Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
220
[principals need the skills of]... managing staff and the skills to
appraise staff, implement mutually acceptable staff appraisal and
staff development programs and allocate workloads. (DEET,
1993, p. 13.)
As can be seen from the above quotes, principals and directors require a
whole range of human resource skills. Although principals of schools,
directors of early childhood centres and education administrators have
been involved in human resource activities (e.g. induction programmes,
supervision, staff appraisal, etc.) for some time, the responsibilities of
managing people in educational organisations have become more
formalised. For example, in primary and secondary schools, professional
development has now been devolved to each school for developing its
own whole school programme, as well as individual staff programmes as
part of their overall strategic plan. Also, within their changing roles,
leaders are required to recruit and select staff, serve on panels and be
informed on human resource policies such as EEO, anti-discrimination,
and health and safety regulations (Garbutcheon Singh et al, 1994, p. 13).
These examples illustrate a significant change in policy, and require
school administrators to demonstrate awareness and understanding of
the different models of professional development. This change applies
both to state education departments, and Catholic and independent
school systems. Similarly, early childhood centres such as kindergartens,
preschools and child care centres which have traditionally met their own
professional development needs, more recently, have collaborated and
shared various educational opportunities for staff. Directors, like
principals, are the leaders and facilitators of individual and group
development (Nailon & McCrea, 1994).
In terms of the broader HRM picture, Cranston (1993, p. 39) argues
that the interface across management of change, organisation culture and
HRM in education is crucial if change is to be meaningful. He follows
Limerick's (1992, p. 51) lead by maintaining that in a turbulent and
discontinuous environment, such as the one we are witnessing in the
1990s, human resource management which focuses on cultures and
organisational structures will have a special role to play in organisations.
Cranston believes that unless all those in education are committed
to changes and a new culture, then the school is not going to achieve its
221
222
Unit
Semester
1
ELECTIVES
Educational Management electives (Faculty of Education)
Career/Life Patterns of Women Teachers
Educators and the Law
The Community and School Administration
Working with Parents and Community
Early Childhood Leadership and Advocacy
Human Resources Management in Education
'
Research Methods in Education
Independent Study
Business electives (Faculty of Business, one only may be selected)
People in Organisations
Labour/Management Relations
Small Business Management
Principles of Marketing
Other Elective (one may be negotiated)
"Human Resource Management in Education" was taught for the first time
in Semester 1, 1994. As has been discussed above, the devolution of
power to administrators in schools and other educational contexts has
meant that leaders have greater responsibility for the development of
various human resource functions such as professional development and
supervision, staff recruitment and selection plus staff support and
appraisal. Because of the 'managerial' focus that education has taken on
and the increased human resource role that managers of education have
been asked to fill, this unit was designed to address several human
resource issues relevant to education settings. Our guiding premise was
"people are the most important resources in the educational enterprise"
(Rationale, unit outline, 1994).
We endeavoured to maintain a balance in the teaching of the unit.
While we recognised that a certain amount of the sessions would be given
over to learning the technical aspects and skills of human resource
management, we also ensured that the content would'be concerned with
broader issues such as the ethical considerations of leaders and the
philosophical questions of the role of education and educational
leadership. We encouraged students to critique the changes they
observed in their workplaces, and to be aware of the wider social and"
political trends which are shaping education. A planning, leading,
organising, controlling framework was used.
The four main topics explored during the semester were:
introduction to HRM including supervision; staff selection; staff support
and appraisal; and professional development. These topics are outlined
as HRM competencies in Smart & Pontifex (1993). Besides the critical
nature of the content addressed within the unit, the teaching strategies,
the learning atmosphere and the flexibility of assessment were significant
educational considerations.
How Did the Teaching and Learning Occur?
Accessing resources for us as staff and for the students was an initial
teaching preparation task. This ongoing task began with identifying the
unit outline references and included locating mini-lecture references,
display resources, handouts and hands-on in-class worksheets. There is a
body of literature concerning the interrelationship between human
resource management and educational institutions (Jorde-Bloom, 1988;
Riches & Morgan, 1989; Castello et al, 1992; Castetter, 1992; Cranston,
1993), and we borrowed approaches, concepts and practices from the
business literature, organisational behaviour references and human
resource journals. Additionally, selected chapters were used from
224
226
Evaluation
To gauge the students' perspectives of the appropriateness and value of
the HRM unit, we provided two evaluation forms and carried-out an
informal brainstorming review. The first evaluation was taken from the
dual content and staff evaluation forms which are part of a formal,
standardised system from the University's Academic Staff Development
Unit (ASDU computerised forms). The second evaluation included
student ratings and open comments about the graduate diploma course
objectives, and the style and content of each unit undertaken during the
semester. The student feedback from the ASDU form was positive. For
example, the students agreed or strongly agreed that we encouraged
interactions and reading widely, were sensitive to their interests and
abilities, and encouraged critical analysis of personal work.
Some of the quotes from the students' open-ended evaluation were:
Professional development plan an essential - fits current needs.
I have found the assignments to be especially good learning
devices and liked the syndicate presentation; good resources
provided.
Relevance to my career - it has supported my gaining knowledge
and writing development and leadership skills.
Assessment has been easily adapted to individual expertise or
interests and has supported my professional development.
Delivery of unit and style of presentation facilitated learning and
interest; and, introduction to resources and readings.
Lessons Learned
A solid, unique team spirit exists partly because of the encouragement of
each participant to have a professional mentor and also a
collegial-reciprocal peer within the course. Although not all students
have a mentor, we have talked and shared many ideas about what, how
and why. The importance of securing a mentor for one's career
development and success has been well illustrated in the literature to
date (Levinson, 1978; Daresh & Playko, 1992). The importance of a
respected mentor is particularly valuable for women (Ehrich, 1994).
Examples of the students' beliefs about such interactions include:
227
The ongoing sharing one night a week and outside class resulted in a
group of supportive, non-competitive adults from all walks of education.
The generic nature of the participants has become a group asset which
blends with unit flexibility to meet individual needs through each topic
and within the assessment tasks. One student commented about how the
Graduate Diploma generally assisted with professional development:
"The main strength has developed out of the interaction between the
students, facilitated by lecturers. Secondly, exposure to ear
current thinking
and research has been extremely beneficial". Next*y . we hope to
further strengthen both individual and collaborative learning through a
constructivist view of teaching for conceptual change across the
semester.
As lecturers, we learned on a weekly basis how to better deal with
the HRM content and ways to teach and learn. As an example, next year
we plan to readjust the four topics. The introduction and supervision
topic will include more organisational behaviour issues (Owens, 1991).
The professional development topic will encompass staff support and
appraisal, thus broadening the definition and possibilities for staff
growth. In terms of our ways of teaching, we plan to refine our
presentation of balancing theory and practice. One strategy will be to
provide a specifically selected set of readings and HRM practise-activities
in place of a formal textbook. Another change will create assessment
tasks that more diligently focus students on the challenge of
understanding HRM theory and practice while personally applying these
in real world ways. In order to construct this meaning, it seems that the
problem-based learning approach described by Hallinger & Bridges
(1994) may be a valuable addition to our teaching and learning for both
unit content and assignments. This approach supports our current
collaborative ways of having the whole group share in the teaching and
learning. Overall, we endeavoured to use a critical approach and
continually raised ethical and moral challenges about acting in
professionally responsible ways. We tried to offer alternatives to the
technocratic view of supervision and appraisal by blending daily
responsibilities with long-view visions that are morally sound. We hope
to improve these teaching and learning ideals next time.
228
Correspondence
Nadine L. McCrea, Centre for Applied Studies in Early Childhood, Faculty
of Education, Queensland University of Technology, Locked Bag No. 2,
Red Hill, Queensland 4059, Australia.
References
Ackland, R. (1991) A review of the peer coaching literature, Journal of Staff
Development, 12, pp. 22-27.
Beck, L. (1992) Meeting the challenge of the future: the place of a caring ethic in
educational administration, American Journal of Education, 100,
pp. 454-492.
Castello, R.T., Fletcher, M.R., Rossetti, A.D. & Sekowski, R.W. (Eds) (1992) School
Personnel Administration: a practitioner's guide. Massachusetts: Allyn & Bacon.
Castetter, W. (1992) The Personal Function in Educational Administration. New York:
Macmillan.
Cranston, N. (1993) Interfacing the management of change, organised culture and
human resource management: a system-level examination, Unicorn, 19,
pp. 36-44.
Daresh, J. & Playko, M. (1992) Mentoring for headteachers, School Organisation, 12,
pp. 145-152.
Davson-Galle, P. & Winning, A. (1994) The CBT Debate, Studies in Educational
Administration, 59, pp. 53-59.
Department of Employment, Education and Training (1993) Leaders and their
Learning: professional development priorities for principals. Canberra: AGPS.
Ehrich, L.C. (1994) A mentoring programme for women educators, School
Organisation, 14, pp. 11-20.
Evers, C.W. & Lakomski, G. (1991) Knowing Educational Administration. Oxford:
Pergamon.
Garbutcheon Singh, M., Roylance, P., Bartlett, L, Gale, T. & Rowan, L. (1994) The
Restructuring of the Work of Teaching: principals, human resource management
and teacher education, Paper presented at the Australian Teacher Education
Association Conference, (QUT, Brisbane), 3-6 July.
Hallinger, P. & Bridges, E. (1994) Problem-based learning in educational
administration: defining its major features for application, Studies in
Educational Administration, 59, pp. 15-23.
Hildebrand, V. (1993) Management of Child Development Centers. New York:
Macmillan.
Hosie, P. (1992) Human resource managers and training: a peek into the future,
Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 30(3), pp. 49-66.
Jorde-Bloom, P. (1988) A Great Place to Work. Washington, DC: NAEYC.
Keith, S. & Girling, R. (1991) Education, Management and Participation. Boston:
Allyn & Bacon.
Knowles, M. (1984) (Ed) Andragogy in Action: applying modern principles of adult
education. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
229
Laws, K., Smith, D. & Sinclair, K. (1992) Leadership styles, skills and technology, in
C. Turney, N. Hatton, K. Laws, K. Sinclair, & D. Smith (Eds) The School
Manager. North-Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
Levinson, D. (1978) The Seasons of a Man's Life. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
Limerick, D. (1992) The Shape of the New Organisation: implications for human
resource management, Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 30,
pp. 38-51.
Lunenberg, F. & Ornstein, A. (1991) Educational Administration, Concepts and
Practices. Belmont: Wadsworth.
Nailon, D. & McCrea, N. (1994) Responding to the challenges of managing early
childhood education, Perspectives, 4(2), pp. 1-2.
Owens, R. (1991) Organizational Behaviour in Education, 4th edn. Boston: Allyn &
Bacon.
Riches, C. & Morgan, C. (Eds) (1989) Human Resource Management in Education.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
Rodd, J. (1994) Leadership in Early Childhood, the Pathway to Professionalism. St
Leonards: Allen & Unwin.
Schaefer, N. & Falciglia, S. (1990) Adult African-American females learn
cooperatively, GEM No. 140, Journal of Nutrition Education, 22, p. 24OD.
Sergiovanni, T. (1990) Value-added Leadership. San Diego: Harcourt, Brace
Jovanovich.
Sergiovanni, T. (1991) The Principalship, 2nd edn. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Sergiovanni, T. (1992) Moral Leadership. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Smart, J. & Pontifex, M. (1993) Human Resources Management and the Australian
Human Resources Institute: the professional and its professional body, Asia
Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 31, pp. 1-19.
Snyder, K. & Anderson, R. (1986) Managing Productive Schools. Orlando: Academic
Press College Division.
Weissglass, J. (1991) Teachers have feelings: what can we do about? Journal of Staff
Development, 12, pp. 28-33.
Winning, A. (1992) Philosophical assumptions underlying current trends in
vocational education and training curriculum policy in Australia, Studies in
Educational Administration, 57, pp. 41-46.
230