CNG HA X HI CH NGHA VIT NAM

S: .........../ HN533-HW-Aprl

c lp - T do - Hnh phc
-------------------H Ni, ngy 08 thng 08 nm 2016

BO CO THM TRA
H S THIT K BN V THI CNG
D N: U T CI TO, NNG CP QL38B
ON T QL10 N QL1A
GIAI ON 1: ON T KM88+000 N KM106+740
Knh gi:
S GIAO THNG VN TI NAM NH
ng knh gi:
BAN QUN L D N GIAO THNG NAM NH
Cng ty CP TVXD 533 Chi nhnh H Ni T vn thm tra nhn H s Thit k
Bn v Thi cng ca D n ci to, nng cp QL38B, giai on 1 t Km88+000 n
Km106+740 thuc tnh Nam nh do Cng ty CP TVXD CTGT 2 (TECCo2) lp thng
03/2013. Sau khi nghin cu, T vn thm tra xin bo co Kt qu thm tra nh sau::
I.
CC CN C THM TRA

Lut Xy dng ngy 26/11/2003; Lut u thu ngy 29/11/2005; Lut sa i,

b sung mt s iu ca cc lut lin quan n u t xy dng c bn ngy 19/6/2009;

Ngh nh s 12/2009/N-CP ngy 12/02/2009 ca Chnh ph v qun l d n

u t xy dng cng trnh; Ngh nh s 83/2009/N-CP ngy 15/10/2009 ca chnh ph
v sa i, b sung mt s iu Ngh nh s 12/2009/N-CP ngy 12/02/2009 ca Chnh
ph v qun l d n u t xy dng cng trnh; Ngh nh s 209/2004/N-CP
ngayf16/12/2004 ca Chnh ph v qun l cht lng cng trnh xy dng v Ngh nh s
49/2008/N-CP ngy 18/4/2008 ca Chnh ph v vic sa i, b sung 1 s iu ca
NDD209/2004/N-CP; Ngh nh s 112/2009/N-CP ngy 14/12/2009 ca Chnh ph v
qun l chi ph u t xy dng cng trnh;

Ngh nh s 11/2010/N-CP ngy 14/12/2010 ca Chnh ph quy nh v qun

l v bo v kt cu h tng giao thng ng b;

Thng t s 06/2007/TT-BXD ngy 25/7/2007 ca B Xy dng v hng dn

hp ng trong hot ng xy dng;

Quyt nh s 957/Q-BXD ngy 29/9/2009 ca B Xy dng v vic cng b

nh mc chi ph qun l d n v t vn u t xy dng cng trnh;

Quyt nh s 764/Q-BGTVT ngy 11/4/2012 ca B GTVT v vic ph duyt

danh mc tiu chun p dng cho D n ci to nng cp QL38B on t QL10 n QL1A,
tnh Nam nh;

Quyt nh s 2727/Q-BGTVT ngy 31/10/2012 ca B GTVT v vic ph

duyt Thit k C s D n u t ci to nng cp QL38B on t QL10 n QL1A, tnh
Nam nh;

Quyt nh s 3265/Q-BGTVT ngy 18/12/2012 ca B GTVT v vic ph

duyt D n u t ci to nng cp QL38B on t QL10 n QL1A, tnh Nam nh;

Page 1 of 31

H s 04/H-TTNB ngy 8/2/2013 gia Ban Qun l D n Giao thng Nam

nh v Cng ty CP TVXD CTGT 2 v/v lp H s Thit k Bn v thi cng thuc D n
u t ci to, nng cp Quc l 38B on QL10 QL1A, giai on 1;
II.
CC THNG TIN CH YU V CNG TRNH:
2.1. Cp hng v quy m cng trnh:

Loi cng trnh: giao thng nhm B (theo N12/2009/N-CP);

Cp cng trnh: giao thng cp II (theo N209/2004/N-CP).
2.2. Ch u t: S GTVT Nam nh;
i din ch u t: Ban QLDA Giao thng Nam nh; .
2.3. a im xy dng: TP Nam nh v cc huyn V Bn, M Lc, Yn thuc tnh
Nam nh;
2.4. Nh thu kho st xy dng: Cng ty CP TVXD CTGT 2;
2.5. Nh thu lp Thit k BVTC: Cng ty CP TVXD CTGT 2;
2.6. H s, ti liu c quan thm tra nhn c: (cho n ngy 08/08/2016)
2.6.1. Cc ti liu c s:
- H s nng lc ca Cng ty CP TVXD CTGT 2: cha nhn c.
- Nhim v KSXD v TK bc BVTC: cha nhn c.
- Quyt nh ph duyt Nhim v KSTK, lp TKBVTC: cha nhn c;
2.6.2. H s kho st xy dng:
Cc Quy hoch lin quan: thu thp trong bc lp DAT;
Cc d n lin quan: thu thp trong bc lp DAT;
H s Kho st Gi (Kinh t X hi): ang thu thp;
H s Kho st a hnh
+ Thuyt minh Kho st tuyn: 1 quyn A4;
+ Bo co Kt qu kho st lp li khng ch mt bng v cao hng IV: 1
quyn A4;
+ Bo co kho st lp li CC2 v cao cp k thut: 1 quyn A4;
+ H s Kho st a hnh Tuyn Thot nc Nt giao: 2 tp A3;
+ H s Kho st a hnh cu: 1 tp A3;
H s Kho st Hin trng cng trnh (thng k n b, GPMB, iu tra h thng cc
cng trnh ngm ni..) theo yu cu ca iu 46 Lut XD s 16/2003/QH11: cha c.
H s Kho st nn mt ng c: 1 quyn A4;
H s Kho st ia cht cng trnh
+ H s KS CCT nn ng v cng: 1 tp A3;
+ H s KS CCT cu nh: 4 tp A4 (Cu T5-5, T3-6, Ch Dn, Knh Bc);
+ H s KS CCT cu trung: 1 tp A4 (Cu Vnh Giang);
+ H s KS CCT nn ng c bit: cha c (lp chung vi nn ng thng
thng?).
H s kho st a cht thy vn:
+ H s kho st thy vn dc tuyn: 1 quyn A4;
Page 2 of 31

+ H s kho st thy vn cu: lp chung vi thu vn dc tuyn?.

H s kho st m vt liu: 1 quyn A4;
2.6.3. Thuyt minh Thit k Bn v Thi cng:
Thuyt minh chung: 1 quyn A4;
Ph lc Cc vn bn: ng km vi Thuyt minh chung;
Ph lc Khi lng: phn Tng hp ng km vi Thuyt minh chung, phn chi tit
ng km vi cc bn v;
Ph lc tnh ton kt cu cu nh: 3 tp A4 (Cu T5-5, T3-6, Knh Bc);
Ph lc tnh ton kt cu cu trung: 1 tp A4 (Cu Vnh Giang);
H s Tnh ton thu vn: 1 quyn A4;
H s Thit k x l nn t yu: 1 quyn A4;
H s D ton: cha c.
2.6.4. Thit k Bn v thi cng:
Bn v Thit k Tuyn Nt giao Cng trnh: cha c.
H s tnh ton thy lc - thy vn: cha c.
Bnh - Ct dc Nt giao Cc bn v in hnh: cha c.
Bn v Thit k cu nh: 3 tp A4 (Cu T5-5, T3-6, Knh Bc);
Bn v Thit k cu trung: 1 tp A4 (Cu Vnh Giang);
III. NI DUNG V KT QU THM TRA
3.1. V cc cn c php l ca D n
c T vn TECCO2 nu kh y trong tp Thuyt minh D n, tuy nhin cn
thiu Quyt nh ph duyt Nhim v KSTK v Hp ng T vn.
3.2. V iu kin nng lc hot ng xy dng ca t chc t vn:
Do cha c H s nng lc, TVTT tm hiu T cch php l ca t chc t vn
thit k da theo thng tin tra trn mng ca c quan ng k kinh doanh. C th ni,
TECCO2 l n v c y t cch php nhn v nng lc kinh nghim thc hin Kho
st Thit k Bn v thi cng cho D n ny.
3.3. V iu kin c xem xt:
TVTT xin nu cc vn pht sinh sau Ch u t xem xt:
Theo Lut Xy dng v cc vn bn php quy hin hnh: H s cha y thnh
phn, cha cp ht cc ni dung v cha khng nh c l ph hp vi cc bc trin
khai trc y (cn c iu 7 & 8 N12/2009/N-CP v ni dung H s v N s
209/2004/N-CP, Chng III v KSXD...). c bit, TVTK cha c cc bng chng v
cng tc kim tra gim st - nghim thu KSXD theo yu cu ca N209/2004/N-CP
(iu 11, iu 12 v PL2) cng nh cha c l c cc tha thun cn thit vi cc c
quan lin quan.
Thuyt minh chung s si, c chng mc hu nh khng c ni dung (hoc yu cu
xem Ph lc?!?). Theo TVTT, thuyt minh ny cha p ng c yu cu ca Thit k
Bn v thi cng.
Page 3 of 31

Thit k BVTC giao np ln ny vn tn ti nhiu im cha tun th / ph hp

Khung Tiu chun thit k, Thit k c s c B GTVT ph duyt. Cng c nhng
du hiu cho thy h s cha c i chiu, khp ni ln nhau v kim sot trong ni b
t vn cht ch. Do vy, kt qu TKBVTC cng cn nhiu sai st, gy thiu khi lng c
th nh hng n Tng D ton v kh khn cho cc bc trin khai tip theo.
Do , TVTT xin nu cc kin sau Ch u t xem xt:
Cha c H s Kho st xy dng p ng yu cu;
H s KSTK do TVTK thc hin l cha y v chi tit so vi thng l.
V ni dung, H s thit k p ng c yu cu, c th chp nhn c.
3.4. V iu kin nng lc ca Ch nhim d n, ch tr thit k, ch tr kho st:
TVTK cn trnh c cho Ch u t v cc c quan c thm quyn trong d n ny:
chng ch hnh ngh ca Ch nhim d n, ch tr thit k, v ch nhim kho st ca bc
TKBVTC theo quy nh trong iu 56 Lut XD16/2003/QH11.
3.5. V ni dung Bo co Kho st xy dng:
Kin ngh N / CT ch o TVTK thc hin:
B sung ton b cc hng mc h s cha c theo mc 2.6.1. , 2.6.2 v 2.6.3 ca
Bo co thm tra ny;
H s KS a hnh s dng TKBVTCv cc H s KS giao np tip theo (nu
c) u phi b sung y cc ni dung cp (3.5.1 3.5.11) sau y:
3.5.1. Ni dung ch yu ca ti liu c s
ngh T vn KSXD nghin cu cc mc sau thc hin cc bc tip theo;
3.5.2. c im, quy m, tnh cht ca cng trnh;
3.5.3. V tr v iu kin t nhin ca khu vc kho st xy dng;
3.5.4. Tiu chun v kho st xy dng c p dng;
TVTK lp y v trnh Khung tiu chun ca D n c cp c thm quyn
ph duyt. TVTT kin ngh b sung cc ti liu tham kho sau:
+ S tay tnh ton thu vn, thu lc cu ng do Tng Cng ty TVTK GTVT
(TEDI) bin son v c B GTVT xt duyt thng qua nm 2006.;
3.5.5. Khi lng kho st;
TVTK cn thng k lm c s kim tra ni b, nghim thu, thm tra v ph duyt.
3.5.6. Quy trnh, phng php v thit b kho st;
3.5.7. Phn tch s liu, nh gi kt qu kho st;
3.5.8. xut gii php k thut phc v cho vic thit k, thi cng xy dng cng trnh;
3.5.9. Kt lun v kin ngh;
3.5.10. Ti liu tham kho;
3.5.11. Cc ph lc km theo
3.6. V ni dung Thuyt minh chung:
3.6.1. Nhn xt chung:
Qua qu trnh cng lm vic vi TVTK, TVTT c cc kin ngh sau y:

Page 4 of 31

TVTK nn ch n trnh by vn bn, bn v sao cho p mt hn. c . bit l

khng nn dng b font ch TCVN3 m nn chuyn sang dng b font ch Unicode theo
tiu chun Vit Nam TCVN 6909:2001.
Cn phi lp tng mc lc H s v Mc lc ring cho cc tp Thuyt minh, Ph lc,
Bn v...
Nn tch Cc vn bn php l lin quan thnh mt Ph lc ring.
Phi cp nht cc s liu n thi im hin ti, trnh dng cc s liu qu c (qu 5
nm k t ngy lp d n).
Trong cc bc tip theo, TTK cn phi tin hnh tha thun vi cc c quan qun l
lin quan v cc vn pht sinh khc vi bc DAT trong lnh vc ng b, ng st,
ng thy, thy li, in lc, thng tin...
3.6.2. Ni dung Thuyt minh chung :
Xin xem chi tit cc bng trang sau:
Chng IX. Kt lun v kin ngh
IX.1. Kt lun
IX.2. Kin ngh
TVTT ngh phi tip tc b sung chnh sa hon thin H s mi c th trnh
cho cc cp c thm quyn xem xt, ph duyt.
3.7. V ni dung Thit k Bn v thi cng:
Xin xem chi tit cc bng trang sau:

Page 5 of 31

1. Thuyt minh thit k

STT

Hng mc
tham chiu

kin v Nhn xt ca T vn thm tra

T vit tt

- Cha c, nn b sung vo TMTK

Bn v tr D
n

- Cha c, nn b sung vo TM TK

I.1. Tng quan v

D n

- TVTK nn a vo s mng li v t chc giao thng ca

vng

Tr li ca T vn Thit k

Mc

- Quyt nh ph duyt Nhim v KSTK: cha nu;

I.2. Cc cn c
php l

I.4. T chc thc

hin

- Hp ng T vn: cha nu;

- Ton b cc cn c php l trong mc ny cn c chuyn cho
TVTT c c s tham chiu, phc v cng tc thm tra m CT
giao.

Chng I.
Gii thiu
chung

- Nn v thnh s , sau m t mi quan h cng tc

- B sung h s kho st nn mt ng

I.5. Ngun ti liu - Ton b cc h s ti liu s liu trong mc ny cn c

s dng
chuyn cho TVTT c c s tham chiu, phc v cng tc thm
tra m CT giao.
II.1. M t chung

- Nn a Bn hng tuyn v chng ny, xoay 90

phng to hn, ng thi nn in mu d dng hn cho ngi c
phn m t hng tuyn i qua.

II.4. c im
thu vn dc
tuyn

- Cn a Bng thng k mc nc iu tra dc tuyn vo phn

ny

Chng II.
iu kin
t nhin
khu vc
tuyn

Page 6 of 31

II.5. c im a
cht

- Cn a Bng tng hp cc ch tiu c l t vo cui phn ny

II.6. iu kin m
vt liu xy
dng ..

- y cn phi c bn v tr m vt liu xy dng v v tr

thi. Trn bn phi ghi c th v chnh xc cht lng, tr lng,
c ly vn chuyn, cp ng... t cc a im c vt liu ti cng
trng ca d n ny hoc t cng trng ti ni thi.

nghin cu

- Cn nu r l o Benkelman theo TCVN 8867-2011;

- Cn c bng Tng hp kt qu kho st nn mt ng theo chiu
dc tuyn, trong c cc ct Edt, loi mt ng c, chiu dy
III.3. Tnh trng
mt ng c trn mt ng c, din tch h hng nng (khng tn dng c), din
tch h hng nh (c th v sa c trc khi b vnh/tng
tuyn
cng), xut gii php tn dng tng cng / lm mi theo tng
on ngi TK c ci nhn tng quan phc v cho vic nh gi
tnh hp l ca cc gii php thit k tng cng mt ng c;
Chng III. Tnh
trng hin ti ca
tuyn ng

- Nn c mt s hnh nh v hin trng tuyn. minh ho tnh trng

tuyn (cong queo, nh hp, dn c, knh mng..), cc nt giao
(khut tm nhn..), nn mt ng, h thng thot nc, cu cng,
thit b ATGT

Chng
III. Tnh
trng hin
ti ca
tuyn
ng

- Ph hp Q 764/Q-BGTVT ngy 11/04/2012

IV.1. Khung tiu
chun

V.1. Thit k bnh

tuyn

- ngh r sot li cc tiu chun c hiu lc t 2013.

- ngh b sung ti liu tham kho: S tay tnh ton thu vn, thu
lc cu ng do Tng Cng ty TVTK GTVT (TEDI) bin son v
c B GTVT xt duyt thng qua nm 2006.;
Cc thng tin cp trong thuyt minh phi dng trnh by v
cn c / khng ch thit k. Cn c thit k bnh tuyn
cn thiu:
- Cha c tha thun khp ni im u, im cui vi D n
khc.

Chng
IV. Quy
m v tiu
chun k
thut
Chng V.
Gii php
v kt qu
thit k

- Cha c ch gii ng lm cn c cho cc on tuyn i

Page 7 of 31

theo quy hoch.

- TVTK cn b sung Bin bn tho thun khp ni vi cu t;
TVTK lp Bng Thng k Kt qu thit k bnh , theo
tuyn thit k v c bn m bo c cc yu cu k thut theo
TCVN 4054-2005;
Cn c k ng cn thiu:
- Cha c tha thun khp ni cao im u, im cui vi D
n khc.
- Cha c cc vn bn tha thun cn thit v ct cao th TP
Nam nh, TT Lm, cu t cng nh vi cc quy hoch / d n
khc.
V.2. Thit k ct
dc tuyn

- Cha c cc vn bn tha thun vi cc a phng, cc ch u

t lin quan v nt giao, ng giao, cng thy li...
- Cn nu r cao thit k ti tim ng hay vai ng;
- Cha c bng Thng k cao thu vn thit k (mc nc tn
sut / mc nc thng xuyn + chnh cao theo tiu chun) lm
cn c k ng trc dc thit k;
TVTK lp Bng Thng k Kt qu thit k Trc dc, theo ct
dc thit k v c bn m bo c cc yu cu k thut theo
TCVN 4054-2005;

V.3. Thit k ct
ngang tuyn

- Cha c tha thun khp ni im u, im cui vi D n khc.

- TVTK c hnh v minh ha, th hin cc b phn chnh yu v
thit k tng th.
- TVTK cn phi lp Bng Thng k cc phn on Thit k ct
ngang in hnh.
- Cn b sung ct ngang ca on tuyn i trng tuyn N5
(Km88+00-Km88+600). Th hin cc chi tit vut ni mt bng,
ct ngang vo v ra on ny;

Page 8 of 31

V.4. Thit k Kt
cu mt ng
(xem cng phn
Bn v in hnh)

- Trong bc DAT, TVTK c lp lun tnh ton xut pht t

lu lng xe, yu cu ca cp ng nhng cha xt thnh phn
xe nng / vt ti la chn m un n hi ti thiu Eyc cho mt
ng.
- TVTK cha c lp lun tnh ton xut pht t lu lng xe, yu
cu ca cp ng, thnh phn xe nng / vt ti la chn m
un n hi ti thiu Eyc cho mt ng i vi cc ng hon
tr v ng gom.
- Vi cc lp mng ng, trn phn on tch nhnh lm mi v
i st h, p, m ly, bi bi, sng nn nghin cu phng n gia
c mng bng xi mng.
- Nn quy nh Eyc cho KC vut ni dn sinh;
- Nn quy nh Eo cho KC3 v KC vut ni dn sinh;
- TVTK nn b sung kt cu mt ng BTXM trong trm thu ph
v cho cc on c ln tng - gim tc, im dng xe, trm dch v,
cc on c nguy c b ngp / i ven bi bi, nn ng o c
bit....
- Kim ton cha ng (xem bnh lun chi tit Ph lc) nn vic
p dng cc kt cu ca TVTK cha ph hp;
- Ch c 2 KCM tng cng (c Eo>=40Mpa v Eo>=45Mpa) +
lp mng di dy 22cm>18cm (phi phn 2 lp lu ln), cha ph
hp v mt Kinh t-K thut -> Kin ngh thit k cu to trc,
kim ton sau -> s dng lp mng di c cc chiu dy (30, 15,
0cm) kt hp lp mng trn c cc chiu dy (15,0) (tc l s c 4
kt cu tng cng), t tnh ngc ra Eo ti thiu tng ng;
- Chun chnh tn gi ca BTN theo TCVN 8819-2011: BTN cht
ht trung phi ghi l BTNC C19; Ring BTN cht ht mn th
TVTK phi la chn BTNC C12,5 hay BTNC C9,5; Nu cn b
vnh bng BTN th nn dng BTNC C9,5 (khng dung BTN ht th
nh TVTK xut);
Page 9 of 31

- Chun chnh tn gi ca CPDD theo TCVN 8859-2011: lp mng

trn dng CPDD loi I, Dmax25; lp mng di dung CPDD loi
II, Dmax37,5; c bit nn dng CPDD Dmax19 nu cn p dng
cho lp b vnh trn mt ng c;
- Lp b vnh phi cng vi lp vt liu ngay bn trn n, v phi
tun th cc yu cu trong 4.2.1 ca 22 TCN 211-06;
- Nn b sung lp y nn vo bn v thy tnh lin tc hp l
ca kt cu nn mt ng; Kt hp cc yu t: a phng ch c
CPD I (theo TVTK?), ng ch yu qua khu dn c ko nng c
cao , mt ng c h hng nhiu a s lm mi -> TVTT kin
ngh s dng cc lp vt li gia c kt hp vi cc bin php tng E
nn ln 50MPa; ng thi, do Eyc=140MPa ch tng ng vi
phn k u t (hon chnh l 190MPa), TVTT kin ngh dng
BTNC C19 ( dm>=50%, lp di) v BNC C12,5 ( dm
>=35%, lp trn);
- Cn quy nh r cc ch tiu Edh, K, CBR cho cc lp vt liu (k
c nn ng);
- Nn b sung bng v thng k cc on tuyn c Eo v s dng
cc kt cu tng cng tng ng;
V.5.1. Thit k
nn ng thng
thng

- Khng nn dng x b p b pha di lp K98 nh

TVTK xut;
- TVTK nn nu y v r rng v sc chu ti ca cc lp nn
ng theo 7.1.2.1 v tnh bng CBR;.v cht tnh bng K theo
7.6.1 v tha mn yu cu 8.3.7 ca TCVN 4054-2005 hin hnh.
- TVTK cng cn phi b sung thuyt minh v chiu dy lp nn
thng (nn dy 50cm). Cn d kin cc bin php thay t / ci
thin / gia c t t nhin dng cho lp ny v lp di n ( c
th m cht c).
- i vi cc on qua khu vc ao, h, m ly, bi bi c t yu
hoc cc on nn ng o su, p cao, cn tin hnh kho st /
Page 10 of 31

iu tra CCT v kim ton n nh ti nhng v tr c bit ny

c c s k thut i n kt lun l cn / khng cn x l.
- Mc 2.1.b. Ch tiu c l: nn lp thnh bng s trc quan hn
cho ngi TK v thm tra, thm nh;
V.5.2. Thit k
nn ng c
bit qua vng t
yu.

- Mc 2.3 . ngh b sung cc Bn v trc ngang i din x l

t yuvo Thuyt minh ny v tp Bn v in hnh;
- Mc 2.3.c sau mc ny nn thm mc 2.3.d. Tng hp x l t
yu. Trong bng ny b sung thm cc ct thuc phn Kt qu kim
ton khi cha x l (trc phn Ni dung x l trong bng ca )
- TVTK cha c gii php x l nn ng c bit mang tnh t
ph nhm tha mn 2 yu cu i lp: rt ngn tin >< bn vng
cng trnh, nht l vi cc on chuyn tip gia ng vi cu /
cng trnh (VD: gia c t bng xi mng...).

V.6. Thit k nt
giao, ng giao

- TVTK nn lp Bng Thng k nt giao ng giao c cc ct

c thng tin v: loi ng giao ct, cp ng (hin ti v quy
hoch), hnh thc giao ct (ng ba, ng t), tnh khng ngang yu
cu ti thiu.
- TVTK cn c lp lun la chn loi hnh nt, cc yu t hnh hc
ca nt da trn cc c s: quy hoch, d bo lu lng xe, iu
kin t nhin x hi, iu tra / kho st mc phc tp nguy
him, v tha thun vi cc a phng c quan qun l lin
quan.
- Nn dng o xuyn, hn ch phng n nt giao c o git
nc, phng nga vic buc phi dng bin php bt ng t, ng
ba sau ny.
- Qua nghin cu, TVTT cho rng, trong d n ny, TVTK cha
ch n cc vn : m bo tm nhn, tng cng nng lc thng
hnh (khng c cc ln m rng v di bo h cho r phi, r
tri...), nghin cu ci to cc nt nguy him trn tuyn (nt c gc
giao qu nh, nt c ng st i qua, nt hay c tai nn...).
Page 11 of 31

- TVTT kin ngh dng kt cu mt ng BTN ng nht vi

tuyn chnh vut ni vi tt c cc ng ngang .
trnh pht sinh ln, ngh TVTK thuyt minh r hn:
- V tr, phn on, khi lng ca h thng ng ngang ny c
TVTK thit k (hay thng k) da trn c s o c c th hay trn
cc c s khc?
- Cc tha thun vi a phng- c quan hu quan.
V.7. Thit k h
thng thot nc

- ngh dung mc b tong theo n v MPa theo quy nh hin

hnh, khng dng nh TVTK trnh by trong thuyt minh ny v
cc bn v;
- Cc thng s hnh hc ca mng on 3: Knh tiu T4A u
khng ng nh tha thun s 128/SNN&PTNT-CCTL ngy
08/03/2012, do cn phi chun b vn bn tha thun li (c km
bn v v bn tnh thy lc, chng minh m bo kh nng thot
nc theo yu cu ca S NN&PTNT Nam nh;
- TVTK c H s Kho st Thy vn, H s tnh ton thy vn
nhng cn b sung H s Kho st Cng trnh hin trang, lm c s
thit k cho h thng cng trnh thot nc.
- TVTK nn nu r cc gii php x l i vi h thng cng ngang
hin ti khi nng cp, m rng ng ln gp i hin ti.
- TVTK cn gp rt thc hin b sung y cc tha thun cn
thit vi cc a phng c quan qun l lin quan ngay t bc
TKCS v: khu , cao , dc, ci dng.. ca h thng cng
thot nc.
- TVTK lp bng Thng k kt qu thit k, tuy nhin nn b
sung 2 ct Chiu di thit k (lm mi v ni cng) d theo di,
kim tra v a vo cc bc tnh ton v sau trong TMT v
TKCS.
- TVTK cn nghin cu, tha thun v thit k kt ni vi cc cng
trnh h tng k thut ngoi nn ng. Nn tch thnh 1 hng
Page 12 of 31

mc thit k ring.
V.7.3. Thit k
cng trnh cu

- ngh tch thnh 1 hng mc ring: V.8. Thit k cu;

- Cc c s quan trng thit k cu gm H s KS a hnh
a cht Thy vn v H s tnh ton thy vn, kim ton nn
mng c, tuy nhin theo TVTT cn thiu H s Kho st Hin
trng cng trnh cu.
- Phn ln cc cu u c thay th / m rng trong phm vi
trng / st cu c, do TVTK phi lm r gii php thi cng ph
d / tn dng mng c ph hp vi mng cu mi nh th no?
- i vi cc cu thit k mi hon ton, TVTT nhn thy TVTK
cha c tng t ph v kt cu v to im nhn cnh quan
kin trc (V d lan can bng chm tr nh trn QL10 qua Nam
nh).
- ngh thuyt minh r hn v tnh trng cc cu ngh tn
dng: 2 cu trung l Bt Di v Ngm, 1 cu nh l Ch Dn (thng
tin qun l, dnh gi qua th st, ng k o c hin trng cu);
- ngh TVTK nu r l do v sao cng s dng kt cu nhp gin
n L=15m nhng cu Knh Bc dng dm bn BTCT thng, cn
cu Vnh Giang dng dm bn BTCT DL? n gin ha ch
to, TVTT kin ngh s dng dm bn BTCT DL cho nhp gin
n L=15m;
- Cu Vnh Giang Km88+782.25: Vi b rng y sng theo quy
hoch l B=18m, TVTK chn s nhp 3x15m=45m, theo
TVTT l cha hp l v: a) tr nm gia sng, chc chn nh hng
n dng chy v giao thng thu. TVTT kin ngh s dng s
12+21+12=45m hoc 9+24+9=45m, s khc phc c nhc im
trn m khng tng tng chiu di cu; c) Cha c vn bn tho c
th v s nhp v cc gii php thit k vi S NNPTNT Nam
nh; b) TVTK cn c cc tnh ton so snh kinh t - k thut ca
cc phng n s nhp v lp lun chi tit nu vn bo lu PA
Page 13 of 31

ny;
- ngh TVTK b sung v a dng ha cc gii php gia c mi ta
luy ngoi xy (tm b tng c sn, li b tng trng c...)
V.8. Thit k cng
nhm m bo cht lng, rt ngn tin , tng tnh m
trnh phng h
quan...Cng cn xut gii php gia c cc mi ta luy o (nu c
cc b), thay v ch quan tm ta luy p;
- TVTK khng cp n cc ni dung Kim ton ATGT (VD:
kim tra tm nhn trong nt giao, ng giao, ng cong bng v
ng cong ng), ngh b sung;
V.9. Thit k An
ton Giao thng

V.10. H tng k
thut ngoi nn
ng
V.11. Cnh quan
kin trc
V.12. Tng hp
cc ch tiu Kinh
t - K thut
Chng VI. Cng
tc GPMB

- TVTT kin ngh nghin cu b sung cc n tn hiu / vch sn

phc v ngi i b i qua tuyn d n ti TP Nam nh v TT
Lm.
- Ti cc im u, cui tuyn, cc im ra vo cc QL phi c thit
k ring, m bo ATGT khi tng, gim tc.
- TVTK cn nghin cu, tha thun v thit k kt ni vi cc cng
trnh h tng k thut ngoi nn ng. Nn tch thnh 1 hng mc
thit k ring.
- TVTT kin ngh TVTK b sung phn ny tun th cc quy
nh hin hnh, ng thi gip cho Nam nh c 1 cng trnh c
ngha v mt thng hiu.
- TVTT ngh TVTK b sung TNG HP CC CH TIU
KINH T K THUT ny, lm c s so snh vi D n u t,
la chn cc gii php k thut, nh gi cht lng thit k, so
snh vi cc d n tng t, ng thi lm cn c thc hin tnh
ton Tng mc u t.
- Nn chuyn cc ni dung t mc VII.1. GPMB trong chng VII.
T chc XD ln Chng VI. ny;
- Vi ni dung th hin ca TVTK, chng ny ch nn l
Thit k t chc thi cng ch o;
- TVTT kin ngh TVTK b sung s v tr D n, s Mng

Chng
VII. T
chc xy
Page 14 of 31

li giao thng, s M vt liu, S vn chuyn (ng lm

mi, ng c tn dng, bo dng, hon tr), s m bo giao
thng ni tuyn v ngoi tuyn, bn Tng hp ch tiu kinh t kt
hp Biu iu phi o p vt liu theo chiu di tuyn lm
c s cho Thit k T chc thi cng ch o;
- Vi cc cng trnh c bit, cng trnh ln, hng mc ln u cn
c t nht 1 s T chc thi cng Tng th / in hnh;
- i vi tuyn nng cp ci to, i hi vic kim sot cht lng
cht ch, hn ch cc ri ro c th xy ra. Chnh v vy, vic t
chc xy dng nn chia lm hai giai on:
+ Giai on mt: xy dng nn ng, cu, cng v cc cng trnh
bo v, trong phn nn ng phi c lp nn thng (subgrade)
xe my thi cng, ch vt liu c th qua li, qua nhng khim
khuyt nu c ca nn v cc cng trnh s bc l v c khc
phc d dng v kp thi. Hin tng ln theo thi gian nhng
on p cao v nn yu, ln lch gia ng hin ti v lm mi
cng s bc l v c khc phc trc khi lm cc lp kt cu mt
ng.

dng

+ Giai on hai: xy dng cc lp kt cu mt ng v cc cng

trnh ph tr do vy s c iu kin xy dng ht sc thun li,
trnh c s b ng sa cha - chp v.
- Cha c ni dung T chc thi cng cu? TVTK cha cp n
cc gii php v khi lng m bo giao thng cu.
VII.1. Gii phng
mt bng

Nn chuyn thnh K hoch T chc thc hin (ni dung GPMB

chuyn ln chng VI.) bao gm:
- VII.1.1. PHN CHIA GI THU:
+ TVTK xin kin ch o ca CT d kin phn chia gi thu
xy lp theo: l trnh ng v khi lng gi tr xy lp. ng
thi cng phi c cc gi thu v cu; Ngoi ra, TVTK cn lit k
y cc gi thu v Qun l D n, T vn, Kim nh, Chng
Page 15 of 31

nhn s ph hp cht lng, Kim ton, Gii phng mt bng v

Ti nh c....
+ TVTK nn thit k Tr s cng trng sao cho sau ny d dng
tn dng lm c s qun l / Trung tm iu hnh.
- VII.1.2. TIN THC HIN: Trn c s kh nng cung cp
vn v phn chia gi thu, TVTK cn nghin cu lp Bn Tin
thc hin tng th;
VII.2. Cng tc
chun b

- Phi c th v chnh xc ha c cht lng, tr lng, c ly vn

chuyn, cp ng... t cc a im c vt liu ti tng kho
xng, bi tp kt vt liu cng trng ca d n ny.

Mc VII.7. Bin
php bo v mi
trng:

- TVTK c nu tuyn ch yu qua cc khu dn c ng c

TVTT ngh TVTK xem xt li vic s dng lu rung 25T s gy
nh hng g n mi trng sinh sng ca dn c? Bin php khc
phc m bo ng thun ca nhn dn?

Chng VIII.
Tng D ton

- Nn b sung chng ny vo Thuyt minh chung;

T vn thm tra cho rng TVTK phi thc hin chng ny tht cn
trng trong Thuyt minh chung:

Chng
VIII. Tng
D ton

- TVTT tin hnh nghin cu nhng g c v thy cn tn ti

cc vn sau:
- Cha c Thuyt minh v C s lp Tng D ton?;
- Cha lm r c Cu thnh v Phng php lp Tng D ton?.
- Cn c c n gi tng hp i km biu phn tch n gi chi tit?
- Nu TVTK la chn phng php tnh ton tng d ton trn
bn v thit k BTVT v bc tch khi lng chi tit th khi lng
ca TKBVTC cha c y v chun xc tng ng vi cc
gii php k thut ph hp. c cc c quan lin quan chp nhn
hoc c TVTK gii trnh.
TVTT kin ngh Ch u t ch o TVTK lp TngD ton nh
sau:
Page 16 of 31

Cc cn c lp n gi chi tit cn cp nht y cc vn bn

hng dn hin hnh:
- Ngh nh s 112/2009/N-CP ngy 14/12/2009 ca Chnh ph v
qun l chi ph u t xy dng cng trnh;
- Thng t s ./????/TT-BXD ngy ??/??/20?? ca B Xy dng
hng dn lp v qun l chi ph u t xy dng cng trnh;
- Quyt nh s 957/Q-BXD ngy 29/9/2009 ca B Xy dng
cng b nh mc chi ph qun l d n v t vn u t xy dng
cng trnh;

VIII.1. C s
lp Tng D ton

- Thng t s 36/2009/TT-BLTBXH ngy 13/11/2009 ca B lao

ng TBXH v hng dn thc hin mc lng ti thiu vng i
vi doanh nghip, hp tc x, lien hip hp tc x, t hp tc, trang
tri, h gia nh, c nhn v cc t chc khc ca Vit nam c thu
mn lao ng;
- nh mc d ton XDCT phn xy dng v lp t cng b km
theo vn bn s ????/BXD-VP v ????/BXD-VP ngy ??/??/20??
ca B Xy dng;
- Bng gi ca my v thit b thi cng tnh Nam nh ban hnh km
theo Quyt nh s ??/20??/Q-UBND ngy ??/??/20?? ca UBND
tnh Nam nh;
- Cng b gi vt liu xy dng s ??/2010/CBGVL-LS
ngy ??/??/20?? ca lin s XD-TC tnh Nam inh;
- Cc vn bn php l khc quy nh v thu GTGT, Bo him cng
trnh; thm tra ph duyt quyt ton ca nh nc.

VIII.2. Cu thnh
v phng php
lp D ton

- Thnh phn h s phi c biu phn tch n gi chi tit, n gi

tng hp ca cc hng mc cng vic, c bng tnh kinh ph xy lp
cho tng cu.
- Tng mc u t d n phi c xy dng theo ng hng dn
ca Thng t s ???/20??/TT-BXD ngy ??/??/20?? v Quyt nh
s ???/Q-BXD ngy ??/??/20?? ca B Xy dng.
Page 17 of 31

- TVTK nn chn phng php tnh ton tng mc u t trn bn

v thit k BVTC v bc tch khi lng chi tit.
Tuy nhin, c nhng vn cn b sung lm r:
- ngh nghin cu nhng ng gp kin v cc vn k thut
m TVTT nu cc phn trn v bn v TK chi tit sau phn ny,
v khng nhng c tc ng n cht lng ca cng trnh d n,
to iu kin d dng thun li cho vic xy dng, ch ng v tin
, gim thiu cc ri ro trong xy dng ng thi l cn c xc
nh tng d ton mt cch thuyt phc v chnh xc.
- Trong kt cu tng d ton xc nh, trong chi ph qun l
d n theo ch hin hnh rt thp, rt kh khn cho vic thu cn
b gim st, cc k s c cht lng v trnh cao tham gia phc
v em li hiu qu nh nh u t mong mun. y l vn
cn c nghin cu gii quyt thch hp bng cch: so snh tnh
ton cc chi ph t vn qun l, t vn KSTK, t vn gim st theo
thng l quc t (cng chuyn gia theo quy nh hin hnh) nhm
nng cao cht lng tin .
- Hin ti, i vi nhng d n nhm A nghnh GTVT phi c
thit k ba bc.
- ngh TVTK nghin cu b sung cc chi ph sau vo phn chi
ph khc: Chi ph cho vic khi cng, khnh thnh; Tuyn truyn
Qung co; L ph ngn hng (l ph qua cc ln thanh ton tin);
Chi ph bo m an ton v v sinh mi trng
- Chi ph bo him cng trnh: nu trong d n c cu ln, do
ngh TVTK tnh tch phn bo him ca hng mc cu v hng
mc ng (VD: i vi cu t l mua bo him theo Quyt nh
s 33/2004/Q-BTC l 0,63% v ng l 0,42%).
- Nu phi vn dng cc vn bn php l ht hiu lc thi hnh,
TVTK cn lp lun hng gii trnh v bo v trc s thm nh
ca cc c quan Nh nc c thm quyn.
Page 18 of 31

- Trong phn thuyt minh cng nh trong bng tnh d ton, TVTK
cn ch r cc v tr m vt liu, tr lng cng nh cha tin hnh
th nghim vt liu ti m. V vy, c ly vn chuyn khai thc vt
liu v p trong D ton cha y c s.
- i vi cc khi lng vn chuyn t i, TVTK cng cha
ch ra c v tr v c ly cc bi thi, v tr din tch cc bi
thi cn c s chp thun ca chnh quyn a phng, v vy
cha y c s TVTK tnh ton c ly vn chuyn t khng
thch hp.
- i vi cc khi lng t p tn dng li, ngh TVTK cn
tnh ton c th, v theo TVTT cc khi lng p tn dng phi
c th nghim v c quyt nh bi T vn gim st hin
trng trong qu trnh thi cng.
- T vn cn lp K hoch gii ngn tng th lm cn c tnh ton;
VIII.3. Phng
thc thc hin

Ph lc

- y l H s BVTC, TVTK cng nn c cc Bng biu v K

hoch Tng th v huy ng my mc, trang thit b, nhn s, vt
liulm r tnh hp l ca cc bin php t chc thi cng ch
o, to iu kin so snh la chn v hng dn nh thu thc
hin.
- ngh b sung bng tnh khi lng chi tit phn nn, mt
ng, gia c mi taluy bng hc xyvv;
- Cc bng kim ton kt cu o ng cn ghi r tn KC? Tng
ng tp Bn v in hnh; Tha bn kim ton KC2 nhng thiu
KC3; Ch tiu c l cc loi BTN mn / trung, CPDD I/II ly nh
nhau l khng ph hp; Cn 1 s li chnh t c KCS ni b
TVTK ch ra nhng ko sa?;
- ngh b sung cc bn Kim ton x l nn ng c bit (c
bit l phn ng cc tre), kt cu rnh / cng , , ca phai, mng
thu li BTCT ....;khng c trong cc Thit k nh hnh c
c quan Nh nc c thm quyn ph duyt; Tuy nhin, TVTK
ghi ti trng TK cng l HL93 nn s phi kim ton li cc kt cu
Page 19 of 31

tham kho Thit k nh hnh;

- y l bc TK BVTC, do cn b sung cc Bng Tin
thi cng Tng th, iu phi t;

2. Bn v in hnh
STT
1

Hng mc tham
chiu

kin v Nhn xt ca T vn thm tra

S bn v

Khng c s bn v, ngh b sung

T vit tt

Cha c, nn b sung vo TMTK

Bn
hng tuen
2

Tr li ca T vn Thit k

Mc

Cha c, nn b sung vo TM TK
- Cha m bo yu cu trong 4.2.4 ca 22 TCN 211-06: kt cu
mt ng m rng phi gi ln kt cu mt ng c 50cm;

- Ct ngang i
din

- Mi dc bn tri dung vt liu no p bao;

- p dng cho
on ngoi khu
dn c

- t bao l loi t g, nhng ch p thp vn dng p bao?

- Nn quy nh v cht ca t p bao;

- Phn o t khng thch hp nh trn bn v c th s ct qu
nhiu vo nn ng c -> ngh b sung phn o cp.
- Nn b sung v tr cc cc GPMB v MLG trn ct ngang in
hnh

p dng cho
on ngoi qua
khu ng dn c
on trng tuyn
N5

- Theo bn v ca TVTK th khng tng cng mt ng c?

ngh TVTK lm r im ny
- Nn b sung ct ngang ca on tuyn ny (Km88+00Km88+600);
Page 20 of 31

- Th hin cc chi tit vut ni mt bng, ct ngang vo v ra on

ny;

Nn c bit

- Cha c trong H s giao np; Nn b tr vo Tp Bn v in

hnh v ngay sau ct ngang i din nn ng thng thng;

Kt cu o ng

- Nn quy nh Eyc cho KC vut ni dn sinh;

- Nn quy nh Eo cho KC3 v KC vut ni dn sinh;
- Ch c 2 KCM tng cng (c Eo>=40Mpa v Eo>=45Mpa) +
lp mng di dy 22cm>18cm (phi phn 2 lp lu ln), cha ph
hp v mt Kinh t-K thut -> Kin ngh thit k cu to trc,
kim ton sau -> s dng lp mng di c cc chiu dy (30, 15,
0cm) kt hp lp mng trn c cc chiu dy (15,0) (tc l s c 4
kt cu tng cng), t tnh ngc ra Eo ti thiu tng ng;
- Chun chnh tn gi ca BTN theo TCVN 8819-2011: BTN cht
ht trung phi ghi l BTNC C19; Ring BTN cht ht mn th
TVTK phi la chn BTNC C12,5 hay BTNC C9,5; Nu cn b
vnh bng BTN th nn dng BTNC C9,5 (khng dung BTN ht th
nh TVTK xut);
- Chun chnh tn gi ca CPDD theo TCVN 8859-2011: lp mng
trn dng CPDD loi I, Dmax25; lp mng di dung CPDD loi
II, Dmax37,5; c bit nn dng CPDD Dmax19 nu cn p dng
cho lp b vnh trn mt ng c;
- Lp b vnh phi cng vi lp vt liu ngay bn trn n, v phi
tun th cc yu cu trong 4.2.1 ca 22 TCN 211-06;
- Nn b sung lp y o ng vo bn v thy tnh lin tc
hp l ca kt cu nn - mt ng; Kt hp cc yu t: a phng
ch c CPD I (theo TVTK?), ng ch yu qua khu dn c ko
nng c cao , mt ng c h hng nhiu a s lm mi ->
TVTT kin ngh s dng cc lp vt li gia c kt hp vi cc bin
php tng E nn ln 50MPa; ng thi, do Eyc=140MPa ch tng
ng vi phn k u t (hon chnh l 190MPa), TVTT kin ngh
Page 21 of 31

dng BTNC C19 ( dm>=50%, lp di) v BNC C12,5 ( dm

>=35%, lp trn);
- Cn quy nh r cc ch tiu Edh, K, CBR cho cc lp vt liu (k
c nn ng);
- Nn b sung bng v thng k cc on tuyn c Eo v s dng
cc kt cu tng cng tng ng;
- Nn b tr ngay sau cc bn v kt cu mt ng;
- Nn kt hp vi bn v Ct ngang i din on gia c mi
taluy p (sau bn v Cu to b va o dn hng);
- Nn thay lp dm di lp xy bng VKT loi khng dt
v d thi cng hn; cht lng ng u; m bo c tc dng
lc ngc chng ht t nn ng b ko ra ngoi, gi thnh r
hn;

Gia c mi ta luy
p; v
Ct ngang i
din on gia
c mi taluy p

- Cn nu r loi t dng p bao di lp gia c hc xy. Yu

cu phi l loi t c th thot nc c t trong nn ng ra
ngoi;
- Phi o cp mi taluy nn ng hin ti trc khi m rng
gia c;
- Cn nu r khi dung khm c thay vng c th c cn dung ghim
tre na khng?
- Quy nh r kch c hc dung chn chn khay, m bo yu
cu v cu to v chng xi;
- Trong bng Thng k phm vi gia c mi ta luy, sau ct Chiu di
nn chn them cc ct Khi lng o / p gia c (tng hp
theo tng on);

Cu to b va
o dn hng

- Nn chuyn ln trc cc bn v in hnh kt cu thot nc,

cng vi phn bn v ATGT;
- B sung b va v tr ngi i b c th i qua o;
- Bn v ca TVTK khng th hin lp cch nc / h thng thot
Page 22 of 31

nc ma v nc ti ngm qua lp t mu trng cy. ngh

lm r nc s ngm xung nn ng / chy trn qua mt ng /
qua h thng rnh xng c tp trung v h thu / rnh / cng thot
nc;
- Cn xem xt xem ln ca o dn hng, nu khng ln th
khng nn b tr t trng cy, bt tin cho thot nc v sinh
trng t nhin ca cy; Theo chng ti th nn thm ht BTN ton
nt, xp tm b va o, theo di, iu chnh trc khi c nh b
va v BTXM ton b mt o;

Cu to rnh
BTCT chu lc B
= 50cm

- Tm BCT lm np y nn lm theo hnh long mng, lm gia

thu nc t 2 bn: t mt ng v t pha nh dn; Nu lm tm
c mt phng nh TVTK th phi b tr mt tm dc nghing t
pha nh dn vo pha mt ng;
- Nn b sung in hnh h ga ni vi cng ngang;
- B sung bn kim ton kt cu vo Ph lc TMTK;

Cc bn v Cng
hp
Mt ct ngang
mng thu li
BxH=0,9x1,2m

- Nn ghi r tn nh hnh p dng, nu khng phi b sung bn

kim ton kt cu;
- Cn phi thit k np y BTCT chu lc 1 s v tr c ng
ngang dn sinh;
- B sung hnh v chi tit o m mng / p tr;
- B sung khi lng n v o / p trong bn khi lng 1m di;
- B sung bn kim ton kt cu vo Ph lc TMTK;

Cu to mng
BTCT B=2m

- Cn v ring 2 bn v cho loi c H=1,5m v H=2m (v y l

BVTC);
- Cn phi thit k np y BTCT chu lc 1 s v tr c ng
ngang dn sinh;
- B sung hnh v chi tit o m mng / p tr;
- B sung khi lng dm, BTCT M150# v cc tre.
- B sung khi lng n v o / p trong bn khi lng 1m di;
Page 23 of 31

- B sung bn kim ton kt cu vo Ph lc TMTK;

- Bc ln xung khng cn lm tng bin, hn ch kh nng nng
dn mang vc c ln xung rung -> lm bc ni trn ng
mi dc thay v lm chm nh bn v ca TVTK;
Bc ln xung
B=2m

- Nn b tr ng dc gia dt xe my, xe p, xe th s;
- B sung cc hnh v th hin chi tit cu to, bng khi lng n
v 1md;
- B sung bn kim ton kt cu vo Ph lc TMTK, c bit l ti
cc v tr c s dng np bn BTCT;
- Nn thit k in hnh ca x nc, u cng c / khng c khe
phai;

Cha c

- y l bc TK BVTC, do cn b sung cc bn v phc v

Thit k t chc thi cng ch o nh: Bn v tr m vt liu v
ng vn chuyn, m bo giao thng ni ngoi tuyn, cc bn
v S cng ngh thi cng chnh yu (o/p/Mt
ng/Cng/Mng) ;

3. Tiu chun k thut

STT

Hng mc tham
chiu

kin v Nhn xt ca T vn thm tra

Tr li ca T vn Thit k

Mc

Page 24 of 31

4. kin c th
STT

Hng mc tham
chiu

Bn v thit k
ct dc

Bn v thit k
ct ngang chi tit

kin v Nhn xt ca T vn thm tra

Tr li ca T vn Thit k

Mc

- R sot cao thit k trc dc m bo ph hp tn xut thy

vn thit k v m bo khng b nh hng bi mc nc ng
thng xuyn theo ng quy trnh, quy phm hin hnh;.
- Cc on p thp phi b tr rnh dc thot nc (VD:
Km99+160-Km180, Km99+220-Km99+240).
- Phi th hin hng nc chy, v tr x ca rnh dc trn bnh
v ct dc thit k, ngh b sung cc dng rnh tri / phi trn
ct dc;
- ngh chun chnh tn cc hng mc ghi trn hnh v theo ng
cc quy inh hin hnh: b tng nha, cp phi dm, mc
BTXM
- Ti nhng on i theo tuyn c c E nn ng c qu thp
TVTK o b mt ng c thay bng kt cu mi l hp l.
Tuy nhin do vic o b mt ng c + o thay t K98 v K95
dn n vic o khun ng su (trung bnh 1.1m) m TVTK
ang o thng l rt kh thi cng, ngh TVTK cho o mng c
dc (nn l 1/0.25) cng vic thi cng c thun li v m
bo cht lng lu ln nn ng.
- X l th no khi TK cao vai ng cao hn nh dn (VD:
on Km93-:-Km93+600, mp vai ng bn phi a phn u TK
cao hn nh dn) khc phc, ngh TVTK nghin cu kt
hp: gim cao trc dc + tng dc ngang ca nn mt ng +
gia c cc lp vt liu o ng
- Cc on nn ng p ln mng hin ti, phi TK hon tr
(VD: on mng ni ng t Km93+96-:-Km93+140.)
- Thng k x l t yu gia Thuyt minh chung (mc 2.3 chng
V) v Ct ngang TK chi tit c ch khng khp nhau. VD: Thng
k: on 22 t Km92+805 n Km93+820 ghi Khng x l tuy
nhin CNTK th li c x l o thay t kt hp VKT ko dt;
hoc Thng k ch ghi chung chung Km93+820-:-Km94+120, o
Page 25 of 31

Bn v thit k
cng

Thuyt minh

Bn v

x l phn p cp nhng CNTK li x l ng cc tre kt hp

thay t v vi KT
- Cn quy nh r sc chu ti R ca t nn di y mng.
- Kim ton phng n khng x l t yu lm r s cn thit
phi s dng mng cc tre, mng cc BTCT; ngh lm r ti
sao khng lm nh thng nht trc y ca Cc G v S GTVT
Nam inh: trc tin x l nn c bit cho ti khi t ln cho
php mi o nn thi cng cng, gim kinh ph lm mng (VD:
cng hp 2,5x2,0 Km88+840 s dng mng cc BTCT, trong khi
TK x l t yu y ch l thay t cu to);
- Kim ton mng cc tre, mng cc BTCT; C nht thit lc no
cng phi s dng 25 cc tre/ m2?
- Lm r l do ti sao ch x l mng cc phn thn cng m
khng thc hin cho phn u, tng cnh, sn cng?
- Thuyt minh thiu yu t hnh hc.
- Thiu tiu chun k thut ca gi cu, thp, b tng...
- Cu Vnh Giang Km88+782.25: Vi b rng y sng theo quy
hoch l B=18m, TVTK chn s nhp 3x15m=45m, theo
TVTT l cha hp l v: a) tr nm gia sng, chc chn nh hng
n dng chy v giao thng thu. TVTT kin ngh s dng s
12+21+12=45m hoc 9+24+9=45m, s khc phc c nhc im
trn m khng tng tng chiu di cu; c) Cha c vn bn tho c
th v s nhp v cc gii php thit k vi S NNPTNT Nam
nh; b) TVTK cn c cc tnh ton so snh kinh t - k thut ca
cc phng n s nhp v lp lun chi tit nu vn bo lu PA
ny;
- ngh TVTK nu r cn c chn ti trng thit k cu tm;
- Cao ct a cht khng khp vi cao y knh quy hoch.
- Trc dc cu yu cu b sung thm yu t ng cong bng.
- Bn v chi tit ng thot nc v b tr chung kt cu nhp (1/2)
ghi khong cch ng thot nc khng ng.
- Bn v bn mt cu b sung thm kch thc chiu dc cu pha
cn li do cu cong.
- Do cu cho nn dm khng i xng nn v ring tng dm.

Tp: Thit
k Bn v
thi cng
Cu Vinh
Giang
Km88+78
2.25

Page 26 of 31

Bn tnh

Cu Knh T5-5
Km90+667

- Bn mt cu cn nghin cu li ct thp theo hng ngang cu:

Theo iu 9.7.1.3 nu gc cheo vt qu 25 th phi b tr ct
thp theo hng vung gc chu lc chnh. ngh b tr li theo
phng vung gc.
- Bt u dm ngi ta dng sikadur ch khng dng epoxy
- Vn khun to l ca dm bng vt liu g?
- Th t bn v khc vi mc lc.
- Cu to k gi trn m M3 u? (Bn v ch ghi cho m M0).
- Bn v b tr chung kt cu nhp th hin mt ct I-I, II-II ch
no.
- Ct thp x m v k gi (2/2) ghi sai mt ct II-II, kch thc
khng khp vi mt bng gi cu.
- Cc bn v lan can, k gi cn ghi r kch thc trong ngoc
(...) dng cho ci g?
- Kch thc bu lng kim tra li: Chi tit A& B khng khp vi
chi tit bu lng.
- Bn v lan can khng c chi tit ct lan can c.
- Xem li kch thc cc ni cc khoan nhi bn xe dng cho D32.
- V tr ng siu m trn mt ct ngang cc nm v tr no?
- Khi lng b tng cc khoan nhi cha tr ng siu m
- Mt bng cng trng khng th hin v tr bi c dm khng th
xc nh c phng n thi cng dm, lp d ton.
- Thiu bng tnh dm.
- Thiu kim ton cc khoan nhi theo ct v ng sut thp.
- Bng tnh x m khng kim tra ng sut thp trong b tng
khng ch nt. Sc khng un, ct tha nhiu.
- Bng tnh x m mt ct A-A, B-B khng phi cnh hng.
- Ct thp ng ca g lan can D=14 c m bo kh nng chu lc
khng ngh b sung bng tnh.
- Cao mt cu 2m93? ngh i chiu vi ct dc TK ng
- Cao y dm nn nng ln l 1m66 (bng cao b knh thit
k);
- Vut ni ng ngang ngay st u m cu, chnh cao ~1m5
nhng chiu di vut ch ~20m (dc dc >4%) -> to nn cc im
Page 27 of 31

nguy him khng ng c -> TVTT kin ngh dch chuyn im

u ni ra xa khi u cu v tng chiu di vut m bo dc dc
<=4%. y l BVTC, ngh TVTK trin khai bn v ct dc v
ct ngang cc ng vut ni ny;
- Cn tnh ton v a ng cao xi chung, xi cc b vo bn
v B tr chung cu -> xem xt tnh hp l ca cc cao y b
m / tr, th hin cc bin php chng xi trn cc bn v cn thit;
- Mt ng phi chnh sa cc vn tng t phn TK ng;
- Cng phi thit k cng nh hnh, cng gii php nh H s
ng; Chnh chun li cc vn tn gi vt liu, n v o nh
T vn ch ra Thuyt minh chung; Cng hp BTCT 1x1m5
nn lm theo trnh t: trc tin x l nn c bit cng nn ng
u cu cho ti khi t ln cho php mi o nn thi cng cng,
gim kinh ph lm mng; ngh TVTK cung cp bn kim ton
kt cu cng;
- ngh thit k ct dc ci mng, cn c vo thit k cao
y cng hp;
- Cha thy TVTK nu bin php thi, thanh thi , c ly, khi
lng vn chuyn.
- Cha c bn Kim ton t yu 2 u cu tuyn chnh, kim ton
mng chn khay gia c t nn;
- Cha c bn Kim ton cu tm, ng tm (c th s pht sinh
khi lng x l t yu, b ln..);
- ngh TVTK nu r cn c chn ti trng thit k cu tm;
Cu Knh T3-6
Km91+124.50
Cu Knh Bc
Km98+766.40

- ngh r sot cc ni dung tng t cu Knh T5-5

- Khng th hin cao y dm trn B tr chung (min>=2.91m);
- Vut ni ng ngang ngay st u m cu, chnh cao 1m nhng
chiu di vut ch ~10m (dc dc 10%) -> to nn cc im nguy
him khng ng c -> TVTT kin ngh dch chuyn im u ni
ra xa khi u cu v tng chiu di vut m bo dc dc <=4%.
y l BVTC, ngh TVTK trin khai bn v ct dc v ct ngang
cc ng vut ni ny;
- Cn tnh ton v a ng cao xi chung, xi cc b vo bn
Page 28 of 31

v B tr chung cu -> xem xt tnh hp l ca cc cao y b

m / tr, th hin cc bin php chng xi trn cc bn v cn thit;
- Mt ng phi chnh sa cc vn tng t phn TK ng;
- Cng ni D750 phi thit k cng nh hnh, cng gii php nh
H s ng; Chnh chun li cc vn tn gi vt liu, n v o
nh T vn ch ra Thuyt minh chung; Ngoi ra ngh lm
r c x l t yu i y mng cng ko? Theo TVTT th ring
i vi cng ni ny, nn ng cc tre trc khi thi cng mng
hn ch kh nng ln lch gia 2 on c mi ca cng; ngh
TVTK cung cp bn kim ton cng t nn y mng cng;
- Cha thy TVTK nu bin php thi, thanh thi , c ly, khi
lng vn chuyn.
- Cha c bn Kim ton t yu 2 u cu tuyn chnh, kim ton
mng chn khay gia c t nn;
- Cha c bn Kim ton cu tm, ng tm (c th s pht sinh
khi lng x l t yu, b ln..);
- ngh TVTK nu r cn c chn ti trng thit k cu tm;

5. Cc vn khc
STT

Hng mc tham
chiu
Thnh phn h s

kin v Nhn xt ca T vn thm tra

Tr li ca T vn Thit k

- H s giao np cho TVTT cn thiu nhiu thnh phn v hng

mc, ngh b sung gp

Mc
Ton b
H s

6. Kt lun
STT

Hng mc tham
chiu

kin v Nhn xt ca T vn thm tra

Tr li ca T vn Thit k

Mc

- ngh TVTK nghin cu cc vn tng th nu chnh

sa v cp nht vo cc hng mc thit k chi tit;
- TVTT s tip tc xem cc hng mc thit k chi tit sau khi TVTK
c phn hi v tho lun thng nht v cc vn nu ra;
Page 29 of 31

Page 30 of 31

IV.

XUT CA T VN THM TRA :

T vn thm tra c c s nghin cu, bo co trnh Ch u t kt lun i vi H
s Thit k Bn v thi cng D n ci to, nng cp QL38B on QL10 QL1A, giai on
1 lp thng 3/2013, ngh T vn thit k b sung / chnh sa cc hng mc sau:

Cc hng mc cn cha tun th quy nh hin hnh nh ch ra.

R sot li ton b khi lng cng trnh;

TT

Tn chuyn gia

V tr m nhim

S nm kinh nghim

Hong Trng c

Ch tr thm tra D n

24

Nguyn S Hin

Thm tra Kho st a hnh

28

Nguyn c Duy

Thm tra Kho st Tnh ton Thy vn

12

L Thanh Bnh

Thm tra Kho st a cht cng trnh

23

Phm Vn Qun

Thm tra ng v h tng k thut

12

Nguyn Th Nh Mai

Thm tra cu v kt cu

15

Nguyn Vn Bnh

Thm tra Thit k a k thut

16

ng Mnh Dng

Thm tra Kin trc - Cnh quan

13

Lng Th Yn Ha

Thm tra GPMB, Ti nh c & Hiu qu x hi

16

10

Nguyn Tn Dn

Thm tra nh gi tc ng mi trng

17

11

Phm Thu Thy

Thm tra K hoch - T chc thc hin

14

12

H Th Hng

Thm tra Tng mc u t Hiu qu BT

15

13

Nguyn Thu Hng

Thm tra Hiu qu Ti chnh Huy ng vn

P. Gim c Cng ty

HONG TRNG C

Page 31 of 31