Known as type
and type Il, there
are two types of
breast caleiications
with distinctly
different chemical
compositions and characteristics (2 Table
‘on page 13). Loffera brief review of breast
calcifications and then some interesting,
facts about the two types.
Breast cakifications were frst reported
in association with breast cancer in
1951. The terms macrocalefication
and microcaleification, like macro- and
‘microscopic, refer to the ability to see
the caleification(9) with the naked eye or
using a mieroscope. (For the purposes of
this article, [will use the nonspecific term
“calcifications” to include both macro- and
rmicrocalcifications,)
Breast calcifications are associated with
palpable and nor-palpable breast lesions.
At mammography, breast calcifications as
‘small as 100 microns can be visualized and
may be the only radiographic abnormality
detected. Although the size and number
‘of breast calcifications are important to
not, itis the distribution and morphology
‘of breast caleifcations that are most
indicative of malignancy. In general,
irregular, pleomorphic calcifications,
heterogeneous in size and measuting less
than 0.5mm, are more often associated
with malignancy; benign lesions tend
to be associated with round or ovoid
calcifications of uniform size that measure
2mm or greater
Asis often the case in surgical pathology,
wwe receive a specimen radiograph with a
breast specimen and are asked to provide
a brief remark regarding presence/absence
of radiographic caleifications. Both type
and type Il calcifications can be seen
radiographically, however, there is a good
reason why you may not have known
there are two types—type Il cakcifications
can be well visualized on tissue sections
HE (25x)
12
Classifying Breast Calcifications
stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)
and type Icannot.
‘Type I cakifications always contain
calcium, but never phosphorus, Calcium
carbonate and calcium oxalate are the
‘two main compounds classified as type
Laleifications. In older references, you
‘may come across the term weddellite
to describe the composition of type
Tealeifications; this isa term used
specifically for calcium oxalate dihydrate.
‘Type I calcifications typically have a
crystalline, polyhedral shape, so are
commonly referred to as crystals rather
than calcifications. As previously noted,
type calcifications stain poorly with H&E,
but, with careful study, the calcifications
can usually be picked out as colorless,
well-defined, three-cimensional crystals
(Images 1a and 1b). Under polarized light,
these strongly birefringent caleifications
are vibrantly apparent (Image 2)
‘The formation of type calcifications
is less certain than type Il calcifications,
Oxalate itself “isan end product of
‘metabolism and has no known metabolic
value in humans” (3). Tornos et al
identified type I calcifications within
benign, dilated ducts, which suggests
formation of oxalate crystals from breast
secretions. It was originally postulated.
that type I calcifications ofthe breast were
‘not found in cases of malignancy, but that
has been disproved. While type I crystals
may be encountered in cases of breast
«cancer, the crystal themselves are not seen
in direct association with the malignant
lesion(s).
‘Type Il breast califications, conversely,
are commonly intimately associated with
both in situ and invasive breast cancer. In
fact, type Il califcations often “target the
location of the most important abnormality
within the breast” on mammography
(7). Type Il calcifications are always
composed of calcium and phosphorus
(predominantly calcium phosphates), with
Image 4--Type Il calcifications
Polarizing lens (25x)
Image 1a—Type | calcifications
HAE (10x)
Image 2--Type | calcifications
Polarizing lens (25x)
ut
iy
Image 3:
Type ll caleifications
HAE (10x)
Continued on next page.
.300-532-AAPAhydroxyapatite its most characteristic
form @). Type I ealications typically
have an amorphous or spherical shape,
and some may resemble psammoma
bodies. These calcifications result from
cellular degradation and necrosis, 0 are
coften found within proliferative breast
lesions, including cancer. Most type
I calcifications ae identified within
ducts, but may also be situated within
lobules. Type ll calcifications are strongly
basophilic when stained with H&E
(Gmages 3a and 3b), but are not birehringent
‘under polarized light (Image 4).
Calcium oxalate has @ unique staining
potter (see Table); when special stains
for calcium (von Kossa and lizerin ed at
pH 42) are performed, calcium carbonate
(type) and calcium phosphate (typeI)
stain positively, but calcium oxalate does
not stain, Variable staining of calcium
oxalate is seen with alizatin xed stain at
1pH170, while both calcium carbonate and
Calcium phosphate slain positively. Silver
nitrate /rubeanic acid stain with 5% acetic
acid pretreatment is fairly specific for
caleium oxalate; the acetic acid dissolves
calcium phosphite and caleium carbonate,
‘0 those two calcium compounds do not
stain @). However, without 5% acetic acid
pretreatment, all beast calcifications stain
positively with silver nitrate/ rubeanic
acid,
In summary, type [ and type Il breast
calcifications are both identified at
mammography. Both calcification
types may be identified in malignant
breast cases, however, unlike type Il
calcifications, type I caleifications have yet
to be identified as part ofthe malignant
lesion itself. When looking to correlate
radiographic celeifcations on H&E tissue
sections, only type I calcifications will be
readily apparent, but only type I breast
calcifications are birefringent uncler
polarized light. Ifyou geta call for gross
recut on a breast case where calcifeations
are not identified microscopically, ask if
the slides were examined with a polarizing
Tens—you might save yourself (and your
pathologist) some work!
Author's note: Thank you to PACI Drs.
Jones, Beckmann, and Gao for their kind
‘assistance in the preparation of this article,
Acute Ad Petestnent
PROPERTY Teed Tel ype
‘Catan Pesan
IDENTIFIED AT Ye Yer
MAMMOGRAPI?
SHAPE Pape acne cya Shea arphom
nay Damn
‘APPEARANCE: iekingom Tobin
olardiog Len
APPEARANCE: Coioress—wetedcpratine Bwophiie
Hae Sts
APFEARANCT oer ne Taek Bist
‘Yon Kos Stn at p42
APPEARANCE | Dakcbownortiaek | — Doessoraain Docs oi saia
‘iver NratRubeaic
‘Ac San ih
Deskbar Das
Daktrownor back
Tegan ang ranged Onngesed
(oeopnaeis (reise
"retnge) ‘retina
Weak onpaine ‘Oranasred ‘angered
sarang
TOCATION IN
[BREAST TISSUE,
‘Wii Taino eign ata dod
Tne ad, ary
naar
"ASSOCIATION WITH
‘BREAST CANCER
incre neon
May be foun ay om ae fener
with cancer
www pathologisteassietanss.org
References:
Fandos-Morera A, Prats-Esteve
M, Tura-soteras JM, Traveria-Cros
‘A. Breast tumors: composition of
icrocaleifcations. Radiol 1988; 168
325.827,
Radi Mj. Calcium oxalate crystals
in breast biopsies: an overlooked
form of microcalefication associated
with benign breast disease. Arch
Pathol Lab Med 1989; 113: 1367-1368.
‘Tomos C, Silva E, El-Hageer A,
Pritzker KPH. Calcium oxalate
‘crystals in breast biopsies: the
missing microcalcifications. Am ]
Surg Patho! 1990; 14(10): 961-958,
Surratt JT; Monsees BS,
Mazouhian G. Calcium oxalate
microcalcifications inthe breast.
Ratio! 1994; 181: 141-142.
Frouge C, Meunier M,
Guenebratiere J-M, Gilles R, Vanel
D, Contesso G, Di Paola R, Biery
‘M. Polyhedral microcaleifcations
at mammography: histology
correlation with calcium oxalate,
Ratiol 1993; 186: 681-684,
Grimes MM, Karageorge LS,
Hogge JP. Does exhaustive search
for microcaleifications improve
diagnostic yield in stereotactic core
noodle breast biopsies? Mod Pathol
‘2001; 14(4) 350-353,
Haka AS, Shafer-Peltior KE,
Fitzmaurice M, Crowe J, Dasari
RR, Feld MS. Identifying
imlcrocaleifcations in benign
bay probing differences in their
chemical composition using rama
spectroscopy. Cancer Research 2002;
(62: 5375-5380,
Chrzan R, Rudnicka L, Popiela
TJs, Nowak W, Podsiadto-
Kleinrok B. The problems with
histopathoiogical verification of
breast microcaleification clusters in
the stereotactic mammotome biopsy
specimens, Pol J Pathol 1006; 5763):
1335.
http:/ /sprojects.mmi.megill.ca/
mammography /califications3 htm.
Downloacled on 8 July 2010,
tp: /wwwchistosearch,
com/histonet/Jul07A/
Re HistonetYasuesSilverNiA. him
Downloacled on 8 July 2010.
hutp:/ /www:iheworld.com/_
protocols/ special. stains/slizarin_
red_shtm. Downloaded on 8 July
2010.
18