Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Sale
Bailment
Possession
Possession of goods is
transferred to the buyer.
Possession of goods is
transferred to the bailee.
Ownership
Ownership is transferred
to the buyer.
Usage
Return
There is no return of
goods from the buyer to
the seller, unless there is
breach.
Consideration
The consideration is an
undertaking to return the
goods after the
accomplishment of the
purpose.
Charges
Duration
Example: Money taken as debt from the money lender by pledging gold as security against it is
an example of Pledge.
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
BAILMENT
PLEDGE
Meaning
Defined in
Parties
Consideration
Always present.
Use of Goods
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
Purpose
BAILMENT
PLEDGE
purpose.
A false representation willfully made by a party to contract in order to mislead the other party
and inducing him to enter into contract is known as fraud.
1. Fraud is defined under Sec. 17.
2. Fraud means a misrepresentation made with an intention to cheat
3. The distinction between fraud and misrepresentation is solely on intention.
4. In case of fraud, the aggrieved party can avoid the contract even if the means to discover the
truth were available.
5. In case of fraud not only the agreement is voidable but also the aggrieved party can claim
damhges
Example: A purchased goods of Rs. 5000 from a shopkeeper B, with the intent of not paying the
money to B, this type of act amounts to Fraud.
Definition of Misrepresentation
A representation of a material fact made by a party to contract who believes it to be true, the
other party relied on the statement, entered into the contract and acted upon it which later on
turned out to be incorrect is known as misrepresentation. The representation is made
unintentionally and unknowingly, not to deceive the other party but it became a reason of loss to
the other party.
Now, the contract is voidable at the option of the injured party who has the right to avoid his
performance. Although, if the truth of material fact can be discovered by the aggrieved party in
the normal course, then the contract is not voidable.
1. Misrepresentation is defined under Sec. 19
2. Misrepresentation means a misstatement made innocently.
3. In case of misrepresntation misstatement is made innocently.
4. In case of misrepresentation if the aggrieved party has the means to discover the truth, it
cannot avoid the contract.
5. In case of misrepresentation no damages can be claimed, the aggrieved party can only avoid
the contract.
Example: A says to B to purchase his car which is in a good condition, B purchased it in good
faith but after a few days, the car did not function properly and B has to suffer loss to repair the
car. So the act amounts to misrepresentation as A believes that the car works properly but this is
not so.
Comparison Chart
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
FRAUD
MISREPRESENTATION
Meaning
The representation of a
misstatement, made innocently,
which persuades other party to enter
into the contract, is known as
misrepresentation.
Defined in
Purpose to
deceive the other
party
Yes
No
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
FRAUD
MISREPRESENTATION
Claim
Voidable
The contract is
The contract is not voidable if the
voidable even if the
truth can be discovered in normal
truth can be discovered diligence.
in normal diligence.
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
COERCION
UNDUE INFLUENCE
Meaning
Coercion is an act of
threatening which
involves the use of
physical force.
Sections
Use of
Psychological pressure
or Physical force
Purpose
To compel a person in
such a way that he enters
into a contract with the
other party.
Criminal Nature
Yes
No
Relationship
What are the differences between Rights in Rem and Rights in Personam?
Differences between Rights in Rem and Rights in Personam are as follows:
Rights in Rem
1.
2.
Example: I have a house. The people of the world have a duty not to interfere with my
possession. Nobody has right to disturb my possession and enjoyment.
3.
I have money in my pocket. I can use my money as like. The world at large has no right to
interfere with my possession.
4.
It is called real right. Converse this right; there is a duty upon every person of the world
not to interfere with others rights.
5.
6.
Patent right, copy right, etc. are the best examples for the rights in rem.
7.
8.
9.
The freedoms given in article 19 of the Indian constitution with its restrictions are the
rights in rem.
10.
Rights in Personam
1.
2.
Example: I let my house to Z-tenant. I have a right to receive rent from my tenant. This
right to receive rent from my tenant. This right to receive rent is a right in personam. The rest of
the world is not concerned with this right.
3.
y-debtor has to give me Rs. 5,000/-, who had taken from me as a hand-loan. I have the
right in personam to receive back the sum of Rs. 5,000/- from X.
4.
It is also called as personal right. Converse this right, there is a duty imposed upon
determinate individuals.
5.
6.
Purchase of good-will of business is the best example for the right in personam.
7.
8.
9.
10.
The kind of business organization in which, two or more persons agree to carry on the
business, on behalf of the firm or partners and to share profits & losses mutually. There are
three major points in this definition, they are:
Agreement There must be an agreement between partners, irrespective of oral or
written.
Profit The profit & loss of the business must be distributed among the partners, in the
specified ratio.
Mutual Agency Each partner is an agent of the firm as well as of the other partners
who carry on the business.
Definition of Company
A company is an association of persons, formed and registered under the Indian Companies
Act, 1956 or any other previous act. The following are the major features of a company:
It is an artificial person.
It has a separate legal entity.
It has limited liability.
It has perpetual succession.
It has a common seal.
It can possess property in its own name.
Some of the major distinction between partnership and a company are as follows:
1. Regulating Act:
A company is regulated by Companies Act, 1956, while a partnership firm is governed by the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932.
2. Registration:
A company cannot come into existence unless it is registered, whereas for a partnership firm
registration is not compulsory.
3. Number:
The minimum number in a public company is seven and in case of a private companies two. In
case of partnership the minimum number of partners is two. The maximum limit of members in
case of a private company is fifty but in case of public company there is no maximum limit. In
partnership the number should not exceed twenty, while in case of banking business, it should
not exceed ten.
4. Liability:
In case of joint stock company the liability of shareholders is limited (except in case of unlimited
companies) to the extent of face value of shares or to the extent of guarantee, whereas, in case of
partnership the liability of partners is unlimited.
5. Management:
The affairs of a company are managed by its directors. Its members have no right to take part in
the day to day management. On the other hand every partner of a firm has a right to participate in
the management of the business unless the partnership deed provides otherwise.
6. Capital:
The share capital of a company can be increased or decreased only in accordance with the
provisions of the Companies Act, whereas partners can alter the amount of their capital by
mutual agreement.
7. Legal Status:
A company has a separate legal status distinct from its shareholders, while a partnership firm has
no legal existence distinct from its partners.
8. Transfer of Interest:
Shares in a public company are freely transferable from one person to another person. In private
company the right to transfer shares is restricted, while a partner cannot transfer his interest to
others without the consent of other partners.
9. Insolvency/Death:
Insolvency or death of a shareholder does not affect the existence of a company. On the other
hand a partnership ceases to exist if any partner retires, dies or is declared insolvent.
10. Winding up:
A company comes to an end only when it is wound up according to the provisions of the
Companies Act. A firm is dissolved by an agreement or by the order of court. It is also
automatically dissolved on the insolvency of a partner.
11. Books:
The provisions of Companies Act, 1956 have their bearing on the preparation of accounts books
of a company but in case of firm there is no specific legal direction to this effect.
12. Audit:
3. Title:
In the case of negotiation if the transferee takes the negotiable instrument for value and in good faith,
i.e., as holder in due course, he takes it free from all defects in the title of the previous transferors.
But in the case of assignment the assignee takes the instrument subject to the defects in the title of his
assignor, even though he took the assignment for value and in good faith.
4. Consideration:
Consideration is always presumed in the case of transfer by negotiation, whereas there is no such
presumption in the case of transfer by assignment, where the burden of proof of consideration lies
upon the assignee.
From the foregoing differences it will be seen that the rights which the transferee of a negotiable
instrument by negotiation acquires are substantially superior to those of an assignee under
assignment, and it is for this reason that the method of transfer by assignment is very rarely used while
transferring negotiable instruments.
Negotiation
Assignment
presumed.
assignment.
mandatory.
mandatory.
1881
A sale is a type of contract in which the seller transfers the ownership of goods to the buyer for
money consideration. Here the relationship amidst the seller and buyer is of creditor and
debtor. It is the result of agreement to sell when the conditions are fulfilled and the specified
time is over. The following are the essential conditions regarding Sale:
1. There must be at least two parties, one is buyer and other is the seller.
2. The subject matter of the sale is the goods.
3. Payment should be made in the countrys legal currency.
4. The goods should pass from seller to buyer.
5. All the necessary conditions of a valid contract should be present like free consent,
consideration, a lawful object, capacity of parties, etc.
If the goods are being sold and the property is transferred to the buyer, but the seller is not
paid. Then, the seller can go to the court and file a suit against the buyer for the damages and
the price too. On the other hand, if the goods are not delivered to the buyer then he can also
sue the seller for damages.
Definition of Agreement to Sell
An agreement to sell is also a contract of sale of goods, in which the seller agrees to transfer
goods to the buyer for a price at a later date or after the fulfillment of a condition.
When there is a willingness of the both the parties to constitute a sale i.e. the buyer agrees to
buy and the seller is ready to sale the goods for monetary value. In an agreement to sell the
performance of the contract is done at a future date, i.e. when the time elapses or when the
necessary conditions are satisfied. After the contract is executed, it becomes a valid sale. All the
necessary conditions required at the time of sale, should exist in case of an agreement to sell
too.
If the seller rescinds the contract, then the buyer can claim damages for the breach of contract.
On the other hand, the unpaid seller can also sue the buyer for damages.
Comparison Chart
BASIS FOR
SALE
COMPARISON
Meaning
AGREEMENT TO SELL
When in a contract of
immediately, it is known
known as an Agreement to
as Sale.
Sell.
Nature
Absolute
Conditional
Type of Contract
Executed Contract
Executory Contract
Transfer of risk
Yes
No
Title
goods.
transfer of goods.
Buyer
Seller
Right to sell
BASIS FOR
SALE
COMPARISON
Consequences of
AGREEMENT TO SELL
Responsibility of buyer
Responsibility of seller
No tax is levied.
subsequent loss or
damage to the goods
Tax
time of sale.
Suit for breach of
seller
Differences Between Condition and Warranty
Definition of Condition
Certain terms, obligations and provisions are imposed by the buyer and seller while entering
into a contract of sale, which needs to be satisfied, which are commonly known as Conditons.
The conditions are indispensable to the objective of the contract. There are two types of
conditions, in a contract of sale which are:
Expressed Condition: The conditions which are clearly defined and agreed upon by
the parties while entering into the contract.
Implied Condition: The conditions which are not expressly provided, but as per law,
some conditions are supposed to be present at the time making the contract. However,
these conditions can be waived off through express agreement. Some examples of
implied conditions are:
A warranty is a guarantee given by the seller to the buyer about the quality, fitness and
performance of the product. It is an assurance provided by the manufacturer to the customer
that the said facts about the goods are true and at its best. Many times, if the warranty given,
proves false and the product does not function as described by the seller then remedies like a
return or exchange are also available to the buyer i.e. as stated in the contract.
A warranty can be for lifetime or for a limited period. It may be either expressed, i.e., which is
specifically defined or implied, which is not explicitly provided, but arises according to the
nature of sale like:
Warranty related to undisturbed possession of the buyer.
Warranty that the goods are free from any charge.
Disclosure of harmful nature of goods.
Warranty as to quality and fitness
Comparison Chart
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
Meaning
CONDITION
WARRANTY
A requirement or event
A warranty is an assurance
BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
Defined in
What is it?
Result of breach
CONDITION
WARRANTY
as Condition.
It is directly associated
It is a subsidiary provision
contract.
contract.
Termination of contract.
Violation
be regarded as a violation
of the warranty.
Remedy available to
on breach