Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
KEY WORDS
errors
ABSTRACT
In this paper, we attempt to reconstruct the mortality
pattern of the population buried in SIllot des Porros (Majorca), an Iron Age
necropolis in the western Mediterranean, by means of paleodemographic
analysis. The skeletal sample consists of 285 individuals, 93 subadults (under
20 years old) and 192 adults. The aim of this study is twofold: first, to identify
and to evaluate the structural anomalies of the skeletal sample, and second,
to obtain a possible and realistic description of the biological dynamics of this
population, with special reference to its mortality pattern. The study uses
current demographic methodology and several demographic models (for
comparison). An abridged life table was built to estimate the mortality
parameters. To evaluate the likelihood of the estimated data, an indirect
analysis, which consisted of a comparison of our results with different
population models (Weiss [1973] American Antiquity 38; Coale and Demeny
[1996] Regional Model Life Tables and Stable Populations. Princeton: Princeton University Press; Ledermann [1969] Nouvelles tablestypes de mortalite. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France), was carried out. An important
bias was identified in the case of children, mostly affecting infants but also
children between the ages of 1 and 5. This was interpreted as a census error
due to taphonomic reasons and to an excluding differential funeral rite. A life
expectancy at birth of approximately 28 years was estimated from the
observed data. When this bias was removed, the estimated life expectancy at
birth dropped to 23 years. The use of the Brass logit system allowed us to
sketch a possible mortality profile for this population: low life expectancy,
high infant mortality and hard life conditions, which were the cause of the low
levels of survivorship in old ages. Am J Phys Anthropol 110:285301, 1999.
r 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
286
A. ALESAN ET AL.
287
chambers in individual pit graves (Hernandez et al., 1998). Unfortunately, the stratigraphy of the site does not allow us to assign
specific chronological subperiods to the burials during the 500 years of use of the necropolis. All the burials were primary, the bodies
were placed in fetal position and some
seemed to be laid down tied or in a shroud.
All the burials were individual, but in the
three big chambers they shared the same
sepulchral space. Cremations were primary
and individual, they never actually achieved
incineration and it looks as if the corpse was
cremated fully dressed and with all the
ornaments (Hernandez, 1998).
While both cremation and burial coexisted
for some time, burials were actually predominant. The reason why some individuals were
cremated and not buried is unknown, as
there is no clear evidence of a differential
funeral rite depending on social status. Statistical analysis (chi-square test) has also
shown that there are no significant differences between both types (cremation and
burials) due to age (P 0.50245) or sex (P
0.8377).
The anthropological material of SIllot des
Porros was recovered during various field
seasons. Initial excavations were undertaken in the 1960s by a crew managed by the
archaeologist M. Tarradell, under the auspices of the William L. Bryant SpanishAmerican Foundation. In recent years, 1996
and 1997, the excavation of the archaeological site was completed. The anthropological
study of the human skeletal remains has
been ongoing since the 1980s, and issues
related to morphological, pathological and
typological aspects, sexual dimorphism, paleodiet and child development have already
been discussed and analyzed (Malgosa, 1985;
Alesan, 1990; Perez, 1990; Carrasco and
Malgosa, 1990; Malgosa and Campillo, 1991;
Castellana and Malgosa, 1991; Subira` and
Malgosa, 1992; Rissech and Malgosa, 1997).
Part of the material used in the present
study comes from the last two field excavations and therefore its anthropological study
is still unpublished. A total of 285 skeletons
were identified, 93 subadults (under 20 years
old) and 192 adults.
A. ALESAN ET AL.
288
METHODS
To reconstruct the structure of the population buried in this necropolis two parameters are essential: the age and sex of skeletal remains. Both the cremated and buried
skeletal remains found were subjected to
age and sex diagnostics.
Age determination
Skeletons have been classified into seven
general age categories: four subadult [infant
(under 1), child I (14), child II (512),
juvenile (1319)] and three adult [adult (20
39), middle age (4059), old age (60w)].
Subadult skeletons. To classify the subadult skeletons, the recommendations suggested by Ferembach et al. (1980) and the
criteria described by Krogman and Iscan
(1986) were followed. In the case of subadult
skeletons up to 12 years, the dental development criterion was preferred (Cretot, 1978;
Ubelaker, 1989). The degree of development
and closure of occipital synchondrosis (Redfield, 1970; Testut and Latarjet, 1975) as
well as temporal tympanic plate development (Weaver, 1979) and maximum diaphyseal length of long bones (Stloukal and Hanakova, 1978; Alduc-Le Bagousse, 1988) were
used as secondary criteria. Over the age of
12, preference was given to the skeletal
criterion based on the degree of ossification
and epiphyseal union of long bones (Brothwell, 1981; Ferembach et al., 1980; Krogman
and Iscan, 1986).
Adult skeletons. To classify the adult skeletons, the recommendations suggested by
Ferembach et al. (1980) were followed, and
the multifactorial approach was preferred.
Then, the degree of cranial sutures synostosis (Masset, 1982), dental wear (Brothwell,
1981), morphological changes of the pubic
symphysis (Meindl et al., 1985; Krogman
and Iscan, 1986), and metamorphosis of
auricular surface of the ilium (Lovejoy et al.,
1985) were employed.
Sex diagnosis
Given the difficulties inherent in the identification of sex in immature skeletons, and
that no consensus exists on the methodology
that should be adopted, sex diagnosis was
not attempted in the case of subadult skeletons (infants and children). With juvenile
and adult skeletons, the classic criteria put
forward by Martin and Saller (1957) and
Olivier (1960) were adopted. That is, sexual
diagnostic characteristics of the os coxae,
cranium, and jaw were used as the main
criteria (Ferembach et al., 1980; Taylor and
Dibennardo, 1984; Rissech and Malgosa,
1997). In addition, long bone metrics i.e.
femora or tibiae (Black, 1978; Iscan and
Miller-Shaivitz, 1984) were used. Only 13%
of juvenile skeletons could be sexed due to
poor preservation of the diagnostic bones.
Demographic methodology
To undertake a demographic study of the
population, the following assumptions were
made. First, that the cemetery was used by
only one population, community or group
and that they did not use other cemeteries at
the same time; second, that all the individuals of that community were buried in the
necropolis; third, that the archaeological
excavation was complete and anthropological recovery was meticulous and not differential; and finally, that entrances (by births)
balanced exits (by deaths) and that there
were no differences between both in terms of
age and sex structure. Without these assumptions, paleodemographic reconstructions are not possible. We therefore assume
that the systematic bias is as small as
possible or is conditioned neither by the age
nor the sex of individuals. That is, our
skeletal population is representative of the
living population who died in this community. These assumptions are a prerequisite
to test the hypothesis that we are working
with a good death register and also to test
the validity of our results.
To evaluate our mortality data for SIllot
des Porros, two methods of analysis were
followed. The first one was a direct analysis
of the observed data. The second, an indirect
analysis through comparison with various
population models which represent different
mortality patterns.
An abridged life table, combined for both
sexes, was created. This table allowed us to
obtain a statistical description of mortality
and was used for comparison with other
population models which allowed us to evalu-
289
A. ALESAN ET AL.
290
Sex
males
females
indeterminable
males
females
indeterminable
males
females
indeterminable
2
23
22
20
26
50
61
15
30
19
3
10
3
1
93
192
90
83
285
Total subadults
Total adults
Total males
Total females
Total
291
TABLE 2. SIllot des Porros abridged life table combined for both sexes
x
n Dx
ndx
1
nd x
ln
nqx
nLx
ex
nCx
0
1
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
65
70
75
Total
2
23
22
20
26
126
0.702
8.070
7.719
7.018
9.123
44.211
52
18.246
14
4.912
0.702
8.070
7.719
7.018
9.123
11.028
11.851
11.464
9.868
7.359
5.118
3.441
2.328
1.708
1.297
1.022
0.885
1000.000
992.983
912.281
835.088
764.912
673.684
563.402
444.897
330.259
231.579
157.992
106.814
72.405
49.123
32.040
19.074
8.851
0.007
0.081
0.085
0.084
0.119
0.164
0.210
0.258
0.299
0.318
0.324
0.322
0.322
0.348
0.405
0.536
1.000
996.491
3810.526
4368.421
4000.000
3596.491
3092.716
2520.749
1937.890
1404.595
973.928
662.017
448.047
303.818
202.908
127.785
69.811
22.127
28.538
27.736
26.013
23.187
20.085
17.466
15.395
13.830
12.763
12.136
11.624
10.996
10.033
8.604
6.858
4.820
2.500
3.492
13.352
15.307
14.016
12.602
10.837
8.833
6.790
4.922
3.413
2.320
1.570
1.065
0.711
0.448
0.245
0.078
285
should have been between 30 and 50% (Angel, 1969; Bennike, 1985; Brothwell, 1986
87; Trinkaus, 1995). Therefore, the life table
reveals the absolute lack of representativeness of endogenous infant mortality. This
pattern contrasts sharply with the data
from age 5 or over, which reflects the expected mortality. In the adult subsample we
note that the increase of deaths is accelerated between the ages of 20 and 35. This
coincides with the inflection point of probability of dying between the ages of 20 and 25.
Over 54, survivorship is insignificant, so
there were very few individuals over 59 and
almost no one who lived to 70 or 75. Having
analyzed this distribution by age and sex,
we think it is possible to assume that over
the age of 5, the distribution by age could
well represent the real survivorship curve of
this population.
Life expectancy at birth was calculated at
approximately 28 years and the crude death
rate was 35.3. These values show very
high mortality and low life expectancy, which
conforms to the expected values for ancient
populations such as this one (Acsadi and
Nemeskeri, 1970; Weiss, 1973). This life
expectancy at birth from observed and interpolated data was compared with two new
estimated values. The first one is a maximum value of life expectancy which represents the optimal survivorship. That is, we
assumed that individuals would live up to
the maximal limit of the age interval. The
second one is a minimum value of life expectancy which represents the highest probability of dying. In this case we assumed that
individuals would die at the beginning of
each age interval. Both values represent the
limits of life expectancy between which the
interpolated data can fluctuate. These new
estimated values were 33.7 years in the first
scenario and 24.6 years in the second one.
Since our computed life expectancy value
ranged between these two values, our interpolation was validated. When we estimated
the life expectancy at birth from the juvenility index (Bocquet-Appel and Masset, 1996),
we obtained a value of 23 years. As we
observed in the case of infant underrepresentation, this new estimation is closer to the
lowest limit of life expectancy that we calculated above.
To examine possible discrepancies, the
population structure of the skeletal sample
was compared with some populational models. The selection of these models was based
on the estimated values of life expectancy at
birth (e0) in SIllot des Porros:
1) Ledermanns model life tables (1969): in
the present study net 100 and three different values for the entrance parameter (e0)
were used: a) e0 23: this is the estimated
value from the juvenility index in our population; b) e0 28: this is the average value
that Acsadi and Nemeskeri (1970) give for
populations of the same chronology as that
of SIllot des Porros. Incidentally, this is the
A. ALESAN ET AL.
292
was chosen according to the parameter values computed in the population under study.
An intermediate model (Coale W3) yielded a
deficit of 32% between birth and the age of 1
and 6.3% between the ages of 1 and 5, which
implies a loss of 110 individuals under 5. We
do not actually know what the real infant
mortality model of ancient populations is,
but according to observed patterns in preindustrial populations we should expect high
infant mortality. In fact, we should expect a
higher probability of dying during the first
year of the life for endogenous reasons. And
we should also expect a higher probability of
dying during the early years for exogenous
reasons related to the development of immunological system and the response capacity
to environmental aggressions (mainly infections, parasites and gastrointestinal disorders). The practical lack of medical and
hygienic practices in these populations could
also be responsible for the infant mortality.
Breastfeeding, the length of breastfeeding
period, and the mothers nutritional status
also determine mortality during the early
years since suckling provides an important
immunological protection for the child and
prevents deaths due to malnutrition and
infectious diseases. However, once weaning
takes place, the child is less protected against
external danger and the risk of disease and
death increases.
Regardless of whether we consider that
greater mortality exists between birth and 1
year (the pattern found in most of the models discussed), or between the ages of 1 and 5
(as in the Coale and Demenys South model)
one thing is clear: that children between
birth and 5 years are underrepresented in
our population, and that this underrepresentation is greater in the 0 to 1 year age group.
How can this be explained? We suggest two
possible and nonexcluding main causes:
a) Taphonomic reasons (Guy et al., 1997).
Since the necropolis of SIllot des Porros is
situated in a place easily exposed to erosion
and with many shallow burials, it seems
reasonable to suggest that taphonomic processes could explain a large part of infants
disappearances.
b) The existence of an excluding differential funeral rite. It is not likely that infants
in the talaiothic culture received different
293
294
A. ALESAN ET AL.
295
models examined. Interestingly, these values are also closer to the ones observed in
the synchronic populations cited above which
also have infant underrepresentation.
Excess of subadults between ages 5
and 20
The second bias was an excess of 2% to 7%
of subadults between ages of 5 and 20 in
each 5-year group. Since dx is a relative
percentage, this excess could be an artifact
A. ALESAN ET AL.
31.01
20.16
31.01
28.19
22.4
21.47
23.02
31.06
15.25
32.51
24.701
28.386
2
0.14
0.26
0.14
0.163
0.221
0.24
0.219
9th cent. BC
7th6th cent. BC
9th7th cent. BC
6th3th cent. BC
7th10th cent.
5th6th cent.
4th cent. BC2nd cent. AD
Castiglione (Lazio, Italy)
Pontecagnano (Campania, Italy)
Osteria dellOsa (Lazio, Italy)
classic period (Athens Corinth)
Ruelles de Serris (France)
Sezegnin (Avusy, Switzerland)
SIllot des Porros
Reference
5q0
0.03
0.15
0.04
0.37
0.044
0.2387
0.3043
0.2387
0.2557
0.291
0.296
0.2871
0.0455
0.1369
0.0099
0.2683
0.007
2
1q0
1
1q0
e02
e01
JI D514/D20-w
Chronology
Series
TABLE 3. Comparison of some demographic parameters between SIllot des Porros and other skeletal series
296
297
Which model could adjust the adult mortality of SIllot des Porros, then? To have a
description of its mortality, an adjusted mortality profile was obtained following the
Brass logit system and taking the different
compared models as the norm. The two
Weiss models fit best, with a progressive
increase of mortality from the 2024 age
group, which runs parallel to decrease of
survivorship in these groups. When we compared the probability of dying at these ages
(qx) (Fig. 4), we observed a perfect fit between the ages of 20 and 55 (particularly
model MT:3550) with a gradual and smooth
increase from 25 years to the 3539 age
group. In the model, the probability of dying
increases more quickly from 55. This suggests a deficit of individuals of these ages or
a lower mortality with respect to the model,
as was mentioned above. The probability of
dying in the 35 to 55 age range is close to
100 and slightly higher than those in
models like Ledermanns (entrance e0 30).
The maximum probability of dying is reached
earlier in SIllot des Porros than in the
Ledermanns model due to the fact that the
final life limit chosen here was 80, while in
the model this limit extends some more
years.
This adjustment also allows us to estimate juvenile mortality. The two Weiss mod-
298
A. ALESAN ET AL.
299
A. ALESAN ET AL.
300
301