Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
3.1
General
The purpose of the low flow analysis is to provide a general idea about the
hydrological condition of the Bengawan Solo River basin based on the available
climatic and hydrological records at the hydro-meteorological observation
network stations. The low flow analysis was carried out to estimate the low flow
conditions at an arbitrary location in the CDMP study area including Bengawan
Solo River system. The estimated low flow conditions are essential for the water
demand and supply balance calculation from the viewpoint of water supply
assessment.
A natural runoff is usually necessary for the water demand and supply balance
calculation. The natural runoff is defined as the river runoff that is not affected by
any water uses in a catchment area. The continuous natural flow is also necessary
in a time sequence of more than 20 years. The natural flow is principally obtained
based on the observed discharges with some adjustment to eliminate the
influences due to water uses.
The observed Bengawan Solo River discharges are subject to various river
structures such as dams, intake weirs, irrigation pumping stations, etc.
Furthermore, the available runoff records are more or less interrupted due to
lacking of observation (see Fig.3.1.1 of the observed daily discharge hydrographs
at Jurug, Ketonggo and Babat station and Table 3.1.1 of the monthly mean
observed discharge at major river water level gauging stations).
For the low flow analysis, it has been decided to model the hydrological process
of the basin using a computer model.
The low flow analysis and overall work flow of master planning for this study is
schematically shown as follows:
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-1
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
Water Usage
Data
Hydrological
Data
Groundwater
Level
Obs.Data
River W.L.
Obs. Data
Discharge
Obs. Data
Rainfall
Obs. Data
Climate
Obs. Data
Rainfall
Analysis
Penman
Method
Rainfall
Data
Evapotranspiration
Data
Unit Water
Requirement
Hydrogeological Data
Cropping
Pattern
Domestic
Water Use
Irrigation
Water Use
Industry
Water Use
Major
River Water
Facilities
(Dam,Weir)
Operation
Record
Maps
Soil
Hydraulic
Data
Topographic
Map
Geological
Data
Land use
Map
Soil
Map
H-Q Curve
Discharge
Data
GWL
Data
Verification
Data
Groundwater
Pump Up
Data
Surface Water
Intake Data
Geological
Map
Dam Operation
Data
Data 2
(Water Usage)
Data 1
(Rain & Ev)
Basic Data
(Present Condition)
Data 3
(Topo & Geo)
Sub-Basin Block
Division
Development of
Low Flow Analysis
Model (PLUMP)
Setting & Tuning
of Parameters
Evaluation of
Sim. Results
Data 1
(Rain & Ev)
Data 3
(Topo & Geo)
NO
OK
Completion of
Low Flow Analysis
Model
Basic Data
(Natural Condition)
Estimation of
Natural Flow
Regional
Plan, etc
Water Demand
Geological
Conditions
Water
Balance
NO
OK
Environmental
Impact
NO
NO
Evaluation
Note)
OK
Alternative Selected of
Priority Projects
Implementation
Programming
Management
Plan
LEDGEND
: Documents of Data
: Data (Input Data)
: Data Sets for Model
: Preparation/Analysis
: Predefine Process
: Decision
:Other Process
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-2
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
3.2
3.2.1
For the low flow analysis, the Tank model is generally applied to natural river
basins. However the Tank model is not suitable for the basin where the land use
condition has changed due to urbanization. Parameter values of Tank model are
required for adjustment according to the change of land uses. It was assessed that
the Tank model was not recommendable for the low flow analysis of the
Bengawan Solo River basin duly because of recent urbanization in the basin,
seasonal land uses in the cultivated area, active exploitation of groundwater, and
various water uses in the basin for irrigation and domestic purposes.
Based on the requirement of this study, a distributed numerical model is the most
suitable. However considering the data availability as well as the time limitation,
it was decided to use a lumped parameter model capable for simulating the
hydrological processes. Model parameters are physically determined (see Table
3.2.2 of the comparison of low flow analysis models).
The Bengawan Solo natural flow was estimated applying a state-of-the-art
simulation model, called the Physically based Lumped Parameter (PLUMP)
model. The analysis procedure is briefly explained below.
3.2.2
PLUMP Model
(1)
General
The PLUMP model was originally developed by Dr. Herath, Dr. Mushiake of
Tokyo University, Japan and Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. in 1992, to forecast the
changes to the main components of basin-scale hydrological cycle due to the
construction of new town and to evaluate the effect of different remedial schemes
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-3
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
Paddy/Fishpond
Evapotranspiration
Pervious Area
(forest etc.)
Pervious Area
(crop field)
Impervious Area
Intake
Surface Runoff
Surface Soil
Unsaturated Zone
Groundwater
Pump Up
Infiltration
Unconfined Groundwater
Aquifer (Saturated Zone)
Subsurface
(Inter) flow
Richarge to River
Confining Bed
Leakage to Deep Aquifers
Rainfall
Unconfined
groundwater flow
The entire river flow consists of the surface flow, sub-surface flow from adjoining
mountainous areas, and unconfined groundwater flow. There is no recharge to the
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-4
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
river flow from the confined aquifer when the aquifer water level (unconfined
groundwater level) is lower than the river bed level.
(3)
Model description
The hydrological process in a catchment (basin flow) described above is
schematically simplified for modeling dividing into the upper soil layer (soil
moisture storage) and the lower underlying aquifer (groundwater) as shown
below.
This model component of basin flow constitutes the unit of the PLUMP model.
As shown below, the model developed is a combination of process and storage
type of modeling. It implements the hydrological process in storage components
using the soil hydraulic parameters.
Rainfall
Surface
flow in
Evapotranspiration
Sub Surface
flow in
Surface
flow out
Moisture Block
Sub Surface
flow out
Recharge to
groundwater
Supply from
groundwater
Groundwater
flow in
Groundwater Block
Leakage
Groundwater
flow out
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-5
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
Computation procedure
The computation flow of hydrological process in the PLUMP model component is
schematically shown below.
Rainfall
Impervious
Area
Evaporation
Evapotranspiration
Pervious Area
Surface
retention
Infiltration capacity
Surface flow
Excess
Surface
retention
Top Soil
Groundwater
recharge
River
Flow
Groundwater flow
Unconfined
Groundwater
Confining layer
Leakage
Input to each surface layer is computed as summation of rainfall and surface flow
from adjoining blocks (for the Bengawan Solo River basin model, surface flow
from adjoining blocks is assumed to be zero). If the surface block includes paddy
field or fish pond, water abstraction (irrigation water) is also added the above
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-6
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
summation. This input is then scaled with respect to the block area and the new
surface flow and the infiltration components are computed.
The main equations are described below.
Notation
mark
area
description
unit
km
day
K0
description
Saturated conductivity
unit
cm/sec
Unsaturated conductivity
cm/sec
mm/day
kr
Relative conductivity
cm/sec
Area (km2)
mark
D in
m /s
Suction pressure
cmH2O
D out
m /s
cmH2O
Irr
Per
m /s
mm/day
cm /cm
IR (imp)
mm/day
cm /cm
Storage
mm
Effective saturation
n
area (river)
m /s
m /s
L max(river) ,
L min(river),
m /s
W (river)
Width of river
W (block )
GWL n
El.m
GWL lower
El.m
GWL max ,
GWL min
El.m
m /s
mm/day
3
m /s
Gwf out
Dis toRiver
m /s
m /s
i)
m /s
deg.
Gwf in
L (river)
m
m
m
m
(3.2.1)
(3.2.2)
where
Din Din ( imp ) Din ( prv ) Din ( paddy )
(3.2.3)
(3.2.4)
Per Per( prv ) Per( paddy )
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
m /s
Leak
Storage coefficient
f in
Se
rech
Dun
cm /cm
-
Hor
f out
Slope
Pump
(3.2.5)
3-7
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
(3.2.6)
(3.2.7)
The surface flow (direct runoff) is divided into that generated by the impervious
area, pervious area and paddy field or fish pond area (see Equation 3.2.6).
[Surface flow from the Impervious area]
If the input to the impervious area is higher than the depression storage of the
impervious area, surplus will overflow as a direct runoff.
Dout ( imp ) R
area ( imp )
area ( block )
IR( imp )
dS ( imp )
(3.2.8)
dt
Rain
Dry
t1
t2
t3
Dry
SATURATED
Wet
t4
TIME
t1
t2
t3
SATURATED
t4
Wet
t5
t5
t4
TIME
D E PT H (m )
DEPTH (m)
t5
t3
MOISTURE PROFILE
t2
MOISTURE PROFILE
Hortonian Mechanism
(Surface flow starts at t4)
Dunn Mechanism
(Surface flow stars at t5)
G.W. Level
G.W. Level
at t1
Horton, R. E. (1933): "The role of infiltration in the hydrologic cycle". Am. Geophys., Union,
Trans., 14, pp.446-460.
Dunne, T., Black, R. D. (1970): "An experimental investigation of runoff production in permeable
soils", Wat. Resour. Res., 6, pp.478-490.
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-8
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
(3.2.9)
Hor( prv ) Inflow( prv ) Permax( prv ) *
area ( prv )
(3.2.10)
area ( block )
(3.2.11)
(3.2.12)
Inflow( prv ) Din ( prv ) R Irr( prv )
(3.2.13)
(3.2.14)
area ( paddy )
area ( block )
(3.2.15)
Dun ( paddy ) S soil ( paddy ) S max( paddy ) Inflow( paddy ) f in ( paddy )
f out ( paddy ) Hor( paddy ) E ( paddy ) rech ( paddy )
Permax( paddy ) K 0 S max( paddy ) S soil ( paddy )
(3.2.17)
(3.2.18)
ii)
(3.2.16)
dS soil
dt
(3.2.19)
where
f in f in ( prv ) f in ( paddy )
f out f out ( prv ) f out ( paddy )
rech rech ( prv ) rech ( paddy )
(3.2.20)
(3.2.21)
(3.2.22)
[Recharge to groundwater]
Recharge (infiltration) to groundwater from top soil will occur under the saturated
- unsaturated soil conditions. The time step of calculation in the model is hourly
(one hour each). Recharge (infiltration) to groundwater is expressed by,
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-9
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
rech
t 24 hr , 1
k dt
(3.2.23)
t 0 hr , 0
[Sub-surface runoff]
The sub-surface runoff (interflow) component is next estimated from the
remaining moisture storage. In this model, the sub-surface runoff is assumed as a
component of unsaturated flow belongs slope. The time step of calculation in the
model is hourly (one hour each).
f out
t 24 hr , st
sin Slope k dt
t 0 hr , 0
(3.2.24)
[Richard's equation]
The saturated - unsaturated flow is estimated using Richards formula shown
below,
k y
k x
x
x
y
y
or k z C
1 C
k z
z
z
t
[Richards (1931)3]
(3.2.25)
where
C
d
d
(3.2.26)
Unsaturated hydraulic properties are divided into two basic relations, referred to
as the soil moisture content - suction ( ) relation (pF curves) and the soil
conductivity - suction ( k ) or the conductivity - moisture content ( k )
relations.
[ relation]
For the ( ) relation, Haverkamp et.al.'s formulas is applied shown below,
Se
4
[Haverkamp et.al (1977) ]
ln
(3.2.27)
where
Richards, L. A. (1931): "Capillary conduction of liquids though porous mediums". Physics, 1, pp.
318-333
Haverkamp, R., Vauclin, M., Touma, J., Wierenga, P. J. and Vachaud, G. (1977): "A comparison of
numerical simulation models for one dimensional infiltration", Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J., Vol. 41, pp. 285294
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-10
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
Se
r
0 r
[Averjanov (1950)5]
(3.2.28)
0 r
r
ln
or
0 r
exp
(3.2.29)
1
(3.2.30)
[ k relation]
For the ( k ) relation, Kozeny-Irmay's ( k r ) formulas is applied shown
below,
k r Se n
[Kozeny-Irmay (1954)6]
r
0 r
k r
(3.2.31)
(3.2.32)
n 3 0.015
d [Mualem (1978)7]
(3.2.33)
k
K0
(3.2.34)
Therefore the ( k ) relation is expressed by,
r
0 r
k K 0
(3.2.35)
[ k relation]
From equations of (3.2.29) and (3.2.35), the ( k ) relation is expressed by,
5
Averjanov, S. F., (1950): "About permeability of subsurface soil in case of incomplete saturation",
Eng. Collect., 7.
Irmay, S., (1954): "On the hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated soils", Trans. Amer. Geophys.
Union, AGU., Vol. 35, pp. 463-467
Mualem, Y. (1978): "Hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated porous media: generalize macroscopic
approach", Water Resources Research, Amer. Geophys. Union, Vol. 114(2), pp.325-522.
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-11
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
1
k K 0
ln
(3.2.36)
Parameter n of
Mualem k
Relation Model
n
3.37
3.97
3.11
4.38
Source) Kanto Loam: Mushiake & Herath (1988), Others taken from the Mualem's catalogue (1976).
Above parameters of sand, loam and clay taken from Mualem's catalogue, and the
Kanto loam (volcanic product loam) was measured in Japan by the Tokyo
University9.
The ( ) relations (pF curves) of the representative soils are shown as follow.
Mualem, Y. [1976]: "A catalogue of the hydraulic properties of unsaturated soil", TECHNION,
Israel Institute of technology, Haifa Israel, Res.project 442, pp.100.
Mushiake, K. and Herath, S. [1988]: "Determination of hydraulic conductivity function using insitu permeability tests". Proc. 6th APD-IHAR Congress. Kyoto, Japan.
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-12
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
pF
(Log Suction =log10 ())
6
5.4
4.8
4.2
3.6
3
2.4
1.8
1.2
0.6
0
sand
loam
K.loam
clay
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
3
80%
90%
100%
iii)
GWf in
dS
rech
Pump GWf out Baseflow Leak
dt
area
(3.2.37)
GWLn GWLmin
DistoRiver
(3.2.38)
where
area ( riverbed ) L( river ) W( river )
(3.2.39)
GWLn GWLmin
Lmax( river ) Lmin( river )
GWLmax GWLmin
(3.2.40)
[Groundwater flow to lower block]
Q=Ko*A*dh/dx
GWf out
[Darcy (1856)]
(3.2.41)
GWLn GWLlower GWL GWLlower
K 0 W( Block )
(3.2.42)
2
DistoBlock
Darcy, H. (1856): Les fontaines publiques de la ville de Dijon.In: "The theory of ground water
motion and related papers." By M. K. Hubbert, Hafner, New York, pp.305-311.
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-13
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
(3.2.43)
Each block is simulated separately and forms a network representing the basin.
The number of components used to represent the basin depends on the number of
soil groups and the variations in topography as well as the degree of detail
expected.
3.3
3.3.1
3.3.2
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-14
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1
3.3.3
NIPPON KOEI
March 2001
311582515.doc
3-15
CDMP Study
FINAL REPORT
SUPPORTING REPORT No. 1