Você está na página 1de 127

A Marketing Research on

the extent to which Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises


adapt to PLDT SME Nations Business Tools utilizing the
Theory of Planned Behavior

A Thesis
Presented to PLDT SME Nation
Through the Faculty of the
Marketing and Advertising Department
Ramon V. Del Rosario College of Business
De La Salle University-Manila

In Partial Fulfillment
of the requirements for the Degree in
Bachelor of Science in Marketing Management
By:
Cruz, Mary Katherine G.
Dailo, Mary Jessica P.
Partosa, Maria Clarissa Beatrice L.

August 25, 2016


1

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION

................

A. Background of The Study

.........

B. Conceptual Framework

.................................................

B.1. The Theory of Planned Behavior


B.2. The New Research Model

....................................

..............................................

C. Statement of The Problem/Hypothesis

...................................

10

.........................................................

12

D.1. Respondents ....................................................................

12

D.2. Questionnaire ....................................................................

12

D.3. Secondary Data .................................................................

12

D.4. Sources of Information ......................................................

13

D.5. Researchers

13

D. Assumption of The Study

....................................................................

D.6. Statistical Method

..........................................................

E. Scope and Limitation of The Study

13

................................................

13

...........................................................

14

...........................................................

14

F.2. Business and Industry .........................................................

14

F.3. Student and Faculty

15

F. Significance of The Study


F.1. Marketing Field

...........................................................

CHAPTER 2: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE ......................................


A. Business Tools and MSMEs

............................................................

A.1. Business Tools Defined


A.2. MSMEs Defined

16

.................................................

16

............................................................

19

A.3. MSMEs in The Philippines

..............................................

A.4. Filipino MSMEs and Adapting Business Tools

20

.................

22

............................................................

23

..................................................................................

26

B. Theory of Planned Behavior


C. Brand Trust

15

CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY ........................................................................ 29


A. Research Design

........................................................................ 29

A.1. Convergent Validity

.............................................................. 30

A.2. Discriminant Validity .............................................................. 34


B. Sampling Method

......................................................................... 36

C. Statistical Treatment of Data

.............................................................. 37

CHAPTER 4: PRESENATION AND DATA ANALYSIS ......................................... 38


A. Respondent Profile

......................................................................... 38

A.1. Profile of all Respondents

................................................. 38

A.2. Respondent Profile of Potential Clients ................................... 41


A.3. Respondent Profile of Existing Clients .................................... 44
B. Potential Clients Data Analysis ............................................................. 48
C. Existing Clients Data Analysis .............................................................. 59
D. Comparative Analysis

......................................................................... 68

CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................. 70


A. Summary and Conclusion

.............................................................

70

B. Implications and Recommendations ..................................................

74

C. Integrated Marketing Communications Plan (IMC) ............................. 76


A. Potential Clients

.............................................................. 76

B. Existing Clients

.............................................................. 89

References ......................................................................................................... 100


Appendices ......................................................................................................... 105

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This study examined the extent to which PLDT SME Nations Business Tools
apply themselves to Small and Medium Enterprises utilizing the Theory of Planned
Behavior (TPB). It aims to predict the intention to incorporate, retain or upgrade PLDT
SME Nation business tools and business tools in general among managers/owners of
SMEs in the Philippines. The study consists of two dependent variables as they apply
to: Intent 1 (Business Tools in General) and Intent 2 (PLDT SME Nation Business
Tools). The study was conducted amongst two different groups. The first group
consists of PLDT SME Nation business tools users that the researchers addressed as
existing clients of PLDT SME Nation while the second group consists of potential clients
of PLDT SME Nation.

The intention to incorporate was tested amongst the potential clients while the
intention to retain/upgrade was tested on existing clients. Moreover, brand trust was
added as a moderating variable to test its relationship with the other variables. Brand
trust was classified into two categories: Hedonic Brand Trust (HBT) which are benefits
driven and Utilitarian Brand Trust (UBT), which are features driven. The sample of the
target population was conveniently selected to address any issues with regards to the
questionnaire. After the pilot test, the surveys were further assessed through the use of
convergent validity and discriminant validity to test the reliability of the constructs. The
instrument was then sent to a larger sample to test the framework. Structural equation
modeling was used to test the hypotheses.

The results showed, for potential clients, that the independent variable Perceived
Behavioral Control (PBC) is the factor that significantly affects both Intent 1 and Intent 2
with HBT significantly affecting the relationship between PBC and the Intent 2.
However, the study also shows that HBT strengthens the relationship of the Subjective
Norm (SNorm) with Intent 2 while UBT was found to strengthen the relationship of
Attitude Towards Behavior (ATB) and Intent 2. For existing clients, all independent
variables have a significant effect on Intent 1. Moreover, results show that HBT
strengthens the relationship of all the independent variables with Intent 1 together with
UBT strengthening the relationship between ATB and Intent 1. For Intent 2, the only
significant independent variables are ATB and PBC. However, the only moderating
factor that the results found out to be significant is UBT strengthening the relationship
between ATB and Intent 2.

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
The beginning of PLDT traces back to November 1928 wherein Samar, Eastern
Visayas, and Bicol Peninsula was devastated due to a typhoon. It was then that
communication became important because people wanted to communicate with their
loved ones. However, people could only call within their own small city and many
Filipinos were disconnected from the rest of world. Because of this, PLDT was given the
franchise to operate telephone services in the country. PLDT was under American
owners at the time and the company acquired many small phone companies in the
provinces to help facilitate seamless communication nationwide.

After a year of PLDTs nationwide franchise, the first national long distance call
was made possible together with overseas radio-telephone services. However, the war
years in the 1940s led to the demolition of the PLDT system to prevent the Japanese
from exploiting it. By the time Americans were able to reclaim control, only 10 percent of
the facilities were operational.

By 1968, PLDT became a Filipino controlled corporation after Ramon Cojuangco


and his group of Filipino businessmen bought the controlling stakes. Under the
leadership of Filipinos, PLDT boarded on developments that led to more Filipinos
benefiting the phones. In the same year, the first major television broadcast was
brought to the Philippines together with the first satellite communications. Continuous
landline innovations were made and by the 1980s subscribers could call long distance
to nine major cities across the nation and 22 countries around the world. In 1987,
wireless communication enters the scene. Cellular phones were installed in cars that led
to the first cellular telephone network in the Philippines.

During the late 90s, Manuel V. Pangilinan took control over PLDT and acquired
Smart Communications, Inc. (Smart), which was the countrys largest mobile phone
operator at the time. Ever since then, PLDT has been undertaking continuous
innovations that made PLDT to become the leading digital services and
telecommunications provider in the Philippines today.

PLDT SME Nation


PLDT SME Nation is one half of PLDT Enterprise alongside PLDT Alpha
Enterprise. While PLDT Alpha Enterprise caters to the 10,000 largest operations in the
Philippines, PLDT SME Nation focuses on the Micro, Small, and Medium enterprises of
the country that accommodates around 99.6 percent of the industry.

Since the founding of PLDT SME Nation in 2008, the company has been
providing entrepreneurs with technologies suitable for their needs. The company offers
solutions such as broadband and mobility resolutions to even more sophisticated cloud
services. PLDT SME Nation is dedicated to aiding Filipino entrepreneurs by giving them
access to business tools related to Internet Connection, Mobile Communication,
Collaboration Tools, Operations Management, Data Management, Industry Solutions,
and Digital Commerce which are all tailored to meet the needs of enterprises of all
sizes.

A. Background of the Study


This study involves the theory of planned behavior applied with the influence of
brand trust among MSMEs towards the use of PLDT SME Nations business tools and
business tools in general. The theory of planned behavior is a recognized intention
model that can predict intention and behavior. The three independent variables that
predict ones intention towards a behavior is attitude towards the behavior, subjective
norm, and perceived behavioral control. These three lead to an outcome of a dependent
variable of intention towards the behavior. In the case of our study, all variables were
put in the context of MSMEs using business tools in their businesses. Aside from this,
4

this study also puts into consideration the inclination of MSMEs to choose PLDT SME
Nation as the brand to aid them in business tools by measuring their brand trust. For
this study, we measured two kinds of brand trust. One is cognitive, which responds to
the utilitarian value of a brand, and the other one is affective, which responds to the
hedonic value of a brand. Through this framework, the study will be able to identify how
MSMEs make decisions towards the use of business tools and measure the kind and
level of brand trust that they have with PLDT SME Nation.

As mentioned earlier, PLDT SME Nation is a unit that provides micro, small, and
medium enterprises in the Philippines with business tools that will help them develop
their businesses. They offer business tools that range from business-enabling voice,
broadband and mobility solutions to more sophisticated enterprise-level information and
communication technologies and Cloud services that are suited to help Filipino
entrepreneurs in their business needs. Since its founding in 2008, PLDT SME Nation
has been committed to support Filipino MSMEs in taking new business opportunities
and developing new business ventures by providing them with mobility, connectivity,
support, and hardware.

Furthermore, they recently launched a campaign called Make It Big, wherein they
drive Filipino entrepreneurs to pursue their dreams and make it big in their respective
industries. They took Filipino entrepreneurs who started small but has now progressed
into big and booming businesses as their brand ambassadors. PLDT SME Nations
campaign Make It Big is all across social media accounts, out-of-home
advertisements, and print media. Other than the campaign, PLDT SME Nation puts their
5

efforts into community partnerships by tying up with associations for MSMEs and by
having small events in different locations in the country.

MSMEs

in

the

Philippines

are

relatively

new

target

market

for

telecommunications companies. Although they are business owners, they are


approached as consumers rather than in a business-to-business approach. PLDT SME
Nation has had a little difficulty in communicating with these entrepreneurs. According to
PLDT SME Nation, one of the reasons that hinder them from communicating with their
target market is the use of business tools among MSMEs is not yet widely spread. Most
business owners rely on technologies that are more suited for home or office
applications, instead of business operations. Another reason is that a lot of MSMEs are
not aware that PLDT SME Nation offers business tools that can aid them in their
businesses.

B. Conceptual Framework
The researchers of this study employed the use of Correlational Statistics. A
correlational research involves the assessment of the relationship between two or more
variables that can be studied with more than two measures at the same time (Stangor).
This type of analysis describes sets of data and the extent to which two or more
variables are related.

B.1. The Theory of Planned Behavior


The theory is guided by three kinds of considerations that can be seen in Figure
1. The 3 considerations are: behavioral beliefs, normative beliefs, and control beliefs.
Behavioral beliefs are about the probable consequences of the behavior, normative
beliefs are about the expectations of others, and control beliefs are about the presence
of elements that may enable or hinder performance of the behavior (Ajzen, 2006).

In their respective aggregates, behavioral beliefs produce a favorable or


unfavorable attitude toward the behavior; normative beliefs result in perceived
social pressure or subjective norm; and control beliefs give rise to perceived
behavioral control. In combination, attitude toward the behavior, subjective norm,
and perception of behavioral control lead to the formation of a behavioral
intention. As a general rule, the more favorable the attitude and subjective norm,
and the greater the perceived control, the stronger should be the persons
intention to perform the behavior in question. Finally, given a sufficient degree of
actual control over the behavior, people are expected to carry out their intentions
when the opportunity arises. Intention is thus assumed to be the immediate
antecedent of behavior. (Ajzen, 2006, p. 1)

Figure 1. The Theory of Planned Behavior taken from Ajzen, 2006

In other words, to predict whether a person intends to do something there are 3


variables that must be taken into consideration: Attitude Towards Behavior, Subjective
Norm and Perceived Behavioral Control. Attitude Towards Behavior is a persons
overall evaluation of the behavior which includes the personal beliefs about the
consequences of the behavior and its corresponding positive or negative judgements.
Subjective Norm is a persons own estimate of the social pressure to perform or not
perform the target behavior which includes beliefs about how other people would like
them to behave. For Perceived Behavioral Control, it is the extent of control a person
has over the behavior and how confident he or she may feel about performing or not
performing the behavior (Francis et al., 2006).

B.2. New Research Model


The base of the new research model is grounded on the Theory of Planned
Behavior (TBP) by Icek Ajzen. However, the researchers have created a new model to
take into consideration the moderating variables of Brand Trust. Also, instead of only
considering the intention of the respondents to incorporate and retain/upgrade PLDT
SME Nation Business Tools, the researchers also test the intention of incorporating and
retaining/upgrading Business Tools in General.

Figure 2: New Research Model

The moderating variable in the new research model is Brand Trust. Brand Trust
can be classified into two: Hedonic and Utilitarian. Utilitarian attitudes are more
instrumental and concerned with the expectation of consequences of product usage,
are based on assessment of functional brand/product attributes, and are more
9

concerned with practical usefulness or benefits derived from a brand/product. Hedonic


attitudes are based more on affective gratification derived from sensory product/brand
attributes. Hedonic attitudes are more experiential and related to how much pleasure a
consumer derives from a brand/product (Batra and Ahtola, 1991). Moreover, it was
mentioned that although both attitudes are related they are still distinct and it is possible
that one attitude could be more relevant than the other.

C. Statement of the Problem/Hypothesis

The researchers want to understand the factors that influence the adaptation of
Business Tools among MSMEs, specifically:
1.

How does the attitude of the Manager/Owner correlate to the

intention of incorporating business tools?


2.

How does the subjective norm of the Manager/Owner correlate to

the intention of incorporating business tools?


3.

How does the perceived behavioral control of the Manager/Owner

correlate to the intention of incorporating business tools?


4.

How does the attitude of the Manager/Owner correlate to the

intention of retaining/upgrading business tools?


5.

How does the subjective norm of the Manager/Owner correlate to

the intention of retaining/upgrading business tools?


6.

How does the perceived behavioral control of the Manager/Owner

correlate to the intention of retaining/upgrading business tools?


7.

How does Brand Trust affect the intention of incorporating PLDT

SME Nation business tools?


10

8.

How does Brand Trust affect the intention of retaining/upgrading

PLDT SME Nation business tools?

Given the framework and in line with the research questions, the following
hypothesis are made:
H1: Attitude towards behavior positively influences the intention to use
business tools.
H2: Subjective norm positively influences intention to use business tools.
H3: Perceived behavioral control positively influences the intention to use
business tools.
H4: Hedonic brand trust positively moderates attitude towards behavior
and intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools.
H5: Hedonic brand trust positively moderates subjective norm and
intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools.
H6: Hedonic brand trust positively moderates perceived behavioral control
over and intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools.
H7: Utilitarian brand trust positively moderates attitude towards behavior
and intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools.
H8: Utilitarian brand trust positively moderates subjective norm and
intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools.
H9: Utilitarian brand trust positively moderates perceived behavioral
control over and intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools.

11

D. Assumption of The Study


The researchers are assuming the following in the context of the study:
D.1.

Respondents
The study assumes that the 256 respondents attained will be

sufficient in attaining intended results provided the limited time.


It is assumed that the respondents fully understand the questions in

the given surveys.


It is assumed that the respondents will provide honest expressions

of their knowledge.
The study assumes that all PLDT SME Nation existing clients are

PLDT SME Nation Business Tools users.


The study assumes that all non users of PLDT SME Nation

business tools are PLDT SME Nation potential clients.


D.2.

Questionnaire

The survey questionnaires are assumed to have been taken either


online or offline by answering the hard copy of the survey.

D.3.

At least 250 are assumed to have completed answers.


Secondary Data

Secondary data as mentioned throughout the study and is


indicated in the reference section will be assumed as an accurate
basis for the research.

12

D.4.

Sources of Information

Sources of information and survey results are all assumed to be


accurate or to the best of the knowledge of its creators.

D.5.

Researchers

The researchers of this study assume that the new model in Figure
2 will give significant results for this study.

D.6.

Statistical Method

Statistical methods using partial least squares method to structural


equation modeling (PLS-SEM) and analyzed via WarpPLS and
other accepted forms of data analysis research tools will be
assumed as valid, reliable and accurate for the results and
conclusion of the study.

E. Scope and Limitation of The Study


This study was conducted to determine how potential and existing micro, small,
and medium enterprise (MSMEs) clients of PLDT SME Nation, in the National Capital
Region of the Philippines incorporate or retain/upgrade business tools. In order to obtain
quantitative data, the investigation was carried out for three weeks during the month of
July and explored how the theory of planned behaviour and brand trust play a role in
MSMEs decision to incorporate or retain business tools. Research on the potential and
existing clients of PLDT SME Nation were administered by survey during business
events, local expos, meetings, interviews and online platforms.
13

The scope of the survey included gender, age, estimated annual household
income, and number of household members as part of the demographics. Additionally,
since the focus of our study are businesses, the researchers included the following:
name of company, business registration, legal entity, industry classification and years of
operation.

F. Significance of The Study

F.1. Marketing Field


This study made use of the Theory of Planned Behavior, which gives light
to several factors that are considered before making a decision towards a brand.
Examining the roles of these factors along with other influences and how they
affect decision-making towards a brand will be beneficial in several applications
in Marketing. The type of influence focused in the study is brand trust. The
results of the study concerning how brand trust influences the decision of a
consumer in choosing or committing to a brand will be useful in developing new
strategies in the marketing field. Furthermore, the results of this study will show
how MSMEs value the use of business tools in their businesses, providing
valuable information for brands that offer business tools.

F.2. Business and Industry


By studying MSMEs in the Philippines, it is expected to contribute to the
understanding of specific factors that may influence the adoption of Business
14

Tools in the Philippine context. Also, since the study focuses on an interesting
target market, which are MSMEs, and how they are approached as consumers
rather than in a business-to-business approach, it can provide insight as to how
to communicate and build a relationship with these businesses. Additionally, the
results of this will provide an understanding of what MSMEs give importance to
when it comes to their intention of incorporating, upgrading, and retaining
businesses tools which can be beneficial to other businesses that have an
interest in the industry and are specifically targeting MSMEs.

F.3. Student and Faculty


This study intends to provide knowledge concerning the application of the
Theory of Planned Behavior in relation to the adaptation of Business Tools
among MSMEs. The research provides significant progress about the marketing
field and the industry of business tools providers, which can be useful for faculty
and students who are interested in the topic. Aside from this, by applying the
TPB and adding other variables into the model, this study can explain which
variables are significant to one another and can aid in contributing to further
theory development.

CHAPTER 2: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

There are studies that have been conducted related to the adoption of
technology. However, most of the studies that have been conducted on technology
adoption were based solely on Information Technology (IT), the researchers did not
15

focus on SMEs and the role of Brand Trust was not taken into consideration. In addition,
the studies concerning SMEs and IT adoption lack strong theoretical basis (e. g.
Farhoomand, Tuunainen, & Yee, 2000; Simpson & Swatman, 1999; Stylianou, Robbins,
& Jackson, 2003; Wresch, 2003). In order to gain more understanding on the adoption
of SMEs, the following literature review concentrates on the study regarding the
adaptation of e-commerce in SMEs with the application of the Theory of Planned
Behavior (TPB) since this research relied on the TPB. However, since this research
focuses on a new model with Brand Trust as its moderating variable, this chapter will be
divided on the significant elements of this research.
A. Business Tools and MSMEs
A.1. Business Tools Defined
Business tools have been instrumental in providing means of
communication using various technologies throughout the past few decades. It
continues to bring significant impact in the way of business as it facilitates how
information is learned and shared.

In

this

study,

business

tools

are

defined

as

information

and

communication technologies (ICTs) that play the role of unifying communications


and integrate telecommunications, computers, middleware, software, storage
systems, as well as audio-visual systems. Such tools enable businesses to
create, access, store, transmit, and manipulate information (Tamilselvan,
Sivakumar, and Sevukan, 2012). Based on the given definition, business tools
are considered high-involvement products. High-involvement products are
16

characterized to have high prices, technical features, major differences between


brands, and risk-evaluation compared to low-involvement products that are the
opposite. They carry a high risk to consumers when they fail but these type of
products are relevant and important (Tanner & Raymond, 2012), similar to how
business tools are to entrepreneurs. Because of this, it is important that brands
offer a lot of information about their business tools because their consumers
engage in extended problem solving, where they spend time gathering a
significant amount of information and compare different aspects of the product
(Tanner & Raymond, 2012), as in the case of high-involvement products.
Consumers of business tools are highly involved in the purchase and must be
assisted by the brand when processing information (Grayson, 2016).

To further understand business tools, Tamilselvan Sivakumar, and


Sevukan defined ICT using its components. Technology was explained as the
process of utilizing scientific material and human resources as a way to satisfy a
human need or purpose. Information was indicated as that which is expected to
be communicated and understood. Combined, information technology is defined
as the use of information to satisfy a human need and purpose.

Using this definition, ICT is the use of information as a way to satisfy a


human need or purpose with reference to contemporary devices. In the business
context, ICT is categorized in two types of products: traditional computer-based
technologies and digital communication technologies. Traditional computer
based technologies include the use of applications, databases, and softwares.
17

Digital communication technologies include internal and external networks that


transmit data electronically.

According to 2003 study by Giovanni and Mario, such business tools offer
enterprises with ways to improve their competitive position in their respective
industries. The study indicated that business tools are able to improve the
management of information and knowledge, internally and externally. This
enables growing businesses, such as micro, small, and medium enterprises
(MSMEs) to enhance the reliability of business-to-business and business-toconsumer transactions.

In addition, the business tools are able to improve the relationships


between suppliers, partners, customers, and other stakeholders of the business.
Indicated in study by Pohjola back in 1998, business tools can bring various
advantages specifically for MSMEs as it allows them to generate sustainable
profit, locally and globally, which can lead to their overall growth in the long-run.
Lymer explained in a 1997 study the hindrances that MSMEs face regarding the
decision to implement business into their daily operations. Though business tools
can reduce costs while increasing productivity, small firms are commonly
discouraged due to the amount of investment needed to implement business
tools.

18

A.2. MSMEs Defined


According to the Philippine Magna Carta for Micro, Small, and Medium
Enterprises (MSMEs) of 2009, MSMEs are defined as any business enterprise or
activity that is involved in industry, agribusiness or services, whether single
proprietorship, cooperative, partnership, or corporation whose total assets, which
includes those arising from loans but excludes the land which the business's
office, plant, and equipment are situated, fall under the following categories:

Micro: not more than P3,000,000


Small : P3,000,001 - P 15,000,000
Medium : P15,000,001 - P100,000,000

Alternatively, the measure of which category businesses fall into could be


determined by the number of employees. According to a 2012 study by Rafaelita
Albada of the Philippine Institute for Development Studies titled Small and
Medium Enterprises' (SMEs) Access to Finance: Philippines, the most common
definition for categorizing SMEs in the Philippines is the following:

Micro: 1-99 employees


Small: 10-99 employees
Medium: 100-199 employees

19

A.3. MSMEs In The Philippines


Albada stated that as of 2008, MSMEs take up 99.6 % of the businesses
in the Philippines, which gives them a vital role in the development of the
economy. From that 99.6%, 92% represent micro enterprises while small and
medium enterprises only take up 8%.

PHILIPPINES

TOTAL

MICRO

SMALL

MEDIUM

LARGE

761,409

697,0777

58,292

3,067

2,973

2,526

1,197

131

131

Agriculture, Hunting, and 3,985


Forestry
Fishing

1,306

897

358

25

26

Mining and Quarrying

340

209

102

10

19

Manufacturing

112,377

100,605

9,763

940

1,069

Electricity, Gas and

1,388

479

688

117

104

Construction

2,202

1,184

832

98

88

Wholesale and Retail

379,005

360,798

17,468

448

291

93,405

85,764

7,382

198

61

Water

Trade
Hotels and Restaurants

20

Transport, Storage and

8,647

6,366

2,016

151

114

Financial Intermediation

25,766

20,733

4,794

120

119

Real Estate, Renting

45,060

40,115

4,016

366

563

Education

13,562

7,242

5,802

293

225

Health and Social Work

31,113

29,633

1,261

116

103

Other Community,

43,253

40,526

2,613

54

60

Communications

and Business Activities

Social and Personal


Service Activities
Table 1. Number of Establishments by Size and Industry (2008)

Table 1 showcases the different establishments by size and industry. To


harness the power of the developing MSMEs, the government shown continued
support for the growth of such businesses since 1970 through various programs
and policies. Despite the initiatives created to propel Philippine MSMEs forward,
businesses belonging in the sector failed to maximize their growth due to several
constraints, one of which is issues on technology and information gaps as well as
skills (FINEX and ACERD; Tecson, 2004; Fukumoto, 2004). Such hindrances
are due to the lack of financial support of formal lending bodies as MSMEs
present have high perceived risks.

21

After several years, MSMEs then experienced an increase in competition,


which urged the government to develop strategies that will expand the market
access for MSMEs. As the nineties rolled in, Albada indicated that MSMEs were
faced with policies that centered on market access and export expansion.

A.4. Filipino MSMEs and Adapting Business Tools


According to the 2013 National Statistics from the Department of Science
and Technology, the Philippine ICT Industry consists of industries participating in
producing and distributing goods and services that satisfy the need to inform,
educate and/or entertain humans through mass communication media. In
addition, it includes industries engaged in the production, publishing and/or the
distribution of content that conveys an organized message intended for
human beings (Abejo 2013). The ICT Industry segments include:

Broadcast Media

Computer Hardware

Semiconductors and Electronics

ICT Enabled Creative Services

IT Services

IT and Business Process Management (IT-BPM)

Software and Applications

Telecommunications

22

B. Theory of Planned Behavior


The Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) is a recognized intention model that is
successful in explaining and predicting behavior (Grandon, 2005). It is an improved
model of the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) wherein perceived behavioral control
was added as an element to predict intention and behavior (Mattingly, 2012). Both
models assume that the intention to perform the behavior in question influences the
persons behavior (Grandon, 2005). However, In the TRA model, only attitude towards
the behavior and subjective norm was taken into consideration.

According to Ajzen, Intentions are assumed to capture the motivational factors


that influence a behavior; they are indications of how hard people are willing to try, of
how much of an effort they are planning to exert, in order to perform the behavior. As a
general rule, the stronger the intention to engage in a behavior, the more likely should
be its performance. (P181). With this said, Intention is a precursor of behavior and it
can be predicted from three variables. The three factors that hypothesize intention are:
attitude toward the behavior, subjective norm, and perceived behavioral control
(Handbook of Theories of Social Psychology, 2012).

The first factor, attitude towards the behavior, refers to the beliefs an individual
has with respect to the consequences associated with performing a particular behavior
(Casper, 2007). Also, it can have a corresponding negative or positive judgment
associated with it (Francis et al., 2006). The second factor, subjective norm, refers to an
individual's own evaluation of the perceived social pressure to perform or not perform
the behavior (Ajzen, 1991). It incorporates views about how other individuals would like
23

them to behave and the negative or positive judgments about each belief. It is
presumed that these components work in interaction (Francis et al., 2006). The third
factor, perceived behavioral control, is a persons perception of the struggle or easiness
associated with accomplishing the behavior (Ajzen, 1991). It has two aspects that
comprise mainly of whether or not an individual feels confident about performing the
behavior and how much control the person think he or she has over the said behavior
(Francis et al., 2006). The more positive the three factors are towards the behavior then
the persons intention to execute the behavior under consideration should be stronger
(Ajzen, 1991). Subsequently, if the three factors show to have negative results towards
the behavior then the intention of an individual to perform the behavior under
consideration will become weaker as well. It is important to note that the weight of the
three predictors of intention varies among different situations.

The application of the theory of planned behavior has been proven to be useful in
providing information amongst many researchers in various studies when it comes to
understanding behavior. Studies have shown that it has contributed in the prediction of
behaviors that require cognitive task performance (Locke, Fredrick, Lee, & Bobko,
1984) and even using interventions that will be applicable in changing them (Van Ryn &
Vinokur, 1990). Although it has been proven to be remarkable in predicting behavior, it
has had even more success with the addition of other variables (Mattingly, 2012). Ajzen
himself suggests that it is important to consider having additional variables.

According to Ajzen (1991), he says: The theory of planned behavior is, in


principle, open to the inclusion of additional predictors if it can be shown

that they
24

capture a significant proportion of the variance in intention or


theorys current variables have been taken into account.

behavior after the

The theory of planned

behavior in fact expanded the original theory of reasoned action by adding the concept
of perceived behavioral control (p.199).

Furthermore, aside from having supplementary predictors as variables, studies


can include the addition of moderators. Moderating variables are included to determine
their effect among the variables in the theory of planned behavior (Mattingly, 2012).
The theory of planned behavior is useful in providing insights with regards to behavior
modification and revealing information that may be applied to create communication
strategies (Casper, 2007). Each predictor of intention also uncovers distinguishing
characteristics of behavior that can aid in changing it (Ajzen, 1991).

In the study of Grandon (2005), he examined the applicability of the Theory of


Planned Behavior (TPB) and competing models to the prediction of the intention to
adopt e-commerce among managers/owners of SMEs in Chile. The outcome of the
study showed that TPB explained 80 percent of the variance in behavioral intention.
Also, it was found that attitude and subjective norm were significant predictors of the
intention to adopt e-commerce among Chilean managers while perceived behavioral
control was not a significant predictor. The researchers support the existing literature in
terms of the method and analysis of results. However, given that the focus of the study
is in a wider scope which includes two sets of respondents, two sets of intention, and
moderating variables, it is expected that the independent variables found to be
significant in the study provided might not be significant in this research.
25

C. Brand Trust
One of the important aspects of marketing research is brand trust. It has been
found to be related to other topics such as brand loyalty and brand preference, which
makes it significant for brands who want to build relationships with their consumers.
According to Hiscock (2001), the ultimate goal of marketing is to generate an intense
bond between the consumer and the brand, and the main ingredient of this bond is
trust (p.1). Brand Trust is defined by Chaudhuri and Holbrook (2001) as the
willingness of the average consumer to rely on the ability of the brand to perform its
stated function (p.82). It influences a consumers choice of brand, especially when it
comes to choosing among a variety of brands or trying out a new product. According to
Bidmon, Grabner-Krauter, and Matzler (2006), trust only plays a role whenever the
outcomes of a certain decision are important and uncertain for the decision-maker
(Bidmon, Grabner-Krauter, and Matzler, 2006). Brand trust is also defined as the
confident expectations of the brands reliability and intentions in situations entailing risk
to the consumer (Delgado-Ballester, 2002). It is often developed when brands make
promises to consumers and these promises are fulfilled, meeting the expectations of the
consumers (Chandio, Z., Qureshi, M., & Ahmed, S., 2015).

The concept of brand trust is based on consumers forming a relationship with


brands. Consumers can easily assign personalities to brands, creating brand
personalities in the field of marketing. Since brands can be personified, it means that
consumers can also have relationships with them as well. Consumers develop a
relationship with brands through their execution of marketing plans and tactics, which
can be viewed as behaviors performed by the brand in the consumer-brand relationship
26

(Srull and Wyer, 1989). In a brand-consumer relationship, trust is considered to be one


of the most desirable qualities (Bidmon, Grabner-Krauter, and Matzler, 2006).

In a study conducted by Deari and Balla (2013), they found out that brand trust is
highly correlated with brand preference and brand loyalty.

Based on previous studies, brand trust is a driver for brand preference. Brand
trust has a positive impact on the consumer preference (Deari & Balla, 2013). Thus, a
brand that is trusted by a consumer is more preferred than brands that are not. This is
important for new brands that want to penetrate a market or a brand that wants to
penetrate a new target market. Based on the research of Aakar (1991) and Keller
(1993), brand preference is defined as a set of brand assets and liabilities linked to a
brand and a customers subjective and intangible assessment of the brand, above and
beyond its objectively perceived value. (Chinomona, Mahlangu, & Pooe, 2013). Brand
preference positively drives the brands value in the marketplace (Azar & Fuller, 2008).
Through brand trust, a high brand value can be achieved by developing brand
preference.

Brand trust often leads to consumers becoming loyal to a brand. According to


Delgado-Ballester and Munuera-Aleman (1999), the better the image of trust attributed
to a brand results in a higher level of commitment towards the brand. When consumers
do not trust a brand in a competitive marketplace, they are less inclined to be loyal to
that brand (Liao, 2015). Brand trust can be developed into brand attachment (Vlachos et
al., 2010), which is an important factor for brand loyalty and equity (Malar et al., 2011).
27

The more that consumers trust a brand, the more that they will be loyal to that brand. It
is important for brands to attain brand loyalty because it is often related to repeat
purchase, preference, commitment and allegiance (Azize, Cemal, & Hakan, 2011).

Based on social psychology literature, there are two types of trust that can be
applied to brands or products, which are cognitive trust and affective trust. Cognitive
trust depends on good rational reasons why the object of trust merits trust (Lewis and
Weigert, 1985, p.972). This type of trust focuses on evaluating the reliability and
competence of the brand or product, leading the individual to arrive at a rational choice.
According to Delgado-Ballester (2002), brand reliability is, at best, a starting point for
describing brand trust (p.575). The other type which is affective trust depends on the
emotions of an individual resulting from the attractiveness, goodwill, and aesthetics of
the brand or product. This is similar to brand intention (Delgado-Ballester, 2002), which
reflects the individuals emotional security towards the brand. It is often that a trustbased behavior is the result of a combination of the cognitive trust and affective trust
(Riegelsberger et al., 2005; Corritore et. al., 2003). These two types of trust can be
related to the two values of products that are suggested to be drivers of brand trust.
Based on consumer research literature, the consumer evaluation of a product depends
on the utilitarian dimension of instrumentality and the hedonic dimension of the
experiential effect from the product (Batra and Ahtola, 1990; Mano and Oliver, 1993).

The utilitarian value of a product is defined by its ability to perform functions in


the day to day life of a consumer (Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001). It also evaluates how
useful and beneficial the product is. Meanwhile, the hedonic value of a product is
28

defined by the pleasure potential that it carries on to the consumer. It reflects a more
subjective, emotional and aesthetic aspect of consumption (Holbrook and Hirschmann,
1982; Mano and Oliver, 1993; Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001). Therefore a product with
a high utilitarian value suggests that it will result in a high cognitive trust toward the
brand, while a product with a high hedonic value suggests that it will result in a high
affective trust toward the brand as well. (Bidmon, Grabner-Krauter, and Matzler, 2006).

CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY
A. Research Design
The type of research done in this study is quantitative which involved the use of a
structured questionnaire wherein 256 respondents were involved. Primary data from the
study shall be coming from an online and offline survey. Meanwhile, secondary data will
mostly come from similar studies and scholarly articles to further explain the findings in
the questionnaire. The method of data collection was through obtaining data from the
given subset.
Reference for the topic of the questions is summarized in Table 2:

Construct

Question Number

Attitude Towards Behavior (ATB)

1, 2, 3

Subjective Norm (SNorm)

4, 5, 6

29

Perceived Behavioral Control (PBC)

7, 8, 9

Hedonic Brand Trust

13, 14, 15

Utilitarian Brand Trust

16, 17, 18

Intention to Incorporate or Retain/Upgrade Business

10, 11, 12

Tools in General

Intention to Incorporate or Retain/Upgrade PLDT SME

19, 20, 21

Nation Business Tools

Table 2: Reference number of Survey Questions

Before the researchers began distributing surveys, they first tested the validity
and reliability of the constructs. Since the study applied Structural Equation Modeling,
the researchers used both convergent validity and discriminant validity in assessing the
constructs in the questionnaire.

A.1 Convergent Validity


Convergent Validity is measured by establishing a set of indicators that
represents the same construct (Henseler et al, 2009). It measures the quality of
the question-statements, which should share a high proportion of variance in
common, that serve as an instrument of a specific construct. According to Kock
30

(2015), the instrument of a specific construct has high convergent validity if each
of the question-statements are understood by the respondents in the same way
the designers of the instrument planned them to be. There are three measures of
convergent validity:

Item loading It is the relationship between the item (question-statement)


and the construct. The p values that are related to the item loadings
should be equal to or lower than .05, while the values of the item loadings
should be equal to or greater than .50 (Hair et al., 1987 & 2009 cited in
Kock, 2015). Since the p values result from a test of the model where the
relationship of the item and the construct were defined previously, it
serves as validation parameters of a confirmatory factor analysis (Kock,
2015).

Average Variance Extracted (AVE) It represents the proportion of


variance in the items that is explained by the construct. According to
Fornell and Larker (1981), the recommended AVE threshold for validity is
.50 (Kock, 2015). An AVE of .50 signifies that a construct is able to explain
about 50% of the variance of its indicators on average.

Composite Reliability and Cronbachs Alpha These are both measures


of internal consistency. As discussed in Kock (2015), conservatively, both
the composite reliability and the Cronbachs alpha should be equal to or
greater than 0.7 (Fornell & Larcker, 1981; Nunnaly, 1978; Nunnally &
Bernstein, 1994). But these measures are more commonly used when at
least one of the two is equal to or greater than 0.7. This rule often applies
31

to the composite reliability because it is more common to result in a higher


value than the Cronbachs alpha (Fornell & Larcker, 1981). In some cases,
both measures are still accepted as valid as long as they reach or exceed
a value of 0.6 (Nunnally & Bernstein, 1994). If any of the constructs do not
meet these criteria, it indicates that one of the items loaded weakly on the
construct and should be considered removed from the instrument.

The results from testing the convergent validity of the constructs from the questionnaire
are shown below (Table 3):

SNor

Intent

Intent

ATB

PBC

HBT

UBT

value

ATB1

0.95

-0.02

0.12

-0.06

0.00

-0.02

-0.01

0.00

ATB2

0.95

-0.05

0.08

-0.03

0.05

-0.03

-0.05

0.00

ATB3

0.91

0.08

-0.20

0.10

-0.05

0.04

0.06

0.00

SN1

0.26

0.81

-0.25

0.01

-0.03

0.27

-0.08

0.00

SN2

-0.09

0.87

-0.09

-0.05

0.12

0.03

-0.22

0.00

SN3

-0.15

0.85

0.34

0.04

-0.09

-0.29

0.31

0.00

PBC1

-0.05

0.21

0.88

-0.11

0.08

-0.13

0.07

0.00

PBC2

0.08

-0.12

0.91

-0.07

-0.18

-0.13

0.32

0.00

32

PBC3

-0.04

-0.09

0.83

0.19

0.11

0.27

-0.41

0.00

IA1

-0.03

-0.01

0.10

0.88

0.12

-0.07

-0.05

0.00

IA2

0.02

0.03

-0.08

0.93

0.06

0.10

-0.18

0.00

IA3

0.01

-0.02

-0.02

0.90

-0.18

-0.04

0.23

0.00

IA1_2

0.16

-0.14

-0.02

0.04

0.89

0.14

0.04

0.00

IA2_2

-0.14

0.15

0.03

-0.04

0.94

-0.12

-0.08

0.00

IA3_2

-0.01

-0.01

-0.01

0.00

0.94

-0.01

0.04

0.00

HBT1

-0.19

-0.03

0.14

0.09

-0.03

0.84

-0.15

0.00

HBT2

0.11

0.01

-0.03

-0.05

-0.04

0.92

-0.04

0.00

HBT3

0.06

0.02

-0.11

-0.04

0.07

0.90

0.18

0.00

UBT1

-0.03

-0.08

0.04

-0.04

-0.06

0.40

0.85

0.00

UBT2

0.08

0.00

-0.05

-0.04

0.05

-0.05

0.95

0.00

UBT3

-0.06

0.08

0.02

0.08

-0.01

-0.34

0.87

0.00

Cronbach's Alpha

0.93

0.80

0.85

0.89

0.91

0.86

0.87

Composite

0.95

0.88

0.91

0.93

0.95

0.92

0.92

0.87

0.71

0.77

0.82

0.85

0.79

0.80

Reliability
Average Variance

33

Extracted
Table 3. Convergent Validity of the Constructs from the questionnaire

Values in Table 3 that are in red are the values of the item loadings. The
p-values at the rightmost column are for the item loadings. As mentioned earlier,
a p-value of less than .05 indicates that an item is statistically a significant
indicator of the corresponding construct. Values in black are cross-loadings. The
significant values in the table all meet the criteria for item loadings, AVE,
composite reliability, and Cronbachs alpha. These results show that there is
convergent validity.

A.2. Discriminant Validity


Similar to convergent validity, discriminant validity measures the quality of
a measurement instrument. According to Kock (2013), there is good discriminant
validity if the question-statements from an instrument used to measure a
construct are not confused by the respondents with other question-statements, in
terms of meaning, that are used to measure a different construct. Based on the
Fornell-Larcker Criterion (Henseler, 2009), the AVE of each construct should be
higher than the constructs highest squared correlation with any other construct.
Another measure for discriminant validity is have the square root of the AVE of
each construct be higher than the correlations with all the other constructs (Mora
et al, 2012).

34

Results from testing the discriminant validity of the constructs from the questionnaire
are shown at the table below (Table 4):

ATB

SNorm

PBC

Intent1

Intent2

HBT

ATB

0.93

SNorm

0.50

0.84

PBC

0.34

0.57

0.88

Intent1

0.37

0.46

0.48

0.91

Intent2

0.18

0.29

0.38

0.31

0.92

HBT

0.10

0.25

0.33

0.28

0.64

0.89

UBT

0.25

0.18

0.21

0.12

0.66

0.71

UBT

0.89

Table 4. Discriminant Validity of the Constructs from the questionnaire

The diagonal values in red that can be seen in Table 4 are the square
roots of the AVE of constructs, while the off-diagonal elements are the correlation
between constructs.

As mentioned earlier, for an instrument to have good

discriminant validity, the square roots of the AVE of each construct should be
larger than the values of the correlations between constructs. The results from
the above table show discriminant validity for the questionnaire.
35

Since the questionnaire was proven to be valid and reliable, the researchers
proceeded to data gathering to be able to test the correlations between constructs
and the corresponding hypotheses.

B. Sampling Method
The sampling method used in this study is non-probability sampling, consisting of
the combined methods of purposive and convenience sampling techniques.
The researchers used purposive sampling method, specifically homogenous sampling,
in seeking out the respondents for the study. Homogenous sampling is a purposive
sampling technique that collects a sample size that shares the same characteristics.
The researchers sought out registered businesses, specifically micro, small, and
medium enterprises, and approached the owners or the top management employees as
respondents of the study. Aside from this, the researchers relied on convenience
sampling because of the limited access to respondents during data gathering.
Convenience sampling is a sampling method that gathers units of a sample that are the
easiest to access. The researchers went to events hosted by PLDT SME Nation for
MSMEs to be able to approach owners and top management of businesses. They also
approached peers whom are business owners and went to nearby business
establishments around their residential areas. The surveys were distributed in two
forms, through an online survey form and through a printed survey form.The surveys
were distributed to respondents based on the circumstance of which form was better to
be used. The criteria for MSMEs that the researchers used is from the data provided by

36

the National Statistics Office and the Small and Medium Enterprise Development
Council Resolution No. 1 (2003).

C. Statistical Treatment of Data


The researchers were able to gather 256 surveys which were used to test the
hypotheses in this study. The questionnaire made use of 21 7-point likert-type scale
questions to gather data that measured the following variables: 1) attitude towards
behavior, 2) subjective norm, 3) perceived behavioral control, 4) hedonic brand trust, 5)
utilitarian brand trust, 6) intention towards business tools, and 7) intention towards
PLDT business tools. Inferential statistics that focus on the correlations among these
variables, leading to the outcome of intention towards business tools and PLDT
business tools were used in the study.

Structural Equation Modeling with Partial Least Squares Path Modeling


PLS Path Modeling intends to estimate relationships among blocks of variables
that are expressions of unobservable constructs. It can be based on simple or multiple
regressions made of a system of interdependent equations. Such system estimates the
links between manifest variables and their own latent variables as well as the network of
relations among the latent variables (Vinzi, Trinchera, & Amato, 2010). Moreover, it is a
component-based estimation method (Tenenhaus 2008a) and an iterative algorithm that
separately solves out the blocks of the measurement model and estimates the path
coefficients in the structural model (Vinzi, Trinchera, & Amato, 2010). It can explain at

37

best the residual variance of the latent variables and also of the manifest variables in
any regression run in the model (Fornell and Bookstein 1982).

CHAPTER 4: PRESENTATION AND DATA ANALYSIS


A. Respondent Profile
A.1. Profile of All Respondents
Table 5 provides representation of the profile of the 256 respondents.
Highlighting the majority of each profile type: 55.8% of the respondents are male,
50.78% are represented by the age bracket of 22-39, 62.5% have an annual
income of more that P 250,000. For the companies represented by the
respondents, 49.2% are Sole Proprietorship while 44.5% are Corporations. The
majority are small businesses, taking up 55.8% of the respondents.

QUESTION

ANSWERS

FREQUENCY

PERCENT

Male

143

55.68%

Female

113

44.14%

0.78

22-39

130

50.78%

40-50

84

32.81%

51-61

40

15.63%

P40,000 and below

15

5.86%

P40,000 to P59,999

3.52%

SEX
21 years old and
below
Age

Annual Income

38

P60,000 to P99,999

22

8.59%

47

18.63%

160

62.50%

Undisclosed

1.17%

Sole Proprietorship

126

49.22%

Partnership

16

6.25%

Corporation

114

44.53%

29

11.33%

1.56%

37

14.45%

47

18.36%

13

5.08%

36

14.06%

18

7.03%

P100,000 to
P249,999
P250,000 and
above

Type of Business

Transportation and
Storage
Financial and
Insurance Activities
Wholesale and
Retail Trade
Accommodation
Industry
and Food Service
Arts, entertainment,
and recreation
Manufacturing
Professional
Scientific and
Technical Services
39

Information and
10

3.91%

0.39%

0.39%

0.78%

50

19.53%

0.78%

0.39%

0.39%

Communication
Water supply,
sewerage, waste
management and
remediation
Education
Real estate
activities
Other Services
Administrative and
support service
activities
Activities of private
households as
employers and
undifferentiated
goods and services
and producing
activities of
household for own
use
Construction

40

Agriculture, forestry,
1

0.39%

0.39%

Undisclosed

0.78%

Micro

64

25.00%

Small

143

55.86%

Medium

38

14.84%

Large

2.73%

and fishing
Electricity, gas,
steam, and airconditioning supply

Size of Business

Table 5. Respondent Profiles

A.2. Respondent Profile of Potential Clients


Table 6 provides representation of the profile of potential clients of PLDT
SME nation that equaled to 143 respondents. Highlighting the majority of each
profile type: 57.34% of the respondents are male, 47.55% are represented by the
age bracket of 22-39, 63.34% have an annual income of more that P250,000. For
the companies represented by the respondents, 51.75% are Sole Proprietorship
while 42.66% are Corporations. The majority are small businesses, taking up
57.34% of the respondents.

QUESTION
SEX

ANSWERS
Male

FREQUENCY
82

PERCENT
57.34%

41

Female

61

42.66%

0.00%

22-39

68

47.55%

40-50

45

31.47%

51-61

30

20.98%

P40,000 and below

4.90%

P40,000 to P59,999

2.80%

P60,000 to P99,999

13

9.09%

25

17.48%

92

64.34%

Undisclosed

1.40%

Sole Proprietorship

74

51.75%

Partnership

5.59%

Corporation

61

42.66%

15

10.49%

1.40%

16

11.19%

21 years old and


below
Age

P100,000 to
Annual Income
P249,999
P250,000 and
above

Type of Business

Transportation and
Storage
Financial and
Industry
Insurance Activities
Wholesale and
Retail Trade
42

Accommodation
27

18.88%

4.90%

27

18.88%

11

7.69%

3.50%

0.70%

0.00%

0.70%

25

17.48%

0.70%

0.70%

and Food Service


Arts, entertainment,
and recreation
Manufacturing
Professional
Scientific and
Technical Services
Information and
Communication
Water supply,
sewerage, waste
management and
remediation
Education
Real estate
activities
Other Services
Administrative and
support service
activities
Activities of private
households as

43

employers and
undifferentiated
goods and services
and producing
activities of
household for own
use
Construction

0.70%

0.70%

0.00%

Undisclosed

0.00%

Micro

32

22.38%

Small

82

57.34%

Medium

23

16.08%

Large

2.80%

Agriculture, forestry,
and fishing
Electricity, gas,
steam, and airconditioning supply

Size of Business

Table 6. Respondent Profile of Potential Clients

A.3. Respondent Profile of Existing Clients


Table 7 provides representation of the profile of existing clients of PLDT
SME nation that equaled to 113 respondents. Highlighting the majority of each

44

profile type: 53.98% of the respondents are male, 54.87% are represented by the
age bracket of 22-39, 60.18% have an annual income of more that P250,000. For
the companies represented by the respondents, 46.01% are Sole Proprietorship
while 46.90% are Corporations. The majority are small businesses, taking up
54.87% of the respondents.

QUESTION

ANSWERS

FREQUENCY

PERCENT

Male

61

53.98%

Female

52

46.02%

1.77%

22-39

62

54.87%

40-50

39

34.51%

51-61

10

8.85%

P40,000 and below

7.08%

P40,000 to P59,999

4.42%

P60,000 to P99,999

7.96%

22

19.47%

68

60.18%

Undisclosed

0.88%

Sole Proprietorship

52

46.02%

SEX
21 years old and
below
Age

P100,000 to
Annual Income
P249,999
P250,000 and
above

Type of Business

45

Partnership

7.08%

Corporation

53

46.90%

14

12.39%

1.77%

21

18.58%

20

17.70%

5.31%

7.96%

6.19%

4.42%

0.00%

0.88%

Transportation and
Storage
Financial and
Insurance Activities
Wholesale and
Retail Trade
Accommodation
and Food Service
Arts, entertainment,
and recreation
Industry

Manufacturing
Professional
Scientific and
Technical Services
Information and
Communication
Water supply,
sewerage, waste
management and
remediation
Education

46

Real estate
1

0.88%

25

22.12%

0.88%

0.00%

0.00%

0.00%

0.88%

Undisclosed

1.77%

Micro

32

28.32%

activities
Other Services
Administrative and
support service
activities
Activities of private
households as
employers and
undifferentiated
goods and services
and producing
activities of
household for own
use
Construction
Agriculture, forestry,
and fishing
Electricity, gas,
steam, and airconditioning supply
Size of Business

47

Small

62

54.87%

Medium

15

13.27%

Large

1.77%

Table 7. Respondent Profiles of Existing Clients

To delve further into the study, the mean and standard deviation was computed to
describe the level of perception respondents have among the variable. After that, the
path coefficients, p-values and effect size are presented.

B. Potential Clients Data Analysis

Table 8 shows the attitude towards behavior of Potential Clients:

Incorporating business tools in our company

Mean

SD

5.45

1.49

5.46

1.50

5.43

1.41

5.45

1.37

within 6 months would be beneficial


Incorporating the use of business tools for
our company within 6 months would be wise
Incorporating the use of business tools in
our company within 6 months would be
advantageous
Overall

Table 8. Attitude Towards Behavior of Potential Clients


48

As illustrated in the table 8, the average overall rating for potential clients attitude
towards the incorporating business tools is 5.45 with a standard deviation of 1.37. The
average ratings for the questions related to attitude towards the behavior indicate that
most of the potential clients slightly agree that incorporating business tools in their
businesses would be beneficial, wise, and advantageous.

Table 9 shows the Subjective Norm of Potential Clients:

Most firms that are important to our

Mean

SD

5.38

1.41

5.14

1.37

5.20

1.45

5.24

1.19

company think that our company should


incorporate the use of business tools within
6 months
Most companies that influence our company
think that our company should incorporate
business tools within 6 months
Most firms that are important to our firm
have incorporated business tools for their
company
Overall

Table 9. Subjective Norm of Potential Clients

49

As illustrated in the table 9, potential clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an


average overall rating of 5.24 with a standard deviation of 1.19 for the subjective norm
towards incorporating business tools. Most of the potential clients slightly agree that
firms important or are an influence to their company have incorporated business tools
into their company and believe that they should do the same.

Table 10 shows the Perceived Behavioral Control of Potential Clients:

Incorporating business tools in our company

Mean

SD

5.03

1.39

5.00

1.43

4.70

1.30

4.91

1.20

within 6 months would be easy


Our company is capable of incorporating
business tools within 6 months
Incorporating business tools for our
company within 6 months would be simple
to arrange
Overall

Table 10. Perceived Behavioral Control of Potential Clients

As illustrated in the table 10, potential clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an
average overall rating of 4.91 with a standard deviation of 1.2 for perceived behavioral
control when incorporating business tools. Most potential clients slightly agree that they
are capable of incorporating the use of business tools in the company and that it will be
50

easy and simple to arrange.

Table 11 shows Potential Clients intention to avail the business tool in general:

Our company strongly intends to incorporate the

Mean

SD

4.90

1.30

4.74

1.35

4.71

1.27

4.78

1.18

use of business tools within 6 months


Our company has certain plans to incorporate
the use of business tools within 6 months

Our company has a strong commitment to make


use of business tools within 6 months
Overall

Table 11. Intention to avail the business tool in general by Potential Clients

As illustrated in the table 11, potential clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an
average overall rating of 4.78 with a standard deviation of 1.18 for intention to use
business tools within the next 6 months. Most of the potential clients slightly agree that
they are committed to and have certain plans to incorporate business tools into their
company in the next 6 months.

51

Table 12 shows the hedonic brand trust of Potential Clients:

PLDT SME Nation is a brand that would

Mean

SD

4.49

1.24

4.50

1.11

4.53

1.24

4.78

1.18

guarantee our companys satisfaction


Our company feels confident in the PLDT
SME Nation brand
PLDT SME Nation is a brand name that
would not disappoint our company
Overall

Table 12. Hedonic brand trust of Potential Clients

As illustrated in table 12, potential clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 4.51 with a standard deviation of 1.06 for hedonic brand trust towards
PLDT SME Nation. Though most are neutral about PLDT SME Nations brand
guarantee to satisfy, most of the potential clients slightly agree that they are confident in
the brand and believe that it will not disappoint.

Table 13 shows the utilitarian brand trust of Potential Clients:

PLDT SME Nation is a reliable brand

Mean

SD

4.54

1.32

52

PLDT SME Nation is an effective brand

4.64

1.34

PLDT SME Nation is a valuable brand

4.72

1.36

4.63

1.19

Overall

Table 13. Utilitarian brand trust of Potential Clients

As illustrated in table 13, potential clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 4.63 with a standard deviation of 1.19 for utilitarian brand trust towards
PLDT SME Nation. Most of the potential clients slightly agree that PLDT SME Nation is
a reliable, effective, and valuable brand.

Table 14 shows the Potential Clients intention to avail PLDT branded business tools:

Our company strongly intends to incorporate

Mean

SD

4.40

1.35

4.39

1.35

4.30

1.34

the use of PLDT SME Nation business tools


within 6 months
Our company has certain plans to
incorporate the use of PLDT SME Nation
business tools within 6 months
Our company has a strong commitment to
make use of PLDT SME Nation business

53

tools within 6 months


Overall

4.36

1.24

Table 14. Intention of Potential Clients to avail PLDT branded business tools

As illustrated in the table 14, potential clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an
average overall rating of 4.26 with a standard deviation of 1.24 for intention to use PLDT
SME Nations business tools within the next 6 months. Most of the potential clients are
neutral in commitment, plans, and intention to incorporate PLDT SME Nations business
tools into their company in the next 6 months.

Below in Figure 3 is a graph showing the comparison between the average ratings of
potential and existing clients for each question of the survey. The questions are
arranged in descending order of the potential results.

54

Figure 3: Average Rating for Potential and Existing Clients

Table 15 shows the legend of the questions illustrated in the graph.

Table 15. Legend of Questions in Figure 3

55

As seen in the representation above, potential clients gave Q1, Q3, Q4, Q5 and Q6 a
higher average rating, compared to the results of existing clients. There are areas that
should be emphasized by PLDT SME Nation when approaching potential clients.

Results from the software application for Potential Clients:


Path

p-value

Effect size
(f2)

Coefficient
ATB Intent 1

.127

.059

.047

ATB Intent 2

.110

.090

.022

SNorm Intent 1

.134

.098

.062

SNorm Intent 2

.098

.117

.030

PBC Intent 1

.384

.000

.204

PBC Intent 2

.259

.000

.009

HBT*ATB Intent 1

.024

.387

.005

HBT*ATB Intent 2

-.068

.207

.012

HBT*SNorm Intent 1

-0.25

.382

.004

HBT*SNorm Intent 2

.226

.000

.057

HBT*PBC Intent 1

-.127

.060

.027

56

HBT*PBC Intent 2

.150

.032

.027

UBT*SNorm Intent 1

.064

.218

.012

UBT*SNorm Intent 2

.063

.222

.014

UBT*ATB Intent 1

-.108

.094

.026

UBT*ATB Intent 2

-.247

.000

.057

UBT*PBC Intent 1

-.018

.416

.001

UBT*PBC Intent 2

.063

.221

.006

Table 16. Main and moderating effects of the Variables (Potential Clients)

Table 16 shows the results of the main and moderating effects of the variables
present in the data collected from Potential Clients. Note: f2 is the Cohens (1988) effect
size coefficient: .02=small, .15=medium, .35=large. The p-value reveals the effect of
one variable on another. Effect is statistically significant if p-value is less than .05.

57

Graphical Summary of Potential Clients Results:

Figure 4. Results from Potential Clients


As seen in Figure 4, the green line indicates that a path is statistically significant
(p<.05). The results present that Perceived Behavioral Control (PBC) is the independent
variable that significantly affects the intention to avail of business tools in general (Intent
1) and the intention to avail of PLDT SME Nation business tools (Intent 2). It should be
noted that for the intention to avail of PLDT SME Nation business tools, Hedonic Brand
58

Trust (HBT) is the only significant moderating factor that strengthens the relationship.
Additionally, it can be noted that Hedonic Brand Trust (HBT) also significantly affects
the relationship between Subjective Norm (SNorm) and Intent 2. While Utilitarian Brand
Trust (UBT) significantly affects Attitude Towards Behavior (ATB) and Intent 2.

C. Existing Clients Data Analysis

Table 17 shows the attitude towards behavior of existing clients:

Retaining/upgrading the use business tools

Mean

SD

5.55

1.48

5.40

1.40

5.35

1.65

5.45

1.37

in our company within 6 months would be


beneficial
Retaining/upgrading the use of business
tools for our company within 6 months would
be wise
Retaining/upgrading the use of business
tools in our company within 6 months would
be advantageous
Overall

Table 17. Attitude Towards Behavior of Existing Clients

59

As illustrated in table 17, the average overall rating for existing clients attitude
towards the retaining/upgrading business tools is 5.43 with a standard deviation of
1.33. Most of the existing clients of PLDT SME Nation moderately agree that
retaining/upgrading the use of business tools will be beneficial to their company. Most
existing clients also slightly agree that retaining/upgrading business tools in their
businesses would be wise and advantageous.

Table 18 shows the subjective norm of existing clients:

Most firms that are important to our company think that our

Mean

SD

5.22

1.51

5.07

1.47

5.08

1.49

5.12

1.27

company should retain/upgrade the use of business tools within 6


months
Most companies that influence our company think that our
company should retain/upgrade our business tools within 6 months
Most firms that are important to our firm have retained/upgraded
their business tools for their company
Overall
Table 18. Subjective Norm of Existing Clients

As illustrated in table 18, existing clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 5.12 with a standard deviation of 1.27 for the subjective norm towards
retaining business tools. Most of the existing clients slightly agree that firms important or
60

are an influence to their company have retained/upgraded the use of business tools into
their company and believe that they should do the same.

Table 19 shows the perceived behavioral control of existing clients:

Retaining/upgrading the use of business tools in our company

Mean

SD

5.14

1.43

5.10

1.45

5.01

1.49

5.08

1.30

within 6 months would be easy


Our company is capable of retaining/upgrading business tools
within 6 months
Retaining/upgrading business tools for our company within 6
months would be simple to arrange
Overall

Table 19. Perceived Behavioral Control of Existing Clients

As illustrated in table 19, existing clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 5.08 with a standard deviation of 1.3 for perceived behavioral control
when retaining/upgrading business tools. Most existing clients slightly agree that they
are capable of retaining/upgrading the use of business tools in the company and that it
will be easy and simple to arrange.

61

Table 20 shows the intention of PLDT SME Nations existing clients to avail of business
tools:

Our company strongly intends to retain/upgrade the use of

Mean

SD

5.50

1.30

5.42

1.16

5.40

1.16

5.44

1.03

business tools within 6 months


Our company has certain plants to retain/upgrade the use of
business tools within 6 months
Our company has a strong commitment to retain/upgrade the use
of business tools within 6 months
Overall

Table 20. Intention to avail of Business Tools by Existing Clients

As illustrated in the table 20, existing clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an
average overall rating of 5.44 with a standard deviation of 1.03 for retaining/upgrading
the use business tools within the next 6 months. Most of the existing clients moderately
agree that they strongly intent to retain/upgrade their use of business tools within the
next 6 months. Most of the existing clients also slightly agree that they are committed to
and have certain plans to retain/upgrade their use of business tools into their company
in the next 6 months.

62

Table 21 shows the hedonic brand trust of existing clients:


Mean

SD

4.92

1.19

Our company feels confident in the PLDT SME Nation brand

4.96

1.18

PLDT SME Nation is a brand name that would not disappoint our

4.84

1.40

4.91

1.15

PLDT SME Nation is a brand that would guarantee our companys


satisfaction

company
Overall
Table 21. Hedonic Brand Trust of Existing Clients

As illustrated in table 21, existing clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 4.91 with a standard deviation of 1.15 for hedonic brand trust towards
PLDT SME Nation. Most of the existing clients slightly agree that PLDT SME Nations
brand guarantee to satisfy, and that they are confident in the brand and believe that it
will not disappoint.

Table 22 shows the utilitarian brand trust of existing clients:


Mean

SD

PLDT SME Nation is a reliable brand

4.88

1.41

PLDT SME Nation is an effective brand

4.93

1.21

PLDT SME Nation is a valuable brand

4.88

1.19

63

Overall

4.89

1.15

Table 22. Utilitarian Brand Trust of Existing Clients

As illustrated in table 22, existing clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 4.89 with a standard deviation of 1.15 for utilitarian brand trust towards
PLDT SME Nation. Most of the existing clients slightly agree that PLDT SME Nation is a
reliable, effective, and valuable brand.

Table 23 shows existing clients intention to avail PLDT branded business tools:

Our company strongly intends to retain/upgrade the use of PLDT

Mean

SD

4.96

1.32

4.99

1.28

5.04

1.34

5.00

1.24

SME Nation business tools within 6 months


Our company has certain plants to retain/upgrade the use of PLDT
SME Nation business tools within 6 months
Our company has a strong commitment of retaining/upgrading
PLDT SME Nation business tools within 6 months
Overall

Table 23. Intention to avail of PLDT Business Tools by Existing Clients

As illustrated in the table 23, existing clients of PLDT SME Nation gave an average
overall rating of 5.00 with a standard deviation of 1.24 for intention to retain/upgrade the
use of PLDT SME Nations business tools within the next 6 months. Most of the
64

potential clients slightly agree that they have commitment, plans, and intention to
retain/upgrade the use of PLDT SME Nations business tools into their company in the
next 6 months.

Results from the software application for Existing Clients:


Path

p-value

Effect size
(f2)

Coefficient
ATB Intent 1

-.233

.005

.122

ATB Intent 2

.266

.002

.156

SNorm Intent 1

.203

.012

.110

SNorm Intent 2

.066

.238

.037

PBC Intent 1

.371

.000

.237

PBC Intent 2

.349

.000

.223

HBT*ATB Intent 1

-.185

.021

.056

HBT*ATB Intent 2

-.264

.002

.102

HBT*SNorm Intent 1

-.224

.007

.065

HBT*SNorm Intent 2

.103

.131

.029

HBT*PBC Intent 1

-.369

.000

.117

65

HBT*PBC Intent 2

-.117

.102

.026

UBT*SNorm Intent 1

-.110

.115

.034

UBT*SNorm Intent 2

-.141

.062

.041

UBT*ATB Intent 1

.128

.002

.040

UBT*ATB Intent 2

.253

.002

.087

UBT*PBC Intent 1

.101

.137

.036

UBT*PBC Intent 2

-.075

.210

.026

Table 24. Main and moderating effects of the Variables (Existing Clients)

Table 24 shows the results of the main and moderating effects of the variables
present in the data collected from Existing Clients. Note: f2 is the Cohens (1988) effect
size coefficient: .02=small, .15=medium, .35=large. The p-value reveals the effect of
one variable on another. Effect is statistically significant if p-value is less than .05.

66

Graphical Summary of Existing Clients Results:

Figure 5. Results from Existing Clients


As seen in Figure 5, the green line indicates that a path is statistically significant
(p<.05). The results show that Attitude Towards Behavior (ATB) and Perceived
Behavioral Control (PBC) are the independent variables that affect the intention of
existing clients to retain or upgrade their PLDT Business Tools (Intent 2). Moreover,
67

both moderating variables must be taken into consideration when it comes to the
relationship of ATB and Intent 2 since Hedonic Brand Trust (HBT) and Utilitarian Brand
Trust (UBT) has a significant effect on this relationship.
D. Comparative Analysis
POTENTIAL
Path

p-value

Coefficient

EXISTING
Path

p-value

Coefficient

ATB Intent 1

.127

.059

-.233

.005

ATB Intent 2

.110

.090

.266

.002

SNorm Intent 1

.134

.098

.203

.012

SNorm Intent 2

.098

.117

.066

.238

PBC Intent 1

.384

.000

.371

.000

PBC Intent 2

.259

.000

.349

.000

HBT*ATB Intent 1

.024

.387

-.185

.021

HBT*ATB Intent 2

-.068

.207

-.264

.002

HBT*SNorm Intent 1

-0.25

.382

-.224

.007

HBT*SNorm Intent 2

.226

.000

.103

.131

68

HBT*PBC Intent 1

-.127

.060

-.369

.000

HBT*PBC Intent 2

.150

.032

-.117

.102

UBT*SNorm Intent 1

.064

.218

-.110

.115

UBT*SNorm Intent 2

.063

.222

-.141

.062

UBT*ATB Intent 1

-.108

.094

.128

.002

UBT*ATB Intent 2

-.247

.000

.253

.002

UBT*PBC Intent 1

-.018

.416

.101

.137

UBT*PBC Intent 2

.063

.221

-.075

.210

Table 25. Comparative Analysis (Path Coefficients and p-value)

As illustrated in Table 25, the results present that for potential clients, the
independent variable Perceived Behavioral Control is the factor that significantly affects
both intention to avail business tools in general and intention to avail of PLDT SME
Nations business tools. It must be noted that for the intention to avail of PLDT SME
Nations business tools, Hedonic Brand Trust is the moderating variable that
strengthens this relationship. Additionally, the study also shows that Hedonic Brand
Trust strengthens the relationship of the Subjective Norm and intention to avail of PLDT
SME Nation business tools while Utilitarian Brand Trust was found to strengthen the
relationship of Attitude Towards Behavior and the intention to avail of PLDT SME Nation
business tools. For existing clients, all independent variables have a significant effect on

69

the intention to avail of business tools in general. Moreover, results show that Hedonic
Brant Trust strengthens the relationship of all the independent variables with the
intention to upgrade or retain business tools in general together with Utilitarian Brand
Trust strengthening the relationship between attitude towards behavior and this intent.
For the intention to retain or upgrade PLDT SME Nation business tools, the only
significant independent variables are Attitude Towards Behavior and Perceived
Behavioral Control. However, the only moderating factor that the results found out to be
significant is Utilitarian Brand Trust strengthening the relationship between Attitude
Towards Behavior and the intention to retain or upgrade PLDT SME Nation business
tools.

CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

A. Summary and Conclusion


Summary of results vis-a-vis hypotheses of the study are summarized in this table:

H1: Attitude towards

Relationship

Result
(Potential)

Result
(Existing)

ATB -> Intent 1

Not supported

Supported

SNORM -> Intent 1

Not supported

Supported

behavior influences the


intention to use business
tools.
H2: Subjective norm
influences the intention to use

70

business tools
H3: Perceived behavioral

PBC->Intent 1

Supported

Supported

HBT*ATB->Intent 2

Not supported

Not
supported

HBT*SNORM->Intent 2

Supported

Not
supported

HBT*PBC->Intent 2

Supported

Not
supported

control influences the


intention to use business
tools.
H4: Hedonic brand trust
positively moderates attitude
towards behavior and
intention to use PLDT SME
Nation business tools.
H5: Hedonic brand trust
positively moderates
subjective norm and intention
to use PLDT SME Nation
business tools.
H6: Hedonic brand trust
positively moderates
perceived behavioral control
over and intention to use
PLDT SME Nation business
tools.

71

H7: Utilitarian brand trust

UTB*ATB->Intent 2

Not supported

Supported

UTB*SNORM->Intent 2

Not supported

Not
supported

UTB*PBC->Intent 2

Not supported

Not
supported

positively moderates attitude


towards behavior and
intention to use PLDT SME
Nation business tools.
H8: Utilitarian brand trust
positively moderates
subjective norm and intention
to use PLDT SME Nation
business tools.
H9: Utilitarian brand trust
positively moderates
perceived behavioral control
over and intention to use
PLDT SME Nation business
tools.
Table 26. Summary of results vis-a-vis hypotheses

The results of the data analysis supported only a few of the presented
hypotheses. Most of the hypotheses that were supported by the results are for existing
clients. For potential clients, the variable that was significant in influencing their intention
to use business tools is perceived behavioral control. The researchers suggest that this

72

is because the use of business tools brings them to unfamiliar ground, and it would
increase their intention to use business tools if it becomes familiar or an easy direction
to proceed with. Also, it is supported that hedonic brand trust positively moderates the
relationship between subjective norm and intention to use PLDT SME Nation business
tools. Hedonic brand trust refers to emotions of an individual regarding the
attractiveness and goodwill of the product (Delgado-Ballester, 2002), which qualities
can often be defined by peers or the community that one belongs to, where subjective
norm plays a role. The researchers suggest that subjective norm is a significant variable
for potential clients because as business owners, they evaluate what other companies
or competitors are doing that can help them improve their business as well. Another
supported hypotheses for potential clients is hedonic brand trust positively moderates
the relationship between perceived behavioral control and intention to use PLDT SME
Nation business tools. Hedonic brand trust is also associated to the emotional security
towards a brand (Delgado-Ballester, 2002), which can be related to a consumer having
confidence or control over a certain action, or perceived behavioral control (Francis et
al., 2006), in relation to a brand. Based on the study, the researchers suggest that
hedonic brand trust stood out more for potential clients because they are not users of
PLDT SME Nation business tools yet, which gives them no experience of the reliability
of the product and rely more on their affective trust on the brand.

For existing clients, it was supported that attitude towards behavior, subjective
norm, and perceived behavioral control all influences their intention to use business
tools in general. The researchers suggest based on literature that all variables were
significant because existing clients are already using and have benefited from business
73

tools, which makes them more positive in considering to retain or upgrade their
business tools. In the existing clients intention to use PLDT SME Nation business tools,
utilitarian brand trust positively moderates its relationship with attitude towards behavior.
Utilitarian brand trust refers to evaluating the reliability and competence of a product
(Lewis and Weigert, 1985, p.972), which can be related to a consumers beliefs with
respect to the consequences associated with performing a behavior related to the
brand, or the attitude towards the behavior (Casper, 2007). Based on the study, the
researchers suggest that utilitarian brand trust is significant for existing clients because
they can appreciate more the reliability of PLDT SME Nation based on their experience
and on-going relationship as clients.

B. Implications and Recommendations


Based on our data analysis, for potential clients, it was found that perceived
behavioral control with hedonic brand trust is the variable that significantly affects the
intention of potential clients of availing PLDT SME Nations business tools. Therefore,
future campaigns targeting potential clients should focus on their control beliefs. They
should be focused on the ease of incorporating said tools and associate it experiential
values such as feelings of confidence. Meanwhile, for existing clients, it was found that
attitude towards behavior with utilitarian brand trust is the variable that significantly
affects the intention of existing clients of retaining or upgrading PLDT SME Nations
business tools. These indicates that campaigns for existing clients should be focused on
their positive evaluations towards retaining or upgrading PLDT SME Nations business
tools and associate it with functional values such as feelings of it being reliable and
effective. Overall, this suggests that the future campaigns should focus and allocate
74

their resources based on the outcomes of the study. Further implications and
recommendations in the layout of an Integrated Marketing Communications (IMC) plan
will be discussed in the following section divided into potential and existing clients.

In the case of hedonic and utilitarian brand trust moderating the relationships
between the independent variables and their intention to use business tools in general,
the researchers agree that these results can be defined as spurious correlations based
on past literatures. According to Burns (1997), A spurious correlation is defined as
having the measures of two or more variables result to be statistically related but are not
causally linked. It is described by Pearson (1923) as an outcome of a certain standard
way of processing the statistical data. Although it was suggested by Yule (1995) that a
spurious correlation is caused or dependent on a third variable, which is often referred
to as a lurking variable. In the case of the study, the lurking variable that influenced the
independent variables and their intention to use business tools in general is brand trust
in PLDT. A lurking variable can be a number of different things, as it is often not
identified because the spurious relationship it produced was not predicted based on the
observation of data (Aldrich, 1995). The researchers suggest based on the results of the
data that brand trust in PLDT became a lurking variable because it is a household name
brand and it was present in all throughout data gathering. A household name is referred
to as a brand name that a great majority of households are very well accustomed to.
Being a household name is strongly related to brand awareness, because it refers to
how well a brand can easily be identified in different conditions (Keller, 1993) on a high
magnitude of household consumers. Most successful brands focus on increasing their
household penetration in the market (Brusselmans, Blasberg, and Lannes, 2014), which
75

leads them in establishing a household name brand. In the case of PLDT, it has long
established itself as a household name brand because it is one of the first and biggest
pioneers in the telephone communications industry and data technology in the
Philippines. Because of this, it is speculated by the researchers that the respondents of
the study associated business tools to PLDT, which affected their intention to use
business tools in general.

C. Integrated Marketing Communications Plan


A. Potential Clients
1. Statement of General Objectives
To improve awareness about PLDT SME Nation and increase intention to buy
PLDT SME Nations business tools by __ %.
2. Creative Strategy
To persuade MSMEs to feel confident as they adapt to and compete in today's
digital world by convincing potential customers that it is easy to incorporate PLDT SME
Nation's business tools into their businesses.
3. Personification
To personify the target market, we introduce John Asha. John Asha is a 27-yearold male entrepreneur. He currently lives with his girlfriend and often sees his family. He
used to have a full time job for another company but left to focus full time on his
business. He has a small enterprise that has been operating for 2 years under a sole
proprietorship. He manages his time well but because his business is growing he is
starting to feel challenged in keeping up with such a fast paced industry. Though he has
a vision for his company, he does not know what tools are available for him to direct his
76

companys future since he is new in the industry. Nevertheless, John Asha is ambitious
and always wakes up in the morning with his goal in mind. He knows that the only way
to succeed is by making a change. He knows that he has to adapt to the times of today
and face whatever trial comes his way with confidence.
4. Consumer Promise, Brand identity, and Tone of Advertising
PLDT SME Nation promises satisfaction. It promises managers/owners that
integrating business tools for their company would be easy and simple to arrange. It
promises that managers/owners will not be disappointed in choosing PLDT SME Nation.
The brand will strive to foster a nation of MSMEs united by the goal of succeeding in
todays disruptive digital culture. For the tone of advertising, PLDT SME Nation will
embody a friendly, pro-active and empowering personality that aims to support MSMEs
every step of their entrepreneurial journey to success. To aid MSMEs further, PLDT
SME Nations tone will have a conversational approach that will develop an improved
relationship and trust between PLDT SME Nation and MSMEs.
5. Consumer Insights and Findings
Table 27 presents the significant relationship of constructs:

HBT*PBC -> Intent2

Path Coefficient

p-value

.150

.032

Table 27. Significant relationship of constructs (Potential Clients)

77

Table 28 presents the perceived behavioral control of potential clients:


Mean Interpretation
Incorporating business tools in our company within 6

5.03

months would be easy

Slightly
Agree

Our company is capable of incorporating the use of

5.00

business tools within 6 months


Incorporating business tools for our company within 6

Agree
4.70

months would be simple to arrange


Overall

Slightly

Slightly
Agree

4.91

Slightly
Agree

Table 28. Potential Clients Perceived Behavioral Control

Table 29 presents the hedonic brand trust of potential clients:


Mean Interpretation
PLDT SME Nation is a brand that would guarantee

4.49

our company's satisfaction

Neither
disagree nor
agree

Our company feels confident in the PLDT SME Nation


Brand

4.50

Slightly
Agree

78

PLDT SME Nation is a brand name that would not

4.53

disappoint our company


Overall

Slightly
Agree

4.51

Slightly
Agree

Table 29. Hedonic brand trust of potential clients

Table 30 shows the intention to avail PLDT branded business tools of potential
clients:
Mean Interpretation
Our company strongly intends to incorporate the use

4.40

Neither

of PLDT SME Nation business tools within the next 6

disagree nor

months

agree

Our company has certain plans to incorporate the use

4.39

Neither

of PLDT SME Nation business tools within the next 6

disagree nor

months

agree

Our company has a strong commitment to make use

4.30

Neither

of PLDT SME Nation business tools in the next 6

disagree nor

months

agree
Overall

4.51

Neither
disagree nor

79

agree
Table 30. Hedonic brand trust of potential clients

Based on the results of our data analysis, Perceived Behavioral Control is the
variable that significantly affects the intention of potential clients to avail of PLDT SME
Nation business tools with Hedonic Brand Trust as the factor that strengthens the
relationship. Potential clients believe that they are capable of adapting the use of
business tools in their company, which inclines them to the decision of doing so. In
terms of brand trust towards PLDT SME Nation, they have confidence in the brand and
they acknowledge that the brand will not disappoint them to a certain extent. This has
given them a hedonic brand trust towards PLDT SME Nation. But when asked about
adapting PLDT SME Nation business tools, the overall results show that they feel
indifferent towards that direction.
Understanding:
Potential clients are highly influenced by their perceived behavioral control in
adapting the use of business tools in their company and that they will choose a brand
that they feel highly satisfied with to provide them with business tools.
6. Big Idea
Feel confident because you are capable of change.
7. Key communication message
Be confident with change.

80

8. Integrated Marketing Campaign


Table 31 presents the integrated marketing campaign for potential clients. Refer to
appendix 4 for the collaterals.

Action
Chain
Step

Awareness

Desired
Behavior

Recognize

Call To
Action

Benefit

Realize
Adapt to
the
todays
availability
digitallyof easy-toinclined
use
market and
business
way of
tools
business

Motivating
Principles

Liking

Message

Channel Creative

LED
The
You can Billboard
focus will
confidently
be
compete
Media
recognizi
in todays Placeme
ng that
digital
nts
there are
world with
easy-toPLDT
Augment
use
SME
ed
business
Nations
reality
tools
easy-tobazaar
though
use
the
business
Techno
element
tools.
Needs
of
Stand
surprise.

81

Attitude

Know

Appreciate

Understan
d

Identify
what your
business
needs to
receive
Ease your
customize way to local
d business and global
tools that
success
can
address
those
needs

Learn
about how
to
transition
smoothly
when
implement
ing
business
tools

Prepare
your
business
and
employees
for growth

Social
Validation

Authority

Imagine
how easy
success
can be
with PLDT
SME
Nations
customize
d business
tools -made just
for your
companys
needs.

PLDT
SME
Nations
Official
Matchm
aker
Blog
posts
Social
media
posts
with
Brand
Ambass
adors

The
focus will
be
identifyin
g the
specific
needs of
business
es and
matching
them
with the
right
tool.

The
Learn
focus will
about how
be
to properly Worksho preparin
prepare
ps/Discu
g
your
ssion
business
company
Groups
es for
for the
growth
growth
Direct
and
that PLDT Mailing changes
SME
(Infograp in their
Nations
hics)
operatio
tools will
ns and in
bring.
the
industry.

82

Buy

Use

Incorporat
e PLDT
SME
Nations
business
tools with
confidenc
e

Gain
control of
your
companys
success

Busines
You are in s Tools
The
control of
Digital
focus will
your
Handbo
be giving
companys
ok
business
Consistenc
success
es
y
with PLDT
App
control
SME
over
Nations
Training
their
business Camp/Si
success.
tools.
mulation

Table 31. Integrated Marketing Communications Plan for Potential Clients


9. Media strategy and budget
Be Confident with Change

Duration

Cost

Campaign
Phase 1: Awareness
Billboard Placement

Digital Bazaar

DEC

JAN

FEB

Week

Week

Week

1-4

1-4

1-4

Week 3

MAR

APR

MAY
P315,000

P150,000

Phase 2: Attitude
Launch Party of MatchMaking
interface on official website

Week

P200,000

83

Daily Blog Post: Highlight Tools

Week

Week

Week

1-4

1-4

1-4

Week

Week

Week

1-4

1-4

Direct mailing: Newsletter and

Week

Week

Week

Infographics

3-4

1 -4

1-4

Social Media Post: The Perfect


Match (Brand Ambassadors)

P210,000

P175,000

Phase 3: Know

Launch Party of Growth Groups

P190,000

Week

P250,000

1
Growth Groups: Series One

Growth Groups: Series Two

Week

Week

2-4

1-2

P80,000

Week

Week

2-4

1-3

P100,000

Phase 4: Buy
Launch Business Handbook

Week

P20,000

3
Launch EasyBiz App

Week

P95,000

3
Launch Training Camp Sessions

Week

P12,000

84

4
Training Sessions

Week

P80,000

1-4
Table 32. Media Strategy and Budget for Potential Clients
10. Creative Execution
Phase One: Awareness
1)

Billboard Placement
Billboards will be placed in the following areas:
SLEX
President Osmena Highway
Ortigas Ave
2) EasyBiz: The Digital Bazaar
PLDT SME Nation will organize an event for people to witness Philippines first
augmented reality bazaar. All will gather at the World Trade Center thinking that
this will be an ordinary bazaar. However, upon entering the venue, there are no
products displayed at the stands. Instead, attendees are given tablets that they
can hold up to areas around the venue to see what kinds of products are
available. If they purchase, the product will be sent to the venues receiving area
via parachute.

Phase Two: Attitude


1) Daily Blog Posts: Highlight Tools
A blog page will be embedded in the current website of PLDT SME Nation to
highlight their different business tools every day. The business tools that will be
85

highlighted will vary on the category per week. Per blog post, the feature of the
PLDT SME Nation business tool will emphasize on the benefits of using it and
enumerate the different operations where it can be applied.
2) Social Media Posts: The Perfect Match (Brand Ambassadors)
A series of social media posts will be launched on PLDT SME Nations social
media sites. These posts will feature a brand ambassador per post, giving a short
testimony about the perfect PLDT SME Nation business tool that matched with
their business needs.
3) BizKit - Online MatchMaking Interface For SMEs and Business Tools
Process:
1. Go To smenation.com.ph
2. Click Find Me My BizKit
3. Enter your company details:
a. Company Name
b. Size (micro, small, medium)
c. Industry
d. Type of Business
e. Contact name
f. E-mail address
g. Contact number
4. Identify needs of your company (check all that apply):
a. I need to manage my data
b. I need to prevent pilferage

86

c. I need connectivity in my area


d. I need to track my vehicles
e. I need to be on-the-go
f. I need to make a website
g. Other needs
5.

Show all possible business tools available to address your


need(s)

6.

Hover on the photos of each business tool to learn more about


how it works.

7.

(Optional) Watch video on how to use it and its features

8.

To create BizKit, check box above tools you are interested in

9.

Click Create BizKit and send details about it to your email as well as PLDT

SME Nation consultant


10.

A PLDT SME Nation consultant will contact you via call and e-mail

to

discuss your BizKit further


Phase Three: Know
1) Direct Mailing: Newsletter and Infographics
2) Growth Groups - Dinner & Discussion (will provide visuals upon approval)
Entrepreneurs will be invited to casual discussion groups and workshops geared
towards bolstering the growth of their businesses over dinner. Moderated by
established business owners or institution representatives (AFFI/PFA), the event
will allow entrepreneurs to develop connections and gain support as their

87

businesses grow. These events aim to give businesses more understanding on how
improve their businesses with by using user-friendly business tools.
Series 1 - Year One Blues
Discusses the challenges faced when starting the business. Established
business owners can advise aspiring entrepreneurs and start-ups on how to aim
for success.
Series 2 - Harnessing Growth
Discusses how to properly prepare all stakeholders of the business with
inevitable changes. Emphasizes the advantages of using business tools in order
to solve problems hindering the growth of a business.
Phase Four: Buy
1) EasyBiz App
Develop an interactive app that will help business owners identify the companys
goals and work towards them. Syncing with the other stakeholders of the business,
the app eases communication between employees as well as information and goal
management. Included in the app will be the digital handbook that provides guidance
for common business problems and suggestions on what business tools to use
depending on problem at hand.
2) Training Sessions
After purchasing business tools, PLDT SME Nation representatives
will visit clients upon teach and monitor employees on how to use
the business tools purchased. There will be three sessions:
orienting, progress reporting, and refining.

88

B. FOR EXISTING CLIENTS


1. Statement of General Objectives
To strengthen relationships with current clients; To increase their intention to
upgrade their use of PLDT SME Nation business tools and increase trial for other
available PLDT SME Nation's business tools.
2. Creative Strategy
To persuade existing clients that PLDT SME Nation's business tools bring
benefits that will complement the growth of their success by highlighting the advantages
and functionality of an effective system of PLDT SME Nations business tools.
3. Personification
To personify our target market, we introduce Aya Santillan. She is a managing
partner in a water purifying business. She is 32 years old and has a family with three
children. Along with 2 other partners, they own a medium enterprise that has been
operating for 5 years. Their business is already a client of PLDT SME Nation, as they
have been using products that equip them with data management and security
surveillance. Since they started using such business tools, she realized how beneficial
PLDT SME Nations products are to their success. Nevertheless, as managing partner,
Aya constantly looks for ways to improve their business operations to maximize time
and productivity. She routinely assesses the needs of their business and she is open to
trying out new business tools that will help their company bolster their growth. Aya is
goal-oriented and she makes sure that their business decisions will always lead to
results that benefit them.
4. Consumer Promise, Brand identity, and Tone of Advertising

89

PLDT SME Nation promises benefits. It promises managers/owners that


upgrading their use of business tools to a system of PLDT SME Nation business tools
would be advantageous for their company. It promises that managers/owners can rely
on PLDT SME Nation. The brand will strive to foster a nation of MSMEs united by the
goal of succeeding in todays disruptive digital culture. For the tone of advertising, PLDT
SME Nation will embody a friendly, pro-active and empowering personality that aims to
help develop MSMEs further by working with them together towards their growth. To aid
MSMEs further, PLDT SME Nations tone will have a conversational approach that will
develop the existing relationship between PLDT SME Nation and MSMEs.
5. Consumer Insights and Findings
Table 33 presents the significant relationship of constructs for existing clients:

UBT*ATB -> Intent2

Path Coefficient

p-value

.253

.002

Table 33. Significant relationship of constructs for existing clients

Table 34 presents existing clients attitude towards behavior:


Mean Interpretation
Retaining/upgrading the use of business tools in our

5.55

company within 6 months would be beneficial


Retaining/Upgrading the use of business tools for our

Moderately
Agree

5.40

Slightly Agree

company within 6 months would be wise

90

Retaining/Upgrading the use of business tools for our

5.35

company within 6 months would be advantageous


Overall

Slightly Agree
5.43

Slightly Agree

Table 34. Existing clients attitude towards behavior

Table 35 presents existing clients utilitarian brand trust:


Mean Interpretation
PLDT SME Nation is a reliable brand

4.88

Slightly Agree

PLDT SME Nation is an effective brand

4.93

Slightly Agree

PLDT SME Nation is a valuable brand

4.88

Slightly Agree

4.89

Slightly Agree

Overall

Table 35. Existing clients utilitarian brand trust.

Table 36 presents existing clients intention to avail PLDT branded business


tools:
Mean Interpretation
Our company strongly intends to retain/upgrade the

4.96

use of PLDT SME Nation business tools within the


next 6 months

Slightly Agree

91

Our Company has certain plants to retain/upgrade the

4.99

use of PLDT SME Nation business tools within the


next 6 months

Slightly Agree

Our company has strong commitment of

5.04

retaining/upgrading PLDT SME Nation business tools


within the next 6 months
Overall

Slightly Agree
5.00

Slightly Agree

Table 36. Existing clients intention to avail PLDT branded business tools

Based on the significant results of our data analysis, the variable that existing
clients of PLDT SME Nation consider the most in retaining or upgrading their business
tools is their attitude towards it. They believe that retaining or upgrading the use of
business tools will be beneficial and advantageous for their company, which inclines
them to the decision of doing so. In terms of brand trust towards PLDT SME Nation,
they agree that the brand is a reliable and effective one based on their experiences
since they already use products of the brand. They believe that the brand is valuable to
an extent, which has given them a utilitarian brand trust towards the PLDT SME Nation.
When asked about retaining or upgrading PLDT SME Nation business tools, the overall
results show that they are only slightly inclined towards that decision.

92

Understanding:
Existing clients are highly influenced with their attitude towards retaining or
upgrading the use of business tools in their company and that they will choose a brand
that they approve to be effective and reliable to provide them further with business tools.
6. Big Idea
Benefit from an effective system of business tools that grow as you grow.
7. Key communication message
Better success together.
8. Integrated Marketing Campaign
Table 37 presents the integrated marketing campaign for existing clients. Refer to
appendix 5 for the collaterals.
Action
Chain
Step

Desired
Behavior

Awareness Recognize

Attitude

Appreciate

Call To
Action

Benefit

Motivating
Principles

Message Channel

Creative

Realize
availabilit
y having
a system
of
business
tools

Prepare
for the
growth
of your
compan
y

Liking

You can
continue
the
SME
growth of Celebrati
your
on
business
a resultoriented Branded
system of Content
business
Video
tools

The focus
will be
recognizing
advantages
of using
PLDT SME
Nation
business
tools in all
aspects of
daily
operations

Social
Validation

Imagine a
Media
more
Placeme
productiv
nts
e
company
Digital
as you
posters
grow with (Brand

The focus
will be
identifying
areas of
their
business
that can be

Imagine
Maximi
an
ze your
effective compan
system of
ys
business producti
tools
vity as
you

93

grow

Know

Buy

Understan
d

Upgrade

Find out
how to
optimize
the use of
certain
business
tools

Utilize an
innovativ
e system
of
business
tools

Becom
ea
market
and
brand
leader

an effect
system of
PLDT
SME
Nations
business
tools
Authority

Direct Consistency
your
compan
y to
take a
step
further
in
reachin
g its full
potentia
l

Become
a market
leader by
learning
about the
optimal
use of
business
tools.

Upgrade
your
business
tool to a
business
system
that will
help your
company
achieve
its full
potential.

Ambass
adors)
Activatio
n/
Product
Expo

Direct
Mailing
Digital
ads
Seminar
s&
Events
(Game
Night)
Direct
Mailing
Infograp
hics of
how to
upgrade
with
PLDT
SME
Nation
and
benefits

improved
with other
PLDT SME
Nation
business
tools.
The focus
will be
conditioning
the
company to
become a
technologic
ally
equipped
enterprise

The focus
will be
empowering
business
owners to
exceed
expectation
s in their
industry

Table 37. Integrated marketing campaign for existing clients

94

9. Media strategy and budget


Better Success Together

Duration

Cost

Campaign
Phase 1: Awareness

APR

MAY

JUN

Billboard Placement

Week

Week

Week

1-4

1-4

1-4

SME Celebration

JUL

AUG

SEP
P300,000

Week

P100,000

2
Phase 2: Attitude
Digital Posters: (Brand

Week

Week

Wee

Ambassadors)

1-4

1-4

k 1-4

Branded Content Videos:

Week

Week

Wee

Behind-The-Scenes of a

2-4

1-4

k 1-4

P480,000

P520,000

Business
Media

Week

Week

Week

Partnerships:Collaboration

P60,000

Brings Success
Phase 3: Know
Direct Mailing: Highlight Tools

Week

Wee

Week

P280,000

95

That Create Best Systems

2-4

Launch of Success Classes

k 1-4

1-4

Wee

P100,000

k1
Success Class: Series One

Wee

Week

k 2-4

1-2

Success Class: Series Two

P80,000

Week

Week

3-4

1-2

P70,000

Phase 4: Buy
Launch of New Features for

Week

EasyBiz App

3-4

Loyalty Promotions

Wee

Week

Week

k 3-4

3-4

3-4

P12,000

P75,000

Table 38. Media strategy and budget for existing clients


10. Creative Execution
Phase One: Awareness
1) Billboard Placement
Billboards will be placed in the following areas:
SLEX
President Osmena Highway
Ortigas Ave
2) SME Celebration
96

PLDT SME Nation will hold an event for their existing clients to celebrate their
companys milestones since they started using PLDT SME Nation business tools.
There will be different categories such as Digital Enterprise, Big Money Makers,
etc. and there will be a minimum of 5 existing clients to be awarded of these
titles. Some of the awarded existing clients will give a testimony about how PLDT
SME Nation has helped them in achieving their milestones. The event will be
held at MOA SMX Convention center. Certificates of appreciation will be given to
all of the invited existing clients.
Phase Two: Attitude
1) Digital Posters: (Brand Ambassadors)
This will be a series of short testimonials from Brand Ambassadors on how
systems of business tools have improved their way of business and helped them
adjust to their growth.
2) Branded Content Video: Behind-The-Scenes of a Business
Existing clients who use more than 2 business tools of PLDT SME Nation will
show just how they operate, touching upon the business tools they use and how
it helps them. Focus will be more on creation of service/product that the business
is known more and how this
3) Media Partnerships: Collaboration Brings Success
This will be a series of interviews of existing clients published in online news
sources. The interview will focus on how they keep their company successful and
adjust to their growth through collaboration and systems of business tools.
Phase Three: Know

97

1) Direct Mailing: Highlight Tools That Create Best Systems


Every week, PLDT SME Nation will send emails to their existing clients that
contain a newsletter and infographics that highlights a set of PLDT SME Nation
business tools that work best when used together. The newsletter series will be
entitled Perfect Systems and will highlight a set of business tools perfect for a
specific industry per week. The infographics will contain information on how the
set of tools are perfect for collaboration and how they can yield better results as a
system.
2) Launch of Success Classes
Existing clients will be invited to send representatives to Success Classes to gain
technical knowledge and skills that to use and troubleshoot the business tools.
Series 2: Optimization
This will give employees of existing clients the tips and tricks to optimize their
use of the business tools and create a perfect system that will maximize their
companys growth and productivity.
Phase Four: Buy
1) Launch of New Feature for EasyBiz App
One new feature will be available for the EasyBiz:
Direct Customer Service Messaging:
The app will release a customer service bot that will help customers
troubleshoot and fix problems they are facing with their systems. This
created a quick and direct access for solving any technical problems.

98

Through this, customers can also adjust settings on their business tools
with ease.
2) Loyalty Promotions
For those who have use PLDT SME Nations business tools for more than
1 year, a discounted business system upgrade will be available at the
renewal of subscription.

99

REFERENCES
Ahmed, S., Chandio, Z., & Qureshi, M. (2015). Brand trust, customer satisfaction,
and brand loyalty - a cross examination. Journal of Business Strategies, 9, 63-82
Ajzen, I. (2006). Constructing a TpB Questionnaire: Conceptual and
Methodological Considerations. Retrieved June 27, 2011 from the World Wide Web:
http://www.people.umass.edu/aizen/pdf/tpb.measurement.pdf
Ajzen I. (1991). The theory of planned behavior. Organizational Behavior and
Human Decision Processes, 50, 179-211.
Batra, Rajeev and O. Ahtola (1991), Measuring the Hedonic and Utilitarian
Sources of Consumer Attitudes, Marketing Letters, 2 (2), 159-70.
Bidmon, S., Grabner-Krauter, S., & Matzler, K. (2006). The value - brand trust brand loyalty chain: An analysis of some moderating variables. Innovative Marketing, 2,
76-88
Casper, E. S. (2007). The theory of planned behavior applied to continuing
education for mental health professionals. Psychiatric Services, 58(10), 1324-9.
Retrieved from http://0search.proquest.com.lib1000.dlsu.edu.ph/docview/213079279?accountid=28547
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.).
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Earlbaum Associates.

100

Chinomona, R., Mahlangu, D., & Pooe, D. (2013). Brand service quality, trust,
and preference as predictors of consumer brand loyalty in the retailing industry.
Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 4-14,
Delgado-Ballester, E. (2002). Applicability of a brand trust scale across product
categories: A multigroup invariance analysis. European Journal of Marketing, 38, 573592
Delgado-Ballester, E. & Munuera-Aleman, J. (1999). Brand trust in the context of
consumer loyalty. European Journal of Marketing, 35-11/12,
Deari, H. & Balla, E. (2013). Consumers trust in the global brands: Empirical
analysis in the context of consumer perspective. European Scientific Journal, 9-1
Fornell, C., and Bookstein, F. L. (1982). Two structural equation models: LISREL
and PLS appliead to consumer exit-voice theory. Journal of Marketing Research, 19,
440452
Fornell, C., Larcker, D.F., (1981). Evaluating structural equation models with
unobservable variables and measurement error. Journal of Marketing Research 18 (1),
39-50.
Francis, J., Eccles, M. P., Johnston, M., Walker, A. E., Grimshaw, J. M., Foy, R.,
Kaner, E. F. S., Smith, L. & Bonetti, D. (2004). Constructing questionnaires based on
the theory of planned behaviour: A manual for health services researchers. Newcastle
upon Tyne, UK: Centre for Health Services Research, University of Newcastle upon
Tyne.

101

Grandon, E. E. (2005). Extension and Validation of The Theory of Planned


Behavior: The Case of Electronic Commerce Adoption in Small and Medium Sized
Businesses (Doctoral dissertation, Southern Illinois University) [Abstract]. Retrieved July
6, 2016, from ProQuest Information and Learning Company. (UMI No. 3195314)
Jrg Henseler, Christian M. Ringle, Rudolf R. Sinkovices (2009), The use of
partial least squares path modeling in international marketing, in Rudolf R. Sinkovics,
Pervez
Kock, N. (2013). Using WarpPLS in e-collaboration studies: What if I have only
one group and one condition? International Journal of e-Collaboration, 9(3), 1-12.
Kock, N. (2015b). WarpPLS 5.0 User Manual. Laredo, TX: ScriptWarp Systems.
van Ryn, M., & Vinokur, A. D. (1990). The role of experimentally manipulated
self-efficacy in determining job-search behavior among the unemployed. Unpublished
manuscript, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan at Ann Arbor.
Locke, E. A., Fredrick, E., Lee, C., & Bobko, P. (1984). Effect of self-efficacy,
goals, and task strategies on task performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69, 241251.
Liao, Y. (2015). The role of trust on brand loyalty and brand equity. Nanhua
University, Taiwan. Joint International Conference 2015

102

Mattingly, M. J. (2012). THE MODERATING ROLE OF SELF-CONSTRUAL ON


THE THEORY OF PLANNED BEHAVIOR (Doctoral dissertation, Saint Louis University)
[Abstract]. Retrieved July 6, 2016, from ProQuest LLC. (UMI No. 3553149)
N. Ghauri (ed.) New Challenges to International Marketing (Advances in
International Marketing, Volume 20) Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp.277 319
Nunnally, J. C. (1978). Psychometric theory (2nd ed.). New York, NY: McGrawHill.
Nunnally, J. C., & Bernstein, I. H. (1994) Psychometric theory (3rd ed.). New
York, NY: McGraw-Hill, Inc.
P. A. M. Lange, A. W. Kruglanski & E. T. Higgins (2012) (Eds.), Handbook of
theories of social psychology (Vol. 1, pp. 438-459). London, UK: Sage.
Stangor, C. (n.d.). Correlational Research: Seeking Relationships Among
Variables. Retrieved August 6, 2016, from
http://catalogI.flatworldknowledge.com/bookhub/127?e=stangor-ch02_s02
Statistics Primer. (2011). Retrieved August 06, 2016, from
http://www.mhhe.com/socscience/intro/cafe/common/stat/index04.mhtml
Tenenhaus, M. (2008a). Component-based structural equation modelling. Total
Quality Management & Business Excellence, 19, 871886.

103

V. Esposito Vinzi et al. (eds.), Handbook of Partial Least Squares, Springer


Handbooks of Computational Statistics, DOI 10.1007/978-3-540-32827-8 3,

104

APPENDICES
Appendix 1: Survey Questionnaire for Potential Clients

105

106

107

Appendix 2: Survey Questionnaire for Existing Clients

108

109

110

Appendix 3: Survey (All Respondents)


a) All Respondents

111

112

113

Appendix 4: Potential Clients IMC Collaterals

114

115

116

117

Appendix 5: Existing Clients IMC Collaterals

118

119

120

121

122

Você também pode gostar