Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
90 JULY 2004
UDC 669 . 14 . 018 . 841
Motohiro OKUSHIMA*2
Satoshi NISHIMURA*4
Kazuhiro KOJIMA*1
Abstract
New S-TENTM*1, a corrosion resistant low alloy steel (CRLS) was developed. Based
on the conventional S-TENTM1, a classic and standard CRLS for sulfuric acid dew
corrosion, its corrosion resistance against acid containing chlorides such as hydrochloric acid was drastically improved by Nippon Steels novel alloy-design technology. As an economical countermeasure against acid dew corrosion, new S-TENTM1
is being widely used for plants such as power stations, waste incinerators, industrial
refuse furnaces, and various so-called eco-plants, in which hydrochloric acid dew
corrosion as well as sulfuric acid dew corrosion is anticipated. New welding materials for new S-TENTM1 were also developed, which show equivalent corrosion resistance and solve selective corrosion of welded metal.
*1
*2
*3
*4
Yawata Works
*5
Tokai Kozai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
* S-TEN and WELACC5 are Nippon Steel Trademarks
1. Introduction
- 25 -
Coal fired
power plants
LNG fired
power plants
100-2,000ppm
<1ppm
5-10%
100-2,000ppm
Not available
5-10%
10-20%
20-150ppm*3)
300-1,500ppm*3)
10-50%
+++ *1)
- *1)
100-150C
(sulfuric acid)
Air preheaters
Ducts, stacks
+++
Low
100-150C
(sulfuric acid)
Air preheaters
Ducts, GGH
+++
Low-high*2)
50-60C
(water)
Air preheaters
Ducts, stacks
++
+++
(++)
Extremely high
Sulfuric acid : 100-150C
Hydorchloric acid : 50-80C
Rapid coolers
Bug-filters
Ducts, stacks
perature and concentration between the gas and the surface. Generally speaking, even when the concentration of SO3 in flue gas is as
low as 1 ppm, the dew point of sulfuric acid becomes higher than
100C, and therefore, it is difficult to avoid the occurrence of sulfuric acid dew corrosion in flue gas treatment facilities in operation.
For this reason, sulfuric acid-resistant steels such as S-TENTM1 have
been widely used for this kind of equipment.
2.2 Waste incineration and recycling plants (sulfuric and hydrochloric acid dew corrosion)
Fig. 1 schematically illustrates how sulfuric and hydrochloric acid
dew corrosion occurs in the flue gas system of a waste incineration
plant. The exhaust gas from a waste incineration plant contains SOX
(50 to 1,000 ppm), HCl (100 to several thousand ppm) and moisture
by a comparatively large percentage (30 to 50%), and thus, when the
steel surface temperature of the flue gas treatment equipment is sufficiently lower than the dew points of sulfuric and hydrochloric acids, these acids form.
Towards the realization of a sustainable and recycling-based society, reduction of environmental loads and enhancement of resource
productivity have come to be strongly aspired in the production and
consumption sectors recently, and as a result, the subject materials
of recycling have been rapidly diversified. However, many of the
materials to be recycled such as waste incineration ash and waste
tires contain chloride ions. While waste incineration plants and recycling plants for various materials were constructed taking advantage of the recent rapid advance in environment protection technologies, there arose an increasing number of cases where the flue gas
treatment facilities of those plants were corroded because of a hydrochloric acid environment.
In October, 2002, Nippon Steel successfully developed new STENTM1 as a new steel product that is resistant to the hydrochloric
acid dew corrosion occurring in the flue gas treatment facilities of
waste incineration plants and recycling plants for various materials.
Since then, the company has sold the newly developed steel under
the trade name of S-TENTM1, replacing conventional S-TENTM1. In
the first year, more than 5,000 t of new S-TENTM1 was sold to more
than 100 customers and, by virtue of its new characteristics, its application is expanding to fields other than environment-related facilities as well. This paper describes the properties and advantages
of new S-TENTM1.
- 26 -
Si
Mn
Conventional
0.10 0.27 0.42
0.019 0.005
S-TEN1
New
0.02 0.27 0.95
0.011 0.011
S-TEN1
Other micro-elements may be contained for purposes.
Cu
(mass%)
Sb
0.31
0.10
0.29
0.10
P
0.025
S
0.025
- 27 -
Cu
0.25/0.50
(mass%)
Sb
0.15
Test piece
(JIS)
No.5
Si
Mn
Carbon steel
0.15 0.14 0.70 0.010 0.010
(JIS SS 400)
Conventional
0.10 0.27 0.42 0.019 0.005
S-TEN1
New
0.02 0.27 0.95 0.011 0.011
S-TEN1
(mass%)
Sb Ti
Cu
Cr
0.31
0.10
0.29
0.10
Youngs
modulus
Specific
heat
Heat
conductivity
(C)
25
100
200
300
400
(GPa)
207.4
203.7
198.3
192.0
184.0
(J/(kg K))
0.450
0.491
0.532
(W/(m K))
44.2
45.5
36.8
Coefficient of
thermal expansion
20C
(106/C)
12.8
13.2
13.6
14.0
Yield point
(mm)
2.3
6
12
16
(N/mm2)
300
320
384
417
Tensile Elongation
strength
(N/mm2)
(%)
436
37
432
42
446
42
458
43
Test
Bending test
R=1.5t
(t : thickness)
piece
JIS
No.5
Good
- 28 -
the results. Heavy corrosion occurs even in stainless steel (JIS SUS
304, SUS 316L, etc.) under such a condition, but conventional STENTM1 and new S-TENTM1 showed excellent corrosion resistance
under this condition. As another exposure test, coupon test pieces of
the chemical compositions shown in Table 6 were attached to a radial seal at the cold-end side of a Ljungstrom type air preheater of a
coal-fired power plant. Table 7 shows the results. It is clear from
these results that new S-TENTM1 exhibits corrosion resistance equal
to or better than that of conventional S-TENTM1 in both the laboratory test and the real sulfuric acid dew corrosion environment.
4.2 Corrosion resistance in hydrochloric acid corrosion environment
Fig. 4 shows the results of immersion tests where specimens of
various steels were immersed in 10.5 and 1% sulfuric acid solutions
at 80C. It is understood from the graphs that the resistance to sulfuric acid of new S-TENTM1 is markedly better than that of conventional S-TENTM1 especially in the 1% solution. Comparing new STENTM1 with the SUS grade steels (with the suffix SS meaning stainless steel), it is seen here that the former is superior to the latter as
the temperature and the concentration increase.
Dew corrosion by sulfuric and hydrochloric acids or sulfuric acid
and metal chloride salts occurs in waste incineration plants and the
like, as described earlier. In consideration of this, the authors investigated the influence of the addition amount of NaCl over the corrosion rate in a dilute sulfuric acid solution (0.3 N, or 1.5 mass %), and
Fig. 5 shows the results. Chloride ions exhibit an effect to decrease
- 29 -
Fig. 6 Corrosion loss in thickness of duct panels at coke oven gas, where
sulfuric acid dew corrosion involving chloride-containing ashes
Welding
material
Base metal
Remarks
Shield metal
arc welding
(SMAW)
Flux cored
arc welding
(FCAW)
ST-16M
ST-16
S-16
SF-1ST
FC-1ST
SF-1
New S-TEN1
Conv. S-TEN1
Mild steel (JIS SS 400)
New S-TEN1
Conv. S-TEN1
Mild steel (JIS SS 400)
New
New
-
Tension test
Charpy impact test
Tensil Elongation Absorbed energy
strength
(MPa)
(%)
(J)
568
31
165 at 0C
640
27
71 at 0C
Yield
point
(MPa)
471
581
Si
Mn
Cu
Sb
ST-16M
SF-1ST
0.04
0.05
0.62
0.60
0.50
1.41
0.009
0.012
0.004
0.013
0.42
0.39
0.08
0.10
- 30 -
- 31 -
- 32 -