Denver Journal - 6:0210 - Romans

Seite 1

Search

Home About Us
Contact Us

Academics

Admissions

Alumni & Friends

Giving

News & Events

Denver Journal
An Online Review of Current Biblical and Theological Studies.

Publications

Students

Volume 6 - 2003
Editor: Richard S. Hess

Talbert, Charles H. Romans. Smyth and Helwys Bible Commentary. Macon: Smyth and Helwys. 2002. xxii + 360 pp. $53.25.
Includes CD-ROM. ISBN 1-57312-081-2.
A significant new commentary series from Smyth and Helwys has produced two OT and two NT volumes as of this
writing. Commissioned authors appear to be largely from the breakaway "Cooperative Baptist Fellowship"-the group of
moderate scholars who were disenfranchised by the conservative takeover in the Southern Baptist Convention. C. H.
Talbert, of course, is widely known far beyond Baptist circles for a lifetime of scholarship and teaching at Wake Forest and,
in very recent years, at Baylor. The format of this commentary is designed to be very user-friendly: sidebars, pictures,
"Connections" sections after each segment of commentary reflecting on contemporary theological debates that emerge
from the text, and a CD-ROM with the entire text and hyper-links to all of the additional side-features found in the hard copy
form.
In recent years, Talbert's most well-known books have probably been his contributions to the "Reading the New
Testament" series-originally published by Crossroad and now taken over also by Smyth and Helwys. Like those volumes
(on Luke, John, Acts and Corinthians), Romans majors consistently on historical background-particularly via crossreferences to other ancient Jewish, Greek, Roman and Christian literature with relevant excerpts quoted-and literary
structure-with frequent appeal to chiasmus, sometimes convincingly but often not.
The introduction produces few controversies: Paul is writing to a predominantly Gentile congregation in Rome ca.
A.D. 56 to prepare the way for a hoped for visit, setting out his understanding of the gospel in detail to a church he did not
found, hoping to unify Jewish and Gentile members especially in light of the return of the former after the end of the
banishment under Claudius. Talbert does surprise, however, with respect to the elements of the "new look on Paul" that he
does and does not embrace. Despite recognizing the diversity within the Judaism of Paul's day, Talbert argues vigorously
for a very traditional form of Reformation Christianity-a pervasive merit theology against which Paul is reacting, especially in
light of his own agonizing wrestling with his inability to keep the Law as a Jew (7:14-25). On the other hand, Talbert rejects
Reformation and particularly Lutheran emphases, by seeing the "righteousness of God" as God's covenant faithfulness
(with issues of imputation to believers very subordinate) and by rendering the controversial pistis Iesou (or Christou) as a
subjective genitive-the faithfulness Jesus exhibited-rather than objective (our faith in Christ). It is arguable that Talbert has
picked the wrong parts of both the "old look" and the "new look" to embrace.
Numerous other exegetical emphases, however, seem solidly defended. There is a general revelation but not a
natural theology taught in chapter 1. The Scriptures resolutely and consistently condemn homosexual practice (and
churches that deny this can no longer be considered "apostolic"--p. 77). Judgment by works only condemns; it never saves.
Neither "propitiation" nor "expiation" captures the sense of hilasterion in chapter 3 as well as the concept of "the new locus
of the divine presence" (p. 115). Suffering is not automatically abusive-for God's Son or for us his children, despite key
feminist claims to the contrary. The real dividing point in chapters 3-8 may be neither at the beginning nor at the end of
chapter 5 but at 5:11/12. The tension between divine sovereignty and human responsibility with respect to both
predestination and perseverance must be allowed to stand, since Paul affirms both simultaneously and repeatedly.
The current hostility to Christianity by most Jews will one day give way to a widespread outpouring of faith in Jesus as
Messiah, but this is not tied in to their living in the land of Israel. Christian reflection on events there must seek peace and
justice for all parties without privileging any of them. But not to evangelize the Jews would be anti-Semitic, uniquely
condemning them by our silence. The sequence in the exhortational material of using gifts in love mirrors 1 Corinthians 1213 and is thus probably deliberate. Love is the unifying theme by way of inclusio of much of the disparate parenetic material
in Romans 12-13. Numerous textual features relativize the submission to government enjoined in 13:1-7. A key to
reproducing the tolerance of chaps. 14-15 in today's world is the Baptist emphasis on liberty of conscience-we can respect
others' differing convictions or even world views without preventing them or us from sharing those views with one another in
polite attempts to persuade one another. The number and prominence of roles for women in chap. 16 is both striking and
significant for current application.
There are a surprising number of typos in what is otherwise a very attractively formatted volume. "Genetive" should be
"genitive" (p. 45); "mades" should be "made" (p. 55); "ECNT" should be "BECNT" (p. 144, n.7); "missionzary" should be

http://www.denverseminary.edu/dj/articles2003/0200/0210

08.03.2007 21:12:34

Denver Journal - 6:0210 - Romans

Seite 2

"missionary" (p. 196; footnotes 13-21 are misnumbered on p. 237, with n. 21 having metathesized into n. 12; "supersede"
and cognates are misspelled seven times on pp. 244, 270-71; "Shreiner" should be "Schreiner" (p. 254); there are two "(4)'s"
on p. 272, throwing the rest of the enumeration off; p. 276, n. 32 reads "Kolchba" instead of "Kochba"; n. 33 has "see"
instead of "sees"; p. 282 is missing an entire "or-clause"; p. 286 has "than" for "that" and p. 309, n. 12 has "Downer's" for
"Downers."
Nevertheless, this book is well worth reading, though perhaps not purchasing at the extravagant price at which it is
offered, especially since the CD reproduces exactly what is in the text and nothing more. For a quick, convenient
introduction to the thought of Romans, but one nevertheless immersed in the most recent scholarship, Talbert can prove
very handy.
Craig L. Blomberg
Distinguished Professor of New Testament
Denver Seminary

Denver Journal Home

Copyright 1997-2006 Denver Seminary. 6399 South Santa Fe Drive, Littleton, CO, 80120. 303.761.2482 or 800.922.3040. info@denverseminary.edu

http://www.denverseminary.edu/dj/articles2003/0200/0210

08.03.2007 21:12:34