Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
381
IOS
Press
23
(2008)
381394
1. Introduction
In the United States, older
individuals are the fastest growing
segment of the population with 20% of
these older Americans experiencing
some type of mental dis- order [25].
One in seven adults 70 years of age
and older have some type of dementia
[60].
As a result, psychological
services to older adults are rapidly
grow- ing. To meet the increasing
needs of older individ- uals various
ISSN 1053-8135/08/$17.00
reserved
126
C.W. Jamora et al. / Geriatric neuropsychology: Implications for front line clinicians
are
raised
by
reimbursement
limitations? and (j) How can we
advance our future services?
1.1. Can psychiatric illnesses, in
particular depression,
exacerbate or cause cognitive
deficits?
Almost one quarter of individuals
over the age of
55 meet the criteria for a psychiatric
disorder [39,
77]. Specifically, in older individuals
it has been esti- mated that 1035%
have significant depressive symptomatology, 1321% have significant
anxiety, and 3.6
4.5% experience psychosis secondary
to major depres- sion [34,47,52].
Moreover, depression following an
acute medical crises, such as stroke
and traumatic brain injury (TBI), are
relatively common.
For example,
some studies estimate that one out of
four stroke sur- vivors will experience
a major depressive episode with- in
one year [64], and 80% of older
individuals with a TBI meet criteria
for an Axis I disorder [70]. Giv- en
the prevalence of these psychiatric
disorders, most referral questions are
best addressed by adding a psychodiagnostic evaluation component
to the cognitive assessment.
A study by Feil and colleagues found
that older individuals with psychiatric diagnoses
have increased lev- els of apathy and
depression and demonstrate slowed
speed of cognitive processing and
diminished executive functioning [27].
High levels of depression were relat-
C.W. Jamora et al. / Geriatric neuropsychology: Implications for front line clinicians
127
What
are
their
current
medications/supplements,
the
dosages, and indications for use?
Are there any recent changes to
their medication regime? Are they
taking
their
medications
regularly?
Tabl
e1
Medications that may have cognitive
effects in older individuals
Drug class Medications Indication
manifestations
Side effects
Adverse behavioral
Anticholinerics
Ditropan, Detrol
Incontinence
Anticholinergic effects
Confusion
Antihistamines
Benadryl, Vistaril
Sleep
Sedation, anticholinergic
Confusion, agitation, effects,
urine retention delirium
Antipsychotics
Haldol, Zyprexa,
Agitation, Psychosis
Akathisia hypotension,
Increased fall risk
due hypotension, Risperdal, Seroquel
orthostatic
anticholinergic
confusion, restlessness, FDA has a
side, effects heart arrhythmias black
box warning on the use of
antipsychotics with
older individuals due
to increased risk of
stroke and cardiac
arrhythmias
Benzodiazepines
Ativan, Serax, Anxiety
Motor slowing,
Increased falls, delirium, may have
Valium, Xanax
diminished motor withdraw symptoms
if discontinued coordination, sedation
abruptly, long acting
are particularly
inappropriate
Diuretics Lasix, Aldactone,
Hypertension, fluid load in
Electrolyte imbalance,
Confusion and falls secondary to
Hydrochlorothiazide, Congestive Heart Failure dehydration
dehydration, fluid volume loss Thiazide
Narcotics Morphine, Vicodin,
Pain
Sedation Confusion,
falls
Loritab, Demerol
Steroids
Prednisone Autoimmune diseases,
Confusion
Confusion, falls, psychosis, mania
Myeloma,
Inflammatory
diseases
Selective Serotonin Paxil
Depression
High anticholinergic
profile
Confusion
Reuptake Inhibitors
Tricyclic Elavil, Tofranil,
Depression Pain High anticholinergic
profile
Increased falls related to orthostatic
Antidepressants
Nortriptyline
hypotension, Confusion
Adapted with permission from (Hunter & Cyr, 2006).
dividuals has negligible effects on
neuropsychological test performance
[11,49].
It can be difficult to assess pain in
patients with
neuropsychological impairment. For
example, patients with cognitive
impairments such as dementia or
apha- sia may be unable to articulate
the severity of their pain. They also
may have reduced pain detection due
to slowed cortical processing [62].
Neuropsychologists may need to
educate family, caregivers, and staff
mem- bers who work with older adults
who are experiencing cognitive
dysfunction or expressive language
difficul- ties
about non-verbal
indicators of pain.
A listing of
common pain behaviors in older adults
with cognitive impairments is
provided in Table 2.
In terms of clinical issues it is
important to assess
the location, frequency, duration,
quality, intensity, as well as, relieving
and exacerbating factors associated
with the patients pain experience
[40]. It is also help- ful to explore
whether patients feel their pain is adequately controlled, what the impact of
pain is on their functional abilities,
and what their knowledge, expectations, and beliefs are regarding pain
management and control [40].
Assessments of emotional function
such as depression and anxiety should
be incorporated as
Tabl
e2
Common pain behaviors in older
adults with cognitive impairment
Facial
Vocalizations/verbalizations
expression
Sighing, moaning, groaning
s
Grunting, chanting, calling out
Slight frown; sad,
frightened face
Grimacing, wrinkled
forehead, closed or
tightened eyes
Any distorted
expression
Rapid
blinking
Body
movement
s
Rigid, tense body
posture, guarding
Fidgeti
ng
Increased pacing,
rocking
Restricted movement
Gait or mobility
changes
Mental status changes
Noisy breathing
Asking for help
Verbally abusive
Changes in interpersonal interactions
Crying
or tears
Increased confusion
Irritabil
ity
Adapted with permission from American Geriatric Association
(2007)
referenced to norms that allow for
characterizations as Below Average,
memory score of
85 neither rules in, nor rules out, the
diagnosis of brain impairment.
In contrast to the descriptive
approach, the diagnos- tic referral
raises the question of whether or not
an in- dividual is impaired. Indeed,
diagnostic assessments follow the
pathognomonic sign approach [20].
Thus, premorbid functioning becomes
the reference standard, with the
neuropsychologist
charged
to
determine if the patients testing
performance deviates from expected
premorbid levels of functioning. In
this context, test performance is
characterized as Intact versus Mildly Impaired, Moderately Impaired,
or Severely Im- paired. However,
these scores or labels by themselves
do not identify abnormal performance.
A score in the
10th or even 5th percentile does not
necessarily indicate an abnormal
performance, unless the clinician
infers that this score deviates
significantly from the patients
premorbid level of functioning.
Therefore, population norms serve
only as points of reference and
premorbid estimates must be taken
into consideration.
Various
neuropsychological
screening batteries used in the
assessment of older individuals are
patterned af- ter the pathognomonic
model, and thus can be characterized as diagnostic or deficitoriented rather than descriptive or
population-based. Indeed, near errorless performances becomes the
comparison standard against which
deviations from this expectation are
7.
Tabl
e3
Diagnostic and descriptive
neuropsychological referrals
Referral questions for neuropsychological consultations according to the
Amer- Diagnostic Descriptive Diagnostic and descriptive ican Academy
of Neurology (1996)
1. When mental status examination reveals mild or questionable cognitive
deficits
X
such as mild cognitive impairment.
2. When following the course of a disorder is either in recovery or decline
such
X
as dementia and stroke.
3. When cognitive strengths and weakness are considered for living
independently.
X
4. In the context of providing specific rehabilitation or other therapeutic
services
X
such as stroke rehabilitation.
5. When a comprehensive profile buttressed with
clinical, laboratory and imaging
X data may assist in diagnosis such as
differentiating subcortical dementia from
frontotemporal dementia.
6. When considering epilepsy surgery.
X
7. When litigation issues arise questioning the patients cognitive status such
as
X
capacity for decision-making.
1.10. What levels of reimbursements
are available?
Beginning July 1, 1990 nonphysician providers of mental health
services (psychologists and licensed
clin- ical social workers) were granted
independent billing authority under
Medicare [66]. Obtaining these billing
privileges
for
geriatric
neuropsychologists has been both a
blessing and a curse. The blessing is
the oppor- tunity to provide services to
a population that is not on- ly growing,
individuals.
Ideally,
our
neuropsychological tests should have
more representative sample sized for
older individuals that are stratified by
age and education, as well as include
those
individuals
who
have
diminished cognition re- lated to
normal aging. That said, test
companies have begun to recognize
the lack of appropriate norms for
older adults and have made greater
efforts to design tests with older adults
in mind and include older adults in
their normative samples (e.g. WAISIV, WMS-IV, Independent Living
Scales, and expanded norms for the
RBANS). Our neuropsychological
tests should al- so be based on our
theoretical understanding of cognitive functions. Finally, more effort
is called for to establish evidencebased links between tests and daily
functioning (i.e. ecological validity).
As we look to the future, we must
begin to devel- op our role in
promoting cognitive health, increasing
the applicability of our research, and
appropriate reim- bursement for
services. Despite the expanding role
of neuropsychology in older adult
populations, it is con- cerning that
reimbursement for services are
shrinking. Rather than solely focusing
on neuropsychopatholo- gy, we should
work toward developing evidencebased treatment approaches that
incorporate case manage-
D. Aizenberg, M. Sigler, A.
Weizman and Y. Barak, Anticholinergic burden and the risk of
falls among elderly psy- chiatric
inpatients: A 4-year case-control
study,
International
Psychogeriatrics 14 (2002), 307
310.
[2] A. Akomolafe, A. Quarshie, P.
Jackson, J. Thomas, O. Def- fer, A.
Oduwole et al., The prevalence of
cognitive impair- ment among
African American patients with
congestive heart failure, J Natl
Med Assoc 97 (2005), 689694.
[3]
American Academy of
Neurology,
Assessment:
Neuropsy- chological testing of
adults,
Considerations
for
neurologists, Neurology 47 (1996),
592599.
[4] American Geriatric Society,
The management of persis- tent
pain in older persons, Retrieved
October 31, 2007.
http//www.americangeriatrics.org/
products/positionpapers/ perisitent
pain guide.shtml.
[5] American Medical Association,
Medicare participation options for physicians, Medicare
Physician Payment Action Kit,
2006, Retrieved November 4,
2007, from www.ama.org.
[6] American Medical Association
Council on Scientific Affairs,
Featured CSA Report: Improving
the
Quality
of
Geriatric
Pharmacotherap, 2004, Retrieved
October
31,
2007
from
http://www.amaassn.org/ama/pub/
category/13592.html.
[7]
American Psychological
Association, Guidelines for the
eval- uation of dementia and agerelated cognitive decline, Amer
Psychologist 53 (1998), 1298
1303.
[8]
American Psychological
Association Practice Organization,
CMS payment rule gravely
impacts Medicare mental health
services, 2006, Washington, DC:
Government Relations Of- fice,
Retrieved November 4, 2007 from
http://geropsych.org/
medicare.html.
[9] D. Attix and K. Welsh-Bohmer,
Geriatric
Neuropsychology
Assessment and Intervention, New
York: Guilford Press,
2006.
[10]
J. Bazarian, J. McClung, M.
[13]
T. Bowers and S. Knapp,
Reimbursement
issues
for
psycholo- gists in independent
practice, Psychothera Private
Pract 12(3), (1993), 7387.
[14]
H. Brodaty, A. Withall, A.
Altendorf and P. Sachdev, Rates of
depression at 3 and 15 months
poststroke and their relationship
with cognitive decline: The
Sydney stroke study, Amer J Geri
Psychtry 15 (2007), 477486.
[15] R. Bush, G. Chelune and Y.
Suchy, Using norms in neuropsychological assessment of the
elderly, in:
Geriatric Neuropsychology: Assessment and
Intervention, D. Attix and K.
Welsh-Bohmer, eds, New York:
Guilford Publications, 2006, pp.
133157.
[16] S. Bush and T. Martin, Geriatric
Neuropsychology: Practice
Essentials, New York:
Taylor & Francis, 2005.
[17] B. Caplan and J. Shechter, Test
accommodation
in
geriatric
neuropsychology, in:
Geriatric
Neuropsychology:
Practice
Essentials, S. Bush, and T. Martin,
eds, New York: Taylor & Francis,
2005, pp. 97114.
[18]
J. Cohen-Mansfield and S.
Lipson, Pain in cognitively impaired nursing home residents:
how well are physicians diagnosing it? J Amer Geri Soc 50
(2002), 10391044.
[19]
N. Col, J. Fanale and P.
Kronholm, The role of medication
noncompliance and adverse drug
reactions in hospitalizations of the
elderly, Arch Intern Med 150
(1990), 841845.
[20]
L. Davison, Current status of
clinical neuropsychology, Clinical Neuropsychology: Current
Status and Applications, Ox- ford,
England: V. H. Winston & Sons,
1974.
[21]
Department of Health and
Human Services, Mental Health: A
report of the Surgeon GeneralExecutive Summary, Rockville,
MD: US Department of Health and
Human Services, Sub- stance
Abuse and Mental Health Services
Administration, Center for Mental
Health Services, National Institutes
of Health, National Institutes of
Mental Health, 1999.
[22] K. Duff, J. Mold, M. Roberts
and S. McKay, Medical burden and
cognition in older patients in
primary care: Selective deficits in
attention, Arch Clin Neuropsych
22 (2007), 569
57
5.
[23]
M. Duffy, Psychological
services in long term care resource
guide, American Psychological
Association Public Interest Office
on Aging, 2006, Retrieved
November
4,
2007,
from
http://www.apa.org/pi/aging/long
term care resource guide
2006.
pdf.
[24] C. Eccleston, Chronic pain and
distraction:
An
experimental
investigation into the role of
sustained and shifting attention in
the processing of chronic persistent
pain, Behav Res Thera py 33
(1995), 391405.
[25] D. Elmore, Reaching the
underserved, Monit on Psych 34(8)
(2003)
, 32.
[26]
E. Erikson, The Life Cycle
Completed: A Review, New York:
Norton & Company, 1982.
[27] D. Feil, J. Razani, K. Boone and
I. Lesser, Apathy and cog- nitive
performance in older adults with
depression, Internat J Geri
Psychtry 18 (2003), 479485.
[28] S. Finn, Assessment feedback
integrating MMPI-2 and
Rorschach findings, J Personality
Assess 67 (1996), 543557. [29] S.
Finn, Therapeutic assessment of a
man with ADD, J
Personality Assess 80
(2003), 115129.
[30]
S. Finn and M.Tonsager,
Therapeutic effects of providing
MMPI-2 feedback to college
students awaiting therapy, Psych
Assess 4 (1992), 278287.
[31]
J. Flaherty, H. Perry, G.
Lynchard
and
L.
Morley,
Polyphar- macy and hospitalization
among older home care patients, J
Geront: Med Sci 55A (2000),
M554M559.
607.
[38] E. Heyer, R. Sharma, C.
Winfree, J. Mocco, D. McMahon, P.
McCormick et al., Severe pain
confounds neuropsychological test
performance, J Clini Experi
Neuropsych 22 (2000), 633
63
9.
[39] M. Hibbard, S. Breed, T.
Ashman and J. Williams, Cooccurring
psychiatric
and
neurological impairments in older
adults,
in:
Geriatric
Neuropsychology:
Practice
Essentials, S. Bush and T. Martin,
eds, New York:
Taylor &
Francis,
2005, pp.
327362.
[40] F. Hill-Briggs, J. Kirk and S.
Wegener, Geriatric pain and
neuropsychological assessment, in:
Geriatric Neuropsychol- ogy:
Practice Essentials, New York:
Taylor & Francis, 2005, pp. 385
400.
[41]
R. Hopkins, S. Gale and L.
Weaver, Brain atrophy and cognitive impairment in survivors of
acute
respiratory
distress
syndrome, Brain Injury 20 (2006),
263271.
[42] K. Hunter and D. Cyr,
Pharmacotherapeutics in older adults,
J Wound Ostomy Continence
Nurs 33 (2006), 630638.
[43] A. Jefferson, A. Poppas, R. Paul
and R. Cohen, Systemic hypoperfusion is associated with
executive dysfunction in geri- atric
cardiac patients, Neurobio Aging
28 (2007), 477483.
699.
[57] M. Newman and P. Greenway,
Therapeutic effects of providing
MMPI-2 test feedback to clients at
a university counseling service: A
collaborative approach, Psych
Asses 9 (1997), 122
13
1.
[58] B. Palmer, The expanding role
of neuropsychology in geriatric
psychiatry, Amer J Geri Psychtry
12 (2004), 338341.
[59] L. Patrick, C. Leclerc and M.
Perugini, Is rehabilitation neuropsychology an evidence-based
practice? Topics Geri Rehab
10 (2003),
160168.
[60] B. Plassman, K. Langa, G.
Fisher, S. Heeringa, D. Weir, M.
Ofstedal, J. Burke, M. Hurd, G.
Potter, W. Rodgers, D. Stef- fens,
R. Willis and R. Wallace,
Prevalence of dementia in the
United
States:
The
aging,
demographics and memory study,
Neuroepidemiology 29 (2007),
125132.
[61] W. Qiu, L. Price, P. Hibberd, J.
Buell et al. Executive dysfunction in homebound older
people with diabetes mellitus, J
Ameri Geri Soc 54 (2006), 496
501.
[62] I. Rainero, S. Vighetti, B.
Bergamasco, L. Pinessi and F.
Benedetti, Autonomic responses
and pain perception in Alzheimers
disease, Euro J Pain 4 (2000),
267274.
[63] C. Randolf, Repeatable Battery
for the Assessment of Neuro-
[70]
J. Silver, R. Kramer, S.
Greenwood and M. Weissman, The
association between head injuries
and psychiatric disorders: Findings
from the New Haven NIMH
epidemiologic catch- ment area
study, Brain Injury 15 (2001),
935945.
[71]
P. Solomon, M. Brush, V.
Calvo, F. Adams, R. DeVeaux,
W. Pendlebury and D. Sullivan,
Identifying dementia in the
primary care practice, Interna
Psychogeriatrics 12 (2000),
483493.
[72] R. Stewart, M. Moore, F. May,
R. Marks and W. Hale, Chang- ing
patterns of therapeutic agents in
the elderly: A ten-year overview,
Age and Ageing 20 (1991), 182
188.
[73] J. Sweet, N. Nelson and P.
Moberg, The TCN/AACN 2005
salary survey: Professional
practices, beliefs, and incomes of
U.S. neuropsychologists. Clini
Neuropsychologist 20 (2006),
325364.
[74]
S. Tariq, N. Tumosa, J.
Chibnall, M. Perry and J. Morley,
Comparison of the Saint Louis
University mental status examination and the mini-mental
state examination for detect- ing
dementia and mild neurocognitive
disorder a pilot study, Amer J
Geri Psychtry 14 (2006), 900910.
[75]
A. Trivedi, A. Zaslavsky, E.
Schneider and J. Ayanian, Trends
in the quality of care and racial
disparities in Medicare man- aged
care, New England J Med 353
(2005), 692700.
[76]
H. Tuokko and T.
Hadjistavropoulos, An Assessment
Guide
to
Geriatric
Neuropsychology, Mahwah, NJ,
US: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
Publishers, 1998.
[77] U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services, Older adults and
mental health, in Mental Health: A
Report of the Surgeon GeneralExecutive Summary, Rockville,
MD: US Department of Health and
Human Services, Substance Abuse
and Men- tal Health Services
Administration, Center for Mental
Health Services, National Institutes
of Health, National Institute of
Mental Health, 1999.
[78] M. Van Eijken, S. Tsang, M.
Wensing, P. de Smet and R.
Grol, Interventions to improve
medication compliance in older
patients living in the community,
Drugs Ageing 20 (2003),
229240.