High Velocity Contact Impact Fracture Study

! "# ! $

!"%
!
&' "#

" (
(
( ( ( )
&
! ! *
( (( + &(

" !
,!'
!
-
!
&

! -&! ! ! "
! ( " . /0 1
!
2 3 /0 4" !
,!' !

! (

!
& ! 5 4 '&

! -&! ! ! &
!
! ! ! !( *-&! '
!
6" ' ! &" " & &! (

! - & 3
( --
!
'& ! ! 7
)( 8 ! !

& 3
&
( 8
9
! " !! ! !(
: 7 ! !
&
& !; &!'
4" -&
- ' (
&' ! ' ! !!! 4" -&
-) ! !
( -7 ! !

4"
#9
( < !& !
7! ! ( # !

! ! !
! !
& !
(

)&
&
&'
! ! ! "( = !
& && "# "
'
;( >
! &&!
!
6 !
" "# ( ! ! "!
"
& " "
"

'(

&
" !
& !
, + &( )&

!
&&
"
# &(
!
& !& )

<? @/ 0
/ *
3 0 &
# "#
)& !(
" # #
A# !

&&
& )

+ &( " '

"
&! , 4#/ &
!
0 " 8
,
/? 0 /?
10(
&!
,'/!!#0 B'#/ 0 /
0
!
' '
& #

(
3
! && &' / !
'&
!0 "# !# "(
! 2

( (( + &
(

#

$

%& '

$
) '

C(C '" 3 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

C(C(C *-&! *

C(C(
! *
( ( (
C(C( 8 ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
C(C(D 5 ,!' ( ( ( ( ( ( (
C( 5 ,!' =# ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
C( ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
*
'
+
$
(C
(
(
(D
(E
(G
! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
+
!
(
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
*! 8 ' * ( ( (
! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(G(C I 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(G( >
'
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(

(
"
)
C

D
E
F
C
CC
)*
C
C
CD
CG
CH
CH
CJ
CJ
(G( ! " ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( CF

(H *-&! 8 ' * ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( CF
(J !
<& 3
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( C
, + -

(C
(
(
(D
(E
(G
(H
(J
(F
) 4 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
*

( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
7 ! !
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(D(C 8 ' *
(D( < !
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
# !
2
( ( ( ( ( ( (
! 8 !
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
4" -& !
( ( ( ( ( ( (
' ! > ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
4
! &! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(F(C 8!
-& ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(F(
& 3 ( ( ( (
(F( <& ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
.

(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
D(C 8 ! 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D( 8 ! ! *)& ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D((C !# ! 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D(( && 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D( +
! 8 4
( ( ( ( ( ( (
D((C !# ! 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D(( && 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D(D 3 & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
D(E

! 3

( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
/ '

(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
((((((((((((((
*-&! 8 !
((((((((((((((
*.
D
G
J

C

D
E
G
H
J
F
F
.)
DC
DD
DE
DG
DH
DH
DF
DF
EC
/,
E(C 3

! *! ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ED
'
E(C(C
! & 8 ' ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
E( 3
*! 8 !-
&! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
E((C
&! " ! ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
E(( 5
&! " ?!# ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
E( 3

! *-! ? (
E((C
! *-! 8 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
E((
! *-&! & ) (
E(D 3
*-! 8 !-
&! ( ( ( (
E(D(C *-&!
&! & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
ED
EH
EH
G
GG
GG
GJ
H
H
0
'
1 2%
3,

4)
G(C 8 ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( J
G( !& =# ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( JD
'

(C )

( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( CE
D(C " ! !
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( D
D( ! ! !
'! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( D
E(C
E(
E(
E(D
E(E
E(G
E(H
E(J
E(F
E(C
E(CC
E(C
E(C
E(CD
E(CE
E(CG
E(CH
E(CJ
E(CF
E(
E(C
E(
8 ' .
! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

! & ! ' @ K DE C ! ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' & @ K DE CD ! ( ( ( ( (
&! " ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

B! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
B! ! ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
5
&! " ! !# ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
L-&!
& ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
M-&!
& ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' !# ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' !# ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
8 .
! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
*-&! & ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
.
! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

&!
& & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' & & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
B ' " ' &! /E E C0 (
B ' " ' &! / D0
&! & & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

& & / '"0 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
'
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
ED
EG
EG
EH
G
G
GC
GC
G
GD
GD
GE
GE
GG
GH
GJ
HC
HC
H
H
H
HD
E(
E(D
E(E
E(G
E(H
E(J
E(F
E(
E(C
E(
E(
E(D
E(E

& & /! '" L-M & 0 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! ! !( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! ! !( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! ! !( ( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! ! !( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' & & ! ! ( ( ( ( (
)

' & & ! ! ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! /&!
0 ! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! /&!
0 ! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! /&!
0 ! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
&!
& -! /&!
0 ! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' & & /&!
0
! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
)

' & & /&!
0
! ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
'
HE
HG
HH
HH
HJ
HJ
HF
HF
J
J
JC
JC
J

4"
# !

" '!

> &

N O
) !
!
&!

N O
) !
- !
&!

N O N "

) & !
&
N O N "

! & !
&
I 9

!

!
&!

2 -3

2 ! '!

4
! ! !

! ! !

! ! !

!
&
N O
) &

*) ! '! !& & C

*) ! '! !& &

2 ) ! '!

8
) ! '!

*7!'
! ! '!

> !!
N O
7
)
N O
3 & 7
)

)
N O
N O
O
N

N O

NO

N O

N O

5
N O

5

4 - & 7

)
*7!' 7
)
8
7
)
*7!'

)
> )&
& !
5"
'!
'!

! '!

) ! & !

!
&
) &
< ! ! '!
8 ! ! '!
! -+!7
) & ! -+!7
! " ! &!
! " &!
&!
! " ! ! !!

!
! ! ' !
!

&!
&! L-!
! !
&
) & 5
) & !
& 5
" &! & !& ) !
&
&!
'! !& & C
&!
'! !& &
2 &!
'!
)

P
Q

R

!

@
"
N"O

"
#
#

N# O #
$
% &
&
'
(
)
N) O
)
P
)
6 T
) )
)
)
N) O )
8
&!
'!
2 '! '!
2 !! '!
&!
&! I-!
B

&!
&! M-!
&
8- ! &!
4"
# &

B

+ !#
!

S @

) &

*' &!
! & N# O !
&
) & !
&
!
" &! & !& ) !
&
4 - & 2 -3
3
9 !
8! !
9

8!
) & 8!
8!
1

2 -4 !
& (
I
!! & 8!
) & !
&
" &!

!
& (
)
U
*
& !
" !

V '

V '
S @
V '
S @ !
" !
+
)W
)

&! &
!!
( ! !!!

&! &
' ! ' ! & &
!! ! & (
!
&!

&!(

! 7!
&
&!(
&! &
!
!
&) &!( &
#
!
''
! -&!
! !
! (
8

! )
! '& '
&

&! &
(
&! ! !

!
&) ! &!
' !

& ( !
&&)

! "!

' & (

!! !
-&! NCO #
&! -&! & ( ! '

' !
- ! &! & (
! ' &! &
!!!

.

(
!
! ! '
&! '( &!

-) !& &! 6"( B
C
! ' && ! ' !( NO " ' !

&
!!
&! '(
6" &! ! ( &

&! & ! &

& # ! ( &! "
!
&! 6"( &&
- &

(
< # !

!
'
-&!
"!
! " & . /0

! " - &!
/0

- - (
! ! &
- .

- ! ! ! !( !

#

! ' " !
- #

( '

!
; !
; !
!
( >"' " '

!
!

& ' ( ! ' ' !
' ' - !
( &

! !

(
7
)
& ! !
( " "# "

! (
" !
(
! ! ' ! & !-&!
!' ! "
!
( ! #
!
&
7
)
!
& ! NO(

"! 7
) #& ! !
&(

! ' !
&! &
( '
" &

!; ! &
"!
!
&
(
! ! 7 !
>
= -*
4"
#
NDO(

! "
! (
4"
#
-
! > NEO(
>
& &
"
( >

! && - &

!
'( !!! & 7
& ? NDO(
! ! ! 7 !
!

& ! &;
4"
#9

!!!(

!
!! -&! NCO #

&! -&! & ( NGO &

! -&! &
( 7!
&! "
$ %
)
" !;
; ' ( " &&! ! !

' !

" ! (
&&! ' !

NO 7
(
>"' &&! " '
'
' " ! ' !
! ' ' !(
4 1 NHO " !
& &! !-&!

(
' "
"! "
&&!
!
( &! " &

( &!
)&!
#
&! ! "

&! !
!

& (
!
"
' !
&

! ( ? " '
! '
!

&
'

!
! (
! -&! ! ' ' 7

! ' !
!
(
,
! 7 ' ! '&
!!
& !
/ !
0
&!( &! !

& * " !
&! * !#" !

( " ! !
"!

&' ! ' ! !!!
NJO( ! "#
' !
&;
&!
NF C CCO '"
& ! ' ! && NCO( &
&!

!#" * !

'&
2 NCO(
? NDO 6 '" 7 &&!
- &
( & 3 !&

'
!

( !
&
' "
' ! &' &&&
! ' ( 5 ! ' ;
!! &&& ,!'
( B ,!'
' ! ? NDO 8# NCDO(

'
! ! C(C(D( !! -&!

!
! ' !
& ! &! &( =

!

&
' !
&&&
NCE CGO (

"
!

!
? NCHO " & &&

!

( & 3 !&
"

!

(

- !
! & " ! # " NCJO(
&& && '" ! !
& !
- ! &&! !
& &
(
3
! '
!

&!

!&

&
( &!!
!
&

& - '( &
!! (
!

!

' D
!; ; '

(
!
!
7!
& ! !

(
' '. !
& ! ! &

7!' ! ( ! !
& & ! !!! !(

& !

! - " ; ? NDO(
) ' !
! ? NDO(
! 2 NCFO
!
& ' &&!' "# -
! & & !
'
& !( ! 7! &
! 7 & !! & &!
! '! !! "
! /&! 0( ' " )
! , ! "
" '&
)

& (
! !& ! '

"-
&!
W & ; "
/ !#" *- !

0 &! 7!( 4"
#
&! !

&
-!
(
#
!
! ! ! !

! ! ( ! !

!
! !
! !-
&!
!! " " " (
' ! !
'
& (

! ' ! (
! ! ! " !. &! !
# " ! ( &! !

& (
&
& ! ! !
&! !
& !( '

&!
" ! !
! !(

&
" ! ! ! "
' >; NO
' !'
& ( >;

!'
E
! '! ! ! ! ! !

( 4!
!
! !
" ! &! >; ? ! ! ! &
&! &! &! ( ! ! " " &
! ! !!( ! "# >;9 & CFJ
'" 1 NCO( >; '
! !
! ! ! & &!' #!
! ( ! ! ! " ; (
!! ! ! '
)

!!
& EH NCO( 3 #' NO 2" NO '

! ! ! &
! ! (
= '&
!
& &&
!
(

" ( ! !
"
! !
! "

( "
&& ( - ! ! !
" !; ! !
! ! ! /! 0 '' &!
! " &&

!
7
) 6)
) ! !
( ' "
5 NDO 2 NEO !'
M #"!; NGO !'
# NHO !(
+# NJO > )! NFO
NO
!

! &
' !

! ! ! &
(

! !
! ! & (
=
& & &
! !
' &!
( -- !

-
!
! ! (
' -

--
!
"!
! ! !
! ! "
( =
--
!
! ! ! ! !
&)

" )&
' (
& !

''

'&
& !& ' "# ! ! !(
"!

G

&
! ! !

!

!
( ?
NCO & !
&
7 ! !
" &&! ( ' ! !
'
? NO(
+#! 5 NO ' &'

! 3
&
( "# ? 8 NDO

& '& )& ! ! 7
)
( "
& )
! &

! !
(
3
& "
& ! ! ! ! ! !
" #$ !
( 4 - ! ! #
! " '&
! ! !
) "
&
=
NEO
! NGO( 3
&
& !
(

)
"
&
" &&
8 I NHO(
- !
" &&
2 ; NJO & 3 ! ( '

" !
! ! ! &
(

" ) -
! ! ! &
ND EO
! -&!
&
NFO( ' ! !
!
& 2
NDO( +"# NDCO ? ! 8 NDO ' &

!
! ! &
! 7! ! (
9 = NDO
& !
& )&

&! !
!
" -&!
&!
&
(
8 !-
&!
"!

!

!
&
-!
&
)&!
- &
! ''
!
'!;
"! & &!
&( ?!# 4 NDDO !
&
"!
&
'!;(
,
& !
!
&
! & ( !
&
3
&
&
( 1 NDEO '& & ! !

&
-
! )&!
&
;
-
!( ! !
!! ! !
H
&

! &
& ! ! ! !
" ! ! ! & "!
&&)
! !
! & ( ?" NDGO ! &;
! !
( !

' ' !
& ' & !

!
! ! &! !
&!
!

( - ! !
! !
& & " "' ! !

&&&(
' ! !
& ! ! &;(
" !# )! " &! ) !
"

& !
& !(
&
!
-
!
' !# " &&( && NDHO
&
! ! ! !( !

&! 4"
#
"# " '

( "# ! !
& ! !
# '! !
&' "' ! ( 3 8" NDJO &&
! '
! ! !
!
! ! &
( " 3
& !
&&&

&! ! ' &&( &!

&! !! "
! ' !

&;
!
(
!; NDFO & "
&'
-&&

&'
!
(
"
- !
"

&
" !& "
!( 2' ! '&
&!
-&&

! ! &
& ! / 0

!
! ! ! (
V " ! ' && " ! (
NEO '& "
! ! &
! !& ! !( 8
)
'' ' "
) !
&
!
& )& '(
" && !
! !
!!#

! )! ( "

J
! && '

, ! ! &
" !
! &
(
3 NECO )
3
"! ! ' ' 3
&

'' ! ! !( + NEO &&
! !

"! !& "

! !
"!
& ! ! ( NEO &

! !W
&! &
"! 7
3
&
&
(
7
)

! ! (

! ! "
! - &
( !

# " ! !

!
! " &
( ? ! )!(
$
%&' ( )*(

-&! &
!
!
&!
( & 3
! !
& !
& ( 4 ! ' '
!
!

( 8!

!
& !

8! !
&
'
S@ ( !
! 8! !
& !! !
(
8! #%& !
& ! '
" !
! & (
" !

/ 0 & !

/
0 !
,!' / 0
(

!
,!'

"

"
-&! &
1

(
! 8! !
&

( ?

& !
( " !

)&! ' !! ( " # "
1

&! ! " !

F
NEDO( 5 ,!'

# 2 -4 *-
' && /NEDO NEEO0( ? ! (
& &
&! && B NEGO "! !! ! 8!
!
& !
( &&! !

'
"! " &! )
( =

!
&

)
S @

!
# !! ( !

!

#%& "#(

" ,!'
!
! ((

! -
-&!
!
! ! &
" ! '& 1& NEHO( 1

!
2 -3
( ,!'
& "# !& " !
,!'

!

!
! ! !
&'
"
(
! "( ! " '

! && ! ! ! --
! !

! ! (
M NFO !! ! !
7
)( 3
&
&& ! ! ! (
8
9 ! "
! 7! ! ! !(
*! '
>#9 " &! '
! 6" ' ! &"-"
& &! ( ! &!
!
& ( !
! & 3
NDO(
4" -& '
'

( ! 4" -& ! ! !
! ! ! ( 7 ! !
! !;

( 4"
#9
"!

!!!
' 7 ! !
&&( <
C
!
!& # ! ! ( !
!
& ! &
! !
7
) ! ! -! ! # !

( ' ! ! ';( ) !

&' ! ' ! !!! 4" -& (
!
"
8& "

!
'
!
-&! &
( '&

7 ! !
'
! !

! !& ( 8& D & ! !
"

! ! 7
) !! ! ! !
!( 8& E ' !
& " "
,!'
! -&! " ! !
&
( !&
"# ! !&

'&
(
CC

! -&! &

! & && (
& !
- ( - ! !
. '

#

(
" - !!
-&!
(
! '
!

" ! ' & !

(
- !! ! !-
&! &

- ! ! ! !(
#

,! )

'
(
# " 3
(

! '

&
"
!
'
! ! ( > !
&& ! !

"! : &!
( 5

&

"! )&
- &!
(

)&
C
! &

(
# ' !
&) ! '( ! ! ! ' '
&
!

# "

(

& !
!!
!

( & @ !!
!
" @ & !

! (
> ! !

(
&! -&!

! ! '
& )&
!

(
$
% &

'

S @ .

,

K

/(C0
" & '! &!

S @
&!'( = & !
&
/NEJO NEFO0
" !
&
.

K
/(0
" &

5
&'
! ! ! ( !

! ; "
& !& !
% .

K
/(0

" NO
)
%

K / -.0
/(D0

) NO '&

" !

!

% (

C
! '

&

! " ( > !

&
#%& "!

' !
& (
!

# " "
,!' ! !
! ' (
,!'
"!

! "(
5 !
,!'

(
) *

"! 8! ) ! !&
' "# " " ! NDO.

K ((
/(E0

)

> ( ( &

S @ &!'
'' & '!
';( " &! (
,!'
+
$
) (
8! )P NDO.
)

@ K )P @
/
)
R

@ 0
) / R

@0
/(G0
/(H0
@ K C / @ @0
> R @ & !
& @ ''
!
&!
'! @ " &! (
NEDO && )6 & &

.
)
T K )P R ) S R )
/(J0
R
"

R K P
/(F0
'!( )6

2 -4
(
& ; NEEO
&

!
& " ! ' ,!'( "
!
,!'
/ ,!'
0
CD
ZF
t+ t
t
XM
[R]
ZM
t
t+
ZM
XM
[Q]
XF
Note:
11
00
00 The Fixed Frame is denoted by subscipt F.
11
00
11
00
11
00 The Material Frame is denoted by subscript M.
11
(C. )

; >#9 3" /(CG0 -&! ! ' /(F0
'& "(
" 8 !
/ (C0 .
C( )
/ !& 0(
(

/ !& 0 "! "

&!(

! ! " & !& ) !

) #"
S @ (
& '
!
& 8!

)

.
)

K )

/(C0
!
!
& 8! " &!

) @) ) !
&
S @ " &!

!.
)

)

S @)
/(CC0

S @ )
'
!
& 8!
S @ .
)

K

)

CE
/(C0
" !

& " &! )
(
&&
!

,!' &! ! &&! ! ' (
( '

&

' !!
-&! ( '

!

(
!
2 -3 - ! &!
NDO.
C
/(C0
@ K / @ S @ S @ @ 0

= !

!

C
/(CD0
@" K / @ S @ 0

!

(
"
!! ' "# )& S @

&!'( !
& 2 3
'
#

!
& ( " ' " ! '

! ' ".
C( & & ; !
&
3
!
; !
(
( !
& ' " & !& ! ;( ! ' " "!
&&& 8! !
& ' / &!
!0 ' !
&
(
! ! '
" !
& !

" & !& ! !
;(

! NEDO ' ' ( !
& !

!

CG

.
@#
K /%0 / -. / 0
/(CE0
" % & !& ! /(D0( !

&
" &!
!
"(

! " ' -&! (
'' -&!
" ! '
& !
!
"
!
! '
"(
) * +
*,

! ! ' ; >#9 3" !
,!' ! & N@# O !

!
.

/(CG0
@) K @#
&! ! ' .

K % S &
/(CH0
" % & 3

9 ! (

! ' !
! , " ! ( >"' &! &
&!-!! !
" ! ! & (
- "
.
.
*-&!

!!; " .
C( I 8 (
( &(
( " (
?! 7! &

&! "#(
CH
"+
, ((
"
! ' & !

! ! ( " && !

&' &! ( &

"! )&
' &! ! !!
( I !! " ' ) ! '
) ) (
) /) 0 K )
/(CJ0

"

K
) )
) '! & ) (
)
"+"
/(CF0
( (,- *
; & !

& &
!
& &!
! &' ( ! '

!

! )&
" ! &( # "

&

)
"
K /# 0
/(0
# #
/(C0

' &!

&- '
# /&! & !

! 0 !

& " &! )
W!
& ( "# " &" " ! & .
#

)

"
)
)
/ # 0

(
CJ
/(0
"+#

. *
&! 6" ! " &! !
(
&! & ! !
& !

&! ( ! 6" "!
!
&! &
& "#(
K

#
/(0
,
, )
" % !

(
/ *
0 +
*,

-&! & " !

' ! &! / ! '0 '&
"(
&!
&! & ' NGO.
/
) #
0 K ) /) 0
"

)
/# 0
K
/(D0
/(E0
& ! ( &! & & 8!
' '
&
# (
&! & !

! #

&! & 6" / (0( 7 /(D0
" &! ) '.
)
,
K
/(G0
,)
)

%
.
K #
/(H0
& ! ! )& % .

%
)

K )
K

CF
/(J0
"

)

K #
K /# 0
/(F0
& !'( /(G0 /(J0 /(0 " ! ' .
) )

# K
/(0
)
! ' & " '! &!
& !

! ! ' <&
3
"! !
: & (
!
/(0 ".
) ,)

# K
/(C0
) ,) )
4
/(D0 /(G0 " .
,
)
,)
K
K
/(0
,)
,)
)
/(0 /(C0 " !
&!
: &.
F ) )

# K
/(0
D ) )

!
! : & / /(CG0 /(CH0
'
0 ! )& .
K C N' ) S /C S ' 0 ) O
#
/(D0

" # ! & #

I 9
' 9
( " & " .

)
F
)
C
S
'

'

S
S
/(E0
# K # S # K
D ) )
!
-&! : & &
3
( >"' " ' & "!

/NGO NGCO0.

/(G0
) K #
"

F& ) )
K & S C ' /& S 0)

'

/(H0
> & 3
9 ! / !
0 ' 9
( 9 3
9 ! % & "
.
%
/(J0
' K
/% S &0
4 !
&& /(G0
,!'
!
)
; !
&
( !

& "# 4" 5 ,!'

! ! ((
& /(G0 '
!
;
(
= ; !
& /(G0 # "

.

/ @# 0
/(F0
@) K

"
F& ) )

K & S C ' /& S / " 0 0 )
/(D0

> &! )& /(F0 !&

# )&! '
(

'
1 # 2 %

,!' & 3

!
!
S @ " ! #
! '

# " ( & !& ' "# NDO.

(
Q
0
/

)

/" 0 K

/(DC0
"
K
S @

Q K !!
S @
0 K ' &!

S @
/

K '

S @
) K 8! S @ (

' /" 0 .

C
,

,

/
" 0 K
S

,
,

(
C
/(D0

K

0

/
/0 S
0
/0

/
0
/0 S
/(D0
"
0 K ! & '

S @

/ 0 K && ! &
S @

K !
S @ " ! &!

/ 0 K ! ! ! &
S @

K ! ! !
S @

! && /(DC0 !
S@
# " ( ' "# )&
S @

' '

(
)
/(D0

&
' ( )& /(DC0

!
NDO.

(
Q
/0 S

/ 0 K

" ' 2 -3 / 0 .

,

,
,
,
C

/
0 K
, S , S , ,
! -+!7 ! !
& .

!

S @ K
)

S @
/0 K / S @0 K / @0
/(DD0
/(DE0
/(DG0
/(DH0
' 2 -3 ! !

& .
/ 0 K /@ 0 K /@" S @$ 0
/(DJ0
"
@"
@$
K C / @ S @0
K C / @ @ 0

/(DF0
/(E0
/(DD0 ! " " !

!
& .

(
Q

@
/@0 S
/ @$
0

@
/ @" 0 S
)

/@$ 0 S
)

/@" 0 K

/(EC0
'

& ! "!
@" .

&&)
@

@" / @" 0 S
/ @ 0 S

) / @$ 0 S
) / @" 0

(
Q

/(E0
; " ' " &&)

&!
'! !! ( &&)

&!& /C0( &&)
'' !!
/(DC0 .
///
) /" 0

(
0
Q
/

&! : !! !
(

/(E0

!

' /(E0 ! '
! "! !
' !
&! &
(
!
'
!
)&

!( !

!
' ( ! &&)

'

,
&
&"
' !
&) ' &
(

"! ' &
! !

-
(( !& & '&

: 7 ! !
' ; '
!
-&! &
(
! ' !

;
' /(E0 & (
! '3 4

) '&

: 7 !
! ' ! !
&
&
(
!
& @" @$ &

".
@# K @# @# @# @# @# @#

@$ K @ @ @ @

D
/(C0
/(0
@# K @# @# @# @# @# @#
/(0
4 !
& @" ! ! "!
! ' "

( !
& 8!
) " .

) K ) ) ) ) ) )
/(D0
.
"
)

C( N O ! ' & @ K N O @"

( N O ! ' & @) K N O @"

)
' .

N O K N O N O N O
S N O

N O K N O N O N O
S N O
'
)
K

)
K /" 0

/(E0
/(G0
/(H0
/(J0
) & '! & 8!

(
&!

! N O N O - ! ' .
C '
N O K /C S ' 0/C

' 0

'
'
'
C '
'
'
'

C '
N O K /C S ' 0/C

' 0

'
'
'
C '
'
'
'

E
C '

C '
C '

C '

C '

/(F0

/(C0

* /(E0 ! " "
"

@" @$ ) .

/@
S
Q
0 (
/ @$

0 N1 O
/@# 0 N O @#

@$ S

) N1 O ' .
N1 O
"

NXO K

/@# 0 ) K
/(CC0
NXO

NXO

NXO
/(C0

)
)
)

)

) )

)
)
)

/(C0
! % * %

!;

!
&!

&&)
' !
.

@

/(CD0
@ K @ K NUO @

@

>
!
&!
'! ' .

@ K @ @ @ @
/(CE0
" @ @ @ # " !

&!

2 3 ! &!'(
) NUO .

NUO K

U
U
U

/(CG0
"
U K

U K

U K

G
/(CH0
"! ! / 2 30 ! & ! ( &

"# J- !#
" & ! ( !
& )&! ( >"' &!&
&; !
&
/ ! 0 ! "
(
!! !
)& .
Q

Q

K Q

Q

K N4O Q
/(CJ0
)&

&!

/(CD0 )& /(DF0 /(E0 .
@" K N O @

@$ K N O @
/(CF0
/(0
"
U

U

U

N O K

U S U

U S U

U S U

N O
/(C0
K U U U U
/(0
< /(CD0 /(CJ0 /(CF0 /(0 ! /(CC0

' &!
" '
.
/@ 0
/@ 0

/@ 0
/ @
0

NUO ( NUO
N O N O N

N
Q S

O @ S

N O N1 O N O

@ S

O ) K / @ 0

/(0
!
)&

) !
'! &! NGO(
H
! ' &!
'! ' !
" .
N O
Q S N O @ S K
/(D0
"

) N O .
N O
NUO ( NUO
/(E0

7
) N O )& .
N O
K N O S N O
/(G0
"
N O
N O

N O N O N
O
N O N1 O N O

/(H0
/(J0

! '! .

K
N O
)
/(F0

/ N O 0 7 /N O 0
! "
!
'!
.
Q S N O @ S K
N O

/(0
"
N O K

)
N O K 7
)
K ! '!

K ) ! '! S @ (
/(0 &
!& ! ( ) ! ! ! ! '
! (
!! % &5

!

!&
7 !

(
J
&& ! ! /(0 "

!
!
'
(
&
' &!
'! !! " !
'

!!! ! &!(
" !! ) !
. , .

( *)&!
&
!

S @ ! &!
! ( 5
' )&! !
!; 7!' 7
) !(
&!

!
!
S @

S @ ( !
&!

!

& ! '
!;
7!' 7
) ! ( "#
&!
! / (

4"
#

# "
& NDO.

P K P S /C 0
Q S Q @

K S P @ S / C !0
Q S ! Q /@ 0 /(C0

&
! !
!!! (
! ' !!
!& ! K K
"# "!
&! ! !
(
4"
# ! ".

K !/@C 0
C
K
!/@ 0
C C
K
!
K @ /C 0
K @
/(0
Q
/(0 & .
K S @
/(0

)& /(0 !

.
N O

@ S / N O S 0 K
F

/(D0
" 7!' 7

) N O 7!' ! '! '
.
N
O
K
K

N O S N O
S N O/ S

P S

Q 0
/(E0
/(G0
!
!

!

) !
' ! "
"!
!

!; /(DC0 "

.
N O
Q S K
/(H0
< /(C0 ! )& .

N O
S K
/(J0
!
& 7!' ! '! .
K S @
/(F0

)& /(J0 " @

/(D0.
N O @ K @
/(D0

< /(G0 /(J0 " .

@ K
K

S N O/ P S

Q 0 /(DC0
!

/ /(D00 ' !
&!

'! @ (
5 ! !
&!
' /(D0 '!
!!
S @ " )& .
Q K / 0 P

P K P S
Q S Q

Q
/(D0
/(D0
!( &

' !
& / 2 &
0
" &" &!.

C( 8! '

N O.
K S , / /@ 0

,
/(DD0
& '! " !&

&
@
!
' &!
/ ! (F(0(
! & '! !& -
&
! ) & ' !
!
(
( !
& N O K
/(0(
NO N O

NO

N O

(
& !& !

! @# /(CE0(
D( 8! @) / (F0( ! ' &
* " ! ! "(
E( < /(C0 !! 8! !
&
S @
#$
-( / 0 *' 1*
B ! ) ! ' (

&
! , !

!
! "(

& !& !
!
& ' !!
2 &
/ 0 # " (

C( 8! !

! '(

@) K N O @"
/(DE0
( 8! ) /(C0(

(
) ) /(CF0(
D( ) ) 2 & ! ) K
) 2 & (
(

*
! &! !( 8!.
K ))

C
)

)
/(DG0
! ( - !

"
!
& " &!

&
! !
!
!
& !&
-&! - !
( N O !& &
.

"
) K ) S N O
@# / K C /(DH0
@# K /C 0 @#

) K ) S N O @#

N O K N O )

/(DJ0
/(DF0
/(E0
< /(C0 ) (

(

!!# ! ! /(D(0(
- !

! /D0 '
&& " ;(
! * " !

-&!
! ! /(H0
#$"
,- 0
&
! !& &!
!
-&! & !( ! 8# NCDO.
@" 5
/(EC0
" @# !
& "

! ! & ) F- &!
&
"#( 4 &' & &!
$5%
/ (EC0 $K% $6%
&!'(
= ! 2 & !
' 2 &
/ ) K ) 0 2
& !
&! ! ! ! ' &&
!! !
N@) O(

!) .

6
.
-

! -&! ! ! &
!
& ' ' 7
! !
&
' &
( #
!
NDO !
! "! ! ! 7
) N O( !

" #
) N O
-
7( >"' " !

&!! &!
N O 7 (
&! "

7
! !
7
)
-
7(

& &! 7
) " ".

N O K
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8

8
8
8
8
8

8

!
) N O
!
'

( . "
-;

!
' . K C & #
)
' /. . 0 & !
( / ;
" #
!
!
-; &!0( !

! !'
( 5 ! !

7
) # " " !
" #
N O -
7Y (( &
/
"
# 0 N O ! !' 7.

7 K 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
8
7 " 7 7 "!

N O 7Y ((
N O 8
7 ' 7 7 (
7 7 K C D G C C

4 7 7
!
& / C0 !
& C(
> !
!'
!
N O 7 7
7 7
7 7 / 7 7 S C0 / 7 7 C0(
" ' !
N O 7 "
7 7 ' !
N O 7 ! (
!- +

! ! '

"!
! ! !# ! ! && ! !( ' !
&

! !

!
& !
&! " ! !
!
& "
(
!
! 7!' 7
)
7!' ! '! ;
"! ! !
! &&(
! &! ' " !.
"! ! ! ! && /
0 0
/ 1 0( !
!
& C

/!

# "
!

# 0( ! /(( &!

! 0 && /(D0(
& ".

@

N O N O @
K

@

@

N O N O
/(E0
" @ !

&!
'! !&
& C @ !
&!
'! !&
& ( * /(E0 ! & ".
N O @ S NO @ K @
N O @ S NO @ K @
/(E0
/(ED0

D
' @

/(ED0 " .
@ K N O /@ N O @ 0
/(EE0
)& @ /(E0

" !
!
.
O@ K @
N
/(EG0
"
O
N
@
@
N7O
K
K
K
K
K
N O N O N7O

@
@ NO
N O N O
N O @
/(EH0
/(EJ0
/(EF0
/(G0
/(GC0

! /(EG0

O '! @T

& C( !!
) N
'
/(EH : (GC0 &
! '!
/(E0( 4 " ' N7O ! '
) N O ( ! ' " 2

.
N O N7O K N O
NO K @
/(G0
/(G0
!
! &&
NO(
" ! ' !
N7O &
2

!# & !& !
N O( '!

&
2
!#
'! @(
!/ '
7 4
0

/(D0 & &&)
'
/(DD0 ! ;
&!
& '
E
/(E0(

; ' '
! ( 5
& ' 7!' !

"! 7 ! ' ! " !
& NDO(
! ! & ".
'.
N O @ K @
/(GD0

"

@ K

K @
@
! ' ! ! .
@

N O Q

/(GE0
/(GG0
/(GH0
( '! @ !

#
! & (
!1 & 8

4" &
'
!Y (( !
! ) ! ! ! ! (

! ! ' !

! ! ! !!&
( "

"!
& 7!' ' ! !!
! ' !

NJO (

&&
&!
'! @ ( >"'
! ! ! !!& ! ! !
!

! &!
'!( "#

&&
! ! '! @ &
&! " ' ! !(
"# 4" & ' " .
@ 6 9 @
/(GJ0

( ' ! 9 # (F(

-) !
! ".
G
5'+ " '7
' ! ! !

! '! @ ! ! ! & ' !
.

K ! @
/(GF0
@
-) ' ! ! "!
' !
" "
(

'7

!
! & "!
!&

! ! &! !
! '! @ ( >"' ' ! &
!
! !

!
& '
( &&! & )
'
! ! / "0 " &! (

@ K
@
" ! ! !
!
/(H0
' ! !&

! ! !
& !& ! !!&
!
(
! '
!
& & !

! ! ' ! -) !

!
&
!( &

"
! ! ' ! '( < -)
!& !
& ! " !
! (
!9 4

! &
!
! !

! -
& ! ! !!!
( " ! ! ' &!
!
!
(
H
#2
0 /

&! !

& ' ? NDO "!
!

&
(
&
! ' !
&
' && '(
& !

&' ! )!

&(
!
& ! &
!!

&& !!
&( > ! && " &

! -
7!
&
; !
&&& '(
!!
& & &
! (

! &
! !; . C( (
# ( 2&

#(

$ 7 & & &!
!
! &
' "(
C( ! '' !( !
! "
( 3 !
! ! (
( 8

! !! & ! &
!! & ! &
K D "

! !3
(
(
! (
& @
1
" 1
K "! (

2( 1 $ 7

!! "' !!
!! "
# "' ' & & ' .
"
K :"
/(HC0
" : "' &(

& ! &
' "'
& .
@ K
J
"

/(H0
&

.

K :@
/(H0
' !!

& !& 7!' &
!
& "' ' !!( ? ! # @ !
" 1

& &
(

!! "

& '
/ @
# 0 !! "

&
&( !!! &!
" @
@
#
& ! " ' !
& !; (
#2"
/(
, ,-

& # ! ' ! ! '!
S @ !! ! ! '! /(GE0(
&! ' ? NCHO !&
& !

'
! 7
) "! !
& )& '(
"#
#

! ' ! 7
!
! 7
)(
#2#
( ,
) "

& 2 & . C( .&
( .

/8 NJO0(
( 51'7 ' &!

!
& '
"! ! ' & /C0
/0(

51'7
' &!

& /0
!
' !
&!
! !
(
!
& !
"! ! '

F
&

& / &' !
0
/0(

& ! ! ! '!
!!

7 ! !
&
! '!( ! ' !
& &!(
)
& ' "#
& !
&
( ' &
! ' !
!(
D
"

!
-&! & 3

'& &' " !& ! ! ! "
&&&
! (

&
! '&

/ '' ! ! 7
)0
# " ! ! ! &!
( "! !
#
! ! ! ! ! )& !;
! ! '&
( '&
! " ! (

!
-&! ! ! &
! 7! !
! (
( +
+

&! " ! !
" /D(C0( !!&

S @ (
'
&!'(

S @ ! ! / K C0 ! & .

"

K ! "! &!

&!
K ! "! ! &!
K ! "! ! ! !!(
DC
/D(C0
t +t
t +t 1
t +t
t +t 2
D(C. " ! !

"
'! &
( 5 "
'!
/ ! 0 / /D(00(
&& " & ! ! " !

S @ ! ! ! 1
( 4" 9
"
" '.
1 K 1
/D(0
" 1
! )& .
1

1 (
/D(0
" !
&
" ! ! "
!
&
! ! ( " '.

/D(D0

8
! " " '.
/ 0 S / 0 &

D
/D(E0
Hitting Body (Body 1)

t + t
t + t
N13
N12
t + t 1
x
t + t
t + t 2
N11
t + t
t + t
N22
N21
t + t
N23
Target Body (Body 2)
D(. ! ! !

'!
/D(E0 $5%
& /
!

$K%
&

( /! 0 !
! && ' '! && ( /D(D0 /D(E0
&

(
! ! ! & (
& ! !

;( ! !

!
.
; K / 0 K
/D(G0

" ; & & " " & ! !(
/D(G0 " ' "
! ! !# ! !
"! ' &!
/&0 " ! ! &
! ( ! ! .
;
;
K /
K /

0 K

0 K
! /D(G0 /D(H0 /D(J0 ! /

(
D
/D(H0
/D(J0
( +
%
*3

! ! !; && '&

! !
! ' !
!

( ! ! !
"#
& --!
!
! "# "
&
! &&
! ! !( 4
! !
! ! !
! ( >

# / C0 !

! ! "
# / 0( & '&

! ! ! )&

'!
&
( ! ) &&(
2

! ! - & ! (

/< $0 K

U /< $0
/D(F0
" U /< $0 + K C & ! & '!

,
&
(
"!
! ! ! !! &'

'
( !
! !

! !!#" " " ! &'
(
!! "
'! ' & (
'!
& /< $0 &'
.

$

%
/D(C0
" $ % " '! /< $0 ' .

$

%
K
K
/< $0$
/< $ 0
%

/D(CC0
/D(C0

'! .

K
K
K

=
$
$
=
%
%
=
/D(C0
/D(CD0
/D(CE0
! ! ! ! ! " ! "

& ! " ! ! ! (
S @
DD
8 !

& & ! '! &

"!
# ! !( ? 4" 9 "
! '! " (
3 ' &!
'!
S @
& / &!'0 " !
! !(
' "# ! )& .
K

/D(CG0
4

'
&!
(
! )&

' &!

/
K C 0 - & ! /U K C 0( .

"
K N
O
C U U
N
O K C U U
C U U

/D(CH0
U
U
U

/D(CJ0

K /D(CF0

$"
3-
( ,
!# ! '! ! )& .

K

K

/D(0
/D(C0
" & + 8 !

& '!
!
& " &! ! ! ! '! ( 8

DE
/D(CG0 /D(CH0 /D(C0 " " )& ' "#
.
/

K
/D(0
" '! /

' .
/
K N
O
! ! ! )&

!# ! ! 0(
$""

/D(0
/

/ "!

- ,
! ! ! )&

/ "! &&

0 '& ".
'! /
/D(0 ! & !

! ! ! ! ! !(
/
K
/ S

"

/ K N
O

/ K N
O

/
/D(D0

/D(E0

S

"
/D(G0
> K C ! 8 !

& '! (
!
& ! ! ! & && (
8
9 ! " " ' .
/0 S /0 K &
/D(H0
" & !! ! && ( !

& ! ! ! ! " .

K & ! *

K & *
DG
/D(J0
/D(F0
" * " /! 0 ! '!

!
! ! ! " !
&' $%
' (
"
!
* 4
! ! ! && ! && '

'! && "!
7 ! !
&!

& ( ! ! !
' . @ @ K /N
O @
0 " !&
! !
& ( .
@
@
K N
O @

K N
O @
* ' .

*
K
/D(0
/D(C0

@
@

/D(0
>"' ' !

!
&
&

!

! !! * (
/D(J0 /D(F0 /D(G0 !
/D(E0 /D(G0 " /D(D0 " .
/
K N
O

& ! * & *

"

/D(0
(! $ +
4
%

#
! ! " & !#
&& (
$#
3-
( ,
)& #
! !
&!
/D(G0
/D(H0 /D(J0 !

)
4" -& .
"

/D(D0
; K ; ; ;
/D(E0
; K

DH

= '
K
S @ @

/D(G0
" !
8 !
&
7 ! &!
'! ! !
! ( .
K

K

/D(H0
/D(CH0 !

/D(G0 !
" .

/D(J0
@ @ K N
O @

" '!.

@
K @ @ @ @ @ @ @ /D(F0
! ' &!

! ( ! ;

/D(G0 !& ; /& &' 0
/D(D0 ! " .
; K

; S

N
O @

/D(D0
"
; K
; K ;

/D(DC0

! ; ; #
! ! !# .
; S

N
O @
K
/D(D0

/D(G0
'&
'.
; K

N
O

/D(D0
"
!

& & &' ( *)& /D(D0 !!
; (
DJ
$#"
- ,
'&
! &&
!#
)!& " ' #
! ! ';( /D(G0(
= ! "
)
#
! ! 4" -&
.
; K
/D(DD0

/D(G0 /D(J0 /D(DD0 " .
;
;
N
O @

/D(DE0
"

;
;
/D(DG0
;
! ; ; #
! ! && .
;
N
O @
K

/D(DH0

!# ! " '.
;
N
O

/D(DJ0
"
! !
& & &' ( *)& /D(DJ0 !!
; (
(( ' '

3 & ! ! ! ! &
# "
#
! ! ! )!( = ' ! ! ! )&
!# ' /D(0 && /D(0(
#
! ! !# ' /D(D0.

N
O @
K ;
/D(DF0
&& ' /D(DH0.
N
O @
K ;

DF
/D(E0
8
/D(0 /D(DF0 !# "

N> O
N> O
"

@

N> O

;
/

K

N
O
/D(EC0
/D(E0

!
/D( D(E0 && "

>
>

@

;
/

K

/D(E0
"

> K N

O
/D(ED0
!
"
> K N O & ! * & *
/D(EE0

/D(EC0 /D(E0 ' & ! ! "
" .

N O
N O

@

K

/D(EG0
> '! @

' @

/ &!'( '!
' ; &!' !#

; && (

! N O N O
' > > &!' !# >
> && (
4 " " !!
) # "

& '!
# "

(
&
# " ( '!
!

" /(GD0 !& ( ? /(GD0 !

"! ! " ! ! (
! !
' &!
! !
! ! !( /(EE0 &!

& (
E
()

&. &

*
0 +

' &!

!
-&! ! ! &

" & .
C( & ! ! "! !
&! (
(
. 4

! ! !
( ! !
! ! 7
) "! & ! !
&

(
(
!!
) '!. ? !

!
7!' 7
) ! '!

(
D( ? 4" -& (
E( 8 ! !. !
!& ! (
-'
(
G( 8 ! .
&

!# ! ! (
! ! 7
) '!
!
" !
7!' 7
) 7!'
! '!(
'(
$ ! !% "!

!
&
! ! ! / /D(D00 ( ! !

! ; ! ! (

' $ ! !% "! &&

( = # " & ! ! !
' /D(E0 )&
(
EC
! ! & !! ! ! !

&& ! !
! (
H( &!
-! ! /& 0
&!
& C (
J( * " !
. & !!
/(
1
4" ,!'0 & & /( ' !
0
* " &
(
1
.
' !
&!

( ! /( ! ! !

&! &! &! &! !0
( &
! * " &
(
4" 5 ,!' . < ' !

&!-

) &
!
&

! (

!
( !
2 & ( & ! 2 &
* " !

&
( &

!# )
(
F( <& . ! ! ! &(

C( 8 ' !. ! ! ! ' ! !!#(
4" -& ! ' !

)
!
( ! ' ! !
4" -& ! ! ' !(
E
#
$

! -
!
-&!
! ! &
" ! '&
'&
!& D( 7
)

) ! '! '

! " 4"
#9 !
& '!
!! !
-&( ! '& J- !#

-& 2-3
! ! ! (
! " 1
!
2 -3

" '& ' 1& NEHO

! &! / - " ! ! &
0( 4"
,!' -

" !
,!'
!

! ( ,!'
! !
&' "
(
" !.
C( 3

! *! ? (
( 3
*! 8 !-
&! (
( 3

! *-&! ? (
D( 3
*-&! 8 ! (
E
) &

&. * :
.
.
4
!
/ '(
P lb/in2
2.85
Z
Time(sec)
P
h
X
L
E(C. 8 ' .

!
!
# &
' ? NCHO !

! ! ( /E(C0 "

! ! ' ;(
!
&

.
3 ! ' 3 K C !
> K C( !
= K C( !
I 9
* K C C W
9 ' K (
( K C C -!W
' 1 (

'
ED

-& ! ' ! ! &&

& ! !! " && ;
!
& !(
! ' ! ! !
&&&
( &

!
& ! ' !
! ) ! &&
&(
C(
(
. " !;
! '-
! (
& CE C
CZ (
! ! ' ! !
!; 4( C.
8 4

. J /
8
. EGH
0
!; 4( .
8 4

. GD /D
8
. HE
D D0

! ' ! ! !; '
!! ( !(

(
1 (
. "
-& !
& ! ' ! ( !; /D D D0 ! ' !
! CZ(

-& CK CE C

-& K DE C
!(
!(

& ' &&)

(

-& DE C !(
!
& " 1
" !
,!'
" /E(-E(0( "

&!
'
)

&!
' -
! (
EE
0.8
Jaumann
New Objective
0.7
Max Deflection Ratio(w/L)
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0.1
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
Time(sec)
E(.
! & ! ' @ K DE C
!
Jaumann
New Objective
1600
Max.Equivalent Stress (psi)
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
Time(sec)
0.01
0.012
0.014
E(. )

' & @ K DE CD !
EG
) &

* +
0# 0
.
4"
/ . , 5(

Z
V=1.0 m/s
10.0 m
Bar A
).1 m
Bar B
Roller B.C
10.0 m
X
1.0 m
Bar B is fixed at thsi end.
E(D.
&! " !
&
' ?!# 4 NDDO( /E(D0 "
! " ! ( 5 '
'!
&! " ! (
&&
! "' & ! C
W!( ! : K &

&& ! .
I 9
* K C 4=.
9 ' K (
( K (C +=.(

! && ! ".
3 3 K C(
!# K C(
EH
= K C(
'!

&! ( C
W!( 4"
#9 !

!! '! !!

' " ; !!
&!( !'
& " " #& C
! ! !
! CC
(
' 1 (
' .

! ' ! ! ! &&&
( 4)

-& ! ' ! ! ! &&
&(
C(
(
. " !;
! '-
! (
& C ! ! ' ! ! CZ
(
!; 4( C.
8 4

. C /C
8
. C
C C0
!; 4( .
8 4

. /
8
. E
C C0
" ! !; ' ( !

(
(
1 (
. "
-& !
& ! ' ! ( !; / C C0 ! ' !
! CZ(

-& CK !(

-& K C !(

-& ! ' ! "
-& ' (
! (
EJ
/E(E0 /E(G0 ' '!

!
/ K CC0 " ! / K C0( /E(H0 /E(J0 ' !
&
"
)

' ? &!'( ?
&!

'
)

' (
EF
1.5
Velocity (m/sec)
0.5
Jaumann
New Objective
0.5
1
0
6
Time(sec)
10
12
E(E. B! !
0.8
Jaumann
New Objective
0.6
Velocity (m/sec)
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.4
0.6
0
6
Time(sec)
10
E(G. B! ! ?
G
12
0.8
Jaumann
New Objective
Max.Equivalent Stress (N/m sq)
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
6
Time(sec)
10
12
E(H. )

'
1.4
Max.Equivalent Stress (N/m sq)
1.2
Jaumann
New Objective
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
6
Time(sec)
10
E(J. )

' ?
GC
12
4""
%1*
/ . 6 53

5
4
Z
P
Vo
6
X
16
E(F. 5

&! " ! !#
! &
!
&
&! " !
!# /& &
0 " E(F( &
& ! NDFO( & !# '
'! K /C C0 /
!
" 0(
!
&& .
> ?!#
8 K E
8 K D
?!#
8 K CG
8 K G
I 9
/
0 K C !#(
9 /' 0 K !#(
/(0 K C !#(
G

!; NDFO ' ' &
& &
( ? NGO
'
&
! ! 1

!
2 -3
" 1& NEHO '
&
! ! ! 1

!
2 -3
( "# "' " !

,!'
!
!
&
7!( ! 9 ; & &

" '
( "# &
' "

? -! ( '!

! ! "
7 ? -! &!
! )
(
" !;
& ! .
!; .
8 4

!# K /E
8 4

!# K FG /CG
8 4
(( !# K CJ
8 4
(( !# K HCD
C D0
C G0

-& K (C
" 7 !( ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! !! /&0 " (D(
&!
& &

1
" !
,!'
/E(C0
/E(CC0( ? &!

! ! "
" !#( 8
&
)

' ? "
/E(C0 /E(C0(
)

' &! "
7 !

-&( 4 &!! '(
G
1
Jaumann(frictionless)
New Objective(frictionless)
Jaumann(frictional)
New Objective(frictional)
0.5
Displacement
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
Time(sec)
0.2
0.25
0.3
E(C. L-&!

& (
1
Jaumann(frictional)
Displacement
0.5
0.5
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
Time(sec)
0.2
E(CC. M-&!

& (
GD
0.25
160
140
Max.Equivalent Stress
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
Jaumann(frictional)
0.5
1.5
2.5
Time(sec)
E(C. )

' !#
140
Max.Equivalent Stress
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
Jaumann(frictional)
0.5
1.5
2.5
Time(sec)
E(C. )

' !# ?
GE
)! &

&. *
0 0
:
. .
4#
!
Z
! / *%

Dynamic load of 40 N/mm2
5(7)
6(8)
5(6)
8(7)
2(1)
4(3)
1(3)
2(4)
L=30mm
E(CD. 8 .

!
&
! ,! ) &
! -&! (

! " /E(CD0(
!
&& .
! /30 K
I 9
/*0 K CCCD(EJ 4W..
9 /' 0 K (G
/(0 K C +W..
> !! /+0 K JH(D 4W..
> )& / 0 K (FF
/ ) 0 K DD(EJ 4W..
GG
!; .
4

K C /C C C0
4

K D
! ' ! ! CZ( ' & '
&! /E(CE0 1
" !

,!'
( ! "
)
)
S /# 0
/E(C0
&
( " & &!
" 7

! " " ! !'

( &! !!(
60
Equivalent Stress(MPa)
50
40
30
20
Hardening Law Actual
Jaumann
New Objective
10
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
Equivalent Plastic Strain
0.08
E(CE. *-&! & !
GH
0.1
4#"
!
/
7, 1*(
P N/mm2
7.5
X
h
Time(sec)
Quarter of plate
L
Fixed
along X
direction
X
L
Fixed along Y direction
E(CG. .

!

&! & & ) !
-&! ' ( /E(CG0 "

! &( 5 &

? )( &! &
(

!
& .
& /30 K CE
!# & /0 K E
I 9
/*0 K CCCD(EJ 4W

9 /' 0 K (G
> !! /+0 K JH(D 4W

> )& / 0 K (FF
/ ) 0 K DD(EJ 4W..
&
/(0 K C +W..
GJ
' 1(

'

-& ! ' ! ! !
&&&

&(

& ' "(
C(
(
.
& @ K
! CZ( !; .
C
- :
! ' !
!; C.
8 4

K /C C 0
8 4

K CJF
!; .
8 4

K CG /
8 4

K GGCE
D0

! ' ! ! !; '
( ! !
& (
(
(
.

& "(

D ! ' ! ! CZ(

-& C. G C

-& . C

- :
- :

& '
(

& (
1
" !
,!'
" /E(CH-E(CJ0( < 1
&! " &!
& / E(CH0 & / E(CJ0
!
& " !
,!'
(
! )& "( "-# " 1

,!' " &!
( = &!
!
&
! 8! !
&
" !! !

!
(
& &
&!

&! &

)

' (
&!
GF

)

' " 1

( >"'
&' &
/! E((C0 !& !
" & (
' ' " ' &! & &! 2 & /! &0 !; / E(CF-E(0( " ' !
&!
" !
,!'

! ' " " !
!'
( 5 &! 1

! ! !'
( !

'
)

' &! 1

(
H
0.35
Maximum Deflection ratio (w/2L)
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
Jaumann at 0.3e03
Jaumann at 0.6e03
New Objective at 0.3e03
0.1
0.05
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
Time(sec)
0.1
0.12
0.14
0.16
E(CH. )

&!
& &
Maximum Equivalent Stress(MPa)
150
100
50
Jaumann at 0.3e03
Jaumann at 0.6e03
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
0.16
Time(sec)
E(CJ. )

' & &
HC
80
Jaumann
New Objective
1st element 1st Gauss point
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
E(CF. B ' " ' &! /E E C0

80
70
60
50
40
30

Jaumann
New Objective
1st element 1st Gauss point
20
10
0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
E(. B ' " ' &! / D0
H
)( &

*
0 +
0#
.
4$

/ 0(
4
X
4
E(C.
&! & &
&

&! & " & ! -&! ! !
&! / /E(C00( & ' '! B K /C-C0
!
" ( & ) ( !!
! & K ((

! & & " /E(C0(

&&
".
I 9
/
0 K D C

9 /' 0 K (
/(0 K D
//) 0 0 K E
H
> !! / 0 K D

> )& /0 K (D

& ( (
& &
".
4

& K GH / /E(0 /E(00
4

& K CD /CG CG D0
4
((( & K CF
4
((( & K DE
E(.

& & / '"0
&!

& "
/E(D0 /E(E0 ! ! /E(G0 /E(H0 !
! ( ' &!
&!

! "( 8 ' ! ! " ! ! ! "
!
,!'
! !

(
'
)

' & &
! ! " /E(J0( ' !
HD
E(.

& & /! '" L-M & 0
1

&! '
)

' & &( ! ! "
/E(F0( >
)

' &! ,

(
" & &
&!
"

(
&&
'
".
I 9
/
0 K CCCDEJ C 4W

9 /' 0 K (G
/(0 K #W

K DDEJ C 4W

> !! / 0 K JHD C 4W

> )& /0 K (FF
'! ' & /C-C0
W !
"
/E(C0 !! ! ! ! ! ( !
" ! (
& ( ! (
HE
&!

& ! ! "
/E(0 /E(C0( ! ! " /E(0
/E(0( '
)

' & &
" /E(D0 ! ! /E(E0 ! ! (
8 ' ! ! " ! ! !
" & (C ! ! 1
(JC !
! " !
,!' ( ! 1

&! '
)

' (
1.4
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj
1.2
Displacement
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
Time(sec)
0.08
0.1
E(D. &!

& -! ! !(
HG
0.6
0.5
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj
Displacement
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.1
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
Time(sec)
0.08
0.1
E(E. &!

& -! ! !(
0.35
0.3
Displacement (m)
0.25
0.2
0.15
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj.
0.1
0.05
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
Time(sec)
0.08
0.1
E(G. &!

& -! ! !(
HH
0.7
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj.
0.6
0.5
Displacement
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0.1
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
Time(sec)
0.08
0.1
E(H. &!

& -! ! !(
x 10
Equivalent Stress
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0
Sphere(J)
plate(J)
Sphere(N)
Plate(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj
0.02
0.04
0.06
Time(sec)
0.08
0.1
E(J. )

' & & ! !
HJ
3.5
x 10
Sphere(J)
Plate(J)
Sphere(N)
Plate(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj.
Equivalent Stress
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
Time(sec)
0.08
0.1
E(F. )

' & & ! !
0.35
0.3
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj.
Displacement
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
Time(sec)
0.02
0.025
0.03
E(. &!

& -! /&!
0 ! !
HF
0.08
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj.
0.06
Displacement
0.04
0.02
0.02
0.04
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
Time(sec)
0.02
0.025
0.03
E(C. &!

& -! /&!
0 ! !
0.09
0.08
Displacement(m)
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
0.01
0.012
0.014
Time(sec)
E(. &!

& -! /&!
0 ! !
J
0.005
Bottom node(J)
Bottom node(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj
Displacement(m)
0.01
0.015
0.02
0.025
0.03
0.035
0.04
0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
0.01
0.012
0.014
Time(sec)
E(. &!

& -! /&!
0 ! !
7
x 10
4.5
4
Equivalent Stress
3.5
3
2.5
Sphere(J)
plate(J)
Sphere(N)
Plate(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
Time(sec)
0.02
0.025
0.03
E(D. )

' & & /&!
0
! !
JC
x 10
Equivalent Stress
3
Sphere(J)
Plate(J)
Sphere(N)
Plate(N)
J Jaumann
N New Obj.
0
0
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
Time(sec)
0.01
0.012
0.014
E(E. )

' & & /&!
0
! !
J
%

& '
- +

,!' & "# !
& ' &
! " ,!'

!
1

"
!
,!'
( !
& ! "
!.
C( 3

! ! (
( 3
! ! !-
&! (
( 3

! -&! (
D( 3
-&! ! !-
&! (
" ! ! ! " .
C( - !
' ! (
( ! ! !
)

' &! "

" 7 (
( - -&! 1

&!
)

' !
& " !
,!'

( >"' &
'' &
!(
J
D( ! -&! ! ! 1

&!
)

' !
& " !
,!'
(
-

%

) "# " .
C( 8 &
&' 1

" ,!'
( 5
" &&&
! !& !
&' ! &
(
( ' ! &! ! !

&
&- &- !# & ! ! ! ! !
4" -& ! (
(
!#
! !&(
D(
& 7! ! !(
E( 5& & !
'& ! ! 7
)
! !&(
G( 5

# #
! &! "
&" " !
&
(
H( 4 -!! ! " !
7! ! (
J( ' ' & & &!
& - (
JD
$
NCO ( >(
CFE(
! )
( 5) < ' 5)
NO 3( *( ' ( .

! "

( !
> !( * " 87 4" 1 CFGF(
NO 5( 8( M #"!; L( +( 3 ( 4#;"(
!
) '

( .
+ ,
.CD CFJG(
NDO +( 1( ?(
,
) ( ! > 4" CFFG(
NEO ( 2( >( 4"
#9
- !
!( .
+ ,
E.JG CFHE(
NGO 1( >( ( *-&!
) &!

! ( + 5 ( GF.G CFGE(
NHO 1( 8( 4 1( *( 1 (
!
& &! !-&!
( .
+ ,
CH.CE CFJC(
NJO ( ( 8(

,
5

C( 1 = 8! CFFD(
! (
(
'-
NFO ( >( 1( 4

! ! &! !
&

( " ( G.HGH CFJH(
NCO ( 1(
&!
&! & (
,
" .EC CFJG(
NCCO ( 8
1( ?( ( 8 ' ! 4" -&

!-&! !
( .
+ ,
C.CHH CFFC(
JE
NCO ( 5; *(( &'( !!!

&! ! ' ( .
+ ,
C.CEGC CFJE(
NCO ( ( 2 ( ( ( )

!

'
&!( .
+ "

,
(
/0.F C(
NCDO 1( 8# (
! )
( !2" > 4" I# CFJC(
NCEO *( >( 3( *!-&!

( + 5 G.C CFGF(
NCGO ( (
! -! # ( ( & (
NCHO +( 1( ? *(
*( 3( = (

! ( .
+ ,
F.E CFHE(
NCJO ( ( # 2( >( "(
- !

! & ( .
+ ,
CC.DFF CFHH(
NCFO ( ( 2 ( ( ( 4
!
) "
&!( .
+ "
,
(
C/C0.C (
NO >( >;( 5 ! ! ! ( + ! F.CEG CJJC( / 2
0(
NCO +( 3( 1 ( 5 >; ! !( )
! .

!
,
'
CFG & G CFJ(
NO 4( ( #'( ( #
47 2 CFE(
) # !
NO 2( ( 3( 2"( "

#
"
[ 47 & , CFJ(
! ,
! ,
NDO ( 5(
! ! ! &
(
CG/FE0.HFH CFH(
( ,7

! +(,
NEO ( 2 ( ' & ! ! ! " ! (
( H.EF CFHH(
"
NGO ( !' 5( 8( M #"!;(

! !
& !
! ! &
( .
+ ,
F.FC CFHE(
JG
NHO ( ( !' 8( B(

# (
"
! ! ! &
" ! ( .
+ ,

CH.CEH CFJC(
NJO 1( 1( +# I( ' (

& !& ! ! ! !
" &&! ->; -&! ! ! &
( + ,
G.CF
CFH(
NFO 4( ( > 2( )!( ! ! ! !

! &
! ( " ( CC.EE CFJ(
NO ( (
( +( -7 ( ( *->( -!

! ! &
!
! ') &

( "
( F/CW0.C CFFC(
NCO 1( ?
( !
& 7 ! !
" &&! (
( G/CW0.H CFJH(
"
NO 4( 2( ?(

' ! !
( 2 / 6' '

4

5
7 !" (
NO 4( +#! 1( ( 5 (
"
) #
, 8 5 ( ! 9

.
3

,
(
& CFJJ(
NDO +( 1( ? ( 8(

& )
!
! ! &
( .
+ ,
C.GE CFJE(
NEO ( = 1( 8(
( 7 - ! !
&
( "
5 C.CFF CFJE(
NGO >( !( ! 7
) -
-
! ! ( .
+ ,
J.CJ CFJF(
NHO =( 8 1( I(

! ! &

" ! ( " ( F/0.D CFJJ(
NJO ( 1( 2 1( 1( ;(
)

! ! !
&
( .
+ ,
J.CDF CFJF(
JH
NFO M( >( M (

,
) ! "
. ) #( 5) < ' 5) CFF(
NDO 2( 2 ( ( 3 ' ! !
!
(

H/C0.CC (
NDCO 1( >( ?( ( +"#( 3 &!

! " !
! ! !
&

( " ( J.FHH (
NDO *( ? ! 2( 1( 8(
-
! !

&!
&
( " ( GF.CF CFFJ(
NDO ( 8( = ( *-&!
&! ! '
-

'
( 9 I " < ' CFFJ(
NDDO ( ?!# ( 5( 4( 8 !-
&! &
" &
3
( .
+ ,
C.EDH CFFC(
NDEO 1( 2( 4( 3( 1 ( &
! !W
&!
- )&! . \ !

! !
! !( .
+ ,
H.EEF CFFD(
NDGO +( ?" ( " (
& ?( > !# ( !

&!
( " 5 ,
CJD.HE (
NDHO ( 3( ( &&( 5

! ! !W
&! &
( .
+ ,
G.C CFF(
NDJO ( ( 3 B( 8"( ! '
!

! ! ! &
( .
+ ,
D.JG CFFH(
NDFO (
*( !;( " &'
-&&
!
! ! &
.
( " 5 ,

CHF.CEC CFFF(
NEO ( 3( B( *(
( !
! ! !W
&! &

! !( .
+ ,
.G CFFC(
NECO 1( 8(
( ( 3 (
3
! !
&
'' ! ( " ( D/C0.CCG CFF(
JJ
NEO 8( + *( ( & ( 5; 1( *( (

! !( " 5 ,
CJ.C CFFF(
NEO +( ( ( B(
! !-
&!
&
( " 5 ,
CJH.GF (
NEDO 1( +( ( 5
(

.CH CFHF
5
NEEO ( (; ( 4( ( 5 ,!'

7 ! '
(
"

C/0.FC CFJG(
NEGO ( 4( B (
!
-&! ! ( 9 &
! ! * + & (
NEHO 1& <(?(

! *-! ! ! &
" ! ( 9 &

! ! * + &
(
NEJO =( 1 ;

"

NEFO 3( ( 5

8
& 4" I# CFHH(
! 8
& 4" I# CFGH(
"

NGO ( ( 1( 5" *( >

,

)
" . /CFJ0(
!

4
)
NGCO ( ( ) B( , 4( 4( + ( # ?

&!
" " ! 3 8
!( ,! & &

! ! * + & CFFE(
NGO 5( 8(M #"!;(
,
( !2"-> 4" C(
NGO +& ?(

! -&! ! ! &
(
9 &
! ! * + & (
JF

High Velocity Contact Impact Fracture Study

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

High Velocity Contact Impact Fracture Study

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis



    

 !   "# !      $ 

  

 &'    "#   

 )( 8 ! !     

C(C '"  3   ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

(G(  ! "  ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( CF

,      +  -

/  ' 

E(C 3 

&!  "  !  ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

&!   &  & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

I 9  

4 -  &   7 

    

    ! &&    -  & 

    !!    -& !  NCO    # 

 ! 

 ' !  ? NDO  8#   NCDO( 

   NCE CGO (

?   NCHO " &     &&   

! ;   ; '      

 &  & !      !!!      ! ( 

/ !#" *-   !

   ! !   !      !        

!  '!    ! ! ! !    ! 

   '  !   

        &

! &&   '

%&' ( )*(

    ,! '  

  NEDO( 5   ,! '   

  

 "# !   !&   

   !    &  

   & !    -& !

"       &  '!   & !  

"        &  

!  !    ! (    ! 

    

!  ' 

    ,! '  

> (  ( &    

R K P 

   '! (    )6  

 (C. ) 

"   !

(  ' 

" %  & !&   !     /(D0( !

" %  &  3

( (,- *

;  &   !       

        

" %   !   

       &   !   !   )& % .

" #    ! &  # 

F& ) )

K &   S C '   /& S  0)

F& )  )

1 #    2    %

" '  2 -3     /  0   .

'  2 -3     ! !

/  0 K /@  0 K /@" S  @$ 0

! "# ! $

&' "#

)( 8 ! !

C(C '" 3 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

(G( ! " ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( CF

, + -

/ '

E(C 3

&! " ! ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

&! & & ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

I 9

4 - & 7

! && - &

!! -&! NCO #

!

' ! ? NDO 8# NCDO(

NCE CGO (

? NCHO " & &&

!; ; '

& & ! !!! !(

/ !#" *- !

! ! ! !

! '! ! ! ! ! !

' !

&

! && '

%&' ( )*(

,!'

NEDO( 5 ,!'

"# ! !&

! &

&! -&!

" & '! &!

" &

! ! ! ( !

! '

,!'

> ( ( &

R K P

'!( )6

(C. )

" !

( '

" % & !& ! /(D0( !

" % & 3

( (,- *

; & !

" % !

& ! ! )& % .

" # ! & #

F& ) )

K & S C ' /& S 0)

F& ) )

1 # 2 %

" ' 2 -3 / 0 .

' 2 -3 ! !

/ 0 K /@ 0 K /@" S @$ 0

/(DD0 ! " " !

'

; " ' " &&)

/(DC0 .

) /" 0

' /(E0 & (

@# K @# @# @# @# @# @#

@# K @# @# @# @# @# @#

) K ) ) ) ) ) )

C( N O ! ' & @ K N O @"

) & '! & 8!

" @ @ @ # " !

U K

"! ! / 2 30 ! & ! ( &

)&

K U U U U

< /(CD0 /(CJ0 /(CF0 /(0 ! /(CC0

! (

!! % &5

&& ! ! /(0 "

! / (

)& /(0 !

" 7!' 7