Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Rand Abbas
Andaluca
A TALE OF THREE CITIES
GRANADA.CORDOBA.SEVILLA
An Architectural Soliloquy
Travel Journal
Acknowledgements
McGill University School of Architecture for the
A. F. Dunlop scholarship that supported this
work. Particular thanks go to Ricardo Castro,
mentor and friend, a constant source of
inspiration. Along with David Covo, both of
whom have inspired me with their passion and
enthusiasm for drawing and design.
I am grateful for the invaluable connection
made with my extended family in Granada
uncle Taher, Carmena & family. I will never
forget their generosity warmth and hospitality
during our stay. Thanks are due to my travel
companion Noor - for her enduring support
and friendship, and a multitude of unforgettable
moments shared on this trip. Thanks to my
family as well, to whom I am always indebted.
Preface
"We are all looking for something of extraordinary importance whose nature we have
forgotten; I am writing the memoirs of a man who has lost his memory."
- Eugene Ionesco, 'Present Past/Past Present, A Personal Memoir' (1998)
This book documents a trip embarked on back in August 2005; instigated by a travel research
proposal that received the McGill University A.F. Dunlop travel scholarship grant. Since then, I
have revisited and continue to revisit themes and ideas that seem to have been silently spoken by
the walls and echoed in the courtyards of the places visited. In an attempt to capture the spirit of
Andalucian times, this travelogue presents a visual treatise on architecture and genius loci.
Through a weaving of images with threads of thoughts and texts collected over time, imaginative
interpretations are drawn, while looking at the works through two main filters, that of literature
and the enchanting landscape of Andalucia. A sort of romance may begin to unfold between image
and word, expressing topophilia, with recordings of architectural soliloquies, forming connections,
exposed or hidden - a meditation on beauty, harmony, and ultimately, on love. An exploration of
parallel narratives and legends of the medieval European and Moorish traditions, as well as more
contemporary sources that resonate. There are many bridges, many mirrors, many echoes.
Concepts of transformation and metamorphosis, evocations of romance, and excerpts from stories, of
heroes and legends; sources that also include manuscripts of the Middle Ages and oral traditions,
poetic narratives that are woven so as to invite the spectator and reader to take part in the journey.
In the tradition of Andalusian mystic Muhiyyi'd-din Ibn al-'Arabi's 'Fusus al Hikam', or 'Pearls
(bezels) of Wisdom', a collection of illustrative quotes accompany images, as part of an exploration of
the spirituality and thought of the influential Spanish mystics and polymaths of that period, as well
as other writers and artists of later periods. The journey is recorded with images that conjure up
poignant memories of the places visited, as well as through words chosen to best suit the imagined
narrative of the image. The reader may draw on the multiple dimensions represented: be they the
physical, elemental, environmental, spiritual, social, cultural or symbolic. In particular what's
conveyed is the personal and experiential connection struck with the place. Considering that
perhaps the act of creating and making architecture is an act of remembering, a process of recreation from memory. And so as a result of the search, and as a means of documenting experience,
this travel journal collects patterns and impressions, of landscapes, cityscapes, streetscapes,
building details, curiosities and enigmas, to aid in the process of discovery and memory, and as a
means of celebrating the place while paying homage to significant writers, artists and thinkers, who
alongside many generations of architects, have been greatly influenced by the Andalucian legacy.
On Methodology
The travel journal comprises of a collection of images in dialogue with words 'mneumonic devices' to help construct a brief memoir, narrating visual fragments with
reference to seemingly correlating passages and quotes.
The interface with the world of language is explored through the framed and annotated
visuals of the book, which may begin to parallel anthologies embedded in the
architecture, as read through phenomenological experience and research. The Garden,
the Path, Water and the Alchemy of light and shadow are some of the themes of
architectural exploration in the cities of the fabled kingdoms of southern Spain.
The work draws on classical texts to explore the roots of thought and creative spirit that
may have influenced the architecture, and conversely how the sites inspired poets and
writers over time. The pages are interspersed with passages, including some from
classical Sufi sources and sacred scriptures, as well as other significant texts and poetry.
Other literary references are made without an actual connection to the place or time, but
are seen to relate thematically and to add alternate layers of meaning.
The venture required a great deal of curiosity: collecting evidence, deciphering symbols,
digging into the labyrinth of the city, under broad daylight, or under the cover of night.
The investigation is documented as a curious chronicle of the sites encountered; mainly
with photographs taken in-situ, as well as with drawings, diagrams and text.
Using embodied experience, the full spectrum of the senses, as well as the imagination,
drawings and photography are used 'as a form of capturing and communicating the
unspeakable in an experience.' - Weidel, J. (1995) 'Being there: Using Pictures to See the
Invisible'. In M. Schratz & R. Walker (Eds.), Research as Social Change: New
Opportunities for Qualitative Research (pp. 72-90). New York: Routledge.
'The role of the photographer is thus to select what to "draw light" into.'
- Anna Kirova, 'Fotonovela as a Research Tool in Image-Based Participatory Research
with Immigrant Children'', International Journal of Qualitative Methods (2008)
15th century map of the coast of Andalusia & the city of Granada by Piri Reis, Ottoman Admiral &
Cartographer
Previous Map p.4-5: Jodocus Hondius' Map of Andaluzia Spain from the Mercator-Hondus Atlas. This is
one of the earliest Dutch maps of the region. The map extends to the coastline from Farson to the Straits of
Gibraltor and east to the coastal city of Almeria. The map includes a Sailing Ship, Sea Monster, and
wonderfully detailed topography. Started by Gerard Mercator, completed by Jodocus Hondius. Amsterdam,
1609. (Van der Krogt 1, 111)
Overview
The images of Moorish castles and palaces have stimulated the imagination of
poets throughout centuries. Full of storied recollections, they are described as
miracles of art, works of magic, a terrestrial paradise - such are the impressions
left by countless legends and traditions, songs and ballads, that describe the
rich cultural legacy of Moorish Spain, a harmonious utopia of repose and
reverie, of oriental luxury. Like Hispano-Islamic literature, Hispano-Islamic
architecture developed an individuality of form. The Legacy and splendor of the
ancient Moorish empire in Spain can still be traced in such wonders as the
Alhambra in Granada, the Mezquita and Alcazar in Cordoba and the Reales
Alcazares in Seville.
One of the interests of this investigation is in the connections between
architecture, literature and culture. Through direct experience of the
Andalusian cultural legacy, I hope to have recovered something of the richness
and insight of Islamic Spain that created one of the most pluralistic advanced
civilizations and outstanding architectural legacies in European history. With
the capacity to evoke aesthetic experience and to embody symbolic significance,
this book may illustrate ideas that can eventually be abstracted to resurface in
later works.
In the tradition of Washington Irving, who in Tales of the Alhambra (1832)
perpetuated a highly romanticized view of Andalusia, the memory of the old
citiesandpalacesofMoorishSpainmayberevivedthroughanimaginative
architecturalquesttouncoverconnectionsandtodiscernspecificfeaturesof
Hispano-Islamicarchitecturethatcharacterizetheartisticprovinceof
Andalusia.Recordedasacomplexlayeringoftracestoreflectacomplex
history,constructingmetaphoricandlinguisticconnectionstoarchitecture.For
centuriesafteritsdemise,Ibero-Islamicarchitecturecontinuedtoleaveits
markbothonnon-IslamicIberianandnon-IberianIslamicarchitecture.
TheMoorsflourishedfirstinCordoba,theninSeville,andtowardstheendof
theiralmost800yearrule,inGranada.Altogether,theproposedjourneywasto
encompassthethreemainmedievalAndalusiancitiesandanumberoftowns
andrurallandmarksontheway.Themajorcitiesnamedinthetitledefinea
moreorlesstrianglerunningbetweensmallertowns.Togetanideanotonlyof
thescopeofMoorishSpainbutalsoofitshistoricaldevelopment,small
excursionswerespacedbetweenlongerstaysinthethreemaincities,primarily
inGranada.Theexperienceofthepalacesandkeymonumentswithintheir
distinctgeomorphologiclocationswascompared,andconnectionsdrawnwith
respecttosuchissuesandarchitecturalthemesaspath,enclosure,forms,
gardens,andtopography.Therecollectionofmomentscapturedinthebookwill
narrateapersonalrelationshipwiththeplacesvisited,forminganarrative
basedondirectencounters.Theresultingvisualmapevokesformethesocial,
experientialandsensorialaspectsoftheexistingsites,aswellasthephysical
andtemporalconditionsandassociatedpatterns.
"...one must seek the essence of Andalusia in its geographic reality on the one
hand, and on the other in the awareness of its inhabitants. From the geographic
point of view, the whole of the southern lands is too vast and varied to be
embraced as a single unit. In reality there are not two, but three Andalusias: the
Sierra Morena, the Valley [of the Guadalquivir] and the [Cordillera] Penibtica."
-AntonioDomnguezOrtiz,TheSevillianhistorian. 'La identidad andaluza.''
Granada:UniversidaddeGranada.(1976)
Fig: Geo-lithological formations - Topographic Relief map shows the difference between the
highest and lowest elevations in the area, sculpted contours and landforms, from river plains to
mountains.
Source: Miren F. Mateo.'El relieve de Espaa' 2011 www.geohistoarteducativa.org
Granada
Crdoba
Sevilla
CapitalofSpain'slastMoorish
kingdomunderNasrids1237
CapitalofAndalusiain750
underUmaayad,Almoravid&
Almohadrule.Onceacentre
ofscience&learninginEurope
CurrentcapitalofAndalusia,
oncethecapitalofthe
Almohadsin1163,undera
kingknownforhisloveof
musicandpoetry.4thlargest
cityinSpain.
Topography
Locatedinafertilevalleyin
highmountainous
Andalucawhereexpansion
isconstrainedbythe
mountains,withthe
highestrangesontheIberian
peninsulainSierraNevada,
formingpartofthe
SistemaPenibtico.
Alhambra y Generalife
Thecomplexrisesabovethe
lowertownandissituatedona
hilladjacenttoAlbaicin.The
structuralandornamental
elementstracevarious
influences.Thepalacewas
workedwithlocalmodest
materials,mainlystone,clay,
plasterandwood.Thesurfaces
displayacomplexand
sophisticatedlevelof
craftsmanship.Thehighly
detailed&sculpturalinteriors
interactwithlightinsucha
wayastomystifythebeholder
'arquitectura encantadora'.
Theelementofwaterplaysa
bigroleintheconceptionofthe
architectureandis
incorporatedinmultiple
ingeniousways.
Topography
Thecitydatesbackfrom
Romantimes,whenitwasthe
highestnavigablepointonthe
RiverGuadalquivir.Crdoba
isdefinedbytwogeographical
features:themountainsofthe
SierraMorena,and
Guadalquivir,whichcuts
throughthem.North&East
it'sverymountainous,with
smalltowns&hiddenvalleys.
TotheSouth&Eastthe
provinceisveryagricultural
alongthefloodplainofthe
Guadalquivir.
Mezquita
Builtinthehistoriccentreon
topofaRomantemple&
remainsofa7thcVisigoth
church.Wasrebuiltasa
mosqueandasharedhouseof
worshipfromthe8th-12thc,
thenre-appropriatedasa
cathedralinthe13c.
fortress,thenaMoorish
palace,rebuiltbyCastillein
1328inMudjarstyle.
Topography
Sevilleprovinceislargelyflat,
exceptalowmountainrange
intheNorth.Animportant
agricultural&industrial
centreontheGuadalquivir
plain.TheAndalusianPlainis
essentiallyawiderivervalley
throughwhichtheRo
Guadalquivirflows,ultimately
intotheAtlantic.Itwasthe
"GatewaytotheIndies"&the
onlytradingportwiththe
IndiesorLatinAmericafrom
1503-1718,andwasdesignated
thecapitaloftheCarrerade
Indias(theIndiesroute)
Alczar of Seville
Palaces&gardensintheheart
oftown.Mudjarstyle:A
symbiosisoftechniquesfrom
Jewish,MuslimandChristian
cultureslivingsidebyside.
Giralda - onceaminaret,
todaypartofSeville's
cathedral,3rdlargestin
Christendom.Bestliving
exampleofAlmohadstyle.
'Granada'
illustrationby:JorgePea/HelenCater
An Andalusian Psalmody
"Memory is the selection of images. Some illusive, others printed indelibly on the
brain. Each image is like a thread. Each thread woven together to make a tapestry
of intricate texture, and the tapestry tells a story, and the story is our past."
- 'Eve's Bayou' film narrator (1997)
"No culture ever developed, bloomed, and matured without feeding on other
cultures and, in turn, nourishing others through a continuous process of
borrowing and giving, reciprocal influences and intermingling. Any attempt to
determine what belonged to which culture would be entirely arbitrary."
-MarioVargasLlosa,NobelPrizeLaureate,2010
"Every society possesses what is called an 'Image of the World'. This image
has its roots in the unconscious structure of society and requires a specific
conception of time to foster it." - Octavio Paz (1914-1998)
Cafe near the hilltop reservoir - with primo Jaber and Tio Taher
Hilltopreservoirandraincistern-waterisstoredanddistributedfromthehighertolowerareas
"The Alhambra hill...is possessed of a special energy only fully perceptible in the
silence of night, when countless watercourses, some above ground, some below,
hurry gurgling and splashing down through the wood (''agua oculta que llora,''
''hidden water that weeps,'' was how another poet, Manuel Machado, defined
Granada)... and you sense around you the phantoms of the city that died in
1492."-IanGibson,NYTimes:'LiteraryPilgrimages:FredericoGarciaLorca',1998
'Carmen' an inner court or private garden of hanging vines in Coral del Carbon
The word originates from the Arabic 'Carma' meaning hanging grape cluster
"We have made every living thing out of water." (Final Testament - Qur'an 21:30)
"And We send the fecundating winds, then cause water to descend from the sky,
therewith providing you with water in abundance"
(Qur'an 15:22, chapter 'the Stone Tract')
"...the kingdom of heaven is like a net that was let down into
the lake and caught all kinds of fish." (Matthew 13:47)
"Ask the animals, the birds, the earth, or the fish to teach you"
(1 Corinthians 15:39)
"O mankind! We created you from a pair of a male and a female and made you
into nations and tribes that ye may know each other. Verily the most honored in
the sight of God is the most righteous. And God has full knowledge and is well
acquainted with all things." (Qur'an 49:13, chapter ' The Chambers')
"Scatter your good deeds all around, not caring whether they fall on those
near or far away, Just as the rain never cares where the clouds pour it out,
whether on fertile ground or on rocks"
-IbnSiraj(Cordova,d.1114CE)Andalucianpoet
sketch-viewtotheAlhambra'sComarestower
"The ancient kingdom of Granada, into which we were about to penetrate, is one
of the most mountainous regions of Spain. Vast sierras, or chains of mountains,
destitute of shrub or tree, and mottled with variegated marbles and granites,
elevate their sunburst summits against a deep blue sky; yet in their bosoms lie
engulfed verdant and fertile valleys, where the desert and the garden strain for
mastery, and the very rock, as it were, compelled to yield the fig, the orange, and
the citron, and to blossom with the myrtle, and the rose...there is a romance
about all the recollections of the Peninsula dear to the imagination."
- Washington Irving: 'Alhambra' (1832)
Plaque inscription at Alhambra Entrance - Jorge Luis Borges, poem 'Granada' (1976):
Fuente de
la Alhambra fountains
are an inviting
welcome into
the courtyards
"It is the star that pierces through darkness" (Final Testament - Qur'an, 86:3)
"And it is He who ordained the stars for you that you may be guided thereby in
the darkness of the land and the sea." (Qur'an 6:97)
Geometryoflight-inElBauelo
"Workstopsatsunset.Darknessfallsoverthebuildingsite.Theskyisfilledwith
stars.'Thereistheblueprint'theysay."-ItaloCalvino,'InvisibleCities'(1974)
"We are Indian, Black, European, but above all mixed, 'mestizo'. We are Iberian
and Greek, Roman and Jewish, Arab, Gothic, and Gypsy. Spain and the New
World are centers where multiple cultures meet - centers of incorporation, not of
exclusion. When we exclude, we betray ourselves. When we include, we find
ourselves." - Carlos Fuentes (1928-2012)
Model of the Alhambra ('from the Arabic: 'al Qal'a al hamra' or 'The Red fort') A palace fortress and
city complex built by the Moorish Monarchs of Granada. The complex sits on the clay Hill of 'AlSabika' or Assabica (meaning form/mold/cast) on the border of Granada, at the confluence of two
rivers, Darro and Genil, and at the foot of Spain's highest mountain range, the Sierra Nevada.
Topography: The terrace and plateau where the Alhambra settles, measures about 2,430
feet in length by 674 feet at its greatest width, extends from W.N.W. to E.S.E., and covers
an area of about 169,831 square yards. It is enclosed by a strongly fortified wall, which is
flanked by 13 towers. The river Darro, which flows through a deep ravine on the north,
divides the plateau from the Albaicn district of Granada; the Assabica valley, containing
the Alhambra Park, on the West and South, and beyond this valley the almost parallel
ridge of Monte Mauror, separate it from the Antequeruela district.
(Source: New world Encyclopaedia)
TheAlhambrafortressisdescribedas
havingbeenconstructed"by the light of
torches",thereflectionsofwhichgavethe
wallstheirparticularcoloration.Another
description:"the hue of the towers and
walls that surround the entire hill of La
Sabica, by starlight is silver, but by
sunlight is transformed into gold."
(Source:www.alhambradegranada.org)
Auniquecomplexofpalaces,gardens,
fortressesandroyalquarters,theRoyal
residenceoftheAlhambrapalace(13thc.)
wasthelastadditiontothefortified
Alhambracitycomplex(9thc.)builtinthe
Nasridperiod,whichwasfinallycomposed
ofthe"alcazaba"(citadel),the
"alczar"(palace),asmall"medina"(city),
andthe"Generalife"(gardensandsummer
palace).TheAlhambrawasnotthe
residenceofkingsuntilthe13thc.
attheAlhambraMuseum
The ground material on which Alhambra is settled has a strong consistency and a stable
binding quality for setting foundations that withstood seismic movements. Granular
components such as gravel, clay and sand in the terrain were reused to make walls,
mortar and cement with the addition of lime and gypsum. The walls of the Alhambra
can be considered as a continuation of the terrain.
(Escobar. The Alhambra Structure & Landscape.2007)
The samples have been prepared using the cross-section technique. This technique
allows the examination of a large portion of a single paint layer in its original condition.
A variety of pigments from samples belonging principally to the Cultural Heritage of
Southern Spain were studied and comprise of blue (azurite, ultramarine blue, Prussian
blue), red (vermilion, haematite, red ochre, red lead, etc.), ochre and yellow (goethite,
orpiment, realgar, etc.), green (malachite, copper resinate), and white (calcite, gypsum,
white lead, titanium white, barite, lithopone) pigments, among others.
Microphotographs Sourced from Research Article: 'Comparison between micro-Raman and microFTIR spectroscopy techniques for the characterization of pigments from Southern Spain Cultural
Heritage'. Journal of Molecular Structure, Volumes 924-926, 30 April 2009, Pages 404-412, M.L.
Franquelo, A. Duran, L.K. Herrera, M.C. Jimenez de Haro, J.L. Perez-Rodriguez
Studysketch:Albaicinroofscape
"...Resting solidly on
thick foundations,
its walls like towers
fortified,
set upon a flat place,
plains all around it
splendid to look at from
within its courts..."
- Ibn Gabirol, 'The Palace
and the Garden' Jewish
Poet (c.a.1021-1058 CE)
'...the most imaginative, the most delicate and fantastic creation that sprang up
on a summer night in a fairy tale.'
- Benjamin Disraeli (1804-1881), on the Alhambra
Calle Real Alta - Cyprus and Myrtle pathway to the Alhambra complex - a worldly walled Garden
of Eden. The calle forms a central backbone of the whole city, from the Puerta del Vino to the
easternmost parts of the fortified precincts. Trimmed cypress trees with openings in the vegetation
screen reveal glimpses into the gardens, remains and ruins of the surrounding houses and palace.
"There are eight gates for Paradise." - saying of Prophet Mohammed (7th c.)
8 Doors/Gates ('Bab'): 1. Door of Prayer 2. Door of service or striving (for goodness) 3. Door of
Charity 4. Door of Fasting 5. Door of Pilgrimage 6. Door of Forgiveness 7. Door of Faith 8. Door of
Remembrance. (Source: Islamic encyclopedia. http://beta.ilmpedia.net/Paradise)
"Opeacefulsoul...enter
intomyparadise"
(Qur'an:27)
Myrtlewindow
Traditional vernacular elements, like arches and arcades, can be considered archetypes.
Besides cultural and regional associations, they also have climatic, practical and or symbolic
significance. Being familiar with these archetypes, can lead to a deeper understanding of
traditions and regional forms, and can enable meaningful innovation.
Archetypes noted include: Path or Promenade - as a leading theme. Arches - heaven's vault.
Arcades - that connect with distant landscapes. Walled Garden and Courtyard - earthly
paradise, microclimatic cooling device. Use of water - cooling, irrigation, basin, channel, cistern
fountain, aqueduct, under/above ground. Screen - privacy, diffused light, veil, Mashrabiya or
Shanasheel. Geometry - anchors, patterns and ornamentation. (Sketches made of the Alhambra)
Fig.4 The Palace of the Lions, Alhambra, Granada: a) view of the courtyard b) section showing solar
control provided by the porticos at midday on solstices and equinox
ViewfromtheOratoryor'Oratorio' backoftheMexuar
"There are lost bells in the depths, and windows open to the dawn..."
-Lorca,Poemofdeepsong"cante jondo"(1921)
"AnditisHewhospreadouttheearth,andsetthereonmountainsandrivers,and
fruitofeverykindHemadeintwopairs,Hedraweththenightasaveilo'ertheDay.
Behold,verilyinthesethingstherearesignsforthosewhocontemplate(reason)."
(FinalTestament-Qur'an13:3,chapter:TheThunder')
"To God belong the East and the West; and wherever you turn, there is
the face of God. For God is omnipresent, all-knowing." Quran 2:115
"Love is the ability to make the invisible visible and the desire to always
feel the invisible in one's midst."
-IbnAlArabi,Andalusiansufipoetandphilosopher
Mexuar Oratory
Epigraphy-poeticiconographicorspiritualinscriptionsarecarvedoutofmodest
materialsofplaster,stuccoandwood,inlaidwithceramicsandinterwovenwithfloral
motifsthatdematerializethewallsurfaces.InterpretationofthePalace'sinscriptions
revealspoeticalepigraphscomposedspecificallyfortheirrespectiveareasinthepalace
withthespeakerbeinganinanimatearchitecturalelement:fountains,niches&windows
describetheirqualities,anthropomorphizingthepalaceandtransformingitselements
intosoliloquies.Stylizedcalligraphyisalsoassociatedwiththe'GeometryofSpirit'
Geometry-anexpressionofrhythm,vibrancy,life.The(hidden)languageofthe
universe,asymbolicorderrelatingtothecosmos,anda'spiritualscience'oftheinnate
harmonyofgeometricalproportions&ratiosinrelationtothewhole.Representingthe
natureofobjectsbytheirhiddendimensions,itseekstoportraythemeaningoressence
ofthingsandtheirinnatenatureratherthanjusttheirphysicalform.Complex
geometriescreatetheimpressionofunendingrepetition,alludingtotheinfinitenature
ofGod,andtheconceptthatinthefiniteliestheinfinite,theintersectionofthetwo
worlds,theworldofthedivineandtheearthinman.Geometrythusexaminesthe
harmonicsoftheuniverse;atangiblemeanstovisualizenumbers-andtheintangible.
7 Sciences of Gnosis, or, the 7 Liberal Arts - AndaluciastudiedtheinheritedGreek
andRomanphilosophiesthroughArabstounderstandtheworldandhowcreationcame
intoexistence,thelawsandtheprinciplesbehindwhatweseeinthesensibleworld:
Trivium:artsthathadtodowithlanguagecorrespondingtoPlato'sobjectivevalues:the
Good,theTrue,theBeautiful.Grammar(whatisGood-inspeechand
writing),Logic(True),Rhetoric(Beautiful):consideredimportantin
understandinghowtodemonstrateorcommunicatethroughtheword
thehighprinciplesofwisdom.
Quadrivium-thesciencesofmanifestation,thelawsthat
governedthephysicalworld:Number,Music,Geometryand
Astronomy.Fromageocentricpointofview,lookingattheworld
aroundthem,studyingthestarsthesuntheplanets,how2&3
dimensionalspaceworked,howtheharmonicsofmusicandnumber
worked,theunderlyingpatternsinallofthesciences.Thesewere
considereddivinesciencessincetheyweredemonstrablytrue,and
thewayinwhichGodcreatedtheuniverse.(Carroll,IbnArabi:Webinar)
Unity in Diversity.
Unity without conformity.
Diversity without
fragmentation.
To transcend from the finite to
the Infinite. To perceive the
Infinite in the finite.
CourtoftheLions
GalleryArchdetail
Alhambra Plan - The palatial complex has two main courts: Court of Myrtles or Patio de Arrayanes, and
Court of the Lions or Patio de Los Leones
(Source - Xunta de Galicia: http://centros.edu.xunta.es/iessantairene/webantiga/Departamentos/Xeo_his/
arte2bac/imaxes/musul-prerrom/alhambra-plan.jpg)
Muqarnas-stalactitevaultorthe'VaultofHeaven'inSaladelasdosHermanas
Hallofthetwosisters-uniqueinthatitoverlookstwocourtyards
"Theso-calledRe-conquest,certainly,
spelledthedestructionofaunique
societyinwhichMuslims,Jewsand
Christianshadlivedandworkedside
bysideforsevencenturies,their
culturesandlanguagesintertwining.
The16thcenturybroughtsuspicion,
persecution,fear,intolerance:the
Inquisition.Itwas,inLorca'swords'a
disaster'thatledtoGranada'losing
it'ssoul.' " - Ian Gibson, NY Times:
'Literary Pilgrimages: Federico Garcia
Lorca', 1998
"Thereisstillasadnessabout
Granadatoday.Perhapsitisthe
awarenessthatmorethanoncethecity
hasalloweditstreasurestoperish...
LorcaperceivedtheAlhambraasa
'jasmineofgrief'"- Leslie Stainton, NY
Times: 'The Granada of Federico Garca
Lorca', 1986
Carlos V Palace
Alhambra transformed
radically following the reconquest by the Christian
Monarchs, who changed the
palace and its surroundings.
The Renaissance Palace of
Charles V, a royal residence for
the emperor, is evidence of this
transformation. It connects to
the Palaces of Comares and
Leones as an extension. The
design is austere and very
distinct from the delicate
Nasrid palaces, with rooms
and galleries organized on two
levels in the curved interior,
with the square exterior. It
utilizes marble in large scale
proportions, in contrast to the
humble plaster stone and wood
of the Alhambra. The forced
integration of an alien form
and structure invades the
space and eliminates links
between the town and the
Moorish palaces as it sits along
the route of the Calle Real
Baja. The structure can be
seen as a manifestation of the
triumph of Christianity and
the Roman Empire over Islam
and the Nasrid dynasty; an
Integration of two different
worldviews, at the expense of
the partial destruction and
upheaval of the Nasrid city..
(Escobar, The Alhambra Structure
and Landscape.2007)
Patio de Lindaraja
or Jardines de Daraxa:
Inside the cloistered calm
of the lower garden, viewed
from the Mirador de
Lindaraja, - room with the
inscription: "... I am not
alone for from here I look
over a lovely garden; no
eyes have ever beheld
anything similar to it. This
is a crystal palace...Here
breathe fresh breezes; the
air is healthy and the
zephyr agreeable. I join
together all beauties in the
same way that the stars in
the high firmament steal
their light from them.
Surely I am in this garden
an eye filled with joy and
the pupil of this eye is
veritably my lord."
Washington Irving had
looked down from the above
room were he resided while
writing "Tales of the
Alhambra" Cypresses,
acacias, orange trees and
myrtle surround the
central marble fountain.
"...gardensunderwhichriversflow,todwelltherein,andbeautifulmansionsingardensof
everlastingbliss..."(Qur'an9:72,Chapter:TheRepentance)
'ThetraditionalIslamicgardenisanearthlyreflectionofParadise,andthewordparadiseitself
comesfromtheMiddlePersianwordparadis,meaninggarden,andisalsotheoriginofthe
Arabicfirdaws,meaningparadiseandgarden.Usingthesymbolofthegarden,theQuranrefers
toParadiseitselfasaGarden...Sufism...thepathtotheGardenand,onthehighestlevelandin
itsinnerreality,the'content'oftheGardenaswellasthemeansofreachingthepresenceofthe
Gardener.'-SeyyedHosseinNasr,'TheGardenofTruth'
"AndariverwentoutofEdentowaterthegarden;andfromthenceitwasparted,andbecame
intofourheads.ThenameofthefirstisPison:thatis,itwhichcompasseththewholelandof
Havilah,wherethereisgold;Andthegoldofthatlandisgood:thereisbdelliumandtheonyx
stone.AndthenameofthesecondriverisGihon:thesameisitthatcompasseththewholeland
ofEthiopia.AndthenameofthethirdriverisHiddekel:thatisitwhichgoethtowardtheeastof
Assyria.AndthefourthriverisEurphrates"(Genesis2:10-14KJV)
Thefour-foldgardenlayoutfoundinthecourtyardsofAndalucianPalacesisdividedinfour
partsandirrigatedbyawaterchannelandcanalludetothefourriversofParadise.Asymbolic
expressionormetaphorthatevokesaparadisialsettingandapoeticphysicaltranslationofa
metaphysicalimageofparadiseasdepictedinthesacredscriptures.InArabicthewordfor'eye'
alsosignifiesa'spring'or'fountain'.IbnArabimakesuseofthisconnectioninhisdescriptionsof
thegardensofparadise:Thegardenasametaphorfortheheart;itscentrebeingthisspring,
whichwatersandvivifiesthegarden,spreadingoutfromthiscentre,carriesmystical
associations.ThePersianCharbagh isanothertermforthequadrilateralgardendividedby
walkwaysorflowingwaterintofourgardensegments.InPersian,'Char'means'four'and'bagh'
means'garden'.
"Attheheartoftraditionalcitystructuresarethetradition'sspiritualprinciples.Theartsare
amongthemostimportantanddirectformsthatechotranscendentarchetypes...Islamicartisa
reflectionintheworldofmatter,ofthespiritandformsfromQuranicrevelation(carrying)
symbolicandmetaphysicalsignificance.ThemostfundamentalprincipleofIslamictraditionis
Unity-Tawheed.TraditionalIslamiccitieshavesoughttointegrateallofitsfeaturestoleadto
thissenseofunity,witharchitecturethatalsorelatestocosmology.Traditionalmanlivedina
universethatwasmeaningful.Man-themicrocosmhimselfwasconnectedtotheuniverse,the
macrocosm."-Ardalan,Bakhtiar.'The Sense of Unity'(1973)
ibnArabi'sdiagramofthe
micro/macro-cosm
- Ibn Arabi
Palacio de Generalife
(From the Arabic: Jannat
al-'Arif' or Mystic/Gnostic's
Garden/Paradise) Terraced
garden and country house or
'Casa de Campo' of the
Alhambra complex: once
accommodated a lifestyle of
contemplation and remains a
vestige of their spirit.
Waterholdsthesecretsof
thepalace'sgardensconstructedchannelsand
aqueductsconveyedwater
fromthesnowcapped
mountainsandriverDarro
totheSabicahill.A
networkofsmallchannels
linkfountainsandpools
throughcomplexsystems,
narrowingbendingand
slopingtomaneuverthe
currentandthrustofwater
flow.Watercreatesa
coolingmicro-climate.Still
waterbasinsandreflective
poolsalsoactasmirrorsfor
thearchitecture.
"...Icarenotfor
grandeur,Icarenotfor
power,Ilanguishonly
forrepose;wouldthatI
hadsomequietretreat
whereImighttake
refugefromtheworld,
andallitscares,and
pompsandtroubles,and
devotetheremainderof
mydaystotranquility
andlove." - Washington
Irving, 'Alhambra' (1832)
"Ifyoulooktheright
way,youcanseethatthe
wholeworldisa
garden."- Frances
Hodgson Burnett, 'The
SecretGarden'(1911)
"Andthesecretgarden
bloomedandbloomed
andeverymorning
revealednewmiracles."
-Ibid
Jardn de la Sultana
Royal Bath section with 8 pointed star skylights piercing the 'Quba' or dome for lighting and
for ventilation (Source: D. Rafael Manzano Martos, School of Architecture - University of Notre Dame, USA)
"The discovery of the structures related to the water, the underground passages and galleries that I
came across by surprise. The observation of the binding relationships between the citadel, the
Gerneralife and the enormous surrounding area, and the all-pervading relationship with that
mysterious ravine, the valley of the river Darro...I understand (the nature of the Alhambra) as a set of
structures, creating a special symbiosis between architecture and nature, and designing a landscape
of intense human dimension." - Escobar. The Alhambra Structure and Landscape. (2007)
'A section through the Court of Myrtles showing the lines of view from the Hall of the
Ambassadors: follows the same general organization of a Granadine regular residence with a
rectangular pool surrounded by four units on the longitudinal sides and a main reception hall to
the north that overlooks the city.' (Source: Aga Khan Islamic Architecture Program, Course 4.611/13 , MIT)
Generalifeexit
The Nasrid kingdom which gave rise to the Alhambra were preoccupied with beauty
and perpetuity, but not permanence. The fragile fortress and its gardens can be seen
as a metaphor for this.
ViewtoAlbaicnandSacromonte-labyrinthineundulatingstreetsandwhitewashed
houseswithinnercourtsorgardens'crmenes'.IntheneighbourhoodofSacromonte
gypsiesstillliveincavedwellings.
"With these thoughts I pursued my way among the mountains. A little further
and Granada, the Vega and the Alhambra, were shut from my view; and thus
ended one of the pleasantest dreams of a life, which the reader perhaps may
think has been too much made up of dreams."
-WashingtonIrving:Alhambra (1832)
floral pathways
"Truepoemsofcantejondoare
attributabletonooneatallbutfloat
onthewindlikegoldenthistledown
andeachgenerationclothestheminits
owndistinctivecolour,inreleasing
themtothefuture...
Truepoemsofcantejondoarein
essencetiedtoaweathervaneofthe
idealthatshowsthedirectionofthe
windsofTime...
Theyarebornofthemselves,onemore
treeinthelandscape;onemorestream
inthepoplargrove...
Woman,theheartoftheworldand
immortalpossessorof'therose,the
lyre,andthescienceofharmony'
inhabitstheendlesshorizonsofthese
poems.Thewomanofdeepsongis
calledSuffering..."
- Lorca, CanteJondo
''IfbythegraceofGodIbecome
famous,''hetoldthecrowd,''halfof
thatfamewillbelongtoGranada,
whichformedmeandmademewhat
Iam:apoetfrombirthandunableto
helpit" - Lorca, 1929
"Onlymysteryallowsusto
live,onlymystery."
-Federico Garca Lorca
2005
Production
pamphlet
Duende - 'emotion and authenticity in Spanish art forms that comes from a
people whose culture is enriched by diaspora and hardship, the human
condition of joys and sorrows - the spirit of evocation, eerie and inexplicable
'soul' that lives in the heart of certain works of art.' - Teora y juego del
duende" (Theory and Play of the Duende); Maurer (1998) pp. 48-62."
"...that mysterious power that everyone feels but no philosopher can explain."
- Goethe (1749-1832) on Duende
Sierra Nevada - a snow capped cloud hovering above Granada's skies. Study sketch.
Granada: The word in Spanish means pomegranate. "The fruit is hard and
skull-like on the outside," wrote Lorca, "but on the inside it contains 'the blood of
the wounded earth'..."I remember Granada as one should remember a sweetheart
who has died.'' - Federico Garcia Lorca
"Iadviseyou,andallmychildren,myrelatives,andwhosoeverreceivesthismessage,
tobeconsciousofGod,toremoveyourdifferences,andtostrengthenyourties.Iheard
yourgrandfather(prophetMohammed),peacebeuponhim,say:"Reconciliationofyour
differencesismoreworthythanallprayersandfasting."- Ali ibn Abi Taleb, 7th c.,.an
"withallhumilityand
gentleness,with
patience,bearingwith
oneanotherinlove,
eagertomaintainthe
unityoftheSpiritinthe
bondofpeace."
(Ephesians4:2-3)
"...Godislove,and
whoeverabidesinlove
abidesinGod,andGod
abidesinhim"
(1John4:16)
aweddinginGranada
Cathedral
"Do everything in
love." (1 Corinthians
16:14)
-AlKindi(c.801-873CE)AbuYusufYaqubibnIshaqas-Sabbahal-Kindi,aMuslimArab
philosopher,mathematician,physician,andmusician.Al-Kindiwasthefirstofthe
Muslimperipateticphilosophers,andisunanimouslyhailedasthefatherofIslamicor
Arabicphilosophy.
"True knowledge is not tied in any way to the transitory world but rather is the
grasp of the eternal and unchanging forms causative of things of this world."
-IbnBajjahorAvempace,(1095-1138)Andalucianphilosopher,poet&physician,
'Treatise on Conjunction with the Intellect'
"It is He Who created Night and Day and the Sun and Moon, each one swimming in a
sphere" (Final Testament, Qur'an 21:33, chapter: 'The Prophets)
"And verily in the skies We have set constellations and beautified it for
beholders." (Qur'an 15:16, chapter 'The Rocky Tract')
"We shall show them Our Signs. On the horizon (in nature and in history) And within
their own souls. Until it is clear to them. That it is indeed the Truth". (Qur'an, 41:53)
"It is He who made the sun a source of radiant light and the moon a reflected light, and
has determined for it phases so that you may know the number of years and to measure
time." (Qur'an 10:5, chapter: 'Jonah')
"And He who made the night for rest and sun and moon for reckoning of time.
This is the decree of the Exalted, the All-knowing" (Qur'an 6:96)
8-pointed star and Quadripartite division: a motif that transcends Islamic iconography to
encompass many other traditions, Christian, Buddhist, Native Indian, and many others, as it is
rooted in primordial symbolism and knowledge, and has come to be associated with the division of
time, cardinal points and coordinates. A primal compass, with a connection to prophet Abraham as
traced in the ruins of the Sumerian city of Ur.
"When the hour came, Jesus and his apostles reclined at the table. And he said
to them, 'I have eagerly desired to eat this Passover with you before I suffer. For
I tell you, I will not eat it again until it finds fulfillment in the kingdom of
God." (New Testament, Luke 22:14-16)
"When the disciples said: O Jesus, son of Mary! Is your Lord able to send down
for us a table spread with food from heaven? He said: Observe your duty to God,
if ye are true believers. They said: We desire to eat of it and our hearts be at
rest, and that We may know that you have spoken truth to us, and that We may
be witnesses thereof. Jesus, son of Mary, said: 'O God, our Lord, send down for
us a Table laden with food out of heaven, that shall be for us a recurring
festival, the first and last of us, and a miracle from You. And provide us our
sustenance, for You are the best of providers!" (Qur'an 5:112-114)
Cartuja Monastery
"And you are to love the stranger, for you yourselves were
strangers in Egypt." (Old Testement, Deuteronomy 10:19)
-PabloNeruda(1904-1973)
NightdrivewithuncleTahertoPinosGenil
AmemorableTapasdinnerbytheriverGenil
"It is a pity indeed to travel and not get this essential sense of landscape values.
You do not need a sixth sense for it. It is there if you just close your eyes and
breathe softly through your nose; you will hear the whispered message, for all
landscapes ask the same question in the same whisper. 'I am watching you -- are
you watching yourself in me?' Most travelers hurry too much...the great thing is
to try and travel with the eyes of the spirit wide open, and not too much factual
information. To tune in, without reverence, idly -- but with real inward attention.
It is to be had for the feeling...you can extract the essence of a place once you
know how. If you just get as still as a needle, you'll be there."
- Lawrence Durrell, 'Spirit Of Place: Letters And Essays on Travel', 1969
en route to Cordoba
While the rest of Europe was languishing during the Dark Ages, al-Andalus
thrived, and Cordoba was its capital. Its scholars created a society that
inherited and built upon the legacy of ancient learning, Hellenistic, Persian,
Indian, and so forth. As capital of al-Andalus until its fall in 1236, Cordoba was
a city of half a million people. Students and merchants flocked to Cordoba from
all over Europe, Africa and even Asia. Its libraries boasted hundreds of
thousands of volumes, its palaces, hospitals, and baths were renowned for their
opulence and its luxury goods were coveted all over Europe.
(Nawawi Foundation: http://www.nawawi.org)
"...ToCordobabelongallthebeautyandornamentsthatdelighttheeyeordazzle
thesight.HerlonglineofSultansformhercrownofglory;hernecklaceisstrung
withthepearlswhichherpoetshavegatheredfromtheoceanoflanguage;her
dressisofthebannersoflearning,well-knittogetherbyhermenofscience;and
themastersofeveryartandindustryarethehemofhergarments.Art,
literatureandscienceprosperedastheythenprosperednowhereelseinEurope.
Mathematics,astronomy,botany,history,philosophyandjurisprudencewereto
bemasteredinSpain,andSpainalone.Whatevermakesakingdomgreatand
prosperous,whatevertendstorefinementandcivilization,wasfoundinMuslim
Spain..."- Stanley Lane-Poole, 'TheMoorsofSpain'(1896)
"History is a mirror of
the past and a lesson for
the present"
-Sa'diShirazi(1184-1291)
Persianpoet
'Crdoba'
Illustrationby:JorgePea/
HelenCater
Crdoba
The earliest learning centre in Andalusia dating back to the 9th and 10th c. with the
famous library and university that brought scholars from around the world. Cordoba
developed into an intellectual capital of Europe, a 'torch of scholar-ship' and scientific
progress in the darkness of the middle ages, spurred by a belief system that unifies all
sciences, philosophy and theology, as inspired by callings of faith and the search for
truth. Mystics and philosophers of the time, the likes of Ibn Arabi urged the spread of
compassion, love and peace among all faiths and beliefs, and called for dialogue and coexistence, and advocated a pluralist world view. Book culture in al Andalus propagated
teachings that entailed translation and exchange, importing paper, languages, new
methods and tools and becoming a true cross-roads for learning and an exporter of
knowledge to the rest of Europe and the New World. The calling for the pursuit of the
Divine through the acquisition of knowledge, or Gnosis, was a driving force for the
polymaths and spiritual seekers of the period: "Toacquireknowledgeisbindingupon
allMuslims,whethermaleorfemale."- Apostle Mohammed (7th c.)
"Fornearlyeightcenturies,underMoorishrule,SpainsetallEuropeashiningexampleof
acivilizedandenlightenedstate.Herfertileprovincesrendereddoublyprolific,bythe
industriousengineeringskilloftheconquerorsborefruitahundredfold,cities
innumerablesprangupintherichvalleysintheGuadalquivirandtheGuadianawhose
names,andnamesonlycommemoratethevanishedgloriesoftheirpast."
- Stanley Lane-Poole, 'TheMoorsinSpain' (1896)
"...TheheightofgnosisisHisconfirmation...TheheightofconfirmationisTawhid
(Oneness/unity)...Heisnotboundbyanything;allthingsareboundbyHim...Heis
infinite,limitless,boundless,beyondTime,beyondSpace,beyondimagination...Heexisted
whentherewasnothing...Hewillexistforever...Hisexistenceisnotsubjecttothelawsof
birthordeath...Heismanifestineverything,butHeisdistinctfromeverything...Heis
unique...Hehasnopartner...HeisTheCreator...HecreatesasHedestroys...Allthingsare
subjecttoHiscommand...ifHeordersathingtobethenitwillbe" - Ali ibn Abi Talib, on
Gnosis and the divine.
-Lorca,'Rider's Song',FromAndalusian
Songs (1927)
CallejainCordoba,BarrioDeLaJuderia
"Scienceisthepoetryof
theintellectandpoetry
thescienceoftheheart's
affections."- Lawrence
Durrell, 'TheAlexandria
Quartet'(1960)
The old roman bridge or Puente Romano across River Guadalquivir in Cordoba or 'Corduba' as
founded by the ancient Roman empire
'To modernize is to adopt and to adapt, but it is also to re-create.' - Octavio Paz
RunnelsinthePatiodelos
NaranjosorOrangeTree
Courtyard.Thechannelsare
designedforirrigation.The
walledcourtyardandits
fountainwerethesiteofritual
ablutionsbeforeprayer.Under
thetreesthereisalargealjibe
orwatertank.
"And a harvest of
righteousness is sown in
peace by those who
make peace."
(James 3:18)
'Thevisittothe
CathedralofCordoba
mayawakethedemand
andthequestforgreater
beautythatwillnot
witherwithtime.
BecauseBeauty,astruth
andrighteousness,are
anantidotefor
pessimism,andan
invitationtotake
pleasureinlife,a
shakingofthesoulthat
provokesthelongingfor
God."- a Reflection from
Mezquita
Mihrab:
the qibla
wall
Opposite:
12c Quran
manuscript
from
Andalusia
Mezquita or Grand Mosque - that contains a cathedral within, is likened to an anthology or book
Orangetreecourtsservedasante-chambersto
theinterioroftheMezquitaprovidingshade
Opposite:Poppiesfromthegardensofthe
AlczardelosReyesCristianosinCordoba
-Sa'diShirazi,(1184-1291)Persianpoet
Behindthemaincastlewalls
elegantgardensdisplay
Moorishhorticulturetraditions
withavarietyofplants,orange
andlemontrees,cypresses,
palms,overlookingfountains
andlargebasins.Originally,
waterfromtheRiver
Guadalquivirwastransported
throughanaqueductfromthe
SierraMorenaandthe
Albolafiawaterwheel.The
scaleofelementsisdistinct
fromtheAlhambrainGranada
andtheAlcazarinSeville,and
onthewholeelementsareless
intricateanddetailedandthe
gardensappearlargerand
moremonumental.
-JalaluddinRumi(13thc)
"BecauseofloveIhavebecomethegiveroflight."
-Rumi
"Onlyfromthe
heartcanyou
touchthesky."
-Rumi
White-washed
wallsand
cobbledstreets
inCordoba
Abu al-Hasan "Ali ibn Nafi," better known as Ziryab, arrived in Crdoba in 822 from
Baghdad, and had a musical reputation that impressed the court of the Umayyad
dynasty and its ruler Abd al-Rahman II with his virtuosic lute-playing and repertoire of
songs, some classic and others of his own invention.
Crdoba had just begun to develop a reputation for its prosperity and culture under the
ruling Umayyads in medieval Europe. However, Crdoba and the rest of the world still
lagged behind Baghdad in terms of arts, science, and trade. Stories of the opulence and
sophistication of Baghdad were famous throughout the world. Ziryab was already an
acclaimed musician at the court of Baghdad's Abbasid caliphs, and he studied under the
celebrated royal court musician Ishaq al-Mawsili. He developed new song styles and,
most famously, added a fifth string to the lute; an instrument that would later evolve
into the 'Ud (or Oud) and guitar.
It is said that Ziryab's talents aroused the anger and jealousy of his mentor, al-Mawsili,
and was forced into exile, never to return to the Round City and its Bayt al-Hikma
(House of Wisdom). With his guitar slung over his shoulder, Ziryab arrived in Crdoba, at
that time perhaps the most populous city in Europe. In addition to his prowess on the
lute, Ziryab quickly set about establishing new standards for beauty, style, and food,
which would have a lasting effect on not only Islamic Spain but all of Europe for
centuries to come. His courtly manners, breadth of interests and education, and
sophisticated conversation made Ziryab a favourite at the court. Though he mainly
circulated in the world of the Umayyad court, Ziryab's innovations spread across
different social and religious groups and trickled down to the merchant and artisan
classes and reaching even the peasantry. (Gluttons & Gourmands: Ziryab. June 5, 2012 (http://
vastmorsels.wordpress.com/2012/06/05/gluttons-gourmands-ziryab/)
The European lute derives both in name and form from the Arab instrument known as al
'Ud, which means literally 'the wood' - either because of its soundboard of wood as
distinct from a parchment skin stretched over the body, or because the body itself was
built up from wooden strips rather than made from a hollow gourd. The Arab 'Ud was
introduced into Europe by the Moors during their reign in Spain (711-1492). Pictorial
evidence shows Moorish 'Ud players, and 9th and 10th century accounts tell of visits of
famous players such as Ziryab to the court of the Andalusian emir 'Abd al Rahman II
(822-52). (Source: http://www.vanedwards.co.uk/history1.htm)
BeneaththemountainssouthofSevillearenestledwhitevillagesthatdrape
acrossAndalusia'shilltopsandvalleys.Wewanderthesmallstreetsofold
Moorishquarters,withtheirdistinctivewroughtironbalconiesand
whitewashedhomes.
"Travelisfataltoprejudice,bigotry,andnarrow-mindedness,andmanyofour
peopleneeditsolelyontheseaccounts.Broad,wholesome,charitableviewsof
menandthingscannotbeacquiredbyvegetatinginonecorneroftheearthall
one'slifetime."-MarkTwain(1835-1910)
"Oneneverreacheshome...Butwherepathsthathaveanaffinityforeachother
intersect,thewholeworldlookslikehome,foratime."-HermannHesse(1877-1962)
"Only a poetry of
specifics, a poetry
emerging from everyday
events, can be conceived
as the appropriate
means to recover a sense
of spiritual purpose"
-OctavioPaz(1914-1998)
CatchingcloudsinSeville
"In his 'Epistle of the Birds', Avicenna (c. 980-1037) likens the soul to a bird
tethered by the human body, seeking to free itself in search of knowledge...to
seek a state of intellectual immortality and happiness...to abstract from nation
and religion, from time and place, from language and culture, what makes one,
transcendentally, a...humanist voice of peace...A philosophy of peace beckons the
heart to free itself, the intellect-soul to immerse into the underlying humanity
that unites us all: Avicenna's bird, Absal, not one which is tied down by
contingent circumstances, such as religion or culture or language, or even place
or time, or associated with a specific community. Absal is the human-being's
quest for ultimate wisdom. A seeker's profession is to tour the world. Avicenna's
model philosopher is a "man-of-the-world", an "enlightenment" seeker of the
truth, an affiliate of free souls, not just of a specific culture religion or
geographic location." - From the 'Three Voices' sympsium presentation by Sari
Nusseibeh, University of Torino, 2008.
-JalaluddinRumi(13thc)
Outdoorrooms
1934SevilleAprilFairposter-Feria de abril de
Sevilla,anannualweeklongSevillefairthat
takesplacetwoweeksafterEastertothisday,
anddatesbackto1847
Opposite:DancingSevillanasdressedin'farales'
Corrida de Toros
La Maestranza in Sevilla
(Plaza de toros de la Real
Maestranza de Caballera
de Sevilla) - the oldest
venue that held the first
bullfighting spectacle in
1765.
Bullfighting traces its roots
to pre-historic bull worship
and sacrifice. The killing of
the sacred bull (tauroctony)
is the essential central
iconic act of Mithras, which
was commemorated in the
mithraeum in Rome, a
place of worship for the
followers of the mystery
religion of Mithraism in the
Roman Empire.
PassagetothePlazadeTorosdelaRealMaestranzadeCaballeradeSevilla
"If the doors of perception were cleansed every thing would appear to
man as it is, infinite"-WilliamBlake(1757-1827)
el arenal steps
Seville Cathedral
The Largest Gothic temple in
Europe, (15th c.) holding the
tomb of Christopher Columbus
- built on top of a mosque
(Mezquita Mayor) but
preserved it's courtyard 'Patio
de los Naranjos' as an access to
the cathedral.
"Love is patient,
Love is kind.
It does not envy,
It does not boast,
It is not proud.
It does not dishonour
others,
It is not self-seeking,
It is not easily angered.
It keeps no record of
wrongs.
Love does not delight in
evil but rejoices with the
truth.
It always protects,
always trusts,
always hopes,
always perseveres.
Love never fails.."
(1 Corinthians 13:4-8)
TheGiralda(from'Giraldillo'
orweather vane,inreferenceto
thesculptureonitssummit)
wastheminaretofthemosque
thatwasreplacedbySeville
Cathedral.Consideredthe
culminationofAlmohad
architecture.Builtin1184-96.
Entrancetothetowerisfrom
insidethecathedral.Insteadof
stairs,thereare35gently
inclinedrampswideenough
fortwoguardsonhorsebackto
pass.Theclimboffersviewsof
thecathedral'sbuttressesand
gargoylesonthewayuptothe
observatoryplatformontop.
Baos
de Doa
Mara
de Padilla
in
Alczares
Reales
de Sevilla
"When you enter the garden, you enter yourself and know yourself..." - Ibn Arabi
"Wonder! a Garden amongst the flames!
My heart has become able
To take on all forms.
It is a pasture for gazelles,
For monks, an abbey.
For the idols, sacred ground,
Ka'ba for the circling pilgrim,
It is the tablets of the Torah
And also the leaves of the Koran
My creed is Love; Wherever its caravan turns,
That is my belief"
- Muhyyeddin Ibn Arabi (1165-1240 CE),
Andalusian Muslim mystic and poet"
Alczar of Seville - once a Moorish fort. It is the oldest royal palace still in use in
Europe, and the official residence of the Spanish royal family when in Seville
Hispano-Moorish
decorative forms:
Almohad and Mudjar
style Architecture
Azulejo (from the Arabic
word zellij meaning
polished stone) HispanoMoresque tile cladding
with interlocking
curvilinear, geometric or
floral motifs famous in
Seville - both ornamental
and a cooling technique.
Mudjar style (12th c.) is a
symbiosis of techniques
and ways of understanding
architecture resulting from
Muslim and Christian
cultures living side by side
in the Iberian Peninsula.
RealesAlczares-Courtyard
"AndsovanquishedforeverfromtheSpanishterritorythisbrave,intelligentand
enlightenedpeople,whowiththeirresolutionandlabourinspiredlifeintotheland,which
thevainprideoftheGothscondemnedtosterility,andendoweditwithprosperityand
abundanceandwithinnumerablecanals,thispeoplewhoseadmirablecouragewas
likewise,inhappinessandadversity,astrongramparttothethroneoftheCaliphs,whose
genius,progressandstudyraisedinitscitiesaninternaledificeoflightwhichsentits
raysintoEuropeandinspireditwiththepassionofstudy,andwhosemagnanimous
spirittintedallitsactswithanunrivalledcolourofgrandeurandnobility,andendowed
itintheeyesofposteritywithasortofextraordinarygreatnessandcharmingcolourof
heroismwhichinvokesthemagicalagesofHomerandwhichpresentsthemtousinthe
garbofGreekhalf-gods." - Conde as quoted in Prescott, Philip II of Spain, Vol. III
"Thoughidealized...thereremainsanappreciationofthefactorsbehinditsdownfall.
Someofthesewereexternal,suchastheunificationandexpansionoftheChristian
kingdomsofSpainandthegeographicandpoliticalisolationofAl-Andalusfromtherest
oftheMuslimworld.TherewerealsointernalfactorsthatcontributedtothedeclineofAlAndalus,particularlytherivalriesthatweakenedanddividedIslamicSpain,thegreed
andself-indulgencethatgrippeditselites,andthelossofaunifyingreligiousvision...On
theotherhand,IslamicSpainwasanimmenselyfertilegroundforlearning,producinga
longseriesofintellectual,aestheticandscientificadvancesattributabletoMuslim,
ChristianandJewishthinkers....Thisblossomingwasdueinparttothespiritof
tolerancethatprevailedformuch,thoughnotall,ofthehistoryofAl-Andalus...Despite
thepassageof(over)500years,Al-Andaluscontinuestocastitsspell.Asthebirthplaceof
someoftheworld'soutstandingscholarsandartisans,homeofdazzlingarchitectural
masterpieces,andsettingofabrilliantsocietynotableforboththeheightofits
achievementsandthedepthsofitsdecadence,Al-Andalusretainsitsemotionalimpact
anditsprivilegedplaceinMuslimhistoricalmemory."-Greg Noakes, 'TheOther1492'(1993)
Alczares Reales de Sevilla - Courtyard of the Maidens,PatiodelasDoncellas
'Time is no longer
succession and becomes
what it originally was
and is: the present, in
which past and future
are reconciled."-Octavio
Paz(1914-1998)
EugeneIonesco,playwright
(1909-1994)
StudysketchoftheBaosde
DoaMaradePadilla
-OctavioPaz(1914-1998)
AnexceptionallytallpalminSeville
Postscript
"These are the moments which are not calculable, and cannot be assessed in words; they
live on in the solution of memory, like wonderful creatures, unique of their own kind,
dredged up from the floors of some unexplored ocean." -Lawrence Durrell, Justine (1957)
This book, essentially a collage of images, drawings and texts pieced together to attempt
to draw meaning, is in essence an object of love. An attempt to unravel some of the
mysteries behind the conception and making of the enchanting places visited, to
communicate something eternal, timeless, transcendent. The architectural readings and
encounters with the remarkable remnants of Andalusia, particularly the Alhambra,
narrated a manifestation of order and unity, internal richness and complexity; while
evoking a tranquil state of being. The interconnectivity of many elements, and the
elaborate integration and use of water in the architecture, is particularly noteworthy.
Other traditional archetypes such as the arch and arcade framing distant views, the path
as a leading theme, and walled gardens and courtyards - these vernacular elements
embody a worldview built to reflect equilibrium, paradisial serenity, and the
interconnectivity of creation. A world where science, faith and art were not incompatible;
the sacred and profane reconcilable; as manifested through the unique spirit of the time.
"Making a Book is like taking part in a dance, you're trying to figure out how the other
person feels, moves, breathes, thinks, to catch his rhythm. You feel drawn along a huge
current...they are meaningful because they are objects of love. They are created by
someone's passion to communicate something through art, and that's the only way an
artist communicates" - Anita Saewitz, 'Beyond Words: The Marriage of Art and
Literature in Bookmaking', Film (1999).
In 'Dance, Consciousness of Life', Thilda Herbillon-Moubayed writes:
"What is 'the fantastic'? A means of escape from a hostile reality? The ability to surrender
to the world of play and imagination? Emancipation? An escape? A distanced view used to
attain light and nourish oneself with poetry? A vagabond of amorous adventure? An
expectation of the exceptional? A transcendence of reality? An admission of the
supernatural? A reaction against rationalism? The avowal of the impossibility of action...?
The fantastic is all of that" (2005)
G l o s s a r y -linguisticcross-roads
Spanishlanguage,alsocalledCastilian,isaRomancedialectthathadgraduallyevolved
fromtheRomanLatin.ArabicbegantofilterinthelanguageduringMoorishtimesin
Andalusiaandthelexicalinfluenceisevidenttoday,insuchArabicderivednamesof
sometownsandvillages,suchasAlginet(al-jannat-thegardens/paradise),Alcacer(alqasr-thecastle),Alzira(al-jazira-theisland).Othercommonexamplesbelow:
Acequia-(orSequia)fromtheArabical-saqiya,meaningAqueduct.
Aciete-fromtheArabicwordforoil,Al Zeit.
Albufera-fromtheArabicwordforlake,Al Buhaira.
Alcachofas-fromtheArabical-kharshuf,meaningArtichoke.
Adobe-fromtheArabicwordforsun-driedmudbrick,Al Tub-e
Arrecife-FromtheArabical-rasif meaningstonepavedroadorsidewalk
Azucar-fromtheArabicwordforsugar,Al Sukar
Berenjena-fromtheArabicbidinjan,meaningAubergine.
Espinacas-fromtheArabicisbinagh,meaningSpinach.
Gibraltar-namegiventotheSouthernendoftheIberianPeninsula(Campode
Gibraltar).FromtheArabicJebel Tariq,or'MountainofTariq'.
Guadalquivir-Granada'smostfamousriver,whosenameisderivedfromtheArabic
'Wadi-al-kabir',or'thebigriver'.
Hasta-fromtheArabic'Hatta',aprepositiontomean'Until'.
MadridorMajrit-Spain'scapitalcity,couldhavebeenderivedfromtheArabic:Majrit,
orMajra,meaningwaterchannel.
Naranja-fromthePersiannaranj,meaningorange.
Ojal-fromtheArabicinsha'Allah orLo sha'Allah or'Godwilling',expressingdesirefor
somethingtopass,andareminderoftheuncertaintyofthingswhenplanningforthe
future,andtoturntoGodinallaffairs.
Ol-fromtheArabicWallah,or'byGod',anexpressiontocheer.
Rincn-Corner.FromAndalusiArabic'Rukan',derivedfromclassicalArabicRukn.
Troubadour-fromtheArabicverbTarab,connotingmusicality,tosing,makemusic,to
fillwithjoy,ortomovewithmusic.
Usted-politeformof'You',comesfromtheArabicUstadh, orsir.
Zoco-(orAzogue)FromArabicsoukmeaningmarket.
"...to open a view into the second dimension of our consciousness, the reality of
dreams, images and memories."
- Juhani Pallasmaa, On the task of Architecture (1986)
Secret gardens in Pinos Genil, Granada
References
Ardalan, Nader, Laleh Bakhtiar. The Sense of Unity. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1973)
Barrucand, Marianne. Moorish Architecture in Andalusia. (Koln: Taschen 2002)
Bishko, Charles Julian, Studies in Medieval Spanish Frontier History (London: Variorum Reprints,
1980)
Buckhardt, Titus. Mirror of the Intellect: Essays on Traditional Science and Sacred Art. (State Univ
of NY Press, 1987)
Buckhardt, Titus. Art of Islam, Language and Meaning. (Westerham: Westerham Press. 1976)
Charles, H. A sense of the sacred: Building Bridges Between Islam and the West. (Wilton Park
International Studies. 1996)
Collins, Roger, Early Medieval Spain: Unity in Diversity, 400-1000, (New York: St. Martin's Press,
1983)
Compton, Linda. Andalusian Lyrical Poetry and Old Spanish Love songs: The Muwashshah and its
Kharja. (New York: New York University Press, 1976)
Corbin, Henry. Alone with the Alone: Creative Imagination in the Sufism of Ibn 'Arabi. (NJ:
Princeton Press, 1997)
Dodds, Jerrilynn D., Mara Rosa Menocal, and Abigail Krasner Balbale. The Arts of Intimacy:
Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Making of Castilian Culture. (Yale University Press, 2008)
Fernndez-Puertas, Antonio. The Alhambra. (London : Saqi Books, 1997)
Grabar, Oleg. The Alhambra. (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978).
Grabar, Oleg. The Meditation of Ornament. (Washington: Princeton University Press. 1992)
Harvey, L. P., Islamic Spain 1250-1500, (Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press,
1990)
Ibn Al'Arabi, Muhyeddin. The Bezels of Wisdom. Translation: Austin (Paulist Press, 1980)
Irving,Washington.TheAlhambra,(London:H.G.Bohn,1850)
Kennedy,Hugh,MuslimSpainandPortugal:APoliticalHistoryofal-Andalus,(London&New
York:Longman,1996)
Lane-Poole,Stanley.'TheStoryofTheMoorsinSpain'(NewYork:PutnamSons,1896)
Lomax,DerekW.andMackenzie,David,eds.,GodandManinMedievalSpain:EssaysinHonourof
J.R.L.Highfield,(Warminster:Aris&Phillips,1989).
Lorca,FedericoG.,C.Maurer.TheCollectedPoems:ABilingualEd(Ferrer,Straus&Giroux,2002)
Menocal,MariaRosaandRaymondP.Scheindlin,andMichaelSells.(ed)TheliteratureofAlAndalus(NewYork:CambridgeUniversityPress,2000)
Nasr,SeyyedHosseinNasr.TheGardenofTruth:TheVision&PromiseofSufism,Islam'sMystical
Tradition.(NY:HarperCollinsPublishers,2007)
Read,Jan.TheMoorsinSpainandPortugal,(London:FaberandFaber,1974)
[Journal]Abercrombie,Thomas.WhentheMoorsRuledSpain.NationalGeographic(July1988)
[interview]Gacek,Adam.Manuscripttraditions.McGillUniversity,SchoolofIslamicStudies.
(September2nd,2003)
[Film]IslamicArt.Princeton:FilmsfortheHumanities,inc.(1988)
[Exhibit]Rahim,Habibeh,curator.InscriptionasArtintheWorldofIslam,UnityinDiversity,New
York:HofstraUniversityMuseum.(1992)
[Conference]:Transculturalisms:DiversityandMetamorphosis.InternationalCouncilforCanadian
Studies..UQAM(May22-24,2003)
[Symposium]MuhyideenIbn'ArabiSociety:'MysticalPerceptionandBeauty',WorcesterCollege,
Oxford,UK-(May2013)
[Web]UNESCO:http://whc.unesco.org/en/statesparties/es
JuntadeAndalucia:http://www.juntadeandalucia.es/andalucia.html
Alhambra:http://www.alhambradegranada.org/,http://www.alhambra-patronato.es/