Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
American Marketing Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Journal of Marketing
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
open.
diminish
the degree of retail competition.
the events of the last twenty years; (3)commodities produced and the people
that the goal of industry will be fullwho buy have obvious effects on disproduction for an expanding markettribution, which serves to bring them
provided by a people on a rising living together. Therefore it is necessary to
standard.
take a look at some of the relevant facThe third assumption is of particulartors in production and consumption;
these will set the frame, so to speak, for
import to retailing. The degree to which
this goal is realized may determine, forthe picture of postwar retail competition.
tailers in general, the more nearly we ductive capacity which the war effort
has unveiled is a lesson the American
approach a state of full productivity and
full employment, the higher will be the
consumer cannot forget; by such an
rewards for success in the competitive
struggle and the less grave will be the 1 M. M. Zimmerman, "Supers as Mass Outlet for
Drugs and Cosmetics," Supermarket Merchandising,
penalties for failure. Realization of that
November, I943, p. 41.
11
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
12
achievement American
industry
has
more leisure and
security than ever bedertaken an obligation
which
it
fore. There are likely
to be changes,
for can
never henceforth example,
deny.
in the character and number of
Even assuming a
postwar
national
in
retail
units through which
this doubled
or trebled
production or
of consumers'
come of i 50o billion
dollars
more, ho
centration of economic
has be
ticipate directly in power
distribution.
hastened by the war. In the words of t
CONSUMPTION
Senate Education and Labor Committee: "America, a land of giant corpora-What will be the ability of the contions before the war, will emerge from
sumers to absorb the increased producthis war with a larger share of its vastly
tion? The answer to this question de-
postwar income.
tration has been accompanied, not only Even if we assume that employment,
by a huge addition to the national plant, together with income, will be maintained
but also by the introduction of newer at wartime peaks, it must be rememand much more efficient labor-saving bered that the present prosperity is iland automatic machines; new materials lusory for a large part of the population.
superseding old materials that called for The OPA study, "Civilian Spending and
greater expenditure of labor, as for ex- Saving, I94I and I942," shows that
ample, plastics and laminated plywood; 6i.8% of the families in the country
and new processes, like centrifugal cast- lived in I942 on an income of less than
ing, which are as economical in man- $50 a week, and this was a year of high
hours. Thus we have a network of forces prices.3 The new high records of departwhich tend toward reduced employment ment store sales reflected the heavy
coupled with the national determination spending of the four out of every ten
to achieve "full employment."
families who had an income of over
Without a huge multiplication of com- $2,500. The OPA tells us further that
modities and an income distribution
over 88% of the savings by individuals
which will permit the consumption ofin I942 were made by people in the inthis output, we shall face crises darker
come level above $2,500, savings of 22.4
than even I930-1933. On the part of thebillion dollars out of a total of 25.4
billions.4
giant industries, such as aluminum, electrical equipment, glass, and perhaps An uneven distribution of income is,
steel, a number of totally new decisions
of course, not a new factor to be reckwill be called for: relaxation of patentoned with; we have always had it. The
monopolies, licensing of additional propoint is that it is still with us; that the
ducers, and especially the renunciationdoubled or trebled income we now enjoy
of superprofits and planned restriction
has not changed it, except in degree.
of production. Of immediate concern, In I935-I936, according to the Nahowever, is the effect upon retailing of ational Resources Committee, 87% of the
nation on a rising living standard with
families in the country lived on an in2 Quoted by Vice-President Henry A. Wallace, "We 8 O.P.A. Division of Research, Civilian Spending and
Must Save Free Enterprise," Saturday Evening Post,
Saving, I94r and I942, p. I6.
October 23, 1943.
4Ibid., p. 17.
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
13
tion":
P. 9.
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
14
Independent $I9,333
Chain 73,484
1935
1929
$i6,738
$27,614
58,231
65,68I
merchandise.
chains.
quality of their operation during a deccreased cash reserves, most of the advanade marked by a drastic decline in national income. Their decision, not neces-tages won by the independent during the
(Washington, United States Government Printing This does not deny to the man who is ex-
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
JORA
FMREIG1
15
marized as follows:10
Chain Units
Over $ioo,ooo
Under $Ioo,000
Totals
1935
37.4
48.2
IOO.0
100.0
1939
62.6%
51.8%
Independents
Over $ioo,ooo
Under $ioo,000
63.6
34.5
65.5
Totals
100.0
100I .0
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
16
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
17
THE
7OURNAL
THE
JOURN,L
OF MARKETING OF MARKETING 17
tribute economically
the
new
com
mins and other drug
items in
superties which they
have
taken
on, an
markets,
with paints
in auto supply
stores, and with
books at newsstands.
probably continue
into
peace m
their marketingTheinnovations.
competition is thus developed be- In th
various
channels
of distribution
ing is the plan tween
of
the
oil
compan
sell at roadside over
filling
stations
the same items-with the point of art
general use. And
food
conflictaset huge
by their differing
minimum pro
who has been making
equipment f
mark-up requirements.
armed forces is reported
preparing
A scale of competition
is likely to be
larger, however, supplies
than a scramble for a th
household electrical
grocery stores.
ency for unrelated channels of distri- Clearly one of the solutions these
bution to add to their lines the fastest
chains will consider (and not necessarily
volume of a department store but protheir fastest moving and most competiduces over 7% of the net profits.13 This
tive items. It is no secret that a number
fast turnover item may become attracof them are already engaged either in
tive to a drug store for the additional
manufacturing or assembling commodivolume it can furnish. But a drug store
ties they sell.
requires approximately the same mark-'
Brands, name and product monopolies
up as a department store. Let cigar store
vs. lower cost distribution. A few years ago
chains or supermarkets take such a fastthe Twentieth Century Fund in its study
moving item and apply their traditional
Does Distribution Cost Too Much? arlower mark-ups to it, and a revolution
rived at the conclusion that of the con-
is affected in the distribution of the artisumer's dollar, 59 cents goes for the costs
cle. This is today happening with vitaof distribution and only 41 cents for
port, p. 47.
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
1818
THE
JOURNAL
tribution of important
which were included
follow:14
OF
THE MARKETING
JOURNAL OF MARKETING
Period Expenses
Processors
CPoerwedg per $i of
Sept. I194I 2. I8
Sept. 194I 26.86
Year 1939 34.66
Year 1939 34.93
Wholesalers
Cooperative Wholesale
Grocers
Retailers
House-to-House Bakeries
faced with declining mark-ups and inare stocked. All prices will reflect the absence
tensified competition; I have called this
of promotional costs such as are needed to
process "marketing arbitrage." We shall build up national brand preference, and the
see both manufacturers and distributors lower warehousing costs of the chain or cogo into new fields or take on new com- operative warehouse as against the greater
modities precisely because the tradiexpense of manufacturers' outlets or the old
tional selling costs or mark-ups of the line wholesaler.
"oldtimers" are higher than those of the
We shall not see such an institution
newcomers. An example, not too visionin the postwar period, but this is the
ary, might be the entry of the Kaiser
theoretical limit of efficiency in distrishipbuilding or the Boeing aircraft inbution
toward which retailing will now
terests into the manufacture of inexhave to move. The compulsion to appensive motor cars, distributed through
proach nearer and nearer this limit will
in fact be the essence of postwar retail
14 Federal Trade Commission, Methods and Costs of
competition.
Distribution, Part one, November i I, 1943, p. 3.
This content downloaded from 128.195.79.244 on Tue, 11 Oct 2016 19:08:54 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms