Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Submitted by :
Supervised by:
Board of Examiners:
President: Dr. GRINE Nadia, Badji Mokhtar University - Annaba
Supervisor: Dr. GHAOUAR Nesrine- Badji Mokhtar University - Annaba
Examiner: MelleNEDJEH Hana, Badji Mokhtar University - Annaba
June 2015
DEDICATION
In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious and the Most Merciful Alhamdulillah, all praises to
Allah for helping me to accomplish this humble work
I would like to dedicate this dissertation
To my beloved parents who have always provided me with the necessary support to succeed
To my sister Rima, her husband Mohamed, and my brother Salah Eddine for their
continuousencouragement
To all my friends who helped me whenever I needed help
To Mr. Rachedi who helped me with his valuable advice throughout my dissertation
To Mr. Frioukh who has always been my moral support
To my new born nephew Ilin
II
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to express my infinite thanks to my supervisor Miss Ghaouar. Without her
advice, patience, guidance, knowledge and support, I would not have been able to complete my
dissertation.
Besides, I would like to express my sincere thanks to all my teachers and the jury members:
Dr. Ghaouar, Dr. Grine, and Miss Nedjeh for reading and evaluating my work.
III
ABSTRACT
The listening skill is one of the four pillars on which language learning stands.
Nevertheless, it has long been neglected and perceived as a passive skill. However, recently,
certain studies have revealed its importance in language learning and have proven that it is not
passive but rather active. Thus, this research sheds light on the importance of listening in
language learning and teaching situations. Therefore, it attempts to provide answers for three
main questions: 1) Is listening a simple or a complex skill? 2) To what extent is the listening
skill important in the teaching/ learning process? And 3) how to teach the listening skill in the
EFL classrooms?As a result, this work shows that listening is not a simple skill to be taken for
granted but rather it is a complex one that needs investigation from different stand points: its
physiology, psychology and types. Besides, this mmoire emphasizes the different approaches
that learners use in order to reach comprehension. Moreover, some studies show that listening
does not play a major roleonlyin daily communication, but also in language learning. Hence, a
comparison has been made between first and foreign language listening and the main
difficulties learners encounter were highlighted. Finally, this work demonstrates that teaching
the listening skill can be effectively achieved through following the three lesson planning steps
and through applying certain strategies that may develop learners listening comprehension.
Furthermore, it suggests some sample listening lessons and tests along with some games that
teachers can play with their learners in order to develop their listening comprehension.
IV
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Results of the studies conducted on the time spent in listening...20
Table 2: Cognitivelistening strategies...24
Table 3: Metacognitive listening strategies....26
Table 4: Socio- affective listening strategies......27
Table 5: Heard vs. not heard words or phrases...45
Table 6: Monu ....48
LIST OF FIGURES
VI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DEDICATION......I
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT....II
ABSTRACT........... III
LIST OF TABLES.....IV
LIST OF FIGURES.............V
General introduction
1. Statement of the problem......1
2. Aim of the study...1
3. Research questions..1
3. Division of the dissertation.......2
VII
5.3. Remembering.................................................................................................................8
5.4. Evaluating......................................................................................................................9
5.5. Responding.....9
6. Listening types...................................................................................................................9
6.1. Informative listening....................................................................................................10
6.2. Evaluative listening..10
6.3. Discriminative listening...11
6.4. Empathetic listening.....11
7. Extensive vs. intensive listening skills....12
7.1. Extensive listening..12
7.2. Intensive listening...13
8. Active vs. passive listening.................................................................................................14
9. Listening comprehension.15
9.1. Listening comprehension approaches..15
9.1.1. The top down approach....16
9.1.2. The bottom up approach...............................................................................17
9.1.3. The interactive approach.......17
Conclusion .....18
VIII
IX
General conclusion..56
Bibliography....58
Webography....64
3. Research questions
2. To what extent is the listening skill important in the teaching/ learning process?
3. Dissertation division
This dissertation consists of three chapters. The first one is an overview on the
listening skill. It provides details related to the physiology and the psychology of listening.
It also stresses the main steps through which the listening process passes. Besides, it
emphasizes the difference between active and passive listening. Moreover, it sheds light on
the listening types and skills. Furthermore, it spots listening comprehension and its
processes.
The second chapter reveals the importance of the listening skill in communication and
in language learning. In addition, it deals with the listening skill as part of the teaching
learning process by providing some strategies which may assist learners to develop their
listening skills. Chapter two also discusses some difficulties encountered by learners while
listening and some standards that should be taken into account by teachers while selecting
listening activities and techniques. Another important point that this chapter stresses is how
to plan for a listening lesson and how to assess this skill.
The third chapter, unlike the first and the second chapters, is somehow practical. It
provides illustrations of listening lessons which promote different comprehension processes
involving the top- down approach, the bottom up approach and the interactive approach; and
some listening tests. Besides, this chapter suggests some listening games which teachers
may play with their learners (especially, young ones) in order to train them and help them
improve their listening skills.
Introduction
Listening is generally regarded as simply decoding an aural input. However, the fact
is that it is much more complex than that. Therefore, having a closer look at it would
certainly clarify the image and would reveal why it is not that simple. This chapter provides
an overview on the listening skill through which one can discover some hidden details
which may serve him/her to deeply understand listening. Thus, this chapter introduces
listening in various ways by different experts. Besides, it deals with both listening
physiology and listening psychology along with the listening process and the different types
of listening. Moreover, it clarifies listening comprehension which learners can reach
through different approaches.
1. Listening definitions
Various definitions were given to listening from different perspectives, and at different
periods of time. However, no definition is accepted as the best. According to Hedahl (2001,
p. 11), listening was defined in the early part of the 20th century, as: the ability to
understand spoken language. She adds that in the mid-20th century listening was defined as:
the process of hearing, identifying, understanding, and interpreting a spoken language
(Hedahl 2001, p.11). Downs (2008, p.1) defines listening simply as making an effort to
hear something. A more detailed definition was given by the International Listening
association (1996) (as cited in Collins book Interpersonal Communication Listening and
Responding 2006, p. 7), it states that listening is: the process of receiving, constructing
meaning from and responding to spoken and/or nonverbal messages. A similar definition
was given by Rost (2002, p. 279) in which he states that listening is a mental process of
constructing meaning from spoken input. Moreover, Rubin and Mendelshon (1995, p. 7),
explain that listening is conceived of as an active process in which listeners select and
interpret information which comes from auditory and visual clues in order to define what is
going on and what the speakers are trying to express. Therefore, from the previous
definitions, one may deduce that listening is a complex active process that passes through a
set of sub-processes starting with hearing and ending with responding.
Considering language teaching methods, the direct method is the first teaching method
that took into account the importance of the listening skill. Learners were immersed in the
target language that was the language of instruction. Therefore, listening played a major role
(Flowerdew and Miller, 2005, p. 6).The audio lingual method, as well, relied on the listening
skill. The listener was required to recognize and practice utterances and then create similar
utterances after the ones s/he was listening to. In fact, developing the listening skill was not
the focus of this method, but rather it was used as a medium to learn grammatical and lexical
structures. Similarly, the communicative approach assumed the listening skill, real- life
listening was a basic principle in this approach but still no direct instruction of the latter was
given (Flowerdew and Miller, 2005, p. 12)
Recently, however, many psycholinguists and foreign language educators have
addressed the importance of the listening skill, starting with the pioneering work of Rankin
(1930) who found that listening is the most frequently used skill in communication amongst
humans.
3. Listening physiology
During communication, the listener receives a verbal/ non- verbal message. The
auditory reception of the verbal vocal message is an auditory logical process that relies on
the hearing mechanism. Problems with the latter impede this receptive process (Wolvin,
2010).
The physiology of listening extends to the neurology of the process (Goss, 1995 as
cited in Listening and human communication in the 21st century by Wolvin, 2010). Once
the auditory and or visual receptors receive the stimulus, that stimulus is stored in the brain.
Thus, the Wernickes area which is one of the cerebral cortex parts that is included in
spoken and written language production (Traxler, 2012), and Brocas area which is an area
in the frontal lobe of the left hemisphere with functions related to speech production
(Pastorino and Doyle-Portillo, 2006), is activated in response to auditory stimuli. Therefore,
brain damage can influence and interrupt the processing of messages (Wolvin 2010).
4. Listening psychology
After receiving the message through the auditory and visual channels, it will be stored
either in short term memory or long term memory according to the amount of attention
given to the message that is influenced not only by the listeners working memory, but also
by his/her perceptual filter which is made up by the listeners background, experience and
mental and physical states. Once the message has been received by the listener, it must be
interpreted. Therefore, this step includes fitting the verbal message into the relevant
linguistic category stored in the brain and then constructing the meaning of the message
(Wolvin, 2010)
5.1. Receiving
It is the first sub- process of the listening process. According to Devito (1997), it
consists of two stages which are hearing and attending.
First, at the hearing phase, the listener receives sound waves that come from the
outside environment and stimulate the sensory receptors of the ear. Many parts of the latter
work together to convert those sound waves into information that the brain transform into
sounds. Scientifically speaking, sound waves enter the outer ear and go through the ear canal
where the waves make the eardrum vibrates (see figure 3). Eardrum is: a thin, cone-shaped
membrane that separates the external ear from the middle ear (Wikipedia, 2015). Then,
those vibrations are transmitted to the middle ear bones making them vibrate too. Finally,
those vibrations go to the innermost part of the ear, which is the cochlea in which there are
tiny hair cells surrounded by fluid. When the latter reacts to the vibrations transmitted from
the middle ear, the tiny cells send signals to the auditory nerve that transmits information to
the brain which interprets those signals into meaningful sounds (Kalat, 2011, p. 113).
5.2. Understanding
The listener, at this phase, tries to decode the speakers message by constructing
meaning from the stream of sounds s/he receives (Osborne, 2005, p. 78). In the listening
process, understanding and interpreting a speakers message is an important stage because it
allows the listener to assess its meaning for correctness and validity (Steinberg, 2006 p. 71).
Although there is no explanation of how understanding occurs, it is evident that past
experiences play a major role (Livingston, 2010, p.187); therefore, the listeners previous
knowledge will help him/her to better understand what is being said.
5.3. Remembering
The listener, at this phase, stores what was said for future use. Therefore,
remembering is the process of storing the meanings that have been received so that they
may be recalled later (Steinberg, 1994, p.77). It is a very important step in the listening
process since it means that the listener did not only receive and decode the speakers
message but also added it to the minds storage bank.
5.4. Evaluating
The listener, at this stage, judges the ideas of the speaker in the light of what s/he
knows about the topic (Flojo, 2009, p. 12). Therefore, evaluating is the process of critically
analyzing information to determine how truthful, authentic, or believable (Solomon,
Theiss, 2013, p. 211). Besides, at this stage, the listener tries to infer the speakers message
and looks for accuracy and evidence of this message (Prentice Hall of India, 2004, p.82).
5.5. Responding
At this stage the listener provides a kind of feedback to the speaker which can be
verbal or non- verbal (Steinberg, 1994, 71). Responding is the only means through which the
speaker can measure the degree of success in transmitting his/her message. Furthermore, it is
considered as a turning point in the listening process since by responding the listener
becomes a speaker and the speaker becomes a listener.
6. Listening types
Listening types vary according to the listeners purpose of listening. We may listen to
get a particular piece of information (informative listening), as we may listen to make
judgments about the speakers message (evaluative listening). We may also listen to
discriminate sounds (discriminative listening), and we may listen to show the speaker that
we are interested in his/her message (empathetic listening). For better understanding, an
explanation and a description of each type is provided bellow:
10
11
When talking about discriminative listening, three elements should be taken into
account: first, the ability to hear, if one is not able to hear, s/he will not be able to
discriminate between sounds. Second, awareness of sounds, if the listener is not a native
speaker s/he may find it difficult to recognize sounds for example: a native speaker says: this
handle, however, a non-native speaker, may hear it this sandal. Third, the ability of
understanding non-verbal clues (Kline, 1996, p .42).
12
Therefore, from the previous quote, empathetic listening can be defined as listening
with empathy, showing the speaker respect, importance, and interest so that s/he will do the
same.
13
so for pleasure and general language improvement. Rost adds that for extensive listening to
be successful, the learner has to have access to an input that is comprehensible.
Extensive listening is certainly a useful way that highly contributes in improving the
learners listening skill. In this context, Brown et al. (2008, p. 195) state that: extensive
listening is also valuable for building confidence and simply enjoying listening in the target
language (cited by Rost, 2002, p. 195). Moreover, Broughton (1980, p. 69) claimed that
extensive listening can be used for two distinct aims. The first one is the re- presentation of
already known material in a new environment. The second one is letting learners listen to
vocabulary items and structures which are not familiar for them. Renandya and Farrell
(2011) argue that extensive listening facilitates language acquisition even at low levels by
providing the opportunity of listening to meaningful, enjoyable and comprehensible, spoken
texts
Moreover, Harmer (2001, p. 229) sees that teachers, heavily rely on taped materials, as
intensive listening means. However, on one hand, these taped materials have advantages
including the fact that they are available, not expensive and portable. On the other hand,
they have some disadvantages involving, the fact that not all students are able to listen at the
same rate, besides, in large classes, it is often difficult to ensure that all students can hear
equally well. Therefore, intensive listening is very demanding either for learners or even for
14
teachers who have to play different roles including machine operators and organizers (Ibid,
p.231-232).
Similarly, Keith and Lundberg (2014, p. 67) state that passive listening is like watching
television or a movie letting words and ideas wash over leaving whatever impact on the
listener. They add that passive listening is like zoning out from a conversation. However,
they see active listening as listening attentively looking for meaning and the appropriateness
of what is being said.
Kasser and Lytle (2005, p. 65) view passive listening as listening without saying
anything while they regard active listening as indicating to the speaker that hearing took
place, this can be done through paraphrasing, questioning, clarifying. Moreover, Grikscheit,
Cash, and Young (1993, p. 58), clarify that a passive listener is the one who only listens to
what is being said while an active is one who takes the initiative in extending the content of
a conversation.
15
9. Listening comprehension
Whenever we talk about listening, we talk about comprehension; therefore, the
relationship between them is very tight since the main aim of listening is to comprehend a
speakers message. Thus, listening comprehension is defined as: The understanding of the
implications and explicit meanings of words and sentences of spoken language (Borkowski
and Martin, 2014, p. 17). Besides, (Hamouda, 2013, p. 117) explains that:
16
The listener, in a top down processing, proceeds from what s/he already knows about
the subject and the lexical knowledge s/he possesses. Besides, s/he activates his/ her
background knowledge to predict and to understand the meaning of the speakers message.
This knowledge is called schema, it can be content schema (general knowledge based on life
experience and previous learning) or textual schema (language and content knowledge used
in a particular situation) (Helgesen and Brown, 2007, p. 6).
Shafaei (2010, p. 218) adds that the top-down approach emphasizes the listeners use of
his/her existing knowledge about the topic and the relevant context in forming hypotheses
about the speakers intended meaning. According to Carroll (1992, p. 56), in a top down
approach, information at the higher levels may affect processing at the lower levels. For
instance, a sentence context may affect meanings of words.
The listener, in this approach, tries to make sense of the input s/he receives by focusing
on different parts: vocabulary, grammar, and sounds. It is then a process of decoding sounds,
from the smallest meaningful units to complex texts (Lengyel and Navracsics, 2007, p. 61)
starting by phonemes moving to individual words, then to the syntactic level followed by the
semantic content analysis to finally reach understanding of the literal meaning.
17
This approach combines both the top- down and the bottom up approaches. It was
developed by Rumelhart (1980). The interactive approach suggests that listening
comprehension is an interaction between the aural input, different types of linguistic
knowledge, details, background knowledge, context and so forth (Gilakjani and Ahmadi,
2011). In other words, bottom up is based on linguistic knowledge while top-down is built on
background knowledge, therefore, if one is missing, the other would compensate it. Besides,
according to Flowerdew and Miller (2005, p. 2), the main advantage of this approach lies on
the fact that it admits the individual variation in linguistic processing i.e. it takes into account
different learning styles.
18
Conclusion
Listening is a highly complex process that passes through a set of sub- processes
namely receiving, understanding, remembering, evaluating, and responding. As a language
skill, listening needs to be developed in both ways: extensively and intensively. Besides, it is
out of doubt that listeners listen for different aims, they may listen to get a particular piece
of information, to make judgments about the speakers message, to discriminate sounds, or
to show the speaker empathy. Moreover, in order to comprehend the aural input, listeners
use either the top- down approach or the bottom- up approach. However, it has been
demonstrated that a third approach may be more effective, it is called the interactive
approach; the latter involves the use of both the top- down and the bottom- up approaches
simultaneously.
19
Introduction
Humans are given two ears and only one mouth, so that they might hear more than
they speak. Therefore, listening plays a major role in human life. As a language skill,
listening has long been neglected; however, recently, it started to gain attention due to the
amount of studies that have demonstrated its great importance not only in communication
but also in language learning. Hence, this chapter sheds light on the importance of the
listening skill in communication and its role in language learning. Besides, it emphasizes the
different roles that a foreign language teacher plays in listening instruction. Moreover, it
provides an insight into the listening strategies that develop learners' comprehension.
Furthermore, it involves a comparison between listening in first language and listening in
foreign language. In addition, it stresses the key element of listening comprehension and the
main difficulties that foreign language learners encounter while listening. Finally, it
highlights some standards that should be taken into account when teaching listening.
Research on the listening skill began with the pioneering work of Rankin (1930) who
found that the time spent in listening is about 42% while speaking takes 32% followed by
reading which takes about 15%, and finally writing which takes the least percentage about
11%. Brieter, as well, conducted a study on homemakers in 1972; he found that listening
takes about 48%, speaking about 35%, reading about 10% and writing about 7%. Barker et.
20
al conducted a study on U.S. college students in 1980. They found that students spend 53%
in listening, 16% in speaking, 17% in reading, and 14% in writing. Bohlkens study, in 1999
on U.S. College Students too, demonstrates that they spend 53% in listening, 22% in
speaking, 13% in reading and 12% in writing (Janusik, 2009, p. 106).
Study
Year
Population
Listening
Speaking
Reading
Writing
Rakin
1930
Varied
42%
32%
15%
11%
Brieter
1972
Homemakers
48%
35%
10%
7%
Barker
1980
U.S. college
53%
16%
17%
14%
53%
22%
13%
12%
students
Bohlken
1999
U.S. college
students
21
The previous results of the previous studies, conducted on the listening skill and
communication, show that the listening skill takes the lions share. Therefore, it is a
prerequisite for effective communication in everyday life. Several studies have confirmed
that listening skills are identified as more important than speaking, and writing skills.
Furthermore, in a foreign language learning situation, listening instruction helps learners to
communicate effectively using the target language in a real-life situation.
22
Listening instruction does not have effects only on the other language skills but also
on the listening skill itself. Petric (2000) conducted a study at the English Department,
University of Novi Sad, Yugoslavia, to confirm the hypothesis that listening instruction
leads to listening skill improvement. Results demonstrate that the experimental group
achieved greater scores than the control group in the post-test of the study. Therefore, this
study demonstrates the significance of listening instruction, and that it should be an integral
part of language development instruction.
23
Playing the role of organizer, the teacher has to inform his/her learners about their
listening aim. Besides, s/he has to give them instructions about how to achieve it. Moreover,
s/he is in charge of building his/her learners confidence by giving them tasks that are
achievable and inputs that are comprehensible (Ibid). As a machine operator, the teacher has
to be efficient in using tape players. Besides, s/he should be able to play and replay the tape.
Therefore, the teacher is supposed to try the material before coming to the class (Ibid). As a
Feedback organizer, the teacher has to conduct a feedback session when students have
completed the task. S/he can make them compare their answers. When performing this role,
the teacher has to be supportive in order not to sustain their motivation (Ibid). Playing the
role of prompter, the teacher plays the role of prompter when s/he replays the tape in order
to draw learners attention to particular language features (Ibid).
24
cognitive strategies are provided in table 2 along with the role of the teacher and the role of
the learner in each one.
Strategy
Linguistic
inferencing
Summarization
Transfer
Note taking
Deduction/
induction
Imagery
25
learners get their attention back when they lose it. Vandergrift (2003) claimed that advanced
listeners use twice as many metacognitive strategies as elementary listeners use.
Metacognition can be defined as thinking about ones own thinking. For instance, if a
student knows s/he encounters difficulties in finding the link between important concepts
within a story. s/he is uses a graphic organizer, such as a concept map, to identify the main
concepts and links them together using lines, similar to a spider web, then that student has
used metacognition to complete the task (Nelson & Conner, 2008).
Hence, using
metacognitive strategies.
26
Strategy
Directed attention
Selective attention
Comprehension
Monitoring
Checking ones
understanding
Performance
evaluation
27
other speakers and their attitude towards learning. Some illustrations of socio- affective
listening strategies are summarized in table 4.
Strategy
Cooperation
Lowering anxiety
Self- encouragement
Roles of learners
Roles of teachers
28
station. Besides, she sees that foreign language learners often are not able to interact or
discuss meaning with a tape. Moreover, time devoted to listening is very limited.
Furthermore, learners are unfamiliar with cultural norms (Ibid, p. 63).
Besides, Swabrik (Ibid, p.63) states that listening in a foreign language situation is
much more demanding than listening in first language situation. This may be due to the fact
that listening in the first language is often social and informal, besides, the context is
common. However, in case of foreign language learning, the listening is usually informative
and the context is formal, therefore, learners have to focus on the actual words used by
teachers.
6.1. Phonology
At the phonological level, the listener has to be able to distinguish between sounds.
Pearson and Fielding (1983, p. 3), provided an illustration, a speaker of English knows that
/bat/ differs from /vat/ but a speaker of Spanish along the Rio Grande does not "know" that
same distinction. Besides, the listener has to know intonation patterns which provide cues
that help him/her to understand whether the speakers statement is command, a request, a
question a declaration and so forth Moreover, the listener has to know stress patterns
because this would tell him/her on what part the focus should be (Ibid p. 4).
29
6.2. Syntax
At the syntactic level, the listener should be able to know paraphrase, as in (1) and
(2); and recognize cues regarding form class (inflections like -ed or -ing for verbs, -er and est for adjectives, etc., as well as sentence position cues like subject, verb, and object slots)
(Ibid, p. 4).
6.3. Semantics
At the semantic level, the listener should be able to recognize words meanings.
Fielding and Pearson illustrated: a dog is an animal that barks, has a sloppy tongue, and
fetches newspapers (Ibid, p. 5).
30
Foreign language learners while listening to the target language encounter some
difficulties that may impede the listening comprehension process. These difficulties may
include: pronunciation problems, speakers speech speed, repetition problems, vocabulary
problems, concentration problems, interpretation problems.
31
32
more learners lose their concentration, and the more likely listening comprehension
problems occur (Ibid).
inappropriateness
of
classrooms
influences
students
listening
comprehension. Students who are sitting on the back rows in large classrooms may not hear
the recording the same way as students sitting in front. Besides, students who sit next to the
windows are influenced by the outside noise. As a teacher we have to take into account all
this conditions in a body. The size of the classroom as well impedes teachers management
of the all class in group activity or to get feedback from students (Bingol et al. 2014, p. 4).
33
Dunkel (1991), Mendelsohn (1994), Morley (1991), Peterson (1991), Richards (1983), and
Rost (1991) as cited by Duzer, 1997).
34
using video can help learners develop cognitive strategies. As they view a segment with the
sound off, learners can be asked to make predictions about what is happening by answering
questions about setting, action, and interaction; viewing the segment again with the sound on
allows them to confirm or modify their hypothesis (Rubin, 1995). Therefore the teacher has
to expose his/her learners to listening activities that elicit the use of those strategies.
35
This stage involves activities done by the students during the listening passage. The
main goal of these activities is helping the students to obtain the main meaning of the text to
have enough information in order to interpret the text. Teachers have to spotlight the idea
that at this stage students should not worry about interpreting long and difficult questions
and subsequent production of complex answers, they should rather be concerned with
36
revealing the important information (Rixon, 1986). Besides, one of the main functions of
while-listening activities is to expose students to the sound of the target language which
enables them to improve their listening comprehension skills. Furthermore, when selecting a
while-listening activity, teachers have to take into account some criteria. First of all, they
should select an activity which is interesting and challenging at the same time. Other criteria
that should be considered are selecting a while-listening activity short enough and doing
various types of listening exercises because it would be annoying to do the same activity
over and over again. Moreover, knowledge based exercises should not be included since
such activities are time consuming and students who have some knowledge can lose their
interest. Another criterion is the level of difficulty, a difficult or too easy listening text can
be demotivating for the learners. Furthermore, graded tasks should be taken into account. In
other words, the learners start with listening to the main gist and then move to more and
more complex listening activities (Machkov, 2009, p. 27).
During this stage, students use their knowledge obtained during the previous stage for
completing the exercises. There are many reasons behind the integration of follow-up
activities into the lesson plans. Checking if the learners have understood the listening
passage or whether they completed the task successfully may be a good reason. Another
reason for a follow-up activity may be reflecting on why some students have failed or have
missed some parts of the text. Besides, there are several activities which can be used in the
follow-up stage such as: Problem solving and decision-making tasks in which students try to
find out a solution for a problem from the recording. Moreover, role- play in which students
are asked to try out newly acquired things. Furthermore, summarizing where students can be
asked to summarize what they heard (Machkov, 2009, p. 28).
37
Conclusion
Listening is an important language skill that plays a major role not only in
communication but also in foreign language learning. Therefore, many studies were
conducted to find out its importance and its effect over the other language skills. Results of
these studies have revealed that listening takes the lions share in communication and that it
38
improves the other language skills, namely, speaking, reading, and writing. Besides,
listening instruction is a challenging task for language teachers as they have to play different
roles at the same time and they have to introduce some strategies that develop learners
listening comprehension involving cognitive, metacognitive and socio-affective strategies.
Furthermore, Learners, while listening, encounter many difficulties that impede their
comprehension such as pronunciation problems, speech speed, and vocabulary problems and
so forth. Hence, teachers have to take into account some standards when selecting listening
activities and techniques including relevance of the topics, authenticity of materials and so
on, in order to minimize these difficulties. Finally, as lesson planning plays a major role in
the success of a listening lesson, being aware of its main stages is necessary for effective
listening instruction.
39
Introduction
Despite of the fact that the listening skill plays a critical role in language learning,
teachers often neglect it. This may be due to the fact that they find it difficult or time
consuming to teach listening or maybe they do not know how to do so. However, neglecting
this skill leads learners to have poor listening skills because they were not trained enough.
For this reason, this chapter provides some illustrations of listening lessons that promote
different approaches to comprehension (the top- down approach, the bottom up approach,
and the interactive approach). Besides, it suggests some games that can be helpful in
improving learners listening skills, especially, young learners
1.
fun day) is taken from Randalls ESL cyber listening lab (1998) and the second one is taken
from Johns ESL community (2000).
At this phase, the teacher asks his/her students to listen to a conversation (see
appendix 1) then answer the following questions:
40
At this phase, the teacher asks his/her students to compare their answers. After that s/he
asks them to answer the following question: What things did you do together with your
family when you were growing up?
41
Why the woman was finally permitted to take her dog into the theater?
At this phase, the teacher asks his/her students to listen to the tape and to change their
answers when needed.
C/ Post- listening
At this stage, the teacher provides his/her learners with the tapescript (see appendix 2)
and asks them how many correct answers they got. If they still have problems in
understanding s/he has to give them the correct answers by playing the part of the record
which contains the answer.
42
At this stage, the teacher asks his/her students to listen to the words in each pair ( see
appendix 3), and then decide whether the two words in each pair have the same stress
pattern by choosing S for the same or D for different.
At this stage, the teacher provides learners with word stress pattern rules including; the
use of suffixes to predict stress for example: stress on the suffix itself as Chinese, the use of
parts of speech to predict stress such as for certain two-syllable words used as both nouns
and verbs, stress nouns on the first syllable, and verbs on the second syllable.
43
At this stage, the teacher asks students to listen and practice the following examples:
S=/Z/
1) a-Telephone
b- telephones
2) a- Camera
b- cameras
3) a-Bookbag
b- bookbags
S=/S/
1) a-Desk
b- desks
2) a- map
b- maps
3) a- basket
b- baskets
S= /IZ/
1) a- sentence
b- sentences
2) a- exercise
b- exercises
3) a- watch
b- watches
44
At this stage the teacher asks his/her students to say the plural form of the following
nouns, and then complete the chart (see appendix 4). After that, the teacher asks them to
listen and check their answers.
At this stage, the teacher introduces the topic of the lesson by asking his/her students to
make a list of the ways they use when looking for a new job. Therefore, through this
activity, their prior knowledge is activated.
B/ While listening stage
At this stage, the teacher provides a bottom up listening task and a top- down listening
task. In the bottom up listening task, students are asked to listen to a tape in which two
interlocutors are talking about a job (see appendix 5), and to check words/ phrases they hear
(by putting either or X see table 5) and then compare their answers with each other.
However, in the top- down listening task, students are asked to listen to the dialogue
again and then answer the following questions:
-
45
Not heard
Lawyer
Find a job
Weekends
Sell
Sure!
Cruise ship
At sea
Good at
Pay
Buy
Phone
46
knowledge. This lesson aims at helping students to use the appropriate listening strategies
and preparing them for the first certificate in English (CFE) listening paper; therefore, this
type of activity, students are asked to listen for specific words or phrases and to provide
written answers.
At this stage, the teacher introduces the topic showing the students a set of pictures.
Then, s/he asks them to identify the jobs: a window cleaner, a vet, a detective, a plumber, a
singer, a dentist, a surgeon, a chef and an astronaut. Besides, at this stage, students are asked
to brainstorm as many words as they can about these jobs while the teacher writes their
ideas, this can be considered as a revision of words related to these jobs. Moreover, students
are asked to discuss the following questions in groups: How do you feel about each job?
Would you be interested in doing this kind of job? Why/ Why not? Finally, the teacher has
to pre- teach the vocabulary which s/he expects his/her leaners do not know (
At this stage, students are going to listen to a part of a radio interview with a woman
whose name is Christine Whitelaw talking about her job ( see appendix 6). The students fist
task is to read the article (see appendix 6), and try to predict the possible answers. Then,
they listen to the women and complete the sentences, after the listening they compare their
answers with their partners and discuss them. After that, they listen again to the women and
fill in the rest and check their answers. Finally, they listen again with the tapescript.
47
At this stage, the teacher asks his/her students what job they do, whether they enjoy it
or not, if they are not working, the teacher asks them about their free time or weekend jobs
or what they would like to do after finishing their studies. S/he can also ask them which
factors they consider as the most important when looking for a new job.
4.
learners progress or to identify their levels. Two sample listening tests are provided bellow
to demonstrate how the listening skill can be assessed. These two tests are taken from
Introduction: Assessment of Speaking and Listening Skills in English (2012, p. 10-20).
First, students are going to listen to a tape about a police announcement (see appendix
7), and then they are asked to select the picture that corresponds to the criminal described in
the tape. Second, students are asked to listen to another tape about the garden of Suresh
see appendix 8), then they have to select the appropriate sign from the given signs that
Suresh should put. Third, students are going to listen to a tape in which Monu describes
himself (see appendix 9), after that they have to fill in table 6. Forth, the teacher plays a tape
which contains a dialogue between Amit and Anand (see appendix 9) who have just
completed their studies, and they are talking about organizations that offer scholarships for
students for different purposes; then, the teacher asks his/her learners which organization
will Amit opt for. Fifth, students listen to a short passage in which a description of a house
48
that joy wants to live in, is provided (see appendix 11); after that students are asked to select
one of the pictures that correspond to the house that joy wants.
Age
Nationality
Table 6- Monu (Introduction: Assessment of Speaking and Listening Skills
in English, 2012, p. 9)
Part two
The students, in this part are going to listen to a talk by Dr. Praveen Chawla on healthy
foods (see appendix 12). The teacher, then, explains that there are three questions to be
answered.
49
Part three
The teacher explains to his/her learners that in this part they are going to listen to a
speech about joint families. Then, they have one of the three given options for each
question.
50
51
Part one
a. e-mail
b. air mail
c. postal department
d. surface mail
3. Complete the following statement according to extract three (see appendix 15)
The speaker advocates the use of now.
a. cars
b. buses
c. bicycles
d. metros
4. According to the extract (see appendix 16), what is the news report is about?
52
a. invention of Curiosity
b. landing of Curiosity
c. happiness at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory
d. possibility of living on Mars
5. According to the extract (see appendix 17), what does the V- chip do?
Part two
At this part the teacher informs his/her students that they are going to listen to a long
text about tigers (see appendix 18) and asks them to read the questions before they listen.
Then, they do the following tasks:
1. State whether the following statements are true (T) or false (F)
a. Peoples fascination with the tigers is causing them harm.
b. Wildlife tourism should be banned.
c. Tigers tourists are destroying their living places.
Part three
At this part, the teacher explains to his/her learners that they are going to listen to a
lecture about libraries and that they are asked to choose one of the three given options.
53
54
55
56
Conclusion
The listening skill, undoubtedly, plays a major role in language learning. Therefore,
giving it some attention becomes a necessity. This attention does not include only the theory
but should also involve practice. Hence, listening instruction should be included in language
learning programs. Besides, teachers have to provide their learners with listening lessons that
require from them to process the aural input using different approaches to comprehension
involving the top- down approach, the bottom approach and the interactive approach as
illustrated in this chapter. Furthermore, in order to have better outcomes teachers may play
with their learners some listening games that would improve their listening skill such as the
telephone game, guess what game, Simon says game and I spy game.
57
General conclusion
Listening is a highly complex process that consists of receiving, understanding,
remembering, and responding. As a language skill, listening is defined as a receptive decoding
skill in the oral mode. This skill has long been neglected and thought of as a passive skill that
does not need to be taught. Hence, this work attempts to provide a deep understanding of
listening by shedding light on its physiology, its psychology, the different listening types, and
the main approaches to attain comprehension. It, further, reveals the importance of the
listening skill and its effect on the development of the other language skills in addition to the
main problems that learners face and some strategies that may help them to overcome these
problems. Besides, it explains how to plan for a listening lesson and how to assess it.
Furthermore, it provides sample listening lessons and tests and suggests listening games which
may be useful for the development of learners listening skills.
The listening skill is an important language skill that should be taken into account by
language teachers. Therefore, this dissertation attempts to provide answers for the following
questions: 1) Is listening a complex or a simple skill? 2). To what extent is the listening skill
important in the teaching/ learning process? 3) How to teach the listening skill in EFL
classrooms?
Having a closer look at the listening skill demonstrates that it is a complex skill. Its
complexity lies on the fact that it requires the learners to go through certain steps to finally
reach comprehension. Besides, it requires them to use different mental processes (the top
down processing, the bottom up processing, and the interactive processing) in order to
construct meaning from the received aural input.
The listening skill is important to a large extent in the teaching/ learning process since it
is the first step to language learning and studies have shown that it positively affects the
58
development of the other language skills as most of learning comes through it. Therefore,
learners are in need of this skill. Hence teaching it should be included in all language
curricula.
Teachers can effectively teach listening through considering some criteria including the
choice of topics, the length of the audio passages, and the level of difficulty and so on.
Besides, lesson planning is the key of successful teaching, therefore, following the steps of
lesson planning is of great usefulness.
The limitation of this research lies in its theoretical nature. Hence, no hypotheses were
proposed because there is no practical part due to time constraints. Classroom observation or
experimental study in addition to teachers /learners questionnaire would be effective tools to
investigate this topic in the department of English, Badji Mokhtar University.
59
Bibliography
Adler, R., Rosenfeld, L. and Proctor, R. (2001). Interplay: the process of interpersonal
communicating (8th ed), Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt.
Badian, N. A. (1999). Reading disability defined as a discrepancy between listening and
reading comprehension. Journal of learning disabilities, 32, pp.138-148.
Barker, L.L., & Watson, K. W. (2000). Listen up. How to improve relationships, reduce
stress, and be more productive by using the power of listening. New York, NY: St.
Martins Press.
Berman, J. (2004). Empathic teaching. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
Berninger, V. (2000). Development of language by hand and its connections to language by
ear, mouth and eye. Topics in language disorders, 20, pp.65-84.
Bohlken, B. (1999). Substantiating the fact that listening is proportionately most used
language skill. The Listening Post, 70, 54-62
Borisoff, D. and Purdy, M. (1991). Listening in everyday life. Lanham, MD: University
Press of America.
Boulfelfel, A. (2014). An Investigation of Second-Year Students View about Studies,
Listening Comprehension, Motivation, and Teachers Styles. Doctoral Thesis,
Constantine University.
Bozorgian, H. (2012). The Relationship between Listening and Other Language Skills in
International English Language Testing System. Theory and Practice in Language
Studies, 2(4), pp.657-663.
Broughton, G. (1980). Teaching English as a foreign language. London: Routledge.
60
Brieter, L.R. (1971). Research in listening and its importance to literature. In Barker, L.L.,
Listening Behavior. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
Carroll, D. (1986). Psychology of language. Monterey, Calif.: Brooks/Cole Pub. Co.
Collins, S. (2006). Module 5: Interpersonal communication listening and Responding. 2nd
ed. United States of America: James O'Rourke.
Dawood, T. (2010). How to develop good study habits. United States of America.
Downs, L. (2008). Listening skills training. United States: ASTD Press.
Duzer, C. A. (1997). Improving ESL Learners' Listening Skills: At the Workplace and
Beyond. Center for adult English language acquisition.washington.
Edwards, S. (1999). Speaking and listening for all. London: D. Fulton Publishers.
Egan, G. (2002). The skilled helper. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole Pub. Co.
Flowerdew, J. and Miller, L. (2005). Second language listening. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Gerngross, G. and Puchta, H. (2004). Cool English. Cambridge: Press Syndicate of the
University of Cambridge in association with ELI.
Gilakjani, A. P. & Ahmadi, M. R. (2011). A Study of Factors Affecting EFL Learners'
English Listening Comprehension and the Strategies for Improvement. Journal of
Language Teaching and Research. 2 (5).Finland: Academy Publisher. 977-988.
Gottlieb, M. (2006). Assessing English language learners : Bridges from language
proficiency to academic proficiency. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
Grikscheit, G., Cash, H. and Young, C. (1993). Handbook of selling. New York: Wiley.
61
62
E.
and
Doyle-Portillo,
S.
(2006).
What
is
psychology?Australia:
Wadsworth/Thomson Learning.
Pearson, D. & Fielding. L (1983). Instructional Implications of Listening Comprehension
Research. Illinois: Urbana-Champaign.
Pemberton, R., Toogood, S. and Barfield, A. (2009). Maintaining control. Hong Kong:
Hong Kong University Press.
Rankin P.T. (1930). Listening ability, its Importance, Measurement, and Development.
Chicago School Journal, 12, 177-179.
63
64
65
Webogprahy
Bergman, O. (1999). Wait for me! Reader control of narration rate in talking books.
International Reading Association's Reading Online. Retrieved April 2, 2015, from
www.readingordine.arg/articles/art_index.asp?HREF=bergman/index.html
Esl-lab.com, (n.d.). Randall's ESL Cyber Listening Lab - For English as a Second
Language. [online] Available at: http://www.esl-lab.com [Accessed 9 May 2015].
Flojo, O. (2009). Module 6.1 curriculum and instruction: The teaching of English. Available
at: https://ditreading.files.wordpress.com/2009/06/module -6-1english.pdf [Accessed
11 Apr. 2015]
Harmer, J. (2012) Introduction: Assessment of Speaking and Listening Skills in English.
Guidelines for teachers to assess Speaking and Listening. Retrieved on May 1st , 2015,
from:
http://cbseacademic.in/web_material/Circulars/2012/63_Guidelines_for_Assessment_
of_Speaking_and_Listening_Skills.pdf
Janusik, L. (2006). Listening facts. D1025403.site.myhosting.com. Retrieved 2 May 2015,
available at: http://d1025403.site.myhosting.com/files.listen.org/Facts.htm.
John's ESL Community, (n.d.). John's ESL Community. [online] Available at:
http://www.johnsesl.com/ [Accessed 10 May 2015]
Petric, B. (2000). The effect of listening instruction on the development of listening skills of
university students of English. novELTy. [online] Available at:
http://deal.elte.hu/pages/novelty/htm2/vol73/bojana.htm [Accessed 13 Apr. 2015].
66
Public Speaking: Practice and Ethics. (2012). 1st ed. [ebook] Available at:
http://2012books.lardbucket.org/books/public-speaking-practice-and-ethics/index.html
[Accessed 10 Apr. 2014].
General introduction
General introduction
1. Statement of the problem
2. Aim of the study
3. Research questions
4. Dissertation division
Chapter one:
An Overview on the
Listening Skill
6.
7.
8.
9.
Listening definitions
Historical background of the listening skill
Listening physiology
Listening psychology
The listening process
5.1. Receiving
5.2. Understanding
5.3. Remembering
5.4. Evaluating
5.5. Responding
Listening types
6.1. Informative listening
6.2. Evaluative listening
6.3. Discriminative listening
6.4. Empathetic listening
Active vs. passive listening
Extensive vs. intensive listening skills
8.1. Extensive listening
8.2. Intensive listening
Listening comprehension
9.1. Listening comprehension approaches
9.1.1 The top down approach
9.1.2 The bottom up approach
9.1.3 The interactive approach
Conclusion
Chapter two:
Teaching and
Learning Listening
Chapter Three:
Listening Instruction
in Practice
Appendices
Appendices
1. A fun day
2. The intelligent dog
3. Word stress
4. The final s
5. I need a job
6. The right job
7. Police announcement
8. The right sign board
9. Monu
10. Amit and Anand
11. Joys dream home
12. Healthy foods
13. The nuclear family
14. Officer comment to his colleagues
15. Report news
16. Bicycles
17. Landing of curiosity
18. AV- chip
19. Tigers
20. Libraries
Appendix 1- A fun day tapescript (Randalls ESL cyber listening lab, 1998)
Rsum
La comptence d'coute est l'une des quatre piliers sur lesquels l'apprentissage des
langues se tient. Nanmoins, elle a t longtemps nglige et perue comme une comptence
passive. Toutefois, rcemment, certaines tudes ont rvl son importance dans
l'apprentissage des langues et ont prouv quelle nest pas passive mais plutt active. Ainsi,
cette tude fait la lumire sur l'importance de l'coute dans des situations d'apprentissage et
denseignement des langues. Par consquent, ce mmoire tente de fournir des rponses trois
questions principales: 1) est ce que l'coute est une comptence simple ou complexe? 2) A
quel point la comptence d'coute est importante dans le processus d'enseignement /
apprentissage? Et 3) comment enseigner la comptence d'coute dans des classes dALE
(lAnglais comme une langue trangre) ? Ce travail montre donc que l'coute nest pas une
comptence simple mais plutt une comptence complexe qui doit tre examine partir de
diffrents points: sa physiologie, sa psychologie et ses types. En outre, ce mmoire souligne
les diffrentes approches que les apprenants utilisent pour parvenir la comprhension.
Certaines tudes montrent que l'coute joue
communication quotidienne, mais aussi dans l'apprentissage des langues. Ainsi, une
comparaison a t faite entre l'coute dans une premire langue et lcoute dans une langue
trangre,
principales
rencontrent ont t
soulignes. Enfin, ce travail montre que l'enseignement de la comptence d'coute peut tre
atteint de manire efficace en suivant les trois tapes de la planification de la leon et en
appliquant certaines stratgies qui peuvent dvelopper la comprhension de l'coute des
apprenants. En outre, il suggre des exemples de leons dcoute et des tests et aussi quelques
jeux que les enseignants peuvent pratiquer avec leurs apprenants afin de dvelopper leur
comprhension orale.
,
,
,
)1 : )2
/ )3
:
.
.
.
General conclusion