Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
1/97)
Saya
(HURUF BESAR)
mengaku membenarkan tesis (PSM/Sarjana/Doktor Falsafah)* ini disimpan di Perpustakaan
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia dengan syarat-syarat kegunaan seperti berikut:
1.
2.
3.
4.
SULIT
TERHAD
TIDAK TERHAD
Disahkan oleh
________________________________
(TANDATANGAN PENULIS)
________________________________
(TANDATANGAN PENYELIA)
Alamat tetap:
SS26/21,TAMAN MAYANG JAYA __
_69,
_________________________________
PETALING JAYA, _____________
_47301
______________________
Nama Penyelia
Tarikh:
21 APRIL 2006
Tarikh :
21 APRIL 2006
CATATAN:
I hereby declare that I have read this thesis and in my opinion this thesis is
sufficient in terms of scope and quality for the award of the degree of civil
engineering.
Signature
Name of Supervisor :
Date
21 APRIL 2006
This Thesis is submitted as a partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of
the Bachelor Degree in Civil Engineering
APRIL, 2006
ii
Signature
..
Name
Date
21 APRIL 2006
iii
IV
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First and foremost, the author would like to take this golden opportunity to
thank Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ramli Nazir for his time, advice, continuous support and
guidance throughout the research period. He has shown great faith in me and has
been very supportive throughout the research. Without his direct supervision and
patience, the research would probably come to a halt.
Besides, token of appreciation will also be given to the authors parents and
family members for their everlasting emotional support, love and patience towards
the accomplishment of the study. This work could not have been completed without
their unconditional support.
The author would also extend his warmest appreciation to the devoted
professionals at Polyfelt Asia Sdn. Bhd and Road Builder (M) Sdn. Bhd. Thank you
for the knowledge and hospitality during my visit to both the company respectively.
It was a great learning experience for me.
ABSTRAK
VI
ABSTRACT
vii
TABLE OF CONTENT
CHAPTER
II
TITLE
PAGE
TITLE
DECLARATION
ii
DEDICATION
iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
iv
ABSTRAK
ABSTRACT
vi
TABLE OF CONTENT
vii
LIST OF TABLE
LIST OF FIGURE
xi
LIST OF SYMBOL
xii
INTRODUCTION
1.1
Introduction
1.2
Problems Statement
1.3
1.4
Scope of Research
1.5
Significance of Research
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1
Introduction
2.2
History of Geotextile
2.3
Classification of Slope
2.4
10
biodegradable Geotextile
viii
2.5
11
2.6
14
2.7
14
Geotextile
2.8
2.9
III
16
2.8.1 UV Resistance
16
17
18
18
METHODOLOGY
21
3.1
21
3.2
21
Study
IV
3.3
22
3.4
22
CASE STUDY
23
4.1
Introduction
23
4.2
24
4.3
25
4.4
Installation of Geotextile
25
4.5
26
Rehabilitation
29
5.1
Introduction
29
29
30
30
5.2
31
5.3
34
(PLAXIS) Software
ix
5.4
VI
Results
35
35
38
41
6.1
Introduction
41
6.2
Discussion
41
6.3
Conclusion
42
6.4
Recommendation
43
REFERENCE
44
LIST OF TABLE
No. Table
2.1
Title
Page
37
xi
LIST OF FIGURES
No. Figure
Title
Page
2.1
2.2
19
2.3
20
2.4
20
Steep Slopes
4.1
28
5.1
32
5.2
33
35
5.4
36
5.5
37
5.6
38
5.7
38
5.8
39
5.9
39
5.10
40
5.11
40
xii
LIST OF SYMBOL
HT
HL
Localised Height
Flow Rate
Kp
Hg
Thickness of Geotextile
FS
Factor of Safety
Ni
wi cos
wi
Weight of Slice
Slice
R
Ti
yi
Number of Slices;
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
2
1.2 Problem Statement
Due to the rapid growth of the industry, hills and forests are being torn apart
to cater for the needs of the industry, for instance construction of railways, highways,
infrastructures, etc. Besides, the construction of residential buildings on hill site has
increased tremendously for the last 15 years due to the depleting flat land and other
influencing factors such as fresh air, beautiful scenery, exclusiveness etc.
The truth is hill site development is safe with proper planning, design,
construction and maintenance. Engineers whom have good engineering expertise on
soil or rock in slopes and foundation stability design are usually engaged in
construction projects. The main priority is to safeguard the safety of the public from
landslide hazards.
On the other hand, gravitational forces are always acting on the mass of soil
or rock beneath a slope. If the strength of the mass is less than gravitational forces,
the forces are imbalance and not in equilibrium mode. Movement of mass will occur
which leads to landslide. Slope failures can range from being a temporary nuisance
3
by partially closing a roadway, to destroying structures, to being catastrophic and
even burying cities.
1.3
1.4
Scope of Research
4
Automobile Workshop, Mechanical Faculty, UTM Skudai. The analysis is based on
research and reports obtained, either directly nor indirectly from relevant party and
authority. In general, the effectiveness of geotextile as a means of soil reinforcement
in slope rehabilitation will be reviewed.
1.5
Significance of Research
CHAPTER II
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
The tensile strength of the geotextile is also important. From scientific research,
it appears that to obtain the highest tensile resistance from a material, the best way is
to use it in the form of fibres, which have a high degree of molecular orientation.
6
2.2 History of Geotextile
The Chinese have used wood, bamboo and straw to strengthen soil for thousands
of years. The importance of soil reinforcement in ancient China is demonstrated by
the fact that the Chinese symbol for Civil Engineering simply means earth and
wood. At that time, portions of the Great Wall of China was constructed using the
soil reinforcement concept. The concept of soil reinforcement method was brought to
Japan and the use of natural materials for stabilization purposes continued to this
decade.
The Romans used reed, wood and animal hides for soil reinforcement during the
Middle Ages. The Dutch, below of the low land and in their age old battle with the
sea, made extensive use of willow fascines to reinforce dikes and to protect
themselves against wave action. Construction of dams to shorten the coastline was
carried out and this action is still on going till this century, culminating with Delta
Project.
7
2.3 Classification of Slopes
According to the Institute Engineering of Malaysia (IEM), slope for hill site
development can be classified into 3 classes and the necessary requirements and
characteristics are as follows:
8
non-technical personnel in our local authorities, simple geometry has been selected
as the basis of risk classification.
9
Table 2.1 Classification of Risk of Landslide on Hill-Site
Development (after IEM, 2000)
10
2.4 Comparisons between Biodegradable and Non-biodegradable Geotextile
For the past few years, geotextile has played a major and significant role in
geo-environmental engineering applications. Woven and non-woven geotextile are
widely used in applications such as soil stabilization, turf reinforcement, erosion
control, separation, filtration and drainage.
Geotextile can be classified into two types, biodegradable and nonbiodegradable geotextile. Biodegradable geotextile are made of natural fibres, for
example penduculata fibre, or Raffia Vinifera, was obtained by drying raffia palm
fronds in the sun and then beating the raffia fronds with a piece of wood to create the
fibre. Non-biodegradable geotextile are made of synthetic materials, for example
polyesters and polypropylene.
11
However, in terms of better slope protection, the polypropylene geotextile
was more effective (lower cover factor values) compared to penduculata geotextile
although the run-off velocity measured for polyprolene geotextile at slope was high.
The performance difference may be attributed to differences in Percentage Open
Area (POA) values between polyprolene and penduculata geotextile.
Despite of this, natural fibre geotextile has potential and has a role in
geotechnical engineering. The potential use was shown in the Manchester, United
Kingdom, airport rail link construction project (Ellis 1993) where a naturally
occurring biodegradable erosion and soil stabilization mat was successfully installed.
A geotextile can perform several functions. The need for identifying and
describing geotextile functions appeared when geotextile began to be used in a
variety of applications. Before design can take its place, it is very important to
identify the functions required of the geotextile in the considered application. A
geotextile function is a specialized action of the geotextile which is required to
achieve a design purpose and results from a unique combination of geotextile
properties.
Q
h
= kp Hg
L
L'
12
where Q = rate of flow (m3/s)
L = length of the cross section of geotextile perpendicular to the flow
direction (m)
kp = coefficient of permeability of the geotextile in its plane (m/s)
Hg = thickness of the geotextile (m)
h = hydraulic head loss (m)
L = length of geotextile parallel to the flow direction (m)
b.) Filtration. A geotextile acts as a filter when it allows liquid to pass normal to its
own plane, while preventing most soil particles from being carried away by the
liquid current. There are three cases to be considered: filter for particles
suspended in a liquid, filter for removing water from a granular soil and filter
associated with armor.
Filter for particles suspended in a liquid: the geotextile is placed across a flow of
liquid carrying fines particles in suspension; the function of the geotextile is to
stop the fine particles while allowing water to go through it.
Filter for removing water from granular soil: the geotextile is placed between the
soil, from which water is removed (by drainage or pumping), and the open
material (aggregate, perforated pipe, porous plastic mat) the function of which is
to collect and convey the water; the function of the geotextile is to prevent
movement of soil particles while allowing the water to go thorugh it.
Filter associated with armor: the geotextile is placed between the soil which has
to be protected from the wave action and the coarse material which constitutes
the armor; the function of the geotextile is to minimize movement and loss of soil
particles while allowing the water to go through it.
The difference between the case of water removal and the case of armor is related
to the flow: in the case of water removal, the flow of water is in one direction and
13
partially steady; in the case of armor exposed to waves, the direction of flow
alternates and the flow is unsteady and dynamic.
c.) Separation. A geotextile is placed between two materials which have a tendency
to mix when they are squeezed together under the applied loads; the function of
the geotextile is to separate these materials. A separator must retain the soil
particles and must have sufficient strength to withstand the stresses induced by
the applied loads. Consequently, designing a geotextile separator involves
retention analysis and strength analysis.
Surface Protection: A geotextile, placed on the soil prevents its surface from
being damaged by such actions as weather, light traffic, etc.
Interface Protection: A geotextile, placed between two materials, prevents one of
the materials from being damaged by concentrated stresses applied by the other
materials.
f.) Tensile member. A geotextile acts as a tensile member when it provides tensile
modulus and strength to a soil with which it is interacting through interface shear
strength, for instance the interlocking, friction, cohesion and adhesion.
14
2.6 Geotextile As Slope Protection
Landslides in the residual soils or weathered rocks in Malaysia are generally rain
induced. These slopes when dry or partially saturated, they are normally stable at
inclinations exceeding the effective angle of internal friction, of the soil. When the
soil is partially saturated, the negative pore water pressures impart to the soil as an
effective stress which is higher than the corresponding total stress. The shear strength
of the soil is thereby increased, enabling the slopes to remain in stable condition even
though when the inclination exceeds the effective friction angle, of the soil. After
heavy rainfall, the soil will become saturated because of the infiltration of the
rainwater into the ground. The original negative pore water pressure existed in the
soil are therefore eliminated or drastically reduced, causing a large reduction in the
effective stress and the shear strength. The slope will become unstable and eventually
fail.
15
materials; the integrity of layers of granular soils can be disrupted by erosion,
settlements and earthquakes while a geotextile layer remains continuous.
16
same, old and dull design. Especially in coastal protection application, geotextile
present solutions to problems which designers have long been struggling, for
instance, sand filters wash away and difficult to construct under water while
geotextile are secure and easy to place.
c) Owners: Owners also plays a major role to the success of geotextile because they
dare to use them in the early days. Motivations of owners are a combination of
contractors and designers motivations. Owners and contractors are most
interested in low cost and designers are interested in stability, reliability and
sometimes experimentation. For owners, by adopting geotextile, maintenance
work can be reduced which in turn save cost.
2.8.1 UV Resistance
Any polymer used for the manufacture of geotextile will degrade when
exposed to the ultraviolet radiation of natural sunlight overtime. Therefore, it is
essential to consider resistance of geotextile to the effects of sunlight when designing
geotextile. Particular care is necessary when geotextile is to be installed in regions of
the world whereby the UV radiation levels are high or when geotextile will remained
exposed over period of weeks or even months on large scale projects.
17
It is wiser to protect the geotextile from degradation. This can be done by
using stabilizers, in order to match the aging process with the long term requirements
of the application. High quality geotextile comes equipped with high performance
stabilizers, therefore the required life time of the geotextile is guaranteed.
a) The degradation process within the polymer of the geotextile takes place
extremely slow under ambient temperatures.
b) There is no proven correlation between laboratory tests and practical application,
as these products have only been in use for 30 years. However, a design lifetime
of 120 years is required.
c) Products installed 30 years ago cannot be compared to todays product, as
structure and chemical composition have changed because of constant ongoing
product development.
d) The chemical reaction of oxidative process is very well known, but in practical
applications other stress factors, such as installation damage, chemical attack and
many others, may be superimposed on it.
18
The fiber surface of polyester yarns is particularly susceptible to degradation
when exposed to alkaline condition (pH >10), external hydrolysis will take place.
But even when it is exposed to acidic condition, the material is gradually degraded
by internal hydrolysis. In this case, the polymer chains are split by the presence of
water, thereby reducing the molecular weight. Last but not least, it will lead to a
drastic reduction of mechanical properties. Therefore, it is essential to protect
polyesters material by providing extra coating.
19
For the construction of slopes (inclination 45o to 70o), we can use either
sacrificial formwork or removable rigid formwork. Types of sacrificial formwork are
sand or gravel filled gabions, concrete elements and welded wire mesh folded to the
desired angle. The advantages for using concrete elements are the placement of
geotextile is relatively simple and no parts of geotextile (reinforced sheeting) can be
visible. The negative aspects are it requires accurate leveling for each layer of
geotextile laid and it is not compatible with large deformations. On the other hand,
for welded wire mesh, the benefits are solely due to easy of placement (light weight),
unnecessary to protect the visible parts of the reinforcing sheets, its facing is very
flexible and a planar slope can be produced.
Figure 2.2 Possible Construction Methods for Slopes (Inclination 45o to 70o)
20
For the construction of slopes (inclination 70o to 90o), for low structures (<
2m), a fixed formwork may be utilized. The advantages are the ease of construction
and the exact geometry of the slope can be obtained. The disadvantages are the high
costs and are space constraint as large space is required for the base of the formwork.
For high structures, the method described for low structures is no longer appropriate,
because the amplitude of the thrusts on the formwork requires strong and expensive
systems of props.
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
In short, the methodology adopted to carry out the research paper can be
summarized accordingly into the following phases:
3.1
Phase 1:
Literature Review
3.2
Phase 2:
Collection of data and information for the case study is from various sources,
for instance Pejabat Pengarah Kerja UTM, Jurutera Perunding OMK and PROPEL
22
(Pro Penyelenggaraan Lebuhraya Berhad). Discussion held with these parties has
certainly further my understanding the application of geotextile in slope
rehabilitation purposes. Among the important information and parameters needed for
this case study is:
a) Location
b) The cause of slope failure
c) Geotextile installation method at site
d) Soil profile at site
3.3
Phase 3:
In this phase, every set of data obtained was analyzed to achieve objective of
research, applicability of geotextile in slope rehabilitation. In addition to this, design
aspect for slope rehabilitation using geotextile will also be overlooked. Two design
approaches were adopted to determine FS, with or without geotextile reinforcement,
that is finite element analysis using PLAXIS software and to design manually using
limit equilibrium concepts.
3.4
Phase 4:
CHAPTER IV
CASE STUDY
4.1
Introduction
A case study has been carried out on the slope located near the Automobile
Workshop, Mechanical Faculty, UTM Skudai. The instability of slope has caused the
slope to collapse in the wee hours on 18th January 2001. It has indeed worried the
public especially the UTM authorities as the failure of slope may endanger the
structures or buildings around the slope, which may lead to unnecessary injuries or
death of innocent people.
The landslide which caused by the failure of slope has partially covered the
vehicles parking lot located downstream of the slope. The severity of the landslide is
proven by the fact that the impact of the landslide has completely destroyed the drain
located nearby the vehicles parking lot.
This location will be an idealistic location for research work to be carried out
because the rehabilitation of the slope is by means using the application of geotextile
as reinforcement to stabilize the slope which has failed.
24
4.2
The heavy downpour has caused the flow rate downstream of the river at the
foot of the slope to increase. Thus, it leads to an overflow at the discharge point of
river (inlet of culvert). The culvert cannot cater for increasing volume of water that
has been rising ever since for the past 48 hours.
The overflow water flowed back into the soil at the foot of the slope. The
basic problem in such case is usually insufficient shear strength of the soil with
respect to the slope angle and the height of the embankment. This often suggests low
relative density in granular soils and high water content in cohesive soils. Both of
these situations (density and water content) could be positively influenced by some
type of insitu stabilization systems.
25
4.3
To rehabilitate the slope, proper site investigation has to be carried out. First
and foremost, it is very important to determine the hard strata approximately1.5m
beneath the base of the slope. The base should have adequate bearing capacity to
sustain the mass of the soil. Mackintosh probe is adopted to determine the bearing
capacity 1.5m beneath the slope.
When the bearing capacity is adequate, the collapsed slope will be rebuilt
layer by layer using geotextile as reinforcement. Reinforcement is needed as there is
not much room for the construction of the slope. Thus, the slope constructed tends to
be steeper than usual. Application of geotextile as reinforcement to rehabilitate the
slope will be the idealistic approach. The slope will be protected with gabion wall
with geotextile anchoring against it to increase global stability and resists the
potential of sliding to occur.
4.4
Installation of Geotextile
a) Site clearing work need to be carried out. The site needs to be free of trees
and vegetation which would obstruct the reconstruction of the collapsed slope.
The site needs to be as flat as possible.
b) Piling of mangrove tree (Rhizophora) needs to be planted 0.5m centre to
centre around the collapsed slope to increase and improve its bearing capacity.
c) Subsoil is inserted into the area within the piling area. Horizontal drain (with
geotextile wrapping around it) is constructed around the area to drain out
water into the main drainage system.
26
d) Gabion wall with the dimension of 1000mm x 1000mm is prepared and
installed onto the slope. The gabion wall will be installed 450mm above the
pile. The gabion wall will be installed at a level from 19m to 23m.
e) Bamboo is installed at the level of 17.5m. Next, the area is backfilled with
1.5m of sand.
f) Geotextile is then laid on top of the sand layer at approximately level of 19m.
It requires pre-tensioning of the geotextile layers before covering them with
sand. If a single roll is not large enough, two of them can be sewn together.
Alternatively, adjacent strips can be overlapped or sewn. In this way the
fabrics machine direction is oriented in the maximum stress direction.
g) Soil is then backfilled on top of the geotextile and compacted.
h) Repeat procedure (f) and (g) until the proposed level of the rehabilitated slope.
4.5
27
In this research, Polyfelt TS Geotextile will be used to reinforce the slope.
Polyfelt TS 80 will be adopted in this research to check the adequacy of this material
to be used as reinforcement. Polyfelt TS 80 possess continuous filament, made of
nonwoven needle punched 100% polypropylene and is UV stabilized. It has an
average tensile strength of 28kN/m and is chemically resistance (no influence at pH
range 2-13). It has a nominal mass of 400g/mm2 and thickness of 3.2mm.
28
CHAPTER V
5.1
Introduction
The area of geotextile is rapidly growing and exciting field with new uses
being developed almost daily. As such, there are a number of possible applications
and even greater number of geotextile to choose from. Due to the very wide range of
applications and tremendous variety of available geotextile, the selection of a
particular design method or design philosophy is a critical decision.
5.1.1
Design by cost and availability simply means take the funds allocated divided
by the area to be covered by the geotextile and calculates a maximum allowable
30
geotextile unit price. The material is then selected within this price limit. This
method sounds technically very weak but is still sometimes being practiced.
5.1.2
Design by Specification
5.1.3
Design by Function
FS =
Allowable Pr operty
Re quired Pr operty
31
In this research, this latter method is the one to be discussed. Polyfelt TS 80
will be checked in terms of adequacy of its factor of safety to rehabilitate the slope
using 2-D finite element software (PLAXIS) and to design manually.
5.2
FS =
i =1
(wi sin i) R
i =1
where
FS
Ni
wi cos I;
wi
centre of slice;
R
Ti
yi
32
These equations are tedious to solve, and when additional considerations is
given to finding the minimum factor of safety by varying the radius and coordinates
of the origin of the cycle, the process becomes unbearable to do by hand. Many
m
Tiyi contribution of
i =1
Figure 5.1 Details of Circular Arc Slope Stability Analysis for (c,
) Shear Strength Soils.
33
For fine grained cohesive soils whose shear strength can be estimated by
undrained conditions, the problem becomes much simpler. Therefore, slices need not
be taken since the soil strength does not depend on the normal force on the shear
place. The latter method will be adopted in this research. Figure gives details of this
situation, which results in the following equation. The example illustrates its use.
FS =
cR + Tiyi
i =1
WX
where
FS
Ti
yi
Figure 5.2 Details of Circular Arc Slope Stability Analysis for Soil
Strength represented by Undrained Conditions.
34
5.3
Finite element analysis (FEMs) has been used to study the performance of
geotextile reinforced slopes in both analysis and design situations. Although these
sophisticated computer based methods might not be routinely used for non-critical
situations, they do give insight into the behavior of the system.
To adapt the FEM to the soil fabric interface for the reinforced section, the
displacement of the soil and fabric were assumed to be compatible until the shear
stress reached the limiting shear stress defined by the Mohr-Coulomb failure
criterion. Once this shear stress was attained, slip occurred.
35
5.4 Results
5.4.1
Manual Design
FS =
Re sistingMoments
DrivingMoments
Adopt: FS =
cR + Tiyi
i =1
WX
Assume that sufficient anchorage behind the slip circle shown is available to
mobilize full geotextile strength and that seams are also adequate to transmit
the stresses.
FS =
(10 15.4136)(10.7)
(395.56)(3.434)
= 0.985
36
2.) Determine the factor of safety with five layers of the high strength
geotextile of allowable tensile strength of 28kN/m placed at 1.5m
intervals from the interface to the top of embankment.
FS =
= 1.578
3.) Determine how much embedment (anchorage) is required behind the slip
circle to mobilized the allowable tensile strength of the geotextile.
Assume that the transfer efficiency of the fabric to the soil is 0.8 and base
the calculation on a FS = 1.5
F = 0
2TELe = T (FS)
2(7) (0.8) Le = 28(1.5)
Le = 3.75m
Use 4m beyond slip circle for anchorage length of each fabric layer.
37
4.) Determine the location of the centre of critical toe circles
1 (deg) 2 (deg)
(deg)
1.0
45
28
37
1.5
33.68
26
35
2.0
26.57
25
35
3.0
18.43
25
35
5.0
11.32
25
37
38
5.4.2
39
FS = 1.376
>1.3 OK
40
CHAPTER VI
6.1
Introduction
This will be the last chapter of this research. The outcome of the analysis and
results from the chapter 5 will be discussed in this chapter. This would be followed
by conclusion and further recommendation to improve this research in future.
6.2
Discussion
42
Geotextile (Polyfelt TS 80) was adopted to rehabilitate the slope. After the
installation of geotextile, the FS of the slope calculated using manual design (1.578
>1.3) and PLAXIS software (1.376 > 1.3) indicate stability of the slope.
It can be seen that the values of FS obtained from manual and software
design is different. It is because of the difference in the geotechnical engineering
approach. Manual design utilizes limit equilibrium concepts while the software
utilizes finite element analysis. However, this is not an issue. The significance or
important part of the analysis is to prove that geotextile can rehabilitate slopes. . It is
hope that this research will ensure complete acceptance of geotextile in rehabilitating
or reinforced slopes.
6.3
Conclusion
Geotextile has risen from a relatively minor and specialty product status to a
worldwide, billion dollar industry. According to Robert M Koerner, no other specific
class of items in civil engineering and related construction activities has had such a
dramatic increase in so short time span. The current situation is both exciting (due to
the newness and unknown challenges posed by the products) and dangerous (due to
obvious uncertainties involved).
43
The manufacturers of the geotextile products have been the prime movers in
the industry. These technical entrepreneurs have sensed the need, developed the
products, have aggressively marketed these products, and have done so in the open
and competitive manner.
6.4
Recommendation
REFERENCE
45
13. Paul S.H.Poh and Bengt B. Broms Slope Stabilization Using Old Rubber
Tires and Geotextiles
14. Robert M. Koerner Designing With Geosynthetics