Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
GRADUATE TEACHERS
REPORT
November 2013
CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 7
INTRODUCTION 8
LITERATURE REVIEW
11
METHODOLOGY 17
QCT REGISTER DATA
19
SURVEY 28
INTERVIEWS 36
CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS 42
REFERENCES 49
APPENDICES AVAILABLE ON THE QCT WEBSITE
www.qct.edu.au
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This project, undertaken by the Queensland College
of Teachers (QCT), involved conducting research
into the attrition of recent Queensland graduate
teachers from the QCT Register of teachers. The aims
of the project were to determine the proportion of
Queensland graduate teachers whose names were
removed from the register of teachers within four years
of initially being granted registration, identify why recent
Queensland graduate teachers leave teaching, what
we can learn from their opinions and experiences and
develop recommendations for action by the QCT to
reduce the attrition rate of these teachers.
The project involved:
undertaking a literature review;
analysing data drawn from the register of teachers;
collating and analysing data obtained from a survey
of Queensland graduate teachers who were no
longer registered with the QCT; and
conducting interviews with a small number of survey
respondents.
KEY FINDINGS
The estimates in the literature of the proportion of
beginning teachers who leave the profession within the
first five years after commencing teaching in Australia
range from 8% to 50%. It is most likely that significant
numbers of beginning teachers who leave the profession
within five years of commencing teaching do not return
to the profession. Of those initially granted provisional
registration in Queensland from 2006 to 2008, 13.5%
had their names removed from the QCT Register within
four years of being granted registration.
There does not appear to be evidence that the attrition
rates of beginning professionals in teaching are higher
than rates in other professions. It is likely though that
greater proportions of talented teachers than less
talented teachers leave teaching. Teacher attrition also
exacerbates teacher shortages in specific disciplines
and some geographic areas. In particular, the literature
suggests the shortages of specialist teachers are
compounded by teacher attrition as secondary teachers
of science, special education and mathematics are the
most likely to leave teaching.
Around 20% of Queensland graduate teachers who
applied for teaching positions in state schools in
Queensland in 2011, 2012 and 2013 were appointed to
permanent positions. Due to the independent nature
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Queensland College of Teachers (QCT)
is proud to present this research report on
attrition of recent Queensland graduate
teachers. The report is the result of a major
research project undertaken by the QCT
in 2013.
This report provides valuable insight into the complex issue
of beginning teacher attrition rates and strategies that can
be pursued to support Queensland graduate teachers
in their first years on entering the teaching profession in
Queensland.
This report would not have been possible without the efforts
of a number of people. In particular, the following people who
contributed to the project and to the preparation of this report:
The Queensland graduate teachers who participated in the
survey and in particular, those who gave willingly of their
time and details of their experiences as beginning teachers
by also participating in interviews.
The members of the Project Reference Group (listed in
Appendix 6).
The Department of Education, Training and Employment
for the provision of data related to the number of
applications for teacher employment from Queensland
graduates and the number of appointments of those
applicants to permanent and temporary teaching positions.
Staff members of the QCT who assisted in drawing the
data and providing information technology support,
the writing, editing and analysis of the research report,
and the preparation and design of the final report. Most
significantly, Marilyn Cole (Senior Registration Officer) who
prepared the report, was instrumental in the design of the
survey, undertook the interviews and managed the project.
INTRODUCTION
The QCT works in the best interests
TEACHER REGISTRATION
The source of this data was the 2012 QCT Annual Report.
Additional data is presented in the QCT REGISTER DATA section
of this report.
Campus Location/s
Additional Information
Brisbane
Bond University
Gold Coast
Bundaberg
Emerald
Gladstone
Mackay
Noosa Heads
Rockhampton
Regional university.
Brisbane
Griffith University
Brisbane
Logan
Gold Coast
Cairns
Townsville
Thursday Island
Regional university.
Brisbane
Caboolture
University of Queensland
Brisbane
Ipswich
Hervey Bay
Springfield
Toowoomba
Regional university.
Sippy Downs
RESEARCH
PROJECT OVERVIEW
10
LITERATURE REVIEW
The issue of teacher attrition, particularly
for recent graduates, has been studied
extensively. The main focus of the literature
review for this project was on Australian
studies reported in the past ten years.
While accurate figures are difficult to obtain, estimates
of the proportion of beginning teachers who leave the
profession within the first five years after commencing
teaching in Australia range from 8% to 50%.
According to the New South Wales (NSW) 2012-2013
Budget Estimates Paper, the percentage of newly
appointed teachers in NSW public schools who resigned
from their position within their first five years was 9.6% in
2009, 9.1% in 2010, and 8.0% in 2011 and was forecast
to reach 10.0% in 2012 (NSW Government, 2012).
A submission from the Australian Government
Department of Education, Science and Training to a
House of Representatives inquiry into teacher education
in 2007 stated that up to 25% of beginning teachers
may leave teaching within the first five years (House of
Representatives Standing Committee on Education and
Vocational Training, 2007).
Research on beginning teacher attrition in Australia being
conducted by Dr Philip Riley and colleagues reportedly
reveals that 40% to 50% of new teachers leave within the
first five years of commencing teaching (Haesler, 2012;
Gallant & Riley, in publication).
An explanation for the absence of definite numbers
regarding teacher attrition is that there is no systematic
12
in a DETE school
2011
2419
443
2012
2219
459
20.7
431
22.8
2013
1894
Table 2 Queensland graduate teachers who applied for teaching positions with DETE 2011 2013 and the number given permanent appointments
in the year they applied (Source DETE 2013)
14
16
METHODOLOGY
The aims of this project were to analyse
18
APPROVED TEACHERS
2008
96,985
2009
98,429
2010
97,086
2011
97,098
2012
98,633
Non-State Primary
Non-State Secondary
16.9
State Primary
43.5
State Secondary
23.8
Percentage of approved
teachers in each age range
Percentage of approved
teachers in each age range
who were male
Percentage of approved
teachers in each age range
who were female
Under 25
4.4
17.4
82.6
25-29
10.8
20.4
79.6
30-34
12.3
23.1
76.9
35-39
11.4
23.0
77.0
40-44
13.1
22.9
77.1
45-49
12.0
23.8
76.2
50-54
12.1
25.7
74.3
55-59
12.0
28.5
71.5
Over 60
11.9
34.5
65.5
33.3
43.7
Female applicants
32.8
Male applicants
34.9
20
7
8
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers
granted
provisional
registration
Number of Qld
graduate teachers
granted full
registration within
4 years of being
granted provisional
registration
Percentage of Qld
graduate teachers
granted full
registration within
4 years of being
granted provisional
registration
2006
4362
3300
75.7
2007
4094
3230
78.9
2008
3683
2771
75.2
The source of this data was the 2012 QCT Annual Report.
The QCT relies on registered teachers and their employers to
update details about a teachers employment in a school.
76.6% of Queensland
graduate teachers move
to full registration
within four years.
21
Initial
registration
year
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers
granted
provisional
registration
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers
granted full
registration
as at 8 March
2013
Percentage of
Qld graduate
teachers
granted full
registration
as at 8 March
2013
2009
3,102
1,948
62.8
2010
3,321
1,549
46.6
2011
3,356
788
23.5
2012
2,993
46
1.5
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers granted
provisional
registration
2006 2012
Under 25
12,366
49.6
25-34
7,281
29.2
35-44
3,778
15.2
45-54
1,331
5.3
Over 54
155
0.6
Total
24,911
22
Number
of Qld
graduate
teachers
granted
provisional
registration
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers
removed
from the
register within
4 years
Percentage of Qld
graduate teachers
removed from the
register within 4
years
2006
4,362
509
11.7
2007
4,094
573
14.0
2008
3,683
558
15.2
Total
12,139
1,640
13.5
Initial
registration
year
Number
of Qld
graduate
teachers
granted
provisional
registration
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers removed from
the register
as of 8 March
2013
Percentage of Qld
graduate teachers
removed from the
register as of 8
March 2013
2009
3,102
459
14.8
2010
3,321
367
11.1
2011
3,356
254
7.6
2012
2,993
30
1.0
25
Percentage
20
15
10
5
0
Under 25
25-34
35-44
45-54
Over 54
Age Range
2006
2007
2008
Total
Gender
Percentage of Qld
graduate teachers
removed from the register
within 4 years
Female
3,313
382
11.5
Male
1,049
127
12.1
Female
3,081
418
13.6
Male
1,013
155
15.3
Female
2,806
415
11.3
Male
877
143
16.3
Female
9,200
1,215
13.2
Male
2,939
425
14.5
Table 12 Queensland graduate teachers initially granted provisional registration 2006 2008 and removed from the register within four years, by gender
Percentage
25
20
15
10
Male
5
0
Female
Under 25
25-34
35-44
45-54
Over 54
24
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers
removed
from the
register within
4 years
Number of
Qld graduate
teachers
who had full
registration
at the time
registration
ended
Percentage of
Qld graduate
teachers
who had full
registration
at the time
registration
ended
2006
509
276
2007
573
142
24.8
2008
558
74
13.3
54.2
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
151
147
185
86
188
118
136
Bond University
22
40
52
26
549
454
364
265
240
222
188
34
36
33
37
35
34
38
Griffith University
948
837
791
778
882
916
794
298
406
332
270
159
267
178
1,555
992
1,026
927
896
874
737
University of Queensland
452
418
329
235
285
251
299
342
573
409
360
470
428
444
11
190
162
113
153
235
168
4,362
4,093
3,683
3,097
3,310
3,348
2,982
Table 14 Queensland graduate teachers initially granted provisional registration 2006 2012, by teacher education provider
1 Bond University no longer offers initial teacher education programs. The final enrolments into an accredited teacher education program were accepted in 2009.
2 The University of the Sunshine Coasts first teacher education graduates completed their program towards the end of 2006.
483
49
10.1
Bond University
114
50
43.9
1,367
131
9.6
103
5.8
Griffith University
2,576
308
12.0
1,036
127
12.3
3,573
547
15.3
University of Queensland
1,199
167
13.9
1,324
164
12.4
363
91
25.1
Total
12,138
1,640
13.5
Table 15 Queensland graduate teachers initially granted provisional registration in 2006 2008 and removed from the register within four years, by
teacher education provider
26
SURVEY
A survey was developed for the purpose
DEMOGRAPHICS
28
Subject area
specialisation
included in initial
teacher education
program
Percentage of
male secondary
teachers who
specialised in
each subject area
Percentage of
female secondary
teachers who
specialised in
each subject area
Information
Communication &
Technology
27.3
4.1
3.6
1.4
Mathematics
29.1
14.9
Chemistry
14.5
8.1
Physics
3.6
1.4
Percentage of all
respondents who
selected this reason
from most popular
to least popular
Percentage of
females who
selected this reason
Percentage of
males who
selected this reason
49.0%
49.4% (1)
47.9% (2)
42.5%
39.8% (2)
48.7% (1)
31.1%
31.2% (3)
30.8% (4)
25.6%
30.5% (4)
14.5% (6)
25.6%
20.4% (6)
37.6% (3)
17.1%
20.8% (5)
8.5% (9)
Job security
16.6%
14.5% (8)
21.4% (5)
16.6%
17.5% (7)
14.5% (6)
10.9%
10.4% (9)
12.0% (8)
4.9%
4.5% (10)
6.0% (10)
School holidays
3.9%
3.7% (11)
4.3% (11)
2.3%
2.2% (12)
2.6% (12)
Salary
1.0%
1.5% (13)
0% (14)
0.8%
0.4% (14)
1.7% (13)
30
EMPLOYMENT AS A TEACHER
Of the 386 respondents, 287 (74.4%) had been employed
in a school at some time following completion of their
initial teaching qualification. The duration of the teaching
experience varied widely from less than one year to
more than five years.
Of the 386 respondents, 99 (25.6%) had never been
employed to teach in a school. Around half of those
(48) had actively sought but had not gained teaching
employment in schools.
Of the 287 respondents who had taught in schools,
203 were not teaching in a school at the time they
participated in the survey. When combined with the
99 respondents who had never taught in a school, this
gives a total of 302 respondents who were not teaching
in a school at the time they completed the survey
questionnaire. This represents 78.2% of the 386 survey
respondents. The remaining 84 respondents were
teaching in a school outside Queensland when they
participated in the survey.
Of the 287 teachers who had taught in schools,
238 were employed as a teacher at some time in a
Queensland school. Geographical locations of these
teachers first teaching positions in Queensland schools
varied widely. The majority gained their first teaching
appointment in the States capital city, Brisbane, or
in adjoining urban areas (Gold and Sunshine Coasts,
Logan, Redcliffe, Ipswich), as Table 18 shows.
Geographical location of
first teaching position
Number of
teachers
Brisbane
87
Gold Coast
19
19
Sunshine Coast
18
North Queensland
18
16
14
Logan
12
Darling Downs
10
(including Toowoomba)
Gained
permanent
employment
17.6%
82.4%
24.1%
75.9%
Primary
17.6%
82.4%
Early Childhood
30.5%
69.5%
Redcliffe
Secondary
41.5%
58.5%
Ipswich
Vocational Education
66.7%
33.3%
40.0%
60.0%
Total
29.8%
70.2%
Not provided
Total
238
Support activity
90.1
70.7
78.9
27.5
76.1
32.9
74.6
30.5
73.2
32.9
71.8
34.1
66.2
32.3
66.2
30.5
60.6
29.9
50.7
31.1
26.8
16.2
Table 20 Percentage of respondents who participated in support activities according to whether they had gained permanent employment in a
Queensland school or not
32
Activity
Percentage
who had
participated
in activity
Percentage of those
who participated
who felt the activity
was effective
37.0
85.2
76.5
80.8
43.7
67.3
39.1
66.7
45.4
63.9
45.0
63.6
42.4
62.4
41.2
60.2
42.9
54.9
Regular meetings with Head of Department, Principal or others for support as a beginning teacher
45.8
49.5
19.3
37.0
Table 21 Number of respondents who participated in support activities and whether or not they considered them to be effective in supporting them
as a beginning teacher
34
Somewhat
likely
Not likely
at all
(a)
....within the
next five years?
7.9%
24.5%
67.5%
(b)
....within the
next ten years?
10.6%
29.5%
59.9%
Somewhat
likely
Not likely
at all
(a)
....within the
next five years?
4.6%
20.9%
74.5%
(b)
....within the
next ten years?
7.6%
25.5%
66.9%
INTERVIEWS
Eleven survey respondents who indicated
INTERVIEW 1 SIMON
36
INTERVIEW 2 MATTHEW
INTERVIEW 3 ZOE
Zoe completed a Graduate Diploma of Education
(Secondary) at a Brisbane university in her late twenties.
She had completed a Bachelor degree around ten
years prior to that. Her teaching areas were studies of
society and environment, history and languages other
than English. Zoe taught in state and non-state schools
in several regional Queensland cities. She had been
employed on contracts and as a relief teacher and had
also been appointed to a permanent position. Zoe had a
total of one year of teaching experience.
38
INTERVIEW 4 JARROD
colleague than as someone who was my supervisor
because she wasnt my supervisor, she was just
another teacher and that was very good. So it was
just very practical information and she pointed out
things that were really useful for me but was positive
and encouraging about it at the same time.
Zoe also commented on the collegial ethos within the
school which helped her to feel supported and part of
it all.
This contrasted with Zoes experience when she was
appointed to a permanent position in another school
where there was no formal induction program for
beginning teachers and nor did she have a mentor.
Zoe felt that her experience as a beginning teacher
would have been enhanced if her teaching load was
reduced. She also felt that beginning teachers should
be given classes that were selected to allow them to
have success and improve more quickly. She felt that
some more experienced teachers had that mentality
of lets, you know, throw her in at the deep end and
she can learn to swim.
INTERVIEW 5 BIANCA
Bianca completed a Graduate Diploma of Education
(Secondary) at a Brisbane university when she was
in her mid-thirties. She had previously completed
undergraduate studies in business. Bianca taught for
more than four years in three state secondary schools
in the Brisbane area.
Bianca stated in the survey questionnaire that she had
left teaching because she felt she had not been given
adequate support as a beginning teacher.
With regard to her teacher education program Bianca felt
that it had provided excellent coverage of the curriculum
requirements for the subjects she would be teaching.
However, she would have liked more in some areas:
I would have preferred a lot more on behaviour
management, dealing with special needs students
and I would have really loved some, some additional
learning in counselling and how to support the
students when you had troubled students, how to
deal with it.
Bianca suggested that one of the issues for beginning
teachers when they are employed initially on a contract
is that they seem to be allocated the classes that other
more experienced teachers dont want:
I think when youre a contract teacher, youre given
whats left over so the permanent teachers tend to
take the cream of the crop and the contract teachers
get all the subjects that the permanent teachers dont
want. Thats the feeling that I got from my, you know,
my eighteen months / two years. it felt like the more
experienced teachers felt like they could take the best
classes and youre a new teacher so youre going to
have the challenging classes. Where really you know,
it should be a mixture or it should be the reverse.
40
SUMMARY
Bianca would have liked to have been able to observe
excellent teachers in action:
I would have loved to have had the opportunity to sit
in on, say, the classrooms of the top five teachers
in the school to see how they dealt with situations,
even if it was videoed or whatever. Just to have
something where I could have learnt some other
strategies rather than what I was hearing on the
grapevine.
One of the areas where Bianca felt supported by
colleagues was when they were willing to share
resources. However, she experienced a culture in
which there was often a lack of willingness to share.
Bianca would have liked a mentor who had a few
years more experience than she did: someone who
understood what it was like for her as a beginning
teacher and could suggest some strategies to try if she
was having difficulty with her teaching.
She participated in some online groups and found that
helpful:
I became a part of a few online groups where we
would share some of our assessment pieces and
things like that.
Bianca was surprised that there was no exit interview
when she resigned from her teaching position and
felt that it would be useful for employers to collect
information on why teachers leave teaching.
42
44
46
48
REFERENCES
Ashiedu, J. & Scott-Ladd, B. (2012). Understanding Teacher Attraction and Retention Drivers: Addressing Teacher Shortages. Australian
Journal of Teacher Education: Vol. 37: Iss. 11, Article 2. Retrieved 11 February 2013 from http://ro.ecu.edu.au/ajte/vol37/iss11/2/.
Australian Education Union, (2008). New Educators Survey 2008: Results and Report. Retrieved 5 June 2013 from http://www.
aeufederal.org.au/Publications/2009/Nesurvey08res.pdf.
AITSL (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership) (2011). Australian Professional Standards for Teachers. Retrieved 2
October 2013 from http://www.qct.edu.au/PDF/PSU/QCT_AustProfStandards.pdf.
Australian Primary Principals Association, (2007). Reports on the Experiences of Beginning Teachers. Canberra: Australian Primary
Principals Association. Retrieved 22 March 2013 from http://www.appa.asn.au/reports/Experiences-of-beginning-teachers.pdf.
Buchanan, J. (2010). May I be excused? Why teachers leave the profession. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 30(2), 199-211.
Caldwell, B. & Sutton, D. (2010). Review of Teacher Education and School Induction: First Report Full report. Brisbane: DET.
Chilcott, T. (2012). Teaching graduates face jobs struggle. The Courier Mail. Retrieved 29 January 2013 from http://www.couriermail.
com.au/news/queensland/teachers-face-jobs-struggle/story-e6freoof-1226502721506.
Commonwealth of Australia (2013). Teaching and Learning maximising our investment in Australian schools. Retrieved 17 May 2013
from http://www.aph.gov.au/parliamentary_business/committees/senate_committees?url=eet_ctte/completed_inquiries/2010-13/
teaching_learning/index.htm.
Department of Education, Science and Training (2003). Australias teachers: Australias future Main Report. Canberra: AGPS.
Fetherstone, T. & Lummis, G. (2012). Why Western Australian Secondary Teachers Resign. Australian Journal of Teacher Education: Vol.
37: Iss. 4, Article 1. Retrieved 11 February 2013 from http://ro.ecu.edu.au/ajte/vol37/iss4/1/.
Gallant, A. & Riley, P. (in publication). Early career teacher attrition: New thoughts on an intractableproblem. Teacher Development.
Haesler, D. (2012). Mass exodus of the educators. Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 14 February 2013 from http://www.smh.com.au/
national/education/mass-exodus-of-the-educators-20120805-23no4.html.
Henke, R., Chen, X. & Geis, S. (2000). Progress through the teacher pipeline: 199293 College graduates and elementary/secondary
school teaching as of 1997. Washington, DC: National Centre for Education Statistics.
House of Representatives Standing Committee on Education and Vocational Training (2007). Top of the class: Report on the inquiry into
teacher education. Canberra: House of Representatives Publishing Unit.
Jenkins, K., Smith, H. & Maxwell, T. (2009). Challenging experiences faced by beginning casual teachers: here one day and gone the
next. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 37(1), 63-78.
Joseph, D. (2011). Early Career Teaching: Learning to be a teacher and staying in the job, Australian Journal of Teacher Education: Vol.
36: Iss. 9, Article 5. Retrieved 11 February 2013 from http://ro.ecu.edu.au/ajte/vol36/iss9/5/.
Lunay, R. & Lock, G. (2006). Alienation among relief teachers servicing government metropolitan primary schools. Issues in Educational
Research, 16(2), 171-192.
Mayer, D. (2006). The changing face of the Australian teaching profession: New generations and new ways of working and learning.
Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 34(1), 57-71.
49
McKenzie, P., Rowley, G., Weldon, P. & Murphy, M. (2011). Staff in Australias schools 2010. Report to Department of Education,
Employment and Workplace Relations. Melbourne: Australian Council for Educational Research.
NSW Government (2012). Budget Paper No. 3. Retrieved 14 February 2013 from http://www.treasury.nsw.gov.au/budget_papers/
budget_papers_2012-13/bp3/2012-13_budget_paper_3.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) (2005). Teachers Matter: Attracting, developing and retaining
effective teachers. Overview. Retrieved 6 February 2013 from http://www.oecd.org/education/preschoolandschool/34990905.pdf.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) (2011). Building a High-Quality Teaching Profession: Lessons from
around the world. Background Report for the International Summit on the Teaching profession. Retrieved 12 February 2013 from http://
www2.ed.gov/about/inits/ed/internationaled/background.pdf.
Productivity Commission (2012). Schools Workforce. Productivity Commission Research Report. Retrieved 29 May 2013 from http://
www.pc.gov.au/projects/study/education-workforce/schools/report.
Queensland Audit Office, (2013). Supply of specialist subject teachers in secondary schools. Report to Parliament 2: 2013-2014.
Schuck, S., Aubusson, P., Buchanan, J., Prescott, A., Louviere, J. & Burke, P. (2011). Retaining Effective Early career Teachers in NSW
Schools. The report of a project commissioned by the NSW Department of Education and Training. Retrieved 8 April 2013 from http://
www.rilc.uts.edu.au/projects/earlycareerteachers.html.
Skilbeck, M. & Connell, H. (2003). Attracting, developing and retaining effective teachers: Australian country background report (Report
prepared for the Department of Education, Science and Training as an input to the OECD Activity). Retrieved 6 August 2013 from http://
www.oecd.org/edu/school/ATTRACTING,%20DEVELOPING%20AND%20RETAINING.pdf.
Skilbeck, M. & Connell, H. (2004). Teachers for the future: The changing nature of society and related issues for the teaching workforce.
A report to the Teacher Quality and Educational Leadership Taskforce of MCEETYA. Retrieved 28 May 2013 from http://www.
mceecdya.edu.au/verve/_resources/teachersforthefuture_file.pdf.
50
51
52