Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Munning:
A (Possibly)
Comprehensive
Guide
By Your EB
Munning: 2
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
1. What is Munning?
HEAVEN! Okay, perhaps not, in fact some people would probably
disagree with me on this, but MUNs or Model United Nations, are events
where people can attend the proceedings as delegates, representing
various nations. The atmosphere is of intense debate, competition
(ruthless at times) and activism. MUNs are of varied levels, and the most
common ones are at the interschool level.
Without further ado, lets jump right in.
Munning: 3
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 4
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
member of the EB acknowledges that you are given the right to speak,
can you speak. Also, go back to the previous paragraph. This is the
reason youre saying that.
Be civil and somewhat formal in your communication. MUNs
have the possibility of using chits/notes to facilitate communication.
However, all notes are read by the EB and the OC member in the
committee, and if deemed appropriate, are sent to the recipient. The
format for a chit/note is
To: Countrys name
From: Countrys name
Message: _________________________________
Okay, I assure you, the boring part is now over.
https://drive.google.com/open?id=0BxGSihTATsOmNVNWVVRGX2V0R2FSU2s0V19iMXly
TTBINVMw
2.
3.
4.
5.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i9Rwhw-L2iU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A0XrpsyFKR0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHH0UApEYis
http://bestdelegate.com/mun-made-easy-how-to-get-started-with-model-united-nations/
2. The Preparation:
Most delegates really struggle with this part. Its hard where to start, how
to start, what to do and generally everything is a huge question mark.
These are the things that I found helpful while preparing. I highly
encourage you to see the same too.
Step 1: Analyse the agenda, if any.
Most committees of the MUN have agendas a clear-cut and decided
range of topics that would be covered in the session. Let me give you an
example:
Munning: 5
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
CIA World Factbook Page: The go-to for MUNers, the CIA World Factbook is filled with
information about your country. The CIA Factbook has information about your countrys
geography, its economy, its government, its population, and many more facts and figures!
Speeches at the UN: Want to find out what your country has actually said about the UN on
your topic? Using the UN Member States on the Record tool, you can find all the statements your
country has made to the UN General Assembly, Economic and Social Council, and Security
Council in the past few decades.
Official Government Website: As a Model UN delegate, youre representing the government
of the country youre assigned. Check out their website to see what your government has to say
about the issue.
Munning: 6
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
UN Permanent Mission: Check out your countrys permanent mission to the UN to find out
who your Permanent Representative to the UN is, find quotes, and search for your countrys
position on the most important issues to your committee.
BBC Timeline: Find the most important events in your countrys history! This can help you
figure out why your country has the policies it does, and what your history may be with the other
countries in your committee.
IMUNA Country Profile: The International Model United Nations Association has some quick
facts and resources for MUNers on each country- check out yours!
Munning: 7
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 8
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
speech, also, is typically rather short. Either way, this is indeed a good
GSL speech, but for its tiny flaws that matter little.
Another GSL speech:
With the prior permission of the executive board, the delegate of France
would like to express his views on the agenda.
France solemnly confirms that the world is becoming increasingly
turbulent. Crises dominate the headlines and new threats have emerged
threats, that unlike before, are affiliated to no nation-state and act
against our very ways of living and the very ideas of our nations.
The emergence of radicalisation, extremism and terrorism, primarily
by non-state actors, is a major concern. They internally displace
innocent civilians, and also form a cause for refugees undertaking the
perilous journeys to Europe, in search of asylum. France has accepted
that it will indeed take in these refugees with open arms, as has the rest
of Europe.
Recently, our nation suffered a horrific tragedy, on the 13th of
November. We know how extremist elements endanger us: how they
strike at our very hearts. Yet were not afraid well never be (pause).
This is exactly why France has joined the much-needed coalition
against Daesh. We implore more and more nations to join, particularly
those which have shown unreasonable reluctance in doing so.
Another major problem facing us today is the emergence of more and
more border conflicts. Nations fighting each other, people losing their
lives in skirmishes this, certainly, has to stop. France is also deeply
concerned about the increasing distances between nations, as
ideologies clash and policies conflict. This era of polarisation in foreign
relations has only one casualty: the people themselves. Sanctions,
embargoes and the like put economic pressure on corrupt institutions,
no doubt; but in the end, it is the people who suffer, people who have no
hand nor interest in the world of diplomacy.
Perhaps it is high time that we, as nations, realise that we are nothing if
not for our people, and work for them. The delegate ends his speech
with the hope that there would be cooperation and cohesion in the
Munning: 9
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
proceedings today. Our enemy is one: our cause is one. Then why are
we divided?
The delegate yield his time to points of information and comments, if
any.
This speech is a minefield, when it comes to tough questions being
asked. Look at this sentence: We implore more and more nations to
join, particularly those which have shown unreasonable reluctance in
doing so. A sure-shot question would be, Which nations? This would
put the delegate in a fix, and lead to complications (and unwanted
retreat of allies) that are unwarranted. Try to avoid this as much as
possible.
As for the last paragraph, its too patronising and come-lets-unitewere-saintly-like. Its not working. Generally, leaving all this out of the
speech is advisable. Be to-the-point and precise.
There are some differences, and flaws, in the two speeches, but they
follow a certain format. Ive identified it as follows:
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
Munning: 10
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
________________________
Supporting facts and figures:
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
______________________________________
Your countrys stance and achievements, in relevance to the
agenda
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
______________________________
Call to action
_____________________________________________
_____________________________________________
______________________________________
Step 4: Getting the International Relations and Geopolitics
Right
Ive seen this is a recurring trend. In most MUNs, countries stray away
from the real-life policies and become heavily influenced by the
delegates opinions themselves (Ive seen China being against
censorship. Duh). This is acceptable to a certain degree, but is not
considered the mark of a good delegate. It could be one massive error in
geopolitics and youre out.
Munning: 11
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
What is geopolitics?
Geopolitics is a method of studying foreign policy to understand,
explain and predict international political behaviour through
geographical variables. (Wikipedia)
A delegate needs to have a basic understanding of foreign
relations. You must know the stance of all major nations and your
neighbours on specific issues. As an example, India and Pakistan cannot
agree on some issues. It would be a gross error to go about making an
alliance with them. Similarly, being Iran, you cant say you deny
Palestinian statehood because you support Israel. Thats not how it is. If
you do that, itll be considered that you lack basic awareness of
international relations. That will go against you.
And for gods sake. Dont quit the NATO just because you dont like the
delegate of USA. Ive seen that happen. Approach like-minded people
and blocs during unmoderated caucuses. Dont go to a bloc that shuns
you and makes you feel like you dont belong there. Make wise decisions.
Sometimes, issues you feel strongly about may be discussed, and if suits
you, join the group that aligns with your views.
Dont compromise on what you believe in (except if its an issue of
geopolitics; DPRK cant say yes to nuclear disarmament).
Russia
Russia
USA
China
France
UK
Italy
India
Germany
Bad
Good
BadNeutral
Good
Bad
Bad
Good
Good
Good
Good
Badneutral
Good
BadNeutral
Good
BadNeutral
Good
BadNeutral
Good
BadNeutral
Good
USA
Bad
China
Good
Bad
Bad/Trade
good
-
France
BadNeutral
Bad
Good
Bad-Neutral
BadNeutral
-
Good
Bad-Neutral
Good
Good
Good
Good
Badneutral
Good
Bad-Neutral
Good
Good
Good
Good
UK
Italy
Munning: 12
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
India
Good
Good
Bad-neutral
Good
Good
Good
Good
Germany
Badneutral
Good
Bad-neutral
Good
Good
Good
Good
3. Must-Knows
(Caution: This part is lengthyyyy.)
As a delegate at a MUN, youre supposed to know whats going on
currently in the world. A leader of a nation surely would be well-aware of
international crises, wars, epidemics, etc. Your duty is to be a wellinformed delegate. Ive compiled a list of must-knows, as of March-April
2016. This is subject to change, especially if something major happens
along the way its bound to.
Anyway, get at least some background information about the following
issues. If you dont know how to start, Id gladly help you if you wish.
(a) The Syrian Civil War and offshoots thereof;
(b)
South China Sea disputes;
(c) ISIS and the terror situation;
(d)
Refugee crisis in Europe;
(e) Israel-Palestine conflict;
(f) The outbreak of i) Ebola and ii) Zika virus;
Munning: 13
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 14
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 15
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 16
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 17
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
speak. People are dying - deaths that are unwarranted, deaths that could
easily be avoided.
Munning: 18
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syrian_Civil_War
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_Spring
http://www.aljazeera.com/topics/spotlight/syrian-crisis.html
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKb9GVU8bHE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5H5w3_QTG0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-l44KUQHoV (excuse the
French accent.)
I completely forgot about the Kurds. You NEED to know about
them, its actually pretty important.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uv5-q_9fpro
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5KLvjs7Yrtw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PMBMn0pwVk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8X0lnlqaUGY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jq9YQaKeiY0
Munning: 19
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Im terribly sorry, but a little bit of Geography here might help. For us
tenth standard students, this concept is no doubt familiar, but to the
rest, maybe not. So heres the concept: Exclusive Economic Zones. They
are well-defined areas that are beyond the shores of a countrys
landmass, which can be used by the said country for its development (i.e.
extracting resources, building military bases, killing aquatic life,
whatever). These are part of the territory of the country. They cannot be
encroached upon by some other entity. Going back to the map, we can
see very clearly that the South China Sea isnt Chinese far from that,
actually. Most of the sea is closer to ASEAN nations, and the southeastAsian nations. Most of the sea is part of their Exclusive Economic Zones.
But heres the thing. China is being an international bully and claiming
the whole of the South China Sea. Whys it doing that? Whats been done
about it? And why is this even a big deal?
Munning: 20
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 21
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 22
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Jews from Europe, from Asia (India too) started migrating to what we
today call Palestine. They called it aliyah. The holy migration.
At the same time, in the region, local Arabs (who were mostly Muslim)
also had caught hold of the idea of nationalism, and were developing the
idea of a Palestinian state. The Arab people who lived in the land of
Judea.
The problem? Both these groups claimed the same land.
Now, in this time period, the region that is today Israel-Palestine was
part of the huge Ottoman Empire. It was part of the Central powers
during the First World War. As we know, the Central powers lost.
Ottoman Turkey, as a result, has to give away lots of its territories
including Israel-Palestine to the Allies i.e. Britain, France and Russia.
These powers, as discussed earlier, cared little about the vast diversity of
the Middle East and just haphazardly made borders.
Britain was given control of Israel-Palestine. At that time, Israel didnt
even exist it was called British Palestine. Influenced by the Zionist
movement in Britain, the British government agreed on allowing the
migration of Jews to the land of British Palestine. This happened in large
numbers. The Jews who migrated were primarily
engaged in farming.
There were slight tensions between the migrant
Jews and the already present Palestinians, but on
the whole, the picture was pretty much peaceful.
Then the Holocaust happened.
Over six million Jews were killed during this time.
Obviously, the international community felt
obliged to listen to the victims of one of the largest,
if not the largest genocide the planet has seen as
a result, the United Nations set up the state of
Israel for the Jews, as promised to them in
religious texts. They didnt give Israel Palestinian
land just as it was. Instead, they demarcated clear
borders between the Israeli nation and the
Palestinian state. Right: Land for Israel in blue;
Palestinian land in orange.
Munning: 23
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 24
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
live in the West Bank in settlements like the one on the right.
Then, the anger boiled over.
Munning: 25
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Munning: 26
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gl8sWCxyPJw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kuH9G3KCYyg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dyqx7CDGrTA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1iVQdjMg_Y4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wo2TLlMhiw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0cG9OR2ofBg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1sib5HbdEV4
4. A Handy Rule-Book:
For all the lazy people like me, it just doesnt help at MUN to be
complacent (your EB always finds out). But, in case you want a small
flip-through of just the rules, here it is:
1. MUN =Model UN.
2. DELEGATE: The person representing a country in a committee is called a
delegate.
3. NO PERSONAL PRONOUNS
4. DRESS CODE is to be respected.
5. AGENDA: The agenda says what you need to research upon and talk upon. It
is the topic for your committee debate.
6. COMMITTEE: A hall with you and delegates of other countries of the same
committee.
7. EB/OC: Executive Board and Organising Committee. They run the entire
MUN.
8. NOTE: The way of communication inside committee. All notes are read by
the OC/EB. The format for a note is: From: (country); To: (country) Message: ------------------.
9. ROLL CALL: Answer when your countrys name is called and say present
or present and voting. If you say voting, then you cannot abstain from
voting on substantial issues (Substantial issues basically means stuff not
relevant to your country directly. For example, NATO has barely anything to
do with India, making it a substantial issue for India). If you do not say
voting, then you can abstain from voting in issues that are substantial to
your nation.
10. POSSIBLE MOTIONS AND POINTS:
Point/Motion
Purpose
Voting
Point of Personal
Personal Discomfort
No
Munning: 27
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Privilege
Point of Order
Point of Information
Factual Inaccuracy,
improper
parliamentary
procedure
No
To question a
delegate after his/her
GSL
No
No
To propose a motion
for a moderated
caucus
To form working
papers/draft
resolutions
Motion to Resume
Debate
To continue session
after a break/day
Motion to Introduce
Draft Resolution
To debate on draft
resolution submitted
2/3rd Majority
11. GENERAL SPEAKERS LIST: GSL is where you put forward the countrys
stances on the issue. And you should always begin by saying With the prior
permission of the EB, the delegate of so-and-so-country would like to begin
their speech. Then you put forward the countrys stance on the agenda. If
you have time left after your speech, then you can yield time. You can yield
time to the Chair, who can ask you questions OR yield your time to
something called points of information. Then other delegates can question
you on the basis of your speech.
12. CAUCUSES: There are 2 types of caucuses: Moderated (shortened MOD) and
Unmoderated (shortened UNMOD).
Munning: 28
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
13. MOD: For the motion of a moderated caucus, you need to specify the time
limit, purpose and Speakers time. For example, The delegate of Germany
would like to motion for a moderated caucus for 20 min, with speakers time
of 1 min and for the purpose of discussing FGM in most Asian and European
countries. It is used to debate upon sub-topics of the agenda. Points of
Information and Order are entertained, as per the EBs wishes.
14. UNMOD: For the motion of an unmoderated caucus, you will need to say
only this-The delegate of so-and-so-country would like to motion for an
unmoderated caucus for a time limit of 30 min (no speakers time, as you
wont be speaking in an unmoderated caucus), for the purpose of creating a
draft resolution. It is used for informal discussion of certain topics or
creating working papers/draft resolutions
15. WORKING PAPER: Working papers are a rough idea of what your bloc
wants from the committee. It has a formatThe heading: It should have the committee name, the authors, the co-authors
and the agenda. Authors are the ones who brought out most of the solutions
and co-authors are the next in importance.
The solutions: They are to be submitted in points.
16. DRAFT RESOLUTION: It has a formatThe sponsors: Delegates who are strongly for all the parts of the draft
resolution.
The signatories: Delegates who are ok with most of the resolution, but are
compromising.
The committee: name of the committee
The agenda: the topic
The committee again: mention it again
The pre-ambulatory clauses: The issues that the paper talks of are covered in
it. The reasons why the issues are talked of and previous resolutions/ UN
issues/ international conventions brought up regarding it can also be
included. The first words of every clause should be an underlined preambulatory clause. Then, write your issue down. Also, end with a comma.
The operative clause: Specific solutions to the pre-ambulatory clauses should
be written here. The first words of every clause should be an operative clause.
Then, write your solution down. Also, end with a semi-colon.
17. AMENDMENTS: There are 3 types of amendments:
Friendly amendment: An amendment that all the sponsors agree on. After all the
sponsors sign and the chair agrees to it, it is made into a draft resolution.
Unfriendly amendment: An amendment to which all the sponsors do not agree.
It is introduced prior to voting on it and it requires a certain number of
Munning: 29
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
compulsory signatories. Delegates who were not part of the sponsors (like the
signatories) can also put forth their opinions in this case. Voting will be held and
a decision will be arrived upon.
E-mendments: Grammatical errors are changed in amendments.
Note: Pre-ambulatory clauses cant be amended.
18. RIGHT TO REPLY: A delegate whose national integrity has been impugned
by another delegate may submit a Right to Reply only in writing to the
Executive Board. The EB will grant the Right of Reply at his/her discretion. A
Right to Reply to a Right to Reply is out of order.
19. EMERGENCY CRISIS: Sometimes, an emergency crisis situation can be
brought into your committee. In that time, no chits/notes will be entertained.
You will keep getting regular information about the crisis at hand and you
have to react on it.
20. DIRECTIVES: A working paper on the emergency submitted individually by
the nations is called Directives.
21. JOINT STATEMENT: When two or more nations, come together and make a
statement, it is called joint statement. A copy of the statement needs to be
submitted to the EB.
22. PRESIENTIAL STATEMENT: The delegate can speak on behalf of their
President and convey messages using this statement. A copy of the statement
needs to be submitted to the EB.
23. 1 FOR 1 AGAINST: On any topic, two delegates can debate for an interval of
a specified time (min 3 mins, max 6 min) at an alternate of 30 seconds per
speaker. This can be extended to 2 for 2 against. Also, the delegates can
change on a rotational basis.
24. CHALLENGE: Basically, it is when delegates debate over any issue but the
number of participants on each side can be infinite (just that both sides should
be equal). The time limit remains the same.
25. QUESTION ANSWER SESSION: In case a particular delegate needs to be
questioned by many delegates, a maximum of 10 questions will be
entertained on a particular delegate in a QA session.
26. DOUBLE DELEGATION: Two delegates represent one country with one
vote. Hence, they share their speeches and ideologies.
27. Examples of pre-ambulatory clauses:
Affirming
Alarmed by
Approving
Bearing in mind
Believing
Confident
Munning: 30
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Contemplating
Convinced
Declaring
Deeply concerned
Deeply conscious
Deeply convinced
Deeply Disturbed
Deeply Regretting
Desiring
Emphasizing
Expecting
Emphasizing
Expecting
Expressing its appreciation
Fulfilling
Fully aware
Emphasizing
Expecting
Expressing its appreciation
Fulfilling
Fully aware
Further deploring
Further recalling
Guided by
Having adopted
Having considered
Having examined
Having received
Keeping in mind
Noting with deep concern
Nothing with satisfaction
Noting further
Observing
Reaffirming
Realizing
Recalling
Recognizing
Referring
Seeking
Taking in concern
Taking note
Viewing with appreciation
Munning: 31
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Welcoming
Operative clauses:
Accepts
Affirms
Approves
Authorizes
Calls
Calls upon
Condemns
Confirms
Congratulates
Considers
Declares accordingly
Deplores
Designates
Draws the attention
Emphasizes Encourages
Endorses
Expresses its appreciation
Expresses its hope
Further invites
Deplores
Designates
Draws the attention
Emphasizes
Encourages
Endorses
Expresses its appreciation
Expresses its hope
Further invites
Further proclaims
Further reminds Further recommends
Further requests
Further resolves
Has resolved
Notes
Proclaims
Reaffirms
Recommends
Munning: 32
A Possibly Comprehensive Guide
Regrets
Reminds
Requests
Solemnly affirms
Strongly condemns
Supports
Takes note of
Transmits
Trusts