Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
56 (2000) 33 40
www.elsevier.com/locate/ijporl
Abstract
Background: acute mastoiditis is the most common intratemporal complication of otitis media. Its management is
still a challenge due to potentially serious consequences. This study was designed to evaluate the recent experience
with pediatric acute mastoiditis at our institution and to determine if the incidence of this entity is changing over time.
Material and methods: retrospective review of records of children with acute mastoiditis treated at the hospital of the
Medical School at the University of Porto, Portugal, between July 1993 and June 1998. Criteria for the diagnosis of
acute mastoiditis were postauricular swelling and erythema, protrusion of the auricle, and evidence of co-existent or
recent otitis media. Results: 43 patients fulfilled the entry criteria. Most were boys (69%). Ages ranged from 8 months
to 14 years and 4 months; infants represented 40% of the total. Acute mastoiditis was the first recognized sign of otitis
media in 48% of patients. More recent years of the study saw an increase in the number of children referred with
acute mastoiditis. Upon admission, 56% were under antibiotic treatment, with an average intake of 5.8 days. All
patients were hospitalized; 26 cases recovered after intravenous antibiotics plus myringotomy, and the rest required
an additional surgical procedure. The most common organisms recovered from cultures were Streptococcus pneumoniae and Streptococcus pyogenes. In our series, associated complications occurred in 13.9%; facial paralysis in one, and
involvement of the central nervous system in five. Conclusions: pediatric acute mastoiditis continues to be a potentially
dangerous infection in the antibiotic era. The incidence of this complication may be increasing recently in the
community studied. Great care is required of clinicians to reach an early diagnosis in order to promote adequate
management and prevent inherently severe complications. 2000 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Acute mastoiditis; Otitis media; Children; Complications
1. Introduction
In the pre-antibiotic era, acute mastoiditis was a
common and feared complication of otitis media,
with high rates of morbidity and mortality [1]. Up
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +351-22-5029661; fax: +
351-22-2080161.
E-mail address: j.spratley@mail.telepac.pt (J. Spratley).
0165-5876/00/$ - see front matter 2000 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 1 6 5 - 5 8 7 6 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 4 0 6 - 7
34
refers to a consequent 80% reduction in the number of mastoidectomies performed [3]. Subsequent
reports reinforced evidence of this tendency, noting that acute mastoiditis had been reduced to an
almost nonexistent event with an incidence between 0.2 and 2% [4 6]. Regardless of this optimistic trend, in recent years sporadic reports have
described possible resurgences of acute mastoiditis
[7 11]. Suggested reasons included the emergence
of antibiotic-resistant organisms associated with
incorrect and sometimes abusive use of antibiotics
[12,13]. Our study aimed to evaluate recent experience with pediatric acute mastoiditis at our institution, and to determine whether the incidence of
this complication is changing over time.
3. Results
Table 1
Distribution of mastoiditis cases by years of the study
35
Table 2
Clinical facts on admission in children with acute mastoiditis
(n= 43)
Facts
Number of
patients
Frequency (%)
39
16
43
(91)
(37)
(100)
7
43
(16)
(100)
10
(23)
21
(48)
24
(56)
36
37
Table 3
Correlation between groups of surgical procedures with mean values for fever and white blood cell count (WBC) upon admission,
and length of hospital stay
Surgical group
Temperature (C)
Hospitalization (days)
37.59 5.58
38.0 9 1.11
37.79 0.69
15.4 9 7.49
19.29 7.68
16.3 94.02
6.0 93.60
8.3 92.92
16.9 9 6.80
4. Discussion
In recent years, acute mastoiditis in children
has attracted renewed interest, and it has appeared more often in published reports. Although
most studies still note this complication of otitis
media to be rare [4 6], controversy is increasing
regarding a hypothetical resurgence of this affliction [711]. Data from two different hospitals in
the south of Portugal [10,14] have recently been
reported that indicate contradictory results concerning variation in the incidence of acute mastoiditis over a period of years. In our study, the
results are consistent with a trend towards an
increasing number of patients with acute mastoiditis in the most recent years of the study. This
is surely a basis for reflection on possible causes
for the increase.
In a retrospective review like ours, we can only
speculate on explanations for this recent tendency.
The use of broad-spectrum antibiotics as initial
treatment for acute otitis media, a rather common
practice in our country, might play a role in
selecting resistant microorganisms. Our series, in
38
39
Five patients in this study who underwent moderate surgical treatment were managed with antibiotics, myringotomy, and drainage of the
subperiosteal abscess without mastoidectomy.
These children were all younger than 2 years old,
and their mean values for fever and WBC were
proportionally higher than to those for patients
treated differently. This favoured the decision towards immediate drainage of the abscess along
with myringotomy upon admission, which proved
to be successful in these cases.
Mastoidectomy is always a delicate procedure
in infants. Whenever possible our decision to perform it in a small or absent retroauricular abscess
was deferred for 2448 h after adequate antibiotherapy, during which we implemented watchful
clinical monitoring including further imaging.
Hawkins and co-workers [17] based their decision
to operate on clinical grounds alone. Although
clinical indicators still hold as basic indications
for surgery, CT-images now play a relevant role
in assisting that decision.
Our overall impression is not absolutely pessimistic considering results obtained currently
with state-of-the-art management of acute mastoiditis, when adequate treatment is instituted.
But our data should raise concern about future
attitudes toward prevention of resurgence of this
potentially serious otologic infection.
5. Conclusions
We conclude from this study that acute mastoiditis affects young children especially, and in a
considerable number of cases without a previous
history of otitis media. With appropriate followup, acute mastoiditis without subperiosteal abscess or co-existing complications may be curable
with use of intravenous antibiotics and myringotomy. In older children presenting with acute
mastoiditis, it is important to exclude
cholesteatoma. Finally, we should stress that pediatric acute mastoiditis continues to be a problem
today, possibly regaining an importance it has
had in the past. It presents significant morbidity
and potential mortality. Great care is required of
pediatricians and otorhinolaryngologists to reach
40
Acknowledgements
This study was supported in part by grant No.
109/99 from the Comissao de Fomento da Investigacao em Cuidados de Saude, Ministerio da
Saude de Portugal. The work of Ginny Hansen in
editing the manuscript is highly appreciated.
References
[1] C. Bluestone, J. Klein, Intratemporal complications and
sequelae of otitis media, in: C. Bluestone, S. Stool, M.
Kenna (Eds.), Pediatric Otolaryngology, vol. 2, third
ed., W.B. Saunders, Philadelphia, PA, 1996, pp. 618
623.
[2] D. Fliss, A. Leiberman, R. Dagan, Acute and chronic
mastoiditis in children, in: Advances in Pediatric Infectious Diseases, Mosby Year-Book, 3, 1998, pp. 165
185.
[3] H. House, Acute otitis media. A comparative study of
the results obtained in therapy before and after the introduction of the sulfonamide compounds, Arch. Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. 43 (1946) 371378.
[4] T. Palva, H. Virtanen, H. Makinen, Acute and latent
mastoiditis in children, J. Laryngol. Otol. 99 (1985)
127 136.
[5] G. Giebink, D. Canafax, Controversies in the management of acute otitis media, in: S. Aronof, W. Hughes,
S. Kohl, W. Speck, E. Wald (Eds.), Advances in Pediatric Infectious Diseases, Year Book Medical Publishers,
Chicago, 1988, pp. 4763.
[6] J. Spiegel, R. Lawrence, M. Lustig, K. Lee, A. Murr,
R. Schindler, Contemporary presentation and management of a spectrum of mastoid abscesses, Laryngoscope
108 (1998) 822 828.
[7] H. Zoeller, Acute mastoiditis and its complications: a
changing trend, South Med. J. 65 (1972) 477480.
[8] J. Ogle, B. Lauer, Acute mastoiditis-diagnosis and complications, AJDC 140 (1986) 11781182.
[9] M. Richier, B. Choulot, J. Petriat, J. Pradoura, A.
Barthelme, Saint-Martin, et al., Mastodite aigue de
lenfant: existe-t-il une recrudescence actuelle?, Arch. Pediatr. 1 (1994) 959 961.
[10] A. Neto, P. Flores, C. Ruah, E. Sousa, P. Pereira, F.
Noronha, et al., Mastoidites agudas na crianca, Acta
Medica Portuguesa 11 (1998) 643647.
.