Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Notation:
DM = "Dark Matter, Missing Planets and New Comets", T. Van
Flandern, North Atlantic Books, Berkeley (1993)
MTW = "Gravitation", C.W. Misner, K.S. Thorne & J.A.
Wheeler, W.H. Freeman & Co., San Francisco (1973)
SR = special relativity
v = orbital velocity relative to a primary such as the Sun
c = speed of light
cg = speed of propagation of gravity
G = gravitational constant
M = mass of primary or reference body, usually the Sun
r = distance between two bodies
r-vect = vector distance between two bodies, which has a
magnitude and a direction
The speed of propagation of Newtonian gravity is infinite
(MTW, p. 177; DM, p. 43). Forces are computed using only the
true, instantaneous positions of moving bodies. Newtonian
gravity gives an excellent approximation of the motions of bodies
in the solar system.
General relativity reduces to Newtonian gravity in the weakfield, low-velocity limit, which is why Newtonain gravity works
so well in the solar system. To avoid the implication of
infinite propagation speed that goes with this reduction, general
relativity postulates that bodies appear to accelerate because
spacetime is curved by the presence of nearby mass; and the
nearest equivalent of a straight line through curved spacetime is
the geodesic path. So general relativity suggests that no
propagating force is needed, since moving bodies are simply
following geodesic paths (straight lines through curved
spacetime) without the help of forces.
However, that explanation avoids the question of how quickly
distant spacetime responds to changes in the position of the
nearby mass acting as the cause of the spacetime curvature.
There must in principle be communication between a mass and the
spacetime around it at some finite speed. If there were not, we
would have a case of true "action at a distance", about which
Isaac Newton said, "That one body may act upon another at a
distance through a vacuum without the mediation of anything else
... is to me so great an absurdity, that I believe no man, who
has in philosophical matters a competent faculty for thinking,
can ever fall into."
Put another way, Einstein's equivalence principle tells us
that a gravitational force and a uniform acceleration are
equivalent. So our question about the speed of propagation of
gravity is equivalent to a question about the direction in which
moving bodies accelerate relative to the body causing that
acceleration.
In the following, we will first show why gravity is
different from electromagnetism. We will then eliminate several
possible red herring arguments. Finally, we will consider the
experimental evidence bearing on the answer to our title
question.