Você está na página 1de 40

Fin ob o ers

j
d n p .in
ca

jo
yo a t
re

ur ge er
May 2010 • Vol. 28 • Issue 5

ne 36 ac
bsxt o t
de r o io
ve nl n.
lop ine or
me at g
nt
Monday Developments Magazine
The Latest Issues and Trends in International Development
and Humanitarian Assistance

A Conversation
with MCC’s
Daniel Yohannes

Reaching Out
to Haiti’s
Overlooked Survivors Winning the NGO
Talent Competition
Bite-sized Islamic Schools

Philanthropy
Does Low-cost, High-volume
Giving Really Work?

www.mondaydevelopments.org

Washington, DC 20036
1400 16th Street NW, Suite 210
InterAction
InterAction’s

FORUM 2010
Kicker

moving at the speed of change

ConnectInfluenceEngage
Forum sessions feature current and emerging international issues,
compelling speakers and interactive workshops.

Workshop Topics Plenary Sessions


➤➤Role of Private Foundations in the new PDA ➤➤New Directions for US Foreign Assistance
‘movement/revolution’ (CEOs Only) ➤➤America’s Ambassadors? The NGO role
➤➤Cost Recovery/Overhead (CEOs Only) in Public Diplomacy
➤➤Working Together to Fight Poverty and Meet the ➤➤Hunger as a Development Priority
MDGs ➤➤The Shifting Paradigm—Challenges in
➤➤Budget Appropriations 101: The Theory and Urban Assistance
Messy Reality ➤➤Haiti—A New Way Forward
➤➤Different Needs Equal Opportunities: Integrating
Gender Into Humanitarian Response
➤➤Promoting Women’s Political Participation in
South Asia: Afghanistan, Nepal and India
➤➤Disaster Risk Reduction in Urban Settings
➤➤NGO Coordination: Lessons Learned from Haiti
and Beyond
June 2-4
➤➤Images of the South in Northern Publications:
Ethical Photography and Related Issues
Walter E. Washington
➤➤Inclusive Foreign Assistance: Bringing Convention Center
Marginalized Voices to the Table
➤➤Managing Two Critical Risk Areas for Overseas Washington, D.C.
Operations: Taxation of American Expatriates
and Global Insurance
➤➤mSurvey—Global Datamapping

Register
2 onlineDEVELOPMENTS
MONDAY at www.interaction.org/forum
May 2010 or call 202-667-8227 for more information
Monday Developments Magazine

THIS ISSUE
23 A Conversation with Departments
MCC’s Daniel Yohannes
The first in a new series of 4 Reflections from
conversational interviews with the President
influential people affecting the
May 2010 Vol. 28 • No. 5 5 Washington Update
NGO community.
By Nasserie Carew 6 InfoBytes

12 26 Winning the NGO


Talent Competition
33 Projects
35 Events
How to retain and leverage your
most valuable resource. 36 Job Opportunities
By Curtis Grund

29 Navigating the Path


to a Rewarding Career
Plotting the career progression
of an international development
professional.
By Andrea Bediako

31 How Young NGO


Professionals Can
Develop a Career
Strategy
Practical steps for making a plan
that works for you.
By Roxy Allen

32 Tradition and
Learning in Islamic
Cover photo-illustration by Chad Brobst
Schools
A conversation with Helen Boyle.
Features 17 Beyond These By Heidi LaFleche
Mountains... More
12 How “Bite-
Sized” Philanthropy
Mountains
Want effective aid in Haiti? Tough 23
is Reshaping the choices need to be made right now.
Development Landscape By Terry F. Buss
New technologies and new
20 What Gets Left
17
strategies reach a new breed of
philanthropists. Behind
By Radha Muthiah and Chris Shea SEA and the long-term benefits
of building accountability to
15 Getting Clear, communities.
Real and Better By Angela Wiens and Daisy Francis
The Goldman Sachs 10,000
Women initiative forges a new 21 Reaching Out to
model of giving. Overlooked Survivors
By Jeri Eckhart-Queenan, Susan Thousands of earthquake survivors
Wolf Ditkoff and Susan J. Colby have dispersed into the Haitian
countryside. Are they doomed to
be forgotten?
By Martha Thompson
26
3
21
May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS
Reflections from the President

Monday Developments Magazine

Recognizing NGOs as Donors Managing Editor/Art Director


Chad Brobst

Advertising/Subscriptions
At the end of March, million individuals)—and
Katherine Delaney

$2.87 billion from the U.S.


InterAction convened two government. With regard
Copy Editor
Kathy Ward
days of meetings on Haiti to Haiti, the NGO commu-
nity has raised over $900 Executive Editor
relief and reconstruction. million in private funds: Nasserie Carew
During those meetings, I met $501 million for recon- News Editor
struction and $464 million
with InterAction CEOs whose for relief efforts.
Tawana Jacobs

Proofreader
organizations are working in Haiti, with Euro- Our community has
Margaret Christoph
pean, Asian and Canadian NGOs working in demonstrated effectively—in this recent crisis, but
Haiti, with Haitian civil society and with U.S. also through its support for the diverse programs Intern
government and UN officials to discuss rebuild- members run worldwide—that the American Nancy Backus
ing the country. public considers us to be the face of American Monday Developments Magazine
The meetings were fruitful and our community assistance overseas. They entrust us with resources is published by:
came out unified on scope and message: we are and expectations to help people rebuild their lives. InterAction
committed to working with the donors, the Haitian As such, our community is a fundamental voice 1400 16th Street, NW, Suite 210
government, the global NGO community and local at the table on discussions regarding aid effective- Washington, DC 20036
civil society to ensure that reconstruction in Haiti is ness, donor impact and global private develop- Tel: 202.667.8227
done in an efficient, effective and life-saving manner. ment flows. At the table we must demonstrate our publications@interaction.org
Part of that discussion focused on the private commitment to transparency and accountability ISSN 1043-8157
funds that the NGO community has raised to work to both our beneficiaries and donors, as well as our
in Haiti; at press time we were at $501 million just commitment to upholding standards for efficient,
Monday Developments Magazine is pub-
for reconstruction efforts and $464 million for relief effective development and humanitarian aid. lished 11 times a year by InterAction,
efforts. Based on the amount of funds the Ameri- This touches on one of the major initiatives Inter- the largest alliance of U.S.-based interna-
can public has entrusted to InterAction members Action is undertaking: mapping the footprint of our tional development and humanitarian non-
alone, the NGO community has proven itself a community created by the programs our members governmental organizations. With more
major donor, capable of raising funds equal to or are carrying out. We’re working with members to than 185 members operating in every
developing country, InterAction works to
greater than that of governments and ODA levels. gather information needed to show donors and overcome poverty, exclusion and suffer-
How we use those funds, and the position it gives others where our community works, what programs ing by advancing social justice and basic
us, should impact our standing as a donor in the we carry out and the reach that we have. Our goal dignity for all.
future—our accountability, our effectiveness and is to show the global reach of our community and InterAction welcomes submissions of
our credibility to speak on issues of importance. the complexity of NGO programming. We are news articles, opinions and announce-
This month’s issue looks at trends in philanthropy, also working to help both NGOs and donors make ments. Article submission does not guar-
as the overall architecture of international develop- better-informed decisions about their investments antee inclusion in Monday Developments.
We reserve the right to reject submis-
ment has become radically more complex with an and development support. We hope to have a map sions for any reason. It is at the discretion
explosive growth of private development funding. soon showing Haiti programs that will contribute to of our editorial team as to which articles
Recent conversations I have had with CEOs have the dialogue on reconstruction. are published in individual issues.
focused on elevating and rationalizing private devel- Regarding the recovery of our costs and the All statements in articles are the sole
opment assistance; understanding the impact of our issue of “overhead,” we hope to convene a group opinion and responsibility of the authors.
programs and how to effectively explain them to of CEOs later this year to discuss an effective path
Articles may be reprinted with prior per-
different audiences; and how to properly recover the to solving this continuing challenge. mission and attribution. Letters to the
cost of running our programs worldwide. I hope to continue these discussions with your editor are encouraged.
Elevating private development assistance is organizations and to continue to work with you
A limited number of subscriptions are
directly linked to the role our community plays in to raise recognition of the U.S. NGO community made available to InterAction member
Haiti, how we relate to other donors, implement- as both a partner and major donor. MD agencies as part of their dues. Individual
ers, the Haitian community itself and beyond. As subscriptions cost $80 a year (add $15
I mentioned on a number of occasions this past for airmail delivery outside the U.S.)
year, the InterAction community in 2006 received Samples are $5, including postage.
Additional discounts are available for
$5.995 billion from private funding sources— Sam Worthington bulk orders. Please allow 4-6 weeks for
including foundations, corporations and over 13.6 President and CEO delivery. Advertising rates are available
million donor groups (which translates to some 40 InterAction on request.

4 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Washington Update If you would like to be added to InterAction’s weekly public policy email update
please contact Margaret Christoph at mchristoph@interaction.org

Budget resolution by the Senate on March 5. In create a strategy to guide future ate Appropriations Leadership
markups planned its passage of its bill, the House U.S. support directed toward outlining recommendations for
As the budget cycle moves adopted a provision from the protecting civilians and regional the anticipated Haiti supple-
forward, the House Budget Senate version instructing the stability from threats posed by mental appropriations legisla-
Committee is likely to mark up Secretary of the Treasury to the Lord’s Resistance Army. tion and other critical matters.
its resolution April 14 or 21. No support the creation and use The bill also contained a sense The recommendations include
word yet as to whether the Sen- of a multilateral trust fund of Congress on the need for $1.482 billion for immedi-
ate committee plans to follow for Haiti in order to leverage increased funding to support ate emergency needs around
suit. A “mark up” involves the potential U.S. contributions and humanitarian assistance and the world (including fund-
appropriate subcommittee(s) promote bilateral donations transitional justice activities. ing for International Disaster
considering, possibly amend- to such a fund. The bill was A sense of Congress is a note Assistance, food assistance
ing, and then voting on a bill so “preconferenced”—the House in a bill stating a firm opinion and Migration and Refugee
it can go back to the full Appro- and Senate versions were rec- on a matter, but not something Assistance) and $2.5 billion for
priations Committee, then the onciled before mark ups instead enforceable by law. The House long-term reconstruction needs
full chamber. of sending it to a Conference is expected to approve the Sen- in Haiti.
Committee after—and the Sen- ate version for passage in the On March 24, the adminis-
Haiti debt relief ate took up the House version next couple of months. tration released its Haiti supple-
legislation to send to the president for his mental funding request. In
On March 10, the House signature. Haiti reconstruction addition to funding for USAID
passed a bill (HR 4573) calling A summary of the results of and the Department of State,
for the U.S. representatives Lord’s Resistance the post disaster needs assess- the $2.8 billion request also
at the World Bank, Interna- Army bill ment (PDNA) for Haiti was seeks funding for the Depart-
tional Monetary Fund, the The Senate passed the Lord’s released on March 17. It put ments of Agriculture, Defense,
Inter-American Development Resistance Army Disarmament the total cost of estimated that Health and Human Services,
Bank and other multilateral and Northern Uganda Recovery $11.5 billion will be needed Homeland Security and
development institutions to Act of 2009 (S 1067) on March for reconstruction in Haiti. Treasury and the Broadcasting
cancel debts owed by Haiti and 11 after Senator Tom Coburn The government of Haiti also Board of Governors to provide
provide new assistance to Haiti (R-OK) lifted a hold he had released its reconstruction plan. for costs associated with relief
primarily in the form of grants. placed on the legislation. The Also on March 17, InterAction and reconstruction in Haiti.
It mirrors a bill (S 2961) passed bill directs the president to sent a letter to House and Sen- A comparison of InterAction’s

Administration’s InterAction’s
Haiti Supplemental Funding Requests March 24, 2010 March 17, 2010
Request Recommendation
Emergency relief funding: $500.7 million $1.482 Billion1
International Disaster Assistance (IDA) $350.7 million $684 million
Food for Peace/food assistance $150 million $580 million2
Migration and Refugee Assistance (MRA) — $165 million3
Economic Support Fund (ESF) — $53 million4

Long-term reconstruction funding: $892.8 million $2.5 million5


Economic Support Fund (ESF) $749.311 million —
International Narcotics Control and Law Enforcement
$143.489 million —
(INCLE)

Multi-Donor Trust Fund up to $120 million —

1
InterAction’s March 17, 2010 supplemental funding request included recommendations for funding to address needs outside of those in Haiti.
2
InterAction’s recommended level for food assistance funding is in support of global needs not limited to Haiti.
3
This recommendation for the Migration and Refugee Assistance (MRA) account is for the support of global needs not limited to Haiti.
4
This recommendation for the Economic Support Fund is for the support of critical activities in southern Sudan.
5
InterAction’s request did not include specific account allocations but rather recommended an overall funding level for long-term reconstruction.

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 5


Washington Update

request and the administration’s responses in Haiti. It also Assistance and $55 million Resources:
request can be found in the contains sector-specific for proposals from private • InterAction’s letter on the
accompanying chart. funding to continue OFDA’s voluntary organizations Haiti supplemental and other
The request for the Depart- response activities in Haiti. (PVOs). critical matters is available at
ment of State and USAID With this request, total IDA www.interaction.org/sites/
includes (but is not limited to): for the government’s 2010 Long-Term Reconstruction default/files/InterAction%20
fiscal year (FY10) funding Funding: -%20March%2017%20
Emergency Relief Funding: would rise to $1.196 billion. • $749.311 million for Eco- 2010%20FY10%20Haiti%20
• $350.7 million for Interna- This week, it was reported nomic Support Fund (ESF) Supp%20Request.pdf.
tional Disaster Assistance that total FY10 IDA spending $68.311 million for the Office • The official French version
(IDA). This request includes in Haiti could increase to as of Transition Initiatives. of the Government of
funding to reimburse the much as $515 million, leav- Haiti’s reconstruction
Office of Foreign Disaster ing $680.7 million for OFDA The request for the Department plan is available at www.
Assistance (OFDA) for trans- operations elsewhere around of the Treasury includes $212 interaction.org/sites/default/
fers to the Department of the world. million to support a U.S. files/2010%20PDNA%20
Defense, FEMA (the Federal • $150 million for Food for contribution to a multi-donor %28French%29.pdf.
Emergency Management Peace. Of this funding, $68 agreement to cancel debts owed • Visit www.interaction.org
Agency) and the Depart- million will be used to supply by Haiti. MD and select the “Shaping the
ment of Health and Human the World Food Program Agenda” tab to discover more
Services for their respective with Title II Emergency Food policy-related issues.

12 Ways to Include
People with Disabilities in Your Development Work
1. Include disabled people’s organizations (DPOs) and other
disability organizations in your outreach work and networks

2. Disaggregate data (gender and disability)

3. Ensure that Education for All (EFA) is really for ALL! Education is
key to economic development

4. Hold skills training and business training workshops in


accessible locations and ensure material and communication is
accessible

5. Create partnerships between mainline development and


The World Bank (from a 2002 report) esti-
disability organizations
mates that 1 out of 6 people living on less
than $1 a day has a disability. Disability 6. Set targets for inclusion in economic development programs
adds to the risk of impoverishment, and
conditions of poverty add to the risk of 7. Raise the awareness of staff about disability rights
disability. By ensuring people, especially 8. Don’t patronize by expecting less of people with disabilities but
women, with disabilities are included we do be innovative to overcome barriers
are better able to meet poverty reduction
targets. Furthermore, when people who 9. Hire qualified staff with disabilities
have been traditionally marginalized have
the opportunity to earn a livelihood, the 10. Accommodate reasonably in the workplace and ASK people
themselves what will work
impact goes far beyond that of poverty
alleviation. The following 12 ways to in- 11. Lobby for inclusive development policies
clude people with disabilities in economic
Photo: Benoit Darrieux

development programs are not exhaus- 12. Support community based initiatives which are key to putting
tive but are drawn from experience. policy into practice
Try them out!
—By Karen Heinicke-Motsch, Director, International Programs, CBM US

6 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


InfoBytes

Films not to miss... Ben Affleck Creates


By Sean Patrick Murphy
Congo Aid Group
Crude (2009)
prepare the viewer for a one-sided David vs. Actor Ben Affleck recently launched
Goliath story, it gives ample time to Chevron a new organization to raise money and
representatives who claim that not only is the awareness of the plight of women and
oil company free from blame but that attention children living in the volatile eastern
should be paid to the role Petroecuador (the Congo. The Eastern Congo Initiative
national oil company) has played in the area (ECI) is a project of the New Venture
since 1993. Fund whose founding members (in
At least one of the Chevron representatives addition to Affleck) include Howard G.
explains that the company acted in a way Buffett (son of billionaire investor Warren
that was consistent with the law. He says Buffet), Humanity United, the Bridgeway
the government of Ecuador allowed for Foundation, Jewish World Watch and
the exploitation of the area and that the others.
condemnation belongs to the government.
Yet, people are getting sick and dying in a
way that hadn’t happened before.
While a Chevron spokesman claims a big
shot law firm in Manhattan is seeking to cash
in on the settlement, it is obvious the people
named in the lawsuit are anything but greedy
people looking to capitalize on a tragedy. They
are residents of an area that was pristine until
oil was extracted.

Photo: Max Culhane


Perhaps most unsettling is the testimony
What is refreshing about this documentary of a Chevron environmentalist who appears
is that it is balanced. Crude is about the 17- totally sincere when she says that she has
year, $27.3 billion lawsuit brought against found no evidence of toxic oil waste in the area
Chevron for allegedly dumping toxic oil waste in question. According to Affleck, ECI will support
in the Amazon sector of Ecuador. That, juxtaposed with interviews of people already established and effective
The 30,000 residents of the area have filed crying because they cannot afford healthcare community-based approaches by
a class action suit against Chevron, which for their sick children, leaves the viewer providing much needed capital. It will
assumed control of Texaco in 2001. The wondering who really is to blame. also advocate to the U.S. government to
indigenous people claim the oil company’s This film strikes a balance and shows both develop peaceful political solutions to
practices have resulted in sickness and death. sides as neither black nor white, but as gray. the countries many troubles.
While the beginning of the film seems to Crude is available for rent. For fear of being considered a self-
promoting celebrity, Affleck said he
didn’t want to get involved in such an

Expat Youth A diverse panel of expatriates


will judge the 2010 Expat Youth
initiative without gaining first-hand
knowledge of the situation. The actor has

Scholarship Scholarship and help award a total


of $10,000 to six students. The
traveled to Congo five times since 2007
to understand the problems affecting
scholarship program is sponsored millions of women and children who are
by Clements International and is designed specifically for expat victims of disease, rape and other forms
students who acquire unique life experiences growing up abroad. of gender based violence. He has also
met with the warlords and child soldiers
who have been accused of committing
Prizes will be awarded to six students ages 12-18 of any nationality
the country’s atrocities.
who have resided in a foreign country for at least two consecutive Previously, Affleck directed 2008’s
years. The scholarship entry deadline is Thursday, May 13, 2010. “Gimme Shelter”, a short film made
with the help of The Rolling Stones’
To learn more about the judges or for more information about the Mick Jagger that called attention to the
scholarship, visit www.expatyouthscholarship.com. country’s refugee camps and 1.3 million
displaced people.

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 7


InfoBytes

Challenges of NGO Organizational Learning


Much has been said about learning in orga-
Sustainability nizations. Organizational assessment is one
By Jerry VanSant, visiting faculty, Duke path to a powerful learning experience that
Center for International Development, Duke an organization can do on its own or in a

Photo: Corazon C .Lagamayo


University highly interactive setting with a facilitating
Organizational sustainability is a key con- donor, consultant or partner organization.
cern of NGO managers. Informed donors In fact, just about anything an NGO does
who want their resources to have a long- can be turned into a learning experience if
term impact on performance and capacity it is done with creative attention to process.
also care about sustainability. Indeed, fundamental organizational functions
There are three major capacity-related
categories of organizational sustainability:
like planning, organizing, performance man-
agement and human resource management
Climate Change
autonomy, learning and leadership. These all should be seen as key learning opportuni- Hour: Tick Tick for
attributes enable an organization to tran-
scend the sum of its component parts. They
ties. For this reason such functions should
never be turned over to outsiders although Evaluation
also are the most useful predictive indicators consulting expertise may be employed in a By Christelle Chapoy, Advocacy and
of future organizational impact. supportive role. Communications Officer, International
Appropriate monitoring and evaluation Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie)
Organizational Autonomy of an NGO’s actual programmatic or other
Autonomy is the organization’s degree of activities also is an obvious tool for learning. As policy makers and development
independence from other agencies or forces These functions, too, should be handled practitioners gear up for the next round of
in its environment. Effective autonomy is internally and for the primary purpose of negotiation talks in Cancun, Mexico, the race
reflected in the power to make decisions informing the organization’s managers and is on to increase financing for climate change
about basic matters such as organizational staff, not just outsiders. mitigation and adaptation.
goals, policy, budget, hiring practices, pay Learning from programmatic activities According to the World Bank, developing
and incentives, and external linkages. serves both better management and also, countries need $400 billion per year to
In Non Governments: NGOs and the in many cases, better support for efforts to mitigate the effects of climate change. If
Political Development of the Third World, influence policymakers or civil society. money is essential to the success of climate
Julie Fisher identified several keys to organi- change interventions, proving the cost
zational autonomy. These include: Leadership effectiveness of current spending will be
• being driven by mission rather than by Leadership is the most essential ingredient even more vital to maintain and gain support
donors or other funding sources; in organizational sustainability and the most from donors. The selection and design of
• financial diversification; important determinant of organizational per- climate change mitigation and adaptation
• a mass constituency; formance. Key elements of leadership are a interventions should be based on evidence
• technical expertise; values-based vision, innovation, proactive deci- of what works, what doesn’t, under what
• strategic knowledge on development siveness, and an enabling and empowering circumstances and at what cost.
issues; and approach to the people in the organization. A new report from the International
• social and managerial knowledge Leadership is the controlling force in Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie)—Impact
organizational development. It is the key Evaluation and Interventions to Address
Critical for building autonomy is commit- to realistically assessing problems and Climate Change—stresses that impact
ment to a clear sense of purpose. Institutions opportunities, establishing priorities, and evaluations must be integrated into program
with a clear vision and internal consensus marshalling internal and external resources designs from the very outset. Development
regarding that vision (often referred to as to address these priorities. In effective insti- agencies need to calculate the cost-
alignment) usually employ resources effec- tutions leadership does not reside only at effectiveness of the emissions reductions
tively because they know what they stand the top; elements of it are evident at various produced by different interventions. Doing
for. Autonomous organizations also tend to levels of the organization. so requires putting a value on all the costs
conduct programs or activities that earn a The importance of leadership of this kind and benefits of the interventions. If we can
high degree of acceptance by relevant stake- and of the resulting core values and internal assess the carbon footprint of a project
holders and, in turn, contribute in demon- alignment to those values in an organization (the carbon emission resulting from the
strable ways to organizational resources and cannot be overemphasized. These fac- intervention) estimating the money the
performance, for example by attracting new tors are key to sustaining an organization’s project could save by reducing its emissions
funding, enhancing organizational learning or capacity to meet its objectives in a changing becomes straightforward as well.
broadening organizational influence. environment. To date, there is limited evidence on
bringing about behavior change in the

8 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


InfoBytes

context of climate change interventions. causing widespread flooding of low-lying Oxfam International found that 83 percent of
However, much can be learned from costal areas and islands. According to a 2007 low-income, single mothers were displaced in
experiences in the field of payment for estimate by the Intergovernmental Panel on the wake of Hurricane Katrina, the deadliest
environmental services, decentralized forest Climate Change, a one-meter rise would United States hurricane since the 1928.
management or conservation. For instance, displace 70 million people in Bangladesh, for The cost of tackling the problem could
deforestation accounts for 20 percent of example, and submerge 80 percent of the be around one percent of global GDP (gross
annual global carbon emissions and tens Marshall Islands. It would also threaten the domestic product) if mitigation policies
of millions of dollars have been invested in Gulf and South Atlantic coasts of the United are well-designed according to the 2007
payments for Ecosystem Services projects States and the coastal zone on which Tokyo, Stern Report. Recent figures from the UN
from South Africa to Costa Rica and even Osaka and Nagoya sit in Japan. Framework Committee on Climate Change
New York City. But do we know if payment The UN Development Program has put the costs of adaptation for developing
schemes work for reducing deforestation reported that during the 20th century countries at between $28 to $67 billion in
and addressing climate change? economic losses from climate-related 2030.
3ie is funding two research projects that disasters were three times higher than those In 2007 the Stern Report noted that
will measure the impact of such interventions involving geophysical disasters (earthquakes, the costs of ignoring climate change have
on the ecosystem and welfare of local avalanches, landslides) and affected 55 been estimated at more than five to twenty
communities. They will in particular assess times the number of people. percent of GDP—more than that of the two
two innovative interventions: a first-of its The 2005 Atlantic hurricane season world wars and the Great Depression.
kind, large-scale project in Mexico and a was the most active on record, the best
pilot project in Uganda. known of which was Hurricane Katrina. 3ie (www.3ieimpact.org, recently nominated
In this climate change hour, time is now Yet 27 other storms wreaked havoc across as part of Aid Watch’s Grand Prize for Best
also ticking for closing the evaluation gap. Central America and the Caribbean, causing in Aid) works to improve the lives of people
  mudslides and claiming more than 1,600 lives. in developing countries by financing high-
Climate Change: Facts with an Impact Women are more severely affected by quality impact evaluations and advocating for
Sea levels could rise by 9 to 88 cm by 2100, climate change because of their social roles. better-informed policy and program design.

Kjaer Group (US Liaison Office) Inc. | 1601 North Kent Street, Suite 100 | Arlington, Virginia 22209
Tel: (703) 778.9400 | Fax: (703) 778-9405 | USA@KjaerGroup.com | www.kjaergroup.com
InfoBytes

Update: UN Commission on the Status of Women Meetings


By Jeannie Harvey, Senior Manager for Gender Integration, InterAction

The UN Commission on the Status of


Women (CSW) met in March to deliberate
about the future of women, women’s
rights and gender equality. This year the Participants in the
CSW asked two questions: (1) how much WFDA Session—
progress have we made to advance Back row: William
gender equality in the world; and (2) how Vendley, Ritu Sharma,
do our goals for equality mesh with the Mary Hawkins, Mary
Millennium Development Goals? Robinson, Yaser
Haddara, Lorelle Curry.
Front row: Jeannie
Answering the first question requires going Harvey, Jane Sloane,
back 15 years to the 4th World Conference Jacqueline Ogega
on Women that was held in Beijing.
Delegations crafted the Beijing Declaration
and Platform for Action, a blueprint for and promote “people-centered policy world. The recent launch of an Asia-Pacific
actions to improve the status of women frameworks” that the CSW suggests WFDA in Australia was seen by all as a great
and girls and to recognize that women’s would accelerate the achievement of the success in replicating the WFDA model.
rights are human rights. To mark the 15th Millennium Development Goals. Founders of the Asia Pacific WFDA, Mary
anniversary, countries, regions and NGO InterAction members participated as Hawkins and Jane Sloane, described their
delegations issued reports detailing progress expert panelists in several side sessions journey bringing communities together
and challenges. There was agreement that and included Amnesty International, during the Parliament of World Religions
although gains had been made, challenges CHANGE, Heifer Project International, IASC/ event in Australia last December. Other
remain for achieving true equality. InterAction E-learning Course on Gender in panelists included Dr. Yaser Haddara from
Humanitarian Relief, ICRW’s MenEngage, Islamic Relief, Dr. Azza Karam from UNFPA
While resolutions were debated inside the Oxfam, Plan International, the Women, (the UN Population Fund) and Dr. Vendley
UN, side events offered by NGOs shared Faith and Development Alliance (WFDA) from Religions for Peace.
best practices and concerns related to and Women for Women International. Two
development practice, research and sessions were particularly noteworthy: MenEngage—Work with Men: Principles,
activism. NGO representatives voiced Priorities and Partnership
dissatisfaction with lack of progress on Women, Faith and Development Alliance: “If men are part of the problem then they
the Beijing Platform for Action: maternal Gaining Momentum need to be part of the solution,” said Mr.
mortality remains high; violence against The momentum was palpable in this Satish Kumar Singh of the New Delhi
women is rampant across the globe; women standing-room only session. Panelists Central Health and Social Justice Program.
and girls continue to be disproportionally recounted the effort that began at the Another panelist, Dr. Gary Barker of ICRW
affected by war and conflict; and women’s Washington Cathedral in 2008 to bring (the International Center for Research on
precarious economic gains have eroded together three diverse communities and Women) explained that we need to help
quickly with the economic downturn. commit to advance gender equality. H.E. men understand the costs of patriarchy to
The second question posed by the 2010 Mary Robinson said that the WFDA is “an them. For example, he said “we need to ask
CSW was whether the Beijing Platform idea whose time has come.” She reminded men, ‘how is this working for you: the social
for Action contributes to achieving the us that “religion can be a great source for limitations on you to be a man, your lower
MDGs. According to the CSW, “the Beijing good, but it can also be a source of harm life expectancy compared to women—how
Declaration and Platform for Action provide for women.” What WFDA helps to do is “to is that going for you?’” When Dr. Lydia
comprehensive guidance for achieving the open the conversation about how religion Mungherera started the Mama’s Club in
MDGs in a gender-responsive manner,” can benefit women, how it can promote Uganda, it dealt only with women’s issues.
even though gender equality is not well development and how it can help to end After urging the women to go home and talk
reflected throughout the MDGs. CSW poverty.” Ms. Ritu Sharma of Women Thrive with the men in their households, the men
delegates agreed that by paying attention Worldwide said that the commitments made wanted to come too. So the men came by
to lessons learned and promising practices by more than 90 organizations, which offered themselves and began to share programs
we could learn more about what works $1.2 billion in new programs to advance such as song, dance and drama. She said
and apply that to the MDG review. This women and girls, were not commitments that the key to changing gender roles “is to
Photo: RFP

conclusion is important for NGOs as they made to WFDA, they were “commitments work with boys as soon as they are born, to
implement new and innovative practices made to women and girls” across the break down patriarchy.” MD

10 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


“Finding the right auto insurance for one vehicle is hard enough - trying to find coverage for
a fleet of vehicles in Sudan seemed almost impossible. Thanks to Clements and their superior
team, our vehicles were protected across borders so we could get our job done.”

Learn more about our unique insurance solutions for NGOs.


+1.202.872.0060 | info@clements.com | word.clements.com
Photo: (This page) photo-illustration by Chad Brobst, elements by Serhat Kavas and vgstudio - Fotolia.com; (opposite) S. Smith Patrick/CARE
“Bite-Sized”
Philanthropy
New technologies and new strategies reach
a new breed of philanthropists.
By Radha Muthiah, Vice President of
Strategic Partnerships and Alliances,
CARE, and Chris Shea, Senior Vice
President, External Relations, General
Mills and President, General Mills
Community Action and Foundation

12 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Bite-Sized philanthropy

T
here is a new category of giving
Naomi Chibwe, 39, is the
these days that we like to call “bite-sized” philan- Mzati (m-ZAH-tee) for the
thropy. And it is creating new ways for everyone to village Kaisi. Visitors to Join
contribute in small but meaningful ways to projects My Village can join Naomi’s
that fight the root causes of global poverty. This village, or select from nine
others, and track their
“low cost, high volume” approach was seen as a progress.
breakthrough strategy for the Obama campaign
and has been rapidly gaining traction in the philanthropy space,
thanks to the power of social networking, mobile giving and virtual
currency such as Twitter twollars. Today’s “philanthropists” are a
totally different group, not at all resembling our traditional view
of the old-time way of giving money. This trend is being driven
by the under-30s, an age group historically characterized more by
energetic consumerism that social activism.
Join My Village:
Historically, the intersection of philanthropy and development A Bold New Model for Social Impact
has been owned by a few key stakeholders contributing large sums With a vision to inspire women in the U.S. to come together in
of money—invariably a combination of bilateral or multilateral solidarity to empower women in Africa to achieve sustainable
organizations such as USAID or the World Bank, large corporations social and economic independence, CARE and General Mills
seeking to demonstrate their commitment to global citizenship launched the program Join My Village (www.joinmyvillage.
or exceedingly wealthy individuals wishing to do something for com) in September 2009. Based on the belief in the power
the world’s poor. of “bite-sized” philanthropy, Join My Village was launched
But in the last 5-7 years a new philanthropic movement has specifically to educate, engage and demonstrate that small
emerged that allows individuals of any income level to support actions could make a big change.
social and economic development around the world through Join My Village channels the power of online communities in
small donations. Organizations such as Kiva, Global Giving and the U.S. to help real communities in Malawi. Through the use of
Samasource, among others, have pioneered new ways for people multimedia storytelling, visitors can immediately get a sense of
of all walks of life to engage in global development. daily life in Malawi, where nearly half the population lives below
But do small donations here and there really make a differ- the poverty line and the average life expectancy is 44 years of
ence? The answer is a resounding YES. In the five years since Kiva age. Three simple acts online—joining a village team, answer-
launched, more than $126 million has been donated in the form ing educational quiz questions about Malawi and extending an
of micro-loans. Average loan: $34. GlobalGiving’s marketplace of invitation to a friend—can unlock $1 each, up to of $250,000
community-based development projects has generated $26 mil- from the General Mills donation fund. Participants also have the
lion in donations since 2002. opportunity to make personal donations to Join My Village. These
There is no one giant Minimum contribution: $10. donations are matched dollar-for-dollar by General Mills, up to
step that does it. It’s a Samasource, the online cash-
for-work program, has helped
an additional $50,000. Regular updates keep Join My Village
members engaged in fundraising progress, as well as successes
lot of little steps. disadvantaged people in Asia and impact in the Malawi villages the effort supports.
—Peter Cohen and Africa increase incomes by In just the first six months the program has had a demonstrable
as much as 200 percent in only a impact in providing project funding to CARE’s work in Malawi,
few months. And one need look no further than the recent Haiti relief while also engaging participants in a new way with both General
fundraising efforts to see how lots of small donations can add up to Mills and CARE. The more than $237,000 raised has already
significant sums. In just 48 hours, the Red Cross was able to raise $5 proved enough to fund 113 scholarships for girls, support 55
million through a text message program. Maximum donation: $10. new village savings and loan groups and begin construction on
Arguably, this grassroots-driven generosity is the result of both houses for female teachers.
the growing influence of the millennial generation and the ease of Although the current mission is to create and fund economic
social mobilization through technology. Pew released a study earlier and educational opportunities for girls and women in approxi-
this year on the millennial generation. Characterized as confident, mately 75 Malawian villages, CARE and General Mills believe
connected and open to change, the millennials (18-29 year-olds) there is great potential to extend the Join My Village model
are more socially liberal and more apt to support companies and beyond Malawi to other countries and continents.
organizations based on social and/or political values. According Notes Chris Shea, Senior Vice President at General Mills, “We
to a Cone Inc. report, 61 percent of this age group feel personally know from our legacy of box-top programs that small contribu-
responsible for making a difference in the world. tions can make a big difference. Our work with CARE and the
Technology—particularly social networks—has catalyzed an Join My Village program gives General Mills an opportunity to
approach to philanthropy that moves faster, drives creativity and is extend this legacy of bite-sized philanthropy to engage even
less hierarchical. Social technologies such as Facebook, Twitter and more people in creating a better world.”
mobile phones make it easier to build social capital around new ideas

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 13


Bite-Sized philanthropy

and causes. One woman last year raised $24,000 and around issues most meaningful to them. paigns, but interest can quickly wane once a
in one day for the NGO charity: water by ask- These grassroots experiences foster a positive campaign ends.
ing her Twitter followers to donate two dollars visceral feeling and are a powerful force for All of this requires a different employee
each. The total was enough to fund the drilling helping the world. skill set than “the old days.” NGOs must take
of permanent wells for five African villages. The challenge is that the competition for cues from the private sector and think more
In addition to believing in their own hearts and minds is intense—according to about creative brand management, campaign-
responsibility to make the world a better place, the National Center for Charitable Statistics oriented communications and audience seg-
78 percent of millennials believe companies the number of operating public charities mentation. Joint campaigns with corporate
have a responsibility to join them in the effort. almost doubled between 1989 and 2004— partners need to reflect simple messages,
Corporations are responding accordingly. In which requires a different model than the demonstrate relevance and be original. NGOs
2006, companies gave an estimated $1.3 bil- one needed to service a smaller circle of big need to know as much as possible about their
lion through cause marketing partnerships funders. It shifts the way we tell our stories various donors in order to understand what
with non-profits. This figure does not include about impact and think about donor steward- is required to maximize the opportunity to
the $4.2 billion in contributions by corporate ship. Big funders have traditionally wanted keep those donors engaged for the long-term.
foundations that same year. to know about technical expertise, building In many ways the grass-roots nature of bite-
So what does this mean for companies and capacity and scale. In contrast, the “bite size” sized philanthropy complements the growing
NGOs seeking to maximize the opportunity philanthropist wants to know about the peo- emphasis on participatory development strat-
presented by the “bite-sized philanthropy” ple, the local context and how their donation egies. More people engaging on both sides of
trend? The obvious news, of course, is that is helping to change real lives. It also means we the equation creates tremendous opportunity
the Web creates significant opportunities to need to keep our message fresh, particularly for uncovering new ideas that foster social and
connect and engage a broader audience. This for the new generation of e-philanthropists economic opportunity for the world’s poor. As
same technology provides the opportunity who tend to be more motivated by causes we know, there is no silver bullet in the fight
for individuals to create a sense of collec- than missions. This group has demonstrated a against global poverty. But it is clear that lots
tive identity based on diverse perspectives willingness to enthusiastically engage in cam- of little steps can make a big difference. MD

Master of Public Health


The Program on Forced Migration and Health is committed to improving the health and well-being of people in crisis-affected
settings. The Program offers a Master of Public Health (MPH) through the Heilbrunn Department of Population and Family
Health at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. The MPH curriculum is intended to prepare health
professionals for the practice of public heath in complex emergencies and post-conflict settings.

The Program's teaching and research components emphasize pragmatic, inter-disciplinary, and human rights-based problem-
solving in the health and social sectors. Upon completion of the degree, graduates will be able to:

• Lead the field of humanitarian response in the 21st century


• Define the nature, impact, and determinants of health and social sector problems in complex emergencies
• Develop effective policies to alleviate problems in the health and social sectors
• Design, manage, and evaluate health and social sector programs
• Undertake population-based research to improve humanitarian response policies and practice

For information about the Program on Forced Migration and Health: www.forcedmigration.columbia.edu
For admissions information: www.mailman.columbia.edu/prospective-students

14 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Focused Philanthropy

The Goldman
Sachs 10,000
Women initiative
forges a new
model of giving.
By Jeri Eckhart-Queenan,
Partner, Susan Wolf Ditkoff,
Partner, and Susan J. Colby,
Partner, The Bridgespan Group

Getting Clear,
Real and Better
I
t’s relatively easy to write a What this means in practical terms is that The 10,000 Women initiative, to which
check. Engaging in a philanthropic philanthropists and foundation leaders are Goldman Sachs has committed $100 mil-
investment—shouldering accountability for explicitly tackling three tough questions: lion over five years, aims to provide at least
outcomes—is much harder. Yet in the course How do we define success? What will it take 10,000 underserved women around the world
of our work in recent years with a select to make change happen? And how can we with a business and management education
group of foundation leaders and individual improve our results over time? They are sys- at a time when UN Millennium Goals have
philanthropists—and in conversations we’ve tematically engaging in research, strategy elevated women’s education and empower-
had with many more—we have observed an development and performance measurement ment to the forefront of development issues.
important and heartening trend: Philanthro- so that they can: better define the problem(s) Currently, 10,000 Women operates through
pists and their organizations are becoming they are trying to solve or the change they a network of more than 70 academic and
increasingly committed to investing money are trying to foster; chart an effective course non-profit partners in countries including
strategically, measuring the results of their towards that end; and continuously improve Afghanistan, Brazil, China, Egypt, India,
giving and adjusting course to increase their their methods. Put another way, they are get- Rwanda and the United States. The initiative
impact. ting clear about what success looks like for develops locally relevant coursework for stu-
This commitment doesn’t reflect a new their investments, getting real about what it dents, across a range of disciplines including
desire for the best possible outcomes; all takes to make change happen and committed marketing, strategic planning, e-commerce
philanthropists want their investments to be to getting better over time. and business plan writing. Courses range from
used to maximum effect. But it does reflect The Goldman Sachs Group’s 10,000 Women five weeks to six months; the programs are
a new approach to the day-to-day work of initiative, launched in 2008, offers an excel- intended to help open doors for women who
philanthropy—a new level of self-assessment, lent example of this type of engagement in would not otherwise have access to a busi-
rigor and follow-through. In the social sector, action. (It also marked our firm’s first strategy ness education. Students are also mentored
there are no market forces driving founda- engagement with corporate philanthropy.) (during their studies and after graduation)
tions to ensure that donations result in impact. To be clear, the “get clear, get real, get better” by partner institutions, local businesses and
Photo: Rodrigo Ordonez

As a result, excellence must be self-imposed. framework was not a blueprint for Goldman’s the people of Goldman Sachs.
What we are seeing in increasing numbers strategic process as this initiative was devel- Getting clear, at Goldman, meant marrying
are individual philanthropists and foundation oped. In hindsight, however, that framing pro- a few, critical strategic anchors—the firm’s
leaders who are willing to hold themselves to vides a very useful overlay through which to values, core competencies, and tangible and
that high standard. view Goldman’s efforts. intangible assets to champion certain social

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 15


Focused Philanthropy

causes—with robust evidence. Reduced to its in the direction of the initiative; they were consulting the field to ensure objectivity and
essentials, philanthropy is a very personal and also confident that they could hold them- accepting feedback with an intention to
values-driven endeavor, even in professional selves accountable for hard evidence of suc- improve.
institutions, and so it is important to explore cess related to job creation and business rev- 10,000 Women enjoyed a successful first
those driving values and assumptions as well enue growth. But what was the best approach year. More than 600 women entrepreneurs
as hard data very early on when determining to that end given Goldman’s capabilities and applied for the first 60 slots opened in Rwanda;
where to invest. Goldman’s leaders first con- the amount of money it was willing and able and as of November 2009, women in 20 coun-
sidered the firm’s understanding and percep- to invest? What should the initiative look tries including Afghanistan, Brazil, China,
tion of the evolving global economy, its own like? Had any other organizations attempted Egypt, India, Rwanda, the United States and
capabilities and their belief that extending to deliver solutions in this area? Were there Zambia were enrolled in the program. By the
the benefits of globalization to underserved already effective, perhaps undersized, pro- end of 2009, 10,000 Women had 939 graduates,
populations would necessitate a concentrated grams in existence? What lessons had already with 1,428 enrolled. To cite just one benefi-
effort. As John Rogers, the firm’s Chief of Staff been learned? What organizations would be ciary experience: Since participating in 10,000
and Secretary to the Board said in a Harvard delivering the services Goldman would be Woman, Ayodeji (“Ayo”) Megbope, a caterer in
Business School case study on 10,000 Women, funding and what were their capabilities? Lagos, Nigeria, has increased her revenues by
“What we do at Goldman Sachs is put capital Goldman’s leaders initially considered a factor of five and grown her company from
behind people and ideas; and we are a catalyst providing grants to women pursuing MBA two full-time staff to five (with 25 temporary
for economic growth. For Goldman Sachs to degrees, but rejected that idea when they con- workers employed on an as-needed basis).
engage in a serious philanthropic initiative, sidered the cost against the potential returns. Instead of renting cooking utensils and using
we knew it had to be authentic, connected to They were, however, were keenly aware that taxis to deliver her goods, she has been able
what we do and to our culture, and we had small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in to purchase her own utensils and a delivery
to own it.” developing countries were often overlooked, truck. She has also begun contracting with
despite their potential to boost local economies. suppliers. Other program graduates, armed
For any philanthropic Through further research, they learned that with a newfound confidence born of increased
women entrepreneurs in these countries did knowledge and ability, have similarly begun
organization, getting not have broad access to education that would to grow their businesses.
better means revisiting help them run and grow their businesses. They
also considered existing efforts to provide
The response within Goldman has been no
less inspiring: Goldman involvement in the
the strategy, regularly, women with a business education. The Lagos initiative spans the organization, including
Business School’s short-term “Certificate of senior management and directors; and the
challenging the status Enterprise Management” was one such pro- mentoring program is oversubscribed, with
gram; the school’s model informed Goldman’s data indicating that Goldman mentors are
quo, measuring and it is now a partner in 10,000 Women. highly valued by students.
performance and Armed with this information, they devel-
oped a set of baseline requirements for their
But these early “returns” have only served
to incite the initiative’s leaders to hone their
assessing results. philanthropic efforts with an overarching goal metrics continually to ensure that the initia-
of creating a pipeline of economic empow- tive is having the maximum possible impact
Data supported the firm’s observations, val- erment that would connect business educa- and to leave no stone unturned in their efforts
ues and culture of giving back—and suggested tion to support services and access to capital. to incorporate what they are learning in real
a target for investment. Ongoing Goldman The firm would help a significant number time.
research—including a 2005 research paper of women, at least 10,000, gain access to the As Dina Powell, Managing Director and
titled “Womenomics,” and a 2007 work titled pipeline and acquire skills and knowledge that Global Head of the Office of Corporate
“Women Hold up Half the Sky”—had high- they could apply immediately in their own Engagement at Goldman Sachs put it, “10,000
lighted the economic potential of investing work. As part of the effort, the firm would Women seeks to address a pressing need and
in women. Goldman’s findings were also in engage and connect leading global business is focused on delivering tangible results. We’re
agreement with major external studies that schools with schools in developing countries encouraged by the early results and remain
had found a strong link in developing coun- to facilitate learning and capacity building. committed to rigorously measuring progress
tries between women’s education and eco- And people from across Goldman Sachs and impact.” MD
nomic growth (improved worker productivity, would involve themselves with the initiative:
healthier and better-educated families, and mentoring students, engaging their networks This article draws on “Galvanizing Philan-
ultimately, more prosperous communities). to build markets and measuring the results. thropy” a recent Harvard Business Review
Given this information, business education Getting better is an ongoing process. For article co-authored by Susan Wolf Ditkoff and
for women entrepreneurs easily emerged as a any philanthropic organization, getting bet- Susan J. Colby, and “Goldman Sachs: The
natural focus for the firm’s charitable efforts. ter means revisiting the strategy, regularly, 10,000 Women Initiative,” a Harvard Business
Getting real meant developing an action- challenging the status quo, measuring per- School case study by Christopher Marquis, V.
able strategy. Goldman leaders were confident formance and assessing results. It also means Kasturi Rangan, and Catherine Ross.

16 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Haiti aid

Beyond These
A
s I began writing this,
the devastating earthquake
in Haiti was all the rage: armies of
Mountains...

More
reporters, charitable organizations,
NGOs, aid donors and well-wishers from
concerned governments descended on the
country. Two months later, as I sent this article
to Monday Developments, Haiti has all but dis-
appeared from the global scene. Earthquakes
in Chile are now all the rage. Such has been
the fate of Haiti: intense short-term interna-
tional interest followed by long-term neglect.
With donors contributing huge sums to Haiti,

Mountains
the country has yet another opportunity to
redevelop. Will they employ the same failed
strategies of the past, or will they try some-
thing different? I vote to try the latter.

Avoid the failed efforts of the past


I fear the Haitian disaster response will likely
Want effective aid in Haiti? replicate donor errors of the past. Donors will
convene conferences to devise grand strate-
Tough choices need to be made right now. gies and pledge funding to achieve them. Pre-
cious time will pass in building consensus and
By Terry F. Buss, Distinguished Professor of Public Policy, engaging stakeholders: process will dominate
Carnegie Mellon University over substance. Many will view process as com-
pliance exercises and there will be duplicity.
Donors will each pursue their own agendas—
planning, development and implementation—
while failing to coordinate, harmonize or align
their efforts. Haitians will go along with just
about any donor scheme so long as they obtain
funding; country ownership, and hence com-
mitment, will be sorely lacking.
Donor funding promised will not be donor
funding forthcoming: monies will be delayed,
government will not absorb it and it will prob-
ably be suspended for geo-political reasons.
Aid funding will attract political and economic
opportunists self-aggrandizing themselves to
Photo: Reuters/Carlos Barria, courtesy www.alertnet.org

Haiti’s detriment. Charges of corruption, real


and imagined, will abound. Donors and NGOs
will launch hundreds of small projects that will
have little impact and they will do so outside
government, claiming it lacks administra-
tive or service delivery capacity or adequate
anti-corruption controls. Donor projects will
report glowing accomplishments, but poor
Haitians will see little improvement in their
A boy stands inside a makeshift tent after
heavy rain during the night in Cite Soleil,
lives. Donors will lose interest and go on to the
Port-au-Prince. next big issue, patting themselves on the back
for a job well done. Haiti will then drop off

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 17


Haiti aid

People walk at a makeshift tent camp in Cite


Soleil in Port-au-Prince. Seasonal rains and
hurricanes spell trouble for Haiti in the best
of times, but with hundreds of thousands of
people living in flimsy makeshift shelters after
January’s earthquake, this year the dangers are
much greater.

the radar until the next natural disaster, coup


or revolution at which time the process will
begin anew. We cannot let this happen again.

Good governance is key, but elusive


Every plan, assessment or implementation
document produced for Haiti—and every
other fragile state for that matter—decries
the absence of good governance as the major and offering programs directly); administrations have declared Haiti a suc-
barrier to development. Until that capacity • Buy good governance (e.g., funding elec- cessful democratic intervention, even
emerges, so the argument goes, no amount tions when the country is not ready); when it was not).
of aid will solve Haiti’s problems, in spite of • Impose good governance (e.g., insisting
everyone’s best efforts. Having acknowledged on decentralization, privatization and Unfortunately, Haiti must develop good
this, donors then go on to pursue counterpro- multi-party systems, again when the governance mostly on its own initiative. It
ductive agendas, attempting to: country is not ready); and cannot be substituted for, bought, imposed
• Bypass government (e.g., funding NGOs • Wish away the problem (e.g., various U.S. or wished into being.
Why does Haiti lack capacity for good gov-
ernance? Easy: government exists to benefit
economic and political elites and opportun-
ists, not to serve the Haitian people. Haiti is a
kleptocracy and has always been one!
How can Haiti get elites to work in the
interests of the country? The obvious answer
is to find ways that link the interests of the
elites with those of the country. Finding ways
to get wealthy Haitians to invest in their own
country would be a start. The country grows
and prospers, and the elites grow and prosper:
Master of New Professional Studies: win-win. This is easy to do: promote invest-

Peace Operations ment opportunities, achieve political and eco-


nomic stability, and promote security.
But even more importantly, there are also
Study the theory and practice of peace operations, international deep seated animosities among elites and poor
civilian police operations, nongovernmental organizations, people, festering over past racial, class, politi-
elections, refugees/internally displaced persons, and cal and economic cleavages that have divided
governance with world-renowned scholars and practitioners Haitians over the past 200 years. No one—
Photos: Reuters/Carlos Barria, courtesy www.alertnet.org

at one of the nation’s leading schools of public policy. including the donor community—knows how
to change this, in spite of funding democra-
• Small classes taught by world-renowned faculty tization programs and the like to address the
• Conveniently located in the metropolitan issues. Likely, Haitians will need to achieve
Washington, D.C., area reconciliation themselves. Regardless, a new
• Full-time or part-time study economic and political order is needed for
• Affordable cost development to succeed.
To find out more, please contact Graduate Admissions
Aid should not worsen
at the School of Public Policy at George Mason University
government capacity
at spp@gmu.edu or 703-993-8099.
Massive aid contributions from around the
world are flowing to Haiti. As in past efforts,

18 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Haiti aid

Children walk past a crack caused by the


earthquake in a street in Port-au-Prince.

the perception is the more aid, the better the just the latest. Donors cannot continue to give Plan, developed and managed by Haitians,
outcome for Haitians. Sadly, this has not been the government a pass on security. is needed.
the case. It is not the amount of aid that is Simply put: aid has made Haiti a protector- Fourth, improve wages and benefits for civil
important, but how it is used. Aid, in many ate. So as long as government is unresponsive servants to deter corruption and improve per-
cases, exacerbates Haitian governance prob- and unaccountable, Haiti will never shed its formance. Make it as difficult as possible to
lems rather than ameliorating them. status as a fragile state. What should be done? take bribes and benefit from them. Prosecute
Consider two examples. Because it is weak Donors need to take a chance on Haiti. officials who violate the law. Reward perfor-
and corrupt, donors deliver public services First, allow for general budget support— mance with incentives. Find ways to really
through NGOs rather than the government. funding not tied to specific projects, but which build capacity in government—this cannot be
Haiti has become “a Republic of NGOs.” The helps fund the government. Haiti has little done in one-day, one-off workshops. In short,
Haitian government is incapable of delivering revenue of its own, so it has little capacity to take civil service reform seriously.
basic services or paying for them. It lacks cred- fend for itself.
ibility and legitimacy among many Haitians. Second, heavily load funding with finan- Rethink development goals
Donors need to wean Haiti off the NGO lifeline. cial controls, making it difficult to misdirect The Haitian people have patiently waited
Or consider the demobilization of the or misappropriate aid. Tie all aid to clear for jobs even after decades of aid, with the
army. Haiti has relied on UN peacekeepers goals and objectives that must be met before government and donors promising much and
for years, because Haitian governments fear funding is released. Distribute funding in delivering little. The country needs a massive
military coups. At the same time, a viable tranches. But do not overload the system with jobs program, even if it does not comport with
civilian police force has yet to develop as an paperwork: how about one strategic plan and the Washington consensus, structural adjust-
alternative. Not only does this undermine the reporting system for Haiti, rather than one ment and basic needs approaches that tend
government’s legitimacy because it cannot for each donor? to define aid. Hiring armies of poor people
protect its citizens, it also deprives Haiti of Third, move away from project-based to clear rubble from the streets following the
much needed capacity to respond to numer- funding that dilutes aid impacts and fund quake is a start.
ous annual natural disasters, the quake being “big ticket” programs. A kind of Marshall continued on page 34

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 19


Accountability

What Gets Left Behind


SEA and the long-term benefits of building
accountability to communities.
By Angela Wiens, Senior Associate, Gender and Flagship Initiatives,
International Medical Corps, and Daisy Francis, Protection Policy/Issues
Advisor, Catholic Relief Services

I
n 2002, scandal rocked the humanitarian community and initiated a long dards (currently section 7.9).
international relief commu- process of standard setting and development Many agencies moved to turn “principles”
nity when Save the Children UK released of systems to address and prevent SEA. In into expected staff conduct, incorporating
a report documenting widespread incidents of June 2002, the Inter-Agency Standing Com- these into codes of conduct that clarified
sexual exploitation and abuse (SEA) against mittee (IASC) issued a detailed report that staff obligations to report incidents of SEA
children from camps for refugees and inter- further analyzed the issue, offered a com- and consequences for those found to be in
nally displaced persons in Guinea, Liberia mon set of definitions of terms such as “sexual violation. Agencies also developed internal
and Sierra Leone. The report indicated that abuse” and “sexual exploitation” and estab- systems for handling allegations of code
the exploitation and abuse was perpetrated lished six core principles related to SEA for violations and established complaints pro-
by employees of national and international the humanitarian community. Once released, cedures so that affected populations could
NGOs, UNHCR (the UN refugee agency) and InterAction quickly adopted these principles bring their concerns forward to the relevant
other UN bodies. The report galvanized the and incorporated them into its PVO Stan- people within the respective agencies. Internal
awareness programs for staff were designed
to ensure that all staff understood why the
code of conduct existed and what were the

Online Master of
agencies’ policies to prevent and respond to
SEA. The emphasis was on mutual responsi-
bility, to protect communities from SEA and

Professional Studies to provide them with mechanisms to bring


concerns to light.

Degree
Despite all of these efforts, exploitation
and abuse of beneficiaries continues to be
a grave problem in the humanitarian arena.
Humanitarian Services But as agencies continue to tackle this issue,
by engaging with communities and working
Administration with them to find the best ways to address this
• Humanitarian Response problem, bold new systems of accountability
can grow out of what began as a black mark
• Disaster Relief
on the international community.
• Sustainable Development In settings such as Haiti, distrust of and
betrayal by local and national authorities are
Be Part of additional barriers. Faced with ineffective legal
and policing systems, communities generally
Something avoid reporting incidents of SEA or do so with
little expectation of a successful outcome. This
Bigger set of circumstances provides the humanitar-
ian community with an opportunity to model
Photo: Moussa Hama Madassalia

For more information a new system of direct accountability. When


contact Donna Campbell conflict or disaster-affected communities are
phone: 860.486.0184 invited to work with international partners to
email: donna.campbell@uconn.edu address SEA, they shift from being passive
recipients of “services” to active partners in a
mps.uconn.edu Center for Continuing Studies
process that gives them agency. An important
continued on page 34

20 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Overlooked Survivors

Reaching Out to
A young girl in a tent camp in the Port-au-Prince
community of Mariani wanders around her new
home. Makeshift shelters such as these offer
some privacy but not much rain protection. The

Overlooked
rainy season begins in April.

Survivors blocks with rubble everywhere. Hospitals,


schools and government ministries were piles
of rubble. Amid such unimaginable loss of
life and massive destruction, it can be hard
Thousands of earthquake survivors have to discern the different barriers that different
dispersed into the Haitian countryside. groups face in accessing aid.
That said, there are obvious signs of how
Are they doomed to be forgotten? class has made a difference for earthquake
survivors. People in the massive slum neigh-
By Martha Thompson, Program Manager for Rights in Humanitarian borhoods of Mariani and Carrefour in Port-au-
Crises, Unitarian Universalist Service Committee Prince had much more precarious houses than
people in wealthier areas such as Petionville.
However, experience shows that groups who
have little power or “voice” are often left behind
in emergency and reconstruction because the

D
isasters, even the massive Port-au-Prince were marginalized even before barriers they face are not immediately visible
earthquake that hit Haiti on Jan- the earthquake, that they faced dire inequali- to aid workers—particularly international aid
uary 12, do not make a clean sweep ties in access to food, health care, water, workers without a clear understanding of the
that leaves everyone equal. Disaster-response education and other basic services. A major economic, political and social complexities of
organizations and personnel need to pay close challenge for relief organizations is to make that society. In short, cultural, political, reli-
attention to the different ways disasters affect sure that the factors that already kept people gious and caste factors that make people invis-
different groups of people. An individual’s marginalized are not unwittingly incorpo- ible in a society can also make them invisible
race, class, religion, gender and ethnic group rated into emergency and long-term recovery in traditional relief efforts.
either marginalize or privilege that person in programs so that these people face the same
any given society. Unfortunately, the social, inequalities of access to aid. Lessons from the Indian Ocean
economic and political systems that margin- At first glance, the massive destruction in Tsunami and Hurricane Katrina
Photo: Wendy Flick/UUSC

alized people before disasters often continue Haiti seems like a leveler. When I was in Haiti During the Indian Ocean Tsunami of 2004,
to disadvantage them during the relief and in February, people told me, “Every Haitian the dalits (Indians who have been discrimi-
recovery. family has lost someone; every family has nated against for centuries) were often barred
There is massive inequality in Haiti. All aid lost something.” The houses on the hillsides by local people from camps for internally dis-
workers know that the majority of people in of Port-au-Prince resembled tumble-down placed persons (IDPs). In Thailand, hospitals

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 21


Identifying Social Inequalities Overlooked Survivors

During Disaster Response


UUSC often asks questions to help understand
the “levers of exclusion.” They are then revised to
reflect lessons learned from experience.
turned away tsunami survivors seeking treat- ing who is excluded can help us identify the
Who is getting moved out so other interests
ment if they were undocumented workers vulnerable population. Understanding why
can get moved in?
from Myanmar. they are excluded gives us an understanding of
»» In Port-au-Prince, the majority of the slum
Sometimes national NGOs do not see the the power dynamics behind vulnerability. We
dwellers were squatters and did not have rights
barriers preventing marginalized groups from continue to develop and hone the set of ques-
to their land. Who has an interest in moving
accessing their rights in a disaster because tions presented in the accompanying sidebar
people off those lands now? If all the displaced
the inequalities are so deeply imbedded in to this article to help us understand the “levers
get moved out to big camps in the outskirts
our own society. After Hurricane Katrina, of exclusion” in a disaster.
of the city, how can they defend their access
reconstruction companies employed undocu-
to land in the city?
mented workers and then refused to pay all or The forgotten families
Who in the relief lines is getting assistance and part of their wages. The Federal Emergency In Haiti, more than half a million people
who is not? Why? Management Agency did not begin to assist who have gone to the countryside and the host
»» When we visited several camps in Port-au- the African-American communities in east families who have taken them in are already
Prince in mid-day with grassroots NGOs, we Plaquemanes Parish, 45 minutes outside of disadvantaged. The 2008 post-electoral vio-
met with camp coordinators and noticed fewer New Orleans, until January 2006 even though lence in Kenya provides an unfortunate warn-
women were present. We were told they were the hurricane struck on August 28, 2005. ing: in that case, the displaced who stayed in
out trying to make money or find aid. Aid dis- the camps for displaced people received aid
tribution often took place during the day when Sometimes international while the hundreds of thousands who went
back to their “ancestral lands” in rural areas
fewer women were present.
aid workers have cultural received almost nothing.
When there are massive numbers of deaths, In Haiti, the 500,000 people who have
assets are changing hands. Who is getting just blinders that keep returned to their relatives in the countryside
are becoming invisible. Along with a peas-
access to inheritance of those assets?
»» Will women and children have access to legal
them from seeing how ant organization in the Central Plateau, the
assistance for inheritance rights? Will poor specific groups become Papaye Peasant Movement, we visited sev-
eral rural homes where peasants had taken
people have access to legal resources?
»» If houses are being rebuilt and handed over to marginalized. in relatives and the friends of relatives. One
families or other assets are given to families for woman who had 24 people living in her small
recovery who is listed as the owner? Sometimes international aid workers have wooden house told us that if God had spared
»» This was a persistent problem following the cultural blinders that keep them from seeing these people’s lives, she had to look after them.
tsunami. Can this be an opportunity for women how specific groups become marginalized in Then she told us about her neighbor down the
to gain co-ownership of assets? the recovery process because of their gender. road whose daughter had shown up with 29
»» Who is being moved in to do the physical con- In the post-tsunami reconstruction phase in people from Port-au-Prince after the quake.
struction work? How are they being controlled? Aceh, international organizations had a pleth- These dispersed displaced people are in
Who is being locked out of work? ora of programs to provide income-generation danger of becoming the disappeared dis-
»» At the moment, this does not yet seem to be an projects for widows. However, young Achenese placed. They are severely straining the avail-
issue in Haiti. It was a critical issue for undocu- activist Wanti Muldar called attention to the fact able food, shelter, sanitation and health facili-
mented workers in the U.S. after Hurricane that rural widows really needed legal assistance ties in the rural areas. Their children have no
Katrina and for undocumented people from to reclaim the land they had owned jointly with access to the few countryside schools. The
Myanmar in Thailand after the 2004 tsunami. their husbands. She formed an organization, dispersed displaced are not settled in camps
Bungenog Jeumpa, to do that. Aid workers had and would likely be forgotten without the rural
Who gets access to government resources? just not been programmed to see the widows as organizations and peasant associations that
Who does not? Why? asset holders. Bungeong Juempa’s work proved provide ready-made networks to reach out
»» This is already an issue in Haiti. Frequent trav- that with the right lens, disasters can open politi- to them.
elling through the capital revealed very nice cal space for certain disadvantaged groups and Cultivating a lens that enables us to under-
tents in middle-class areas and torn tarps and people can create change. stand the dynamics of exclusion in Haiti, both
plastic in poorer neighborhoods. before and after the earthquake, will help us
»» What are the effective distribution networks if Reaching out through a human- address not just the results of exclusion, but
government ones are compromised or weak? rights lens also the levers of exclusion. And working with
»» There is a plethora of community groups at In Haiti, we need to discern which groups local grassroots organizations can help mar-
the grassroots level that can be strengthened of survivors will face the greatest obstacles ginalized groups rebuild their lives and liveli-
to use their networks effectively for distribu- to accessing aid and recovery and why. At hoods in a way that empowers them to address
tion. Groups like the Platform of Community the Unitarian Universalist Service Commit- the inequalities they face. MD
Organizations of the Port-au-Prince Metro- tee (UUSC) we have found that addressing
politan Zone and the Regional Coordination of these issues from a rights focus rather than a For more information about UUSC’s response
Southeast Organizations are effectively using vulnerability focus is a helpful lens. Determin- to the Haiti earthquake, visit www.uusc.org/haiti.
neighborhood networks and volunteers to
organize camps and distribution.
22 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010
Conversations Series

A Conversation
with...

ments alone or aid organizations alone can-


not make a big difference. We are making a
down payment, if you will. But we want to
partner with the private sector, which is the

Daniel Yohannes
engine of growth and job creation.
I want to knock on the door of every
single American business to make sure
they consider investing in many of MCC’s
partner countries. I want to continue to

CEO of the Millennium work with partner country governments


to make sure that they continue to reform

Challenge Corporation
their economic policies, so their coun-
tries can become extremely attractive for
investments from within their country as
well as from outside.
NC: Mr. Yohannes, one of the ques- I also want to work very closely with all
tions we’ve had at InterAction, with the development agencies that are primar-
your appointment to the MCC, has been ily U.S. government agencies. In addition,
what your priorities would be. We know I want to make sure that we work together
you have spoken a lot about innovation. with other nonprofits, philanthropy orga-
We were hoping you could share with nizations and businesses. You know, we
us and some of our stakeholders how have very limited resources. We have a
you see your first year at MCC. budget of about $1.1 billion this year and
I want to make sure that we utilize addi-
DY: My first priority, of course, is to carry tional resources so that we can have a
out the mission of MCC, which is to reduce very effective program when we consider
poverty through long-term economic growth MCC’s investments.
by working with countries that are poor, but
countries that are also relatively well gov- NC: You mentioned leveraging the pri-
erned. That’s my number one priority. Hav- vate sector. It’s very hard to quantify
ing said that, we have three major objec- NGOs results. Where do you see their
tives. One is results. MCC just celebrated value? In addition to the private sector
our sixth anniversary. We want to show are you also looking to still strengthen
results to the American people in terms of the NGO contribution to the MCC
how our programs and our investments are and the MCA [Millennium Challenge
impacting the poor in terms of making some Account] model?
significant changes to their income, as well
Visit www.interaction.org/conversations as to their whole economic progress. DY: The NGOs are extremely critical to
to view a video excerpt of this interview Number two is innovation. MCC was our success. They have been great part-
created to be innovative from day one, so ners and I look forward to working with
we want to make sure that we continue on them in the near term. You know, many
Monday Developments’ Executive that same path in terms of our products MCC projects have had the support and
Editor Nasserie Carew sat down with the and services. In terms of our approach the consultation of the NGOs, civil society
new CEO of the Millennium Challenge Cor- overseas, in terms of the partners we and the private sector as well. One part
poration (MCC) Daniel Yohannes to talk choose, the last twenty compacts have of our model that makes it unique is that
about the organization’s challenges and been primarily with central governments. MCC programs are country owned from
opportunities for growth. Since retiring from We have not done anything with NGOS; design to implementation. At every stage
his post as Vice Chairman of U.S. Bank we have really not done anything with the of the compact process, beginning with
in 2003, Mr. Yohannes has been a private private sector or with the regional govern- the design stage, we involve the private
investor specializing in real estate, financial ments. So I want to make sure that we sector, NGOs and civil society. During the
institutions and the renewable energy sec- at least consider partnering with others implementation process, NGOS are also
tor. From 1992 to 1999, Mr. Yohannes was outside central governments. included in governing and making sure
President and CEO of Colorado National Third is leverage. How do we leverage the that implementation is going well. Also, in
Bank (part of U.S. Bank), and before this investments that have been made in many our threshold programs, NGOS are man-
Photo: MCC

held a number of leadership roles at Secu- of MCC’s partner countries? We have made aging some aspects of those programs.
rity Pacific Bank (now Bank of America). a commitment of about $7.5 billion. Govern- The NGOs are extremely critical to

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 23


Conversations Series

“We are looking


at every segment
of MCC’s business
including the
participation of civil
society on some of
the MCA boards.”
what we do and we have to seek out within the MCA boards. There has been results. I had to deliver results for the last
their advice and counsel; they keep us some conversation with some of the 30 years on a quarterly basis. And I know
true to our principles. They are extremely MCA civil society folks who are on the that there are a lot of expectations that
important to MCC and I am really look- MCA boards that they don’t have staff- MCC must provide great results and given
ing forward to working with them. I have ing and adequate facilities to leverage my background and where I come from I
already met with a lot of them since I have their position on the board. Do you see think my experience is a good complement
been in town. They are a very critical com- that as a conversation that you will have and hopefully we will accomplish a lot.
ponent of our business model. They have with your staff in terms of really helping
been great advocates for the MCC model augment the civil society participation NC: MCC has been a role model among
and we have a common theme, we have on MCA boards whether it is through U.S. government agencies in account-
a common objective, which is to reduce funding or technical expertise or other ability and transparency. Do you see
poverty throughout the world. relevant steps? yourself sharing some of those best
practices with other development agen-
NC: To follow on that line of thinking, DY: Definitely. We are looking at every cies within the U.S. government?
some countries have had various lev- segment of MCC’s business including the
els of civil society consultations. Some participation of civil society on some of DY: Right now there are two different stud-
are great and some are not so great. the MCA boards. To the extent that they ies that are being conducted by the U.S.
Our working group members would need some modification or need some government. One is the QDDR [Quadren-
like to know how you plan to ensure additional resources, I am committed to nial Diplomacy and Development Review]
a consistent level of consultation. This make it happen being conducted by the State Department
includes reaching out to a wide array and the other one is the PSD [Presidential
of civil society groups such as disabil- NC: What unique expertise do you bring Security Directive (initiating a review of
ity groups, gender groups and others to this job? What is the one skill that you U.S. global development policy)], which is
within compact development. bring that will help you address MCC’s conducted by the White House. We have
growth issues and challenges? been providing them with a lot of informa-
DY: It is my intent to make sure that we tion, with lessons learned from the last five
invest resources where we have some DY: First of all, there are a lot of other years at MCC.
weaknesses. I have asked Cassandra Butts people that could bring the expertise that I It is my understanding that many of our
to lead the gender integration process for have to the table and who can also be very principles are emerging as priorities for the
MCC. Cassandra comes from the White successful. When I first came to the United administration as they consider reforming
House where she was previously the deputy States, I came with absolutely nothing. I foreign aid. MCC is built on transparency
counsel. I want to make sure that the gender was 17 and I came from one of the poorest and accountability so we are more than
integration process is consistent through- countries in the world. I understand pov- happy to provide, not only for our govern-
out our partner countries. When I arrived erty better than most people and I want to ment, but also for the entire world, what has
at MCC, I heard that gender integration give back to the United States, which has worked and what has not worked for MCC.
was not consistent in some of the country given me so much. So that is my intent in
programs, but I promise you, I give you my undertaking public service. Having said NC: Gender integration, we spoke about
commitment that we will have a uniform that, I have spent 30 years in the banking/ it a little earlier, and you mentioned that
approach to every development program finance/investment area in which I have Cassandra Butts would be heading that
that we do, including gender integration. had a very successful career. arena. Can tell us the steps you have in
I believe that my background will com- place to make sure that there is some
Photo: MCC

NC: Another area of concern is the plement MCC in what we need to achieve accountability within the MCA about
amount of civil society participation especially in the areas of investments and gender integration in the programs?

24 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Conversations Series

DY: Number one, every single program NC: How do you define your relationship the development industry as well. I want
that’s being considered must include gen- with InterAction? to strengthen the relationship that exists
der integration. That is given. There is no between MCC and InterAction and all other
exception before a compact or project is DY: It is a great group. I look forward to development agencies in this country.
approved. We want to make sure we have getting their advice and counsel on mat-
the resources so that MCC programs are ters that are extremely critical to develop- NC: What message would you like to
implemented very well. I recently went to ment. They are a great ally for MCC. They leave from this interview for the NGO
Ghana and I saw many of our projects over have been advocates for us and also for community—both here and our members
there. In fact, I went to a land title office the entire development community in the overseas? What would you like them to
where I participated in handing out land world. I look forward to working with them know about your priorities for the MCC
titles to both men and women. I came back on matters that are extremely important to and where you see this organization in
from Cape Verde and Ghana believing that MCC. I have already met with them and terms of championing economic growth?
our gender integration program is working they are important to us. I am really excited
extremely well. to work with them. DY: We share the common theme, the
So I want to make sure—and I am com- What makes this agency unique is the common objective, which is to reduce
mitted to it—that at every aspect, in every fact that we are very transparent. If a pro- poverty globally and we’ve been great
stage of MCC programs, that gender is gram or policy doesn’t work, we work with partners. I look forward in the future to
included, that it is working, and that every- our constituencies to fix it. If our programs working very closely with InterAction and
one who works on the ground also under- and policies work, we continue to work with the development community to make
stands that they are accountable for that. with our constituencies to make it better. sure we solve this issue of poverty that
We are working on hiring additional staff to We have the same theme, the same goal affects about 2.5 billion people worldwide.
work on gender and I would also like to see and the same objective, which is to fight
some sort of internal incentives to ensure poverty globally. InterAction has been a NC: It was a pleasure speaking with you
gender is integrated as much as possible. great advocate for us and an advocate for today Mr. Yohannes. Thank you. MD

Plant knowledge. 
Grow justice. 
GRADUATE PROGRAMS IN  
SUSTAINABLE INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT 
• MA in Sustainable International Development 
• MS in International Health Policy and Management 
• Dual MA in Sustainable Development & Coexistence 

Brandeis University Boston 

http://heller.brandeis.edu 

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 25


Keeping Talent

Winning
the NGO Talent
Competition

How to retain and leverage


Photo: FotolEdhar - Fotolia.com

your most valuable resource.


By Curtis Grund, Vice President, and Mary
Martinez, Director, Workforce Management and
Diversity Consulting, ORC Worldwide

26 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Keeping Talent

M
any global development and human- most important roles in the organization. For example, country directors
itarian organizations are caught or program managers should outline the capabilities required and the
between a rock and a hard place: They are under pres- stepping stones to develop those capabilities. There may be specific jobs
sure to dedicate a greater proportion of their resources that people aspiring to those roles should pass through along the way
to program delivery while also confronting complex and these jobs might be reserved for people needing that experience.
management challenges that impact the organization’s ability to deliver This transparency will help employees understand the sorts of roles
services. Talent management is a prime example. Competition for they might aspire to and what they need to learn in order to prepare
people with limited technical and program skills is intensifying, for them. It will allow managers to make informed, equitable deci-
and many organizations are having difficulty retaining their most sions about who to place in roles based on their capabilities and what
experienced and pivotal staff members. In time, the loss of critical they need to learn in order to develop further, how to evaluate their
skills and the disarray created by frequent turnover can threaten performance, and how to compensate them fairly and competitively.
the sustainability of programs and of the organization itself.
Know the talent
The employees’ perspective The second step is to have a similarly clear picture of the talent in
Professional employees in NGOs tend to be idealistic the organization available to fill these roles. To get a comprehensive
and mission focused. However, like professionals in any portrait of the organization’s talent, the same basic processes, criteria,
field, they have ambitions for greater responsibility; they and tools for tracking individuals and their performance and their
seek new challenges and may be frustrated by the lack of future potential should be used throughout the organization. Although
opportunity for promotion in their organizations. Like the process may involve some customization to respond to differences
other professionals, they want to be recognized for their in local culture and the way each operation works, the vocabulary for
contributions, but monetary rewards may be hard to talking about job expectations, performance and potential should
come by. Often, the only way they can see to fulfill their be uniform and there should be a process in place for calibrating the
needs is to move to another NGO or the private sector. vocabulary so that everyone means pretty much the same thing by the
terms and ratings they use.
The organization’s challenge
Many international NGOs are challenged by the
very nature of their missions and their organization.
While headquartered in the U.S., they deliver services
throughout the world. Two separate management struc-
tures develop. Headquarters staff, expatriates and senior
local leaders are subject to processes promulgated and Internationally focused
monitored by headquarters, while country directors are master’s degree programs
generally free to manage local employees as they judge fit designed to advance
depending on local conditions. NGOs are usually fairly your career.
flat organizations with limited opportunities for promo-
tion. Further complications arise when a position has fund-
ing for only a limited period of time, leaving uncertainty
about the employee’s future once the contract ends.
So, at the local level, opportunities are limited by the
autonomy of the local operation and its relative isolation from
headquarters and other local units and by internal competition
between local and expatriate employees. At the same time, head-
quarters and international employees are frustrated by flat hierar-
chies and term contracts. How, then, can employers create incentives
that keep critical employees committed to their organizations? Put Your passion
Into Practice
Know the jobs and how they fit together across the
organization
The first step is a comprehensive view of the organization’s roles and
the capabilities required to perform those roles. Job descriptions should
be harmonized across the organization so that performance expecta-
tions, titles and job levels are consistent across functions and locations.
This can be a big undertaking, but it can be done with relatively few
resources by having employees fill out simple, standardized forms about Learn more at www.sit.edu
their major responsibilities and capabilities required to perform them. admissions@sit.edu
Toll-free (US) 800-336-1616 or 802-258-3510
It is also very helpful to describe the basic career path that leads to the

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 27


Keeping Talent

There should also be a process for tracking employees’ interests and


ambitions, whether or not they are willing to relocate, new skills they
Identifying the most
have acquired and other data that will inform decisions about whom to
place in assignments that arise. Keeping the information in a searchable
valuable employees
database will make it easy to locate individuals with special skills, to check doesn’t mean devaluing
whether candidates for a job are open to moving and to understand the
motivations of individuals the organization wants to be sure to retain. everyone else.
Review talent annually important to retain because they are likely to be the organization’s
An annual talent review process is an efficient, effective way to future leaders (often called “high potentials”) or because they pos-
align decisions about key jobs and highly valued individuals. Once a sess critical skills in high demand. This discussion will also help the
year the international leadership team (which might include country leadership team develop a consistent definition of what it means to
directors, program directors and headquarters leaders) have a struc- be a high potential or critical employee.
tured discussion about their most valued employees. The outcomes
of this talent review are: Succession plans for key roles
Eventually it will be necessary to replace someone in a leadership
A list or lists of the organization’s most valuable position or someone who holds a key role. Knowing in advance who
employees those replacements are likely to be will save a great deal of pain later
One of the most important reasons for conducting the exercise is to on and reassure donors that the organization is stable and sustainable.
get to know talent that might otherwise be hidden from view. It may Succession plans can be made for specific jobs (e.g., the next CFO or
be the only time during the year that leaders at the head office or in CEO) or for types of jobs (e.g., country directors). Typically, a succes-
different countries get to hear about talented individuals on local field sion plan will identify 3-5 people who might be able to do the job and
staffs and think collectively about how they can be best developed and whether they are ready now or require time to develop into the role.
deployed for the good of the entire organization. Identifying the most
valuable employees doesn’t mean devaluing everyone else. It does mean Development plans for successors and other critical
recognizing that there are a few critical people whom it is especially employees
Succession plans often fail because they remain bits of paper or
computer files and when the time comes to fill a position on the plan,
LOOKING FOR A NEW JOB it turns out the designated individuals are not ready to assume that
level of responsibility. The annual talent reviews are an opportunity
in International Development or Humanitarian Relief?
for the leadership team to share the development needs of their key
employees and come to some provisional agreements about next assign-
ments and alternatives.

Communicate with employees


Employees frequently express frustration when they do not under-
stand how they can move ahead or what options are open to them.
Managers can help employees make realistic choices about their careers
by talking honestly about how performance and potential are judged
and what it takes to be prepared for different kinds of roles. These
conversations are much easier when the job structure has been defined
and the leadership team has done the groundwork in the talent review
process to agree on what it takes to be a leader in the organization.

InterAction’s online job board instantly In addition to one-on-one conversations with subordinates, the
connects you to the latest humanitarian relief leadership should communicate frequently with employees about the
and international development jobs as they organization’s talent management strategy and how that translates into
become available. opportunities and expectations. And though your talent is often sub-
ject to your program timelines, there is no doubt that the future of the
Search by job sector, level, region and organization will benefit greatly from using these tools to monitor
country—or post your resume and let the skills, capabilities and requirements, and allow you to spot and move
hiring managers come to you! those key people to the next program or next country as it becomes
feasible. Being able to show you value your staff in this way will also
allow them to use your processes to plan a career with your organiza-
Visit: careers.interaction.org tion, rather than work from contract to contract, creating a win/win
for both the organization and the employee. MD

28 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Career Progression

Plotting the career


progression of
an international
development
professional.
By Andrea Bediako,

Navigating the Path


International Program
Coordinator, Katherine
A. Kendall Institute for

to a Rewarding Career
International Social Work
Education, Council on Social
Work Education

P
Ublic INterest in interna- despair they have witnessed firsthand and felt internship. The work may be mostly admin-
tional issues has increased in compelled to help the situation. istrative, but being in the environment and
the last decade. Publicity given to the Whatever the motivation to enter this field, interacting with professionals will provide
protests during international trade sum- from the outside, a career in international opportunities to gain knowledge and make
mits and economic forums has highlighted development seems like a fun and exciting job, professional contacts who can help you with
the interconnectivity of the world and how because it often involves traveling to exotic, career guidance. During this first stage of your
decisions made in Washington, DC affect far-away places. But breaking into the field is career, work on learning one of the predomi-
rural farmers around the world. In addition, not easy. It requires a lot of training, diverse nant languages in your region of interest. Also
many celebrities have partnered with inter- skills, and experience, along with a bit of luck work on developing strong administrative,
national NGOs and various UN agencies to to get a foot in the door. If you believe this grant management, analytical and logistical
bring issues such as malaria prevention, the profession is your life’s mission, you must be skills.
economic development of women and access innovative and tenacious if you want to suc- Because breaking into this field is competi-
to clean water to the forefront. In this media- ceed. In addition, skill development must be tive, you may not be able to find an entry-
driven age, these celebrities can significantly a career-long commitment. level job right away. If that happens, find a job
increase attention to substantive global issues There are essentially three stages in an focusing on the domestic side of the sector of
Photo: VIPDesign - Fotolia.com

and their involvement can encourage more international development career: international development that most inter-
young people to enter the international devel- ests you. For example, if you are interested in
opment workforce. Other new recruits include Entry-level professional microfinance, try working for an organiza-
children of immigrant parents from the devel- When you are first starting out, the best way tion that runs microfinance projects in the
oping world who have visited their parents’ to learn about the profession and gain expe- United States. If democracy and governance
homeland, been affected by the poverty and rience is to secure an international-focused is your passion, you could work for a domestic

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 29


Career Progression

There are endless Mid-level professional


As you become a mid-level professional,
or an organization. It requires having a broad
perspective with a particular focus on finan-
possibilities and paths the level of responsibility increases. At this
stage you begin to specialize and develop a
cial and organizational stability and often
entails fundraising and justifying budgets. It
to get a foot in the stronger network of contacts in and across also requires strategic planning and building
the sector. Your primary responsibilities will partnerships and coalitions with allied orga-
door if you are willing include managing and evaluating multiple nizations and funders. People at this level are
to think creatively in programs and projects. Working at this level
also often involves managing subordinates,
often looked to as an authority within their
area of expertise.
your approach to your which requires strong interpersonal skills. At The career of an international development
this point you might also get a Master’s degree professional requires a lot of planning and
career. or a post-graduate certificate to help enhance preparation. You need persistence to get your
skills and further develop credentials. Frequent foot in the door, but once you are in, you’re
organization that monitors governance issues travel is often required and living overseas for in. It is a difficult, but rewarding career. It
at the state and federal levels. If you choose an extended amount of time is a possibility. requires many sacrifices, particularly if your
this route, it is important to keep abreast of Some people decide to spend the entire balance work is overseas, but the sense of satisfaction
international issues and develop international- of their career progression at this level taking one gets from working on a project that brings
focused contacts outside of your main job to on broader programmatic responsibilities over clean water to a community or helping women
help you prepare for when you transition into time, but others decide to pursue an executive- become economically self-sufficient is immea-
the international realm. There are endless pos- level position. surable. Working in the international develop-
sibilities and paths to get a foot in the door ment field is not just a job. It is a calling that
if you are willing to think creatively in your Executive-level professional allows you to contribute to the improvement
approach to your career. The skills developed Work at the executive level involves moni- of humanity.
at this stage can be transferable later. toring the overall functions of a department MD

JENNINGS RANDOLPH FELLOWSHIP PROGRAM


The United States Institute of Peace invites applications for Senior Fellowships for up to ten months
as part of the Jennings Randolph (JR) Program for International Peace.
Senior Fellowships are awarded annually to scholars, policymakers, journalists, and other
United professionals to write and conduct research on peace, conflict, and international security issues.
StateS Citizens of any country may apply. Senior Fellow application deadline: September 8, 2010. For
more information on JR Fellowship programs, please visit our Web site.
inStitUte
The JR program also supports doctoral research. For more on the Peace Scholar Dissertation
of Peace Fellowships, please visit our Web site.
www.usip.org/fellows • E-mail: jrprogram@usip.org
1200 17th Street NW
Suite 200

GRANT PROGRAM
Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 457-1700
Fax (202) 429-6063
www.usip.org The United States Institute of Peace (USIP) invites applications for its Grant competitions.
Annual Grant Competition considers applications that focus on preventing, managing, and
resolving violent conflict and promoting post-conflict peacebuilding outside the United States.
Annual Grant application deadline: October 1, 2010.
Priority Grant Competition: Through Summer 2010, USIP continues to focus its grantmaking
on seven countries as they relate to USIP’s mandate: Afghanistan, Colombia, Iran, Iraq, Nigeria,
Pakistan, and Sudan. Applicants may apply at any time throughout the year.
For more information about the Grant Program’s priorities and eligibility requirements, please visit
our Web site.
www.usip.org/grants • E-mail: grants@usip.org

30 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Career growth

How Young NGO


Communication needs to be a central part of your career strategy.
As noted author and speaker Tim Sanders says, your network is your
net worth. You cannot develop your career strategy and goals and

Professionals silently hope they become reality. You need to talk to the people in
your network about your plan. Network at live events and through
social media like LinkedIn. Prepare and clearly project your personal

Can Develop a brand. The projects and activities you work on, the professional associa-
tions you belong to, the research you have done and the professional

Career Strategy
development training you have received all serve to create a statement
about who you are and where you are headed.
Review your strategic plan regularly and frequently, and make adjust-
ments as you learn and progress. Seize the opportunity to learn
Practical steps for making by your experience.
At a recent webinar, InsideNGO member senior
a plan that works for you. human resources leaders offered many ideas includ-
ing this very useful tip: look at your resume every
By Roxy Allen, Training Events January and reflect on your accomplishments over
Coordinator, InsideNGO the past year. If you are not adding to your list of
skills and experiences, review your career strategic
plan and see if you are stalled and what you can do

L
ast year InsideNGO, an associa- to move it forward. MD
tion that supports operational teams For more information about InsideNGO or its
of relief and development organizations working Young Professionals program, please contact rallen@
internationally, launched a Young Professionals Forum to InsideNGO.org
support career growth, encourage professional development
and create opportunities for professional connections with others in the
international NGO community. Several recent InsideNGO workshops
and roundtables have offered practical tips on career advancement,
with developing a career strategy foremost among them.
Your career is your platform to do great things—to do meaningful
work that you love. At a recent InsideNGO workshop on career devel-
opment, participating young professionals were advised to take the 2010 Annual Meeting for Members
concepts of strategic planning and apply them to their own strategic Washington, DC  
career growth plan. What is your personal vision and what are your
goals? Who do you want to be? What job do you want now or in the Finance, Grants & Contracts—July 12‐13 
future? How will you get there? Setting three to five-year strategic Cross Operations—July 14 
career goals will help you get yourself moving forward. Human Resources—July 15‐16 
As in strategic planning, start with a scan of your environment: your
career does not just happen; you need to be proactive. Stay current
Learn  from  experts,  share  your  experience  with 
with industry trends, join relevant professional groups and under-
stand your organization’s strategic plan. Read a variety of books and peers,  connect  with  colleagues  from  InsideNGO’s 
journals to gain a wider understanding of the sector and field you are member base of more than 250 organizations.  
interested in. Become associated with professional groups and attend
seminars and events they offer. Talk with colleagues in similar posi- The full agenda will include over 60 sessions aimed 
tions at other organizations. Find out what they have found helpful. at addressing the core challenges faced by interna‐
Talk to senior leaders about their experiences and learn about new tional development and relief operations staff. 
opportunities in your sector. Your career strategic plan needs to take
these environmental triggers into account. Then use what you have
learned to develop tactical plans and career benchmarks. “Good mix of people with different perspectives and experiences 
coming together to discuss relevant and important issues that impact 
Organizations are constantly changing. In your current position, do
the effectiveness of our work.” 
you understand where your organization is going? Learn about the
Photo: Spencer Millsap

future plans of the organization and the skills you will need to be part “It was so informative…. I walked away from each session with 
of its evolving future. Ensure your skills and experiences are relevant something that I can use or that I can learn from.” 
not only to the work you do now but also the positions to which you
aspire and start thinking and acting like a person in the position you’d To learn more, go to—www.InsideNGO.org 
love to have. Demonstrate flexibility. Find a mentor.

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 31


Islamic Schools

Tradition
of the educational institutions that developed
in Arabia under the prophet Muhammad. The
traditional model was a school that solely
taught children to memorize the Qur’an. As

and Learning in
they evolved, these schools branched out
into other areas—Arabic philosophy, science,
mathematics. The longer a student stayed in
school, the more they would encounter other

Islamic Schools subjects beyond Qur’anic memorization.


Centuries ago, these schools had interesting
forms of pedagogy, including peer learning,
individualized instruction, and self-paced learn-
ing. Students were evaluated on their mastery
A conversation with Helen Boyle. of the materials studied and not by a formal
exam process. If a student did not master the
By Heidi LaFleche, Senior Writer, material he was studying, he simply went back,
Education Development Center, Inc. got more instruction and tried again. Although
the schools were very authoritarian, many of
the instructional practices they employed are

A
s a project director at and English. In several countries (Nigeria, Mali ones that we are promoting today in our teacher
Education Development Center, Inc. and Ghana, to name a few), national ministries training activities.
(EDC), Helen Boyle’s work has taken of education are encouraging and supporting In many post-colonial African countries,
her across the Middle East and Northern the addition of these subjects. The international Muslim populations were reluctant to send
Africa. She has come to know parents, teach- development community is increasingly look- their children to the emerging public school
ers, and students in many different Islamic ing at how to offer culturally sensitive technical system as that system was associated with the
school classrooms. assistance to these schools, whether it be teacher colonizer and/or Christian traditions. So they
Boyle seemed destined for a life in edu- training or interactive radio instruction. tended to keep their kids in Qur’anic schools
cation; her father was a teacher and school to ensure that they learned about and were
principal, and her mother was a librarian. What are some of the challenges faithful to their own religious traditions.
After teaching junior high for one year, Boyle facing Islamic schools today?
joined the Peace Corps. While in Morocco, Many students in Islamic schools have not Why are there so many
she became intrigued with Islamic schools. “I learned the official language of their coun- misperceptions of Islamic schools?
knew Islam was a religion that put great value try: for example, French in Mali or English in People in the United States don’t really
on learning,” she says. “That got me interested Nigeria. This leaves them behind in terms of know much about them. We hope the Islamic
in researching these kinds of schools.” education, particularly if they try to matric- Sector Education Study we conducted for
Boyle did her dissertation on the Qur’anic ulate from Islamic schools into the public USAID in Ghana and our report, Educational
schools in Morocco and earned a doctorate in school system. Many Muslims in these coun- Quality in Islamic Schools Report in Nigeria
comparative education. She teaches Education in tries have expressed the need for their children clarify some misconceptions about Islamic
Islamic Society, a course at George Washington to receive both a secular and an Islamic edu- schools in general.
University. In Africa, Boyle and her colleagues cation so they can better participate in both After September 11, 2001, we heard a lot
have carried out research on Islamic schools political and economic life. of negative commentary about Islamic educa-
(known as “madrassas” or “medersas”) to bridge EDC has completed studies, as part of vari- tion. Ninety-nine percent of the time, con-
the teaching of religion with math, sciences, lan- ous USAID projects, that look at the character- cerns that Islamic schools promote terrorism
guages and other secular subjects. The following istics of Islamic schools, particularly in terms are completely misplaced. When you talk to
excerpts from a recent conversation with her of teaching practices, as a first step to assisting many teachers and parents in Muslim com-
offer some of her insights. Islamic schools as they integrate new subjects munities: they all want the best for their kids,
into their curriculum. Indeed, one of the pri- the same way American parents do. No mat-
Describe the kinds of Islamic schools. orities of our funder (USAID) is to learn more ter where we are, we hear parents of children
There are different types of Islamic schools about how we can develop secular programs in an Islamic school say, “I hope my child
across Africa, in countries such as Nigeria, that are sensitive to Muslim religious tradi- graduates from high school. I hope my child
Ghana, and Mali, and the Somali region of Ethi- tions and improve the quality of teaching and goes to college and becomes a doctor.” Those
opia. The most traditional Qur’anic schools just learning in those classrooms. hopes are universal. MD
have religious instruction, in particular, memo- A version of this conversation previously
rization of the Qur’an, the Islamic holy book. How have Islamic schools changed? appeared in EDC Update, the quarterly magazine
Other Islamic schools offer both religious studies As Islam spread across Africa in the seventh of Education Development Center. Comments can
and some secular subjects, such as math, science and eighth centuries, it brought with it some be sent to comment@edc.org.

32 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Kicker

Projects
Does your organization implement
unique projects or programs? Share
them with the Monday Developments
community. Send your project’s
name, implementing organization,
location and funder(s) along with a
brief description of 400 words or less
to cbrobst@interaction.org

in a specific geographic area qualify as


Kenya Urban Cash a humanitarian emergency. But in the Haiti Earthquake Relief and
Transfer Program slums, with their high population density, Reconstruction
this international standard measurement
Organization would mean that there were hundreds Organization
Concern Worldwide of thousands of severely malnourished Movimiento de Mujeres
Location children—a crisis of monumental Dominico Haitiana (MUDHA)
Nairobi, Kenya proportions to which neither NGOs nor the Location
government would have the capacity to
Dominican Republic
Funders respond to rapidly and effectively.
As Concern Country Director Anne Funders
Private donors and SIDA
O’Mahony explained, “We know that American Jewish World Service
(Swedish International
the international standard for signaling (AJWS)
Development Cooperation a nutrition emergency does not apply in
Agency) Nairobi’s slums. We must act now! If we
wait until we have evidence of reaching that The Project
The Project standard, it will already be too late.” While the earthquake in Haiti did
Kenya is the first country in the world to Deceptively, there is plenty of food for not discriminate, its effects on women
use mobile phones for cash transfers. In sale in markets, but the extremely poor and children remain dire and largely
another first, in response to a food crisis simply can no longer afford to buy it. As a undiscussed. Already traumatized by the
affecting four million people in urban slums, result, said O’Mahony, families are resorting loss of homes and loved ones, women and
the government of Kenya’s Food Subsidy to desperate measures just to survive. children are now suffering the additional
Taskforce has recommended working There are sharply rising rates of malnutrition trauma of rape, abuse and gender-based
with Concern to pilot the nation’s first- among children under five. violence in tent cities and refugee camps
ever social welfare program using mobile Based on the Food Subsidy Taskforce that have become home to hundreds of
phones to distribute emergency cash to the recommendations and with funding thousands of people.
poorest living in the slums of Nairobi. support from the Swedish International To address these problems, American
Concern’s Kenya Urban Cash Transfer Development Cooperation Agency, Jewish World Service, an international
Program is partnering with Kenya’s largest Concern has begun to distribute emergency development organization motivated by
telecommunications company, Safaricom cash via mobile phones to some 2,000 Judaism’s imperative to pursue justice, is
Limited, on the use of its M-Pesa money- families in Korogocho, one of Nairobi’s supporting many grassroots organizations
transfer service. A code sent via text poorest slums. including the Movement of Haitian and
message to beneficiaries allows them “In an emergency, we want to respond Dominico-Haitian Women (MUDHA),
collect the money from authorized M-Pesa as quickly as possible. This technology a Dominico-Haitian community-based
agents. can get the money here in minutes, as organization based in the Dominican
The Kenyan government declared a opposed to the very difficult logistics and Republic that advances human rights,
national food emergency in 2009, but high transportation costs of shipping in community health education, gender
there is no coordination mechanism in food,” said O’Mahony. “Before this pilot, in equality and environmental conservation, to
the country to determine how recent Kenya’s informal settlements and slums, respond to the neglected needs of Haitian
shocks—post-election violence and rising there was no social welfare and no safety women and children.
food costs—have impacted people in nets of any kinds. If you didn’t have money, Just hours after the earthquake hit,
the urban slums. The findings in a joint you didn’t eat,” she said. MUDHA coordinated a series of relief
report spearheaded by Concern (along caravans with medical and personal
with partners CARE and Oxfam) confirm hygiene supplies to Port-au-Prince.
Subscribe to Monday Developments
suspicions that the urban food crisis has Traveling on bumpy roads across the
reached a critical impasse. Call 202-552-6548 or border of Haiti, members of MUDHA treated
Under normal circumstances, email publications@interaction.org patients for 24 hours straight, exhausting
malnutrition rates of at least 15 percent all of their supplies. Since its first caravan,

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 33


Projects

MUDHA has installed 12 encampments in Haiti Aid indefinitely delayed, making it difficult to
five communities outside of Port-au-Prince continued from page 19 form a viable government.
and has implemented an innovative strategy
to train youth in first-responder skills to Also, the vast majority of the Haitian Conclusion
support the work of doctors in providing economy is hidden in the black market where Haiti is a unique place: it has experienced
counseling, emotional support and needs- taxes are uncollectable and corruption is continuing, unprecedented natural and man-
assessment for earthquake survivors. rampant. Haiti should legalize underground made disasters over its 200-year history and
MUDHA’s caravans were propelled by the entrepreneurship and not tax it until these throughout that time Haitians, especially the
limitations of large-scale food distribution businesses grow larger and more sustainable. poor, have endured and struggled on. Let’s
without equitable rationing according to Haitians are incredibly entrepreneurial: they unite to get this country on the right track once
family size. Food had not arrived in many of need to be nurtured, not exploited or sup- and for all. Haiti would make a perfect candi-
the refugee camps—full of large families— pressed. Donors should flood the country date to “demonstrate” aid effectiveness. MD
until nearly two weeks after the earthquake with microcredit. Professor Buss is also the author of Haiti
hit. MUDHA has been working exclusively The earthquake created an opportunity to in the Balance: Why Foreign Aid Failed and
with camps of earthquake refugees that break up the massive slums dominating Port- What We Can Do About It (Brookings Institu-
are organized on a community level. By au-Prince. Aid needs to create jobs and hous- tion Press, 2008).
coordinating directly with camp leaders to ing outside the capitol so that people will not
conduct censuses in the camps, MUDHA be locked in inner city ghettos where there is Accountability
determines which aid is most needed and little hope. Unfortunately, even though large continued from page 20
focuses particularly on women’s needs numbers are homeless following the quake,
including feminine hygiene products, government and donors are still dithering part of this process is creating a participatory
diapers, undergarments, condoms and about how to relocate them. work relationship in which the people of the
other reproductive health supplies that On a parallel issue, many poor Haitians community are well informed about what they
are frequently missed by humanitarian aid are squatters who have no legal right to their can rightfully expect from the humanitar-
efforts. property. Where illegal housing and busi- ian community: namely, that food and other
MUDHA is now also working in affected nesses can be salvaged or rehabilitated, the forms of assistance are given freely to them,
communities in Leogane, Petit Goave and government needs to promote legal prop- without any expectation that sexual favors
Grand Goave, establishing safe spaces erty ownership so that people can invest in must be given in return.
for women and conducting workshops on improvements. Hernando DeSoto, author of Moreover, by playing a role in design-
sexual and reproductive health. The Mystery of Capital, has offered a viable ing complaints and reporting mechanisms,
The key to Haiti’s future is to equip Haitian agenda for transforming this “dead capital.” affected communities gain experience not only
grassroots organizations with the resources in identifying the violations of their rights but
they need to rebuild Haiti from the ground The current administration also in seeking and securing effective and just
up. AJWS is proud to support MUDHA in its In my view, President Rene Preval was the remedies for these violations. When interna-
effort to revive Haitian society and build right person to take over after President Jean- tional NGOs establish such systems, it creates a
sustainable, grassroots change. MD Bertrand Aristide’s overthrow. Preval did the model for similar accountability by the govern-
right things in gaining support from donors, ment to local communities. In short, a system
Project claims are made by the featured especially the U.S., patching up diplomatic to prevent and respond to SEA can blossom
organizations and are not confirmed or relations in Latin America, Caribbean, the into an educational process for communities
endorsed by InterAction. U.S. and Europe, and defusing a lot of political about securing their rights more broadly.
problems with opposing parties and factions. If we are honest with ourselves, we in the
Monday Developments There were probably few leaders in Haiti who humanitarian community must acknowledge
Magazine provides could have accomplished this. Preval is ineli- that much still needs to be done to address
in-depth news and gible to run for re-election and he should not SEA. If we do what is needed, we can leave
commentary on global
Monday Developments Magazine
trends that affect relief,
attempt to do so (a practice all too common behind the foundation for long-lasting change.
refugee and development work. It features the in Haiti’s past). When we set up accountability systems that
latest information on the work of InterAction The next leader will need to sustain Preval’s work, then, long after we leave, the communi-
members around the world and keeps readers political accomplishments, but also articulate ties that gained experience in exercising their
up-to-date on legislative action in Congress a vision for the country that he/she can deliver rights while working with us, will be better
that could impact U.S. foreign assistance on. Haiti’s future will rely on charismatic lead- able to seek similar respect from their local
to poor countries. Monday Developments
ership and effective management. It is unclear and national governments. They now know
Magazine also describes new resources for
relief and development workers, professional whether such a person exists. Unfortunately, that a system can be accountable and serve all
growth opportunities, upcoming events and Haiti has lost much of its governance capac- equally. MD
employment listings. ity: parliament and ministries have been The authors are co-chairs of the InterAction
www.interaction.org/monday-developments devastated by the earthquake and elections Sexual Exploitation and Abuse Sub-Working
that were to be held last year have now been Group.

34 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


Kicker

Events
It’s free and easy to publicize
your upcoming events in Monday
Developments Magazine. Send your
event’s name, date, location and
contact information to publications@
interaction.org

April www.insidengo.org/ 26–27 June Deep Ecology &


workshops.htm Annual G20 Summit Sustainable Living
25 April Toronto, Ontario San Ramon, Alajuela,
Earth Day / World Malaria 22 May www.g20.org Costa Rica
Day International Day for www.earthedintl.org/
Biodiversity 28 June Summer.htm
25 April www.biodiversity-day.info/ Habitat For Humanity
2010 Spring Meetings of International September
the International June Mongolia Blue Sky Build
Monetary Fund and the Bangkok, Thailand TBD
World Bank Group  2–4 June Contact: +66 2 632 0415 Third UN Private Sector
Washington, DC InterAction Forum: MDGs
www.imf.org/external/am/ Annual Member JUly New York, NY
index.htm Forum Contact: Melissa Powell,
Washington, DC 12–13 July powell1@un.org
May Contact: bwallace@ Annual Meeting: Finance,
interaction.org Grants and Contracts 22–24 September
3–14 May Washington, DC Millennium Development
Commission on 7–9 June www.insidengo.org/ Goals Summit
Sustainable Development Women Deliver workshops.htm New York, NY
New York, NY Conference www.un.org/millenniumgoals/
www.un.org/esa/dsd/csd/ Washington, DC 14 July calendar.shtml
csd_csd18.shtml womendeliver.org Annual Meeting: Cross-
Operations October
4 May 23 June Washington, DC
Young Professionals VIII Annual Local www.insidengo.org/ 9–11 October
Forum: Facilitation Skills Networks Forum workshops.htm 2010 Annual Meetings of the
Washington, DC New York, USA International Monetary Fund
www.insidengo.org/ Contact: haertle@un.org 15–16 July and the World Bank Group
workshops.htm Annual Meeting: Human Washington, DC
24–25 June Resources www.imf.org/external/am/
18–19 May UN Compact Global Washington, DC index.htm
Navigating International Leaders Summit www.insidengo.org/
Human Resources in the New York, NY workshops.htm 9–15 October
InterAction’s Progress
Nonprofit World www.unglobalcompact.
Against Poverty Week
Washington, DC org/newsandevents/2010_ 18–23 July
http://www.insidengo.org/ Leaders_Summit/index.html XVIII International AIDS
17 October
workshops.htm Conference
International Day for the
25–27 June Vienna, Austria
Eradication of Poverty
20 May 36th Annual www.aids2010.org/
Worldwide
Federal Grant & Contract G8 Summit
www.un.org/esa/socdev/
Requirements for HR Huntsville, Ontario 25 July
social/intldays/IntlDay/
Professionals www.canada-g8-summit. Earth Education
International
index.html
Washington, DC com/

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 35


Jobs
Are you looking to hire experienced
development and humanitarian
professionals? The candidates
you’re looking for read Monday
Developments! Send your classified
position announcements or display
advertisements to Katie Delaney at
publications@interaction.org

Finance & Administration Manager gramming. S/he will accomplish this by setting ed candidates please submit your resume and
Boston, MA up complaints/feedback mechanisms, training cover letter on-line at www.savethechildren.org
JSI/BOSTON INTERNATIONAL DIVISION. staff on accountability and quality standards, under “Careers” ref # 4250
The F&A Manager focuses on issues related to and ensuring that these standards are met. The
efficient management of financial systems for Accountability specialist will also work with the Senior Manager, Logistics
field projects. S/he works closely with project M&E specialist to include quality and account- Haiti
teams to provide daily direction and support to ability standards in regular M&E activities, such Save the Children US, the leading independent
JSI bilateral projects. Responsibilities include as assessment, design, monitoring and evalua- organization creating real and lasting change
serving as a resource, ensuring implementa- tion (ADM&E), and other learning activities such for children in need in the U.S. and around the
tion of financial policies, developing tools, and as program reviews during Save the Children’s world seeks a Logistics Manager to be respon-
training staff in their use, and traveling to field Emergency programming. Required Skills: sible to lead and manage the set up or scale
offices to perform financial reviews. Qualifica- Advanced degree in a social science and/or up of all emergency response logistics functions
tions: BS in finance, MBA preferred, five years equivalent discipline. Experience in international and responsibilities and associated staff. As a
experience managing financial systems, prefer- emergency programming. Proven practical ex- member of the emergency management team,
ably overseas, good knowledge of USAID rules, perience in Quality Assurance of Accountability the Emergency Logistics Manager will support
ability to work as part of a team. Interested can- Standards. Strong understanding of HAP-I and the Response Team Leader and other mem-
didates should apply online: www.jsi.com. Sphere. Experience in development of training bers of the emergency management team on
programs including curriculum design, presen- the best use of Save the Children’s resources.
tation and teaching skills, and training of trainers Requires two years international experience in
ProQuest CultureGrams methods. Strong analytical ability, especially re-
Reviewers Needed humanitarian logistics at County Program Lo-
lated to problem solving and systems develop- gistics Manager level. International experience
Anywhere ment Excellent oral and written communication in supply chain management in a sudden onset
Use your overseas experience to become a skills in English. Strong French or Haitian Creole emergency or complex environment. Interna-
reviewer for CultureGrams, a series of educa- language skills required. Apply on-line at www. tional experience in coordination of humanitar-
tional reports describing the cultures of more savethechildren.org under “Careers” ian logistics with multiple external agencies or
than 200 countries. Reviewers receive $100 clusters. Experience in proposal development,
to $300 for providing feedback and additional Senior Specialist, Emergency Food budget planning and management, and the reg-
content on an existing country-specific report. Security and Livelihoods ulations of key international emergency donors
More than 80 reports are available for review. Haiti governing supply chain, stocks and assets.
Professional writing experience is not required. The Senior Specialist, Emergency Food Securi- Please apply online at www.savethechildren.org
Applicants must speak a national language, be ty and Livelihoods will lead the development of under “Careers” and reference job #4390.
well integrated in the culture, and have lived in SC’s Emergency Food Security and Livelihoods
the country for at least two and a half of the unit; provide technical support for Save the Deputy Director,
last four years. Visit www.culturegrams.com/ Children’s food security and livelihoods emer- Operations Manager
submissions/reviewers.htm for more informa- gency response and recovery portfolio, particu- Haiti
tion and an online application. larly in the areas of: short term safety nets (cash Save the Children, the leading independent
and food resource provisioning), disaster risk organization creating real and lasting change
Senior Specialist, reduction, livelihoods recovery, and emergency for children in need in the U.S. and around
Global Disaster Response food security assessment. Documentation, the world seeks an Operations Manager to
Habitat for Humanity International is seeking proposal development, training, tool develop- be responsible for overall on-going manage-
a seasoned professional for the position of Se- ment and capacity building will be key compo- ment responsibility for the program delivery
nior Specialist, Global Disaster Response. The nents. Advanced degree in a related area; field- aspect of SC’s Emergency Operations in Haiti.
successful candidate will have a minimum of based experience in response and recovery; at Oversee hiring of properties and premises as
6 plus years in international disaster response least 5 years experience in emergency and/or required, ensuring that contracts, leases and
including on the ground experience in coun- developmental food security and/or livelihoods other agreements are properly prepared and
tries outside of the US. MUST be comfortable program management and technical support; updated. Ensure that Standard Operation Pro-
working in a fast paced environment and have understanding of food security concepts and cedures are strictly followed and adhered to
the ability to respond quickly to changing envi- multi-sectoral programming; experience with by all. Help to liaise with relevant program staff
ronments. If you would like to be a part of the designing and implementing cash and food- and oversee development of timely and sound
dynamic international organization, you can ex- based safety net activities, asset protection, proposals and budget development. Requires
press interest online at www.habitat.org. Habi- disaster risk reduction (preparedness and miti- 7 years experience in human resource, logistics
tat is an EOE. gation), food security assessment and program and/or grant management, including budget
design. Solid writing, editing, training and grant holding & donor reporting. At least 5 years sub-
Specialist, Accountability writing experience essential. Ability to work stantial experience managing finance, human
Haiti independently, even in harsh environments; to resources and logistics in international pro-
The Accountability Specialist will provide leader- travel up to 40% of the time; be deployed for grams with a humanitarian organization within
ship, technical guidance in ensuring humanitar- emergency response and assessment activi- an emergency environment. Experience work-
ian accountability and community engagement ties. Strong communication and interpersonal ing with NGO partners and a participatory ap-
are incorporated into Save the Children pro- skills and cultural sensitivity required. Interest- proach. Experience managing USAID-OFDA/

36 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS May 2010


USG funded projects. Please apply online at www.savethechildren.org
under “Careers” and reference job #4364.

Director,
Deputy Team Leader, Programs
Haiti
Save the Children US, the leading independent organization creating
    
real and lasting change for children in need in the U.S. and around the 
world seeks a Director, Deputy Team Leader, Programs to be responsible
to provide strong leadership to the Haiti program and ensure implementa-
 
tion of quality, integrated programs in Haiti. The Director will directly su-
pervise all sector leads/advisors and will ensure strong program design,  
implementation and reporting. S/he will also directly supervise the M&E
staff, ensuring quality, evidence-based programming and effective moni-
toring and evaluation systems and protocols are in place. The Director  
will ensure that program activities are effective and meet the designated
goals and objectives of Save the Children and the target population. Re-  
quires at least 10 years experience in holistic development work and at
least 5 years experience working in an emergency setting. Must have 
strong and demonstrated strategic planning skills. Must have knowledge  
of and proven experience in management, including financial manage-
ment, and including management of a large team of expatriate and na- 
tional experts. Must have experience with various government and multi-  
lateral funding sources. Please apply online at www.savethechildren.org
under “Careers” and reference job #4360.
 

InterAction’s online job board
instantly connects you to the

latest humanitarian relief and 
international development jobs 
as they become available.

careers.interaction.org 
  

NOW HIRING:
Country Directors* Program & Training Officers* Administrative Officers*
The Peace Corps is looking for senior-level executives and The Peace Corps is looking for senior-level managers with exceptional The Peace Corps is looking for senior-level managers with
managers with exceptional leadership and motivational skills to manage staff and design and manage international extensive administration and finance experience, international
skills, international experience (including living overseas), development programs in a variety of fields such as health, education, and cross-cultural experience (including living overseas),
administrative and financial management expertise, and small business development and agriculture/environment that and exceptional management and leadership skills to serve
strong cross-cultural experience to serve as country directors. positively impact communities overseas. International and cross- overseas as administrative officers.
International development experience is desired. cultural experience are required.
The Administrative Officer ensures the effective management
We seek candidates that are reflective of the diversity of PTOs manage, advise and develop teams of professional program of country operations in support of a population of staff
Peace Corps and our Volunteers. and training staff to support Peace Corps Volunteers at post. Our and Volunteers entirely dependent on the critical services
PTOs oversee the processes of planning, analysis, implementation (administrative unit supervision, financial analysis, policy
Country directors must be United States citizens and must not and monitoring of programs and training activities, support staff and execution and implementation) the AO provides.
have been associated with intelligence activities. Candidates Volunteers to meet the expectations of project partners and conduct
should have work experience managing a program or business staff development. These officers guide coordination between working We seek candidates that are reflective of the diversity of
of comparable size to a Peace Corps country program (i.e., units to ensure effective strategic planning, cost-effective budgeting, Peace Corps and our Volunteers.
approximately 15 to 50 staff, 50 to 250 Volunteers, and an and appropriate recommendations.
operating budget ranging from $900,000 to $4 million), as All Administrative Officers must be United States citizens and
well as experience mentoring staff and volunteers. Since We seek candidates that are reflective of the diversity of Peace Corps must not have been associated with intelligence activities.
approximately 90 percent of Peace Corps staff at each post and our Volunteers. Candidates should have work experience managing a program
are host country nationals, cross-cultural communication skills or business, and mentoring staff and volunteers. Since
are critical. All PTOs must be United States citizens and must not have been approximately 90 percent of Peace Corps staff at each post
associated with intelligence activities. Candidates should have work are host country nationals, cross-cultural communication skills
The salary range for these positions is $87,848 - $140,940. experience managing an international development program or are critical.
These positions are time limited, as are the positions of business, and mentoring staff and volunteers. Since approximately 90
all Peace Corps U.S. direct hire employees. Employees are percent of Peace Corps staff at each post are host country nationals, The salary range for these positions is $46,736 - $104,534.
appointed for a 30-month tour and may be granted a second strong cross-cultural communication skills are critical. All Peace Corps U.S. direct hire positions are time limited.
tour for a maximum of five years (60 months) with the agency. Employees are appointed for a 30-month tour and may
The salary range for these positions is $57,678 - $129,008. All Peace be granted a second tour for a maximum of five years (60
Corps U.S. direct hire positions are time limited. Employees are months) with the agency.
appointed for a 30-month tour and may be granted a second tour for a
maximum of five years (60 months) with the agency.

The Peace Corps is one of the most successful and respected development agencies in the world. More than 195,000 Volunteers have served in 139 countries
since the inception of the Peace Corps in 1961. Thousands more from every background are eager to serve as teachers, business advisors, information technology
consultants, health and HIV/AIDS educators, and agricultural extension Volunteers.
Peace Corps accepts applications for these positions throughout the year. You may apply on-line through the website, http://pcoverseasjobs.avuedigital.us/. You
must complete the on-line application to be considered for a position; resumes are supplemental.
If you have any questions, please contact the Office of Overseas Recruitment, Selection and Support at 202-692-2411 or e-mail AOandPTOjobs@peacecorps.gov for
AO and PTO positions and CDSelection@peacecorps.gov for Country Director positions.
*While many of these positions do not require fluency in a language, some do. We anticipate a specific need for fluent French, Portuguese and Spanish speakers.

May 2010 MONDAY DEVELOPMENTS 37


Brandeis University
RETHINKING DEVELOPMENT
One Degree at a Time
The Heller School for Social Policy and Management
Graduate Programs in Sustainable International Development

VISITING APPOINTMENTS IN THE LARGEST AND MOST


DIVERSE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM IN THE US

The Graduate Programs in Sustainable International Development (SID) invites applications for two one-year posts (with
possibility of renewal for a second year) beginning mid-August 2010. SID includes an MA in Sustainable Development, an MS
in International Health Policy and Management, and the PhD in Global Health and Development Policy. Also dual degrees with
Coexistence and Conflict Resolution, as well as Gender and Women’s Studies. Faculty are drawn from the major development
agencies and interact with students from 70 countries annually.

Laurence R. Simon, Director

Practicum Coordinator and Visiting Associate or Full Professor in Development Studies


This full-time position will combine 1) advising students on professional internships in major development organizations
around the world and 2) course instruction. Candidates must have extensive experience in international development
organizations including diverse geographical and thematic expertise. Additionally, candidates should have demonstrated ability
to mentor students preparing their Master’s papers as well as familiarity with experiential training methods and case studies.
Fluency in a second language preferably French or Spanish is a plus.

Visiting Associate or Full Professor in Development Studies


This full time position is for a social scientist with a strong theoretical and methodological background in the political economy
of poverty (related disciplines to be considered) to teach interdisciplinary courses on Poverty and Inequalities, the theory,
history and practice of development at the Masters and PhD levels. S/he will teach the equivalent of four full semester
courses in the academic year, mentor students, engage in the community, and liaison with the Institute on Global Health and
Development. The successful candidate will combine a strong background in development studies with practical experience
in international development through international organizations. Knowledge of current policy debates about development
assistance, development models and climate change is required. Research publications are a plus.

Applications for both positions


Please include a letter of interest, curriculum vitae, a list of three professional references, a sample article
or report written. Evidence of teaching and mentoring ability welcome. Submit to Alba Bego (abego@
brandeis.edu). Positions will remain open until filled. Visit http://www.heller.brandeis.edu/sid for
more information about our programs.

Brandeis University is an equal opportunity employer, committed to building a culturally diverse


intellectual community and strongly encourages applications from women and minorities.
Job Openings Chief, Program
Development
Arlington,VA

Deputy, Chief
Financial Officer
Arlington,VA

Deputy Director,
Health
Arlington,VA

Chief of
Operations,
Infrastructure
Kabul,
Afghanistan

Deputy Chief
of Operations,
Infrastructure
Kabul,
Afghanistan

1621 North Kent Street For more


Fourth Floor information,
Arlington,VA 22209 contact Christine
P: 703.248.0161 Dalpino at
F: 703.248.0194 703.248.0161
www.ird.org or visit
www.ird.org and
click on “careers.”
Wherever Your Mission Takes You - We Will Be There...
ContaCt our PVo SPeCialiStS:
Robert W. Albrecht, CPA / ralbrecht@grfcpa.com
Andreas A. Alexandrou, CPA / aalexandrou@grfcpa.com

Worldwide Field Office Travel

• Auditing, A-133 compliance • Internal control evaluation


• Pension plan auditing • Expatriate tax preparation
• Grant compliance procedures • Investment policy analysis
• Employee tax planning • Subrecipient activity review

4550 Montgomery Avenue, Suite 650 North


Bethesda, MD 20814
Phone: 301-951-9090 Fax: 301-951-3570
www.grfcpa.com

Member of CPAmerica and Horwath International - a worldwide network of independent CPA firms dedicated to the integrity of the profession.

COUNTRY DIRECTORS Tanzania.Zambia.Haiti


Qualifications for all positions: PROJECT CONCERN INTERNATIONAL is seeking to fill three Country Director
Master’s degree required - MBA positions. Two of the positions are located in Africa and the third is for our
or MPH preferred; Excellent continued efforts in Port au Prince, Haiti.
understanding and familiarity with
US Government donor regulations; • In Tanzania, the Country Director will lead the organization’s 3-year USDA funded
managing sub-grantees, fostering Global Food for Education program starting in July, 2010.
mentorship and organizational • In Zambia, the Country Director will lead the HR management and leadership of
strengthening; Demonstrated the PCI field staff; new program and resource development; program planning
abilities in NGO reporting, and quality implementation; budgeting, budget execution and financial reporting;
budgeting, procurement, and project program monitoring, evaluation and documentation; liaison with relevant ministries,
management; At least 7 years of donors, partners, and other national and international agencies and stakeholders.
experience in project management in • In Port au Prince, Haiti the Country Director will ensure optimal quality of PCI/
a complex international development Haiti’s programs; initially the OFDA-funded emergency response and the USAID
environment, start up experience proposed single-year assistance program (SYAP), increase impact of these existing
required. PCI offers a competitive programs, provide technical oversight for PCI/H programs and ensure quality and
salary and benefits package. timely program implementation and reporting. This position absolutely requires the
ability to read, write and speak French fluently with Creole being a plus. S/he must
also have experience working in Haiti doing program development in order to be
considered.

For a more detailed description of each of these positions, please go to our website at
www.projectconcern.org under the Get Involved link. Interested parties should forward
a cover letter and resume to careers@projectconcern.org. Please be sure to list the
position you are applying for in the subject line. EOE

Você também pode gostar