Você está na página 1de 125

Investment Strategy for

Engineers

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Money and Investing




Investment Strategy for Engineers

Roger Manzolini
November, 2010

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Disclaimer


This presentation is the creation of Roger


Manzolini and is to be used for informational use
only
Roger is not a certified financial planner nor a
financial advisor of any kind, so use of this
information is at your own risk
None of the information provided should be
considered a recommendation or solicitation to
invest in, or liquidate, a particular security or
type of security
Additional caution: My peers call me Maddog

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Portfolio Strategy Topics





Introduction
Capital Market Characteristics
 Composition
 Asset Classes
 Performance







Risk and Return

Ideal Portfolio
Stock Selection
Financial Ratios
10 Things to Know

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Characteristics of an Engineer
Per Google search
















Sales people at the local computer store cant answer any of your questions
Youve already calculated how much you make per second
You look forward to Christmas so you can put the kids toys together
You have saved every power cord from every broken appliance
You still own a slide rule and know how to use it
Youve tried to repair a $5.00 radio
You window shop at Radio Shack
At an air show, you know how fast the skydivers are falling
You see a good design, and have to change it
You take a cruise so you can go on a personal tour of the engine room
You know what http:// stands for
You spent more on your calculator than you did on your wedding ring I paid $8
You comment to your wife that her straight hair is nice and parallel
Your spouse doesnt have the foggiest idea of what you do at work
You think that people yawning around you are sleep deprived

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Characteristics of an Engineer
As observed by Roger
















Like manipulating numbers


Like doing things yourself
Creatures of habit; pretty much the same routine every day
 Work, work, work, no time to relax or play
Dont plan week-ends or vacations
Not able to dress themselves
Show limited interest in others, especially non-contributors
Tend to dislike managers
Tend to repeat themselves
Very interested in how things work
Very conservative
Not particularly interested in money
Dont like to spend money
Reluctantly trusting verify everything
Generally not active traders
More buy and hold type of investors

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Introduction
Fitting the strategy to the audience




Goals need to be established by each individual


I geared this presentation towards a typical conservative engineer
I assumed the most prevalent goal of:
 Financial success in the stock market; that is:


Consistent, market-beating returns


 Do better than the general market (10-12% annually)

Improve your return year over year


 Do better each year

Keep losses (trade) small


 Less than 1-2% of total portfolio

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Introduction
Compound Interest

480
480 $
6

0.055
0.004583333
174,103.96 $

0.116
0.009666667
1,037,198.97

Exactly what Einstein said (or even if he said anything at all) about
compound interest varies quite a bit from source to source. He allegedly
said that compound interest was:
 the greatest invention in human history
 the greatest invention of mankind
 the greatest invention of all
 the most significant invention of the 19th century
 the most powerful force in the universe

Whatever he allegedly said, the message is clear; the power of compound


interest is strong and cannot be overlooked. E.g.
 Saving $100/month for 40 years @ 5.5% grows to ~$174K
 Saving $100/month for 40 years @ 11.6% grows to ~$1M

~Twice the interest ..~Six times the result


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

Early Saver

Late Saver

($5k for 10 years; age 22-31)

($10k for 25 years; age 41-65)

age

Money
and
Investing
Early
Savings
Lesson

22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65

save
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$50,000

8.00%
interest

total

save
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$250,000

8.00%
interest

Late saver contributes 5 times as much

total

Early Saver

Late Saver

($5k for 10 years; age 22-31)

($10k for 25 years; age 41-65)

age

Money
and
Investing
Early
Savings
Lesson

22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65

save
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$5,000
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$50,000

8.00%
interest
$400
$832
$1,299
$1,802
$2,347
$2,934
$3,569
$4,255
$4,995
$5,795
$6,258
$6,759
$7,300
$7,884
$8,514
$9,195
$9,931
$10,725
$11,583
$12,510
$13,511
$14,592
$15,759
$17,020
$18,382
$19,852
$21,440
$23,155
$25,008
$27,008
$29,169
$31,503
$34,023
$36,745
$39,684
$42,859
$46,288
$49,991
$53,990
$58,309
$62,974
$68,012
$73,453
$79,329
$1,020,944

total
$5,400
$11,232
$17,531
$24,333
$31,680
$39,614
$48,183
$57,438
$67,433
$78,227
$84,486
$91,244
$98,544
$106,428
$114,942
$124,137
$134,068
$144,794
$156,377
$168,887
$182,398
$196,990
$212,749
$229,769
$248,151
$268,003
$289,443
$312,598
$337,606
$364,615
$393,784
$425,287
$459,310
$496,054
$535,739
$578,598
$624,886
$674,876
$728,867
$787,176
$850,150
$918,162
$991,615
$1,070,944
$1,070,944

15.64
8.12
5.62
4.37
3.63
3.13
2.78
2.52
2.32
2.16
2.03
1.92
1.83
1.76
1.69
1.64
1.59
1.54
1.51
1.47
1.45
1.42
1.40
1.38
1.36

save
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$10,000
$250,000

8.00%
interest
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$800
$1,664
$2,597
$3,605
$4,693
$5,869
$7,138
$8,509
$9,990
$11,589
$13,316
$15,182
$17,196
$19,372
$21,722
$24,259
$27,000
$29,960
$33,157
$36,610
$40,338
$44,365
$48,715
$53,412
$58,485
$539,544

Early saver accumulates 35% more

total
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$10,800
$22,464
$35,061
$48,666
$63,359
$79,228
$96,366
$114,876
$134,866
$156,455
$179,771
$204,953
$232,149
$261,521
$293,243
$327,502
$364,502
$404,463
$447,620
$494,229
$544,568
$598,933
$657,648
$721,059
$789,544
$789,544

Introduction
Start Early
What about at different interest rates?
Return
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%

Early Saver
invested $50k
$109,491
$236,886
$506,544
$1,070,944
$2,239,402
$4,632,883

Late Saver
invested $250k
$326,709
$433,117
$581,564
$789,544
$1,081,818
$1,593,339

Difference
in accounts
($217,218)
($196,231)
($75,020)
$281,400
$1,157,584
$3,039,544

Clue: Time and Rate of Return is critical.


Small bits of return can make a huge difference
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

11

Introduction
High Level Strategic View
Portion of money
to be managed
10% but not more
than $30K

Options used to generate money


High risk/high return (30% or more)

Investment
Portfolio

Stocks / Bonds used to grow money


Moderate risk/moderate return (8-12%)

Savings Portfolio

CDs / Treasury Bills used to


preserve / protect money (1-5%)

75-50%

15-40%

Money
Engine

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

12

Introduction
Savings Portfolio
Dividend as of
11/17/2010

Savings Portfolio Strategy


 Establish a ladder of CDs
and Treasury Bills
Generally longer term
certificates or T-Bills pay
higher premiums.
 Give up some liquidity for
2.5 times the premium

Roger Manzolini

1.04%

1.54%

1.88%

2.23%

2.57%

1.5

1.8

2.1

2.5

1-yr CD

2-yr CD

3-yr CD

4-yr CD

5-yr CD

multiplier

year 1

Buy 1-yr, 2-yr,


3-yr, 4-yr, and
5-yr CDs

year 2

Roll 1yr CD
into 5yr CD

year 3

Roll 2yr CD
into 5yr CD

year 4

Roll 3yr CD
into 5yr CD

year 5

Roll 4yr CD
into 5yr CD

year 6
and all
subsequent
years

Roll 5yr CD
into 5yr CD

October 10, 2003

13

Capital Market Characteristics


Market Composition


Stock Market
 12 Sectors


Basic Materials, Capital Goods, Conglomerates, Consumer Cyclical,


Consumer/Non-Cyclical, Energy, Financial, Healthcare, Services,
Technology, Transportation, Utilities
Each sector is comprised of a number of industries

 102 industries
 E.g. the Technology sector is comprised of 11 industries
 Communications Equipment, Computer Hardware, Computer
Networks, Computer Peripherals, Computer Services, Computer
Storage Devices, Electronic Instr. & Controls, Office Equipment,
Scientific & Technical Instr., Semiconductors, Software &
Programming
 Each industry is comprised of a number of stocks
 ~14,000 stocks
 E.g. the Computer Hardware industry is comprised of 34 stocks

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

14

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

# Stocks in each Industry

207

105

26
62
23
23
1,045
48
384
81
92
41

37
84
42
159
197
11

Roger Manzolini

90

Services

Technology

Transportation

Utilities

4
1,054

10
3,674

4
1,243

25
2,296

11
1,990

6
226

3
262

Non-Cyclicals

Consumer

12
479

Healthcare

1
90

Cyclicals

Consumer

Conglomerates

Goods

7
635

Financial

11
2,032

Energy

102 Industries
14,387
Stocks

Capital

Sectors
Basic

12

Materials

Capital Market Characteristics


Market Composition
8
406

70

37

57

122

708

78

224

11

164

28
45
44
91
25
43
15
12
83
15
8

49
27
15
175
12
79
12

83
712
202

23
52
22
127
183
2,252
43
649
201

158
33
344

101
369
76
296
38
66
49
75
19
345
57
41
102
65
46
33
26
50
11
119
16
62
57
99

34
38
49
347
28
266
17
129
272
586

43
48
20
38
66

71
27

October 10, 2003

15

Capital Market Characteristics


Market Composition
12 Sectors
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.

102 Industries

Basic Materials
Capital Goods
Conglomerates
Consumer Cyclical
Consumer/Non-Cyclical
Energy
Financial
Healthcare
Services
Technology
Transportation
Utilities

Roger Manzolini

11
7
1
12
8
4
10
4
25
11
6
3

14,387 Stocks
2,032
635
90
479
406
1,054
3,674
1,243
2,296
1,990
226
262
October 10, 2003

16

Capital Market Characteristics


Market Composition


The 34 stocks in the Computer Hardware industry


1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.

Apple Inc.
Agilysys, Inc.
Asiarim Corp
Boundless Corp
Softchoice Corp.
Canadian Energy Exploration
Inc (Tier2)
Intensity Company Inc
Concurrent Computer
Corporation
Cray Inc
Dell Inc.
Digi International Inc.
Global E-Point Inc
Gtsi Corp.
Hewlett-Packard Co
Ingram Micro Inc.
Intermec Inc
Lenovo Group Ltd S/Adr

Roger Manzolini

18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.

Metro One Dev Inc New


Insight Enterprises, Inc.
Radisys Corporation
Socket Mobile, Inc.
Steelcloud Inc
Sed Intl Holdings Inc
Secure Netwerks Inc
Silicon Graphics International
Corp
Silicon Mtn Holdings Inc
Super Micro Computer, Inc.
Softnet Tech Corp
Speaking Roses Intl Inc
Tech Data Corporation
Televideo Inc
Transnet Corp
Voltaire Ltd.
Wareforce .Com Inc

October 10, 2003

17

Capital Market Characteristics


Key points


Asset Allocation (e.g., large-cap, small-cap, bonds, )


 Asset class diversification will have the largest positive

impact on your portfolio return

The trade-off between Return and Risk


 Performance and risk are positively intertwined
 Small changes in these percentages have huge

consequences

Long term
 Long term investing is pertinent to both total return and risk

reduction

Investment style (e.g., growth, income, )


 Investment style diversification positively impacts your

portfolio return

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

18

Capital Market Characteristics


Asset Classes


Investment choices fall into three main categories


called asset classes
 Short-term investments or money market funds


Also referred to as Cash & cash equivalent assets

 Fixed Income


Loosely referred to as Bond or Fixed income assets

 Equity


Loosely referred to as Stock or Equity assets

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

19

Capital Market Characteristics


More on Asset Classes



Cash & cash equivalents


Fixed income
 Taxable bonds
 Tax-exempt bonds
Equity
 Balanced
 Large-cap Value
 Large-cap Growth
 Mid-cap
 Small-cap
 Diversified
 Global
 International

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

20

Capital Market Characteristics


Cash & Cash Equivalents


Any short term liquid asset


 Cash
 Savings & checking accounts
 Certificates of deposit
 Money markets funds (e.g.stable value fund)

Not included in most long term portfolios


 The idea of investing is to exceed the market risk rate
of return, the short term treasury rate of return
generally considered to be ~ 5%


Exceeds typical C&CE returns

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

21

Capital Market Characteristics


Fixed Income


Taxable bonds
 Short term bonds
 Long term bonds
 Bond funds

Tax-exempt bonds
 Municipal bonds
 .

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

22

Capital Market Characteristics


Balanced Equity


A type of fund that pursues a hybrid investing strategy in


order to offer investors both capital appreciation and
income generation. Balanced funds contain a mix of:
 Stocks,
 Bonds
 other types of securities.

My take is to avoid these types of


funds:
-You dont control mix
-Typically excessive fee
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

23

Capital Market Characteristics


Large-Cap, Mid-Cap, Small-Cap


Large-Cap - Stocks of companies with a market


capitalization >$5B
 Traded mostly on the NYSE
 Lowest risk; lowest return (potential)
Mid-Cap - Stocks of companies with market capitalization
between $500M and $5B
 Traded on both the NYSE and NASDAQ
 moderate risk; moderate return (potential)
Small-Cap - Stocks of companies with a market
capitalization < $500M
 Traded mostly on the NASDAQ
 highest risk; highest return (potential)

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

24

Capital Market Characteristics


Large-Cap Value


Stocks of companies with a market capitalization greater


than $5 billion that:
 Trade at discounts to book value or tangible book value
 Have high dividend yields
 Have low price-to-earning multiples or
 Have low price-to-book ratios

My take is to avoid specific value funds


but to use an index fund instead:
-Spreads risk (diversification)
-Reduces fee
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

25

Capital Market Characteristics


Book value and tangible book value



Book value is often synonymous with the net value


Book value = Assets Liabilities, where:
 Assets include
 Tangible assets
 Owned property, product inventory, cash reserves, receivables and

investments

Intangible assets
 Patents, trademarks, copyrights, and future earnings potential or

expected returns

Tangible book value


 Book value where assets include only tangible assets
 Always less than book value
 A more conservative estimate of net value

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

26

Capital Market Characteristics


Large-Cap Growth


Stocks of companies with a market capitalization greater


than $5 billion that:
 Have historically achieved measurable growth traits,

particularly characterized by:


 Strong earnings growth and
 High profitability ratios. .

My take is to avoid specific growth funds


but to use an index fund instead:
-Spreads risk (diversification)
-Reduces fee
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

27

Capital Market Characteristics


Diversified


An investment fund that contains a wide array of


securities to reduce the amount of risk in the fund
A diversified fund contrasts with specialized or focused
funds, such as sector funds, which focus on stocks in
specific sectors such as biotechnology, pharmaceuticals
or utilities, or in particular regions such as Asia or
Europe
 Maintaining diversification
 Prevents events that affect one sector from affecting
an entire portfolio
 Makes large losses less likely

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

28

Capital Market Characteristics


Global, International


Global - A fund (typically a mutual fund) that invests in


companies located:
 Anywhere in the world

International - A fund (typically a mutual fund) that invests


in companies located:
 Anywhere outside of its investors' country of residence

My take is to avoid specific Global or


International funds but to use a Global or
International ETF (index) instead:
-Spreads risk (diversification)
-Reduces fee
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

29

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Expectations


Returns based on historical results are


useful for learning and demonstrating
strategy
Historically, each asset class has produced
different returns and risks associated with
those returns
 Each class can be loosely tied to a particular

investment objective
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

30

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Data Example

Asset Class
U.S. large growth stocks
U.S. large value stocks
U.S. small growth stocks
U.S. small value stocks

Roger Manzolini

Return
1927-1969
9.3%
11.1
10.9
13.4

Return
1970-2002
10.7%
13.9
11.7
15.5

October 10, 2003

31

One-month T-Bills
Six-month Rolling T-Bills
One-Year Rolling T-Bills
Five-Year T-Notes
20-Year Govt. Bonds

Capital Market Characteristics


Return vs. Risk

Return
6.2
7.0
7.2
7.8
7.7

Volatility
1.3
1.7
2.3
6.4
11.1

Annual Return

Fixed Income Assets 1964-2002


18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0

Note: Risk can be


managed by
avoiding longer term
fixed assets
0

10

15

20

25

Volatility (Standard Deviation)

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

32

Return
3.9
5.6
11.0

Capital Market Characteristics


Return vs. Risk

US Treasury Bills
Long Term US Bonds
Large-Cap Stocks

Volatility
3.3
9.3
19.3

Annual Return

Risk and Return over 70 Years (1931-2000)


18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0

10

15

20

25

Volatility (Standard Deviation)

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

33

Return
7.0
10.1
13.6
15.3
16.2

US Treasury Bills
Long Term US Bonds
International Stocks
Large-Cap Stocks
Small-Cap Stocks

Capital Market Characteristics


Return vs. Risk

Volatility
2.9
10.8
19.1
17.2
24.1

Annual Return

Risk and Return over 25 Years (1976-2000)


18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0

Note: Higher returns


only come at the
cost of increased
risk
0

10

15

20

25

Volatility (Standard Deviation)

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

34

Capital Market Characteristics


Return and Risk relationship


Risk is an important factor in determining how to effectively manage a


portfolio of investments. Risk:
 Determines the variation in returns on the asset and/or portfolio
 Provides investors a mathematical basis for investment decisions
(known as mean-variance optimization).
The overall concept of risk is:
 That as it increases, the expected return on the asset will increase
as a result of the risk premium earned i.e.,
 investors should expect a higher return on an investment when
that investment carries a higher level of risk, or uncertainty of that
return
When evaluating investments, investors should estimate both:
 The expected return and
 The uncertainty of future returns (Standard Deviation)

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

35

Capital Market Characteristics


Risk (Standard Deviation)


Standard deviation () is a representation of the risk


associated with a given security (cash and cash
equivalents, fixed income, equity or a combination
(portfolio) portfolio of these
Recall:
 Expected result = Distribution Average +/- n




~67% probability that future return = Re +/- 1


~95% probability that future return = Re +/- 2
~99.7% probability that future return = Re +/- 3

So knowing the historical rates of return on given asset


classes and the historical volatility (), one can
reasonably assess (analyze) expected future returns

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

36

Capital Market Characteristics


Return vs. Probability
risk

return
3.3

19.3

24.1

40

low
3.9 Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
11 Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
16.2 Small-Cap Stocks16.2
Small-Cap Stocks16.2
Small-Cap Stocks16.2

68%
3.9
7.2
0.6
11
30.3
-8.3
16.2
40.3
-7.9

95%
3.9
10.5
-2.7
11
49.6
-27.6
16.2
64.4
-32

99%
3.9
13.8
-6
11
68.9
-46.9
16.2
88.5
-56.1

100

Return

50

80

Short Term Bonds

60

Short Term Bonds

40

Short Term Bonds


Large-Cap Stocks

20

Large-Cap Stocks

Small-Cap Stocks

-40

Small-Cap Stocks

-60

Small-Cap Stocks

-80
low

68%

95%

20

68%
3.9
7.2
0.6
11
30.3
-8.3
16.2
40.3
-7.9

Short Term Bonds

50
Short Term Bonds

40

Short Term Bonds


30

Short Term Bonds

20

Large-Cap Stocks

10

Large-Cap Stocks

Small-Cap Stocks

-10

10

low

Large-Cap Stocks

68%
Probability

12

-10

11

low
10 portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 1
11 portfolio 2
portfolio 2
portfolio 2
11.5 portfolio 6
portfolio 6
portfolio 6

10
10
10
11
11
11
11.5
11.5
11.5

68%
10
19
1
11
23
-1
11.5
22.5
0.5

95%
10
28
-8
11
35
-13
11.5
33.5
-10.5

99%
10
37
-17
11
47
-25
11.5
44.5
-21.5

Small-Cap Stocks
60

Return

return
9

Large-Cap Stocks

Small-Cap Stocks

-20

risk

Large-Cap Stocks

Large-Cap Stocks

Small-Cap Stocks

Short Term Bonds

99%

Probability
low
Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Small-Cap Stocks16.2
Small-Cap Stocks16.2
Small-Cap Stocks16.2

Return

Return

30

Short Term Bonds

Large-Cap Stocks

-20

50

portfolio 1

40

portfolio 1

30

portfolio 1
portfolio 2

20

portfolio 2

-20

Small-Cap Stocks

portfolio 2

10

portfolio 6

-10

portfolio 6

-20

portfolio 6

Small-Cap Stocks

-30
low

68%

95%

99%

Probability

portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 2
portfolio 2
portfolio 2
portfolio 6
portfolio 6
portfolio 6

10
10
10
11
11
11
11.5
11.5
11.5

68%
10
19
1
11
23
-1
11.5
22.5
0.5

25
20

Probability
15

Return

low

low

10

portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 2
portfolio 2
portfolio 2

Roger Manzolini

68%
portfolio 6

October 10, 2003

37

Capital Market Characteristics


Return vs. Probability
return
3.3

100

19.3

24.1

80

low
3.9 Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
11 Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
16.2 Small-Cap Stocks
16.2
Small-Cap Stocks
16.2
Small-Cap Stocks
16.2

68%
3.9
7.2
0.6
11
30.3
-8.3
16.2
40.3
-7.9

95%
3.9
10.5
-2.7
11
49.6
-27.6
16.2
64.4
-32

99%
3.9
13.8
-6
11
68.9
-46.9
16.2
88.5
-56.1

100

Return

risk

80

Short Term Bonds

60

Short Term Bonds

40

Short Term Bonds


Large-Cap Stocks

20

Large-Cap Stocks

Large-Cap Stocks

-20

Small-Cap Stocks

-60

60

Small-Cap Stocks

-80
low

68%

95%

99%

Short Term Bonds

Probability

20

68%
3.9
7.2
0.6
11
30.3
-8.3
16.2
40.3
-7.9

Short Term Bonds

50
Short Term Bonds

40

Short Term Bonds

Return

low
Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
Short Term Bonds3.9
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Large-Cap Stocks 11
Small-Cap Stocks
16.2
Small-Cap Stocks
16.2
Small-Cap Stocks
16.2

40
Return

Short Term Bonds

Small-Cap Stocks

-40

30

Short Term Bonds

20

Large-Cap Stocks
Large-Cap Stocks

Small-Cap Stocks
Small-Cap Stocks

Large-Cap Stocks

Large-Cap Stocks
10

-10

Small-Cap Stocks

Large-Cap Stocks

-20
low

Large-Cap Stocks

68%
Probability

-20
-40

return
9

12

-60

11

low
10 portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
11 portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
11.5 portfolio
portfolio
portfolio

1
1
1
2
2
2
6
6
6

10
10
10
11
11
11
11.5
11.5
11.5

68%
10
19
1
11
23
-1
11.5
22.5
0.5

95%
10
28
-8
11
35
-13
11.5
33.5
-10.5

Small-Cap Stocks

99%
10
37
-17
11
47
-25
11.5
44.5
-21.5

60

Return

risk

50

portfolio 1

40

portfolio 1

30

portfolio 1
portfolio 2

20

portfolio 2

-80

Small-Cap Stocks

portfolio 2

10

portfolio 6

-10

portfolio 6

-20

portfolio 6

Small-Cap Stocks

-30
low

68%

95%

99%

Probability

68%
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio
portfolio

1
1
1
2
2
2
6
6
6

10
10
10
11
11
11
11.5
11.5
11.5

68%
10
19
1
11
23
-1
11.5
22.5
0.5

95%

Probability

99%

25
20
15
Return

low

low

portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 1
portfolio 2

10

portfolio 2
portfolio 2

portfolio 6

Clue: Risk must be managed


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

38

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Data - Example
Historical (1931 2001) Class Performance
Asset Class

Average
Annual Return

Best Return,
Year

Worst Return,
Year

Short Term
Investments

3.9%

14.7%, 1981

-0.02%, 1938

Bonds

6.0%

42.6%, 1982

-8.1%, 1969

Stocks

13.5%

54%, 1933

-35%, 1937

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

39

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance


Performance expectation should be established based on


needs and risk tolerance
Long term and short term needs and expectations may
differ
 Therefore involve different investment strategies
When you diversify, spread your investment over a variety
of investment classes, you can smooth both
 Your expected return and
 Variance (standard deviation) on your investment
portfolio

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

40

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Benchmarks


Investment funds are measured against


benchmarks called market indexes
 A market index is a collection of securities
of a similar type (class) accepted by the
financial services industry as being
broadly representative of a particular
market segment; e.g.
Dow Jones Industrial Average (the Dow)
 Standard & Poors 500 Index (S&P 500)


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

41

Capital Market Characteristics


Some Performance Benchmarks
Index

Composition, Use

Dow

Made up of 30 major industrial companies. Barometer for the entire US


stock market. Benchmark for Funds that invest in blue-chip companies
(price weighted index)

S&P 500

Made up of 500 leading US companies diversified across 90 different


industries. Benchmark for large company US stocks. (market-valueweighted index)

Lehman Brothers Aggregate Bond

Benchmark for the overall US bond market, including corporate,


government and mortgage bonds

Wilshire 5000

Contains over 7,000 stocks and attempts to capture the behavior of the
overall stock market

Russell 1000

A benchmark for large-company US stocks. More broadly diversified


than the S&P 500 index. It has separate growth and value versions

Russell 2000

The most common index for tracking small company US stocks. It has
separate growth and value versions

NASDAQ Composite

Made up ,of mare than 5,000 US stocks, most of them small


companies. (market-value-weighted index)

Morgan Stanley Capital International,


Europe, Australia, Far East (MSCI EAFE)

Benchmark for developed foreign stock markets

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

42

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Benchmarks


Use indices to help evaluate fund


performance; but
Use the appropriate index
Dont treat them as gospel


Most are market-value-weighted and are


strongly influenced by a small handful of
companies

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

43

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Data Another Example

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

44

Capital Market Characteristics


Performance Drivers


Portfolio performance drivers (contribution


to return) have been determined to be:
 Asset allocation
91.5%
 Investment selection
4.6%
 Market timing
1.8%
 Other
2.1%

Asset Allocation is Key


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

45

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

46

Portfolio Strategy for Engineers


Classical Stock / Bond Portfolio
Classical Stock / Bond
Portfolio




Stocks

60%
S&P 500 Index


Bonds

40%
Short Term

Return

10.0%

Risk

11.2%

 Diversification is your only

67% Expectation

-1.2%

21.2%

95% Expectation

-12.4%

32.4%

99% Expectation

-23.6%

43.6%

Roger Manzolini

10.0% Annualized Return


11.2% Annualized Risk
(Standard Deviation) often
referred to as volatility
Back tested Jan 1973 through
December 2002
Can we do better?
Hint
free lunch Jim Cramer

October 10, 2003

47

Portfolio Strategy for Engineers


Diversified by Capitalization
Classical Stock / Bond
Portfolio

Diversify Large Cap /


Small Cap

30%
US Micro Cap
Stocks





60%
S&P 500 Index


30%
S&P 500 Index


Bonds

40%
Short Term

40%
Short Term

Return

10.0%

11.3%

Risk

11.2%

12.4%

67% Expectation

-1.2%

21.2%

-1.1%

23.7%

95% Expectation

-12.4%

32.4%

-13.5%

36.1%

99% Expectation

-23.6%

43.6%

-25.9%

48.5%

Roger Manzolini

Maybe
Improved Return
But more Risk
Can we do
better?
Hint
 Diversify

October 10, 2003

48

Portfolio Strategy for Engineers


Further Diversified by Growth / Value
Classical Stock / Bond
Portfolio

Diversify Large Cap /


Small Cap

Diversify Growth / Value


15%
US Micro Cap

30%
US Micro Cap
Stocks

60%
S&P 500 Index

30%
S&P 500 Index

15%
US Small Cap Value

15%
S&P 500 Index
15%
US Large Cap Value

Bonds

40%
Short Term

40%
Short Term

40%
Short Term

Return

10.0%

11.3%

12.2%

Risk

11.2%

12.4%

12.0%

67% Expectation

-1.2%

21.2%

-1.1%

23.7%

0.2%

24.2%

95% Expectation

-12.4%

32.4%

-13.5%

36.1%

-11.8%

36.2%

99% Expectation

-23.6%

43.6%

-25.9%

48.5%

-23.8%

48.2%

Roger Manzolini

Yes
Improved
Return
Less
Risk
Can we
do
better?
Hint
 Same

October 10, 2003

49

Portfolio Strategy for Engineers


Further Diversified by US / International
Classical Stock / Bond
Portfolio

Diversify Large Cap /


Small Cap

30%
US Micro Cap
Stocks

60%
S&P 500 Index

Diversify Growth / Value

Diversify US / International

15%
US Micro Cap

7.5% US Micro Cap


6.0% Int'l Small Cap
7.5% US Small Cap Value

15%
US Small Cap Value

6.0% Int'l Small Cap Value


6.0% Emerging Markets

30%
S&P 500 Index

15%
S&P 500 Index

7.5% S&P 500 Index

15%
US Large Cap Value

7.5% US Large Cap Value


6.0% Int'l Large Cap Value

6.0% Int'l Large Cap

Bonds

40%
Short Term

40%
Short Term

40%
Short Term

40%
Short Term

Return

10.0%

11.3%

12.2%

12.4%

Risk

11.2%

12.4%

12.0%

11.7%

67% Expectation

-1.2%

21.2%

-1.1%

23.7%

0.2%

24.2%

0.7%

24.1%

95% Expectation

-12.4%

32.4%

-13.5%

36.1%

-11.8%

36.2%

-11.0%

35.8%

99% Expectation

-23.6%

43.6%

-25.9%

48.5%

-23.8%

48.2%

-22.7%

47.5%

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

50

Portfolio Strategy for Engineers


The ideal buy and hold portfolio
Allocation
7.5% US Micro Cap

6.0% Int'l Small Cap


7.5% US Small Cap Value
6.0% Int'l Small Cap Value
60%
Stocks

6.0% Emerging Markets


7.5% S&P 500 Index

6.0% Int'l Large Cap


7.5% US Large Cap Value
6.0% Int'l Large Cap Value

40%
Bonds

40%
Short Term

Return

12.4%

Risk

11.7%

67% Expectation

0.7%

24.1%

95% Expectation

-11.0%

35.8%

99% Expectation

-22.7%

47.5%

Roger Manzolini

The ideal buy and hold


portfolio
12.4% Annualized Return
11.7% Annualized Risk
Re-balance periodically
 6 months or Annually

October 10, 2003

51

Portfolio Strategy for Engineers


The ideal buy and hold portfolio
60

Allocation

50

7.5% US Micro Cap

40

6.0% Int'l Small Cap

Return

30
20
60%
Stocks

7.5% US Small Cap Value


6.0% Int'l Small Cap Value

7.5% S&P 500 Index

6.0% Int'l Large Cap

-20

6.0% Emerging Markets

10

-10

7.5% US Large Cap Value




The ideal buy and hold


portfolio
12.4% Annualized Return
11.7% Annualized Risk
Re-balance periodically

6.0% Int'l Large Cap Value

low

40%
Short Term

Return

12.4%

Risk

11.7%

67% Expectation

0.7%

24.1%

95% Expectation

-11.0%

35.8%

99% Expectation

-22.7%

47.5%

Roger Manzolini

Basic
Basic
Ideal
Ideal
Ideal

 6 months or Annually

-30
40%
Bonds

Basic

68%

95%

99%

Probability

October 10, 2003

52

Introduction
Start Early


Remember this?
Return
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%

Early Saver
invested $50k
$109,491
$236,886
$506,544
$1,070,944
$2,239,402
$4,632,883

Late Saver
invested $250k
$326,709
$433,117
$581,564
$789,544
$1,081,818
$1,593,339

Difference
in accounts
($217,218)
($196,231)
($75,020)
$281,400
$1,157,584
$3,039,544

Yes, it can be done


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

53

Money and Investing


Performance Expectations



For those who have different risk tolerance


Other stock / bond allocations
Allocation
% equity
% bonds
Annualized Return
Std. Deviation
30 yr. Growth of $10k

Roger Manzolini

All Bonds
0
100
8.8
4.9
$125,653

30/70
30
70
10.8
6.9
$214,170

50/50
50
50
11.9
10
$291,452

60/40
60
40
12.4
11.7
$335,284

70/30 All Equities


70
100
30
0
12.9
14.2
13.4
18.8
$382,153 $535,075

October 10, 2003

54

Money and Investing


Equity allocation diversification


Suggested Holdings for various allocations

Allocation
Short-term bonds
S&P 500 Index
U. S. large-cap value
U.S. Micro Cap
U.S. small-cap value
International large-cap
International large-cap value
International small-cap
International small-cap value
Emerging markets

Roger Manzolini

All bonds
100
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

30/70
70
3.75
3.75
3.75
3.75
3
3
3
3
3

50/50
50
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
5
5
5
5
5

60/40
40
7.5
7.5
7.5
7.5
6
6
6
6
6

70/30
30
8.75
8.75
8.75
8.75
7
7
7
7
7

All equities
0
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
10
10
10
10
10

October 10, 2003

55

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

56

Money and Investing




Stock Selection

Roger Manzolini
November 4, 2003

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

57

Stock Selection
Topics









Whats stock?
Understand what youre buying
Companies
Company fundamentals
What to look for general
What to look for specifically
Where to look general
Where to look specifically

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

58

Stock Selection
Whats stock?


A certificate of ownership in a portion of a


company
Stock certificate
 A document representing the number of shares of

a corporation owned by a shareholder




Issued by the company as a means to raise


money

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

59

Stock Selection
Understand what youre buying


Youre buying a stake in the company. So whats it worth?


 From an accounting viewpoint, a company is worth its
net worth; that is, shareholders equity (SE)


Recall; A = L + SE; therefore, a company stock share is worth


SE / # of outstanding shares

 From a technical point of view, a company share is

worth its intrinsic value




((PV of future earnings)-(PV of debt)) / # of outstanding shares

 From a market point of view, a company share is worth

what it trades for on the open market


These measures of worth are seldom equal. Hint; buy and
hold shares where the market price for those shares is less
October 10, 2003
60
Roger
Manzolini
than the
shares intrinsic value

Stock Selection
Recognizing value
A guy sees a sign in front of a house: "Talking Dog for Sale." He rings the bell and
the owner tells him the dog is in the back yard. The guy goes into the back yard and
sees a black mutt just sitting there. "You talk?" he asks. "Yep," the mutt replies.
"So, what's your story?"
The mutt looks up and says, "Well, I discovered this gift pretty young and I wanted
to help the government, so I told the CIA about my gift, and in no time they had me
jetting from country to country, sitting in rooms with spies and world leaders,
because no one figured a dog would be eavesdropping. I was one of their most
valuable spies eight years running. The jetting around really tired me out, and I
knew I wasn't getting any younger and wanted to settle down. So I signed up for a
job at the airport to do some undercover security work, mostly wandering near
suspicious characters and listening in. I uncovered some incredible dealings there
and was awarded a batch of medals. Had a wife, a mess of puppies, and now I'm
just retired."
The guy is amazed. He goes back in and asks the owner what he wants for the dog.
The owner says, "Ten dollars." The guy says, Good God man, this dog is amazing.
Why on earth are you selling him, so cheap?" The owner replies, "He's such a lying
SOB; he didn't do any of that stuff!"

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

61

Stock Selection
Companies


Young, not yet established (highest risk; highest return potential)


 Companies that may emerge as future market leaders
 Traded over the counter OTC) and best left for the most

experienced traders with high risk tolerance




Small-cap (moderate risk; moderate to very high return potential)


 Companies with market capitalization < $500M
 Traded mostly on the NASDAQ

Large-cap (lowest risk; lowest return potential)


 Companies with market capitalization > $5B
 Traded mostly on the NYSE

Mid-cap -- you guessed it, Cos between $500M and $5B

Hint; your focus could be on Mid-cap and Small-cap


October 10, 2003
Roger
Manzolini
companies
and managing risk

62

Stock Selection
What is market capitalization?


Market Capitalization is a measure of corporate


size
 The total dollar value of all outstanding shares
 Computed as:
 Total number of shares times current market price
 Shown on trading screens along with trading

range, volume,P/E, earnings,

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

63

Stock Selection
Company fundamentals


Business structure
 Is it simple or is it very complex?
Ownership
 Insiders, institutions, common shareholders
Management
 Visionary leaders or passive caretakers
All the numbers; financial and otherwise
 Performance
 Growth
 Value

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

64

Stock Selection
What to look for - general




Simple, well defined, easy to understand businesses


Companies with insider and institutional ownership
Companies with visionary leaders, or leaders with a
demonstrated, recognized and respected performance
record
Improving trends in all numbers
 Growth trends
 Financial health
 Management performance
 Market multiples
 Intrinsic value

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

65

Stock Selection
Growth trends


Examine
 revenues (sales),
 net income (earnings), and
 cash flow
To see how well a company is translating revenues into
earnings
 necessary for growth
Look for companies whose revenues, net income, and
cash flow are
 Rising steadily, or
 At faster rates than their competitors

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

66

Stock Selection
Financial health


Long-term and total debt/equity


 compare the company's debt to its assets minus its
liabilities
Reveals how much debt is cutting into the bottom line
 The higher the debt, the more important it is to have
positive earnings and steady cash flow
 At some point, the company must pay off the debt, or
interest payments will sap its finances
 Some industries have more debt, so
 compare the company's debt to the industry average
and competitors' debt


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

67

Stock Selection
Management performance


Return on Equity, Return on Assets, and Return


on Invested Capital
 Used to measure a company's profitability
 Reveals how successful managers are converting

shareholders' equity, assets, and invested capital


into net earnings
 Compare to the industry average and competitors
to gauge the company's success

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

68

Stock Selection
Market multiples


Price/earnings, price/sales, and PEG ratios


 Measure how the market values a stock

compared to its earnings, sales, and estimated


earnings growth


A low P/E ratio (in comparison to the industry)


indicates the market is undervaluing a stock
The P/S ratio is especially important when the
company has no reported earnings (and thus no
P/E)
A lower PEG ratio is better because the market is
paying a lower price for future earnings

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

69

Stock Selection
PEG ratio


An indicator of whether a stock is undervalued or


overvalued.
 The PEG ratio is the stock's price/earnings ratio (P/E)
divided by its forecasted earnings growth rate
 A fairly valued stock would have a PEG ratio of 1; its
current P/E and future earnings growth rate being
equal
 A ratio of less than 1.0 can be an indication that the
stock is undervalued, and poised to grow.
 The usefulness of this calculation depends on the
accuracy of the stock's earnings estimates, which you
can find at Quotes Plus.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

70

Stock Selection
Intrinsic value


An intrinsic value/share is a hypothetical value that is


based on the
 Company's future earnings (assessment)
 Company's current debt, and the
 Number of outstanding shares
This value can be compared to a stock's current price to
help determine if a stock is overvalued or undervalued.
 Warren Buffet looks for stocks that are selling for a
discount (Ps < Intrinsic value / 3)
 Good to look at to reduce risk

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

71

Stock Selection
What else should you look for - general


More ratios:
 Dividend


yield, growth rate, payout ratio

 Profit margin


Gross, EBITD, operating, pre-tax, net profit, effective tax rate

 Other efficiencies



Per employee: revenue, net income


Turnover:
receivables, inventory, asset

Float: common shares / # shares outstanding


 Generally, insiders and institutions arent actively trading;

therefore, float is indicative of supply. Low float, high volatility




Earnings relative to market cap: >10X

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

72

Stock Selection
SWOT


Analysis of a companys

Strengths and
Weaknesses


Used to establish strategies and plans to exploit


and address

Opportunities and
Threats
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

73

Stock Selection
SEPTEmber moDel


An analysis that assesses impacts to a companys future


due to various environmental factors
S-E-P-T-E-D Analysis
 The model divides the external environment of business

into six segments for analysis









Sociocultural
Economic
Political/Legal
Technological
Ecological
Demographic

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

74

Stock Selection
Porters five forces


Porters 5 Force Analysis


 The intensity of industry competition and an

industrys profit potential are a function of five


competitive forces






Threats Posed by New Entrants


Power of the Suppliers
Power of the Buyers
Threat of Substitutes
Rivalry Among Competitors

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

75

Stock Selection
What else should you look for - general


Look for change(s)


 Market changes


Whats new (hot), whats not,


 E.g. nylons in an egg, disposable razors, VCRs, PCs, cell

phones, viagra, , nano-technology, biometrics,

 Environmental changes


Societal, legal, political, weather, , whatever


 E.g. terrorism, fire/storm catastrophes, war,

 Technology changes


Medical, financial, technical,

 Notice macro changes too




Debt growth, aging society, world developments, ,business


changes. E.g. GE evolution away from production to service

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

76

Stock Selection
What to look for point specific


From How to Make Money in Stocks; A Winning System


in Good Times or Bad by William J. ONeal, founder of
the Investors Daily
CANSLIM
 Current quarterly earnings per share (EPS)
 Annual earnings increases
 New products, new management, new highs
 Supply and demand
 Leader or laggard
 Institutional ownership
 Market direction

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

77

Stock Selection
Current quarterly EPS


How much is enough?


 More than 20% over same quarter last year
 Watch out for misleading reports
 Omit one time extraordinary gains
 Accelerating quarterly earnings growth
 rate of change of earnings
 The change and improvement from the prior rate of

earnings increases


Two quarters of earnings deceleration may mean


trouble!

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

78

Stock Selection
Annual earnings increases


Look for meaningful growth


 Annual earnings growth rate of 15 to 50%
 Stable five-year record

Insist on both annual and current quarter


earnings being excellent

Earnings are the most critical fundamental factor available


for selecting potential winning stocks

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

79

Stock Selection
New products, management, highs


Buying at the right time


 The value created by new products are easy to

understand


E.g. Tupperware, Polaroid, oral contraceptives, fast food franchising,


wholesale warehouse membership stores,

 New management; similarly easy to understand




Potential current opportunity?.TYCO

 New highs.hum? Is this a paradox?




Many independent studies have shown that stocks listed on the new
highs list tend to go higher; contrary to most popular thinking buy
low, sell high, consider buy high, sell higher
Stocks listed on the new lows list tend to go lower; avoid them

 Always look for new whatever and who owns the

patent


Opportunities: Nano-technology, biometrics, oral insulin, AIDS,

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

80

Stock Selection
Supply and demand


Small capitalization plus volume demand


 The law of supply and demand is more important

than all the analyst opinion on Wall Street




Big is not better


 Most meaningful growth (opportunity) has already

occurred


Look for companies buying their own stock


 Reduces common stock shares (supply);

therefore, tends to drive the stock price higher


Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

81

Stock Selection
Leader or laggard


Which is the company (stock) being considered?


 Buy among the best 2 or 3 stocks in a group (same

industry)


We all know the winners, but who came in next?


 For example, who here knows the name of the cyclist (yes,

it was the same person) who came in second in all five of


Lance Armstrongs consecutive Tour de-France wins?

 Always sell laggards first, hold leaders until your in

good profit, or until the reasons you bought no longer


apply
It seldom pays to invest in laggard performing stocks even if
they are invitingly cheap. Look for and buy market leaders
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

82

Stock Selection
Institutional ownership


A little can go a long way


 Its like sponsorship in the form of mutual funds, corporate

pension funds, insurance companies, .. You get the idea


 If a stock has no sponsors, it is likely that its performance
is run-of-the-mill, and chances are that many institutional
investors looked at the stock and passed it over in favor of
another
 Look at institutional ownership quarterly trend. Decreases
can be a red flag
 Look at the quality of ownership

Buy stocks that have at least a few institutional sponsors


with a recent better than average performance record
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

83

Stock Selection
Market direction


Which way is it going? How to determine it?


 In order to get a reasonable handle on the

answer to these questions, one must be strongly


connected to the market.
 At a minimum one must read the financial papers
(Investors Daily, Wall Street Journal, )
 Id suggest that investors get the Investors Daily
and also rely on an expert in the field
Be guided with the help of an expert to get a handle on
Market direction
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

84

Stock Selection
Where to look general


Everywhere around you


 At home, at work, and when you are out and

about


Notice what is hot with teenagers, techies, and the


elderly (all large consumer groups)

 Financial news
 Papers, magazines, newsletters
 Internet
 Yahoo Finance, MS money, cnnmoney
 Quicken
 Barchart
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

85

Stock Selection
Where to look specific


*http://www.moneycentral.com
 Lots of good info links here
 Click Investing
 Click Screener, more
 To create your own customized searches


Click power searches


 To get a selection of searches based on
 Technical analysis or
 Fundamental analysis
factors of the underlying companies

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

86

Stock Selection
Where to look specific


*http://www.corporateinformation.com/
 Lots of good info links here too
 Click United States to get several categorized links









Comparison to other firms


Delayed quotes and graphs
Earnings estimates and analysts reports
General information
Historical data
Ownership information
*Screening
Other useful information

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

87

Stock Selection
Where to look specific


*www.quicken.com
 Click stock evaluator to



Appraise the health and performance of a company


Get intrinsic value

 Click one-click stock analysis to get perspective from

four different investing strategists


 These are useful stops to reduce risk
*http://quotes.barchart.com/texpert.asp?sym=gd
 Good reference to get opinion (Buy / hold / sell), and
classical technical indicators
 Another useful stop to reduce risk

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

88

Stock Selection
Quicken Strategists


Motley Fool's Foolish 8 Strategy


 The Motley Fool helps you identify fast-growing small-cap

companies using the Foolish 8 strategy




*Strong interest stocks

Robert Hagstrom's The Warren Buffett Way


 Fund manager Robert Hagstrom, author of the New York

Times best-seller The Warren Buffett Way, demonstrates


how one of history's all-time great investors identifies his
favorite buys. Hagstrom shows you how Buffett judges a
company's management, financials and price


*Strong interest stocks

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

89

Stock Selection
Quicken Strategists


NAIC's Established Growth Strategy


 The National Association of Investors Corporation (NAIC) shares

their time-tested growth stock strategy with Quicken.com users.


Since 1951, the NAIC has helped investment clubs and
individuals identify blue-chip stocks likely to double in 5 years


*Strong interest stocks

Geraldine Weiss' Blue-Chip Value Strategy


 Experts have ranked Geraldine and Gregory Weiss' newsletter,

Investment Quality Trends, among the top ten percent in the field
over the last 15 years. The Weiss' show you how they find highquality, high-yielding income stocks selling at attractive prices


*Strong interest stocks

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

90

Stock Selection
Screening


Stock Screener - From Hoover's. This is really a good


site if you want to screen stocks based on many different
criteria, including price/book, P/E, growth rates, size,
ratios, etc. One of the best sites for screening. Also,
when you get the list of companies, one click gives you
the profiles provided by Hoover's. You can also restrict
your search to a particular industry (which might be
useful).
Research Mag - Has a stock screening criteria which is
fairly similar to that offered by stock screener. Also
allows you to graph several stocks on the same graph so
you can see how they've performed in relation to the
other.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

91

Stock Selection
Screening (cont.)


Market Player - Allows screening on many variables,


including expected future earnings. Has a very powerful
screening engine, but it looks like it'll take some practice
to become comfortable with it. But they also have a
simple screening which is more user friendly, but not as
powerful. This site requires registration, but it's free.
*Stock Selector - Allows general or industry-specific
screening on price/book, analyst recommendations, P/E,
PEG, dividend yield, five year estimate Earnings growth
rate and five year historic growth rate.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

92

Stock Selection
Screening (cont.)


Wall Street Research Network - Allows screening on


P/E, Price/Sales, Price/Book, Price, yield, beta, EPS
change, sales, market cap and index membership.
StockTools - From this site, you can choose stocks
based on criteria, including the industry. Other criteria
are P/E, volatility, Yield, shares outstanding, market cap,
price, change in price, and others.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

93

Stock Selection
What I use




Finance.yahoo.com
Scottrade.com
Investools.com
 Uses Fundamental Analysis to determine what stocks
to own


Scores 13 key fundamentals


 Volume Ratio 5/30 Day, P/E Ratio, P/E Relative Ratio, Projected EPS 1M Chg CFY,

EPS Growth 5 Yr, Company Growth Ratio, Acc. Dist Current, Cash Flow Growth 5
Yr, Debt/Equity Ratio, Insider Trading, EPS Rank, 5 Price Rank, Group Rank

 Uses Technical Analysis to determine when to buy,

hold, and sell




Scores 3 key charts used conjuntively


 30 day rolling average
 MACD(8,17,9) a simple momentum indicator (trend following & momentum)
 STO (14,5,0) a timing indicator

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

94

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

95

Buy

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

96

Sell

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

97

Start
buy @
sell @
buy @
sell @
buy @
sell @

Roger Manzolini

$
$
$
$
$
$
$

67.50
75.10
61.25
61.20
60.00
65.20

$
$
$

$
10,000.00
11,125.93
11,116.84
12,080.30

Stock shares
148.15
181.65
185.28
-

October 10, 2003

98

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

99

Money and Investing




Financial Ratios

Roger Manzolini
October 20, 2003

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

100

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios
First

recall income statement:


Sales
- CGS
- Depreciation
EBIT (earnings before interest and taxes)
- Interest
Taxable Income
- Taxes
Net Income (also called earnings)
Net Income = Earnings
Available for payouts (dividends), and
Plowback (retained earnings and reinvestment in
company)
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

101

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Leverage Ratios
Total

debt ratio =

Total Debt
Total Assets

A measure of how much of the companies assets are financed by debt


Typically want this to be less than 1; otherwise be concerned
Debt

equity ratio =

Total Debt
Total Equity

Typically want this to be less than 1; otherwise be concerned


Times

interest earned =

EBIT
Interest Payments

Typically want this to be greater than 1; otherwise be concerned

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

102

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Liquidity Ratios
Current

ratio =

Current assets
Current liabilities

A measure of the companys ability to pay its debt;


i.e. to stay a viable company.
Typically want this to be greater than 2
Lower values are a sign of trouble

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

103

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Efficiency Ratios
Inventory

turnover ratio =

CGS
Inventory

The higher the better


Typically greater than 20 is considered good
Receivables

Turnover (RT) =

Sales
AR

The lower the better


Typically less than 4 is considered good
Days

sales in receivables =

365
RT

The lower the better


Days inventory is on hand. Typically less than 4 is considered good

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

104

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Profitability Ratios
Profit

margin =

Net income
sales

The higher the better


Typically greater than 15% is considered good
Return

on assets (ROA) =

Net income
Total assets

The higher the better


Typically greater than 15% is considered good
Return

on equity (ROE) =

Net income
Total equity

The higher the better


Typically greater than 15% is considered good

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

105

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


The Dupont System


ROA

sales
assets

asset
turnover

ROE

assets
equity
leverage
ratio

Roger Manzolini

Net income
sales
profit
margin

sales
assets
asset
turnover

Net income
sales
profit
margin

October 10, 2003

106

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Profitability Ratios
payout

ratio =

dividends
earnings

How much of the companies earnings are returned to the shareholder


Typically GE payout ratio has been ~ 12%

Earnings - dividends
plowback ratio =
earnings
=
1 payout ratio

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

107

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Market Value Ratios


Earnings

per share =

Net income
# of shares outstanding

The higher the better


Typically GE EPS has been ~ 12%

Price

earnings (PE) =

Stock price
Earnings per share

The lower the better; less risk to investor; not over-priced


Typically GE PE has ranged from ~ 9 to ~ 18
Typically the market PE has ranged from ~ 15 to ~ 30

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

108

Money and Investing


Financial Ratios


Market Value Ratios


Dividend

yield =

Dividend per share


Stock price

The higher the better


Greater than 4% is considered good
Market

to book ratio =

Stock price
Book value per share

The higher the better


Varies between industries

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

109

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

110

Money and Investing




Top 10 Things to Know

Roger Manzolini
November 25, 2003

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

111

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know (CNN and MONEY magazine)
1. Over the long term, stocks have historically
outperformed all other investments.



From 1926 to 2001, the stock market returned


an average annual 10.7 percent gain.
The next best performing asset class, bonds,
returned 5.3 percent.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

112

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
2. Over the short term, stocks can be hazardous to
your financial health.



On Oct. 28,1997, the Dow dropped 554-points


(7.2%).
10 years earlier, on Oct. 19, 1987 -- the worst
one-day drop in stock market history -- the Dow
dropped 508-points (22.6%).
In March 2000, if you had invested in a Nasdaq
index fund around the time of the market's peak,
you would have lost three-fourths of your money
over the next three years.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

113

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
3. Risky investments generally pay more than safe
ones (except when they fail).
 Investors demand a higher rate of return for

taking greater risks.


 That's one reason that stocks, which are
perceived as riskier than bonds, tend to return
more than bonds.
 It also explains why long-term bonds pay more
than short-term bonds.


The longer investors have to wait for their final


payoff on the bond, the greater the chance that
something will intervene to erode the investment's
value.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

114

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
4. The biggest single determiner of stock prices is
earnings.
 Over the short term, stock prices fluctuate based

on everything from




interest rates, to
investor sentiment, to
the weather; you name it,

 But over the long term, what matters are

earnings.


If a stock's earnings rise substantially over the


course of 10 years, so will its share price.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

115

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
5. A bad year for bonds isnt really all that bad
compared to a bad year for stocks.
 In 1994, the worst year for bonds in recent

history, intermediate-term Treasury securities fell


1.8%, and the following year they bounced back
14.4%.
 By comparison, in the 1973-74 crash, the Dow
Jones industrial average fell 44%. It didn't return
to its old highs for more than three years or push
significantly above the old highs for more than 10
years.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

116

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
6. Rising interest rates are bad for bonds.
 When interest rates go up, bond prices fall.
 Why? Because bond buyers won't pay as much
for an existing bond with a fixed interest rate of 5
percent as they will for a new one that is paying,
say, 6 percent or more.
 Conversely, when interest rates fall, bond prices

go up in lockstep fashion.


And the effect is strongest on bonds with the


longest term, or time to maturity. That is, long-term
bonds get hit harder than short-term bonds when
rates climb, and gain the most when rates fall.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

117

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
7. Inflation may be the biggest threat to your longterm investments.
 While a stock market crash can knock the

stuffing out of your stock investments, so far, the


market has always bounced back and eventually
gone on to new highs.
 However; inflation, which has historically stripped
3.2 percent a year off the value of your money,
rarely gives back what it takes away.


That's why it's important to put your retirement


investments where they'll earn the highest longterm returns.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

118

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
8. U.S. Treasury bonds are as close to a sure thing
as an investor can get.
 The conventional wisdom is that the U.S. Government is

unlikely ever to default on its bonds.




partly because the American economy has historically been


fairly strong and,
partly because the government can always print more
money to pay them off if need be.

 As a result, the interest rate of Treasuries is considered a

risk-free rate, and the yield of every other kind of fixedincome investment is higher in proportion to how much
more risky that investment is perceived to be.
 Of course, your return on Treasuries will suffer if interest
rates rise, just like all other kinds of bonds.
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

119

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
9. A diversified portfolio is less risky than a
portfolio that is concentrated in one or a few
investments.
 Diversifying (spreading your money among a

number of different types of investments) lessens


your risk;


because even if some of your holdings go down,


others may go up (or at least not go down as
much).

 On the flip side, a diversified portfolio is unlikely

to outperform the market by a big margin for


exactly the same reason.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

120

Money and Investing


Top 10 Things To Know
10. Index mutual funds often outperform actively
managed funds.
 In an index fund, the manager sets up his

portfolio to mirror a market index-- such as


Standard & Poor's 500-stock index -- rather than
actively picking which stocks to purchase.
 This is often good enough to beat the majority of
competitors among actively managed funds.
 One reason


Few actively managed funds can consistently


outperform the market by enough to cover the cost
of their generally higher trading fees.

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

121

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

122

Money and Investing


Parting thoughts


What does it take?


 Willingness to accept some risk
 The risk-free rate of return (ror) is 4-5% with low volatility
 To beat this risk-free ror risk must be taken
 The moderate allocation portfolio ror is 8-10% with
moderate volatility
 The market ror is 10-12% with high volatility
 Time to educate yourself
 Markets
 Fundamental analysis (FA)
 Technical analysis (TA)
 Trading
 Stocks, bonds, options

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

123

Money and Investing


Parting thoughts


What does it take? (continued)


 Time to manage your portfolio
 Positive attitude
 Belief in yourself that you can do it
 Separation of emotion from trading decisions
 FA and TA decisions vs. emotional decisions
 Knowledge vs. guessing
 Learning from your mistakes
 Tenacity to continue

Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

124

Money and Investing


Parting thoughts


Warren Buffet
 When everyone is greedy, be scared;

When everyone is scared, be greedy




Peter Lynch

(In response to: To what do you attribute your success?)

 I always sold too soon




William Simons

(When he was the secretary of the US Treasury and


being questioned about the National Budget)

 What do you expect; for us to account for

every million
Roger Manzolini

October 10, 2003

125

Você também pode gostar