Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Jennifer Hubbard-Snchez
Certificate of Approval:
John Sedlacek
Associate Professor
MES Coordinator
Charlie Collins
Assistant Professor
MES Program
Mara Merlino
Associate Professor
Division of Behavioral
and Social Sciences
Tierra Freeman
Associate Professor
Division of Behavioral
and Social Sciences
David Allen
Assistant Professor
Murray State University
Michael Bomford
Professor
Kwantlen Polytechnic University
Kirk Pomper
Interim Director
Land Grant Programs
Lorna Shaw-Berbick
Dean of the University
Jennifer Hubbard-Snchez
A Thesis
Submitted to
Frankfort, KY
Jennifer Hubbard-Snchez
Jennifer Hubbard-Snchez
Date
2015
All Rights Reserved
iii
Vita
iv
Thesis Abstract
vi
Acknowledgments
The author would like to thank Drs. Buddhi Gyawali, John
Sedlacek, Charlie Collins, Mara Merlino, Tierra Freeman,
Michael Bomford, and David Allen for serving as committee
members for this thesis research. She would also like to
thank Mr. Ken Bates for his assistance with the creation of
maps, and Ms. Susan Templeton for her help with navigating
SPSS.
Table of Contents
List of Tables...........................................ix
List of Figures...........................................x
Chapter I- Introduction...................................1
Chapter II- Literature Review and Theoretical Framework...6
Consensus on Climate Change in the United States.....6
Priorities and Beliefs in the United States..........9
The Social Construction of Climate Change...........15
Discourse, Framing, and the Media...................20
Climate Change Beliefs and Kentucky Political
Discourse...........................................29
Research Questions and Hypotheses...................36
Chapter III- Methodology.................................39
Survey Instrument Design and Sample Population
Selection...........................................39
Scores Assigned to Assess Climate Change Beliefs and
Climate Science Literacy............................44
Chapter IV- Results......................................46
Kentucky Climate Change Survey Respondent
Population..........................................46
Kentuckians Beliefs about Climate Change...........49
Kentuckians Knowledge of Basic Climate Science.....52
Chapter V- Discussion and Conclusion.....................59
References...............................................70
Appendices...............................................83
A. Kentucky Climate Change Survey....................83
B. Recoding of Survey Variables......................89
viii
List of Tables
Table
Page
ix
List of Figures
Figure
Page
Chapter I: Introduction
13
14
20
Framing is especially important when dealing with policyrelevant information, where frames are utilized as
organizing devices that allow the selection and emphasis of
topics to determine what is most important about an issue
(Grundmann & Stehr, 2010).
Recognition of
Millions of industry
For
29
Governors Conference on
35
38
39
41
42
43
45
46
47
Political
Affiliation
Age
Education
Race / Ethnicity
Gender
Always Republican
Usually Republican
Equally Republican or
Democrat
Always Democrat
Usually Democrat
Neither Democrat nor
Republican
Refused
Count Percent
28
12.2
40
17.5
12.2
28
33
44
49
14.4
19.2
21.4
3.1
18-24
25-34
35-44
45-54
55-64
65-74
75+
13
36
35
34
49
36
26
5.7
15.7
15.3
14.8
21.4
15.7
11.4
1
0
1
6
6
1
51
46
25
51
37
4
0.4
0.0
0.4
2.6
2.6
0.4
22.3
20.1
10.9
22.3
16.2
1.7
White, Non-Hispanic
Black, Non-Hispanic
Other, Non-Hispanic
Hispanic
2+ Races, Non-Hispanic
204
13
2
4
6
89.1
5.7
0.9
1.7
2.6
Male
Female
118
111
51.5
48.5
Total Respondents
48
229
When asked
does climate
change worry
you? most
respondents
professed at
least some
worry about
climate change
(Figure 3).
Figure 3: Level of Respondent Worry about Climate Change
An overall
50
A Pearson
product-moment
correlation
coefficient was
computed to
assess the
relationship
between age and
belief scores,
and it was
understand where
Kentuckians obtain
information about
climate change,
respondents were
asked to report their
most common sources
Percentage
Television broadcasts
69.9
Internet
51.5
Print Media
25.3
22.3
Talk Radio
19.7
Social Media
18.8
Politicians
7.4
21.0
of
information on
Table 3: Respondent Sources of Information on Climate Change
it
52
To measure
respondent
knowledge of basic
climate science
questions, an
overall knowledge
score was
calculated that
combined points
Figure 5: Frequency of Mean Knowledge Scores on a Scale of 0-17
generated from
responses on Q6-1 Q8-12 on the survey (Appendix A). The
range of possible knowledge scores for this study was 0
17 points and the mean score for all respondents was 7.5
(SD = 3.14), calculated using the compare means function of
SPSS (Figure 5).
Respondents were asked about impacts in the improbable
event that we were to stop burning fossil fuels today. When
asked to respond to the statement, If we were to stop
burning fossil fuels today, climate change would stop
almost immediately, a majority of respondents (67.7%)
answered correctly that the statement is false or probably
false. Over one-fifth of respondents (21.4%) claimed to not
know the answer.
53
54
% of correct
% who said
Contributing Factors to
responses
they did
among
not know:
participants:
Factor:
Burning Fossil Fuels for Heat
43.7%
6.6%
Deforestation*
43.2%
5.2%
40.2%
11.4%
and Electricity*
55
39.7%
16.6%
20.5%
9.6%
The Sun*
16.6%
9.6%
Acid Rain
16.2%
17%
14%
7.9%
Cows*
10%
14.4%
Toxic Wastes
9.2%
8.7%
7.9%
15.3%
Volcanic Eruptions
6.6%
12.7%
republicans.
56
57
59
60
The mean knowledge score for all respondents was 7.5 out of
a possible 17 points. Kentuckians surveyed are unsure of
how the burning of fossil fuels contribute to CO emissions
and climate change, as well as how climate differs from
weather. Knowledge scores on questions related to the heattrapping capabilities of major greenhouse gases were also
quite low, as most respondents were unclear about water
vapor, methane, and CO as being efficient at trapping heat
from Earths surface. Further, when asked about specific
factors that contribute to climate change, most respondents
did not answer survey questions correctly.
Hypotheses tested in this study included: H1) Selfidentified democrats will have a higher professed climate
change belief score than self-identified republicans, which
was supported; H2) An increased understanding of basic
climate science correlates with an increased level of
belief that climate change is happening, which was not
supported; and H3) An increased understanding of basic
climate science concepts will correlate with an increased
level of belief that climate change is occurring due to
anthropogenic factors, which was not supported.
62
the public and combat this issue, one that will soon be
theirs to confront.
Conclusion
69
References
Augoustinos, M., Walker, I., & Donaghue, N. (2006). Social
Cognition: an integrated introduction. Thousand Oaks,
CA: Sage Publishing.
Barron-Lopez, L. (2014). Senate Dems stage climate allnighter. Washington DC: The Hill. Retrieved April 8,
2014, from http://thehill.com/blogs/e2-wire/e2wire/200263-climate-change-all-nighter-in-congress
Benson, E. (2008). Society's Grand Challenges: Insights
from Psychological Science. Global Climate Change.
Washington DC: American Psychological Association
Science Directorate. Retrieved April 8, 2014, from
www.apa/org/science
Boykoff, M. T., & Boykoff, J. (2007). Climate Change and
Journalistic Norms: A casy-study of US mass-media
coverage. ELSEVIER, 1190-1204.
doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2007.01.008
Brand, A., & Brunnengraber, A. (2012). Conflictive
Knowledge Constructions on Climate Change through
Mainstream and Alternative Media. Transcience, 3(1),
7-24.
70
http://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2014/04/09/earthinstitute-scientists-speak-out-on-climate-change/
Clement, S. (2013, April 22). How Americans see global
warming- in 8 charts. The Washington Post. Retrieved
March 3, 2014, from
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/thefix/wp/2013/04/22/how-americans-see-global-warming-in8-charts/
Cook, J., Nuccitelli, D., Green, S. A., Richardson, M.,
Winkler, B., Painting, R., . . . Skuce, A. (2013).
Quantifying the consensus on anthropogenic global
warming in the scientific literature. Environmental
Research Letters, 8(2). doi:10.1088/17489326/8/2/024024
Davenport, C. (2015). McConnell Urges States to Help Thwart
Obama's War on Coal. NY Times. Retrieved December 9,
2015, from
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/20/us/politics/mitchmcconnell-urges-states-to-help-thwart-obamas-war-oncoal.html?_r=0
72
73
74
76
77
78
79
80
are-wasting-precious-time-influential-nasa-scientistsays-government-must-take-action-on-climate-change/#
Roos, J. (2011, February 3). Toward a Social Theory of
Climate Change. The Breakthrough. Retrieved from
http://thebreakthrough.org/archive/towards_a_social_th
eory_of_cli
Rosa, E., & Dietz, T. (1998). Climate Change and Society:
Speculation, Construction, and Scientific
Investigation. International Sociology, 13(4), 421455. doi:10.1177/026858098013004002
U.S. Census Bureau. (2014). Kentucky State and County Quick
Facts. Retrieved December 8, 2015, from
http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/21000.html
U.S. House of Representatives. (2014). Congressman John
Yarmouth: The Environment (webpage). Frankfort, KY:
U.S. House of Representatives. Retrieved June 1, 2014,
from http://www.yarmuth.house.gov/environment
United States Global Change Research Program. (2014). 2014
National Climate Assessment. Washington DC: US Global
Change Research Program. Retrieved May 19, 2014, from
http://nca2014.globalchange.gov/report
81
82
83
SURVEY
Section A: Climate Change Beliefs In this first series of
questions, we will be asking you for information about your
views and opinions on climate change and where you most
often get your information about this topic. This will
provide us with good background information about
Kentuckians beliefs about climate change.
Q1) Which of the following statements most accurately
reflects your views on climate change?
___I am extremely sure that it is happening. (21%)
___I am very sure that it is happening. (24%)
___I am somewhat sure that it is happening. (25.3%)
___I am not at all sure if it is happening. (16.2%)
___I am somewhat sure that it is not happening. (3.5%)
___I am very sure that it is not happening. (4.4%)
___I am extremely sure that it is not happening. (4.4%)
Q1A) If you believe climate change is happening, do you
think it is caused by
___Mostly by human activities (16.6%)
___Both human activities and natural changes (52.4%)
___Mostly by natural changes in the environment (12.7%)
___Dont know/Refused (4.8%)
Printed Materials
(Newspapers,
Magazines,
Newsletters,
Journals):
85
Internet
(Blogs, News, Social
media):
Broadcast Media
(TV and Radio):
Definitely
True
Probably
True
Probably
False
Definitely
False
Dont
Know
2.2%
8.3%
37.6%
30.1%
21.8%
53.7%
35.8%
2.6%
0.4%
7.4%
45.9%
31.4%
6.1%
3.1%
13.5%
25.3%
40.6%
13.5%
10.5%
13.5%
86
average
climate
conditions
in a region
Climate and
weather
mean pretty
much the
same thing
21.4%
27.5%
18.8%
17.5%
14.8%
11.8%
17.9%
28.4%
28.8%
13.1%
Description
Efficient
at
trapping
heat from
the
earths
surface
(Choose
all that
apply)
Most
abundant
greenhouse
gas
Carbon
dioxide
Water
vapor
Hydrogen
Methane
Oxygen
Ozone
Dont
Know
26.6%
13.5%
2.6%
14%
3.9%
34.9%
35.8%
34.5%
8.3%
3.5%
9.2%
7%
5.7%
31.9%
Not at all
A little
Some
33.6%
A
lot
40.2%
Dont
Know
5.2%
7.4%
13.5%
7.9%
13.1%
28.4%
43.7%
7%
4.4%
6.6%
11.4%
25.3%
29.3%
34.9%
43.2%
19.7%
11.8%
13.6%
87
The hole in
the ozone
layer
Toxic wastes
Aerosol spray
cans
Nuclear power
plants
The sun
Acid rain
The space
program
Cows
7.9%
14%
31.4%
31%
15.7%
9.2%
14%
14.8%
27.5%
27.1%
34.9%
39.7%
15.7%
9.1%
7.9%
20.5%
17%
21.8%
31%
9.6%
16.6%
16.2%
39.7%
18.8%
21%
18.3%
29.7%
27.9%
17.5%
24%
17.9%
7.9%
10.9%
17%
16.6%
34.5%
22.3%
18.3%
10%
14.8%
88
Recoded
Variable/Points
Assigned
0
0
-1
-2
Missing
Dont Know
Refused to Answer
Q1A on survey (if skipped)
Q1 on survey
1 point
2 points
3 points
1 or 2
3, 4, or 5
6 or 7
Q1A on survey
1 point
2 points
3 points
1
2
3 or 4
Q2
1 point
2 points
3 points
1
2
3
Q3
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
4
Belief Score
point
points
points
points
Q1+Q1A+Q2+Q3/4
89
or
Q1+Q2+Q3/3