfo.
-I J\; g 4 0..,;j
Jp
-.
aA>4
oR. cit.
SliRfills
6-4 tojo.
.
op. cit.
statement,
k'.
kv)6
.'
%.
'
')
VL4
-
29
232,233
pp.
pvol.
4 1:>I-S
':;
_93
But
cf.
a-
A. j,
Sl&f: -i
Is
evidence,
j
-)X
e-s
(A.. ?
ol!. cit.
'ckj. \. 'O e
'Al
P-,, 9429.
cit--jvol-l,
IV,
4L
I'
-tj-
op. cit.,
But of.
.
5%Z23
o.
C:
J-'
Vj, "
4%;
vt-
OJ%
032-cit-iloc-cit-
Slia-fi"I's
", 4
"
(:
vol. 29 p. 800. )
as below
41
("
( See Muslim,
C-A
jpj!
-91%
-'J%
ploc. cit.
-op.
But the haCith appears in the collection
'j--)
6Q-
CJ
04
(12)
4!
bk'
,, -Z;
C)-
L)
cyr-
SI;a-fjlls
statementg
e
03A
A-es"
evidence,
L; ; j
op. cit.,
CA
(0
...
4,
100.0it.
k'J'%
C
CA
3 ce-
C)I
lu--4
-,
- 165 -
op. cit.
Iloo. cit.
a.
Kitab
(2)
Cf.
If,.
-Ipl;;
Lv,
op. cit.
cit.;
Iloo.
p
rk
Cf. Sldiraz-i,
"Ir
fo. 296a
op. cit.,
Sllrazllq
v
Adab al-QaC47
op. cit.,
fo. 294b
lool -U.-18u
And'sce
Ibn Farht
op. cit.,
6,
vol.
p. 201 ;
But cf-
Sh7afills
&. 0
ttujl
Shgfi'lls
4aL, al -,
statement,
*,
jU
AP
hadlith.
evidence,
,1-J%
Cf.
But
cf.
.
oP. cit-ofo-324b
op. cit.
KJ C..:L U
glococits
k;
K4 DA-Li &
(;
'w
oloc. cit.
oa
ev
6\&
%.,
O!
J-o
%-V
1,
-;.
Cf.
Cf.
Ibn
Farh,
k4l
gfo.
294a
OP#cit-tfo-325a-
OP-cit-tfo-325b
d,
o
V4
C.;
%
AIA;
CA-6;
V-4>:
61-OJ
OV
I
6,
>-,:!
I
j
%J
,
----
*
U-N t,:,,
- 166 -
(10)
See above
(11)
Cf.
Juwaird,
10
.
e;k
cre-
(12) Cf.
no. 16 .
p. 189
oP*cit.
gfo.
",
0'%
-,
Juwairdq
223b
op. cit.
(-' 6&:,
it g cjL ct,,4
#loc. cit.
'I
"-(!
Litz
I
1
C)-r
.
I
>-z
*9
Puz,
-
--al
- -;
(13) Our"an 65 2.
*
(14) Shafilte
jurisprudents
accounts
on this
ruling
Shirazi,
o2. cit.,
fo. 296b
Juwaird,
op. cit.
224b
vfo.
JL
fo-326b
"I
(15)'See
(16) Cf.
Sldrazl,
OP.Cit.,
IOC. Cit.
x-c 611-11tl, &; tg-11 Apj
op. cit.,
(18)
OP-011-00ja
Shlriwdq
CY
I
->
no-7,6.
U:P, ac
Cf.
- QM7tp
LAkl >
I Lai lou
loc. cit.
But of.
5''..
-L
Shafi
its
stateinentg
02-cit-tvol-7t
P-43
41
.0
167
-
Sh7afi i's
Cf.
op. cit.
tjoc, cit.
V,
)
0.
!, 6> ; s 6, x.
10
;n2
'Qur>
'(20)
(21)
ovidencog
282.
Zamakhshwiiq
P-304
OP-cit-tvol-19
(See appendix
.
P-30v
)
l,
no,
Slafi'-Ils
statementp
OP-cit-tvol-79
P-38
au
6k;
(euA%
k!
4
Jl
...
v(Jl
61
61
\;?,
dl;0.4
rL,C(11% 4---1&. 6-"(A)
(23) But of.
SlTafjlls
P-39
evidenceg OP-cit-tvol-7v
u-9
Ulu
J &,
6u"
U\,
z
t3\;
V
(J-gZ>
ILg
06-Ml
-5
6>4
cj-, V, ZJUI
-5A
But of.
,
Sha-fi i's
statement,
OP-citvpvOl-7#
P-42 ;
4 %>\JeA
(26)'Qur". in-93
(27) Khadlja.
Ibn
8.
bint,
'Abdul' Barri
Khuwailid
(d- 3 B-11.
02-cit-ovol-4t
)o
PP. 1817-1825-
isee
168
-
(28)
But of.
Sb7afi'lls
evidencel
Ioc. cit.
o-p. cit.,
l a"A
(29)
Cf.
(30)
But cf.
Shlraziq
op. cit.,
Sli-afillls
C-'
4);
'
3%;
loc. cit.
statementt
op. cit.,
vol.
A3
qh
k2
6, p. 213
(o
'
c: 4t
t)4
Shifi"E's
athar.
evidence,
op. cit.
ploc. cit.
Cj(34)
SEd
b. aLl-llusayyib
Ibn Hajart
(d. 94
OP-Cit-tvol-4p
A. H. ) . For
pp. 84-86.
p. 257-
his
biographyg
see
169
-
Kit; ib al-Daw;
But cf.
Sh-afi18
8tatementp
le
-j , , il f>:Z jj &--
0
6,
248
vol.
;
p.
9
op-cit.
a,
v5
Z.
>u
cy
1,
b (-Y%
f
di
dii"t
-,
4...
',
>,(-ss,y>u k"
012-cit-tvol-3tP-7-
OU
But cf.
Shaft"I's
statementp
vol. 6, P-275
op. cit.,
i..
%. )
j L9
C, J
--ki
29
p280.
pvol.
'o
(8)
Cf. Tirmidhr
Cfe Zamakhshwlij'
-u-cit-,
op. cit.
vol-
3, p. 627
-
2t
P-375-(See
ovol.
appendix
qS-iraz-iq =-cJ-t*qfo.
)
2,
PP039031 np.
302a I
dJ
ci
'>.,
&-'
&?
- 170 -
eShafi its
But cf,
(10)
Cf.
Zamakhsharl,
(11) Qur"in
(12)
Cf.
statement,
OR-cit-ovol-7t
P-41
24 - 4v 5.
Zamakhsha349
Sarazif
op. cit.
opgoit.
tlooscitep
U.
A'""
ploc. cit.,
AO
a.
ao\.
0-91
104
0-u-:
tp
op. cit.
cit.
floe.
Skia-fi"lp
298a
ffp297b,
op. cit.,
)I 'Au
(14) Cf. SIFirazip
Ioo. cit.
op. cit.,
dN--m
"t
'
6k;
ci
*j
cj-4
,,
&;.
rI-vG
-e.
-
-jr'i
.,
01
ok. A
Q..
II
cit.
fo-332b
g
Wl J*
(J%
CC.
But cf.
statementp
V: A'-t' OQU-41
-,
-A
. G-
C&01.r
Sh7affils
r4
ov
d%U104 %:
)1..9
V-
\j
vol. 6, p. 263
or. cit.,
et;..
A%
Ot.
-Ul
Lisk-lil ov,
ICu
I,-,
a 0.. j
46
I >!
O\
*
110.
'_L&
A^
UI
Cf.
Sh3fi'l,
loc. cit.
op. cit.,
t-y-
c,
,.,
ve
-9
k?
_xjv
-k
-4-
zu k-A9
60
wo
% N)
Ibn
Farhq*op,
ejt,,
joc, cjt,
Q#6Cju
U-. -Z
4. $
171
-
(1)
Cf.
Ibn
Farho
OP-cit-ofo-335a
Lsk;
-011
op. cit.,
statementt
li-.
av
G..
extIV,
911,1
-1
'%
q 1 &<u ta.' 0,-- e-4 G24- -. K.:
s -, C,%e
u
-9
P. 347
ce .p -, e -1,4
Cf.
2t P-351.
pvol.
(4)
X-V.ce -,j
Q-I
A
-!
691---
fo-333b
ki)
dj
See Sarazis,
ID'P-Oltfvvol.
P-344 ;-
42 (:
",
4e
eu9>;
: i, %
But cf.
Sliifills
statement,
&,
->
#
0
px>'t
u: t %--
i
..
ji
* L; v09.4
% du &.. e
LAOki
zc
And see Ibn Farho
op. cit.
tlococits
172
-
tradition
appears
as below ;
J jj
(See
(8)
Cf.
vol. 2, P-349-)
Ibn
fo-334b
Fart
OP-cit-,
6uI
L;ej-
PC
;;jl
But cf.
&. I: 6L"
Shififls
u.
"co
P-337
statementg OP-cit-tvol-79
:>>t -Y
CuA-:,
J-
J% OV
QP
dJ
But of,
Slafills
oR. cit.,
evidence'.
loc. cit,
lot
kit;
t.,5 e-t--4
r .0
Jl
C.
%6L,k-
0:>j c-ro-'A
(35:1
ou-oLy---' "-
vol-
39 p. 238
(il)
Cf. Juwaird,
op. cit.
g'fo.
(t2)
Cf.
o-n.cit.
230a
;
pfo.
Juwaizdt
"A-9
229b
"Jjtl
ONJ
a;
ex. "Ij
A>
QA;
ujA%
ko.
GV-Jil
->
-41)
173
-
Kitab
al-Mudabbar
it.
But cf.
Shfi`lls
A#
ul t.ue,.
P-348 ;
tju *u
V-5
(N
\j >3,
Ou j
bLtks.
G,
ztl
ShgfiTos
'to.,
*t
ii->
%.
X-,
G
-9
,-
OP-cit-tvol-7t
statemento
G J_e 49 iraJ oi
1.: O-,
j-105t.
CA-j
P-347 ;
evidencet on-clt-pvol-7,
0541
L4
Kit7ab al-Mk-atab
(1)
Cf.
zamakhsha3j'l
(2)
Cf,
Zamakhsharill
op. cit.
op. cit,,
es,
(3) Qur-n 24 33
-
..
29 P-387ovol.
locscit-,
PSIdia
(See appendix
-it
oj!. cit.
Qu..
4 aka--el-
-)?
'-z
statement, op-oit-rvol-7p
lfo.
NJ ; -w i
P-373
P-31 t no, l
Zu
192a
kj- 104
- 174 -
But cf.
ShEfiils
evidencev
op*.cit.
oloo. cit.
_9
51
1:
>l oo
01:
6'i,
O-ZL4j
Q. G: .
OJ
'5L. ej.
ozuj
cj
_J,
'-.
J'
OP.Cit., fo-193a
AP
4.0
Bat cf.
it
.0
Ut
Sb7afi'lfs
"t
Ir
U.-0
i &t (3v;
jtJ,
(-,
%
NO,
)1D,e,c\,
&
kmt
2-1
d
%
-q
GU %btU- I
OPA
>9
P-41?
C,;jlz.
C).
sJ
op. cit.
GIS
e Wd, y2
ll
91
tsu
cxU
t)-ki-5
.
(7) Cf. ZawaMshalv
i
A-.
6
UJI
tr
(t1...
U.2.) cu
2t P-388.
gvol.
cit.
ploc.
> x.. 3
(See appendix
Shli-aliv
OP-cit.
p
PP, 5lp3Zvno. 2. )
tfo-193b
1-9
But cf,
SIGSi"I's
statement,
o2. cit-ovol-7t
p. 364 ;
46,44
(p
10
(6
.
a-.
P -di ux,
Sh7afi"I's
Cf.
Shirazip
0'0-cil--,
su
U--
u
ve-,
lS-9
C-)%6
a.:.c t
ti
Ioc. cit.
(10)
Uil
fo-300a
ox
Aj, -
- 175 -
But cf.
that
Muzard's
statementg
pp. 266,277
OP-cit-ovol-5t
;
1.
iSis '
(11)
But of.
Muzard's
c'
Ch'
Ioc. cit.
.,
op. ci
statemento
'L
O's; 0:,:
that
Shlifi .r
evidence;
'j ILS4%
YZZ.-A ,.>'
9)
(12)
(13)
See above p.
See above p,
(14)'Cf.
Shlrazl,
169, no.
no@28
12
OP-clt-tfo-184b
it
But cf.
SITaft"T's
statementg
02-011-ovol-3v
p. 285
"'
43
it
je-9
Cb
%>3,
Cl
-K-0_9
'
Z: >
. _j-.
OP-cll-tfo-184a
3
But cf.
Muzard's
Sli7afi"'i
had
(&
op. cit,,
statement,
said
it
> Ut
.t