Coating Thickness Measurement: The Fundament...

ARTICLES
EXPERTS

EVENTS

PROCESS ZONES

http://www.pfonline.com/articles/coating-thickne...

SUPPLIERS

PRODUCTS

Newsletter

Subscribe

Advertise

Contact Us

RESOURCES

Coating Thickness Measurement: The

Fundamentals
Article From: Products Finishing, Paul Lomax, Director of Marketing from Fischer
50
Technology, Inc.
Posted on: 2/1/2006

A review of available test methods, common applications and innovative

instrumentation...
CLICK IMAGE TO ENLARGE (+)

The Coulometric Method

Coating thickness measurement is a concern for

both finishers and for companies receiving
finished components. Defective coatings lead to
rust. As a result, product liability requires quality
control of coatings, and in many cases
documentation of measurements in an electronic
format. Conflicts can occur if a manufacturer and
a customer of a finished good use different
methods or types of instruments to determine
coating thickness. This article will discuss the test
methods available for determining coating
thickness, common applications, and innovations
in coating thickness instrumentation.

The Magnetic Induction Method

The Eddy Current Method

A unit measuring powder coating

using the magnetic induction
method
Test Methods
The magnetic induction method measures non-magnetic coatings over ferrous
substrates and magnetic coatings over non-magnetic substrates. The process is direct,
in that a probe is placed on the part to be measured. When the probe is positioned, the
linear distance between the probe tip that contacts the surface and the base substrate is
measured.
Inside the measurement probe is a coil that generates a changing magnetic field. When
the probe is placed on the substrate, the magnetic flux density of this field is altered.

1 of 5

Wednesday 13 July 2016 10:25 AM

Coating Thickness Measurement: The Fundament...

http://www.pfonline.com/articles/coating-thickne...

The change in magnetic inductance is measured by a secondary coil. The output of the
secondary coil is transferred to a microprocessor where it is viewed as a coating
thickness measurement on a digital display.
The magnetic induction method is quick and can be used with either a bench-top or
hand-held coating thickness gage. Its also non-destructive, relatively low-cost, easy to
operate, accurate and repeatable, and measurements are instantaneous with a digital
display.
Common applications for this test method include liquid or powder coatings, as well as
plated finishes such as chrome, zinc, cadmium or phosphate over steel or iron
substrates.
The eddy-current method of coating thickness measurement measures non-conductive
coatings on non-ferrous conductive substrates, non-ferrous conductive coatings on
non-conductive substrates and some non-ferrous metal coatings on non-ferrous metals.
It is very similar to the magnetic induction method and can even use many of the same
probe designs. Advantages of the eddy-current method are also very similar to those of
magnetic induction, including low cost, ease of operation, accuracy and repeatability
and instantaneous measurement with a digital display.
Eddy-current coating thickness measurement uses a probe that also contains a coil.
This probe/coil is driven by a high-frequency oscillator to generate an alternating
high-frequency field. When this field is brought near a metallic conductor, eddy currents
are generated in that conductive material, which results in the impedance change of the
probe coil.
The distance between the probe coil and the conductive substrate material determines
the amount of impedance change. Therefore, coating thickness is determined by the
impedance change in the form of a digital reading.
Common applications for eddy-current coating thickness measurement include liquid or
powder coating over aluminum and non-magnetic stainless steel as well as anodize
over aluminum.
Selecting A Gage
Many instruments available today combine both magnetic induction and eddy-current
methods. This allows the user to perform multiple measurement tasks without switching
gages. Users also can choose between basic gages that just provide a value on the
digital display or gages that store measurements and provide statistical information such
as average, standard deviation and high/low values.
Another important selection criterion is based on the shape of the part to be measured.
Not all parts can be measured using a gage with a built-in probe. Units that offer a probe
on a cable provide more flexibility when it comes to multiple part configurations. Many
units with separate probes also offer the ability to exchange probes should the
application change; for example, measuring coating thickness on the inner diameter of a
tube may require a 90-degree probe, while measurements on a flat surface are best
performed with a zero-degree probe. Factors such as curvature, edge effect, surface
roughness, substrate thickness, permeability and conductivity all influence coating
thickness measurement but can be accounted for through proper calibration.
As previously mentioned, the ability to store measurements for later documentation and
report generation is often very important. These types of reports can help to determine
spray patterns, for example, or may also be used for incoming inspection of parts. Some
gages feature an on-board radio transmitter that allows users to send readings in real
time to a computer up to 60 ft away from where the measurements are being taken.
Data can be input directly into a statistical process control program, eliminating the need
to key in data to save time and eliminate input errors.
Another option for coating thickness measurement and data documentation is a
bench-top system. Bench-top systems provide a large digital display with full statistical
evaluation of measurements. This includes mean value, standard deviation, coefficient
of variation, maximum and minimum, number of measurements, statistics of single
readings or groups; calculation of process capability factors; histograms; probability
charts with test for normal distribution; automatic grouping after N measurements and/or
automatic final evaluation after N groups; and group evaluation according to group
numbers or group identifications. Some bench-top systems even provide customerspecific print form templates.
In addition to documentation benefits, some bench-top systems can combine multiple
test methods into one measuring system. A single unit combining multiple test methods

2 of 5

Wednesday 13 July 2016 10:25 AM

Coating Thickness Measurement: The Fundament...

http://www.pfonline.com/articles/coating-thickne...

benefits companies that perhaps might be plating parts as well as painting in another
department, for example. Such systems also use separate probes, meaning they have
wider application than built-in coating thickness gages.
Special Applications
Not all coating thickness applications are as straight-forward as measuring paint over
steel. Coatings consisting of a paint applied to galvanized sheet steel are sometimes
called duplex coatings, and are frequently used in the automotive industry. Thickness of
the individual layers of both the paint and galvanize are important. In automotive vehicle
body manufacturing zinc thicknesses are between zero and 10 m. Paint thicknesses
are usually up to 150 m.
The galvanize coating is applied by the sheet metal supplier either by hot-dip
galvanizing or by electrogalvanizing. If the zinc coating thickness were uniform, the
thickness of the subsequently applied paint coating could be measured using a
conventional magnetic induction coating thickness measurement instrument. One would
simply have to deduct a constant value from the actual reading.
However, zinc thickness changes when the sheet is formed. During forming, flowing or
even scraping off of the zinc coating may occur in areas of severe bending. This may
vary its thickness by between 3 and 9 m, and occasionally remove the coating
altogether.
Similar situations may be encountered when repairing a body area that has coating
defects due to sanding and subsequent re-painting of the defective area. In this case,
the zinc coating may be sanded away as well, leading to an apparent reduction in the
paint thickness if a conventional coating thickness measurement system is used. This is
not only problematic for inspection, but also critical to the quality of a cataphoretic paint,
because that thickness is typically only about 20 m. An error of 5-6 m in the thickness
measurement through a reduced zinc coating will exceed the tolerance limits.
Our companys Phascope PMP10 Duplex instrument, for example, can measure paint
thickness independent of zinc thickness. Repeatability precision of the zinc thickness
measurement is as low as a few tens of nanometers; that of the paint thickness
measurement is below 0.5 m.
To reduce vehicle weight, some automakers are using increasing amounts of aluminum
sheet in non-safety-relevant body components. Measuring coating thickness over an
aluminum alloy substrate can be accomplished using a conventional eddy current
channel to measure the paint thickness according to a standard. With no human
intervention (the operator may not even know whether parts are made of steel or
aluminum), the instrument automatically selects duplex or eddy-current method
immediately after the probe touches down and stores that paint thickness data in such a
way that a simple evaluation of paint distribution is possible regardless of the type of
sheet metal.
Other Thickness Measurement Techniques
There are other methods for measuring coating thickness, especially in automotive
applications. These include the Coulometric, beta backscatter, and X-ray fluorescence
techniques.
The Coulometric method has many important functions, such as measuring duplex
nickel coatings in automotive applications. The technique involves determining the
weight of an area of a metallic coating through localized anodic stripping of the coating,
the calculating thickness based on mass per unit area.
Thickness measurement is made using an electrolysis cell, which is filled with an
electrolyte specifically selected for stripping the particular coating. Constant current runs
through the test cell to deplate the coating material, which serves as the anode. With
current density and surface area being constant, coating thickness is proportional to the
time it takes to strip the coating.
This method is particularly useful for measuring electrically conductive coatings on a
conductive substrate.
The beta backscatter method begins when a test sample is exposed to beta particles
from a beta-emitting isotope. A beam of beta particles is directed through an aperture
onto the coated component, and a portion of these particles is backscattered from the
coating through the aperture to penetrate a very thin window of a Geiger Muller (GM)
tube. The gas of the GM tube ionizes, causing a momentary discharge across the tube
electrodes. The discharge in the form of a pulse is counted by an electronic counter,
which is then translated into coating thickness.

3 of 5

Wednesday 13 July 2016 10:25 AM

Coating Thickness Measurement: The Fundament...

http://www.pfonline.com/articles/coating-thickne...

Materials of relatively low atomic number backscatter the beta particles at a significantly
lower rate than materials of high atomic number. For example, a component with copper
as a substrate and a gold coating 40 micro-inches thick, beta particles are scattered by
both the substrate and the coating material. If coating thickness increases, the
backscatter rate increases. The change in the rate of particles scattered is therefore a
measure of coating thickness.
The technique is applicable when the atomic number of the coating and substrate differ
by 20%. Applications include thickness measurement of gold, silver, and tin on
electronic components, coatings on cutting tools, decorative plating on plumbing
fixtures, and vapor-deposited coatings on electronic components, ceramics and glass.
Other applications could include organic coatings such as oil or lubricant coatings over
metals.
X-ray fluorescence (XRF) is a versatile, non-contact, coating thickness measurement
method for very thin multi-layer alloy coatings on small parts.
Measurement is performed by exposing the part to X-radiation. A collimator focuses the
X-rays onto an exactly defined area of the test specimen. This X-radiation causes
characteristic X-ray emission (fluorescence) from both the coating and the substrate
materials. This emission is detected with an energy-dispersive detector.
Using the appropriate electronics, it is possible to register only the emission from the
coating material or from the substrate. It is also possible to selectively detect a specific
coating when intermediate layers are present. Common applications include printed
circuit boards, electronic components, jewelry, and optical components.
Acknowledgement
The author would like to acknowledge the work of a colleague, Peter Neumaier of
Helmut-Fischer GmbH & Co. KG (Sindelfingen, Germany) on the portion of this article
that covers measurement of paint thickness over galvanized coatings and over
aluminum substrates.
Comments are reviewed by moderators before they appear to ensure they meet Products
Finishings submission guidelines.

0 Comments
Recommend

Products Finishing

Share

Login

Sort by Best

Start the discussion

Subscribe

Add Disqus to your site Add Disqus Add

Privacy

You might also like:

Valence Surface
Technologies
Expands Capacity
And Approvals

Technic enters
agreement with
Otomec for wire,
strip, coil, bar, and
tube equipment

Plateco Earns
Columbia
Chemical's CAR
Certification

Chicago NASF
Midwest Chapter
Hosting
Sustainability
Summit

50

4 of 5

Wednesday 13 July 2016 10:25 AM

Coating Thickness Measurement: The Fundament...

http://www.pfonline.com/articles/coating-thickne...

The Voice of the Finishing Industry Since 1936 Copyright Gardner Business Media, Inc. 2016

5 of 5

Wednesday 13 July 2016 10:25 AM