Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
No. 11-2277
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Western
District of Virginia, at Abingdon.
James P. Jones, District
Judge. (1:11-cv-00049-JPJ-PMS)
Argued:
Decided:
PER CURIAM:
The Oryn Treadway Sheffield, Jr. Trust and the John Tolman
Sheffield
Trust
dismissing
(Appellants)
their
complaint
(Consolidation).
appeal
against
district
Consolidation
court
Coal
order
Company
assumpsit,
and
negligence,
and
seeking
money
lands
hereinafter
identified,
together
with
all
rights,
County,
Virginia,
as
described].
J.A.
71.
On
Coal
with
Corporation
all
all
rights,
the
coal,
privileges
and
metals
and
easements
timber,
incident
J.A. 76.
Following that
which
[Island
Creek
Coal]
may
deem
needful
or
J.A.
his
second
wife,
Jessie
Maie
Pobst.
As
part
of
the
Pobst
granted
her
late
husbands
children
one-half
Pobst
died
Buchanan County.
seized
J.A. 37.
and
possessed,
and
situate[d]
in
Treadway
Sheffield
Sheffield,
Trust.
Her
Jr.,
interest
Trust
in
the
and
the
Buchanan
John
Tolman
parcels
thus
Buchanan
parcels
other
than
timber.
coal,
oil,
minerals in
gas,
metals
or
Island
Creek
Coal
mined
coal
from
the
Buchanan
parcels
that, during the time Island Creek Coal was utilizing the VP3
Mine,
minerals
such
as
ore,
rock,
mining
in
the
VP3
Mine
or
any
other
J.A. 62-63.
ceased
in
homogeneous
While active
1988,
the
amended
wastewater
from
the
Buchanan
No.
Mine
into
the
The district
Appellants
in
failed
to
allege
facts
their
complaint
that
As such, it
on
[Appellants]
minerals.
Consolidation
Oryn
Coal
ownership
Treadway
Co.,
819
interest
Sheffield,
F.
Supp.
2d
in
the
Jr.,
625,
631
other
Trust
v.
(W.D.
Va.
2011).
Appellants
now
appeal
the
dismissal
of
their
complaint.