Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Datuk Kwek Leng San, aged 58, a Singaporean, graduated from University of London
with a Bachelor of Science (Engineering) degree. He also holds a Master of Science (Finance)
degree from City University London. He has extensive business experience in various business
sectors, including financial services and manufacturing.
Datuk Kwek was appointed to the Board of Directors (Board) of Narra Industries
Berhad (Narra) on 1 July 2001 and assumed the position of Managing Director on 1 March
2003. He was appointed as the Chairman of Narra on 21 February 2012. He is a member of the
Nominating Committee of Narra.
He is the Chairman of Malaysian Pacific Industries Berhad (MPI), Hong Leong
Industries Berhad and Southern Steel Berhad (SSB), and a Director of Hong Leong Bank
Berhad, companies listed on the Main Market of Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad (Bursa
Securities). He is also a Director of Hong Leong Company (Malaysia) Berhad and Hong Leong
Foundation.
Datuk Syed Zaid bin Syed Jaffar Albar, aged 59, a Malaysian, graduated with a Bachelor
of Arts (Honours) degree in Law in the United Kingdom and qualified as a Barrister-at-Law from
Lincolns Inn. He has been in active legal practice for more than 30 years. Presently, he is the
managing partner of a law firm in Kuala Lumpur.
Datuk Syed Zaid was appointed to the Board of Narra on 18 September 1995. He is
presently the Chairman of the Board Audit & Risk Management Committee and Nominating
Committee of Narra.
He is a Director of MPI and Malaysia Building Society Berhad, companies listed on the
Main Market of Bursa Securities. He is also a Director of Motorsports Association of Malaysia.
3.
Dato Rosman bin Abdullah, aged 46, a Malaysian, is a chartered member of the
Malaysian Institute of Accountants and a member of the Australian Society of Certified
Practicing Accountants. He holds a Bachelor of Commerce (Accounting) degree from the
Australian National University and had attended the Advanced Management Programme at the
University of Oxford.
Dato Rosman started his career with Arthur Andersen & Co from 1989 to 1997. He was
an Executive Director of Malaysia Airport Holdings Berhad from 1997 to 2003 and a NonIndependent Non-Executive Director of KUB Malaysia Berhad from 2006 to 2011. In 2006, he
was appointed as Group Chief Executive Officer of PECD Berhad and held the position until
2009. He then served as Chief Executive Officer of Syarikat Air Negeri Sembilan Sdn Bhd from
2009 to 2012.
Currently, he is the Executive Chairman of Putrajaya Perdana Berhad. He also serves as a
Non-Independent Non-Executive Director of Cuscapi Berhad and as an Independent NonExecutive Director of Kumpulan Fima Berhad and CLIQ Energy Berhad, companies listed on
the Main Market of Bursa Securities.
Dato Rosman was appointed to the Board of Narra on 3 February 2006. He is a member
of the Board Audit & Risk Management Committee of Narra.
Mr Seow Yoo Lin, aged 57, a Malaysian, qualified as a Certified Public Accountant in
1981. He holds a Master in Business Administration from The International Management Centre,
Buckingham, United Kingdom.
Mr Seow joined KPMG Malaysia in 1977. In 1983, he was seconded to the United States
to gain overseas experience. He returned in 1985 and was admitted as Partner in 1990. He was
the Managing Partner of KPMG Malaysia from 2007 to 2010 and retired from the firm in 2011.
During his tenure with KPMG, he has been the Audit Partner on a wide range of companies
including public listed companies and multinationals in banking and finance, manufacturing,
trading and services industries.
Mr Seow was a member of the Executive Committee of the Malaysian Institute of
Certified Public Accountants from 2009 to 2011 and was a Council member of the Malaysian
Institute of Accountants from year 2007 to 2011.
Mr Seow is a Director of SSB. Mr Seow was appointed to the Board of Narra on 21
February 2012. He is a member of the Nominating Committee of Narra.
Authorised share capitals for Narra Industries Berhad were 350,000,000 ordinary shares where
each of shares was RM 1.00.
Narra Industries Berhad issued and paid up capital was 62,188,000 ordinary shares where each of
shares was RM 1.00.
10
2. MISSION
The Group sees Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) beyond its core mission. The
Group contributes to the socio-economic development of the nation by promoting education,
providing aid to marginalised communities, supporting and developing local talent,
preserving the environment and practicing sustainable supply-chain in its operations.
11
2. ECONOMIC FORCES
12
The state of competitive environment in which a firm operates is determine by the factors
such as the level of employment, rate of inflation, rate of interest, demographic changes, and
fiscal and monetary policies. These forces will affect the outcome of the firms marketing
activities, by determining the volume and strength of demand for its products.
The Malaysian economy expanded by 4.3% in the second quarter of 2013. While
domestic demand remained firm, growing by 7.3%, exports registered a larger decline, amid
weakness across most export products. On the supply side, the major economic sectors expanded
further in the second quarter, supported by the continued strength in domestic demand. On a
quarter-on-quarter seasonally adjusted basis, the economy recorded a growth of 1.4%.
For the Malaysian economy, the prolonged weakness in the external environment has
affected the overall growth performance of the economy going forward. While domestic demand
is expected to remain firm, supported by sustained private consumption, capital spending in the
domestic-oriented industries and the on-going implementation of infrastructure projects, the
weak external sector in the first half of this year will affect our overall growth performance for
the year. The overall growth of the economy for this year has now been revised to 4.5 - 5.0%.
Going forward, domestic demand is expected to remain on its steady growth trajectory and will
continue to be supported by an accommodative monetary policy.
The Proposed Acquisitions will allow the Narra Group to diversify its business into the
concrete and cement-related industry, and provide it with an immediate stream of revenue and
earnings. Malaysias economy is expected to continue its growth trend on the back of the
expected roll out of more infrastructure investments by the private and public sectors. The
prospects of the concrete and cement-related business are expected to be optimistic going
forward and, subject to the completion of the Proposed Acquisitions, the business would
contribute positively to the Narra Group.
3. SOCIAL FORCES
The social environment of a business can be integral to its success or failure. Employees
are often influenced by the context in which they work and this can have implications for
13
productivity. Employers who take the necessary strides to create a positive and harmonious
social environment in the workplace can set themselves up for future success. The social factors
like customs, traditions, values, beliefs, poverty, literacy and life expectancy rate are include in
the social environment of business. The social structure and the values that a society cherishes
have a considerable influence on the functioning of business firms.
Malaysian lifestyle shift towards wellness and self-administered healthcare has open
up opportunities for Hai-O to modify its strategies and product offerings to suit the market
demands.
Besides, the Group also develops talent regardless of race, gender or religious belief. Employee
advancement is based on merit and we believe that it is this variety of persuasions and cultures
that fuel creativity, entrepreneurship and openness. The Group also actively promotes work-life
balance through various sports, family and social initiatives. In this regard, various initiatives
such as sports activities, social events and family day outings were carried out with the full
support and commitment of the employees throughout the financial year.
4. TECHNOLOGICAL FORCES
Technological factors affecting businesses all over the world demands a changing
behaviour with regard to traditional marketing. The rapid development of technology requires
quick reaction by businesses in order to survive in an emerging competitive environment and
keep up with new trends and innovative services which other competitors might be offering.
These technological factors can include both products and processes and can present
opportunities and threats but it is vital for competitive advantage and is a successful driver in
globalisation. Products can be marketed in new ways and processes present immense Value to the
business.
Emphasizing more on technological aspects, Hai-O strives to improve the quality and its
product line and taking traditional medicine up to the level of the mainstream medicine
14
today. The analysis also indicated that the industrys external factors will continue to open
up huge opportunities for Hai-Os business in the near future.
. These shared services are provided in-house in order to align with the Hong Leong Groups
corporate objective and management disciplines and to reduce operating cost and improve
efficiency such as through economies of scale, better utilisation and allocation of resources,
standardisation of processes and operating procedures and information technology. Accordingly,
the Board considers it beneficial to enter into transactions in respect of the Group Management
and Support Services. The Group Management and Support Services are carried out on
commercial terms, on terms not more favourable to the related parties than those generally
available to and from the public, where applicable, and which will not be detrimental to the
minority shareholders of Narra.
5. ECOLOGY FORCES
The environmental forces are elements of constant changes due to government actions
and industrial events. Environmental force can also be ecological and environmental aspects
such as weather, climate, and climate change, which may affect industries in some way.
Narra Industries Berhad has a side on environmental preservation. They practise
environmental preservation and maintain high standards of Occupational Safety and Health
management practices. Environmental management programmes such as recycling campaigns,
air pollution controls and waste management programmes are continuously deployed to achieve
the Groups objectives. In addition, they also conduct regular occupational safety and awareness
programmes for their employees.
15
16
17
Home Stores, IKEA Home Furnishings, Gaoya Furniture Industries Sendirian Berhad, and
others.
3. THREAT OF SUBSTITUTE PRODUCTS
Threat of substitute in furniture industry is relatively weak because there are no
substitutes for furniture product that exist in the market. Until now, people use furniture from
wood, metal, plastic, and other materials in everyday activities. Furniture being used to sit, sleep,
work, and do other activities everywhere and nothing can substitute this furniture. The function
of furniture in everyday activities cannot be substitute by other thing until now. The only
substitute that exists is material substitute. For example, a wood chair can be substituted with
plastic chair. But, in this analysis we include all of material to be furniture. And furniture as a
whole group of material has no substitute at all, at least until now. So the threat of substitute in
this industry is weak and there are no threats from the substitute part.
18
19
INTERNAL: WEAKNESSES
S1
W1
S2
W2
S3
Innovative products
W3
S4
EXTERNAL: THREATS
O1
T1
Close substitutes
O2
T2
furniture technology
T3
Numbers of competitors
O3
20
1. STRENGTHS
i.
academic knowledge and technical skills in relevance industry. The chairman of Narra
Industries Berhad, Datuk Kwek Leng San is a holder of Bachelor of Science (Engineering)
from University of London and also holds Master of Science (Finance) degree from City
University London. Knowledge of engineering is useful on manufacturing company. Besides,
Datuk Syed Zaid bin Syed Jaffar Albar, one of the directors of the company was graduated
with Bachelor of Art (Honour) degree in law in United Kingdom. He had more than 30 years
working experience and has a strong knowledge on law. He could provide consultation for
any matter that deal with legal issue or the published acts. Furthermore, there are also
directors who are expertise in accounting. They have deep knowledge on accounting and
auditing. One of the directors was the Managing Partner of KPMG. This could be assist in
dealing with auditors while auditing on company report. They are more understand on the
audit work and could check whether the auditors was carryout the auditing work properly. Mr
Seow Yoo Lin, holds a Master in Business Administration from The International
Management Centre, Buckingham, United Kingdom. He has more than 20 years of extensive
experience in the manufacturing of wood-based panels. While, Mr Terence Lee Chai Koon, a
non-executive director, holds a Diploma in Marketing from the Chartered Institute of
Marketing, United Kingdom and another from Australia Council of Marketing. It clearly
shows that all of the board of directors with a high qualification in different field. A strong
board of directors formed due to the combination of expert and experience directors.
ii.
was performed in order to make sure the quality of the products could be achieved and be
sustained. Hume Furniture Industries Sdn Bhd obtained the Forest Stewardship Council
("FSC") certification, which is a first for a Malaysian indoor furniture manufacturer. This
certification has positioned HFI as a preferred supplier for "Green Products". The company
21
has well established internal testing equipment and it is capable to conduct own testing on the
wooden furniture products such as in-house packaging drop test and product quality test.
These testing are to ensure the compliance of high quality standard of wooden furniture to
meet the stringent international standard and requirement.
iii.
INNOVATIVE PRODUCTS
Due to the advancement of technology and the combination with intellectual capital
of the company, the products that produced by Narra Industries Berhad was innovative and
with a multi-purpose function for a product. For example, the foldable table can also be use
as a chair or a coffee table can also be use as a books rack. A creative and good design is one
of the attractions of the products. The design of the products mostly would be simple and
easy structure. But it mainly focuses in on the functional of the products. The main concept is
that the company was tried to come out with some ideas on products which able to save place
and match together different kind of function all in one. The wholly owned subsidiary of
Narra Industries Berhad (Hume Furniture Industries Sdn Bhd) are Original Equipment
Manufacturer ("OEM") and as an Original Design Manufacturer ("ODM"). HFI performed
interior design and fit-out ("IFO") works to the hospitality sector such as hotels and service
apartments, and commercial sectors such as banks and offices. It manufactures and supplies
customized case goods furniture to hotels and serviced apartments.
iv.
Malaysia. Hence, the information of the company could be easily be assessed by the public.
In order to become a listed company, Narra Industries Berhad had fulfilled all the
requirements stated by the Bursa Malaysia. In other words, Narra Industries Berhad was able
to operate accordance to what being required. Being the public listed company, the capital
could be more easily to be obtaining as compare to the private company.
22
2. WEAKNESSES
i.
It shows that Narra Industries Berhad has losses before tax on year of assessment
2007, year 2008, year 2009 and year 2011, which are 4 million, 5 million, 1 million and 4
million respectively. The profit of the company was fluctuated over the year and it proved
that the financial position of the company was not stable which lead losses in before tax
amount in some particular years. In year 2013, according to the annual report, from the
chairmans statement, it stated that the Group recorded a slightly lower profit before
taxation (PBT) of RM0.07 million for FY 2013 as compared with a PBT of RM1.1
million in FY 2012, due mainly to unfavorable sales mix and increase in project expenses
during FY 2013.
23
ii.
iii.
others media. The market of the company on local was not popular and it is mainly export to
overseas. Hence, the brand of the company was unknown to the Malaysian. Hume Furniture
Industries Sdn Bhd do not have any warehouse to sales on their products, they are more
focusing on manufacturing and not direct sales to the end consumers. Through the annual
report, the company does not record any expenses made on the advertisement or marketing
purposes.
3. OPPORTUNITIES
i.
terms of reputation and also gaining the confidence of the customers. It is like a warranty on
the product purchased. The customers could consult the company on any problems regarding
the products. Repairing service is also encouraged to be put into practice by the company.
The company should not only focus on generating the revenue, but it also crucial for the
company to concern on the feedback made by the customers. The company should have a
customer service department to deal with matter regarding on after sales service.
24
ii.
CONSUMERS
PREFERENCES
TOWARD
NEW
FURNITURE
TECHNOLOGY
There are high demands on the new innovative items by the customers nowadays.
Technology was changing from time to time; company should in line with the technology
advancement in order to gain the competitive advancement. It is importance for the company
to apply the new technology and the innovative concept on the products produce by the
company. The technology that used by the company must be up to date. Besides, the
company should provide a variety products which the innovation and design could not be
duplicate by the others. A unique product that promoted by company would be the main
factors that help company to become dominant amongst the others.
iii.
package. The designer could design on the products and also gives an idea on how to furnish
and decorate the furniture on customers premises. A custom made of the products according
to the requirement made by customers. The service would be provided as to ensure that the
furniture purchased was suitable for the customers premises. There are demanding on high
living standard nowadays, by providing such service will increase the sales of the furniture.
4. THREAT
i.
CLOSE SUBSTITUTES
Furniture could be easily substitutes by competitors companies products. Basically,
customers would concern on the design and the quality of the products. The branding would
not be the main focus by the customers. Customers might switch their preference from one
brand to another if the furniture was met their requirements. There are also a portion of
customers who are just concern on the usefulness of the furniture.
25
ii.
manufactures industries. Hence, the new entrance could easily get their license to operate the
manufacturing business. Moreover, the capital requirement of the industry was considered
low as compare to others.
iii.
NUMBER OF COMPETITORS
There was increase in number of competitors nowadays. The bargaining power of
supplier could be affected inversely with the increase in number of competitors. In other
words, the bargaining power of suppliers would decrease if there was increase in numbers of
competitors in the market. Due to the surplus on supplies, the customers have variety choices
and the company might be faced the risk of being eliminated from the market. Unless the
company was keep on improvement on their operation and products in order to gain
competitive advantages to compete in the saturated industry field. The competitors of Narra
Industries Berhad are Rozel, Lorenzo, Ikea and etc.
26
Strong Board of
W1
Directors
S2
High
quality
products
S3
S4
EXTERNAL
FACTORS
OPPORTUNITIES
O1
O2
W3
Low
products
(Advertisement)
Public
listed
company
S2S3O2 Research and
W3O1O2O3 Advertising
development
S3O3
and
Consultation
service
S2O1
product
publicity
Consumers
preferences
W2
Innovative
After sales
services
Losses in after
marketing
W1O3
After sales
toward new
service
New
business
W201
furniture
Attract
customers
technology
O3
Interior
Close
substitutes
T2
S4T3
Limited
barrier to
T3
S2T1
entry
Numbers of
Special
W2T3
Focus on
product
large scale
Competitive
production
advantages
S3T3
Continuous
improvement
competitors
1. SO STRATEGIC
i.
ii.
CONSULTATION SERVICE
Consultation service provided to the customers before or during the customers
purchase on the products. The company would response on customer requests and
transformed it into the products. It could be from the suggestion or demand by the customers
before purchase on the products. By gathering the ideas from the customers, through the
creative and innovative of the employees, the product that produced could be more tallies
with customers preferences. Moreover, consultation services provide a platform for the
company to assist customers on interior design task. Narra Industries Berhad is stressed on
innovative and quality product, through providing interior design to the customers rather than
just manufactured on the product, company was allowed customers to giving their ideas on
the design and decoration, company would give some professional advice to them on the
products. This could increase the reputation of the company. Furthermore, this could be one
of the strategic that able to increase the demand of the customers on the products that being
produced.
iii.
business operation. In contrast, Narra Industries Berhad should collect and response to the
28
feedback from the customers. After sales service is encourage to be executed by the
company, for example, by providing repairing service on the products purchased or giving
consultation for any problems faced by customers. Company continuous improvement could
be achieved if the company provided after sales service. Besides, due to the improvement,
the production line of the company products able to sustain a good quality. After sales service
was like giving a warranty to customers on the products purchased. As a result, the branding
of company able to improve and it also provide a medium for company as advertisement
purposes.
2. ST STRATEGIC
i.
SPECIAL PRODUCTS
Narra Industries Berhad situated in the industry that was highly competitive field.
ii.
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE
A company competitive advantage is a main factor to decide on the success or failure
of the company. Capital playing an important role to achieve the competitive advantages of
the company. Company should enlarge it competitive advantages since there are increasing in
number of competitors recently. Narra Industries Berhad is a public listed company, so the
company able to obtain capital from the public. Besides, the branding of the company must
be outstanding amongst the competitors; loyalty to the companys brand is required to be
built on the consumers so that they will not exchange to others brand.
29
iii.
CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT
Company should be able to continuous improve on business operation. Innovation
does not have an end, a continuous improvement is important in order to gain competitive
advantage within the field. Continuous improvement could be achieve through involvement
of employees in training courses or keep the technology of the company up-to-date. Besides,
quality control should be executed on the quality of the products by consider the
recommendation or ideas given by the customers so that the products able to improved and
ensure the level of the quality could be achieved above the benchmark that being set.
3. WO STRATEGIC
i.
of the company name in the market. Advertising could be done through advertise on mass
media like broadcasting through television, radio, magazine or newspapers. Besides, services
provided other than production of the furniture could be a medium for company to advertise
on their brand name. Reputation and visibility of company could be increase through the
activities provided by the company.
ii.
NEW BUSINESS
Company should focus on other business segment other than the main business
operation, manufacturing. From last few years, the company was shown a negative amount
on the net profit on the annual report of the company. Hence, Narra Industries Berhad should
find an alternative solution in order to solve on this issue. New business can be carry out by
the company in order to get the other sources of income rather than manufacturing. By
providing the interior design for the customers, an extra consultation fees could be generate
through the intellectual and creativity by giving some of the professional advice, where there
30
are no cost was charged on the profit generating. This might decrease the losses that incurred
by the company.
iii.
ATTRACT CUSTOMERS
Higher price on the furniture was set by the company in order to cover on the
production costs incurred during the production activities were carry out. Some of the
customers might resist purchasing on the products due to the high cost charged by the
company. Hence, company should providing the after sales service to offset on the high price
charged. Customers might be willing to pay more if the safeguard on the interest of the
customers. This is also one of the strategic to avoid the customers refuse to buy on
companys product due to the price factor.
4. WT STRATEGIC
i.
the customers that giving chance for the company to supply on the furniture in large quantity.
This is because if the furniture was produce in batch, the economic scale could be achieved
due to the large quantity production where the efficiency also can be achieved. As a result,
the profit margin of the business operation could be increase. Since the production cost in
batch is lower compare to the production in single unit, so the prices of the products could be
decrease. The increase in the number of competitors, company should be able to be more
efficient in term of production as compare to the competitors. Company should have a
strategic that enables the company to become the product differentiation leader and also the
cost leader among the others.
31
2012
(27,258,000)
(417,000)
62,188,000
62,188,000
= (0.4383)
= (0.0067)
Earning per share (EPS) indicate the portion of a company's profit allocated to each
outstanding share of common stock. It also serves as an indicator of a company's profitability.
Hence, the higher the earning per share (EPS) of the company indicates the good performance by
the company on it profit generation.
The company has only the basic earning per share and it does not have diluted earning
per share since the company only has ordinary shares. Both of the years were shown a negative
amount. This is due to the net income on both of the years were shown a net loss. In year 2012,
the amount is negative 0.67 cent per share. It shown decrease in value on year 2013 with a value
of negative 48.84 cent per share. Basically, we can conclude that the company was not performed
well on both of the years. But, to be more specific, we can summarized that the company was
less performed on year 2013 compare to year 2012.
32
2012
(27,259,000)
(413,000)
185,000
214,000
= (147.3459)
= (1.9299)
Return on sales providing insight into how much profit is being produced per ringgit of
sales. The higher value of return on sales ratio indicates the company was efficient on its sales
generating. This ratio provides an alternative to compare on the companys return on sales over
time period to analyze on the trends and it is also can compare with other companies in the same
industry.
Through this ratio, we get to know that the company was less efficiency on year 2013
compare to year 2012. The return on sales ratio was shown a negative amount in both of the
years. The company was generated losses on both of the years. The ratio show a negative amount
of 1.9299 in year 2012, with a higher revenue amount which is RM 214,000 as compare with
year 2013 (RM 185,000). A huge difference shows between the amounts of ROS ratio for both of
the years. In years 2013, the ROS ratio was 76 times of the ROS ratio for year 2012 (in negative
value). The large amount of losses was bear by the company on year 2013.
33
2012
(27,258,000)
(417,000)
30,246,000
57,582,000
= (0.9012)
= (0.0072)
Return on investment (ROI) is one of the ratio analysis which is to measure on the net
profit that a companys management able to earn through the use of the company total assets. It
is basically to measure on how efficient the company was used its total assets to generate the net
profit. Hence, the higher the value calculate on the return on investment ratio illustrate that the
company was efficient in applied of its total assets to generate the net income. The lower return
on investment proved the company does not fully used the total assets in its business operation.
According to the return on investment that have been calculated above, it have proved
that the company having a lower amount of return on investment ratio (more negative value) on
year 2013 which is in bracket 0.9012 as compared to year 2012, in bracket 0.0072. We can
conclude that year 2013; the investment was not utilized as efficient as year 2012. But, in overall,
the companys management does not manage to utilize efficiently on the assets in order to
generate the net income.
34
2012
(27,259,000)
(413,000)
(30,246,000 + 57,582,000) / 2
(57,582,000 + 57,751,000) / 2
= (0.6207)
= (0.0072)
Return on assets is an indicator that shows how profitability the company is in relative to
its total assets. It indicates how efficient the business operation in using the companys to
generate earning. It should be noted that the return on assets for public companies can vary
substantially and it is highly dependent on the industry. The ROA works ideal as a comparative
measure, when it is used to compare it against a company's previous ROA numbers or the ROA
of a similar company. The higher return on assets figure is more favorable due to more efficient
of a company in managing its assets to generate the earnings. Sometimes, return on assets is also
referred as the return on investment.
Through the return on assets ratio that calculated above, it is same as the previous ratio
which the ratio figure is in negative value for both of the years. In year 2012, the ratio is in
bracket 0.0072 and for year 2013, the figure is in bracket 0.6207. Refer to this figure, we can
concluded that the company managed the assets more efficiently in year 2012 compare to year
2013.
35
2012
(27,258,000)
(417,000)
(29,696,000 + 56,954,000) / 2
(56,954,000 + 57,371,000) / 2
= (0.6292)
= (0.0073)
Return on equity (ROE) defined as the amount of net income returned as a percentage of
shareholders equity. This ratio is measures a corporation's profitability by revealing how much
profit a company generates with the money shareholders have invested. It is useful for
comparing the profitability of a company to that of other firms in the same industry. The higher
the figure generate from the ratio, the more preferable the company is from the perspective of
shareholder. A high ROE ratio is also indicate that the company was performed well in generate
earning through the used shareholder equity.
The return on equity calculate on year 2013 was much lower as compare to the return on
equity ratio of year 2012. In year 2012, return on equity was in bracket 0.0073 and for year 2013
it is shows a value of bracket 0.6292. As a conclusion, the efficiency on profit generating of year
2013 is less than year 2012; where less profit is generate from the shareholders equity on year
2013.
36
37
During the third stage, after sales service through getting the feedback from the
customers is a must for the purpose of continuous improvement of a company. A team should be
established on work on the after sales service. Analysis on the feedback or comments received
would be carried out. Through the outcome from the analysis, alteration would be made on the
operation or the production method of the products. Company might incorporate with the others
corporation to deal with the repairing or supply on the accessories of the products to the
customers.
38
39
This news is retrieve from The Star webpage where it was reported regarding the Narra
Industries shares price was down 18sen to RM 1.14. This incident was happen right after the
company announced on the corporate transaction where the HLI is disposing its entire issued and
paid-up capital in Hume Industries (M) Sdn Bhd for RM48mil, as well as its non-cumulative
irredeemable convertible preference shares (ICPS) in Hume Cement Sdn Bhd (HCement) for
RM300mil to Narra.
40
This is news for Narra Industries Berhad on dated 17 th June 2014 where it reported on the
share price spike without an explainable reason.
HFI was the first Malaysian indoor furniture manufacturer, who received the Forest Stewardship
Council (FSC) certification. Due to this award, HFI was named as a preferred supplier for
Green Products.
41
42
Tan Sri Dato Seri Syed Zainol Anwar Jamalullail is a Malaysian Citizen who age in 62
years old. Initially, he was appointed as a Non-Independent and Non-Executive Director on 25
February 2002 which representing Lembaga Tabung Haji. Subsequently, when Lembaga Tabung
Haji ceased to be a substantial shareholder, he was re-designated as an Independent, NonExecutive Director on 05 November 2004, and was later appointed as Chairman of the Board of
Directors on 16 April 2009. He is also Chairman of the Audit Committee and Chairman of the
Nomination Committee. In addition, he is the Chancellor of SEGi University, and the Chairman
of Cahya Mata Sarawak Berhad, Lembaga Zakat Selangor and Pulau Indah Ventures Sdn. Bhd.
Tan Sri Dato Seri Syed Zainol Anwar Jamalullail studied Bachelor of Arts degree in
Accounting from Macquarie University in Sydney, Australia. He is a qualified Chartered
Accountant from the Malaysian Institute of Accountants and also a Certified Practising
Accountant from the Australian Society of Certified Practising Accountants having qualified in
1984.
43
Dato Mohd. Rafik Bin Shah Mohamad is 63 years old who is a citizen of Malaysia. He is
Independent and Non-Executive Director in board. He was appointed to the Board on 01 June
2007. He is a member of the Audit Committee and the Chairman of the Compensation
Committee. Besides that, he is the Chairman of Malaysian AgriFood Corp. Berhad, Cold Chain
Network Sdn. Bhd. (a subsidiary of Malaysian AgriFood Corp. Berhad) and the Chairman of
Biotropics Malaysia Berhad.
Dato Mohd. Rafik Bin Shah Mohamad is a qualified Chartered Accountant from the
Malaysian Institute of Accountants and is a member of the Association of Chartered Certified
Accountants, United Kingdom. He has also attended the Executive Development Programme at
the International Institute for Management Development, in Lausanne, Switzerland.
44
Tan Sri Datuk (Dr.) Rafiah Binti Salim is Independent and Non-Executive Director who
is a Malaysian Cititzen with age of 67 years. She was appointed to the Board on 17 April 2009.
She is a member of the Audit Committee and the Compensation Committee. Moreover, she is the
Director of Perbadanan Usahawan Nasional Berhad and the Chairman of the Board of Directors
for Malaysian Genomics Resource Centre Berhad. Tan Sri Datuk (Dr.) Rafiah is also the Director
of Allianz Malaysia Bhd., Allianz Life Insurance Malaysia Bhd. and Allianz General Insurance
Company (Malaysia) Bhd. Tan Sri Datuk (Dr.) Rafiah Binti Salim, graduated with Masters and
Bachelor Degrees in Law from the Queens University Belfast, United Kingdom and was
awarded an honorary Doctorate by the same University in 2002. She was called to the Malaysian
Bar in 1988.
45
Dato Frits van Dijk is Dutch National with age 66 years. He is Independent and NonExecutive Director in Board. Originally, he was appointed to the Board on 26 April 2006 as a
Non-Independent, Non-Executive Director. After a few years, he was re-designated as an
Independent, Non-Executive Director on 19 November 2013. He is a member of the Nomination
Committee and the Compensation Committee. He has a priority to his retirement from the Nestl
Group at the end of September 2011. He served the Nestl group of companies and held many
senior positions in other Nestl Markets over the last 40 years.
Dato Frits van Dijk graduated with a Bachelors Degree in Economics from the School
of Economics, Rotterdam, and the Netherlands and has also attended the Executive Development
Programme at the International Institute for Management Development, in Lausanne,
Switzerland.
46
Tan Sri Datuk Yong Poh Kon is Independent and Non-Executive Director who is a 68
years old of Malaysian Citizen. He was appointed to the Board on 25 April 2011. He is a member
of the Nomination Committee. Besides that, he is also the Managing Director of Royal Selangor
International Sdn. Bhd., a manufacturer and exporter of pewter products, a Director of TAHPS
Group Berhad and is a Fellow of the Academy of Sciences and the Malaysian Institute of
Management. He graduated from the University of Adelaide with First Class Honours in
Mechanical Engineering in 1968.
47
Toh Puan Dato Seri Hajjah Dr. Aishah Ong is an Independent and Non- Executive
Director who are a 68 years old of Malaysian Citizen. She was appointed to the Board on 28
November 2013. Currently, she is also the Director of the Board of the Malaysian Philharmonic
Orchestra (MPO) and a Trustee of the Dewan Filharmonik Petronas. In addition, she is also the
Pro-Chancellor of the University of Malaya and having been Chairman of University Hospital
for many years. She is currently Chairman of the Institute Jantung Negara (IJN) Foundation,
the New Straits Times (NST) Press Charity Fund and Chairman of the Welfare subcommittee
of Badan Kebajikan Isteri-isteri Menteri (BAKTI). In year 1969, she was graduated from the
University of London and a qualified medical doctor and active social worker.
48
7. ALOIS HOFBAUER
Alois Hofbauer is Managing Director who is an Austrian National with age of 48 years
old. He was appointed to the Board on 22 February 2013. He has served the Nestl group of
companies for more than 20 years. Besides that, he had served several of senior positions in other
Nestl markets. Moreover, he was also the Managing Director of Nestl Sri Lanka since 2010.
Additionally, he is also a member of the Federation of Manufacturers Malaysia (FMM)
Council. For his education, he is graduate of the International Institute for Management
Development, in Lausanne, Switzerland and the University of Innsbruck, Austria.
49
8. MARC SEILER
Marc Seiler is Executive Director (Responsible for Finance & Control) who is a 90 years
old of French National. He was appointed to the Board on 01 December 2008. He had served
various senior positions in other Nestl Markets since he joined the Nestl group of companies in
1990. In addition, he is also Treasurer of the Swiss Malaysian Business Association. For his
education history, he graduated from Ecole Suprieure de Commerce de Paris, France with a
Master of Science in Management and an Accounting & Finance Diploma (Diplome dEtudes
Suprieure Comptables et Financieres).
50
Authorised share capitals for Nestle Malaysia Berhad were 300,000,000 ordinary shares
where each of shares was RM 1.00.
Nestle Malaysia Berhad issued and paid up capital was 234,500,000 ordinary shares
where each of shares was RM 1.00.
Provide consumers with the best tasting, most nutritious choices in a wide range of food
and beverage categories and eating occasions, from morning to night.
52
1.
POLITICAL FORCES
Political factors can be representing the degree of intervention of government in the
economy which is also the role of government to shaping in all the businesses. These factors can
be included tax policies, political stability, pricing regulations, intellectual property rights, trade
regulations, tariffs, employee wages and benefits. Political factor is a very vital factor that can
influence the companies no matter is in term of bad or good impact on it. There are different
political systems for every country. In Malaysia, democratic system is used for the political
system in country. Therefore, Nestle Malaysia Berhad can manage and organize their business in
their own way or tactics yet still need the control by the government. This will be affected the
companies when the companies desires to be a globalization organization. Due to the control by
government, Nestle is fully supported by the government to encourage healthier diets and active
lifestyles for solve the problems of obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular diseases to create a
healthier population in country.
Besides that, government can be charged the tariffs for the import products from other
countries. This can influenced all the local companys businesses. When the government
decrease the tariffs charging for the import products, it means that the import products can be
import hugely to our country. Due to the tariffs charging towards the import items are low, the
price of import products might be cheaper than local products. Thus, citizen will rather choose to
buy import products than local products because of the tariffs and prices influencing.
53
In addition, the stability politics in a country can lead to the faster rate of economic
growth in country. In oppositely, the instability politics will be slower the economic growth in
country. For this case, the political stability of Malaysia can affected the Nestle Malaysia Berhad.
The networking between the companies in Malaysia or other countries can be wide when the
stability political Malaysia is good. Through the wide networking, Nestle Malaysia Berhad can
manage the company to increase their profit.
2.
ECONOMIC FORCES
Economic factor is also one of the factors that can be affecting to general environment in
the company. Economic factor are those which have a direct impact on the capital loss of
organizations and purchasing power of customers. The factors are included exchange rates, rate
of unemployment, interest rates, business cycle, and inflation rate, stability of currency and
efficiency of free market.
The rate of the unemployment is rising can be affected the consumers unwilling to buy
things that expensive. For the Nestle, they considered this factor carefully and create a strategy
that selling their product with the reasonable price and the consumers can afford to buy it.
Besides that, they need always be aware the current situation of the economy. Through this
action, they cannot increase the price of the products randomly during the deflation economy
situation. This may influenced the customers change their choice to other brands or companies
which selling the cheaper product compared to them.
3.
SOCIAL FORCES
Social factors are cultural and demographic variables such as age, education, leisure
activities, attitude toward career, changing lifestyle, gender, population and attitude towards
health and environment which can closely affected to the market potential and customers needs.
54
The population will increases from time to time for all the countries.
Moreover, the cultural differences for every country are very important because this also
can affect the company. Nestle Malaysia Berhad has released the brand Maggi with various types
of Asia sauce and flavour. However, this brand does not released in some of the countries such as
England because of the different taste and cultural. Therefore, Nestle Malaysia Berhad can attract
the Malaysia citizen to purchase and also increase the demand on this brand and others by
understand the culture of each country.
4. TECHNOLOGICAL FORCES
Technological factor is means by the advancement of the technology issues that can
influence the companies brings its product or service to the marketplace. These factors are
included ecological and environmental aspects such as Research & Development (R&D) activity,
technology incentives rate of technological change, telecommunication infrastructure, internet
available and patent protection.
It cans be advantage to manufacturer when the company using the advanced technology
to its company such as machines that need to use. This is because the advancing machines can
lead to the productivity increase, lowering the cost of goods and the raw material will becomes
cheaper. In addition, the cost of labour recruitment is decreasing due to the production is used by
the advancing machines. Thus, Nestle Malaysia Berhad has used the advance technology
machines to produce its products for fulfil the customer needs.
Besides that, internet and mobile technology is keep advancing nowadays and lead to
almost all the people will use it no matter is kids or adults. Through this technological era, Nestle
Malaysia Berhad gets this opportunity by using this technology to promote their products to
everyone. Nowadays the citizens always view their Smartphone for doing everything on it
whenever they have. So, this is easily to interact with the customers about its product and
customers can get the information from their websites. Moreover, Nestle staff can use this
internet service to connect and communicate to its industry to other countries such as Singapore,
Taiwan, England and more. Therefore, technological factors are very for Nestle Malaysia
Berhad.
56
57
2.
Nestle is large food industry, it still facing the strong competition with other existing company
such as Kraft Foods Group Inc, Hershey Foods (HSY), Cadbury Schweppes (CSG), Mars
Incorporated, Unilever, PepsiCo and more. These companies are continuously competing with
each other not matter is in Malaysia or worldwide. To competing with these companies, Nestle
has keeps improving their operating efficiency. For customer perception, this competing is good
for them because companies can keep improving their products to battle with other competitors.
In other words, consumers can enjoy the products which keep improving continuously.
58
Moreover, Nestle has released many new products for every year to maintain their position in
this industry.
4.
the higher quality for the same price then decrease the profits of the company. In other words, the
bargaining power of customer is high when the products are undifferentiated and standard.
Nestle has understand well about the customer needs and power so that they can meet the needs
of the customers and products easily to maintain its customers for giving the best choice to them.
Besides that, Nestle has focused more about health and wellness products recently and desire to
produce more healthy products to society.
5.
Bargaining power of suppliers is the suppliers have the ability to raise prices or bargain to
reduce quality for the products and squeeze the companys profits. It can be influence much to
the industry if the bargaining power of suppliers is strong. For Nestle, it has the long term
positive relationship between its suppliers all over the world. This is because Nestle has the large
purchasing power and the suppliers of agricultural merchandise offer the product is far from
unique. Hence, Nestle has the more bargaining power that its suppliers.
60
S1
S2
S3
INTERNAL: WEAKNESSES
W1
R&D capabilities
S5
Customer loyalty
EXTERNAL: OPPORTUNITIES
O1
O2
EXTERNAL: THREATS
T1
T2
Competition
T3
products
Globalization
61
1. STRENGTHS
i.
Malaysia. In the other words, Nestle has a reputable brand for its products almost in
everywhere and millions of people used on it every day. Nestle Malaysia has over 100 years
for its brand to sustain in food and beverage industry. Thus, this can prove that the
experiences in manufacturing, food and beverage of Nestle are high. With these experiences,
the strong reputation brand has let Nestle become confident to beat up with other competitors
such as Kraft Foods Group Inc. Besides that, Nestle also continuous produce more innovative
products to the market for sustain the brand and reputation. Through Nestle Malaysias
reputation, it had get many awards such as The Prime Ministers Hibiscus Awards, The
ACCA Malaysia Sustainability Reporting Awards (ACCA MaSRA), The National Annual
Corporate Report Awards (NACRA), Life at Work Award 2013,and so on.
ii.
included in Sales and Marketing, Finance, Supply Chain, Human Resource and Technical and
Production. Nestle is probably find the new talents who are with right attitude, good
communication with others, take on challenge and desire for learn new things. Based on this
programme, Nestle provided experience coaches and mentors for each trainee who is
involved to train their new skills, networking and communication. In year 2013, Nestle has
successfully recruited 20 new Management Trainees out of the 1500 applications.
62
iii.
children. There are around 40 active students who their parents are working with Nestle are
having the beneficial form the Nestle Scholarship Award in year 2013. This scholarship is
chosen based on their academic results, participation in co-curricular activities and parents
financial situation. With this beneficial, students who have been chosen can receive the
award RM7000 annually during their degree programme. Besides that, they also have the
chance to do their internship programme at Nestle and have the work opportunities at Nestle
after internship. Through this care, Nestle Malaysia had get Malaysias 100 Leading
Graduate Employers Award in year 2012/2013.
iv.
its products have met the needs of consumers, Nestle has do innovation and renovation
continuously for its product. This innovation and renovation can let Nestle continuously
introduce its new products each year and reinforce firms competitive advantage.
v.
CUSTOMER LOYALTY
Nestle have over 100 years in the market at Malaysia. Due to its long term existing
and experienced in Malaysias market, customers are usually more confident on it products
and willing to become loyal on it because of the long lasting brand and good quality.
63
2. WEAKNESSES
i.
is considering its core business. However, Nestle are introduce many products included
healthy or less healthy such as Brand Maggi of instant noodle is unhealthy to consumers. The
first concept for consumer toward Nestle is healthy product, but the instant noodle become
different categories compare to Nestle really focusing. Besides that, Nestle also released
confectionery with high sugar to consumers such as Kit Kat and ice-cream. Therefore, Nestle
has released too much of products that distract from its core business which is provided
different aim of the product business to consumers compared to its core business.
3. OPPORTUNITIES
i.
beverage for daily meals. This kind of healthy food and beverage has become a trend to
consumers. Due to this trend of consumers tastes, Nestle has introduced more healthy food
and beverage products to fulfil this trend and increase the demand to consumers.
ii.
GLOBALIZATION
Globalization is one of the opportunities to Nestle Malaysia Berhad. Nestle Malaysia
is the biggest range of Halal products producer in Nestle world. Its also appointed as Halal
Centre of Excellence for Nestle worldwide now. From previous to now, Nestle Malaysia
produces around 300 halal products included food and beverage. Other than that, it exported
the halal products to more than 50 countries in worldwide. There are 7 Halal factories and
total of 150 Halal factories in worldwide. The worldwide of the consumers can buy the halal
version of the Nestle Malaysias brand such as Milo, Nescafe, Maggi, Kit Kat and Nespray.
64
Hence, Nestle Malaysia has the opportunities to go global with their product especially halal
products which can meet the needs of Muslim consumers in globally.
4. THREATS
i.
and Malaysians favourite beverage have increase the price by 5% to 7%. This is because of
the unavoidable of milk products price had increased due to the higher raw material prices.
Besides that, the commodities costs are become higher included milk, coffee and cocoa.
Nestle Malaysia is finding the ways to solve it because it cant burden all these costs and
affected the price of products slightly increase. With this high price of products, it might be
influenced their consumers burden and also the demand for this products and sales.
ii.
COMPETITION
Due to Nestle Malaysia is large food and beverage industry, there are many
competitors to compete with it automatically such as Kraft Foods Group Inc, Unilever,
PepsiCo and others. To compete with its strong competitors, Nestle has produced and offer
variety of food and beverage to consumers in order to battle with its competitors easily.
Beyond than that, Nestle also make sure about it product must be in good quality, good taste
and reasonable price to consumers so that wont be loss its consumers and sales.
65
iii.
beverage currently, but it is also a major supplier of chocolate and chocolate drinks which
contain high calories on it. Recently, healthy food and beverage are gradually been favorites
by consumers. Due to this trend, the changing of customers habits is influenced the demand
of high calories for chocolate food and beverage is decline. But on the other hand, its also a
good sign because consumers are become healthier for their daily life.
66
STRENGTHS
WEAKNESSES
FACTORS
(IFAS)
S1
S2
W1
reputation
Strong management
business
capability
EXTERNAL
S3
FACTORS
(EFAS)
children
S4
R&D capabilities
S5
Customer loyalty
OPPORTUNITIES
O1 Increasing demand
SO STRATEGIES
S1S5O2 Strong brand name and
WO STRATEGIES
W1O1 Healthier food
products demand
O2 Globalization
Nestle to go globally
reduce the
unhealthier products
S4O1
ST STRATEGIES
S1S5T2
WT STRATEGIES
W1T2 Reduce the
T2 Competition
production of
allow Nestle to
unhealthy food
eating
compete against
products
competitor
1.
SO STRATEGIES
67
i.
of over 100 years established in Malaysia. Even every day we are using the Nestle products
such as Milo and Maggi. With the strong brand name and reputation, Nestle can expand its
business to international level. Everyone of us know what the Nestle products is and this
show the brand name of Nestle that has been deeply influenced in the society and customers.
A well established and strong brand like Nestle can have low barriers to enter the new
international market. For the additional information, Nestle has also plan to enter global
market especially the halal market. With the halal product and also the brand name of Nestle,
Nestle will have a lot of opportunity and increase the brand name again in the international
market.
Nestle has the support not only from its brand name but also its customer loyalty. As
Nestle has been long existed in the food and beverage industry, thus the customers will have
confident in its products quality. Nestle also come out with the healthier products which is
also a demand from the customers strengthen the customer loyalty towards Nestle.
Customers will feel confident to use any products from Nestle as they believe in the Nestle
which is a large and strong company. The long lasting brand and good quality of the Nestle
products will gain the confidence from the customers to support their products in the long
run.
With both the strong brand name and customer loyalty that the Nestle have, Nestle
can easily expand its business into global market. With these advantages, Nestle can grab the
external opportunities to expand its business to international market such as the Islam market.
Nestle has to build a strong customer royalty relationship with its customers in order to
survive in the international market. Good quality will be the first requirement for the
customers to buy the products. With the customer royalty and the brand name developed in
global market, only Nestle can fight against all the global competitors in the food and
beverage industry.
ii.
Each year, Nestle will allocate more than RM 6 billion of the fund in carrying out
R&D. This is done in order to do more research in its products creation and innovation and
increase the number of customers using the Nestle products. Nestle is doing R&D so that it
can best meet what the customers demand from the products and thus can best serve the
customers needs. Other than that, R&D also purposely carried out so that Nestle can produce
more and more different and innovative products in which has the competitive advantage
over its competitor.
Nowadays, due to the trends of healthier life and also the increasing type of diseases
in the society, customers try and start to demand for a healthier life through their eating
habits. So, the customers taste and choice will start to move towards healthier products such
as less sugar, less calories products. The R&D carried out by the Nestle can best match with
this opportunity as the purpose of the R&D is to meet the customers demand of healthier
food products which are increasing. The R&D can be carried out in the aspect of healthier
products which is also what the customer trend demand for. Having the information and
demand from the customers on the characteristics of healthier product, Nestle can add on
with its innovative and creative in designing the packaging of the products so that it can win
definitely in the food and beverages industry. With this best match, Nestle can continue to
survive in the food and beverage industry and even attract more customers on its newly
developed healthier products.
2. WO STRATEGIES
i.
products from its core businesses. This included the healthier food products and also
unhealthier food products. Unhealthier food products that produced by the Nestle are the
instant noodles of Maggi, confectionery with high sugar such as ice cream and Kit Kat. This
is the weaknesses of the Nestle in which that opposite with the slogan of the Nestle good
69
food, good life. These unhealthier products are in conflict with the image of Nestle in the
consumers sight which is the producer of health, nutrition, and wellness to consumers.
However, this weakness can be overcome by the opportunities in the external
environment. The trends of healthier life and healthier foods force the Nestle to consider in
the production of these unhealthier food products. In order to suit with the opportunities in
the external surrounding or market, Nestle has to focus its production in the healthier food
products rather than unhealthier products. This is because consumers will be those generate
income for Nestle and therefore it influence deeply in the Nestle financial performance.
Nestle has to follow the trends and change in its food products so that it can long lasting in
the food and beverage industry. Time after time, Nestle can overcome its weaknesses and
stay with its slogan of Good Food, Good Life.
3. ST STRATEGIES
i.
industry. Almost everyone knows about the product of Nestle and may consume it every day.
Nestle also comes out with a variety of products for the consumers such as beverages, foods,
liquid drinks, performance nutrition, healthcare nutrition, breakfast cereals, ice cream,
confectionery, dairy, infant and maternal nutrition, chilled dairy and nestle professional. With
these choices of products, Nestle successfully in attracting the consumers and thus gain the
customer royalty from its products. With also the support and confident from the customers,
Nestle can survive long lasting in the food and beverages industry. A lot of competitors in the
food and beverages industry such as Kraft Foods Group Inc, PepsiCo, Unilever and so on
compete against Nestle which is one of the large company in the industry. Nestle has the
customer royalty and customer confident in its food products and thus has a competitive
advantages over its competitors. Nestle has to keep on its products quality in order to gain the
customer royalty. Once Nestle has the customer royalty to support its food products, then
70
Nestle will has an extra advantages for it to compete against the large competitor in the food
and beverages industry.
Besides that, brand name is also an important factors or characteristics for a company
to compete and survive in the related industry. Nestle, is a famous term in the food products.
Everyone know about it and has been consumed its product such as Maggi. Maggi, one of the
instant noodles produced by Nestle, is very well known among the consumers choice in
which the term has been used to replace the instant noodles term. The consumers will say
Maggi to represent all the instant noodles of other brands. This is one of the examples in
which to show that the brand name of Nestle has been wide spread among the food and
beverage industry. With this famous brand name, Nestle has been standing stable in the food
and beverages industry. The strong brand name of Nestle can avoid Nestle from being
withdraw from the food and beverages industry as the brand name is already well known by
the consumers. What Nestle has to do is that Nestle has to work on to spread its brand name
worldwide and on the other side keep on control the products quality.
4. WT STRATEGIES
i.
start to look for more healthier food products such as low sugar, low calories, low fats, low
salty and so on. However, this has become a problem for Nestle because of the variety of
food products comes from its core business. Some of the food products are unhealthier for
example Kit Kat, Maggi, ice cream and so on. Nestle has to do some changes in its
production in order to follow the trend and also compete with the competitors.
In this highly competitive industry, Nestle can set a strategy that can best reduce its
weaknesses and at the same time can survive in the market or industry. Having the trend of
healthy life as a factor, the other competitors will also follow the trend by producing healthier
food products. This is because the consumers will consume the products produced and if the
company did not change according to the consumers taste, it will not long lasting and be
71
kick out from the industry. Therefore, to avoid the threat of competition and continue as the
large company in the food and beverage industry, Nestle has to focus its production line in
the healthy food products such as the healthcare nutrition, infant and maternal nutrition,
breakfast cereals and others.
With the changes made by Nestle, Nestle not only can compete with the competitors
in the industry, Nestle can also overcome its weakness of the unhealthy food products
produced from its core business. Nestle can enhance its slogan of Good Food, Good Life
and also the image in the perspective of consumers which Nestle is the producer of health,
nutrition and wellness food and beverages products. And thus in conclusion, Nestle can use
this strategy of producing healthy food products so that Nestle can overcome its weakness
and avoid the threat at the same time.
72
Year 2013
Year 2012
551,436,000
490,472,000
234,500,000
234,500,000
Earnings per share (EPS) ratio measures how many of RM of net income have been
earned by each share of common stock. It is computed by dividing net income less preferred
dividend by the number of shares of common stock outstanding during the period. The
calculation of EPS is very important for actual and potential common stockholders due to the
payment of dividend and increase in the value of stock in future largely relied on the earnings of
the company and thus need to show the EPS figure in the income statement. The higher the EPS,
the better it is. This is because a higher EPS is the sign of higher earnings, strong financial
position and thus is a reliable company to invest money.
From the calculation shown above, the earnings per share of Nestle are RM 2.0916 per
share in year 2012 and RM 2.3515 per share in year 2013. The earnings per share have been
increase from year 2012 to year 2013 in the amount of RM 0.2599 per share as the income
generated is increasing. Thus, it can be said that the financial performance of Nestle is better in
year 2013.
73
2.
Year 2013
Year 2012
552,026,000
491,274,000
551,075,000
490,950,000
= 1.0017
= 1.0007
74
3.
Year 2013
Year 2012
551,436,000
490,472,000
679,937,000
632,640,000
= 0.8110 / 81.10%
= 0.7753 / 77.53%
Return on investment (ROI) measure the gain or loss generated on an investment relative
to the amount of the money invested. It is computed b dividing the net profit after interest and
tax by total assets. ROI is usually expressed as a percentage and is typically used for personal
financial decisions, to compare a companys profitability or to make a decision of investing an
investment by comparing the efficiency of different investments. If an investment result in a
positive ROI, then the investment should be undertaken. A higher ROI is better as the higher ROI
means that investment gains compare favorable to investment costs.
From the calculation shown above, the return on investment of Nestle is 0.8110 or
81.10% in year 2013 and 0.7753 or 77.53% in year 2012. It shows an increase of the return on
investment of 0.0357 from year 2012 to 2013. This is a good result for the Nestle as the
increasing return on investment indicates that the investment gain in Nestle is more favorable
than the investment costs incurred and thus is a good investment.
75
4.
Year 2013
Year 2012
551,436,000
490,472,000
679,937,000 + 632,640,000
632,640,000 + 563,514,000
= 0.8402 / 84.02%
= 0.8201 / 82.01%
Return on assets (ROA) is a financial ratio that shows the percentage of profit that a
company earns in relation to its overall resources or total assets. It is computed by dividing the
net income by average total assets. ROA also means of the measurement of the amount of profit
made by a company per RM of its assets. It shows the companys ability to generate profits using
its assets rather than leverage. Thus, ROA can indicate how efficient management use company
assets to generate profit. A higher ROA shows the efficiency of the assts been used to generate
profit and thus the higher it is, the better it is.
From the calculation shown above, the return on assets for Nestle is 0.8402 or 84.02% in
year 2013 and 0.8201 or 82.01% in year 2012. There is an increase of 0.0201 from year 2012 to
2013. This means that in year 2013, Nestle can generate higher income using its assets and
therefore is more stable. Each RM of assets can generate 84.02% of income for Nestle in year
2013.
76
5.
Year 2013
Year 2012
551,436,000
490,472,000
678,404,000 + 631,143,000
631,143,000 + 562,771,000
= 0.8422 / 84.22%
= 0.8216 / 82.16%
77
78
For the second strategy which is the Research and Development done by the Nestle need
to change the direction so that it can fulfill the increasing demand of the healthier food products,
Nestle can properly allocate its fund in carrying out the R&D in the appropriate direction. Nestle
is doing R&D so that it can best meet what the customers demand from the products and thus can
best serve the customers needs. Other than that, R&D also purposely carried out so that Nestle
can produce more and more different and innovative products in which has the competitive
advantage over its competitor.
Nowadays, due to the trends of healthier life and also the increasing type of diseases in
the society, customers try and start to demand for a healthier life through their eating habits. So,
the customers taste and choice will start to move towards healthier products such as less sugar,
less calories products. The R&D carried out by the Nestle can best match with this opportunity as
the purpose of the R&D is to meet the customers demand of healthier food products which are
increasing. Having the information and demand from the customers on the characteristics of
healthier product, Nestle can add on with its innovative and creative in designing the packaging
of the products so that it can win definitely in the food and beverages industry. With this best
match, Nestle can continue to survive in the food and beverage industry and even attract more
customers on its newly developed healthier products.
Thus, in conclusion, both the SO strategies developed will be useful to the Nestle in order
to make their company stronger if the strategies are properly and correctly be implemented. The
suggested strategies will be those chosen among the best alternative. SO strategies will be the
best strategies as the Nestle is using what the competitive advantages it has among other
competitors and apply it in the external opportunity that existed in the food and beverage
industry.
79
80
81
82
Madam Kam is an executive chairman aged 50 years old. Madam Kam was appointed as
Executive Director of the Group on 8 April 1998, and was later appointed as an Executive
Chairman on 15 May 2008. She also serves as a member of Remuneration Committee. She holds
a Bachelor Degree in Business from South Australia Institute of Technology [now known as
University of South Australia, Australia.
She has been a key person in the Groups management and organization since graduation.
As Executive Chairman, she is responsible to oversee the strategic direction, overall performance
and business development of the Group, for both Malaysian and overseas operations. She
ensures that the operations are managed in line with the Companys mission and vision.
Currently, she sits on the Boards of the subsidiaries of the New Hoong Fatt (NHF) Group.
Madam Kam is the spouse of Chin Jit Sin, sibling of Kam Foong Sim, both are Directors
of the Company, and daughter of Wong Ah Moy @ Wong Yoke Len, a major shareholder of the
Company.
83
She has no material conflict of interest with the Group other than that which has been
disclosed to the Board of Directors and shareholders in the audited financial statements.
2. CHIN JIT SIN
Mr Chin is a managing director aged 52 years old. Mr Chin is the Group Managing
Director of NHF. He was appointed as Executive Director on 8 April 1998 and was re-designated
as Managing Director on 25 October 2007. As the Group Managing Director, he acts as Chief
Executive Officer of the Group. He holds a Bachelor of Economics (Hons) Degree (major in
Business Administration) from University of Malaya.
Mr Chin was attached to a banking institution prior to joining NHF. His experience
covers a variety of industries including banking and financial institutions, manufacturing and
trading. As the Group Managing Director of NHF, he also oversees the strategic planning, talent
management and operational management of the Group, particularly in operational effectiveness
and efficiency and ensuring adherence to the Groups policies and procedures. Currently, he sits
on the Board of the subsidiaries of the NHF Group.
He is also a director in another public company, namely the Malaysian Automotive
Component Parts Manufacturers where he serves as a member of the Executive Committee.
84
Mr Chin is the spouse of Kam Foong Keng, the Executive Chairman and major
shareholder of the Company, and is therefore related to members of her family. He has no direct
conflict of interest with the Group.
3. KAM FOONG SIM
85
86
Datuk Dr. Anis is an independent non-executive director aged 68 years old. Datuk Dr.
Anis was appointed as Independent Non-Executive Director on 2 December 2002. He also serves
as the Chairman of the Remuneration Committee and a member of the Audit Committee and
Nomination Committee.
He holds a Ph.D. in Pharmacology from University of Bath, United Kingdom, a Master
of Science in Pharmaceutical Technology from University of London and a Bachelor of
Pharmacy from University of Singapore.
Datuk Dr. Anis started his career with the Ministry of Health (MoH) in 1968 and served
the Malaysian Government in various capacities, namely as Lecturer and Head of Department of
Pharmacology in Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Director of the National Pharmaceutical
Control Bureau (NPCB) of MoH, Secretary of the Drug Control Authority of MoH, Deputy
Director of the Pharmacy Division of MoH and DeputyDirector of Health (Pharmacy) for the
Department of Health, Johor. He was promoted to Director of NPCB and then Director of
Pharmacy of MoH, where he served until his retirement in 2001.
Currently, Datuk Dr. Anis is the Chairman of the Board of Directors of Y.S.P. Southeast
Asia Holding Berhad, and a Director of several private limited companies.
Datuk Dr. Anis does not have any family relationship with any Director and/or major
shareholder of the Company. He has no conflict of interest with the Group.
87
88
2. COVER RATIONALE
89
In recent years, many Asian countries have experienced rapid growth. In particular, the
Automotive industries have developed greatly and in turn the demand for automotive
replacement parts have consequently increased. As such, NHF continues its mission to grow and
expand within Asia whilst also pursuing growing demands in other regions around the world.
90
91
2. ECONOMIC FORCES
One factor that affects the world economies and industry trade was the weakening of
currencies included Malaysia. It affected the slowdown of demand .By comparing New Hoong
Fatt Holdings Berhad financial year ended 31 December 2013, there are decline of 3.2 %
compared 2012. At 2013 total revenue 210.6 million compared to RM 217.5 million in 2012.
Moreover, profit before tax which amount of RM 27.4 million declined by 1.1 %
compared to 27.7 million in 2012. Even though the revenue Ws lower expense is higher in 2013
lower manufacturing cost and impairment goodwill helped cushion their impart.
Next the Net profit also dropped, which is RM20.1 million was 11.8 % lower compare
2012 which is RM22.8 million. For taxation, it is higher in 2013 because of the higher provision
for deferred taxation compared 2013.Thus, The earning per share dropped to 26.81 cent
compared to 30.29 cent in 2012 financial year.
92
3. SOCIAL FORCES
For social environment, NHF Holdings Berhad has to focus on population, demographic,
taste of consumers on buying car. This is because NHF Holding mostly focuses on local auto part
like Proton, Perodua auto part. Thus, social environment is a challenge foe NHF Holdings
Berhad. This is because nowadays, many customers are buying import car like Honda, Toyota
and so on.
4. TECHNOLOGICAL FORCES
NHF Holding Berhad follow the changes of technology growth, NHF spend
approximately RM11.0 million in 2012, the new Cathodic Electro-Deposition paint line,
hydraulic press machines and plastic injection machines were fully installed and readily in 2013.
NHF also upgrade the stamping division and plastic section. Due to technology changes, NHF
need to follow the changes of technology, spending huge amount of capital to upgrades itself in
the auto parts industry. Next, NHF was capable to expand its capacity to oversea trading arms in
Indonesia and China. China and Indonesia is a major growing automotive market, NFH Holdings
Berhad continue to develop the channel in these market for future progress and growth.
5. ECOLOGY FORCES
For environmental like ecology factor, NHF holding has to follow the Environment Act
in Malaysia and schedule waste 1972. To prevent our environment pollution, auto part inset to
the car should not pollute the air environment.
93
6. LEGAL FORCES
NHF Holding Berhad has to follow the rule and regulation of Malaysia. As required by
Companies Act 1965 and listing Requirement, The financial statement have to prepared follow
the applicable approved accounting standard in Malaysia. NHF Holding Berhads director needs
to ensure the annual financial report statement give a true and fair view in the state of affairs.
Lastly, NHF Holding Berhad also is given option to make an irrevocable election to move
to single tier system or to keep on use the tax exempt account or tax credit under Section 108 of
Income Tax Act, 1967 for the objective of dividend distribution until fully utilized by 31
December 2013.
94
1.
competitors increases. Highly competitive industries generally earn low returns because the cost
of competition is high. The NHF holdings Berhad is considered to be an oligopoly, which helps
to minimize the effects of price-based competition. NHF holdings Berhad know that price-based
competition does not necessarily lead to increases in the size of the marketplace, but more
recently the competition has intensified, NHF holding rebates, preferred financing and long-term
warranties have helped to lure in customers, but they also put pressure on the profit margins for
vehicle sales.
95
3. THREAT OF SUBSTITUTION
For threat of substitution NHF Holding Berhad suffers the threat of someone buying a
different car. However, this is the likelihood of people taking the bus, train or airplane to their
destination. The higher the cost of operating a vehicle, the more likely people will seek
alternative transportation options. The price of auto vehicle has a large effect on consumers'
decisions to buy vehicles. Trucks and sport utility vehicles have higher profit margins. When
determining the availability of substitutes you should also consider time, money, personal
preference and convenience in the auto travel industry. Then decide car auto maker poses a big
threat as a substitute.
96
97
S2
S3
S4
S5
Market leader
S6
Financial stability
S7
WEAKNESSES
W
1
W
2
W
3
OPPORTUNITIES
O1
THREATS
T1
Competitor
T2
T3
T4
Exchange rate
Technological advances
O2
New target market
O3
Change in customer behavior
O4
98
1. STRENGTHS
i. UP TO DATE TECHNOLOGY AND IT SKILL
NHF Holdings Berhad have acquire another facility specialized in manufacturing of
metal and plastic automotive part products in order to make the production become more
efficient and effective. The example of the facility such as 3D Laser Machine, CED Painting,
Stamping Press and so on to help and make sure the product that been produced is in high
quality. Besides of increasing the efficiency of production, the protection of safety for worker
also can have improvement.
NHF Holdings Berhad has become the market leader in the manufacture and supply
of automotive spare parts to the replacement market.
2. WEAKNESSES
i. VOYAGE WILL MAKE THE COST INCREASE
NHF Holdings Berhad distributed over 50 countries, but they do not have the factory
among all of the country. So that, most of the product needs to be transport and voyage from
Malaysia to other country. This will increase the transportation fees and the price of goods
sold will increase. This issue will directly effect to the demand of product from foreign
country because they maybe can get a cheaper price for the same product with other
manufacture.
Most of the materials that used by NHF Holdings Berhad to produce their products
are metal, plastic and oil. The volume of supply for this kind of material is been estimated
that, it will decrease in the future due to supply shortage because it is not a renewable energy.
3. OPPORTUNITIES
i. TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCES
A technological advance is happened when a company is outsourcing in a foreign
country. For example, there will be an interaction between the local labors and the foreign
labors. They might observe or learn the style, attitude, skill from other to make improvement
on them to get higher achievement. For example, NHF Holdings Berhad has two overseas
operations in Jakarta, Indonesia and Shanghai, China.
101
Nowadays, many of the younger like to reequip their car. This is because they like to
make their car looks different from others. Thus, the trend for now is they would change the
outlook of their car such as change the bumpers, mirrors, fenders, accessory lamps and others.
4.
THREAT
i.
COMPETITOR
The competitor of this industry is huge. This is because of many of the car
manufacture produce the car automotive part by their own. This is to minimize the cost and
maximize the profit earned. For example, Proton car do produce the car automotive part by
own.
ii.
that with high qualification. For example, the do need many of engineer, HR manager,
technician, warehouse operator and so on. This is very hard to find a good career with require
qualification. The loyalty also had become a very concern issue by top management of the
NHF Holdings Berhad.
iii.
102
iv.
EXCHANGE RATES
NHF Holdings Berhad earns more than half of its revenue outside the Malaysia.
Exchange rate fluctuations threaten NHF Holdings Berhads profits if the MYR (Malaysia
Ringgit) would appreciate against other currencies.
103
STRENGTHS
INTERNAL
FACTORS
(IFAS)
S1
Up to date skill
S2
S3
Different
W1
W2
geographical
sectors
EXTERNAL
FACTORS
WEAKNESSES
S4
(EFAS)
OPPORTUNITIES
SO STRATEGY
WO STRATEGY
Technological
advances
O2
Holdings
Berhad
of
technology
their
operation
while
and
it
cost
budget
Next,
implements
its
budget
by
using
yellow
pages
or
attract
customers
demands.
NHF
increase
Holding
development.
THREATS
T1
Competitor
T2
The Career
ST STRATEGY
There
are
more
and
WT STRATEGY
more In order to increase the
industry
nowadays.
NHF Holdings
sales,
NHF
Berhad
could
cost
of
raw
has
various
social
change
through to
this
industry.
NHF
1.
SO STRATEGY
105
NHF Holdings Berhad haS strong corporate culture as a market leader in auto parts
industry. It is one of its strengths to manage it corporation to be the market leader in auto parts
industry. Due to this, the demands will increase. When NHF Holdings Berhad go global, it can
expand their business into foreign market. Besides that, they can compete healthy with other
company at around the world. The organization need to combine strength with the NHF
Holdings Berhad opportunities which is to produce high quality products with nice packaging
by adoption information technology in order to keep with changing of technology while
improving their operation and demands. NHF Holding can increase market share for market
development.
2.
ST STRATEGY
There are more and more competitors to penetrate in the auto arts industry nowadays.
NHF Holdings Berhad has to always up to date to the technology and it skill to maintain as a
market leader in the auto parts industry.
NHF Holdings Berhad has various notable implementations have to be carried out though
out the year in the pursuit of excellence to enhance the quality of their products. They should
provide high value than competitors and create strong supplier customer relationship because it
can bring positive social change through effective business strategies. By using this method, an
organization could get benefit in their production and thus increase the profit.
3. WO STRATEGY
NHF Holdings Berhad should manage it cost budget effective like doing schedule set
limit for cash out as cost rising. Next, implements marketing promotion based on its budget by
using advertisement through mass media like a television, radio and newspaper or listing in the
yellow pages or a billboard, show it corporation, product to meet the target market needs. NHF
Holdings Berhad should always remind their consumer about them nowadays. The advertisement
should attract customers attention in order to increase in term of demands.
4. WT STRATEGY
106
In order to increase the companys sales, NHF Holdings Berhad could minimize cost of
raw material, cost of product. Next, NHF Holdings Berhad need to recruit expertise in marketing
areas by have the competent person and experts in that filed to handle the business. This is due to
the increase new entrants on the auto parts industry and many auto industry can use other
substitute products that come to this industry. NHF Holdings Berhad just not only be able could
use this ways to overcome the threats but also able improve their company performance.
107
Net Income
Average Outstanding Share
Year 2013
Year 2012
20,149,000
22,763,000
75,157,000
75,157,000
= 0.2681
= 0.3029
Earnings per share serve as an indicator of a companys profitability. The earnings per
share for the year 2012 are even better than year 2013 which is 0.3029 compare to the year 2013
which is 0.2681.
108
Year 2012
52,218,000
32,623,000
52,723,000
33,238,000
= 0.9904
= 0.9815
109
Year 2012
52,665,000
29,121,000
148,553,000
105,421,000
= 0.3545
= 0.2763
The return on investment is the ratio of money gained or lost on an investment relative to
the amount of money invested. For the year 2012 there is a gained of 0.2763 compared to the
year 2013 which is only 0.3.545. The gains are increasing.
110
Year 2012
27,358,000
27,669,000
148,553,000+105,421,000
105,421,000+85,721,721
= 0.2154
= 0.2895
Return on asset gives an idea as to how efficient management is at using its assets to
generate earnings. From the table, we can see that on the year 2012 the management of company
is more efficient which is 0.2895 compared to the year 2013 which only 0.2154.
111
112
Door
Hood
Grille
Panel
113
4.0 CONCLUSION
If comparison is made between Narra Industries Berhad, Nestle (Malaysia) Berhad and
New Hoong Fatt Holdings Berhad, we found that these companies have not much similarity for
us to do comparison due to the different industry. So, we take the ratio analysis of these three
companies to find out which is better to invest.
The Earning Per Share (EPS) for NHF Holding Berhad is RM 0.2681 per share while the
EPS ratio for Narra Industires Berhad and Nestle (Malaysia) Berhad are (RM 0.4383) per share
and RM 2.3515 per share in year 2013. The EPS ratio performance shows that Nestle (Malaysia)
Berhad had the greater value than the other companies. For conclusion, we will suggest BOD
IZAARA PLC to choose Nestle (Malaysia) Berhad as their target for them to invest in Malaysia.
Nestle (Malaysia) Berhad is a well established company in the food and beverage
industry and has strong financial performance as compared to the others. Nestle is a dominant
company among the competitors and has tendency to expand the companys share market.
Narra Industries Berhad is facing the financial downturn and is now in crisis. The losses
of the company are continuous for years and the figure of the losses is keeps on increasing. The
company was sold out their assets nearly half of the total assets in year 2012.
In conclusion, through the comparison among the three companies, we found that Nestle
(Malaysia) Berhad is the most favourable company to invest in. Thus, we suggest the company to
invest in Nestle (Malaysia) Berhad.
114
5.0 REFERENCES
1. Hong Leong Manufacturing Group Sdn Bhd. (n.d.). 10-Year Financial Highlights. Retrieved
from Hong Leong Manufacturing Group: http://www.hlmg.com.my/financial-highlights.php?
rid=4
2. Hong Leong Manufacturing Group Sdn Bhd. (n.d.). Our Businesses. Retrieved from Hong
Leong Manufacturing Group: http://www.hlmg.com.my/our-businesses.php?rid=4
3. Khuen, L. W. (2014, 6 17). Narra hits limit-up, says unaware of any reason for share price
spike. Retrieved from The Sun Daily: http://www.thesundaily.my/news/1083680
4. Narra Industries Berhad. (2013). Annual Report.
5. The Star. (2013, October 17). Narra Industries losing its lustre after HL Industries deal.
Retrieved
from
The
Star:
http://www.thestar.com.my/Business/Business-
News/2013/10/17/Narra-Industries-losing-its-lustre-after-HL-Industries-deal/
6. Malaysia Population 1960-2014.(n.d.). Malaysia Population. Retrieved September 22, 2014,
from http://www.tradingeconomics.com/malaysia/population
7. Nestle Company. (2011, 09). StudyMode.com. Retrieved September 21, 2014, from
http://www.studymode.com/essays/Nestle-Company-781198.html
8. Nestle Malaysia. (n.d.). http://www.nestle.com.my. Retrieved September 21, 2014, from
http://www.nestle.com.my/
9. Nestle to increase Milo's price by 5% to 7% .(n.d.). TheSundaily. Retrieved September 29,
2014, from http://www.thesundaily.my/news/1028188
10. Porter's Five Forces. (n.d.). Strategic Management Insight. Retrieved September 22, 2014,
from http://www.strategicmanagementinsight.com/tools/porters-five-forces.html
11. SWOT analysis of Nestle. (n.d.). Nestle SWOT analysis 2013. Retrieved September 21, 2014,
from http://www.strategicmanagementinsight.com/swot- analyses/nestle-swot-analysis.html
115
12. WikiWealth. (n.d.). Nestle Malaysia SWOT Analysis -. Retrieved September 22, 2014, from
http://www.wikiwealth.com/swot-analysis:nestle-malaysia
13. (2013). Annual Report New Holdings Berhad .
116