U-turn as lab accepts scientist caught

meningitis at work
5:00 AM Monday Aug 4, 2008

A strain of meningococcal disease which nearly killed a visiting scientist in 2005 is likely to have resulted
from her work at an Environmental Science and Research lab, a new investigation has found.
The scientist, Jeannette Adu-Bobie, worked at the lab in Porirua for three weeks researching

meningococcal disease before being admitted to hospital with neisseria meningitidis in March 2005.

She almost died, and doctors had to amputate both her legs, an arm and some fingers on her remaining
hand.

But Dr Adu-Bobie, who returned to England, later raised concerns about work practices at the lab and

was stunned when a Labour Department investigation concluded it was "extremely unlikely" the disease
was picked up at the lab. ESR said at the time it was a "tragic coincidence".

But the Labour Department revealed early today that it now believed Dr Adu-Bobie probably contracted
the disease from the laboratory in the course of her work.

The department said it had apologised following a new investigation by its chief adviser on occupational
health, Geraint Emrys.

Dr Emrys said that, as with the original investigators, he was unable to identify exactly how Dr AduBobie was infected or find any faults with ESR's safety systems that could have led to the infection.

"ESR's safety systems conform to international best practice and no failure of these systems has been
identified," he said.

However, there was no compelling evidence to suggest she was infected anywhere else. "Given the

circumstances, it is my opinion as an occupational health specialist that on the balance of probabilities,

Dr Adu-Bobie was infected at the laboratory. The cause of this infection remains unknown."

Labour Department regional manager Mike Munnelly said he had apologised for the distress caused by
the original investigation. "We acknowledge the ordeal that this has been for Dr Adu-Bobie, and
appreciate that she wishes to ensure no other scientists suffer as she has."

Dr Emrys said new research on lab-acquired infections and the handling of neisseria meningitidis had

concluded safety standards here were consistent with international recommendations, and there was no
clear or urgent need for change.

"That view has not changed," Dr Emrys said.

The wider review on the issue confirmed the original investigation findings that the strain of the

organism that infected Dr Adu-Bobie was indistinguishable from the one she worked with in the
laboratory and the epidemic strain present in New Zealand.

But it provided new information that four of the five cases reported in Wellington around the same time
Dr Adu-Bobie fell ill involved a different strain of the disease.

The fifth case was a similar strain but couldn't be confirmed as the same one that infected Dr Adu-Bobie.
- NZPA

Copyright 2015, NZME. Publishing Limited