Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
RuxandraGuu
FREEDOMANDDISCIPLINE
Introduction
TraditionalUnderstandingofDiscipline
TheConceptofFreedom
TheRelationshipbetweenFreedomandDiscipline
StylesofEducation
IndependenceasAFormofSelfDiscipline
TheDevelopmentofSelfDiscipline
Work
Concentration
Fulfillment
DevelopmentoftheWillandObedience
MakingRealChoices
FreedomwithinLimits
RoleoftheAdult
Conclusion
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
RuxandraGuu
FreedomandDiscipline
FREEDOMANDDISCIPLINE
Throughdisciplinecomesfreedom.Aristotle
Introduction
At the time when Maria Montessori openedthefirstChildrensHouse,itwasnot
customary to offer children freedom. In traditionalschoolsthesubjects were given by
professors and teachers. Thedilemmaofbalancingfreedomanddisciplinewasandstill
remainsatask tosolvebytheadultsinthechildslife(parentsand teachers).Ifweoffer
children too much freedom, weexpose themto chaos and we restrictthepotential for
creativity. Conversely, too much discipline inhibits the childs will and becomes a
hindrance in his development. One of the essential goals of the Montessori method is
achievingthebalancebetweenthesetwoseeminglyopposingconcepts.
TraditionalUnderstandingofDiscipline
Discipline in the traditional sense is related to the teachers will, which is
imposedon the children, with little regardtotheirneeds or desires.Thechildrenmust
follow the teachers request and obey without questioning and sometimes without
understanding the reason behind that request. True discipline, however, comes from
within the child and it is a long process. This level of discipline cannot be achieved
throughimposedrequestsororders,butthroughrealfreedomgiventothechild.
Maria Montessori considered that discipline is not a concept that the teacher
applies directly onto the child with the purpose of controlling his behavior,butitisa
virtue that the child himself develops along with patience, self control, and
independence. The emphasis is put on the childs gradual development of self
discipline, which is acquired providing him with enough freedom to choose the
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
TheConceptofFreedom
Ideasand opinionshave been bothforandagainsttheconcept oftotalfreedom.
Nowadays there is still a misconception of this concept regarding the Montessori
method. On the one hand, people still believe that inthe Montessorischoolschildren
have toomuch, if nottotalfreedominchoosingtheiractivities.On theotherhand,when
childrensitquietlyandwork,,peoplethinkthereistoomuchstrictnessanddiscipline.
Rules are essential to the achievement of freedom, otherwise the concept of
freedom becomes chaos. Discipline by itself leads to either submission or rebellion
against the authority. Therefore, rules mustbe appliedinorder toacquirebalance.The
Montessori environment must have few rules, but they must be followed by all the
adults in the classroom consistently. Whenwespeakaboutdiscipline, wealso imply a
senseofresponsibility,whichisgivenbyfreedom.
Freedom is essential in the first planeofdevelopment,whenthechild feels the
need to explore, to absorb everything aroundhim,and to acquireskillsthat contribute
in the constructionof his intelligence.The Montessorimethoddoesnotfocusonsimply
teaching facts about life to children, but rather offer them the possibility to discover
those facts by themselves.Thepreparedenvironmenthelpsthemdeveloptheirinterest
1
Montessori,Maria.TheDiscoveryoftheChild,2007MontessoriPiersonPublishingCo.p.305;
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
RuxandraGuu
FreedomandDiscipline
and focus their attention on experience based learning. Children feel free, as they
choosetheirworkbasedontheirneedsandcuriosities.
TheRelationshipbetweenFreedomandDiscipline
Maria Montessori saw freedom and discipline as two interrelated concepts. By
encouragingthechildrentoworkfreely,shenoticedthattheyshowedadevelopmentin
decisionmaking,independence, self esteem,and responsibility.Dr.Montessorirealized
that freedom helps the child discover his true self, bychoosingactivities based onhis
needs andinterests. Nevertheless,she did not seetheconcept offreedomastheideaof
children wandering around aimlessly and doing whatever they liked, but rather
working purposely andenjoying the process. The solution to thatkind offreedom was
establishing a clearsetof rules. One oftheessentialrules inaMontessorienvironment
is showing respect towards the materials, the people, and the environment. The
freedom to move about within these conditions lead to thedevelopment ofdiscipline.
Maria Montessori was referring to the idea of self discipline, innerdiscipline. In this
sense,thechildmusthaveinnergrowth,itdoesnotsimplyappear.
Dr. Montessori believed that freedom and discipline aremeanttobe usedwith
the purpose of finding inner balance, through the developing of self control.
Montessoris vision of self discipline was not one of a child being inert, silent, and
motionless. Thatkind ofindividualis annihilated. Her idea was to preparethechildfor
life, for society, not just for discipline within the school. The true discipline would be
seeninwhatMontessoriconsideredasagoodandproperbehaviorofthechild.
External discipline, which is used in traditional pedagogy, is perceived by the
child as a force that is opposing his will and thus creates a barrier in the process of
learning. The child is not allowed to make mistakes and discover his own solutions,
hence he willnot bemotivatedto succeed. Hefeelsthatthelearningprocessisrathera
burden than a pleasure. On the contrary, when he is given freedom within limits, he
develops asense ofself correction through repetition,he gains self respectoncehehas
found his own solutions, and gradually acquires independence and self confidence.
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
External discipline annihilates the childs will, whereas inner discipline nourishes the
childs will, and ultimately builds his true character by creating a positive attitude
towardsworkandlifeitself.
Despite their easy freedom of manner, the children on the whole gave the
impression of being extraordinarily disciplined. They worked quietly, each one
intent on his own particular occupation. (...) What particularly fascinatedvisitors
was the order and discipline they managed to combine with spontaneity. The
peaceful atmosphere that pervaded the classroom as the children pursued their
work was extremely touching. No one had provoked it, and no one could have
obtaineditbyexternalmeans.2
StylesofEducation
Nowadays, psychology differentiates three styles of education: authoritarian,
permissive, and authoritative.Eachoneof thesestyles hasdifferentcharacteristics and
causesvariousreactionsinthechildrenwhichthemethodsareusedon.
Authoritarian
The authoritarian adult is strict, demanding, and puts his own will before the
childsneeds(sometimes,withoutbeingawareofit).Theauthoritarianstyleleaveslittle
space for opencommunication betweenthe adult andthechild.Thedisciplineispurely
external and childrenfollowtherulesimpliedbyitstrictlyoutof fearofbeingpunished
if they dontobey. The goalof the adult istobeincontrol.Thechildhasnofreedom,no
choice. He is expected to obey without questioning. The authoritarian style is
counterproductive and it results in children dominated by insecurities, lack of
responsibility, and often, with limited skills regarding problemsolving. Moreover, it
encourages dependency. Punishment is the central characteristic of the authoritarian
parent. The child can become either submissive,with no willof his own,orrebellious,
one who takes pleasure intreatingothersin the same way he is being treated. He will
have the tendency to victimize himself andhissense of trust(including self trust)will
Montessori,Maria.TheSecretofChildhood,1966BallantineBooks,NewYork;p.130;
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
RuxandraGuu
FreedomandDiscipline
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
has expectations of them, as they are being treated with maturity. The success of the
authoritative style is based on the flexibility of the adult and his adaptation to the
circumstances. The adultallows the childtoexplain hisactionsand applies logicto his
ownresponse to the child.The consistent discipline isofferedin a fairway, takinginto
accountboththechildsbehaviorandthesituation.
The authoritative approachis proven tobethemosteffectivestyleofeducation.
Childrenraised inthis mannerdevelopinto calm,selfconfidentadults, with ahighself
esteem, and a positive attitude towards life. The Montessori method is similar to the
authoritativeapproach,ratherthanauthoritarianorpermissive.
IndependenceasAFormofSelfDiscipline
Independence is the secret behind self discipline. An independent individual is
abletothinkforhimselfandhecanmakegoodchoicesforhimselfandforsociety.At the
sametime, makinggooddecisions for ones wellbeingdoesnotimplybeingselfish.An
independentperson iscapable to cooperate with otherpeopleandbeusefultothem.It
is one of the Montessori teachers main tasks to make sure thatthechild reaches a
thorough understanding of independence. This outcome comes through free, but
purposeful work, concentration, and the development of the will. The adult must be
mindful when preparing the environment,sothat it doesnt become an obstacletothe
child, but on the contrary, it motivates him to work. Motivation is important when
learningsomethingnew.
According to Dr. Montessori, there are four levels of independence that the
humanbeingachievesgraduallyintheprocessofforminghisownpersonality:
1. Physicalandfunctionalindependence
Through birth, the child makes his first step towards independence. After a
while, he starts eating by himself, then he is able to speakandwalk.With a prepared
environment, heisofferedtheindependenceofknowingwhereeveryitemisplacedand
knows that is available to him. The area of practical life helps the child acquire his
functional independence. The child must acquire physical independence by being
6
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
RuxandraGuu
FreedomandDiscipline
3
4
Montessori,Maria.TheAbsorbentMind,2014SublimeBooksloc.3963;
Montessori,Maria.TheAbsorbentMind,2014SublimeBooksloc.1305;
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
TheDevelopmentofSelfDiscipline
When the childbeginstoadapt to the Montessori environment, hequicklyfinds
joy in his activity, as he is able to choose his own work and decide his own daily
schedule. He works for as long as he wants, concentratesas much as hecanand heis
given the chance to exert and develop his own will. By pursuinghisowninterest and
concentrating freely on work, he eventually develops self discipline, provided that he
respectsthelimitsimposedbytheadultinthesamewaytheadultrespectshisfreedom.
Work
When the child first joins a group, the adult helps himand guideshim.At first,
the guideiscentral,but asmoreandmorepresentationsaregiventothechildandthere
are more activities to choosefrom, the powerofconcentrationdevelops.Concentration
on work revealsthechildsinner poweranddeepenshisunderstandingofthematerial.
When preparing the environment, the Montessori adult must offer children the
possibility toconcentrate.Whenconcentrationhasbeenachieved,theadultwitnessesa
further development of the childs independence. The young children who join the
environmentarenotcapabletofocusandseetherealworkinthematerial,sotheytend
to abandon work in mid process, and start another activity. This is a sign that inner
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
discipline has not yet been acquired. The more presentations the directressgives,the
morepossibilitiestoconcentratethechildwillhave.
The childrenscycle ofrepetition, concentration, and satisfaction (...)would
lead to a development of inner discipline, selfassurance, and preference for
purposefulactivity.5
Fulfillment
Will is needed for self control to work and for increasing the level of self
discipline. A strongwill helpsthechild inhisselfmotivationtowork.IntheMontessori
environmentthere isonly onecopy of eachmaterial.Childrenmust learntobepatient,
to wait for their turns. Patience is build through the process of self control, which is
helped by the childs will. The SilenceGame isa group activitythat alsoparticipates in
thedevelopmentofthechildswill.
The will, like every other faculty, is developed and strengthened through
methodical exercises. In our schools exercises for the will are to be foundinallof
the childs intellectual exercises and hisexercisesin practicalliving. Achild seems
to be learning how to carry out his movements with grace and accuracy, how to
sharpen his sense perceptions, and how to read and count, but actually he is
becoming the master of himself and laying the foundation for a strong and ready
will.6
PolkLillard,Paula.MontessoriAModernApproach,1972SchockenBooks,p.8;
Montessori,Maria:TheDiscoveryoftheChild,2007MontessoriPiersonPublishingCo.,p.315;
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
II.
III.
Inthefinalstage,everything happensundertheconsciouscontrolofthewill.The
childnow wantstoobey, heunderstandsthere is someone superiorwholistens
andunderstands him, andwhomhetrusts.Thisperiodismanifestedbyastrong
emotionalbondbetweenthechildandtheadult.
Obedience developed through successive degrees to a higher degree of
7
8
Montessori,Maria.TheAbsorbentMind,2014SublimeBooksloc.3761;
Montessori,Maria.TheFormationofMan,2007MontessoriPiersonPublishingCo.,p.28;
10
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
RuxandraGuu
FreedomandDiscipline
deeper in obedience, the child starts choosing out of profound interest and he
understandsthattheresultsofhisdecisionscanbelongterm.
Inhumandevelopment the acquisitionofsuccessivegradesofindependence
correspondsto such experiencesasbirth,beingweaned,learningtotalk,towalk,to
reason, and so forth. No animal, however independent, can be free inthesense in
which man can achieve freedom; for true liberty of choice is bound up with the
power tothinkandreasoneveryactofchoicebeingnecessarilyprecededbyanact
ofintellect,i.e.,ajudgment.9
FreedomwithinLimits
In the Montessori environment, children have the freedom to choose the
materials, but the choice has to be within the range of materials which have already
been presented to themby the Montessori guideoranolderchild.At thebeginning,the
adult offersthechoice between twomaterials (ofthesamearea),thenthree,andsoon.
Finally,thechildchoosesbasedonhisknowledge,notcuriosity.
Thelibertyof the childshouldhave as its limitsthecollectiveinterest;asits
formwhatweusuallyconsideragoodbreeding.10
Freedom could not work unless it is conditioned by certain limits. The child is
free to work with a material, but it needs tobe free inorder tobeused, andthechild
must putitbackwhenhefinishes,inthesameconditionashefounditontheshelfthat
is hisresponsibility.Childrencanworkwithamaterialforaslongastheywant,butthey
need to do real work andnothidebehind the material. The childhas the possibility to
work alone or in groups, depending on his desire. The lessons of grace and courtesy
helpin displayingaproperbehaviorwhenworkingwithotherchildren.Thelimitinthis
sense isworkingwithoutdisturbingothers. Childrenhave thefreedomtomovearound
the environment.Movementisconnectedtolearning,to thedevelopmentofthewilland
obedience. By manipulating the objects with their hands, children build their
Standing,E.M.Montessori:HerLifeandWork,1998APlumeBook,p.282;
Standing,E.M.Montessori:HerLifeandWork,1998APlumeBook,p.285;
10
11
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
RoleoftheAdult
Adults must aim todiminishtheiregocentricandauthoritariantowardsthe
child and adopt a passive attitude in order to aidin his [the childs]development.
They must approach children with humility, recognizing theirrole asasecondary
one.11
In orderfor thechild toacquireselfdiscipline,theadulthastheresponsibilityto
guide the child by offering him freedom within limits. The teacher shows respect
expressedthroughherlanguage,toneofvoiceandposture(sheshouldaddressthechild
byloweringherbody at hislevel). The directressmust beaware thatdisciplinecomes
from withinand itis thesecrettowardsthenormalizationofthechild.Shemustnotfeel
reluctanttointerferewhenshenoticesthatthechildisnotincontrolofhisownwilland
if his actions cross the limits andtherules set by her.Thechildswill shouldbeguided
towards purposefulworkand mustbe giventhefreedom to influencethedevelopment
of obedience and self confidence. By offering freedom to work within boundaries,the
PolkLillard,Paula.MontessoriAModernApproach,1972SchockenBooks,p.79;
11
12
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
adult assist the child in constructing a future responsible adult. The main goal of the
teacher is to help them balance their impulses, by inhibiting some that hinder their
development, and acting on others that lead to a proper behavior. The teacher must
provide time for the child to choose, to work freely and uninterrupted, to practice
patience, repetition, and concentration. The adultmust set clearrules,providelessons
ofgraceandcourtesyregardingproperbehavior,andactasanexampleforthechildren.
The directress should prepare an environment with regards to the childs
developmentofindependence. Functionalindependence intheMontessorienvironment
is essentialand it hasbeenproventobuildthechildsintelligence.Montessoribelieved
that the adultshould prepare an environmentwhere the children would beallowedto
work individually, but should also encourage working in small groups and learn to
collaborate with one another. The adult should communicate and cooperate with the
children, without making them feel dependent on her assistance. Shemust encourage
them towardsdeveloping their conflict resolution skills,ratherthaninterferingintheir
communicationto others.Lastly, the directressshouldmake sure thatthechildrenfeel
they are an active part of the community, working for the betterment of their
environment.
Conclusion
MariaMontessorirealizedthatinordertofindhisplaceintheworldandtowork
asa part ofsociety, the childmust acquire independence andspiritualequilibrium.The
balance between freedom and discipline is an essential part in the childs conquestof
independence. By offering a prepared environment and freedom within limits, the
Montessoriguideleadsthechildtowardsthedevelopmentofself(inner)discipline,and
ultimately, the construction of his true character. Guided by inner balance, the childs
character willshapethesuccessful developmentof the adultand willhelphim find his
cosmicmission.
13
MontessoriInstituteofBucharest
RuxandraGuu
ChildrensHouse36(20152017)
FreedomandDiscipline
Bibliography
14