Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
MAY 2016
splcenter.org
This report was prepared by the staff of the Intelligence Project of the Southern Poverty Law Center.
The SPLC is supported entirely by private donations. No government funds are involved.
© Southern Poverty Law Center. All rights reserved.
About the Report
This report was written by Mark Potok, with contributions from Evelyn Schlatter,
who interviewed Alan Chambers.
Special Recognition
Great thanks are due to the attorneys whose remarkable and pioneering work
in the 2015 JONAH trial informs this report.
They include David Dinielli, Sam Wolfe and Scott McCoy of the Southern Poverty
Law Center; James Bromley, Lina Bensman and Tom Kessler of Cleary Gottlieb
Steen & Hamilton LLP of New York, N.Y.; and Allyn Lite and Bruce Greenberg of
Lite DePalma Greenberg LLC of Newark, N.J.
Thanks also are owed to the important work of Wayne Besen, an activist
whose Truth Wins Out organization has been at the forefront
of the battle against conversion therapy.
Table of Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 4
James E. Phelan was utterly convinced. After all, he “aversion therapy” — such “treatments” as the
had himself overcome “unwanted same-sex attrac- administration of electric shock or noxious chem-
tions,” and since then had worked for years as a icals in conjunction with images of gay sex — that
conversion therapist, counseling men who wanted he testified “do work.” He even said the only sci-
to become heterosexual. He’d been on the scien- entific study that could convince him conversion
tific advisory board of the National Association for therapy was harmful would be one where “a major-
Research & Therapy of Homosexuality. And, ear- ity of the people commit suicide.”
lier in 2014, Phelan had written a book touting the Phelan was one of six defense “experts” offered
therapy’s alleged successes. by Jews Offering New Alternatives for Healing, or
But now he was on the spot. A lawyer for the JONAH (the acronym formerly stood for Jews
Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), which Offering New Alternatives to Homosexuality),
earlier had filed a lawsuit against a conversion in the case that was finally tried in a New Jersey
therapy group for consumer fraud, was deposing courtroom last year. Two were excluded because
him about his new book, Successful Outcomes of their testimony would have been irrelevant to the
Sexual Orientation Change Efforts: An Annotated issues being tried. But James Phelan, Joseph Berger,
Bibliography. Christopher Doyle and Joseph Nicolosi — all key
“You report in your book on a drug called metra- figures in the conversion therapy movement —
zol,” attorney Sam Wolfe said. “That’s also been wrote lengthy reports to the judge outlining their
reported in your book as having some value for peo- purported expertise.
ple who want to convert to heterosexual.” Superior Court Judge Peter F. Bariso Jr. barred
“Okay,” Phelan agreed. them all.*
“Are you aware that the FDA [Food & Drug Finding that the men’s assertions were all based
Administration] revoked approval for that drug on the claim that homosexuality is a mental dis-
in 1982?” order even though the “overwhelming weight of
“No.” scientific authority” concludes otherwise, Bariso
“Are you aware that that drug causes seizures?” ruled that “the theory that homosexuality is a disor-
“No.” der is not novel but — like the notion that the earth
That’s not all. Metrazol, a drug that was used in is flat and the sun revolves around it — instead is
the 1930s and 1940s to treat various mental health outdated and refuted.”
disorders, produces explosive convulsions — so Conversion therapy, also known as “reparative”
explosive that in one large study 42% of patients or “ex-gay” therapy, is on the ropes. Virtually all
undergoing the procedure suffered spinal fractures. relevant U.S. medical associations — plus, just this
Ultimately, the FDA found that the acutely painful March, the world’s largest professional association
treatments, lasting from two to four months, were of psychiatrists — have condemned it. In the last
barbaric and banned them.
Phelan didn’t know any of that, even though his
book was written 32 years after the FDA action. * T
he judge made a narrow exception for Berger, who was allowed to testify
only that it was unusual that Unger’s therapist’s notes did not make more
His book also listed another 35 sources favoring mention of JONAH.
But by then, the ex-gay movement already was resigned after a sociology professor studying his
in trouble. claims interviewed 14 of Cook’s former clients.
Every one said their sexual orientation had not
Things Fall Apart changed, and 12 said they had had sexual con-
The idea that gay people could convert to het- tact with Cook during “treatment.” As a result,
erosexuality began to unravel within a few short the Seventh-day Adventist church pulled its fund-
years of the first ex-gay groups’ formation. Over the ing, the group moved to Houston, and Cook’s
course of the next four decades, that claim received co-founder took over.
a battering of biblical proportions. After the religious right’s expensive 1998 ad
Just a few years after Love in Action became campaign brought the reparative therapy move-
the first reparative therapy group in America, a ment to national attention, things went from bad
prominent member, John Evans, quit the group in to worse. It started the same year, with the hor-
disgust after a close friend, Jack McIntyre, report- rific murder of gay student Matthew Shepard in
edly committed suicide over his inability to become Wyoming. The much-publicized killing illustrated
heterosexual. And in 1979, four years after group the violence that LGBT people faced.
founder Kent Philpott published his book recount- Then, in 1999, Russ Goringe, one of the first
ing six “successful” conversions, Evans and three of board members of the Mormon reparative
the others whose stories were featured wrote the therapy group Evergreen International, found
publisher of Philpott’s The Third Sex? to say that himself hiking in the mountains with his wife
his claims that the four had become heterosexual and four children. In despair over his continu-
were “100% false.” ing same-sex attractions, he says he was about to
That same year, two of the five founders of commit suicide by leaping off a rope bridge when
Exodus International, Michael Bussee and Gary one of his daughters saw and stopped him. In the
Cooper, quit that group to become a couple. They aftermath, he reevaluated his beliefs, divorced
later divorced their wives and, in 1982, joined in his wife and, with his children’s support, mar-
COURTESY OF MICHAEL BUSSEE (COUPLE); LINKEDIN (BUSSEE)
that reparative therapy changes sexual orientation; sexual contact with the man, saying he was merely
in fact, it does great harm to many people.” helping to carry luggage, but the man told a wholly
Paulk’s fellow ad campaign star, Michael different story. Rekers resigned from NARTH’s
Johnston, soon ran into trouble of his own. board a week later.
Johnston, who had been featured in 1998 TV ads The reparative therapy movement was also
touting reparative therapy and was the founder seriously damaged as professional organization
of “National Coming Out of Homosexuality Day,” after professional organization followed the lead
was accused in 2003 of infecting men he met via of the American Psychiatric Association in declas-
the Internet with HIV. The American Family sifying homosexuality as a disorder. Over the
Association, which had partly funded the ad cam- years, the American Psychological Association,
paign, acknowledged that Johnston, who was the American Academy of Pediatrics, the National
featured in its “It’s Not Gay” video, had had a Association of Social Workers, the American
“moral fall.” Nevertheless, the group, after initially Counseling Association, the American Association
stopping, soon resumed distributing its video. for Marriage and Family Therapy, the American
In 2007, the industry hit a new low with the Medical Association, the American School
conviction of Chris Austin, a reparative therapist Counselor Association, the American School Health
from Texas who had addressed both Evergreen Association and the American Psychoanalytic
International and NARTH, for sexually assaulting Association all issued similar statements. Each one
a male client. He was sentenced to 10 years. also condemned the practice of conversion therapy.
The next embarrassment was the third for Love Then, in 2012, Robert Spitzer, the psychologist
in Action. John Smid — another ostensibly ex-gay who had led the 1973 effort to declassify homo-
man who had married a woman, joined that group sexuality as a disorder, retracted a 2003 study that
and finally become its executive director — quit had concluded that some highly motivated people
in 2008. He divorced his wife of 19 years shortly could change their sexual orientation. The study,
afterward and, in 2010, apologized for his role in which was published in a peer-reviewed journal,
the reparative therapy movement. “I offer my most had been used repeatedly by ex-gay groups to val-
sincere and heartfelt apology to the men, women idate their own beliefs. However, most of Spitzer’s
and especially children and teens who felt unlov- subjects had been referred by ex-gay groups and, as
able, unworthy, shamed or thrown away by God he later explained, that meant that at best he could
or the church,” he said. In 2014, Smid married his only conclude that his study reported what those
male partner. people claimed.
In 2010, NARTH officer and scientific advisory But the most dramatic blow to hit reparative
board member George Rekers was exposed for therapy came in 2013, when Exodus International
traveling abroad with a male prostitute. He denied President Alan Chambers, who had grown
other men for long periods of time. Ostensibly an blindfolded while other participants bounced bas-
exercise to develop nonsexual relationships with ketballs nearby and hurled anti-gay epithets at him.
men, it involved positions like “the motorcycle,” in He recounted how Downing told him to go to ritual
which one man sat backed up into the lap of a man Jewish baths in order to see men naked.
hugging him from behind. Ferguson described the Summarizing some of the plaintiff’s testimony,
exercise as both “predatory” and “very homoerotic.” Judge Bariso described one particularly strange
JONAH’s
‘Scientific’ Testimony
The defense in last year’s civil lawsuit against Jews disorder “requires that any expert opinion to the
Offering New Alternatives for Healing, or JONAH contrary be barred,” along with any opinion based
(the acronym formerly stood for Jews Offering on that claim. As Judge Bariso concluded, “[T]he
New Alternatives to Homosexuality), offered theory that homosexuality is a disorder is not novel
six men it claimed were “expert” witnesses. The but — like the notion that the earth is flat and the
six — Joseph Berger, Christopher Doyle, Joseph sun revolves around it — instead is outdated and
Nicolosi, James Phelan, John Diggs and Rabbi refuted.” He also asserted that one of the proffered
Avrohom Stulberger — were presented as people experts had plagiarized others’ work for his expert
who could, based on evidence generally accepted report to the court. What follows are excerpts from
by the scientific community, explain and defend depositions taken from Berger, Doyle, Nicolosi and
the practices of JONAH. As such, they were each Phelan by plaintiffs’ lawyers in late 2014, in advance
required to submit an expert report in advance of of trial.
trial explaining their opinions, and also had to sub-
mit to depositions taken by the plaintiffs’ lawyers,
who worked hard to discredit them. The plaintiffs’ DR. JOSEPH BERGER
attorneys later argued to the judge that the experts Dr. Joseph Berger is a Jewish psy-
should be excluded largely because their testimony chiatrist and psychotherapist who
was based on the assertion that homosexuality is has long been part of the conver-
a disorder, despite the fact that no authoritative sion therapy movement, although
medical organization agrees. In the cases of Diggs he is married to a woman and
and Stulberger, New Jersey Superior Court Judge says he has never experienced
Peter F. Bariso Jr. excluded their testimony because same-sex attractions (SSA) him-
Diggs’ assertion that homosexual behavior involves self. Trained in the United States,
health risks and Stulberger’s expertise on Orthodox Berger practices from offices in Ontario, Canada,
Judaism’s view of homosexuality were irrelevant where he has treated men with SSA and in which
to the issues at trial. Bariso also excluded the much country, in 2006, he addressed a parliamentary
more important testimony of the other four men, committee in order to urge it not to afford “special
who are longtime proponents of reparative ther- rights” to transgender people. (If such people claim
apy and well known in their field (with a narrow that they are, for instance, a “woman trapped in a
exception allowing one of them to testify that it man’s body,” Berger described them as a clinically
BOXTURTLEBULLETIN.COM
was unusual that one of the plaintiff’s therapist’s “psychotic.” If they say they merely feel that way,
notes did not make more mention of JONAH). but recognize that they are not one sex trapped in
Bariso ruled that “the universal acceptance” of the another’s body, then they are simply unhappy, Berger
“scientific conclusion” that homosexuality is not a testified, and “[t]he proper treatment of emotional
years of training from ex-gay advocates including 2,000 individuals who are homosexual and hun-
the National Association for Research & Therapy dreds changed, if he was really lying or trying to
of Homosexuality, the conversion therapy group make a point, wouldn’t he say that more than a few
that he has been a part of since 2008. Today, he is hundred changed?
ward] Bindrim, and you have a citation to Bindrim. late Charles Socarides) in 1992. In the years that
… And my question is, how did you rely on that followed, Nicolosi produced three similar titles:
piece of work in forming your opinions in this case? Healing Homosexuality: Case Stories of Reparative
I don’t recall. Therapy (1993), A Parent’s Guide to Preventing
gerous thing? And when they survive it, it’s like [Y]our book reports on the reported outcomes in
a, it’s like a rite of passage. That happens to be the studies?
male psychology. Yes. Yes.
Portraits of
Three Survivors
The plaintiffs in last year’s civil suit against Jews Offering New Alternatives for Healing (JONAH) were
young men who, mainly because of the religious beliefs of their families, were desperate to resist homo-
sexuality. But, as each testified, the idea that they could be “cured” and converted to heterosexuality
actually was a phantasm, and the treatment offered by JONAH and related organizations often turned
out to be downright bizarre and sexually creepy. There were originally six plaintiffs — Michael Ferguson,
Benjamin Unger, Chaim Levin and his mother, Bella Levin, and Sheldon Bruck and his mother, Jo Bruck.
But because the plaintiffs were only seeking reimbursement for the money they actually spent because of
JONAH, Sheldon Bruck was dismissed as a plaintiff as it was his mother who paid his therapy bills. What
follows are portraits of the three remaining plaintiffs who underwent JONAH therapy, and accounts of
what happened to them there.
BENJAMIN UNGER Luckily, Ben Unger had his parents, whom he’d
HIS MOTHER PAID THE PRICE felt close to throughout his childhood. On a break
Ben Unger was coming into from the school in Israel, he approached his mom.
his own as a teenager, a shy “I went back home, and I was very, very con-
kid emerging from his shell as fused,” Ben testified during the lawsuit last year
he grew into an increasingly against JONAH. “So I told my mom. She was the
rambunctious and self-confi- — the first person I told. … She was very loving, no
dent young man. By his third judging. She actually recommended that I should
year at the all-boys Jewish talk to my father, after she gave me support, of
religious high school he attended near his home in course. She felt my father would be more … well-
Brooklyn, N.Y., he felt he had joined the “in” group equipped ... to handle this.”
of his peers. How did that go? Ben was asked in court. “It
AMY SUSSMAN/AP IMAGES FOR SOUTHERN POVERTY LAW CENTER
But Ben had a terrible secret. went great, considering … the way we grew up,”
He had grown up in an Orthodox Jewish he testified. “I mean, he was extremely loving,
community that rejected even the possibility of very supportive, almost, I would say, as confused
homosexuality; he was expected to soon begin as I was as far as, like, what to do and how to deal
dating girls on his way to an early marriage and with it. But he — he’s a great dad, so he was — he
children within that community; and he had was awesome.”
been feeling increasingly attracted to boys ever Still, Ben’s father was at a loss. At first, he recom-
since he was 11 or 12 years old. During a post- mended that his son seek advice from various rabbis,
high school year in Israel at an all-boys yeshiva, it which Ben did upon his return to Israel. One told
became unbearable. him — seriously — “that if I find a wife who cooks
time,” he said. “And I did that literally — I had over life, which means that you abstain from having sex,
here, I had a huge gash and my hands were actually or that you marry a woman anyway.”
know, one of the principles that I was taught on something you see in San Francisco or on televi-
Journey Into Manhood was the principle of sur- sion but never in Crown Heights. And being outed
Homophobia and
‘Reparative Therapy’
While some ancient societies had no problem with homosexuality and others treated it with savage
violence, there also have been hundreds of years of attempts made by some to “cure” or “repair” homosex-
uality. Many have been barbaric, like using electric shock therapy in conjunction with gay pornographic
images, but that kind of treatment has virtually disappeared at this point. The following timeline describes
some of the high and low points in the battle over whether homosexuality is a treatable disorder or dis-
ease that can be overcome with therapy or prayer.
1075 BC 1889
The Middle Assyrian Empire’s Code of Assura Baron Albert von Schrenck-Notzing of Munich,
imposes castration on soldiers who engage in same- Germany, a leading advocate of hypnosis and its
sex intercourse. supposed therapeutic qualities as well as a stu-
dent of parapsychology, tells the First International
390 AD Congress on Hypnotism that it took him 45 hypno-
Christian emperors criminalize homosexual sex, sis sessions over four months to “cure” a gay patient
with public burning as the punishment. of his homosexuality. Three years later, Schrenck-
Notzing will claim to have completely cured or
654 significantly improved a total of 70 people with
The Visigoths in southwestern Europe criminal- homosexual or other “perverse inclinations.”
ize sodomy, making it punishable by castration, the
first such law on the continent. 1892
Graeme Hammond, a leading
1179 American neurologist and propo-
The Third Lateran Council of Rome decrees that nent of physical exercise to treat
sodomy is punishable by excommunication. mental conditions, proposes rid-
ing a bicycle in order to treat a
1533 variety of supposed disorders
Anal intercourse is made punishable by death that includes homosexuality.
in England.
1899
1610 Dr. Denslow Lewis says some lesbians suffer from
Virginia makes sodomy punishable by death, the hyperesthesia, or excessive sensitivity to stim-
first of many such laws in the American colonies. uli, and suggests cures including “the application
of cocaine solutions, saline cathartics, the surgi-
AP IMAGES
that gay men “are more treatable and curable than them. In 1987, that, too, will be dropped.
is generally believed.”
Love in Action, the first contem-
1968-1976 porary reparative therapy ministry
Pioneering sexologists in America, is founded in Marin
William Masters and County, Calif., by Frank Worthen
Virginia Johnson over- and the Rev. Kent Philpott. But
see a program aimed at John Evans, a prominent early
converting gay people member, will later quit the group
to heterosexuality that and denounce it after a friend, Jack
claims a success rate of McIntyre, reportedly commits sui-
72%. In 1979, they will publish a book on that topic, cide over his inability to become heterosexual. John
Homosexuality in Perspective, based on 14 years of Smid, a later executive director of the group, also
research. But both Johnson and another top asso- will eventually denounce sexual orientation change
ciate will later reject Masters’ theory that sexual efforts as fruitless and dangerous, saying in 2011 that
orientation can be changed, even suggesting that he “never met a man who experienced a change from
his data might have been faked or composites of homosexual to heterosexual.” In 2014, Smid will marry
many cases. his same-sex partner. In 2012, the group, now based in
Memphis, Tenn., will be renamed Restoration Path.
E. Mansell Pattison and his wife, Myrna Loy Nicolosi and Benjamin Kaufman found the
Pattison, introduce the scientific community to the National Association for Research & Therapy of
term “ex-gay” in an article in the American Journal Homosexuality (NARTH), which will grow into
2003
1999 The U.S. Supreme Court strikes down sodomy laws
The American Counseling Association adopts a in 13 states in Lawrence v. Texas, ending the crimi-
resolution “opposing the promotion of ‘repara- nalization of gay sex throughout the country. In his
tive therapy’ and a ‘cure’ for individuals who are majority opinion, which overturns a 1986 decision
homosexual.” In 2003, the professional counseling by the same court, Justice Anthony Kennedy cites
association will permanently expel Richard Cohen, the 14th Amendment and writes that the petition-
founder of the International Healing Foundation ers “are entitled to respect for their private lives.
and past president of Parents and Friends of Ex-Gays The State cannot demean their existence or con-
and Gays, over of a series of ethical violations. trol their destiny by making their private sexual
conduct a crime.”
2000
Arthur Goldberg, a convicted con man who once 2006
went by Arthur Abba Goldberg, forms JONAH, The American Psychological Association issues a
an ex-gay organization based in Jersey City, N.J., statement saying that conversion therapy is “not
whose acronym stands for Jews Offering New supported by the science.” Furthermore, it says, the
Alternatives to Homosexuality. Later, the last two claims made about conversion therapy by ex-gay
words of the group’s full name will be changed to groups NARTH and Focus on the Family “create
“for Healing.” an environment in which prejudice and discrimi-
nation can flourish.”
and Christine Bakke, both formerly involved with his post at NARTH, which said it had known noth-
Exodus International. The pair also launches the ing of his past until then.
“Beyond Ex-Gay” website.
George Rekers, a NARTH board member and also a
Longtime ex-gay counselor Chris member of its scientific advisory board, is found to
Austin, who has given speeches have paid a male prostitute to accompany him on a
for both Evergreen International European vacation. While Rekers says the man was
and the National Association hired only to carry his luggage, the man says he in
for the Research & Therapy of fact gave Rekers daily nude massages that included
Homosexuality, is convicted of genital contact. A week later, Rekers, a founding
sexually assaulting a male client, board member of the Family Research Council
sentenced to 10 years in prison who has testified as an expert witness repeatedly
and required to register as a sex against LGBT people but been sharply criticized by
offender. According to LGBT activist Wayne Besen, the judges in some of those cases for slanted testi-
Austin, whose therapy practice is based in Irving, mony, resigns from NARTH.
April 8, 2015
Saying in a statement that the
practice “can cause substantial
harm,” President Obama calls
for an end to reparative ther- June 25, 2015
apy for minors nationwide. The In a first-of-its-kind decision, a state jury in New
president is acting in response to Jersey finds that JONAH committed consumer
a petition to outlaw such therapy fraud by selling services that it claimed could turn
sparked by the suicide of trans- clients from gay to straight.
gender teenager Leelah Alcorn.
Aug. 20, 2015
LAZERPRINCESS/TUMBLR (ALCORN); AP IMAGES/SUSAN WALSH (OBAMA); AP IMAGES/TOM WILLIAMS/CQ ROLL CALL (LIEU); KARSTEN MORAN (JONAH)
April 15, 2015 Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner signs a law banning
Calvin Chang, a gay lawyer who works for the reparative therapy for minors, making his state
California Department of Corrections, files suit the fourth to do so, along with Washington, D.C.
against NARTH co-founder Benjamin Kaufman,
who he accuses of defaming him to his employer Oct. 7, 2015
and confining him with “a large dog under com- NARTH co-founder Benjamin Kaufman, a psychi-
pelled coercion.” Chang alleges that he was denied atrist, surrenders his medical license to California
promotion because of his sexual orientation, then authorities after being accused of an “extreme
ordered to see Kaufman, who Chang says subjected departure from the standard of care” in treating
him to reparative therapy without his consent. an alcoholic, severely depressed patient. According
Chang also accuses Kaufman of threatening to to the complaint, which Kaufman does not contest,
have him fired (which he later will be) if he doesn’t the psychiatrist repeatedly prescribed the patient
accept a demotion. identified as “L.S.” Schedule III medications and
mood stabilizers without seeing her in person. As
May 19, 2015 a result, it says, the woman’s alcoholism led to “an
U.S. Rep. Ted Lieu (D-Calif.) irreversible neurological condition” and she fell
introduces the Therapeutic into a coma on Sept. 9, 2011.
Fraud Prevention Act, which
would classify conversion ther- Oct. 14, 2015
apy as a fraudulent practice The federal government’s Substance Abuse and
banned under the Federal Trade Mental Health Services Administration releases
Commission Act. The law, a 67-page report, Ending Conversion Therapy:
co-sponsored by House Minority Supporting and Affirming LGBTQ Youth, that says
The Groups
Historically, attempts to “cure” gay people of their homosexuality have been marked by real horror
stories — the use of castration, shock therapy, brain surgery, aversion therapy, the implantation of a het-
erosexual man’s testicles and more. But the contemporary reparative therapy movement, which began
in earnest with the 1973 creation of Love in Action, has generally taken two calmer routes: the heav-
ily religious, “pray away the gay” avenue, and a purportedly scientific path based on ideas about family
structure drawn from Freudian psychotherapy that have been discredited for decades. The clients of
these “ex-gay” or “conversion therapy” groups are often gay men and lesbians who feel a conflict between
their faith — typically, sexually conservative religions like Catholicism, Orthodox Judaism, Mormonism
and fundamentalist Protestantism — and their sexual desires. Some of the groups below provide thera-
peutic or other services to their LGBT clients, while others act as referral services. A few engage in truly
bizarre practices. Many of them have suffered scandals as their leaders, board members or other prom-
inent members were exposed for engaging in secret gay liaisons or, in some cases, sex with their gay
clients. In recent years, and especially since the devastating 2015 loss of the ex-gay group JONAH in a
civil suit, reparative therapy groups have been increasingly on the defensive. What follows are descrip-
tions of 10 of the most prominent ex-gay groups. There are many other smaller, similar groups, as well
as uncounted individual practitioners.
COURAGE INTERNATIONAL across the United States and abroad and was offi-
NORWALK, CONN. cially recommended in 2006 by the U.S. Conference
FOUNDED 1980 of Catholic Bishops as a support group for Catholics
with unwanted same-sex attractions. The group,
FOUNDER FATHER JOHN HARVEY
which in the U.S. goes by the name Courage, also
Courage International is a ministry authorized as has a ministry aimed at relatives and friends of gay
an apostolate of the Catholic Church and conceived people called Encourage.
by Cardinal Terence J. Cooke, the archbishop of
New York, as a “spiritual support system which
would assist men and women with same-sex attrac- EVERGREEN INTERNATIONAL/NORTH STAR
tions in living chaste lives in fellowship, truth and SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
love.” Its leaders say they do not practice reparative
FOUNDED 1989
therapy. But the founder, John Harvey, saw homo-
sexuality as pathological, and the organization has The group originally known simply as Evergreen
long had a 12-step program, based on the similar was founded by 11 men who were troubled by their
Alcoholics Anonymous program, that’s meant to same-sex attractions in light of their faith in the
help gay people abstain from sex. Moreover, an Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS),
early history of the group, found on the EWTN which condemns homosexual relations. The group
Catholic television website, says sexual orientation never took a position on the cause of homosexu-
change is possible and homosexuality is disordered. ality, but did say that “many people find success
Courage International today has chapters in cities in overcoming homosexual behavior, diminishing
An Interview
Alan Manning Chambers is a Christian who was long attracted to men but felt that that was incompat-
ible with his faith and struggled for years against his desires. After working at an Orlando, Fla., church,
he joined Exodus International, the largest ex-gay religious organization in the country, eventually ris-
ing to executive director and then president of the organization. Chambers spent 20 years as an activist
working against LGBT rights like same-sex marriage, and he married a woman with whom he adopted
two children. In 2004, according to the American Prospect magazine, he even claimed that he knew “tens
of thousands of people who have successfully changed their sexual orientation.” But in recent years, he
increasingly began to believe that efforts to change the sexual orientation of gay men and lesbians did not
work and actually could harm subjects. In 2013, after years of voicing increasing doubts about reparative
therapy and the like, Chambers and his board of directors decided to permanently shut down Exodus
International, and he apologized for his past actions. In 2015, Chambers wrote a book, My Exodus: From
Fear to Grace, that describes his life as an activist, his own personal struggles with same-sex attractions,
and how he came to change his beliefs. Today, Chambers remains married to his wife and also a Christian,
although his vision of Christianity is considerably more inclusive today than when he was an activist.
Chambers spoke to the Southern Poverty Law Center’s Evelyn Schlatter about his journey.
Alan, how did you come to be involved in ex-gay but Eleutheros taught me that “such were some of
ministry? you.” It was mixture of bad and good news for me
In 1991, at the age of 19, I responded to an altar call at the time. A part of me I had no control over was
at the end of an evangelical youth mega-confer- sinful but change was possible. Despite some focus
ence. That evening, I uttered the words “I’m gay” to on change, I found hope, acceptance and encour-
another human being for the first time. Through a agement. It was 1991 and help for gay Christians
series of events stemming from that evening, I was was nonexistent. Exodus was it and it was a gift.
referred to Eleutheros, the Orlando [Fla.] affiliate
of Exodus International. You were involved with Exodus for many years. Can
Eleutheros — Exodus — was a lifeline for me. you tell us how you came to the group and some-
Being raised in a Southern Baptist home and thing about your role there?
church, and believing in Jesus from an During the time I was involved, in
early age, my faith was real and strong. the early 1990s, Eleutheros was one
Yet, internal, and sometimes external, of 90 or so local ministries affiliated
torment was my constant compan- with Exodus International. The min-
ion. I’d felt different my entire life and istries were loosely connected and
when, at the onset of puberty, differ- Exodus’ primary role was as a refer-
ent materialized into gay, gay didn’t ral base. Exodus’ main event was its
jibe with Southern Baptist. annual conference.
The local ministry undergirded The conference was well-attended,
my faith and propelled my trust in with over 500 people the first year I
God. I had heard that homosexuals went. The compelling speakers and
wouldn’t inherit the kingdom of God, topics, great music, and people proved
splcenter.org
This report was prepared by the staff of the Intelligence Project of the Southern Poverty Law Center.
The SPLC is supported entirely by private donations. No government funds are involved.
© Southern Poverty Law Center. All rights reserved.