Fdswxor 5

Hvwlpdr Hvwwlfd gh Hvwdgrv hp

Vlvwhpdv gh Srwqfld
514

Lqwurgxr

D dydoldr gd vhjxudqd gd rshudr gh vlvwhpdv gh srwqfld ihlwd dwudyv gh gxdv

ixqhv evlfdv/ txh vr Prqlwrudr gd Vhjxudqd h Dqolvh gd Vhjxudqd1 R ghvhp0
shqkr ghvvdv ixqhv ghshqgh gd glvsrqlelolgdgh gh lqirupdhv frqyhlv d uhvshlwr gr
srqwr gh rshudr dwxdo gr vlvwhpd/ vhqgr sruwdqwr hvvhqfldo d dwxdol}dr hp whpsr
uhdo gr edqfr gh gdgrv gr vlvwhpd1 D ixqr hqfduuhjdgd gh ghvhpshqkdu hvwh sdsho d
Hvwlpdr gh Hvwdgrv hp Vlvwhpdv gh Srwqfld +HHVS,1
Hvwh fdswxor ghvfuhyh lqlfldophqwh d ixqr gd HHVS qd Rshudr hp Whpsr Uhdo
gh Vlvwhpdv gh Srwqfld h rv glyhuvrv vxe0sureohpdv txh d frpshp1 Hp vhjxlgd
dsuhvhqwdgd xpd fodvvlfdr grv hvwlpdgruhv gh hvwdgr vhjxqgr glyhuvdv shuvshfwlydv1
Vhjxh0vh r ghvhqyroylphqwr gr prghor gh phglr xwlol}dgr h d irupxodr gd HHVS
frpr xp sureohpd gh Pqlprv Txdgudgrv Srqghudgrv +PTS,1 Hperud r pwrgr PTS
vhmd vhp gylgd r pdlv xwlol}dgr qd vroxr gd HHVS/ hvwd qr d qlfd derugdjhp gr
sureohpd1 R fdswxor hqfhuud frp xpd euhyh ghvfulr gr pwrgr gr Pqlprv Ydoruhv
Devroxwrv Srqghudgrv +PYDS,/ txh vh frqvwlwxl hp xpd dowhuqdwlyd sdud d irupxodr
PTS1

515

D Hvwlpdr gh Hvwdgrv qd Rshudr hp Whpsr

Uhdo

D ixqr gd Hvwlpdr gh Hvwdgrv hp Vlvwhpdv gh Srwqfld iruqhfhu xpd edvh gh gdgrv

hp whpsr uhdo frqyho d sduwlu gh whohphglgdv uhgxqgdqwhv +jhudophqwh pdjqlwxgh gd
whqvr qdv eduudv/ lqmhhv gh srwqfld qdv eduudv/ x{rv gh srwqfld qdv olqkdv gh wudqv0
plvvr/ h hyhqwxdophqwh pdjqlwxgh gd fruuhqwh qdv olqkdv gh wudqvplvvr, h fruurpslgdv
sru huurv gh yuldv hvsflhv1 R hvwlpdgru gh hvwdgrv surfhvvd hvvdv phglgdv gh irupd
d hvwlpdu ydoruhv sdud d whqvr frpsoh{d hp wrgdv dv eduudv +frqvlghudgd r hvwdgr gr
vlvwhpd hp uhjlph shupdqhqwh,1 sduwlu grv hvwdgrv srvvyho ghwhuplqdu dv rxwudv
ydulyhlv + x{r gh srwqfld qdv olqkdv gh wudqvplvvr/ lqmhhv gh srwqfld qdv eduudv
hwf, qhfhvvuldv sdud d dqolvh h prqlwrudr gd vhjxudqd gr vlvwhpd1 Dop gdv whohph0
glgdv wrpdgdv dr orqjr gr vlvwhpd/ rxwudv txdqwlgdghv qr phglgdv gluhwdphqwh pdv txh
48

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

49

wdpep frqwp lqirupdhv uhohydqwhv vreuh r hvwdgr gr vlvwhpd srghp vhu surfhvvdgdv
shor hvwlpdgru1 Hvvdv txdqwlgdghv/ fxmrv ydoruhv srghp vhu hvwlpdgrv vhp d xwlol}dr gh
lqvwuxphqwrv gh phglr +lqmhhv gh srwqfld hp eduudv gh wudqvihuqfld/ sru h{hpsor,/
vr fkdpdgdv svhxgrphglgdv1
Ghqwuh dv sulqflsdlv dsolfdhv grv uhvxowdgrv iruqhflgrv shor hvwlpdgru gh hvwdgrv/ rv
vhjxlqwhv wuv vr gd pdlru uhohyqfld ^4`=
 Prqlwrudr gd Vhjxudqd/ fxmr remhwlyr revhuydu d frqglr fruuhqwh gh rshudr
gr vlvwhpd +qrupdo/ gh hphujqfld/ rx uhvwdxudwlyd,>
 Dqolvh gd Vhjxudqd/ fxmd ixqr dydoldu rv hihlwrv gh hyhqwxdlv frqwlqjqfldv qr
vlvwhpd>
 Suhylvr gh fdujd/ fxmr remhwlyr hvwlpdu d ghpdqgd ixwxud gdv eduudv gr vlvwhpd1

51514

Prqlwrudr gh Vlvwhpdv gh Srwqfld

Glihuhqwhv dowhuqdwlydv irudp sursrvwdv qr sdvvdgr sdud surfhvvdu gdgrv hp whpsr uhdo
d p gh prqlwrudu r vlvwhpd gh srwqfld1 Xpd gdv sulphludv whqwdwlydv frqvlvwld hp
vxshuylvlrqdu r vlvwhpd frp edvh qd phglr gh txdqwlgdghv gluhwdphqwh uhodflrqdgdv
v ydulyhlv frqvlghudgdv evlfdv gd uhgh howulfd h dvvrfldgdv d fhuwdv lqvwdodhv0fkdyh
gr vlvwhpd1 Hvwd suwlfd prvwurx0vh lqfrpsohwd dop gh hqwudu hp frq lwr frp r sodqh0
mdphqwr gr vlvwhpd gh srwqfld/ srlv qhvwhv hvwxgrv txdotxhu lqvwdodr srgh vh wruqdu
fkdyh/ ghshqghqgr gd frrughqdr gd rshudr1
Srvwhulruphqwh/ sursv0vh d xwlol}dr gluhwd grv gdgrv rulxqgrv gr vlvwhpd VFDGD
+Vlvwhpd Vxshuylvulr h gh Dtxlvlr gh Gdgrv,1 Hvwh surfhglphqwr wdpep irl frqvlgh0
udgr lqfrpsohwr srutxh dshqdv phglgdv euxwdv hudp dsuhvhqwdgdv dr rshudgru h/ dgl0
flrqdophqwh qr vr iruqhflgdv lqirupdhv vreuh ydulyhlv qr0prqlwrudgdv1
Vxjhulx0vh dlqgd r xvr gr Iox{r gh Srwqfld rq0olqh/ dshqdv frp phglgdv gh lqmhr
gh srwqfld h pdjqlwxgh gd whqvr1 Dshvdu gh vxshulru drv surfhglphqwrv ghvfulwrv
dqwhulruphqwh/ hvwd hvwudwjld dsuhvhqwdyd glyhuvdv olplwdhv1 D sulqflsdo ghodv txh dv
phglgdv xwlol}dgdv ghyhp vh uhvwulqjlu txhodv fxmd hvshflfdr uhtxhulgd qr sureohpd
gh x{r gh srwqfld/ lvwr lqmhhv gh srwqfld qdv eduudv gh fdujd h lqmhhv gh srwqfld
dwlyd h pdjqlwxgh gd whqvr qdv eduudv gh whqvr frqwurodgd1 Dop glvvr/ d shugd gh xpd
phglgd lpsolfd qd lpsrvvlelolgdgh gh vroxr/ h d suhvhqd gh xpd phglgd lqfruuhwd whp
xp lpsdfwr gluhwr qd txdolgdgh grv uhvxowdgrv1
Hvvdv ghflqfldv ohydudp dr ghvhqyroylphqwr gh phwrgrorjldv gh prqlwrudr gr
vlvwhpd gh srwqfld edvhdgdv qd hvwlpdr gh hvwdgrv/ txh shuplwh r surfhvvdphqwr gh
glyhuvrv wlsrv gh phglgdv h frqvlghud d h{lvwqfld grv huurv lqhuhqwhv phvpdv1 Dglflrqdo0
phqwh/ d uhgxqgqfld gdv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv srvvlelolwd hvwlpdu r hvwdgr gr vlvwhpd
phvpr txdqgr dojxpdv ghodv vr shuglgdv1 D h{whqvr grv uhvxowdgrv gd HHVS wruqd
srvvyho ghwhfwdu d suhvhqd gh huurv jurvvhlurv/ lghqwlfdu vxd orfdol}dr h ghwhuplqdu
txdqwlgdghv qr prqlwrudgdv1 Hvvdv fdudfwhuvwlfdv ghvwdfdp dv ydqwdjhqv ghvvh surfh0
glphqwr gh prqlwrudr hp uhodr v derugdjhqv uhihulgdv dqwhulruphqwh1

51515

Vxesureohpdv gd HHVS

Rv vhjxlqwhv vxesureohpdv hvwr dvvrfldgrv dr sureohpd gh Hvwlpdr gh Hvwdgrv hp

Vlvwhpdv gh Srwqfld=

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

4:

 Revhuydelolgdgh= vxesureohpd txh frqvlvwh hp yhulfdu vh r qphur h d orfdol}dr

gdv phglgdv d vhuhp surfhvvdgdv shor hvwlpdgru shuplwh d ghwhuplqdr gr hvwdgr
gr vlvwhpd>
 Hvwlpdr gh hvwdgrv= surfhvvr txh frqvlvwh qr fofxor gh hvwlpdwlydv sdud rv hvwd0
grv d sduwlu gr frqkhflphqwr gd hvwuxwxud h grv gdgrv gr vlvwhpd h gh whohphglgdv
wrpdgdv dr orqjr gr phvpr>
 Ghwhfr gh huurv jurvvhlurv= vxesureohpd txh wudwd gd yhulfdr gd h{lvwqfld gh
huurv hvwuxwxudlv h2rx phglgdv hvsuldv +lvwr / dtxhodv txh vr pdlv lpsuhflvdv gr
txh vxsrvwr qr prghor gh phglr,>
 Lghqwlfdr gh huurv jurvvhlurv= surfhglphqwr sdud vh ghwhuplqdu txdlv vr dv ph0
glgdv sruwdgrudv gh huurv jurvvhlurv/ rx txh sduwh gd wrsrorjld qr hvw fruuhwdphqwh
prghodgd>
 Uhfxshudr gh phglgdv sruwdgrudv gh huurv jurvvhlurv= surfhvvr txh frqvlvwh qr
wudwdphqwr gh phglgdv hvsuldv/ wdo txh hodv srvvdp vhu xwlol}dgdv qd hvwlpdr gh
hvwdgrv1
Dop ghvwhv/ rxwurv sureohpdv oljdgrv prghodjhp hp whpsr uhdo gh vlvwhpdv gh
srwqfld vr d Su0owudjhp gh phglgdv h r Frqjxudgru gd uhgh howulfd=
 Su0owudjhp= frqvlvwh qxp su0surfhvvdphqwr qr txdo dv phglgdv vr vxephwlgdv
d xpd vhohr wdo txh dtxhodv pdlv fodudphqwh sruwdgrudv gh huurv jurvvhlurv vr
ghvfduwdgdv>
 Frqjxudgru = ghwhuplqd xp prghor eduud0udpr sdud d uhgh howulfd d sduwlu gr
surfhvvdphqwr gdv srvlhv +vwdwxv, gh glvmxqwruhv h fkdyhv gh vxehvwdhv1
R hqfdghdphqwr gh wrgdv dv ixqhv dflpd hvw uhsuhvhqwdgr qd Ilj1 5141

51516

Fodvvlfdr grv Hvwlpdgruhv gh Hvwdgr

Dv sulqflsdlv glihuhqdv hqwuh rv pwrgrv gh hvwlpdr gh hvwdgrv vh ruljlqdp qrv vhjxlqwhv

srqwrv= d prghodjhp gr sureohpd gh HHVS/ d pdqhlud frpr rv gdgrv vr surfhvvdgrv h
r dojrulwpr xwlol}dgr sdud uhvroyhu r sureohpd irupxodgr1
D irupxodr dqdowlfd gr sureohpd gh HHVS pdlv xwlol}dgd edvhdgd qd plqlpl}dr
gd vrpd srqghudgd grv txdgudgrv grv uhvgxrv +hvwlpdgruhv gr wlsr pqlprv txdgudgrv
srqghudgrv/ PTS,1 Srup/ prghodjhqv dowhuqdwlydv edvhdgdv qd plqlpl}dr gd vrpd
grv ydoruhv devroxwrv grv uhvgxrv +hvwlpdgruhv gr wlsr pqlprv ydoruhv devroxwrv srq0
ghudgrv/ PYDS, wdpep vr hqfrqwudgdv qd olwhudwxud1
Txdqwr dr prgr gh surfhvvdu rv gdgrv/ rv hvwlpdgruhv gh hvwdgr srghp vhu gh grlv
wlsrv= edwfk/ qr txdo dv phglgdv glvsrqyhlv vr surfhvvdgdv vlpxowdqhdphqwh h vhthq0
fldlv/ qr txdo dv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv vr surfhvvdgdv xpd sru yh}1
R sureohpd gh pqlprv txdgudgrv srqghudgrv txh prghod d HHVS srgh vhu uhvroylgr
sru xpd ydulhgdgh gh dojrulwprv gh rwlpl}dr1 Hqwuhwdqwr/ ghylgr v fdudfwhuvwlfdv
sduwlfxoduhv ghvwh sureohpd/ r surfhvvr lwhudwlyr sdud d ghwhuplqdr gr hvwdgr hp jhudo
vh edvhld=

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

Iljxud 514= Ixqhv txh frpshp d Hvwlpdr gh Hvwdgrv1

4;

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

4<

 qd vroxr yld Htxdr Qrupdo +pwrgr fovvlfr,>

 qr xvr gh pwrgrv ruwrjrqdlv +uh h{hv gh Krxvhkroghu/ urwdhv gh Jlyhqv/ hwf,>
 qd dsolfdr gh pwrgrv keulgrv +idwrudr ruwrjrqdo frpelqdgd d vroxr gr vlv0
whpd olqhdu qr0ruwrjrqdo,>
 qd vroxr dwudyv gr pwrgr gh Kdfkwho +ghqrplqdgr dowhuqdwlydphqwh pwrgr gd
Pdwul} Dxphqwdgd rx gr Wdeohdx hvsduvr,>
 qd h{sorudr gr ghvdfrsodphqwr  B  'T +hvwlpdgruhv ghvdfrsodgrv,1
Rv hvwlpdgruhv vhthqfldlv/ sru vxd yh}/ iruqhfhp d vroxr gh xp sureohpd gh p0
qlprv txdgudgrv uhfxuvlyrv/ srghqgr vhu edvhdgrv qr Ilowur gh Ndopdq rx hp pwrgrv
ruwrjrqdlv edvhdgrv qdv urwdhv gh Jlyhqv1

516

R Prghor gh Phglr

Frqvlghuh xp vlvwhpd gh srwqfld frp  eduudv/ qr txdo 6 txdqwlgdghv vr phglgdv1

Vxsrqkd dlqgd/ txh d wrsrorjld h rv sduphwurv gd uhgh howulfd vr frqkhflgrv1 Vre hvwdv
frqglhv/ srvvyho ghwhuplqdu rv x{rv gh srwqfld hp txdotxhu olqkd gh wudqvplvvr
h2rx d lqmhr gh srwqfld hp txdotxhu eduud/ d sduwlu gr frqkhflphqwr gdv whqvhv
frpsoh{dv qdv eduudv gr vlvwhpd1 Hvwd d ud}r shod txdo dv whqvhv frpsoh{dv qdv
eduudv vr fkdpdgdv ydulyhlv gh hvwdgr gr vlvwhpd gh srwqfld1
R frqmxqwr gh 6 phglgdv wrpdgdv dr orqjr gd uhgh howulfd h rv huurv gh phglr
hvwr uhodflrqdgrv dwudyv gr vhjxlqwh prghor ^4`=
3 ' 3f n 

+514,

rqgh/ 3 r yhwru gh rughp E6   gdv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv +lvwr / pdjqlwxgh gd whqvr

qdv eduudv/ lqmhhv gh srwqfld dwlyd h uhdwlyd/ x{rv gh srwqfld dwlyd h uhdwlyd/ fruuhqwh
hwf,> 3f r yhwru gh rughp E6   frp rv ydoruhv yhugdghlurv gdv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv/ r
txdo ixqr gr hvwdgr yhugdghlur h  r yhwru gh rughp E6  dohdwulr txh prghod rv
huurv gh phglr +lpsuhflvr grv phglgruhv/ huurv gh wudqvirupdgruhv frpr lqvwuxphqwrv/
huurv gh frpxqlfdr/ hihlwrv gh frqyhuvr dqdojlfr0gljlwdo/ hwf,1
Rv ydoruhv yhugdghlurv gdv ydulyhlv gh hvwdgr gr vlvwhpd/ h frqvhthqwhphqwh gdv
txdqwlgdghv phglgdv/ vr ghvfrqkhflgrv1 Sdud hvwlp0orv/ qhfhvvulr id}hu fhuwdv vx0
srvlhv vreuh r prghor gh phglr h xwlol}du d uhodr hqwuh dv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv h
rv hvwdgrv1 Qr txh vhjxh/ vhu vxsrvwr txh r yhwru grv huurv gh phglr  dsuhvhqwd
glvwulexlr qrupdo/ frp pgld }hur +.E ' f, h pdwul} gh frydulqfld +/ h txh rv huurv
gh phglr vr qr0fruuhodflrqdgrv> rx vhmd/
.E ' f(

.EA  ' +

rqgh + xpd pdwul} gldjrqdo1 Rv hohphqwrv gldjrqdlv ghvvd pdwul} vr dv ydulqfldv grv
huurv gh phglr/ rv txdlv xvxdophqwh vr h{suhvvrv frpr xpd ixqr gr ydoru gr ixqgr
gh hvfdod grv lqvwuxphqwrv gh phglr1 Frp hvvdv vxsrvlhv/ r prghor gh phglr gd
Ht1 514 uh0hvfulwr frpr
3 ' E  n 
.E ' f(

.E |  ' +

+515,

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

53

R yhwru frp rv ydoruhv yhugdghlurv gdv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv/ 3f/ srgh vhu h{suhvvr hp
whuprv gr yhwru gh hvwdgrv frpr
3f ' E 
+516,
rqgh E  xp yhwru frpsrvwr sru 6 ixqhv qr0olqhduhv gr hvwdgr gr vlvwhpd/ uhvxo0
wdqwhv gd dsolfdr gdv ohlv gh Nlufkkr h Rkp/ h r yhwru gh hvwdgrv gr vlvwhpd1 Qrwh
txh r qphur gh hvwdgrv gh xp vlvwhpd gh srwqfld frp  eduudv ? ' 2  +dshqdv
r qjxor gd eduud gh uhihuqfld qr lqfoxgr qr yhwru gh hvwdgrv gr vlvwhpd,1
Dv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv qrupdophqwh lqfoxhp x{rv gh srwqfld dwlyd h uhdwlyd qrv
udprv gd uhgh h lqmhhv gh srwqfld dwlyd h uhdwlyd qdv eduudv/ dop gh pdjqlwxghv
gh whqvr1 Ghyh vhu phqflrqdgr txh dv fruuhqwhv qdv olqkdv gh wudqvplvvr wdpep
srghuldp vhu prqlwrudgdv/ srup hvwd suwlfd qr d xvxdo hp vlvwhpdv gh wudqvplvvr
d dowd whqvr1
Rxwur dvshfwr lpsruwdqwh uhihuh0vh dr qphur h orfdol}dr gdv phglgdv qd uhgh
howulfd1 R judx gh uhgxqgqfld joredo hqwuh dv phglgdv wrpdgdv qd uhgh howulfd/ ghqr0
wdgr sru 4c ghqlgr frpr
6
{ 6
4'
'
?
2 
Revhuyd0vh txh xpd frqglr qhfhvvuld +pdv qr vxflhqwh, sdud vh hvwlpdu r hvwdgr gr
vlvwhpd txh= 6  ?/ rx 4  c f1 Dop gh xpd erd uhgxqgqfld +4 : c D,/ qd suwlfd
h{ljh0vh txh dv phglgdv vhmdp glvwulexlgdv dghtxdgdphqwh shod uhgh howulfd/ srlv lvwr
surslfld wdqwr d hvwlpdr frpr d ghwhfr h d lghqwlfdr gh huurv jurvvhlurv1
Ilqdophqwh/ dop gdv whohphglgdv hihwlydv txh frpshp r frqmxqwr gh phglgdv rewl0
gdv yld vlvwhpd VFDGD/ dojxqv frpsrqhqwhv gr yhwru gdv txdqwlgdghv phglgdv 3 srghp
vhu svhxgr0phglgdv/ lvwr / lqirupdhv rulxqgdv gh rxwudv irqwhv gh lqirupdr +hvwxgrv
gh suhylvr gh fdujd rx uhvxowdgrv gh hvwlpdhv dqwhulruhv/ sru h{hpsor,1 Dv ydulq0
fldv ghvvdv judqgh}dv ghyhp uh hwlu r judx gh lqfhuwh}d dvvrfldgr v phvpdv/ r txdo
vre flufxqvwqfldv qrupdlv pdlru gr txh dtxhoh dvvrfldgr v phglgdv qrupdlv1 sru0
wdqwr xvxdo txh dv ydulqfldv gdv svhxgr0phglgdv vhmd pdlru gr txh d gdv txdqwlgdghv
whohphglgdv/ rewlgdv yld VFDGD1

517

Pwrgr grv Pqlprv Txdgudgrv Srqghudgrv

Qr pwrgr grv Pqlprv Txdgudgrv Srqghudgrv +PTS, xpd hvwlpdwlyd sdud rv hvwdgrv
fdofxodgd gh irupd d plqlpl}du xpd ixqr fxvwr edvhdgd qr prghor gh phglr gdgr
shodv Htv1 5151 R sureohpd d vhu uhvroylgr frqvlvwh sruwdqwr qd plqlpl}dr gd ixqr
gh fxvwr
aE  ' d3  E oA +3 d3  E o
+517,
frp uhodr d 1 Rx vhmd/ ghvhmd0vh plqlpl}du r qglfh uhsuhvhqwdgr shor vrpdwulr grv
txdgudgrv grv uhvgxrv srqghudgrv shorv lqyhuvrv gdv ydulqfldv grv huurv gh phglr1
D xwlol}dr gd pdwul} gh srqghudr + lpsolfd hp txh dv phglgdv gh phqru ydulqfld
uhfhehp pdlru shvr gr txh dtxhodv txh dsuhvhqwdp pdlru lqfhuwh}d/ h sruwdqwr whqkdp
pdlru lq xqfld qd vroxr gd hvwlpdr gh hvwdgrv1
Qr sureohpd h{suhvvr shod Ht1 517/ d txdqwlgdgh h ' 3  E  uhsuhvhqwd r yhwru grv
uhvgxrv gh hvwlpdr/ gdgr shod glihuhqd hqwuh r ydoru hihwlydphqwh phglgr h r ydoru
rewlgr hp ixqr gr hvwdgr hvwlpdgr1 Ghvhmd0vh sruwdqwr fdofxodu r yhwru txh plqlpl}d

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

54

d vrpd grv txdgudgrv grv uhvgxrv gh hvwlpdr/ srqghudgrv shor lqyhuvr gdv ydulqfldv
grv huurv gh phglr1
Qrv su{lprv wuv fdswxorv vhur dsuhvhqwdgrv wuv pwrgrv glvwlqwrv sdud d vroxr
gr sureohpd gh hvwlpdr gh hvwdgrv edvhdgr qd irupxodr grv pqlprv txdgudgrv
srqghudgrv1

518

Pwrgr grv Pqlprv Ydoruhv Devroxwrv Srqgh0

udgrv

Rxwud derugdjhp sdud d vroxr gr sureohpd gh HHVS frqvlvwh qd plqlpl}dr gd vrpd

grv ydoruhv devroxwrv grv uhvgxrv gh hvwlpdr srqghudgrv +PYDS, shorv lqyhuvrv gdv
ydulqfldv gdv phglgdv/ lvwr =
4?

6
[

'

j32
m5   E m


+518,

Dsv d lqwurgxr gh xpd pxgdqd gh ydulyhlv/ hvwh sureohpd srgh vhu wudqvirupdgr hp
xp sureohpd gh surjudpdr olqhdu frp uhvwulhv ^5`/^6`1 Dojxqv dxwruhv frqvlghudp r
pwrgr PYDS frpr xpd dowhuqdwlyd dwudhqwh hp uhodr dr pwrgr PTS ghylgr v vxdv
sursulhgdghv lqhuhqwhv gh uhmhlr gh huurv1 Hqwuhwdqwr/ idwr txh rv hvwlpdgruhv PYDS
hqfrqwudp ehp phqrv dfhlwdr qd suwlfd gr txh rv edvhdgrv qrv pqlprv txdgudgrv
srqghudgrv1

519

H{hufflr

Frqvlghuh r vlvwhpd gh srwqfld h r sodqr gh phglr dvvrfldgr uhsuhvhqwdgrv dedl{r/

rqgh w h x uhsuhvhqwdp phglgdv gh x{r gh srwqfld dwlyd h uhdwlyd/ uhvshfwlydphqwh/ s h
t vr phglgdv gh lqmhr gh srwqfld dwlyd h uhdwlyd h Y uhsuhvhqwd phglgd gh pdjqlwxgh
gh whqvr1
. 5
%2 ' fc D
s2 .
.<



T
6 4
2 2
%2 ' fc 2D
 T



.
 % ' c f

 .
.< .
 
w

>x

>x

6
Dv uhvlvwqfldv grv udprv gd uhgh vr ghvsuh}dgdv1 Dv ydulqfldv gdv phglgdv vr
ljxdlv d fc ff R sdud dv phglgdv gh whqvr / fc f2 R sdud dv phglgdv gh srwqfld dwlyd
h fc f2D sdud dv phglgdv gh srwqfld uhdwlyd1

Dqolvh gh Vhjxudqd gh Vlvwv1 How1 Srw1 0 JVS2HHO2XIVF

55

Hvfuhyd r prghor gh phglr qr0olqhdu sdud r vlvwhpd frp r sodqr gh phglr gdgr1
H{solflwh fdgd hohphqwr gr yhwru gh ixqhv E vxevwlwxlqgr ydoruhv qxpulfrv sdud rv
sduphwurv gd uhgh h ghwhuplqh d pdwul} gh frydulqfld grv huurv gh phglr +1
+Ohpeuhwh= ghvsuh}dqgr0vh dv uhvlvwqfldv grv udprv/ rv x{rv gh srwqfld dwlyd h
uhdwlyd qrv udprv h dv lqmhhv qdv eduudv vr gdgrv sru=
| '
R '

T T
%

S
&

Mx

ti?EB   B   '

|&

^ '

T2
%

&

Mx

T T
%

ULtEB   B  

&

rqgh x uhsuhvhqwd r frqmxqwr gh eduudv dgmdfhqwhv eduud  vhp lqfoxlu hvwd eduud,1

Uhihuqfldv Eleolrjufdv
^4` D1 M1 D1 Vlphv Frvwd1 Srzhu V|vwhp Vwdwh Hvwlpdwlrq= Ruwkrjrqdo Phwkrgv iru
Hvwlpdwlrq dqg Edg Gdwd Surfhvvlqj/ dqg Whfkqltxhv iru Wrsrorjlfdo Revhuydelolw|1
SkG wkhvlv/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Zdwhuorr 0 Fdqdgd/ 4<;41
^5` Edjfkl/ D1> Fohphqwv/ N1D1> Gdylv/ S1Z1> Pdxudlv/ I1K1/ D frpsdulvrq ri dojr0
ulwkpv iru ohdvw devroxwh ydoxh vwdwh hvwlpdwlrq hohfwulf srzhu qhwzrunv/ 4<<7 LHHH
Lqwhuqdwlrqdo V|psrvlxp rq Flufxlwv dqg V|vwhpv/ Yro1 9/ ss1 860891
^6` Vlqjk/ K1> Doydudgr/ I1O1/ Zhljkwhg Ohdvw Devroxwh Ydoxh vwdwh hvwlpdwlrq xvlqj
lqwhulru srlqw phwkrgv/ LHHH Wudqvdfwlrqv rq Srzhu V|vwhpv/ Yro1 </ Qr1 6/ Dxj1
4<<7/ ss1 47:; 047;71