Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
EN BANC
TIJAM V. SIBONGHANOY
April 15, 1968, G.R. No. L-21450
DIZON, J.:
Topic: Jurisdiction by Estoppel (A party is barred by laches from
raising the question of jurisdiction 15 years after the judgment was
rendered.)
FACTS: Spouses Serafin Tijam and Felicitas Tagalog filed in CFI of
Cebu for recovery of P1,908 + legal interest against spouses
Magdaleno Sibongahanoy and Lucia Baguio.
Defendants filed a counter bond with Manila Surety and Fidelity Co
(Surety).
Judgement was in favor of the plaintiffs, a writ of execution was
issued against the defendant. Then the defendants moved for writ of
execution against surety which was granted.
Surety moved to quash the writ but was denied, and subsequently
appealed to CA without raising the issue on lack of jurisdiction.
CA affirmed the appealed decision.
A month prior to the filing of the complaint, the Judiciary Act of 1948
(R.A. 296) took effect depriving the Court of First Instance of original
jurisdiction over cases in which the demand, exclusive of interest, is
not more than P 2,000.00 (Secs. 44[c] and 86[b], R.A. 296.)
The case has already been pending now for almost 15 years, and
throughout the entire proceeding the appellant never raised the
question of jurisdiction until the receipt of the Court of Appeals'
adverse decision.
Considering that the Supreme Court has the exclusive appellate
jurisdiction over all cases in which jurisdiction of any inferior court is
in issue, the Court of Appeals forwarded the case to the Supreme
Court along with the records of the case.
ISSUE:
WON Surety bond is estopped from questioning the jurisdiction of
the CFI Cebu for the first time upon appeal. YES
RATIO: SC believes that that the Surety is now barred by laches
from invoking this plea after almost fifteen years before the Surety
De Vera, K
commenced on July 19, 1948 and compel the judgment
creditors to go up their Calvary once more. The inequity and
unfairness of this is not only patent but revolting.
Coming now to the merits of the appeal: after going over the
entire record, We have become persuaded that We can do
nothing better than to quote in toto, with approval, the