86 16 541 1 10 20160407

TheHabsburgsandtheirCourts
inEurope,14001700

PALATIUMePublications
Volume1
SeriesEditors:KristaDeJongeandPieterMartens

TheworkreportedoninthispublicationhasbeenfinanciallysupportedbytheEuropean
ScienceFoundation(ESF)intheframeworkoftheResearchNetworkingProgramme
PALATIUM.CourtResidencesasPlacesofExchangeinLateMedievalandEarlyModern
Europe(14001700),20102015.

The European Science Foundation was established in
1974 to provide a common platform for its Member
Organisations to advance European research
collaboration and explore new directions for research. It
is an independent organisation, owned by 67 Member
Organisations, which are research funding organisations,
research performing organisations and academies from
29 countries. ESF promotes collaboration in research
itself, in funding of research and in science policy
activitiesattheEuropeanlevel.CurrentlyESFisreducing
its research programmes whiledeveloping new activities
to serve the science community, including peer review
andevaluationservices.
PALATIUMissupportedby14organisationsfrom11countries:
Austrian Science Fund (FWF) Austrian Academy of Sciences
(AW)ResearchFoundationFlanders,Belgium(FWO)Czech
ScienceFoundation(GACR)AcademyofSciencesoftheCzech
Republic (ASCR) Danish Agency for Science, Technology and
Innovation(FI)|TheDanishCouncilforIndependentResearch
| Humanities (FKK) National Centre for Scientific Research,
France (CNRS) German Research Foundation (DFG)
Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO)
FoundationforScienceandTechnology,Portugal(FCT)Slovak
AcademyofSciences(SAV)SlovakResearchandDevelopment
Agency(APVV)CarlosdeAmberesFoundation,Spain(FCA)
SwedishResearchCouncil(VR).
http://www.courtresidences.eu/
ThePALATIUMconferenceTheHabsburgsandtheirCourtsinEurope,14001700.
Between Cosmopolitism and Regionalism, held in Vienna on 710 December
2011,receivedadditionalsupportfromtheAustrianAcademyofSciencesandthe
SlovakAcademyofSciences.
sterreichischeAkademiederWissenschaften,KULeuvenandauthors,2014
ISBN9789460184833

Copyright: This is an open access work distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
ShareAlike4.0InternationalLicense(CCBYSA4.0),whichpermitsunrestricteduse,distributionandreproduction
in any medium, provided that the original author and source are properly credited and that any adaptations or
derivativeworksaredistributedunderthesamelicense.Copyrightisretainedbytheauthors.
Coverimage:TournamentontheBurgplatzinfrontoftheHofburginViennain1560.ColouredetchingbyHans
Lautensack, in: Hans von Francolin, Rerum praeclare gestarum intra et extra moenia munitissimae civitatis
Viennensis...(Vienna,1561).sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,HAD,662.700CAltRara.
Coverdesign:PieterMartens
PALATIUMePublication1

TheHabsburgsandtheirCourts
inEurope,14001700

www.courtresidences.eu
2014
Contents
Preface
KristaDeJonge
IntroductionandAcknowledgements
HerbertKarner,IngridCiulisov&BernardoJ.GarcaGarca
I.RepraesentatioMajestatisandResidency
BescheideneBurgenundkleineStdte.DiePrsenzderDynastieindenvordersterreichischen
StammlandenimSptmittelalter(12.bis15.Jahrhundert)
BrunoMeier
12
BausteineeinesResidenzprojekts.KaiserMaximilianI.inInnsbruck
NicoleRiegel
28
Architecturaancillamusicae.ArchitekturinderBeziehungzurMusikaufdemPragerHof
derHabsburger
IvanP.Muchka
PalacesontheEdgeoftheAtlantic.TheArchitecturalReformationandtheSpaceRitualization
ofthePortugueseRoyalResidencesduringtheReignofPhilipIofHabsburg(15801598)
MiltonPedroDiasPacheco
46
55
II.Imperial,RoyalorPrincelyIdentityandRegionalPatriotism
HabsburgMythologyandtheWaldsteinPalaceinPrague
JanBaant
OfficialPortraitsandRegionalIdentities.TheCaseofEmperorMaximilianI(14591519)
DagmarEichberger
73
100
DynastischeIdentittundeuropischePolitikderspanischenHabsburgerinden1650erJahren.
DiegoVelzquezBildnissealsTeileinerhfischpolitischenPortraitkultur
EvaBettinaKrems
115
Presentation,RepresentationandInvisibility.EmperorFerdinandIandhisSonArchduke
FerdinandIIofAustriainPrague(15471567)
MadelonSimons
TheCourtsoftheHabsburgsasRelatedbyJakubSobieski
CezaryTaracha
132
148
III.ReligiousPracticesandtheCourt
ThePietasAustriaca.APoliticalMyth?OntheInstrumentalisationofPietytowardstheCross
attheVienneseCourtintheSeventeenthCentury
WernerTelesko
159
EngenderingPietasAustriaca.TheVillaPoggioImperialeinFlorenceunderMariaMaddalena
ofAustria
IlariaHoppe
181
PietasAustriacaattheLisbonCourt.TheMonumentalChapelandFuneraryTombsbuiltby
CatherineofAustriaintheSanJernimosMonasticCompexinBelm
AnnemarieJordanGschwend
207
IV.HabsburgsandMuslims
EuropesTurkishNemesis
LarrySilver
242
TheGoodandHonestTurk.AEuropeanLegendintheContextofSixteenthCenturyOriental
Studies
Plcs
267
TheMoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcs.SleymanandCharlesV:IconographicDiscourse,
EnhancementofPowerandMagnificence,orTwoFacesoftheSameCoin?
AnnickBorn
283
Allaturca.TrkischeElementeinTheaterundFestandenHabsburgerhfenim16.und17.
Jahrhundert
AndreaSommerMathis
303
TheSpanishHabsburgsandtheArtsofIslamicIberia
CatherineWilkinsonZerner
ListofContributors
336
348
THEHABSBURGSANDTHEIRCOURTSINEUROPE,14001700.BETWEENCOSMOPOLITISMANDREGIONALISM
Preface
KristaDeJonge
Founded in 2010 and financed by the European Science Foundation, the PALATIUM research
networking programme aims at creating a common forum for research on the late medieval and
early modern European court residence or palace (palatium) in a multi and transdisciplinary
perspective (www.courtresidences.eu). In the broad and varied field of court studies, PALATIUMs
focus on the court residence stands out as a main defining characteristic, distinguishing it clearly
from similar initiatives in Europe. Fourteen research institutions from eleven European countries
support this programme, amongst which the organizing institutes of this conference: the Austrian
AcademyofSciencesandtheSlovakAcademyofSciences,bothofwhomwesincerelythankforthe
essentialroletheyhaveplayedinenablingthenetworkandinmakingthiseventpossible.

ThechoiceofvenueseemsparticularlyfittinginretrospectbecauseofPALATIUMsroots.It
was in Vienna in 2008, at the occasion of the aptly named conference Vorbild, Austausch,
Konkurrenz. Hfe und Residenzen in der gegenseitigen Wahrnehmung organized by our host, the
Austrian Academy of Sciences together with the ResidenzenKommission of the Akademie fr
WissenschafteninGttingen,thatsomeoftheessentialcontactsweremade,whicheventuallyledto
thePALATIUMprogramme.TheHofburgProjectoftheAcademythusdeservesparticularmention.
However,sincePALATIUMcouldbecalledanetworkfundedbyaconsortium,thanksarealsodue
totheothermemberorganisationswhostandbehindusandtoourparentcompanytheEuropean
ScienceFoundation.
The world of the courts 14001700 constituted a network of truly European scale and
internationalcharacter.Withinthiscontext,theintricateHabsburgnetworkofcourts,bornfromthe
marriagealliancesbetweentheHouseofAustria,theHouseofBurgundy,theHouseofSpainandthe
HouseofJagielloninthelatefifteenthandearlysixteenthcentury,stoodoutbecauseofitsterritorial
reach, connecting the Low Countries with the Holy Roman Empire, Bohemia and Hungary, and the
Iberian peninsula. PALATIUM quite naturally has addressed these Habsburg Spheres on different
occasions,firstinitsstartupstageinthemeetingofMadridinNovember2010(FelixAustria),and
nowonavasterscaleintheconferenceatViennainDecember2011.Theorganizershavesoughtthe
input of many disciplines apart from the architectural historians, combining the knowledge of the
historian of art, of the theatre, and of collecting, with that of the specialist in religious history,
politics,diplomacyandtravel,toaddresstheHabsburgworldfromdifferentangles.Thecollectionof
essays presented hereafter thus offers a first example of the inclusive approach PALATIUM has
soughttoencourage.
AW,KULeuvenandauthors
ISBN9789460184833
6
IntroductionandAcknowledgements
HerbertKarner
IngridCiulisov
BernardoJ.GarcaGarca

TheessaysgatheredinthisvolumewerepresentedaspapersattheconferenceTheHabsburgsand
theirCourtsinEurope.BetweenCosmopolitismandRegionalism,14001700,whichwasorganizedby
theAustrianAcademyofSciencesincooperationwiththeSlovakAcademyofSciencesandheldin
Vienna on 710 December 2011. It should be noted that it was also the first thematic conference
prepared within the framework of the European Science Foundation research networking
programmePALATIUM.CourtResidencesasPlacesofExchangeinLateMedievalandEarlyModern
Europe(14001700).

The history of almost all PALATIUM member states if they may be called that relates
closely to the House of Habsburg, which in the period under investigation was one of the most
importantroyalhousesofEurope.Forthisreasonitwasdecidedtoorganizetheconferenceasan
internationalscholarlymeetingfocusedonthecourtcultureoftheHabsburgdynastyinitsbroader
context. The scholarly concept of the conference was developed by the two convenors: Ingrid
Ciulisov (Bratislava, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Institute of Art History) and Herbert Karner
(Vienna, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Institute of History of Art and Musicology, Division of Art
History(formerlytheCommissionofArtHistory)).ThetwoconvenorsareindebtedtoKristaDeJonge
(Chair of PALATIUM), Bernardo J. Garca Garca (ViceChair) and Pieter Martens (Programme
Coordinator) for their kind assistance, for which they offer them their warmest thanks. Sincere
thanks go also to the Austrian Academy of Sciences and the Slovak Academy of Sciences for their
generoussupport.Finally,wewouldliketothankJohnNicholsonforhisfinalreadingofthetexts.
Of seventyfour abstracts submitted from eighteen countries, thirtyone papers were
selected and delivered at the conference, including a poster section for younger scholars. The
ceremonial opening lecture was delivered by Larry Silver (University of Pennsylvania). The chosen
papersweredevotedtovarioustopicsspecifiedintheconferencecall,whichishererecalledbothas
atestimonytotheconferenceandforthesakeofclarity.Theeditorsbelievethatthepresentvolume
willserveausefulpurposeinbringingtogetherstudiesofsomeoftheprincipaltopicsencounteredin
thestudyoftheHabsburgsroyalcourts.
ISBN9789460184833
7
A variety of extant visual and written sources demonstrate that the members of the House of
Habsburg devoted special attention to the creation of their dynastic identity (e.g. the
Frstenspiegel,panegyricandemblematicliterature).Itwasthisphenomenonthatmotivatedour
attempt to trace a Habsburg dynastic idiom in the sphere of archducal, kingly or imperial
representation, particularly at the residence courts, and to consider its supranational features in
contrast to its regional ones. Our intention was that court culture in Vienna, Madrid, Brussels,
Prague,BratislavaandBudapestshouldbesubjectedtodetailedexaminationandcomparisonwith
a double focus trained on instances of interaction both within the Europewide Habsburg network
and also with local traditions. All cases of exchange were to be elaborated upon with the help of
visualmediausedbytheHabsburgs,andweretobedevelopedinthefollowingfourpanels:
I.RepraesentatioMajestatisandResidency
Thecourtresidenceisviewedasthenucleusofrepresentation.Investigationsweretofocusprimarily
on the official apartments built up by the Habsburgs in relation to their court ceremony, with the
principal question being: Is there a model unifying the court residences in Madrid, Brussels and
Central Europe? Special attention was devoted to the display of codes and symbols of Habsburg
princelyrepresentation.Itwasintendedthatallvisualmediaandelementsofperformance(theatre,
festivities,ephemeralart),includingdifferentsortsofcollections(ofartworks,books,horses,plants
etc.),shouldbegivenfurtherconsiderationinthecontextsoftheirdisplay.

Fourcasestudiesarepresentedhere.BrunoMeierremindsusthattheearlyHabsburgshad
awidespreadregionalpresencefromAlsacetotheAargauanddescribesitsarchitecturalexpression
(Bescheidene Burgen und kleine Stdte. Die Prsenz der Dynastie in den vordersterreichischen
Stammlanden im Sptmittelalter). In her precise analysis of Maximilian Is building activities in
Innsbruck (Bausteine eines Residenzprojekts. Kaiser Maximilian I. in Innsbruck), Nicole Riegel
demonstrateshowanexistingbuildingcomplexwasturnedstepbystepintoanimperialresidence.
Ivan Prokop Muchka examines the organ in Prague Cathedral as a case of Habsburg self
representationinhispaperonArchitecturaancillamusicae:ArchitekturinderBeziehungzurMusik
amPragerHofderHabsburger.InhispaperonPalacesontheEdgeoftheAtlantic.TheArchitectural
Reformation and the Space Ritualization of the Portuguese Royal Residences during the Reign of
PhilipIofHabsburg(15801598)MiltonPedroDiasPachecodiscussestheinterventionsofPhilipIIof
Spain on Lisbons main royal palace at his succession to the Portuguese throne in the light of
Habsburgrepresentationofmajesty.
II.Imperial,RoyalorPrincelyIdentityandRegionalPatriotism
The Habsburgs developed a supranational form of dynastic identity. In addition, however, other
forms of identity were cultivated and articulated by the local nobility in Bohemia, Hungary and
Poland.TheseformsofidentityrelatedspecificallytowhatmaybecalledLandespatriotismusinthe
senseofloyaltytothe traditionsofthecountriestheystillviewedastheirrespectivehomelands.
WelookedforvariousformsofexpressionofLandespatriotismusinthevisualartsasrealizedinthe
ISBN9789460184833
8
palaces of the time. Works of art glorifying local saints or earlier rulers produced in Bohemia,
Hungary,andPolandwereofparticularinterestinthiscontext.
Fivecasestudiesarecontainedwithinthissectionofthecollection.Goingagainsttraditional
Czechhistoriography,JanBaantdemonstratesinHabsburgMythologyandtheWaldsteinPalacein
Praguethattheheroofitsartisticprogrammeisnotitsowner,regionalpotentatethoughhemay
have been, but the Habsburg Empire he served. Conversely, in her paper on Official Portraits and
RegionalIdentities.TheCaseofEmperorMaximilianI(14591519),DagmarEichbergershowshowa
Habsburg ruler could adopt different types of artistic representation in accordance with the
particular regional context he wanted to communicate with. EvaBettina Krems studies the role
which dynastic portraits, specifically Velzquez, could play in the identitybuilding and foreign
politics of the Spanish midseventeenth century Habsburg court (Dynastische Identitt und
europische PolitikderspanischenHabsburgerin den1650erJahren:DiegoVelzquezBildnisseals
Teil einer hfischpolitischen Portrtkultur). Madelon Simons, in Presentation, Representation and
Invisibility.EmperorFerdinandIandhisSonArchdukeFerdinandIIofAustriainPrague(15471567),
connects the stucco decoration of Villa Stern near Prague with Ferdinands activities as a collector
andapatron,whilecriticallyconsideringthequestionofaHabsburgartisticidiom.InTheCourtsof
the Habsburgs as Related by Jakub Sobieski, Cezary Taracha shows how an outsider viewed the
differentHabsburgcourts,fromViennatoMadrid.
III.ReligiousPracticesatCourt
A decisive element in Habsburg dynastic identity was what has been called Pietas Austriaca
(adorationoftheBlessedSacramentandvenerationoftheBlessedVirginMary,theHolyCross,and
thesaints).Howdidthesespecificreligiouspracticesmanifestthemselves,eitherinpublicliturgyor
in private devotion? How were these practices reflected in the art, culture and architecture of the
court? What can be said about the sacred spaces at the Habsburg courts, their location, structure
and function in ceremonial and private life? Are there possibly connections and interdependencies
betweenprincelyresidencesandreligiousbuildings?Canvirtuessuchaspietasandmodestiabe
seenascriteriaforareconsiderationofHabsburgarchitecture?Whatdifferencesorsimilaritiescan
beseenbetweentheSpanishandtheAustrianHabsburgsintheirpracticeanduseofpietas?

Thissectioncomprisesthreecasestudies.WernerTeleskolooksatthepracticeofpietasat
the seventeenthcentury Viennese court, in particular at its veneration for the Holy Cross under
Emperor Ferdinand II (The Pietas Austriaca. A political myth? On the Instrumentalisation of Piety
towardstheCrossattheVienneseCourtintheSeventeenthCentury),whileIlariaHoppeexaminesits
programmaticuseinthedecorationofVillaPoggioImperiale,Florence,byhiswidowedsisterGrand
Duchess Maria Maddalena (Engendering Pietas Austriaca. The Villa Poggio Imperiale in Florence
under Maria Maddalena of Austria). In her paper on Pietas Austriaca at the Lisbon Court. The
MonumentalChapelandFuneraryTombsbuiltbyCatherineofAustriaintheSanJernimosMonastic
ComplexinBelm,AnnemarieJordanGschwendshowshowCatherine,queenofPortugal,showed
herselfatrueHabsburgrulerinthecreationoftheroyalPantheonatBlem.

ISBN9789460184833
9
IV.HabsburgsandMuslims
The longstanding threat posed by the Ottomans in eastern Central Europe and by the Moors in
Spain provoked the construction of images and stereotypes of enemies of the Faith. Were there
similar strategies in Spain and Austria, in particular within the context of court culture, for the
creation of propaganda presenting the Habsburgs as defenders of the Faith? Did this image have
any tangible influence on Habsburg court culture? Further issues were: Turkish perception of
Habsburg courts and palaces; the possible role of the Ottoman palace as a rival to the Habsburg
model;andmanifestationsofthetriumphovertheMoorsandtheOttomansinpalatialart.

InEuropesTurkishNemesis,ourkeynotespeakerLarrySilverpaintsabroadpanoramaof
the manifold image of the Turk in the long Habsburg sixteenth century, from Albrecht Drer and
MaximilianI,toHansvonAachenandRudolfII,showingtherichnessofartisticstrategiesavailableto
HabsburgrulersintheirpropagandawarwiththeTurks.PlcsexaminesearlyOttomanStudiesin
hispaperon TheGoodandHonestTurk.AEuropeanLegendintheContext ofSixteenthCentury
OrientalStudies,particularlyastrainwhichrunscountertotheprevalentimageoftheTurkasthe
enemy.Afamouspictorialinstance,duetotheFlemishartistPieterCoeckevanAelst,isanalysedby
Annick Born in her paper on The Moeurs et fachons de faire de Turcs. Sleyman and Charles V:
IconographicDiscourse,EnhancementofPowerandMagnificence,orTwoFacesoftheSameCoin?.
TheissueofcrosspollinationisaddressedbothbyAndreaSommerMathisinAllaturca.Trkische
ElementeinTheaterundFestandenHabsburgerhfenim16.und17.Jahrhundert,andbyCatherine
Wilkinson Zerner in her paper on The Spanish Habsburgs and the Arts of Islamic Iberia, both
demonstratingparsprototohowtheHabsburgcourtsinbothAustriaandSpainshowedacontinuing
interestintheartefacts,moresandcultureoftheirarchenemy.

ISBN9789460184833
10

I
RepraesentatioMajestatisandResidency

ISBN9789460184833
11
BescheideneBurgenundkleineStdte
Die Prsenz der Dynastie in den vordersterreichischen Stammlanden im
Sptmittelalter(12.bis15.Jahrhundert)
BrunoMeier

Die von Legenden umrankte Frhgeschichte der Habsburger geht zurck auf das 10. und 11.
Jahrhundert. Die Ursprnge des Geschlechts werden im Umfeld des grflichen Adels im Sden des
Elsassvermutet,sicherseitdemfrhen11.JahrhundertistdieHochadelsfamilie,dieerstmals1108
urkundlich mit dem Zunamen von Habsburg verbrgt ist, im Aargau im Norden der heutigen
Schweiz prsent. Es wird in den folgenden Abschnitten darum gehen, die zentralen Orte im
wachsenden Machtbereich der Habsburger zu definieren und die Bedeutung der vorlndischen
ZentrennachdemErwerbdersterreichischenHerzogtmerimJahr1282zuskizzieren.Gabesvor
undnachdiesemWechselnachWienAnstzezuHofhaltungenimWesten,wiemanifestiertesichdie
PrsenzderDynastieindenehemaligenStammlandenbisins15.Jahrhundert?1
Grndungsorte:DieHabsburgunddieKlsterMuriundOttmarsheim
Die Frhgeschichte der Habsburger ist einzig ber eine erzhlende Quelle, die sogenannten Acta
Murensia,diewahrscheinlichinderZeitnach1140entstandenundineinerAbschriftausderZeitum
1400berliefertsind,greifbar.2DarinwirddieGrndungdesKlostersMuridurchRadbotundItaals
Shne fr die Vertreibung von freien Bauern geschildert. Bischof Werner von Strassburg, der
mglicheOheimderIta,genanntvonLothringen,sollgleichzeitigzusammenmitRadbotdenBauder
Habsburg veranlasst haben. Kurze Zeit spter soll von Radbots Bruder Rudolf das Kloster
OttmarsheimamRanddesHardwaldsstlichvonMlhausengestiftetwordensein.Datiertwerden
dieGrndungenderKlsterswiefolgt:MuriaufdasJahr1027,geweiht1064durchdenBischofvon
Konstanz; Ottmarsheim um 1030, geweiht 1049 durch Papst Leo IX. Ungefhr gleichzeitig soll die
Habsburgentstandensein.
Lassen sich diese erzhlerischen Quellen mit dem heutigen Stand des Wissens in
bereinstimmung bringen?DieHabsburgistin denJahren197883und199495bauarchologisch
untersuchtworden.SiewirdaufgrundverschiedenerBefundetatschlichaufdieZeitum1020/1030
datiert.ZusammenmitAusbautenausderZeitum1100kannvoneinergrossenundimVergleichzu
hnlichen Burgen am Ober und Hochrhein reprsentativen Anlage gesprochen werden. Sie war zu
derZeitmchtigeralsdieLenzburg,SitzderdamalsinderRegiontonangebendenGrafenimAargau.3
ISBN9789460184833
12
Sie ist sowohl symbolischer als auch wehrhafter Ausdruck eines offenbar aufstrebenden
Adelsgeschlechts.DieHabsburgersindim12.undfrhen13.JahrhundertAnhngerderstaufischen
Knige und orientierten sich in ihrer Grndungsund Bauttigkeit wohl am staufischen Umfeld und
dessenBurgenbau.

Abb.2DieltereBurgdes11.Jahrhundertsistaufder
RekonstruktionlinkerHandsichtbar.DieErweiterung
rechtsstammtausdem12.und13.Jahrhundert.

Abb.1Derheutenochstehende,jngereTeilderHabsburg
stelltnurdenkleinerenTeilderursprnglichenBurgdar.
ImHintergrunddieFundamentederlterenBurg.

Mit den beiden Klostergrndungen markierten die frhen Habsburger gleichzeitig ihren
damaligen Einflussbereich: den Sden des Elsass und den Aargau. Sicher nach 1100 bten sie
grfliche Rechte im oberen Elsass aus, nach dem Aussterben der Grafen von Lenzburg 1173 auch
sdlich des Rheins. Sie waren seit 1135 Vgte der Abtei Murbach im Elsass und nach 1173 des
Klosters Sckingen, Mitte des 13. Jahrhunderts auch des Klosters St. Blasien im Schwarzwald. Im
Reichbewegtensiesichseitdemfrhen12.JahrhundertinderRegelintreuerGefolgschaftzuden
Staufern.4
SowohlinMuri(1953)wieinOttmarsheim(1981)sinddieFundamenteunddieStiftergrber
archologischuntersuchtworden.AnbeidenOrtenhabensichdieGrndungserzhlungenderActa
Murensia besttigt. Im Zentrum des Oktogons in Ottmarsheim wurde ein gemauerter, mit
Steinplatten bedeckter Sarkophag gefunden. Das offenbar ungestrte Grab enthielt Teile eines
SchdelsundRestevonKleidung.GemssderLegendesollderStifterRudolfinppstlichenDiensten
im Kampf gegen die Normannen im Sden Italiens umgekommen sein. Vielleicht sind Teile seines
Leichnamsnachtrglichbestattetworden.5InMuriwurden1953dreiGrbergeffnet.Imzentralen
Grab vor dem ehemaligen Lettner konnte eine Frau identifiziert werden, im nrdlich davon
gelegenen Grab ein Mann mit einem Jngling. Sdlich davon war eine Sammelbestattung. Diese
Situation entspricht der Erzhlung in den Acta Murensia. Die Klosterstifterin Ita soll in der Mitte
begrabenwordensein,ihrGatteRadbotzusammenmitdemfrhverstorbenenSohnAdalbertgleich
daneben.DieGrbersindnachweislichimJanuar1701geffnetworden,alsMurivonKaiserLeopold
ISBN9789460184833
13
zur Frstabtei erhoben wurde. Graf Ehrenreich von Trautmansdorff, der damalige sterreichische
Gesandte in der Eidgenossenschaft, konnte sich von der Existenz der mythischen Vorfahren des
KaiserhausesanOrtundStelleberzeugen.6

Abb.3TeilederKlosterkircheMuri(Krypta,Trme)
gehennochindieromanischeGrndungszeitzurck.
Endedes17.Jahrhundertsistindasromanische
Kirchenschiffeinmchtiger,achteckigerBau
eingefgtworden,dergrsstebarocke
KuppelzentralbauderSchweiz.

Abb.4DieKirchevonOttmarsheimzeigtbisheuteden
achteckigenGrundrissderGrndungsanlage,
typologischangelegtandiekarolingischePfalzkapelle
inAachen.DasDamenstiftistniezueinergrossen
Abteigewachsenundhatdeshalbdieursprngliche
Strukturbewahrt.
Adelsresidenzenim12.und13.Jahrhundert?
Der grfliche Adel besass im 12. Jahrhundert in der Regel noch keine festen Residenzen und
Hofhaltungen.Erwarstndigunterwegs,imDienstdesKnigsoderinAusbungseinerHerrschaft.
Beim Versuch, sogenannte Itinerare einzelner Vertreter der Dynastie aufgrund der verfgbaren
Quellenzuerstellen,wirddiesevident.Dennochlassensichzumindestfrdas13.Jahrhunderterste
zentrale Orte oder Sttzpunkte ausmachen, an denen sich die Habsburger bevorzugt aufgehalten
habenoderdiesiefrHerschaftsundzunehmendfrVerwaltungszweckeverwendethaben.Neben
Burgen waren dies Stadthuser in Bischofs oder Reichsstdten, aber auch feste Huser oder
Stadtburgen in den eigenen Stdten. Fr Strassburg, Hagenau, Colmar, Mlhausen, Basel oder
Rheinfelden,wosichVertreterderDynastienachweislichimmerwiederaufgehaltenhaben,istkein
Besitz von eigenen Husern belegt.7 Hingegen sind die habsburgischen Kleinstdte Laufenburg am
RheinundBruggunweitderHabsburgmitStadtburgenbelegt.
ISBN9789460184833
14

Abb.5DieberrestederBurgSteininLaufenburg
amRhein,im13.und14.JahrhundertSitzderNebenlinie
derGrafenvonHabsburgLaufenburg.

Graf Rudolf IV., der sptere Knig, der im Jahr 1240 die Fhrung innerhalb der Familie
bernahm,hatkaumlngereZeitaufderStammburgderFamiliegelebtundwirdsieauchkaumals
Residenz verwendet haben. Seine politischen Ambitionen lagen in der Zeit der Stauferwirren und
des Interregnums zwischen etwa 1245 und 1265 vornehmlich im Elsass und im Schwarzwald. Im
SchwarzwaldsetzteersichgegenadligeMitkonkurrentenalsVogtdesKlostersSt.Blasiendurchund
grndetedieStadtWaldshutamRhein.ImElsasswarerindieKonfliktezwischenderStadtunddem
BischofvonStrassburginvolviert,erstaufbischflicher,dannaufdersiegreichenstdtischenSeite.
In diesem Zusammenhang steht der Ausbau der Ortenburg nordwestlich von Schlettstadt. ber
seineHeiratmitGertrudvonHohenbergimJahr1254hatteRudolfindiesemRaumFussgefasst.Er
liess die Burg in den Jahren zwischen 1262 und 1265 markant ausbauen. Die berreste der Burg
lassendaraufschliessen,dassderHabsburgerdenOrtnichtnuralsweithinsichtbaresSymbolseiner
Wehrhaftigkeiterbauenliess,sonderndassdieOrtenburgauchRumefrresidenzielleFunktionen
beherbergte.8

ISBN9789460184833
15

Abb.6DieOrtenburgmitihremmarkanten,fnfeckigen
und30MeterhohenBergfried,ihrvorgelagertdieBurg
Ramstein.DieHabsburgerverkauftendieBurgbereits
1314.Siewurde1633vondenSchwedenzerstrt.

Abb.7BlickinsInnerederBurgmitdergotischen
FensterfronteinesehemaligenFestssaalsimersten
Obergeschoss,dersichreprsentativzurEbenehin
ffnet.
DieKnigswahlalsWendepunkt
Graf Rudolf IV. war mit seiner expansiven Politik erfolgreich. 1263/64 konnte er den Besitz der
GrafenvonKyburgsdlichdesRheins,ehemaligesErbederHerzgevonZhringen,mitpolitischem
Geschick unter seinen Einfluss bringen. Er erlangte Kontrolle ber Stdte und Burgen im heutigen
SchweizerMittellandwieFrauenfeld,Winterthur,Baden,dieLenzburgoderFreiburgimUechtland.
Gegen die Ansprche der mchtigen Grafen von Savoyen im Westen konnte er sich durchsetzen.
DamitschwangersichzumwichtigstenadligenMitspielerzwischenStrassburgundZrichauf.
Ab 1268 stand er nicht zum ersten Mal in Fehde mit dem Bischof von Basel. Die
Bischofsstadt wre fr ihn ein natrlicher Residenzort gewesen, als Scharnier zwischen seinen
EinflussbereichenimElsassundimRaumdesAargaus,quasiMittelpunkteineskleinenFrstentums.9
Ein mehrjhriger Kleinkrieg war die Folge, in dem auch die habsburgische Klosterstiftung in
Ottmarsheim von Basler Sldnern geplndert wurde. Im Sommer 1273 schliesslich sammelte der
HabsburgerseineVerbndetenzueinerBelagerungvonBasel.ImLagervorBaselerhieltRudolfdie
NachrichtvonseinerWahlzumrmischdeutschenKnig.ErscheintfrdiewhlendenFrstenein
nichtzumchtigerscheinenderKompromisskandidatgewesenzusein.Damitverndertensichder
AnspruchunddieAusrichtungdesdynastischenWegsderHabsburgervllig.AlsKnigschlossermit
derbelagertenStadtBaselumgehendFrieden.SeinResidenzprojektwardamitkeinThemamehr.
DervomkleinenGrafenzumKniggewordeneRudolfnderteseinePolitikschlagartig.Aus
heutiger Perspektive erscheint sein Handeln in den folgenden Monaten und Jahren derart
zielgerichtet,dassmanmeinenknnte,dassdiesvonlangerHandgeplantgewesensei.Erverstand
offenbardieMechanikderReichspolitikaufsBeste.ErverstndigtesichmitdenwhlendenFrsten
auf eine Strkung der im Interregnum stark beschdigten Stellung des Reichs, insbesondere durch
Rckforderung von dem Reich entfremdeten Rechten, erreichte mit einer systematischen
Verheiratung seiner Nachkommen in die frstlichen Huser eine Integration seiner kleinen
Grafenfamilieunter die GrossendesReichsundschaffteesschliesslich,eine Koalitionzustandezu
bringen, mit der er den mchtigsten Reichsfrsten herausfordern konnte: Knig Ottokar von
Bhmen.10
ISBN9789460184833
16
Der Konflikt entstand aus der Rckforderung der von Ottokar in den Jahrzehnten zuvor
usurpiertenHerzgtmersterreich,Steiermark,KrntenundKrainsowiederWindischenMark.An
einem Reichstag in Augsburg im Mai 1275 sicherte sich der neue Knig die Rckendeckung der
Reichsrsten fr ein Vorgehen gegen den Bhmen, dem die sterreichischen Reichslehen
abgesprochen wurden. In den sdostlichen Lndern brach die bhmische Herrschaft bereits im
Herbst1276zusammen.DieGrafenvonGrzTirolwurdenzuRudolfswichtigstenVerbndeten.Der
ungarische Knig Ladislaus IV. wandte sich ebenfalls gegen Ottokar. Knig Rudolf erschien im
Oktober 1276 ein erstes Mal vor Wien. Ottokar von Bhmen musste klein beigeben. Der reiche
Knigmusstesichvomgrflichen Emporkmmling demtigenlassen.DerFriedewarabernurvon
kurzerDauer.Am26.August1278fandschliesslichaufdemMarchfeldbeiDrnkrutnordstlichvon
Wien die entscheidende Auseinandersetzung statt. Rudolf von Habsburg konnte mit seiner
schwbischen Hausmacht und mit den Verbndeten Ungarn und GrzTirol seinen bermchtig
erscheinendenGegnerberwinden.OttokarkaminderSchlachtselbstumsLeben.11
DamithattederKnigalleTrmpfeinderHand.EsgelangihmindenfolgendenJahrendie
Reichsfrstendazuzubringen,einerVerleihungder sterreichischen HerzogtmeranseineShne
zuzustimmen.
Krnten berliess er seinem Verbndeten Meinrad von GrzTirol. Seinen ltesten Sohn
Albrecht verheiratete er mit dessen Tochter Elisabeth. Ende 1282 konnten seine Shne die
Herzogtmer aus der Hand des kniglichen Vaters in Empfang nehmen. Eine innerfamilire
Hausordnungvom1.Juni1283hieltfest,dassAlbrechtdiesterreichischenLehenerhaltensollte,
der jngere Rudolf sollte wohl im Westen mit einem wiedererrichteten Herzogtum Schwaben
ausgestattet werden. Mit dem bhmischen Knigshaus gingen die Habsburger 1285 eine doppelte
Verbindungein.DerjngereSohnRudolfheirateteAgnes,TochterdesOttokar.GutavonHabsburg
ehelichte den als bhmischer Knig nachfolgenden Wenzel II. Damit zeichnete sich Ende des 13.
Jahrhunderts bereits eine Strategie der Habsburger ab, die bhmische Krone ins Haus zu bringen.
EineStrategie,dienotabeneerst1526unterFerdinandI.vondauerhaftemErfolggekrntwar.
EinekniglicheResidenz?
Eine Reichsverwaltung oder eine Reichsresidenz existierte nicht. Der Habsburger besa keine
glanzvolle Burg und Stadt wie Ottokar in Prag. Knigswahlort war Frankfurt, Krnungsort Aachen.
Die wichtigen politischen Entscheidungen wurden an Reichstagen gefllt, die in der Regel in den
grossenReichsundBischofsstdtenwieNrnberg,AugsburgoderFrankfurtdurchgefhrtwurden.
Solche Reichstage waren fr die knigliche Hofhaltung letztlich in erster Linie ein enormer
Kostenfaktor.OftmusstesichderKnigvonderentsprechendenStadtdieAuslagendafrausleihen.
Im Februar 1291 als Beispiel, kurz vor seinem Tod, erliess Knig Rudolf der Reichsstadt Zrich fr
sechsJahredieReichssteuern.DafrlsteZrichbeiderStadtErfurtRudolfsSchuldvomReichstag
imDezember1290ab.12RudolfselbsthatsichniesehrlangeimneuenHerrschaftszentruminWien
aufgehalten.DieReichsgeschfteerfordertenPrsenzanverschiedenenOrten.EsisteherseinSohn
Albrecht, 1298 nach dem Konflikt mit Adolf von Nassau selbst zum Knig gewhlt, der Wien als
neuenMittelpunktderDynastieaufgebauthat.
ISBN9789460184833
17
Es stellt sich nun die Frage, welche Orte in den vorlndischen Stammlanden mit allenfalls
residenziellenFunktionenbestehenblieben.DieUntersuchungdernachfolgendenPeriodebiszum
Beginndes15.Jahrhundertszeigt,dassdiesstarkvonderinnerfamilirenKonstellationabhing,das
heisst,obundwennjawelcherFamilienzweigdievorlndischenBesitzungenbeherrschte.

BruggundKnigsfeldenalszeitweiligesGravitationszentrum
KurznachdemTodevonHerzogRudolfII.imFrhling1290wurdeseinSohnJohanngeboren.Die
WitweundjungeMutterAgnesvonBhmenhieltsichzudieserZeitimaltenHabsburgerstdtchen
Brugg auf. Hier hatte die Familie wahrscheinlich zu Beginn des 13. Jahrhunderts gleichzeitig mit
GrndungundAufbauderStadteineStadtburggebaut.Die StadtundeineBrckeentstandenam
Engnis der Aare einige hundert Meter flussabwrts der Burgstelle Altenburg, die in den Mauern
eines rmischen Kastells entstanden war. Der Stifter von Ottmarsheim, Rudolf, wird in den Acta
Murensia mit dem Zunamen von Altenburg benannt. Der Raum sdlich der Aare, das spter
Eigenamt genannte Gebiet zu Fssen der Habsburg selbst, wird alter Besitz der Dynastie gewesen
sein.DieserBesitzwarTeildesvonHerzogRudolfindieEhemitAgnesvonBhmeneingebrachten
Eheguts. Die Brugger Stadtburg erfllte deshalb kurzzeitig eine Funktion als Residenz. Allerdings
befandsichdieWitwegegenberihrenSchwgernineinerprekrenSituationundkehrtedennauch
1295nachPragzurck,wosiekurzeZeitspterverstarb.13

Abb. 8 Das Habsburger Stadtschloss in Brugg. Lithographie vor dem
Abbruch 1864. 12901295 Residenz der Agnes von Bhmen, Witwe von
HerzogRudolf.HerzogLeopoldIII.verkauftedasfesteHausimJahr1383
anseinenDienstmannFriedrichEffinger.
InSichtweitedeStadtmauernvonBruggfandauchdaseinschneidendeEreignisstatt,dasdie
Geschichte der Dynastie in den folgenden Jahrzehnten entscheidend prgen sollte: der Mord an
KnigAlbrechtI.AlbrechtwarnachdemTodseinesVatersimSommer1291nichtalsNachfolgerim
Reich gewhlt worden. Er arrangierte sich vorerst mit dem neuen Knig Adolf von Nassau. In den
folgenden Jahren spitzten sich die Konflikte zwischen dem Habsburger und dem Knig einerseits,
und den Reichsfrstenandererseitszu.DieFrsten setztenAdolfvonNassauimJuni1298abund
ISBN9789460184833
18
whlten an seiner Stelle Albrecht von Habsburgsterreich. In der Schlacht bei Gllheim in der
nrdlichenPfalzsetztesichderHabsburgerdurch,seinKontrahentkamum.Albrechtkonntesichin
denfolgendenJahrenalsKnigerfolgreichetablieren.UndersetztedieHeiratspolitikseinesVaters
fort. Mit Verbindungen nach Bhmen, Ungarn, Savoyen und gar Aragon knpften er und seine
KinderdasNetzerfolgreichweiter.14
EinKonfliktmitseinenNeffenJohann,demSohnderAgnesvonBhmen,erwiessichaber
als verhngnisvoll. Herzog Johann hatte, kaum volljhrig geworden, Anteil am Erbe beansprucht,
mglicherweiseAnsprcheandasHerzogtumSchwaben,dasdurchseinenfrhverstorbenenVater
htte wieder aufgebaut werden sollen, mindestens aber Ansprche an die vorlndischen
Besitzungen,EhegutseinerMutter.AlbrechtscheintihmdieHerausgabediesesErbteilsverweigert
zuhaben,einletztesMalaneinemHoftaginBadenam30.April1308.AmFolgetag,alsdasGefolge
in Richtung Rheinfelden loszog, wo sich Albrechts Gattin Elisabeth von GrzTirol aufhielt, berfiel
Herzog Johann mit einer kleinen Gruppe von Verschwrern den vorausreitenden Knig nach dem
bergangberdieReussaufderHhedesehemaligenrmischenLegionslagersVindonissa.
Der Mord an Albrecht war eine familire Katastrophe und beeintrchtigte die Ambitionen
derHabsburgeraufdenKnigstitelauflangeZeit.DieGegenknigswahlvonHerzogFriedrichdem
Schnen 1314 scheiterte und die Dynastie erlangte erst 1437 wieder die Knigswrde, dann aber
nachhaltigundauflangeZeit.

Abb.9DieDarstellungdesMordesanKnig
AlbrechtI.am1.Mai1308beiBrugg.Linker
HanddieStadtBaden,ausderdas
kniglicheGefolgelosreitet.InderMitte
derbergangberdieReuss.Rechts
anschliessenddieMordszene,im
HintergrundfliehendieMrder,im
VordergrundstirbtderKnigindenArmen
desBischofsvonStrassburg.RechterHand
dieStadtBrugg,aufderAnhheim
HintergrunddieHabsburg.Kolorierte
ZeichnungausdemEhrenspiegeldes
ErzhausessterreichvonJohannJacob
Fugger,1555.

Am Ort der Ermordung stiftete die Witwe zusammen mit ihren Kindern ein Doppelkloster:
Knigsfelden.UntermassgeblicherFrderungvonElisabethvonGrzTirolundihrerTochterAgnes,
Witwe des schon 1301 verstorbenen Knigs Andreas III. von Ungarn, entstand in den folgenden
JahrenundJahrzehnteneinreichausgestatterFranziskanerundKlarissenkonvent.Knigsfeldenwar
in den Anfngen nicht nur Memoria fr die Ermordung Albrechts, sondern auch wichtiger
Begrbnisort fr die Familie. Neben der 1313 verstorbenen Witwe Elisabeth wurden auch die
Tochter Agnes, die Shne Leopold I. und Heinrich und einige weitere Verwandte in Knigsfelden
ISBN9789460184833
19
begraben; schliesslich auch Herzog Leopold III. nach seinem Schlachtentod bei Sempach.15 Das
Klosterentwickeltesichfretwa50JahrezureigentlichenvorlndischenResidenzderHabsburger,
daAgnesvonUngarn1316/17dortWohnsitznahm,ohneindenOrdeneinzutreten.Sieprgtebiszu
ihremTod1364diePolitikderFamiliestark.

Abb.10DieKlosterkircheKnigsfeldenvonSden.AmSeitenschiffangebautdieberrestedes
KlarissenKreuzgangs,rechterHandnocherhalteneGebudeteiledesFrauenkonvents.Das
KlosteristinderReformation1528aufgehobenwordenunddientealsbernischeLandvogtei.
GrosseTeilederKonventgebudewurdenim19.Jahrhundertabgebrochen.
AgnesvonUngarnflltewhrendeinigerZeitdieRolleeinerMaterfamiliasaus,vorallem
indenerstenJahren,alsihreBrderteilsnochminderjhrigwaren.SiewaraufsBestevernetztmit
demKnigshofundderKurieinRom.IndenKonfliktenmitdersichausbildendenEidgenossenschaft
vertrat sie einerseits die Interessen ihrer Familie, andrerseits spielte sie zumindest bis etwa 1350
auch die Rolle als Vermittlerin in verschiedenen Konflikten zwischen den eidgenssischen Stdten
und Lndern und dem Adel.16 Allerdings begannen sich die Machtverhltnisse seit den 1350er
Jahren, vor allem im Konflikt mit der Stadt Zrich, gegen die Habsburger zu wenden. Die
eidgenssischen Lnder der Innerschweiz begannen, sich mit den Reichsstdten des Mittellandes
(BernundZrich)zuverbndenunderlangtensoeineStrke,diedenhabsburgischenLandesherren
gefhrlich werden konnte. Agnes Bruder, Herzog Albrecht II., zeigte sich whrend 14 Jahren nicht
mehrimWesten.SeineInterventioninZrichzusammenmitKnigKarlIV.imJahr1353/54warnur
teilweiseerfolgreich.17KarlIV.sollindiesemJahrAgnesvonUngarninKngisfeldeneinen Besuch
abgestattet haben. Die beiden Familien waren ber eine Heirat der Knigstochter Katharina mit
HerzogRudolfIV.inVerbindunggetreten.
Im Bildprogramm der teilweise erhaltenen Glasmalereien von Knigsfelden schuf Agnes
einen eigentlichen Memorialort fr die Dynastie, einerseits im heilsgeschichtlich ausgerichteten
ProgrammdesChors(bisum1340),andrerseitsineinemdynastischaufgebautenScheibenzyklusim
ISBN9789460184833
20
LanghausderKirche(bisum1360).VondiesemScheibensindallerdingsnurwenigeberliefert.Die
Stifterscheiben von Elisabeth und Agnes sind indirekt ber die Zeichnungen im Habsburger
Ehrenspiegelvon1555berliefert.18

Abb.11StifterbildderAgnesvonUngarnnachdem
VorbildderGlasscheibenimdynastischenZyklus
vonKnigsfelden,um1360.Zeichnungim
EhrenspiegeldesErzhausessterreichvonJohann
JacobFugger1555.

Abb.12DiebisheuteerhaltenenStifterbildervonKnig
RudolfvonBhmen(links)undHerzogAlbrechtII.Aus
demdynastischenScheibenzyklusinKnigsfelden,um
1360.
Im Umfeld von Knigsfelden scheinen Agnes und ihre Brder zumindest in Anstzen ein
Residenzprojekt vorangetrieben zu haben: den Ausbau der Lenzburg. Die Stammfeste der 1173
ausgestorbenen Grafen von Lenzburg war mit dem Kyburger Erbe nach 1264 an die Habsburger
gelangt. Knig Rudolf I. hielt 1275 auf der Burg einen Hoftag ab. Die mchtige Hhenburg ist bis
heuteeinmarkantesSymboladligerSelbstdarstellungimAargau.InderZeitum1335/1340liessen
dieHabsburgereinenmarkantenNeubauerstellen,dasRitterhaus.DergrossrumigePalasbaumit
zwei bereinanderliegenden Slen von ber 20 Metern Lnge und ber 10 Metern Breite
beeindrucktbisheute.MglicherweisewarderBaualsResidenzfrHerzogFriedrichII.,demSohn
des Otto, vorgesehen, der vor 1339 der letzte mnnliche Vertreter der Enkelgeneration von Knig
AlbrechtI.war.FrFriedrichwareinEheprojektmitJohanna,TochterdesenglischenKnigsEduard
III. geplant. Das Ehegut von Friedrich wird dabei, wie schon einige Jahrzehnte zuvor, aus dem
vorlndischenBesitzderHabsburgerbestandenhaben.DieLenzburgwredazudiereprsentative
Residenz gewesen. Der Bau wurde vollendet, allerdings scheiterte das Eheprojekt und Friedrich
verstarbbereits1344.19
ISBN9789460184833
21
NachdemHerzogAlbrechtII.undseineGattinJohannavonPfirtnach15kinderlosenJahren
mit Rudolf 1339 endlich einen Nachkommen bekommen hatten, war der Fortbestand des
Geschlechtswiedergarantiert.

Abb. 14 Rekonstruierter Baubestand der Lenzburg in der Mitte
des14.JahrhundertsmitdemmchtigenPalasbau.

Abb.13DieLenzburgheute:linkerHandderRitter
hausausderZeitum1340,rechterHanddieBurgder
Lenzburgerausdem11.und12.Jahrhundert.

Abb.15Rekonstruktionsversuchdesunteren,
kleinerenRittersaalsaufderLenzburgmitder
sptgotischenFensterfront.DerSaalerinnertin
seinerGrsseundAusgestaltungandennurnoch
ruinserhaltenenRittersaalderOrtenburgim
ElsassausderZeitum1265(Zeichnung:Ruth
Baur).

ISBN9789460184833
22
KeineResidenzenmehr,nurnochVerwaltungssitze
Seit der Zeit um 1300 hatten die Habsburger die Verwaltungskompetenzen der Vorlande auf dem
LandvogteisitzinBadenkonzentriert,nichtweitvonBruggundKnigsfeldengelegen.Diehochber
derStadtgelegeneBurgStein,fastinSichtweitederReichsstadtZrich,warSitzdesLandvogtsim
Aargau, zeitweise wurden von hier aus auch das Elsass und der Schwarzwald regiert. Die
vorlndischen Landvgte gehrten zur Spitzengruppe der habsburgischen Dienstleute und hatten,
vor allem nach dem Tod der Agens von Ungarn 1364, eine grosse Bedeutung, da whrend des
ganzen14.JahrhundertsdieHerzgesichseltenimWestenaufhielten.RudolfIV.scheintalsjunger
Mann zeitweise unter den Fittichen seiner Tante Agnes gestanden zu haben, aber erst Herzog
Leopold III. entfaltete wieder grssere Aktivitten in den Vorlanden. Die Stadt Baden eignete sich
speziell als zumindest kleine Residenzstadt, da seit dem 13. Jahrhundert die Bder wieder instand
gesetzt worden waren und sich zum wichtigsten Badekurort im Raum der spteren Schweiz
entwickelthatten.DasAngebotanGasthfenundGstebettenwargrossunddasgesellschaftliche
LebenderBderbotauchfrdiePolitikeingutesUmfeld.
Der1351geboreneLeopoldIII.hattemitdemHausvertragvon1364bereitsinjungenJahren
dieVerantwortunginKrain,imTirolundindenVorlandenbernommen.Erresidiertenachseiner
HeiratmitViridisViscontiausMailand1368vorerstaufderBurgTirolbeiMeran.Erentfaltetevon
dortauseineaktivePolitiksowohlimSdeninRichtungAdriawieauchimWestenamRhein.1368
begab sich Freiburg im Breisgau unter habsburgischen Schutz, 1375 sicherte sich Leopold das
MontforterErbeinVorarlberg(Feldkirch),1381dieGrafschaftHohenbergamOberlaufdesNeckar.
Neben seiner Italienpolitk stand in den folgenden Jahren Basel im Mittelpunkt, gut 100 Jahre
nachdem bereits sein Urgrossvater Rudolf sich um die Stadt bemht hatte. Die Habsburger waren
seit 1330 mit dem Erwerb von Schaffhausen, Rheinfelden, Breisach, Neuenburg am Rhein,
Laufenburg und Freiburg im Breisgau am Ober und Hochrhein zur beherrschenden Macht
geworden. Die mittendrin gelegene Stadt Basel stand in einem schweren Konflikt mit dem Bischof
alsStadtherrn.HerzogLeopoldIII.nutztedieseKonstellation,konnte1375Kleinbaselgewinnenund
erhielteinJahrsptervonKnigWenzeldieReichsvogteiberdieStadt.
Nach einem schweren Konflikt mit den Basler Stadtbrgern an der sogenannten bsen
Fasnacht in Basel im Januar 1376 verhngte der Knig die Reichsacht ber Basel. Der Habsburger
stand kurz davor, die Stadt in seinen Machtbereich eingliedern zu knnen: ein idealer Residenzort
fr die seine vorlndischen Besitzungen. Allerdings vernderte sich die Situation in den folgenden
Jahrendramatisch.LeopoldsetztebeiderBischofswahlinBasel1382aufdenfalschenKandidaten
undverlordenRckhaltbeimKnig.DieNeuKyburger,seineVerwandtenimRaumBern,dieunter
seinerLehensherrschaftstanden,beganneneinenKonfliktmitderReichsstadtBernundmusstenin
derFolge1384ihrenBesitzderStadtBernunterDruckverkaufen.UndeinJahrspterbeganndie
Stadt Luzern, de jure noch habsburgische Landstadt, de facto Teil der eidgenssischen Bnde,
aggressiv in das noch habsburgisch beherrschte Umland auszugreifen. Herzog Leopold musste
reagieren,umeinem
ISBN9789460184833
23
ZusammenbruchseinerHerrschaftsdlichdesRheinsvorzubeugen.Ersammelteseinevorlndische
undtirolischeAnhngerschaftundverlorimJuli1386gegendieEidgenossenSchlachtundLebenbei
Sempach. Das Kloster Knigsfelden wurde zum zweiten Mal Memorialort fr einen toten
Habsburger.LeopoldundseineengstenMitstreiterwurdeninderKlosterkirchebeigesetzt.20

Abb. 16 Die Ruine der 1415 zerstrten Burg Stein im Zustand der
erstenHlftedes17.Jahrhunderts,vordemWiederaufbaudurchdie
Stadt Baden. Zeichnung von Johann Rudolf Rahn nach einem
Altargemlde aus dem Kapuzinerkloster, um 1650. Linker Hand
sichtbarderursprnglichePalasbau.

Abb. 17 Die berreste der 1712 ein zweites Mal
zerstrten Burg Stein im Weichbild der
StadtsilhouettevonBaden.
DerAnfangvomEndeimAargau
Die Katastrophe vom Sempach war ein schwerer Einschnitt fr die Dynastie. Leopolds Bruder
Albrecht III. reiste in den Westen und versuchte zu retten, was zu retten war, mit wenig Erfolg.
Luzern war verloren, die Blte des vorlndischen Adels bei Sempach umgekommen. 1393 erfolgte
einFriedensschlussauf20Jahre.IndenfolgendenJahrenwardieFamiliewiederkaumprsentim
Westen, die innerdynastischen Probleme verhinderten eine Rckgewinnung des Verlorenen.
Leopold IV. war zeitweise im Westen, seine Gattin Katharina von Burgund residierte auf der
EngelsburginThannimElsass,demVerwaltungszentrumimSundgau.DassptgotischeMnstervon
Thann verdankt den beiden grosszgige Frderung. Leopolds Bruder Friedrich IV. bernahm
schliesslichdefinitivab1406dieRegentschaftinTirolundindenVorlanden.Erresidierteabermeist
in Innsbruck. Die Parteinahme fr das Kloster St. Gallen in den sogenannten Appenzellerkriegen
brachte seine Herrschaft in der Ostschweiz und in Vorarlberg zeitweise schwer ins Wanken. Und
schliesslich fhrte sein Konflikt mit Knig Sigmund am Konzil von Konstanz 1415 zum
Zusammenbruch der vorlndischen Herrschaft. Der Knig hatte die Reichsacht ber Friedrich
verhngt,nachdemdieseraufdenGegenpapstJohannesXXIII.gesetzthatte.
ISBN9789460184833
24
DieKonkurrentenFriedrichs,dieBischfevonChur,BrixenundTrient,dieAdligenanHoch
und Alpenrhein sowie die eidgenssischen Stdte und Lnder brachten die Herrschaft des
HabsburgersjenseitsdesArlbergsinkurzerZeitzumEinsturz.Friedrichkonntezwarbis1425,dem
endgltigen Friedensschluss mit dem Knig, den grssten Teil der Verluste zurckgewinnen. Auch
einen Reichskrieg Sigmunds gegen Tirol konnte er abwehren. Die Besitzungen im Aargau blieben
aberverloren.DieStdteBernundZrichlstendieReichspfandschaft1418ausundverweigerten
eine Rckgabe. Damit hatten die Habsburger ihre alten zentralen Orte aus der Frhzeit ihrer
Geschichte verloren: Baden, Brugg, die Lenzburg und auch die Habsburg selbst. Der symbolisch
schwersteVerlustwardasKlosterKnigsfelden,GrabstttederFamilie.Wiedergewinnungsversuche
schlugenfehl.KnigFriedrichIII.reistezwar1442aufseinerKrnungsreisedemonstrativdurchdie
EidgenossenschaftundbesuchteKnigsfelden,esbliebaberbeiderSymbolik.SeinVetterSigmund
von Tirol verlor in den folgenden Jahren mit Freiburg im Uechtland und dem Thurgau die letzten
PositionensdlichdesRheins.AlleindiesogenanntenWaldstdteamRhein,Waldshut,Laufenburg,
Sckingen und Rheinfelden verblieben dem Habsburger, der 1474 vor dem Hintergrund der
BedrohungdurchKarl denKhnenvonBurgundeinenewigenFrieden mit derEidgenossenschaft
schloss.DerSchwabenoderSchweizerkriegMaximiliansmitdenEidgenossen1499ndertenichts
mehranderSituation.21

Abb.18DasRathausinRheinfeldenausden1530er
Jahren.DieInselburgSteinalsherrschaftlicherSitzwar
1446imKriegmitBaselgeschleiftworden.

Abb.19DerRegentenpalastdervordersterreichischen
RegierunginEnisheim,einRenaissancebauausderMitte
des16.Jahrhunderts.
Die verbliebenen Besitzungen im Elsass, im Breisgau, im Schwarzwald und in Schwaben
wurden vorerst von Ensisheim in der Nhe von Mlhausen aus verwaltet, nach dem Verlust des
ElsassanFrankreich1648vonFreiburgimBreisgauaus:dassogenannteVordersterreich,oderauch
dieSchwanzfederdesKaiseradlers,wieesim18.Jahrhundertgenanntwurde.22
ISBN9789460184833
25
Bibliographie
Baum, Wilhelm, Reichs und Territorialgewalt (12371473). Knigtum, Haus sterreich und
SchweizerEidgenossenimsptenMittelalter(Wien,1994).
Biller,Thomas,undMetz,Bernhard,DerfrhgotischeBurgenbauimElsass(12501300).DieBurgen
desElsass,BandIII(Mnchen,1995).
Frey, Peter, Die Habsburg im Aargau. Bericht ber die Ausgrabungen von 197883, Argovia, 98
(1986),pp.90108.
Frey, Peter, Die Habsburg. Bericht ber die Ausgrabungen von 1994/95, Argovia, 109 (1998), pp.
12375.
Frey, Peter, Die baugeschichtliche Untersuchung und Konservierung der Ruine Stein in Baden,
BadenerNeujahrsbltter,78(Baden,2002),pp.13038.
Frey,Peter,DieLenzburg,eineResidenzderHabsburger,Argovia,120(2008),pp.15666.
Krieger,KarlFriedrich,DieHabsburgerimMittelalter.VonRudolfI.bisFriedrichIII(Stuttgart,1994).
Krieger,KarlFriedrich,RudolfvonHabsburg(Darmstadt,2003).
KurmannSchwarz, Brigitte, Die mittelalterlichen Glasmalereien der ehemaligen Klosterkirche
Knigsfelden(CorpusVitrearumMediiAeviSchweiz,II),(Bern,2008).
Lauro,Brigitte,DieGrabstttenderHabsburger,KunstdenkmlereinereuropischenDynastie(Wien,
2007).
Meier, Bruno, Ein Knigshaus aus der Schweiz. Die Habsburger, der Aargau und die
EidgenossenschaftimMittelalter(Baden,2008).
Meier,Bruno,DasKlosterMuri.GeschichteundGegenwartderBenediktinerabtei(Baden,2011).
Niedersttter, Alois, sterreichische Geschichte 12781411. Die Herrschaft sterreich. Frst und
LandimSptmittelalter(Wien,2001).
Rauschert, Jeannette; Teuscher, Simon, und Zotz Thomas, Habsburger Herrschaft vor Ort weltweit
(13001600)(Ostfildern,2013)
Rck,Peter,undKoller,Heinrich(ed.),DieEidgenossenundihreNachbarnimdeutschenReichdes
Mittelalters(Marburg,1991).
Sieber,Christian,undBretscher,Charlotte(ed.),ActaMurensia.DieAktendesKlostersMurimitder
GenealogiederfrhenHabsburger(Basel,2012).
Speck,Dieter,KleineGeschichteVordersterreichs(LeinfeldenEchterdingen,2010).
ISBN9789460184833
26
Teuscher, Simon, und Moddelmog, Claudia, Knigsfelden. Knigsmord, Kloster und Klinik (Baden,
2012).
Wrner,HansJakob,undWrner,JudithOttilie,KunstfhrerAbteikircheOttmarsheim(Lindenberg,
2006).
Wrttembergisches Landesmuseum Stuttgart (ed.), Vordersterreich, nur die Schwanzfeder des
Kaiseradlers?DieHabsburgerimdeutschenSdwesten(Stuttgart,1999).
Abbildungen
Abb.3,4,5,13,17,18,19:FotoAutor.
Abb.1,2,14,15:AargauerKantonsarchologie.
Abb.6,7:Biller/Metz1995.
Abb.8,9,12:AargauerDenkmalpflege.
Abb.9,11:Wien,sterreichischeNationalbilbiothek.
Abb.16:ZentralbibliothekZrich.

1
GrundlagedesArtikelsistmeinBuchberdieHabsburgerimMittelalter:Meier2008.AllgemeinzurDynastie
siehe Krieger 1994. Verschiedene Aspekte aus der neuesten Forschung siehe: Rauschert et.al., 2013,
insbesonderedieBeitrgevonThomasZotz,AloisNiedersttterundundMartinaStercken.
2
SiehedazudieNeueditionvonSieberu.Bretscher2012.
3
Frey1986,Frey1998.
4
Meier2008,pp.1134.
5
Wrner2006,p.30.
6
Meier2011,p.17,103f.
7
Krieger2003,pp.1832.
8
Billeru.Metz1995.
9
Zotz,Thomas,ZentrenundPeripheriendeshabsburgischenImperiums,in:Rauschertet.al.2013,pp.23.
10
11
12
Meier2008,p.9f.
13
Meier2008,p.95f.
14
Zum Knigsmord, Stiftung und Aufbau von Knigsfelden siehe die neuesten Forschungen in Teuscher u.
Moddelmog2012,insbesonderederersteArtikelvonTobiasHodel,pp.1147.
15
Lauro2007,pp.24047.
16
EntgegenderAnsichtvonAndreasBihrer;sieheBihrer,Andreas,ZwischenWienundKnigsfelden.Die
KirchenpolitikderHabsburgerindenvorderenLandenim14.Jhahrundert,in:Rauschertet.al.2013,besonders
pp.124133.
17
Meier2008,pp.11036.
18
ZudenGlasgemldenvonKnigsfeldensieheKurmannSchwarz2008.
19
Frey2008.
20
Meier2008,pp.13752.
21
Meier2008,pp.156213.
22
Zur Geschichte Vordersterreichs siehe den materialreichen Sammelband Vordersterreich 1999 sowie
Speck2010.
ISBN9789460184833
27
BausteineeinesResidenzprojekts
KaiserMaximilianI.inInnsbruck

NicoleRiegel

InnsbruckgehrtzudenltestenhabsburgischenHfen,gewannjedocherstunterMaximilianI.den
Status einer kniglichen und schlielich kaiserlichen Residenz (Abb. 1). In den beiden Jahrzehnten
nachseinerRegierungsbernahmeinTirol1490widmeteMaximilianeinenGroteilseinerbaulichen
AktivittenderStadtunddemHofInnsbruck.DiesebetrafendieHofburgselbst,denNeuhofmitdem
GoldenenDachl,denWappenturmmitdersdlichanschlieendenuerenBurgunddasZeughaus
Manahmen, die funktional, fortifikatorisch und insbesondere im Hinblick auf Zeremoniell und
Reprsentation miteinander verbunden sind und deshalb nicht getrennt voneinander betrachtet,
sondern auf ihre Zusammenhnge und urbanistischen Implikationen befragt werden sollen. Der
folgendeBeitragverstehtsichalsVorberichteinesumfangreicherenUntersuchungsprojekts,weshalb
dieFunotenaufeinMinimumbeschrnktwurden.

Abb.1AlbrechtDrer,InnsbruckvonNorden,Wien,Albertina,Inv.3056.
Fr die kunsthistorische Erforschung der Bauttigkeit Maximilians in Innsbruck sind die
wichtigsten Grundlagen vor rund hundertzwanzig Jahren in den Regesten des Wiener Jahrbuchs
ISBN9789460184833
28

gelegtworden.11921gelangMorizDregerineinerakribischenAnalysederltestenGeschichteder
Innsbrucker Hofburg die Identifizierung der beiden Drerschen Hofansichten (Abb. 23).2 Dieser
Aufsatz blieb das Fundament jeder weiteren Untersuchung, etwa der erhellenden Beobachtungen
Patrick Werkners im Tiroler Burgenbuch ebenso wie der umfassenden Dokumentation von Ricarda
Oettinger in der sterreichischen Kunsttopographie.3 Hinzu kamen in jngster Zeit die
UntersuchungenvonLieselotteHanzlWachterzuBauundAusstattunginmariatheresianischerZeit
sowiediemonographischangelegteGeschichtederHofburgvonBenediktSauer.4DemHoflebenund
denAnstzeneiner Residenzbildung MaximiliansinInnsbruck hatsich die Forschungvorallemvon
historischer und kulturhistorischer Warte gewidmet, vertreten durch Anneliese Gatt, Monika Fritz
sowiezuletztIngeborgWiesfleckerFriedhuberundManfredHollegger.5

Abb.2AlbrechtDrer,BurghofinInnsbruckgegen
Sden,Wien,Albertina,Inv.3057.

Abb.3AlbrechtDrer,BurghofinInnsbruckgegen
Norden,Wien,Albertina,Inv.3058.
VonkunsthistorischerSeitebliebendieseAnregungenweitgehendunbeantwortet.6Zwarhat
DregerbedeutendeErkenntnissezurrelativenBauchronologiegewonnen,dochwederistbislangdie
Entstehungsgeschichte detailliert errtert noch durch die Methoden der Bauforschung hinreichend
geprft. ber die Funktionen konnte vielfach nur gemutmat oder an Legenden entlanggearbeitet
werden. Eine systematische Untersuchung von Reise und Gesandtenberichten im Hinblick auf die
funktionale Struktur der Innsbrucker Hofburg selbst sowie auf eine auch zeremoniell bedingte
RelationzuanderenFixpunkteninderStadtwiedemGoldenenDachlundderPfarrkirchestehtvllig
aus. Genausowenig hat man sich bisher der Frage gewidmet, wie sich die Residenz des Kaisers im
internationalen Rahmen eigentlich ausnimmt. Ihr kunsthistorischer Rang ist kaum einmal
thematisiert worden. berlegungen zur Semiotik maximilianischer Architektur in Innsbruck
konzentriertensichaufdenWappenturmunddasGoldeneDachl,jedochnichtaufdasEnsembleim
ISBN9789460184833
29

urbanistischenKontext.7Unddies,obwohlschonKoschatzkyaufdietreffende,wennauchzugleich
topische Charakterisierung Martin Luthers hingewiesen hat: Inspruck parva est, sed aequalibus
aedificiis composita, ac si esset una continua domus [Innsbruck sei klein, aber durch gleichartige
Gebudesogefgt,alswreeseineinzigesausgedehntesHaus].8

Abb.4Innsbruck,StadtplanmitAndechsischerBurg(1),Neuhof(2)undMitterhof(3).

Versuchen wir zunchst eine Revision der Fakten. In Innsbruck ist mit Baumanahmen
Maximilians naturgem erst nach der Abdankung Erzherzog Sigmunds am 16. Mrz 1490 und
Maximilians Regierungsbernahme in Tirol zu rechnen.9 Der auerordentlich baufreudige Sigmund
hatte am Beginn seiner Regentschaft 1446 noch die alte andechsische Burg an der Innbrcke
bezogen, ab Ende der fnfziger Jahre aber sowohl den Neuhof mitten in der Stadt als auch den
damals als Mitterhof bezeichneten Komplex an der Ostflanke der Stadtmauer durch Erwerbungen
undBaumanahmenvergrertundindiesemMitterhof,derspterenHofburg,auchgewohnt(Abb.
4).10Dasheit,MaximilianbernahmmitInnsbruck1490bereitseinebetrchtlicheunddazurezent
erweiterte Bausubstanz, die die Hauptadern der Stadt kontrollierte eine gute Grundlage, um die
erzherzoglicheineinekniglicheResidenzzuverwandeln.WannMaximiliandieseAufgabeinAngriff
nahm, ist unsicher, doch mu in der Hofburg schon bald nach 1490, sptestens 1492 mit einem
neuen Frauenzimmerbau begonnen worden sein, den Drer um 1495/96 als uerlich
abgeschlossenenBauzeichnenkonnte(Abb.3).11WenigeTage,nachdemBiancaMariaSforzaam23.
Dezember1493inInnsbruckeingetroffenwar,schriebsienachFerrara,dieBurggefalleihrsehrgut,
undsieglaubenicht,dasielterseialsfnfJahre.12ObdieKniginbeiihrerAnkunftinInnsbruck
ein wohlvorbereitetes Logis beziehen konnte, ist damit nicht gesagt. Der Gemahl lie bekanntlich
einige Zeit auf sich warten, die Hochzeit fand erst am 16. Mrz 1494 statt.13 Mitte Januar war bei
ISBN9789460184833
30

einem Brand das Saggentor zuschaden gekommen, was man in der Folge zum Anla nahm, den
Wappenturm davorzusetzen, der laut Bauinschrift am sdstlichen Eckerker 1496 kurz vor dem
Abschlustand.14
AnfangMrz1496starbSigmund,seineWitweverheiratetesichnochimselbenJahrneu,so
da der von Sigmund als Alterssitz genutzte Neuhof fr Maximilian verfgbar wurde.15 Der Knig
unternahmhierzweierlei:ZumeinenfunktionierteerdieStadtresidenzineinenVerwaltungsbaumit
groem Archiv fr die Hofkammer um, zum anderen setzte er an der Fassade mit dem Prunkerker
desGoldenenDachlseinenfernwirksamenAkzent.16DiedendrochronologischeUntersuchungergab
frdiehierverwendetenHlzereineFllzeitimWinter1497/98,dieAusmalungistinschriftlich1500
datiert.ImselbenJahrwurdeauchdasvergoldeteKupferdachbezahlt.17Paralleldazu,imMai1498,
beauftragte Maximilian Hofmaler Klderer, sein stblin in unserm neuen frauenzimmer
auszumalen, d.h. er bemhte sich um eine ergnzende Ausstattung der Wohnrume in der
Hofburg.18VonMitteSeptember1500datierteineVereinbarung,ausderhervorgeht,daMaximilian
mittelfristigeinenUmbauderHofburgplantezumindestgaberdiesvor.19Aucherfahrenwir,da
er ein Bad auf dem Inn, wohl in Flunhe, besa.20 Im Dezember sollten, wie so oft, im Auftrag
Maximilians Truhen in der Burg gesucht und umgerumt werden: Aus der stubn, darinn die
junkfrawengewesenseinsollteneinigeinzweikleinereGewlbe,andereindasgewelbimnewen
pawtransferiertwerden.WelcherneueBaugemeintist,bleibtoffen.21
Aus dem Jahr 1500 besitzen wir auch erste Hinweise auf die Errichtung des neuen
Zeughauses im Osten der Stadt an der Sill, das eine Erweiterung und Neustrukturierung des
Geschtzbestandes, der bis dahin in der alten andechsischen Burg am Inn und partiell
mglicherweise auch im schon 1465 erwhnten Harnaschhaus sdlich der Hofburg aufbewahrt
worden war, erlaubte.22 Auf eine geplante Neuverwendung dieses Harnaschhauses deutet unter
anderemdievonMaximilian1503verfgteErwerbungbenachbarterBauten,desHufschmiedhauses
und des Goldschmiedhauses, zugunsten einer Neugestaltung, mit der das unmittelbare
architektonische Umfeld der Burg gebessert werden sollte. Maximilian verlangte in diesem
Zusammenhang, was sehr charakteristisch ist, die Einrichtung einer fr ihn vom Harnaschhaus aus
zugnglichen Drechselstube mit kaminbeheizter Kammer.23 In den Kontext dieser Vernderungen
beimHarnaschhausgehrtdie1505datierteillusionistischeFassadenmalerei,dieehemalsberdie
Stadtmauer hinweg sichtbar, sich im Inneren des Stiftskellers fragmentarisch erhalten hat.24 1506
war der neue Hofplattnereibau in der Neustadt begonnen, in dessen Obergescho ein Saal zur
Ausstellung der Harnische dienen sollte.25 Etwa gleichzeitig dachte Maximilian an eine Verlegung
seinesInnsbruckerMarstalls.26
Ab1507wirddasehemaligeHarnaschhausalsWappenhausbezeichnet,wenigstenshatdies
die Forschung immer so verstanden.27 Ende Mrz legte Klderer eine Aufstellung seiner aktuellen
Arbeiten vor, darunter zwo visierung gemacht zu dem newen paw bey dem wappenhaws sowie
drey visierung zu kn. mt. capellen zu hof.28 Die ihm bertragene Ausstattung des Wappenhauses,
insbesondere der Gehrnstube, sowie die Neuausmalung der Hofkapelle standen also noch aus.
1508/09 scheint der an die Kaiserproklamation in Trient sich anschlieende Venezianerkrieg
MaximilianinAtemgehaltenzuhaben,29dochimMrz1510wurdedamitbegonnen,denlangenSaal
zwischenParadeisundNeuemBauzuerhhenundumzugestalten.30ImselbenJahrwurdenauchim
NeuhofeinigeRumegewlbtzwecksAufnahmedesArchivsderRaitkammer.31InderSilvesternacht
ISBN9789460184833
31

1510 auf '11 starb Bianca Maria Sforza,32 und damit scheint auch Maximilians Bauttigkeit in
Innsbruck weitgehend erloschen zu sein. Als nach der habsburgischjagiellonischen Doppelhochzeit
diebeidenBruteAnnaundMariaeinigeJahreinderInnsbruckerHofburgverbrachten,kameszu
Reparaturen und Nachbesserungen, nicht jedoch zu eingreifenden baulichen Vernderungen.33
Hieraus entsteht der Eindruck, da Maximilians Residenzprojekt fr Innsbruck an seine Ehe mit
BiancaMariaSforzaundderengemeinsameReprsentationspflichtengebundenwarundsichaufdie
knappzweiJahrzehntezwischen1490/92und1510begrenzte.Dementsprechenauchdienach1510
nur noch seltenen Aufenthalte des Kaisers, nmlich fr je drei Wochen im Sommer und im
November 1511, dann erst wieder im Januar 1514. Ein letzter lngerer Aufenthalt datiert von
September 1514 bis Mrz 1515. Krzere Prsenzen Maximilians sind noch im Sommer 1515
verzeichnet,gefolgtvonwenigenTagenimAugust1516.34DadieInnsbruckerMaximilianEndedes
Jahres1518dieAufnahmeverweigerthaben,isthinreichendbekannt.35
ZwischendenfrhenneunzigerJahrenund1510hingegenhatMaximiliandenAusbauseiner
Innsbrucker Residenz ber alle finanziellen Engpsse und andere Schwierigkeiten hinweg nicht nur
kontinuierlich betrieben, sondern auch systematisch. Zunchst ging es um neue Wohnrume und
wahrscheinlich einen halbwegs standesgemen Komfort in der Burg. Die Notwendigkeit zur
Erneuerung desSaggentorsnachdessenBrand1494drftedanndieAufmerksamkeitverstrktauf
die Auenerscheinung gelenkt haben: Nach dem Bau des Wappenturms ergab sich mit dem Tod
SigmundsdieGelegenheit,auchdenNeuhoffernwirksamzuakzentuieren Zuflle,diejedochmit
Bedacht genutzt wurden. Ab 1500 wurde das Zeughausprojekt realisiert und die uere Burg der
Reprsentation verstrkt einbezogen. Danach scheint man darangegangen zu sein, den noch
bestehenden sigmundischen Teil der Hofburg durch einen greren Saalbau zu ersetzen im Sinne
einerVereinheitlichungderOstfront.DieseletztePhasedrftebereitsimKontextderAnnahmedes
Kaisertitels zu verstehen sein. Bemerkenswert an diesen Manahmen ist zum einen, da der
Landesfrst an den drei prominentesten Punkten der Stadt nicht nur ansssig war, sondern da er
die entscheidenden Zugnge der Stadt und ihr Zentrum auch zeichenhaft besetzte, ja sie sogar in
ihrenFassadenmalereienmotivischzueinanderinBeziehungsetzte,zumandern,daerbemhtwar,
dieOstfront derStadt nachNordenundSdenfr seineResidenzweitmglichst zuvereinnahmen,
um damit dem von auen Kommenden die frstliche Herrschaft zu demonstrieren, aber auch um
grere Bauvolumina zu suggerieren, als sie tatschlich vorhanden waren. Hierin spricht sich ein
betrchtlichesurbanistischesBewutseinaus,frdasVergleichbaresimdeutschenSprachraumerst
zu finden wre.36 Selbstverstndlich wird Maximilian von der ab 1490 mit Mitteln der Urbanistik
betriebenen Inszenierung der Herrschaft der Sforza in Vigevano ber seine Mailnder Familie
erfahren haben:37 aber abgesehen davon, da sich hier keine formale, sondern allenfalls eine
prinzipielle Vergleichbarkeit konstatieren lt: lagen hier Maximilians Mastbe? Oder verstehen
sich die architektonischzeichenhaften Fixpunkte im Stadtbild eher als Antwort auf den Bedarf des
hfischenZeremoniellsbeiEmpfngenundfestlichenAnlssen?
ISBN9789460184833
32

Abb.5AugustinHirschvogel(attr.),VedutederInnsbruckerHofburgvonOsten,
Erlangen,GraphischeSammlungderUniversitt,Inv.B458.
DieseFragen,diehiernochunbeantwortetbleibenmssen,fhrenzurDiskussionderFunktion,die
imgegebenenRahmenaufdieHofburgselbstbeschrnktwerdenmu.MitdenbeidenHofansichten
derAlbertina,dieumoderkurznachderMittederneunzigerJahreentstandenseindrften(Abb.2
3),38sowiemiteinerAugustinHirschvogelzugeschriebenen,zwischen1525und1534gezeichneten
Vedute der Ostfront (Abb. 5) liegt uns eine sehr gute zeitgenssische Bilddokumentation vor,39 die
vor dem Hintergrund der Schriftquellen mit den im Vorfeld des mariatheresianischen Umbaus
angefertigtenGrundundAufrisseninBeziehungzusetzenist(Abb.610).40

Abb.6JohannMartinGumppd.J.,InnsbruckerHofburg,Grundri2.OG(Ausschnitt),Wien,Albertina,Inv.7549.

ISBN9789460184833
33

Abb.7ConstantinJohannWalter,InnsbruckerHofburg,LngsschnittdurchdenOsttrakt,
Innsbruck,MuseumFerdinandeum,AignerCodex,Bl.3

Abb.8Innsbruck,Hofburg,Grundri2.OGnachGumpp(N.Riegel).
Abb.9JohannMartinGumppd.J.,InnsbruckerHofburg,
Grundri1.OG,Wien,Albertina,Inv.7548.
Abb.10JohannMartinGumppd.J.,InnsbruckerHofburg,
GrundriEG,Wien,Albertina,Inv.7547.
ISBN9789460184833
34
DabeisindallerdingsVernderungeninden Geschohhenzu bercksichtigen.Schrift und

BildquellenlassenkeinenZweifeldaran,daMaximiliansfrhesteBauvornahme,dasFrauenzimmer,
die Ausdehnung der Hofburg bis zur Nordostecke der Stadtmauer durch einen mchtigen, nahezu
quadratischen Kopfbau fixierte, der die sigmundischen Bauten an Tiefe weit bertraf. Diesem
Kopfbau sdlich vorgelagert wurde ein kleiner Hof, an dessen Ostflanke eine dreiteilige Raumfolge
mit begleitendem Flur vermutlich ltere Bausubstanz integrierte, whrend an der Westseite ein
schmalerGangzurPfarrkircheundzumHaupthofderBurgfhrte.InDrersHofansicht(Abb.3)ragt
dasFrauenzimmermitseinemerkergeschmcktenFachwerkobergeschohinterdemQuergangdes
Hofeshervor,inderAuenansicht(Abb.5)schlieensichKopfbauundsdlichangrenzenderFlgel
zueinervonRundtrmengefatenErkerfassadezusammen.DerdengroenHofbegrenzendeGang
sttimOstenaufeineschmalezweirumigeEinheit,dieschonindenQuellenmaximilianischerZeit
als Paradeis bezeichnet wird.41 Ihr folgt gegen Sden der groe, seinerseits lteres integrierende
Saalbau.ImerstenObergescho(Abb.89)enthielterdienachauendurcheinenErkerartikulierte
Schlokapelle, im zweiten Obergescho den Hauptsaal, den Maximilian 1510 erhhen und neu
ausstattenlassenwollte(Abb.68).42DieVerbindungvonhierzumWappenturmstellteder1507so
genannteNeueBauher,undamWappenturmselbstliefeinGanghinberzumHarnaschhaus.43Ein
mit etwa 130 Metern Lnge gewaltiger Komplex, der vorwiegend auf seine Auenwirkung hin
orientiertwar.DemgegenberbliebdasInneredesHofgevierts,denunverkennbarenBemhungen
umGeschlossenheitzumTrotz,imWestabschnittvondisparater,jazuflligerErscheinung(Abb.23).
DievertikalenErschlieungswegesindmiteinigenFragezeichenbehaftet,zumalderpolygonaleTurm
imHofnichtalsTreppenturmangesprochenwerdenkann.44DochscheinteinegeradlufigeTreppe
vonhierwenigstensbisaufKapellenebenegefhrtzuhaben.DasFrauenzimmerhingegenerschlo
sich durch eine zweilufige Treppe vom kleineren Hof her. Auerdem fhrte eine kleine
WendeltreppevomhofbegrenzendenQuergangindaszweiteObergeschodesParadeis.
AufderGrundlagedieserBeobachtungenstellensichzunchstvorallemzweiFragen,dieim
gegebenenRahmennurhypothetischbeantwortetwerdenknnen:1.WashatesmitdemParadeis
nrdlichdesFestsaalsaufsich?2.WolagenundwieverteiltensichdieWohnrumevonKnigund
Knigin? Komplex ist die Frage nach dem Paradeis. Man hat die eher aus der christlichen
Sakralarchitektur gelufige Bezeichnung im Falle der Innsbrucker Hofburg durchwegs mit der
Ikonographie der Ausmalung durch Klderer erklrt: Denn 1548, als das Paradeis, das bei einem
Brand 1534 sehr gelitten hatte, nach altem Vorbild wiederhergestellt werden sollte, wurden ber
den Vertfelungen Paradiesesszenen an die Wand gemalt.45 Allerdings stie die Instruktion
Ferdinands I., sich in der Neuausstattung daran zu halten, wie die vormalen gewesen an
Schwierigkeiten, da, wie im Zusammenhang mit der Vertfelung geklagt wurde,niemand so gar
aigentlichwssend,wiedieselbiggewesenist.46DieDeckejedenfallssollteinderFolgemitplaneten
undfigurngeschmcktwerden.47berdieFunktiondesInnsbruckerParadeisistdamitfreilichnoch
nichts gesagt. Vor der Errichtung des Frauenzimmerbaus unter Maximilian drfte der zweirumige
BaukrperdenstlichenRepsentationstraktdesMitterhofsgegenNordenabgeschlossenhaben.Er
bestand ursprnglich aus hofseitiger Stube und feldseitiger Kammer und besa vielleicht schon
frhzeitigErkerzumHofebensowiezurRennwiese.48MittelseinerkleinenTreppenspindelverfgte
erbereinendirektenZugangauchzumWesttraktdesHofes,indembereitsdamalsunteranderem
die Kchen situiert gewesen sein knnten.49 Stephan Hoppe vermutete auf der Grundlage dieser
DispositioninderkompaktenbaulichenEinheitsehrplausibeldasehemaligeherzoglicheLogis.50
ISBN9789460184833
35

Mit den maximilianischen Erweiterungen der Hofburg nach Norden wurde sie hingegen zu
einer Art zentralem Scharnier im Burgzusammenhang, nmlich zwischen den vom groen Burghof
zugnglichen, gewissermaen ffentlichen Reprsentationsrumen und dem vom inneren Hof
erschlossenen Komplex, was eine Neuverwendung bedingte, die sich mit der Bezeichnung als
Paradeis verband. Denkbar wre unter diesen Voraussetzungen die Nutzung des dem Saal
benachbarten Raums als Tafel oder Trinkstube,51 beweisbar ist dies derzeit indes nicht. 1520 fand
hier der symbolische Vollzug der Ehe zwischen dem knftigen Erzherzog Ferdinand und Anna von
Bhmen und Ungarn statt.52 Raum und funktionstypologisch bleibt die Bezeichnung als Paradeis
bislang verschwommen, auch wenn zeitgenssisch eine Parallele bestand, die sogar im
KenntnishorizontMaximiliansgelegenhabendrfte:DennwieneueForschungenergebenhaben,53
lieBiancaMariasOnkel,derMailnderRegentLudovicoilMoro,inseinerNebenresidenzVigevano
ab 1492/93 unter Konsultation von Donato Bramante nicht nur die schon erwhnte weitlufige
Platzanlage gestalten, sondern auch das Kastell selbst modernisieren, etwa durch umfngliche
StallungenebensowiedurcheinendreiseitiggeschlossenenGartenhoffrseineGemahlinBeatrice
dEste. Die Wohnrume des Vigevaneser Frauenzimmers wurden auf diese Weise durch einen
Giardino pensile erweitert, der gegen Sden durch einen Loggienflgel, im Norden durch ein
Badehaus zur exklusiven Nutzung Beatrices abgeschlossen und, wie aus einem Bericht von 1550
hervorgeht,nuncupabaturnomineParadisi.Derreprsentative Sdflgelenthieltim Obergescho
einesiebenachsigeLoggia,darunter,aufGartenebene,einenSaalmitanliegenderKammer.54
Eine solche, in Vigevano mglicherweise auf antike Palastgrten anspielende Konstellation
lt sich fr die Innsbrucker Hofburg selbstverstndlich nicht rekonstruieren,55 doch bleibt
bemerkenswert, da das maximilianische Paradeis den vielleicht ebenfalls grtnerisch gestalteten
Inneren Burghof gegen Sden abschlo, und da es ber einen Gang mit dem Frauenzimmer
verbunden war. So gesehen mte es nicht berraschen, wenn das Innsbrucker Paradeis seinen
ungewhnlichenNameninhalbironischerAllusionaufdiesehrvielanspruchsvolleren,imUmfeldder
bersiedelungBiancaMariasnachInnsbruckrealisiertenManahmenLudovicoilMorosinVigevano
erhaltenhtteundinErmangelungeinerveritablenLoggiadelleDameentsprechendillusionistisch
ausgestattet worden wre.56 Doch gert man mit solchen berlegungen beim derzeitigen
KenntnisstandandieGrenzezurSpekulation.
Eine in der Funktionsfrage etwas hhere Indiziendichte liegt im Falle des Innsbrucker
Frauenzimmersvor.57ObgleichdieltesteQuelleineinerInstruktionMaximilians,auchunserstblin
in unserm neuen frauenzimmer zum tail zu malen besteht,58 hat die Forschung das Frauenzimmer
bzw.diehinterevergtterteBurg,wieesspteroftgenanntist,gernealseinzigundalleinfrdie
FrauenderHofhaltungreserviertenAbschnittderBurgangesehenundsich besondersgernederen
vermeintlich klsterliche Abgeschiedenheit vorgestellt.59 Die Tatsache, da es sich um den grten
undvorderSaalerhhung1510zweifellosprominentestenBaukrperderBurghandelt(Abb.3,8),
wurdedabeidurchwegsauerAchtgelassen.Undvorallem:WohatderKnigresidiert?Betrachtet
man die Burg aus der Perspektive des Zeichners der Erlanger Vedute (Abb. 5), so beantwortet sich
dieseFragedurchdieArchitekturspracheunddenaufgemaltenTirolerAdlernahezuvonselbst.60Wie
schon gesagt, schlieen sich in der Auenerscheinung das eigentliche Frauenzimmer mit dem
VerbindungsflgelzumParadeisoptischzusammen.DerFrauenzimmerbauselbstreichtetwabiszum
zweitenPolygonalerkervonNorden.BetrachtenwirdieAufteilungdiesesKopfbausvordenbarocken
Vernderungen (Abb. 610), so lagen ber einer gratgewlbten Tiefgeschohalle, deren
ISBN9789460184833
36

ursprngliche Funktion wir nicht kennen, und deren unregelmige Pfeilerstellungen die
Rcksichtnahme auf ltere Bestnde hier vermuten lassen (Abb. 1011), nicht wie heute drei,
sondern nur zwei Stockwerke sowie das Dachgescho.61 Die Etagen erschlossen sich ber die
erwhnte,sdlichvorgelagerteTreppeaminnerenHof.DerZugangvonhierauserfolgtebereinen
Mittelflur, an den sich links und rechts zwei nahezu identisch disponierte quadratische Rume
fgten.EtwaimZentrumdesBaustrafderMittelfluraufeinenQuergangmitoffenemOstabschnitt
undgeschlossenemWestabschnitt.DerMittelflurselbstfandeinenFortsatzgegenNorden,verengte
sichhierallerdingsinEntsprechungzurPfeilerstellungdarunter.ZubeidenSeitendiesesFortsatzes
lagenwiederumetwagleichgroe,wohlsekundrunterteilteRume,denenjeweilseinTurmzimmer
beigefgtwar.BeidseitigdesverengtenMittelflursverzeichnendieGrundrisseAbtritte.Amvorderen
Mittelflur lagen mehrere Hinterladerffnungen, die freilich nicht alle aus maximilianischer Zeit
gewesen sein werden. Zwei fragmentarisch erhaltene, bauzeitliche Portalgewnde, eines im ersten
Stock gegen Westen, das andere im zweiten Stock gegen Osten, belegen, da der Mittelflur dem
ursprnglichen Baubestand angehrt.62 Im ersten Obergescho des der Kirche zugewandten
Westteils hat sich die ursprngliche Situation einigermaen erhalten. Ein gekehltes Portal mit
einbeschriebenemSpitzbogenfhrthiervomMittelflurausindenerstenRaumlinkerhand(Abb.12).
DernrdlichangrenzendeGangzeigtzweibauzeitlicheTrffnungengegenNordenundSden(Abb.
13). Analoges ist auch fr die Ostseite zu vermuten und fr den zweiten Stock durch ein
Schulterbogenportalbelegt(Abb.14).

Abb.12Innsbruck,Hofburg,Frauenzimmerbau,1.OG,Mittelflur,
Westseite,Portalfragment.

Abb.11Innsbruck,Hofburg,Frauenzimmerbau,sog.Tiefgeschohalle.

Sucht man den Rumen Funktionen zuzuweisen, so legt sich im Vergleich mit
zeitgenssischenBeispielendieFolgeStube,Gang,KammermitAbtritt,TurmstubezubeidenSeiten
des Mittelflurs nahe. Die Identifizierung der Raumkonfiguration mit zwei gleichfrmigen
AppartementsdrngtsichaufAppartements,dieberdenengeren,abgeschlossenenMittelflurim
Nordabschnitt diskret zu verbinden waren. Ein paar feinere Unterschiede zwischen beiden
AppartementsliegeninAussichtundKomfort:imOstenderBlickaufdieRennwiese,imWestenauf
dieKirche.DementsprechendistdiestlicheStubemiteinemErkerausgestattet,diewestlichenicht.
Die ihrerseits mit Erkern versehene stliche Turmstube gestaltet sich ganz zeitgem als eine Art
ISBN9789460184833
37

Rundstube, hingegen haftet der im alten Torturm der Stadtbefestigung eingerichteten westlichen
Turmstube die Unregelmigkeit einer Kompromilsung an. Folgt man dieser Lesart der
architektonischen Disposition, so liegt die Hypothese nahe, der Frauenzimmerbau habe die
eigentliche Wohnung des Knigspaars dargestellt, wobei Bianca Maria der der Kirche zugewandte
WestteilundMaximiliandernachdrauengewandteOstteilzugestandenhtte.DieAppartements
wren in diesem Fall beide im zweiten Obergescho auf etwa derselben Ebene wie die
Reprsentationsrume zu denken. Die Tatsache, da die Grundrisse keine Geheimtreppen
verzeichnen, spricht gemeinsam mit der Parallelitt der Appartements bis in die Abtritte hinein
gegeneinegeschoweiseAufteilungderWohnung.Eherwrezuvermuten,daimDachgeschodie
Hofdamen beherbergt wurden, und da im ersten Obergescho bedarfsweise Gste und vielleicht
diehchstrangigenBedienstetenuntergebrachtwaren.63

Abb.14Innsbruck,Hofburg,Frauenzimmerbau,2.OG,Mittelflur,
Ostseite,Portalfragment.

Abb.13Innsbruck,Hofburg,Frauenzimmerbau,1.OG,Gangim
Westabschnitt,Portalfragmente.

NunmagdieschlichteFolgeStube,Gang,Kammer,TurmstubefrdieWohnungeinesKnigs
zu klein erscheinen. Doch ist zu bercksichtigen, da in der Flucht des hier angenommenen
maximilianischenAppartementsdreiweitereRumelagen(Abb.8),daruntereinezweiteRundstube
Rume, die zwischen dem Paradeis auf der einen und den eigentlichen Wohnrumen auf der
anderen Seite lagen, und die vielleicht im Zusammenhang privater Audienzen genutzt werden
konnten.AucheinPrivatoratoriumwreindiesemKontextdenkbar.64Wieaberverhaltensichdie
Aussagen der Schriftquellen zu einer solchen Rekonstruktion der Funktionen? Dagegen knnte
zunchst sprechen, da fr das Frauenzimmer Ordnungen vorliegen, die das Miteinander der
Hofdamen regelten, Zeiten der ffnung und Schlieung festlegten und die Bewachung des
Frauenzimmers organisierten.65 Diese Sicherheitsvorkehrungen werden aber nicht allein der Sorge
um den Lebenswandel der Hofdamen geschuldet gewesen sein, sondern zum einen auch der
Tatsache,dasichimFrauenzimmerderHausschatzbefand,66zumanderen,daderKniginseiner
ResidenzselbstebenfallsvordemZutrittUnbefugtergeschtztseinmute.DaFrauenzimmernicht
mitKlsterngleichzusetzensind,zeigtbeispielsweiseaucheinekniglicheInstruktionvomNovember
ISBN9789460184833
38

1493,inderbefohlenwurde,dasFrauenzimmerderWienerHofburgherzurichten,damitdesKnigs
Schwager Herzog Albrecht von Bayern dort logieren knne dies erscheint bemerkenswert, auch
wennesdamalsmangelsKniginauchkeinenweiblichenHofstaatinWiengegebenhat.67
Wichtiger ist, da im Innsbrucker Frauenzimmer, und zwar vermutlich im weniger
exponierten Turm, das Schatzgewlbe und das Briefgewlbe lagen, und da sicherlich beides dem
Knigganzunmittelbarzugnglichgewesenist.AlsimMai1510imAuftragdesabwesendenKnigs
wiesohufigvergeblichbestimmteTruhengesuchtwurden,przisierteMaximiliandenStandort:Die
gesuchteTruhewarvordemTransportindasobergewelbinunnsercamerdarinnwirbeyunnser
gemachlgelegensein,gestannden.68DieseQuellewarschonDregerbekannt,underistdereinzige,
derdarausgeschlossenhat,daMaximilianwenigstenszeitweiseimFrauenzimmergewohnthat.69
Die jngere Forschung hat angesichts des eingangs zitierten Auftrags an Klderer von 1498, dem
Knigseinstblininunsermneuenfrauenzimmerauszumalen,MaximilianeineArtGstezimmerim
Frauenzimmerbauzugestanden.70MglicherweiseaberwirdmanknftigeinenSchrittweitergehen
drfen:SofernderKniginInnsbruck war,haterwahrscheinlichimFrauenzimmerresidiertdem
regulrenLogisdesKnigspaares.

Bibliographie

Alberti,LeonBattista,LArchitettura(Dereaedificatoria),ed.GiovanniOrlandiu.PaoloPortoghesi,2
Bde.(Mailand1966).

Albrecht, Stephan, Zeremonialrume in den mittelalterlichen Stdten des alten Reiches, in
Stadtgestalt und ffentlichkeit. Die Entstehung politischer Rume in der Stadt der Vormoderne, ed.
StephanAlbrecht(Kln/Weimar/Wien,2010),pp.23352.

Bhmer, Johann Friedrich, Regesta Imperii XIV. Ausgewhlte Regesten des Kaiserreiches unter
MaximilianI.14931519,bearb.v.HermannWiesfleckeru.a.,Bd.14/2,(Wien/Kln/Weimar,1990
2004).

Bojcov,MichailA.,ZumFrauenzimmeramInnsbruckerHofErzherzogSigmunds,inDerInnsbrucker
Hof.ResidenzundhfischeGesellschaftinTirolvom15.bis19.Jahrhundert,ed.HeinzNoflatscheru.
JanPaulNiederkorn(Wien,2005),pp.195211.

Castiglione,Baldassare,IlCortegiano,ed.AmedeoQuondam,2Bde.(Mailand2002).

Dankl,Gnther,DieBautenErzherzogSigmunds,inDerHerzogundseinTaler.ErzherzogSigmund
derMnzreiche.Politik,Mnzwesen,Kunst(LandesausstellungTirolerLandesmuseumFerdinandeum
Innsbruck1986)(Innsbruck,1986),pp.6678.
ISBN9789460184833
39

Dreger, Moriz, Zur ltesten Geschichte der Innsbrucker Hofburg, Kunst und Kunsthandwerk, 24
(1921),pp.133201.

Felmayer,Johanna,DieprofanenKunstdenkmlerderStadtInnsbruck.AltstadtStadterweiterungen
biszurMittedes19.Jahrhunderts(sterreichischeKunsttopographie,Bd.38)(Wien,1972).

FranchettiPardo,Vittorio,Storiadellurbanistica.DalTrecentoalQuattrocento(Bari,1982).

Fritz,Monika,KaiserMaximilianI.undInnsbruck(VerffentlichungenausdemStadtarchivInnsbruck,
Bd.31)(Innsbruck,1968).

Galter,HannesD.;u.Kppel,Lutz,Paradeisos,inDerNeuePauly(BrillOnline,2012).

Garber, Josef, Das Zeughaus Kaiser Maximilians I. in Innsbruck, Wiener Jahrbuch fr
Kunstgeschichte,5(1928),pp.14260.

Gatt,Anneliese,DerInnsbruckerHofzurZeitKaiserMaximiliansI.14931519(Phil.Diss.Innsbruck,
1943).

Giordano,Luisa,Costruirelacitt.LadinastiavisconteasforzescaeVigevano(Vigevano,2011).

Grossmann,G.Ulrich,AlbrechtDrerinInnsbruck.ZurDatierungdererstenitalienischenReise,in
Das DrerHaus. Neue Ergebnisse der Forschung, ed. G. Ulrich Grossmann u. Franz Sonnenberger
(Nrnberg,2007),pp.22740.

HanzlWachter, Lieselotte, Hofburg zu Innsbruck. Architektur, Mbel, Raumkunst. Reprsentatives
WohnenindenKaiserappartementsvonMariaTheresiabisKaiserFranzJoseph(Wien,2004).

Heinig,PaulJoachim,TheorieundPraxisderhfischenOrdnungunterFriedrichIII.undMaximilian
I., in Hfe und Hofordnungen 12001600. 5. Symposium der ResidenzenKommission der Akademie
der Wissenschaften in Gttingen, ed. Holger Kruse u. Werner Paravicini (Sigmaringen, 1999), pp.
22342.

Hollegger, Manfred,MaximilianI.(14591519)HerrscherundMensch einerZeitenwende(Stuttgart,
2005).

Hollegger, Manfred, Lebenszeugnisse und Archivalien zur Rekonstruktion des Hoflebens Kaiser
Maximilians I., in Kaiser Maximilian I. (14591519) und die Hofkultur seiner Zeit, ed. Sieglinde
Hartmannu.FreimutLser(JahrbuchderOswaldvonWolkensteinGesellschaft,Bd.17)(Wiesbaden,
2009),pp.41123.

Hoppe, Stephan, Bauliche Gestalt und Lage von Frauenwohnrumen in deutschen
Residenzschlsserndesspten15.unddes16.Jahrhunderts,inDasFrauenzimmer.DieFraubeiHofe
in Sptmittelalter und frher Neuzeit. 6. Symposium der ResidenzenKommission der Akademie der
WissenschafteninGttingen,ed.JanHirschbiegelu.WernerParavicini(Stuttgart,2000),pp.15174.
ISBN9789460184833
40

Hoppe, Stephan, Hofstube und Tafelstube. Funktionale Raumdifferenzierungen auf
mitteleuropischen Adelssitzen seit dem Hochmittelalter, in Die Burg. Wissenschaftlicher
BegleitbandzudenAusstellungenBurgundHerrschaftundMythosBurg,ed.G.UlrichGromann
u.HansOttomeyer(Nrnberg,2010),pp.196207.

Koschatzky,Walter,AlbrechtDrer.DieLandschaftsaquarelle.rtlichkeit,Datierung,Stilkritik(Wien,
1971).

Kraus, Victor von, Intinerarium Maximiliani I. 15081518. Mit einleitenden Bemerkungen ber das
KanzleiwesenMaximiliansI.,ArchivfrsterreichischeGeschichte,87(1899),pp.229318.

MartinLuthersWerke.KritischeGesamtausgabe.Tischreden,Bd.5(Weimar,1919).

Morscher,Lukas;Grossmann,G.Ulrich;u.Grebe,Anja,DasGoldeneDachlinInnsbruck(Regensburg,
2004).

Oettinger,Ricarda,HofburgundAdeligesDamenstift,inDieKunstdenkmlerderStadtInnsbruck.
DieHofbauten(sterreichischeKunsttopographie,Bd.47),ed.JohannaFelmayer(Wien,1986),pp.
55235.

Pertot,Gianfranco,IlParadisodellaDuchessa.LaLoggiadelleDamenelcastellodiVigevano.Rilievi,
letture stratigrafiche e proposte per linterpretazione della sequenza costruttiva e per la
conservazione,Viglevanum,19(2009),pp.1631.

Pizzinini, Meinrad, Erzherzog Sigmund und Tirol, in Der Herzog und sein Taler. Erzherzog Sigmund
derMnzreiche.Politik,Mnzwesen,Kunst(LandesausstellungTirolerLandesmuseumFerdinandeum
Innsbruck1986)(Innsbruck,1986),pp.825.

Quellen zur Geschichte der kaiserlichen Haussammlungen und der Kunstbestrebungen des
Allerdurchlauchtigsten Erzhauses, erschienen als Teil II des Jahrbuch der kunsthistorischen
SammlungendesAllerhchstenKaiserhauses,1(1883).

Riegel,Nicole,DieBauttigkeitdesKardinalsMatthusLangvonWellenburg(14681540)(Mnster,
2009).

Sauer,Benedikt,HofburgInnsbruck(Wien/Bozen,2010).

Schnherr,David,UrkundenundRegestenausdemK.K.StatthaltereiArchivinInnsbruck,Jahrbuch
derkunsthistorischenSammlungendesAllerhchstenKaiserhauses,2(1884),TeilII,pp.ICLXXII.

Schnherr, David von, Urkunden und Regesten aus dem K.K. StatthaltereiArchiv in Innsbruck,
Jahrbuch der kunsthistorischen Sammlungen des Allerhchsten Kaiserhauses, 11 (1890), Teil II, pp.
LXXXIVCCXLI.
ISBN9789460184833
41

Scholz, Michael, ...da zoge mein herre mit macht hinein... Die Stadt Halle nach der Unterwerfung
durchdenErzbischofvonMagdeburg1478,inDerHofunddieStadt.Konfrontation,Koexistenzund
Integration in Sptmittelalter und Frher Neuzeit, ed. Werner Paravicini u. Jrg Wettlaufer
(Ostfildern,2006),pp.6388.

Solmi, Edmondo, La Festa del Paradiso di Leonardo da Vinci e Bernardo Bellincione (13 Gennaio
1490),ArchivioStoricoLombardo,31(1904),H.1,pp.7589.

StdtischesBrgertumundHofgesellschaft.KulturenintegrativerundkonkurrierenderBeziehungenin
ResidenzundHauptstdtenvom14.bisins19.Jahrhundert,ed.JanHirschbiegel,WernerParavicini
u.JrgWettlaufer(Ostfildern,2012).

Weiss, Sabine, Die vergessene Kaiserin. Bianca Maria Sforza. Kaiser Maximilians zweite Gemahlin
(Innsbruck/Wien,2010).

Werkner, Patrick, Der Wappenturm Kaiser Maximilians I. in Innsbruck, Wiener Jahrbuch fr
Kunstgeschichte,34(1981),pp.10114.

Werkner,Patrick,DieInnsbruckerBurgen,inMittleresInntal(TirolerBurgenbuch,Bd.6),ed.Oswald
Trapp(Bozen,1982),pp.10732.

Wiesflecker, Hermann, Kaiser Maximilian I. Das Reich, sterreich und Europa an der Wende zur
Neuzeit,5Bde.(Wien,19711986).

WiesfleckerFriedhuber,Ingeborg,KaiserMaximilianI.unddieStadtInnsbruck,inDerInnsbrucker
Hof.ResidenzundhfischeGesellschaftinTirolvom15.bis19.Jahrhundert,ed.HeinzNoflatscheru.
JanPaulNiederkorn(Wien,2005),pp.12358.

Zimerman, Heinrich; Fiedler, Joseph; Paukert, Johann, Urkunden und Regesten aus dem K. u. K.
Haus,HofundStaatsarchivinWien,JahrbuchderkunsthistorischenSammlungendesAllerhchsten
Kaiserhauses,1(1883),TeilII,pp.ILXXVIII.

Zimerman,Heinrich;Kreyczi,Franz,UrkundenundRegestenausdemk.u.k.ReichsFinanzArchiv,
Jahrbuch der kunsthistorischen Sammlungen des Allerhchsten Kaiserhauses, 3 (1885), Teil II, pp.
ILXXXI.

Zoller, Franz Carl, Geschichte und Denkwrdigkeiten der Stadt Innsbruck und der umliegenden
Gegend von den ltesten Zeiten bis zur Erlschung der sterreichischtirolischen linie mit Erzherzog
SigmundFranz(Innsbruck,1816).

ISBN9789460184833
42
Abbildungen
Abb.13,6,910:Wien,Albertina,Inv.3056,3057,3058,7549,7548,7547.
Abb.4,7,1114:ArchivdesAutors.
Abb.5:Erlangen,GraphischeSammlungderUniversitt,Inv.B458.
Abb.7:Innsbruck,MuseumFerdinandeum,AignerCodex,Bl.3.

1
QuellenzurGeschichtederkaiserlichenHaussammlungen1883ff.
Dreger1921.
3
Werkner1982.Oettinger1986.
4
HanzlWachter2004.Sauer2010.
5
Gatt1943.Fritz1968.WiesfleckerFriedhuber2005.Hollegger2009.
6
DervonWiesfleckerFriedhuber2005,p.129,geuertenAnnahmeeinerimeinzelnengenauuntersuchte[n]
Baugeschichte der maximilianischen Burg ist aus kunsthistorischer Sicht zu widersprechen. Einige der
zahlreichenoffenenFragenwerdenimFolgendenskizziert.
7
ZumGoldenenDachlsiehezuletztMorscher,Grossmannu.Grebe2004(mitAngabenderlterenLiteratur).
ZumWappenturmsieheWerkner1981,auerdemGrossmann2007.
8
Koschatzky1971,Kat.Nr.7;Luther,Tischreden,Bd.5,1919,p.638f,Nr.6392.Lutherknntesichdarinauf
AlbertisCivitatisetdomusdiffinitiophilosophicabezogenhaben.Vgl.Alberti,ed.Orlandi/Portoghesi1966,p.
64f: Quod si civitas philosophorum sententia maxima quaedam est domus et contra domus ipsa minima
quaedam est civitas, quidni harum ipsarum membra minima quaedam esse domicilia dicentur? (De re
aedificatoria, I, 9). Denselben Gedanken nimmt auch Baldassare Castiglione in seinem Libro del Cortegiano
(I,2.5) auf, wenn er die herzogliche Residenz in Urbino beschreibt: Federico edific un palazzo, secondo la
opinione di molti, il pi bello che in tutta Italia si ritrovi; e dogni opportuna cosa s ben lo forn, che non un
palazzo,maunacittinformadipalazzoesserpareva.SieheCastiglione2002,Bd.1,p.14.
9
ZuMaximiliansRegierungsbernahme1490sieheWiesflecker,Bd.1,1971,pp.25864;Hollegger2005,pp.
6872;zusammenfassendauchWiesfleckerFriedhuber2005,pp.12728.
10
Werkner1982.Dankl1986.
11
Die Entstehungszeit der Veduten der Innsbrucker Hofburg und der Stadt Innsbruck in der Albertina (Inv.
3056,3057,3058)istunsicher.AnhaltspunktfrdieDatierungistderBaudesWappenturmsanderStelledes
1494 niedergebrannten Saggentors. Eine durch einen Stich Salomon Kleiners aus der Mitte des 18.
Jahrhunderts berlieferte Bauinschrift 1496 am sdstlichen Eckerker wurde von der Forschung als
Schluinschrift und damit als terminus ante quem verstanden, da die InnsbruckVedute noch den
eingersteten Wappenturm zeigt. Davon ausgehend, da HofburgAnsichten und InnsbruckVedute (trotz
markanterstilistischerUnterschiede)voneinundderselbenHandstammenundAlbrechtDrerzuzuschreiben
seien,dieHofburgAnsichtgegenSdendenWappenturmabernichtzeigt,wurdedieerstenItalienreiseDrers
frdieJahre1494/95angenommen,wobeidieHofburgAnsichtenaufderHinreiseunddieInnsbruckVedute
aufderRckreiseentstandenseinknnten.Grossmann2007pldiertehingegenfreinesptereDatierungin
AnbetrachtderPositionderInschrifteinStckweitunterdemTurmhelm,welchererstdanach,alsofrhestens
1496aufgesetztwordenseinknnte.ChristophMetzger(frdl.mndl.Mitteilung)erkanntezudem,dainder
HofburgAnsicht gegen Sden Silberstiftspuren davon zeugen, dader Zeichner denHelm des Wappenturms
durchaus im Blick hatte und erwog, ihn in die Vedute aufzunehmen, mglicherweise aber davon Abstand
nahm, um die Ansicht des Hofburginneren nicht zu verunklren. Die Datierung der Bltter hngt demnach
davon ab, welches Gewicht man der Position der von Salomon Kleiner dokumentierten Bauinschrift beimit.
2
ISBN9789460184833
43

IchdankeG.UlrichGrossmannherzlichfrdieDiskussiondieserFrageunddenanregendenAustauschberdie
maximilianischeHofburg.
12
RegestaImperii,XIV,Nr.2883.Vgl.auchWeiss2010,p.62(ohneNachweis).
13
WiesfleckerFriedhuber2005,p.129.Weiss2010,pp.6266.
14
Oettinger1986,pp.5960;sowiezuletztGrossmann2007.
15
Pizzinini1986,p.23.
16
Felmayer1972,p.103.
17
Morscher,Grossmannu.Grebe2004,pp.1114.
18
Schnherr1884,p.VII,Reg.585;RegestaImperii,XIV,Nr.6217;sieheauchOettinger1986,p.57mitAnm.
16.
19
nach dem wir willens sein, ettlich der oberuerten zimer mit der zeitt durch gepew zu verkeren, in Wien,
HKA,gb5,f.99=84.SieheauchRegestaImperii,XIV,Nr.10875.
20
RegestaImperii,XIV,Nr.10797.
21
Zimerman, Fiedler u. Paukert 1883, pp. XXXVIXXXIX, Nr. 219; Regesta Imperii, XIV, Nr. 11307. Siehe auch
Dreger1921,pp.14647undp.161.
22
ZumHarnaschhaussieheDreger1921,p.152;Oettinger1986,p.55f;zumZeughausGarber1928.
23
Zimermanu.Kreyczi1885,p.XXVI,Nr.2542u.2543.Dreger1921,p.154.
24
Oettinger1986,pp.22527.
25
Schnherr1884,p.XXVI,Nr.793.
26
TirolerLandesarchiv,KammerKopialbuch,Bd.29,f.93v(12.Juni1506).
27
Dreger1921,p.152.Oettinger1986,p.209mitAnm.2.
28
Schnherr1884,p.XXVIII,Nr.831.
29
Wiesflecker,Bd.4,1981,pp.166.Hollegger2005,pp.19198.
30
Schnherr1884,p.XLVIII,Nr.978u.980.Dreger1921,p.161.EineBezeichnungdiesesSaalsalsGoldener
Saalistanders,alsvonOettinger1986,p.58,nahegelegt,1510nochnichtnachweisbar.
31
Tiroler Landesarchiv, KammerKopialbuch, Bd. 48, 6. September 1510. Siehe auch Felmayer 1972, p. 103;
sowieWiesflecker,Bd.5,1986,p.297.
32
Weiss2010,pp.17980.
33
Gatt1943,p.157u.pp.19597.Fritz1968,p.23.Wiesflecker,Bd.5,1986,p.385.
34
Kraus1899,passim.
35
Wiesflecker,Bd.4,1981,p.422.
36
Hinzuweisen wre hier beispielsweise auf die Umgestaltung von Halle an der Saale zur erzbischflichen
Residenzstadt insbesondere unter Kardinal Albrecht von Brandenburg in den zwanziger Jahren des 16.
Jahrhunderts. Vgl. Scholz 2006, pp. 8183. Siehe auerdem Albrecht 2010 sowie die jngst erschienenen
TagungsaktenStdtischesBrgertumundHofgesellschaft2012.
37
Zu Vigevano zuletzt Giordano 2011. Auch die schon im 15. Jahrhundert berhmte Residenz Federicos da
MontefeltroinUrbino,derseinerseitsdieStadtimSinnederherzoglichenReprsentationumstrukturierthatte,
drfteimKenntnishorizontMaximiliansgelegenhaben.Vgl.FranchettiPardo1982,pp.52732.
38
Sieheoben,Anm.11.
39
GraphischeSammlungderUniversittErlangen,Inv.Nr.B458.WiebeidenHofburgVedutenderAlbertina
giltauchhierderZustanddesWappenturmdachsalsDatierungsanhaltindieZeitzwischen1525,demErsatz
desvonDreraufderInnsbruckVedutedargestellten,spitzenHelms,derdurchBlitzschlagbeschdigtworden
war,und1534,alseinneuerlicherBranddasinderErlangerZeichnunggezeigteProvisoriumzunichtemachte.
SiehehierzuOettinger1986,p.82.
40
VonbesondererBedeutungsinddieaufderGrundlageeinerVermessungimHerbst1754angefertigtenRisse
Johann Martin Gumpps d. J., die den damaligen Zustand der Hofburg vergegenwrtigen. Diese Serie wird
ergnzt durch entsprechende Deckbltter sowie eine eigene Planfolge des nach dem Siebenjhrigen Krieg
ausfhrendenBaumeistersConstantinJ.Walter,derab1763mitdemAuftrageinerumfassendenErneuerung
ISBN9789460184833
44

des Rennwegtraktes die Gumppschen Plne einer Revision unterzog. Siehe hierzu Dreger 1921, pp. 135144;
sowieOettinger1986,pp.6576undpp.8693.
41
Nachrichtenvom8.und17.Mrz1510,sieheRegesteninSchnherr1884,p.XLVIII,Nr.978u.980.
42
Sieheoben,Anm.30.
43
Dreger1921,p.154u.pp.16162.
44
Grossmann2007,p.230.
45
Schnherr1890,p.CIX,Nr.6741.Vgl.Dreger1921,p.149.Werkner1982,p.119.
46
Schnherr1890,p.CV,Nr.6737.
47
Schnherr1890,p.CV,Nr.6737.
48
SieheDreger1921,pp.15859.
49
Vgl.Oettinger1986,pp.18991.
50
FreundlichemndlicheMitteilungvom6.Dezember2011.
51
ZumRaumtypderTafelstubesieheHoppe2010.ZumRaumtypderTrinkstubefehlenUntersuchungen.Als
zeitgenssichesBeispielseihieraufdie1540dokumentierteTrinkstubeimSalzburgerBischofshofverwiesen.
Vgl.Riegel2009,p.330.
52
Zoller 1816, pp. 19596, berichtet ber den symbolischen Vollzug der Ehe am 11. Dezember 1520 in der
Innsbrucker Hofburg, allwo in einem Zimmer nchst dem groen Saal, das Paradies genannt, 2 prchtige
BettenmitgoldenenDeckenbereitetwaren.
53
Pertot2009.
54
Pertot2009,pp.2122.
55
Vgl.Galteru.Kppel2012.
56
HinzuweisenisthierauchaufeineamMailnderHof1490anllichderHochzeitdesHerzogsGianGaleazzo
Sforza von Leonardo da Vinci inszenierte Festa del paradiso, in der Jupiter auftrat, um Gottvater fr die
Geburt einer so schnen und tugendhaften Frau wie der Braut zu danken. Ein Fest brigens, an dem
Gesandte des Kaiserhauses teilnahmen, und dessen Beschreibung durch den Hofdichter Bernardo Bellincioni
1493kurzvorMaximiliansHochzeitmitBiancaMariaSforzaimDruckerschien.SieheSolmi1904.
57
SiehehierzuDreger1921,pp.14647.ZumBaubzw.RaumtypdesFrauenzimmerssieheHoppe2000.Jngst
wrdedasThemaaufderPALATIUMTagungPrinces,PrincessesandtheirLodgings(Paris,INHA,27.30.Juni
2011)ausfhrlichdiskutiert.DieTagungsaktensindinVorbereitung.
58
Schnherr1884,p.VII,Reg.585.
59
ZuletztBojcov2005.
60
Dargestellt ist der Tiroler Adler mit dem Erzherzogshut, der sich einer Aktualisierung unter Erzherzog
Ferdinandverdankenknnte.WieobeninAnm.39dargelegt,drftedieZeichnungzwischen1525und1534
entstandensein.
61
Vgl.Dreger1921,pp.14147.
62
Vgl.Oettinger1986,pp.11517mitAbb.99101.
63
Frdasspte15.JahrhundertistdieLagevonFrauenwohnrumennurseltenzuermitteln,wieHoppe2000
dargelegt hat. Ein Beispiel fr eine 1470 geplante Unterbringung des weiblichen Gefolges im zweiten
ObergeschowredasBerlinerSchlo.AussptererZeitistdieLagedesFrauenzimmersimoberstenStockund
inZwerchhusernhufigerdokumentiert.SieheHoppe2000,p.164.
64
EinerdernachOstengerichtetenErkerknntehierfrVerwendunggefundenhaben.
65
Gatt1943,p.16u.pp.19597.Heinig1999,p.231.
66
Zimerman,Fiedleru.Paukert1883,p.XXVI,Reg.219.
67
RegestaImperii,XIV,Nr.115.
68
TirolerLandesarchivInnsbruck,KammerKopialbuch,Bd.47,6.Mai1510.
69
Dreger1921,p.179.
70
Weiss2010,p.98.
ISBN9789460184833
45
Architecturaancillamusicae
ArchitekturinderBeziehungzurMusikamPragerHofderHabsburger
IvanP.Muchka

DieserkurzeAufsatzbeschftigtsichmitderRenaissanceorgelimSt.VeitsDomunddamitauchmit
denFragennachderhabsburgischenSelbstprsentation.BemerkenswertistschondieTatsache,da
sichKnigFerdinandI.imJahr1547entschied,nachdemTodseinerFrau,KniginAnna,demPrager
DomeineneueOrgelaufeigeneKostenzustiften.DieSorgeumdieBeschaffungdesInstrumentes
lagallerdingsaufdenSchulternseinesSohnes,desErzherzogsFerdinandII.,StatthalterinBhmen.1
ber das Aussehen und die Platzierung des Vorgngerinstruments, einer gotischen Orgel,
wissenwirleidernichtviel,nurdasssiebeimgroenBrandaufdemHradschinundderKleinseiteim
Jahr1541zerstrtwurde.EtwazehnJahrenachdemBrand(wobeidieerstenberlegungendazuins
Jahr1547zurckgehen)musstensichFerdinandI.undseinSohnFerdinandII.entscheiden,wiedie
neueOrgelauszusehenhabe:SolltesienachdemfranzsischenVorbildausgefhrtwerden,etwa
gem den Orgeln im Dom zu Straburg (Schwalbennestorgel) oder im Dom zu Perpignan, wo die
OrgelaufeinermchtigenSttzeentlangderSeitenwanddesHauptschiffssteht?Odersolltesieauf
einer Musikempore, einer Tribne oder einem Balkon am westlichen Ende des Domes, in einer
besonderen Polaritt zum Hochaltar stehen, und dessen Flgelform spiegeln (Abb. 1)? Die zweite
Lsungerschienihnenzweifelloswrdevollerundreprsentativer,wieessichfr einknigliches
Instrumentgehrt,auchwaresgnstig,dassdamitdieglatteWand,diedamalsanderWestseitedes
DomesalsprovisorischerAbschlussstand,abgedecktwerdenkonnte.
In der Korrespondenz der beiden Habsburger von 1553, die sich in dieser Sache fleiig
austauschten(ErzherzogFerdinandII.warzudiesemZeitpunktvierundzwanzigJahrealt),findenwir
in diesem Zusammenhang zuerst den etwas pejorativen Ausdruck Orgelfu.2 Whrend der
RealisierungbekamdieserFuimposanteAusmaeundeineWirkung,diewiranHandhistorischer
FotoaufnahmenausderZeitderErweiterungdesDomesum1900nachvollziehenknnen,woman
letztendlichentschied,dassdieMusikemporevomwestlichenEndedesaltenBauesindasnrdliche
QuerschiffdesneuenBauesversetztwerdensoll.
ISBN9789460184833
46

Abb.1MusikemporeimSt.VeitsDom,Prag.
Als im Jahr 1553 der Orgelbauer Friedrich Pfanmller aus Amberg in Franken von den
kaiserlichen Auftraggebern aufgefordert wurde, mit den Vorbereitungsarbeiten etwa der
Herstellung der Orgelpfeifen anzufangen, war die definitive Gestalt des neuen Bauabschnitts des
Domes und des neuen Instruments wohl noch nicht ganz klar. In diesem Beitrag kann man weder
eine Zusammenfassung der Daten aus den Archivquellen bieten, obwohl sie noch nicht
zufriedenstellend klassifiziert und analysiert wurden, noch nher auf den Wettbewerb fr den Bau
der Musikempore oder auf die zwanzig Jahre andauernden Peripetien beim Bau der riesigen Orgel
eingehen. Es ist aber klar, dass die Aufforderung an den Orgelbauer, er solle das grte und
schnsteInstrumentderChristenheitbauen,vonAnfangandawar.3
Der Stand unserer Kenntnisse ber die Renaissanceorgel im St.VeitsDom war bisher vor
allem hinsichtlich des eigentlichen Aussehens des Instruments lckenhaft. Die Renaissanceorgel
wurde im Jahre 1757 Opfer der preuischen Bombardierung von Hradschin und musste durch ein
neuesInstrumentvomOrgelbauerAntoninGartnerausTachauersetztwerden(17621765).
Es gibt Dutzende Ansichten des Dominterieurs aus jener Zeit, auf denen meistens die
Krnungsfeierderbhmischen Knige undKniginnenzusehen sind,oderauch,wieimFallKaiser
Rudolfs II., sein Castrum doloris. Diese Ansichten zeigen das Dominterieur jedoch immer Richtung
Osten,zumHochaltar.
ISBN9789460184833
47
Eine Ausnahme bildet eine aus Holz geschnitzte Tafel von Kaspar Bechteler, auf der die
Verwstung des Domes whrend der Regierungszeit des Winterknigs Friedrich von Pfalz im Jahre
1619 dargestellt ist (Abb. 2). Auf dieser Tafel, die sich heutzutage im St.VeitsDom an der
ZwischenwandzwischendemPresbyterium unddemKapellenkranzbefindet,siehtmandasInnere
des Domes vom Sden, und auch die Musikempore ist hier wenn auch sehr summarisch
dargestellt.

Abb.2KasparBechteler,DerSt.VeitsDomimJahre1619,
whrendderprotestantischenPlnderung(Detail).
Es gibt zwei Details, die von Bedeutung sind: Man kann deutlich erkennen, dass das
Rckpositiv (also nicht das Orgelprospekt) konvex gewlbt war und dass es Flgel zum Schlieen
hatte. Zweitens sehen wir, dass sich im ersten Gescho der Musikempore, wo einige Forscher das
RckpositivunddaherdieOrgelzwischenzweiStockwerkenaufgeteiltvermuteten,4keinInstrument
befand.DamanaufBechtelersReliefeinenEinblickindasHauptschiffdesDomesdurchdieArkaden
des Seitenschiffes hat, sieht man vom zweiten Gescho der Musikempore, die uns vorrangig
interessieren wrde, nur sehr wenig. Man knnte vermuten, dass gerade das Thema des Reliefs,
nmlich die ikonoklastische Plnderung des Domes, die Orgel selbst betroffen hat und dass sie
vielleicht auch damals beschdigt wurde was aber eine sehr unsichere Hypothese darstellt. Man
knnteaberandererseitsvermuten,dassdieSzenederAuferstehungChristi,dieamHauptflgeldes
Orgelprospektsdargestelltwar,frdenPredigerScultetiusGrundgenugwar,dieOrgelbeidemvon
ihminitiiertenikonoklastischenAngriffaufdenDomzuverschonen.
Es gibt eine weitere, ungefhre und sehr schematische Zeichnung des Hauptteils der
Renaissanceorgel,aufbewahrtimNationalarchivinPrag,diedenStandderArbeitenanderOrgelim
Juni1563zeigt(Abb.3).5
ISBN9789460184833
48

Abb.3ZeichnungderOrgelausdemJahre1563.
MansiehtdenHauptteildesOrgelprospekts,gegliedertdurchvierSulenmitKapitel.Diemit
Akanthusschnitzereien verzierten Teile oberhalb der Orgelpfeifen sind auf der Zeichnung mit
Anmerkungen versehen, ob sie bereits fertig oder noch nicht fertig waren (das ist fertig, das ist
nichtfertig).AusdiesenAnmerkungengehthervor,dassdiePaneeleimoberenTeildesmittleren
Feldesnochnichtfertigwaren.DiesesummarischeZeichnungansichwrenichtsohilfreich,wenn
man sie nicht mit einer wunderschnen Vedute von Salomon Kleiner mit der Aufschrift Schema
mausoleiregumBohemiae,quodPragaeestindiviVitivergleichenknnte(Abb.4und5).6

Abb.4SalomonKleiner,SchemamausoleiregumBohemiae,
quodPragaeestindiviViti.
ISBN9789460184833
49
Der Grund fr die Entstehung dieser Vedute war die Abbildung des Mausoleums der
Habsburger. Man erkennt auch weitere Grabmler im Dom, jenes der Familie Schlik, also ein
aktuellesWerkMatthiasBernardBrauns,unddieGrabstttederFamilieLobkowiczanderWandder
Wenzelskapelle,einweiteresMonumentausderZeitum1600.WasandieserAbbildungberrascht,
sind die Ungenauigkeiten in der Darstellung von Wohlmuths Musikempore. Die Empore hat in
Wirklichkeit ein Rippengewlbe, im Grundgeschoss mit auslaufenden Rippen, die bis zu den
Nebenschiffen auslaufen. Auf der Vedute Salomon Kleiners sehen wir stattdessen ein barockes
GewlbeinderFormderbhmischenKappeberGurten.Esistoffensichtlich,dasssichderKnstler
fr die gotischen Formen des Domes, zu denen immer noch das Gewlbe Wolmuths aus dem
sechzehnten Jahrhundert zhlt, nicht begeistern konnte, da er z.B. auch das Parlersche Triforium,
denStolzdergotischenArchitektur,alseinfachetoskanischeKolonnadedarstellte.
Diese knstlerische Ungenauigkeit Kleiners ist etwas schwierig zu verstehen, es scheint
jedoch, dass der Knstler die Renaissance und Barockformen und alle Grabmler sehr treu
abbildete,sodasswirdasselbeauchberdenTeilvermutenknnen,derunsammeisteninteressiert
die zweigeschossige Musikempore. Die Empore wird hier im ersten Stockwerk einschlielich der
ausgerundetenHolzbrstungundderkleinenOrgel,dieimJahre1732ErzbischofJosefDanielMayer
vonMayernstiftete,detailliertundkorrektabgebildet.

Abb.5SalomonKleiner,SchemamausoleiregumBohemiae,quodPragaeestindiviViti
(Detail).
Im zweiten Geschoss mit voller Steinbrstung mit einem Akanthusfries und Putten steht
mittig das Rckpositiv, das wir auf Bechtelers Holzrelief identifizieren konnten, diesmal aber ohne
FlgelzumAbschlieen.
ISBN9789460184833
50
Den Orgelprospekt knnen wir mit der Zeichnung von 1563 vergleichen. Bis auf kleine
UnterschiedeindenBgendesmittlerenTeilsistdieGliederungdesProspektesidentisch:Aufvier
kannelierten Sulen oder Halbsulen mit korinthischen Kapiteln ruht ein Geblk mit dreiteiligem
Architrav, einem Fries, auf dem glatte Metopen mit Triglyphenkonsolen wechseln, und einem
abgestuftenGesims.IndenSeitenfeldernsinddiegrtenPfeifenvonAuennachInnenabfallend
gestaffelt, der mittlere Abschnitt hingegen gliedert sich in drei Pfeifenfelder, in denen die Pfeifen
jeweils zur Mitte aufsteigend angebracht sind. Ein ovalfrmiger Lorbeerkranz, gehalten von zwei
Putten an der mittleren Achse des Prospektes, trgt ein Wappen mit fnf Gegenstnden am
silbernenFeld,dasnichtidentifiziertwerdenkonnte.
DieZeichnungvon1563zeigtnichtdieganzeOrgelesfehltinsbesondereeinhoherSockel,
wobeiKleinereinFeldmitMusikinstrumenten,beflgeltenKpfenundeinemBandmitBockkpfen
undFestonsdargestelltist.SolcheBockkpfekennenwirunteranderemauchaufdenKapitellenin
denArkadendesLustschlossesBelvedereimKniglichenGartenamHradschin(Abb.6).7

Abb.6WandkapitellmitZiegenbockkpfen,SommerschloderKniginAnnaBelvedere,
PragerBurg.
Als oberer Abschluss der Orgel waren drei Wappen angebracht: das mittlere Wappen der
Habsburger wird von Greifen gehalten, das sdliche zeigt den bhmischen Lwen. Vom
kunsthistorischenGesichtspunktistdieAbbildungdessdlichenOrgelflgelsvomgrtenWert,an
dem die Auferstehung Christi dargestellt ist. Christus mit gehobener rechter Hand hlt die
Siegesflagge in der Linken. Darunter sieht man das Grab, umgeben von Soldaten. Eine Bordre
umrahmt die Szene, die eher an das Bandlwerk von Kleiners Zeit erinnert als an das
BeschlagwerkausderZeitvonFrancesoTerzio.
DieDarstellungdesFlgelsistineinemPunktetwasproblematisch:DievortretendeSulen
oder Halbsulen wrden es erschweren, die Orgel zu schlieen und so vor Staub zu schtzen.
ISBN9789460184833
51
Dennoch mssen wir dankbar sein, dass uns diese Vedute Kleiners eine seltene historische
DarstellungderRenaissanceorgelberliefert.
Noch einige Angaben zur Grsse des Instrumentes: Da wir die Disposition mit der
Beschreibung der Register kennen (Pedal Principal ganz durch 32 Fu8), kann man mit einer
Pfeifengre um 10 m rechnen. Die Gesamthhe der Kirche betrgt etwa 32 m, das zweite
StockwerkderOrgelemporereichteetwabiszurHhevon15m.DieverbleibendeHhefrdieOrgel
darberbetrugalsoca.17m(beieinerBreitevon13m),wobeidieserBereichaufdemStichKleiners
weitestgehendvomoberstenOrgelgeschoausgeflltgewesenzuseinscheint.
ImRahmendiesesBeitragsistesnichtmglich,sichzurAutorschaftdereinzelnenTeileder
OrgeloderzuihremTypusundFormzuuern.TrotzdemmchteichaufeineParalleleaufmerksam
machen,diedieFragederVorlagenteilweiseangeht:EshandeltsichumeinehervorragendeOrgel,
diekurzvordemPragerInstrumententstand,inderMailnderMauritiusKirche.9Wiebekannt,ist
Francesco Terzio Bergamese durch seine Abstammung und Schulung mit der Kunst Norditaliens
verbunden und es ist ganz legitim, als Vergleich diese Orgel heranzuziehen, die Gian Giacomo
AntegnatiindenJahren1554bis1557schuf(Abb.7).

Abb.7GianGiacomoAntegnati,OrgelinderMauritiuskirche
inMailand.
Es handelt sich um ein Schrankinstrument, das im Inneren durch kannelierte Pfeiler in
mehrereFeldergegliedertist.InnerhalbdieserGliederungsinddiePfeifenzurMittehinaufsteigend
ISBN9789460184833
52
gestaffelt. Der Reliefdekor ist hnlich wie in Prag. Auf den Flgeln, die man schlieen kann, sind
groe Gestalten der Hll. Barbara und Katharina dargestellt, umrahmt von einer Bordre von
hnlichenAusmaenwieinPrag.EinKuriosumsinddieRelieffigurenderhalbnacktenSirenenausder
OdysseusLegende, die deutlich belegen, wie stark die Beziehung zu antiken Themen war, die es
mglichmachte,solcheMotiveaneinerOrgelineinerchristlichenKirchezuverwenden.
DieErforschungderMusikemporeundderRenaissanceorgelimSt.VeitsDominPrag,diefr
unser Wissen ber die knstlerischen Aktivitten des Prager Statthalters Erzherzogs Ferdinands II.
von Tirol von gleicher Bedeutung wie z.B. die Erforschung des Areals mit dem Namen Neuer
ThiergartenSternmitdemeinzigartigenLusthaus,oderderAusstattungdesKniglichenGartensauf
der Prager Burg (mit Springbrunnen, Fischkalter usw.) sind, ist noch nicht abgeschlossen. Diese
AusfhrungenwarennuneinersterSchrittindieseRichtung.
Bibliographie
Dank,Petr,AuswahlbibliographiezurMusikkulturamHosRudolfsII.,StudiaRudolphina,9(2009),
pp.14255.
Dank Petr, Hudebn kruchta Musicloft, in Rudolfinsk PrahaRudolfine Prague, ed. Ivan P.
Muchka(Praha,2006),pp.976.
Hilbert, Kamil, Hudebn kruchta v chrm sv. Vta na Hrad Praskm, asopis Spolenosti ptel
staroitnosteskch,17(1909),pp.117,4147.
Hilbert,Kamil,Okruchtvdmusv.Vta,asopisSpolenostiptelstaroitnosteskch,32(1924),
pp.140146.
HolzschuhHofer, Renate, Feuereisen im Dienst politischer Propaganda von Burgund bis Habsburg.
Zur Entwicklung der Symbolik des Ordens vom Goldenen Vlies von Herzog Philipp dem Guten bis
KaiserFerdinand,RIHAJournal,6(16.August2010).
Muchka, Ivan P., Musikrume der rudolfinischen Zeit: Methodisches zur musikwissenschaftlichen
undkunsthistorischenPraxis,StudiaRudolphina,9(2009),pp.10009.
Quoika,Rudolf,DiePragerKaiserorgel,KirchenmusikalischesJahrbuch,36(1952),pp.3545.
Abbildungen
Abb.1,6,7PhotoAuthor
Abb.2PhotoAuthor
Abb.3NationalarchivinPrag.
Abb.4,5sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,Wien.
ISBN9789460184833
53
Zur Prager Orgel siehe vorallem Quoika 1952; einen guten berblick, Hilbert 1909, pp. 117, 4147 und
Hilbert,1924,pp.14046;Muchka2009,pp.10009.BibliographiesieheDank2009,pp.14255.
2
Diesen Begriff bentzten auch die Architekten und Knstlersiehe die Regesten im Jahrbuch der
Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen des Allerhchsten KaiserhausesKaiser Ferdinand I (Reg. 4284), Hans Tirol
(Reg.4282),BonifazWohlmut(Reg.4288)undvieleandere.
3
ZitiertnachQuoika1952(sieheAnm.1),p.35.
4
Vgl.Dank2006,p.76.
5
Sign.N,DKMIV,P191I/Blatt347.
6
IchbinmeinemKollegentpnVchafrdieBereitstellungeinerReproduktionderVeduteSalomonKleiners
ausderNationalbibliothekinWiensehrdankbar.
7
IneinerNachrichtvom13.Mai1563informiertFrancescoTerzio,dermitderBemalungderOrgelbeauftragt
war,denKaiser,dassdieOrgelmitKonsolen,Blten,Rosetten,Bockkpfen,Kapitellengeschmcktwird.Siehe
Reg.4346[...]Primolemensolechesononumero22.Itemroseefiorininumero18,.Itemtested'arietenumero
9. Item capitelli numero 4, i quali da me sono ingessiati, rasciati, et puliti et similmente le sue base. Sehr
wahrscheinlichhandeltessichbeidenBockskpfenumeineAllusionaufdenOrdenvomGoldenenVliesund
aufdieHabsburger,siehedazuHolzschuhHofer2010.
8
SieheQuoika1952(zitiertinAnm.1),p.45.
9
ChiesadiS.MaurizioalMonasteroMaggiore.
ISBN9789460184833
54

PalacesontheEdgeoftheAtlantic
TheArchitecturalReformationandtheSpaceRitualizationofthePortuguese
RoyalResidencesduringtheReignofPhilipIofHabsburg(15801598)
MiltonPedroDiasPacheco

PortugalisminebecauseIinheritedit,boughtitandconqueredit!
D.PhilipIofPortugal

FourhundredyearsafterthedeathofD.PhilipIofPortugal(PhilipIIofSpain,1527|1580
1598)wehavestillnotclearlyrecognizedallthemajorarchitecturalandartisticcampaignspromoted
inthePortugueseroyalpalacesduringhisreign.Despitethefullscalebiographiesdedicatedtothe
Habsburg king that portray him as deeply connected with imperial expansion and religious
fanaticism, he must also be seen as a profoundly devoted patron of the arts, a dedicated
Kunstfreund.2
D.PhilipI,thePrudent,wassonoftheHolyRomanEmperorCharlesV(15001558),fromthe
AustrianHouseofHabsburg,andqueenElisabeth(15031539),princessofthePortugueseHouseof
Avis.AfterseveralpoliticalmovementsheinheritedpartofthevastHabsburgEmpire.Ashereditary
princehereceivedtheNetherlandsandalltheSpanishpossessions,whichincludedtheItalianstates
ofNaples,Milan,SardiniaandSicily,andtheFrenchregionofBurgundy.Bymarriage,hewasbriefly
kingconsort of England and in 1580, through de iure sanguinis but chosen by the divine will,3 he
inheritedthethroneofthePortuguesekingdomandvastoverseasdomains,includingtheterritories
of America, Africa and Asia, an empire on which the sun never set. Under his rule, the Habsburg
EmpireintheWestreachedtheheightofitsinfluenceandpower.
In order to consolidate his political position, after the acclamation ceremony at Tomar
Courts, on 16 April 1581, the monarch decided to observe and maintain all the vowed national
sovereignprivilegesandtraditionalprerogatives.So,ashadbeenpredictedinTomarschartersigned
atthePalaceofAlmeirimon20March1580,thekingwouldkeepthesamelegislativerights,withthe
exclusiverightofnationalnominationforadministrativepositions;economicrights,withacurrency
of his own; religious rights, with the appointment of innate bishops; and cultural rights, with the
native language. Despite his deep suffering because of the queens death, during the acclamation

ISBN9789460184833
55

ceremony D. Philip I wore a white and gilded brocade suit to demonstrate to his new subjects the
continuityofthePortugueseprotocolroyalrites.4
AccordingtosomeSpanishandPortugueseGoldenAgeauthors,Lisbonwastheeyesofthe
IberianPeninsulaandoneofthemosteclectic,economicandcrowdedcitiesofEuropeatthetime.It
wasinanycasetheperfectcapitalfortheWesternHabsburgEmpire.Curiously,in1580oneofthe
worstfearsofthedualmonarchyopponentswasthesuspicionthatthekingwantedtoestablishthe
Empires capital at Europes tail and reinforce Lisbon as the utmost economic city of the world,
combiningalltheAtlanticandIndiccommercialroutes.5Obviously,thekingwasnotgoingtoneglect
thegeographicpotentialoftheLisbonportsforthemilitarycampaigns,sinceitwasfromthemthat
he prepared numerous armed expeditions, in particular against England, as his successors did too,
themostfamousbutalsothemostdisastrousepisodebeingLaArmadaInvenciblein1588.
Raised with a deep religious faith but with an education firmly in the spirit of the
Renaissance,themonarch,ashehaddoneinotherdomains,undertookanenormousarchitectural
campaign in Portugal, erecting or renewing important public infrastructures such as bridges,
aqueducts,fortresses,andmanyothers.Healsomadelargesumsofsilveravailabletoproceedwith
therenovationofsomeemblematicconventsandmonasteries,especiallythosewhichwererelated
with the foundation of the kingdom.6 In 1590 the marquis of Velada, Gmez Dvila (15411616),
described the three main passions ofthe king, his own personal trinity, as architecture, gardens,
and hunting.7 These were indeed passions that he could enjoy to the full in the Portuguese royal
residences. Determined to restructure the Portuguese kingdom to his own image, the king would
spendmorethantwoyearsasthepowerfulrulerofthevastWesternHabsburgEmpireinPortugalin
order to reorganize it in accordance with the requirements for the administration of his global
domainsandhisconcernforpoliticalcentralization.
InLisbonthemonarchshadtwoprincipalresidences:the13thcenturyAlcazarPalace(Pao
daAlcova),ontheurbanhill,andasecond,early16thcenturyonelocatedalongthebanksofthe
Tagusriverembankments,theRiverPalace(socalledPaodaRibeira)[Fig.1].8Probablydazzledwith
the epics of medieval knights that led him to his sad adventure in North Africa, D. Sebastian of
Portugal(1554|15571578)hadshownpreferenceforthefortifiedresidence(moreforitssuitability
than its exquisiteness9), which he reformed. For that reason he relegated the River Palace to the
background, and it entered into a certain material decay, already having been affected by two
earthquakesinthe16thcentury.ThemedievalappearanceoftheRiverPalace,stillinthePortuguese
lateGothic,socalledManuelinostyle,wasvisiblefromtheexteriorinitsdifferentbuildingmasses,a
conditionthatdeterminedthecomplexityanddisorderofitsinteriorsandexteriors(liketheAlcazar
ofMadrid),especiallyifcomparedwiththerigidframesofthemonasterypalaceofSanLorenzodeEl
Escorial.10
Although D. Philip I soon recognized the impossibility of living regularly in Portugal, after
some personal observations about the material situation of the Portuguese Crown residences he
promptly decided to promote an intensive program of architectural renovation and aesthetic
enrichment,notonlyofthemajorroyalpalace,butalsooftheothercountrysideresidences.Aiming
at a pomp and visibility combined with the sober and austere mood proper to the Counter
Reformation, he also established new court ceremonial protocols, both civil and religious, for the

ISBN9789460184833
56

public and private palatine dependencies. Once more, art patronage would become vital to
emphasizingthepoliticalprojectofrepraesentatiomajestatisandsotoreinforcingadherencetothe
SpanishHabsburgmonarchyontheseregionsontheedgeoftheAtlantic.

Fig.1Lisbonin1572withtheRiverPalace(below)andtheAlcazarPalace(above)
The truth, however, is that the monarch started his embellishment campaigns on the
Portugueseresidencesbeforeevenbeingacclaimedasasovereign.InNovember1580,thedukeof
Alba, Fernando de Toledo y Pimentel (15071582), already in Lisbon after the invasion of the
kingdom,senttothekingtheplansoftheroyalresidencestoprepareforhisarrivalatLisbon,which
wasprobablycarriedoutbytheministerMigueldeMoura(15381600).11Afterthathesentalsothe
building plans for the Salvaterra de Magos countryside palace made by the Italian Filippo Terzi
(15201597),whowasalsotoberesponsibleforthelatedesignsofthePalaceofAlmeirim.Theplan
for Lisbon alcazar was made by Giovanni Battista Antonelli (15271588), another Italian military
engineerworkingonthismajorreformplan.12
Inhisletters,thedukeofAlba,whowastheprincipalchamberlainofRoyalHouseholdand
the first Portuguese viceroy nominee, describes both Lisbon residences. Concerning the palace
erected near the river, he mentioned that it was a gloomy house, "sad as a prison" and that the
second one, in the castle, was too cold to spend the winter periods.13 Therefore, both residences
weredefinitelynotsuitableforoccupationbytheKingsMajesty!

ISBN9789460184833
57

Curiously, some years earlier, in 1571, the Portuguese humanist Francisco de Holanda
(c.15181585)hadalreadydeclaredthatLisbonlackedonedecentroyalresidence,stressingfurther
the absence of a resilient fortress to keep the city safe.14 Could this be the reason for the regular
absenceofthekingD.SebastianfromthecapitaltenyearsbeforeD.PhilipI acclamation?15Besides,
the cardinalking D. Henry of Portugal (1512|15781580) refused to live in the main royal palace
after his acclamation, thus creating a situation that certainly did not contribute to the cause of
buildingmaintenanceduringbothreigns.
So it was that as early as 14 January 1581 the monarch instructed Duarte Castelo Branco
(c.1540?), count of Sabugal, to undertake a survey of all Portuguese royal residences projects,
mainlytheLisbonRiverPalaceandtheseasonalpalacesofAlmeirimandSalvaterradeMagos,with
the aim of lodging him.16 In order to give the building greater comfort and better internal
arrangements,themonarchcalleduponFilippoTerzitocoordinatetheprojectsexecution,aidedby
thePortuguesemasterbuilderlvaroPires,bothundertheadministrativesupervisionofthecount
ofSabugal.17
Despitetheopinionofseveralauthors,wecannottodaybesurewhowasthearchitectthat
drew the architectural plan of the palace, whether it was the Italian Filippo Terzi, or whether the
Spanish Juan de Herrera (15301597) made a contribution of his own. Furthermore, the name of
another Spanish architect, Francisco de Mora (15531610), appears to have been involved in a
secondphaseatthebeginningsofthe17thcentury.18Actually,HerrerahadcomeuptoPortugalwith
themissionofoverseeingtheinstallationofthekingsembassyinTomarsCourtsandpreparingthe
officialentranceinLisbon,19buthereturnedimmediatelytoSpaintotakeoverthenumerousroyal
architecturalprojects.20OurpositionisthatTerzi,aBolognesemilitaryengineerattheserviceofthe
PortugueseCrownsince1577andlaternominatedmajorarchitectengineerofthereign,projected
and directed himself the several campaigns under the close proximity of the king and his royal
architect.21
Onthebasisoftheletterssenttohisyoungdaughters,IsabelClaraEugenia(15661633)and
Catalina Micaela (15671597), during the Royal Journey of Portugal Succession, it appears that
between1581and1583themonarchmadeseveralappointmentsrelatedtothepalatineresidences,
suchasLisbon,Sintra,AlmeirimandXabregas.22ConcerningtheLisbonofficialresidence,whichhad
been erected as the new economic and financial centre by the spices king D. Emmanuel I
(1469|14951521),grandfatherofD.PhilipI,neartheshipbuildingharborcomplex(theRibeiradas
Naus)andtheIndianandMineCommerceHouses(CasasdaMinaandIndia),D.PhilipIdescribedit
asahugebuildingwithlargecorridors,anexoticanddelightfulinteriorgarden,andseveralbalconies
withmagnificentviewsoverthecity.Nevertheless,despitethecuriositythatwasevident,hepoints
outthatitwascarelesslyorganizedinternally.23
TheavailablesourcesleadustobelievethatTerzimetthemonarchinElvasinJanuary1581
todiscussthearchitecturalplanspersonally.Thekingspecifiedtherefurbishmentoftheresidential
wings,includingtheroyalchapeldedicatedtotheapostleoftheOrient,SaintThomas,andelevated
topatriarchalstatus24duringthereignofD.JohnV(1689|17061750).InthesubsequentAprilthe
Italianarchitectinformedthekingthattheworkshadbeeninterruptedduetolackofmoney.25

ISBN9789460184833
58

Asthekinglaterwrotetohisdaughters,theworkswerealmostfinishedbeforetheofficial
entryofD.PhilipIintotheLisbonPalace26on29June,precededbyamagnificentjoyeuseentrewith
fifteentriumphalarchesplannedbyHerrera.27However,ontheoccasionofthekingssecretvisitto
thepalacefourdaysbefore,inthepresenceofhisnephewandfutureviceroy,themonarchsawthe
progress of the works and stressed that the building still revealed some internal spatial disorder,
perhapsonaccountofthelargesizeoftheresidentialstructure,whichwasareasonfortheexcessive
expensesthathehadnotanticipated.Upuntil27August1581,theCrownhadalreadyspent40,000
ris,thePortuguesecurrencyofthetime,withinthemaximumamountof200,000.28
After the elder resident members of the royal Avis court were evicted, the Habsburg king
manifested his intention of giving a larger unit to the palatine monument, reorganizing its interior
and facades according to the classical and austere principles of Mannerism. But the major
architecturalworkwastheturretconstructionattheextremeendofthepalacecomplexalongside
theriverandovertheoldbulwark.Theescorialescopalatineturret[Fig.2],withdirectaccessfrom
theriver,wascoveredbyanoctagonalleaddomeandhadonitsfirsttwofloorsanarmsroomand,
asweknowfroma16thcenturydrawingandadescriptionwrittenin1619,theartillerywarehouse.29
Above these, between other rooms and stairs, was the royal library; on the last floor,
occupying the entire area, was the throne chamber, also known as the ambassadors room.30 The
main connecting corridor between the palatine residential areas and the turret, a late medieval
colonnadewithseveralarchesandbalconies,wasclosed.Thesefirstworkswerecompletedbefore
1598.31

Fig.2TheRiverPalaceafterD.PhilipIsintervention.DetailfromanengravingpublishedinJoo
BaptistaLavanha,ViagemdacatholicarealmagestadedelReyD.FilipeII(Madrid,1622).

ISBN9789460184833
59

Precedingtheambassadorsroomwasanotherspacedevotedtothepublicstagingofroyal
power,theTudescosroom,32whichaccommodatedtheGermanroyalguardofhalberdiersservingin
closeproximitytothemonarch.Itwasamultifunctionalgreatchamberwherethemostimportant
ceremoniestookplace,andwheretheking,andviceroysandgovernorslateron,gatheredthecourt,
acclaimedtheirsovereigntyandmadetheiroaths,33ashappenedon30January1583,whenprince
Philip,futureD.PhilipIIofPortugal(PhilipIIIofSpain,1578|15981621)wassworninasheirtothe
Portuguesethrone.34Itisobviousthatallthesearchitecturalchangeswouldleavetheirmarkonthe
adjacent urban environment, especially around Commerce Square (Praa do Comrcio/Terreiro do
Pao).
In a brilliant political move D. Philip I had the last two Portuguese kings reburied in the
Monastery of Belem before abandoning the kingdom in February 1583, taking with him the
PortugueseCouncil.AshisviceroythemonarchappointedhisnephewthearchdukeAlbertofAustria
(15591621), who was assisted in government by a group of statesmen.35 Having been in Portugal
since the end of 1580, and after having assumed the reins of government two years later, the
archduke would continue with the embellishment works desired by his uncle at the royal palaces
until1593,theyearinwhichhewascalledtoMadrid.36
Even though out of the kingdom, the monarch followed closely the works on the Crown
palacesthathadbeenhisprojectfromthebeginning,ashehadduringtheperiodhewasamongus,
withtheconstructionofthegreatmonasterypalaceofElEscorial.Fromthismomentonwards,the
royal residence of Lisbon would be a public image of the kings majestic power and the
representationofhisauthority,butanemptypalacewithoutthepresenceofhislegalrepresentative
regisimagorexest.37Infact,asthetestimonyofIncioFerreira(16thcentury)suggests,withthe
kingsdepartureLisbonbecamealmostawidowcity.38
The court established by the viceroy in Lisbon was a princely one but it was domestic in
characterbecausethemostimportantnoblemenwentwiththekingtoMadridandtheotherswent
totheircountrysidedomains,wheretheypromotedminorvillagercourts,astheworkofFrancisco
RodriguesLobo(15801622)entitledCourtsintheVillagesuggests.InaccordancewithPortuguese
royalceremonial,itwasalsointhisgreatchamberthatthekingsreceptionsandprivateandpublic
banquetswereheld,ashappenedlaterduringthevisitofD.PhilipIIin1619.Althoughcommittedto
respecting the Portuguese court rites, the monarch would change them, introducing a new set of
ritualizedbutrigidgesturestosymbolicallyreinforcethekingsimageandperson.
In 1593, after the absence of the viceroy, D. Philip I issued the Kingdom Governors
Regimentation. In this royal ordinance the King established a new court protocol, which stipulated
rigid rules of procedure and planned the demand for a hieratical distribution of the royal power
spaces,reducingtheuseofthepalatineareas,butemphasizingtherepresentationofthegovernorin
public.39Afterall,thegovernorswerethemonarchsagents,butwerenotthekinghimself.
FranciscoPorrasdelaCmara,whoparticipatedintheJourneyofLisbon,aSevillianembassy
preparedbyJuanNezdeIllescasatthebeginningofthe1590s,givesusparticulardescriptionsof
Lisbonpalaceinteriors,whichhedescribesasbeinggreatandworthyofthegreatnessandmajesty.
Itwasprobablyinthemainreceptionapartmentthatthechroniclerwatchedatheatricalcomedy,in

ISBN9789460184833
60

thepresenceofaneccentriccourt.Inaccordancewiththeceremonial,thearchdukewasatoneend
oftheroom seatedon thethroneunderthecanopy,surroundedbywealthyaristocrats,illustrious
ambassadorsandexoticjesters.40
Regarding the organization of space, we are acquainted with the existence of two major
intercommunicating courtyards. One of them led to the royal audience and chancellery chambers,
andtheotheronetothegovernmentaldepartmentsandalsototheroyalchapel.41Nearthemost
privateareaswerelocatedthegardensthealegretes42whichweredescribedbythekinghimself
in 1581 as a very pleasant garden, embellished with colorful little tiles and perfumed by many
different trees and flowers.43 In the north and east extremes of the palatine complex, facing the
greatNewStreet(RuaNova)andthemajorsquare(TerreirodoPao),werethehousingareasforthe
RoyalFamilyandthecourtiers.ThiswaswheretheempressMaryofAustria(15281603),motherof
thearchdukeAlbertofAustria,stayedashersonsguestwhenshevisitedLisbonin1582.44
Unfortunately, iconographic sources illustrating only the external facade of the palace are
rare,thoughwhenconsideringtheinteriorsPorrasdelaCmaranotedthemagnificentmarbleand
jasper architectural structures.45 The global vastness of the Habsburg Empire facilitated the
acquisitionofthemostrefinedmaterials,whichweretransformedbythemostreputedartists:the
marblebeingfromthePortugueseminesofEstremoz,thejasperfromtheSpanishminesofOsmaor
Espeja, the exotic woods from the Indian or Brazilian forests, the works in gold or lapis lazuli from
Milan,andtheextravagantdamasktissuesfromGranada.46
Nevertheless,therestillexistsararedocumentarydescriptionoftheiconographicprogram
oftheornamentationinthethronechamber.Itscompositionillustratedseveralqualitiesandvirtues
oftheHabsburgmonarch:notonlygreatnessandmagnificence,butalsodevoutnessandprudence,
whichwerealsoconsiderednecessarytoarulerofsuchagreatempire.47
Thedecorationprogramdisplayedaningeniousmythicalandhistoricalsuccessionofthemes,
whichweredepictedinthirtysevenpaintingsasatestimonytothevastnessanddiversityoftheking
domains.OnthetopoftheroofweretheRoyalArmsoftheHabsburgmonarchandaboveitaglobe
withthecityofLisbonintegratedwithinamapofHispaniaflankedbyseveralallegoricalsignsofthe
zodiac and enriched with distinguished Latin mottos. Despite his profound piety, the monarch was
represented as the Greek hero Hercules (or might it be Ulysses, the mythic founder of Lisbon city
Ulissipone?)inthepresenceofthemajorOlympicgods,especiallythosewhowereassociatedwith
theocean,inathemealsoexploredonthetriumphalarcheserectedinLisbonin1581.48
The paintings attributed to the Italian Tiburcio Spannocchi (1541c.1606), who is generally
consideredabetterpainterthanhewasanengineer,49weredirectedbyGonaloPirezinLisbonin
theyear1590.Startedduringthegovernmentoftheviceroy,thesedecorativeworksremainedthere
until 1593. In fact, when Albert of Austria was already in Madrid, he received other architectural
plansoftheroyalpalaceinLisbonthatprovethattheartisticcampaignwasbeingcontinued.50
Despite some improvement works during the next decades, we believe that the palatine
structure, which acted as the symbolic presence of the House of Habsburg in Portugal, did not

ISBN9789460184833
61

changeinitsessenceuntilthemajorrenovationduringthereignofthePortuguesesunkingD.Joo
Vinthe18thcentury.
Althoughwe donot knowin detailtheprogressof theresidentialworks,we doknow that
thechapelwasfinishedinthemiddleofOctober1581.Locatednearthekingsprivateapartments
thehouseofthekingbeingnexttothehouseofGod51thechapelwasrenovatedduringthisperiod
butwithsomeancientstructuresbeingpreserved,suchastheprivategalleriesinwhichthemonarch
couldattendMassandwhichwereenshrinedintheirfullintimacy.52
Renewingthebuildingandadorningitwithdevotionalimagesandpreciousrelicswasoneof
thekingsmajorreligiouspassions.Nowitwasnecessarytoupdatetheroyalchurchinstitution.In
the absence of a proper, wellorganized ceremonial and musicians of quality, the king decided to
intensifythereligiousobservances.PreservinginitiallytheBourgognetraditionalrites,53thekingfirst
hiredabodyofmusiciansincludingsuchfiguresastheSpanishcourtorganistHernandodeCabezn
(15411602)54, son of the famous Antonio de Cabezn (15101566), and then ordered the
preparationofthefirstritualstatutesforthechapelroyal.
PrintedinJanuary1592underthesupervisionofthemajorchaplain,BishopJorgedeAtade
(15351611), the new ceremonial was twenty chapters long and established a corps of ninetytwo
officials,bothreligiousandnonreligious.Inadditiontoabattalionofchaplainsandacolytes(thirty
and twenty respectively), there were around thirty musicians: twentyfour singers, two organists,
twobassoonistsandonecornetplayer.55WeshouldnotforgetthattheGoldenAgeofSpanishmusic
occurred during the reign of D. Philip I, when the court music reached its highest splendor in
Europe,56aCatholicEuropedefendedandrepresentedbyhisroyalperson.
Describedasalittlecathedral,theroyalchapelwasaprivilegedinstitutioninsideoftheroyal
institution; and as such it was a highly hierarchical space in the framework of the kings public
appearance and ritualization.57 Among those who preached here in 1582 was one of the most
eloquentpreachersofthetime,theSpanishDominicanLuisofGranada(15041588),thesamefriar
whohadoriginallyconsideredD.PhilipIsacclamationtothePortuguesethroneillegitimate!58
Butallthisbegsonequestioninparticular:Whatwasthereasonforthereorganizationofthe
chapelritualprocedures?OnecluemaybefoundinalettersenttothecountofOlivaresEnriquede
Guzmn y Ribera (15401607), in which Juan de Silva (15281601), the Spanish ambassador who
became the 4th count of Portalegre by marriage, criticizes, after the detachment from the kings
Court, the royal chapel for its peculiarly vain ceremonials. Could it be that the king had wanted to
piouslysubverttheDivineCulttohisroyalconditioninCourtatthattime?59
Before the threat from the English navy, especially from 1585, the military architects
Giacomo Palearo (c.15201586) and Leonardo Torriani (c.15601628) were given the mission of
renovatingtheentirePortuguesenetworkofcoastlinefortresses.TheecclesiasticalhistorianBaltasar
Porreo (15691639), nephew of the architect Francisco de Mora, testifies that the king was also
responsible for the renovation of the ancient Lisbon alcazar and all the Tagus river fortresses,
providingthemwithnewmilitaryarchitecturalstructuresandartillerymechanisms.60

ISBN9789460184833
62

As in Spain, the royal countryside residences were located near the capital in fertile plains
with pleasant forests amply stocked with game and were plentifully fitted with gardens and
fountains.Theseprovidedthekingwiththemainreasonsforhisregularvisits:hecameinsearchof
amusementandpleasureinhuntingandequestriansports.Curiously,theseleisureactivitieswerea
littlebitdifferentfromthecityones,suchastheviolentbullfightingorthefrighteninginquisitorial
autosdaF.
We have found no documentation of work being done on the palatine residences of
Santarm during Philips reign, despite the bad material condition of both buildings. According to
some documents, in January 1531 the marquis of Tarifa revealed in one of his letters that both
palaces were ruined, scattered on the ground. Another source dating from February 1622 tells us
that those buildings still remained in the same material condition, 61 even though Isidro Velazquez
(16thcentury)reportshavingstayedathispalace!62ButwhyisthatD.PhilipIIofPortugal/IIIofSpain
wasaccommodatedinthehouseofthecountofTaroucawhenhevisitedSantarmfewyearsbefore
inOctober1619?63
When one considers the events of 1580, when the village of Santarm gave political and
military support for D. Antonios acclamation as king of Portugal, one can understand the king not
promotinganypalacerestoration.On19June1580D.Antonio(15311595),priorofCratoandthe
illegitimate son of the prince D. Louis (15061555), one of the most young descendants of D.
Emmanuel I, was popularly acclaimed in Santarm, that is to say, in the same village where he
established the resistance base until the defeat of his troops in the Battle of Alcntara, near the
Portuguesecapital.64ItisalsonotablethatwhenthepriorofCratoreceivedthekingsambassador
Gutirrez de Valencia in March 1580, he was lodged at the palace of D. Antonio de Castro, after a
firststopatthelocalDominicanmonastery.Accordingtothediplomaticaccount,D.Antoniowasina
residencesurroundedbyhisnoblesupporters,inapalatineenvironmentthatwasreminiscentofa
kingscourt.65Andthen,whenD.PhilipI,duringhisexpeditionfromTomartoLisbon,stoppedfora
fewdaysinSantarmbetween2and6June1581,hewaspoorlyreceivedbythepeople.66Theking
couldcertainlynothavehadgoodmemoriesofthisvillage,asaresultofwhich,insteadoftryingto
eradicatethesymbolicpresenceofD.Antonio,hepreferredtodespiseit.67
Consideredoneofthemostfavoritewinterresidencesof16thcenturyPortugueserulers,the
countrysidePalaceofAlmeirim,nearSantarm,wasthescene,on12May1543,ofthemarriageby
proxy between D. Philip I represented by his ambassador in Lisbon, Luiz Sarmiento de Mendoza
(14921556)andthePortugueseprincessD.MariaManuela(15271545),daughterofthekingD.
John III (1502|15211557) and the Austrian D. Catarina of Habsburg (15071578), the princes
aunt.68AnditwasalsowherethecardinalkingD.HenriquegatheredtheCourtstochooseD.PhilipI
asthelegalsuccessortothethroneon11January1580,andalsowherehewasburied.69Infact,the
palaceshouldhavebeenveryspecialtotheking,becauseithadbeenthesceneofseveralimportant
momentsinhislife.
Thefirsttimethathevisitedtheresidencewas6June1581,withthepurposeofbecoming
acquaintedwiththegoodqualityofthebuildingandthenearbygamereserves.70Oneyearlater,the
kingreturnedtherewithhissister,theempressMaryofAustriaandhisson,theprinceAlbert.71

ISBN9789460184833
63

Oncemore,weknowneitherwhentheworks,whichweresupervisedbythearchitectlvaro
Pires and the gardener Rodrigo lvares, started, nor the dimensions of the construction work.72
CommissionedbytheprinceD.Louis,fatheroftherebelPriorofCrato,thePalaceofSalvaterrade
Magos(Fig.3)wasalsopartofthecountrysideresidencesnetworkwheretheroyalfamilydedicated
itselftothehuntandpleasuresofthegarden.LeavingfromAlmeirim,thekingarrivedatSalvaterra
deMagosonThursday8April1581.73
In 1589, D. Philip I disposed of an annual budget of 80,000 for architectural building and
gardening maintenance, which was later confirmed in 1595. In 1581 the choice fell on the palace
gardener Rodrigo lvares, the Portuguese disciple of the royal gardener the Italian Jernimo de
Algora,whoworkedatthepalatinegardensofAranjuez.74However,thecharacterofthemonarchs
interventionisnotknownbecausethebuildingwaslaterrebuiltaftertheearthquakeof1755.Now
all that remains of the original building is the royal chapel, where we can be sure that the king
prayed.

Fig.3ThePalaceofSalvaterradeMagosinthe1740s(detailfromanexvotopainting)

In 1581, D. Philip I ordered Giovanni Battista Antonelli to complete the Tagus river
navigational course, already started in the Spanish river Manzanares by Juan Bautista de Toledo
(c.15151567), with the purpose of connecting the two Iberian capitals: Lisbon and Madrid.75
However,theorderprovedimpossibletofulfillandtheprojectlinkedonlypopulationcenterswhere

ISBN9789460184833
64

royal residences were located, such as Toledo and Aranjuez on Spanish territory, or Almeirim and
SalvaterradeMagosonthePortugueseside.76Healsomadesomewonderfulobservationsaboutthe
gardensandfountainsofthecountrysidePalaceofSintraandvisitedthePalaceofXabregaswhenhe
arrivedinLisbon.77ButneitherinthecaseofthecountrypalaceofSintranorinthatofXabregasare
weatpresentawarethathemadeanymaterialintervention.
WithaprivilegedviewovertheMondegoriver,theancientAlcazarofCoimbrawastheoldest
seats and had been one of the main royal residences of the Portuguese kings for more than four
centuries,fromthe12thtothe15thcentury.Sincethenithadfulfilledtheroleofasecondaryroyal
residencethatwassubstantiallyrestoredtomakeitmorecomfortable;finally,itwasmadethehome
oftheUniversityofCoimbraafteritsfinalaccommodationinthecity,in1537.
Goingonwithhispolicyofcreatingavigorousnetworkofroyalresidencesforitinerancyuse
bytheroyalfamilythroughoutthePortuguesekingdom,onSeptember30,1583,D.PhilipI,already
in Spain, sent Manuel de Quadros (?1593), the future Bishop of Guarda, to demand the handing
over of the palatine alcazar to the university institution and the construction of new buildings for
academicpurposes.78
Theofficialacademicvisitorcalledforthetemporaryhandingoverofthebuilding,reclaimed
it, and suggested the construction of a new one nearby.79 Beyond this measure, there is also the
question of the kings punishment of the scholars who gave ideological support to D. Catherine of
Braganza (15401614) and then military support to D. Antnio as legitimate heirs to Portuguese
thronethreeyearsearlier.
Facedbythesubstantialcostsandinconvenienceofsuchanenterprise,theUniversitywrote
to the king pleading for the royal building to be put at its disposition. The monarch replied to this
petition on 30 September 1583, stressing the necessity of restoring the palatine residence for the
reasonthathewishedtohavethereadecentdwellingforhimself,asheplannedtovisititsoon,as
wellasaplacetostayforhissuccessors.Inreality,thekingalsohadaspecialconnectionwiththis
fortifiedpalace,becauseitwaswherefirstwifeD.MariaManuelahadbeenborn.
ThatthisprocesslastedalmosttheentirereignofD.PhilipIisclearfromthefactthaton17
May 1597, through a royal decree, he eventually sold the building to the University for 30,000
cruzadosofsilver.80Knownfrom16OctoberofthatyearastheSchoolsPalace(PaodasEscolas),as
itisstillknowntoday,theacademicinstitutionkeptsomeoftheroyalbuildingprerogatives,suchas:
thechapelshonorableroyaltitlewithallceremonialritesandimmunityfromepiscopaljurisdiction;
thealcazarprison,reservedonlyforscholars;andtheroyalguardofhalberdierswiththeirtraditional
garmentsandweapons.81
ButeventhoughD.PhilipIandhissuccessorsdidnotbearagrudgeagainsttheUniversityof
Coimbra, the academic institution, by contrast, was after 1640 to exclude the three Habsburg
sovereignsfromtheschoolgalleryofroyalportraits...

ISBN9789460184833
65

Fig.4TheAlcazarofCoimbrainthe16thcentury(detailofthenorthfaade)

*
*
*
Inthissummarizedessaywehavemadeassertionsabouttheinvestmentmadeonthemainpalacein
Lisbon, which was D. Philip Is major patronage campaign in the capital if we exclude the majestic
construction of the Monastery of Saint Vincent also in Lisbon, about the renovation of the other
countryside residences in Almeirim and Salvaterra de Magos, and about the requisitioning of the
Coimbraalcazar.
Unfortunately we dont know the accurate dimension or the direct results of the artistic
campaignspreparedinthosemonumentswiththepurposeofmakingthemmorecomfortableand
more acceptable to the taste and to the political image of a devout, determined and exquisite
sovereign.Infact,notonlywerenewworkscarriedoutattheRiverPalaceattheendofthereignof
his successor, in order for him to be received in Lisbon in 1619, but the works carried out in the
followingdecadesinthereignofD.JohnVweredramaticallyerasedbytheearthquakeof1755.
Under the supervision of Italian architects based in Portugal, the ambitious refurbishment
programwasallpartofthekingsstrategyoflegitimizinghisrightstothethroneandenhancinghis
powerful image in accordance with the Portuguese palaces, which were places of identity and
political unity of real ostentation and royal celebration. These majestic p(a)laces were in any case
politicalinstruments,intendedtoreflecttheextensionofthepoweroftheking.

ISBN9789460184833
66

Curiously, the main events of the Restoration of Independence, which put an end to the
HabsburgDynastyinPortugalsdomains,tookplaceintheLisbonRiverPalace.Thisroyalresidence
on the edge of the Atlantic was where the duchess of Mantua, Margarida of Savoy (15891655),
Portuguesevicereinebetween1634and1640,wasdetained;whereherfaithfulsecretaryMiguelde
Vasconcelos(15901640)wasthrownfromapalacewindow;andwherefinallythedukeofBraganza
wasacclaimedkingofPortugalasD.JohnIV(1604|16401656).
Finally,everythingendedwhereithadbeguninthepalace!

Bibliography

Beirante,Mariangela,SantarmMedieval(Lisboa,1980).

Beirante,Mariangela,SantarmQuinhentista(Lisboa,1981).

Bouza,Fernando,D.FilipeI(Lisboa,2005).

Bouzalvarez,Fernando,LisboaSozinha,QuaseViva.ACidadeeMudanadaCortenoPortugal
dosFilipes,Penlope.FazeredesfazeraHistria,13(Lisboa,1994),pp.7193.

Bouzalvarez,FernandoJess,Retricadaimagemreal.PortugaleamemriafiguradadeFilipeII,
Penlope.FazeredesfazeraHistria,4(Lisboa,1989),pp.2058.

Bouzalvarez,Fernando,PortugalnotempodosFilipes(Lisboa,2000).

Braz,JosCampos,Santarm:razeshistricos(Santarm,2000).

Buescu,AnaIsabel,Memriaepoder:ensaiosdehistriacultural(sculosXVXVIII)(Lisboa,2000).

CmaraMuoz,Alicia,Fortificacionesycontroldelterritorio,inFelipeII.Unmonarcaysupoca.
Lastierrasyloshombresdelrey(Valladolid,1998),pp.121133.

Checa Cremades (Coordination), Fernando, Felipe II. Un monarca y su poca. Un prncipe del
Renacimiento(Madrid,1998).

ContrerasDomingo,Ignacio,LamsicaentiemposdeFelipeII,inFelipeII.Unmonarcaysupoca.
Lastierrasyloshombresdelrey(Valladolid,1998),pp.179186.

Correia,JoaquimManueldaSilva,OPaoRealdeSalvaterradeMagos(Lisboa,1989).

Curto, Diogo Ramada, A Capela Real: um espao de conflitos (sculos XVI a XVIII), Revista da
FaculdadedeLetrasLnguaseLiteraturas,10,(Porto,1993),pp.143154.

Curto, Diogo Ramada, Ritos e cerimnias da monarquia em Portugal, in A Memria da Nao,
(Lisboa,1991),pp.201265.

ISBN9789460184833
67

D.FelipeI,CartasparaDuasInfantasMeninas(Lisboa,1999).

Guerreiro, Afonso, Das festas qye se fizeram na cidade de Lisboa na entrada del Rey D. Philippe
(Lisboa,1581).

Gis,Damiode,DescriodaCidadedeLisboa(Lisboa,2001).

Kubler, George, A arquitectura portuguesa ch: entre as especiarias e os diamantes (15211706)
(Lisboa,1988).

Lobo,RoqueFerreira,HistriadafelizaclamaodoSenhorReiD.JooIV(Lisboa,1703).

Martinho,Bruno,OPaodaRibeiranasVsperasdoTerramoto(Lisboa,2009)[graduationthesis].

Martinho, Bruno, Pr a mesa no Pao da Ribeira. Espacialidades e encenaes da refeio no
interiordopalciorgio,AmesadosreisdePortugal(Lisboa,2011),pp.116133.

Meneses,Lusde,HistriadePortugalRestaurado,I(Lisboa,1679).

Moreira,Rafael,OTorreodoPaodaRibeira,MundodaArte,14,1983,pp.4348.

Moura,Miguelde,ChronicadoCardealReiD.HenriqueeVidadeMigueldeMoura,Typographiada
SociedadePropagadoradosConhecimentosteis,Lisboa,1840.

Nogueira,PedroAlvares,LivrodosbisposdeCoimbra(Coimbra,1942).

Oliveira,FreiNicolaude,LivrodasGrandezasdeLisboa(Lisboa,1991).

Pacheco,MiltonPedroDias,Paragovernaredesfrutar.Asresidnciaspalatinasdionisnas,Actasdo
CongressoInternacionalDomDinis.750anosdoseunascimento(Lisboa,2011).[inpress]

Pacheco, Milton Pedro Dias, Por detrs de um Museu. O Pao Episcopal de Coimbra: histria e
memria(Coimbra,2009).[graduationthesis]

Pereira,Paulo,Lisboa(sculosXVIXVII),speechpresentedatDeutschesHistorichesMuseumNeue
Welten,Novembrode2006,pp.127.

Pimentel,AntnioFilipe,ArquitecturaePoder:orealedifciodeMafra(Lisboa,2002).

Pimentel,AntnioFilipe,JooBaptistaRibeiroeosretratosrgiosdaSaladosCapelos,Boletimdo
ArquivodaUniversidadedeCoimbra,8(Coimbra,1986),pp.2363.

Pimentel, Antnio Filipe, O laboratrio da reconstruo: reflexes em torno do pensamento e da
prticadourbanismoportugus,inPropagandaePoder(Lisboa,2000),pp.347364.

Pimentel,AntnioFilipe,AMoradadaSabedoria(Coimbra,2005).

Pimentel, Antnio Filipe, Poder, corte e palcio real: os palcios manuelinos e a reforma
quinhentista da alcova de Coimbra, 2, in Universidade(s), Histrias, Memrias, Perspectivas,
(Coimbra,1991),pp.231253.

ISBN9789460184833
68

Pimentel, Antnio Filipe, Repercusses do tema do PalcioBloco na arquitectura portuguesa, in
ActasdelVIISimposioHispanoPortugus(Badajoz,1995),pp.8194.

Pimentel,AntnioFilipe,Asagraodoreinoemtornodo(s)projecto(s)daSVelha,Revistado
InstitutodeHistriadaArtedaFaculdadedeLetrasdeLisboa,3(Lisboa,2004),pp.87122.

Polnia,Amlia,D.Henrique(Lisboa,2009).

Porreo,Baltasar,DichosyhechosdelseordonFelipeII(Madrid,1723).

Ribot, Luis (coordinator), Felipe II. Un monarca y su poca. Las tierras y los hombres del rey
(Valladolid,1998).

Rodrigues,MartinhoVicente,SantarmnotempodosFilipes,2vs.(Santarm,2001).

Rossa,Walter,LisboaQuinhentista,oterreirodopao:prennciosdeumaafirmao
dacapitalidade,inActasD.JooIIIeoImprio(Lisboa,2004),pp.945967.

Senos,Nuno,OPaodaRibeira(Lisboa,2002).

Soromenho,Miguel,ArtePortuguesa.Aarquitecturadociclofilipino(Lisboa,2009).

Sousa,D.AntnioCaetanode,HistriaGenealgicadaCasaRealPortuguesa,III(Lisboa,1947).

Vasconcelos,Antniode,RealCapeladaUniversidade(Coimbra,1990).

Velazquez,Isidro,LaentradaqueenelReinodePortugalhizolaS.C.R.M.deDonPhilippe,invictissimo
ReylelasEspaas,segundodestenombreprimerodePortugal,assiconsuRealpresencia,comocon
elexercitodesufelicecampo(Madrid1583).

Viterbo, Sousa, Dicionrio histrico e documental dos arquitectos, engenheiros e construtores
portugueses,3vs(Lisboa,1988).

Illustrations
Fig.1GeorgBraunandFranzHogenberg,CivitatesOrbisTerrarum,1598.

Fig.2JooBaptistaLavanha,ViagemdaCatholicaRealMagestadedelReyD.FilipeIIN.S.aoReyno
dePortugalErellaodosolenerecebimentoquenelleselhefezS.Magestadeamandouescrever
porJooBaptistaLavanhasevcronistamayor,1622.

Fig.3JoaquimManueldaSilvaCorreia,OPaoRealdeSalvaterradeMagos,1989.

Fig.4Photoauthor,2011.

ISBN9789460184833
69

1
The Humanities Research Networking Programmes from the European Science Foundation, by conceding a
short visit grant, allowed us to make a public presentation of this essay at the international meeting The
HabsburgandtheirCourtsinEurope(14001700).BetweenCosmopolitismandRegionalism,organizedatthe
AustrianAcademyofSciences,Vienna,from7to10December2011.Wewouldliketoexpressourgratitudefor
alltheESFfinancialaidandthelogisticalsupportprovidedbythePALATIUMResearchNetworkingProgramme
steeringcommitteeProfessorsHerbertKarner,IngridCiulisov,KristaDeJonge,BernardoGarcaGarca,Pieter
MartensandNunoSenos.
2
Bouza2005,p.275.
3
Velazquez1583,f.19v.
4
Bouza2005,p.19.D.FilipeI1999,p.22.
5
Bouzalvarez1994,pp.75,80,82.
6
LiketheConventofSoVicentedeFora,inLisbon,ortheConventofChrist,inTomar,tonamebuttwo.
7
Bouza2005,p.247.
8
D.FilipeI1999,p.74,note40.
9
Pimentel1991,p.238.
10
FilipeI1999,p.63,note13.Senos2002,pp.8,70.
11
Moura1840,pp.129130.
12
Correia1989,p.25.
13
Senos2002,p.69.Kubler1988,p.120.Velasquez1583,f.65.
14
Bouzalvarez1994,p.85.
15
But we cannot forget that the 1569 plague was responsible for the Court retreat, for example. Velazquez
1583,f.5v.
16
D.FilipeI1999,p.22.Kubler1988,p.101.
17
D.FilipeI1999,p.63,note13.Viterbo1988,3,pp.9396.Pimentel2006,p.10.
18
Chueca Goitia advocated that Juan Herrera should be the major architect and Terzi the project promoter.
Bouzalvarez2000,p.83,note105.Ribot1998,p.278.
19
Kubler1988,p.101.
20
21
Viterbo1988,3,p.93;Kubler1988,p.101.
22
D.FilipeI1999,p.28.
23
Whenthekingshowedtheintimateapartmentstohissistertheempress,heconfessedthathewishedhe
possessedsuchstunningviewsinotherpalaces.Bouza2005,p.265.D.FilipeI1999,pp.15,150.
24
Pimentel2002,p.114.
25
26
Bouza2005,p.265.
27
28
D.FilipeI1999,p.74,note41,75,103.TorredoTombo,liv.26.fol.47daChancelariadelReiD.Sebastio,e
liv.45.fol.371quotedbySousa1947,pp.345353.JoaquimCorreia,PaodeSalvaterra,p.25.Velazquez1583,
f.118.
29
Butisittruethattheoldfortresswouldregainitsmilitaryfunction,integratingtheTagusestuarydefense
network?Oliveira1991,pp.144,145.Moreira1983,pp.4345.
30
Moreira1983,p.43.
31
Senos2002,pp.39,70,75.Bouzalvarez2000,p.83,note108.Kubler1988,p.104.
32
Menses1679,pp.99,368,904.Lobo1703,pp.158,164,167,310.
33
34
ForabetterunderstandingoftheinteriorspacesseeSenos2002andMartinho2009.D.FilipeI1999,p.182.
35
Bouza2005,p.196.
36
D.FilipeI1999,p.61.
37
38
Bouzalvarez1994,pp.7476.
39
Martinho2011,pp.120,125.
40
Bouza2005,pp.197,198.
41
Bouza2005,p.197.
42

ISBN9789460184833
70

43
D.FilipeI1999,p.161.
45
Bouza2005,p.197.
46
Porreo1723,pp.117118v.
47
Bouzalvarez2000,pp.83,89.Kubler1988,103.
48
Actuallythekinghadalreadyusedthethemesofmythologicalheroestorepresenthimselfinthecollection
orderedfromTitianthirtyyearsbefore.Bouza2005,p.265.Bouzalvarez2000,pp.8389,101104.Guerreiro
1581,cap.V,p.4;cap.XI,pp.15.Velazquez1583,f.121141v.
49
CmaraMuoz1998,p.130.
50
Bouzalvarez2000,pp.8385.Moreira1983,p.45.
51
Pimentel2002,p.205.
52
Bouzalvarez2000,pp.8385.Curto1991,p.228.
53
WiththeagreementproposedbytheCardinalKingD.Henrique,inNovember10,1579,thefuturekingwas
obliged to respect several official regulations, namely that the maintaining and administration of the royal
chapelshouldbedonelocally,asthe23chapterprovided.Polnia2009,pp.277,278.
54
55
Curto 1993, p. 149. Nogueira 1942, pp. 226, 227. Patente das merces, graas, e privilegios, de que elrei D
Philippenossosenhor,1583,cap.XXI.Gabinetehistrico,174550,p.132
56
ContrerasDomingo1998,p.179,185,186
57
Curto1993,p.154.
58
D.FilipeI1999,pp.115,131,note140.
59
Curto1993,pp.151.
60
Porreo1723,pp.92,93,109.
61
Beirante,1980,p.61.Beirante,1981,pp.44,67.

62
63
Rodrigues2001,I,p.93.
64
Rodrigues2001,I,pp.59,69.
65
Butitisneverthelesspossiblethatthemeetingoccurredatonelocalreligioushouse,sincethechroniclers
arenotveryclearinthismatter.Bouza2005,p.206.Velazquez1583,fs.27,36v,37.
66
Guerreiro1581,cap.I,pp.2,3.
67
Braz2000,p.71;D.FilipeI1999,p.71,note33.
68
The ceremony was celebrated by the future Portuguese CardinalKing, D. Henrique, who was largely
responsibleforthepromotionoftheIberianUnionundertheSpanishHabsburgCrown.Polnia2009,p.28.
69
ThecardinalkingwasburiedatthemainchapeloftheroyalpalaceofAlmeirimandlatertransferredbyD.
FilipetotheMonasteryofBelm,theroyalmausoleumofthePortuguesekingssinceD.EmmanuelI.Velazquez
1583,f.110v.
70
Guerreiro1581,cap.II,pp.1,2.Velazquez1583,f.110v.
71
D.FilipeI1999,p.143;Rodrigues1997,I,pp.55,93.
72
73
74
D.FilipeI1999,p.143.Guerreiro1581,cap.II,pp.25.Correia1989,p.25.
75
IsidroVelazquezdescribedthepiernexttothepalaceandthegoldenbrigantineusedtotransporttheroyal
family.Velazquez1583,f.112.
76
Bouza2005,p.230.Porreo1723,p.93.
77
Bouza2005,pp.207,230.D.FilipeI1999,pp.88,100.Velazquez1583,f.117v.
78
FollowingtheroyalPortuguesetraditionthekingD.FilipeIwasdesignatedprotectoroftheUniversityMarch
9,1583.
79
Vasconcelos1990,pp.1920.
80
Pimentel1991,p.249.
81
Vasconcelos1990,pp.2023.

44

ISBN9789460184833
71

II
Imperial,RoyalorPrincelyIdentity
andRegionalPatriotism

ISBN9789460184833
72
HabsburgMythologyandtheWaldstein
PalaceinPrague
JanBaant

In the 1620s Albrecht of Waldstein wholly identified himself with the Holy Roman Empire.1
Nevertheless,allusionstohispersonagehaveallegedlybeenfoundandarestillpredominantlybeing
sought in the decoration of his palace in Prague (162130), Czech Republic.2 The most famous
exampleistheMarsofBaccioBiancointheGreatHall,whichistraditionallyinterpretedasacrypto
portrait of Albrecht von Waldstein in spite of the fact that archival documents do not corroborate
this identification. In his autobiographical letter of 1654, Baccio Bianco wrote: The Great Hall was
already finished [].His Excellence ordered me to paint something on the ceiling. The hall was
already decorated with arms and trophies in stucco. Pieroni proposed that I paint the chariot of
Mars. I have made a drawing and its form was well received.3 The formulation of Baccio Biancos
reportimpliesthatamartialthemewasallocatedtotheGreatHallfromthebeginningandthatthe
iconographyoftheceilingpaintingwasproposedbyarchitectGiovanniBattistaPieroni.Waldsteinis
notmentionedanywhere.
In all the scholarly books and guides the ceiling painting in the Great Hall of Waldsteins
PalaceinPragueisinterpretedasacryptoportraitofWaldstein(fig.1).Why?BaccioBiancosMars
hasafullbeard,whileWaldsteinwasalwaysportrayedwithacarefullytrimmedgoatee.Marsface
has the same physiognomic features as all the other men Baccio Bianco painted on the walls of
Waldstein Palace and there is nothing in this representation which enables us to connect it with
AlbrechtvonWaldstein.TheattributesofMars,thestarabovehisheadandthesignoftheplaneton
the shield, point exclusively to the planetary divinity. Moreover, he is represented exactly like the
Mars in the Sala Terrena of Waldstein Palace, who could not possibly be Waldstein. So, why
Waldstein?

Fig.1MarsintheGreatHall
ISBN9789460184833
73
TheanswermustbesoughtinAlbrechtvonWaldsteinsstatusinCentralEuropeanhistorical
consciousness.Afterthedukehadbeenassassinatedon25February1634,asearlyasMarchofthat
yearaveryinfluentialbookappearedinPraguewhichsummedupthemainargumentsofimperial
propaganda, which still influence our perception of this man. The Latin title of this unsigned
pamphlet,writtenbyacertainAlbertvonKurtz,maybetranslatedasfollows:HavocofDisloyaltyof
Albrecht of Friedland or the Hell of an Ungrateful Soul.4 According to this pamphlet, the Duke of
FriedlandwantedtobecomekingofBohemiaandorganizedanuprisingwiththeaimofseizingthe
Czech lands, which were the hereditary property of the Habsburgs. In the subsequent centuries, a
positive evaluation of Waldstein prevailed because of his antiimperial attitude. Especially in
Germany and Bohemia, this was taken for granted and he was sometimes even portrayed as a
pioneeroftheresistancetoRomeandtheHabsburgs.
Although the Czech language and nationhood were revived in the nineteenth century, the
CzechscouldnotseparatethemselvespoliticallyfromtheHabsburgempire.Atleast,however,they
couldsystematicallycuttheHabsburgsoutoftheculturalhistoryoftheirland.Specialcarewastaken
toweakentheHabsburgpresenceinPragueshistoricalmonuments.Whilenobodyatthattimewas
interestedintheimperialthemesinthedecorationoftheWaldsteinPalace,anylinkwithitscreator
would, on the contrary, be most welcome. An 1848 edition of a guide to Prague contains the
followingpassageaboutWaldsteinspalace:
After great and famous victories by which he conquered for the Emperor the whole of
northernGermanyhefellintoimperialdisgraceandbuiltitashisresidence.Herehesetupa
courtsomagnificentthatitequalledeventhatoftheEmperor[].[IntheGreatHall]hehad
himselfportrayedonaceilingasavictoronatwowheelchariotdrawnbyfourhorses,with
astarabovehishead,whichisdecoratedwithalaurel.5
Needlesstosay,thereisnolaurelpaintedonMarshead.
Inthetwentiethcentury,whenarthistoriansstartedtoanalysethedepictionofMarsonthe
ceilingoftheGreatHall,itsidentificationwithWaldsteinwassofirmlyestablishedthatitoccurredto
noonetosearchforitsroots.ThemoststrikingfeatureofWaldsteinsPraguepalaceisnotwhatit
reveals, but what it hides. What we miss on the faade and in the palace interior is any direct
referencetoitsbuilder.Neitheronthepalacefaadenorinitsinterioristhereanythingwhichcould
be connected directly with Albrecht Wenzel Eusebius of Waldstein, Duke of Friedland and
Mecklenburg, Generalissimo of the Imperial Army, Admiral of the North and Baltic Seas, and
Supreme Commander of Prague. The Waldstein Palace in Prague is one of the biggest aristocratic
residences,butitsbuilderisabsentfromitsdecoration.Whomandwhatdoesitthencelebrate?
FerdinandII
IntheseventeenthcenturythefirstroomthatvisitorsreachedwastheGreatHall,wheretheywaited
beforetheywerereceived.Thehallwascolossal,notsomuchtoaccommodatewaitingvisitors,but
abovealltoshowoffWaldsteinslargebodyguardlinedupalongthewalls.Webegintheinspection
ISBN9789460184833
74
oftheGreatHallattheoriginalentrance,whichisoppositethepresentone.Onthenorthernsideof
thehalltherearetwodoors,buttheonenearthewindowsfacingthestreetisasham(fig.2).

Fig.2ThenorthernwalloftheGreatHall,withtheoriginalentranceontheright
Waldsteinsguestsenteredthroughtheeasterndoor.TheywerewelcomedintheGreatHall
not only by the dukes guard lining the walls and Mars on the ceiling but also by stucco genii with
outstretchedwingslookingdownonthemfromundertheceiling,executedbySantinoGalliin1623.
Thesesnowwhiteguardsweretheoppositeineveryrespecttothedukesguardsmeninfullarmour.
Thegeniiarenakedandholdthegildedsymbolsofapeacefulreignintheirhandspalmbranches,
laurelwreathsandcrowns(fig.3).

Fig.3Geniiwithawreath,apalmleaf,acrown,andacrownwithinsertedpalmleaves
ISBN9789460184833
75
To the left of the original entrance a genius stands to introduce this heavenly guard to
Waldsteins visitors (fig. 3, far right). Over the heads of all who enter the Great Hall he raises a
symbolconsistingofacrowninwhichtwopalmleavesareinserted.InWaldsteinstimeeverybody
knew this symbol because it was the personal emblem of the Holy Roman Emperor, Ferdinand II,
who used this emblem together with the motto LEGITIME CERTANTIBUS (To those who who fight
withhonour),whichrevealsthemeaningofthecombinationofcrownandpalmleaves,symbolsof
victory(fig.4).6AmongsttheitemsonwhichFerdinandIIrepresentedhimselfwiththisemblemisa
medal mintedto commemoratetheBattleof the White Mountainof20November1620,inwhich
thearmyoftheCzechEstateswasdefeated.

Fig.4EmblemofFerdinandIIinJacobTypotius,
Symboladivinaethumana(Prague,1601),fig.106
IntheGreatHalltheheavenlyguardhasitsleaderisrepresentedintheimportantplacein
themiddleofthesouthwall.Inhisrighthandheholdsthelaurelwreathandwithhislefthandhe
ceremoniously raises the marshals baton to stress that peace is victorious. On either side he has
adjutantswithpalmbranches:thegeniusonhisleftpointstohisheart,whilethegeniusonhisright
points upwards to the ceiling fresco of Baccio Bianco, which is the culmination of the halls rich
decoration (fig. 5). In a reading that is both unsubstantiated and improbable, the Czech patriotic
mythseesWaldsteininthefigureofMarsonthisceilingfresco.Afarmoreseriouscandidateisthe
geniusholdingamarshalsbaton,whomightreallybeAlbrechtvonWaldsteinsalterego.Thisgenius
leads the heavenly mission, which is explicitly defined as the mission of Emperor Ferdinand II. The
horrorofwar,whichtheceilingwithMarshasevoked,isthusavertedandthewallsoftheGreatHall
ofWaldsteinspalaceacquireasymbolicdimension.Ithasbecomeanimpenetrablebarriertowar,a
guaranteeofeternalpeace.
ISBN9789460184833
76

Fig.5Geniionthesouthwall,themiddleoneholdingaloftthemarshalsbaton
WarDefeated
TheceilingfrescooftheGreatHallrepresentsMarsinarmouronawarchariot,headingintobattle
togetherwithhiscompanions(fig.1).Thissubjectwasinspiredbythefunctionofthishall,inwhich
Waldsteinparadedhisguard.InGermanythistypeofhallwasknownasaTrabantensaal(hallof
companions).ThemostfamousanalogyforWaldsteinsGreatHallistheHallofMarsinthePalaceof
Versailles, named after the ceiling painting of 1672 by Claude II Audran. The Hall of Mars was
originally reserved for the guard, which was announced by the ceiling painting representing Mars
ridingintheskyinachariotdrawnbywolves.
IntheWaldsteinPalace,Marsisclearlyidentifiedbythestaroverhisheadandthesignof
theplanetonhisshield.Raisedinhishandisalethalweapon,thespikedmace.ItisMars,butheis
notrepresentedhereastheOlympiandeity.WhileinancientmythologyMarsalwaysfightsaloneor
withotherOlympians,BaccioBiancorepresentedMarsattheheadofanarmydressedandarmed
like soldiers of Waldsteins time. This Mars is clearly a personification of War. The true nature of
Mars army on the ceiling of the Great Hall of the Waldstein Palace is revealed in a similar
representationpaintedbyAntonioBelluccifortheLiechtensteinPalaceinViennabetween1697and
1704.7 In this ceiling painting we also see Mars in his chariot as he rides through the clouds into
battle. The god is as dignified as his Prague counterpart, perhaps even more so, because he is
represented allantica. But Mars companions in Vienna are ugly, naked savages who aggressively
urge their lord to demonstrate his full destructive powers. This painting also features the spiked
mace but we do not see it in Mars hand: instead, a naked Turklike barbarian raises it in his right
hand,whilepushingMarsforwardwithhislefthand.
ISBN9789460184833
77

Fig.6AntonioBellucci,Mars,16971704,LiechtensteinPalaceinVienna
Mars in the Great Hall of Waldsteins palace personifies War, which dominates the ceiling
decoration. Thecentralpanelwith the chariotofthegodofWarisflankedbypanelswith painted
trophies,whichreappearinthestuccoreliefsontheperimeteroftheceiling.TheGreatHallisnot,
however,atempleofMars:itswallsarenotintheDoricorder,asitwouldbefitthegodofWar,but
are Ionic in style. Genii with symbols of peace and just rule are standing on fragments of Ionic
entablature supported by Ionic pilasters. If we completed the entablature in our imagination, we
couldbestandinginsideanIonictemple,atempleofpeaceandprosperity,inwhichthedemonof
warisforeverimprisoned.
TheImperialDynasty
AccordingtotheinventoryofthepalacefurnishingsdrawnupstraightafterWaldsteinsdeath(1634)
therewerenoportraitsofhimorofmembersofhisfamily.8Instead,thepalacewasfullofportraits
ofmembersoftheHabsburgimperialdynasty.Themostimportantportraitswereinthesouthwing,
whichcontainedanenfiladeofthreerooms.ThroughtheGreatHallthevisitorsenteredtheKnights
Hall, where Waldstein received collective audiences. This was separated by the Antechamber from
the Audience Hall, where the duke received only the most important visitors.9 In the Knights Hall
there were portraits of Emperor Ferdinand II and his wife, and in the Antechamber portraits of
Ferdinand III and his wife. These were fulllength, lifesize representations, which was the most
official type of portraiture. The Habsburg portraits were complemented by a series of twelve
portraits of ancient Roman emperors.10 The gallery of portraits which originally decorated the
KnightsHallandAntechamberwasmeanttoemphasizethecontinuitybetweentheancientRoman
Empireanditssuccessor,theHolyRomanEmpire,whichwasatthattimefirmlyinHabsburghands.
ISBN9789460184833
78
Consequently this double portrait gallery clearly highlighted the dynastic idea. Just as in ancient
RomerulepassedfromoneEmperortothenext,intheHabsburgfamilyitpassedfromfathertoson.
The decorative schemes of the individual rooms in Waldsteins palace were interlinked.
WhileintheGreatHallWaldsteinsvisitorswereconfrontedwiththepersonificationofWar,inthe
followingtworoomstheywereassuredthattheimperialdynastywouldnotallowthefuryofwarto
reign forever. The opposite number of the Triumph of War on the ceiling of the Great Hall is the
GoldenAge,akeyelementintheHabsburgimperialpropaganda,whichwasexplicitlycelebratedin
theAudienceHall.
TheGoldenAge
The Audience Hall was richly decorated with a wall painting which Baccio Bianco created between
1623and1624.DepictedontheceilingisthevisitofVenustotheworkshopofherhusbandVulcan,
who is preparing new armour for her son Aeneas (fig. 7). The Audience Hall was the heart of
Waldsteins palace and its ceiling fresco was the key representation and emblem of the whole
residence.ThankstoVulcansarmour,AeneasbecamelordofItalyandfoundedtheIuliandynasty,
fromwhichnotonlytheancientRomanemperorsbutalsotheirHabsburgsuccessorsderivedtheir
origins. Vergils Aeneid contains two prophecies on which Habsburg imperial mythology was
founded.WhenVenusconfidesinJupiteraboutherfearsforAeneas,thesupremegodcalmsherby
predictingnotonlyhersonsvictorybutthegloriousfutureofhiskinaswell:ThenshallCaesarbe
born,theTrojanfromthenoblefamily,whoseempireshallreachtotheseaandreputationtothe
stars.11 In the prophecy predicting the coming of the Golden Age under imperial rule, Anchises
speaksasfollowstohissonvisitinghimintheunderworld:Thereheis,therethepromisedman,as
youoftenheard,AugustusCaesarhimself,theDivinesonwhoshallusherintheGoldenAgeforusin
Latiumonceagain.12

Fig.7VulcaninhisworkshopwithVenusandAmor
ISBN9789460184833
79
IntheAudienceHallthecomingoftheGoldenAgeiscelebratedbytwosetsoffourpaintings.
Depicted on the vault is the succession of the ages, culminating in the Golden Age, while the
paintings on the wall celebrated the rulers virtues that are its precondition. The historical series
decorates the vault, counterclockwise. Beginning on the right of the entrance door, we see the
Gigantomachy(thebattleoftheOlympiangodswiththeGiants),theIronAge,theSilverAge,andthe
GoldenAge(fig.7).ThisreversaloftheageswasprophesiedinVergilsfamousFourthEclogue:The
greatlineofthecenturiesbeginsanew[]anewgenerationdescendsfromheavenonhigh[]The
ironbroodshallatlastceaseandagoldenracespringupthroughouttheworld!13Thesuccessionof
theageswasknownaboveallfromOvidsMetamorphoses.Theillustrationsof1610forthisworkby
AntonioTempestaprovidedthe modelsforthepaintings.14Thestartingpoint ofthe AudienceHall
decorationistheGigantomachy,whichisdepictedtotheleftoftheentrancedooronthenorthwall.
It is placed directly above the fireplace, the flames of which thus completed the depiction of the
GiantsattackingOlympus.

Fig.8Gigantomachy,IronAge,SilverAge,andGoldenAge
In the painting the Giants are characterized by their huge size, nakedness and long hair.
While in the foreground they are lifting rocks, in the background they are attacking heaven with
branches. The Olympian gods are defending themselves from behind the clouds; Jupiter, in the
middle,hasaboltoflightning,asOviddescribeshiminMetamorphoses:Renderingtheheightsof
heavennosaferthantheearth,theysaythegiantsattemptedtotaketheCelestialkingdom,piling
mountains up to the distant stars. Then the allpowerful father of the gods hurled his bolt of
lightning.15ThebasicdifferencebetweenGigantomachyandTitanomachywasthatinthelattercase
JupiteropeneduphisroutetopowerbyovercomingtheTitans,whileintheformercaseitwasthe
GiantswhoroseupagainstJupiter.Consequently,thedefeatoftheGiantscouldbepresentedasa
previewoflatervictoriesoverotherinsurgents.
In Habsburg iconography the Gigantomachy was a standard allusion to the dynastys
opponents. The greatest internal enemies of Ferdinand II were the rebellious Bohemian Estates.
After the Austrian and Hungarian Estates had joined their revolt, the Czech uprising practically
brought the Habsburg empire to the point of dissolution. The defeat of the Czech Estates was
therefore the greatest victory of Ferdinand II, and was appropriately immortalized in art. In 1622
FerdinandIIcelebratedthevictoryovertheBohemianEstatesandtheirWinterKingFrederickwitha
ISBN9789460184833
80
medal containing his portrait and the Gigantomachy on the reverse.16 On top there is Justice and
Jupiter,thealteregoofFerdinandII,whoiscastingdowntheGiantswithhisboltoflightning.Inthe
prominentpositionofbottomcentreweseeacrushedGiantwithFredericksattributes.Heislying
onhisback,withhishandshelplesslyoutstretched.Holdingasceptreinhislefthand,withhisright
handhetriesinvaintopreventthecrownfromfallingoffhishead.Thedepictionisaccompaniedby
Ferdinandsmotto:LEGITIMECERTANTIBUS.
Since theBohemianrebelliontookplaceonlyafewyearsbeforetheWaldsteinPalacewas
erected, it would be surprising not to find an echo of the rebellions suppression in its decoration.
WhenweentertheAudienceHallwehavetherepresentationoftheGigantomachyonourleftand
ourrightthatoftheIronAge,aboutwhichOvidwritesintheMetamorphoses:Andnowharmfuliron
appeared, and gold more harmful than iron. War came, whose struggles employ both, waving
clashingarmswithbloodstainedhands.Theylivedonplunder.17Intheforegroundofthepaintingan
armouredriderattacksasoldierwhoislyingdownandtryinginvaintodefendhimselfwithashield.
Inthebackground,soldierscaptureawalledcitytoplunderit.
TheprophecyofthecomingoftheGoldenAgewasthethemeofthetwopaintingsonthe
oppositesideofthevault.Whenweproceedinacounterclockwisedirection,universalpeacedoes
notcomeuntiltheSilverAge.Whileitistheageofuniversalpeace,alludedtobyawomanwhosits
withachildonherlap,itisalsotheageofhardwork,symbolizedbymenwithshovelsandbagsover
theirshoulders,amanploughingthefieldwithapairofoxen,andmendiggingapatchofground.
Finally,theSilverAgewillbefollowedbythecovetedGoldenAge,whenhumanbeingswillhaveno
enemies,asissuggestedbyawildanimalpeacefullywalkingpastthemen.Itwillbeablessedagein
which everybody will have everything without working; all they will have to do is to pick the fruit
from the trees. This terrestrial paradise is illustrated by naked people relaxing and happy children
immersedinplay.Thepaintingislocatedrightnexttothegardenwindow.Inthesamewayasthe
flamesofthefireplaceenhancedthehorroroftheGigantomachy,therustleofleaves,thegurglingof
fountains and bird song enliven the representation of the eternal peace and universal bliss of the
GoldenAge.
InthelunettesoftheAudienceHallwefindfourpersonifications.Inthewest,placedinan
importantpositionabove the entrancedoors,isGlory(fig.9,left),representedbyabarebreasted
womanwithacornucopia,thesymboloffertilityandplenty,inherlefthand.Shelooksupwardsand
hasaburstofraysaroundherhead;inherraisedrighthandsheholdsagoldenfigure,asymbolof
victory.Onthenorthwall,nexttotheGoldenAge,Victoryisbringingpeace(fig.9,right).Thisisa
youngwomanflyingthroughtheair;inherrighthandsheholdsalaurelwreathandinherlefthanda
palmleaf.Withherrightfootshetreadsonaheapofarmsandarmour.Belowherthereisanother
symbolofwar,aburnedoutcity.ThepainterrepresentedVictoryinayellowblouseandwhitedress,
asymbolofvictoryuntaintedbyanyguilt.
ISBN9789460184833
81

Fig.9GloryandVictory
Totherightoftheentrancedoorsonthesouthwestwall,Fame,withhugecolouredwings,
isholdingatrumpetinherraisedrighthand.Sheisdressedinalightrobehitcheduptomidcalfso
thatsheisabletorunquickly(fig.10,left).Whenweproceedinacounterclockwisedirection,we
findEternity,awomansittingonadarkcloud,withherlefthandrestingonacrescentmoonandher
righthandpointingtothesun(fig.10,right).

Fig.10FameandEternity
TwopanelswithputticonnectthewallpaintingswiththeceilingfrescorepresentingVulcan
makingarmourforAeneasatVenusrequest.BetweentheallegoryofEternityandFame,thereisa
puttowithaboltoflightningandAmorsbow,symbolsofJupitersandVenuspatronageofAeneas
(fig. 11, left). The putto on the opposite wall, with a quiver on his back and holding the helmet of
Aeneas,hasasimilarmeaning(fig.11,right).Thesepersonificationsdidnothaveageneralmeaning:
theyspecificallycelebratedthefameofvictoryandtheeternalgloryoftheHolyRomanEmperorsas
thedescendantsofAeneas.
ISBN9789460184833
82

Fig.11PuttowithboltoflightningandbowandputtowithAeneashelmet

AncestorsoftheHabsburgDynasty
TheAudienceHallisconnectedwithWaldsteinsprivateapartmentbymeansofagalleryfeaturinga
ceiling decorated with a cycle of sixteen wall paintings illustrating Ovids Metamorphoses. Baccio
Bianco painted them between 1623 and 1624, using as models Antonio Tempestas illustrations of
the Metamorphoses published in 1610.18 As his models for some scenes he also used older
illustrationsofVirgilSolisof1563.19Thesuccessionofscenescloselyfollowstheliterarywork.The
beginningoftheworld,withwhichOvidstartedhispoem,isrepresentedatthedoortotheAudience
Hall. Through scenes arranged in analogous or contrasting pairs, the wall paintings in the Lower
Gallerysumupthehistoryoftheuniverse.Intheseventhfieldtherearetwotragicdescents,Pluto
carryingProserpinatoHadesand,ontheoppositeside,Icarusfallingfromheaven.Thispairmakesa
dramaticcontrastwiththepairinthelastfield,whichflankthedoorstoWaldsteinsstudy.Inthelast
field,wefindtheapotheosesofAeneasandRomulus(fig.12).

Fig.12ThedeificationsofAeneasandRomulus
ISBN9789460184833
83
Although the Lower Gallery is known in the modern literature as the Mythological Gallery,
the main function of the strange tales from the mythical past which decorate its ceiling was to
prepare the ground for the key scenes flanking the doors of the Dukes study. The apotheosis of
Aeneas,whoisassistedbyhismotherVenus(fig.12,left),andtheapotheosisofRomulus,whomhis
fatherMarsdrivestoheaven(fig.12,right),representednotonlyamythicalpastbutaboveallthe
promiseofasplendidfuture.AeneasandRomuluswerenotonlymythicalheroes,butalsoancestors
oftherulingdynasty,whichwaswhatwasbeingcelebrated.
ThedecorationoftheUpperGallerycorroboratesourreadingoftheLowerGallery.Theeast
wingof the palaceofAlbrechtvonWaldstein containstwogalleries,theoneabovethe other. The
Upper Gallery connected the bedrooms of Waldsteins wife and the room which was probably
destined at the outset to be the childrens bedroom. The ceiling paintings by Baccio Bianco from
162324 that decorate the gallery do not have the intimate character we might expect. On the
contrary,theyaredominatedbythecelebrationoftheimperialhouse,asifitwasapublicspace.
TheHabsburgworldruleisalludedtowithaseriesofrepresentationsofthefourcontinents
ontheeastwall,variationsonmodelsintheIconologyofCesareRipa,theillustratededitionofwhich
wasfirstpublishedin1603.20ThepaintingontheceilingglorifiesthecosmicdimensionoftheHoly
RomanEmpirewithpersonificationsofthesevenplanets,whichareaccompaniedonbothsidesby
therelevantsignsoftheZodiac.Onthenorthernside,theseriesbeginswiththeMoon,followedby
Mercury, Venus, the Sun, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn. The planets are arranged in the traditional
manner,intheorderinwhichtheysupposedlyorbitedtheearth.
The modern name for the Upper Gallery, Astrological Gallery, is misleading. There is no
depictionofaspecificconstellationofplanetsinit,noristhereeventheslightesthintatastrology,
only the traditional Christian reading of the stars, that is, as a link between Earth and the upper
Heaven, the abode of God. After Saturn, the eighth and highest sphere, follows the wall behind
which the bedroom of Waldsteins daughter was situated. The wall is decorated with two
superimposedpersonificationsflankedbysymbols,exactlyasonthenorthernside.Butwhereason
the northern side plenty and public wellbeing are celebrated in general terms, the southern wall
bearsanallusiontotherulingdynasty(fig.13).
ISBN9789460184833
84

Fig.13AllegoryofthewiseruleofFerdinandIIonthesouthernwallofUpperGallery
Onthesouthernwallwefindacrownedwomanwithapeacock,theattributeofthegoddess
Juno, while on the left there is a sceptre and on the right a peacock. The Junoesque figure is a
personification of Virtue: as a peacock shines with its own feathers, so Virtue shines with its own
light.Belowthewomanwithapeacockthereisayoungmanwithawreathandspearinhishand,
symbolsofvictoryandofrule.Ontheleftaretwosceptresinsertedintoanimperialcrown,onthe
righttwopalmleavesinsertedintoacrownwithspikes.ThiswasthepersonalemblemofEmperor
Ferdinand II, which we have already encountered in the Great Hall. The young man with a wreath
thuscelebratesvictoriousrule,whichisexplicitlyspecifiedastheruleofFerdinandII.
AeneasVictory
The construction of the Waldstein Palace is a chronicle of its builders career in the Holy Roman
Empire.TheDukestartedtocreateitin1621whenhewasappointedastheSupremeCommanderof
Prague,andthemainbuildingofthepalacewasconstructedanddecoratedbefore1625,whenhe
wasappointedGeneralissimooftheImperialArmy.AfterhavingbecomeaPrinceoftheHolyRoman
Empire in 1624, Waldstein was made Duke of Friedland in 1627 and a year later Duke of
Mecklenburg, which were all very prestigious titles indeed. This triumphant entry into the elite of
European aristocracy brought with it considerably higher requirements, which Waldstein rose to
meetwithhisPragueresidence.Thisupgradeisevidentaboveallintheconceptionofthegarden,in
thetrulyimperialSalaTerrena,andinthemonumentalfountaindecoratedwithbronzesculptures.
WiththesefeaturesWaldsteinsurpassedeverythinghehadsofarcreatedinhisPragueresidence.
ISBN9789460184833
85
The most ambitious part of the architecture of the Waldstein Palace is no doubt the
impressiveSalaTerrena,whichistherightlyfamousmasterpieceofGiovanniBattistaPieroni.Itisno
ordinarygardenbuildingbut,rather,anarchitectonicandconceptualdominantofthewholepalace
complex,asisemphasizedbyitsgiganticsize,sumptuousdecoration,andthewayitdetachesitself
fromthegarden.TheimperialnatureoftheSalaTerrenaisreflectedinitsrichdecoration.Although
the niches in the walls are now empty, the painted decoration has survived. The Sala is decorated
withtwentyfourpaintingsandtensmallpanelsfrom162829inwhichapainterfromtheworkshop
of Baccio Bianco celebrated the Trojan hero Aeneas. The sequence of paintings begins with the
Sacrifice of Polyxena on the northern wall, behind which was situated the Audience Hall.21 As a
model,thepainterusedtheAntonioTempestaillustrationforOvidsMetamorphoses.22
OnthesouthernsideoftheSalaTerrenathereisascenewithNeptuneraisinghistridentto
calmaseastorm.ThiscompositionisknownasQuosego,aftertheversefromtheAeneidinwhich
Neptune rebukes the disobedient elements.23 This oftimitated type of Neptune was created by
RaphaelandowesitsenormouspopularitytoMarcantonioRaimondisengravingof151516.24Inthe
Sala Terrena the painting celebrated the end of Aeneas wanderings, while the painting on the
opposite side evoked its beginning. With the death of Polyxena the Trojan War was definitively
ended and Aeneas began the distressful wanderings that only ended thanks to Neptunes
intervention,makingpossiblethesuccessfullandingofAeneasarmyinItaly.
In the interpretation of the paintings in the Sala Terrena, visitors are guided by the plaster
genii incorporated into the architectural decoration of the walls. While the genii at the sides of
Polyxena are turning away from the tragic scene, on the opposite wall the genii are rejoicing in
Neptunes timely intervention. The genius on the right is triumphantly pointing to the stormy
heavenswhichthegodoftheoceanshastamed.ThegeniussittingbeneaththeimageofpiusAeneas
onthewesternwallistheonlyoneintheSalaTerrenawhoisalsolookingatapaintingaswellas
pointingtoit.Bydoingthisheisadvisingvisitorstostarttheirinspectionofthepaintingsatthatvery
point.InthreelunettesonthewesternwalloftheSalaTerrenatherearepaintingsfeaturingAeneas
asthemainhero.Ontheleft,inthesouthernlunette,wefindthewellknownpictorialtypeofpius
Aeneas,inwhichthehero,accompaniedbyIulus,isseencarryinghisfatherAnchisesfromburning
Troy.25ThepainterfollowedAntonioTempestasillustrationforOvidsMetamorphoses.26

Fig.14PiusAeneas
ISBN9789460184833
86

Fig.15GeniussittingbeneaththepaintingofpiusAeneas
The series continues on the opposite, northern side of the western wall with the Trojan
attackonLaurentum,thecapitalcityoftheLatinsdefendedbyCamilla,whomweseeonhorseback
intheleftcorner,theriderinfrontofherbeingAeneas(fig.16).WhenthecapitaloftheLatinswas
besieged, Aeneas set off on a dangerous journey through a mountain pass in order to attack
Laurentumfromitsundefendedside.Turnusdiscoveredhisplanandlayinambushtheretokillhim.
However,whenTurnuslearnedthatCamillahadfallen,hehadtoreturntothedefenceofLaurentum
and Aeneas was able to reach the Laurentum battlefield safely and win the war. The painters
inspirationwasanillustrationofAeneasepicpublishedforthefirsttimein1559,inwhichthemain
eventsoftheeleventhbookweresummedup.Intheaccompanyingtextweread:Aeneasarrivesat
theenemycity.Everybodystartstofight,theTrojansstarttoprevail,andCamillawasalsokilled.27

Fig.16Camilla(left)andAeneas(centre)
TheillustrationoftheAeneidculminatesinthemiddlelunettedepictingtheclosingsceneof
thewholeepic,Aeneashesitationbeforehisdeadlyblow(fig.17).WhenTurnuswasdefeated,he
ISBN9789460184833
87
beggedAeneastosparehislife,andtheherohesitated.Fierceinhisarms,Aeneasstoodwithrolling
eyes,andstayedhishand;andnowmoreandmore,ashepaused,thesewordsbegantoswayhim.28
The duel of Aeneas and Turnus, together with the depiction of pius Aeneas, was the most oft
illustratedsceneofthewholeAeneid.29

Fig.17TheduelofAeneasandTurnus
OnthevaultoftheSalaTerrena,betweenthelunettesandarchesofthearcades,areeight
figuresfromancientmythsaccompaniedbyinscriptions.Thechoiceandplacementoftheseheroes
andheroinesiscoherent.Theyaredividedintothreegroups:theGreeksbesiegingTroy,theTrojans
defendingtheircity,andtheTrojansandtheirenemiesinItaly.TheduelbetweenAeneasandTurnus
in the central lunette is flanked by the related figures of Aeneas and Pallas, an obvious choice
becausePallaswaskilledbyTurnusandhisdeathwasavengedbyAeneas.Depictedontheopposite
sideoftheSalaTerrenaareTurnusandCamilla,themainopponentsoftheTrojansinItaly.Asisto
beexpected,TurnusisfacinghisadversaryAeneas.ThequartetofprotagonistsfromVergilsAeneid
representedinthemiddleoftheSalaTerrenaisflankedbytheheroesoftheTrojanWarrepresented
inallfourcorners.OnthenorthernsidearedepictedtwodefendersofTroy,HectorandPenthesilea,
HectorthusbeingplacednexttohissisterPolyxena,whosesacrificeisrepresentedonthenorthern
wall.OnthesouthernsidearetwoprotagonistsoftheGreekinvasionarmy,AchillesandOdysseus
withthestatuetteofMinervathathestolefromTroy.
The Sala Terrena decoration culminates in its ceiling, where there are three panels with
Olympiangodsthearrangementofwhichiscloselylinkedtothedepictionsonthevaultandinthe
lunettes. The middle panel shows Jupiter, who is flanked by Juno, Aeneas main divine opponent ,
andVenus,hismainprotector(fig.18).Onthesouthernceilingpanel,abovetwoGreekprotagonists
oftheTrojanWar,OdysseusandAchilles,weseeanassemblyofgodswhosidedwiththeGreeks:
Minerva,Juno,Neptune,VulcanandMercury.Ontheleftthereisasmallpanelwiththeemblemof
themainsupportersoftheGreeks,Junospeacock;ontherightisJupiterseagle.Onthenorthern
sideoftheceiling,abovethemaindefendersofTroy,HectorandPenthesilea,whoareshowninthe
northern corners, we see an assembly of gods who sided with the Trojans: Venus, Apollo, Mars,
Diana,andtherivergodXanthos/Skamandros.Atitssidestherearetwosmallpanelswiththebirds
associatedwithVenus,theswanandthedove.
ISBN9789460184833
88

Fig.18VenusandAmor,Jupiter,andJuno
ThepainterwhodecoratedtheSalaTerrenaalsopaintedacycleofpaintingswithArgonauts
on the ceiling of the Banquet Room, which is behind the doors on the Salas southern wall. The
depictionofthequestfortheGoldenFleecewasaresponsetoaveryimportanteventinWaldsteins
lifethatconsiderablyheightenedhisidentificationwiththeHolyRomanEmpire.In1628hereceived
thehighestHabsburghonour,theOrderoftheGoldenFleece,whichwasanupdatingofthemythsof
JasonandtheArgonauts.AncientmythwasinterpretedalongChristianlinesandtheGoldenFleece
wasidentifiedwiththemysticalDivineLamb,whichthusfounditsgreatestprotectorintheGrand
MasteroftheOrder,therulingHabsburgEmperor.30AlthoughthedecorationoftheDiningHalland
SalaTerrenawasinspiredbyancientmyths,itsmessagewasthecelebrationoftheHabsburgdynasty
andtheHolyRomanEmpiretogetherwithitshistoricalmission.Jasonseasternexpeditioninsearch
oftheGoldenFleecewasaprefigurationofAlexandertheGreatsconquestsandhisempireinthe
East.However,muchmoreimportantforthefutureofmankindwastheduelbetweenAeneasand
Turnus,whichwasrepresentedinthemostimportantplaceintheSalaTerrena,inthecentrallunette
ofitsbackwall.ThisvictoryenabledthedescendantsofthegreatTrojantobecomelordsnotonlyof
Italybutalsoofthewholeworld.
RebelsDebacle
The story told by the wall paintings in the Sala Terrena is continued seamlessly in the garden. The
counterpartofAeneasvictoryintheSalaTerrenaisthecelebrationoftheCzechrebelsdebaclein
thegardenstatuary.Althoughthepresentdayplacementofthegardenstatuesunfortunatelydoes
notcorrespondtotheiroriginalarrangement,thiscanbecorrectedinourimagination.Whiletoday
the fountain with a bronze statue of Venus with Amor is situated in front of the Sala Terrena,31 in
Waldsteins time this site was occupied by an elaborate fountain with bronze sculptures which
summed up the whole message of the dukes Prague residence. The fountain was crowned by
Neptuneandsupplementarilydecoratedwithfourdogs,fourhorseheads,twolionheadsandtwo
gryphon heads. It was complemented by four bronze sculptural groups on marble bases standing
betweenthefountainandtheSalaTerrena:Laocoonandhisson,theWrestlers,VenuswithAdonis,
ISBN9789460184833
89
andBacchuswiththelittleSatyr.32Thesestatueswerecreatedbetween1623and1627inthePrague
studioofthecelebratedAdriendeVries,formercourtsculptortoEmperorRudolfII.33
In1625,AdriendeVriescreatedastatueofLaocoon(fig.19),whichwasintendedtocrown
thefountaininfrontoftheSalaTerrenabut,atWaldsteinsrequest,wasreplacedbyNeptune.This
changewasevidentlyveryimportantforWaldstein,becausethisorderofhisseriouslyendangered
thecompletionofthegardensculptures.AdriendeVrieswasinhisseventiesatthetimeanddied
soonafterwards.TheNeptunestatue,thelastworkofthemaster,wascompletedinhisstudioafter
his death, in 1627. Before we ask why Waldstein preferred Neptune, we must ask ourselves what
madeAdriendeVrieschoosetheLaocoonmyth.

Fig.19Laocoon
All the sculptures which de Vries created for Waldstein represented classical themes and
could have had the same function as those created by this sculptor for the imperial residence of
RudolfIIatPragueCastle,namely,toturnPragueintoasecondRome.Thisseemslogicalbecausean
ancientRomangroupstatuedepictingthedeathofLaocoonandhissonswasafamousiconofRome,
asitwasahighlightofthePapalcollectionattheVatican.ButthePragueLaocoonisnotacopyofan
ancientoriginal:infact,itistheveryfirstvariationonthisancientthemeinEuropeanmonumental
sculpture. Although the Vatican statue was often copied, in spite of (or precisely because of) its
enormouspopularitynosculptorbeforedeVrieshaddepictedthestoryofLaocooninawaywhich
differedfromtheVaticanoriginal.NorwasthesecondvariationontheLaocoonthemecreateduntil
afulltwocenturieslater,whichmakesAdriendeVriessLaocoonabsolutelyexceptional.FordeVries
the subject itself was evidently more important than a reference to the ancient marble statue in
Rome,withwhichhisLaocoonhasonlytheunderlyingmythicalstoryincommon.
ISBN9789460184833
90
What could make Laocoon topical in Central Europe at the beginning of the seventeenth
century?LaocoonwastheTrojanpriestwhorevoltedagainstthegodsdecisionthathiscitymustbe
capturedbytheGreeks,forwhichhewasimmediatelycruellypunished.Whenhewaspreparingto
sacrifice to Neptune, two snakes emerged from the sea and strangled him together with both his
sons. Laocoon had to die because Troy had to be burned to allow Aeneas to arrive in Italy in a
sequenceofeventsthatwouldleadtothebirthofRomeanditsworldempire.AsatokenofGods
plan,Laocoonthuslegitimizedimperialruleonearth.AdriendeVriessLaocooncanalsobetakenas
alludingtothedefeatoftheBohemianEstatesintheBattleofWhiteMountainin1620.Whenthe
themeofLaocoonappearedinartofthattime,itwasalwaysinanegativecontext,asanexampleof
justlypunishedtransgression.IntheWaldsteingardenanimpiousLaocoonwouldbecomeanegative
counterparttopiusAeneas,whowastheancestorandalteregooftheEmperor.
Given that Waldstein decided that Neptune would fit better into the programme of the
decoration of his palace, we must ask what his motivation could have been. Adrien de Vriess
NeptunecalmingtheseaalludestotherelevantpassageintheAeneid,whichisalsoillustratedinthe
SalaTerrena.34RaphaelsQuosegotyperepresentstheangrygod,whoholdsreinsinhislefthand
andinhisrightaclearlymenacingtrident.ButAdriendeVriessNeptunedoesnotraisehisweapon
to strike: he holds it as an attribute in his left hand, and is even hiding it behind his back.
Furthermore,heisholdingtheterribletridentupsidedown,withthespikespointingdownwardsin
adetailthatmusthavebeendeVriessinventionbecausewedonotfinditonanyotherNeptune
statueofthistype.ThecontrasttoRaphaelsaggressiveNeptunecouldnotbegreater.TheNeptune
of Adrien de Vries has his right hand raised in a way which compares the ancient god to a mortal
oratorcalmingadisorderlycrowd.ItwasclearlyanallusiontothesubsequentversesintheAeneidin
whichVergilcomparesNeptunecalmingtheseatoamanwhoresolutelystandsupinthemiddleofa
civilriotandcalmsthemutineerswithhiswisewords.35Vergilsverseswereatransparentallusionto
the role of Emperor Augustus in the civil war. It was thanks to this that the iconographic type
enteredthepropagandisticartofWaldsteinstime.

Fig.20Neptunecalmingthesea
ISBN9789460184833
91
WhilethePragueNeptunecorrespondstothewaythegodwasrepresentedintheartofthat
time, Adrien de Vries intensified the image of the peacemaker with a number of small details.
Nevertheless,hisNeptuneisaspowerfulandauthoritativeasthatofRaphael.InPragueNeptunes
enemiesarerepresentedbyadog,anotheradditionofAdriendeVriesthatisabsolutelyuniquein
theiconographyofthisgod.Neptunewasoftenrepresentedwithhorsesordolphins,butneverwith
adog.ThedogwouldsuitPluto,butthereisnodoubtthatthestatuerepresentsNeptune,whichde
Vriesstressedbyaddingsmalldolphinstothetrident.ThedogrepresentstherebelstowhichVergils
description of Neptune calming the sea alludes. It could also allude to the defeated Bohemian
Estates.ItisaconspicuouslysmalldogwhencomparedwithNeptune.Thisdogisnomonster,merely
a dog that has got into a fury and has been quickly pacified by his master. He stands with head
threateninglylowered,tryingtobefrightening,butonlyatadistance,becauseNeptunesauthority
doesnotallowhimtoleavetheplacebetweenhisfeet.

Fig.21WrestlersandVenuswithAdonis
Neptunes fountain in the Waldstein garden was originally complemented by four statues,
which are all mentioned in the correspondence between Waldstein and Adrien de Vries. The
Wrestlers,whichaccordingtotheinscriptiononitsbasewascreatedin1625,mightbeadistantecho
ofanancientRomanstatue,butwasmostprobablyalsoanallusiontothedefeatoftheBohemian
rebels(fig.21,left).AdriendeVriescharacterizedhisstatueasagroupofthosewhowrestlewith
eachother,buttheiractionsdonotcorrespondtothisdescription,becausetheoutcomeofthefight
hasalreadybeendecided.Thelefthandwrestlerisrepresentedinadeepforwardbend,evidently
tryingtopulltherightwrestlerdowntothegroundwithbothhishands.Withhislefthandhehas
graspedhisopponentsshoulderandwiththeotherhandhisthigh.Heistheaggressor:hestarted
thefight,whiletherightwrestlerisonlyresolutelyreactingtohisactionandsuccessfullydefending
himself.Thevictorisrepresentedstandingfirmlyuprightwithlegsapart,butheisnotattacking:he
holdstheaggressorshandswithbothhishandssothathecanforcethemawayfromhisbody.The
ISBN9789460184833
92
righthandwrestlerisevidentlythewinner,becauseinthefollowingmomenttheaggressorwillbe
lyingontheground.Theallegoricalcontentofthewrestlersismadeclearbythelaurelwreathwhich
isdepictedontheground,aprizeawaitingthevictor,whofoughtwithhonour.
The wreath also appears in the 1624 group with Venus and Adonis, although it is never
includedin depictionsofthismythicalcouple!Duringthe hundredyearsspanning1600Venusand
AdoniswasaveryfashionablethemeinpaintingandweoftenfinditintheartofthePraguecourtof
RudolfII.ThetwoscenesmostoftendepictedwereVenustryingtostopAdonisfromdepartingon
thefatefulboarhuntandVenuslamentinghisdeath.TherepresentationofAdonisdeparturewas
noticeablystereotyped:werepeatedlyseeaseatedVenustryingtoembraceAdonis,whoiswalking
away.ThePraguestatueseeminglyconformstothistype,becauseVenusisalsorepresentedonthe
groundandsheisraisingherhandstowardsthewalkingAdonis(fig.21,right).Butthehunterisnot
departing: he is returning from a successful hunt with the game over his shoulder! Adonis
triumphant return is highlighted by the wreath in Venus raised hand, which occupies a central
positioninthegroup.
InWaldsteinstimethestandardallegoricalreadingoftheAdonismythwascentredonthe
heros refusal of divine counsel, his departure from Venus, and its tragic consequence. This would
make Adonis a perfect counterpart to Laocoon, who likewise disobeyed and had to pay for it. But
PraguesAdonisissafelyreturningfromahuntwithadeeron hisshouldersandVenusisgreeting
himwithawreathbecausehehasdoneexactlywhatshehadadvisedhim:Beboldwhentheyrun,
butbraveryisunsafewhenfacedwiththebrave.Donotbefoolish,bewareofendangeringme,and
donotprovokethecreaturesnaturehasarmed,lestyourglorybetomygreatcost.Neitheryouth
norbeauty,northecharmsthataffectVenus,affectlionsorbristlingboarsortheeyesandmindsof
other wild creatures.36 In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries we do not find any other
examplesofVenuswithawreathorthemotifofAdonisreturnfromthehuntwithasmallanimalon
hisshoulders.AdriendeVriesreversedthetraditionaliconographicaltype,butretaineditspolitical
message. The tamed Adonis obeys his divine master and is justly rewarded; or, when we translate
themotifintocontemporarypoliticalterminology,Adonismaybeseenasanobstinaterebelwhois
transformedintoadutifulsubject.
NexttothefountainintheWaldsteingardenitispossibletoimaginethestatuesofLaocoon
and the Wrestlers standing side by side, the former symbolizing punished impiety and the latter
defeated revolt. Next to the group with Laocoon, in which resistance was condemned, the group
withVenusandAdoniscouldhavestood,celebratingtheadvantagesofforesightfulsubmission.The
groupwithBacchusandthelittleSatyr(fig.22),whichcelebratedtheblessingsofpeace,couldhave
stood on the other end of the row, next to the Wrestlers. In this arrangement, the peacebringing
VenuswouldbeacounterparttothepeacefulBacchus,whowouldbetheoppositeoftheWrestlers.
WhileinthefightbetweentheWrestlerslifeisatstake,Bacchuswithawinebeakerbehindhisback
isonlyteasingthelittleSatyr.
ISBN9789460184833
93

Fig.22BacchusandSatyr
All the mythological statues Adrien de Vries created for Waldstein were sitespecific
commentsonpoliticaldevelopmentsinPragueandthekingdomofBohemia.Thesnarlingdogtamed
byagodstressedthatthefountainofNeptunewasnotonlyanillustrationofanancientmyth.This
impressive detail, which has no substantiation in ancient mythology, indicates that this Neptune
actuallyisFerdinandII,andthatWaldsteinmostprobablywishedhisgardentobedominatedbythis
verygod.TheEmperorwasbeingcelebratedbecausehehadcalmedthepoliticalstormwhichhad
threatenedtheveryexistenceoftheHolyRomanEmpire.
WaldsteinsAbsence
AlthoughWaldsteinspentconsiderabletimeonthebattlefieldsandhadathousandpredilections,he
never displayed his personal experiences, feelings or attitudes unless he could turn them to his
personal advantage. In the last years of his life, his physical condition quickly deteriorated, which
mayhaveinfluencedhispsychologicalstateandhispoliticalattitudes.Butinthe1620s,atthepeak
ofhiscareer,AlbrechtvonWaldsteinwhollyidentifiedhimselfwiththeHolyRomanEmpire.Thiswas
alsoexpressedinthedecorationofhispalaceinPrague,whichheconstructedatthattime.Inthis
sense,wemaysaythatinthepalaceofthemostenergeticmanofhistime,impersonalityreigned.
Nordoweanywhereinthepalacefindthecrownedeagle,theprincelyandlaterducalemblemthat
hestartedtousein1622(fig.23).
ISBN9789460184833
94

Fig.23The1622coatofarmsofWaldsteinasacount
In the Waldstein Palace we find depictions of lions,which are interpreted as an allusion to
Waldsteins ancestral family.37 But why do we not find the main motif of the Waldstein family
emblemastandinglionwithadoubletaildepictedfromtheside?Whydowefindhereexclusively
the lions head depicted en face, which is not part of the Waldstein emblem? These lions heads
evidentlydonotalludetoWaldsteinbuttothevanquishedenemiesoftheHolyRomanEmpire.The
lionsheadoftenhasaringinitsmouth,symbolizingadangerousbeastwhichhasbeenoverpowered
andtamed.

Fig.24LionsheadsonporchofthemainfaadeofWaldsteinpalace
ISBN9789460184833
95
In1626,whenWaldsteinstartedtomintcoins,hehesitatedbetweentwomottos:Godismy
protector and In defiance of envy. As the former evidently seemed to him too general and the
lattertoopersonal,hefinallyadoptedthemotto:SACRIROMANIIMPERIIPRINCEPS(fig.25).

Fig.25Waldsteinscoinof1626withtheeagleandinscriptionPrinceoftheHolyRomanEmpire
AlthoughweknowAlbrechtofWaldsteinwasinterestedinastrology,nowhereinhispalace
have we found constellations of stars at the moment of Waldsteins birth or anything else which
wouldalludetohim.Inthepaintings,stuccodecorationsandsculptureswhichdecoratedthepalace,
therewerenoportraitsofitsbuilder,notevenhiscoatofarmsorpersonalemblem.Whenwelook
for celebrations of Waldsteins person or his family, we find nothing. But as soon as we forget his
personage and start to look for allusions to his office, the Prince of the Holy Roman Empire is
suddenlyvividlypresent.TheherooftheWaldsteinpalaceinPraguewasnotitsbuilder,buttheHoly
RomanEmpireanditsEmperor.
Bibliography
AlbertiFridlandiPerduellionisChaosSiveIngratiAnimiAbyssus(1634).
AlbrechtvonWallenstein.Interarmasilentmusae?,ed.ElikaFukovandLadislavepika(Praha,
2007).
Baldinucci,Filippo,NotiziedeprofessorideldisegnodaCimabueinqua,12vols.(Milano,181112).
Baant, Jan, SACRI ROMANI IMPERII PRINCEPS: Wallensteins Palace in Prague Revisited, in Ad
HonoremEvaStehlkov,ed.Pavlnapov(Praha,2011),pp.3238.
Baant,JanandBaantov,Nina,WaldsteinPalaceinPrague:TheFirstBaroqueResidenceinCentral
Europe(KindleEdition,2011).
Baant,JanandBaantov,Nina,WaldsteinPalaceinPrague:TheFirstBaroqueResidenceinCentral
Europe(Prague,2011).
ISBN9789460184833
96
Kleisner, Tom, Giovanni Pietro de Pomis Medal of the Battle of White Mountain, Studia
Rudolphina,8(2008),pp.9093.
Klipcov, Barbora and Ulin, Petr, Domenico Pugliani: A New Face in the History of Wallenstein
Palace in Prague (Domenico Pugliani a nov tv djin Valdtejnskho palce v Praze), Umn, 41
(2013),pp.206220.
Konen, Lubomr, Albrecht von Wallenstein, His Buildings, and His Artists: A Bibliography, Studia
Rudolphina,5(2005),pp.8086.
Lange, Ludwig, Prag und seine nchsten Umgebungen in malerischen OriginalAnsichten nach der
Naturaufgenommen(Darmstadt,1841).
Larsson,LarsOlof,EinneuesRomanderMoldau?DerSkulpturengartenAlbrechtvonWallensteins
in Prag, in 1648: Krieg und Frieden in Europa, ed. Klaus Bumann and Heinz Schilling, 2 vols.
(Mnster,1998),vol.2,pp.201208.
Larsson,LarsOlof,Imitatioundaemulatio:AdriaendeVriesunddieantikeSkulptur,inAdriaende
Vries15561626:AugsburgsGlanzEuropasRuhm,ed.UrselBergerandBjrnR.Kommer,exhibition
catalogue(Augsburg,2000),pp.6672.
Michalski, Sergiusz, Der Laokoon und die Ringer des Adriaen de Vries im Garten des Prager
Wallensteinpalastes:SymbolederberwindungdesbhmischenAufstandes?,StudiaRudolphina,4
(2004),pp.2830.
Muchka,IvanandKov,Kvta,Valdtejnskpalc(Praha,1996).
Reuss, Matthias, Belluccis Gemldefolge fr das Stadtpalais Liechtenstein in Wien (Hildesheim,
Zurich&NewYork1998).
Ripa,Cesare,Iconologia(Roma,1603).
Schebek,Edmund,DieLsungderWallensteinsfrage(Berlin,1881).
Scholten,Frits,AdriaendeVries15561626:ImperialSculptor(Zwolle,1999).
Spreng,Johannes,MetamorphoseosOvidii...(FrankfurtamMain,1563).
Tanner,Marie,TheLastDescendantsofAeneas.TheHabsburgsandtheMythicImageoftheEmperor
(NewHaven,1993).
Tempesta, Antonio, Metamorphoseon Sive Transformationum Ovidianarum Libri Quindecim, Nunc
Primum...(Antwerpen,ca.1610).
Typotius,Jacob,Symboladivinaethumana(Praga,1601).
Ulin,Petr,ManieraoftheArchitectureofAlbrechtofWallenstein,Umn,59(2011),pp.194213.
ISBN9789460184833
97
UmleckpamtkyPrahy,MalStrana,ed.PavelVlek(Praha,1999).
TheWallensteinPalaceinPrague,eds.MojmrHorynaandothers(Praha,2002).
Zap,KarelVladislav,PrwodcepoPraze(Praha,1848).
Illustrations
Alldrawings(exceptFig.4)arebyNinaBaantov
Fig.4:archiveoftheauthor

1
Thisworkwassupportedbygrantnr.IAA800090902(Antickinspiraceveskmbaroknmumn/Classical
inspirationinCzechBaroqueart)oftheGrantAgencyoftheAcademyofSciencesoftheCzechRepublic.
2
UmleckpamtkyPrahy,MalStrana1999,pp.147159;MuchkaandKov1996;TheWallensteinPalace
inPrague2002;Konen2005;AlbrechtvonWallenstein.Interarmasilentmusae2007;BaantandBaantov
2011;Baant2011;Ulin2011;Klipcov,Ulin2013.
3
EragifinitalasalaprincipaleMicommessasuaEccellenza,chedovessiapesareaqualcosa.Giilsalone
eraadornodiarmeetrofeidiguerrafintidistucco.IlPieronipropose,chesifacessedentroilcarrodiMarte.Ne
feciildisegno,epiacqueinbuonaforma,inBaldinucci1812,vol.XII,p.402.
4
AlbertiFridlandiPerduellionisChaosSiveIngratiAnimiAbyssus1634.Onthetitlepageweread,CumLicentia
Superiorum,butnoauthor,publisherorplaceofpublicationisgiven.
5
Zap1848,p.209.ThefirstidentificationsofMarsinWaldsteinPalaceasAlbrechtvonWaldstein:Lange1841,
p.74.
6
Typotius1601,fig.106.
7
Reuss1998,pp.276278.
8
Inventory ofWaldstein palace of 1634: Praha,State regional archive(Sttn oblastn archiv), Family archive
(Rodinnarchiv),Valdtejnov(Waldsteins),cart.6,sign.A29;Schebek1881,pp.587608.
9
TodaytheKnightsHallisdominatedbyamonumentalpaintingofWaldsteinonhorsebackwhichdatesfrom
1631, but the painting was brought to the palace long after the Dukes death (presumably from Valdice
monastery). The painting was hung in 1877 in its present place above the fireplace, the idea coming from
CountessMariaofWaldstein,whoatthattimesupervisedextensivereconstructionworksinthepalaceofher
husband,CountErnstvonWaldstein.AlbrechtvonWaldsteinsportraitmettheanticipationsofCzechpatriots,
whoexpectedtofindallusionstothegreatCzechinthepalace.However,theportraitsdominantpositionin
theKnightsHallcontradictseverythingweknowaboutthepalacesoriginaldecoration.
10
Fromthesixteenthcenturyonwards,suchaportraitserieswasstandarddecorationinthepublicroomsof
importantresidences.ItspredecessorinPraguewasinthepalaceofEmperorRudolfII.Theideaisrootedin
ancientRome,whereGaiusSuetoniusTranquilluswrotehisfamousDevitacaesarum,thebiographiesofthe
twelvefoundersoftheancientRomanEmpire,fromCaesartoDomitianus.
11
Vergil,Aeneis,I,286287(translationbyH.R.Fairclough).
12
Vergil,Aeneis,VI,791795(translationbyH.R.Fairclough).
13
Vergil,Eclogues,IV,59.(translationbyH.R.Fairclough).
14
Tempesta1610,figs.3,4,5and6.
15
Ovid,Metamorphoses,I,151155(translationbyA.S.Kline).
16
NationalMuseum,Prague,inv.Nr.H558.539;AlbrechtvonWallenstein.Interarmasilentmusae2007,nr.
14,48.Kleisner2008,fig.4.
17
Ovid,Metamorphoses,I,141144(translationbyA.S.Kline).
18
Tempesta1610,figs.1,8,10,12,22,24,25,28,32,41,47,75,141and172.
19
Spreng1563,figs.27,40and172.
20
Ripa1603.
21
Ovid,Metamorphoses,XIII,475480.
ISBN9789460184833
98

22
Tempesta1610,fig.122.
Vergil,Aeneis,I,148156.
24
Bartsch,vol.XIV,204,352.
25
Vergil,Aeneis,II,707720.
26
Tempesta1610,fig.126.
27
VergiliiMaronisdreyzehenBchervondemtewrenHeldenEnea...(FrankfurtamMain,1559),book11.
28
Vergil,Aeneis,XII,939941.
29
E.g.DellEneidediVirgiliodelcommendatoreAnnibalCaro(Roma,1622),book12.
30
Tanner1993,146161.
31
Itistheworkin1599ofBenediktWurzelbauerandtheRudolphinesculptor,NikolausPfaff(theoriginalisin
the Gallery of Prague Castle). Waldstein bought the statue from the Lobkovic family in 1630, but he did not
placeitinfrontoftheSalaTerrena.
32
In1648thestatueswerestolenbytheSwedisharmyandmovedtoDrottningholm,wheretheybecamethe
pride of the residence of the Swedish kings. In 1910, copies of all the sculptures which had decorated the
Neptunefountainweremade.TodaytheyareinstalledintheWaldsteingarden,butnotintheiroriginalsite.
They are arranged along the axis of the Sala Terrena, together with the statue of Apollo. This statue is not
dated and probably it was never exhibited in the garden because, after Waldsteins death, a white box was
foundinhispalacewhichcontainedametalstatueofApollo.
33
Larsson1998;Scholten1999;Larsson2000;S.Michalski,2004.
34
Seenotes21and22.
35
Vergil,Aeneis,I,148156.
36
Ovid,Metamorphoses,X,543552(translatedbyB.More).
37
IntheWaldsteinPalacewefindthecoatofarmsofWaldsteinfamilywithlionsinthegarden.Itdecorates
thestonesoclewhichistodaypartofthefountainwithVenusandthecopiesofbronzevases.
23
ISBN9789460184833
99
OfficialPortraitsandRegionalIdentities
ThecaseofEmperorMaximilianI(14591519)
DagmarEichberger

InhismonographMarketingMaximilian.ThevisualideologyofaHolyRomanEmperor,LarrySilver
investigates the multifaceted artistic projects that Maximilian I undertook in order to further his
fame and to shape his public image.2 The recent exhibition Kaiser Maximilian I. und die Kunst der
Drerzeitanalysedtheemperorslifeandhispatronageoftheartswithparticularemphasisonthe
triumphalprocessionbothonparchmentandpaper.3Incontrasttohisfather,EmperorFrederickIII,
Maximilian can be described as a most ambitious and modern patron. This applies not only to the
employmentofnewmediasuchasprintedmaterial,butequallytoMaximiliansimaginativeuseof
multiplelikenesses.Thepresentpaperinvestigatestheroleofportraitpaintingsbyfocusingbothon
the geographic conditions that determined the production of images and on Maximilians political
agenda. Within the large body of portraits that have survived until today, one can identify at least
fivedifferenttypesofimages.4
ManyofthecourtartistsinvolvedincreatingthepublicpersonaofMaximilianareknownby
name:AmbrogiodePredisfromMilan,BernhardStrigelfromMemmingenandAlbrechtDrerfrom
Nuremberg. Each can be associated with one or two specific portrait types that were used and
reusedindifferentcontexts.TheNetherlandishpainterJoosvanClevewasnotformallyattachedto
theimperial court,butneverthelessproducedadistinctiveportraittypethat wasimportantat the
time.5Thisessaywillinvestigatethespecificfeaturesoftheseportraittypesandpursuethequestion
astowhethertherewasaregionalpreferenceinparticularfortheimagecreatedbyJoosvanCleve.
AmbrogiodePredis.Theclassicalportrait
ThereexistsonlyonecopyoftheportraitcreatedbyGiovanniAmbrogiodePredis,apaintingsigned
and dated by the artist in the bottom lefthand corner.6 The Milan portraitist joined the Habsburg
court in 1493, shortly after Maximilian had married Bianca Maria Sforza, his second wife. This
particular portrait has occasionally been described as oldfashioned, as it adheres to the strict
portrait in profile. It is, however, a classical format that was reintroduced at the beginning of the
fifteenth century via coins and medals and remained popular well into the sixteenth century.7 The
likeness emphasizes Maximilians aquiline nose, a distinctive trait that appears in most of his
ISBN9789460184833
100

portraits. If the anonymous drawing in Berlin is an authentic likeness of the emperor, De Predis
idealized his facial features.8 In this mediumsized portrait Maximilian wears a gold brocade dress
withablackfurcollarandablackhatprobablymadefromthesamematerial.Whilehispositionas
KingoftheRomansishighlightedbyaLatininscription,heiswearingneitherasuitofarmournorany
oftheattributestypicalofthisoffice.Thepatternofhisgoldbrocadedresshasbeeninterpretedby
Karl Schtz as a symbol of his new alliance with the house of Sforza.9 The ceremonial chain of the
OrderoftheGoldenFleeceisthemostprominentattributeinthepainting.Maximilianwasmadea
memberofthisBurgundianorderon31April1477,whichwasasignificantmomentinhislifeandin
the historyofthe Order. The ceremonialinaugurationisdocumentedbya miniaturein theBruges
chronicle of 148110 and is also described in the Vienna statute book of the Order of the Golden
Fleece.11MaximilianimmediatelytookontheofficeofsovereignandheadoftheOrderandgreatly
cherished his newly gained status. He held the office twice during his lifetime, first during the
minorityofhissonPhiliptheHandsome(14781506),andasecondtimeduringtheminorityofhis
grandsonthefutureEmperorCharlesV(15001558).Thisportraittypewasrepeatedinamodified
versionbyananonymousGermanartistshowingMaximilianinashoulderlengthportrait,withthe
emperorfacingtotheright.12
AlbrechtDrer.Alateportrait
AverydifferentimageoftheemperorisrepresentedbyaportraittypethatwascreatedbyAlbrecht
Drerin1518.Attherequestoftheemperor,theNurembergartistdrewMaximilianfromlifewhile
he was staying in the city of Augsburg to attend the Diet of Augsburg. Drers charcoal drawing
served as the blueprint for the two painted portraits now in Vienna and Nuremberg,13 and for the
woodcut that was published in several editions soon after Maximilians death in January 1519.14
Drers woodcut became the most widely distributed image of the emperor and exists in several
editions; some prints were embellished with colour and shell gold.15 While the Vienna painting on
wood and the Nuremberg painting on canvas were unique und probably not meant to travel, the
woodcutinspiredmanycontemporaryprintmakers:HansWeiditz,LucasvanLeyden,PieterdeJode
andothers.16
JoosvanCleve.MaximiliansNetherlandishlikeness
The third portrait type can be associated with the Antwerpbased painter Joos van Cleve and his
workshop(fig.1).Sofar,thisportraithaslargelyattractedtheinterestofasmallnumberofvanCleve
specialistssuchasJohnHandandCcileScaillirez.17Theportraitexistsinseveralreplicasandcopies
thatvaryinsizeandshowsnumerousvariationsregardingthechoiceofattributes.18
Maximiliansbodyisalwaysshowninafrontalposition,withhisheadturnedslightlytothe
left,sothathisfaceappearsinthreequarterview.InsimilarfashiontotheportraitbyAmbrogiode
Predis,Maximilianwearsaluxuriousovercoatmadefromgoldbrocadeandfittedwithabroadfur
collar. Maximilians undershirt is black in colour and his head is covered with a soft black hat. He
wears very fine leather gloves that are almost white in colour. Maximilians only ornament is the
ISBN9789460184833
101

OrderoftheGoldenFleece;therearenoreferencestohispositionasKingoftheRomansorasHoly
Roman Emperor. While his left hand is portrayed as if resting on the ledge of the frame, his right
handisliftedupslightlyhigherandholdsaposyofcarnations.19

Fig.1JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianI
assovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,
wood,30.8x21.1cm,Berlin,KMPK,GG1321.

BernhardStrigel.Thefirstofficialportrait
A large group of portraits represents Maximilian wearing a polished suit of armour and carrying
numerous regalia such as a halfarch crown, asceptre, a sword, and a coronation cloak. While the
paintings from this group show a wide range of styles and diverging facial features, they are all
attributedtoBernhardStrigelandhisworkshop.20TheSwabianartistStrigelwascloselyattachedto
Maximilians court.21 He produced two different portrait types, one showing Maximilian clad in
armourandanotherinwhichheisdressedinmorecivilianorcourtlydress.22Formanyyears,Strigel
seemstohavebeenMaximilianspreferredportraitistuntilhefinallyturnedtoAlbrechtDreronlya
fewmonthbeforehisprematuredeath.
WithintheStrigelgroupveryfewpanelscanbedatedaccurately.Theindividualportraitsare
generallydatedbymeansofcircumstantialevidence,onthebasisofthestyleofthearmourorthe
particular crown Maximilian is wearing. Karl Schtz proposed that the earliest portraits date from
circa 1500.23 The Strigel portrait, now in Berlin, carries the date '1496' in the central axis of the
painting(fig.2),thoughtheauthenticityofthedate1496hasbeenquestionedbyErichEggbecause
MaximilianwasappointedKingoftheRomansin1486andcrownedHolyRomanEmperorin1508.24
TheinscriptionDIVIMAXIMILIANIIMPERATORISFIGURAANNOSCUMESSETNATUSQUADRAGINTA
to the right of the cloth of honour points to the year 1499, asMaximilian is described as being 40
ISBN9789460184833
102

yearsofage. 25 DieterVorsteherhasrecentlyarguedinfavourof1496beingtheyearinwhichthe
panelwaspaintedbyStrigel.Heproposedthatthesecondinscriptionwasaddedthreeyearslater,
whentheportraitwasgivenawayasagift.26

Fig.2BernhardStrigel,EmperorMaximilianI
dressedinarmourandpresentinghisregalia,oilon
parchmentonwood,76,5x48cm,Berlin,
DeutschesHistorischesMuseum,inv.no.
1988/1496.

Fig.3BernhardSrigel,MaximilianIasHolyRoman
Emperor,circa1507/08,oilonwood,84x51.8cm,
Innsbruck,TirolerLandesmuseum.
Inportraitsofthiskind,Maximilianisalwaysshownasahalflengthfigureinthreequarter
view,turningbodyandfacetotheright.Heisplacedinfrontofatextilebackgroundthatrepresents
aclothofhonour.Inadditiontohismilitaryattire,hecarriessceptre,swordandacrown.Hisbent
rightarmrestseitheronawindowsilloronapillow,demarcatingthespaceofthesitterfromthatof
theviewer.IthasbeensuggestedthatStrigelsofficialportraitofMaximilianinarmourwasmodelled
onanearlierportraitofhisfather,EmperorFrederickIII(14151493),27whichMaximilianprobably
commissionedhimselfintheseconddecadeofthesixteenthcentury.Thereareindeedanumberof
similarities, such as the choice of attributes and the positioning of the figure within the pictorial
space.Bothmenholdemblemsofpower,thegoldensceptrerunsdiagonallyfromlowerrighttothe
upperleft,andtherightarmrestscomfortablyonahorizontalparapet.Allthesefactorspointtoan
intrinsicinterrelationshipbetweenthesetwoportraits.
It can be assumed that they were both conceived as one left wing of a portrait diptych.
Father and son are both turning to the right, facing their spouses Eleanor of Portugal and Bianca
Maria Sforza on a complementary panel.28 While only one version of the portrait of Emperor
ISBN9789460184833
103

Frederick III is known, multiple copies of Emperor Maximilians portrait have survived. It can be
assumed that many copies of Maximilians official portraits were given away as gifts, as this was a
common practice at the time. The inscription on a lost version from Strasbourg indicated that
Maximilian donated the likeness to the Johannite monastery after his visit to the imperial city of
Strasbourgin1507.29

MaximilianinMargaretofAustriasportraitcollection
IntheNetherlands,Archduchess MargaretofAustria(14801530)representedtheinterestsofher
familyasRegentandGovernessoftheBurgundianterritories.30Inall,shekeptfourportraitsofher
father in different parts of her principal residence, the socalled Palais de Savoy in Mechelen or
Malines.Thespatialcontextsinwhichtheseportraitswereoncedisplayedcanbereconstructedand
thusprovidesignificantcluestoreconstructingthefunctionofeachofthelikenesses.31 Theportraits
inquestionwerelocatedinMargaretslibrary,herdininghallandthesmallcabinetorStudiolonext
toherbedroom.MargaretofAustriasstocklistofmovableitems(1516)mentionsalargeportrait
panelofMaximilian,whichisdescribedasfollows:
autretableau,plusgrant,delempereur,habillensonaccoustrementimprial
[anotherpanel,larger,oftheemperor,dressedinhisimperialaccoutrement].32
This painting is described as larger than the previous one depicting John the Fearless (Jehan de
Bourgoigne).AsthemostprominentfeatureinthispaintingwasMaximiliansimperialattire,itcan
beassumedthatinherlibraryMargaretdisplayedacopyoftheStrigelsstatelyportraitasEmperor
in order to represent her father as the ruling head of the Habsburg dynasty (fig. 3).33 The richly
furnishedlibrarywasoneofthemorepublicspaceswithintheresidenceandwasopentomembers
ofhercourtaswellastooutsidevisitors.34Thiswasthelocationwherethemilitarytriumphsofthe
Habsburgfamilywerecommemorated:thevictoryovertheDukeofGuelders,theBattleofPavia,the
conquest of the New Americas, and others. In her library Margaret also kept her personal copy of
DrersArchofHonour,theeternalmonumenttoMaximiliansentireachievement.
The 1516 stock list of paintings in the library refers to a second, albeit somewhat smaller
portraitofEmperorMaximilian.Itisdescribedasfollows:
ungpetittableauduchiefdelEmpereur,pourtantrobeetbonnetdecramoisy,etunelettre
ensamain
[a small panel of the head of the Emperor, wearing a crimson red robe and bonnet, and a
letterinhishand].35
ThisentrycallstomindaparticularStrigelportraitinwhichMaximilianisdressedinaredovercoat
withafurcollar.InthisportraitMaximilianwearsnoarmourandnoregalia.Heisproudlypresenting
thecollaroftheOrderoftheGoldenFleeceandholdsaletterinhislefthand.Thetwopaintingsthat
correspondtothisdescription,however,arenotparticularlysmallinsize.AfineportraitbyStrigelin
theNationalTrustcollectionmeasures39.5x30cm;36anotherversioninBerlinmeasures37x25.37
The inscription in the Berlin portrait names Maximilians position as Holy Roman Emperor:
MaximilianiprimiRomanoru(m)ImperatorisArchducisAustrieEffigies.Hisraisedhandandhisindex
ISBN9789460184833
104

fingerpointforwardasifgivinginstructionstoapersonoutsideofthepictureframe.Inthepast,this
portrait type has been labelled Maximilian as a private man, because he is depicted without his
paraphernalia.38 Maximilians attire corresponds to the image of the White King in Maximilians
autobiography Weisskunig.39 While this portrait type from the Strigel workshop served as an
alternativelikenessforMaximilianitisnotclearwhenitappearedforthefirsttime.
In addition to the portraits of Maximilian in the Mechelen library already mentioned, a
portrait by Joos van Cleve was kept in Margarets official portrait gallery, the socalled premire
chamber chemyne on the second floor of the western wing. In the household inventory of
152324theportraitofthedeceasedemperorisdescribedasfollows:
Item, ungaultre tableaudelaportraituredelempereur Maximilien,prede Madame,que
Dieupardonne,habilldunerobbededraptdor,fouredemartre,aungbonnetnoirsurson
chief,pourtantlecolierdelaThoisondor,tenantunroletensamaindextre.
[Item,anotherpanelwiththeportraitofEmperorMaximilian,thefatherofMadame,whom
Godforgive,dressedinarobemadefromgoldcloth,linedwithmarten,ablackcaponhis
head, wearing the collar of the Order of the Golden Fleece, holding a scroll in his right
hand].40
Therearetwopaintingsthatmatchthisdescriptionveryclosely,oneinBrussels(fig.4)and
one in Berlin (fig. 1).41 These two panels are almost identical in size and colour. In the Brussels
painting, three letters M R I discreetly point to the identity of the sitter: M(aximilianus)
R(omanorum)I(mperator).Inbothexamples,Maximilianslefthandrestsontheedgeoftheframe,a
popularmotiveinNetherlandishportraiturethatcanbetracedbacktoRogiervanderWeyden.Itcan
beassumedthatJoosvanClevesworkshopusedatemplatetoproducemultiplecopiesofthisnew
portraittype.42

Fig.4JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIas
sovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,wood,33x
23cm,Brussels,MusesRoyauxdesBeauxArtsde
Belgique,inv.no.2581.
ISBN9789460184833
Fig.5Anonymous,Maximilianassovereignofthe
OrderoftheGoldenFleece,inthestatutebookofthe
OrderoftheGoldenFleece,parchment,28.4x21cm,
Bruges,after1518,Vienna,NB,Cod.2606,fol.77.
105

A large, fullpage miniature in the Vienna statute book of the Order of the Golden Fleece
reproduces the same portrait type in which Maximilian is represented first and foremost as the
sovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece(fig.5).43Thesitterspostureandthepatterningofhis
goldbrocadedressareveryclosetotheportraitpanelinBerlin.Ifweassumethatthiscopywasonce
keptinMargaretsportraitgallery,itismostlikelythattheminiaturistwouldhavehadaccesstothis
copy.ThispanelwasjustoneofseveralpaintingsfromMargaretsportraitgallerythatwereusedas
modelsbytheilluminatoroftheViennastatuebook.44
InthismanuscriptMaximilianisdescribedas:Mostdistinguishedandverypowerfulprince,
Monseigneur Maximilian, Archduke of Austria, Duke of Lorraine, of Brabant, of Luxemburg, etc.45
Given that this manuscript was made after 1518, it is remarkable that the caption accompanying
Maximilians portrait refrains from mentioning his rank as emperor. This wording confirms that
Maximilianspublicprofilechangedaccordingtothedifferentregionalandpoliticalcontextsinwhich
he operated. In the Burgundian Netherlands he gained respect and exerted political influence by
stressinghispositionassovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,hisroleasHolyRomanEmperor
not being an asset in this political region. In Margaret of Austrias official portrait gallery, many
membersofthisprestigiousorderwererepresentedwithanemblemoftheirmembership,mostlya
goldpendantoftheGoldenFleecehangingfromasimpleblackstring.Maximilianalwayswearsthe
collarofthesovereignwhichconsistsofagoldchainwithbroadlinksandagoldpendant.Joosvan
Cleves portrait of Maximilian I with a scroll (fig. 1) was thus considered most appropriate for
MargaretofAustriasofficialportraitgallery.
Maximilianasbridegroom
AsecondversionofJoosvanClevesportraittypewaskeptinMargaretofAustriaspetitcabinet,an
intimatespaceadjoiningherstatelybedroom.Insteadofascroll,Maximilianholdstwocarnationsin
hisrighthand.In152324,theportraitwasdescribedasfollows:
Item, ung aultre tableau de la portraicture de lempereur Maximilien, tenant deux fleurs
dulletzensamain,habilldedrapdor,pourtantlaThoison.
[Item,anotherpanelwiththeportraitofEmperorMaximilian,holdingtwocarnationsinhis
hand,dressedingoldfabric,wearingtheFleece.]46
JohnHandliststhreeversionsofthisalternativeportraittypefromtheJoosvanCleveworkshop.47
The Paris painting is the smallest, measuring 19 x 13 cm; the Amsterdam painting is the largest,
measuring34.6x24.4(fig.6).IntheAmsterdamportrait,Maximiliansbodyisdepicteddowntothe
waist.ThisdetailiscomparabletotheBerlinpaintingwithscroll(fig.1).ThecopiesinVienna(fig.7)
and Paris have rounded tops and opt for a narrower closeup concentrating more on Maximilians
headandhands.Inallthreepaintings,Maximilianturnshisheadtotherightandraiseshislefthand,
whichtouchestheledgeoftheframe.
MarissaBasshasarguedthattheAmsterdampaintingshouldbeidentifiedastheonefrom
MargaretscollectionbecauseMaximilianholdstwoinsteadofthreecarnations.48Thefactthatthe
inventory does not explicitly talk about a small painting supports her assumption. The van Cleve
portrait with two carnations was kept in the most secluded section of Margarets residence, the
studiolonexttoherbedroom.Itissignificanttonote,however,thatMargaretgaveawaythisportrait
ISBN9789460184833
106

toherbastardsister,inOctober1527.49Whatwasthereasonforthisdecision?Didsheherselflose
interestinthisportraitafterherfatherdied?

Fig.6JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIwith
Twocarnations,oak,34,6x24,4cm(withoutframe),
Amsterdam,Rijksmuseum,inv.No.SKA3293.

Fig.7JoosvanCleve,MaximilianIwiththreecarnations,
oilonoak,27x18cm,Vienna,Kunsthistorisches
Museum,inv.no.GG972.
TheParisversionistheonlypaintingwithadate.Theyear1510onthelowerledgeofthe
frameprovidesuswithaterminusantequem.50Itisunlikelythattheblueprintforthisportraitwas
conceivedaslateas1510,becauseMaximiliandidnotvisittheNetherlandsinthatparticularyear.51
BoththewrittencorrespondencebetweenMaximilianandhisdaughterandtheemperorsdetailed
itinerary demonstrate that Maximilian sojourned in the Netherlands in 1508/09 because of the
ongoing war with the Duke of Guelders; in fact, he stayed continuously in this region from 1
November1508to31March1509,Antwerp,Brussels,Gent,Kalkar,Mechelen,Lier,Dordrechtbeing
someoftheplaceshepassedthroughatthetime.DuringthesefivemonthsMaximilianwillhavehad
manyopportunitiestomeetJoosvanCleveinperson.52GivenMaximiliansstrongpersonalinterest
incommissioningofficialportraits,itseemsmorethanlikelythathehimselfselectedtheartistand
decided on the choice of attributes, a scroll and several carnations. The specific nature of these
imagesandtheprecisionofthefacialfeaturessuggestthattheartistwasgivenachancetomakea
preparatory drawing from life. The large number of copies confirms that Joos van Cleves portrait
wasconsideredanimportantlikeness,aportraitthatwascopiedoverandoveragain.53
In the light of these considerations the image of Maximilian with carnations raises several
questions.Depictingasitterwithoneorseveralflowersinhishandisusuallyunderstoodasasymbol
ofloveandcourtship;itwasamotivefrequentlyemployedinconnectionwithbetrothalormarriage
ISBN9789460184833
107

portraits.54 Maximilian wedded his first wife Duchess Mary of Burgundy on 18 August 1477, a
historicallyimportanteventdatingbackmorethanthirtyyears.WhenJoosvanClevestartedworking
onthisnewportrait,Maximilianhadbeenmarriedtohissecondwifeformorethanfifteenyears.If
thisimagerefersbacktotheemperorsfirstmarriage,wearedealingwitharetrospectiveportrait
and a considerable lapse in time. John Hand convincingly argued that this composition may have
beenmodelledonasimilarpaintinginMargaretofAustriascollection,theportraitoftheTudorKing
Henry VII as a potential bridegroom (1505).55 At the time, Henry had the intention of marrying
Maximilian's widowed daughter. For the King of the Romans, Henry VII was an important political
ally, which was why he had been made a member of the Order of the Golden Fleece. After the
marriage negotiations failed, the panel painting was kept in Margarets illustrious portrait gallery.
The treatment of the frame as pictorial border is reminiscent of the official portraits of Philip the
GoodandCharlestheBoldbyRogiervanderWeydenandhisworkshop.
TheretrospectivenatureofEmperorMaximiliansportraitbyJoosvanCleveislesssurprising
than it seems at first sight. To Maximilian and his offspring, the union of the two dynasties
Habsburg and Burgundyremained one of the most important events for this upwardmoving
dynasty. This is documented in his Arch of Honour, the Triumphal Procession and in the chivalric
romancecalledTheuerdank.Between1505and1516MaximiliandictatedthestoryofWeisskunigto
hissecretaryMarxTreitzsauerwein.MaximiliansjourneytotheNetherlands,hisarrivalattheBruges
court, his meetings and negotiations with Margaret of York and Mary of Burgundy, and the final
marriage ceremony are dealt with in great detail. The luxurious coat that Maximilian is wearing in
most of these woodcuts by Hans Burgkmair is reminiscent of the furlined overcoat in the portrait
panelsbyJoosvanCleveandhisworkshop(fig.1).56Weisskunig,Maximiliansalterego,wearsarich
collarandaroyalcrownsymbolsofpowerthattheyoungprincewasstillstrivingforin1477.
In1511,notlongafterthedeathofhissecondwife,Maximilianreissuedacommemorative
silvercoininthecityofHall,Tyrol,basedonthedesignofanearlymedalbyGiovanniCandida.The
socalledHochzeitsguldinerbyUlrichUrsentalerreproducesMaximiliansportraitasayoungprince
on one side and that of his young bride on the reverse.57 The inscription ETATIS 19 points to
Maximiliansyoungage,andthedate1479equallyrefersbacktothetimeofhisyouth.Thisminted
likenessofMaximiliancommemoratesaneventofthepastthathadongoingpoliticalsignificancefor
theHabsburgfamily.ItcanbeassumedthatMaximiliandistributedthesecoinsamonghisallies.
In the light of Maximilians ambition to glorify his union with the house of Burgundy, the
commission of a portrait as an ageless courtier with flowers appears to be more of a strategic
decisionthananexpressionofromanticlove.ThemodestywithwhichMaximilianisrepresentedin
this portrait can be interpreted as a wellconsidered manoeuvre. In the Burgundian Netherlands,
Maximilianwasseenmoreasaninvoluntaryguestthanasapotentruler:inthisregionofhisempire
hewasmerelytoleratedasMaryofBurgundyshusbandandasthefatheroftheirchildren,Philipthe
HandsomeandMargaretofAustria.JoosvanCleveportrayedMaximiliantwiceassovereignofthe
OrderoftheGoldenFleece,alwaysshowingoffthecollaroftheOrder.
In this political context, the creation of a new likeness by Joos van Cleve in 1508/09 is as
significant as the conception of an official portrait by Bernhard Strigel in 1496 (fig. 2). The Strigel
portraitwas developedatatimewhenMaximilian wasclimbingup the politicalladderandhad to
asserthimselfasKingoftheRomansandasthemostpromisingcandidateforthepositionofHoly
ISBN9789460184833
108

Roman Emperor (fig. 3). Strigels portrait of Maximilian in armour reflects this ambition and was
employedacrosstheEmpire,asthecopiesinStrasbourgandMechelenshow.
TheportraitthatwasconceivedbyvanCleveadecadelaterwasprobablyemployedwithina
much more limited geographical area, the Burgundian Netherlands. This portrait established
MaximiliansroleasleaderoftheBurgundiannetwork(fig.1)equalinimportancetoPhiliptheGood,
Charles the Bold and Philip the Handsome. It reminded visitors to Margarets residence that
MaximilianwastheactingsovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece(fig.5),whilehisgrandson,
thenineyearoldCharles,wasstillaminor.MaximiliansmarriagetoMaryofBurgundywasthekey
tohisrisetopower,aturningpointinthehistoryoftheHabsburgdynasty.Theportraitwithaposy
ofcarnations(fig.6),ontheotherhand,wasemployedbyMaximilianasaposthumousmonumentto
hishappyandprosperousunionwithMaryofBurgundy,thelastheirtotheBurgundianempire.

Bibliography
Albrecht Drer. Das druckgraphische Werk, vol. II: Holzschnitte und Holzschnittfolgen, ed. Rainer
Schoch,MatthiasMendeandAnnaScherbaum(Munich,Berlin,London&NewYork,2004).
DasStatutenbuchdesOrdensvomGoldenenVlies,NationalbibliothekinWien,Handschrift2606,ed.
HansGerstinger(Vienna,1934).
Eichberger, Dagmar and Lisa Beaven, Family Members and Political Allies: The Portrait Gallery of
MargaretofAustriainMechelen,ArtBulletin,LXXVII(1995),pp.22548.
Eichberger,Dagmar,MargaretofAustriaandthedocumentationofhercollectioninMechelen,in:
LosInventariosdeCarlosVylafamiliaimperial/TheInventoriesofCharlesVandtheImperialFamily,
ed.FernandoChecaCremades(Madrid,2010),vol.III,pp.235163.
Eichberger,Dagmar,MargaretofAustria.APrincesswithAmbitionandPoliticalInsight,in:Women
ofDistinction.MargaretofYorkandMargaretofAustria,ed.DagmarEichberger(Leuven,2005),pp.
4855.
Eichberger, Dagmar, Una libreria per donne assai ornata et riccha Frauenbibliotheken des 16.
Jahrhunderts zwischen Ideal und Wirklichkeit, in Die lesende Frau, ed. Gabriela Signori
(Wolfenbttel,2009),pp.24164.
Eichberger, Dagmar, Leben mit Kunst Wirken durch Kunst. Sammelwesen und Hofkunst unter
Margaretevonsterreich,RegentinderNiederlande(Turnhout,2002).
Fillitz,Hermann,DerSchatzdesOrdensvomGoldenenVlies(Salzburg&Vienna,1988).
Frimmel, Theodor and Joseph Klemme, 'Ein Statutenbuch des Ordens vom Goldenen Vliesse',
JahrbuchderKunsthistorischenMuseendesallerhchstenKaiserhauses5(1887),pp.263338.
ISBN9789460184833
109

GemldegalerieBerlin,Gesamtverzeichnis,ed.HenningBocketal.(Berlin,1996).
Gesichter der Renaissance. Meisterwerke italienischer Portrtkunst, ed. Keith Christiansen and
PatriciaLeeRubin(Berlin,2012).
Hand,JohnOliver,JoosvanCleve.ThecompletePaintings(NewHaven&London,2004).
Hochrenaissance im Vatikan, Kunst und Kultur im Rom der Ppste, 15031534, ed. Petra Kruse
(Ostfildern&Ruit,1999).
Im Atelier der Geschichte. Gemlde bis 1914 aus der Sammlung des Deutschen Historischen
Museums,ed.SabineBeneke(Dresden,2012).
ItinerariumMaximilianI.,15081518,ed.VictorvonKraus(Vienna,1899).
JoosvanCleve.LeonardodesNordens,ed.PetervandenBrink(Aachen&Stuttgart,2011).
JoosvanCleve.LeonardodesNordens,ed.PetervandenBrink(Aachen,2011).
Kaiser Maximilian I. und die Kunst der Drerzeit, ed. Eva Michel und Maria Luise Sternath (Vienna,
2012).
Lcher, Kurt, Germanisches Nationalmuseum Nrnberg. Die Gemlde des 16. Jahrhunderts
(OstfildernRuit,1997).
LosInventariosdeCarlosVylafamiliaimperial/TheInventoriesofCharlesVandtheImperialFamily,
dir.FernandoChecaCremades,3vols(Madrid,2010).
Luber, Katherine Crawford, Albrecht Drer's Maximilian portraits: an investigation of versions, in
MasterDrawings29(1991),pp.3047.
MaximilianI.,ed.ErichEgg(Innsbruck,1969).
Maximilian I. and Marx Treitzsauerwein, Der WeiKunig. Eine Erzhlung von den Thaten Kaiser
Maximilian des Ersten, herausgegeben aus dem Manuscripte der kaiserl. knigl. Hofbibliothek von
MarxTreitzsaurwein,aufdessenAngebenzusammengetragen,nebstd.vonHannsenBurgmairdazu
verfertigtenHolzschnitten(Vienna,1775).
Mende,Matthias,AlbrechtDrer,einKnstlerinseinerStadt(Nuremberg,2000).
Muses royaux des BeauxArts de Belgique, Dpartement dArt Ancien. Catalogue inventaire de la
peintureancienne,ed.PhilippeRobertsJones(Brussels,1984).
NetherlandishartintheRijksmuseum,14001600,ed.AnkOverbeek,JanPietFiledtKok,Annemiek
Overbeek(Amsterdam,2000).
Pollero,Friedrich,'TraditionundInnovation.KaiserMaximilianI.imPortrt',in:KaiserMaximilianI.
unddieKunstderDrerzeit,ed.MichelandSternath(Vienna,2012),pp.10115.
Scaillirez,Ccile,DiePortrtkunstJoosvanCleves,in:JoosvanCleve.LeonardodesNordens, ed.
PetervandenBrink(Aachen,2011),pp.86111.
ISBN9789460184833
110

Scheller,RobertW.,'KaiserMaximilianunddiePpsteseinerZeit',in:HochrenaissanceimVatikan,
KunstundKulturimRomderPpste,15031534,ed.PetraKruse(Ostfildern&Ruit,1999),pp.7076.
SchtzKarl,'DieEntstehungdeshfischenReprsentationsportrtsinderZeitKaiserMaximiliansI.',
in:WerkefrdieEwigkeit.Kaiser MaximilianI.und ErzherzogFerdinandII., ed.WilfriedSeipeland
AlfredAuer(Innsbruck,2002),pp.1618.
WerkefrdieEwigkeit.KaiserMaximilianI.undErzherzogFerdinandII.,ed.WilfriedSeipelandAlfred
Auer(Innsbruck,2002).
WomenofDistinction.MargaretofYorkandMargaretofAustria,ed.DagmarEichberger,exhibition
catalogue(Leuven,2005).
Illustrations
Fig.1JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIassovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,
wood,30.8x21,1cmBerlin,KMPK,GG1321.
Fig.2BernhardStrigel,EmperorMaximilianIdressedinarmourandpresentinghisregalia,oilon
parchmentonwood,76.5x48cm,Berlin,DeutschesHistorischesMuseum,inv.no.1988/1496.
Fig.3BernhardStrigel,MaximilianIasHolyRomanEmperor,circa1507/08,oilonwood,84x51.8
cm,Innsbruck,TirolerLandesmuseum.
Fig.4JoosvanCleveandWorkshop,MaximilianIassovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,
wood,33x23cm,Brussels,MusesRoyauxdesBeauxArtsdeBelgique,inv.no.2581.
Fig.5Anonymous,MaximilianassovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,Vienna,NB,Cod.
2606,fol.77:StatutebookoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,parchment,28.4x21cm,Bruges,after
1518.
Fig.6JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIwithtwocarnations,oak,34.6x24.4cm(without
frame),Amsterdam,Rijskmuseum,inv.no.SKA3293.
Fig.7JoosvanCleve,MaximilianIwiththreecarnations,oilonoak,27x18cm,Vienna,
KunsthistorischesMuseum,inv.no.GG972.

1
In2011,PhilippeLorentzkindlyinvitedmetoParistolectureontheearlyHabsburgsattheEPHA.Itwasin
this context that I first developed the idea for this paper. I would like to thank the following colleagues for
helpingmetoputthematerialforthisessaytogether:KatrinDyballa,EvaMariaHllerer,StephanKemperdick,
PilarSilvaMaroto,MatthiasUblandJoostvanderAuwera.IamgratefultoHerbertKarnerforencouragingme
topursuethistopicandforhispatience.
2
Silver2008.
3
Pollero2012,pp.10115;seealso:Scheller1999,pp.7076.
ISBN9789460184833
111

4
ThisincludestheremarkableimageofthedeceasedMaximilianonhisdeathbed(diedon2January1519),see
GuidoMessling,MonogrammistA.A.,DasTotenbildnisMaximiliansI.,1519,inKaiserMaximilianI.2012,cat.
no.127,pp.38083.
5
Hand2004,pp.11214.
6
AmbrogiodePredis,MaximilianI,oak,44x30.3cm,1502,Vienna,KunsthistorischesMuseum,inv.no.GG
4431.KarlSchtz,AmbrogiodePredis,MaximilianI.,1502,inMaximilianI.2012,cat.no.11,pp.14647;fora
digitalimagesee:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giovanni_Ambrogio_de_Predis(accessedon22February2013).
7
SeealsothemedalbyBenediktBurkhartdepictingMaximilianinarmour,withtheinscriptionMAXIMILIANUS
ROMANO(RVM) REX IMPERATOR AVG(VSTVS), 1505, Prague, Nrodn museum; for a digital image see:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Maximilian_I_1505_av.jpgand
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Maximilian_I_1505_rv.jpg(accessedon11February2013).
8
Anonymous, Maximilian I, charcoal drawing, 37.3 x 25.3 cm, Berlin, Staatliche Museen Preussischer
Kulturbesitz,Kupferstichkabinett,KdZ10;AndreasBayerhasrecentlyattributedthisdrawingtoAmbrogiode
Predis,inGesichterderRenaissance2011,cat.no.106;foradigitalimagesee:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ambrogio_de_Predis_001.jpg(accessedon12February2013)
9
KarlSchtz,AmbrogiodePredis,inMaximilianI.2012,p.146.
10
ExzellenteChronikvanFlandern,Brgge,1481,inBrssel,KBR,Ms.130734,f.335v.;seeFillitz1988,pp.70
71,ill.4.
11
Vienna, sterreichische Nationalbibliothek (NB), Cod. Vin. 2606, fol. 75: Et mondit seigneur le duc
Maximilianotemprisetaccepteleditordrepourenestrechiefetsouveraincequilfitapresavoirrechutlordre
dechevalerieenleglisedesaintsauveuretlecollierduditordrelederrnierjourdumoisdavrillanmiliiijclxxvij
enlavilledebruges,quotedfromFrimmelandKlemme1887,p.296.
12
Anonymous,MaximilianI,paintingonconifer,54.6x36.1cm,Berlin,SMPK,inv.no.GG2111;althoughthe
date given in the inscription is 1504, the accompanying text seems corrupted and is thus less reliable; see:
http://bpkgate.picturemaxx.com/webgate_cms/(accessedon5December,2012).
13
AlbrechtDrer,EmperorMaximilianI,Vienna,1519,oil onlimewood,74x61.5cm,KarlSchtz,Albrecht
Drer, Kaiser Maximilian I, um 1519, in Maximilian I. 2012, cat. no. 78, pp. 29295; another version of this
painting is held by the Germanisches Nationalmuseum in Nuremberg: Albrecht Drer, Emperor Maximilian I,
1519,canvas,86.2x67.2cm,seeLcher1997,pp.21316.
14
Ontheprocessoftransferringthedesignfrompapertocanvasorwood,seeLuber1991,pp.3047.
15
Mende2000,cat.no.14,pp.31617.
16
DagmarEichberger,'KaiserMaximilianI.,um1519',inAlbrechtDrer2002,cat.no.252,pp.45659.
17
Scaillirez2011,pp.86111.
18
Hand2004,cat.nos.2.12.10,pp.11214.
19
Thismotiveisgenerallyemployedinportraitsthatwereproducedinthecontextofmarriagenegotiations.I
willcomebacktothemeaningofthismotiveatalaterpoint.
20
For example, Bernhard Strigel and workshop, Emperor Maximilian I, wood, 60.5 x 41 cm, Vienna,
KunsthistorischesMuseum,inv.no.GG922;anotherversionofthesametypeisinv.no.GG4403,75.5x49cm.
A slightly later version shows Maximilian with his imperial mitre crown: Bernhard Strigel, Maximilian I as
Emperor, circa 1507/08, wood, 82.8 x 50.5 cm, private collection / Innsbruck, Maximilianeum, inv. no. Gem
136.
21
StrigelsprofessionalconnectionwithEmperorMaximilianisbasedonaninscriptiononthebackofapanel
paintingthatshowsAnnaandJohannesCuspian(14731529)andtheiroffspring:Annohumannaereparacionis
MDXXMensoctobri...BernhardinusStrigilpictorcivisMemingennobilisquisolusedictoCaesareMaximilianuut
olim Apelles Alexandrum pingere iussus has imagines manu sinistra per specula ferme sexagenarius Viennae
pingebat, Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum, inv. no. GG 6411, see also Karl Schtz, 'Berhard Strigel, Die
FamilieKaiserMaximiliansI.,zwischen1515und1520',inMaximilianI.2012,cat.no.13,pp.152.
22
Bernhard Strigel and workshop, Emperor Maximilian I, limewood, 29 x 22 cm, Vienna, Kunsthistorisches
Museum,inv.no.GG828;foradigitalreproductionsee:
http://www.lessingphoto.com/dispimg.asp?i=26010224+&cr=10&cl=1.
23
Schtz2002,p.17.
24
ErichEgg,BildnisKnigMaximiliansI.,inMaximilianI.1969,cat.no.547,p.148.AccordingtoEgg,thecopy
inBerlin,formerlyinSchweinfurt,istheearliestportraitfromthisseries.Hequestionsthedate1496asitisin
contradictionwiththeinscriptionontherighthandside.
ISBN9789460184833
112

25
IwishtothankBrigitteReinekeforprovidingthisinformation;BernhardStrigel,EmperorMaximilianI,oilon
parchment on wood, 76,5 x 48 cm, Berlin, Deutsches Historisches Museum, inv. no. 1988/1496; for a digital
reproduction see: http://www.dhm.de/datenbank/dhm.php?seite=5&fld_0=K1000080 (accessed on 15
February2013).
26
DieterVorsteher,BerhardStrigel,KaiserMaximilianI.,1496,inHochrenaissanceimVatikan1999,cat.no.
72,pp.45455.ThisviewisalsoadoptedbyBrigitteReinekeinImAtelierderGeschichte2012,cat.no.8,pp.
32and346.
27
Hans Burgkmair the Elder (?), Emperor Frederick III, wood, circa 1510, 78,5 x 51,5 cm, Vienna,
KunsthistorischesMuseum,inv.no.GG4398.Ithasbeensuggestedthatitwasbasedonalostpaintingdating
from 1468; Margot Rauch Friedrich III., in Werke fr die Ewigkeit 2002, cat. no. 11, pp. 4547; for a digital
reproduction see: http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Hans_Burgkmair_d._%C3%84._005.jpg (accessed on 15
February2013).
28
Hans Burgkmair the Elder (?), Empress Eleanor of Portugal, wood, circa 1510, 79 x 51.5 cm, Vienna,
KunsthistorischesMuseum,inv.no.GG4399;MargotRauchEleonorevonPortugal.,inWerkefrdieEwigkeit
2002,cat.no.11,pp.4749;foradigitalimagesee:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Hans_Burgkmair_d._%C3%84._006.jpg(accessedon15February2013).
29
Silver2008,p.102.AsmallnumberofportraitscanbetracedbacktothecollectionofArchdukeFerdinandII,
whoestablishedaportraitcollectionatSchlossAmbras.
30
Eichberger2005,pp.4855.
31
32
Lille, AdN, Chambre des Comptes de Lille, no. 123904, fol. 4: Les painctures estans en la librairye de
madame, in The Inventories of Charles V (2010), vol. III, p. 2393. The portrait is mentioned again in the
householdinventoryof152324:Celledelempereurtrespass,Paris,BNF,CinqCentsdeColbert128,fol.46v,
seeEichberger2002,p.173,fn.117.Formoreinformationonthevariousinventories,seeEichberger2010,vol.
III,pp.235163.
33
BernhardStrigel,EmperorMaximilianI,Innsbruck,TirolerLandesmuseum,oilonwood,84x51.8cm,circa
1507/08.
34
35
Lille,AdN,ChambresdesComptes,123904,inTheInventoriesofCharlesV2010,vol.III,p.2393.
36
Bernhard Strigel, Maximilian I, oil on limewood, 39.5 x 30 cm, National Trust, Upton House, Banbury,
Warwickshire, cat. no. 213; for a digital image see: http://www.bbc.co.uk/arts/yourpaintings/paintings/the
emperormaximiliani14591519(accessedon21February2013).
37
Bernhard Strigel and workshop, Emperor Maximilian I with scroll, ca. 1515, limewood, 37 x 25 cm, Berlin,
Gemldegalerie,inv.no.2110;foradigitalimagesee:
http://bpkgate.picturemaxx.com/preview.php?WGSESSID=dcec51b266a2804a19350a3e18fc6aca&UURL=67f5
b88c215c9a208c2b26be9036ab15&IMGID=00025455. Further versions of this portrait exist in: Vienna
[Kunsthistorisches Museum, inv. no. GG 828], Kreuzlingen [Sammlung Kisters] and Innsbruck [Tiroler
LandesmuseumFerdinandeum,inv.no.1277].
38
ErichEgg,BildnisKaiserMaximiliansI.alsPrivatman,inMaximilianI.1969,cat.no.551/552,p.148.
39
Larry Silver, Leonard Beck, Hans Burgkmair the Elder, Hans Schufelein, Hans Springinklee, Weisskunig,
151416,inKaiserMaximilianI.2012,cat.no.74,pp.28889.
40
Paris,BNF,CinqCentsdeColbert128,fol.59v,inTheInventoriesofCharlesV2010,vol.III,p.2448.
41
JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIassovereignoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,wood,30.8x21.1
cmBerlin,KMPK,GG1321;seeGemldegalerieBerlin1996,vol.2,cat.no.791;JoosvanCleveandworkshop,
Maximilian as sovereign of the Order of the Golden Fleece, wood, 33 x 23 cm, Brussels, Muses Royaux des
BeauxArtsdeBelgique,inv.no.2581;seeMusesroyauxdesBeauxArtsdeBelgique1984,p.60.
42
ThepaintingwasstudiedwithIRRbyMollyFairiesinMarch2001.Thecolourofthebackgroundisgreen,the
hatisblack;theunderdrawinginexecutedinadrymedium,delineatinghisfaceandhands(correspondence
withEvaMariaHllererdatingfrom2December2012).
43
StatutebookoftheOrderoftheGoldenFleece,Vienna,NB,Cod.2606,fol.77:anonymous,'MaximilianIas
sovereignoftheorder',Bruges,after1518,parchment,28.4x21cm;seeDasStatutenbuchdesOrdensvom
GoldenenVlies(1934).Foradigitalimagesee:
http://wwwg.uniklu.ac.at/kultdoku/kataloge/37/html/2756.htm(accessedon20February2013).
44
EichbergerandBeaven1995,pp.23335.
ISBN9789460184833
113

45
Tres excellent et tres puissant prince, monseigneur Maximilien, archidux dautriche, duc de lothrie, de
Brabant,deluxemburg,etc.
46
Paris,BNF,CinqCentsdeColbert128,fol.81v;inTheInventoriesofCharlesV(2010),vol.III,p.2455.
47
Hand 2004, pp. 11214; [2.0] Joos van Cleve, Maximilian I with carnations, oak, 28.5 x 22.3 cm, Vienna,
KunsthistorischesMuseum,inv.no.GG972;[2.1]JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIwithcarnations,
oak, 19 x 13 cm, the date 1510 is written onto the original frame; Paris, Muse JacquemartAndr, inv. no.
2234;[2.2]JoosvanCleveandworkshop,MaximilianIwithcarnations,oak,34.6x24.4cm(withoutframe),
Amsterdam,Rijskmuseum,inv.no.SKA3293,foradigitalimagesee:
https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/search/objecten?q=maximiliaan+I&js=1&p=6&ps=12#/SKA3293,70
(accessedon20February2013).
48
IntheViennaandthePariscopiesMaximilianisholdingthreeflowersinsteadoftwo,seeNetherlandishart
intheRijksmuseum2000,p.43.OnedetailthatraisesquestionsintheAmsterdamversionisthewayinwhich
theOrderoftheGoldenFleeceisdepicted.Thefiligreestyleinwhichthecollaroftheorderhasbeenpainted
does not correspond to the more solid chains in the other paintings. For digital information see:
http://www.rijksmuseum.nl/collectie/zoeken/asset.jsp?id=SKA3293&lang=nl (accessed on 22 November
2011).
49
Text in the margins of the entry quoted above: Ce tableau a est donn par Madame sa seur batarde,
religieusedeBoisleDucparsalettredu10doctobreanno1527,pourceroy.
50
Hand2004,p.20.
51
ItinerariumMaximilianI1899,pp.4856.
52
OntheearlycareerofJoosvanCleveseeHand2004,pp.1321.
53
ThisisalsoemphasizedbyScaillrez2011,p.104.Theauthorsofthecatalogueentryseemtoquestionthe
suppositionthatMaximilianmetupwiththeartists,seeJoosvanCleve2011,p.179.
54
JoosvanCleve2011,cat.nos.4849,50,pp.18081;seealsoScaillirez2011,p.104.
55
Hand2004,p.20;anonymous,HenryVII,oilonwood,42.5x30.5cm,London,NationalPortraitGallery,inv.
no.416.TheinscriptionontheLondonpaintingdocumentsthatHenrysportraitwaspaintedon29October
1505 on command of Herman Rinck, a London agent for the Holy Roman Emperor; for a digital image see:
www.npg.org.uk/collections/search/portraitLarge/mw03078/KingHenryVII?LinkID=mp02144&role=sit&rNo=1
(accessedon21February2013).
56
Hans Burgkmair, no. 53: The marriage ceremony of Maximilian and Mary of Burgundy in Bruges 1477, in
MaximilianI.andTreitzsauerwein1775,online:http://digi.ub.uniheidelberg.de/diglit/maximilian1775.
57
The 1511 silver coin is modelled on an earlier medal by Giovanni Candida; for a digital image of the 1511
silvercoin,see:http://www.coingallery.de/KarlV/Maximil_D.htm.Thereareseveralversionsingold(Dresden,
Prague, Vienna): Ulrich Ursentaler, Kaiser Maximilian, 1511, Dresden, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen,
Mnzkabinett, inv. no. 886; for a digital image see: http://www.habsburger.net/de/kapitel/kunstimdienste
derherrschaft;thereverseofUrsentalerscoinisreproducedunder:
http://www.habsburger.net/en/node/3120(accessedon21February2013).
ISBN9789460184833
114
DynastischeIdentittundeuropischePolitik
derspanischenHabsburgerinden1650er
Jahren
DiegoVelzquezBildnissealsTeileinerhfischpolitischenPortrtkultur

EvaBettinaKrems

Als Don Juan Jos, der natrliche Sohn des spanischen Knigs Philipp IV., im Mrz 1659 von der
franzsischen Knigin Anne dAutriche in ihrem Palais bei Val de Grce in Paris empfangen wurde,
zeigte ihm diese die Bildnisse der spanischen Habsburger, die sich in ihrem Kabinett befanden.
DarberinformierteinzeitgenssischerBericht,derdieSzeneinderGaleriezueinemEreignisvon
staatspolitischer Bedeutung verdichtet:1 Eines der Portrts nmlich zeigte die spanische Infantin
Maria Teresa, die Tochter Philipps IV. An der gegenberliegenden Wand hingen die Portrts der
franzsischen Familie. Neben Ludwig XIV., damals bereits einundzwanzigjhrig, war noch ein Platz
frei fr seine zuknftige Gemahlin. Der Spanier Don Juan merkte an, dass diese Lcke in der
Bildnisreihe leicht zu fllen sei. Man msse nur das gegenberliegende Portrt der spanischen
InfantinabnehmenundnebenLudwigaufhngen.
Dieser berlieferte Bericht vollfhrt unter Verweis auf den Gebrauch von Portrts eine
Vorausschau,diekaumeinJahrsptererflltwerdensollte:DieVerknpfungderbeidenDynastien
durchdieHochzeitLudwigsXIV.mitderspanischenInfantinMariaTeresa.IhrimBerichterwhntes
Bildnis ist vermutlich das von Diego Velzquez 1653 vollendete Werk, jedoch ist die in Paris
gelandete Version eine Werkstattarbeit. Das von Velzquez angefertigte Original war nahezu
zeitgleich nach Wien gelangt. Es hat sogar eine dritte Version gegeben, die nach Brssel gesendet
wurde.2
Die Ausfhrung des originalen Portrts und seiner beiden Kopien fllt in das letzte
SchaffensjahrzehntdesspanischenHofmalersDiegoVelzquez,der1660starb.IndiesemJahrzehnt
sind auch zwei seiner heute berhmtesten Werke entstanden: Las Meninas (1656) und Las
Hilanderas (vermutlich um 1658) fhren den intellektuellen Rang des Malers deutlich vor.3 Diese
Jahrewarenabervorallemdadurchgeprgt,dassVelzquezdashchstefrihnerreichbareAmtbei
Hofeerlangenkonnte,nmlichdasdesSchlossmarschalls.4DiesesAmtverpflichteteihnzustndiger
AnwesenheitamHof,dennerleitetenichtnureinigeBauprojekte,sondernentwickelteEinsatzplne
fr die Kammerdiener, berwachte die Etikette bei den Mahlzeiten des Knigs, sorgte fr die
Quartiere bei kniglichen Reisen, fr die Mblierung und Ausstattung der Residenzen und
organisierte Dekorationen fr Feste.5 Eine seiner letzten Amtsttigkeiten, bevor er im August 1660
ISBN9789460184833
115
starb,galtderorganisatorischen und gestalterischen BesorgungderzeremoniellenZusammenkunft

zwischendemspanischenundfranzsischenHofmitdenbeidenKnigenPhilippIV.undLudwigXIV.
imOktober1659aufderPfaueninsel.6
Schon die Zeitgenossen bemerkten, die hfischen mter htten den Maler von seiner
knstlerischen Ttigkeit abgehalten. Diese Einschtzung reicht bis in die jngste Forschung hinein.
Laut Martin Warnke habe Philipp IV. auf Velzquez Indienstnahme als Hofmaler verzichtet, was
dieser wiederum dazu genutzt habe, seinen Malerberuf aufzugeben, um aus freien Stcken zu
malen.7MitdenbeidenGemldenLasHilanderasundLasMeninashabeVelzquezvorallemseine
knstlerischeNobilitierungimAugegehabt.
JedochmalteVelzquezimselbenJahrzehnt,alsoab1651,eineganzeReihevonPortrait
und dasjenige der eingangs genannten Maria Teresa war eines davon , die eben nicht in den
mutmalichen Bereich eines vom Hofamt losgelsten und somit womglich entfesselten
Knstlertumsfallen,sonderngenaudemPflichtenspektrumdesHofknstlersentsprachen.Eswaren
diePortrtsderFamilienmitgliederderspanischenHabsburger.Dasklingtzunchstnachbruchloser
Fortsetzung,warVelzquezdochalsPortrtistbereitsberauserfahren.Indessenleisteteerhierin
seinen letzten Lebensjahren etwas Neues in seinem ohnehin reichen Portrtschaffen. Um dies zu
verstehen, ist ein kurzer Blick auf die politische Situation der spanischen Habsburger notwendig,
befand sich doch die spanische Linie der Casa Austria in diesen Jahren in einer ernsthaften Krise.
Ausgelst wurde diese 1646 durch den unvermittelten Tod von Philipps einzigem Sohn Baltasar
CarlosunddamitdesrechtmigenThronfolgers,nurwenigeWochennachdemmitKaiserFerdinand
III.inWienvereinbartwordenwar,dassdessenTochterMariaAnna,damalszwlfJahrealt,Baltasar
Carlos zur Frau gegeben werden sollte.8 Zwei Jahre zuvor, 1644, war bereits Philipps Gemahlin
IsabellavonBourbonverstorben.DerKnigwarnunmehrohneeinenmnnlichenErben;dereinzig
verbliebeneNachkommedieserVerbindungwardieInfantinMariaTeresa.
Die durch den Tod des Prinzen hervorgerufene Situation war jedoch nicht nur fr die
spanischen Habsburger, sondern insgesamt fr das Gleichgewicht der europischen Mchte zum
AusgangdesDreiigjhrigenKriegesausgesprochenheikel.GeradediedynastischenSchwchender
Habsburger und ihre Erbfolgekrisen brachten das europische Staatensystem im siebzehnten und
frhen achtzehnten Jahrhundert immer wieder ins Wanken, weil die Monarchien am veralteten
CharakterderPatrimonialstaatenfesthaltenwolltenunddamitaneinerErbfolge,vonderdieFrauen
ausgeschlossenwaren.9SobliebdasdynastischeEuropaeineQuelleunzhligerKonflikteinfolgedes
Aussterbens herrschender Huser und der durch die Nebenlinien aufgrund von Erbrechten
erhobenen Ansprche. Das Problem der biologischen Schwche der spanischen Linie des Hauses
Habsburg wurde schon whrend der Friedensverhandlungen in Mnster 1648 von den spanischen
undfranzsischenDelegationendiskutiert.10
ISBN9789460184833
116

Abb. 1 Diego Velzquez, Isabella von Bourbon,
163132,NewYork,Privatsammlung.
Abb.2DiegoVelzquez,BaltasarCarlos,ca.1640,Wien,
KunsthistorischesMuseum.

UmdieHegemoniederHabsburgerinEuropadennochzusichern,beschlossderdamals42
jhrigePhilippIV.kurzerhandselbstdieBrautseinesverstorbenenSohneszuheiraten,obwohldiese,
Maria Anna, seine leibliche Nichte war und zum Zeitpunkt des Heiratskontrakts 1647 gerade erst
dreizehnJahrezhlte.MariaAnna,imfolgendenMarianagenannt,trafimHerbst1649inMadridein.
VelzquezbefandsichzudiesemZeitpunktinItalienundkehrteerstimSommer1651andenHofin
Madrid zurck, wo er die neue politische Situation vorfand, die sowohl ihn den frisch ernannten
Schlossmarschall,alsauchdiespanischeLiniederCasaAustriavorneueAufgabenstellte.DerBlick
aufdieseit1651geschaffenenPortrtszeigtunverkennbareinedeutlicheDominanzderweiblichen
Familienmitglieder.11 Diese waren bisher, mit Ausnahme von einem Portrt der ersten Gemahlin
Philipps IV. (Abb. 1),12 nicht im Fokus des ersten Hofmalers Velzquez gewesen, der freilich in
AnlehnunganeinenantikenToposalseinzigerberechtigtwar,denKnigzumalen.Zudemoblag
ihm bisher die Aufgabe, Baltasar Carlos, den Sohn des Knigs im Portrt festzuhalten (Abb. 2),13
gleichsamalsBelegderalsgesichertgeglaubtenFortsetzungderDynastie.
VondessenneunJahrejngerenSchwester,MariaTeresa,gibteskeinevonVelzquez,dem
ersten Hofmaler, ausgefhrten Kinderbildnisse. Dafr waren offenbar andere zustndig, wie etwa
Velzquez Schwiegersohn Juan Bautista Martnez del Mazo, der die Prinzessin als etwa Vierjhrige
malte(Abb.3).14MartnezdelMazoerweistsichalsengvertrautmitderknstlerischenHandschrift
seines Schwiegervaters Velzquez: in der leicht gedrehten Haltung des Kindes, das sich an einem
ISBN9789460184833
117
Stuhlabsttzt,hinterfangenvoneinemfigrlichenBildteppich,folgtdasBildnisdemvonVelzquez
geprgten Typus des Kinderportrts, wie demjenigen des zweijhrigen Balthasar Carlos von 1631
(Abb.4).15EinentscheidenderUnterschiedliegtbeimBildnisderMariaTeresajedochimFehlenvon
InsignienderMacht,wiesieselbstdemzweijhrigenBaltasarCarlosinderKleidung,imSchwertund
KommandostabundindenvomZwerggehaltenenRasselundApfel,dieaufSzepterundReichsapfel
anspielenknnten,beigegebensind.
Abb. 4 Diego Velzquez, Baltasar Carlos mit einem Zwerg,

1631,Boston,MuseumofFineArts.
Abb.3JuanBautistaMartnezdelMazo,MariaTeresa,
um1642,NewYork,MetropolitanMuseumofArt.
DemRangdesjeweiligenHofmalersentsprachsomitdieRangstellungderzuportrtierenden
Familienmitglieder, etwa des Thronerben gegenber den anderen, vor allem weiblichen
Nachkommen.DieTchterspieltenzwarinderErbfolgekeineRolle,warenabereinwichtigesSymbol
frdieflorierendenFamilienverbindungen,geradenachdemdieCasaAustriaineinesterreicheund
einespanischeLiniegespaltenwar.
UnterdemAspektderklarenRollenverteilungunterdenHofmalernistesdahererstaunlich,
dassVelzquezalsersterunterihnennunauchdieweiblichenNachkommenzuportrtierenhatte,
trotz seiner hohen Belastung auf dem wichtigen Hofamt als Schlossmarschall. Das lsst darauf
schlieen, dass man die Bedeutung der weiblichen Familienmitglieder in den 1650er Jahren hher
schtzte als bislang und ihrer Rolle ein greres Gewicht beima, zumal die neue Verbindung von
PhilippIV.mitMarianajahrelangohnemnnlichenSprossblieb.
Noch ein weiterer Aspekt ist wichtig: Der Groteil dieser Portrts gelangte in einen
interhfischen Bilderkreislauf zwischen dem spanischen Knigshof in Madrid, Paris als Sitz des
ISBN9789460184833
118
franzsischen Knigs, Wien als Sitz des Kaisers und Brssel als Sitz des Statthalters der spanischen
Niederlande. Es war ein den Akteuren vertrautes und ritualisiertes Spiel mit Kopien, Repliken und
Originalen,mitGroformatenundKleinformaten,mitBrustbildernundganzfigurigenPortrts.16Eine
effiziente und gut organisierte Werkstatt war dabei Voraussetzung fr das Gelingen des
diplomatischenAustauschsvonPortrts,wasmanchenHofmalersicherauchberfordernkonnte.
JederbeteiligteMalerkonnteseinePortrtsunddieseinerinderFernearbeitendenKollegen
als Medien eines kalkulierbaren Kulturtransfers betrachten, wenngleich die knstlerische Aufgabe
keine leichte war. Denn nicht selten kollidierte das Informationsbedrfnis der Empfnger mit den
Idealisierungsbestrebungen der Absender, was den Knstler dazu zwang, den Zielkonflikt zwischen
dem Verismus in der Darstellung und ihrer symbolischen bersteigerung weitgehend aufzulsen.
ImmerhinmusstendieKnstlernichtselbstreisenwienochVelzqueznachItalien,umSpuren
ihrerPortrtkunstandenferngelegenenHfenzuhinterlassen.
DiebermittlervonBildnisundBotschaftwarenvorallem die GesandtenundDiplomaten,
diedieInteressendeseigenenHofesandenjeweilsanderenHfenvertraten.Siegehrtenzuden
zentralen Akteuren in diesem hochgradig ritualisierten Austausch von Portrts entlang der
politischen Achsen, quer durch das dynastische Europa. Daher wirft die Portrtpraxis, in die auch
VelzquezBildnisseeingebundenwaren,einigesLichtaufdieBeziehungenzwischendenspanischen
unddensterreichischenHabsburgernbzw.denfranzsischenBourbonen:Wieesumdiejeweiligen
Verhltnisse bestellt war, kann man an den Bildern selbst, an ihrem Gebrauch und schlielich
sofernhierQuellenvorliegenanihrerFremdwahrnehmungablesen.
Velzquez spte Bildnisse der vor allem weiblichen Mitglieder der Knigsfamilie knnen
somitalsTeileinerhfischenPortrtkulturbetrachtetwerden,dieeinerseitsausderBildverwendung
innerhalb des dynastischdiplomatischen Austauschs und andererseits der Rezeption durch
KommentarederZeitgenossendefiniertwird.Jedochistzubedenken,dasssehrvielwenigerQuellen
ber Fragen der Rezeption Auskunft geben als zu der Tauschpraxis selbst, die ihrerseits in der
knstlerischen Disposition des jeweiligen Gemldes ihren eigenen, eben bildhaften Quellenbefund
findet.DennimRahmenderhfischenPortrtkulturerfllendieBildnisseunterschiedlicheZwecke,
die man so dieThese an ihren stilistischen, kompositionellen und ikonographischen
Besonderheiten ablesen kann. ber ihre pragmatische Funktion steuern Portrts die
WahrnehmungenderpolitischenAkteure,erinnernangetroffeneinterhfischeVerabredungenoder
nhren politische Hoffnungen. Bisweilen sind es die kleinen Unterschiede im Arrangement eines
Portrts, die darber entscheiden, ob es der Brautwerbung, einem Erbschaftsversprechen, der
BetonungeinesMachtanspruchsoderdemErweisdynastischerProsperittdienensoll.
AneinerkleinenAuswahlseienimFolgendensolcheUnterschiedeinVelzquezPortrts,die
im interhfischen Bilderverkehr kursierten, beispielhaft dargelegt, um Rolle und Bedeutung des
hfischen Bildnisses als Teil einer regelrechten Portrtkultur sichtbar zu machen. Ich mchte
beginnenmitdemgroformatigenPortrtderneuenKniginMariana(Abb.5).17ImJahre1649,als
dieneueKnigininMadrideingetroffenwar,befandsichVelzqueznochinItalienundkonnteerst
nach seiner Rckkehr aus Rom 1651 mit dem Portrt der jungen Regentin beginnen. Obwohl der
KaiserbereitsimJuli1650umeinPortrtseinerTochternachihrerHochzeitgebetenhatte,wartete
manoffenbaraufdieRckkehrdeserstenkniglichenHofmalers,wasdieBedeutungdieserAufgabe
unterstrich.18 Das Bild war sptestens im Dezember 1652 beendet, denn mit der diplomatischen
UniversityofLeuven,andAuthors
ISBN9789460184833
119
Mission des Marquis von Caracena19 wurde zu diesem Zeitpunkt ein Portrt der Knigin an den
KaiserhofnachWiengesendeteswarjedochnureineWerkstattreplik,dieWienerreichte(Abb.
6).20DasOriginalverbliebinMadrid(Abb.5).21
Abb. 5 Diego Velzquez, Knigin Mariana, um

1652,Madrid,MuseodelPrado.
Abb. 6 Diego Velzquez (Werkstatt), Knigin Mariana,

um1652,Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum.

DerVergleichmitdemPortrtderfrherenKnigin(Abb.1)liegtnahe:Velzquezschufdes
BildnisderIsabellavonBourbonetwazwanzigJahrevorher.22DiehnlichkeitinderDispositionder
beidenBildnisseistdeutlich:DerdieSzenehinterfangenderoteVorhang,dasAufsttzenaufdenmit
SamtbezogenenStuhl,diesteifeKrperhaltung,diediefrmlicheEtiketteimoffiziellen Hofportrt
demonstriert und den Eindruck kniglicher Majestt hervorruft. Alle diese gemeinsamen Elemente
belegen die Vertrautheit Velzquez mit der schon durch Rubens am spanischen Hof etablierten
Portrtform. Dennoch gibt es im Bildnis der Mariana neuartige Aspekte, die nicht allein auf
stilistische Variationen zurckzufhren sind, sondern mit der bildgewordenen Funktion der Knigin
als Reprsentantin der Dynastie zu tun haben. So etwa trgt Mariana, deren Hals im Gegensatz zu
Isabella nicht bedeckt ist, eine aufwndig und kunstvoll frisierte Percke, die das Gesicht wie ein
Fcherhinterfngt;seitlichwirddasHauptvoneinerbuschigenStrauenfederbekrnt.23
Die aufflligste nderung in der Mode ist jedoch der sogenannte Guardainfante, der
weitausladende Reifrock. Durch das enge Korsett wird die Taille und damit der ausgestellte Rock
ISBN9789460184833
120
nochbetont.DieEntscheidung,denGuardainfantefrdieKniginzuwhlen,wargewissnichtallein
dem reinen Diktat der Mode geschuldet, denn diese Gewandform hatte eine durchaus heikle
Bedeutung. Die weit verbreitete Befrchtung war, dass sich unter dem Guardainfante, also
Kinderwchter genannten Rock, so manche Schwangerschaft verbergen lie, die, so eine
zeitgenssische Quelle, nicht die Frucht einer legitimen Liebesbeziehung sei.24 1639 war der Rock
daherperkniglichemDekretalshurenmigverbotenworden(Abb.7).25DerRockerfreutesich
dennochungeahnterBeliebtheit,undvieleFrauensetztensichberdasVerbothinweg.DasGesetz
wurde verschiedentlich erneuert, doch ohne die Verbreitung dieser modischen Attraktion wirklich
eindmmen zu knnen. Velzquez portrtierte die Knigin in diesem strittigen Auftritt sogar zur
selbenZeit,alsderspanischeHofdramatikerCalderndenGuardainfantesatirischinseinenamHof
aufgefhrtenTheaterstckenverarbeitete.26

Abb.7KniglichesDekretzumVerbotdes
Guardainfante,1639.
Die Frage stellt sich, warum Velzquez diese so auffllige Gewandung in einem hfischen
Staatsportrt einsetzte, das als solches ausgewiesen ist etwa durch den Stuhl und die Tischuhr als
SymbolekniglichenRanges.IsteseinZeichenfrFruchtbarkeitunddamitdaszentraleSymbolfr
die Kontinuitt der Habsburger Herrschaft?27 Oder knnte dieses modischprchtige, mit silbernen
LitzenbestickteundmitrotenBndernverzierteKleid,kombiniertmitwertvollemSchmuck,darunter
Goldketten,ArmbnderundeinegroegoldeneBroscheamMieder,genaudasreprsentieren,was
es ostentativ zeigt: nmlich Mode und Pracht, eine betont spanische Aktualitt und Reichtum,28
somit einen prosperierenden spanischen Hof, biologisch wie finanziell. Beides entsprach zu dieser
Zeit freilich kaum der Realitt. Die finanziellen Ressourcen waren beraus kritisch und ein
Thronfolger noch lange nicht geboren. Die weibliche Reprsentantin der Dynastie liefert in diesem
ISBN9789460184833
121
BildnisdasnachdemfrhenToddesThronfolgerslangeberflligeVersprechen,dassmaninEuropa
weiterhinmitdenspanischenHabsburgernzurechnenhat.
Schlielich sei auf eine dritte Neuerung in diesem Kniginportrt gegenber dem frheren
der Isabella von Bourbon (Abb. 1) hingewiesen, die ebenfalls der aktualisierten symbolischen
bersteigerungdient:derKontrastzwischenderkrperlichenStarrederFigurunddertechnischen
VirtuosittdesPinselstrichs,eineSpontaneittundLeichtigkeit,diederMalervorallemimBereich
derGewandungvorfhrt.HierverwandeltsichdiearretierteGewandhlleineinbewegtesGlitzern
und Flirren, das die ganze Person zum Erstrahlen bringt. Mit Marianas Portrt wurde in diesen
Aspekten ein neuer Typus des Bildnisses am Hof der spanischen Habsburger etabliert und zwar
zumZeitpunkteinerernsthaftenErbfolgekrisederdesselbststndigenweiblichenHofportrts.
Die Typenhaftigkeit zeigt sich in dem nur wenig spter entstandenen Portrt der Maria
Teresa(Abb.8),29welchesschonzuBeginnkurzerwhntwurde.MariaTeresawares,aufdiesichdie
Aufmerksamkeit der anderen europischen Mchte noch weitaus strker richtete als auf die junge
Knigin:dieTochterPhilippsIV.ausdessenersterEhemitIsabellavonBourbonwargeradeeinmal
vier Jahre jnger als ihre Stiefmutter Mariana, und vor allem war sie der einzig noch verbliebene,
wenn auch weibliche Spross des spanischen Knigshauses. Bereits 1646, kurz nach dem Tod des
KnigsohnsBaltasarCarlos,schlugFrankreichsregierenderMinisterMazarindieseVerbindungvor.
Der Bruch der Verhandlungen zwischen beiden Herrscherhusern auf dem Friedenskongress in
Mnster und somit der fortdauernde Krieg vereitelten zunchst den Heiratsplan. Erst nach vielen
Jahren, 1659, sollte der Pyrenenfrieden den vorgezeichneten Weg fr die neue Verbindung
freimachen.
Abb.8DiegoVelzquez(Werkstatt),MariaTeresa,um1653,Boston,MuseumofFineArts.
MariaTeresasRolleerlangtesomitnachdemTodevonBalthasarCarloseineneuepolitische
Bedeutung, die ber die gngige Heiratspraxis am spanischen Hof weit hinausging. Dies lsst sich
allein an der Versendungsbreite ihres Portrts ablesen, denn es wurde an noch mehr Hfe und in
ISBN9789460184833
122
nochdichtererFrequenzverteiltalsdasjenigederKnigin.DavonzeugendieBerichtederGesandten
und Diplomaten zu dieser Zeit, die fr die Transfers der Portrts der Infantin zustndig waren. Die
Versendung eines Bildnisses der spanischen Infantin kam am Zielort dem Versprechen gleich, dass
hierwiedorteinerHeiratzugestimmtwerdenknnte.30EinsolchesVersprechenkonntebereitszur
Zeit der Anfertigung des jeweiligen Bildnisses und der Planung seiner Versendungsziele
wahrgenommen werden, was den beteiligten Akteuren mitunter einen diplomatisch nutzbaren
Zeitvorteilverschaffenkonnte.
FeinnervigregistriertenauswrtigeGesandteambetreffendenHof,obPortrtsaufdieReise
an bestimmte Ziele gehen sollten, was als ein Zeichen fr Verhandlungen entlang einer wichtigen
politischen Achse gedeutet wurde: So berichtet der in Madrid ansssige Gesandte vom Hof zu
Modena,FrancescoOttonelli,am22.Februar1653,derMarcheseMattei,dervoreinigenMonaten
nach Madrid geschickt worden sei, reise morgen wieder nach Flandern ab; man habe ihm
mitgegeben il ritratto della serenissima infanta e con esso quello del re e della regina.31 Es seien
alsoPortrtsderInfantindieanersterStellegenanntwird,desKnigsundderKniginfrden
Statthalter Erzherzog Leopold Wilhelm, den Bruder des Kaisers, nach Brssel gesendet worden,
natrlich um dessen Hoffnung auf seine Vermhlung mit der Infantin zu nhren, la speranza del
matrimonioconladettaserenissimainfanta.32

Abb.9DiegoVelzquez,MariaTeresa,um1653,Wien,
Portrts konnten somit zu politisch aktivierbaren Medien werden, ja zum diplomatischen
SurrogatvonneuenBndnisformierungen;siedientensogaralsVertrauensspendezurVorbereitung
von Friedensverhandlungen. Der gemalten spanischen Prinzessin kam dabei eine multiple Funktion
ISBN9789460184833
123
zu,dennbeiderVersendungdesPortrtsnachBrssel(Abb.8)33bliebesnicht;eineweitereVersion
ging, so ein Bericht des venezianischen Gesandten Giacomo Querini vom 17. Dezember 1653, fast
zeitgleich an den Wiener Kaiserhof (Abb. 9):34 Maria Teresa war 1653 fr den ltesten Sohn des
Kaisers bestimmt, der jedoch bereits ein Jahr spter verstarb. Im selben Schreiben fgte der
Gesandtehinzu,erselbstwerdeeindrittesBildnisderInfantinwiederumnachFrankreichschicken.35
DieserVorgangerstauntammeisten,denndieFranzosenbefandensichzudieserZeitnochimKrieg
mitSpanien:DiebersendungeinesPortrtsaneinfeindlichesLandwareinegroeNeuerungfrdie
spanischen Habsburger. Bisher hatte sich der Spanische Hof allgemein mit Bildnisgeschenken ber
die Grenzen der Dynastie hinaus sehr zurckgehalten;36 Portrts zirkulierten fast ausschlielich
innerhalbderHabsburgerFamilie,alsozwischenWienundMadrid.Nunabermusstemansichden
Mchten ob Kriegsgegner oder Bndnispartner gleichermaen politisch anbieten, und
innerhalbderzugehrigenGeschftsgngederGesandtenwardasBildnisderPrinzessinklarerweise
eingeeignetesMediumzurBekrftigungseinerInteressen.37

Abb.10DiegoVelzquez(Werkstatt),MariaTeresa,um1653,Paris,Louvre.
Das Portrt der Infantin wurde also innerhalb kurzer Zeit an drei verschiedene Hfe
geschickt: Das Original ging nach Wien, eine Kopie nach Brssel an den Hof des Statthalters der
spanischen Niederlande und eine weitere Kopie schlielich nach Paris, die erheblich beschnitten
worden ist und nur noch als Brustbild existiert (Abb. 10).38 Auch die beiden groformatigen
Versionen(siewarenursprnglichber2Meterhoch)sindbeschnittenwordeninderHheum
ca.70cm,inderBreiteknapp30cm.39ManmusssichMariaTeresaalsoursprnglichalsGanzfigur,
wie auf dem Portrt Marianas (Abb. 5), vorstellen. Auch im Typus ist das Portrt der Infantin, wie
angedeutet,demderKniginverblffendhnlich,wasdieHaltungderdiszipliniertstehendenFigur
mit der auffllig modischen Frisur, dem Schmuck und dem Guardainfante verdeutlicht. Selbst die
physiognomischehnlichkeitistberdasverwandtschaftlichengeVerhltnishinausgesucht,umdie
ISBN9789460184833
124
Habsburger Familienzugehrigkeit ber die Trennung der Casa Austria in eine spanische und eine
sterreichischeLiniehinauszupropagieren.
Jedoch sind bei der vor einem tiefdunklen schwarzgrnen Vorhang stehenden Infantin,
abgesehen von der ber den Rock entlang gefhrten Uhr und mglicherweise einem
Bildnismedaillon,40keinerleiAttributezufinden.DerdunkelgrneschwereTeppichscheintsogarden
Tisch links regelrecht verdecken zu wollen, um keinerlei Deutungsmglichkeiten zu bieten. Diese
AusblendungpolitischerIkonographienistkeineWillkr,dennsptereBildnisseVelzquezbedienen
durchausdenattributivenApparatderHerrschaftsdarstellung.VielmehrhltsichdiesesPortrtder
Infantinoffenbarabsichtlichbedeckt. EsisteinStaatsportrtohneAttribute;damitaberauchohne
den im Staatsportrt gewohnten Ausdruck von sozialer Egalitt und hfischer Vernetzung.41 Der
HofmalerVelzquezwirdgewussthaben,dassdasPortrtanmehrereHfegeschicktwerdensollte,
darunter sogar der franzsische Hof der Bourbonen. Er bemht sich also um eine ikonographisch
multiple Passform fr eine bildpragmatische Bewhrung des Portrts an drei verschiedenen Orten
zugleich.
Es gibt einen weiteren wichtigen Aspekt, der die Attributlosigkeit erklrt: es durfte kein
HinweisaufeinenErbansprucherkennbarsein.DasPortrtderMariaTheresadurftenichtwiedie
Bildnisse ihres Bruders, des Prinzen Baltasar Carlos ein Symbol fr die Kontinuitt spanischer
Herrschaftsein.DenndieVerheiratungMariaTeresasbotfrdieeuropischenMchteeineGefahr,
so lange kein mnnlicher Thronfolger geboren war. Das jahrelange Buhlen der Franzosen um die
spanischeInfantinalsBrautfrLudwigXIV.wurdeinEuropamitgrterSorgeregistriert,damanzu
RechtdenfranzsischenAnspruchaufdasspanischeErbebefrchtete.42DasEinlenkenPhilippsIV.in
den Hochzeitsverhandlungen erfolgte erst in den spten 1650er Jahren, denn erst 1657 war mit
FelipePrsperoderlangersehntemnnlicheThronfolgergeboren.
IndiesemZusammenhangmchteichabschlieendzweiPortrtskurzindenBlicknehmen,
die1659,alsowenigeMonatevorderspanischfranzsischenHochzeit,alsGeschenkePhilippsIV.an
denKaisernachWiengesendetwurden:DiebeidenBildnissezeigendiezweiNachkommenausder
Ehe mit Mariana von sterreich, Margarita Teresa (Abb. 11) und ihren jngeren Bruder, den eben
erwhntenFelipePrspero(Abb.12).43
ISBN9789460184833
125

Abb.11DiegoVelzquez,MargaritaTeresa,1659,Wien,
Diese beiden von Velzquez fr den Kaiser angefertigten Bildnisse hatten in dem hier
dargelegten, mit hoher politischer Symbolik behafteten interhfischen Portrttransfer der 1650er
Jahre wiederum wichtige Rollen auszufllen. Margarita Teresa war dem seit wenigen Monaten als
Kaiser, nach hart umkmpfter Wahl, regierenden Habsburgers Leopold I. als zuknftige Braut
versprochen. Diese eindeutige Bestimmung der Infantin spiegelt sich in dem reichen attributiven
Apparat ihres Portrts (Abb. 11), zu dessen Dechiffrierung aufgrund des ruinsen Zustandes des
HintergrundesnurzeitgenssischeQuellenhelfen.44LautdiesenstehtaufdemBeistelltischlinkseine
Standuhr aus Ebenholz ruhend auf vergoldeten Bronzefiguren, ganz offensichtlich Lwen. In der
MittederUhristeinKreismitdemSonnenwagengemalt.DerSonnenwagengiltalswohlbekanntes
SymbolfreinneuesZeitalter,dieSonneallgemeinalsSinnbildfrdenHerrscher.Undauchderneu
gewhlteKaiserLeopoldwarschonkurznachseinerKrnung1658alsneueSonneinFlugschriften
apostrophiert worden.45 Der Beginn des neuen Zeitalters starker Beziehungen innerhalb der Casa
AustriakommtinMargaritaTeresasPortrtzumAusdruckalsdeutlichesprohabsburgischesZeichen,
whrend die spanischbourbonische Hochzeit zwischen ihrer Halbschwester und Ludwig XIV.
besiegeltwar.
ISBN9789460184833
126

Abb.12DiegoVelzquez,FelipePrspero,1659,Wien,
Garant fr dieses neu anbrechende Habsburger Zeitalter war indessen vor allem der
Thronfolger Felipe Prspero, dessen Portrt zeitgleich mit demjenigen Margaritas nach Wien
gesendet wurde (Abb. 12). Man hat diesem Bildnis immer wieder einen melancholischen Zug
unterstellt und die Dunkelheit, die sich hinter dem von Abwehramuletten gegen den bsen Blick
behangenenPrinzenausbreitet,alsfinstereZukunftderDynastielesenwollen,soalshabeVelzquez
den frhen Tod Felipe Prsperos 1661 starb er vierjhrig geahnt und ins Bild gebannt.46 Eine
solcheDarstellungkonntenatrlichinkeinsterWeisedenAbsichtendesHofesentsprochenhaben,
mgen auch die zeitgenssischen Berichte das Bild von einem schwchlichen Kind zeichnen. Der
MalerVelzquezstieim PortrtFelipePrsperossicherlichandieGrenzen desKonfliktszwischen
mimetischerDarstellungundderzupropagierendenRolledesDargestellten,dessenreinePrsenzim
Bildnis die Befrchtungen des Kaisers um ein gefhrdetes spanisches Erbe zerstreuen sollten. Der
Hofmann Velzquez wusste sehr wohl um die mit Hilfe von Portrts gefhrten Schachzge im
Mchtehaushalt der Hfe und die Regeln dieses kulturellen Spiels um den dynastischen
Machterhalt.47

ISBN9789460184833
127
Bibliographie
Arte y diplomacia de la monarqua hispnica en el siglo XVII, hrsg. v. Jos Luis Colomer (Madrid,
2003).
Barta, Ilsebill, Familienportrts der Habsburger. Dynastische Reprsentation im Zeitalter der
Aufklrung(Wien,2001).
Baticle, Jeannine, Note sur les portraits de la maison de Bourbon, envoys en Espagne au XVIIe
sicle,LarevuedesArts.MusesdeFrance,10,45(1960),pp.195200.
Brenger, Jean, Die Habsburger und ihre Erbfolgekrisen als Formationsphase des neuen
europischen Staatensystems, in: Das europische Staatensystem im Wandel. Strukturelle
BedingungenundbewegendeKrfteseitderFrhenNeuzeit,hrsg.v.PeterKrger(Mnchen,1996),
pp.6388.
Bernis,Carmen,Velzquezyelguardainfante,inVelzquezyelartedesutiempo(Madrid,1991),
pp.4960.
Brown,Jonathan,Velzquez.MalerundHfling(Mnchen,1988).
Brown,Jonathan,PaintinginSpain.15001700(NewHaven,1998).
Das Portrt in der frhen Neuzeit, hrsg. v. Eva Krems und Sigrid Ruby (Mnchen/Berlin, 2014, in
Vorbereitung).
Defourneaux,Marcel,SpanienimGoldenenZeitalter(Stuttgart,1986).
DieKnstlerderKaiser.VonDrerbisTizian,vonRubensbisVelzquez,hrsg.v.AdrianiGtz(Wien,
2009).
Gasta,ChadM.,ThePoliticsofPainting.VelzquezandDiplomacyintheCourtofPhilipIV,Letras
Hispanas, 3, 2 (2006), auf: http://www.modlang.txstate.edu/letrashispanas/previousvolumes/vol3
2/contentParagraph/0/content_files/file/Velazquez.pdf.
HorcajoPalomero, Natalia, Amuletos y talismanes en el retrato del prncipe Felipe Prspero de
Velzquez,ArchivoEspaoldeArte,72,288(1999),pp.521530.
Justi,Carl,VelzquezundseinJahrhundert(Zrich,1933).
Kennedy,Paul,AufstiegundFalldergroenMchte.konomischerWandelundmilitrischerKonflikt
von15002000(Frankfurt,1989).
LasMeninasimSpiegelderDeutungen,hrsg.v.ThierryGreub(Berlin,2001).
LpezRey,Jos,Velzquez.MalerderMaler,2Bde.(Kln,1996).
Llorente,Mercedes,Imagenyautoridadenunaregencia.LosretratosdeMarianadeAustriaylos
lmites del poder, in La corte de la Monarqua Hispnica. Studia Historica, Historia Moderna, 28
(2006),pp.1761.
ISBN9789460184833
128
Palomino, Antonio, Lives of the Eminent Spanisch Painters and Sculptors, bers. N. A. Mallory,
Cambridge1987.
Pointon,Marcia,AccessoriesasPortraitsandPortraitsasAccessories,inDasPortrtinderfrhen
Neuzeit,hrsg.v.EvaKremsundSigridRuby(Mnchen/Berlin,2014,inVorbereitung).
Saxl,Fritz,Velzquez,inLectures,hrsg.v.FritzSaxl,Bd.1(London,1957).
Schumann, Jutta, Die andere Sonne. Kaiserbild und Medienstrategien im Zeitalter Leopolds I.
(Mnchen,2003).
Stradling,R.A.,PhilipIVandtheGovernmentofSpain.16211665(Cambridge,1988).
Velzquez,hrsg.v.AntonioDomnguezOrtiz,AlfonsoPrezSnchez,u.JulinGllego(Madrid,1990).
Velzquez,hrsg.vonDawsonCarr(London,2006).
Warnke,Martin,Hofknstler.ZurVorgeschichtedesmodernenKnstlers(Kln,1985).
Warnke,Martin,Velzquez.FormundReform(Kln,2005).
Winkler, Hubert, Bildnis und Gebrauch. Zum Umgang mit dem frstlichen Bildnis in der frhen
Neuzeit:Vermhlung,Gesandtschaftswesen,SpanischerErbfolgekrieg(Wien,1993).
Zanger,AbbyE.,ScenesfromtheMarriageofLouisXIV.NuptialFictionsandtheMakingofAbsolutist
Power(Stanford,1997).
Zimmermann, Heinrich, Zur Ikonographie des Hauses Habsburg, Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen
SammlungeninWien,25(1905),pp.171218.
Abbildungen
Abb.1,2,4,5,6,8,9,11,12:LpezRey,Jos,Velzquez.MalerderMaler,2Bde.(Kln,1996).
Abb.3:MetropolitanMuseumofArt,NewYork(metmuseum.org).
Abb.7:http://historiaturaniana.blogspot.de/2012/03/pregonrealsobreguedejasycopetes.html
Abb.10:BildarchivFotoMarburg.
MmoiresdeFranoisdePauledeClermont,marquisdeMonglat,[...]contenantl'histoiredelaguerreentrela
Franceetlamaisond'Autriche[...]souslergnedeLouisXIIIetdeLouisXIV,Amsterdam1727,Bd.IV,S.206f.
Zu dieser Quelle vgl. bes. Zimmermann 1905, pp. 189 (dort auch der Wortlaut der Quelle). Siehe ebenso
Winkler1993,p.88.
2
ZudiesenVersionensieheimVerlaufdesBeitrags.
3
SieheetwadenSammelbandzuLasMeninas:Greub2001.
4
ZudenmternundAufgabendesMalersamspanischenHofsieheWarnke2005,pp.139143.
5
SieheauchBrown1988,S.215.
6
Brown1988,pp.248f.ZurgroenpolitischenRollevonVelzquezvgl.auch:Gasta2006.
ISBN9789460184833
129
Warnke2005,S.139.DiePhasebiszuVelzquezTod1660charakterisiertWarnkefolgendermaen:Jedem
Biographen des Velzquez ist aufgefallen, dass der Maler im letzten Jahrzehnt seines Lebens eigentlich nicht
mehr seinen Malberuf ausgebt hat, obwohl wenigstens zwei Werke aus diesem Jahrzehnt Hauptwerke der
Malereigeschichtedarstellen.
8
ZurGeschichteSpaniensimsiebzehntenJahrhundertsiehe:Defourneaux1986;Kennedy1989,pp.69189.
9
Brenger1996,p.6388.
10
Ebd.,p.65.
11
Vgl.denWerkkatalogbeiLpezRey1996.
12
Vgl.z.B.das163132entstandenePortrtderIsabellavonBourbon,NewYork,Privatsammlung,207x119
cm;LpezRey1996,Bd.II,pp.5355.
13
Vgl.etwadasPortrtvonca.1640,BaltasarCarlos,Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,128x99cm;LpezRey
1996,Bd.II,S.222.
14
DasWerkbefindetsichinNewYork,MetropolitanMuseumofArt,um1642;zumKnstlervgl.Brown1998,
pp.188190.
15
BaltasarCarlosmiteinemZwerg,1631,Boston,MuseumofFineArts.SieheLpezRey1996,Bd.II,p.51.
16
Mit vielen Quellenverweisen: Winkler 1993. Zu den Konflikten beim interhfischen Bildnistausch siehe
besondersWarnke1985,pp.270284undpassim.SieheauchWarnke2005,p.3848.ZumPortrtgebrauch
undzurPortrtpraxisvgl.Krems/Ruby2014(inVorbereitung).
17
Es geht um folgende Version: Maria Anna von sterreich, um 165253, l auf Leinwand, 234 x 132 cm,
Madrid,MuseodelPrado;vgl.Velzquez1990,Kat.71,p.409;LpezRey1996,Bd.II,pp.298ff.;Justi1933,
pp. 663671 und Zimmermann 1905, p. 185 haben Grundlegendes zur Erforschung der Versionen in
verschiedeneneuropischenundauereuropischenSammlungengeleistet.
18
VelzquezwargegenEnde1648nachItalienaufgebrochenundkehrteerstimJuni1651nachMadridzurck.
Justi1933,p.667,verweistdarauf,dasszwarzunchstJuanBautistadelMazoeinBildnisanfertigte,welches
aberoffenbarnichtfrandereHfebestimmtgewesenwar.
19
Luis Francisco de Benavides Carrillo de Toledo, Marquis von Caracena (16081668), war von 16481656
StatthaltervonMailand.
20
Leinwandgre 204 x 126,5 cm; Rahmenmae 226 x 148,5 x 10 cm, Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien,
Gemldegalerie,Zimmermann1905,S.172;LpezRey1996,Bd.II,p.121124.
21
Eswurdeum1800umrund20cmnachobenverlngert.ZurForschungsieheauchdenAusstellungskatalog
Velzquez1990,p.408417.
22
Vgl.obenAnm.12.
23
ZudenUnterschiedenzwischendenPortrtsderaltenundneuenKniginsieheauchSaxl1957,Bd.I,p.320.
SaxlbezeichnetdasPortrtMarianasalsunreal.
24
Zum Guardainfante vgl. Defourneaux 1989, pp. 185187; Bernis 1991, pp. 4960. Zum MarianaPortrt:
Llorente2006,pp.211238.
25
FernandodeVallejo,Pregonenquesumagestadmanda,queningunamugerdequalquierestadoycalidad
queseapuedatraer,nitraigaguardainfante,otroinstrumento,tragesemehante,exceptolasmugeresque
con licencia de las justicias publicamente son malas de sus personas, Madrid, En la imprenta de Francisco
Martinez,1639.
26
Zanger 1997, p. 156, verweist zudem darauf, dass der weitausladende Reifrock von den Franzosen im
Zusammenhang mit der Hochzeit zwischen Ludwig XIV. und Maria Teresa (1660) als altmodisch bezeichnet
wurde.ZudieserZeittrugmaninFrankreichengereRcke.LautZangerwurdedieInfantinberredet,enger
anliegendeRckezutragen,umdieVerhandlungennichtzugefhrden.ZuRechtweistZangerdaraufhin,dass
KleidungeinepolitischeundideologischeQualitthabenkann.ZurBedeutungderAccessoiresimPortrtsiehe
auchPointon2014(inVorbereitung).
27
Barta 2001, p. 62: Bei der Auswahl der Ehefrauen spielten nicht nur politische berlegungen eine Rolle,
sondern auch die wahrscheinliche Fruchtbarkeit der Braut. Dabei informierte man sich genau ber ihre
KrperbeschaffenheitunddasFunktionierenderGebrorgane.
28
SchonaufderHochzeitwarPhilippIV.,wiezeitgenssischeBerichtebelegen,inhchstprchtigerKleidung
erschienen.Vgl.Stradling1988,p.339.
29
AuchhiergibtesmehrereVersionen.DiewichtigstenzweibefindensichinBoston,MuseumofFineArts,und
Wien,128x106cm;KunsthistorischesMuseum,Gemldegalerie;127x98,5cm;Velzquez2006,S.231,Kat.
Nr.43,Abb.109.ZudenbeidenVersionenvgl.auchLpezRey1996,Bd.II,pp.292195.AusfhrlichbeiJusti
1933,S.671676;Zimmermann1905,pp.185187.
ISBN9789460184833
130
30
Vgl.z.B.dieReaktionMazarins,alserdavonerfuhr,dasseinBildnisderspanischenInfantinMariaTheresia
nachWiengesendetwurde;Baticle1960,p.197.
31
Justi1933,p.667.AusfhrlicherwirddieQuellebeiZimmermann1905,p.185,zitiert.
32
Ebd.ImInventarderGalerieLeopoldWilhelms1659wirddasGemldebeschriebenwiefolgt:EinContrafait
[]derInfantinvonSpanien,lebensgro,anihreSeithenhangenzweykleineUhrl,unndauffeinerSeithenein
TaffelmiteinemgrnenTpich.[]OriginalvonIhrMajesttdesKnigsinHispaniaMahler.
33
HeuteinBoston,MuseumofFineArts.
34
DerZeitpunktistnichtganzgeklrt;entwedernahezuzeitgleichodererstimDezember1653;vgl.Knstler
derKaiser2009,p.176.SiehezuderQuellebes.auchZimmermann1905,p.186.ZudemKomplexderPortrts
undderQuellensieheauchBrown1988,pp.217221.
35
Zimmermann 1905, S. 186. Im Januar 1654 besttigt der Gesandte, dass er dieses Werk nun nach Paris
gesendethabebzw.demflandrischenGesandtenmitgegebenhabe.Freilichistnichtgesichert,welchesWerk
das1654nachParisgesandteBildniswar,dasichimLaufederJahrenochweitereinPariseinfanden.Zuden
WerkenfrParissieheauchBaticle1960,pp.197198.
36
SiehedazuauchBaticle1960,p.198.
37
Nach1654verlangteunderhieltdiefranzsischeKniginAnnedAutrichefnfzehnunddannnochweitere
vier Bildnisse des Hauses sterreich, wofr sie sich mit zehn Bildnissen des franzsischen Knigshauses
erkenntlicherwies.DazuZimmermann1905,p.188.
38
Esistungeklrt,umwelchesBildessichgenauhandelt.DashiergezeigteBrustbildausdemLouvremisst71x
60cm(Louvre,M.I.898).berseineProvenienzistnichtsbekannt.LpezRey1996,Bd.II,Abb.332.
39
BereitsbeiZimmermann1905,p.186.
40
Obwohl das Brsseler Inventar von 1659 von zwei Uhren spricht (siehe oben Anm. 32), ist dies eher
unwahrscheinlich.
41
EinvermutlichkurzeZeitspterinBrsselnachdemBildentstandenerStich(vgl.Zimmermann1905,p.187)
wird genau beschriftet mit dem Titel der Infantin als Tochter des spanischen Knigs, vermutlich um die
Identifikationzuerleichtern.
42
Nach der Hochzeit 1660 wusste dennoch jeder Staatsmann in Paris, Wien oder Madrid, dass der formelle
Verzicht der jungen franzsischen Knigin auf das spanische Erbe nicht ernst genommen werden sollte und
FrankreichinZukunftAnspruchdarauferhebenwrde.
43
InfantinMargaritaTeresainBlau,1659,laufLeinwand,127x107cm;FelipePrspero,1659,128,5x99,5
cm,beideWien,KunsthistorischesMuseum;LpezRey1996,Bd.II,p.318,320;Velzquez2006,pp.236242.
Nur zgerlich wird in der Forschung bis in die jngste Zeit die quellenberlieferte Nachricht aufgenommen,
diesebeidenBilderseienzurgleichenZeitgemaltundsieseienzurgleichenZeitnachWiengeschicktworden.
Palominoerwhntsiealsgleichzeitiggemalt,umsienachWienzuKaiserLeopoldI.zusendendocheswird
zumeistbezweifelt,dassdiebeidenBilderalsPendantsgeplantwaren;ebd.Bd.II,p.318.
44
Palominobeschreibt1724dasBildausfhrlich:AntonioPalomino,LivesoftheEminentSpanischPaintersand
Sculptors,bers.N.A.Mallory,Cambridge1987,p.173.
45
Vgl.bes.Schumann2003.
46
Vgl.zuletztz.B. Velzquez2006,p.46;Justi1933,pp.682f.ZudenAmulettenetc.vgl.HorcajoPalomero
1999,pp.521530.
47
SieheallgemeinzuKunstundDiplomatie:Arteydiplomacia2003.
ISBN9789460184833
131
Presentation,RepresentationandInvisibility
Emperor Ferdinand I and his Son Archduke Ferdinand II of Austria in Prague
(15471567)
MadelonSimons

The theme of this volume is, among others, how a (Habsburg) sovereign had himself represented
withintheframeworkofhiscourtculture.Doesnteveryroyalorprincelycommissioncontributeto
theimageandthestampthesovereignwantstoputonhisresidence?Thiscertainlyappliedtothe
KingofBohemiaatPragueCastleinthemidsixteenthcentury.Itwillneverthelessbecomeapparent
that the sovereign did not or could not give his commission for the building of the Prague Court a
highpriorityandwhiletheworkdevelopedslowlytheKingaboveallseemedtowanttobeinvisible
whileinresidenceinPrague.AtthesametimetheHabsburgresidenceinPraguewasalsoinuseas
residence of the representative of the King. It can therefore be argued that Repraesentatio
Maiestatis,picturingthesovereigninhishighandmightytasks,wasnotalwaystheprimaryaimof
everycommissionattheRoyalCourt.Especiallynotwhentheviceregent,theofficialrepresentative
oftheKing,wasawilfulmanwhowouldleavehisownmark,amarkwithimaginativequalitiesofits
own, on the Prague Court. However, I wonder if our reconstructive descriptions of these
manifestationsdonotpresupposetoocomplicatedandtoohighlyintellectualasubstance.Whilethe
sovereignKingFerdinand I(15031564)wasofcourserepresentedinallhis dignityandvirtueand
this was emphasized in a scholarly manner in contemporary publications,1 there were of course
differentlevelsofrepresentation.ThespectatorsatRoyaleventswerefascinatedorbewildered,but
thingswerenotalwaysasseriousandonashighanintellectuallevelastheyhavesubsequentlybeen
interpreted.Whilevirtuewasbeingportrayed,theremusthavebeenalotoflaughter.Peoplemust
alsohavelaughedloudandfrequentlyatsomuch(moreorless)hiddendepravity.
Prague1526
King Ferdinand I was the sovereign in Prague for thirtyeight years. In 1526 he became King of
Bohemiaandin1556waselectedRomanEmperor.Atayoungageamarriageagreementhadbeen
madeforthisverysuccessfuldescendantoftheHabsburgdynastywithPrincessAnnaJagiello(1503
1547), the daughter of the Bohemian/Hungarian King. Anna and her husband contributed fifteen
childrentothedynasty.FerdinandIclaimedandwasgrantedtheBohemiancrownafterthedeathof
hisbrotherinlawLudwigJagiello(15051526).Thisclaim,however,wasnotanobviousoneforthe
Bohemian parties and was not awarded without discussion. After difficult negotiations Ferdinand I
andAnnawerecrownedKingandQueenofBohemiainthechurchofSaintVitusin1526.2Thiswould
seemtohavebeentheobviousmomentfortheHabsburgdynastytostartbuildingtheirownspecific
courtcultureanddesignaspecialimageforKingandQueen(also)inPrague.3TheKingstartedthisby
ISBN9789460184833
132

ordering the extension of the Castle with a garden complex and a summer palace in 1534. And in
1556 his son took care of the Ceremonial Entry of Ferdinand I as Roman Emperor. The Castle thus
becameacentreofRepraesentatioMajestatis,inthesenseofitsrepresentingtheselfevidentglory
andvirtueofthesovereign.Butthisisarathersuperficialandartificialimage.Oncloserinspection
both members of the Habsburg house named Ferdinand left on Prague a fairly modest, but at the
sametimeambiguousstamp.

PragueCastle
The history of the Castle shows that the garden complex was the only large project King
Ferdinandhadcommissioned.4ForthisextensionoutsidethefortresswallsItalianmigrantworkers
werebroughttoPrague,whostayedforjustafewmonthsandinsummerreturnedtotheirvillages
intheItalianAlps.Thisisoneoftheexplanationswhyprogresswasslow.Therecordsshowthatthe
Kingwasdefinitelyinterestedintheproject.Heinsistedforexamplethatthebridgetothegardens
should be finished as a matter of urgency, and wished to check the progress of the work himself.5
This bridge over the socalled Stag ditch between the northern wall of the Castle and the garden
areawasnotonlymeantforthetransportofgoodsbutalsocontainedaremarkableconstructionon
theeasternside,acoveredcorridorcalledtheGallerie.6TheKinghimselfdescribeditsfunction:the
corridorenabledhimtoenterthegardensunseen.Itbelongedtoawholecomplexofpassagesfrom
the Kings palace in the western part of the Castle via the socalled Western Palace, the fortress
walls,thestablesandthebridgeintothegardens,justatthepointwheretheSummerPalacewas
built.7 The wooden structures that were given so much priority played a dramatic role during the
destructivefirewhichburnedlargepartsofPragueCastlein1541.8Thefirespreadviathewooden
galleries up to the building site of the Summer Palace and destroyed all the plants. Prague Castle
wouldshowthescarsofthisdisasterforyears.Notuntil1555,forexample,weretheapartmentsof
the King and Queen in the socalled Old Palace renovated, with the ceilings being raised and
decorated,althoughtheywerenotfundamentallyaltered.9InthesameyearArchdukeFerdinandII
ordered,asaprecaution,thewoodengallerieswithintheCastlewallstoberebuiltinstone.10Those
in the garden complex were left in wood. As Emperor Maximilian II had these hardtomaintain
woodenstructuresrestoredandpartlyaltered,itseemsthataconcealedwalkintothegardenwas
importantforhimtoo.11
There are no detailed images of Prague Castle, either drawings or prints, to give us
information about the situation around 1555, apart from some townscapes. This lack of visual
records could be related to the low priority the King gave these commissions for his residence in
Bohemia.Butitismorelikelythatmanyrecords,suchasfloorplans,modelsandprints,arelost.Itis
verydifficulttoimaginewhattheinteriorofPragueCastlelookedlike.ItseemsthatKingFerdinandI
made the old constructions within the fortress walls accessible through wooden (later stone)
galleries,staircasesandgallerybridges.
ISBN9789460184833
133

Fig.1JohannMinsinger,TafeletownedbyKingFerdinandI,dat.1529.
One of those structures can, in my opinion, be seen in a Royal notebook (fig. 1), which
becomesaninterestingsourceifweregarditasanopportunitytolookwithinthecastlewalls.Itisa
luxuriously decorated, but everyday object which was owned by King Ferdinand I himself.12 This
notebook, in a textile cover, has two slates with both sides written on and little boxes for slate
pencils and a sponge. The covers of these boxes are decorated with the picture of an impressive
squaretowerwithastaircasetotheleftandaviewofagate,atower(?)and totherighttheside
facadeofabuilding.13Highbetweenthewalls,silhouettedagainstthebluesky,thereisawooden
bridge covered with red roof tiles. The building to the right must, in my opinion, be the socalled
WesternPalace.In1555,ArchdukeFerdinandIIcommissionedthedecorationofthreeclockfacesfor
the white tower to the left, which were described in a document as follows: drei wollgezierti
khompasurn auf die drei ort mit lustiger zier volendt werden.14 If this is a look within the walls of
Prague Castle, it shows that the Habsburg sovereigns until Emperor Rudolf II did not alter the
constructionoftheexistingbuildings,whichwereconnectedthroughexternalfacilitiesand,aswill
bedemonstratedlateron,onlydecoratedwithpaintedclockfaces,nichesandpilasters.FerdinandI
never achieved a larger project within the walls of Prague Castle, nor did he ever intend any such
projectduringhislongreignasKingofBohemianbetween1526and1564.

ISBN9789460184833
134
TheKingsrepresentative
ArchdukeFerdinandIIsupervisedtherestorationsandbuildingactivitiesinthegardensbyorderof
theKing,buthealsohadtheopportunitytoestablishhisownprofile.In1555theArchdukehada
hunting lodge built, the socalled Lustschloss of Stern [Star, Hvzda].15 This remarkable building,
whichispreservedpracticallyundamaged,isintroducedheretoshowthattheArchdukedidhavethe
opportunitytoaddarepresentativebuildingtothecourtcultureofhisfatherandthustoleavehis
markonPrague.AndthearchitectureofSternrevealssomethingofthearchdukespersonality.
FerdinandisnumberedIIbecausehewasthesecondFerdinandinhisline.Hewasalsothe
secondsonoftheroyalcouple.Bornin1529,hespenthisyouthmostlyinInnsbruckandmovedto
Praguein1543.In1547hebecamehisfathersrepresentative,orStatthalter.In1555,whenStern
was built, the Archduke was already in a relationship with Philippine Welser, the daughter of a
merchant from Augsburg. Contrary to one of the romanticized stories made up in the nineteenth
century,hedidnotbuiltSternforher.FerdinandIImarriedPhilippineinsecretin1557,theyearof
the birth of their first son. His loyalty to this morganatic marriage made a future European royal
career impossible.16 But this does not mean that the Prague court had a lesser status among the
nobility.NorwasPraguearegionalorprovincialcourtineitherapoliticalorinaculturalsense.
Stern
By building Stern in a game reserve on the White Mountain some six kilometres from
Prague Castle, the Archduke started, and with great diligence also finished, an undertaking
representative for the Habsburgs. The game reserve was (and still is) enclosed by high walls and
gates.Sterncouldinthemiddleofthesixteenthcenturybereachedbywayofaroadfringedwith
trees.Thebuildingitselfliesattheendofanavenue,justattheslopeofthemountain.Therefore
andbecauseoftheenclosingwallsaroundit,Sterndoesnotseemtobeexactlymonumental.Buta
visitwillhaveimpressedthevisitorinthesixteenthcentury,asitstilldoestoday(fig.2).

Fig.2ThehuntinglodgeofStern.
ISBN9789460184833
135

A guest of the Archdukes might have been a member of the hunting party or might have
beeninvitedtovisitthegardensontheterracesandthefishpondsbehindStern.Hemightevenhave
participated in a game of tennis in the small gallery on the first terrace just below Stern. But this
visitorwouldcertainlynothavebeenamemberofalargegroup.TheroomsatSternaresimplytoo
smallforalargenumberofguests.
As mentioned before, Stern in the Neue Tiergarten was the Archdukes most important
commission in Prague. He followed the building progress carefully, even when he was in an army
camp in the south of Hungar waiting for battle with the Turks. Ferdinand II might even have been
involvedindesigningthebuilding.Insourcesconnectedtoceremoniesaroundthelayingofthefirst
stone,theArchdukeismentionedasthearchitectofStern.17Thiswasofcoursedonetohonourhim,
but since the Archduke was very anxious to build and to complete the project, I presume that he
could well have been involved in the design, probably in close collaboration with a builder of
fortifications. The characteristic sixpointed star, the basic plan of Stern, is derived from the
geometricalformsoffortresses.
The building had four floors. The cellars must have been designated for storage. On the
entrancefloortherearearemarkablenumberofniches,possiblyusedfora(temporary)exhibition.
The Archduke began collecting in Prague and, as will be described later, he exhibited weaponry in
Prague Castle at the time of the Ceremonial Entry of Emperor Ferdinand I in 1558. It is therefore
possible that he already started to make the presentation of his weaponry in Prague, on which he
wouldlaterelaborateatthecastleofAmbrasnearInnsbruck.18
Moreimportantthanthepossibleobjectsinthenichesismyargumentabouthowavisitto
Sterncouldhavebeenarranged.Asmentionedbefore,Sterncanbecomparedtoatowerinwhich
onecanloseonesway.19IftheArchdukewantedtouseSternasanenvironmentinwhichhecould
showandspelloutthevirtuesofhisdynasty,hehadmanychoices.Notonlybypresentingspecific
objectsinniches,butalsobyreferringtothescenesonthestuccoceilingsofthemainhallonthe
entrancefloor.20Fortheinformedvisitorthehistoricalscenesinstuccowereeasytorecognizeand
to associate with the virtues of the Habsburgs themselves. In the sixteenth century as well, the
central image of Aeneas escaping from burning Troy with his father Anchises on his back was a
reference to the foundation of Rome, an event the Habsburgs would have been pleased to be
associatedwith. ManliusCurtius Rufus heroism,asinLivy,orthatofMarcus Attilius Regulusasin
Valerius Maximus, can easily be linked to the heroic deeds of the Habsburg hero whose suite of
armorisplacedinanicheinoneoftherooms.Buttherecognitionofanobjectoraniconographical
associationwiththevirtuesoftheHouseofHabsburgwasnottheonlymeansbywhichtheArchduke
would have impressed his (imaginary) visitor in 1560. Anyone doing the rounds with the Archduke
willveryquicklyhavelosthisorherway,especiallyifthetwoupperfloorswerevisitedaswell.Ifthis
guestclimbedthestaircaseinthesixthpointofthestarofStern,theArchdukecouldevendisappear
andreachoneoftheotherfloorsbeforehisguest,viathesmallspiralstaircaseinthemiddle.Andhe
couldwaitforhisguestinthecellaramongsthiswine,bythefireplaceonthefirstfloor,orwiththe
musiciansinthegreat(dancing)hallunderneaththeroof.
JustasintheprojectsintheCastleandinthegardens,therepresentationofthesovereign
thereforewasatthesametimehisunseenpassing.Butwasthesystemofcorridorsjustintendedfor
ISBN9789460184833
136

theprivacyoftheRoyalfamilyand,forpracticalpurposes,tokeeponesfeetdryintimesofrain?21In
SternthesecretconnectionalsomighthaveenabledtheArchduketoamazeandconfusehispublic.22
Insearchofadirectorofmanifestations
In the records, all manifestations of Royal Representation are assigned to the sovereign himself,
althoughitisclearthatinpracticethiswasnotaltogetherthecase.Theroleofdesigneroradvisor
couldhavebeeninthehandsofascientist,ahumanistoranarchitectatcourt.KingFerdinandItoo
had many advisors for the design of his courts at Innsbruck, Vienna and Prague and for the
developmentofthenumerousprojectsinhisempire.
Benedict Ried, the architect for the Royal Castle in Prague, was until his death in 1534 His
MajestysadvisorinBohemia.Rieddidnothaveasuccessorassuch.After1534,ItalianandGerman
speakingcraftsmenworkedincompetition.AlthoughatthetimetheKingsuggestedgivingBonifatius
WolmutthepositionofRoyalmasterbuilder,thisneverhappened.ThecourtoftheArchdukedidnot
have just the one master builder either. The Italian Paolo della Stella and the Germanspeaking
WolmutandHansvonTirolwereresponsibleforseparatebuildingactivities.Notuntil1557dothe
recordsindicatethatWolmuthadacquiredaleadingpositionandwasinapositiontoevaluatethe
workoftheothermasterbuilders.23Butnoneofthemistrulyincharge,astheproducerofallforms
ofrepresentationinPragueduringthetimeArchdukeFerdinandIIstayedthere.
No leading architect is mentioned for the court in Vienna either. The painter and master
builderPietroFerraboscoworkedwithhisemployeesinandaroundtheHofburgatthetime.Hewas
sent to Prague regularly to assess progress, but again not much is known about the status of
FerraboscoatKingFerdinandscourt.HecertainlyhadtheabilitytodesignSternindetail,withthe
Archdukelookingoverhisshoulderandgettingthecredit.Ferraboscowasbornin1512or1513in
LainonearComoandservedtheHabsburgsfrom1544onwards.Hebeganhiscareerasasocalled
warpainterandactedasafortressbuilderlateron.24Thisiswhyhecouldhavebeenthearchitect
of Stern, since he was able to apply the geometrical forms used in fortresses. This interesting but
littleknowncourtartistworkedinallsortsofimportantplacesintheempireofFerdinandI.Hewas
certainlyversatile,sinceheworkednotonlyformilitaryoperations,butalsoattheHofburginVienna
andattheNeugebude.ForhisservicesFerraboscowasknightedbyFerdinandI,anhonourwhich
mostfortressbuildersinRoyalservicewereawarded.25Despitehisknighthood,however,Ferrabosco
was not the archducal advisor I am looking for, the man responsible for the representation of the
sovereignandtheHabsburgdynastyinPrague.FerraboscowasinvolvedintheHabsburgcourt,but
hewasneverlongenoughinPragueandlittleisknownabouthistheoreticalknowledge.
Wasthisroleinthehandsofoneofthehumanistsatthearchducalcourt?WasittheItalian
courtphysicianandbotanistPierAndreaMattioli(15011579)?MattiolididliveatthePraguecourt
foralongtimeanddidhavethetheoreticalknowledge.InPragueMattiolicontinuedthebotanical
studieshehadstartedinItaly,publishingtheLatineditionofalargebotanicalsurveybasedonthe
work of the classical Greek Dioskurides and having the edition translated into other languages.26
EarlierMattiolihadbeenthecourtphysicianoftheCardinalofTrento,wherehepublishedaeulogy
forhisemployer.27SocouldhehavehadasimilarroleinPraguetoo?
ISBN9789460184833
137

AlthoughMattioliwasinvolvedinsomerepresentationaltasks,therearestillfewindications
that he played a dominant role in the creation of the Habsburg image in Prague in the 1550s. The
commissiontowriteareportonthefestivitiesduringtheEntryofFerdinandIin1558wasgivento
himonlyafterwards.28Thetextdescribesthemovementsofthesovereignandhisretinueon8and9
November1558.Italsorevealssomethingofthearchducalcourt.FerdinandIIhimself,who,asmuch
ofthetextindicates,musthavemadeafaircontributiontothecontentsofthescenario,directedall
themovementsandrodeinfrontoftheparade.
TheEntry
Mattioli refers to the salutations outside the city gates when under the command of the
Archduke the Bohemian nobles joined the Imperial retinue. First they met a group of about a
thousandmenalldressedinblack,theirheadscoveredbycaps,dancingandshouting;withtheirso
called anticamente, an oldfashioned sort of flail with metal pins, they were beating straw. This
detailisoftenmentionedintheCzechhistoricalliteratureassignificant.Butisthisintermezzoatthe
startoftheCeremonialEntrymerelyasuperficialreferencetotheHussiterevoltanddefeatofmany
yearsbeforeor,rather,anemphaticreminder?Whateverthecase,theEmperorandhisentourage,
notesMattioli,simplyhadtolaughatthoseprimitivefarmers.29
The ride through the three cities of Prague is characterized by Mattioli as a long series of
meetings with members of the city councils, the clergy of different denominations, and speakers
from the Charles University and the Jesuit Grammar School. The honour the Prague population
accordedtotheirEmperorwascarefullydirected.Tributewaspaidbyboys,girls,womenandmen,
alldividedintoagegroups.Widows,forexample,hadgatheredinthesquareoftheSmallSide,the
thirdPraguecity,belowPragueCastle.GreyhairedmenwereallowedtogreettheEmperoratthe
endofhistourattheStrahovgateonthewaytotheCastle.Theyhadtowaitforaverylongtime,
butfortunatelytheywerestandingnexttoafountainspoutingredandwhitewine.Mattiolisreport
is partly based on a written scenario and partly on his own observations. He stresses that all
participants were dressed for the occasion and that thousands of horses must have squeezed
through the small streets of the Old City. In the middle of the crowd Mattioli recognized a
remarkablenumberofhiscompatriots:overtwothousandItalianswerestandingalongtherouteto
theCastle,whichwasthequarterwheretheylived.Mattiolidescribesthetriumphalarchesalongside
the route, mainly in relation to those who had commissioned them. The Jesuits, for example, of
whom a fairly complicated iconography might have been expected, had raised an arch at the
Klementinum,butMattiolimentionsonlyrathersimplethemes,suchasJusticeandPeacewiththe
god Mars above. He gives the quite obvious interpretation of the image: the arch refers to His
Majestyspeacefulreign.
FromMattiolisdescriptionsofthedecorationsinandaroundtheCastleitcanbededuced
thathehadtakenthetimetoconsiderthemcarefullyorthathemightevenhaveplayedsomerolein
thechoicesoftheiconographyorclassicalquotations.Mattioliismorepreciseaboutthedecorations
madefortheCastlethanheisaboutthosealongthetour.Heevenreferstothemakers,whowere
artistsfromthecirclesaroundtheArchduke,althoughhementionsnonames.
ISBN9789460184833
138

Fig.3FrancescoTerzio(attr.),PortraitofArchdukeFerdinandII.
The designer and painter of the largest triumphal arch before the Castle wall is a talented
Italian painter.30 This must have been (Giovanni) Francesco Terzio from Bergamo (ca. 15231591),
whoin1558hadalreadybeenworkingforFerdinandIIforsomeyears(fig.3).However,itisnotclear
who Mattioli refers to as: unico maestro di stucchi et di basi relievi.31 In 1558 a whole group of
stuccoworkerswereworkingfortheArchdukeFerdinandII,constructingthestuccoceilingsatStern,
but none is known by name.32 Mattioli describes the wellproportioned parts of Terzios big arch,
such as the eight Corinthian columns on a marble base with reliefs. In two colossal statues he
recognizesbiblicalheroes:totheleftSamson,withalionsskininonehandandintheotheranasss
jaw, and to the right Gideon with a big Persian sword in his left hand and in his right hand an
enormousshield.OntheedgesofthearchMattiolimentionsbronzelikereliefs.Theimagesofthe
virtues Justice and Temperance were bronzecoloured too. To explain the significance of these
imagesthephraseJustitiaarmaregat,sanctahaecmoderatioservetwasputonthearch,aswas
notedbyMattioli,whomaypossiblyhavebeenresponsibleforthischoiceofmotto.Ontopofthe
ISBN9789460184833
139

arch the author identified Imperial regalia such as the crowned eagle, the chain with the Golden
Fleece, and four historical personalities of the Habsburg dynasty: Charles V, Maximilian I, Rudolf I,
andFrederickIII.AccordingtoMattiolithistriumphalarchdidnotcontainanycomplicatedmessages
either.Hehadstudiedthearchcarefully,buthisdescriptionisnotpreciseenoughtosuggestthathe
was the inventor of its iconographical programme. It seems that the arch at Prague Castle fits
Jacquotsinventoryoftheiconographyofarchesraisedforsovereignsinthesixteenthcentury.33
ThecourtphysiciansdescriptionofthedecorationswithinthewallsofPragueCastleshows
thatrestorationprojectshadbeencarriedoutandthatthedecorationswerepartlytheworkofthe
Archdukehimself.ThehouseoftheArchdukesLordChamberlain,forinstance,wasfreshlypainted
and decorated with columns, mouldings and marbled niches. The entrance of the house of the
ArchdukewasfurnishedwitharepresentationoftheallegoryPeaceinlivelycolours,surroundedby
attributes and a quotation from Vergil. Very interesting is Mattiolis description of a construction
roundalargedoor.Thismusthavebeensomesortofexhibitionofbella&raraArmaria,according
toMattioliaselectionfromthearchducalcollectionofweaponsincludingpiecesofarmourandother
valuableobjectssuchasahorsescuirass,TurkishbowsandPersianswords.Sadly,theauthorisnot
more precise, probably not having an eye for this type of object. But he was impressed by the
colourful silk hangings around this exhibition, especially by the flapping banners that created the
theatricalsetting.34
Thenextevening
Theatricals and spectacles were also at the heart of the festivities on the evening of 11
November,thedayaftertheEntryoftheEmperor.35Mattioliattendedthispartoftheprogramme
together with the most important guests. He describes the entourage in the gardens, where the
Summer Palace formed the backdrop for the spectacles. The site in front of the Palace had been
levelledandfencedoff,Mattioliwrites,andwasilluminatedandequippedwithtwolowtowerlike
constructions for the musicians of the Archduke. On one side there were pieces of scenery: a
beautiful wild and barren mountain and next to it the throne of Jupiter. According to Mattioli the
playwasaboutabattlebetweentheGodsandtheGiants,withalotoffireworksandextravaganza;
however,thephysicianstextdoesnotcontainaproperexplanationoftheplaysmeaning.Together
withaselectpartoftheinternationalandtheBohemianguests,hewaswitnesstothespectacular
endofthefestivitieswhenthesceneryburneddowncompletely.Butagain,Mattiolidoesnotappear
tohavebeeninvolvedinthecontentsoftheplay,nordoesheseemhavehadanyresponsibilityfor
the intellectual creation of the Entry as a whole. His reports are clearly the contribution of a
spectator.HewasnotthedirectorofthemanifestationsthatIamlookingfor.
Thearchducalcourt
TheactiveroleFerdinandIIplayedinthecreationofhiscourtcanbedemonstratedinseveralways.
IncomparisonwiththeSummerPalace,Sternwasbuiltandfinishedremarkablyquickly.Thebuilding
process had his close attention, certainly because of his personal involvement in the design of the
ISBN9789460184833
140

starshaped hunting lodge. The Archduke himself directed the Entry of his father Ferdinand I
describedbrieflyabove.AsthefestivitiesduringthetouraroundthePraguecitiestookmuchlonger
than expected, the Archduke postponed the official finale to the next day. Not only in the
decorations oftheCastlebutalsothroughasmallbutsignificantdetailof theplay itis possibleto
showthearchducalconcernwithstudioprops,withcollections,andwiththeplayitself.Themonkeys
that popped out of Evil (the heads of the Giants) probably came from the Archdukes own
menagerie.36
Therearenoimagesoftheseliterallyexplosiveexpressionsofimperialrepresentationheld
on 9 November 1558. But there are, thanks to the Archduke himself, images of meetings of lesser
status. Reports on tournaments are illustrated in a Turnierbuch.37 And there are images in a
wonderful record by one of the spectators of the festivities at the socalled Kolowrat Hochzeit.38
AlthoughFerdinandIIhimselfwasneverthecentralfigurethebridegroominanofficialHabsburg
wedding in Prague, he certainly was the director of several others.39 The Archduke seems to have
beenactivelyinvolvedinandpresentatallpartsoftheprogramme.Hisroleataweddingpartyin
1555canbereconstructedonthebasisofafairlydetailedreport.

Fig.4SigmundElssser,Spring.
Fig.5Watermen,inclosefittingsuits.
Duringthemasquerade,forexample,fourgoddessesenteredthehallwearingwhitetaffeta
dresseswithgoldensleevesofleather,masks,andlongblondewigswithcrownsofboxleaves(fig.
4). They brought the bride a socalled Munsanc (wedding gift) and danced with four watermen
who were dressed in closefitting suits (fig. 5). The highlight of the evening was the moment the
watermenlefttheroomandthefinalscenewasthemostsurprising:thegoddessesprovedtobe
men in drag, led by Sn. Gn. der Erzfuers, i.e. the Archduke himself, as Johann von Schwamberg
wrotein1555.40FerdinandIInotonlyplayedtheleadingpartthateveningbutwasalsotheownerof
thecostumesandprobablyalsoofmanyoftheotherpartyprops.
In his collections, still to be seen at Schloss Ambras near Innsbruck and in the
Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna, are masks, exotic weaponry and (replicas of) textiles, helmet
decorationsandhorseblanketsthatwereusedasrequisitesatparadesandparties.FerdinandIInot
onlycollectedthismaterialbutalsohadatleastpartofitdepicted.Therequisiteswereusedover
andoveragain.Thedressesofthegoddesseswere,itseems,usedagainatanotherweddinginthe
ISBN9789460184833
141

KolowratfamilytwentyfiveyearslaterandthewatermenwerebackonthesceneattheArchdukes
weddingpartyin1582.41
Seriousrepresentationwithmuchlaughter
ThesefewexamplesofcourtlyrepresentationduringthetimeFerdinandIwasKingofBohemiaand
his son Archduke Ferdinand II viceregent show that the Habsburgs certainly did put their stamp
uponPrague,althoughduringtheirlongperiodofgovernancealotmoremighthavebeenachieved.
It seems that their main focus was not on Princely, Royal or Imperial representation but on the
privatesphere,atleastatthebeginning.KingFerdinandIaddedgardenstothecastlecomplexwhere
hecouldwanderaroundinpeace.HissonwaspersonallyresponsibleforthebuildingofStern,avery
special starshaped building that must have astonished all his visitors and probably also the
Bohemiannobility.Inadditiontotheseremainsinstone,meetingswiththesovereignandhisdeputy
illuminateourknowledgeofhisappearanceandhisrepresentationsinPrague.TheCeremonialEntry
oftheEmperorunderthecommandoftheArchduketransformedthestreetsofPragueintoared
andwhitecolouredseaofspectators.Allthedecorationswereademonstrationofdevotiontothe
sovereign. Here and there within the iconography of decorations and play there was room for a
warning finger, but there was also probably much more room for laughter. The celebrations and
tournaments for the Bohemian nobles in and around the court of the Archduke were also
characterizedbyamusementandamazement,althoughnotinthefirstplaceinanintellectualsense.
Thedanceofthewiggedgoddesseswasnotmeanttoidentifythemandtoremindtheaudienceof
theirvirtuebut,onthecontrary,tomakethepeoplelaughoutloudattherevelationoftheirtravesty
(fig.6).

Fig.6Goddesswithmaskandblondewig(detailfromfig.4).

ISBN9789460184833
142
Bibliography
Baant,Jan,PrakBelvedr(Prague,2006).
Baant, Jan, Nina Baantov, Villa Star in Prague, the Northern Renaissance masterpiece, (Prague,
2012)
Bretholz,Berthold,NeuereGeschichteBhmens,I(Gotha,1920).
Collinus, Mattheus, Ad invictissimum ac potentissimum imperatoremFerdinandumode
gratulatoria continens brevem descriptionem pompae in ingress suac majestatis in urbem Pragam
instructaeabserenissimoarchiduceetc.Ferninandi,Viiidienovembrisanni1558(Prague,1558).
Cornova,Ignaz,BeschreibungendesfeyerlichenEinzugsKaiserFerdinandI.IndieHauptschatdtPrag
den 8sten November 1558. Aus dem Lateinisch einer gleichzeitigen Feders bersetzt und mit
Anmerkungenvergelicht(Prague,1882).
Diemer, Dorothea, Antonio Brocco und der Singende Brunnen in Prag, Jahrbuch der
kunsthistorischenSammlungeninWien91,(1995)pp.1836.
Diemer, Dorothea, Peter Diemer, Die Musenquelle am Festungbau eine neuentdeckte
StuckdecorationdesAntonioBroccoinBayern,MnchnerJahrbuchderbildendenKunst,3.Folgebd
51,(2000)pp.101136
Dobalov,Sylva,ZahradyRudolfaII.Jejichvznikavvoj(Prague,2009).
Ilg,Albert,FrancescoTerzio,derHofmalerErz.FerdinandIIvonTirol,JahrbuchdesAllerhchsten
Kaiserhauses,XIII(1889)pp.234374.
Irblich, Eva, Namen und Geburtsdaten der Kinder Kaiser Ferdinand I, in Kaiser Ferdinand I 1503
1564,dasWerdenderHabsurgermonarchie,ed.WilfriedSeipel(Vienna,2003).
Jacquot,Jean,Panoramadesftesetcrmoniesdurgne,inLesFtesdelaRenaissance,ed.Jean
Jacquot(Paris,1960).
Kpl,Karl,Urkunden,ActenundInventareausdemk.k.StatthaltereiArchivinPrag(1),Jahrbuchdes
AllerhchstenKaiserhauses,XIII(1889),pp. LXIIICC.
Kreyzci, Franz, Urkunden und Regesten aus dem K.u.K. ReichsFinanzArchiv (2), Jahrbuch des
AllerhchstenKaiserhauses,V(1887),pp.XXVCXIX.
Lietzmann,Hilda,IrdischeParadies:BeispielehfischerGartenkunstder1.Hlftedes16.Jahrhunderts
(Mnchen,2007).
Lhotsky, Alphons, Ein SchiefertafelPolyptychon Kaiser Ferdinand I, Gesammelte Aufstze und
Vortrge,Bd4.(Vienna,1972).
ISBN9789460184833
143

Luchner, Laurin, Denkmal einer Renaissancefrsten. Versuch einer Rekonstruktion des Ambraser
Museumsvon1583(Vienna,1958).
Mattioli,PietroAndrea,IlMagnoPalazzodelCardinalediTrento(Venice,1539).
Mattioli di Siena, Pier Andrea, Commentarii, in libros sex Pedacii Dioscoridis Anazarbei [] (first
editionVenice,1554).
Matthiolio, Pier Andrea, New Kreterbuch. Mit dem allerschnsten und artlichen Figuren aller
Gewechszdergleichen()FolgendtdurchGeorgiumHandschderArttsnenDoctoremverdeutlicht[]
(Prague,1563).
Mattioli, Pietro Andrea, Le solemni pompe, I superbi et gloriosi apparati, I trionfifatti alla venuta
dellnvitissimoimperadoreFerdinandoprimo,dalserenissimosuofigliulilarchiducaFerdinando,nella
cittdiPragalottaviogiornodinovembre(Prague,1559).
Sandbichler, Veronika, Der Hochzeitskodex Erzherzog Ferdinand II, in ed. Wilfried Seipel, Wir sind
Helden.HabsburgischeFesteinderRenaissance(SchlossAmbras,Innsbruck,2005),pp.11732.
Sandbichler, Veronika, Die Bedeutung hinter dem Sichtbaren: AllegorieTrionfoVisuelle
Propaganda,ined.WilfriedSeipel,WirsindHelden.HabsburgischeFesteinderRenaissance(Schloss
Ambras,Innsbruck,2005),pp.4562.
Sauer,K.G.,AllgemeinesKnstlerLexikon,38(Mnchen,2003).
Schnherr,Davidvon,UrkundenundRegestenausdemK.K.StatthaltereiArchivinInnsbruck(2),
JahrbuchdesAllerhchstenKaiserhauses,XI(1890),pp. LXXXIVCCXLI.
Simons, Madelon, Archduke Ferdinand II of Austria, Governor of Bohemia and the Theatre of
Representation,inL.Konenandothers,RudolfIIPragueandtheWorld(Prague,1998),pp.27078.
Simons, Madelon, Das Werk erdacht und cirkulirt. The position of Architects at the Court of King
FerdinandI,inThelearnedEye.RegardingArt,TheoryandtheArtistsReputation,ed.(a.o)Marieke
vandenDoel(Amsterdam,2005),pp.14050.
Simons, Madelon, 'Een theatrum van representatie?' Aartshertog Ferdinand van Oostenrijk
stadhouder in Praag tussen 1547 en 1567, (diss. Univ. of Amsterdam, 2009), at
http://dare.uva.nl/document/142662.
Suchomel,M.,tukovvzdobalethohrdkuHvzda,Umn,21(1973),pp.10416.
Sources(unpublished)
Gamber, Charlotte, transcription of Hochzeitsturnier Pilsen; letter of Johann von Schwamberg,
unpublishedtypescript,Vienna,KunsthistorischeMuseum,dept.Waffensammlungen.
ISBN9789460184833
144
Illustrations
Fig.1JohannMinsinger,tafeletornotebookownedbyKingFerdinandI,signedanddated1529,
KHM,Vienna,Kkinv.nr.5378.
Fig.2LetohrdekHvzda,BlaHora(WhiteMountain),Prague,photoauthor.
Fig.3FrancesoTerzio(attr.),PortraitofArchdukeFerdinandII,ca.155758,oilonparchment,KHM,
Vienna,WKK4974.ThearchisnotanexactillustrationofMattiolistext,buttheformsandthe
materialsaresimilar.
Fig.4SigmundElssser,KolowratHochzeit,Spring,KHM,Vienna,inv.no.5269.
Fig.5SigmundElssser,Hochzeitscodex,pagewithwatermenandaseagod,colouredprints,New
YorkPublicLibraryGer.1582.
Fig.6Detailfromfig.4.

1
Baant2006,forinstance,analysesthoroughlytheiconographyoftheSummerPalaceintheRoyalgardens
fromthisintellectualpointofview.
2
The church of St Vitus within the Castle walls was not a cathedral in 1526 since there was no archbishop
consecrated.
3
Irblich2003,p.461.AssovereignsofAustria,AnnaandFerdinandIhadresidencesinInnsbruckandVienna
andseveralhuntinglodgesandcastles.TheplacesofbirthofthechildrenindicatethattheQueentravelleda
lot.Notuntil1543didshesettleinPrague,whereshediedin1547givingbirthtoherfourthson,Johannes.
4
Lietzmann 2007,pp. 67108, reconstructed the gardencomplex. The commission was issued in 1534, eight
yearsafterAnnaandFerdinandIwerecrowned.TheconstructionoftheSummerPalacedidnotstartbefore
1538.
5
Kpl,X1889,p.LXXII,regest5971,1April1535.
6
Kpl,X1889,p.LXXI,regest5962,30November1534.Inatextconcerningthebuildingactivitieswithinthe
Castle walls, the between the buildings are typified as: die Gallerie unter den Zimmern der Koningins die
StallungenentlangbiszurBrcke[].
7
Lietzmann2007,p.68.HereferstocorrespondencebetweenFlorianGriesbeckandKingFerdinandI,1July
1535,AKD.DK20.
8
Bretholz1920,pp.13537.VclavnaHradanech,acontemporaryreportonthefirefortheKing.
9
Kreyzci1887,pp.LXVIIIIX.Reg.4240,20July1555inAugsburg.MemorialforHansvonTirolwiththelistof
alterationstobedoneatRoyalbuildings:[]Zumanderenseinerkgl.Majleibzimersollobenmitgethremund
mitgespartenrestenerhebtwerden.
10
Schnherr,XI1890,reg.7463,p.CXCIV.
11
Lietzmann2007,pp.8688.ThemostrecentandextensivestudyonthesesourcesisprovidedbyDobalov
2009.
12
Lhotsky1972,pp.17072.Thehandwritingonthetwotwosidedpiecesofslatehasbeenidentifiedasthatof
KingFerdinandI.
13
AccordingtoLhotsky1972,p.172.Itisthisroundbastiontowerthatmakestheseimagesdifficulttoidentify.
Formeitisnotobviousthathereapartofthefortresswallshasbeenpictured.Totherightbetweentheso
calledWhiteTowerandtheWesternPalaceapartofthesocalledOldPalaceofKingWladislavisdisplayed.
14
Kreyzci,V1887,reg.4240,p.LXIX.
15
NofunctionalnamecanbegiventoStern.InsomesourcesithasbeencalledLustschlossandisthelocation
called Neue Tiergarten, a hunting park. Stern could therefore best be called a hunting lodge. Noble hunters
could rest here, since it has five large fireplaces and a cellar to keep wine. Nearby there was a building
containingakitchen,soallfacilitiesforagoodhuntingpartyanddinnerwereavailable.
ISBN9789460184833
145

16
Simons2009,p.186.TheroleofPhilippineWelserinPraguegetslittleattentionintheliterature.Sheissaid
tohavelivedfarfromPragueCastleinahuntingcastlenamedKivoklt[Brglitz].Thegeneralopinionstillis
thatPhilippinewouldnothaveplayedanofficialrole.Idoubtthisiscorrect.PhilippineWelserappearstobe
themostimportantwomanatatleastonetournamentoftheBohemiannobility.
17
Kreyzci1887,reg.4283,p.LXXXIII.
18
VeronicaSandbichler(SchlossAmbras)proposed,inheramendmentattheconferenceinDecember2011,
that Stern and its numerous niches were meant to be empty. These contradictory ideas call for further
examination,forinstanceincomparisonwiththeuseofspaceinItalianvillas.
19
Simons1998,pp.27078.
20
JanBaantpublishedin2012adetaileddescriptionofthisdecoration.DorotheaDiemerattributesthe
stucchiinHvzdasince2000toAntonioBrocco,whowasresponsibleforthesocalledsingingfountaininthe
gardensofPragueCastle.SimilarstuccoworksarefoundatvariousothercourtsinBohemia,Germanyand
PolandandinIngolstadt.Itappearsthatagroupofstuccoworkerstravelledaround,possiblyinthecompany
ofotherbuilders.Forsomeofthestucchitheyusedthesamemodelbooks,eventhesamemoulds.Itwillbe
interestingtogetabetterunderstandingofwheretheyworkedandtheirspecificcommissions.
21
Lietzman 2007, p. 86, note 80. Emperor Maximilian II even mentions the function as secret corridor:
heimlicheEingang.
22
During the visit to the Neugebude (during the conference in December 2011), Dr. Andreas Kusternig
pointedoutthehiddencorridorsandstepsinthedoublewallsofthisfascinatingbuilding.Thisalsoindicates
thatfacilitatingsecretlymovingaroundbycourtiersand(probably)bythesovereignwasanintentionalpartof
theHabsburgbuildingprogramme.
23
Simons2005,p.146.
24
Sauer2003,38,pp.29495.
25
Simons2005,p.146.
26
Pier AndreaMattioli di Siena 1554. A translation intoGerman by Georg Hantsch, another physician at the
Praguecourtalsoahumanist,scientistandwriter,waspublishedin1563inPrague.
27
PietroAndreaMattioli1559.
28
PietroAndreaMattioli1559.Theyearbefore,areportonthefestivitieswaspublishedbythehumanistand
professoratCharlesUniversityMattheusCollinus.InatranslationbyIgnazCornovaof1802,hisintroduction
states(withoutsource)thatMattioligottheinstructiontowritehisreportfromArchdukeFerdinandIIhimself
sinceCollinusdescriptionwasnotgoodenough.
29
Imentionthisdetailbecauseinthehistoricalliteratureithasreceivedaratherheavypoliticalinterpretation.
Baant2006(pp.22425)seesnotonlyareferencetotheHussitepast,butalsotocontrareformisttensions
caused by the Habsburgs in Prague. The Bohemian nobility would surely have recognized the costumes, but
Mattioli didnt take the incident very seriously. His characterization of the farmers who non sapendo come
farlereverenzaisabeautifulexampleofsixteenthcenturycourtcultureassprezzaturaandofhowallwho
didnotorcouldnotbehavelikethecourtwerelaughable.
30
Mattioli1559,fol.25(ownpaging):Peropere&inventione.
31
Ilg1889,p.238.
32
The stuccodecorated ceilings in Stern have (until now) been attributed to the stone workers Johann
CampionandAndreaAostallisdePambio,(a.o.)Suchomel1973.Theirnamesarementionedinadocumentin
relationtothedecorationofthesocalledLandrechtstube,aconferenceroomforAffairsofStateintheCastle.
Inthedesignitwasmeanttobemadeofstone.ItisnotcleariftheItaliansculpturesworkingattheSummer
Palace were capable of working in stone and in stucco at the same time, although Mattiolis words can be
interpretedasconfirmation.Therearealsosomestylisticandcompositionalsimilaritiesinthestuccoandthe
reliefs.TheItalianscouldhavebeenworkinginstoneandstucco.
33
Jacquot1960,II,p.478,concludesthattheiconographyofthearchesraisedwithintheiconographyofRoyal
(orImperial)Entrieswerenotcomplicated.
34
ThispresentationresemblesthewayLaurinLuchnerin1957madehisreconstructionoftheRstkammern,
theroomswherethearmourycollectionofArchdukeFerdinandIIwaskeptatSchlossAmbras.
35
Cornova 1802, Introduction. It is remarkable that Collinus, who was assigned to write a report on the
festivitiesin1558,wasnotallowedtoseetheprogrammeinthegardenshimself.Collinuswasthereforerather
shortontheshow.
36
Simons 2009, pp. 14554. Archduke Ferdinand had guenons, one of which answered to the name Schelm
(Rascal),accordingtothenotesofphysicianGeorgHantschinhissocalledTierbcher.
ISBN9789460184833
146

37
Sandbichler2005,pp.6770.TheArchdukeorganizedatleastthirtythreetournamentsbetween1547and
1560. The dates, the locations and the participants are recorded in text and sometimes in images in the so
calledTurnierbch.
38
Sandbichler2005, p.57. Sigismund Elssser, Kolowrat Hochzeit,KHM,Vienna, Kk. Inv. nr. 5269 (unpaged).
The same kind of costumes were pictured in the pageantry on floats with goddesses representing the four
seasons.
39
InFebruary1555aMaskenfest(maskedball)washeldattheweddingofJaroslawvonKolowratandLusanka
UngnadinPilsen.UnpublishedtypescriptCharlotteGambler.
40
JohannderlterevonSchwambergtoWilhelmvonRosenberg,whodidntattendthewedding.Theletter
alsogivesaccountsofthedifferenttournamentsheld.Johannwasnotaparticipantandappearstobeacritical
observerwhoisratherastonishedbythephysicalconfrontations.Severaloftheparticipantswereinjured.See
note38.
41
Sandbichler2005,pp.5657,pp.13031.
ISBN9789460184833
147
TheCourtsoftheHabsburgsasRelatedby
JakubSobieski
CezaryTaracha
Introduction
DescriptionsofEuropeancourtsholdakeypositionintheaccountsofearlymoderntravellers.After
all,incountriesruledbymonarchs,particularlyabsolutemonarchs,thecourtwasthepoliticalcentre
of the state. Here all the most important decisions were made, not only regarding internal and
foreignpolicybutalsoconcerningtherulerssubjectsandthefateoftheoldcontinentandtheNew
World.Vienna,Paris,Rome,Madrid,WarsawandLondonsetthecourseofeventsinseventeenth
centuryEurope.Courtswerealsothefocalpointoftheworldsofculture,artandscience.Emperors,
popes,kings,dukes,theirfamilies,courtofficials,ministers,advisersanddiplomatswereobjectsof
interesttomosttravellersofthosetimes.Theyappearonthepagesoftheiraccounts,memoirs,and
diaries, just as they do on the canvases of the great baroque masters, not least the celebrated
Velzquez.

The organisation and manner of functioning of European courts in the light of various
historicalsourcesisasubjectwhichcontinuestointerestscholarsofvariousdisciplines,especiallyin
the humanities. As a result, the bibliography of this subject is extensive and rich. However, there
remain certain issues that still require further historical study, analysis, and presentation to those
whoareinterested.
InthepresentpaperwewouldliketoconsidertheimageofHabsburgcourtsinthefirsthalf
of the seventeenth century as recounted in the writings of Jakub Sobieski. We will look at how a
subjectofelectedkings,acitizenofthePolishLithuanianCommonwealth,andamagnateenjoying
the extensive privileges and freedoms to which all Polish nobles were entitled perceived the
absolutist courts of the Spanish and Austrian Habsburgs. And finally we will try to assess whether
Jakub Sobieskis observations tell us anything new about this subject. But let us begin by taking a
closer look at Jakub Sobieski, a historical figure who is not very well known among European
scholars.

ISBN9789460184833
148
I.JakubSobieski(15901646)andhisEuropeantravelaccounts
Traveller,politician,writerandfatherofthevictorofthebattleofVienna
ForalongtimetheSobieskifamilybelongedtothemoderatelyaffluentclassofnobility.Itsascension
to greatness began at the turn of the seventeenth century, in the lifetime of the father of our
traveller,MarekSobieski.ItwasMarekSobieskiwhoputhisfamilyamongthesocial,economicand
politicaleliteofthePolishLithuanianCommonwealth.Hewasthefirstinhisfamilytoholdaseatin
the Senate. According to Wadysaw Syrokomla,1 he was greatly valued by the kings Stefan Batory
and Sigismund III Vasa, first as castellan and next as voivode of Lublin. Other reasons for the
Sobieskis status were their family connections (e. g. with the mighty Zamoyski family)2 and their
social contacts. His first wife was Jadwiga of Snopkowski family and the last child she bore him, in
May1590,wasJakub.Jakubdiedinkiewin1646.
Intellectualdevelopmentandstudiesabroad
Placinggreatemphasisoneducation,Jakubsparentssenthim,theiryoungestson,tostudy
firstattheZamoyskiAcademyandtheninKrakow.Nexthespentalmostsixyears,fromApril1607to
March 1613, abroad. The young magnate not only studied but also learned the realities of
contemporaryEuropethroughtravel.Inthattimehecoveredadistanceofover8,500kilometres.He
acquiredhismostessentialeducationinParis,learningtheclassicallanguages(GreekandLatin)as
well as French and Spanish. He also took lessons in horse riding, fencing, music and dance. Jzef
Dugosz,thepublisherofJakubstravelaccounts,writesthatunlikeothermagnateheirs,theyoung
Sobieskiwasmoreinterestedinstudyandlearningasmuchashecouldfromtheplaceshevisited.
Whenhewasnotstudying,hetouredcountriesinwesternandsouthernEurope.HevisitedEngland,
the Netherlands, Germany, Spain, Portugal, Italy and the Habsburg crown lands. Belonging to a
magnate family and having excellent references provided him the opportunity to get to know the
majorpoliticalandculturalcentresofEuropeaswellasthemosteminentmembersofroyalfamilies
and the aristocracy, and also prominent state and church officials. His interlocutors included Pope
Paul V, Holy Roman Emperor Matthias, Henry IV of France, James I of England, Philip III of Spain,
MauriceofNassau,politicians,ministers,militarycommandersaswellasimportantfiguresinscience
andculture(e.g.JuliusScaligier,DanielHeinius,JuandeMarianaandFranciscoSurez).
JakubSobieskiscareeranddistinctions
Sobieskis public service began soon after he returned from abroad. In 1613 he became a
royalcourtierandwasforthefirsttimeelecteddeputytotheSejmfortheLublinvoivodeship,thus
beginning a parliamentary career that was to span a quarter of a century. In that time he
distinguished himself as a mover and shaker in politics, a speaker in the chamber of deputies, a
memberofparliamentarycommissions,andanastuteobserverandbrilliantorator,calledinhisday
ISBN9789460184833
149
thePolishDemosthenes.Despitehisconsiderablecontributionsandtalent,hiscriticalappraisalof
court politics meant that he was never a royal favourite. For this reason too he did not acquire
senatorialstatusuntil1638,afterbeingappointedvoivodeofBez.Andonlyafewmonthsbeforehis
deathhiscareerreacheditspinnaclewhenhewasmadecastellanofKrakow.
Another area of Jakub Sobieskis public activity was his military service. He was in prince
WadysawsexpeditiontoMoscow(16171618),holdingthepostofwarcommissioner,commanding
avolunteerdetachment,andparticipatingintheunsuccessfulstormingoftheKremlin.Thenin1621
hefoughttheTurksatChocim.
Furthermore, Jakub Sobieski distinguished himself as a diplomat. As royal commissioner, in
1619hesignedtheTruceofDeulino.AfterthefirstbattleofChocim,heconductedpeacetalkswith
the Turks, meeting Sultan Othman II (1621). He represented Poland in the difficult peace
negotiationswiththeSwedesatAltmark(1629)andlateragainattheTreatyofStuhmsdorf(1635).
In1636hewasdelegatedtotheinternationalpeaceconferenceinMnster,whichwassupposedto
endthewarinEurope(latercalledtheThirtyYearsWar).Ayearlater,togetherwithWadysawIVof
Poland he greeted Archduchess Cecilia Renata of Habsburg in Warsaw, while in 1641 he spoke on
behalfofthePolishSejmtothepapalnuncioFilonardi.Furthermore,heparticipatedinnegotiations
withtheRussiandelegateAlexeiMikhailovichLvov(1644).
JakubSobieskistartedafamilywhenhewasalreadyanestablishedandmaturethirtyyear
old. His first wife (married in 1620) was Marianna Winiowiecka, the daughter of the wealthy and
influential voivode of Ruthenia Konstanty Winiowiecki. Sadly, his wife died after four years of
marriageandtheirtwodaughtersperishedinearlychildhood.In1627Sobieskimarriedhissecond
wife, Zofia Theophila Danilewicz, daughter of the Ruthenian voivode Jan Danilewicz and heiress to
vastlandedestates.SheboreJakubsevenchildren,threeofwhomsurvivedtoadulthood.Themost
important among them was Jan, born on 17 August 1629, the future King Jan III Sobieski, the
vanquisheroftheTurksatViennain1683.
JakubSobieskiwillinglyputpentopaperandthuslethimselfbeknownasachroniclerofa
timewhenthePolishLithuanianCommonwealthwasathergreatest,andalsoasaneducatorofthe
younger generation. Being associated with the main areas of his activities, his writings varied
considerablyintermsofcontentandform.Theyincludedletters,memoirs,parliamentaryspeeches,
and accounts of war (against the Turks and Russia)3 and peace negotiations (with the Swedes in
1629), and also extended to parliamentary diaries and accounts of his travels across Europe. The
most important of his writings were published in Gdansk in 1646, including: his account of the
ChocimWarentitledComentariorumchotinensisbellilibritres,4theDiaryoftheCoronationSejmin
Krakowin1633,5aswellasaccountsofhistravels,whichIshalldescribelater.
Like many other young magnates in the early modern era, Jakub Sobieski liked travelling.
Journeysprovidedhimwiththeopportunitytomeetnewpeopleandtoexperiencenewplacesand
other cultural, religious and national realities. They enriched his knowledge, broadened his
imagination and developed his aesthetic appreciation. As stated earlier, the years of his travels in
westernandsouthernEurope,16071613,werethemostimportantperiodinthedevelopmentofhis
mentalityandcharacter.Thirtyyearslater(in1638),nowanestablishedpoliticianandheadofthe
Sobieski family, he accompanied King Wadysaw IV Vasa to a health spa in Baden (near Vienna),
ISBN9789460184833
150
duringwhichtimehevisitedimperialestatesinSilesia,BohemiaandAustria.Letusalsonotforget
that,albeitforaverydifferentpurpose,healsovisitedtheMuscoviteState.
JakubSobieskileftbehindaccountsofhisEuropeantravels.Formanyyearstheyremainedin
manuscript form. They were first published by Edward Raczyski in 1833.6 Next, fragments of his
accountconcerningGermanyandFrancewerepublishedinFrenchin1846byLeonardChodzko.7In
1879partof Sobieskisaccountswere publishedin SpanishbyFr.FeliksRaski,8theheadofthe
San Lorenzo del Escorial Library near Madrid. However, the best full publication of his accounts,
editedbyJzefDugosz,waspublishedin1991bytheWydawnictwoOssolineum.9
Sobieskis accounts have not only been referred to by many Polish historians, but also by
foreignonessuchasGeorgesCirotandMarcelinDfourneaux,thelatterinhisnowclassicDailyLife
inSpainintheGoldenAge.Itismoreoverworthnotingthathistravelaccountsbecamethebasisofa
historicaltalebyMieczysawLepecki,10entitledPanJakobusSobieski.11Thepresentinvestigationis
basedonthe1991publicationofthishistoricalsource.
II.TheHabsburgcourts
ThetermcourtasunderstoodbyJakubSobieski
The key word in Jakub Sobieskis accounts is court. The word appears in his texts very often, at
variousoccasionsandinvariouscontexts.Themostfrequentcasesareasfollows:
1)Courtasthecentreandcapitalofthestate. SettingoutforMadridin1611,Sobieski
writes: There is the capital and the place of residence of the Spanish kings.12 He has a similar
reflectionatthegatesofVienna:Thisisthefinestcity,arealmetropolisAustriae.Residingthereat
the time was Matthias with his wife Anna.13 For Sobieski, therefore, the state capital was the
permanent place of residence of the monarch and his court. However, in his opinion the concepts
royalcourtandroyalpalacewerenotsynonymous.TheroyalcourtwasMadrid,whereasElPardo
andEscorialwerepalaces.AtElPardo,Sobieskiwrites,thereisasmallroyalpalaceofpleasure,14in
otherwordsaplaceofrecreation;andtheEscorialPalaceisasecludedplacefortheroyalcourt.15
Sobieski similarly makes a distinction between the royal court and the royal family. Members of
themonarchs(emperorsorkings)familywereclearlydistinguishedfromthelargercommunityof
theroyalcourt:[]theemperorleftViennatogetherwithhiscourtandhiswife,theempress.16
2)Courtasaplace. Sobieskialsousesthewordcourtinadifferentsense,assomewhere
tobe,aplaceforpeopletogatherandmeet,andasajourneysdestination.Onewasinthecourt,at
thecourtorwiththecourt:LivinginthecourtatthetimewasPrinceFilibertoofSavoy[]17;The
Spanishgentlemenwerethenresidingwiththecourt[];18Inthattimehealsolivedattheimperial
court []. Ordinary deputies also lived at the imperial court [].19 One moreover arrived at the
court:inthattimehearrivedattheSpanishcourt[].20
3) Court as the rulers circle and collective. The court is made up of people forming a
collectiveofverydistinctivecharacteristics.Itcomprisestherulersclosestcircleaswellashisfamily.
ISBN9789460184833
151
With regard to the Spanish and imperial courts, Sobieski emphasised their size: When I was in
Madrid,thecourtwasverylarge[];21theimperialcourt[]fairlypopulous;22[]Spaniardswere
addedtohiscourt[];23theemperorleftViennatogetherwithhiscourt.24
4)Courtasaninstitution. Sobieskialsoperceivedthecourtintheinstitutionalsense,asa
place where the ruler and officials formed the central administration of the state: [] at his court
andthroughoutthekingdomhehadhisloyalclerks;25IencountereddeputiesattheSpanishcourt
[];26theyhavetheiragentsattheroyalcourt[];27Therearefourseniorsabovethecourtassort
ofmarshals.28
For our Polish traveller the word court was therefore a universal concept that he applied
with respect to all the European monarchies. Naturally, depending on which state he was in he
qualified it as the French court, Spanish court, English Court, imperial court or papal court.
Occasionally,asasynonym,hespeaksoftheplaceofresidenceofkings29ortheroyalhousehold.30
DistinctivefeaturesoftheHabsburgcourt
What were the distinctive features of the Habsburg courts? What distinguished them from other
Europeancourts?
Firstly, these courts were characterised by their exceptionally close dynastic ties. In his
accounts Jakub Sobieski frequently stresses the family ties between the Spanish rulers and the
emperors. Already in the second sentence of his description of Madrid he states that at the royal
courthesawPhilipIIIandhiswifeMargaret,thedaughterofArchdukeCharles.31Sobieskireturned
tothesamethemeinhisdescriptionofhowin1638KingWadysawIVwasgreetedbytheEmpress
Maria:HisRoyalHighnessspokeinItalian,andshereceivedhimquitepleasantly,speakingbrieflyin
Spanish.32
OnthisoccasionthePolishmagnateallowedhimselftomakeafewbitingremarksaboutthe
proudandconceitedSpanishroyal,whoduringtheceremonyofkissingherhandcoollyreceivedher
Polish guests with Hispanico fastu, i.e. Spanish haughtiness.33 These close ties between the two
dynasticlineswereapparent,asSobieskinotes,inthepresenceofGermansattheMadridcourtand
Spaniards at the Vienna court. As an example, the Polish traveller mentions Empress Marias
housemistress,MadameGirona[Girn].34ThiscourtofficialmusthaveannoyedSobieski,asinhis
accountshewritesshewasfiercelyproudandneverwillingtoallowPolishladiestositontheright
hand side of the Empress.35 In his accounts Sobieski never uses the name Habsburg, referring
insteadtotheRakuskiHouse(fromtheCzechwordrakouski,meaningAustrian).

Another characteristic element of Habsburg courts was their expanded ceremonial
procedures and etiquette, which dictated relations between rulers, including their families, their
subjects,andforeignguests.

Athirdimportantdistinguishingfeatureofthesecourtswastheircloseassociationwiththe
Roman Catholic faith and religious practice. Sobieski emphasises the piety of Philip III and his wife
Margaret.36IncontrasttoHenryIVofFrance,37thePolishtravellernotesthattheSpanishkingspent
ISBN9789460184833
152
his time on religious devotion and willingly took part in religious processions. For example, he
recordsthatintheliturgicalperiodfromthefeastofCorpusChristitotheAssumptioneverydaythe
kingpubliclyparticipatedinchurchprocessions[].38ForthisreasonSobieskiwasnotsurprisedthat
Dominican and Franciscan confessors played such an important role at the courts of the Catholic
monarchs.
Theroleoftheruler
WhatkindofrulerswerethemonarchsofSpainandtheHolyRomanEmpire?Whatrolesdidthey
performatcourt?
ItshouldbenotedfromtheoutsetthatSobieskiscommentsonthissubjectreflectedviews
he had acquired from the quite different political system of what was then the PolishLithuanian
Commonwealth,wherethekingwaselectedbythenobles.Moreover,inPolandthemonarchywas
not hereditary; even if a son happened to succeed his father,39 it still required the approval of the
nobleestateoritsparliamentaryrepresentation.ThepowerofPolishkingswaslimitedbyasystem
of noble privileges (e.g., the socalled Henrician Articles and the pacta conventa) and freedoms
guaranteed,sincetheMiddleAges,bytheconstitutionofthePolishSejm.Affiliatedashewaswith
the powerful magnate dynasty of the Zamoyskis, Sobieski frequently disagreed with and openly
criticised the policies of the Polish royal court, and even criticised the king. On account of these
constitutional constraints, Polish monarchs were keenly interested in personally exercising what
authoritytheyhadand,whereverpossible,extendingtheirrangeofresponsibilities.
MeanwhileSobieskinotesthefactthatneitherPhilipIIInorMatthiasIshowedmuchinterest
in personal rule. Of the emperor he writes: A kindly man, but not very adept ad res agendas [in
governing].40WhereasaboutthekingofSpainhecomments:Moreexpertadvitamprivatamthan
adresgerendas[inrunningaffairs].41
SobieskidoesnotanalysethepoliticalsystemsofSpainortheHolyRomanEmpire.However,
perhaps having in mind the limited authority of Polish monarchs, he does remark that absolute
monarchs also share their potestas with officials and ministers. Nevertheless, he also notes that
whileintheCommonwealththeparticipationofthenobilitywaslaiddownintheconstitution,inthe
Habsburg monarchies it resulted from the personal decisions or the character traits of the ruler.
Thoserulingontheirbehalfthusincludednotonlynominatedofficials,butalsofavouritesandgrey
eminences. Imperial and royal favourites do feature in Sobieskis travel accounts. At the Spanish
courthedescribestheDukeofLermaasfollows:
ThekingtookhimtoheartandintohisconfidencesomuchsothatduringmystayinSpain
hererumpatiebatur[heldsway],afterhimtheentiregovernment,theconsilia[orConsejos]
andthenthepretenders.Whomsoeverhefavoured,sodidtheking,whomsoeverhedisliked,
thekingdislikedtoo.ThewholeofSpainadoredhim;thekingshoweredhimandhisfamily
andfriendswithgifts.42
MatthiasIHabsburgalsohadhisfavourites,whomSobieskiunequivocallycallshislovers.In
ISBN9789460184833
153
this group he includes the bishop of Vienna and later cardinal Melchior Klesl, the Italian adviser
Ottavio Cavriani as well as two military commanders, Siegfried Kollonich and Henri Duval
Dampierre.43

AlltheseobservationsregardingtheHabsburgcourtsandtherolesplayedbytheHabsburg
monarchs inclined the Polish traveller to make some rather astonishing conclusions reflecting his
surpriseatencounteringasituationquitedifferenttowhathehadexpected.Hewrites:Itisstrange
thatalthoughtheretheyhaveabsolutumdominium,thesemonarchsdonothingwithoutacouncil,
theywillnotsignanypublicletter,orsineconsiliotheywonteventouchuponpublicisnegotiis.44
Was Sobieski here expressing a conviction that Habsburg absolutism in Spain and the Holy
Roman Empire, so much reviled by the antiroyal opposition in Poland, was a stereotype form of
propagandaandmanipulation?Thiswouldbegoingtoofar,buttherecanbenodoubtthatwhathe
saw of the courts of absolute monarchs, particularly those of the Habsburgs, allowed Sobieski to
concludethatevenwhitehaditsshades.
EverydaylifeinseventeenthcenturyHabsburgcourts
Spending some time in Madrid and subsequently in Vienna provided Sobieski with an excellent
opportunitytoobserveeverydaylifeinHabsburgcourts.Naturally,theseobservationswererather
general, as they were made from the outside. The young magnate paid particular attention to the
official aspect of the life of the king and his entourage, that is to say, the court ceremonies (e.g.
awardingtheOrderoftheGoldenFleece)andaudienceswithministers,foreigndiplomatsandhigh
bornguests.Forexample,SobieskiwitnessedAmbrosioSpinolabeingawardedthetitleofGrandee
of Spain. Spinola would later become famous for his capture of Breda (1625), a scene which was
immortalisedbythebrilliantVelzquezinhispaintingLaslanzas.
The Polish traveller devotes a lot of time to describing the way the monarch and his
entourage spent their free time, and their forms of recreation. He noticed that this primarily
depended on the monarch, whose preferences and tastes constituted guidelines for those
responsible for organising royal or imperial entertainment. Sobieski recalls that the favourite
pastimesofPhilipIIIwerehuntingandriding.TherewasalsomuchmerrimentattheViennacourt.
TocelebratethearrivalofArchdukeFerdinandandhisfamily,45EmperorMatthiashadvariousfeasts
and games organised for their delight.46 Later we learn that these included races, masks, ballet,
theatreplaysandhunting.Sobieski,however,recordsanegativeaspectofrecreationattheimperial
court of Matthias I, namely, excessive drinking. Decades later, by contrast, on another visit to the
imperialcapitalhewastocomment:[...]fortheydidnotdrinkliketheGermansdidwhenIwasin
ViennainEmperorMatthiastime.47
In describing the Habsburg courts, Sobieski concentrates more on their structure than on
howtheyfunctioned.Heisinterestedintheirhierarchyofvalues,inrelationsbetweentheruler,his
family, and the court, in the roles of particular individuals, in the network of family ties and in
political,social,formalandinformalrelationships.Althoughheconcentratesonthemainplayers,he
doesalsomakeanefforttounderstandthemechanismsbehindtheexerciseofpower.Forexample,
ISBN9789460184833
154
Sobieskinotesthatthemostpowerfularistocratsaregiventhehighestofficesofstateandremainin
the court. He explains this policy as follows: He deliberately wants to have them together [], so
thattheywillnotthinkofrebellionorfactions,astheymightiftheywereseparated.48
Theformandlanguageofdescribingthecourt
There can be no doubt that in describing European courts Sobieski realised that they were the
centres of political power in particular states: places where monarchs, their families, officials,
ministers and diplomats convened, as well as others who were distinguished and important. In his
descriptionshethereforetakescaretowritewithappropriateprecision,seriousnessandrespect.
On the other hand, he does occasionally cite opinions and rumours concerning particular
courtcircles.DuringhisstayinMadrid,hementionsthecomplicatedsituationofPhilibertbeingthe
son of the duke of Savoy and at the same time the nephew of Philip III. Sobieski cites two
explanationsforPhilibertspresenceinMadrid.Somereckonedthiswasduetohisunclesconcern
forhimandtheintentiontomakePhilibertviceroyofPortugal,whileothersbelievedhewasbeing
heldasasortofhostage,tokeephisbrotherinlawtheDukeofSavoyincheck.Sobieskiaddsthat
theyoungdukewasdiscreetlywatchedoverbySpanishguardsasakindofprisoner.49Letusalsonot
forget that he did not refrain from writing about drunkenness at the court of Matthias I or from
laughingatthegratuitousetiquette.
Thelanguageinhisdescriptionsofthecourtisfundamentallydifferentfromthatintherest
of his travel accounts. It includes far more examples of elevated and sophisticated phrases, court
terminology,conceptsassociatedwithetiquetteandceremony,andLatinexpressions.

Bibliography
DiariuszsejmukoronacyjnegowKrakowiew1633roku,ed.byW.Kaczorowski,Opole,2008.
DwiepodreJ.Sobieskiego,ojcakrlaJanaIII,odbytepokrajacheuropejskichwlatach16071613i
1638,publishedbyE.Raczyski,Pozna,1833.
Lepecki,Mieczysaw,PanJakobusSobieski,Warszawa1970.
Makowiecki,Gabriela,Podrogachpolskohiszpaskich,Krakw,1984.
Malewska,Hanna,ListystaropolskiezepokiWazw,Warsaw,1977.
Sobieski,Jakub,JournaldunvoyagefaitenAllemagneetFranceaucommencementduXVIIesicle,
inLaPolognehistorique,litteraire,monumentaleetillustre,Paris,1846.
Sobieski, Jakub, Peregrynacja po Europie [16071613]. Droga do Baden [1638], ed. by J. Dugosz,
Wrocaw,Warszawa&Krakw,1991.
ISBN9789460184833
155
Syrokomla, Wadysaw, Rys ycia Jakuba Sobieskiego., in Jakuba Sobieskiego Pamitnik wojny
chocimskiejksigtroje,translatedfromLatin,withauthorsbiographyandexplanatorynotesadded
byW.Syrokomla,Petersburg,1854.
Witusik,A.A.,ListykanclerzynyBarbaryZamoyskiejdosynaTomaszazlat16051610,inOjczyznai
wolno.PraceofiarowaneProfesorowiJanowiZikowiwsiedemdziesitrocznicurodzin,ed.byA.
Baraska,W.Matwiejczyk&E.M.Ziek,Lublin,2000.
Syrokomla1854.
For example, Marek Sobieski was made one of the legal guardians of the underage Tomasz, son of Jan
Zamoyski.SeeWitusik2000,p.729.
3
JakubSobieskiistheauthorofthefirstPolishlanguagedescriptionofMoscow.SeeMalewska1977,p.140.
4
Syrokomla1854.
5
DiariuszsejmukoronacyjnegowKrakowiew1633roku,2008.
6
DwiepodreJ.Sobieskiego,ojcakrlaJanaIII...,1833.
7
Sobieski1846.
8
FatherFeliksRaski,seeMakowiecki1984.
9
Sobieski1991.
10
MieczysawBogdanLepecki(18971969),PolishArmyofficer,writer,journalist,traveller,intheyears1931
1935adjutantofMarshalJzefPisudski.
11
Lepecki1970.
12
Sobieski1991,p.142.
13
Sobieski1991,p.216.
14
Sobieski1991,p.148.
15
Sobieski1991,p.149.
16
Sobieski1991,p.217.
17
Sobieski1991,p.142.
18
Sobieski1991,p.144.
19
Sobieski1991,p.216.
20
Sobieski1991,p.145.
21
Sobieski1991,p.146.
22
Sobieski1991,p.216.
23
Sobieski1991,p.142.
24
Sobieski1991,p.217.
25
Sobieski1991,p.143.
26
Sobieski1991,p.143.
27
Sobieski1991,p.144.
28
Sobieski1991,p.145.
29
Sobieski1991,p.142.
30
Sobieski1991,p.143.
31
Sobieski1991,p.142.
32
Sobieski1991,p.234.
33
Sobieski1991,p.23435.
34
Ins Reynoso de Salamanca, the wife of Sancho Girn de Salcedo, Marquis de Sofraga, see:
http://www.geneall.net/H/per_page.php?id=1599773. In the years 16301637 Sancho was presidente del
Reino de Nueva Granada (i.e. president of the Real Audicencia of Nueva Granada), see:
http://www.heraldaria.com/phorum5/read.php?3,4571. Here his wife appears as Ins Rodrguez de
Salamanca.
35
Sobieski1991,p.244.
36
Sobieski1991,pp.121and142.
37
Sobieski1991,p.47.
38
Sobieski1991,p.146.
2
ISBN9789460184833
156
39
Such was the case with the Vasa dynasty. After thedeath of Zygmunt III, his son Wadysaw IV was made
king,andheinturnwassucceededbyhisbrotherJanIIKazimierz.
40
Sobieski1991,p.216.
41
Sobieski1991,p.121.
42
Sobieski1991,p.121.
43
Sobieski1991,p.216.
44
Sobieski1991,p.145.
45
LaterHolyRomanEmperorFerdinandII.
46
Sobieski1991,p.217.
47
Sobieski1991(DrogadoBaden),p.235.
48
Sobieski1991,p.145.
49
Sobieski1991,p.142.
ISBN9789460184833
157

III
ReligiousPracticesandtheCourt

ISBN9789460184833
158

ThePietasAustriaca.Apoliticalmyth?
OntheInstrumentalisationofPietytowardstheCrossattheVienneseCourtin
theSeventeenthCentury
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
WernerTelesko

It is well known that the Habsburg practice of piety was based on the fundamental pillars of the
venerationoftheVirginMary,thecultofthesaints,Eucharisticpiety,andthevenerationoftheHoly
Cross. In her fundamental work Pietas Austriaca (1959) Anna Coreth provides an exemplary
introduction to the effectiveness of this practice of piety over the centuries and showed how the
Habsburgsregardedreligiouslydefinedpietas(meaningbothpietyandthefearofGod)asthemost
importantvirtueofrulers.1ItwasonthebasisofthisparticularpracticeofpietythattheHabsburg
rulers from Ferdinand II onwards set themselves apart from other royal dynasties who were more
concerned with earthly glory, and from the French Bourbons in particular. Unlike other monarchs
whotendedtoemphasisetheirpersonalaccomplishments,theHabsburgs2wereconvincedthattheir
royallinewasdivinelyordained;thattheyhadbeenespeciallychosenandentrustedwithamission;
and that they had a special relationship to God in the sense that they enjoyed the divine right of
kings.
Thepresentpaperintendstoinvestigatethewayinwhichtheritualpracticeofdevotionto
thecrosshastobedistinguishedfromthepoliticallyinstrumentalisedpropagandaoftheveneration
of the cross. In this context the question arises whether Pietas Austriaca was not perhaps
instrumentalised over the course of centuries as a welcome myth of Habsburg chosenness, one
whichwasintensivelypropagatedthroughappropriatemediasoastoconductpoliticalpropaganda
more effectively, i.e., in the sense ofavehement and dynastically political profanation ofdifferent
forms of piety. In his Dissertatio polemica de prima origine Augustissimae Domus Habspurgo
Austriacae (1680), Johann Ludwig Schnleben had good reason to refer to Pietas Austriaca as
HaereditariaPietas,3orahereditarilyboundformofpiety.
The specific intention here is therefore not so much to address the theological content of
PietasAustriacawhichhasalreadybeenthesubjectofextensivetreatmentbyotherresearchers
astoinvestigatethemanywaysinwhichitcouldbeexploitedforpoliticalpurposes.Inthisregard
StefanSamerski,forexample,hasalreadydemonstratedthatLeopoldandJoseph,themainpatrons,
stood completely in the service of a dynasticpolitical raison d'tat under the reign of Leopold I.
ThesetwopatronswerecloselylinkedtothepersonoftheEmperorandhisneedforrepresentation
ISBN9789460184833
159

withrespecttogenealogy,functionandritual.4JustasitwaspopulartoequateHabsburgrulerswith
mythological persons, Pietas Austriaca formed an essential part of the Habsburgs dynastic
propaganda.Inthissenseitwasparticularlysubject,inmyview,tosubtlydifferentiatedmechanisms
of representation which correspondingly transformed the particular manifestations of piety in the
processoftheirmediation.
The veneration of the Holy Cross was propagated in different ways and in different media
followingtheCouncilofTrent.Effortsinthisregardweredirected,asitwere,atanarchaeologically
precise and comprehensive study of the circumstances surrounding the crucifixion, the Holy Cross
and the form or symbol of the cross. This is amply demonstrated by such works as the multiple
editionsofJustusLipsiusDecrucelibritresadsacramprofanamquehistoriamutiles(1593);Jacobus
BosiosCruxtriumphansetgloriosa(1617),withitsmanysourcesandthespecialemphasisitplaced
onLateAntiquityandtheearlyperiodofChristianity;andthethreevolumesbytheJesuitJacobus
GretserentitledDecruceChristi(16051608).5
TheywerealsoaccompaniedbyspecialisedstudiessuchasHonoratusNicquetusSJshistory
of the title of the Holy Cross, Titulus Sanctae Crucis seu Historia et mysterium tituli Sanctae Crucis
Domini nostri Jesu Christi (1670), or Thomas Bartholinus investigations of the Arma Christi, which
appearedunderthetitleDecruceChristiHypomnemataIV(1670).Bothadoptedacriticalhistorical
approach to their subject and fall into the category of demystifications of the circumstances
surroundingChristscrucifixion.Ontheotherhand,compendiaalsoappearedwhichdemonstrated
the possibilities each specific religious order had to approach the history of the veneration of the
cross.OnesuchexampleisMagnoaldusZiegelbaurOSBstreatiseHistoriadidacticadeSanctaeCrucis
cultuetvenerationeinordinediviBenedicti(1746),whichdealsinparticularwiththevenerationof
thecrossintheBenedictineOrder.
Such studies, which adopted a criticalhistorical approach, should be distinguished from
publications that dealt specifically with historical or legendary events that related to the Habsburg
practiceofpietyandinsodoingreflectedaframeworkofdiscourseinwhichthevenerationofthe
crosswascontextualisedunderprimarilydynasticauspices.Inordertounderpinthedynasticclaim
tothecultofthecross,NicolausVernulaeus,forexample,statedinhisworkVirtutesAugustaeGentis
Austriacaelibritres(1640)6thatGodhadpointedtheHabsburgdynastylikeConstantinetheGreat
yearsbeforetothecrossasasignandpledgeofvictory.7In thisreferencetothe time when the
venerationofthecrossstartedtobeusedforpoliticalpurposes,thecultoftheHolyCrossunderKing
RudolfIofHabsburginparticularisofcentralimportancesuchasontheoccasionwhen(according
tolegend)thefoundingfatherofthedynastyheldawoodencrossintheabsenceofasceptrewhile
tributewaspaidtohimasthenewlyelectedkingandusedittohavetheprincespledgetheiroathof
allegiance to him;8 in his treatise Austriaci Caesares (1649), the Jesuit Horstensio Pallavicini
commentedthatRudolf(theGreat)wassimplyfollowingonfromtheexamplesetbyConstantine
theGreatonaparalleloccasion:vincetcummagnoConstantinoRudolphusMagnus.9Onthisbasis
the cross was also assigned the legitimising function of pointing to the expansion of Habsburg
territoryasasymboloftheHolyCrosssuchaswhenPallavicini,inoneofhisremarks,interpreted
theexpansionoftheHabsburgEmpiretowardsallfourpointsofthecompassaslogical:afterall,it
wasconsistentwiththeshapeofthecross(!).10
ISBN9789460184833
160

ThesediversewaysoftakingHabsburgtraditionsofpietyandturningthemintomythsneed
to be taken into consideration when we come to discuss a pivotal event in the history of the
Habsburgs imperial residence in Vienna. When the Kammerkapelle (the imperial familys private
chapel) in the Leopoldine Wing of the Vienna Hofburg was destroyed by a catastrophic fire in
February 1668, it provided a new thrust to the dynastys veneration of the cross.11 Although the
availablesourcesgiveapreciseaccountofthefire,whichappearstohaveoccurredon6February
1668,12thereisnosignofareportconcerningtherelicofthecrosswhichwaskeptthere,butwhich
somehowescapeddestruction:
ein feyerbrunst in den neu erpauten stockh gegen der pasteyen, gleich vnder den Zmern
Ihrer Mt: der Verwittibten Kayserin [scil. Eleonore Gonzaga] aukhomen, dessen Vrsprung
man nehe wissen khnen, vnd derselbe ganze stokh vngeacht aller beschechenen rettung,
abgebrunnen,vnddadurchgrosserschadenanmobilienbeschechen[].13
A relatively close description of the place where this catastrophe took place is given in the
diaryofJohannSigray,anintimateofthePlffyfamily,in1668:Maniviennaecircahoramtertiam
Matutinam actum fuit incendium in Aula viduae Imperatricis et Combusta est tota residentia ipsius
Seu nomen [].14 According to a report by the papal nuncio Pignatelli,15 chests full of precious
objectsaswellasasolidgoldcrucifixandtwosilvercandelabraswereconsumedbythefireinthe
cabinetoftheEmperorswidow,EleonoreGonzaga.Afterthedisastrousfire,themeltedcaseofthe
reliquarywaslaterfoundintheashesbuttheparticlesofthecrosswhichhadbeenreveredbythe
Habsburgs centuriesin particular by Emperor Maximilian Iare supposed to have remained
unharmed.16 Emperor Leopold I (16401705) had given this holy relic to his stepmother, Empress
Eleonore Magdalena Gonzaga of MantuaNevers (16301686), the third consort of Emperor
FerdinandIII (16081657),17forsafekeepingduringherlifetime.Thispreciousreliciskept todayin
the monstrance of the Order of the Starry Cross in Viennas Kunsthistorisches Museum (with the
footandshaftmadebyHansJakobMairinAugsburgaround1668)(fig.1).18
Themiraculousrescueoftheholyrelic,whichwasfoundintactfivedaysafterthefireinthe
ruinsofEleonoreGonzagaschambers,wascelebratedbythefoundationoftheOrderoftheStarry
Cross for the high nobility on 18 September 1668.19 In particular, its members were to devote
themselvestotheworshipoftheHolyCross,asthetextsoftherelevantofficiummakeabundantly
clear.TheorderwasreconstitutedbyEmpressEleonoraMagdalenaTheresiavonderPfalz(1655
1720),thethirdwifeofEmperorLeopoldI,andelevatedtobecomethedynastyshighestaristocratic
allfemale order in 1688.20 The Empress invested members21 with the Order of the Starry Cross,
which featured golden crosses with four diamonds (hence the name Order of the Starry Cross)
heraldically designed as a combination of the Mantuan Cross with the sloping singleheaded black
Mantuaneagle22aswellasthemottoSalusetGloria,ontwooccasions:on3May(TheFindingof
the Holy Cross) and on 14 September (The Feast of the Exaltation of the Cross), bei den obern
Jesuiten(meaningtheJesuitsattheKircheAmHofinVienna).23
The circumstances surrounding the foundation of the Order of the Starry Cross were
propagated above all in a booklet entitled HochAdeliche und Gottseelige Versamblung von Stern
Creutz genandt. So von Ihr Kayserlichen Mayestt Eleonora, Verwittibten Rmischen Kayserin
auffgerichtet[](1671),24whichwaswrittenbytheJesuitJohannesBaptistaManni(fig.2).
ISBN9789460184833
161

Fig. 1 Monstrance of the Order of the Starry Cross,
Vienna,KunsthistorischesMuseum(footandshaftmade
byHansJakobMairinAugsburgca.1668).
Fig. 2 Johannes Baptista Manni SJ, HochAdeliche und

Gottseelige Versamblung von SternCreutz genandt. So
von Ihr Kayserlichen Mayestt Eleonora, Verwittibten
Rmischen Kayserin auffgerichtet (Vienna, 1671), title
page.

Thisinterestingpublicationprovidestheessentialbasicsforgainingabetterunderstanding
ofhowtheHabsburgdynastyactuallyperformedthevenerationofthecrossaswellasthespecific
circumstancessurroundingthefoundationoftheOrderoftheStarryCross.InMannispublicationon
the circumstances surrounding the foundation of the Order of the Starry Cross, references to
Habsburgpietyaresubsequentlylinkedtothesituationatthetimewithareportaboutthefireinthe
Hofburg in 1668,25 with Emperor Leopold Is veneration of the cross, with his confirmation of the
OrderoftheStarryCross,26andwiththemanuscriptoftheordersdeedoffoundationbyEleonore.27
Thishistoricalaccountisfollowedbyanextensivesectiondealingwiththewaysinwhichpietywas
specifically practised by the members of the Order of the Starry Cross (Enchiridion oder Hand
Buechlein underschiedlicher Gebett [] zu Ehr de H. Creutzes [] von HochAdelichen Frawen
ZimmerunderdenTituldeSternCreutzes zu gebrauchen);28requisite textformulasarepresented
forthepassionprayersandfortherosaryofdevotiontotheFiveWoundsherethecharacterofa
specificallyJesuitspiritualityisparticularlyevidentintheemphasisplacedontheearthlytrinityof
Jesus, Mary and Joseph.29 This is also expressed in a curious entanglement of Christological and
Marianformulasforpietywhichareclearlydiscernibleinthetexts.30Inthisparticularcasethefixed
textfortheAveMariaistransposedtotheVenerationoftheHolyCross:Gegrssetseystduheiliges
Creutz/vollBluts/derHerristmitdir/dubistgebenedeyetunderdenBumen/undgebenedeyet
ISBN9789460184833
162

istdieFrucht/soandirgehangenmeinHerrJesusChristus./HeiligesCreutzseymein[sic!]Zuflucht
jetztundinderStundmeinesAbsterbens/Amen.31
A central point for gaining an understanding of the aristocratic practice of piety in the
seventeenthcenturyisthefactthatselfreflectionandpropagandaofHabsburgpietaswerenotonly
closely linked to the veneration of the saints and the early cult of the Holy Cross, but were also
conceived as growing genealogically, as it were, from these two threads. This interesting idea of
utilisingmembersofonesowndynastyforacalendarofthesaints(!)isexpressedwiththegreatest
clarity in Johann Ludwig Schnlebens publication Annus Sanctus HabspurgoAustriacus; sive
QuingentiSancti,Beati,&Venerabiles,utriusquesexus,AugustissimaeDomuiHabspurgoAustriacae
Sanguinis et cognationis nexu illigati (Salzburg 1696)32 and in church decors which are essentially
based on a programme of saints that propagated Habsburg piety, such as Carpoforo Tencallas
paintingfortheChapelofSt.PetrusCanisiusintheKircheAmHofinVienna(aroundorafter1668).33
In addition to its triumphal aspects, the Habsburg veneration of the cross under Emperor
FerdinandII(15781637)hadincreasinglybeenassignedafurtherdimensionofmeaningwhichwas
aboveallexpressedinthewillingnesstoacceptanysufferingthatcamefromGod.34Whenon5June
1619 protestant nobles from Lower Austria were pressuring Emperor Ferdinand II in the Vienna
Hofburgtograntthemthefreedomtopractisetheirreligion(aneventwhichbecameknownasthe
Sturm petition), Christ apparently whispered to the regent praying before the cross: Ferdinand, I
wont abandon you!. Shortly afterwards a regiment appeared in the Burghof courtyard and saved
thehardpressedruler.35ThepresenceofadeputationoftheAustrianprotestantnoblesledbyPaul
JakobGrafStarhembergandAndreasFreiherrvonThonrdelbeforeanEmperorFerdinandIIgazing
atthecrossintheViennaHofburginJune1619becameadefiningthemeintheprintedgraphicartof
the eighteenth century.36 Usually Ferdinand II stands in the centre of such depictions, looking with
great pathos up to the cross with a banner proclaiming the words of Christ (Ferdinande, non te
deseram!)(fig.3).37
In early modern visual propaganda the reproduction of this moment was regarded as the
mostimportanteventintheruleofFerdinandII,asbecomesclearinthefrescosofhisburialchapel
intheGrazMausoleum(169193),whichwerebasedonadesignbyFischervonErlach(1688),38and
in the corresponding fresco in the Kaisersaal, which was painted by Melchior Steidl in 1709, and
whichformspartoftheBambergResidenz.39
In the twelfth and final part of his Annales Ferdinandei [] (1726), Franz Christoph
KhevenhllerpublishedaGermanversionofFerdinandIIsvirtuesandshowedthedialoguebetween
Christ crucified and Emperor Ferdinand in a large copper engraving depicting the extraordinarily
Jesuitfriendly emperor as a pilgrim (!) and hence as a direct successor to St. Ignatiusa unique
example in iconography (fig. 4).40 Even in the mortuary roll written by the Prague Jesuit Petrus
Wadding for Emperor Ferdinand II, which associated the late ruler with the various virtues of
Constantine,TheodosiusandCharlemagne,Ferdinandspietasisemphasisedintheinvocationofhis
successor(?)withtheaidofadirectreferencetothecross,evidentlyinaninterpolationoftheTe
igiturfrom theofficiumofthe mass:TuigiturCruceinsignis,Provinciarum quas Ferdinandus caelo
fidelesreddidit,agminaposttetrahes[].41

ISBN9789460184833
163

Fig.3FerdinandIIlookinguptothecross,engraving,
Prague,after1730.
Fig.4FranzChristophKhevenhller,Annales
th
Ferdinandei(Leipzig,1726),12 part,engraving,
dialoguebetweenChristandEmperorFerdinandII.

Notwithoutreason,MariaTheresaalsoinvokedthisnowfamouslegendofherpredecessor
whenshetookthecrosswithhertotheReichstaginPreburg(Bratislava)inSeptember1741.Today
the cross is kept in the Ecclesiastical Treasury.42 After returning to the Vienna Hofburg, she had it
displayedforpublicvenerationintheKammerkapellefortwoweeksstartingon22Decemberofthat
yearandon5January1742decreedthatthecrossshouldingeneralbedisplayedintheHofkapelle
every Friday because of the throngs of people who had come to see it.43 Later on, in 1748, Maria
Theresa ordered Ferdinands cross to be placed in the tabernacle of the renovated imperial court
chapel,44whichledtothecustomofpresentingittobekissedonSundaysandfeastdays.45Rightup
totheendoftheMonarchy,thiseventundertheruleofEmperorFerdinandIIformedanessential
pointofreferencefortheHabsburgideologyofpiety.46
The peculiar thing about this episode in 1619 is the fact that we note an extraordinary
confluence between the efforts of the Jesuit Order and the piety of the Habsburgsas we have
already clearly seen with the foundation of the Order of the Starry Cross. The pivotal words,
Ferdinande,nontedeseram!,withwhichChristissupposedtohaveassuredEmperorFerdinandof
hissupport,alsosupplythecorrespondingexplanation.Notonlyaretheyareaquotationfromthe
Bible (Letter to the Hebrews 13:5, I will not abandon you, and I will not neglect you.),47 but the
passagealsoconstitutesanexplicitreferencetotheSocietyofJesussincetheversefromHebrews
also provides a direct reference to the following event in the life of St. Ignatius of Loyola. On his
ISBN9789460184833
164

journey from Rome to Venice the saint was repeatedly turned away from lodgings because of a
virulentplagueandendeduphavingtosleepintheopen,butreceivedcomfortandsupportwhen
Christ appeared and promised not to abandon him, using the words quoted in the above passage
from the Bible.48 Consequently, in terms of their subject matter, the verse from Hebrews, the
episodeinthelifeofIgnatius,andthelegendofFerdinandIIandthecrossin1619allreferwithone
and the same text quotationto the assurance of Christs support. In the twelfth part of Franz
ChristophKhevenhllersAnnalesFerdinandeitheconfluenceheassertsbetweenthesaintandthe
piousemperorisevenmadeexplicitlyclearinthecitedpilgrimlikedescriptionoftheregent.

Fig.5Unsignedbroadsheet(1636)whichdisplaysamaypole(afreshandgreen
maypoleaccordingtothelegendbelow).
ThemultiplicityofmeaningswhichthesymbolismofthecrosshadinEmperorFerdinandIIs
propagandaisparticularlyevidentinanunsignedbroadsheet(1636)(fig.5)whichdisplaysamaypole
ortreeoflife(afreshandgreenmaypoleaccordingtothelegend)theleavesofwhichareturning
green and present certain virtues that supposedly embody Ferdinand II.49 The thread of salvation
thatrunsthroughthisdocumentbecomesclearinthecaseofthetree,whichalludestothetreeof
theCross,andintheEucharistaboveitwhichisexplainedbythebannerlocatedabovetheinsignia.
Itreferences thepassageGodhimself willprovidethelambfortheburntoffering(Genesis22:8),
ISBN9789460184833
165

whichwasAbrahamsreplytoIsaacsfearfulquestionabouttheanimalwhichwastobesacrificedto
God.Here,thedynasticvenerationofthecrossisgeneralisedandcloselylinkedtotheProvidentia
motif which was fundamental for the Habsburg dynasty in general and Ferdinand II in particular,50
sincethepassagetakenfromthebookofGenesisGottWirdtfrsehen(Godwillprovide)isquoted
in the representational copper engraving. Hence the motto Deus providebit,51 which was also the
mottoofEmperorMaximilianII(15271576),appearstohaveapplieddirectlytotheemperorandto
the Domus Austriaca he represented. According to this perspective, Emperor Ferdinand IIor the
virtuesheembodiedfoundhimselfinthebroadtraditionofHabsburgpietytowardstheCrossand
the Eucharist. A detail in the upper part of this engraving shows the wood of the tree now
transformedintoasmallcrucifix,whichRudolfvonHabsburg,thefatherofthedynasty,ishanding
overtoFerdinandIIinanahistoricalmontage.Thiseventisbasedonthefamouslegendcitedatthe
beginningofthispaper,accordingtowhichRudolfvonHabsburgissupposedtohaveheldandkissed
awoodencrucifixintheabsenceofasceptrewhiletributewaspaidtohimasthenewlyelectedking
andusedittohavetheprincespledgetheiroathofallegiancetohimwhenhewaselectedkingin
1273.Accordingtothelegend,thewordsweseeonthebannerhere,mitdisemscepterwollenwir
regieren,arealiteralquotationofwhatRudolfactuallysaidonthisoccasion.52
This little and somewhat unprepossessing scene assumes greater significance to the extent
thatRudolfIshandingofacrosstoEmperorFerdinandIIIalsoplaysanimportantroleinanemblem
withthelemmaABHOCSIGNO,meaningthecross,intheunpaginatedbookofemblemsentitled
Annus primus imperii Austriaci, duodecim caesareomensium (Graz 1638), which was dedicated to
Emperor Ferdinand III.53 Hence the wood of the cross at the very top of the maypole has been
transformedinaqualitativesensethroughtheadditionofthecentrallegendofHabsburghistory.It
nowassumesthecharacterofareligiousobjectwhichtransfersthevegetablesymbolismofthetree
into an obvious reminder of the presence of the Habsburg Pietas Austriaca. Furthermore, the
hagiographic aspect of the dynastys practice of piety is also underlined by the addition of the
apostlesPhilipandJamestheLess,bothofwhosefeastdaysfallon1May(!)theverydaytowhich
theerectionofthemaypolerefers.JamestheYoungerhandsoverhisown(!)attribute,asitwere,in
the sword which he gives to Ferdinand III (crowned King of Hungary in 1626 and Holy Roman
Emperor in 1636), who is kneeling next to Ferdinand II. Just as the cross is the actual fruit of the
maypole, the crowns in the branches of the tree should be understood not only as individual
achievementsoftheruler(orvirtues)butalsoasfruitsoftheHouseofHabsburgintheformof
insignia.
ThedifferentformsoftheHabsburgvenerationofthecrosswhichhavebeenpresentedhere
leadtothefundamentalproblemareaoftheauspicesunderwhichthevitallinesoftraditionsince
theglorificationofKingRudolfIwerereceivedintheseventeenthandeighteenthcentury,andhow
theywerepropagatedintextsandimages.54HereitisapparentthattheHabsburgFiduciainCrucem
ChristiwasprimarilylinkedtotheotherimportantelementsofPietasAustriacaandtothepolitical
leitmotifofProvidentia,theimportanceofwhichwastoprotecttheHabsburgdynastythroughthe
centuries.55Rightuptothenineteenthcenturythisprovidencewasactuallythecentralmotifinthe
selfprojection of the House of Habsburg, in bitter opposition to a tendency, manifest since the
beginnings of early modern philosophy, to view Gods work on earth, and hence the relevance of
Providentiainthehistoryofsalvation,fromanincreasinglycriticalperspective.56
ISBN9789460184833
166

Inadditiontoitsvitalreligiousimplications,thePietasAustriacawhichwaspractisedunder
the protection of Providentia was a particular guarantee of the assurance of continuity. This was
further underpinned by the approach taken in a compendium of Habsburg values and princes,
PrincepsinCompendio,57whichwaswrittenundertheinfluenceoftheJesuitsintheclosestcirclesof
thecourtofEmperorFerdinandII.ItmightbedescribedasamanualfortheHabsburgconceptionof
imperial office. The compendium of princes first appeared during the rule of Ferdinand II (1632).
Moreover, even in the very first chapter (Quomodo cum Deo se Princeps gerere debeat.), it
formulatesin the form of a catechism, as it werethe relevance of unequivocal trust and
confidence that was to be placed in God and the saints, and which supposedly distinguished the
steadfast behaviour of Emperor Ferdinand II when he came under pressure from the protestant
noblesin1619,asdescribedabove.58
Thus,theemphasisplacedonthefinalityofeventsinthehistoryofsalvationcharacterises
eachofthetwoexamplesoftheHabsburgvenerationofthecrossattheVienneseCourtintheearly
ModernAge59whichwehavebrieflypresentedhere.Thefirstcasedealswiththefoundationofthe
OrderoftheStarryCross(1668)andhowEmperorLeopoldIhadentrustedtherelicofthecrossto
the safekeeping of his stepmother, Empress Eleonore Gonzaga, Emperor Ferdinand IIIs widow, for
the duration of her lifetimea wise and farsighted measure which could not even be undone by
majorhistoricdisasterssuchasthefireintheLeopoldineWingoftheViennaHofburgin1668.On
thisoccasionthevenerationofthecrossstoodunderthesamesupremelyprovidentialauspicesas
thedemonstrationofunshakablepietasbyEmperorFerdinandIIwhenheprayedtothecrossinJune
1619.OnceagaininthiscaseitisGodsguidingcareandprovidencewhichrepresentsthepivotal
momentinthesequenceofevents.InthissensethesetwoexamplesoftheHabsburgsvenerationof
thecrossprovidedhighlywelcomefoundationsfortransformingeventswhichweretakenfromthe
history of the Habsburg dynasty into a history with a dimension of destiny and truly divine
providence,andforlegitimisingthedynastyspoliticalmandatesbyclaimingthattheywerefounded
on Gods farsighted rulewhich therefore proved their righteousness. The treatment of these
events in the sense of the functionalisation of piety under a central guiding motif (Providentia)
ultimatelyledtoasituationinwhichtherighteousnessandthepietyoftheHouseofHabsburghad
toberegardedaspracticallyinvincible.Butnotonlythat:Thesignificanceofcatholicisminthesense
ofitbeingadynasticconstantresidedlessintheactsofdemonstratingsuchpietyandfarmoreina
cleverlypresentedamalgamationofpoliticalandreligiouspretentions.Whenwelookmorecloselyat
the inserted inscriptions, even Elias Nessenthalers famous copper engraving on the cover of
Johannes Ludovicus Schnlebens Annus Sanctus HabspurgoAustriacus (1696)60 not only tries to
embedthedepictionofEmperorLeopoldatprayerintoanambitiousprogrammeofvirtues,butalso
attemptstoidentifytheHouseofAustriawiththebiblicalDomusandtoconferGodspromiseto
Abraham in the book of Genesis (15:5) on the rich descendants of the Habsburgs, on saints and
secularnobles,andonchurchdignitaries61allofwhomareseencrowdingaroundtheHolyTrinityin
theupperthirdoftheengraving(fig.6).
ISBN9789460184833
167

Fig. 6 Elias Nessenthaler, copper engraving on the cover of Johannes
Ludovicus Schnlebens Annus Sanctus HabspurgoAustriacus (Ljubljana,
1696).
HencethewiderworldofhistoricalmeaningwasprimarilydefinedbyProvidentiaDei;and
the history of the Habsburg dynasty, marked by the symbol of the cross, became a history of
salvationtoacertainextent,withtheHabsburgscastintheroleofGodschosenfew.Ultimately,all
this was justified by the leading role which God had supposedly assigned to the Habsburgs in the
Sacrum Imperium ever since Rudolf I. Not without reason does a Viennese document of theses
published in 1649 with the title Campus Liliorum invoke the function of Rudolf I as Caesar (sic!)
EucharisticoMarianus,Austriacus.
Seenfromthispointofview,thelettering(AUSTRIAELECTA)ontheedgeofamedalstruck
in 1690 by Philipp Heinrich Mller to mark Josephs coronation as Emperor of the Holy Roman
Empirecertainlydoesnotrefersolelytothespecific(historical)actoftheelectionitself:italsostakes
outaclaimtothepoliticalprimacyoftheHabsburgs.ApublicationentitledTypusGloriaeAustriacae,
ISBN9789460184833
168

whichappearedin1658,shortlyafterLeopoldItookofficeintheHolyRomanEmpire,investigated
the continuity of the founding father Rudolf, PRIMVS EX AVGVSTA AVSTRIACORVM STIRPE
ROMANORVM IMPERATOR62, up to that particular time in the symbolic form of Pietas Augusta (!)
and,intheintroductoryemblem63withtheHabsburgeaglesittingonaglobeandgazingupatthe
sun,relatedtheglobetotheroundformoftheEucharistgleaminginthesun.Theenclosedmotto
HICORBISINILLVMEXTVLITillustrateshowtheglobeliftsuptheeagletotheallredeemingsunand
how world domination and world redemption, as it were, are brought together in the symbol of
circularity.ItwasnotunusualfordynasticandChristiantypestooccursidebysideasinthiscaseso
thattheywereviewedasoneandthesamething.ThecopperengravingofJohannBaptistJezlthe
OlderonthefrontispieceofthefirstvolumeofthefamouspublicationPietasAustriaca,writtenby
DiegoTafuri(Innsbruck,1655),64offersagoodexampleofthis:HerculeshydraiskilledbytheThree
FacesofAustria,whicharedescribedasanimageofpietyinthelegend.HenceAustriaisnotonly
assignedanapocalypticmotif(Revelation1:16:Andinhisrighthand,heheldthesevenstars;and
fromhismouthwentoutasharptwoedgedsword;andhisfacewaslikethesun,shiningwithallits
might):theshieldofthedynastywiththeHabsburglionalsofunctionsasaprotectiveshieldfora
personification, triumphant along the lines of St. Michael, whose striking Tricephalus obviously
mirrorsthetypeoftheHolyTrinity,butwhichhadactuallybeenforbiddeninthisformbytheHoly
Seesince1628(fig.7).

Fig.7EngravingofJohannBaptistJezltheOlderonthefrontispieceofthefirstvolume
ofthepublicationPietasAustriaca,writtenbyDiegoTafuri(Innsbruck,1655).
ISBN9789460184833
169

IfinconclusionwenowaskhowPietasAustriacawasactuallydefinedintheearlyModern
Age, we find ourselves back once more in the same broad complex of themes surrounding finality
andchosennessinthehistoryofsalvationwhichisregardedasacausalrelationshipinpietas.Here,
too,itisnotsomuchaproblemofdefiningorcategorisingcertainformsofreligiousnessthatmight
justifythecriterionofHabsburgchosenness.Moreimportantly,weneedtoinvestigatethehistoryof
salvationforitspoliticalfunctionality:AUSTRIACAMGENTEMPrimoEcclesiaeCatholicaeApostolicae
Romanae suae perdilectae sponsae, ac deinde Imperio Occidentis magna jugique PIETATE
profuturam, vidit Deus, & gavisus est., is Tafuris definition in the abovementioned publication:65
God saw that the House of Austria would first benefit the catholic, apostolic Roman Church, its
belovedbride,andthenthewesternempire,i.e.theHolyRomanEmpirefoundedbyCharlemagne,
throughgreatandconstantpiety;Godsawthisandwasglad.Theauthorunderlinesthisaspectinhis
briefsidecomment:Beforetheworldwascreated(!),GodsawAustriaandwasglad.Thequotation
that hasbeenwovenintothisremark istakenfromtheGospel accordingto St. John (8:56),which
demonstratesGodsjoyathisdecision.ItnotonlypointstotheaccountoftheCreationinthefirst
chapter of Genesis (1:31) and the repeatedly expressed satisfaction of the Creator in this regard
(AndGodsawitwasgood),butalsototheGospelofSt.John(8:58)withChristsselfdefinitionin
relationtotheOldTestament:[]beforeAbrahamwasmade,Iam.Theuseofthisclassicpassage
about the Christian perception of time and the quotation from Genesis66 illustrate Tafuris lively
interestinaninstrumentalisationofPietasAustriacathroughasophisticatedandpoliticallyoriented
theologyofhistorywhichfunctionalisesthenotionofpietasinrelationtotheroleofAustriainthe
sense that regnum and sacerdotium were able to evolve in the Western world solely through the
circumstanceofAustriabeingsingledoutastheempireorrealmofpreference.Hencetheelements
ofHabsburgpietyandrecoursetothetraditionoftheGraecoRomanProvidentiaAugustiwerenot
somuchregardedintermsofthespecificallytheologicalorreligiousaspectsoftheirsubjectmatter
but rather as a multifunctional set and instrument of concrete political strategies.67 From the
Habsburg point of view, pietasan essential part of an ideological identity [] for sacralizing and
sanctifying the legitimacy of the dynasty68became an irrefutable historical and theological
argumentinthestruggleforworldsupremacy.

Bibliography
AppuhnRadtke, Sibylle, Sol oder Phaeton? Invention und Imitation barocker Bildpropaganda in
Wien und Paris, in Wilhelm Hofmann & HansOtto Mhleisen (Ed.), Kunst und Macht: Politik und
HerrschaftimMediumderbildendenKunst(Mnster,2005),pp.94127.
Augustin, Christian; Hengerer, Mark; Mayr, Stefan; Schnadenberger, Eva; and Voegele, Michael, in
Zusammenarbeit mit Melanie Thoben, Ambrosius Roggerius OP: Lvcerna Principis Christiani. Ein
Frstenspiegel fr Erzherzog Ernst (Kaiser Ferdinand III.), Rmische Historische Mitteilungen 50
(2008),pp.209312.
Avancini SJ, Nicolaus, Cyrus. Ludis nuptialibus Augustissimi Romanorum Imperatoris Leopoldi et
ClaudiaeFelicis[](Graz,1673).
ISBN9789460184833
170

Bandion, Wolfgang J., Steinerne Zeugen des Glaubens. Die heiligen Sttten der Stadt Wien (Vienna,
1989).
Brenger, Jean, Pietas Austriaca. Contribution ltude de la sensibilit des Habsbourg, in Jean
Pierre Bardet & Madeleine Foisil (ed.), La vie, la mort, la foi, le temps. Mlanges offerts Pierre
Chaunu(Paris,1993),pp.403421.
BireleySJ,Robert,ReligionandPoliticsintheAgeoftheCounterreformation.EmperorFerdinandII,
WilliamLamormaini,S.J.,andtheFormationofImperialPolicy(ChapelHill,1981).
Bsel, Richard, Ein Projekt im Auftrag Ferdinands II. fr das IgnatiusHeiligtum in der rmischen
Kirche Il Ges, in Richard Bsel, Grete Klingenstein, & Alexander Koller (ed.), KaiserhofPapsthof
(16.18.Jahrhundert)[sterreichischeAkademiederWissenschaften,PublikationendesHistorischen
InstitutsbeimsterreichischenKulturforuminRom,Abhandlungen12](Vienna,2006),pp.225249.
Brean SJ, Franz Xaver, Die starcke Tugend und Tugendsambe Strcke Eleonorae Magdalenae
Theresiae[](Vienna,1720).
Brockmann, Thomas, Dynastie, Kaiseramt und Konfession. Politik und Ordnungsvorstellungen
Ferdinands II. im Dreiigjhrigen Krieg (Quellen und Forschungen aus dem Gebiet der Geschichte
N.S.,Nr.25)(Paderborn,2011).
Buchaim, Otto Fridericus Comes a, Orientis occidentisque imperium Ferdinandi II. Imperatoris
auspiciisconjungendum[](Rome,1627).
Coreth,Anna,PietasAustriaca.sterreichischeFrmmigkeitimBarock(ViennaMunich, 21982[ibid.
1
1959,englishversion:WestLafayette,Indiana2004[CentralEuropeanStudies]).
DiviFerdinandiII.[]VirtutesRegiae(Graz,1737).
DornnSJ,FranciscusXaverius,GlowuerdigsterEinflug,undEinzugdesAdlersInSeinvorigesNest,Das
ist: In das uraltOesterreichischWienerische AdlersHau, Beyden allerhoechsten gecroenten
Haeupteren Francisco I. Neuerwaehlten, und gecroenten Roemischen Kayser, [...] (Augsburg, ca.
1745)
Ducreux, MarieElizabeth,Derheilige WenzelalsBegrnderderPietasAustriaca:DieSymbolikder
Wallfahrt nach Star Boleslav (Alt Bunzlau) im 17. Jahrhundert, in Hartmut Lehmann & Anne
Charlott Trepp (ed.), Im Zeichen der Krise. Religiositt im Europa des 17. Jahrhunderts
(VerffentlichungendesMaxPlanckInstitutsfrGeschichte152)(Gttingen,1999),pp.597636.
Ducreux, MarieElizabeth, Emperors, Kingdoms, Territories: Multiple Versions of the Pietas
Austriaca,TheCatholicHistoricalReview,97,2(April2011),pp.276304.
Duerloo, Luc, Pietas Albertina. Dynastieke vroomheid en herbouw van het vorstelijke gezag,
BijdragenenmededelingenbetreffendedegeschiedenisderNederlanden,112(1997),pp.118.
Duerloo,Luc,Dynasty andpiety.ArchdukeAlbert(15981621)andHabsburgPoliticalCultureinan
ageofReligiousWars(Farnham,2012).
ISBN9789460184833
171

Erichsen, Johannes; Heinemann, Katharina; & Janis, Katrin (ed.), KaiserRume KaiserTrume.
Forschen und Restaurieren in der Bamberger Residenz, exhibition catalogue, Bayerische
Schlsserverwaltung(Munich,2007).
Fassbinder, Brigitte, Studien zur Malerei des 17. Jahrhunderts im Wiener Raum, PhD dissertation
(Vienna,1979).
Graff,Hedwig,CarpoforoTencalla.SeinWerknrdlichderAlpen,diplomathesis(Graz,2000).
Gugitz,Gustav(ed.),DieSagenundLegendenderStadtWien(Vienna,1952).
Hainisch, Erwin (ed.), Die Kunstdenkmler des Gerichtsbezirkes Lambach (sterreichische
Kunsttopographie34)(Vienna,1959).
Hargittay, Emil, Die ungarischen Bezge Wilhelm Lamormainis und der ,Ferdinandi II. Romanorum
ImperatorisVirtutes(1638),inMrtaNagy&LszlJncsik(ed.),swersnenvriuntbehaltet,daz
istlobelchFestschriftfrAndrsVizkeletyzum70.Geburtstag(Budapest,2001),pp.281287.
Hecht,Christian,KatholischeBildertheologieimZeitaltervonGegenreformationundBarock.Studien
zuTraktatenvonJohannesMolanus,GabrielePaleottiundanderenAutoren(Berlin,1997).
Herrgott OSB, Marquard & Heer OSB, Rustenus (ed.), Pinacotheca principum Austriae []
(Monumenta Augustae Domus Austriacae, vol. III/1), (Freiburg & Breisgau, 1760 [2nd edition, ed.
MartinusGerbertOSB,St.Blasien,1773]).
HochadeligeundgottseligeVersammlungvomSternkreuzgenannt[...](Vienna,1805).
Hochadelige und gottselige Versammlung vom Sternkreuze. Herausgegeben auf Ihrer k. k. apost.
MajesttallergndigsteVerordnung(Vienna,1839).
HochadeligeundgottseligeVersammlungvomSternkreuze(Vienna,1960).
Hoppe,Ilaria,DieRumederRegentin.DieVillaPoggioImperialezuFlorenz(Berlin,2012).
Irblich,Eva(ed.),ThesaurusAustriacus.EuropasGlanzimSpiegelderBuchkunst.Handschriftenund
Kunstalbenvon800bis1600,catalogue(Vienna,1996).
KastnerMichalitschke, Else, Geschichte und Verfassungen des Sternkreuzordens, (Leipzig & Vienna,
1909).
Khevenhller,FranzChristoph,AnnalesFerdinandei[],part12(Leipzig,1726).
Kitlitschka,Werner,BeitrgezurErforschungderTtigkeitCarpoforoTencallasnrdlichderAlpen,
WienerJahrbuchfrKunstgeschichte,23(1970),pp.208231.
Khler, Johannes, Vorsehung, in Joachim Ritter, Karlfried Grnder, & Gottfried Gabriel (ed.),
HistorischesWrterbuchderPhilosophie,vol.11(Basle,2001),pp.12061218.
ISBN9789460184833
172

KnigNordhoff, Ursula, Ignatius von Loyola. Studien zur Entwicklung einer neuen Heiligen
IkonographieimRahmeneinerKanonisationskampageum1600(Berlin,1982).
Kretschmer, Helmut, Sturmpetition und Blockade Wiens im Jahr 1619 (Militrhistorische
Schriftenreihe38)(Vienna,1978).
Kusternig,Andreas,DieProvidentiaerteiltderAustriadenAuftragzurWeltherrschaft.Problemeum
das Deckengemlde im Groen Saal des Niedersterreichischen Landhauses ein
Werkstattbericht,inGerhardAmmerer,WilliamD.Godsey,Jr.,MartinScheutz,PeterUrbanitsch,&
Alfred Stefan Wei (ed.), Bndnispartner und Konkurrenten der Landesfrsten? Die Stnde in der
Habsburgermonarchie(VerffentlichungendesInstitutsfrsterreichischeGeschichtsforschung49)
(ViennaMunich,2007),pp.533581.
Lamormaini SJ, Guilielmus, Ferdinandi II Romanorum Imperatoris Virtutes, Trnava 1739 (Vienna,
1
1638[inLatinandGerman]).
Lauro, Brigitta, Die Grabsttten der Habsburger. Kunstdenkmler einer europischen Dynastie
(Vienna,2007).
Lebzelter,CarolusWolffgangus,DivusLeopolduspiusAustriacus(Vienna,1701).
Leithejasper,Manfred&Distelberger,Rudoplf,KunsthistorischesMuseumWienDieSchatzkammer
(London,1998).
Lorenz, Hellmut (ed.), Barock (Geschichte der bildenden Kunst in sterreich 4) (Munich, London &
NewYork,1999).
Lnig,JohannChristian,Theatrumceremonialehistoricopoliticum[],vol.II/2(Leipzig,1720).
MaderKratky,Anna,LiturgieimengstenKreise.DieKammerkapellenimLeopoldinischenTraktder
WienerHofburg,sterreichischeZeitschriftfrKunstundDenkmalpflege,65,4(2011),pp.437451.
ManniSJ,JohannesBaptista,HochAdelicheundGottseeligeVersamblungvonSternCreutzgenandt.
So von Ihr Kayserlichen Mayestt Eleonora, Verwittibten Rmischen Kayserin auffgerichtet []
(Vienna,1671).
MontegnanaSJ,Ferdinandus,OratiofunebrisinexequiisDiviFerdinandiII.[](Graz,1637).
Oberparleiter, Veronika Coroleu, Nicolaus Vernulaeus. Darstellung der Habsburger: Apologia,
VirtutesundHistoriaaustriaca,miteinemExkursberdieMethoduslegendiHistorias,Humanistica
Lovaniensia.JournalofNeoLatinStudies,56(2007),pp.233268.
PallaviciniSJ,Horstensio,AustriaciCaesares[](Milan,1649).
Panegyricus ob victoriam Bohemicam Augustissimo Imperatori Ferdinando II. dictus (Ingolstadt,
1621).
ISBN9789460184833
173

Phosphori Austriaci sive compendiosae Historiae de Augustissimae Domus Austriacae Origine,
MagnitudineetPotentialibriduo(Vienna,1699).
Polleross,Friedrich,BildnisseoderPortrts.HistorischePersonenundihrBildamBeispielLeopolds
I., in Hans Ottomeyer (ed.), Das Exponat als historisches Zeugnis. Prsentationsformen politischer
Ikonographie,DeutschesHistorischesMuseumBerlin(Dresden,2010),pp.147156.
Polleross,Friedrich,Masexemplar,queimitadordeDavid.ZurFunktiondesIdentifikationsportrts
zwischenTugendspiegelundPanegyrik,inDieterBreuer(ed.),ReligionundReligiosittimZeitalter
desBarock(WolfenbttelerArbeitenzurBarockforschung25/I)(Wiesbaden,1995),pp.229241.
Princeps in Compendio, ed. by Franz Bosbach, in Konrad Repgen (ed.), Das Herrscherbild im 17.
Jahrhundert (Schriftenreihe der Vereinigung zur Erforschung der neueren Geschichte 19) (Mnster,
[Westfalia]1991),pp.79114.
Princeps in Compendio. Hoc est, Puncta aliquot compendiosa, quae circa gubernationem Reipub.
observanda videntur, Vienna 1668 (ibid. 11632), reprinted in Oswald Redlich, Princeps in
Compendio.EinFrstenspiegelvomWienerHofeausdemXVII.Jahrhundert(Vienna,1906),pp.8
20.
Quednau, Rolf, Konstantin als Vorbild weltlicher Herrschaft im Westen, in Alexander Demandt &
JosefEngemann(ed.),KonstantinderGroe,exhibitioncatalogue(Mayence,2007),pp.455466.
Rein,Aldus,OratiofunebrisinexequiisFerdinandiII.RomanorumImperatoris[](Graz,1637).
RibadeneiraSJ,Petrus,VitaIgnatiiLoiolae[](Ingolstadt,1590[Naples,11572]).
Rinck, Eucharius Gottlieb, Leopolds des Groen, Roem. Kaysers wunderwrdiges Leben und Thaten
[],vol.I(Leipzig,21709).
Rizzi,WilhelmGeorg,EinAltarentwurfvonMatthiasSteinlfrdieWienerHofburg?,sterreichische
ZeitschriftfrKunstundDenkmalpflege,51,34(1997),pp.620626.
Samerski, Stefan, Hausheilige statt Staatspatrone. Der milungene Absolutismus in sterreichs
Heiligenhimmel, in Petr Mata & Thomas Winkelbauer (ed.), Die Habsburgermonarchie 1620 bis
1740.LeistungenundGrenzendesAbsolutismusparadigmas(ForschungenzurGeschichteundKultur
desstlichenMitteleuropa24)(Stuttgart,2006),pp.251278.
Schicht, Patrick & Telesko, Werner, Die ehemalige Jesuitenkirche Am Hof in Wien. Zu den neu
entdeckten Stuck und Malereiresten der frhbarocken Ausstattung, sterreichische Zeitschrift fr
KunstundDenkmalpflege,61,4(2007),pp.535553.
Schmal,Kerstin,DiePietasMariaTheresiasimSpannungsfeldvonBarockundAufklrung.Religise
PraxisundSendungsbewusstseingegenberFamilie,UntertanenundDynastie(MainzerStudienzur
NeuerenGeschichte7)(FrankfurtontheMain,2001).
Schnleben,JohannLudwig,DissertatiopolemicadeprimaorigineAugustissimaeDomusHabspurgo
Austriacae[](Ljubljana,1680).
ISBN9789460184833
174

Schumann,Jutta,DieandereSonne.KaiserbildundMedienstrategienimZeitalterLeopoldsI.(Institut
frEuropischeKulturgeschichtederUniversittAugsburg,ColloquiaAugustana17)(Berlin,2003).
Seipel, Wilfried (ed.), Hauptwerke der Geistlichen Schatzkammer (Kurzfhrer durch das
KunsthistorischeMuseum7)(Vienna,2007).
Silver, Larry, Marketing Maximilian. The Visual Ideology of a Holy Roman Emperor (Princeton &
Oxford,2008).
Starzer, Albert, Der Brand der Hofburg zu Wien im Februar 1668, Bltter des Vereines fr
LandeskundevonNiedersterreich,N.S.25(1891),pp.153154.
Strohmeyer,Arno,NurLorbeerkrnzeundPietas?HerrschaftinderhfischenGeschichtsschreibung
unterLeopoldI.,inMarkusVlkel&ArnoStrohmeyer(ed.),HistoriographieaneuropischenHfen
(16.18.Jahrhundert).StudienzumHofalsProduktionsortvonGeschichtsschreibungundhistorischer
Reprsentation(ZeitschriftfrhistorischeForschung,supplement43)(Berlin,2009),pp.6195.
Sturmberger,Hans,PrincepsinCompendioundseinFrstenbild,inHugoHantsch,EricVoegelin&
Franco Valsecchi (ed.), Historica. Studien zum geschichtlichen Denken und Forschen (Vienna, 1965),
pp.91116.
Sturmberger, Hans, Kaiser Ferdinand II. und das Problem des Absolutismus (Schriftenreihe des
ArbeitskreisesfrsterreichischeGeschichte)(Vienna,1957).
Tanner,Marie,TheLastDescendantofAeneas.TheHapsburgsandtheMythicImageoftheEmperor
(NewHavenLondon,1993).
Telesko,Werner,DieVerherrlichungKaiserFerdinandsII.(15781637)ineinemFlugblattdesJahres
1636. Zur Bedeutung von WortBildRelationen in der Graphik des konfessionellen Zeitalters,
MitteilungendesMitteilungendesInstitutsfrsterreichischeGeschichtsforschung,119,34(2011),
pp.331348.
Telesko, Werner, Geschichtsraum sterreich. Die Habsburger und ihre Geschichte in der bildenden
Kunstdes19.Jahrhunderts(ViennaCologneWeimar,2006).
Treichler, Willi, Mittelalterliche Erzhlungen und Anekdoten um Rudolf von Habsburg (Geist und
WerkderZeiten26)(Bern&FrankfurtontheMain,1971).
Vcha,tpn,DerHerrscheraufdemSakralbildzurZeitderGegenreformationunddesBarock.Eine
ikonologischeUntersuchungzurherrschaftlichenReprsentationKaiserFerdinandsII.(Prague,2009).
Vernulaeus,Nicolaus,LaudatiofunebrisAugustissimiImperatorisFerdinandiII.(Louvain,1637).
Vernulaeus,Nicolaus,VirtutesAugustaeGentisAustriacaelibritres(Louvain,1640).
Vocelka, Karl, Glanz und Untergang der hfischen Welt. Reprsentation, Reform und Reaktion im
habsburgischenVielvlkerstaat(sterreichischeGeschichte16991815)(Vienna,2001).
ISBN9789460184833
175

WaddingSJ,Petrus,LaudatiofunebrisdictaaP.PetroWadingo[]FerdinandiSecundiRomanorum
ImperatorisetregisBohemiae(Vienna,1638).
Wandruszka,Adam,Die Religiositt FranzStephansvonLothringen. EinBeitragzur Geschichteder
Pietas Austriaca und zur Vorgeschichte des Josephinismus in sterreich, Mitteilungen des
sterreichischenStaatsarchivs,12(1959),pp.162173.
Weaver, Andrew H., Music in the Service of CounterReformation Politics: The Immaculate
Conception at the Habsburg Court of Ferdinand III (16371657), Music and Letters, 87, 3 (August
2006),pp.361378.
Weaver, Andrew H., Sacred Music as Public Image for Holy Roman Emperor Ferdinand III
RepresentingtheCounterReformationMonarchattheEndoftheThirtyYears'War(Farnham,2012).
Winkelbauer, Thomas, Stndefreiheit und Frstenmacht. Lnder und Untertanen des Hauses
HabsburgimkonfessionellenZeitalter,part2(sterreichischeGeschichte15221699)(Vienna,2003).
Wolfsgruber, Clestin, Das Kaiser FerdinandKruzifix in der k. u. k. Hofburgkapelle in Wien (Vienna,
1903).
Wolfsgruber,Clestin,Diek.u.k.Hofburgkapelleunddiek.u.k.geistlicheHofkapelle(Vienna,1905).
Wurffbain,Leonhartt(Leonhard),VierunterschiedlicheRelationeshistoricae[](Nuremberg,1636).
WurzbachTannenberg,WolfgangRittervon,KatalogmeinerSammlungvonMedaillen,Plakettenund
JetonszugleicheinHandbuchfrSammler,vol.1(Zurich,1943).
Zedinger, Renate, Franz Stephan von Lothringen (17081765). Monarch Manager Mzen
(SchriftenreihedersterreichischenGesellschaftzurErforschungdes18.Jahrhunderts13)(Vienna,
2008).
Ziegler,Hendrik,StatSol. Lunafugit:HansJacobWolrabsJosuaMedailleauf KaiserLeopoldI.und
ihre Rezeption in Frankreich, in Christoph Kampmann, Katharina Krause, EvaBettina Krems &
Anuschka Tischer (ed.), Bourbon Habsburg Oranien. Konkurrierende Modelle im dynastischen
Europaum1700(Cologne,Weimar&Vienna,2008),pp.166181.
Ziegler, Hendrik, Der Sonnenknig und seine Feinde. Die Bildpropaganda Ludwigs XIV. in der Kritik.
Mit einem Vorwort von Martin Warnke und einer franzsischen Zusammenfassung (Petersberg,
2010).
Zimerman,Heinrich(ed.),Inventare,ActenundRegestenausderSchatzkammerdesAllerhchsten
Kaiserhauses, Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen des Allerhchsten Kaiserhauses, 16
(1895),pp.ILIX.
ISBN9789460184833
176

Illustrations
Fig.1Vienna,KunsthistorischesMuseum.
Fig.25Vienna,AustrianNationalLibrary.
Fig.67Photoauthor.

Coreth1982,seealsothebookreviewsbyMarcR.Forster(inTheCatholicHistoricalReview,90,4[2004],pp.
798800) and Andrew L. Thomas (in HGerman, HNet Reviews, January, 2005); a detailed analysis of the
objectivesofCorethsbookisgivenbyWilliamD.BowmaninhisintroductiontotheEnglishedition(2004),pp.
XIXVIII,herep.XII:PietasAustriacaas[]theguidingprincipleoftheHabsburgs,andp.XVII:[]dominant
ruling ideology of the Habsburg familiy. For a summarizing commentary on Pietas Austriaca see Brenger
1993;Vocelka2001,pp.208221;Winkelbauer2003,pp.185239.
2
Alleffortstosharpentheviewoftimeswhen,andregionswhere,PietasAustriacamanifesteditselfinvarying
forms automatically require that more attention must be attached to the personal aims of prominent
representativesofthisspecialkindofpiety,seeforexampleDuerloo1997,pp.118;Duerloo2012.
3
Schnleben 1680, p. 136 (c. VIII, octava praerogativa). The following section deals with the Pietas of the
membersoftheHouseofHabsburgindividuallyandatgreatlength(pp.136213).
4
Samerski2006,pp.251278.
5
Hecht1997,pp.382384.
6
Vernulaeus1640,p.32;seeCoreth1982,p.38;Oberparleiter2007,pp.246252.
7
Kap.IV.(monitum),33;seeCoreth1982,p.38.
8
Coreth1982,p.39;Tanner1993,pp.188190.
9
Pallavicini1649,p.46.Evenlater,AldusRein,BishopofLaibach,inhisfuneralspeechonEmperorFerdinandII
(Rein 1637) (without pagination), referred to Rudolfs legendary investiture with the cross, portraying
FerdinandIIasalterquidamConstantinusMagnus[].ThechapterCultusSS.EucharistiaeofthetreatiseDivi
Ferdinandi II. [] (1737), pp. 1415, relates Emperor Ferdinand II to Rudolf of Habsburg and so does, in
depictedform,thetitlepageofWurffbain1636.
10
Pallavicini1649,pp.4546,seeCoreth1982,p.39.
11
Afterthefire,theEmperorhadthechapelrestoredfirstofallotherrooms.DedicatedtoSaintJoseph,foster
father of Jesus, in 1670, the Kammerkapelle, from 1672 onwards, served as the place where pregnant
empresses were blessed in an official ceremony, see Samerski 2006, p. 268; for references from the
architecturalhistorianspointofviewseeRizzi1997,p.622;MaderKratky2011,pp.437451.
12
Hochadelige und gottselige Versammlung vom Sternkreuze 1960, pp. 3, 20. This publication has been
reprintedseveraltimes.Thelasteditiondatesfrom2008.
13
Vienna,AustrianStateArchives,Haus,HofundStaatsarchiv(inthefollowing:HHStA),ceremonialprotocols
(Zeremonialprotokolle)vol.2(1668),14051406.Thesamedescriptionoftheplaceappearsinthepublication
HochadeligeundgottseligeVersammlungvomSternkreuze1839,p.3.ThefoundingoftheOrderoftheStarry
Cross,ontheotherhand,isnotmentionedinanyoftheceremonialprotocols.
14
HHStA,collectionKos,box1,fol.22v.
15
Rome,BibliothecaCasanatense,Cod.2044;seeStarzer1891,pp.153154.
16
Coreth 1982, pp. 4243; Bandion 1989, pp. 8384; cast into legendary form, the event is reported in
VersammlungvomSternkreuze1839,pp.37,andalsoinKastnerMichalitschke1909,pp.1822.
17
Works of medal art commissioned by Ferdinand IIIand inspired by his motto Pietate et Iustitiaare
characterised by distinct references to the cross, too, see WurzbachTannenberg I 1943, p. 323, nos. 2008,
2009;fordetailsconcerningFerdinandIIIsspecialdevotiontoMaria,theMotherofGod,seeWeaver2006;
Weaver2012.
18
Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum, The Ecclesiastical Treasury, inv. no. D 25, see LeitheJasper &
Distelberger 1998, p. 86 (fig.); Seipel 2007, pp. 108109, no. 42. A detailed description of the history of the
monstrance and its creation from various parts that had been at hand will be given in volume 1 of the new
collection catalogue of Viennas Ecclesiastical Treasury, which is presently being prepared (the author is
ISBN9789460184833
177

grateful to Dr. Franz Kirchweger from the Kunstkammer of Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, for this
information).
19
Theorderwasconfirmedbythepopeonthe28July1668.
20
Coreth1982,p.43.AnelaborateaccountofEleonoraMagdalenasvirtuesgivesBrean1720.
21
KeeperoftheoldestmemberregisteristheprivatelyrunarchiveoftheStarryCrossOrderinVienna:The
AlbumNobilium Cruciferarum Deren Hochadelichen Creutz Frauen, so in den CreutzOrden angenommen und
eingeschriebenseindtlists1035entriesforthetimefrom1686to1739.Acompletedirectorylistingthefilesin
thearchive(16681936)iskeptinHHStA,registryAB303a.
22
Inthecourseoftimetheheraldicdesignoftheinsignia(arrangementandnumberofeagles)wouldchange.
The insignia of Empress Eleonore Gonzaga, first Grand Mistress of the Order, was the only one that showed
foureagles.TheIHSsignatthepointwherethebeamsofthecrossintersect(withthenailsofthecross)does
not appear until the third Grand Mistress, Empress Amalie Wilhelmine (16731742), see Hochadelige und
gottseligeVersammlungvomSternkreuzgenannt1805,copperplateengravingafterp.160.
23
LnigII/21720,p.1161.
24
Manni1671.
25
Ibid.,pp.118.
26
Ibid.,pp.3745.
27
Ibid.,pp.4653.
28
Ibid.,pp.159386.
29
SeeVersammlungvomSternkreuze1839,p.23.
30
Coreth1982,p.43,n.101.ThestatutesarelistedinVersammlungvomSternkreuze1839,pp.2234.One
sectionofthispublication(pp.35115)namesthedreivorzglichstenFesttagederhochadeligenVersammlung:
ConstantinesvictoryandHelenasfindingoftheTrueCross(on3May),theElevationoftheHolyCross(on14
September),andthedaywhentheBlessedSacramentisexposedforvenerationinthecourtchapel(onthelast
ThursdaythatprecedesPalmSunday).
31
Manni 1671,p. 76. The prayer is also an integral part of the ceremonial formula spoken by the candidate
when accepting the Order, see Lnig II/2 1720, p. 1161; Versammlung vom Sternkreuze 1839, p. 23; Coreth
1982,p.43,n.101.
32
For instance, pp. 168169 (holy Kunigunde) and pp. 666667 (holy Hedwig von Andechs), see here also
similarHabsburgtraditionsofthesixteenthcentury:Irblich1996,pp.142148,nos.29,30(chronicles,Jakob
Mennel, 1518); Silver 2008, pp. 37, 59f. Besides, Schnleben points out to relations between the Habsburgs
and Roman Emperor Constantine, see also Coreth 1982, p. 39, and, for basic information, Quednau 2007;
Hoppe2012,p.177(lit.).
33
Kitlitschka1970,p.216,fig.181,182;Fassbinder1979,catalogue,pp.2324,no..I/15;Graff2000,pp.91
95;recently:Schicht&Telesko2007.
34
Coreth1982,pp.4041;seeSturmberger1957,pp.3944.
35
Wolfsgruber1903,pp.1314;Gugitz1952,pp.100101,no.83;Kretschmer1978,pp.67(lit.);Coreth1982,
pp.4041;Bsel2006,pp.226227.
36
Bsel 2006, pp. 226227, fig. 3; see Vienna, Austrian National Library, Image collection, LW 73943C, LW
74299C; Nuremberg, German National Museum, graphics collection, inv. no. HB 19.207, see also The
banishmentoftheProtestants,afresco(1619)intheVillaPoggioImperialeatFlorence:Hoppe2012,p.174,
fig.96;concerningthecultoftheHolyCrossduringthereignofFerdinandII:Vcha2009,pp.6889.
37
Already Lamormaini 1638, pp. 1114 (German edition, chapter II), reported that the crucified Christ had
spoken to the monarch on various occasions, however Lamormaini keeps the validity of this famous legend
open: Mir ist nicht unbewust [sic!], das [sic!] dazumalen haimblich und ffentlich von vielen gesagt worden,
ChristushabeaueinemCrucifixmitFerdinandogeredet,undgesagetersolleguetHertzunndHoffnunghaben.
Ichkan[sic!]aberhiervonwederjanochnainsagen.[],seealsoCoreth1982,p.41;fordetailedinformation
on the various Virtutes editions see Brockmann 2011, p. 19, n. 20. In Bratislava a now destroyed cycle of
paintingsinthepalace(wheredecorationworkstarted1638)includedPaulJuvenels(15791643)depictionof
EmperorFerdinandIIsencounterwithKingDavidsingingthepsalms,seePolleross1995,p.234,fig.2.There
aregoodreasonswhythissubjectmatterusedtobeofalmostundiminishedrelevanceintheHabsburgareas
untilfarintothenineteenthcentury;seeTelesko2006,pp.180,338,fig.10;377.
38
Lauro2007,pp.184185(fig.).
39
SeeErichsen,Heinemann&Janis2007,pp.228229(fig.).
ISBN9789460184833
178

40
Khevenhller1726,pp.23852389(text),pp.23882389(copperplateengraving).Comparedtothepicture,
thetext(column2387)reportsonthecircumstancesofthemonarchsdialoguewithChristwithmuchmore
reservation;forbasicinformationseeHargittay2001,p.285.
41
Wadding1638(withoutpagination).InthenonpaginatedtextofthesermonwhichtheJesuitFerdinandus
MontegnanawroteontheoccasionofthedeathofFerdinandII(Montegnana1637),thedeceasedisreferred
to as fortis Athleta Ferdinandus: in doing so, the author alludes to Paulinian terminology (1 Kor., 9:2526; 2
Kor.,10:35),ontheonehand,andtothehonorarytitlewhichpopeshadgranted,sincethefifteenthcentury,
foroutstandingmeritsindefenceoftheChristianfaith,ontheotherhand.
42
Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum, The Ecclesiastical Treasury, inv. no. E 36, see Bsel 2006, p. 225, n. 1
(lit.).In1740JakobvanSchuppen,thenheadofViennasAcademyofFineArts,commissionedareplicaofthe
crucifix,seeKretschmer1978,p.29.
43
Nachdeme Ihro Knigl:e Mayl: das Wunderthtige Crucifix des Heyl:n Caroli Borromoi, Welches zu Weyl:
Kayser Ferdinands2.do dieWorte Non Te deseramgesprochen, und bishero in der geistlichenSchazCammer
aufgehobengewesen,IhroKnigl:eMayl:aberausbesonderenAndachtsEyffernachPresburg,undvondannen
wiederumnacherWienninderoCammerberbringenlassen,zurVenerationinderoKnigl:eCammerCapellen
bereitsvor14.Tgenauffdendaselbstbefindl:nLeopoldiAltar(fol.422v)offentl:aussetzenlassen.inHHStA,
ceremonialprotocols[Zeremonialprotokolle]vol.18[17411742],fol.422rv,5January1742;seeWolfsgruber
1903, p. 15; Coreth 1982, p. 41. Even the unpaginated leaflet of Dornn (about 1745) is commenting the
importantroleofthecrucifixofemperorFerdinand.Aftertheyear1755adonationofaparticleoftheHoly
Crossisrecorded,seeZimerman1895,III,nr.12617.
44
Wolfsgruber1903,p.16;Wolfsgruber1905,p.252;Schmal2001,p.207.
45
Coreth1982,p.41;Schmal2001,pp.207208,218;forvisualdepictionsofthesubjectseevariousexamples
intheimagecollectionoftheNationalLibraryofAustriainVienna:LW74078CandLW74298C.
46
Coreth1982,p.41.
47
OfessentialimportanceinthiscontextisthechangeinLeopoldsiconographyfromanemperortoanew
Joshua,seeSchumann2003,p.328,fig.33(medal,HansJacobWolrab,1686);Ziegler2008;Ziegler2010,pp.
6473,fig.48a/b.
48
Ribadeneira1590,p.39(bookI,chapter10)[Nontedeseram,nequederelinquam];seeKnigNordhoff1982
(adindicem).InthedivergentopinionofBsel2006,pp.227228,thiseventisconnectedwithSt.IgnatiusLa
Stortavisionof1537;theevidenceisinsufficientinsofarasitlacksadirectreferencetothepassageinthe
LettertotheHebrews.
49
Vienna, Image collection of the National Library of Austria, NB 740.032C, 740.087B, and 740.088B;
Nuremberg,GermanNationalMuseum,graphicscollection,inv.no.HB18.663;foranelaboratediscussionof
thepamphletseeTelesko2011.
50
ForbasicinformationseeBireley1981,p.15.
51
This motto was revived in the interior decoration of Pressburg castle, made under the reign of emperor
FerdinandIII(before1647,destroyed1747),publishedinHerrgott&Heer1760,pl.CIV.
52
SeeTreichler1971,p.49,no.9(withagoodrecordofusedsources).Thethirdroominthetreasuryofthe
Benedictine monastery of Lambach in Upper Austria has a fresco which one of the painter brothers
Grabenberger is likely to have created around 1700 and which combines the scene of Ferdinand saying his
prayerinfrontofthecrucifixwiththatofRudolfvonHabsburggrippingthecrossinsteadofthesceptre,see
Hainisch1959,pp.141142,fig.123.Vernulaeus1637,pp.29,3233,emphasizestherelevanceoftheDivina
ProvidentiaanddescribesFerdinandIIasanimitatoroftheimperialmottoofemperorMaximilianII,Dominus
providebit.SeeherealsotheJesuitPanegyricusobvictoriamBohemicamAugustissimoImperatoriFerdinando
II.dictus1621,p.29.
53
Telesko2011,pp.341342,fig.4.
54
How much emphasis was put particularly on the issue of continuity in traditional forms of piety for the
purpose of historic argumentation becomes evident, in the same context, from Eucharius Gottlieb Rincks
famous narrative description of the life of Emperor Leopold I and the formers reference to the legendary
momentwhenRudolfI,newlyelectedking,grippednotthesceptrebutthecross,seeRinckI21709,p.98,see
Coreth1982,p.44.
55
TheissueofProvidentiaisshowntobeofcentralimportanceparticularlyinconnectionwithFerdinandIIin
Montegnana 1637be it to make Gods rule appear superior to personal ambition (non voluntate sua [scil.
regarding the emperor Ferdinand, W.T.], sed divinae Providentiae consilio), or be it to recommend the
deceasedtofuturegenerationsasanadmirableexampleofgodlyprovidence(quemdemumimmortalisDeus
ISBN9789460184833
179

insingulareProvidentiaesuaeexemplummundoexhibuit,tottantisquerebus,adomniumaetatum,omnisque
posteritatis admirationem, illustrem). Later on, the Viennese author of the treatise Phosphori Austriaci sive
compendiosaeHistoriaedeAugustissimaeDomusAustriacaeOrigine,MagnitudineetPotentialibriduo1699,p.
245,voicespraiseofFerdinandsmeritsbyreferringtohimasagodlike(!)prince:FerdinandusII.Imp.hicest
illeDiissimiliorPrinceps,quamhominibus.;theissueofProvidentiaisdiscussedindetailinKusternig2007,
pp.553556;Strohmeyer2009,p.81.
56
Khler2001,p.1214.UndiminishedbeliefinProvidentiaanditsinfluencewasexpressedstilllaterbyMaria
Theresia,seeSchmal2001,p.212;inaletterbyMariaTheresiatoherdaughterMarieChristine,writtenbefore
August1765:esgeschiehtohnehinnurdas,wasdieVorsehungberunsverhngt.
57
PrincepsinCompendio.Hocest,Punctaaliquotcompendiosa,quaecircagubernationemReipub.observanda
videntur1668;reprintedinRedlich1906,pp.820;seealsoSturmberger1965,pp.9899;Bosbach&Repgen
1991,pp.79114;Augustin,Hengerer,Mayr,Schnadenberger&Voegele2008.
58
Princeps in Compendio, 16 (punctum I), pp. 56: Denique in negotiis gravioribus & magis arduis non
intermittet specialiter ad Deum recurrere, atque eadem viris piis & religiosis in preces & sacrificia
commendare.,seeinthiscontextalsothetreatiseOrientisoccidentisqueimperiumFerdinandiII.Imperatoris
auspiciis conjungendum [] (1627), in which the author Otto Fridericus Comes a Buchaim, an official at the
imperialcourt,addressesthemonarchinthreeodesnamedReligio,BellonaandFortuna.
59
TheruleofEmperorFranzI.Stephan(from1745to1765)apparentlycoincidedwitharenunciationofthe
principles of Pietas Austriaca and thus of the veneration of the cross, due to changes in the religious
orientation,seeWandruszka1959,p.170;Zedinger2008,pp.266268.
60
Lorenz1999,p.20,fig.9;Polleross2010,p.154.
61
It was because of the attached connotation of numerous future progeny why the authors of Habsburg
panegyricsrepeatedlyusedthispassageintheirtexts,seeforexampleAvancini1673(withoutpagination).See
herealsothefrequentuseofbiblicalquotationswithreferenceto1Tim4:8:Lebzelter1701.
62
p.[2].
63
p.[1].
64
SeeLorenz1999,pp.633634,no.334(fig.).
65
Vol.1,pp.6566.
66
Seeherealso:AppuhnRadtke2005,p.110(withreferencetoSolAustriacus,1698,Vienna,NationalLibrary,
ofAustria,Cod.8617,fol.3r,andthequotationofGen.1:16).
67
MultifunctionalityinthiscontextalsomeansthatthewaysinwhichPietasAustriacawasmanifestedcould
serveasaplatformofargumentationinthesenseofdeliveringcompetingnarrativesonnationalandregional
levels,seeforthispurposeDucreux1999,andalsoundertheheadingDecentralizingPietasAustriaca:Ducreux
2011.
68
Ducreux2011,pp.278279.
ISBN9789460184833
180
EngenderingPietasAustriaca
TheVillaPoggioImperialeinFlorenceunderMariaMaddalenaofAustria*
IlariaHoppe

The magnificent decoration of the Villa Poggio Imperiale in Florence long made it one of the citys
most important attractions. When it ceased to serve as an aristocratic residence in the nineteenth
century, the villa and its history gradually began to sink into oblivion. This is equally true of
Archduchess Maria Maddalena of Austria, Grand Duchess of Tuscany, the originator of the
commissiontoredesignthevillaatthebeginningoftheseventeenthcentury.Researchershavelong
neglectedthishistoricalfigurebecauseherpiousreligiositydidnotappeartofitinwiththeimageof
the Medici as seemingly enlightened Renaissance rulers. Gaetano Pieraccini, one of the most
influential biographers of the family, described her as a religious zealot, egoistical, and lacking in
intellectandculture,andthisledhertobeignoredbothasapatronandpolitician.1Theshiftinthe
historicalassessmentoftheCatholicReformandresearchintowomensparticipationinit,haveled
to an entirely new perspective upon the biography of Maria Maddalena.2 It was precisely her
religiousness that proved to be the key to understanding the function and decoration of Poggio
Imperialeasanimpressivesettingforcourtactivity,where,inkeepingwithamodernunderstanding,
secularandsacredaswellasprivateandpublicspheresconstantlyinformedoneanother.3
Between1621and1624ArchduchessMariaMaddalenaofAustriacommissionedtheedifice
formerlyknownasVillaBaroncellitobelargelyrebuiltforthefirsttime.4Workbeganfollowingthe
death of her husband Grand Duke Cosimo II de Medici in 1621, when she became regent in the
name of her underage son, Ferdinando II de Medicitogether with her motherinlaw, Grand
DuchessChristineofLorraine,andafourmemberFlorentinecouncil.Althoughtheyounggrandduke
wasimmediatelyformallyenthroned,thesetwowomenactivelymanagedtheaffairsofStateuntilhe
turned eighteen in 1628.5 Within this constellation, Grand Duchess Christine remained very
influential, even after the death of her son;6 however, her daughterinlaw managed to
commandinglystagetheregencyintheinterestofherselfandFerdinandoIIbymeansoftheartsand
aningeniousceremonial.
LocationandarchitectureofPoggioImperiale
ThelocationofPoggioImperialealreadysuggeststhatthevillawasnotonlyaplaceforrelaxation,
but also a setting for the regents political activities. Through the purchase of further estates, the
ISBN9789460184833
181
propertycametoreachallthewaytotheBoboliGardensandthustotheprimaryresidenceofthe
Medici,thePalazzoPitti(fig.1).7Theacquiredpropertiesalsopermittedthecourtarchitect,Giulio
Parigi,toinstallamonumental,steeplyinclinedavenue,whichisstillpreservedtoday,andissituated
at right angles to the grand viale of the Boboli Gardens. A symbolic relationship between the
residenceswasthusestablishedbymeansoftheseaxes,whichbothopenontothePiazzadiPorta
Romana. There must also have been other routes connecting the two estates, because the court
chronicle of Cesare Tinghi relates that a guest of the regent made his way incognito from Poggio
Imperiale via the Boboli Gardens and the Corridoio Vasariano to his guest quarters in the Palazzo
Vecchio,theformerseatoftheMedicisontheothersideoftheArno.8Thisrevealsthattheseatof
the Mediciandtheregentspowerstretchedacrossthe city.AlthoughPoggioImperialesuggestsa
reclusivevillasuburbanaonthehillofArcetri,itwasnonethelesslinkedtotheofficialgovernment
buildingsoftheMediciinvariousways.

Fig.1LocationoftheVillaPoggioImperialeinFlorence.
The building itself has undergone several campaigns of remodelling that have altered its
appearancecompletely.Withtheaidofhistoricalveduteandpreviouslyneglectedsourcematerial,
thereconstructionofthevillaunderthepatronageoftheregenthasbecomepossible.Theimperial
doubleheaded eagle and the combined coat of arms of the MediciHabsburg alliance, found in a
sculpturalensembleatthefootofthehill,alreadysetthestageforentranceintotherealmofMaria
Maddalena (fig. 2).9 The sometimes more and sometimes less subtle play with references to both
dynastiesissetforthinthedesignofthefacadeandinthenameofthevilla.AlfonsoParigi,theson
of the court architect Giulio, created an illustration for the libretto of the 1625 performance of La
liberazionediRuggierodallisoladiAlcinainhonourofWladyslawofPoland,sonofKingSigismundIII
andnephew oftheregent:this image providesthe essentialsourceforreconstructing thestateof
the faade at that point in time (fig. 3).10 The more or less nondescript fifteenthcentury villa had
ISBN9789460184833
182
been transformed into a modern, early Baroque estate with cour dhonneur and belvedere. The
understatedarticulationofthefaade,withbandsalongtheboundariesandopeningsofthewalls,is
consistentwiththearchitecturaltraditionofMediceanvillasandsignalizestheirownershipevenata
considerable distance. Nonetheless, the monumental coat of arms and inscription over the portal
clearlyidentifytheowneroftheresidence.Thisismadeapparentthroughtheuseofthedoublecoat
of arms and the inscription, which is still known today and which links the villa topos with a
dedication:Lettheimperialvilla,whichwasgivenitsnamebytheexaltedAustrians,eternallyserve
the otium and pleasure of the future Grand Duchesses of Etruria.11 After construction was
completedin1624,theregentrechristenedtheformerVillaBaroncelliasPoggioImperiale(imperial
seat)bymeansofanirreversibleedictandthusprovidedafurtherreferencetoherlineage.12While
itistruethatMariaMaddalenacamefromacadetbranchoftheHabsburgswhichwasresidentin
Graz, it was this line that provided the emperor after 1619, when her brother Ferdinand II was
elected. The result was a direct link to the royal house of the emperor: alongside religious motifs,
imperialiconographywasoneofthekeyelementsinthearchduchesssselfpresentationatPoggio
Imperiale.

Fig.2MarcoCredoandFrancescodeCocchi,FormerentrancetoVillaPoggioImperiale,
Florence,BibliotecaMarucelliana,1652.

Fig.3AlfonsoParigi,VillaPoggioImperiale,Florence,GabinettoDisegniestampe,Uffizi,1625
(Soprintendenzaperibeniambientaliearchitettonici,Gabinettofotografico,PalazzoPitti).
ISBN9789460184833
183
Theroomsandtheirdecoration
MyanalysisofCesareTinghiscourtchronicleandthe1625inventoryofthevillamadeitpossibleto
reconstruct the rooms and their decoration and to reestablish the nature of their original
functions.13 The inventory lists a large number of paintings on the walls of the interior courtyard
surrounded by loggias (fig. 4, no. 1): these consist primarily of still lifes and animal paintings, in
keeping with the ideal of the vita rustica. There were also sculptures and ancient busts of Roman
emperorsandempresses,whichweresetonpedestalsbearingtheHabsburgcoatofarms.14Several
of these busts have been preserved in situ; however, their bases are from a later phase in the
palacesdecoration(fig.5).Theseriesoriginallycontinuedonbothintothehallofthegroundfloor
(fig.4,no.3)andintothegallerythatsurroundedthecourtyardattheleveloftheupperstorey.15

Fig.4VillaPoggioImperiale,Florence,Groundfloorplan,reconstructionof1625.
ISBN9789460184833
184

Fig.5VillaPoggioImperiale,Florence.PhotographofthepresentstateoftheInnercourtyard
(Soprintendenzaperibeniambientaliearchitettonici,Gabinettofotografico,PalazzoPitti).
TheroomsofFerdinandoIIdeMedici
The apartments of Maria Maddalena and her son Ferdinando extended to the right of the
courtyard,withtheapartmentofthelatterconsistingonlyofanantechamberandbedchamber(fig.
4,nos.14and15).Hisroomswereprovidedwithanofficialcharacterprimarilythroughthefrescoes
ofthelunettesandtheceiling,whichwereexecutedbyvariousFlorentinepainters.16Theydepictthe
heroicdeedsofHabsburgemperorsthemaleancestorsofhismother.Asinalloftheotherrooms,
everysceneislinkedtoapersonifiedvirtueandtoaninscription,whichhistoricallyandallegorically
conveythesignificanceofthedepictednarrative.Chronologically,thegenealogicalsequencebegins
in the former bedchamber (fig. 4, no. 14) with the fresco by Matteo Rosselli representing the
foundingmythoftheHabsburgdynasty:theLegendofRudolphIandthePriest(fig.15).Theother
imagesdepicttheBaronsOathofAllegiancetoRudolphI,whoisaddressedhereasemperor,and
thedeedsofEmperorMaximilianI(TheSentencingofHansPienzenauerin1504andMaximilianIat
Battle).Intheformerantechamberoftheyounggrandduke(fig.4,no.15),twolunettesaredevoted
tothevictoriesofCharlesVovertheTurks(SiegeofViennain1529andConquestofTunis)andtwo
further images depict the famous deeds of Emperor Ferdinand II, brother of the regent and
namesake of her son Ferdinando II. Each of these frescoes takes a current political event as its
theme: the Battle of the White Mountain, fought near Prague in 1620, and the expulsion of the
ProtestantsfromInnerAustriaduringtheforciblereCatholicizingofthisterritorythroughArchduke
Ferdinand,beginningin1596(fig.6).FeaturingthemesthatareuniqueinthehistoryofItalianart,
the sequence of Habsburg emperors presents the young grand duke and heir to the throne with a
ISBN9789460184833
185
dynasticgenealogical mirror for princes; however, it is unconventionally based not on his agnatic
lineage, but on the house of his mother, which was far superior to that of the Medici in terms of
dynastic rank. The scenes illustrate essential virtues of male rulerssuch as military successin
combination with Pietas Austriaca, the typically Habsburg piety that is explicitly thematized here
throughthePietasEucharisticaofRudolphIandthroughtheFiducemincrucemChristiofEmperor
FerdinandII.17

Fig.6MatteoRosselliandMichelangeloCinganelli,ArchdukeFerdinandbanishestheProtestants,
Florence,VillaPoggioImperiale,formerantechamberofFerdinand,162324.
ThechambersofMariaMaddalenaofAustria
All of the other rooms in this wing were for the use of the regent Maria Maddalena. With
theirfrescoprogrammeoffamouswomen,thehall,antechamber,andbedchamber(fig.4,nos.3,4
and13)formapendanttothedecorationofhersonsrooms.18Thelongandexemplarytraditionof
female Christian rulers of the empire is displayed in the hall (fig. 4, no. 3): alongside Matilda of
Tuscany, conceptual predecessor of Maria Maddalena as regent of Tuscany, we find the first two
femaleregentsoftheEasternandWesternRomanempires,GallaPlacidiaandPulcheria(fig.7).With
theexceptionofStCatherineofAlexandria,whoservesasafemaleexemplumfortheteachingsof
the Church (dottrina) and apostolic activity, every other heroine depicted in the hall can be traced
backtoeithertherealorthefictivegenealogyoftheHabsburgs.Thismayeasilyberecognizedinthe
case of Isabella the Catholic, who presents Christopher Columbus with his commanders baton, or
Isabella of Portugal, whose canonization had received the personal support of the regent and her
sisterMargaretofAustria,QueenofSpain.19ConstanceofAragonandtheHolyRomanEmpressSt
Cunigunde were two equally renowned female ancestors; they are each flanked by putti with
armour,whichmakereferencetothelegendoftheoriginsoftheHabsburgcoatofarmsduringthe
thirdcrusadeandemphasizethedynasticcontext(fig.8).20Myresearchhasalsorevealedthatthe
ISBN9789460184833
186
collectivevitaDeClarismulierbusdomusHabsburgicae,writtenbyJakobMennelduringthereignof
Emperor Maximilian I, begins with Clotilde as a grandmother of the Habsburg rulers21thus
providing an explanation for the presence of the first Christian queen of France in the Poggio
Imperialegalleryofheroines.ThisisalsotrueofStUrsula,anotheraristocraticsaintappropriatedby
the Habsburgs.22 The genealogical construct was surely the main reason why a theatrical
presentation of the life of the saint was performed in the Uffizi during the 1624 visit of Archduke
Karl,MariaMaddalenasbrother,andthe1625visitofWladyslaw,herPolishnephew.23Onthestage,
asinthefresco,theregentsfemaleforebearwaspresentedasamodelofpietyandselfsacrifice,
whotriumphedovertheenemiesofChristianitythroughthepowerofherfaith.

Fig.7MatteoRosselli,MatildaofTuscanyandGallaPlacidia,Florence,HallofVillaPoggioImperiale,1624.

Fig.8FilippoTarchiani,ConstanceofAragon,Florence,HallofVillaPoggioImperiale,1624.
On the whole, the exemplary figures of the hall indicate both the legitimate succession of
female sovereigns in the Holy Roman Empire and the positive effects of their rule upon the well
beingoftheirsubjectsthroughboththeirlegaciesandtheirpiety.TheyareapartoftheHabsburg
constructofastirpsregiaetbeata:presentedaspredestinedtoruleonthe basisofdivineright.24
Furthermore, the selection of heroines succeeds in adeptly shifting between a dynastic genealogy
and one based on salvation history, between militant and pious heroines that illustrate a great
ISBN9789460184833
187
number of rulers virtues in combination with desirable feminine attributes, such as modesty and
beauty.

Fig.9MatteoRosselli,Semiramis,Florence,VilladellaPetraia,1623(Soprintendenzapolomusealefiorentino).
This balance between behaviour conforming to and transgressing gender discourse equally
appliestothefourlargeformatpaintingsfeaturingantiqueheroines,whichwerealsoincludedinthe
decoration of the hall. Semiramis (fig. 9), Lucretia, Artemisia and Sophonisba form an independent
groupwithintheprogrammeoffamouswomen,whichisotherwiseorganizedaccordingtoepochs
of salvation history.25 On the one hand, they represent the virtues of marital fidelity and of self
sacrificeforthesakeoftheinterestsofthestate;ontheother,theyareexemplaryregentswhoas
in the case of Semiramiscould also exhibit militant qualities. Through the alternation in
composition and narrative, the images deal with gender discourse and the question of power. The
paintingsdisplaypositiveexamplesoffemalerulers;however,itisalwaysonlyinsituationsofcrisis
that they intervene for the wellbeing of their subjects, and they do not fundamentally call the
genderorderintoquestion.
Adepictionoftheemperorsandgranddukescrownsarealsoincludedinthedecorationof
the hall, as well as an allegory of government on the central ceiling panel, which, according to my
interpretation, represents the virtue of fortitudo, accompanied by the attributes of imperial and
papalpower(fig.10).26Theseimagesdepictanassociationofsecularandsacredpowerunitedinthe
ideals of rule by divine right and universal monarchy, and this proves defining for the entire
programme: at Poggio Imperiale, the subject of famous women and men is linked both to the
translatioimperii,claimedbytheHabsburgs,andtothePietasAustriaca,thetopicalsacralizationof
thedynasty.
ISBN9789460184833
188

Fig.10FilippoTarchiani,CeilingfrescowithFortitudo,
Florence,HallofVillaPoggioImperiale,162324.
Theprogrammeiscontinuedintheformerantechamberoftheregentsapartments(fig.4,
no.13)withOldTestamentheroineswhointervenedaschampionsofGodonbehalfoftheirpeople,
such as Judith, Jael and Esther, or who ensured a legitimate succession with the help of divine
providence,suchasRebeccaorthedaughterofPharaoh.27Advancingtothenextleveloftypological
status, the former bedchamber of Maria Maddalena (fig. 4, no. 4) depicts early Christian virgin
martyrs.28TheonlyexceptionisprovidedbytheimageofthefindingoftheTrueCrossbyStHelena,
anothercanonizedfemalerulertobeappropriatedfortheHouseofHabsburg(fig.11).29Thevirgin
martyrs provided the widow regent with a desexualized life model for her bedchamberone that
permittedhertocompensatefortheabsenceofmasculinereproductionandcontrol.Thenarratives
couldalsoprovideastimulustoreligiousmeditation,assuggestedbythemartyrologythatNiccol
Lorini dedicated to Maria Maddalena, which includes detailed discussions of all the saints in the
frescoes.30 They also function as typological figurations of Christ: the depicted martyrdoms make
themapartofsalvationhistoryandthuspointtothesalvationthroughthepassionofChrist.TheSt
Helena fresco thus establishes a dynastic and theological link that communicates the special
significanceoftheTrueCrossfortheHabsburgs.31MariaMaddalenaalsolinkedthissignificancevery
concretely to her own person: in 1616, she discovered an ostensible relic of the True Cross in
Imprunetaanddonatedapreciousreliquarytohouseit.32Beyondtheelevationofherownstatus,
heridentificationwiththishistoricalfigurealsoinvolvedtheruleofStHelenasson:Constantine,the
first Christian emperor, also provided an allusion related to the young Ferdinando II de Medici.
ISBN9789460184833
189
Finally,asaChristianempressandsaint,Helenaprovidedthethematiclink tothefemalerulersof
thehall,permittingtheentireprogrammetofunctionasatimelesscycleofsalvationhistory.

Fig.11DomenicoPugliani,TheFindingoftheTrueCrossbyStHelena,Florence,
VillaPoggioImperiale,formerbedchamberofMariaMaddalenaofAustria,162324.
Until now, the decoration of the rooms of mother and son have always been considered
separately, without taking into account the rooms functional roles or the relevance of Poggio
Imperiale as the residence of the head of state during the regency. It is only by viewing them in
combinationandbytracingthefemalefiguresassociationwiththegenealogyofthefemaleheadof
the household that we can recognize the link to the male genealogywhich, for its part, also
emphatically presents the high birth of Maria Maddalena and claims it for her son. Although the
techniqueoffrescopaintingandtheillustrationofheroicdeedsinnarrativescenesaredeeplyrooted
inFlorentineartistictradition,thecyclescontentdiffersprofoundlyfromthedynasticcyclesofthe
Medici,forexample,inthePalazzoVecchioortheCasinoMediceo,whereonlythemalemembersof
therelativelyyoungdynastyarerepresented.33TheprogrammeinPoggioImperialeemphasizesthe
ancientnessofthelineage,itssacralizationthroughthesaintsitincludes,anditsconstantdedication
to the support of the Catholic faith and a united empire. The Medicis efforts focused more on
compensating for their lowly dynastic rank by means of motifs related to their achievement of
nobilitythroughvirtueandtoarmaetlitterae:aprogrammeofthistypewasalsorealizedinthevilla.
TheVolticinaandotherrooms
In memory of her deceased husband, Maria Maddalena commissioned the decoration of a
gallerywithaccesstothegarden:itsvaultedceiling,thesourceofthenameVolticina,depictsthe
diplomaticandmilitarysuccessesofGrandDukeCosimoII(fig.4,no.7).34Asinanancientpantheon
ofgreatmen,theroomsdecorationincludedeightstatuesplacedinnichesandanabundanceofart
objects. This classicizing character continues in the adjacent, small interior court, which includes a
grotto(fig.4,no.8)whereadditionalantiquepiecesweredisplayed.Achapelwithasecretexit(fig.
4,no.9)alsobelongedtothegroundfloorapartmentsoftheregentandherson.Thepresenceof
ISBN9789460184833
190
Jacopo Ligozzis panel painting of the St Francis receiving the divine enfant from the Madonna
(Florence, Palazzo Pitti, Galleria Palatina) in the chapel is documented. The smaller rooms located
behindthechapelwerereservedformoreintimatepurposes.Thestairsledtothemezzanineandto
a so called secret room of the regent, mentioned as such in the inventory and which featured a
collection of miniature sculpture, objects of precious materials, sea shells and corals etc.35 The
presenceofaBibleinanelaborateshelfwithinthistinyartchamberandcabinetofwonderisagaina
clearsignofthegreatpietyoftheregent.

Fig.12OttavioVanniniandothers,Volticina,Ceilingfrescowiththedeeds
ofCosimoIIdeMedici,Florence,VillaPoggioImperiale,1623/24.
The opposite wing (fig. 4, nos. 1928) was reserved for guests; its hall was decorated with
portraitsofthefamilyofMariaMaddalenaandwithhistorypaintings.36Thedispositionoftherooms
of the first storey corresponded to that of the level below. An additional gallery, with busts of
emperorsandportraitsofrulersfromthehousesofMediciandHabsburg,surroundedtheinterior
courtyard.Asonthegroundfloor,thisledtoasuiteformotherandsonandanadditionalchapel;the
opposite side housed an apartment for the coregent, the Grand Duchess Christine of Lorraine.37
Hereagain,theinventorydocumentsanabundanceofpaintings.Itremainsunclearwhetherornot
there were frescoes here, because the first storey was heavily altered at a later point in time. The
secondstoreycontainedtheroomsoftheheirtothethronessiblingsandofothermembersofthe
entourage.38
ISBN9789460184833
191

Fig.13JustusSustermans,MariaMaddalenaofAustriaas
StMaryMagdalene,Florence,PalazzoPitti,GalleriaPalatina,
before1625.
Thecollection
Particularlyonthegroundfloor,butelsewhereaswell,theroomsofPoggioImperialewere
decorated with a luxurious and diverse array of artworks.39 To this purpose, the regent had whole
series of paintings from the collections of the Medici transferred to Poggio Imperiale, purchased a
greatnumberofworksthroughagents,andalsocommissionednewworksherself.40Imagesofher
namesaint,MaryMagdalene,wereclearlyemphasizedinthecollectionandwerespreadthroughout
theentirehouse,markingthesovereignterritoryofthearchduchesslikeasystemofsigns.Sheeven
had herself painted by Justus Sustermans in the garments of the penitent hermit (fig. 13).41 The
paraphernaliaofasceticismandmeditationaredepictedplainly.Thearchduchesspubliclypresented
herinnerpietyinthisreligiousidealportraitwhichidentifiedherwithhernamesaint,mergingthe
imagesofrulerandsaint.Thedescriptionintheinventorymakesitpossibletosituatethispaintingin
the midst of the dynastic portrait gallery of the first storey.42 Placement and theme make Maria
ISBN9789460184833
192
Maddalenasselfconcept asholyruler clear:thisis bluntlydisplayedandthusbecomes capableof

fulfillingapoliticalpurposeaswell.43Throughthesacralizationofherbody,heregivendirectvisual
expression,theregentlegitimatesherrulewhichwasfarfromuncontroversialbypointingtoher
pietyanddivinecalling.44Thecycleoffrescoeshasalreadyprovedtobeagenderedformulationof
the Pietas Austriaca and its most important characteristics: the Pietas Eucharistica, the Fiducem in
crucem Christi, and the veneration of the saintsparticularly those of the fictive genealogy of the
Habsburgs. Only the Pietas Mariana is absent. Instead, the regent instigated a Pietas Maria
Magdalenae and embodied saint and ruler in personal union. This personalized cult was,
furthermore,easilyassociatedwiththelocalvenerationofMariaMaddalenadePazzi,aFlorentine
mysticwhosecanonizationwasstronglysupportedbytheMediciandthearchduchessherself.45
PoggioImperialeasresidenceoftheregent
The regent thus spared neither expense nor effort in decorating her villa suburbana until it could
stand comparison with contemporary Medici building complexes. It was certainly true that Poggio
Imperialealsoservedher,herentourage,andherguestsfortheenjoymentofrusticpleasures,just
aspromisedbythededication:localpeasantgirlswereinvitedtodance,andhuntsandoutingson
horseback were organized.46 In addition, smaller parties were entertained by means of chamber
musicorperformancesbyMariaMaddalenaschildren.Severalaccountsofguestsbeinggiventours
throughthehousehavealsobeenpreserved.Theoperaperformancementionedabovewasamong
thelargerevents,duringwhichtheentireluxuriouslydecoratedvillawasopenedtoacourtlypublic.
Religiousfestivals,forexample,theFeastofCorpusChristiin1625,werealsotobecountedamong
such events.47 For this occasion, the palace faade was adorned with tapestries, paintings, and
festoons.Attheentrancetothespacebeforethepalacethereweretwofountainswithicechilled
red wine flowing out of them. An altar with a baldachinand adorned with golden vessels,
candelabra, and flowershad been set up in the interior courtyard. To conclude the festivities, a
solemnprocessioncarriedthebaldachintoanearbychurch,whereamasswasattended.
These examples demonstrate that numerous important social events took place at Poggio
Imperialeduringtheyearsoftheregency.WhileitistruethatthePalazzoPittiofficiallyremainedthe
mainresidenceofGrandDukeFerdinandoII,whohadalreadybeenformallyenthroned,theregent
adeptly used diverse activities to attract the attention of the court and its guests to her villa
suburbana, which thustookontheroleofaresidence.AllpersonsofrankwhovisitedFlorenceat
that time were received by Maria Maddalena there. Repeated descriptions in the court chronicle
makeitclearthatthereceptionceremoniesconductedbytheirhighnessesalwaysbeganinthehall
ofthegroundfloor,intheapartmentoftheregent(fig.4,no.3);hostsandgueststhenwithdrewto
theadjacentantechamberinordertospeakprivately(fig.4,no.13).Inthecaseofparticularlyhigh
ranking guests, the young Grand Duke Ferdinando II de Medici first waited upon them in the hall,
while the women waited in the antechamber. It is also documented that the regent repeatedly
received guests in her bedchamber when she was unwell (fig. 4, no. 4).48 This means that the
ceremonial unfolded primarily in the three impressive, official rooms of the regent on the ground
floor,withtheirfrescoesoffamouswomen.Thecircularroutewhichwasfollowedcorrelatedwith
theroomscycleonsalvationhistory,thusinvestingitwithparticularrelevance.
ISBN9789460184833
193
PietasAustriacaandthegoldenageoffemalerule
Programmeswithgroupsoffiguresrelatedtosalvationhistoryalwaysculminateinaviewofagolden
age: at Poggio Imperiale, this role is realized both through the men and women of the House of
HabsburgandthrougharecoursetothefourtheclogueofVergil,whichprophesiedthefoundationof
a gens aurea through a boy: in this case, Ferdinando II de Medici.49 Thus, the space of physical
activityandthepictorialspacecomplemented,insteadofcontradicting,oneanother.Theactionsof
some of the female exemplary figures selectedlike those of the militant Semiramistransgress
theirgenderrole;however,theinterpretationaccordingtoVergilopensaprospectontoapositive
resolution to a situation of crisis, one in which female rule does not call the social order into
question.
Nonetheless,theroomsoftheheirtothethronewereintegratedintoawomansapartment,
incontradictiontotheconventionalgenderedtopographyofthecourts;theywerealsothematically
linked to the rooms of his mother through the gallery of Habsburg emperors.50 Ferdinandos suite
clearly seems to have had a more symbolic function: it played no major role in the ceremonial. In
spiteofthis,previousscholarshavefocusedtheirattentionprimarilyonthemalegenealogyandits
link to Pietas Austriaca. It is in fact possible to point out fundamental motifs, such as the Pietas
Eucharistica in the image of Rudolph and the Priest (fig. 15), which underwent a performative
intensificationthroughthecelebrationoftheFeastofCorpusChristiatPoggioImperialesomething
thatalsooccurredatthecourtsofPragueandMadrid.51ThedeedsofEmperorCharlesVcelebrate
hisvictoriesagainsttheOttomansandthoseofFerdinandIIhisvictoriesagainsttheProtestants.The
two rulers are presented as Defensor Ecclesiae and Defensor fidei, and Ferdinands personal
venerationoftheTrueCrossisdepicted(fig.6).52Inmyopinion,however,thisapproachisalsovalid
fortheprogrammeoffamouswomen,whichwasrealized(amongotherplaces)inthehall,thatis,
in a space typically reserved for male heroes.53 By tracing most of the empresses and queens
pictured there back to the Habsburg genealogy, they come to correspond to theonly later
codifiedconceptofPietasAustriacathroughtheirexemplaryandoftenalsomiraculousrule.
The ambiguity of previous contextualizations of the Poggio Imperiale fresco programme
derives,ontheonehand,fromthelackofattentionpaidtoMariaMaddalenaasapatronand,onthe
otherhand,fromtheprogrammesuniqueinterweavingoflocalartandHabsburgiconography.The
depiction of uomini famosi and donne famose had a long local tradition in Florence, shaped by its
republicantradition:here,itisfilledoutwithfiguresfromtheHouseofHabsburg.54TheHabsburgs
already had their own tradition of ancestral portrait galleries consisting of saints and emperors of
bothsexesdrawnfromtheirownlineage.ThecombinationofimperialgenealogywithPietasmotifs
gradually replaced the Habsburgs purely dynasticgenealogical veneration of their ancestors.55 The
spread of this new constellation is typically dated to the reign of Emperor Ferdinand II, who was
heavily influenced by the Jesuits. However, the earliest known visual manifestations of such
programmesdatefromthereignofhissonEmperorFerdinandIII.56ThecycleatPoggioImperialeis
therefore of special significance: while the iconography of famous women and men continues to
point back to an older tradition that was increasingly being supplanted by mythological cycles, the
combinationwithPietasAustriacamotifsisthefirstofitskind.
ISBN9789460184833
194
Thissuggeststomethat asimilarlyintensivereceptionoftheCatholicReformsspirituality
and concept of government took place in the case of Maria Maddalena as is documented for her
siblingsEmperorFerdinandIIandMargaretofAustria,QueenofSpain.57Itwastheirmother,Maria
ofBavaria,ArchduchessofInnerAustria,whowasprimarilyresponsiblefortheirupbringingandfor
their strongly Catholic formation, because their father, Karl II, died at a relatively young age.58
Bavarianinfluencewasoftheutmostimportance,becauseMariasfather,DukeAlbertVofBavaria,
and her brother, the future Wilhelm V, both exercised a decisive influence over politics in Graz.
Bavaria served as a model of success for the Catholic Reform: here, religious unity was initially
successfully implemented.59 The House of Wittelsbach developed a Pietas Bavariae of their own,
including a marked veneration of the True Cross and the saints.60 To date, however, there is little
researchintotheroleoftheduchessesattheBavariancourt.BoththemotherofMariaMaddalena
ofAustriaMariaofBavaria,whowasadaughterofAnna,adaughterofEmperorFerdinandIand
thusaHabsburgherselfandMariaMaddalenasgrandmotherMariaJakobaeaofBadenSponheim
were known as prominent patrons and stout defenders of the Catholic faith. It is, for example,
commonly accepted that the latter embodies St Helena in the depiction of the Finding of the True
CrossbyBarthelBehamofcirca1530(fig.14).61Thispaintingisalwaysthoughtofasbeingapartof
thecyclewithancienthistoriescommissionedbyDukeWilhelmIV.AsitistheonlyChristiantheme
knownfortheprogramme,itseemstomethatitillustratesoneoftheearliestexamplesofCatholic
Reformartandmayhaveservedasparadigmforthegenerationsthatfollowed.Moreresearchinto
the field of this matrilineal tradition would certainly deepen our understanding of the spread of
devotionalpracticesandoficonographicalPietasmotifsthroughoutEurope.

Fig.14BarthelBeham,TheFindingoftheTrueCrossbyStHelena,Munich,AltePinakothek,ca.1530,
MariaJakobaeaofBadenSponheimisdepictedkneelingontheleftsideofthecross
ItisalsoremarkablethatRubensandWildenspaintingofRudolphandthePriestwascreated
atroughlythesametimeastheimageatPoggioImperiale(figs.15and16).SimilaritiestoRosellis
fresco become apparent, particularly in the twisted figure of Rudolph. According to Elizabeth
ISBN9789460184833
195
McGraths research, the painting was to be found in the bedchamber (as was the case at Poggio
Imperiale) of King Philip IV in the Alcazar of Madrid. It was very probably hung together with a
dynastic portrait gallery, Titians Religion saved by Spain, and Rubens Garden of Love.62 Earlier
versionsofthemotifhavebeenpreservedinbooksandasabackgroundsceneinpaintings,butnot
as primary subject matter.63 The decoration of the bedchamber probably coincided with Philips
accessiontopowerin1621,andbothimagesfulfilledaprogrammaticfunctionatalocationthatwas
centraltodynasticprogeny.TherewasaveryintensiveexchangebetweentheMadridandFlorence
courts during the life of Margaret of Austria, Queen of Spain, who was Philips mother and Maria
Maddalenassister.64Thealmostsimultaneousplacementofthissubjectmatterinthechambersof
thetworulerscouldpointtoacommunicationbetweenthecourts.Atanyrate,itdemonstratesthe
cleariconographicchoiceforthePietasAustriacathroughtheHabsburgmonarchyatthatmomentin
time.
TheunusualsituationoftheregencyinTuscanyledtotherealizationofamonumentaland
genderedarticulationoftheconceptofPietasAustriaca.InherprofoundstudyofMariaMaddalenas
musicalpatronage,KelleyHarnesswasabletodemonstratehowintensivelytheregentparticipated
in the production of the performances that she financed. It is therefore plausible to consider the
regentherselftobetheprimarycreatoroftheprogramme:onlysheandherclosestadvisorscould
havehadsuchanintimateknowledgeoftheHabsburggenealogyandthepracticesassociatedwith
it.65 It is even possible that the decoration of Poggio Imperiale provided a model for the plans
surrounding the apartment of Maria Maddalenas niece Anna of Austria, Queen of France, for her
residence in the Parisian abbey ValdeGrce, which she had founded and which was meant to
featureanequallyextensiveprogrammeinvolvingsaintedfemalerulers.66
While the concept of Pietas Austriaca has begun to be criticized for being too static to
describethehighlydiversephenomenaoftheHabsburgcourts,67itwasextremelyproductiveinthe
presentcontext,becauseithelpedtoclarifythedistinctionwithrespecttoMedicicyclesandtheir
conceptofgovernment.However,MariaMaddalenaformulatedherownengenderedversionofthe
Pietas.ShemadeuseoftheprizedartisticresourcesofFlorenceinordertoprovidehervulnerable
positionasregentofTuscanywithanimpressiveouterform.Thisunusualsituationfoundexpression
bothintheatypicaldispositionoftheroomsandintheextremelyrarepictorialinventions.Still,the
fullsignificanceoftheprogrammeofPoggioImperialeunfoldsonlywhenitisseenwithinthecontext
of the House of Habsburg as a transnationally organized network of rulers. Further research could
clarifyhowthismodelofPietasAustriacawascommunicatedbetweenthedifferentcourtsandalso
in which ways the performative and visual realizations of the theme affected the subsequent
theoreticalconsiderationsandwrittenformulationoftheconcept.
ISBN9789460184833
196

Fig.15MatteoRosselli,RudolphIofHabsburgandthepriest,Florence,
VillaPoggioImperiale,formerbedchamberofFerdinandoIIdeMedici,162324.

Fig.16PeterPaulRubensandJanWildens,RudolphIofHabsburgandthepriest,Madrid,MuseodelPrado,ca.1625.
ISBN9789460184833
197
Bibliography
Acanfora,Elisa,MariaMaddalenadAustria,donnadigovernoevirtuosadellearti,inFastodicorte.
La Decorazione murale nelle residenze dei Medici e dei Lorena, ed. Mina Gregori, 4 vols. (Florence,
200507),vol.I,pp.13187.
ArchitectureandthepoliticsofgenderinearlymodernEurope,ed.HelenHills(Aldershot,2003).
Armenini, Giovanni Battista da Faenza, De veri precetti della pittura, ed. Stefano Ticozzi (Ravenna,
1587;Milan,1820).
Arrighi, V., Maria Maddalena dAustria, in Dizionario biografico degli Italiani, ed. Alberto M.
GhisalbertiandMarioCaravale,73vols.(Rome,19602009),vol.LXX,pp.26064.
Baumgarten,Jens,Konfession,BildundMacht:VisualisierungalskatholischesHerrschaftskonzeptin
RomundimhabsburgischenSchlesien(15601740)(Hamburg&Munich,2004).
Brenger,Jean,PietasAustriaca:ContributionltudedelassensibilitreligieusedesHabsburg,in
Lavie,lamort,lafoi,letemps.MlangesoffertsaPierreChaunu(Paris,1993),pp.40321.
Betz, Susanne Helene, Von Innersterreich in die Toskana: Erzherzogin Maria Magdalena und ihre
HeiratmitCosimodeMedici(FrankfurtontheMainetal.,2008).
Bietti,Monica,PittoriaccademicifiorentinifraCorteeterritorio:AggiunteaicicliinonorediFilippo
II di Spagna e Margherita dAustria, in Arte Collezionismo Conservazione: Scritti in onore di Marco
Chiarini(Florence&Milan,2004),pp.25054.
Bireley, Robert, Religion and Politics in the Age of the Counterreformation: Emperor Ferdinand II,
WilliamLamormaini,S.J.,andtheFormationofImperialPolicy(ChapelHill,1981).
Blumenthal,ArthurR.,GiulioParigisStageDesigns:FlorenceandtheEarlyBaroqueSpectacle(New
York,1984).
Bohr, Michael, Die Villa Poggio Imperiale und die Skizzenbcher des Architekten Diacinto Maria
Marmi:ZurBautypologieundInnenraumgestaltungmediceischerProfanbautenumdieWendevom
17. zum 18. Jahrhundert, Mitteilungen des Kunsthistorischen Institutes Florenz, 38 (1994), pp.
337418.
Bruckmller, Ernst, sterreich An Ehren und Siegen reich, in Mythen der Nationen: Ein
EuropischesPanorama,ed.MonikaFlacke(Berlin,1998),pp.26994.
Cantelli,Giuseppe,RepertoriodellapitturafiorentinadelSeicento(Florence,1983).
Coreth,Anna,PietasAustriaca:sterreichischeFrmmigkeitimBarock,II,2nded.(Vienna,1982).
Coutoux, Sophie, Images de preuses Florence au XVII sicle, Mlanges de lEcole franaise de
Rome:ItalieetMditerrane,110(1998),pp.73153.
ISBN9789460184833
198
Cusick, Suzanne G., Francesca Caccini at the Medici Court: Music and the Circulation of Power
(Chicago&London,2009).
DasFrauenzimmer:DieFraubeiHofeinSptmittelalterundfrherNeuzeit,ed.JanHirschbiegeland
WernerParavicini(Stuttgart,2000).
Diaz,Furio,IlGranducatodiToscana:IMedici(Turin,1976).
Donneefede,ed.LucettaScaraffiaandGabriellaZarri(Rome&Bari,1994).
Dorival, Bernard, Philippe de Champagne, 16021674: La vie, luvre, et le catalogue raisonn de
luvre,2vols.(Paris,1976).
Ducreux, MarieElizabeth, Emperors, Kingdoms, Territories: Multiple Versions of the Pietas
Austriaca?,TheCatholicHistoricalReview,97(2011),pp.276304.
Faini Guazzelli, Fiammetta, La Volticina del Poggio Imperiale: Unattribuizione sbagliata, Antichit
Viva,7(1968),pp.2534.
Fantoni, Marcello, Il Principe santo. Clero regolare e modelli di sovranit nella Toscana tardo
medicea, in I religiosi a Corte: Teologia, politica e diplomazia in Antico regime, ed. Flavio Rurale
(Rome,1998),pp.22948.
Fumagalli, Elena, Pittori senesi del Seicento e committenza medicea, nuove date per Francesco
Rustici,Paragone,61(1990),pp.6982.
Fumgalli(a),Elena,CommittenzaeiconografiamediceaaRomanelseicento:Ilciclodiaffreschidi
PalazzoMadama,MitteilungendeskunsthistorischenInstitutesFlorenz,41(1997),pp.31447.
Fumagalli (b), Elena, Il Granducato di Cosimo II (16091621) e la reggenza (16211628), in Il
GiardinodelGranduca.Naturamortanellecollezionimedicee,ed.MarcoChiarini(Turin,1997),pp.
4373.
Fumagalli,Elena,CollezionismomediceodaCosimoIIaCosimoIII:lostatodeglistudielericerchein
corso,inGeografiadelcollezionismo:ItaliaeFranciatrailXVIeilXVIIsecolo,ed.OlivierBonfaitand
others(Rome,2001),pp.23955.
GalassoCalderara,Estella,LaGranduchessaMariaMaddalenadAustria:Unamazzonetedescanella
Firenzemediceadel600(Genoa,1985).
Galluzzi,Riguccio,IstoriadelGranducatodiToscanasottoilgovernodellaCasaMedici,aSuaAltezza
Reale il Serenissimo Pietro Leopoldo Principe Reale dUngheria e di Boemia, Arciduca dAustria,
GranducadiToscana,3vols.(Florence,1781).
GoldenbergStoppato,Lisa,DipintifiorentiniperLasDescalzasRealesealtridoniallaSpagna,inLa
morteelagloria:ApparatifunebrimediceiperFilippoIIdiSpagnaeMargheritadAustria,ed.Monica
Betti(Livorno,1999),pp.5067.
ISBN9789460184833
199
GuerraMedici,MariaTeresa,DonnedigovernonellEuropamoderna(Rome,2005).
Greiselmayer, Volkmar, Kunst und Geschichte: Die Historienbilder Herzog Wilhelms IV. von Bayern
undseinerGemahlinJacoba,VersucheinerInterpretation(Berlin1996).
Harness, Kelley, Habsburgs, Heretics, and Horses: Equestrian Ballets and other Staged Battles in
FlorenceduringtheFirstDecadeoftheThirtyYearsWar,inLarmeegliamori:Ariosto,Tassoand
Guarini in Late Renaissance Florence, ed. Massimiliano Rossi and Fiorella Gioffredi Superbi, 2 vols.
(Florence,2004),vol.II,pp.25583.
Harness, Kelley, Echoes of Womens Voices: Music, Art and Female Patronage in Early Modern
Florence(Chicago&London,2006).
Herbst,Arnulf,ZurIkonologiedesbarockenKaisersaals,in106.BerichtdeshistorischenVereinsfr
diePflegedesehemaligenFrstbistumsBamberg(1970),pp.207343.
Herzig, Arno, Der Zwang zum wahren Glauben: Rekatholisierung vom 16. bis zum 18. Jahrhundert
(Gttingen,2000).
Hoppe(a),Ilaria,ADuchessPlaceatCourt:TheQuartierediEleonorainthePalazzodellaSignoriain
Florence, in The Cultural World of Eleonora di Toledo, Duchess of Florence and Siena, ed. Konrad
Eisenbichler(Aldershot&Burlington,2004),pp.98118.
Hoppe(b),Ilaria,RumevonundfrFrauen?DieGemcherderMariaMagdalenavonsterreichin
Florenz, in Frauen in der Frhen Neuzeit: Lebensentwrfe in Kunst und Literatur, ed. AnneMarie
BonnetandBarbaraSchellewald(Vienna,Cologne&Weimar,2004),pp.21334.
Hoppe, Ilaria, Maria Maddalena dAustria e il culto delle reliquie alla corte dei Medici: scambi di
modelli dinastici ed ecclesiastici, in Artful Allies: Medici Women as Cultural Mediators 15331743,
ed.ChristinaStrunck(CiniselloBalsamo,2011),pp.227251.
Hoppe,Ilaria,DieRumederRegentin:DieVillaPoggioImperialezuFlorenz(Berlin,2012).
Hoppe,Ilaria,DieRumederRegentinamHofederMedici:SakraleundprofaneInszenierungender
VillaPoggioImperialeunterMariaMagdalenavonsterreich(16211628),inDieErschlieungdes
Raumes:Konstruktion,ImaginationundDarstellungvonRumenundGrenzenimBarockzeitalter,ed.
KarinFriedrichandothers(Wolfenbttel,forthcoming).
Hoppe, Ilaria, Die Villa Poggio Imperiale in Florenz als Schwellenraum, in Metamorphosen der
Macht: Transformationen urbaner und hortikultureller Rume im Europa der Frhen Neuzeit, ed.
AnnaAnanievaandothers(Bielefeld,2013).
In Christo ist weder man noch weyb: Frauen in der Zeit der Reformation und der katholischen
Reform,ed.AnneConrad(Mnster,1999).
Keller, Katrin, Erzherzogin Maria von Innersterreich (15511608). Zwischen Habsburg und
Wittelsbach(Vienna,Cologne&Weimar,2012).
ISBN9789460184833
200
Kliemann, Julian, Gesta Dipinte: La grande decorazione nelle dimore italiane dal Quattrocento al
Seicento(CiniselloBalsamo,1993).
Koldau,LindaMaria,FrauenMusikKultur:EinHandbuchzumdeutschenSprachgebietderFrhen
Neuzeit(Vienna,Cologne&Weimar,2005).
Kovcs,Elisabeth,SptmittelalterlicheTraditionenindersterreichischenFrmmigkeitdes17.und
18. Jahrhunderts, in Volksreligion im hohen und spten Mittelalter, ed. Peter Dinzelbacher and
DieterR.Bauer(Paderborn,1990),pp.396417.
Kovcs, Elisabeth, Die Heiligen und heiligen Knige der frhen Habsburger (12731519), in
LaienfrmmigkeitimsptenMittelalter,ed.KlausSchreiner(Munich,1992),pp.93126.
LaMaddalenatrasacroeprofano:DaGiottoadeChirico,ed.MarilenaMosco(Florence,1986).
Matsche, Franz, Die Kunst im Dienst der Staatsidee Kaiser Karls VI.: Ikonographie, Ikonologie und
ProgrammatikdesKaiserstils,2vols.(Berlin&NewYork,1981).
McGrath,Elisabeth,Rubens:SubjectsfromHistory,2vols(London,1997).
Meloni Trkulja, Silvia, Appendice: I Quadri della Sala dellUdienza, Antichit Viva, 12 (1973), pp.
4446.
NegroSpina,Annamaria,GiulioParigiegliincisoridellasuacerchia(Naples,1983).
Panichi,Ornella,VillaMediceoLorenesedelPoggioImperiale,inVilleitaliane,Toscana1,Villedella
ProvinciadiFirenze,LaCitt,ed.LuigiZangheri(Milan,1989),pp.14869.
PerunregaleeventoSpettacolinuzialieoperainmusicaallacortedeiMedici,ed.MariaAdelaide
BartoliBacherini(Florence,2000).
Pieraccini,Gateano,LastirpeMedicidiCaffagiolo,3vols(Florence,192425,reedition1986).
Pizzorusso, Claudio, Filippo Tarchiani, in Il Seicento Fiorentino: Arte a Firenze da Ferdinando I a
CosimoIII,3vols.(Florence,1986),vol.III,p.173.
Pollero, Friedrich B., Imperiale Reprsentation in Klosterresidenzen und Kaiserslen, Alte und
moderneKunst,30(1985),pp.1727.
Pollero,FriedrichB.,DassakraleIdentifikationsportrait:EinhfischerBildtypusvom13.biszum20.
Jahrhundert,2vols.(Worms,1988).
Prato,Cesareda,R.VilladelPoggioImperialeoggiR.IstitutodellaSS.Annunziata:StoriaeDescrizioni
(Florence,1895).
Preiss, Pavel, Eucharistia Hic Austria: Die Ursprungslegende der Pietas HabsburgoAustriaca
Eucharistica und der Entstehung des Bindenschildes in den Gemlden des Habsburgersaales im
ISBN9789460184833
201
Lustschlo Troja bei Prag, in Bilder des Reiches, ed. Rainer A. Mller (Sigmaringen, 1997), pp.
36995.
Reinhard, Wolfgang, Was ist katholische Konfessionalisierung?, in Die katholische
Konfessionalisierung,ed.WolfgangReinhard(Mnster,1995),pp.41952.
Reinhardt, Tanja, Die habsburgischen Heiligen des Jakob Mennel (doctoral thesis, AlbertLudwigs
UniversittzuFreiburgi.Br.,2002),atwww.freidok.unifreiburg.de/volltexte/2438/(accessedon28
August2012).
Richter,Katja,DerTriumphdesKreuzes:KunstundKonfessionimletztenVierteldes16.Jahrhunderts
(Berlin&Munich,2009).
Rossi, Massimiliano, I dipinti introduzione: la novella di Sandro e Nastagio, in Boccaccio
visualizzato: narrare per parole e per immagini fra Medioevo e Rinascimento, ed. Vittore Branca
(Turin,1999),pp.15387.
Snchez, Magdalena S., The Empress, the Queen and the Nun: Women and Power at the Court of
PhilipIIIofSpain(Baltimore&London,1998).
Schilling, Heinz, Das konfessionelle Europa: Die Konfessionalisierung der europischen Lnder seit
Mitte des 16. Jahrhunderts und ihre Folgen fr Kirche, Staat, Gesellschaft und Kultur, in
Konfessionalisierung in Ostmitteleuropa: Wirkungen des religisen Wandels im 16. und 17.
Jahrhundert in Staat, Gesellschaft und Kultur, ed. Joachim Bahlke and others (Stuttgart, 1999), pp.
1362.
Sodini,Carla,LErcoleTirreno:Guerraedinastiamediceanellaprimametdel600(Florence,2001).
Solerti,Angelo,Musica,BalloeDrammaticaallaCorteMediceadal1600al1637:Notizietrattedaun
Diarioconappendiceditestiineditierari(Florence,1905;reeditionBologna,1969).
Spinelli, Riccardo, Francesco Rustici e Giovan Battista Marmi in palazzo Panciatichi a Firenze
(Florence,1997).
Spinelli, Riccardo, Note su un dipinto di Ottavio Vannini e su alcuni disegni inediti, Paragone, 52
(2001),pp.1335.
Spinelli,Riccardo,Simbologiadinasticaelegittimazionedelpotere:MariaMaddalenadAustriaegli
affreschidelPoggioImperiale,inLedonneMedicinelsistemaeuropeodellecortiXVIXVIIIsecolo,ed.
GiuliaCalviandRiccardoSpinelli,2vols.(Florence,2008),vol.II,pp.64579.
Strunck,Christina,ChristianevonLothringen,GroherzoginderToskana(15651636):Einweiblicher
Herkules, in Die Frauen des Hauses Medici: Politik, Mzenatentum, Rollenbilder (15121743), ed.
ChristinaStrunck(Petersberg,2011),pp.7591.
Sustermans:SessantanniallacortedeiMedici,ed.MarcoChiariniandClaudioPizzorusso(Florence,
1983).
ISBN9789460184833
202
Tarchi,Rossella,UnaletteradiMariaMaddalenadAustriasullareliquiadellaSantaCroceinS.Maria
Impruneta,Rivistadarte,41(1989),pp.15965.
Tippelskirch, Xenia von, Con la lettura di questa santa operina, attender ad infiammare se
medesima Annotazioni alla vita di Maria di Portogallo, Principessa di Parma e Piacenza (1538
1577), in Alle origini della biografia femminile: dal modello alla storia, ed. Catherine Brice and
Gabriella Zarri, Mlanges de lcole franaise de Rome, Italie et Mditerrane, 113 (2001), pp.
23355.
Tippelskirch, Xenia von, Die Indexkongregation und die Wrde der Frauen: Cristofano Bronzini,
Delladignitenobiltdelledonne,inFraueninderFrhenNeuzeit:LebensentwrfeinKunstund
Literatur, ed. AnneMarie Bonnet and Barbara Schellewald (Vienna, Cologne & Weimar, 2004), pp.
23562.
Vcha,tpn,DerHerrscheraufdemSakralbildzurZeitderGegenreformationunddesBarock:Eine
ikonologische Untersuchung zur herrscherlichen Reprsentation Kaiser Ferdinands II. in Bhmen
(Prague,2009).
Valenta, Rainer, Schloss Windhaag und die Topographia Windhagiana (Aucta): Zur Darstellung der
Pietas Austriaca Eucharistica in einem adeligen Landsitz, Acta Historiae Artium, Academiae
ScientiarumHungaricea,47(2006),pp.17589.
Visconti, Enzo, La saletta di Cosimo II. Capolavoro di Matteo Rosselli, Il Poggio: Giornale
dellEducandando Governativo della SS. Annunziata al Poggio Imperiale di Firenze (May 1960), pp.
15.
Visconti, Enzo, Rapsodia di Matteo Rosselli a Poggio Imperiale, Il Poggio: Giornale
dellEducandandoGovernativodellaSS.AnnunziataalPoggioImperialediFirenze(October1960),pp.
236.
Wandruszka, Adam, Ein Freskenzyklus der Pietas Austriaca in Florenz, Mitteilungen des
sterreichischenStaatsarchivs,15(1962),pp.49599.
Wandruszka, Adam, Maria Magdalena von sterreich, in Die Habsburger: Ein biographisches
Lexikon,ed.BrigitteHamann(Vienna,1988),pp.33839.
Wenzel, Michael, Heldinnengalerie Schnheitengalerie: Studien zu Genese und Funktion
weiblicherBildnisgalerien14701715(doctoralthesis,UniversittHeidelberg,2005)atwww.ub.uni
heidelberg.de/archiv/5771/(accessedon29August2012).
Winkelbauer, Thomas, Stndefreiheit und Frstenmacht 15221699: Lnder und Untertanen des
HausesHabsburgimkonfessionellenZeitalter,2vols.(Vienna,2003),vol.I,pp.185239.
ISBN9789460184833
203
Vienna, sterreichische Nationalbibliothek, Handschriftenabteilung, Biblioteca Palatina
Vindobonensi,Cod.3077***,JacobusMennelsiveManlius,DeclarismulierbusdomusHabsburgicae
libergermanicus,Augsburg1518.
Illustrations
Fig.1,4MapsauthorandHenningGrope.
Fig.2Fanelli,Giovanni,FirenzeArchitetturaecitt(Florence,1973),fig.730.
Fig.3,5Soprintendenzaperibeniambientaliearchitettonici,Gabinettofotografico,PalazzoPitti.
Fig.6Spinelli2008,p.653,fig.4.
Fig.7,8,10,12,15Acanfora2005,p.144,fig.83;platesLXXXVIII,LXXXV,CII,XCIV.
Fig.9MinisteroperiBenieleAttivitCulturali.SoprintendenzaspecialeperilPolomuseale
fiorentino.
Fig.11Photoauthor.
Fig.13Stanzesegreteraccoltepercaso.ImediciSantiGliarredicelati,ed.CristinaGiannini(Cittdi
Castello,2004),p.37,fig.23.
Fig.14Greiselmayer1996,plateX.
Fig.16ElSiglodeRubensenElMuseodelPardo,CatlogorazonadodePinturaFlamencadelSiglo
XVII,ed.MatasDazPardon,3vols.(Barcelona,1997),vol.II,cat.no.1645.

*IwouldliketothankthegenderequalityprogrammeoftheHumboldtUniversittzuBerlin,whichfacilitated
thetranslationofMichaelWetzel,towhomIamgratefulforhisaccuratework.
1
For the biography of Mary Magdalene, see Pieraccini 192425, vol. II, pp. 34564; Galasso Calderara 1986;
Wandruzska1988;Arrighi2008;Betz2008.
2
SeminalarethestudiesDonneefede1994;Reinhard1995;InChristo1999;Schilling1999,pp.5155.
3
Forthisaspect,seeHoppeforthcoming.
4
Hoppe2004b;Hoppe2012.
5
Galluzzi1781,vol.III,p.394;Diaz1976,p.366;Pieraccini1925,vol.II,p.345;GalassoCalderara1985,p.93;
Cusick2009,p.193,n.9;Hoppe2012,pp.2734.
6
ForChristineofLorraine,seenowStrunck2011.
7
Forthehistoryandthearchitectureofthevilla,seePanichi1989;Bohr1994,pp.34446;Hoppe2012,pp.
3555.
8
Hoppe2012,p.283.
9
ForthediscussionofthecompleteensembleofsculpturesandfountainsseeHoppe2012,pp.4243,55.
ISBN9789460184833
204

10
TheauthorofthelibrettoisFerdinandoSaracinelli,themusicwascomposedbyFrancescaCaccini.SeeSolerti
1905,pp.17983;Harness2004,vol.II,pp.26480;Cusick2009,pp.191246.Fortheseriesofillustraons,
seeNegroSpina1983,p.118;Blumenthal1984,pp.20107.
11
VILLAIMPERIALISABAUSTRIACIS/AUGUSTISNOMENCONSECUTA/FUTURAEMAGNAEDUCESETRURIAE/
VESTROOCIODELICIISQUE/AETERNUMINSERVIAT,quotedafterPrato1895,p.41.Theblazonisnowlost.
12
Hoppe2012,p.281.
13
TheinventoryispublishedfullyinHoppe2012,pp.290330;thechroniclepartially.
14
Hoppe2012,p.57.
15
Hoppe2012,pp.5859.
16
Wandruszka1962;Klieman1993,p.181;Preiss1997,pp.38283;Acanfora2005,pp.14950;Spinelli2008,
pp.65056;Hoppe2012,pp.65,16989.
17
For the concept of the Pietas Austriaca, see Coreth 1982; Kovcs 1990; Kovcs 1992; Brenger 1993;
Winkelbauer2003;Baumgarten2004,pp.164172;Ducreux2011.
18
Visconti1960(October),pp.236;Coutoux1998,pp.73139;Rossi1999,pp.16974;Acanfora2005,vol.I,
pp.14357;Spinelli2008,pp.64579;Hoppe2012,pp.95168.
19
Spinelli2008,p.670;Hoppe2012,pp.10809.
20
Preiss1997,p.387.
21
Mennel1518,fol.1v,4r4v.
22
Kovcs1992,p.94;Reinhardt2002,pp.74,77,13334,16667;Hoppe2012,p.116.
23
ArgomentodellareginasantOrsola:RappresentazionediAndreaSalvadori(Florence,1624),seeSolerti1905,
pp.159,17478.Perunregaleevento,cat.no.109,110;seeHarness2006,pp.79110.
24
Kovcs1992,pp.9496.
25
MeloniTrkulja1973;Fumagalli1990,pp.7173;Hoppe2012,pp.95102.
26
Hoppe2012,pp.11824.Cf.Pizzorusso1986;Acanfora2005,p.146;Spinelli2008,p.667.
27
Painted are Jael, Judith, Miriam, Esther, the Mother of the Maccabees, Rebecca, The Finding of Moses,
Susanna,andZipporah.
28
PaintedarethemartyrdomsofLucia,Dorothea,Christina,Agnes,Caecilia,Agatha,Barbara,Margareta,and
Apollonia.
29
Mennel1518,fol.108v110r;Reinhardt2003,pp.158,229;Hoppe2012,pp.14648.
30
Lorini,Niccol,ElogiidellepivprincipaliS.donnedelsacrocalendario,emartirologioromano,vergini,martiri,
etaltre.Messiinsiemeconmoltevigilie.DalM.R.P.M.ePredicatoreGeneraleF.NiccolLorinidelMonte,ed.
ZanobiPignoni(Florence,1617).
31
Coreth1982,pp.3844;Matsche1981,pp.12342.
32
Tarchi1989;Hoppe2011,pp.22732,244.
33
Foramoredetailedcomparison,seeHoppe2012,pp.198201.
34
Visconti 1960 (May); Faini Guazzelli 1968; Cantelli 1983, p. 131; Spinelli 2001, pp. 2425, 4046;Acanfora
2005,p.149;Sodini2011,pp.29092;Hoppe2012,pp.189205.
35
Hoppe2012,p.65.
36
Spinelli1997,pp.517;Hoppe2012,p.70.
37
Hoppe2012,pp.6869.
38
Hoppe2012,pp.6970.
39
Forasummary,seeHoppe2012,pp.7076.
40
Fumagalli1990;Fumagalli1997b;Fumagalli2001.
41
Sustermans1983,cat.no.14.Lamaddalena1986,cat.no.99;seePollero1988,vol.I,pp.1316,4850,
cat.no.434.
42
Hoppe2012,pp.6667.
43
ForthemodeloftheholyprincessintermsoftheCatholicReform,seeTippelskirch2001.Forasurveyof
themaleconceptoftheChristianprinceafterAdrianoProsperi,seeFantoni1998.
44
TherewererumoursthattheregencyhadtobeassignedfirsttoCardinalCarlodeMedici,brotherofthe
deceasedGrandDukeCosimoII.SeeFumagalli1997a,p.315,n.14.IntheencomiumbyCristofanoBronzini,
dedicated to Maria Maddalena, the praise of female rulership and the predominance of the female sex was
criticized by the Vatican and therefore censored. See Tippelskirch 2004. For female regencies and their
problematiclegalbasis,seetheseminalstudybyGuerraMedici2005.
ISBN9789460184833
205

45
La maddalena 1986, pp. 16667; Hoppe 2012, pp. 2526, 7476. See also the records in Archivio di Stato
Firenze,MediceodelPrincipato,6081:16077;6077:15741,15744,15745,15746,15748;6101:15547;6100:
15502attheMediciArchiveProject,www.medici.org(accessedon19November2012).
46
ForthefunctionofPoggioImperialeintheseyearsandtheinnerdispositionofrooms,seeHoppe2012,pp.
7793.
47
Hoppe2012,p.84.
48
Hoppe2012,pp.8788.
49
UltimaCumaeivenitiamcarminisaetas;/magnusabintegrosaeclorumnasciturordo./iamreditetvirgo,
redeunt saturnia regna; / iam nopva progenies caelo dimittitur alto. / to modo nascent puero, quo ferrea
primum / desinet actoto surget genas aurea mundo,/ caste fave Lucina: tuus iam regnat Apollo,Vergil, IV.
Eclogue.
50
ForthegenderedspheresatItaliancourts,seeHoppe2004a,pp.104106;Hoppe2012,pp.1113,8893,
227229.BroadersurveysongenderandspaceintheearlymodernperiodareDasFrauenzimmer2000;and
Architecture2003.
51
ForthePietasEucharisticaandtheImitatioRudolfi,seeMatsche1981,pp.8083,112,11617;Coreth1982,
pp.2025;Preiss1997,pp.37778;Bruckmller1998,p.273;Valenta2006,p.180.
52
ForthedevotionofFerdinandIItotheHolyCross,seeVcha2009,pp.6889.
53
Explicitly mentioned in Armenini 1587, vol. III, VIII, p. 262. The famous women iconography was
recommendedforthebedchambersofwivesanddaughters.
54
For a summary on the different traditions of famous men and women iconography, see Hoppe 2012, pp.
20525.
55
Herbst1970,pp.290,326;Matsche1997,pp.33031;Pollero1985,p.24.
56
Matsche1981,p.74;Vcha2009,pp.10,6889.
57
ForFerdinandII,seeBireley1981.ForMargaret,seeSnchez1998.
58
SeenowtheseminalstudyofKeller2012.Fortheeducationofherchildren,seeBetz2008,pp.5061;Keller
2012,pp.5056.ForthedecisiveinfluenceofMariaofBavariaintermsofculturalexchange,seeKoldau2005,
pp.6979.
59
Herzig2000,p.17andpassim.
60
Herzig2000,p.13;Richter2009,pp.225304.
61
Greiselmayer1996,pp.13156.
62
McGrath1997,cat.no56.
63
Hoppe2012,p.184.
64
Queen Margaret of Spain ordered an extensive painting cycle in Florence in 1610 and she was herself
rememberedinFlorencewithavastfuneralcycleingrisailleafterherdeathin1611,afterwardsshowninthe
CorridoioVasariano.SeeGoldenbergStoppato1999;Bietti2004;Strunck2011,p.86.
65
ForabroaderdiscussionoftheauthorshipseeHoppe2012,p.219.
66
Theconcettowasdescribedas:touteslesimpratricesetlesreinesquionttenreputationdesaintet.
SeeDorival1976,vol.I,p.49,vol.II,cat.no.424;Wenzel2005,pp.7879.
67
See,e.g.,Ducreux2011.
ISBN9789460184833
206
PietasAustriacaattheLisbonCourt
TheMonumentalChapelandFuneraryTombsbuiltbyCatherineofAustria
intheSanJernimosMonasticComplexinBelm
AnnemarieJordanGschwend
Prologue
In1570,atacrucialstageinherlifeandreign,CatherineofAustria(15071578),QueenofPortugal,
decided to retire from politics and government.1 She sought official permission from court and
church officials to leave Portugal and return to her native country of Spain, where she hoped to
reside in a convent, living out the remaining years of her life in prayer and meditation. Although
Catherinewasinspiredbyearlierprecedencediscussedbelow,shewasalsotroubledbyintriguesat
theLisboncourt.By1570,afterhavingbeenpredeceasedbyherbelovedhusbandJohnIIIandher
ninechildren,thequeenwasreadytoliveouttherestofherlifeinsolitude.
In 1498 the Dowager Queen Leonor of Portugal (14581525) had founded a new
confraternity in Portugal dedicated to the Virgin of Mercy (Virgem da Misericordia), the primary
purposeofwhichwastoassisttheindigent,illandvagabond,ransomcaptivesoftheMoors,shelter
orphans, run hospitals and hospices, promote works of charity, and build convents and churches.2
Leonor, who earned a reputation in Portugal, as the Perfect Queen (Rainha Perfeita), was
celebrated by her subjects for her Christian virtues, charity and cultural patronage. The Madre de
Deus convent of Franciscan nuns with its church in Xabregas on the city outskirts of Lisbon was
foundedandbuiltbyLeonorin1519tohousetherelicsofSaintAutaandthe11,000VirginMartyrs
thatshehadreceivedfromhercousinEmperorMaximilianIin1517.3Leonorbecameanexemplary
modelforsubsequentPortuguesequeensandprincesses,andwasagreatsourceofinspirationfor
Catherine of Austria. Following the Dowager Queens example, Catherine retired to the summer
palaceofXabregasseveralyearsaftershegaveuptheregencyin1562,havingruledforhergrandson
for five years. Catherines residence at Xabregas was situated near a princely retreat that her
husbandJohnIIIhadbuilttherebetween1556and1557,basedondesignsbyFranciscodeHolanda.4
Catherines palace was situated in quarters near the premises of Leonors convent,5 to which she
haddirectaccessviaaninteriordoorthatlinkedherapartmentswiththeMadredeDeuschurchand
the chapel of the Passion of Christ, also known as the Capela do Espirito Santo.6 In the latter,
Catherinebuiltatribunetoaccommodateherandherfemaleretinuewhenattendingattendmass.A
contemporary account describes Catherine leaving her apartments daily by means of a corridor to
reachthesmallchurchwheresheheardmasswithherladiesandtheresidentSpanishAmbassador,
Juan de Borja (15331606), when he was present.7 Catherines determination to lead a vita
contemplativa completely removed from court politics and intrigues is reminiscent of other close
ISBN9789460184833
207

Habsburg family members who sought seclusion and refuge within the precincts of a religious
foundation.
ThedramaticdecisionofCatherinetochoosetoabandonthecountryshehadruledoveras
queen for close to fifty years was certainly inspired by the example of her elder brother Emperor
Charles V (15001558), who abdicated and moved to a monastery at Yuste in the Extremadura (in
Spain)in1556.CatherineturnedtoherHabsburgnephewPhilipIIofSpainforguidance,supportand
adviceregardingherretirement,8andthisdramaticmomentinCatherineslifeisdocumentedbya
numberofunpublishedlettersintheArchivoGeneraldeSimancas(Valladolid)exchangedbetween
them,aswellaswiththeabovementionedSpanishAmbassadorinPortugal,JuandeBorja.9Thiswas
thefirsttimeinherreignthatCatherinehadfeltincapableofconfrontingthechallengeswhichfaced
her, in particular, her intractable grandson King Sebastian of Portugal (15541578). Sebastian had
since early childhood adamantly refused to follow her sound advice and heeded her counsel even
less after he assumed the Portuguese crown in 1568. Catherines insistence that he marry and
produceanheirforthethronebroughttheiralreadyfragilerelationshiptoagrindinghalt.Catherine
hadtried in vaintosecureamarriageworthyofSebastiansrank,seekingallianceswith theValois
courtinFrance,theHabsburgcourtsinSpainandAustria,andtheducalcourtinBavaria.Catherine
hadbankedonbringingamarriageableprincesstoLisbonwhomshecouldeducatetobethefuture
queen of Portugal and its vast overseas empire. However, her various matrimonial plans to marry
Sebastian to Margaret of Valois, Isabella Clara Eugenia (daughter of Philip II), Isabel of Austria
(daughter of Emperor Maximilian II), and Maximiliana (daughter of Duke Albrecht V of Bavaria) all
metwithfailure.
By 1570 the elderly queen felt emotionally and physically overwhelmed, unable to further
confrontSebastiansnoncomplianceandinsubordinationandthemultiplecourtfactionsalliedwith
himandhisuncletheInfanteCardinalHenry(Henrique)(15121580),who,likeCatherine,hadserved
asregentfortheyoungprincefrom1562to1568.Thequeendecideditwouldbebestforcourtand
countryforhertoleave,andsheinitiatedcomplexnegotiationswiththeSpanishHabsburgcourtto
verifyherrents,propertiesandwealthbothinPortugalandinSpain,sothatshecouldfinanceher
existence in her future convent.10 However, her plans to depart to Spain were thwarted by her
subjects, who refused to allow their beloved queen to go. Her departure officially impeded, the
reluctant queen was compelled by duty and by her personal devotion to stay in Portugal and
superviseanarchitecturalprojectwhichwouldhighlighttheendofherlifeandreign:therebuilding
of the main chapel (the capela mor) of the Jernimos monastery located in Blem (Lisbon). The
transformation of the former ornate Manueline chapel into a severe classicistic structure
underscoresCatherinesdesiretobuildachapelinanarchitecturalvernacularandstyleneverbefore
deployed in Portugal, a desire coupled with an aspiration to leave a remarkable personal imprint
uponthefabricofthismonumentalmonastery(figs.12).Catherinespiety,religiosityanddevotion
motivatedhertorebuildthecapelamorfirstbuiltbyherlatefatherinlaw,KingManuelI(r.1498
1521),shortlyafterVascodaGamadiscoveredthesearoutetoIndiain1498.11Hersenseofdutyand
dedicationtotheAvisandHabsburgroyalhousesalsopromptedhertobuildapantheonworthyof
herillustriousfamilies.

ISBN9789460184833
208

Fig.1ExteriorviewoftheJernimosMonasteryinBelm(Lisbon).Thesquareboxlike
structureatthefarrightdemarcatesthecapelamorbuiltbyCatherineofAustria.
Photo:JosAntnioSilva.

Fig.2FloorplanoftheJernimoschurchwiththecapelamormarked
intheyellowbox.Photo:publicdomain.
CatherineofAustriasRoyalPantheonfortheAvisDynasty
ModelsandPrecedences:TheIdealHabsburgWidow
In 1530, shortly before her death, Catherine of Austrias aunt Margaret of Austria (1480
1530), regent of the Netherlands, made a pivotal decision to build a funerary monument in the
Flamboyant Gothic style at Brou near BourgenBresse (France), in memory of her third husband,
PhilibertIItheFair,DukeofSavoy,whohaddiedprematurelyattheageoftwentyfour.Margaret
undertook this architectural project in fulfilment of a vow she had made just before her beloved
husband died. The monumental chapel and tombs, which the regent intended as architectural
ISBN9789460184833
209

expressionsofherpiety,wereattachedtoasumptuousmonasterywiththreecloisterserectedthere
between 1506 and 1532. This funerary complex was to commemorate, in accordance with the
teachings of the Spanish humanist and philosopher Juan Luis Vives (14921540), the glory of
Margaretsdeadhusbandandhisfamily.DuringherregencyMargarettooktofashioningherselfas
the ideal widow, as Vives advised in his writings. His influential book, De institutione feminae
Christianae,publishedinAntwerpin1524,definedmarriageasthelegitimateunionofonemanand
one woman bound together for life. He strongly counseled widows to devote themselves to the
memory of their dead husbands rather than to marry again. Vives advocated absolute faithfulness
and chaste abstinence for widows: advice that Margaret took to heart. The Brou church was
conceivedofasavotivechapel,atempleofremembranceandasumptuoussettingforthreeprincely
tombs: one for her husband Philibert the Fair, one for herself, and one for her motherinlaw,
MargaretofBourbon.

During the lifetime of her beloved father Emperor Maximilian I and during her marriages,
Margaret had been proud of her roles as exemplary daughter and wife. She was educated to be a
paragonofvirtuouswomanhood:agoodwife,loyal,trueandsubmissivetofatherandhusband.She
assumedherwifelyattributeswithdedication,goingsofarastomendandsewclothesforthemen
of her immediate family. In one letter dated 17 May 1511, Maximilian expressed his delight upon
receivingshirtsmadebyhisdaughter,gratefulforthespecialcareandattentionshegiveshisbody,
especiallysincethisyearhemustwearheavy,hardarmorinthefaceofwarandbattle.12Margaret
wasnot,however,theonlywomaninCatherineofAustriasfamilytopromoteherselfastheideal
spouse. Queen Isabel of Castile (14511504), Catherines grandmother, the woman she was later
often compared with, and who had also been Margaret of Austrias motherinlaw, set an even
earlier precedence. Margarets second marriage to the heir of the Catholic Kings of Spain, Prince
Juan, in 1497, exposed her to the exotic splendor of Isabels court, where the artistic and cultural
influenceofIslamcoloureddailylife.Isabelwasahighlyeducated,scholarlywomanwholovedmusic
andLatin;skilledinthedomesticartsofsewingandneedlework,shewaspraisedbycontemporaries
formendingherhusbandsshirtswithherowndelicatehands.13Shewaswellreadinreligiousand
secular works and especially fond of chivalric romances, and her library numbered nearly four
hundredvolumes.SheguidedintellectuallifeinSpainandsolidifiedeconomic,cultural,artisticand
dynastic ties with Burgundy and the Habsburg territories, which culminated in the marriage of her
son Juan with Margaret. Isabel would have considerable repercussions upon Margaret and later
generationsofwomeninherfamily.

Margaret of Austrias third marriage in 1501 to Philibert II, Duke of Savoy, united her to a
ducalhousewithclosetiestotheFrenchcourt.ThisallianceconsolidatedHabsburgpowersouthof
theAlpsand furtheredherfathersprestigeaswellashisdynasticandpoliticalaimsabroad.Their
short marriage was marked by a magnificent itinerant court life marked by royal entries, jousts,
dances, masques, theatrical productions and ftes. They held court throughout the duchy, which
extended from Lake Geneva to the Piedmont, at their palaces in BourgenBresse, Chambry and
Turin. Philiberts untimely death in 1504 forced widowhood upon Margaret, who definitively
returnedtoFlandersandrefusedallthemaritalalliancesthatMaximilianhopedshewouldcontract
againfortheHabsburgdynasty.Notlongafter,Margarettooktofashioningherselfinthevisualarts,
inparticular,inherofficialcourtportraits,asawidowinperpetualstateofmourning,adoptingthe
ISBN9789460184833
210

motto:Fortune,Infortune,Fort,Une(Luck,MisfortuneMakesOneStrong),topromoteherimageas
theidealChristianwidowdevotedtoherfamilyandtheHabsburgdynasty.14
PatronageprovidedHabsburgwomen,especiallyprominentwidowslikeMargaretwhowere
liberated from marital duties and childbearing responsibilities, with creative and social outlets.
Margaret and such of her female relations who were in control of their own financial resources
undertookprojectsandartisticcommissionswhichnotonlypromotedtheinterestsoftheirnataland
conjugal dynasties but also gave expression to their own personal piety within the context of the
Church, in the form of family tombs, and the commissions of chapels with their decoration. This
channel offered Habsburg female patrons the opportunity to exercise patronage outside of the
private domain in the form of public piety.15 But these Habsburg women were not the only
prominent patrons and collectors of their day to follow such a path: Isabella dEste (14741539),
Marquise of Mantua, similarly acknowledged the necessity for widows to succumb to political
exigencies and carefully stage acts of public piety by way of religious commissions. The Habsburg
womenwhodesignedtheirowntombscultivatedandnurturedapersonalagendapreoccupiedwith
andfocuseduponselfpromotion,selfimaging,andthelegitimacyofstatus.
Inaddition,Margaretwasmotivatedbyherprincelymausoleumtoconsciouslycelebrateher
ownfamilyatBrou,withtheintentofglorifyingtheBurgundianandHabsburgdynastiesinthismost
publicofsettingsbyprominentlypositioninginthechancelsfivestainedglasswindowsthecoatsof
arms of these two royal houses. The church serves as a monumental platform which equally
memorializes Margaret herself, with her princely background and rank being displayed throughout
the church with personal heraldic emblems and devices. Her physical memoria is likewise
rememberedherebyhersculpturalportrayal,withtheregentbeingrealisticallydepictedrecumbent
on her tomb. Brou and its construction essentially offered Margaret of Austria the opportunity to
identifyherselfasacontemporaryArtemisiaofCaria,whohadbuilttheMausoleumatHalicarnassus
in the fourth century BC. In the words of Margarets French contemporary Pierre de Bourdeilles,
Seigneur of Brantme, Brou was a beautiful and sumptuous memorial that far surpassed the one
erectedbyherancientfemalecounterpartArtemisia.16TheBroucomplexconstitutedanastuteact
ofpoliticalselffashioningonthepartofMargaret,whereheridentityasapiouswidowwasfirmly
consolidated.
Assovereignandregent,Margaretwieldedmorepowerthanherdeadhusband,PhilibertII
of Savoy, and her ultimate objective with Brou may have been to rival the imperial, monumental
tombherfather,MaximilianI,projectedatInnsbruck.BesidesVives,Margaretwasmuchencouraged
by Cornelius Agrippa von Nettesheims book On the Nobility and Excellence of Women, which he
dedicatedtotheregentin1529,ayearbeforeherdeath,andinwhichheunconventionallypromotes
thefullequalityofthesexes:Womenandmenwereequallyendowedwiththegiftsofspirit,reason
andtheuseofwords;theywerecreatedforthesameendandthesexualdifferencebetweenthem
willnotconferadifferentdestiny.17
AdynasticmessagewasthereforeprojectedbyMargaretforBrou,andonethatwasnoless
potentthanthepoliticalmessageswhichunderscoredthenumerousartisticcommissionsherfather
undertook. As a selffashioned, modern Artemisia, Margaret asserted herself both at the Flemish
courtandinthemasculine,publicrealmofpoliticsandwar,withoutsacrificingherequality,power
orinfluencewithintheHabsburgfamilynetwork.NordidMargaretcompromiseherroleasaruler,
ISBN9789460184833
211

learnedscholarandcollector,becomingamodelandexampleforotherfemalerelatives,especially
herniece,CatherineofAustria.Asafunerarycomplex,Brouestablishedaprototypeforasuccession
of Habsburg women and widows who followed Margarets example with their own conceptions of
personal and family tombs, and in particular dynastic pantheons, such as the capela mor of the
JernimosmonasteryinBelmdedicatedtothememoryoftheAvizroyalhouse.
Margaret certainly influenced Catherine of Austrias rebuilding of the Manueline chapel in
thismonastery,erectedbyManuelIin1498tohonorthemaritimeexplorationsofthePortuguese.
This royal pantheon was one of the few building projects Catherine would assume as a personal
initiative. In doing she also broke new ground architecturally, replacing a lateGothic nave with a
classicalstructureneverbeforeseeninRenaissancePortugal.Untilthisjunctureinherlifeandreign,
Catherinesarchitecturalpatronagehadbeenmoderateandconstrained.Shehadoftenshouldered
thecostsofunfinishedbuildingprojectsinitiatedbyotherroyalswhichshefeltcompelledbydutyto
complete,asshedidwiththeConventofNossaSenhoradaAssunoinFaro(Algarve)foundedby
heraunt,theDowagerQueenLeonorofPortugal(14581525).Immediatelyafterherentryin1525,
Catherine ordered the court architect, Afonso Pires, to supervise and complete its construction in
Faro, and by 1541 the first nuns of the First Order of Saint Clare entered this convent.18 Until the
Jernimos project, Catherines religious patronage can be best defined as gifting convents and
religiousinstitutionswithendowmentsanddonations,evenwithofferingsoffemaleblackslaves,19
preferring to leave architectural concerns in the hands of her husband, John III. As king, he used
architecture to advance personal ideologies, and his building commissions reflect visions of global
rule in which he promoted himself, as did his father Manuel I, as dominus mundi of a new Roman
empire.20 Catherines interests in secular or profane building projects were not as ambitious, until
shebeganremodelingandtransformingtheJernimoschapelintoafamilypantheon.
InthecapelamoratBelm,onbothsidesofthemainaltar,setwithinindividualarches,are
four royal tombs in the form of sarcophagi, ornamented with giltbronze crowns resting upon
caryatidsintheformofanelephant,anexoticanimalcloselyassociatedwiththeLisboncourtasa
symbol of the Portuguese conquests (figs. 34).21 Catherines intent was to superimpose a severe,
monumentalprogramontheornate,flamboyantdecoroftheJernimoscomplex,whilethetombs
reflect a hybrid intermingling of East and West. This was a conception where the exotic and the
antiquewereperfectlyamalgamated.ThealtarpiececommissionedbythequeendepictingScenesof
theLifeofChristmirrorsnotionsofimperialismandauniversalChristianmonarchycultivatedatthe
Lisbon court.22 This pantheon reflects Catherines concern with her own selfimaging for posterity.
NotunlikewhatwasthecasewithMargaretsfunerarycomplexatBrou,shesoughttopromotetwo
dynasties, first and foremost focusing on the Aviz dynasty while at the same time legitimizing her
own association and status within the House of Habsburg. In essence, Catherine dedicated the
JernimoschapeltothememoryoftheAvizdynasty,whodividedtheworldwithHabsburgSpainin
theRenaissance.
ISBN9789460184833
212

Fig.3InteriorviewoftheJernimoschurch.Viewofthecapelamor
throughtheornateManuelinenave.Photo:publicdomain.

Fig.4ThetombsofJohnIII(farleft)andCatherineofAustriaontheright
sideofthecapelamorfacingthealtar.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
SobrietyandOpulence:TheHistoryofConstructionoftheCapelaMor(156372)
The capela mor underwent a complicated construction history before reaching its present
form,startingwithseveralbuildingphasesinitiatedbyManuelIbeforethoseundertakenbyJohnIII
andfinallyCatherineofAustria.23In1563,shortlyafterCatherinesabdicationasregent,Sebastianof
Portugal, under the influence of his grandmother, began remodeling the main chapel first
constructedbyManuelI,whichhadbeendesignatedinhis1521testamentashismausoleum.Bythe
endofCatherinesregencyin1562,theManuelinechapelwasconsideredbythecourttoosmalland
too low in height, despite transformations made by John III around 1551. Descriptions from this
period,whichcouldshedmorelightonthechapelsolderappearance,havenotsurvived.By1569,all
works in Belm were suspended upon Sebastians orders: fortifications on the African coast
necessitatedfinancingfromthecrownandfundswereredirectedforthesemilitaryrenovations.It
ISBN9789460184833
213

was at this juncture that Catherine assumed responsibility as she had done for previous building
projects,undertakingresponsibilityforthecompletionofthechapelsremodelinganddefrayingall
costsfromherpersonalincome.
SousaViterbowasthefirsttopublish,inhismonumentaldictionaryofPortuguesearchitects
and engineers, the series of documents in the Torre do Tombo archive which outline this later
constructionphasesupervisedbythequeen.24Thearchitectappointedmasteroftheroyalworksin
1571,JernimodeRuo(JrmedeRouen,ca.15311601),sonofthesculptorJoodeRuo(Jean
deRouen),wascontractedbyCatherine.25Theplanconceivedwasatunnellikebarrelvaultattached
tothenaveofthemonastery(seefig.3),replacingtheolderstructurewhichwasformerlysquarein
plan. This chapel was the first of its kind seen in Renaissance Portugal and was to exert great
influence upon later religious buildings.26 In particular, as the architectural historian George Kubler
found, the distinctive contrast between the Manueline nave and the chapel sanctuary created a
forbiddingantithesisbetweensacredandeverydayspace.Measuringthirteenmetersinlengthand
slightlyovereightmetersinwidth,thechapelinteriorissevereandrestrained,inaformalclassicism
thatcontrastsgreatlywiththesurroundingornatestyle(fig.5).

Fig.6PanelwithgrotesqueinthearchnexttoCatherineof
AustriastombafteraFlemishmodel.Photo:A.Jordan
Gschwend.
Fig.5ThecapelamorbuiltbyJernimode
Ruo.Photo:publicdomain.
SixteenwhitemarbleIoniccolumnssuperimposedbyaslenderCorinthianorder(disproportionatein
scale)intersected by six windows above and two belowsurround the walls until the arch,
supporting cornices that circumvent the vault. The opulent, luxurious play of colored marble
revetment(blue,whiteandred),broughtfromVilaViosa(Estremoz),isfinelycarved.Thecheckered
floorlaidoutingeometricpatternsreflectsthissamecoloration.Atotalof224,960reaiswasspent
on the cutting, polishing and transportation of the marble, all elements and details being highly
carvedandfinelyexecuted.27Thevaultimitatesinstoneawoodencofferedceiling,inasimulationof
wood paneling that is carried further in the window frames below, which are carved like wooden
screens, projecting an illusionistic perspective meant to make the chapel appear larger than in
reality. In each of the niches where the tombs are housed, carved in the upper registers of the
ISBN9789460184833
214

arches,areveryplastic,illusionisticgrotesquescopiedafterFlemishengravingsdesignedbyCornelis
BosandHansVredemandeVries(fig.6).
The documents published by Sousa Viterbo indicate that the window grates were
embellished with brass plates costing 20,000 reais, which were later gilded, the gilding being
commissionedfromthemetalfounderSimodaRosa.AleixoPires,locksmithandmetalworker,was
paid 40,000 reais for iron grates made for these same windows, while the tinsmiths, Diogo
FernandezandSimoFeio,werepaid50,000reaisforbalustersdescribedinFrei(orFrayinSpanish)
Manuel Baptista de Castros seventeenthcentury chronicle of the Hieronymite order, Chronica do
maximoDoutorePrncipedosPatriarchasS.Jeronymo,ParticulardoReynodePortugal.28Thesewere
madeofbronzeandplacedabovethestepsleadinguptothechapel,whichclearlysegregatedthis
spacefromthenave.Nowremoved,theymeasuredsixpalmosinheight(132cm).BaptistadeCastro
relatesthatanothersetofgiltbronzegrates(intheformofspears)oncedividedthechapelfromthe
presbytery. According to a contemporary 1572 account written by an anonymous courtier, the
fenestration commissioned by Catherine of Austria came from Venice.29 The project was finally
completedbyOctoberof1572.

Fig.7ViewofCatherineofAustriasTomb.
Photo:A.JordanGschwend.

Fig.8Detailwithoneelephantcaryatid
holdingCatherineofAustriassarcophagus
withtusksofrealivory.Photo:A.Jordan
Gschwend.

Throughout, Jeronimo de Ruo displays a preference for contrasting surface pattern and
soberlinearity.Onbothsidesofthechapel,setintoindividualarcades,arefourpyramidaltombsin
the form of classical sarcophagi made of colored marble (pink and gray), resting on dark grayish
green marble elephant caryatids with real ivory tusks (figs. 78). Each elephant wears a different
trapping or caparison; all eight were carved between 1571 and 1572 (fig. 9).30 Set on top of the
sepulchersaregiltbronzeroyalcrownsrestingonrealisticallycarvedmarblepillowswithfourtassels
(fig. 10). Catherines decision to display Portuguese regalia resting on richly appointed pillows
adornedwithtrompeloeiltextileswasborrowedfromHabsburgephemeralcatafalquesdisplayedat
ISBN9789460184833
215

Fig.9ViewofthepairofelephantcaryatidsofCatherineofAustrias
tomb.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.

Fig.10ViewofCatherineofAustriasbronzeroyalcrownrestingabove
hersarcophagus.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.

royalexequiesandfunerals,prefiguringtheadornmentoftheatricalBaroquefunerarymonuments
withregalattributes.
Each tomb bears cenotaphs with panegyric inscriptions in Latin composed by the court
humanistAndrdeResende(14981573)(fig.11).Facingthealtartotheleft(theGospelside)arethe
remains of Manuel I and his second spouse, Maria of Castile (14821517), while to the right (the
Epistle side) are those of his son John III and Catherine of Austria (see fig. 4). The queen had first
planned to be buried with her husband on the Gospel side, which is considered more noble.
However, her intentions were challenged by Cardinal Infante Henry, who claimed this privilege
belongedexclusivelytohisfatherManuelIasfounderoftheJernimosmonastery.Amarblealtar
below the painted retable is encased with the same geometric patterns of circles, squares and
lozenges, and the muted color schemes of pinks, grays and white used throughout the chapel. Its
table was described, in this same 1572 anonymous account, as a large block of porphyry, a
particularlyhard,expensivestoneusedsinceAntiquityforsepulchersandmausolea.However,this
stoneisnotnativetoPortugalandtheauthormusthaveconfuseditwithdarkredmarble,purple
beingacolorlongassociatedwithroyalty.

Fig.11CatherineofAustriasepitaph,composedby
AndrdeResende.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
ISBN9789460184833
216

Thelateralchapelsinthetranseptflankingthecapelamoremulatetheseverestyleusedby
Ruo for the main chapel. They postdate the commission issued by Catherine, who may not have
evenenvisagedtheirconception,andbecamearepositoryforprincesoftheAvizroyalfamilyafter
1580. Ten tombs are set within niches, made with the same contrasting play of colored marble.
Amongthoseburiedhereare:Sebastian,Catherinesgrandson,JohnIIIsbrothers,CardinalInfante
Henry, former Regent and King of Portugal, Infantes Luis, Ferdinand and Afonso, and two of
Catherineschildrenwhodiedinearlyinfancy.Thereissomeconfusionastothedatesofexecution
of these lateral chapels and whether Ruo himself undertook this later project. They were built
sometime between 1587 and 1591. These later sarcophagi with Latin inscriptions also rest upon
identicalmarbleelephants,asinthecapelamor.
The exterior of the capela mor is encased with a turreted square box with small round
towers punctuated by small windows and a heavy bracketed cornice (figs. 1213). Whether Ruo
executedhisowndesignorcompletedonedrawnupearlierbyDiogodeTorralva(active15451566)
hasremainedapointofcontention.Theoutsideechoestheinteriorsobrietyandisarchitectonically
reminiscent of military structures, in particular towers. George Kubler dubbed this style the estilo
cho,orplainstyle.Ruosintention,andtoadegreeCatherineofAustriasaspatron,wastoimpose
dignity and majesty on the Jernimos complex. By the midsixteenth century the Lisbon court
evidently found the ornate Manueline style too outdated to convey the royal decorum and
statelinessthequeenrequired.BoththeinteriorandexteriorofCatherinescapelamordemonstrate
a complete break with older traditions, and the integration of novel architectural ideals borrowed
fromItalywasdeemedappropriatebyCatherine.31

Fig.12Exteriorviewofthecapelamor.Photo:A.Jordan
Gschwend.

ISBN9789460184833
Fig.13Therearofthecapelamorwithits
fortified,towerlikeexteriorinastyle
GeorgeKublerdubbedtheestilocho.
217

Catherinerenouncedherregencyin1562.In1563PiusIVbestoweduponherthePapalrose,
the highest recognition granted by the Church to a Renaissance queen. The rose, made of gold
branchesoftenembellishedwithjewels,symbolizedChristsloveandpassion,andwasgivenonrare
occasions to royal monarchs and queens for services to the Church, as a token of reverence and
affection.Despiteher capacityforgovernment,especiallyduringherregency (15571562), andthe
recognition granted her by the Papacy, in the late 1560s Catherine was determined to retire to a
convent in Spain. In later letters to Pope Pius V of 1572 seeking his advice and support, Catherine
confided in him, mentioning her discontent about residing in Portugal and her persistent wish to
leave:tambemdasrazesqueeutenhoparaviverdescontentoeintentar,eaindaefectuarqualquer
mudana.32Herearnestintenttorelocatetwoyearsearlierhadbeenfullysupportedbyhernephew
inSpain,PhilipII,withwhomshecultivatedclosepersonalties.TheSpanishkinghadevenproposed
variouslocationsforhisaunt,firstamongthemCarmonaandBaeza.33ThenTalaveraandOcaawere
consideredoptimalcitiesforthequeensnewresidence,andwhenCatherinefinallysettledforthe
latterlocation,muchtoPhilipssatisfaction,shedecidedtotravelthereviathepilgrimagechurchof
Guadalupe(Extremadura).34Theseplans soondisintegratedwhen newsofherimminentdeparture
reachedgovernment,courtandchurchofficialsinPortugal.35Attheirinsistence,Catherineresigned
herself to remaining in Portugal, removing herself to the Madre de Deus convent in Xabregas,
determinedtocompletetheJernimoschapelaccordingtohergrandiosevisionandintendingthis
structure to be her last official undertaking as patron and queen. Despite her satisfaction with the
building,thequeensdesiretoleavethekingdomofPortugalpersistedlongaftershehadcompleted
herpantheon.
A combination of motives lay behind Catherines rebuilding of the capela mor. Taking her
auntMargaretofAustriaandBrouasoneexemplum,Catherinesoughttocreateherownmonument
honoringherlatehusbandJohnIII,hisfatherManuelI,andtheAvisdynasty.Withhertomblocated
in this sumptuous funerary chapel, Catherine also wished to glorify her Habsburg family. A third
motive was to demonstrate her piety and her devotion to the religious order of the Hieronymites.
The queens attachment to religious orders in Portugal throughout her reign,36 and in the closing
years of her life to the Jerminos monastery, did not differ from the devotion displayed by her
HabsburgrelativesattheFlemishandSpanishcourts.HerbrotherCharlesVretiredtoaHieronymite
monasteryatYuste,whichwasreconstructedtofithisspecificneedforadignifiedretreatandafinal
restingplace.HernephewPhilipIIbuiltasuperlativeHabsburgpantheonattheEscorialmonastery,
whileherniece,JuanaofAustria,conceivedtheideaofapersonaltombandmemorialencapsulated
within the Convent of the Descalzas Reales in Madrid, which she founded in 1555 and whose
institutional purpose was to be the leading spiritual center in Spain. In these monastic complexes
Catherineandherimmediatefamilymadepublictheircommonconcernforsalvation,memoria,and
remembrance.
Above all, Catherines commission reaffirmed the original intentions of Manuel I, who
transferredcontrolofthemonasteryin1496fromtheOrderofChristtotheHieronymites,building
thechurchin1498.Fromtheoutsethevisualizedthecomplexasaroyalpantheonincombination
with a symbolic, iconographical program that was implemented throughout.37 In the medieval
interpretationofkingshipManuelimagedhimselfasanOldTestamentking,andmorespecificallyas
DavidLusitanus.ThisideologywasappliedinthedecorationandsculpturalprogramoftheJernimos
cloister where the Portuguese were depicted as the newly elected people of God, who because of
ISBN9789460184833
218

their maritime achievements and conquests in Africa and Portuguese Asia were able to spread
Christianitytotheendsoftheglobe.ThecloistersculpturesshowManuelasthetriumphantmessiah
surrounded by Virtues and being promoted as the victorious leader of the quasimythological and
historicalexploitsofthePortuguesediscoverers.Hisearlypantheonwasintendedasadignifiedfinal
resting place for himself and his illustrious royal dynasty. Andr de Resendes Latin epitaph on
Manuel Is tomb reconfirms this ideology: To whomfrom the western sands to where the sun
risesextended the cult and knowledge of God. To whom so many subjugated kings relinquished
theircrowns.Here,inthistomb,restsManueltheGreat.
Inordertoensureeternalsalvation,Manuelstipulatedthatahundredmonksbededicated
to the eternal service of the deceased royal souls. In her 1577 testament Catherine provided for
merceeiros who would pray for her after her death.38 Twenty people were appointed to the
Jernimos monastery for this purpose: courtiers with limited financial means were paid an annual
rentof20,000reaistoprayforthesoulsoftheroyalfamily,withpreciseinstructionsstipulatedby
the queen for the number of liturgical services and prayers to be said. The queen purchased land
neartheJernimosmonasteryforhermerceeiros,inordertohousetheminthevicinityandfacilitate
the carrying out of the functions of their offices: tambem se lhes daram pera sua habitao e
morada casas convenientes no sitio que pera ellas tenho mandado comprar perto do mosteiro de
Nossa Senhora de Beleem onde esto as sepulturas del rey meu senhor que Deus tem e minha. A
plaque was hung in the sacristy listing all the perpetual masses and devotions to be said for the
queenandJohnIII.Thus,therelationshipofthemainaltartotheroyaltombswasintendedtofulfill
two functions: the service of God and the service of the dead. According to CounterReformation
ideologyCatherineofAustriawascomplyingwithobjectiveslaiddownbytheCouncilofTrent:the
intercessiononbehalfofthedeadandtheperpetualadorationofChristintheBlessedSacrament.
The cult of the host gained momentum in Portugal precisely in this period. It was probably at this
timethatJernimoOsrio(15061580),Bishopof Algarveand thequeens confessor,dedicatedto
Catherine a treatise on the sacrifice of the mass, which the court humanist considered one of the
mostprofoundmysteriesoftheChristianreligion,entitledBrevesumariodoqueaReligiochristiana
insinaaercadosacrificiodamissa.39CatherinesdevotiontotheEucharistwaswellknownamongst
conventsandchurchesinLisbon,40especiallytheMadredeDeus,forwhichchurchthequeenmade
graycurtainsembroideredwithgoldforthetabernaclewheretheBlessedSacramentwasreserved.41
Thememorializationofdeceasedroyals,withstatuesinperpetualprayer,withinthecontext
ofahighaltarsanctuarywascertainlynotnovel,especiallyinfuneraryartinFrance,Italy,Austriaand
Spain.ContemporaryexamplescanfoundontombswithgisantsoftheBurgundiancourt(Dijon),on
the tomb of the recumbent Mary of Burgundy in Bruges, on the monument to Maximilian I at
InnsbruckwithitslifesizebronzeportrayalsofhisHabsburgancestors,ontheroyalFrenchtombsat
St.Denis,attheCartuxadeMirafloresinBurgos,andintheCapillaRealinGranada.Ruospyramidal
tombs show a conscious break with older traditions, rejecting representational jacent or orant
effigies (with portraits) for severe, classical sarcophagi in keeping with the new, innovative type of
sepulchersintroducedbyCatherine.TheelephantcaryatidsinBelmrecallthoseoftheSigismondo
chapel in the Tempio Malatestiano in Rimini, which were designed by Alberti and executed by
AgostinodiDucciobetween1446and1447(seefig.9).TheMalatestafamilyadoptedtheelephantas
an emblem and devisa that appeared everywhere on family escutcheons, medals, and sarcophagi.
Although this Italian precedence may have influenced the Lisbon tombs, whether Francisco de
ISBN9789460184833
219

Holanda (15171584), who was familiar with Italian monuments, had any influence as an artistic
advisor to the queen is difficult to confirm. Holanda has often been proposed as designer of the
capela mor, because of his firsthand experience with contemporary Italian architecture and his
position as courtierartist to Catherine of Austria. There is, however, no documentary evidence for
his participation in this building project. During the period of the chapels construction, Holandas
careerattheLisboncourtwaswaning,andin1572hesoughtapostfromPhilipIIofSpain,offering
his services to the Spanish monarch through a letter of petition.42 Albertis De Re Aedificatoria,
translated in 1551 by Andr de Resende upon the orders of John III, could equally well have
transmitted ideas about the iconography and symbolism of the Malatestiano temple to the Lisbon
court.43
IntheRenaissancetherepresentationoftheelephantasabeastofburden(withacastleon
its back) was assimilated by the Western imagination as the beast of regal triumphs, a symbol of
vanquishedmight.44InAntiquity,Romanimperialtriumphsinvariablyincludedelephants,andinthe
sixteenth century ancient entries coupled with imperial imagery were enthusiastically revived.
Manuel I paraded daily around Lisbonin triumphwith his five Asian elephants and their Indian
mahouts.45 Renaissance artists incorporated the timehonored motif of the elephant as a worthy
visual element for pageants and festivities. A series of Tournai tapestries depicting the Portuguese
conquestsinIndiacommissionedbyManuelIin1510,whichincludeddepictionsofelephants,were
usedasportableformsofvisualpropagandaforthenationsachievementsinhisroyalresidences.46
TheConquestofIndiatapestrycyclewasthesinglemostimportantcommissionofhisreign,which
celebratedthePortuguesediscoveryofIndiainthemannerofancientRomantrionfi.47
Elephants had played a fundamental role at the Portuguese court since the early sixteenth
century, both for the image and the prestige of Lusitanian monarchs.48 Damio de Gis, the court
humanist and chronicler of Manuel Is life and reign, was truly impressed with the elephants that
Indian kings and Ceylonese emperors sent to Manuel as tokens of respect and as tribute.49 In his
writings he referred to these Lisbon elephants and especially to the spectacle they caused when
paraded through the city streets. It is clear that Manuels pachyderms were a source of pride for
Gis,whoviewedthemasphysicalmanifestationsoftheforeignlandsdiscoveredbythePortuguese.
Catherine cultivated a special affinity for elephant imagery, often purchasing costly objects in the
form of elephants for her Kunstkammer collection.50 Her fascination with elephants is further
evidencedbythequantityofivoryobjectsfromCeylonandIndiaonceinhercollection;furthermore,
asatokenofheraffectionshepresentedliveAsianelephantsasgiftstoherHabsburgrelativesfor
their menageries in Spain and Austria. For the Portuguese court, the elephant represented the
triumphant conquest of overseas territories. Not surprisingly, in Hindu culture the elephant was
considered strictly the property of the king, a practice later adopted by the Portuguese monarchs,
whoregardedthemselvesasrulersofempire.
ElephanticonographypermeatedPortugalsartisticcircles.In1571,inanefforttoboosthis
career at court, Francisco de Holanda sent Sebastian a manuscript entitled Da fabrica que falece a
cidade de Lisbon.51 In this treatise, the artist pleads with the young king to undertake certain
architectural projects abandoned after John IIIs death in 1557, which would transform Lisbon into
thejewelofallcities.Holandasconceptionforafountainplacedneartheroyalpalace,thePaoda
Ribeira,builtbyManuelI,wasofanelephantwithacastleonitsback(fig.14).
ISBN9789460184833
220

Fig.14FranciscodeHolanda,Drawingforafountainprojectedfortheship
dockyardsofLisbon(Ribeiradosnaos)fromDaFabricaquefaleceLisboa,1571,
BibliotecadaAjuda,Lisbon,Ms.51III9,f.18r.
DuringtheMiddleAgestheelephantalsobecamethetoposforthesymbolicbattlebetween
good and evil; the death of the elephant was considered a prefiguration of Christs death on the
cross. Combats between wild beasts were staged in Lisbon. The natural antipathy of wild animals
provokeddebateatManuelIscourt.Curiosityandaninterestinthewritingsofancientauthorssuch
asPlinycombinedwiththedesiretoimitateanimalcombatsofancientRomeinspiredthestagingof
abattleinJuneof1515betweenanelephantandarhinocerosfromCambay(thefirstseeninEurope
sinceAntiquity),whichhadbeensenttoLisbonbythesultanofGujarat.Inacourtyardbetweenthe
Lisbon royal palace and the Casa da India, the India customs house, this confrontation ended
unexpectedlywiththeelephantfleeinginfrighttohisstablesatRossiosquare.Therhinoceroswas
declared victorious by default. The Lisbon court fully appreciated the medieval moralization of the
elephants virtues: power, might, diligence, sagacity, humility, and industry. This melding of pagan
and Christian symbolism in the use of elephant caryatids for the capela mor was intentional on
CatherinespartandinkeepingwithManuelIsideologyandherownlovefortheAsianpachyderms
shecollected.
TheRetabloMor(15711572):LourenodeSalzedo
Catherine of Austrias close supervision of the painting of the altarpiece she commissioned
forthecapelamorisdemonstratedbyaletterwrittenbyCatherinetoherambassadorinRome,Joo
Telles de Meneses.52 In this missive dated 7 July 1571 the queen thanked the diplomat for
assiduouslyexpeditingthedeliveryofthecolorsshehadrequested.Thiswasnotthefirsttimeinthe
courseofthiscommissionthatthequeenwouldgotosuchlengthstoobtainqualitypigmentsfrom
Italy. In reality the altarpiece took months to realize and Catherines concept underwent several
stagesandtransformationsbeforereachingitsfinalandpresentstate.
Forheroriginalaltarpiece,thequeenchosetoemulateherelderbrotherCharlesVandthe
commissionhegaveTitian(ca.14881576)forthemonumentalLaGloriaaltarpiecedestinedforthe
Yustemonasterychurch,todayintheMuseodelPrado(Madrid).53In1568Catherinecommissioned
fromthesameVenetianmasterapaintingoftheFlagellationofChrist,whichisnowlostbutwhich
wasrecordedinanengravingentitled,IlSemolei(fig.15)bytheVenetiandraughtsman,painterand
ISBN9789460184833
221

etcherBattistaFranco(ca.15101568?).GiorgioVasariwasthefirsttorelate,inthesecondeditionof
hisVite,thatCatherineorderedfromTitianalargescalepaintingofTheFlagellationofChristforthe
Jernimoschapel,whichVasaridescribedasexquisite:allareinadiPortogalloinunquadrofeceun
Christo poco minore del vivo, battuto da giudei alla colonna, che bellissimo.54 This was the first
ItalianRenaissancepaintingCatherineevercommissionedforaspecificlocationandwithaspecific
purposeinmind,anditistellingthatshechoseTitian,CharlesVsfavoritecourtpainter,toexecute
forheranaltarpieceintendedforthemostsignificantprojectofherreign.Itequallyemphasizesthat
thequeensoriginalconceptionforthecapelamoraltarpiecewasradicallydifferentfromitspresent
form. Her intention was to hang one single magnificent painting as the focal point of her austere
chapel.TitiansFlagellationreflectedCatherinesdevotiontotheHoursoftheCrossandthePassion
ofChrist.

Fig.15BattistaFranco(ca.15101568?),IlSemolei,TheFlagellation
ofChrist,engravingafteralostTitian,Venice,1568,British
Museum,London,inv.no.1874,0808.369.
Catherine was greatly influenced by a contemporary manuscript from the hand of the
Hieronymite priest and mystic Frei Miguel de Valena, Meditaciones sobre las horas de la Cruz.
ValenabecamePrioroftheJernimosmonasteryin1550,wherehededicatedhimselftostudyand
meditation.Underhispriorship,andinlinewiththedictatesoftheCouncilofTrent,theimagingand
iconographyofChristinthemonasterywasgivennewdirectionandsignificance.Valenamusthave
encouraged the queen to present in the visual program of the altarpiece a more direct, accessible
and straightforward image of Christ. Through information provided by agents or resident
ambassadors in Italy, the Portuguese queen may well have been aware of a contemporary
commissionforaTransfigurationofChristexecutedbyTitianfortheChurchofSanSalvadorinVenice
anddatedaround1560(fig.16),the TransfigurationbeingaChristologicalthemewhich dealswith
the dual nature of Christ as God and man.55 The dedication of this church to the divine nature of
ChristasSaviorprovidedthejustificationforTitiansextraordinarilylargepainting(245x295cm)at
themainaltarformingthecentralfocusofthechurch(fig.17).Thismonumentalcanvasissetintoan
elaborate marble tabernacle, recalling a smallscale monstrance containing the Holy Eucharist.
Evidently, Catherine had envisaged, if not the identical theme, a similar concept and manner of
presentation for her commission of the Flagellation for the capela mor, probably at the advice of
Titianhimself.
ISBN9789460184833
222

Fig.16Titian,Transfiguration,ChurchofSanSalvador,Venice.
Photo:publicdomain.

Fig.17InteriorviewoftheChurchofSanSalvadorwiththemain
altar,Venice.Photo:publicdomain.
For inexplicable reasons, however, Titians Flagellation never reached Lisbon, and it is not
known if the queen ever expressed regrets about Titian being unable to complete her altarpiece.
Why the Flagellation remained in Titians workshop, and why Catherine never received it, is
enigmatic.56TheanswermaylieinthefactthatTitianandhisstudioassistantswereextremelybusy
in1568completinganumberofotherpaintingsfortheSpanishcourt,whichtookpriority,including
thecolossalMartyrdomofSt.LawrenceforPhilipIIandtheEscorialmonastery,whichisstillinsitu.
ThesecommissionsforSpainmadeitimpossibleforTitiantofulfilCatherineswishesatthisjuncture,
let alone to have the time needed to complete a gigantic altarpiece for the Jernimos chapel. But
whohadguidedandadvisedCatherinetoorderatourdeforcepaintingbyTitian?Onepossibilityis
thathersister,MaryofHungary(15051558),oneofTitiansforemostpatrons,mayhaveintroduced
thePortuguesequeentotheVenetianmasterbeforeherdeathin1558.
MarysowncourtportraitbyTitian,ofwhichCatherineownedareplicainherportraitgallery
intheLisbonroyalpalace,visuallyemphasizedherpoliticalroleasregentoftheLowCountries.No
ISBN9789460184833
223

longer extant but known through copies, it was executed in Augsburg in 1548 and depicts Mary
dressed in widows weeds standing in front of a column, a pictorial allusion to Charles V and his
emblemofthetwincolumnsofHercules(NonPlusUltra).57Maryspecificallychosetomoldherselfin
the likeness of her widowed aunt Margaret of Austria, selfimaging herself as a loyal servant
dedicated to the rule of the Habsburg dynasty. This Titian portrait was a conscious commission, a
political move by Mary, who chose to have herself portrayed both as a pious widow and as a
stateswomanengagedinHabsburgcourtpoliticsanddiplomacy.
CatherinewasnotaconnoisseurofItalianpainting,nordidshecollectthekindofItalianart
works, sculpture or antiquities so avidly sought by contemporary princes, collectors and her sister
Mary. An introduction to Titian through Mary of Hungary is quite plausible. An important link
between the Habsburg court in Flanders and Portugal was cultivated through the relationship of
MaryandCatherine.DocumentsintheLisbonarchivehavedisclosedthatthesesisters,whonever
met, maintained close contact, exchanging ideas on artistic and political matters.58 Gifts, court
portraits, Flemish tapestries, slaves, and exotica from Portuguese Asia were reciprocated between
the two siblings. Catherines patronage reflects patterns of collecting and modes of patronage
established by Mary in Flanders.59 Catherines preference for Flemish art works and craftsmen
reflectstheguidinginfluenceofthissister,60butinthecaseoftheJernimosaltarpiece,aVenetian
TitianwasconsideredbyCatherine,underMarysinfluence,tobeamoresuitablechoice.
WhilefewartworkswithanItalianprovenancewererecordedinCatherinescollectionand
Kunstkammer,Flemishtapestries,paintingsandobjectswerepresent.61Throughherclosetieswith
thePapalcourt,CatherinedidreceivegiftsfromtheVatican,asinJanuary1577,whenacasketfullof
Agnus Dei was sent by the Pope to the queen.62 Only one painting from Rome is documented in
CatherinesprivatechapelintheLisbonroyalpalace:themiraculousimageoftheVirginfromSanta
MariaMaggiore,commissionedbyFranciscodeBorjain1569forthequeen.OrwasitCharlesVwho
inspiredhisyoungersistertothinkofTitianasthepainterforheraltarpiece?Catherineidolizedher
brother and knew many details of his living arrangements and daily life at Yuste. From courtiers
whomshesentalmostonadailybasistovisitherbrothershewaswellinformedabouttheemperor
hearingmassfromhisquarters,withadirectview ofthehighaltarintheYustemonasterychurch
where Titians La Gloria hung. Despite the emperors predilection for Flemish tapestries, portraits
andpaintings,hisrespect andadmirationfortheVenetianpainterwascelebratedat hiscourtand
amonghisfamily.
CircumstancesinTitianscareerandworkshopforcedCatherinetobeginanewsearchfora
newconceptforheraltarpieceandforasuitablepainterofquality.63Atthisjunctureshehopedto
securetheservicesoftheSpaniardGasparBecerra(1568),whowasengagedintheserviceofher
niece, Juana of Austria in Madrid, or of the Fleming Frans Floris (15191570), through the
intervention of her nephew Philip II and her ambassador in Spain, Francisco Pereira. However,
Becerra had recently passed away and the queen was unaware that Floris resided in Flanders.
Consequently, Catherine next solicited her nephew and her court diplomat Pereira to obtain the
services of the Italian painter Francesco da Urbino (1592), who was then working at the Escorial
monastery,butthistooendedinanimpasse.Catherinesextendedsearchfinallyledhertosettlefor
apainterwhowasactiveatherowncourtherlastchoiceforreasonsofnecessityandtimeandof
Spanish origin (from Seville), Loureno de Salzedo (ca. 15301577).64 He subsequently designed an
ISBN9789460184833
224

altarpieceradicallydifferentfromheroriginalmasterpiece,thegrandiosebutminimalistconception
tohavebeenexecutedbyTitian.Salzedosretable,morecomplexindesign,ismadeupoffivepanels
superimposed on two levels with Scenes of the Life of Christ, mirroring the notion of a universal
ChristianmonarchycultivatedattheLisboncourt.65
Once the queen had committed herself to Salzedo, she went, as discussed above, to great
lengths to obtain for him the best artists materials and pigments from Italy and from Spain, as
recently discovered archival documents reveal. Catherine had no intention of leaving any detail to
chance, as she expected her memorial to last forever. From two surviving letters,66 we know she
closelysupervisedSalzedosaltarpiece,havingwrittenherambassadorinRomeasearlyasFebruary
of 1571 to secure quality pigments, ordering him to send these as quickly as possible to Lisbon.67
TimewasoftheessenceforCatherine,andwhenthoseexpectedfromItalyhadinJune1571notyet
arrived in Portugal, she then requested Juan de Borja, the Castilian ambassador in Portugal, to
intervenewithhernephewPhilipII.68ThediplomatinturnaskedtheSpanishkingssecretary,Gabriel
Zayas,toorganizethepigmentsCatherineneededforheraltarpieceandtoadvisehimoftheircost
andexpense:
LaReynamemandoquedesuparteescrivieseaV.M.yleenbiaselamemoriaqueconesta
vadeiertascoloresqueamenesterparaelRetabloquemandapintarembelenparaquesi
aylashuviereV.M.lasmandecomprarylasenbieavisandodeloquecuestanparaqueayse
denluegolosdinerosynoallandoseacomprarsepidanasuMagestat[PhilipII]delasque
sus pintores tienen / su Alteza a muchos dias que tiene escrito por ellas a Italia y no se las
[han]enbiadoyaquitienenyaneesidaddeellas.
WhenZayasdidnotimmediatelyreactandrespond,Borjaremindedhimagaininasecondletterof
theimportanceofthesecolorsforthequeensJernimosaltarpiece:lascoloresmemandoLaReyna
[Catherine]quetornaseaacordaraV.M.escosadequesuAltezallevamuchogustoporserparael
monasterio de belen. Shortly after, Philip II sent word to Lisbon agreeing to help his aunt obtain
pigmentsthroughhissquadronofItalianandforeignpaintersworkingattheEscorial.Muchtothe
queens dismay and outrage, however, the courier organized by her Portuguese ambassador in
Castile encountered problems en route to Lisbon and her package with colors was mistakenly
confiscatedbycustomofficialsnearBadajoz,inAlbuquerque(intheExtremadura).69Thismishapof
coursecausedmoreunexpecteddelays,asJuandeBorjadulyreportedbacktoZayas:
Elcorreoquetruxolas[cartas]de26[deJunio]queesunoque despacho el embaxadorde
portugalquesellamaPintomedixocomometrayaunemboltorioqueV.M.ledioelqualle
tomaronenAlburquerquecomoV.M.loveraporlacartadeGasparRamirezqueconestava
estoy con muy gran cuydado de saber lo que era aunque tengo por ierto que seran las
colores que su Magestad [Philip II] enbia a la Reyna lo qual me pareze que es ya tanta
desverguenaqueyonosecomollevarloyconfiesoaV.M.quehetenidoquehazercomigo
elholvidarlatierraadondenaiporquenosecosaquesellevepeorquesinjustiiaarmada
laReynaquedamuyescandaliadaytantoquequeriaenbiaruncriadosuyoaquexarsede
todosestos.70
Philip II again had to intervene and promised to remedy the matter and punish the official
responsibleforthisblunder.Oncematterswereresolved,thepigmentsfinallyarrivedattheLisbon
ISBN9789460184833
225

courtandthemoniesforpaymentwereforwardedtoSpain.71Catherinesartisticexchangewithher
nephew at this date was a fruitful one and demonstrates that identical pigments were used for
frescoesattheEscorialandforthealtarpieceoftheJernimoscapelamor,thuscreatingasymbolic
link, through color and paint, between these two representative churches and their pictorial
decoration.
InasecondseriesoflettersfromLisbon,BorjainformedGabrielZayasofawoodenwriting
desk, perfumes and gloves that Catherine had sent to the kings secretary for his invaluable
assistance with the purchase of the pigments.72 In equal gratitude, the queen sent her nephew a
numberofgifts,amongthemchurchvestmentsandpaliosfortheEscorialmonasterythatshehad
personallyembroideredin1575,forwhichPhilipwasmostgratefulbecausetheyweremadebyhis
aunt,kissingherhandsmanytimesforthem.73
TheneedfornotimetobelostinthecompletionofthealtarpiecewasduetoCatherines
advancedageandfragilehealthatthisdate.Thiswascompoundedbythefactthatherrelationswith
her grandson Sebastian had disintegrated, both personally and politically. In a letter Catherine
addressed to Sebastian in 1571 she justified her reasons for moving to Spain, complaining that he
neverresidedinLisbonwhenshedid,andstatingthatbecauseoftheirestrangementshepreferred
toburyherselfalive(enterrarseviva)inaconvent.74InanotherlettertoJernimoOsrio,Bishopof
Algarve, she confessed that her departure would be a wakeup call for the country: desejo de ser
com minha ida hun despertador.75 Just before the Jernimos chapel and altarpiece were even
completed,thequeenagainmadeseriousmovestoretiretoaconventinSpain,makingitimperative
forherthattheJernimosprojectbeterminatedbeforeherintendeddeparture.BoththeJernimos
project and the continuous strife with her grandson had left the queen tired and exhausted. In a
personal note to Philip II, Catherine confirmed she would retire to the Madre de Deus convent
foundedbyheraunt,ManuelIssister,theDowagerQueenLeonor,andthatshewouldresideinher
auntsformerquarters.76Thecapelamoraltarpiecehadtakenitstoll:ithadbeenalongjourneyfrom
Titian to Salzedo. The queen, worn down by the tense political situation at the Lisbon court, was
mostpleasedtoseethecompletionofherchapel,asJuandeBorjareportedtoPhilipIIinOctoberof
1572:alacapillanuevaquelaReynaleshahechoenBelen,hizoseconmuchasolemnidad,yestaya
lacapillaacabadaypuestaensuperfeion,esunedifiiomuyparaver,quedolaReynamuycontenta
dehaverledadofin.77
TheJernimosaltarpiecewasfirstattributedtoLourenodeSalzedobyBaptistadeCastroin
hisseventeenthcenturyaccountofthemonastery.Atotaloffivepanelsdepictscenesfromthelife
ofChristwithtwothemesthatwhichunderscorethehumananddivinenature.Oneithersideofthe
altar are paintings of the Adoration of the Magi, while above the altar are three scenes from the
PassionofChrist(fig.18ab).Thesequenceofthetwolastsceneswasdeliberatelyinverted,sothat
oneseesfromlefttoright,ChristcarryingtheCross,thentheDescentfromtheCrossandthenthe
Flagellation. The representation of Christs dead body, which normally follows the Flagellation,
visually dominates the central area, directly above the altar, and serves as an antithesis to the
paintingbelow,nowlost,oftheinfantChrist,thenewMessiah,inthemangerbeingworshippedby
oneofthekneelingMagi:Caspar,theeldestofthethree.Totherightofthelostcentralpanel,each
withhisretinue,areBalthasar,theblackAfrican,andtotheleftMelchior(orBelchior,theyoungest
ofthethree),towhomSalzedogavetheidealizedappearanceofthelatekingJohnIII.Theblackking
ISBN9789460184833
226

is realistically portrayed and may have been a reallife portrait of one the numerous slaves (some
manumitted) employed in Catherines household.78 Balthasar wears the turban and cloak of an
easternpotentateasheoffersthechildaluxuriousgoldvessel.Theseatedmaleandfemalefigures
to left of Melchior are very sculptural in appearance, particularly in their poses and drapery,
reflecting the impact of the Roman school of painting represented by Michelangelo and Giulio
Romano,andSalzedosexposuretotheseartistsduringhisinfluentialperiodofresidenceinRome.79
Melchiorisprecededbyapagecarryingacasket,dressedasanOldTestamentkingandwearinga
crown.TheelementsofexoticismusuallydepictedwiththethreeMagicamels,tigers,leopards
wereeliminatedinthispanel,beingreplacedbytherealisticportrayaloftwoAsianelephantsinthe
rightbackground,sharingawaterfountainwithmules.
The decision to juxtapose the Adoration of the Magi with the Life of Christ was deliberate
andSalzedosFlagellationwasevidentlycommissionedbyCatherinetoreplacethepaintingshehad
expectedfromTitian.IntheLateMiddleAgesthethreeMagicametorepresentthethreepartsof
theknownworld:Europe,AfricaandAsia.TheluxurioussymbolicgiftsbroughttotheChristchild
frankincense (homage to Christs divinity), myrrh (used for embalming), gold (symbol of Christs
kingship)foreshadow his death on the cross. The theme of the Adoration of the Magi essentially
representedthesubjugationoftemporalpowerstotheauthorityofGodandtheChurch.Inkeeping
withCatherineofAustriasbeliefsandCounterReformationphilosophy,theultimatepurposeofher
chapelwastheworshipofChristintheEucharist,visuallyreinforcedbythebodyofthedeadChrist
dominatingthepaintedspaceabovethealtar.

ThepresbyterywasconsideredthesymboliccenteroftheBlessedSacrament.Theprincipal
themestressedhereisthevenerationoftheCrossandtheEucharistintheformofChristsbodyand
blood.DevotiontotheEucharistbecameaformoffamilypietyinstitutionalizedbytheBurgundian
andHabsburgcourts.80Piety,asCatherinefullyappreciated,wasavirtueclaimedbytheHabsburgs
asaninalienablebirthrightofthefamily,andtheEucharistwasadoptedasanamuletandtalismanof
the Habsburg dynasty. The image of the Holy Cross and Eucharist became potent politicoreligious
symbolsrepresentingthesacrosanctnatureofHabsburgpower,whichCatherinetransposedtoher
chapel.

ISBN9789460184833
227

Fig.18LourenodeSalzedo,mainaltarpiece,CapelaMor,
JernimosMonastery,Belm.Photo:LusPavo.

The Christological themes of passion and death in the altarpiece, highlighting Christs dual
natureashumananddivine,werecarefullyselectedandintentionallyjuxtaposedwiththeMagiasa
prefigurationofthesalvationofmankind.Theentireconceptionandiconographicalprogramofthe
capelamorandtheretablewithitspictorialprogramrevolvedaroundthemass,whichwasoffered
both for Christ and for the deceased members of the royal family. The symbols of majesty
representedbytheactualdeadbodiesofthemonarchsandtheirqueens,placeddiscreetlyoneither
side of the chapel and reposing in severe classical sarcophagi set upon elephant caryatids, were
subjecttotheglorificationofChrist.Bothterrestrialand celestialpowersare honoredhere,asare
the immortality and divine character of kingship. This notion was reinforced by the now lost iron
balustersandgratesthatonceseparatedtheAvizmonarchs,thechosenrepresentativesofGodon
earth,fromtherestoftheChurchandhumanity.ManuelIsideologyreflectedinthedecorationof
thecloistersculminateshereinCatherinesagendaforthecapelamor:theJernimoscomplexhad
notonlybeendedicatedbyManueltotheVirginMary,butalsototheThreeMagi.
Thereisnodoubtthatthisaltarpiecewasconceivedofwithitsarchitecturalcontextinmind.
Catherines letters to Rome reconfirm that Salzedo had begun painting the retable in February of
1571, precisely when construction of the chapel was nearing completion. Details in the formal
composition of the altarpiece show that Salzedo allowed himself to be dictated to by its structural
andarchitectonicframe.Certainelementsvisuallyandillusionisticallyunitethetwopaintedcycles:
the background pilaster in the panel of Melchior is placed directly underneath the column in the
Flagellationabove.ThesmalllandscapewithChristcarryingtheCrossispreciselyrepeatedbelowin
theMelchiorpanel.Thenumerousfiguresareunusuallylarge,placedclosetotheforegroundplane,
ISBN9789460184833
228

filling the entire scene. There is little room for any progression into background space and for
extraneous details. The objective was to render the figures as large as possible, in order that they
might be seen from a greater distance, particularly since the chapel was once divided from the
church. Salzedo intentionally painted the Magi as bulky giants (colossi), while Christ appears more
delicateandslender.
Salzedo adhered to the strict, cohesive symmetry of the chapel. There is uniformity in its
simplicity, both in the architecture and in the altarpiece. It appears that Catherine of Austria
informedherselfofcurrentaesthetictrendsimportedfromItalyandconsciouslyappliedthesetothe
capela mor. Decorum and gravitas are emphasized throughout, in conformity with Counter
Reformationthought,butwhoadvisedandguidedher?CouldithavebeentheintellectualSpanish
Ambassador,JuandeBorja,whowasveryclosetothequeenandwhoobservedthebuildingofthe
capelamorateverystage?OrwasitSalzedo,whohadlivedforaconsiderableperiodinRome?The
modelsforthefigureswereadaptedfromcontemporaryItalianart,andthestrongandevenlighting
projects a sense of realism and monumentality. The red, blue, and yellow palette is strident,
emulatingin certainareasthecompositionsandcolorschemesfavoredbysuchcontemporariesas
ParmigianinoandSebastianodelPiombo,whosealtarpiecesand paintingswereavidlycollectedby
Spanish nationals residing in Rome. Despite his erstwhile rival Titian, Salzedo fulfilled Catherines
patronagerequirements,andwasequallyableunderpressuretocompletethealtarpiecewithinthe
queensrestrictivetimeframe.DespiteCatherinesneedfornotimetobelost,hisretablebrokewith
tradition, innovatively keeping in line with Italianizing influences which appeared in Portuguese
paintinginthethirdquarterofthesixteenthcentury.Salzedo,thoughobviouslynotofthecaliberof
Titian or del Piombo, nevertheless satisfied the queens requirements, finding pictorial solutions
which satisfied his demanding patron. The capela mor with the Salzedo altarpiece prefigured the
stylisticandaesthetictendenciesthatoccurredslightlylater(after1576)atthecourtofPhilipII,and
whichmanifesteditselfattheEscorialmonasteryinthepaintingsandfrescoesemulatingtheRoman
schoolofpaintingbyPellegrinoTibaldi,LucaCambiaso,FederigoZuccaroandRomuloCincinnato.81
TheQueensFuneralandExequies:February1578
ArareaccountofCatherinesdeathandfuneralceremony,theonlyonetohavesurvived,can
be found in the Archivio Segreto in the Vatican. The Papal Nuncio in Portugal, Roberto Fontana,
summarized these events in two letters he wrote to Cardinal Como in Rome on 7 February 1578.
Catherineshealthhaddeterioratedtosuchadegreethattwodaysbeforeshehadbeengiventhe
lastrites.Then,intheearlymorninghoursofFebruary6,accordingtoFontana,thequeendiedwith
greatpain,passingintoabetterworld:equestanottepassataamegliorvita,congrandolore.82
KingSebastianwaspresentandretiredafterwardstotheConventofS.FranciscoinXabregas,aswas
the Cardinal Infante Henry, who went to the Madre de Deus convent adjacent to the queens
residence.FontanafurtherexplainedtoCardinalComohowthequeenssepulcherwaslocatedmany
leagues from Xabregas, in the capela mor of the Jernimos monastery, which she had built for
herself,herhusbandandherchildren:moltilegati[...]lasuaseputturaellastessagisilehaveva
preparatanelleCapellaMaggioredellaChiesadiBelemmonasteriodimonachedeS.Geronimodove
tuvo parimente quelle de suo Marito e figliuoli. On the morning and evening of February 6,
processions and orations were held throughout the city of Lisbon. In his second letter, Fontana
ISBN9789460184833
229

relates how that same evening Catherines body was carried to her sepulcher at Belm on a litter
coveredwithblackvelvet,decoratedwithawhitecross,infrontofwhichmarchedmanynoblemen,
courtiers and members of the Confraternity of the Misericordia.83 This group was followed by one
hundredfriars,eachcarryingatorch,andtheroyalfamilyonhorsebacksurroundingthefuneralbier.
Catherineschiefladyinwaitingwalkedbehindthebier,withtheArchbishopTeotnioofBraganza
and a great multitude of gentlemen and courtiers on horseback. Other participants, priests and
clergymenwentaheadtoBelm,towaitatthedooroftheJernimoschurchforthearrivalofthe
Count of Vimioso and three other principal officials of the realm. When Catherines funeral
processionarrived,theceremonyandofficesbegan,lastingwellpastmidnight.FrayLuisdeGranada
(15041588),Catherinesspiritualadvisorandconfessor,deliveredtheprincipalsermon,whichwas
wellreceivedbythosepresent.InitGranadaeulogizedthevirtuesofthedeceasedqueen,comparing
herreligiositytothatofacanonizedsaint:predic[...]congranencarecimientodelasvirtudesdela
Reina,quehayaGloria.84
In her own testament, Catherine of Austria requested that she be buried in her sepulcher
with the accompaniment and funereal pomp normally observed for the burial of the kings and
queensofthiskingdom.85Hersoleconcernwasthatherfuneralexequiesshouldnotbeexcessivein
displayandspectacle;accordingly,asnotedbytheCastiliancourtierinLisbonJuandeSilva,although
celebrated with pomp, they were less sumptuous than those observed at the Madrid court.86
CatherineofAustriawasthuslaidtorestinhersplendidtombwiththesamemajesty,restraintand
decorumwithwhichshehadlivedherlife.Herincomparablequeenlyvirtues,pioussoulandsingular
prudence were praised and memorialized in her epitaph composed by Andr de Resende (see fig.
11).87

Bibliography
Alves,JosdaFelicidade,OMosteirodeJernimos.I.Descrioeevocao(Lisbon,1989).

Alves,JosdaFelicidade,OMosteirodeJernimos.II.Descrioeevocao(Lisbon,1991).

As Gavetas do Torre do Tombo, Centro de Estudos Histricos Ultramarinos, 12 vols. (Lisbon, 1960
1977).(http://digitarq.dgarq.gov.pt/details?id=4185743).

Azcrate,J.M.,LosenterramientosrealesenElEscorial,Goya,5657(1963),pp.13039.

BaptistaPereira,F.A.,OretratodeD.SebastiodoMuseuNacionaldeArteAntiga,Prelo,11(1986),
pp.5366.

Brantme, Pierre de Bourdeille, Seigneur de, Recueil des dames, posies et tombeaux, ed. Etienne
Vaucheret(Paris,1991).
ISBN9789460184833
230

Bohde,Daniela,TitiansthreealtarprojectintheVenetianchurchofSanSalvador:strategiesofself
representation by members of the Scuola Grande di San Rocco, Renaissance Studies, 15, 4 (2001),
pp.45072.

Bouza,Fernando,CartasdeFelipeIIasushijas(Madrid,1998).

Bouza, Fernando, Imagen y Propaganda. Captulos de historia cultural del reinado de Felipe II
(Madrid,1998b).
Carpino, A., Margaret of Austrias Funerary Complex at Brou. Conjugal Love, Political Ambition, or
PersonalGlory,inWomenandArtinEarlyModernEurope.Patrons,CollectorsandConnoisseurs,ed.
CynthiaLawrence(UniversityPark,Penn.,1997),pp.3752.
Carvalho,A.,Marquesde,DoMosteirodosJernimos(Lisbon,1990).

Chiari,MariaAgnese,IncisionidaTiziano.CatalogodelfondograficoastampadelMuseoCorrer
(Venice,1982).

IVCentenariodelMonasteriodeElEscorial,4vols.(Madrid,1986).

ChuecaGoitia,Fernando,Casasrealesenmonasteriosyconventosespaoles(Madrid,1987).
Deswarte,Sylvie,LesenluminuresdelaLeituraNova15041552.tudesurlacultureartistiqueau
Portugalautempsdelhumanisme(Paris,1977).

Deswarte, Sylvie, De lemblematique lespionage: autour de D. Juan de Borja, ambassadeur
espagnol au Portugal, in As Relaes Artisticas entre Portugal e Espanha na poca dos
Descobrimentos.IISimpsioLusoEspanholdeHistriadaArte(Coimbra,1987),pp.14783.

Deswarte,Sylvie,EspoirsetDsspoirsdelInfantD.Luis,MareLiberum,3(1991),pp.24398.

Deswarte,Sylvie,IdeiaseImagensemPortugalnapocadosDescobrimentos(Lisbon,1992).

Deswarte,Sylvie,FranciscodeHolandaeoMosteirodeSantaMariadeBelem,inJernimos.Quatro
SeculosdePintura,ed.AnsioFranco(Lisbon,1992),pp.4067.

Deswarte, Sylvie, Le Panthon royal de Belm, in Demeures dternit. glises et chapelles
funrairesauxXVeetXVIesicles,ed.JeanGuillaume(Paris,2005),pp.15798.

Eichberger, Dagmar, ed., Women of Distinction. Margaret of York/Margaret of Austria (Leuven,
2005).

FerreiradeAndrade,ManuelVaz,PalciosreaisdeLisboa(Lisbon,2nded.,1990).

Franco,Ansio,2oNcleo.AreconstruodacapelamorpelaRainhaDonaCatarina,inJernimos.
QuatroSculosdePintura,ed.AnsioFranco(Lisbon,1992),pp.7071.
ISBN9789460184833
231

Giesey,Ralph,Leroinemeurtjamais.LesobsquesroyalesdanslaFrancedelaRenaissance(Paris,
1987).

Haupt,Albrecht,AArquitecturadoRenascimentoemPortugal(Lisbon,1986).

Heckscher,William,BerninisElephantandObelisk,ArtBulletin,29(1947),pp.15582.

Hirsch,ElizabethFeist,DamiodeGois.TheLifeandThoughtofaPortugueseHumanist.15021574
(TheHague,1967).

Hofmann,Christina,DasSpansicheHofzeremoniellvon15001700(FrankfurtBern,1985).

Jordan, Annemarie, Portuguese Royal Collections (15051580): A Bibliographic and Documentary
Survey(mastersthesis,GeorgeWashingtonUniversity,1985).
Jordan,Annemarie,TheDevelopmentofCatherineofAustria'sCollectionintheQueensHousehold:
ItsCharacterandCost(doctoralthesis,BrownUniversity,1994).
Jordan,Annemarie,RetratodeCorteemPortugal.OLegadodeAntnioMoro(15521572)(Lisbon,
1994b).
Jordan,Annemarie,PortugueseRoyalCollectingafter1521:thechoicebetweenFlandersandItaly,
inCulturalLinksbetweenPortugalandItalyintheRenaissance,ed.K.J.P.Lowe(Oxford,2000),pp.
26593.
Jordan, Annemarie, Catarina de ustria.
(http://rainhasdeportugal.blogspot.ch/).
A
rainha
colecionadora
(Lisbon,
2012).
Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie, Catherine of Austria and a Habsburg Relic for the Monastery of
Valbemfeito,Obidos,JournaloftheHistoryofCollections,2(1990),pp.18798.
Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie, A Crystal Elephant from the Kunstkammer of Catherine of Austria,
JahrbuchderKunsthistorischenSammlungeninWien,87(1991),pp.12126.
JordanGschwend,Annemarie,ACapelaMor:umpanteorealparaadinastiadeAvis,inJernimos.
QuatroSculosdePintura,ed.AnsioFranco(Lisbon,1992),pp.7090.
Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie, Lisbon: Between Spices and Diamonds, 1500 to 1700, The Court
Historian,3,1(March1998),pp.1623.
Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie, La Capela Real del Palazzo Reale di Lisbona: Politica, Dottrina,
Ceremoniale e Committenza Religiosa alla Corte di Giovanni III e Caterina dAustria, in Maria di
Portogallo, sposa di Alessandro Farnese. Principessa di Parma e Piacenza dal 1565 al 1577, ed.
GiuseppeBertini(Parma,2001),pp.2781.
ISBN9789460184833
232

Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie, The Portuguese Quest for Exotic Animals, in Triumphal Procession
withGiraffes.ExoticAnimalsattheServiceofPower/CortejoTriunfalcomGirafas.Animaisexticos
aoserviodopoder,ed.JessicaHallett(Lisbon,2009),pp.3242.

JordanGschwend,Annemarie,ReliquiasdelosHabsburgoyconventosportugueses.El patronazgo
religioso de Catalina de Austria, in V centenario de la llegada de la reina Juana I a Tordesillas.
CongresointernacionaldeArteehistoria,ed.M.A.Zalama(Valladolid,2010),pp.21538.
(http://arteysociedad.blogs.uva.es/files/2012/09/13JORDAN.pdf).
Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie and Beltz, Joahnnes, eds., Elfenbeine aus Ceylon: Luxusgter fr
KatharinavonHabsburg(15071578),exhibitioncatalogue,MuseumRietberg(Zurich,2010).
Jordan Gschwend, Annemarie, The Story of Sleyman. Celebrity Elephants and other Exotica in
RenaissancePortugal(ZurichPhiladelphia,2010b).(http://suleymantheelephant.ch/).

Kantorowicz, Ernst, The Kings Two Bodies. A Study in Medieval Political Thought (Princeton, N. J.,
1981).

King, Margaret, Virgo et Virago. Women and High Culture, Women of the Renaissance (Chicago,
1991),pp.157239.

Kubler, George, Portuguese Plain Architecture. Between Spices and Diamonds 15211706
(Middletown,Ct.,1972).

Lawrence,Cynthia,Introduction,inWomenandArtinEarlyModernEurope.Patrons,Collectorsand
Connoisseurs,ed.CynthiaLawrence(UniversityPark,Penn.,1997),pp.120.

LlanosyTorriglia,Flix,ContribucinalestudiodelareinadePortugal,DoaCatalina,hermanade
CarlosV(Madrid,1923).
Lowe, Kate, Rainha D. Leonor of Portugals Patronage in Renaissance Florence and Cultural
Exchange,inCulturalLinksbetweenPortugalandItalyintheRenaissance,ed.K.J.P.Lowe(Oxford,
2000),pp.22648.
Lunenfeld,Marvin,IsabellaofCastileandtheCompanyofWomeninPower,HistoricalReflections/
ReflectionsHistoriques,4(1977),pp.20729.
Lunenfeld, Marvin, The Royal Image: Symbol and Paradigm in Portraits of Early Modern Female
SovereignsandRegents,GazettedesBeauxArts,97(April1981),pp.15762.
MartnGonzlez,JuanJos,ElpantendeSanLorenzodelEscorial,Goya,5657(1963),pp.14047.
Moreira, Rafael, A Ermida da Nossa Senhora da Conceio, Mausoleu de D. Joo III?, Boletim
CulturaleInformativodaCmaraMunicipaldeTomar,1,(1981),pp.93100.
Moreira,Rafael,Jernimos(Lisbon,1987).
ISBN9789460184833
233

Moreira,Rafael,OCadeiraldosJernimos,inORostodeCameseoutrasimagens(Lisbon,1989),
pp.611.
Moreira, Rafael, A Arquitectura do renascimento no Sul de Portugal. A Encomenda Rgia entre o
ModernoeoRomano(doctoralthesis,UniversidadeNovadeLisboa,1991).
Moser,Jorgede,LourenodeSalzedo,PintordaRainhaD.Catarina,BoletimdoMuseuNacionalde
ArteAntiga,11,1(1950),pp.2731.
Mulcahy, Rosemarie, A la mayor gloria de Dios y el Rey. La decoracin de la Real Baslica del
MonasteriodeElEscorial(Madrid,1992).
Orso, Steven, Art and Death at the Spanish Habsburg Court. The Royal Exequies for Philip IV
(Columbia,Mo.,1989).

Oriol e Trindade, Antnio de, Jernimo de Ruo e o programa arquitectnico da capelamor do
MosteirodeSantaMariadeBelm,inOLargoTempodoRenascimento.Arte,PropagandaePoder,
eds.MaraJosRedondoCanteraandVtorSerro(Lisbon,2008),pp.459534.

OstenSacken,Corneliavon,ElEscorial.EstudioIconolgico(Madrid,1984).

Pereira,Paulo,AObraSilvestreeaEsferadoRei.IconologiadaArquitecturaManuelinanaGrande
Estremadura(Lisbon,1991).

Pinheiro,Antonio,SummariodapregaamfunebreetrasladaodosossosdelreyDomManuel,ed.
F.Portugal(Lisbon,1985).

Portugal, Miguel Joam de, Elogios das Rainhas. Mulheres dos Cinco Reys de Portugal do Nome de
JooescritopeloCondedeVimiosoDomJoseph(Lisbon,1747).
ResinaRodrigues,M.I.,FrayLuisdeGranadaylaliteraturadeespiritualidadenPortugal(15541632)
(Madrid,1988).
Segurado,Jorge,FranciscodOllanda(Lisbon,1970).
Senos,Nuno,ACoroaeaIgrejanaLisboadeQuinhentos,LusitaniaSacra,2srie,15(2003),pp.
97117.
Serro,Vtor,APinturaManieristaemPortugal(Lisbon,1982).
Serro, Vtor, O rtablomor do Mosteiro dos Jernimos (15701572) pelo pintor Loureno de
Salzedo,inHistriaerestaurodapinturadortablomordoMosteirodosJernimos(Lisbon,2000),
pp.1780.
Serro, Vtor, Loureno de Salzedo en Roma. Influencias del Manierismo romano en la obra del
pintordelareinaCatarinadePortugal,ArchivoEspaoldeArte,76,303(2003),pp.24965.
ISBN9789460184833
234

Sigenza,FrayJosde,HistoriadelaOrdenJernima(Madrid,1605).

SousaViterbo,F.M.,Dicionriohistoricoedocumentaldosarquitectos,engenheiroseconstructores
portugueses(Lisbon,3vols.,reprint,1988).

Sullivan,Edward,PoliticsandPropagandaintheSagradaFormabyClaudoCoello,TheArtBulletin,
67,2(June1985),pp.24359.
Tanner,Maria,TheLastDescendantofAeneas.TheHapsburgsandtheMythicImageoftheEmperor
(NewHaven,1993).
Thomaz,LuisFilipe,Lideimprialemanueline,inLadcouverte,lePortugaletlEurope.Actesdu
colloque.Parisles26,27et28mai1988,eds.JeanAubinetal.(Paris1990),pp.35103.
Varela, Javier, La Muerte del Rey. El ceremonial funerario de la monarqua espaola (15001885)
(Madrid,1990).
Vasari, Giorgio, Le vite de piu excellenti pittori, scultori ed architettori (1568), ed. G. Milanesi
(Florence,1881).
Lisbon,DirecoGeraldosArquivos(DGARQ),TorredoTombo,Mss.daLivraria,Ms.729,Baptistade
Castro,FreiManuel,ChronicadomaximoDoutore Prncipedos PatriarchasS.Jeronymo,Particular
doReynodePortugal(unpublishedmanuscript).
Simancas (Valladolid), Archivo General de Simancas (AGS), Estado (Portugal), leg. 390, Anonymous
(DonJuandeBorja?),RelacindelmodoquesetuvoenlatranslacindeloshuesosdelReyDonJuan
ydelReyDonManuelydelaReinaDoaMariaalacapillamayordeBelen(1572).

Illustrations
Fig.1ExteriorviewoftheJernimosMonasteryinBelm(Lisbon).Thesquareboxlikestructureat
thefarrightdemarcatesthecapelamorbuiltbyCatherineofAustria.Photo:JosAntnioSilva.
Fig.2FloorplanoftheJernimoschurchwiththecapelamormarkedintheyellowbox.Photo:
publicdomain.
Fig.3InteriorviewoftheJernimoschurch.ViewofthecapelamorthroughtheornateManueline
nave.Photo:publicdomain.
Fig.4ThetombsofJohnIII(farleft)andCatherineofAustriaontherightsideofthecapelamor
facingthealtar.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
ISBN9789460184833
235

Fig.5ThecapelamorbuiltbyJernimodeRuo.Photo:publicdomain.
Fig.6PanelwithgrotesqueinthearchnexttoCatherineofAustriastombafteraFlemishmodel.
Fig.7ViewofCatherineofAustriasTomb.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
Fig.8DetailwithoneelephantcaryatidholdingCatherineofAustriassarcophaguswithtusksofreal
ivory.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
Fig.9ViewofthepairofelephantcaryatidsofCatherineofAustriastomb.Photo:A.Jordan
Gschwend.
Fig.10ViewofCatherineofAustriasbronzeroyalcrownrestingabovehersarcophagus.Photo:A.
JordanGschwend.
Fig.11CatherineofAustriasepitaphwrittenbyAndrdeResende.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
Fig.12Exteriorviewofthecapelamor.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
Fig.13Therearofthecapelamorwithitsfortified,towerlikeexteriorinastyleGeorgeKubler
dubbedtheestilocho.Photo:A.JordanGschwend.
Fig.14FranciscodeHolanda,DrawingforafountainprojectedfortheshipdockyardsofLisbon
(Ribeiradosnaos)fromDaFabricaquefaleceLisboa,1571,BibliotecadaAjuda,Lisbon,Ms.51III9,
f.18r.
Fig.15BattistaFranco(ca.15101568?),IlSemolei,TheFlagellationofChrist,engravingafteralost
Titian,Venice,1568,BritishMuseum,London,inv.no.1874,0808.369.
Fig.16Titian,Transfiguration,ChurchofSanSalvador,Venice.Photo:publicdomain.
Fig.17InteriorviewoftheChurchofSanSalvadorwiththemainaltar,Venice.Photo:public
domain.
Fig.18abLourenodeSalzedo,mainaltarpiece(anddetail),CapelaMor,JernimosMonastery,
Belm.Photo:LusPavo.

ThequeensmalaiseandmelancholywerecompoundedbythefactthatLisbonwasbesiegedbytheplaguein
1569, in the worst epidemic to have struck Portugal in the sixteenth century. Catherine and the Portuguese
courtfledtocitiesalongandacrosstheTagusRiver,movingbetweenVilaFrancadeXira,SantarmandAlvito,
residingoutsideofLisbonformonths.
2
ConsultLowe2000,pp.22648,forLeonorsculturalandreligiouspatronage.Morerecently,theexhibition
catalogue:CasaPerfeitissima.500anosdaFundaodoMonasteriodaMadredeDeus(Lisbon,2010).
3
ForacopyofaletterwrittenbyMaximilianin1517toLeonorconcerningtheserelicsseeLisbon,Bibliotecada
Ajuda(hereafterBA),Ms.51VI25,no.7:CartadoEmperadorperaaRainhadonaLianorsobreasreliquiasque
lheinviou.SeeBouza1998,p.52:[...]enlaMadredeDiosdeEnxobregashaycuerposdesantos.
ISBN9789460184833
236

4
Jordan1985,pp.1618;JordanGschwend1990,pp.18798.
See Bouza 1998, p. 52, note 73 for a letter which describes Catherines residence at Xabregas: [] en un
monasterio que hay fuera de aqu, de la misma orden, que se llama Madre de Dios de Enxobregas []. Y en
medioestlacasadondelamiatia[CatherineofAustria]vivioynolapodrverporqueestanallsuscriados.
5
FerreiradeAndrade1990,pp.2123.On18August1558CatherinewasgrantedaspecialPapaldispensation
whichallowedhertolaterbuildthisdoor,givingherdirectaccesstothePassionchapel.Shewasallowedto
build such doors at other monasteries she frequented in Lisbon, such as the Esperana convent. Cf. Corpo
Diplomtico Portugus, vol. 8 (Lisbon, 1884), pp. 5657: Bulla de penitenciaria Rainha. Bulla Exigit
Celsitaclinem:absolvendoaRainhaD.Catherinaporterabertoumaportadeseuhospicioparaoconventoda
Esperana,edandolhepermissoqueopossafazerparaoutrosconventos.AlsoBouza1998,p.52,note73:
DeallidioenXabregas,dondelaserenssimaReynadePortugaltienesualczarysaleporuncorredoraoyr
misaaunayglesianogrande,consusdamas,yelembajadordeEspaa[].
7
JuandeBorja,sonofFranciscodeBorja(aSpanishcourtierwhogrewupwithCatherineatTordesillas),was
ambassadortothePortuguesecourtfrom1569to1575.Hewasatrustedconfidantofthequeenandinher
1578codicilshelefthimthesumof4,000cruzadosforhisdaughtersdowry.Borjawasalsoactiveartistically
during his Portuguese residency, enjoying the friendship of Francisco de Holanda. Borja, an amateur of
emblems and devisas, published in Prague in 1581 a book entitled Empresas Morales which was partially
conceivedofduringhisresidencyattheLisboncourt.
8
Catherine set into motion serious plans to consolidate her finances in Portugal in order to undertake her
movetoSpain.ForletterswhichdocumentherintentionsseeArchivoGeneraldeSimancas(hereafterAGS).
SeeespeciallytheminuteofaletterfromPhilipIItohisambassadorJuandeBorjadated12May1571,AGS,
Estado(Portugal),leg.388,f.108fortheproblemsCatherinefacedintakingherestateandmoniestoSpain,
becausehergrandsonSebastianwasherlegalheir.Atthesametime,Catherineorderedresearchundertaken
attheHabsburgfamilyarchivesinSimancastoseewhichrentsandpropertieswerelegallyherswhileareview
ofher1524marriagecontractandcapitulationswasmade.Shewantedacopyofthiscontractsenttoherto
Lisbon.Cf.AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.388,f.115forthenotarizedcourtpapersregardingCatherinesdowry
andjewelsdated1525.AswellasAGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.390,f.99.AlsoaletterfromJuandeBorjato
PhilipIIssecretary,GabrieldeZayas,writtenfromLisbon(22May1571),AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.389,ff.
162and160,concernsCatherinesestatein1570whichtheambassadorfoundtobeverymodestinincome:
[...]nohepodidoentenderloiertoenloquetocaadinerosyajoyasylosdemasmueblessonpocos[],and
f.172,BorjatoZayas(12June1571):yaescreviav.m.comoloquesabiadelaaiendadelaReynaeraquela
Rentaserancomosesentamilducados,lasjoyasnosesillegaranaientoyinquentamil,loquesesabela
demasRecamaraespocacosa[...].
9
TheexchangeoflettersbetweenPhilipII,JuandeBorjaandCatherineofAustria,regardingwheresheshould
retiretoinSpainareinAGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.387,f.21(21August1570);AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.388,
f.216(29August1570).AlsoLisbon,BibliotecaNacionalofPortugal(hereafterBNP),Cod.8570,ff.143144v,
DecomoaRainhaDonaCatherinasequeriairagravadadestesReynosperaCastella.
10
SeeAGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.389,f.91(1571)foraletterCatherineaddressedtoSebastianjustifyingher
reasonsformovingtoSpain.ShecomplainedtoSebastianthatheneverresidedinLisbonwhenshedid,and
that she preferred to bury herself (enterrarse viva) in a convent rather than continue the tense relationship
theycultivated.
11
Moreira1987.
12
Lunenfeld1977,pp.5778.
Lunenfeld1977,p.69.
14
Eichberger2005.
13
15
Lawrence1997,p.17;Carpin1997,pp.3940.
16
Brantme1991,p.511.AlsoKing1991,pp.188193.
King1991,p.182.
18
DGARQ,NA792,f.193v(1543).
17
19
FormoreonCatherinesreligiouspatronageseeJordanGschwend2010,pp.21538.
(http://arteysociedad.blogs.uva.es/files/2012/09/13JORDAN.pdf).
20
Moreira1987.
ISBN9789460184833
237

21
JordanGschwend2009,pp.3242.
22
Thomaz1991,pp.35103.
23
JordanGschwend1992,pp.7090;DeswarteRosa1996,pp.15798;OrioleTrindade2008,pp.459533.
24
SousaViterbo1988,pp.41924;Jordan1994,PartTwo:Appendix6,cats.11,13,1518,20.
25
DGARQ,CCI,mao109,doc.40;DGARQ,CCII,mao248,doc.23.Cf.SousaViterbo1988,pp.41924.
26
Kubler1972,pp.6364.
27
DGARQ,CCII,mao248,doc.80.Cf.SousaViterbo1988,pp.42324;Alves1991,pp.18384.
DGARQ,CCI,mao29,doc.47;DGARQ,CCI,mao109,docs.42and55;DGARQ,CCII,mao248,doc.38;
DGARQ,TorredoTombo,Ms.daLivraria,Ms.729,ch.26,f.597v.
28
29
30
Carvalho1990,pp.18184;Alves1991,pp.19195.
Onepachydermhadbrokenduringproductionortransportationandwasimmediatelyreplaced.
31
OrioleTrindade2008,pp.459533.
BA,Ms.46X22,f.77v.
33
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.387,f.21(12August1570).
34
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.388,f.216(29August1570)andf.225(20December1570).
35
Lisbon, Biblioteca Nacional de Portugal (hereafter BNP), Reservados, Cod. 8920 (1571); London, British
Library(hereafterBL),AdditionalMss.,ff.6165,forlettersthecitymunicipality(camra)ofLisbonwrotethe
queenaboutherwishtomovetoCastile.
36
Amongthem,theHieronymitemonasteryatValeBemfeitonearObids,theDominicanconventofPedrogo
Grande,theconventofSoFranciscoinFaro,andthechurchesofSantaCatarinaandS.DomingosinLisbon.In
alettertoPopePiusIV,CatherinetoldhimofthespecialdevotionsheandJohnIIIhadfortheConventofSanta
CruzinCoimbra.SeeBibliotecaApostolicaVaticana(hereafterBAV),Barb.Lat.9920,f.213(Lisbon,8October
1564):[orei]aquetinhasingulardevoo[totheSantaCruzconvent]comoeutenho.
37
Moreira1987,pp.1618.
38
BNP,ColecoPombalina686,ff.803822:TresladodoCompromissodasCapellasdaRainhaD.Catharina
tiradodooriginalqueestnoTorredoTombodondeestseutestamento.TratadadoaofeitaaoConvento
deBelemparasustenode20Merceeiros.
39
Madrid, Biblioteca Nacional de Espaa (hereafter BNE), Ms. 474. This religious tract personally written by
Osrio has never been studied and remains unpublished. Also Jordan 1994, pp. 136150; Jordan Gschwend
32
2001,pp.6068.
40
Over the years a number of gifts had been given by Catherine of Austria to the Jernimos monastery in
Belm.Shedonatedreliquaries(inasilvergiltcoffer),costlyornamentsandreligiousobjects(amiraculouscult
statueofOurLadyofAjudaandaSt.Sebastian)whichwerelaterlistedinthemonasterysinventoriesinthe
seventeenthcentury.Otherobjectsperhapsassociatedwiththequeen(asilvergiltcross,chaliceandvarious
churchvestmentspossiblyembroideredbyCatherine)areintheMuseuNacionaldeArteAntiga(Lisbon).Fora
summarizeddiscussionofalltheseobjectsseeMoreira1987,p.21.
41
Jordan 1994, p. 27, note 66; Jordan Gschwend 2001, p. 62, note 129. See also Noticia da fundao do
convento da Madre de Deos de Lisboa das religiosas descalas da primeira regra de Nossa Madre de Santa
Clara, located in the library of the Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga, Estante 74, no. 2, ff. 2627r. Other
generousdonationsmadebythequeentotheMadredeDeusconventincluded,in1565,largescaleportraits
ofherselfandJohnIIIinprayeranddevotionbyCristvoLopesandin1574severalorgans.Sometimebefore
Catherines death in 1578, she gave the convent a number of important relics, including two heads of the
11,000VirginMartyrs,andcurtainsofgraysilkembroideredwithgoldshehadsewnherselfforthetabernacle
containingtheBlessedSacrament.ThislattergiftisnotedintheaboveNoticia...,f.27r:[a]indaestroutrodia
soubequefizeraaSenhoraRaynha[CatherineofAustria]comsuasmaosascortinasdoSantissimoSacramento
deretrosPardo,lavradodeouro.
42
43
44
45
Segurado1970,pp.330333;DeswarteRosa1987,pp.14783.
Moreira1981,p.98.
Hecksher1947,pp.15582.
Jordan1985,p.30.
ISBN9789460184833
238

46
Jordan1985,pp.5657.
JordanGschwend2009,p.34.
48
JordanGschwend2010b.
49
Hirsch2001,p.3;JordanGschwendandBeltz2010.
47
50
JordanGschwend1991,pp.12126.
51
FelicidadeAlves1984;Jordan1985,p.17,note38andpp.12122.
52
BaptistaPereira1986,pp.5366.
Madrid,MuseodelPrado,oiloncanvas,346x240cm,inv.no.432.
(http://www.museodelprado.es/coleccion/galeriaonline/galeriaonline/obra/lagloria/).
54
Vasari1881,p.453;Chiari1982,p.29.
53
55
Bohde2001,pp.45072.
AnotherVenetianpainter,Tintoretto,isrecordedashavingpurchasedCatherineofAustriasFlagellationat
theauctionofthecontentsofTitiansworkshopafter1576.WhethertheFlagellationwasevercompletedand
whatbecameofthispaintingisnotknown.
57
Paris,MusedesArtDcoratifs,inv.no.PE243.FormoreonthisportraitconsultJordan1994b,p.88,fig.51.
56
58
Jordan2005,pp.91113.
59
PatternsofPatronageamongHabsburgQueens,RegentsandPrincesses,inJordan1994,pp.41731.For
moreonHabsburgwomen,theircourtsandcollectionsinthesixteenthcenturysee:
http://habsburgsintherenaissance.blogspot.ch/.
60
DGARQ,NA792,f.95v,forunspecifiedgoodsthePortuguesefactorinFlanderssentthequeenin1538.
61
Serro 2003, p. 252, argues for Catherines gusto romanista and her taste for things Italian (specifically
Roman) throughout her reign. However, in the queens inventories and related documents this cannot be
corroborated, and Serros assertion that Catherine purchased engravings and works of art in Rome is not
documented.
62
63
VaticanCity,ArchivioSegretoVaticano(hereafterASV),SegretariadiStato,Portogallo,3,ff.3233v.
ThecomplexitiesregardingCatherinessearchforasuitablepainterwerefirstoutlinedinBouza1998b,pp.
7778.SubsequentlytakenupbySerro2000,pp.1777;Serro2003,pp.24965.
64
Moser1950,pp.2731;Serro2003,pp.24965.
65
Franco1992,pp.7071.
ThequeenwroteatotalofthreeletterstoRomein1571requestingherambassadorbuyhighqualitypaints.
66
67
TwolettersinBA,citedinJordan2000,pp.28586,note56.
68
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.389,ff.17273(12June1571).
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.389,f.58(7July1571).
70
SeeAGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.389,f.59,foraresponsewithamarginalnotemadebyPhilipII:Justosera
bolver a remediar esto y aun a castigarlo. In short: the need to remedy this unfortunate situation and to
punishthecustomsofficerforhisblunder.
71
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.390,f.94,letterfromBorjatoZayas(9January1572).
72
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.390,f.10(July25,1572),f.27(7September1572),f.33(23October1572),f.120
69
(29October1572)andff.12122(10December1572):estandoparapartirseestecorreovinoamiposadael
secretario de la Reyna y me dio esta escrivania para V. M. la qual le embia su Alteza por seal de
agradeimientoquetienedelcuydadoqueV.M.tieneenloquetocaasuservicio.
73
MinuteofaletterfromPhilipIItoCatherine,inAGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.392,f.204(19September1575):
ytambienrecibimuchameredycontentamientoconloscorporalesypaliosparasanctlorenio[ElEscorial],
queporsertanpulidosydemanodeV.A.loshetenidoenloqueesrazonylasbesoaV.Altezamuchasvezes
porellos.
74
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.389,f.91(1571).
75
BNP,Reservados,Cod.8570,f.144v.
76
AGS, Estado (Portugal), leg. 392, f. 175 (18 July 1575): en iertas casas y aposiento en que la reyna doa
leonormytiavivio.
ISBN9789460184833
239

77
AGS,Estado(Portugal),leg.390,f.117(28October1572).
78
Jordan2005,pp.15580.
Serro2003,p.252andp.264.Thereisnodocumentation,however,whichconfirmsCatherineofAustria
broughtSalzedotohercourtin1564toworkasherpainterorportraitist.
79
80
Tanner1993,pp.183222.In1565CatherinecommissionedfromtheLisboncourtpainterCristvoLopes
twolifesizeportraitsofherselfandthelateKingJohnIIIatprayer,whichshedonatedtotheConventofMadre
deDeus.Theseportraits,whichhungfacingthemainaltaroftheMadredeDeuschurchinadorationofthe
Eucharist, not only express the pietas and devotion of the Portuguese monarchs, but were also visual
reaffirmations of the queens own fidelity to the Habsburg notions of Pietas Austriaca cultivated by her and
othermembersofthedynasty.FormoreonthesedevotionalportraitsseeJordan1994b,pp.13650.
81
FortheimmenseinterestPhilipIIshowedinthebuildingandconstructionofhisauntCatherinescapelamor
consult Serro 2000, pp. 2934. The Spanish king went so far as to request a drawing of the Jernimos
monasteryin1568(Serro2000,p.21).
82
ThedateofCatherinesdeathinthescholarshiphasinvariablyanderroneouslybeengivenas12February
1578.Cf.ASV,SegretariadiStato,Portogallo,1,f.61v.
83
ASV,SegretariadiStato,Portogallo,1,f.63(8February1578).
84
ExcerptofaletterwrittenbyJuandeSilvatoPhilipII(April1578)citedinLlanosyTorriglia1923,p.90,note
118,whileacopyofGranadasspeechsentbyCardinalInfanteHenrytotheSpanishkinghasnotsurvived.Cf.
ResinaRodrigues1988,p.578.
85
TestamentoecodycillodaRainhaCatarinaqueDeustem[],inAsGavetas,6(1967),p.10.
86
Resina Rodrigues 1988, p. 578: a pesar de su innegable pompa, se revisti de un aparato menor que lo
habitualenlacortedeMadrid,enidnticascircunstancias.
87
Resendesinscriptionreads:CATHERINAPHILLIPICASTELREGISF.JOANNISIIILUSITAN.REGIS.P.F.INVICTI
CONIUXMAGNIANIMIPIECTATISEXIMIOPRUDENTIASINGULARISETINCOMPARABILISEXEMPLIREGINAH.S.
E.
ISBN9789460184833
240

IV
HabsburgsandMuslims

ISBN9789460184833
241
EuropesTurkishNemesis
LarrySilver

Americans who lived through the Cold War with the Soviet Union from World War II until the late
twentieth century probably can well imagine from the Iron Curtain what life was like across the
ChristianMuslim frontier during the sixteenth century. Ever since the fall of Constantinople to the
OttomanTurksin1453,threatsfrombothmilitaryattackaswellasideologicalwaragainstthealien
religionofIslampreoccupiedtheconsciousnessandcreatedaclimateoffearinEuropeanChristian
states. Nowhere was this anxiety concerning the rival superpower greater than within the loose
Germanspeaking confederation known as the Holy Roman Empire, led by Habsburg emperor
Maximilian I (r. 14931519).1 Indeed the eventual frontier between Catholics and Muslims,
established after the battle of Mohcs in Hungary (1526), still coincides almost exactly with the
modern, hostile frontier between Catholic Croatia and Orthodox Serbia (Catholics who remained
behind the Ottoman lines were forced to convert to Islam and became the Muslims of Bosnia
Herzegovina).

Fig.1MapoftheDanube,byWillemandJohannBlaeu,
NovusAtlas(Amsterdam,1636).

InanatlasmapoftheDanubewatershed,producedbyJohannBlaeuinAmsterdamduring
the 1630s we see this confrontation institutionalized around the image caption (fig. 1). Here this
heightened awareness of both a political and religious frontier, manned against a mysterious and
foreignenemyattheborder,ispersonifiedbytheconfrontationoftwopairsoffigures.Ononeside,
the east, a sultan with an elaborate turban brandishes his scimitar above a round shield with the
crescent moon of Islam. His female companion, surely an allegory of the Muslim faith, stands
contemptuouslyuponacrucifixanddispensestheexoticscentofincense;butsheisscantilycladina
revealinglylowcutdress,certainlyisnotafiguretoadmire.Incasetheviewermissedtheseobvious
visualcues,anoxioustoadrestsonthegroundbetweentheseOttomanpersonifications.Bycontrast,
ISBN9789460184833
242
onthewesternsideofthestandoff,ahandsomebeardedrulerfigureinarmorsteadfastlyconfronts
this enemy with a broadsword. His shield displays the doubleheaded eagle of the Holy Roman
Empire,andhiscrownresemblestheofficialBgelkrone;complementinghisorbofoffice,hewears
theexclusivependantofthenobleOrderoftheGoldenFleece,headedbytheHabsburgs.Hisfemale
companion, who personifies the Christian religion, holds her crucifix upright and wears a distinctly
modestgown.

Throughout the sixteenth century Turks were regarded in apocalyptic terms by leading
ChristianthinkersasascourgeofGod.Thisattitudebeganearly:wecanalreadyfinditprominently
advancedinSebastianBrantsShipofFools(1494).2InChapter99,OftheDeclineoftheFaith,Brant
intonesaboutChristendom,
Atfirstthecruelheretic
didtearandwoundittothequick
andthenMohammedshamefully
abuseditsnoblesanctity
withheresyandbaseintent.[]
SostrongtheTurkshavegrowntobe
theyholdtheoceannotalone,
theDanubetooisnowtheirown,
theymaketheirinroadswhentheywill,
bishoprics,churches,sufferill[]
ButthepoetplaceshistrustintheyoungEmperorelectedtobetheantidote,
ThenobleMaximilian,
hemeritswelltheRomancrown.
Theyllsurelycomeintohishand,
theHolyEarth,thePromisedLand.

Many of the woodcut illustrations in Brants popular volume were designed by the young
Albrecht Drer, the same artist who produced some of the earliest German images of Ottoman
Turks. Beginning with his first visit to Venice in 1494, Drer turned his omnivorous gaze to the
substantialcommunityofTurkishvisitors,documentingtheirexoticdress.3Heseriouslyengagedwith
this unfamiliar nationality, which had such a strong trade presence in Venice, and his curiosity
resulted in a series of drawings that emphasize distinctive costumes.4 Some of these colored
drawings of orientals by Drer survive in copies, indicating their importance as models, used for
later reference by his many followers and credited with an onsite accuracy. However, several of
these drawings actually derive, not from studies of costumed models, but rather from earlier
artworksbylocalVenetianpainters,particularlyGentileBellini,whohadevenvisitedIstanbulearlier
onadiplomaticmission(figs.23).5

ISBN9789460184833
243

Fig.2AlbrechtDrer,ThreeTurkish
Men,ca.1495.

Fig.3GentileBellini,ProcessioninPiazzaSanMarco,
1496,detailofthreeTurkishmeninbackground,
Venice,GalleriedellAccademia.
Other Drer drawings expressly focus on the military trappings and skills of Turkish soldiers,
specifically theirarchery (fig.4).This otherpreoccupationafocusonTurksasformidablemilitary
enemieswould strongly inflect not only Drers own presentations but also those of many of his
laterGermanfollowers.

Fig.4AlbrechtDrer,Oriental
familyofanottomanarcher,1496,
Milan,BibliotecaAmbrosiana.
Fig.5AlbrechtDrer,Oriental
RulerseatedonhisThrone,ca.
1496/97),Washington,National
Gallery.
Fig.6AlbrechtDrer,Apocalypse
Series,1497,pl.2:TortureofSt.
JohntheEvangelist.

Inthewake ofhis1494visittoVenice,Dreralsoproducedadrawingstudy(fig.5)foran
uncompletedengraving:anOrientalRulerSeatedonhisThrone(ca.1496/97).6Inthisfantasyimage
any firsthand experience of Turks inVenice is overwhelmed by an intimidating suggestion of both
powerandmajestyaswellassternmenace.Detailsofthisexoticforeigncostumestillpreoccupythe
artist. A distinctive crowned turban (probably imaginary) marks the royal rank and status of this
ISBN9789460184833
244
frontal,enthronedfigure;itsencrustedroundjewelsareechoedonhisprincelyrobes,highlightedby
anenormousnecklacewithpendant.7Exoticdetailsofthecostumespeakto itsAsiaticcharacter:
fringesaddedtotherobeaswellasthefootwearofsandalsbeneathit.Bothpowerandauthorityof
thisrulerareconveyed,respectively,byahuge,twohandedbattleswordinhisrighthandandbyan
orbinhisleft.WhileakintotheceremonialorboftheHolyRomanEmpire,whichDrershometown
ofNurembergproudlyguarded,theorbinthedrawingsignificantlylacks thesurmountingcrossof
imperialChristianregalia.Thethreateningauthorityofthisbeardedpotentateisfurtherenhancedby
hissternandmenacingfacialexpression;despitehisformalfrontality,hisgloweringeyesturnaway
toscowlobliquelyoutoftheframe,asakindofnegativeinversionofholyiconsofthefaceofJesus.8
This image clearly does not record a portrait of any particular Ottoman sultan; instead, it uses a
figureofauthoritytopersonifytheperceivedthreatofTurkishIslamtoChristendom.Indeed,Drer
would soon adapt this enthroned orientalist ruler as the persecuting emperor Domitian in the
woodcut scene of the Martyrdom of St. John, the first illustration of his 1498 publication of the
Apocalypse(fig.6).

Fig.7AlbrechtDrer,SultanSleyman,
1526,Bayonne,MuseBonnat.
Fig.8Anonymous,SultanSleyman,ca.1530/40,
Vienna,KunsthistorischesMuseum.

AttheendofhiscareerDrerproducedaverydifferentimageofaTurkishruler,theprofile
portraitofrulingSultanSleyman(monogrammedanddated1526,seefig.7),intheartistsfavored
medium for portrait drawings, silverpoint.9 Its profile presentation suggests that the German artist
had access to an existing portrait prototype, almost surely derived from a Venetian painter, in the
form of a medal.10 In fact, a specific source survives: a silver medal in which the profile faces the
oppositewaybutwiththebusttruncatedatthesamepointofthechestandshoulders.Therethe
sultanwearsthesameturbanasinDrerssilverpoint,andheisidentifiedbyaninscriptioninthe
blockLatinletters,SULEYMAN.CAESARTURCARUM/MELECK.ET.ARAB.TURC.11Boththemedalof
SleymanandtheDrerprofiledrawingpresentthesamedistinctivelongneckandprominentnose
ISBN9789460184833
245
andlips.AroundadecadelateraVenetianpainterclosetoTitianpaintedabustlengthportraitofa
young, mustachioed Sultan Sleyman in the same orientation as Drer (ca. 1530/40; see fig. 8),
presumablyusingthesamevisualsource.12

Fig.9AlbrechtDrer,TheMartyrdomofTen
Thousand,1508,oilonpanel,Vienna,

Fig.10AlbrechtDrer,TheMartyrdom
oftheTenThousand,ca.1497/98,
woodcut.

In 1508, in response to a commission by one of his principal courtly patrons, Frederick the
Wise of Saxony, Drer painted an image to commemorate martyrs relics in the princes extensive
religiouscollectionatWittenberg.Forthisimage,DreragaincasttheTurksassadisticpersecutors
forthenarrative,TheMartyrdomoftheTenThousand(1508,fig.9).13InthisearlyChristiansubject
from the Middle East, the Persian king Sapor, acting on command of Emperor Diocletian of Rome,
slaughtered the Christians of Bithynia (343 C.E.). Drer had depicted this same subject already
appearedadecadeearlierinawoodcut(ca.1497/98;fig.10).Inbothcompositions,Christiansare
cruelly tortured to death, tossed from cliffs by turbaned conquerors. In the painting, however, the
martyrs imitation of Christ is emphasized by two figures on crosses and a third standing awaiting
execution; two wear crowns of thorns like Christ in the Passion, a clear medieval allusion to
martyrdomandsainthoodasanimitatioChristi,butnowwiththeoppressorsrepresentedasTurks.
Opposite, in the lower right corner, both standing and mounted figures with distinctive beards,
complexturbansandcolorfulrobesclearlyconflatetheancientking,throughdress,tothemodern
Turks.Hissinistercommandsthusbecomefusedwiththoseoftheimplacablereligiousenemiesof
Drersownday.

Inaddition,thepaintingalsotookonmorepersonalsignificancefortheartist,whoincluded
hisownselfportraitasadarklycladwitnessinthecenter,inscribinghimselfexpresslyasAlbrecht
Drer,German(AlbertoDreraleman),tolinkhisidentitystillclosertohispatron,anElectorofthe
Empire and the leading lieutenant to Emperor Maximilian. He also included a friend, plausibly
ISBN9789460184833
246
identifiedwiththerecentlydeceasedpoetlaureateoftheEmpire,ConradCeltis.Thus,Drerfuses
past with present and assimilates modern Ottomans onto historic persecutions of Christians in the
Levant.14

Theyear1529markedtheclimaxoftheongoingconflictbetweentheforcesofHolyRoman
Empireandtheirenemies,theOttomanTurks,thenpoisedinsiegeatthegatesofViennaafteran
unbroken string of victories in the Balkans and along the Danube (a series highlighted by Belgrade
1521,MohcsandBuda,1526).NotonlydidtheadvanceofthearmiesofSultanSleymanposean
immediate threat to the Habsburg rulers in their traditional capital, but ultimately the siege
undermined their own Christian claims to universal monarchy, claims implicit to the title of Holy
Roman Emperor. This peril was actually redoubled by the contemporary odd couple alliance,
especially after 1530, between the Ottomans and the Habsburgs mortal enemy in Europe, King
Francis I of France, an alliance that encompassed commercial privileges, nonaggression pacts, and
culminated in coordinated military campaigns (153637).15 Taken together, this period of political
tension heightened national selfconsciousness in Germany of the Empire as the ultimate bulwark
againstfurtherTurkishincursion.

Fig.11NicolausMeldemann,CircularViewofthe
CityofViennaattheTimeoftheFirstTurkishSiegein
1529,eightsheetwoodcut,1530.

TheSiegeofViennain1529,amomentouseventattheHabsburgcapitalthatturned back
thetideofTurkishadvancesintocontinentalEurope,receivedcarefuldocumentationintheformof
alarge(81.2x85.6cm.)multisheetcommemorativewoodcut,designedbyDrersfollowerSebald
BehamandprintedinNurembergbyNicolausMeldemannfromsixblocks(1530)(fig.11).16Thework
hadanofficialimprimatur,aprivilegegrantedbytheNurembergcitycouncil.Theprintmakerprized
reportorial accuracy of battle details; topographical accuracy was emphasized as well, with all the
viewsbasedoncarefulstudiestakenfromthegreattowerofSt.Stephenscathedralintheheartof
thecity.TodocumentfullythedefenseagainstthetroopsoftheTurks,theprintshowsthecityat
the pictorial center; the siege itself outside the city walls is seen in the round from an elevated,
birdseye viewpoint above the central cathedral tower.17 This composite image visualizes actual
troopmovements,tents,andartilleryexplosionscharacteristicofcontemporarypracticesofwarfare.
ISBN9789460184833
247
Intheprocess,BehamswoodcutcelebratesvictoryoverTurkishinvadersevenasitparticipatesin
thevogueforprintedimagesofmilitarydocumentaries.

Meldemanns local rival as publisher of woodcut broadsheets in Nuremberg, Hans
Guldenmundt, made his own commemoration of the great event as a pamphlet with text by local
poetHansSachsandprintsbySebaldBeham,asTheThreeBesiegersofVienna.Hisprocessionseries
of Turkish officers and soldiers included archers, armed spahis (roughly akin to European knights),
and earnest profile equestrian portraits of Turks on horses. These Turkish besiegers were led by
Sultan Sleyman himself, plus his principal counselor Ibrahim Pasha and General Sansaco.18 The
source for these images stemmed from an earlier suite of five woodcuts, produced in the
NetherlandsbyJanSwartofGroningenanddated1526,thehighwatermarkofOttomanconquests
along the Danube.19 These images thus held contemporary pertinence as newsworthy while also
catering to the ongoing fascination with Turkish costume, particularly headwear, as well as their
exoticweaponsandbattlefieldinstruments(trumpet,bagpipe,andhighpitchedshawm).Thesultan
himself (fig. 12)appearsinprofileat the center,ridingonhorseback,accompaniedby alonefoot
soldierandlabeledSolimanusimperatorTurcharumwiththedate.Othermountedtriads,variously
dressed,arealsolabeledasMamelukes,Arabs,andheathens,respectively.

Fig.12SebaldBeham,TheTurkishSultanSleyman,
woodcutpublishedwiththepamphletTheThree
BesiegersofVienna.

AdarkersideofTurksatwarwasproducedin1530byHansGuldenmundtatNurembergasa
woodcutseriesforopinionformationandrallyingofimperialtroopsinrevengeforallegedatrocities
inandaroundVienna.Images,attributedtoErhardSchoenbutfreelyadaptedfromSwart,nowshow
mountedTurkishwarriorsleadingpairsofcaptiveChristiansonfootwitharopearoundtheirnecks;
versesbyHansSachsdescribetheircruelconditions.20Evenworseisthebabycarriedbyoneofthem
on his spear. The text laments how the evil, gruesome Turk has killed children, stolen sheep and
cattle,burneddownhomes,andcondemnedChristiancaptivestoslavery,pullingplowslikeanimals.
Worse still is the 1530 Guldenmundt/Schoen broadsheet woodcut collaboration recounting the
ISBN9789460184833
248
threat to civilians by Turks on the outskirts of the Vienna Woods, showing them killing babies by
impalingthemonstakesorslicingthemwithscimitars(fig.13).21HeretheSachspoemreads:
OhLordGodonthehighestthrone,
lookatthisgreatmisery,
theTurkishragingtyrant
hascarriedoutintheViennaWoods,
murderingvirginsandwives,
cuttingchildreninhalf,
andimpalingthemonpikes[]
Oh,ourshepherdJesusChrist[]
saveusfromthehandoftheTurk.

Fig.13ErhardSchoen,TurkishAtrocities,
woodcut,publishedbyHans
GuldenmundtinNuremberg,1530.
NofriendtoeitherpapacyorEmpire,MartinLutherdeclaredinhisprefacetotheBookofRevelation
(1530;publishedin1546)thattheTurkswereascourgesentbyGodtochastenChristiansontheeve
oftheapocalypse:
Here, now the devils final wrath gets to work: there in the East is the second woe.
MohammedandtheSaracens,hereintheWestarepapacyandempirewiththethirdwoe.
To these is added for good measure the Turk, Gog and Magog [] Thus Christendom is
plagued most terribly and miserably, everywhere and on all sides, with false doctrines and
withwars,withscrollandwithsword.22

Butforthecurrentemperor,defenderofChristendom,theongoingcontestagainsttheTurk
wasconceivedasacrusade,soafterViennain1529,EmperorCharlesVlookedforanopportunityto
goontheoffensiveandreverseTurkishconquestsinmainlandEurope.Indoingso,hecouldreassert
his imperial status as well as his leadership of the Christian faith. He got his opportunity in 1535,
when he led a campaign from his base in Spain against the fortified city of Goleta near Tunis. The
1535campaignintheMaghrebcombatedBerbercorsairKheiredDin(knownintheChristianwest
asBarbarossa),admiraloftheTurksintheMediterranean.Equippedwithfourhundredshipsand
somethirtythousandsoldiers,CharlesVhadsetouttostopMuslimraidsonChristianshippingand
tosecuremaritimedominanceovertheSultansfleets.FrancisIofFrance,CharlesVsnemesis,was
supplying Barbarossa with arms while treating with Sultan Sleyman (thus forging an alliance
between the two principal enemies of the Empire). The proximate cause of war was Barbarossas
deposing of King Mulay Hasan of Tunis, a nominal vassal of the emperor. Andrea Doria of Genoa
commandedtheimperialfleet;landforcesservedunderAlfonsodAvalos,marquisofVasto.

Commemoratingandcelebratingthat(shortlived)victory,theemperorwaslaterpresented
with a suite of tapestries, the most costly and luxurious of all media. Using the same panoramic
ISBN9789460184833
249
designasan earliertapestrycycle, celebrating the militaryspectacleofthe 1525Battle ofPavia(a

glorious1525victoryovertheFrenchinItaly),designedforCharlesVatthebehestofMargaretof
Austria by her court artist, Bernart van Orley. This twelvepart set on the Conquest of Tunis was
woveninBrusselsbyWillemdePannemaker(154954)afterdesignsbyDutchartistJanVermeyen
(who had been embedded with the invading troops, like recent American journalists in Iraq),
probablywiththehelpofexperiencedtapestrydesignerPieterCoeckevanAelst(154650).23

In terms of documentary validity, this tapestry suite offered a mixture of careful
observations, especially of costumes and settings, even as it conveyed a fully realized propaganda
message.TheclimaxoftheconflictwasthemonthlongsiegeofthefortofGoleta(whichprotected
Tunis)andthesubsequentsackofthecapital.Particularlycarefultopographicalrenderingsofthecity
ofTunisincludemosquesandcitywalls.FurtherdetailsincludeancientruinsofCarthage,especially
the prominent aqueducts, seen from different angles in successive tapestries, as well as the
distinctive Mediterranean oared galleys, marked by their triangular, lateenrigged sails. Moreover,
theentireseriesbeginswithanaerialmapoftheentireMediterraneanbasin,seenfromthevantage
pointofBarcelona,withAfricaatthetop.Thedocumentarycharacterofthesetapestriesisfurther
emphasizedbytheinclusionoftexthistoriesintwolanguages;longerpassagesinCastilianatthetop,
shorterLatinversesatthebottom.24Asiftoassuretheimagesdocumentaryclaims,Vermeyeneven
included a selfportrait while drawing in the field into the design of The Sack of Tunis. He also
appearsintheinitial map panel,whereafulllengthselfportrait figurestandsbesideatabletwith
the proud declaration: The course of events is represented in this work as exactly as possible the
actionistreatedinthistapestryaccordingtonature,allthatconcernscosmographyleavingnothing
tobedesired.25

Fig.14WillemdePannemakerafterJanC.Vermeyen,TheQuestforFodder,Sixth
tapestryoftheConquestofTunisseries(includingancientruinsofCarthage),Madrid,
PatrimonioNacional.

According to Hendrick Horn, Vermeyen distinguishes between the Maghrebi Moors, and
their Turkish allies, and he even subdivides the former group into the more urban Arabs and the
nomadicBerbers.BothgroupsofturbanedMoorsareshownmoresympatheticallythantheTurkish
ISBN9789460184833
250
warriors, Janissaries, in their pointed caps, who fought for Barbarossa and are shown in several
tapestries as headhunters. These varied groups are especially evident across the foreground of
severalworks,notablythesixthtapestry,TheQuestforFodder(fig.14).MulayHassanandhisretinue
ofMoorishalliesofCharlesValsoappear,acrosstheforegroundoftheFallofTunis.

LikeVermeyen,carefullyproducingcostumestudiesandlandscapetopographiesinTunisia,
the artistically trained nobleman Melchior Lorichs of Flensberg was another Northerner who
exploitedhisprivilegedroleinanimperialentouragetogainaccesstotheIslamicworld.Lorichswent
totheOttomancapitalofIstanbulasamemberoftheHolyRomanEmpiresentouragetothecourt
ofSleyman underambassadorOgier GhiselindeBusbecq(155462),thesameindividualcredited
with importing the tulip into Europe from Turkey.26 He served as the ambassadors eyes for the
military capacities and resources of the Ottomans, and published several treatises (1568, 1574)
concerningthedangersthattheTurkisharmyposedtoChristianEurope.YetLorichsalsoproduced
themostmeticulousonsitestudiesofthepeopleandbuildingsofConstantinoplebyanyEuropean
visitorduringthesixteenthcentury.

Fig.15MelchiorLorichs,ByzantiumsiveConstantineopolis(ViewofIstanbul),1559,two
sections,Leiden,UniversityLibrary.

FromthehighgroundofGalata(thepartofthecityoppositetheGoldenHornfromwhatis
now called the Old City), Lorichs made a vast yet careful sepia and black ink panorama of Istanbul
(Leiden,UniversityLibrary,45x1.127,5cm;nowdividedintotwentyonesections;seefig.15).27This
panorama, obviously composed out of separate studies from various positions, records the city
skyline,includingnotonlythedominatingdomesandminaretsofmosquesbutalsoancientRoman
memorial columns, palaces, caravanserais, gates, and city walls. Ships of all sizes and shapes,
including European carracks as well as Levantine vessels with lateenrigged sails, fill the crowded
waterways. Inscriptions label the points of interest in two different colors of sepia ink, though
writteninasinglehand.Nearthecenteroftheensembleappearsanidealizedselfportrait;awell
dressed, youthful European in dark costume seen from the back, prepares to write or draw on an
extended scroll similar to the one today at Leiden. He dips his quill into an elaborate gobletlike
inkwellthatisheldforhimbyaturbanedTurk(fig.16).
ISBN9789460184833
251

Fig.16MelchiorLorichs,Sectionwithan
idealselfportraitoftheauthoratthe
centerofByzantiumsiveConstantineopolis,
1559,Leiden,UniversityLibrary.
Fig.17MelchiorLorichs,SultanSleymansMosque,
1570,woodcut.

Lorichs also produced a woodcut, monogrammed and dated 1570 (fig. 17), of the great
mosquecomplex,theSleymaniye,thatthearchitectSinanhadrecentlybuilt(155057)forSultan
Sleyman.28 Scholars have suggested that this print lacks both the clarity and the accuracy of the
skylinedrawingsmadeonsite,butsuchdistortionsmayhavebeenintentionaleffortsonthepartof
the artist to convey the grandeur of the complex to an audience that had never actually seen it.
Lorichs print furthermore suggests a momentous historical event by placing in the sky above the
mosquebothgatheringstormcloudsaswellasaglowingstarwithatail,likethecometsandother
ominous celestial apparitions associated with earthly catastrophes or conflicts in contemporary
German cosmology.29 To many Europeans, the architectural splendor of this complex would have
beencompromisedbythesourceofitsfunding,tributeamassedthroughconquestandcolonization
ofChristianruledterritories,sothismaybeLorichswayofaccommodatinghiswesternaudiences.

Lorichs careful drawings of both male and female costumes served as studies for his later
woodcut illustrations and were composed with clear graphic syntax of parallel and cross hatchings
that indicates that he was thinking from the outset about reproduction in printed form. In fact,
Lorichs planned a large edition of woodcut illustrations based upon his onsite drawings in Turkey.
Blockswerecutfromthesedesignsin1565,1570,1575and1576,buteventhoughatitlepagewas
produced (1575) the planned publication was never completed.30 A small, reduced version of this
volumeappearedinAntwerpin1574(publishedbyGillisCoppensvanDiest,whoalsopublishedthe
first atlas, Abraham Orteliuss, Theatrum orbis terrarum, 1570) under the title, Soldan Soleyman
TurckischenKhaysersWhareundeigendtlichecontrafectungundbildtnuss(SultanSleyman,ATrue
and Real Facsimile and Portrait of the Turkish Emperor). One drawing (monogrammed and dated
1557,Paris,Louvre)showsarichlycaparisoneddromedarycamel,stridingthroughalandscapewith
a royal drummer on his back pounding his instrument, presumably to announce the advent of the
sultan behind him.31 This image was produced as a reversed woodcut in 1576. The artist also
producedotherdrawingsofdistinctive,sometimeshistorical,Germancostumes,thatwereprobably
intendedforacompanionvolumeofEuropeancostumes,akintocontemporarycostumebookslike
CesareVecellios(Venice,1590)orAbrahamdeBruyns(Antwerp1577).32
ISBN9789460184833
252

Fig.18MelchiorLorichs,PortraitofSleymanthe
Magnificent,1562(?),engraving.
Fig.19MelchiorLorichs,SleymantheMagnificentwith
theSuleymaniyeCamiinBackground,1574.

Lorichs also produced portrait engravings of the Sultan Sleyman when the latter was
advanced in years (1574). One of these, based on a drawing of 1559 and monogrammed with the
artistsinitials(fig.18),presentsthesultanatbustlength,wearinghisown,distinctivelyhighturban.
FollowingtheformulaestablishedinthelateportraitengravingsbyDrer,suchasFredericktheWise
(1524), the sitter appears before a neutral, toned background with a ledge bearing an inscription.
TheprintiselaboratelycaptionedinbothArabicandLatin.TheArabicinscriptiondeclaresthesitter
tobeSultanofsultans,Sleymanshah,sonofSultanSelimKhan,andconcludeswiththeformula,
may God protect his helper. The Latin inscription is even more elaborate: Imago Suleymanni
TurcorumImp.inOriente,UniciSelimiyFilii,QuiAn.DoMDXX.PatriinImperioSuccessit:QuoEtiam
AnnoCarolus.V.MaxaemylianiCaesarisNeposAquisgraniinOccidenteCoronatusestChristian:Imp:
A Melchiore Loricis, Flensburgensi, Holsatio, Antiquitatis Studiosiss, Constantinopoli, An. MDLIX,
Men. Feb., Die XV, Verissime Expressa.33 The fullbearded rulers face is somewhat haggard and
drawn,showinghisageandthecumulativestrainofhisreign.

Lorichs second engraved portrait of Sleyman shows the sultan standing at fulllength
beforeagateofthecity,throughwhichpassesacaparisonedelephantbearingtwobannercarriers,
oneofthemdisplayingthecrescentmoonofIslam(fig.19).Visiblethroughthegatebehindhimis
Sleymaniye mosque complex, which Lorichs had studied on site in preparation for the
abovementioned woodcut. The features of the sultan derive from the bustlength study made by
Lorichsin1559,buttheengravingwasonlyproducedin1574.Inthatyear,inscribedasthetrueand
reallikeness[counterfeit]ofthesultan,itaccompaniedGillisCoppensvanDiestspublication.34
ISBN9789460184833
253

Lorichs woodcut images return us to the tradition of observant, onsite documentary
treatment of the Ottoman Turks and their empire, first conveyed by the woodcut illustrations by
Erhard Reuwich for the pilgrimage guide of Bernhard von Breydenbach in 1486 and maintained in
Drers early accurate drawings of Turkish costume and custom in Venice. However, after the
decisive military advances in the Balkans, especially during the 1520s, the heightened threat of
TurkisharmiestoboththeGermanHolyRomanEmpireaswellastowiderEuropeanChristendom
made it difficult for Drer and his followers to remain neutral observers of contemporary Islam.
Aroundthetimeofthe1529siegeofVienna,Europeanfascinationintensifiedaboutmilitaryaspects
of the Turks. Both in Germany and in The Netherlands, sixteenthcentury artists designsfor
printmakers and for tapestry producers alikekept images of Turkish armies richly available to
Northernaudiences,whetherprincesorgeneralpublic.

After the Emperor Charles Vs siege of Tunis in 1535, the next signal victory over Turkish
forcesintheMediterraneanoccurredatsea,theBattleofLepanto(1571).Maincreditforthevictory
wassharedbetweenthenavalforcesofVeniceandthearmiesofCharlessson,SpanishKingPhilipII.
SoappropriatelytwoprincipalcommemorationsofLepantowereproducedfortheSpanishmonarch
andsenttotheEscorialpalacebytheagedVenetianpainterTitian.

Fig.20Titian,PhilipIIOfferingthe
InfanteDonFerdinandtoHeaven,(1573
75),Madrid,PradoMuseum.

The first of these is an allegorical portrait, Philip II Offering the Infante Don Ferdinand to
Heaven (157375) (fig. 20), which shows a fierce naval battle behind the principals, where dark
smoke silhouettes the flaming vessels.35 Documents describe the picture as The Naval Battle
(BatallaNaval).Ironically,DonFernando,presumptiveheirandfirstsonofthekingsfinalmarriage,
whowasbornintheverysameyearastheBattleofLepanto,1571,woulddieascantthreeyears
aftertheimagewaspainted.Inthepictureadescendingangeland/orawingedVictoryextends
both a laurel crown and palm of military conquest, together with a banderole with a message
intended for the youth: Maiora tibi (greater things for you). This same combination of classical
referencewithreligioussymbolismsuffusesthemainaction.Philip,bareheaded,wearsparadearmor
ISBN9789460184833
254
asheoffershissonatwhatlookslikeanaltartableinaChristomimeticact,likethePresentationof
Jesus in the Temple (Panofsky has compared this gesture to imagery in late medieval manuscripts,
whereapriestisshownliftingupanudechild,asymbolofthesoul;thissceneadornstheopeningof
Psalm 24: Unto thee O Lord, do I lift up my soul). A row of columns like a temple entry recedes
along the right side; the sturdy column, symbol of the virtue of Fortitude, frequently accompanies
thefulllengthstandingsubjectsofcourtportraits,suchasTitiansformative1551imageofPhilipII,
thenaprince.Thisrowconvergesperspectivallylikeaseriesofancestorsonthebrightcentralfigure
oftheinfante.Meanwhile,inthelowerleftcornercrouchesashackledTurkishprisoner,identified
not only by his features but also by his crescent banner and his discarded turban; the spoils of his
weaponsbehindhimwereaddedonastripbypainterVicenteCarduchoin1625,whenthepainting
was enlarged to match the grand dimensions of Titians earlier great military celebration for a
Spanishkinginarmor:hisequestrianportrait,EmperorCharlesVattheBattleofMhlberg(1548),a
conquestnotofTurksbutoveraProtestantalliance.

Fig.21Titian,ReligionSuccoredbySpain,
1573,Madrid,PradoMuseum.

TheotherpaintingsentbyTitiantoSpainincelebrationofKingPhilipscontributiontothe
BattleofLepantowasanallegory,ReligionSuccoredbySpain(1573,fig.21).36Itshowstheencounter
oftwofemalepersonificationsbeforeaseabattleinthebackground.Crouchingontherightside,a
nude who attempts modestly to cover herself can be identified as Catholicism from the chalice
behindherandacrossleaningagainstasolidrock(offaithandthepapacy).Abovethatcross,snakes
onthetrunkofadeadtreesignifydevilishthreatstoChristendom,presumablybytheIslamicTurks
as well as by heretic Protestants in Europe. Striding boldly in from the left and facing Religion, a
femalewarriorenterscarryingaspearandashieldlikethegoddessMinervainearliermythologies
by the artist. Panofsky rightly associates her with the pictorial tradition of the goddess of war,
Bellona,andcallsherEcclesiamilitans.Behindherasecondwomanadvanceswithupraisedsword,
likeafigureofFortitude;sheinturnheadsatroopofAmazons.Theirarmedforceisidentifiedwith
SpainthroughtheheraldicarmsofPhilipIIonthecornershield.Oncemorethespoilsofwarappear
as weapons in the center foreground, between Spain and Religion. At the head of the background
navalbattle,inplaceofaNeptuneonhismarinechariot,drawnbyseahorses,weseeinsteadthe
personificationofaturbanedTurk,headingforshoretothreatenthevulnerablefigureoftheChurch,
whoturnstoacceptwelcomereinforcementfromherdeliverer.Thustheallegory,deftlyunpacked
ISBN9789460184833
255
by Panofsky, can be described in his words as The Christian Religion, Threatened by Internal
Subversion (the snakes of Heresy) and External Enemies (the Turk), Seeking the Protection of the
ChurchMilitantandFortitude.

Fig.22DomenikosTheotokopoulos,ElGreco,
AdorationoftheHolyNameofJesus,ca.
157779,RoyalMonasteryofS.Lawrenceof
theEscorial,PatrimonioNacional.

One final image commemorates the Catholic unity that provided victory at Lepanto. It
survivesonlyasanambitiousvisionbyanartistwhohopedinvaintoservethecourtofPhilipII:El
Greco,arrivinginSpainin1576,freshfromhisownperiodoffinishingschoolatVeniceandRome.
HisAdorationoftheHolyNameofJesus(ca.157779)survivesintwoversions,oneintheEscorial
(fig. 22), the other now in London (National Gallery).37 Its subject was correctly identified in the
seventeenthcenturybyFrayFranciscodelosSantos(1657),whoidentifieditasarepresentationof
the mouth of Hell and the bridge of Purgatory, called it the Gloria by El Greco for Philip II, thus
comparing it directly with Titians Gloria, made earlier for the meditation of Charles V. Kneeling in
adoration of the holy name, itself a Jesuit object of devotion, the three great leaders of the Holy
LeaguewhomarshaledtheforcesforLepanto:PhilipII,dressedasalwaysinblack,DogeMocenigoof
Veniceinarobetrimmedwithermine,andthecurrentpope,PiusV,inclericalrobes.On9March
1566, Pius V had issued a bull, Cum gravissima, exhorting all Christian powers to unite against the
Turk.38Afourthkneelingfigureatthepopesrightisdressedinclassicalarmorandholdsasword;he
hasbeenidentifiedbyAnthonyBluntasanidealizedportraitofthegeneraloftheLepantofleet,Don
Juan of Austria, halfbrother of Philip II, who died in 1578 and was buried in the Escorial Royal
Pantheon.Indeed,accordingtoFranciscodelosSantos,thisimagehungnearthattombinthemid
seventeenth century. This picture reaffirms Christian doctrine and Catholic unity while also
presentingtheseimportantcontemporaryfiguresalongsideresurrectedsoulswhoawaitredemption
and admission to heaven and the company of the angels above. Even more than an allegory, this
visionsituatescontemporaryreligionwithinacosmosoftheLastJudgmentandthetriumphofgood
overevil.
ISBN9789460184833
256

Ontheeasternfront,theHolyRomanEmpireresumeditsownactiveTurkishWars(1593
1606), fought during the reign of Emperor Rudolf II (r. 15761612). The renewed conflict began in
August1593,whenSultanMuradIIIbrokeatrucethathadbeenineffectsince1584.39Althoughthe
two sides fought to a deadlock before the peace of ZsitvaTorok (11 November 1606) was ratified,
this protracted activity along a Central European front held worldwide significance as another
boundarycontestbetweenChristendomandIslam.Italsoprovidedtheopportunity(or,indeed,the
necessity) for considerable propagandaincluding visual arton the part of the Habsburg ruler.
AlthoughRudolfIIneveractuallyledhistroopsinbattle,hehadhimselfportrayedbyhisnumerous
courtartistsasagreatmilitaryvictorandpreserverofthefaith.

Fig.23HansvonAachen,Allegoryofthe
TurkishWar(BattleofKronstadt/Brasov),
1603,Vienna.KunsthistorischesMuseum.

PrincipalpropagandisticcommissionswenttoRudolfscourtpainterinPrague,Hansvon
Aachen,theauthorofabelatedcycleofoilsketchesonparchment,boundtogetherinavolume
underthetitleAllegoryoftheTurkishWar(completedbefore1607).40Thelatestofthemilitary
eventsdepictedinthecycle,theBattleofKronstadt/Brasov,datesfrommid1603(fig.23).This
motivationtocelebratevictoriesthroughvisualimageryechoestheheritageofthegrandiose
cartoonsandtapestriesofCharlesVsearlierTuniscampaign.LikeVermeyenpreparingtopainthis
cartoons,vonAachenmademeticuloustopographicstudies.Yethealteredtherhetoricofthe
presentationbyutilizingallegoricalfigures,chieflyfemalepersonifications,suchaswingedvictories
orplaces(e.g.Hungary),alongwithmorehistoricallycrediblegroupingsofinfantryandcavalry.In
thefinaltwoimageshealsoincludedbannersastrophiestosignifyvictory.
ISBN9789460184833
257
Frequentlythecompositionsdisplaytheheavensopentoshowdivinefiguresoverseeingthebattle:
classicalgodsappearinpersonorthroughthesurrogatesoftheirsymbolicanimals,andtheartist
doesnotmisstheopportunitytosuggestparallelsbetweentheeagleofJupiterandtheheraldic
eagleoftheHolyRomanEmpire.Theeagleclawingthecrescentmoon,symbolofIslam,wasalsoa
favoriteimpresaofRudolfII.

Fig.24AdriaendeVries,Reliefwiththeregainingofthe
fortressofRaab/Gor(1598),Vienna,Kunsthistorisches
Museum.

Fig.25HansvonAachen,TheBattleofSissek(1593),
Vienna,HeeresgeschichtlichesMuseum.

SomeofvonAachensdesignsweretranslatedintosculptedreliefbyRudolfscourtsculptor,
Adriaen de Vries, notably the image (ca. 160405) of the regaining (1598) of the fortress of
Raab/Gyr(fig.24).41Boththeoilsketchesandthebronzereliefweremorepersonal,privateitems
thantapestriesorprints,andwerereservedforthenotoriouslywithdrawnemperorhimselfrather
thanconceivedforlargescalepublicdisplayorbroadcirculation.Yettheirgenesisandpresentation
receivedmoredirectinputfromtherulerhimselfthanhadthetapestries,commissionedthroughthe
agencyoftheemperorssisterandregent,MaryofHungary.

A characteristic von Aachen image, The Battle of Sissek (1593; one of the sources for de
Vriess relief) (fig. 25), inaugurates the scenes of war. It shows the emperors eagle attacking the
sultanscrescentintheskyabove,andplacesclassicalrivergodsinthecornerstosuggestthesite.
Additionally, a winged Victory extends palm and laurel garlands to the seated female allegory of
Croatia,whobearsacrownandscepterandheraldicblueandwhitesquaresonherskirt.Alongside
thesefantasticallegoricalelements,thebackgroundoftheimageclearlydepictstheactualriverside
setting of the city and its fortified walls. The battle is in progress: imperial forces move inexorably
fromlefttoright,sportingtheirbanners,andvanquishedTurksarecastintotheriver.Cavalrywith
lances are complemented by infantry with pikes; the modern firearm, a harquebus or musket, is
visibleintheleftmiddleground.SomeTurkswearidentifiablecostume,especiallyturbans,butthese
are less ethnographically accurate records of dress than they are symbolic attributes to help
communicateandcelebratethepartisanvictoryoveradreadedenemy.Alongwiththeirallegorical
ISBN9789460184833
258
mainfigures,theserepresentationsofbattlesbyvonAachenattendmoretothespecifictopography
ofthesitesthantheydocumenttheactualmovementsofarmies.

VonAachensworkssurviveforthemostpartbothintheformofoilsketches(Vienna)and
presentationdrawings(Dresden),thelatterofwhichwerefinishedin1604andpresentedin1607to
Christian II, Elector of Saxony.42 Once more both patron and audience are courtly, imperial
adversaries of the Turks, and again the chosen subjects are battlesa different category from the
traditionof dispassionateethnographicstudyofcostumesorcustoms,intendedtosatisfy curiosity
anddisplaytheexotic.

By contrast, Rudolf II assembled in his castle at Prague the actual battlefield booty seized
fromtheTurks,makingitafeaturewithinhisvastcollections.43Consistingchieflyofbowsandtheir
leather cases, as well metaledged weapons (daggers, swords, battleaxes), these trophies were
displayedtoimpressvisitingambassadors.SuchdelegationsincludedSafavidPersians,envoysfrom
the empire that abutted the Ottomans on the opposite flank. This display of trophies must have
helped kindle a proposed alliance between the Holy Roman Empire and the Persian Shah Abbas
(15871629).44

TheartistofprintedportraitsofRudolfIIwashiscourtengraver,AegidiusSadeler.45Sadeler,
like the imperial sculptor, Adriaen de Vries, devoted his main portrait energies to depicting the
majestyofRudolfII.Andhisallegoricalvocabularyinframingtheimperialmajestypartakesofanew
learned artistic vocabulary, which asserts conquest over the Turkish nemesis. After an extended
century of visualizing Turks, this imperial program fits firmly into an ongoing Habsburg tradition,
albeit with a more propagandistic purpose. Indeed the allegories, like Rubenss cycle for Queen
MotherMariedeMediciinFranceduringthe1620s,notonlyofferamorelearnedandelitepictorial
vocabulary but also serve to airbrush embarrassing setbacks and harsh realities, in this case the
ultimatemilitarystalematewiththeTurkishforcesbytheEmpire.Likethemodernexampleofthe
Cold War adduced above, no European Christian could ever forget the clear and present danger
posedtobothhisfaithandhispoliticalautonomybytheIslamicOttomanEmpireacrosstheborder.
That threatening superpower, however, also held ongoing fascination and exotic allure, realized in
pictorialtermsallthemorebythoseartists,particularlyVermeyenandLorichs,whohadexperienced
TunisandIstanbulinpersoninsteadofpicturingstereotypesofTurks.

Ultimately,almostallimagesofTurksfromtheHolyRomanEmpirenecessarilyblended(to
varying degrees) these opposing qualities: fear and loathing towards a formidable enemy that
defined Christian Europe through contrast; alongside fascinated, careful observation, produced,
usuallyinmultipleprintimages,forthedelectationinEuropeofcommonersaswellasrulers.

ISBN9789460184833
259
Bibliography
Aikema, Bernard and Brown, Beverly L. (eds.), Renaissance Venice and the North, exhibition
catalogue(Venice,1999).
Anzelewsky,Fedja,TheDrawingsandGraphicWorksofDrer(London,1970).
Atil,Esin(ed.),TheAgeofSleymantheMagnificent,exhibitioncatalogue(Washington,1987).
Bartrum,Giulia(ed.),AlbrechtDrerandhisLegacy,exhibitioncatalogue(London,2003).
Blunt, Anthony, El Grecos Dream of Philip II: An Allegory of the Holy League, Journal of the
WarburgandCourtauldInstitutes,3(193940),pp.5869.
Brown, Christopher and Vlieghe, Hans, Van Dyck 15991641, exhibition catalogue (London &
Antwerp,1999).
Brown,Jonathanetal.(eds.),ElGrecoofToledo,exhibitioncatalogue(Toledo,1982).
Campbell,Caroline,andChong,Alan(eds.),BelliniandtheEast,exhibitioncatalogue(Boston,2005).
Campbell, Thomas P., Tapestry in the Renaissance. Art and Magnificence, exhibition catalogue
(LondonandNewHaven,2002).
Carboni,Stefano(ed.),VeniceandIslam,exhibitioncatalogue(NewYork,2007).
Checa, Fernando, Tiziano y la Monarqua Hispnica. Usos y funciones de la pintura veneciana en
Espaa(siglosXVIyXVII)(Madrid,1994).
Clifton, James, Mediated War, in The Plains of Mars. European War Prints, 15001825, ed. James
CliftonandLeslieScattone,(Houston2009),pp.4150.
ColdingSmith,Charlotte,MilitaryImagesoftheTurkandtheConflictsoftheSixteenthCentury,in
Apocalyptic Battles and Exotic Courts: Printed Images of the Turk from SixteenthCentury German
Territories,Ph.D.dissertation(UniversityofMelbourne,2010).
Dessins de Drer et de la Renaissance germanique dans les collections publiques parisiennes,
exhibitioncatalogue(Paris,1991).
DeWitt, Lloyd, Testing Tradition against Nature. Rembrandts Radical New Image of Jesus, in
RembrandtandtheFaceofJesus,exhibitioncatalogue(Philadelphia,2011),pp.10945.
Evans, Helen C. (ed.), Byzantium: Faith and Power (12611557), exhibition catalogue, The
MetropolitanMuseumofArt(NewYork,2004).
Evans,R.J.W.,RudolfIIandhisWorld(London,1997).
Fischer,Erik,MelchiorLorck,exhibitioncatalogue(Copenhagen,1962).
ISBN9789460184833
260
Fisher,Erik,MelchiorLorck(Copenhagen,2009).
Goodwin,Godfrey,AHistoryofOttomanArchitecture(London,1971).
Goodwin,Jason,LordsoftheHorizon(NewYork,1998).
Haupt,Herbert,DerTrkenkriegKaiserRudolfsII.15931606,inPragum1600,exhibitioncatalogue
(Essen&Vienna,1988),vol.I,pp.9798.
Heinz,GntherandSchtz,Karl,PortrtgaleriezurGeschichtesterreichsvon1400bis1800(Vienna,
1976).
Horn,Hendrik,JanCorneliszVermeyen(Doornspijk,1989).
Humfrey,Peter,Titian:theCompletePaintings(Ghent,2007).
Im Lichte des Halbmonds. Das Abendland und der trkische Orient, exhibition catalogue (Dresden,
1995).
Jacoby,Joachim,HansvonAachen15521615(Berlin,2000).
Jardine, Lisa and Brotton Jerry, Global Interests: Renaissance Art between East and West (Ithaca,
2000).
Kafadar, Cemal, The Ottomans and Europe, in Handbook of European History, ed. Thomas Brady
(jr.),HeikoObermanandJamesTracy(Leiden,1994),vol.I,pp.599628.
Kappel, Jutta, Die Trkennot des Kaisers. Zu einigen Aspekten der Darstellung des Trkenkrieges
(15931606) in der Hofkunst Rudolfs II, in Im Lichte des Halbmonds. Das Abendland und der
trkischeOrient,exhibitioncatalogue(Dresden,1995),pp.12533.
Kaufmann,ThomasDaCosta,TheSchoolofPrague(Chicago,1988).
Knecht,RobertJ.,FrancisI(Cambridge,1992).
Koschatzky,WalterandStrobl,Alice(eds.),DrerDrawings.TheAlbertinaCollection(Greenwich,CT,
1971).
KunstvoordeBeeldenstorm.NoordnederlandseKunst15251580,exhibitioncatalogue(Amsterdam,
1986).
Landau,DavidandParshall,Peter,TheRenaissancePrint14701550(NewHaven,1994).
Levenson,Jay(ed.),Circa1492,exhibitioncatalogue(Washington,1991).
Luther, Martin, Luthers Works, vol. 35: Word and Sacrament I, ed. E. Theodore Bachman
(Philadelphia,1960).
Mango,Cyriletal.,MelchiorLorichsPanoramaofIstanbul1559(Berlin,1999).
ISBN9789460184833
261
Moxey, Keith, Peasants, Warriors and Wives. Popular Imagery in the Reformation (Chicago and
London,1989).
Necipoglu,Gulru,Sinan(Princeton,2005).
Nuti,Lucia,Rittratidicitt(Venezia,1996).
Panofsky,Erwin,ConradCeltesandKunzvonderRosen:TwoProblemsinPortraitIdentification,Art
Bulletin,24(1942),pp.3954.
Panofsky,Erwin,ProblemsinTitian,mostlyiconographic(NewYork,1969).
Pfaffenbichler,Matthias,DietrkischenWaffeninderKunstkammerRudolfsII,inRudolfII,Prague
andtheWorld,ed.LubomirKonenyetal.(Prague,1998),pp.16165.
Pragum1600,exhibitioncatalogue(Essen&Vienna,1988),2vols.
Press,Volker,TheHabsburgLands:TheHolyRomanEmpire,14001555,inHandbookofEuropean
History,ed.ThomasBrady(jr.),HeikoObermanandJamesTracy(Leiden,1994),vol.I,pp.599628.
Raby,Julian,Venice,DrerandtheOrientalMode(London,1982).
Romanelli, Giandomenico (ed.), A volo duccello: Jacopo de Barbari e le rappresentatzioni di citt
nellEuropadelRinascimento,exhibitioncatalogue(Venezia,1999).
St.Clair,AlexandrineN.,TheImageoftheTurkinEurope,exhibitioncatalogue(NewYork,1973).
SchtzeausdemTopkapiSerail,exhibitioncatalogue(Berlin,1988).
Scholten,Frits,AdriaendeVries15561626,exhibitioncatalogue(Amsterdam,199899).
Seipel,Wilfried,DerKriegszugKaiserKarlsVgegenTunis.KartonsundTapisserien(Vienna,2000).
Sievernich,GereonandBudde,Henrich(eds.),EuropaundderOrient,8001900,(Mnchen,1989).
Silver,Larry,NatureandNaturesGod:LandscapeandCosmosofAlbrechtAltdorfer,ArtBulletin,81
(1999),pp.194214.
Silver, Larry, The Face is Familiar: German Renaissance Portrait Multiples in Prints and Medals,
WordandImage,19(2003),pp.621.
Silver,Larry,CivicCourtliness:AlbrechtDrer,theDukeandtheEmperor,inArtistsatCourt:Image
MakingandIdentity13001500,ed.StephenCampbell(Boston,2004),pp.14962.
Silver,Larry,MarketingMaximilian:TheVisualIdeologyofaHolyRomanEmperor(Princeton,2008).
Spitz,Lewis,ConradCeltis(Cambridge,Mass.,1958).
Strauss,Walter,TheCompleteDrawingsofAlbrechtDrer(NewYork,1974).
ISBN9789460184833
262
Strauss,Walter,TheIntaglioPrintsofAlbrechtDrer(NewYork,1981).
WardJackson,Peter,SomeRareDrawingsbyMelchiorLorichs,TheConnoisseur(March,1955),83
93.
Westbrook, Nigel, Rainsbury Dark, Kenneth and van Meeuwen, Rene, Constructing Melchior
LorichssPanoramaofConstantinople,JournaloftheSocietyofArchitecturalHistorians,69(2010),
pp.6287.
White,Christopher,AnOrientalRuleronHisThroneandTheEntombment:TwoNewDrawings
byAlbrechtDrer,MasterDrawings,11(1973),pp.36574.
Wien1529.DieersteTrkenbelagerung,exhibitioncatalogue(Vienna,197980).
Wittkower,Rudolf,TitiansAllegoryofReligionSuccoredbySpain,inAllegoryandtheMigration
ofSymbols(London,1977),pp.14346.
Yerasimos, Stphane, Istanbul au XVIe sicle. Images dune capitale, in Soliman le Magnifique,
exhibitioncatalogue(Paris,1990),pp.184321.
Zeydel,Edwin,TheShipofFools(NewYork,1944).

Illustrations
Fig.1MapoftheDanubeRiver,byWillemandJohannBlaeu,inNovusAtlas(Amsterdam,1636).
Fig.2AlbrechtDrer,ThreeTurkishMen,ca.1495.
Fig.3GentileBellini,ProcessioninPiazzaSanMarco,1496,detailofthreeTurkishmenin
background,Venice,GalleriedellAccademia.
Fig.4AlbrechtDrer,Orientalfamilyofanottomanarcher,1496,Milan,BibliotecaAmbrosiana.
Fig.5AlbrechtDrer,OrientalRulerseatedonhisThrone,ca.1496/97),Washington,National
Gallery.
Fig.6AlbrechtDrer,ApocalypseSeries,1497,pl.2:TortureofSt.JohntheEvangelist.
Fig.7AlbrechtDrer,SultanSleyman,1526,Bayonne,MuseBonnat.
Fig.8Anonymous,SultanSleyman,ca.1530/40,Vienna,KunsthistorischesMuseum.
Fig.9AlbrechtDrer,TheMartyrdomofTenThousand,1508,oilonpanel,Vienna,Kunsthistorisches
Museum.
Fig.10AlbrechtDrer,TheMartyrdomoftheTenThousand,ca.1497/98,woodcut.
ISBN9789460184833
263
Fig.11NicolausMeldemann,CircularViewoftheCityofViennaattheTimeoftheFirstTurkish
Siegein1529,eightsheetwoodcut,1530.
Fig.12SebaldBeham,TheTurkishSultanSleyman,woodcutpublishedwiththepamphletThe
ThreeBesiegersofVienna.
Fig.13ErhardSchoen,TurkishAtrocities,woodcut,publishedbyHansGuldenmundtinNuremberg,
1530.
Fig.14WillemdePannemakerafterJanC.Vermeyen,TheQuestforFodder,Sixthtapestryofthe
ConquestofTunisseries(includingancientruinsofCarthage),Madrid,PatrimonioNacional.
Fig.15MelchiorLorichs,ByzantiumsiveConstantineopolis(ViewofIstanbul),1559,twosections,
Leiden,UniversityLibrary.
Fig.16MelchiorLorichs,SectionwithanidealselfportraitoftheauthoratthecenterofByzantium
siveConstantineopolis,1559,Leiden,UniversityLibrary.
Fig.17MelchiorLorichs,SultanSleymansMosque,1570,woodcut.
Fig.18MelchiorLorichs,PortraitofSleymantheMagnificent,1562?,engraving.
Fig.19MelchiorLorichs,SlemaniyetheMagnificentwiththeSuleymaniyeCamiinBackground,
1574.
Fig.20Titian,PhilipIIOfferingtheInfanteDonFerdinandtoHeaven,(157375),Madrid,Prado
Museum.
Fig.21Titian,ReligionSuccoredbySpain,1573,Madrid,PradoMuseum.
Fig.22DomenikosTheotokopoulos,ElGreco,AdorationoftheHolyNameofJesus,ca.157779,
RoyalMonasteryofS.LawrenceoftheEscorial,PatrimonioNacional.
Fig.23HansvonAachen,AllegoryoftheTurkishWar(BattleofKronstadt/Brasov),1603,Vienna,
Fig.24AdriaendeVries,ReliefwiththeRegainingofthefortressofRaab/Gor(1598),Vienna,
Fig.25HansvonAachen,TheBattleofSissek(1593),Vienna,HeeresgeschichtlichesMuseum.

1
For a discussion of Maximilians art patronage, including his various verbal and visual campaigns for a
contemporarycrusadeagainsttheOttomanTurks,seeSilver2008.
2
EditedandtranslatedbyZeydel1944,pp.31522.
3
Raby1982;Levenson1991,pp.21213,nos.109110.
4
Carboni2007.SeealsotheessaybyElizabethRodiniinthesamevolume.
5
Raby1982,p.25;Aikema&Brown1999,pp.26667,no.38;Koschatzky&Strobl,1971,pp.6465,no.15(W.
79,ca.1495);Levenson1991,p.213,no.110;Bartrum2003,pp.10809,no.38(W.78,ca.149495).Seenow
Campbell&Chong2005.InthespecificcaseoftheThreeOrientals(London,BritishMuseum,W.78,ca.1494
ISBN9789460184833
264

95),DrerexplicitlyreplicatedthreesmallfiguresinthebackgroundofalargepaintingbyGentileBellini,the
Corpus Christi Procession in the Piazza San Marco, dated 1496; therefore, these figures must have been
experiencedbyDrerpriortocompletionofthefinalpicture,perhapsthroughpreliminarydrawingstudies.
6
Levenson1991,pp.21213,no.109,White1973,36574.Thefigureofthedrawingwastracedthroughto
theothersideofthesheet,toserveasthemodelfortheengraving.Thatprintexistsinonlyoneunfinished
proof (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum) and was unrecorded by Bartsch. See also Strauss 1981, pp. 5455; and
Strauss1974,no.1495/1818a.
7
Additionofbothrubiesandturquoisedoesindeedmarkanumberofthesultanspersonaldecorativeobjects,
includingtheroyalmace;seeAtil1987;andSchtzeausdemTopkapiSerail,1988.
8
DeWitt2011,pp.10945,esp.11213,12123.
9
See Strauss 1974, pp. 2320 2321, no. 1526/8. The drawing is inscribed in German script, Suleyman
imperator,dieleibfarbistgantzlederfarb(EmperorSleyman,thebodycoloriscompletelyleathercolored).
10
Fortherelationsbetweenportraitmedalsandportraitwoodcutsasmultiplelikenesses,Silver2003.
11
Dresden,Mnzkabinett;ImLichtedesHalbmonds...1995,p.75,no.24.Thisraremedaldoesnotappearin
thecelebratedcollectionsofLondon,Vienna,Berlin,andMunich,anditsartistandoriginremainunknown.It
alsoresemblesarelatedetchingbyHieronymusHopfer.ComparealsotheprofilemedalwithturbanofSultan
Mehmet II (the Conqueror), facing the same leftward direction as Drer drawing, dating ca. 1480 and
patternedafteradesignbyGentileBelliniofVenice,ibid.,p.53,no.5,withGentilescelebratednearprofile
paintedportraitofMehmetII(1480;London,NationalGallery),ibid.,p.52,no.1.
12
ImLichtedesHalbmonds...1995,p.74,no.21;Heinz&Schtz1976,pp.18284,no.156,fig.101.Basedon
theageofthesultan,theprofilemodelforthepaintingprobablydatestothe1520's,likeDrersownsource.
13
Anzelewsky1970,pp.21218,no.105.Ahorizontalformatdrawing,preservedinafastidiouscopy(W.438,
Vienna, Albertina; see Koschatzky & Strobl, pp. 16871, no. 62), served as a preliminary composition of this
complextheme.MorewidelyonFredericktheWiseasacourtlypatronofDrer,seeSilver2004,pp.14962.
14
Panofsky1942,3954;Spitz1958.
15
Especiallyafter1530.Knecht1992,pp.22425,23334,29495.ForthebestrecentsurveyoftheHabsburgs
andtheOttomansinthesixteenthcentury,seePress1994andKafadar1994.
16
ImLichtedesHalbmonds1995,pp.7879,no.36;Landau&Parshall1994,pp.22728,figs.23334;Moxey
1989,pp.7879,n.28forreferences.
17
ColdingSmith2010,pp.7273;Hale,1990,pp.1719;Clifton2009,pp.4150;Landau&Parshall1994,pp.
22728.
18
ImLichtedesHalbmonds...1995,pp.7980,no.37.Wien1529...197980,pp.6369,no.151.
19
ColdingSmith2010,pp.5482,esp.6567(IamgratefultoDr.Smithforsharingherresearchwithmeprior
topublication);KunstvoordeBeeldenstorm1986,pp.17576,no.59.
20
ColdingSmith2010,p.54,withtranslation;Moxey1989,pp.7677,fig.4.7.
21
ColdingSmith2010,p.1,withtranslation.
22
Luther1960,vol.35,p.407.
23
Campbell2002,pp.38591,42834;Jardine&Brotton2000,pp.8287;alsoHorn1989,pp.1317,3537,
4147, 111223; Seipel 2000. Scholarly debate continues about whether Vermeyen designed the tapestries
aloneorwhetherhecollaboratedwithexperienceddesignerPieterCoeckevanAelst.
24
History,indeed,butnotwithoutbias.TheSackofTunisusesitsLatininscriptiontoeditorialize:Thetroops
sentagainsttheoutskirtsofthetownlaysiegetoandtakethem,slaughtertheenemy[hostemque]inarmor
and, taking the houses, spare the inhabitants. They use the right of conquest [iure belli]. More than twenty
thousandcaptivesrecovertheirlibertyandthricesaluteCharlestheAvenger[VictoremCarolum]withcriesof
gratitude.TheconquerorreestablishestheunfortunateHasanonthethroneofhisancestors,thoughhehardly
meritedthis,ashehadpromisedsomuchandperformednothing,translatedbyCampbell2002,p.429,no.
50.OrtheLatinfromtheinitialtapestry:WishingtoovercometheinfidelarmiesoftheTurkandthewarrior
[Barbarossa]who,obeyingtheordersofSuleiman,raisescruelwaragainsttherealmsofSpain,Caesar,Charles
theFifthofthatname,gatherstogetherwiththeblessingsofheaven,thearmiesandfleetsofSpainandItalyto
threatentheAfricantroops.Notbrookingdelaywhiletimeandthehourproceed,heenergeticallyhastensto
hisshipsandhisloyalcompanions,translatedbyHorn1989,p.181.
25
Horn1989,p.181.
26
Fischer1962;Fisher2009;St.Clair1973,nos.610.
ISBN9789460184833
265

27
Westbrook,RainsburyDark&vanMeeuwen2010,pp.6287;Evans2004,pp.40608,no.249;Sievernich&
Budde1989,pp.24144;Mangoetal.1989;Romanelli1999,pp.15458,no.16;Yerasimos1990,pp.29497;
Fisher1962,p.24.Forthegeneralphenomenon,seeNuti,1996.
28
SchtzeausdemTopkapiSerail1988,p.72,no.6.Forthebuildingcomplex,Goodwin1971,pp.21539;now
seeNecipoglu2005.
29
Silver1999,pp.194214,withreferences.
30
Fischer 1962,pp.3858. After several false starts, the publication first appeared in1626 in Hamburg with
MichaelHering.WardJackson1955,8393.
31
DessinsdeDrer1991,pp.12829,no.120,arguesthatthedrawingwasdoneatalatermomentbackin
Germany,withthedaterecordingtheperiodofobservation.
32
Kaufmann1988,pp.6465,nos.1415;andFisher1962,pp.5864,nos.6478.
33
ThetranslationoftheLatininscriptionwillbeaddedhere.
34
Soldan Soleyman Turckischen Khaysers... Whare und eigenliche contrafectung und biltnuss, dated 21 April
1574.
35
Humfrey2007,p.368,no.293;Checa1994,pp.5256;Panofsky1969,pp.7273.
36
Humfrey2007,p.367,no.292;Checa1994,pp.5860;Panofsky1969,pp.18690.AlsoWittkower1977,pp.
14346,whichseestheChurchTriumphantintheMinervafigureandthenudefigureastheMagdalene,Sin
redeemed.ButseeaseventeenthcenturyassessmentoftheimagebyFrayFranciscodelosSantos,Wittkower
1977,p.145,n.8.Humfrey2007rejectsthenotionthatthispictureisareworkedversionofamuchearlier
painting,seentheartistsstudioanddescribedin1566byVasari(VII,458)asaworkbegunforAlfonsodEste,
who had commissioned the Ferrara Camerino dalabastro. However, recent technical examination does not
showchangestotheattributesofthemainallegories,sotheVasariworkisprobablylost,thoughitispossibly
identicaltoaworksenttoEmperorMaximilianIIandengravedin1568byGiulioFontana.Intheengravingthe
suppliant nude is described in Latin as the pious image of the religion of the unvanquished Emperor of the
Christians, in Panofsky 1969, p. 187. A workshop copy of the Escorial painting is in Rome, Palazzo Doria
Pamphilij.
37
Brownetal.1982,pp.23132,no.12;Blunt193940,pp.5869.
38
Panofsky1969,p.188.
39
Kappel 1995, pp. 12533; Haupt 1988, vol. I, 9798. For the complex diplomatic history via an imperial
perspective, Evans 1997, pp. 7578; the Ottoman outlook, between Europe and Persia, is conveyed by
Goodwin1998,pp.16467.
40
Jacoby 2000, esp. pp. 17475, 17880, 182203; nos. 56, 58, 60; more generally for von Aachen and the
other artists at Prague, Kaufmann 1988, esp. pp. 13363, nos. 1.44, 1.4860. Ink drawing copies of the oil
sketchesbyvonAachensworkshopshowalargeroriginalcycle.
41
Scholten199899,pp.15961,no.18.Thismorecompositework,derivedfromseveralofthevonAachen
designs,speaksmoregenerallytotheTurkishWaronthebattlegroundofHungary,anditfeaturestheMuslim
dragon and serpent being attacked by imperial eagle and lion along with river personifications (Danube and
Sava).
42
Unusually for von Aachen a pair of preliminary compositional drawings survive: one in Dusseldorf,
Kunstmuseum(inv.no.941),theotherinMoscow,PushkinMuseum(inv.no.7456;discussedinPragum1600,
vol.I,pp.33334,no.183).
43
Pfaffenbichler1998,pp.16165.
44
ThisproposedalliancewasbrokeredbytheEnglishmanRobertShirley;seeEvans1997,pp.7778;seealso
theremarkabledoubleportraitsinPersianambassadorialdress(1622),paintedinRomebyAnthonyvanDyck
ofSirRobertandTeresia,LadyShirley(PetworthHouse),inBrown&Vlieghe1999,pp.16063,nos.2930.
45
ImLichtedesHalbmonds,nos.13234;Pragum1600,vol.I,nos.19,3637,esp.HuseinAliBeg,depictedin
1601,whoalsovisitedtheElectorofSaxony.
ISBN9789460184833
266
TheGoodandHonestTurk
AEuropeanLegendintheContextofSixteenthCenturyOrientalStudies
Plcs

Butdeliverusfromevil
Believe me, it is a greater pleasure to repay with good deeds and injustice suffered, rather than
punishevilwithevil.Takeyourfreedom,takeConstanzeandbemorehumanethanyourfather[...]
thisishowSelimpashaaddressesBelmonte,thesonofhisardentenemyintheclosingsceneof
MozartsoperaTheAbductionfromtheSeraglio.Nothingisasuglyasrevenge[],singthefreed
prisoners,totheutmostangerofthefat,meanandbloodthirstyOsmin.1Weknowthatthefigureof
the good and noble Turk, Selim pasha, who generously overcomes his prejudices and voluntarily
forgives his enemies was formed by the composer himself in accordance with his Enlightenment
ideals, and that it was Mozart himself who turned Osmin into a comic yet bloodcurdlingly cruel
figuretobalancethepashasgenerosity.2WemaysaythatSelimandOsmindemonstratethelight
andthedarksideoftheEuropeanimageoftheTurkinaperfectlyclearform.3

Lightandshadowareinseparableafactthatthosestudyingthecenturieslongstruggleof
ChristianityandtheOttomanEmpireoftentendtoforget.Intheoldandnewliteratureexploringthe
image of the Turk, dark and light tones seem to alternate and never to find harmony: in the
foregroundisthefictitiousorrealfigureofeitherthemeanandcruelorgoodandnobleTurk.4The
literaryfigureofthepaganTurkconceivedasthenaturalenemyofChristianityandthescourgeof
God5islostinthedistantpastbeforetheEuropeanappearanceoftheOttomansandiswoveninto
conceptsoftheHuns,theTartarsandtheHungarians.JeanDelumeauisrightinsayingthattheWest
representeditsownfearsinthedemonizedMuslimenemy.6Thisishowtheenemyturnedintothe
apocalypticdragonidentifiedwithSatan:dracorufus.7

Theothersideofthecoin,thelegendofthehonestTurk(Voltairesbonmusulman)8in
the form depicted by Paolo Giovio, Guillaume Postel and Jean Bodin,9 and then in the age of the
Enlightenment10byVoltaire,Lessing,HumeandMozartmayalsobetracedbacktothedepthsof
thepast.11ItisrelatedtotheideastemmingfromOrigenthatneitheralltheevilthingsintheworld
nor even Satan and hell can be considered everlasting, as God will destroy them on the last day,
whenherestoresallthings.12Sedliberanosamalo,thusprayedChristians,notknowingwhether
tolookforevilintheoutsideworldorinthemselves.Theycouldnotdecidewhetherfinalliberation
wastobethedestructionorthetransformationandimprovementofevil.Thewholecreationcarries
thehopeofliberty,saidOrigen,13andhisfaithwassharedbymanygreatmenoftheRenaissance
ISBN9789460184833
267
suchasPicodellaMirandola,Erasmusandothers.14Renaissanceitselfamongmanyotherthings
was the rebirth of the desire for liberty. This ray of hope sometimes projected itself on the image
ChristiansformedoftheTurk.15
ThesecondRome
Travellers, ambassadors, writers, scientists, artists and polymaths interested in the world of the
Orientsixteenthcentury intellectuals in the service of the Habsburgs promising to describe the
OttomanEmpireintheirworkswereallawareofthesharpcontrastbetweentheEuropeanimage
oftheTurkandtheirs.16TheyhaddifferentviewsofTurkishness,17yettheybasicallytreatedtheir
subjectasanintellectualproblemandtriedtograspitwithinRenaissanceconcepts.

Fig.1TheSerpentineColumnandtheObeliskofTheodosiusinConstantinople.

ItisworthwhileexaminingthesignificanceoftheHabsburgpeacedelegationsenttoIstanbul
in1553fromthepointofviewofthedevelopmentofOrientalstudies.18Therelationshipbetween
theHabsburgsandthePortewasextremelytenseatthetime;sultanSleymanIcouldnotforgive
Ferdinand for the 1551 attack against Transylvania and the murdering of governor Frater Georgius
(GeorgeMartinuzzi),19withtheresultthatin1552helaunchedageneralattackagainstthekingdom
of Hungary.20 Peace negotiations came to a halt and the Habsburg ambassador Giovanni Maria
Malvezzi was imprisoned by the Ottomans.21 The new delegates of Ferdinand I had been charged
with a very difficult and multilayered task: they were supposed to sign a peace agreement that
ISBN9789460184833
268
wouldleaveTransylvaniaunderHabsburgrule,andatthesametimetoseekpoliticalrelationswith
theexternalenemiesoftheSultan,primarilythePersians.22

Researchers of the history of Ottoman and Habsburg diplomacy are usually amazed that
Ferdinandsenvoyscarriedouttheirdelicatemissioninsuchawayastoleavethemplentyoftime
for scholarly and scientific research: they discovered and studied ancient architectural remains,
explored thepeoplesoftheSultansempire,andobservedthefloraandfaunaofthelandscapein
frontofthem.23Inreality,theprofoundinterestoftheambassadorsintheOttomanEmpirewasnot
atallasideactivity.Onthecontrary,thefeverishsearchforantiquitiesexpressedtheessenceofthe
mission, tellingly representing the aims for powerhowever far exceeding their current
possibilitiesoftheViennesecourt.
Fig.2MartinoRota:AntoniusVerantius.

We know that the embassy was led by the best Humanist intellectuals of the time. Antal
Verancsics (cr. Antun Vrani, it. Antonio Veranzio; 15041573), the bishop of Pcs (Fnfkirchen),
wasascholarwithanoriginalmindandawideintellectualhorizon.24Amerelistofhisdiscoveries
and works would fill pages. We still treasure his uniquely rich collection of Hungarian historical
sourcesdiaries,memoirs,memorandums,biographies,etc.:thesocalledVerancsicsCollection25,
hisabundantcorrespondence,26andhighqualityhistoricalessays.27Aspartoftheembassy,heused
Ptolemaiossmaptofindancientruins,copiedRomaninscriptions,andcollectedGreekandRoman
coins.28 This is when he came into possession of a valuable Turkish manuscript, the socalled
enlarged version of the narrative of the Ottoman chronicler Mehmed Muhj alDn. The author of
thisimportantsourcecompiledanonymousOttomanchroniclesfromthebeginningsoftheOttoman
Empiretohisownera(until1549).ThemanuscriptlaternamedafterVerancsics(CodexVerantianus)
becameoneofthemainsourcesforEuropeanhistoriansresearchingOttomanhistory.29
ISBN9789460184833
269

Another important role in the Istanbul embassy was played by Ferenc Zay, a brilliant
Hungarian soldier who was captain of the Danube fleet. He was an educated man; his Hungarian
military chronicle of the 1521 fall of Nndorfehrvr (Belgrade) is preserved in the Verancsics
Collection.30DespitehismanybattlesagainsttheTurks,Zaywasknowntohaveexcellentrelations
withthem,whichispreciselywhyhewasselectedforthePortedelegation.31Anothermemberofthe
mission was the Hungarian commissioner of the Fugger bank, Hans Dernschwam, who profoundly
despised the Turks but studied the countrys glorious past with holy devotion.32 Dernschwam
possessedoneoftherichestlibrariesoftheera,33anditwasprimarilyduetohimthattheembassy
gotholdofsuchvaluablemanuscriptsastherarecopiesofDioskoridessHerbarium34andZnarass
Annales, which are now great treasures of the Hofbibliothek in Vienna.35 The brilliant Hungarian
humanist Joannes Belsius completed Dernschwams famous travel diary with sketches of ancient
monumentsandinscriptions.36

In1555,Verancsicsandhisembassywerejoinedbyoneofthebestdiplomatsofthetime,
OgierGhiselindeBusbecqfromFlanders,whosedelicate,readableandelegantTurkishLettersthe
literary adaptation of the mission in questionintroduced the Ottoman Empire and the Turks to
Europe.37 The other ornament of the delegation was Melchior Lorck, a DanishGerman painter in
Ferdinandsservice.38HisengravingsanddrawingsofOttomansubjectsrepresentthesamequalityin
the fine arts as Busbecqs book doesin line with the works of Montaigne and Justus Lipsiusin
literature. Ferenc Zay, Verancsics and Busbecq were depicted by Lorck in a Renaissance series of
portraits,39 which is perfectly harmonious in elaboration and compositionexpressing the
intellectualtogethernessofthemembersoftheOttomanmissionwithartisticmeans(seefigs.35).
We may learn a lot by highlighting typical motives in the works of Lorck, Busbecq and Verancsics,
motivesthathelpexploretheinnerlinksofthissharedworldofthoughts.40

Figs.35MelchiorLorck:TheportraitsofAntoniusVerantius,FranciscusZayandAugeriusBusbequius.

In1559,MelchiorLorckpaintedhisselfportraitontheextremelypreciseandlightpanorama
of Constantinople (fig. 6).41 The extract shows the painter standing on the banks of the Galata,
paintingthehugemetropolisontheotherside.Weseeanelegantlydressed,blondhaired,Western
Europeanyoungman,lethargicallydippinghispeninaninkpothandedtohimbyaclearlysymbolic
ISBN9789460184833
270
figure, a big Turk wearing a turban. The meaning of the allegoric gesture is quite clear. Lorck
interprets the panorama before him and himself getting lost in the landscape simultaneously. The
artistantiquitatis studiosissimus42spectacularly turns away from the Turk but at the same time
acceptshishelp.HeisdrawingthemosquesoftheOttomancapital(seefigs.7and9),Istanbul,but
seestheaqueductsandcolumnsofConstantinople,thesecondRome.Thearchaicizingpanoramaof
IstanbulwastheintellectualrecapturingoftheOttomanEmpire.

Fig.6SelfportraitofMelchiorLorck.

Fig.7MelchiorLorck:TheSuleimanyeinIstanbul.

BusbecqelaboratedonthesamethoughtintheclosingchapteroftheTurkishLetters,inthe
panegyricofFerdinandI,writteninthestyleofancientroyalmirrors.Hecomparedhisownkingto
SleymanI.Heusedvividcolourstodepicttheimmeasurablenumericalsuperiorityandpowerofthe
Ottoman emperor, against which Ferdinandthe stoic philosopher, the persevering and ingenious
new Fabius Cunctatorcould primarily rely on his morals and rationality, and these virtues indeed
ensuredhimsuccess:
Three things Solyman is said to set his heart on, namely to see the building of his mosque
finished (which is indeed a costly and beautiful work),43 by restoring the ancient aqueducts to
giveConstantinopleanabundantsupplyofwater,andtotakeVienna.Intwoofthesethingshis
wishes have been accomplished, in the third he has been stopped and I hope will be stopped.
Viennaheiswonttocallbynoothernamethanhisdisgraceandshame.44
Busbecq thus saw the rivalry between Habsburgs and Ottomans not as the struggle of good and
evilbutasatrialbetweentwodifferentlystructuredancientempires,RomeandCarthage.
ISBN9789460184833
271

Fig.9MelchiorLorck:TheHagiaSophiainIstanbul.
Fig.8TheMonumentumAncyranuminAnkara.

When sultan Sleyman invited the Habsburg embassy to Amasya in Asia Minor in 1555,
Verancsics,DernschwamandBelsius,thedelegationssecretary,discoveredthemostfamousancient
inscriptionamongtheruinsofasanctuarynearAnkara,thepoliticaltestamentofEmperorAugustus,
latertobeknownastheMonumentumAncyranum(fig.8).45Althoughthepublicwasonlyinformed
about the findings through Busbecqs bookpublished almost two decades laterand he was the
one to carry the glory, success had in reality been shared. Many scholars have studied the
circumstances under which the findings were discovered. Here I would only like to emphasize that
Augustuss inscription, apart from its historical significance, expressed the humanist aims of the
ambassadorsinaperfectlyconstructedform.AsBusbecqsays:
Herewesawaverybeautifulinscription,containingacopyofthetabletsinwhichAugustusgave
a summary of his achievements. We made our people copy out as much as was legible. It is
engravedonthemarblewallsofabuildingnowruinousandroofless,whichformerlymayhave
formed the official residence of the governor. As you enter the building one half of the
inscription is on the right, and the other on the left. The top lines are nearly perfect; in the
middle the gaps begin to present difficulties; the lowest lines are so mutilated with blows of
clubsandaxesastobeillegible.Thisisindeedagreatliteraryloss,andonewhichscholarshave
much reason to regret; the more so as it is an ascertained fact that Ancyra was dedicated to
AugustusasthecommongiftofAsia.46

Letusfocusonthelastsentenceofthequote.WeknowtheMonumentumAncyranumtobe
a basic document of the institution of the Roman principatus, and in this document Octavian
seemingly defined himself as the reformer of Roman freedom and republic but in reality as the
omnipotentAugustusCaesar,reconstructorofworldorder(restitutororbis).47PeopleinViennaknew
thattheOttomansultandeclaredhimselftheheirofByzantinerulers,inotherwords,emperorofthe
ISBN9789460184833
272
Eastern Roman Empire.48 Western and Eastern emperors were considered to be of the same rank.
Augustuss testamentwhich was discovered in the Orientrepresented the unity of the empire
onceruledfromtheWest.WecanrestassuredthatFerdinandI,thewouldbeemperoroftheHoly
RomanEmpire,entirelyagreedwiththisdefinitionoftheconceptofemperorship.
Studiaturcica
Peter Lambeck and Adam Frantiek Kollr, the scholarly seventeenth and eighteenthcentury
librariansoftheVienneseHofbibliothek,alreadynotedthatthefindingsoftheVerancsicsdelegation
lookingforOttomanantiquitiesandtheentireintellectualresultsoftheembassybecameanintegral
part of the imperial library and the scientific work supported by the court.49 During the reign of
Ferdinand Is heirs Maximilian II and Rudolph II, a new generation of humanists belonging to the
Viennese circle turned to Oriental studies. Ottoman studies at the time owe the most to two
competing foreign scholars, the Dutch Hugo Blotius50 from Delft, the first praefectus of the
Hofbibliothek,andJohannesLwenklau,51theWestphalianhistorian,bothofwhomwereprotgsof
LazarusvonSchwendi.

In 1576, Blotius wrote his important Turcica catalogue entitled Ex bibliotheca librorum et
orationum de Turcis et contra Turcas scriptorum catalogus. Research has shown that the scholarly
librarian compiled his encyclopaedic workan attempt to assemble and collect all works and
knowledge on the Ottomanswith strong antiTurkish intentions.52 In the preface addressed to
Rudolph,Blotiustalkedaboutthepracticalusesofthecollection,expressinghiswishthathiswork
might serve as an intellectual weapon in the hands of warriors fighting in the ultimate struggle
againstTurks.ResearchershaveoftenwonderedwhytheirenicBlotius,whowasagainstallreligious
conflict53and was himself a member of the mystic religious community called the Family of Love
(FamiliaCharitatis)spokeoftheOttomanquestioninsuchharshtones.

Thereareseveralcorrectanswerstothisquestion.ItispossiblethatBlotiussimplywantedto
please the new ruler, Rudolph, who was much more aggressive and violent than his predecessors.
AnothersolutionisthatthelibrarianurgedtheemperortoleadawaragainsttheTurksbecausehe
wantedtodeterhimfromtakingotheraggressivestepslaunchinganarmedCounterReformation
againstProtestants.

Itisalsopossible,however,thatBlotiussantiTurkishfeelingsdidnotimmediatelystemfrom
the topical political and religious aims of the collection but from the genre of the work, the
encyclopaedicspiritofthecatalogue.54WeknowthatwhileBlotiuswaseditingTurcica,hehadin
mindtheexampleofalibrarycontainingeverysinglebookintheworld,encompassingscienceand
cultureasawholeConradGessnersBibliothecaUniversalis.55Theimaginaryuniversallibrarywasa
modeloftheuniverse,servedomniscience,andthuscontainedallbranchesofscience,includingthe
culturaltreasuresoftheMuslimenemiesofChristianity,aswellasalltheliteratureonthesubject.
TheBaconianprincipleofscientiaestpotestasnaturallyexistedlongbeforeBacon.

Johannes Lwenklau wrote his famous Ottoman chronicles with highly similar ideas.
Publishedbetween1588and1591,hisLatinandGermanhistoricalworksaretothisdayinvaluable
ISBN9789460184833
273
andessentialsourcesforthosestudyingthehistoryoftheOttomanEmpire.Theauthortracedthe
historyoftheOttomansfromthebeginningstohisowntime,wishingtowriteanauthenticOttoman
history. He used all available genuine sourcesthe books of Guillaume Postel, Ogier Busbecq and
Ottomanhistorians,andAntalVerancsicssabovementionedTurkishcodexamongothers.56Justlike
Blotiuss Turcica catalogue, Lwenklaus Ottoman chronicles were encyclopaedic works, elaborated
withtheaimofhistoriauniversalis.LwenklausLatinlanguageTurkishchroniclepublishedin1591
(fig. 10) also served as intellectual ammunition for the European powers preparing to attack the
Turks.TheGermanhistorianwasalsoamemberofaProtestantspiritualcommunity,theMoravian
Brethren. He was a tolerant, gentle Humanist, but he nevertheless supported the imminent great
antiOttoman war with all his heart, and a few years later ended his life in the fifteenyear war in
Hungary, during the siege of Esztergom/Gran. In a dedication to the German princeelectors,
Lwenklausummeduptheprimaryaimofhisworkasfollows:

Fig.10JohannesLwenklaus
OttomanChronicles(1591).

Fig.11JohannesLwenklau:VaticiniumdeIIIregibus.
Thetimeofchangesissoontocome,bringingthemenacingtyrannistoanend.IthinktheTurks
arenotfarfromit[].Ogenerousprinces[],youwerepromisedbeautifullaurelleavesalong
time ago, this is what the prophecies cited by so many warn you of. The prophecies say that
threekingswillkilltheTurkishkingbytheriverRhine(fig.11).Thereisnoreasontowaitforthe
helpandworkofthesethreemortalkings,itisevendoubtfulwhethertheywerekingsatall.You
arethosekings,partiallybecauseofthedignityofthetitleyouarewearing,partiallybecauseof
the great power that few kings have. You now have protective weapons, great treasures and
strongarmies[],youaresuppliedwithexcellentammunition.57

This confessionlike prophecy was the intellectual programme of Lwenklau and other
humanists interested in Ottoman studies, stemming from the almost apocalyptic, late Renaissance
thinkingoftheendofthesixteenthcentury.58Whileononehanditurgedtheevolutionofscience
andtheencyclopaedicsummingupofknowledge,ontheotheritannouncedtheimminentendof
ISBN9789460184833
274
theworld.Ourcontemporarythinkingfindsthesetwoviewpointsincompatible,yettheycontained
nocontradictionsforBlotiusandLwenklau.

The scholars of the time of Ferdinand I were still hoping for the return of ancient Rome
(Roma instaurata)59 and they integrated the programme of the intellectual occupation and
transformationofTurksintothisbeliefinrenewal.Thisideawastheveryoriginofthelegendabout
thegoodandhonest Turk.ItseemsthatLwenklauand hiscontemporariesdid notcounton the
returnofgoldenantiquity:onthecontrary,theybelievedinsteadinthequickperfectionoftheworld
(instauratiomagna)andtheimminentendofhistory.60Theprophecythehistorianisreferringtois
evidentlyfromJohannesLichtenbergersfamousbookofprophecies(Heidelberg,1488,seefig.12),
which says that at the end of time the Turkish emperor is going to march to Cologne by the river
Rhine,wherehewilllosehishead.61Thewordsaboutthethreekingsrefertotherelicsofthepatron
saintsofCologne,theMagirelicswhichtheauthorfindsitunnecessarytobelievein.62
Fig.12JohannesLichtenberger:Prognosticatio
ontheEndoftheOttomanEmpire.

The time of changes, the approaching universal reformatioLichtenberger uses the same word
will seize and transform everything and everyone. In Saint Pauls words, often cited at the time:
Where there is neither Greek nor Jew, circumcision nor uncircumcision, Barbarian, Scythian bond
norfree:butChristisallandinall(Col.3,11)thatis,theMessiah.Thisratherpessimisticprophecy
paradoxicallyenvisionedapositivepictureoftheTurk:theTurkishwillfallbutwewillfallwiththem.
Whatwouldcomenextwasnottobepartofhistoryanymore.

ISBN9789460184833
275
Bibliography

cs,Pl,TheNamesoftheHolyMaccabees.ErasmusandtheOriginoftheHungarianProtestant
Martirology,inRepublicofLetters,Humanism,Humanities,ed.MarcellSebk(Budapest,2005),pp.
4562.
cs, Pl, Apocalypsis cum figuris. A rgi magyar irodalom trtnelemkpe [Apocalypsis cum
figuris. The Image of History in Ancient Hungarian Literature], in Trtnelemkp. Szemelvnyek
mlt s mvszet kapcsolatbl Magyarorszgon [HistoryImage: Selected Examples of the
InterplaybetweenthePastandArtinHungary],eds.rpdMikandKatalinSink(Budapest,2000),
pp.4862.
cs,Pl,ProTurcisandcontraTurcos.Curiosity,ScholarshipandSpiritualisminTurkishHistoriesby
JohannesLwenklau(15411594),ActaComeniana,25(2011),pp.122.
goston,Gbor,Information,IdeologyandLimitsofImperialPower,inTheEarlyModernOttomans:
RemappingtheEmpire,eds.VirginiaH.AksanandDanielGoffman(Cambridge,2007),pp.75103.
Andermann, Ulrich, Geschichtsdeutung und Prophetie. Krisenerfahrung und bewltigung am
BeispielderosmanischenExpansionimSptmittelalterundinderReformationszeit,inEuropaund
dieTrken,eds.WilhelmKhlmannandBodoGuthmller(Tbingen,2000)(=FrheNeuzeit,54),pp.
2954.
Assman,Jan,MosestheEgyptian.TheMemoryofEgyptinWesternMonotheism(Cambridge,Mass.,
1997).
Babinger, Franz, Tagebuch einer Reise nach Konstantinopol und Kleinasien (155355) (Mnchen &
Leipzig,1923).
Ball,BryanW.,AGreatExpectation:EschatologicalThoughtinEnglishProtestantismto1660(Leiden,
1975).
Barnes,RobinBruce,ProphecyandGnosis.ApocalypticismintheWakeoftheLutheranReformation
(Stanford,1988).
Bartoniek,Emma,Fejezeteka1617.szzadimagyarorszgitrtnetrstrtnetbl[Chaptersfrom
theHistoryoftheHistoriographyinHungaryinthesixteenthandseventeenthcenturies](Budapest,
1975).
Berlsz,Jen(ed.),ADerschwamknyvtr[TheDerschwamLibrary](Szeged,1984).
Biondo,Flavio,Romainstaurata,ed.KlraPczy,EdinaZsupn(Budapest,2005).
Bredekamp, Horst, The Lure of Antiquity and the Cult of the Machine. The Kunstkammer and the
EvolutionofNature,ArtandTechnology,transl.AllisonBrown(Princeton,1995).
Brotton,Jerry,St.GeorgebetweenEastandWest,inMacLean2005,pp.5065.
ISBN9789460184833
276
Busbecq,OgierGhiselinde,LifeandLetters,vol1.,eds.CharlesThorntonForsterandF.H.Blackburn
Daniell(London,1881).
Busbequius,AugeriusGislenius,LegationisTurcicaeEpistolaequatuor(Hanau,1605);firstpublished
(Paris,1589).
Cairns,David,MozartandhisOperas(Berkeley,California,2006).
Centorio, Ascanio degli Hortensii, Commentarii della guerra di Transilvania (Vinegia, 1566);
riproduzionefotograficaconunsaggiointroduttivodiLadislaoGldi(Budapest,1940).
Cooley,Alison(ed.),ResGestaeDiviAugusti.Text,Translation,andCommentary(Cambridge,2009).
DAyala, Mariano, Vita di Giambattista Castaldo, famosissimo guerriero del secolo XVI (Firenze,
1867).
Dark, Jen, Csszrimd Rmakprombol Biznc [Caesar Worshipping Rome and Iconoclastic
Byzantium](Budapest,1977).
Delumeau,Jean,LaPeurenOccident(XVIeXVIIIesicles)(Paris,1978).
Dernschwam, Hans, Erdly, Besztercebnya, trkorszgi tinapl [Transylvania,
Besztercebnya/Bansk Bystrica, Itinerary in Turkey], ed. by Lajos Tardy (= Bibliotheca Historica),
(Budapest,1984).
Dimmock, Matthew, New Turkes. Dramatizing Islam and the Ottomans in Early Modern England
(London,2005).
Faroqhi,Suraiya,SubjectsoftheSultan.CultureandDailyLifeintheOttomanEmpire(London,2007).
Fischer, Erik, Bencard, Ernst Jonas, and Rasmussen, Mikael Bgh (eds.), Melchior Lorck, 4 vols.
(Copenhagen,2009);vol.5(forthcoming).
Green,Jonathan,PrintingandProphecy.PrognosticationandMediaChange14501550(AnnArbor,
MI,2011).
Gyulai,va,EnseopusestVerancsicsAntalemblmaverseI.Szulejmnszultnrl,1558[Enseopus
estTheEmblemPoembyAntalVerancsicsonsultanSuleymanI,1558],PublicationesUniversitatis
Miskolcinensis,SectioPhilosophica,16/2(2011),pp.129167.
Hberlein, Mark, The Fuggers of Augsburg. Pursuing Wealth and Honor in Renaissance Germany
(Charlottesville,VA,2012).
Iuliano,Marco,MelchiorLorcksIstanbulintheEuropeanContext,inFischer,Bencard&Rasmussen,
vol.5(forthcoming),pp.2560.
Jacob, Margaret C., The Radical Enlightenment. Pantheists, Freemasons, and Republicans (London,
1981).
Jardine, Lisa and Brotton, Jerry, Global Interests. Renaissance Art between East and West (London,
2000).
ISBN9789460184833
277
Jellinek George, History through the Opera Glass. From the Rise of Caesar to the Fall of Napoleon
(NewYork,1994).
Kuntz,MarionLeathers,GuillaumePostel.ProphetofRestitutionofAllThings,HisLifeandThought
(TheHague,1981).
Kurtze,Dietrich,PopularAstrologyandProphecyinthefifteenthandsixteenthCenturies.Johannes
Lichtenberger,inAstrologihallucinati:StarsandtheEndoftheWorldinLuthersTime,ed.Paola
Zambelli(Berlin,1986),pp.177193.
Leu,UrsB.,Keller,Raffael,andWeidmann,Sandra,ConradGessnersPrivateLibrary(Leiden,2008).
Leunclavius, Johannes, Historiae Musulmanae Turcorum, de monumentis ipsorum exscriptae libri
XVIII.Commentariiduocumonomasticogemino(FrankfurtamMain,1591).
Lichtenberger,Johannes,Prognosticatio(Straburg,after31December1499).
Louthan, Howard, The Quest for Compromise: Peacemakers in CounterReformation Vienna
(Cambridge,2006).
MacLean, Gerald (ed.), ReOrienting the Renaissance. Cultural Exchanges with the East (London,
2005).
Martels,RudolfWillemMariavon,TheColouringEffectofAttic Styleand StoicisminBusbequius
Turkish Letters, in Travel Fact and Travel Fiction. Studies on Fiction, Literary Tradition, Scholarly
Discovery,andObservationinTravelWriting,ed.id.(Leiden,1994),pp.140157.
Martels, Zweder Rudolf Willem Maria von, The Discovery of the Inscription of the Res Gestae Divi
Augusti,inResPublicaLitterarum.StudiesintheClassicalTradition14(1991),pp.147156.
Maurer, Zsuzsanna, Si nos haec spes fefellerit aliud conabimurNicasius Ellebodius s a respublica
litteraria[NicasiusEllebodiusandthe RepublicofLetters],inCorollarium.Tanulmnyoka hatvant
vesTarIbolyatiszteletre[EssaysinHonourofIbolyaTarontheOccasioninthe65thAnniversaryof
herBirthday],ed.MariannCzerovszkiandJnosNagyills(Szeged,2011),pp.166176.
McCabe, Ina Baghdiantz, Orientalism in Early Modern France. Eurasian Trade, Exoticism, and the
AncienRgime(Oxford,2008).
Meyer Setton, Kenneth, Western Hostility to Islam and Prophecies of Turkish Doom (Philadelphia,
1992).
Mik, rpd, Gtika s barokk kztt. A renesznsz mvszet problmi a kora jkori
Magyarorszgon [Between Gothic and Baroque. The Problems of the Renaissance Art in the Early
Modern Hungary], in Mtys kirly rksge. Ks renesznsz mvszet Magyarorszgon (1617.
szzad),vol.1.[TheHeritageofKingMatthiasCorvinus.LateRenaissanceArtinHungary,16th17th
Century],ed.id.andMriaVer(Budapest,2008),pp.2235.
Miller, Iacobus Ferdinandus, Epistolae imperatorum, et regum Hungariae Ferdinandi primi et
Maximiliani secundi ad suos in Porta Ottomanica oratores, Antonium Verantium, Franciscum Zay,
AugeriumBusbek,AlbertumWyss,etChristophorumTeuffenpach(Pest,1808).
ISBN9789460184833
278
Molino, Paola, Die andere Stimme. La formazione di un intellettuale erasmiano nellEuropa del
tardoCinquecento.HugoBlotius(15341574).(Tesidilaurea)(Firenze,2005).
Molino, Paola, Limpero di carta. Hugo Blotius Hofbibliothekar nella Vienna di fine Cinquecento
(PgDthesis):
(http://www.academia.edu/1106461/LImpero_di_carta._Hugo_Blotius_Hofbibliothekar_nella_Vienn
a_di_fine_Cinquecento_PhD_thesis_2011_)
Molino, Paola, Esperimenti bibliografici fra Vienna e Zurigo. La corrispondenza fra Hugo Blotius e
JohannJakobFrisius(15761589),Bibliothecae.it,1/12(2012):
(http://www.bibliothecae.it/index.php?content=pagina&page=16)
Mommsen,Theodor,MonumentumAncyranum(Berlin,1883).
Niewhner, Friedrich, Veritas sive varietas. Lessings Toleranzparabel und das Buch Von den drei
Betrgern(=BibliothekderAufklrung,5)(Heidelberg1988).
Panofsky,Erwin,RenaissanceandRenascencesinWesternArt(Stockholm,1960).
Papo,Adriano,LediverseversionisullassassiniodiGyrgyMartinuzziUtyeszenicsesulritrovamento
delsuotesoro,MediterrnTanulmnyok,18(2009),pp521.
Papo, Adriano and Nemeth, Gizella, La carriera, le propriet e i tesori di Gyrgy Martinuzzi
Utyeszenics,Crisia,29(2009),pp.173184.
Rogerson,Barnaby,ADoublePerspectiveandaLostRivalry.OgierdeBusbecqandMelchiorLorckin
Istanbul,inMacLean2005,pp.8895.
Schlosser, Julius von, Die Kunst und Wunderkammern der Sptrenaissance. Ein Beitrag zur
GeschichtedesSammelwesens(Leipzig,1908).
SchmidtBiggemann, Wilhelm, Philosophia Perennis: Historical Outlines of Western Spirituality in
Ancient, Medieval and Early Modern Thought (=Archives internationals dhistoire des ides, 189),
(Dordrecht,2004),pp.339368.
Sebk, Marcell, Humanista a hatron: a ksmrki Sebastian Ambrosius trtnete, 15541600.
[HumanistontheBorder:theStoryofSebastianAmbrosiusofKsmrk],(Budapest,2007).
Srs,Pongrc,VerancsicsAntallete[TheLifeofAntalVerancsics],(Esztergom,1898).
Sutter Fichtner, Paula, Terror and Toleration. The Habsburg Empire Confronts Islam, 15261850
(London,2008).
Tardy, Lajos and Moskovszky, va, Zur Entdeckung des Monumentum Ancyranum (1555), Acta
AntiquaAcademiaeScientiarumHungaricae21(1973),pp.375401.
Tardy, Lajos, Rgi magyar kvetjrsok Keleten [Ancient Hungarian Embassies to the Orient], (=
KrsiCsomaKisknyvtr,11),(Budapest,1983),pp.110135.
ISBN9789460184833
279
Thallczy, Lajos, Csmri Zay Ferenc, 15051570 [Ferenc Zay of Csmr, 15051570] (Budapest,
1885).
Tzamalikos,Panagits,Origen:PhilosophyofHistory&Eschatology(Leiden,2007).
Verancsics,Antal,sszesmunki[CollectedWorks],eds.LszlSzalayandGusztvWenzel,12vols.
(PestBudapest,18571875).
Viskolcz, Nomi, Corvink Bcsben a 1618. szzadban. Grg szerzk latin fordtsai [Corvinas in
Vienna in the 16th18th Centuries. Latin Translations of Greek Authors], Magyar Knyvszemle 124
(2008),pp.272291.
Visser,Arnoud,FromtheRepublicofLetterstotheOlympus.TheRiseandFallofMedicalHumanism
in 67 Portraits, in Living in Posterity. Essays in Honour of Bart Westerweel, ed. Jan Frans van
Dijkhuizen,PaulHoftijzer,JulietteRodingandPaulSmith(Hilversum,2004),pp.299313.
Westbrook, Nigel, Dark, Kenneth Rainsbury, and Meeuwen, Rene van, Constructing Melchior
LorichssPanoramaofConstantinople,JournaloftheSocietyofArchitecturalHistorians,69/1(2010),
pp.6287.
Zay, Ferenc, Az Lndorfejrvr elveszsnek oka e vt, s gy estt [On the Cause and the
CircumstancesoftheFallofBelgrade/1522],eds.IstvnKovcs,FerencSzakly(Budapest,1980).
Zimmermann, T. C. Price, Paolo Giovio. The Historian and the Crisis of SixteenthCentury Italy
(Princeton,1995).

Illustrations
Fig.1ManuscriptLwenklau.PortraitsofTurkishEmperors,Courtiers,Soldiers,andTowns,paper,
185folios.Vienna,NB,8615,f.142r.
Fig.2MartinoRota:ThePortraitofAntoniusVerantius,1571,engravingandetching.Budapest,
HungarianNationalMuseum,HistoricalGallery,cat.4552.
Figs.35MelchiorLorck:ThePortraitsofAntoniusVerantius,FranciscusZayandAugerius
Busbequius,1557,woodcuts,tobereproducedinFischer,Bencard&Rasmussen,vol.5,cat.nos.
1556,2;1557,1and1557,2;
Figs.6,9MelchiorLorck:PanoramaofIstanbul,ByzantivmsiveCostantineopolis,1559,paper,pen
andink.Leiden,UniversityofLeiden,TheNetherlands,cat.BPL1758sheetsVI,XI.
Fig.7MelchiorLorck:SleymaniyeMosque,1570,woodcut.Copenhagen,DepartmentofPrintsand
Drawings,StatensMuseumforKunst,cat.KKSgb8249.
Fig.8ResGestaeDiviAugusti,Ankara,Turkey.
ISBN9789460184833
280
Fig.10JohannesLeunclavius,HistoriaeMusulmanaeTurcorum(FrankfurtamMain,1591).
Fig.11JohannesLichtenberger,Prognosticatio(Straburg,after31December1499),p.Diijr.

1
Glaubemir,esisteinweitgreresVergngen,eineerlitteneUngerechtigkeitdurchGromutzuvergelten,
alsSchulddurchSchuldzushnen.NimmdeineFreiheit,nimmKonstanzeundwerdedumenschlicheralsdein
Vater[]NichtsistsohlichwiedieRache(WolfgangAmadeusMozart,DieEntfhrungausdemSerail,K
384,librettoGottliebStephanienachChristophFriedrichBretzner,N21a;N21b).
2
Cairns2006,pp.6992.
3
Jellinek1994,pp.16364;SutterFichtner2008,pp.10007.
4
Dimmock2005,pp.542.
5
Barnes1988;MeyerSetton1992;Andermann2000;cs2000;Schmidt&Biggemann2004,pp.392408.
6
Delumeau1978,pp.34255.
7
Schlosser1908,pp.17,19;Jardine&Brotton2000,pp.1322;Brotton2005.
8
Candide,enretournantdanssamtairie,fitdeprofondesrflexionssurlediscoursduTurc;ilditPanglosset
Martin:Celionvieillardmeparaitstrefaitunsortbienprfrableceluidessixroisavecquinousavonseu
lhonneurdesouper.(Voltaire,Candide,chapter192).
9
Zimmermann1995,pp.121122;Kuntz1981,pp.97100;McCabe2008,pp.1536,5864.
10
Jacob1981.
11
ThetopicofthegoodandhonestTurk,whichappearsforinstanceinLessingsNathantheWise,MozartsIl
SeraglioandVoltairesCandide,hasaremarkableprehistory.Onthehistoricalandphilosophicalcontextofthe
anonymoustreatiseDetribusimpostoribus(1598)seeNiewhner1988;Assman1997,pp.93,157,238,240,
249.
12
Schmidt&Biggemann2004,pp.33968.
13
Tzamalikos2007,p.320.
14
Panofsky1960,pp.1821.
15
Coles1968,pp.14558;MacLean2005,pp.128.
16
Faroqhi2007,pp.80100;goston2007.
17
Dimmock2005,pp.2025.
18
Miller1808;Verancsics18571875,vols.34;Busbequius1605;Busbecq1881;Tardy1983,pp.11020.
19
DAyala1867;Papo2009,Papo&Nmeth2009.
20
Centorio1566.
21
MalvecziusoratorTurcicusincarceratur:Busbequius1605,pp.89.
22
Thallczy1885,pp.76106.
23
Tardy1983,pp.1217;Dernschwam1984.
24
Srs1898;Gyulai2011.
25
Bartoniek1975,pp.3556.
26
Verancsics18571875,vols.612.
27
Verancsics18571875,vol.1.,cf.Bartoniek1975,pp.3739.
28
Thallczy1885,p.83.
29
cs2011,p.11.
30
Zay1980.
31
Thallczy1885,p.7275.
32
Babinger1923,cf.Hberlein2012.
33
Berlsz1984.
34
OnthediscoveryandfateofthesixthcenturyilluminatedmanuscriptcalledViennaDioskoridesseeVisser
2004.
35
Dernschwam1984,p.51.
36
TardyMoskovszky1973,pp.39094;Tardy1983,pp.12835.
37
Busbequius1605;Busbecq1881;Martels1994.
38
FischerBencardRasmussen2009,vol.1,pp.pp. 66138 (biography), pp. 87106 (Turkish sojourn).
ISBN9789460184833
281
39
Mik 2008, pp. 2627; Fischer, Bencard & Rasmussen, vol. 5. (forthcoming), cat. nos. 1556,2; 1557, 1 and
1557,2;Gyulai2011,pp.12930.
40
Rogerson2005.
41
Iuliano,p.56;Westbrook,Dark&Meeuwen2010,pp.7576.
42
Fischer,Bencard&Rasmussen2009,vol.1,p.108.Thisselfdesignationisusedforthefirsttimeonhis
engravedportraitofsultanSleymanpublishedin1562.Ibidem,vol.5(forthcoming),cat.no.1562,1.
43
The Suleimanyeh, or mosque of Solyman, is the most glorious masterpiece of Ottoman architecture. It is
builtafterthepatternofSt.Sophia,andwasintendedtosurpassit.Asregardstheregularityoftheplan,the
perfection of the individual parts, and the harmony of the whole, that intention appears to have been fully
attained.Itwasbegunin1550andfinishedin1555.Noteoftheeditors:Busbecq1881,p.410.
44
Busbequius1605,pp.28990.
45
TardyMoskovszky1973;Tardy1983,pp.12835;Martels1991.
46
Busbequius1605,p.62;Busbecq1881,p.14243.
47
Mommsen1883;Cooley2009;cf.Dark1977,pp.3445.
48
JardineBrotton2000,pp.2347.
49
Viskolcz2008.
50
Molino2005;Molino2011.
51
cs2011.
52
Cf.Louthan2005,pp.7579.
53
Molino2005,pp.284298;Sebk2007,pp.302332;Maurer2011.
54
Bredekamp1995,pp.3036.
55
Leu,Keller&Weidmann2008;Molino2012.
56
cs2011.
57
Leunclavius1591,p.15.
58
MeyerSetton1992;Green2011.
59
Biondo2005.
60
Ball1975,1554.
61
Lichtenberger1499,p.Diijr;Kurtze1986.
62
cs2005.
ISBN9789460184833
282
TheMoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcs
SleymanandCharlesV:IconographicDiscourse,EnhancementofPower
andMagnificence,orTwoFacesoftheSameCoin?1
AnnickBorn

Introduction
Incourtculture,setsoftapestrieswereoftencommissionedtocelebratethegloryofprinces,kings
ortheEmperor,withiconographicprogrammesemphasizingthesepersonagesbraveryorillustrious
provenance. The political use of tapestries as visual paraphernalia (or artefacts) of monarchal and
imperialstatusdesignedtobedisplayedduringpubliceventssuchasprocessions,coronationsand
receptions of foreign ambassadors is well established today. In the context of the longstanding
conflict between the Ottoman Empire and Emperor Charles V (r. 15191556), the series of the
Moeurs et fachons de faire de Turcz, intended as tapestry designs, made after drawings by Pieter
CoeckevanAelst(Aelst,1502Brussels,1550)isofgreatinterest.2

The iconographic programme cannot be grasped without an indepth understanding of
Ottoman history bound by ideology rather than race,3 and without a reassessment of the reign of
Sleyman the Magnificent (15201566),4 particularly with regard to the political, economic and
cultural exchanges with the West and to court ritual and rivalry. In this respect, the 1989 study of
GlruNecipoluhashighlightedthemimeticdiscoursebetweenSleymanandCharlesV,focusingon
the symbolic meaning of the regalia as a visual representation of sovereign insignia supporting a
clever mise en scne of political powerlust.5 Elaborating further on the topos of a selffashioning
compelling image of imperial power, Lisa Jardine and Jerry Brotton shed light on the permeable
natureofthepoliticalandartisticboundariesbetweentheOttomanempireandChristendomonthe
basisofareevaluationoftheculturalproductionoftheRenaissancewithparticularattentiontothe
politicalideologicaluseoftapestriesasacommoncourtlanguagethatprevailedalloverEurope.6For
these authors, the journey to Constantinople was not simply an unprincipled attempt to sell
sumptuousbuticonographicallyincomprehensivetapestriestotheOttomancourt[]itshowedan
astute understanding of the shared imperial and iconographic preoccupations of the courts []
skilfully [] manipulated by a firm, and designer, situated at the nexus of the European tapestry
industry.7

The present study aims to review critically the documentary value of these prints as
primarysources,thecircumstancesofCoeckesjourneytoConstantinople,andfinallytheartisticand
culturalcontextinwhichthischorographicfriezewascreated.
ISBN9789460184833
283
TheMoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcs
Several copies of the original edition of the Moeurs et fachons de faire de Turcz are conserved in
publiccollections(fig.1).Mostly,onlythesevenwoodcutswithpanoramicscenesdividedfromone
anotherbyterms8withalternatemaleandfemalefiguresinTurkishcostumesarepreserved.9When
assembled,thesevencompositionsformafriezeframedbyanentablatureandabase,withatitle
pageandacolophon,likethesetintheBritishMuseum.10Theworkwasintendedtobepresented
togetherintheformofascrollorperhapsasamuraldecoration.11

Fig.1PieterCoeckevanAelst,LesmoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcz...,FeastoftheCircumcisionoutsideof
Constantinople,Antwerp(?),1553,London,BritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings.

The title page and the colophon (fig. 23) with elaborate strapwork and scrollworklike
design,inthestyleofCornelisBos(sHertogenbosch,before1515Groningen,1555)12andCornelis
IIFlorisdeVriendt(Antwerp,15141575),providethedataaboutthisset,mentioningexplicitlythat
thesceneswereauvifcontrefaictezparPierreCoeckdAlost,luyestantenTurquie,lAndeIesuchrist
M.D. 33 and that the woodcuts were published posthumously, three years after the death of the
artist,byhiswidow,MaykenVerhulst(Malines,1518after1593/1596).
ISBN9789460184833
284
Fig.23PieterCoeckevanAelst,LesmoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcz...,titlepageandcolophonAntwerp(?),1553,
London,BritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings.

The same year she published in de coopstadt van Antwerpen the Dutch translation of
SebastianoSerliosBooksI,IIandVonArchitecturethatopenwithsimilartitlepagesdecoratedwith
strapwork(fig.4).13TheplacewheretheMoeurswoodcutswereprintedisnotmentioned,butitis
verylikelythatitwasAntwerp.
ISBN9789460184833
285

Fig.4DeneerstenboeckvanarchitecturenSebastianiSerlij.../overgesedtuitenItaliaenischeinnederlandts,duerPeeter
CoekevanAelst...GedructindevermaerdecoopstadtvanAntuerpen:...duerMaykenVerhulstvveduwedesseluenPeeters
voers,1553,Ghent,UniversiteitsbibliotheekGent.

Mayken Verhulst, mentioned by Guicchardini among the female painters, was well
acquaintedwiththeAntwerphumanistandprintermilieu,firstandforemostwiththebookprinter
Gillis Coppens van Diest (?, c. 1496 Antwerp, 1572), who printed for Coecke several of his
translationsofbooksonarchitecturebySerlio,butalsothefamousaccountoftheJoyousEntryof
PhilipIIinAntwerpwrittenin1549byCorneliusGrapheus,citysecretary,withwoodcutillustrations
oftheephemeraldecorationsafterdesignsbyCoecke.14MaykenVerhulst,asmotherinlawofPieter
Bruegel the Elder (Breda (?) c. 1525 Brussels, 1569), also maintained close ties with Hieronymus
Cock(Antwerp,15181570),founderin1548oftheprintinghouseAuxQuatreVentsortheHouse
of the Four Winds.15 Moreover, from 1548 on, Cock published series of prints with cartouches
framed by interlaced bands and scrollwork with grotesque figures, garlands and trophies after
designsbythearchitectandsculptorCornelisFloris.16Although noconclusion canbe drawnabout
theauthorofthetitlepageandthecolophonoftheMoeurs,itismorethanlikelythatFlorisknew
personallyCoeckeandhisentourage.17
TheLondonseriesmountedoncanvasshowsclearlythatthearchitecturalframewasprinted
fromseparatewoodblocksrepeatingthesamemotif,whereasthecommentaryinvernacularFrench
ISBN9789460184833
286
alongthebottomunderneatheachscenewasmostprobablyimpressedwithblockletters.Contrary
towhatisfoundintheliterature,thefriezepreservedintheBrusselsRoyalLibrarywasassembledin
thenineteenthcenturypriortoitsentrancein the collection,theentablatureandbasebeinglater
additionsbasedontheLondonsetorevenafterthefacsimileeditionofSirStirlingMaxwell.18
Thematerialdescriptionraisesquestionsconcerningthegenesisofthewoodcutseries.Does
thewholecompositionwithanarchitecturalborderalongthetopandthebottomreflectfaithfully
the original project of Coecke, even though modelli for tapestries usually did not include borders?
Thiscouldalsoexplaintheblankspaceoftheborders.Nevertheless,thetitlepagementionsthatthe
artistdrew thedesignontheblockslater:Lequel aussydesa mainpropre apourtraict cesfigures
duysantes limpression dycelles. This would suggest that he was only responsible for the
preparatorydrawings,thoughthewellbalancedratiobetweentheheightofthecompartmentsand
theentablatureandbasetestifiestotheartistspersonalknowledgeoftheprinciplesofarchitecture.
Finally,theFrenchtextisproblematicasfarasitsauthorisconcerned.Isitanaccuraterecordofthe
notes made by Pieter Coecke on the original drawings? Or are we dealing with posthumous
commentarieswrittendownbyhiswidow?19Similarly,textsinCastilianintheupperborderandLatin
in the lower describe the events illustrated in the Conquest of Tunis designed by Jan Cornelisz
Vermeyen(Beverwijck,c.1500Brussels,1559)after1546andwovenintheBrusselsworkshopof
WillemdePannemakerbetween1549and1554aftercartoonsproducedincollaborationwithPieter
Coecke.20

CoeckejourneytoConstantinople:apoliticocommercialenterprise?
AlthoughtheexactcircumstancesofCoeckestraveltoConstantinopleremainuncertain,allwritten
sourcessituateitwithinthecontextoftheAntwerpBrusselstapestry.InhislifeofPieterCoeckeof
1604,KarelVanManderreportsinmuchdetailonthevoyagetoTurkey:
[]He[i.e.Coecke]wasurgedonbysometradesmen,tapestrymakersfromBrusselscalled
Van der Moeyen, to travel to Constantinople in Turkey where they were planning to
undertake something special by making beautiful, costly tapestries for the Great Turk, and
theygotPietertopaintsomethingsforthatpurposetoshowtheTurkishEmperor;butsince
theTurk,accordingtohisMohammedanLaw,didnotwantfiguresofpeopleoranimals,it
was fruitless and nothing came of itexcept that a useless journey and high expenses
incurred.21
AnotherimportantaccountisbyAndrFlibien,whoreportedin1666that[]hewentto
Turkey,fromwherehebroughtthesecretofbeautifuldyesofsilkandwool[].22
Somearchivalsourceshavebeenconnectedtotheseliteraryones.On15 June1533,Jacob
Rehlinger,merchantfromAugsburgandhisAntwerpassociatePietervanderWalle,trader,jeweller
andmerchantofluxurygoods,signedacontractwithWillemDermoyenforanoptiononreediting
thesetoftheHuntsofMaximilianandoftheBattleofPaviaseries.Rehlingerdeclaredthathehad
receivedatapestryofeachsetassamplestosendoffabroad.FortheHunts,theexamplewasthe
MonthofSeptember,thoughthedocumentdoesnotspecifywhichonewasselectedfromtheother
ISBN9789460184833
287
series.RehlingerandhisassociatecommittedthemselvestoinformingDermoyen,beforetheendof
yearoratlastinDecember1533,whethertheywouldacquirethefirst,thesecond,orbothseries.
The document provides other valuable data concerning the transaction that are also found in
another contract concluded at the request of Marco Casarli by a notary in Venice on 18 Augustus
1533, between Jacob Rehlinger and the Venetian jeweller Marco di Niccol. This second source,
dated two months later than the first contract, mentions explicitly that the samples of tapestries
weretobeofferedforsaletoSleymanbytheirVenetianpartnerMarcodiNiccol.23Thedelayofa
maximumoffourmonthsbetweenthesigningofthesecondcontractandthecommitmentvisvis
Dermoyen concerning the commercial issue of this enterprise is very short, which allows us to
conclude that this trading network operated efficiently. The average time for couriers to travel
betweenVeniceandConstantinoplewasfortysixdays,withaminimumoffifteenandamaximumof
eightyonedays.24Similarly,aVenetiantravellerundertookthejourneytoConstantinopleinJanuary
1534 and arrived sixtyseven days later; a month to six weeks seems to have been the usual time
span.25
Untilnow,noarchivaldocumentmentioningthenameofCoeckecanbeconnectedtothis
attempttopenetratetheLevantinemarket.Nevertheless,itisverylikelythattheartistcouldhave
beeninvolvedinonewayoranother.Indeed,businesstieslinkedCoecketotheAntwerpmerchant
PetervanderWalle,whosoldasetoftheSevenDeadlySinstoMaryofHungaryin1544.According
to Thomas Campbell, maistre pierre van aelst paintre danvers, as he is cited in a contemporary
manuscript describing the iconography of the designs prepared for the Brussels weaver Willem de
Pannemaker,26mayhavedesignedthisseriesjustbeforeheleftforTurkey.Campbellalsosuggests
that Van der Walle commissioned the cartoons as a speculative venture.27 Coecke, as a pupil of
Bernard van Orley (Brussels, c. 1491/92 1541), was also very familiar with the Brussels circle of
tapestry designers and weavers and maintained close connections with it during his entire career.
Moreover, the name of Coecke has been associated with the cartoons for three series woven in
Brusselsduringthe1520s:theLifeofChrist,theBattleofPaviaandtheHuntsofMaximilian(fig.7),
the last two sets being attributed to Van Orley and assistants.28 Although it is still a matter of
conjecture, Coeckes collaboration on the design of the Hunts was already mentioned by Andr
Flibienin1666,andthiswasthefirsttimethathewasdirectlyassociatedwithasetoftapestriesin
awrittensource,which thusprovidesadirectlinkbetweenCoeckeandDermoyen.29Finally,Jacob
Rehlinger,oneofCharlesVsimportantfinanciersandfactorfortheFuggerCompanyinAntwerpin
152021andagainin153840,translatedSerliosBookIVonarchitecture,whichhadbeenpublished
in1542byCoecke,intoGerman.
Whileacommercialpurposeofthiswholeenterprisecannotbedenied,itisalsolikelythatit
wasapretexttosendspiestotheOttomanCourt.AsrecordedinvariousletterskeptintheImperial
archives,theRomanEmperorendeavouredtokeephimselfinformedonadailybasisaboutwhatwas
happeninginTurkey,especiallyasof1529.Toachievethis,heestablishedadiversifiednetworkof
informants that was parallel or complementary to the one created by his brother Ferdinand.
AmongsttheseinformantswasMarcodiNiccol,doubleagentforbothCharlesVandSleymanthe
Magnificent,whowasdecapitatedinMars1536inConstantinople.30
AfteryearsofhostilitiesattheeasternbordersoftheHabsburgempire,theconstantthreats
to Vienna, and at last the alliance of Francis I with Sleyman, Charles V delegated the Fleming
ISBN9789460184833
288
Cornelis de Schepper to negotiate an agreement concerning Hungary. He entered into pourparlers
withtheGrandVizierIbrahimPashabetweenMayandJuly1533andconcludedatruceallowingfree
trade between the Holy German Empire and the Ottoman Empire.31 De Schepper went back to
BrusselsandthenjoinedtheRomanEmperorinMonzn(Aragon);bytheendofDecember1533he
had returned to Constantinople via Venice and Ragusa (today Dubrovnik), where his presence is
attested on 26 April 1534. In a letter dated 2 June 1534 and addressed to a certain Monsieur de
Malines, an encoded name for Charles V, references are made to the tapestries sent to
Constantinople:
Last,IwrotetoyouhowIarrivedatthatplace,andwhatIthoughtcouldbesaidtoPierre
VandeWalleconcerningthetapestriesandothergoods.Sincethenthemerchantshavehad
muchtosuffer,andareoppressedincreasinglyfromdaytoday,tosuchanextentthatIdont
advisethemtocomeanymore,andIthinktheywillfollowmyadvice.Otherwayshavetobe
foundtoselloffthesaidmerchandise.32
Regardingtheintensepoliticalexchangeandtheflowofinformationthatcirculatedatthat
time, itisimpossibletocreditVanMandersassertionthatthetriptoConstantinopleledtonothing
because of Islamic law, first and foremost because human representations are indeed found in
contemporaryminiaturesbutalsobecausesetsoftapestrieswerealreadysenttoConstantinoplein
thelatefourteenthcentury.34ItcouldevenbearguedthattheGrandVizierIbrahimPashawaseager
tocompetewiththelustreoftheWesterncourts,asattestedbythetiaracommissionedinVenice
anddeliveredin1532;theluxurygoodsconsistedmostlyofjewelleryandcuriosities.Afterhisdeath
in1536hissuccessorsavoidedconspicuousconsumptionattheOttomancourt.35Thepoliticalevents
themselvesnecessitatedaradicalbreakwiththediplomacyofreconciliation.Beforetheendof1533
Sleyman summoned the pirate leader Barbarossafrom Algiers to the court in Constantinople and
orderedhimtoreorganizetheOttomanfleetintheMediterranean.DeSchepperleftConstantinople
on13,June1534forVienna,viaBelgrade(30June),Pressburg(todayBratislava,15 July),andPrague
(30July).
33
With the exception of the date of 1533 on the frontpage of the woodcut series and Van
Manders statement that Pieter Coecke was there for about a year, no accurate information with
respecttohistripisknown,36neitherthedatesofhisdeparturefromAntwerpandConstantinople,
norhisitineraryfortheoutwardorthereturnjourney.Manyscenariosareplausible.Theartistcould
havebeenamemberoftheentourageofDeSchepperwhoarrivedintheOttomancityinMay1533
or, as a representative of the Dermoyen firm, he may have left Venice soon after the 18 Augustus
1533,thedateofthesecondcontract,withthesamplesoftapestriesandcouldhaveaccompanied
DeSchepperonhisreturn,butthisispurespeculation.37Onlythedrawingsthatthepainterbrought
from his journey, which are considered as the first reliable and illustrated reportage on Turkish
civilizationwithviewsoflandscapesandcityscapesfromlife,andthecommentariesthatlocatedthe
scenesallowapartialreconstructionofthecountrieshevisited.

ISBN9789460184833
289
Thesevenpanoramicscenesauvifcontrefaictez
AccordingtoVanMander,thislongfriezeshouldbereadfromrighttoleft,startingwithSleyman
ridingthroughtheruinsoftheHippodrome(fig.6),sothattheSultanandthecavalcadearelooking
left from the epitomized centre of the Ottoman Empire to his widely spread territories with the
representationofAnEncampmentinSlavonia(fig.5)atthebordersoftheHabsburgempireensuring
thateventhemostrecentlyconqueredterritoriesareincluded.Aftertheinvasionofthekingdomof
HungaryandthedefeatatthebattleofMohcs,from1529until1552theOttomanarmygradually
conquered the eastern part of Slavonia, one of the three core regions of the medieval kingdom of
Croatia. This scene reflects everyday life in a camp and the difficult conditions encountered by
travellers in the mountains, especially during winter. At the time, caravanserais were not yet built
alongthewholeImperialroadbetweenConstantinopleandBelgrade,viaSofiaandEdirne.Cornelius
deSchepper,onthewaybackfromConstantinopleinJuly1533,relatedthat,afterEdirne,theyput
uppavilionsandtentsinordertosleepinthecountryside.

Fig.5PieterCoeckevanAelst,LesmoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcz...,EncampmentinSlavonia,Antwerp(?),1553,
London,BritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings.

The commentaries are a mine of information for viewers unfamiliar with the Turkish
civilization and Muslim traditions. The detailed description of each scene interacts with the visual
depictionanddrawsattentiontoparticularsituations,customsandbeliefsthatareconfirmedamply
byothersources,notonlythelettersandtraveldiaryofCorneliusdeSchepperalreadymentioned,
but also the accounts of other ambassadors, the most famous being the Turkish Letters of Ogier
GhislendeBusbecq,whowasappointedbyFerdinandbetween1554and1562asambassadortothe
ISBN9789460184833
290
courtinConstantinopletonegotiate,interalia,thedisputedterritoryofTransylvania(whichmoreor
lesscorrespondstopresentdayRomania).38
Theiconographyofthewholesetatteststoahighsenseofobservationandathorough
understandingofOttomansociety,emphasizingthediversityofcultureintheextensivelandsaround
theeasternMediterraneanandtheBalkansunderOttomancontrol.Everythingisdepictedwitha
greatrespectforforeignersandanonChristiancivilization,whichitevenglorifies.39Itistemptingto
followFriedlndersassumptionandtoconsiderthewoodcutsasbeingbasedonthemodelli40
intendedtobesubmittedtoSleymansapprovalbeforetapestrieswerecommissioned.Necipolu
suggestedthatthedecisiontoshowtapestrieswithproHabsburgsubjectswasprobablymeantto
incitetheSultantoordersimilartapestriesforOttomanpropaganda.41However,afterthetruce
negotiatedbyCorneliusdeSchepper,thesendingoftheMonthofSeptemberwasprobablynot
insignificant,giventhatitfeaturedahorsemanseenfromthebackwhoseprofileandbeardlessface
recallthatofFerdinandintheMonthofDecember.42Indeed,thefigureofariderperfectlycontrolling
hishorse,inthiscasethekingofBohemiaandHungary,couldbeconsidered,inlightoftherecent
politicalevents,asamessagedeliveredfortheattentionoftheSultan.Evenifthesehypotheses
cannotbeignored,especiallyinthecontextofcourtculture,thesamplesprobablyalsohadanother
functionaswell,namely,toshowwithconcreteexamplestherefinementofexecutionandthehigh
qualityofthematerialusedinthetapestrieswovenbytheBrusselsfirmofDermoyen.
The very similarity that the generic iconographic programme of the woodcut frieze shares
withtheHuntsofMaximilianisstriking.Thesamerhetoricprevails:intheHunts,thedepictionofthe
leisureoftheEmperorandothernoblemenisthepretexttorepresentthecentreofHabsburgpower
in the Low Countries during the reign of Charles V on the first tapestry of the set, the Month of
March.ThecityscapeoffersauniqueviewofBrusselswiththeoldCoudenbergpalaceontheleft,the
tower of the town hall as a symbol of the civic authorities and the church of St Nicholas in the
middle, and finally the church of Sts Michel and Gudule on the right. Both tapestries feature
representations of places and buildings directly associated with the Emperor and court ritual and
practices,forexample,theSoignesforest,thecastleofTervueren,orthePlacedesBaillescreatedby
theEmperorinfrontoftheCoudenbergpalace.
In the Moeurs et Fachons de Faire des Turcs, the ethnographic reportage made by Coecke
was also a way to visualize for the others the vast territories of the Ottoman Empire. As for the
Hunts,thefirstscenepresentstheruler,thePadisharidingthroughtheruinsoftheHippodromein
Constantinople,theheartoftheOttomanEmpire,formerlycapitaloftheEasternRomanEmpire,and
astrategicplacefortradewithAsiaandAfrica.SincethefallofthecityinMay1453,thereconquest
ofoldByzantiumconstitutedaleitmotivatWesterncourts,reflectingitshighsymbolicsignificance
forChristendom.
As a court painter familiar with the imperial propaganda programme, Coecke intentionally
chosetosituatethesceneontheHippodrome,whichwasfilledwithstatuesofgods,emperorsand
heroesaswellaswithlootedtrophiessuchasthreesculpturesofantiquegodsandnudegoddesses
placedonacolumn(HerculesandVenusorDianaandApollo?)thathadtakenfromtheroyalcastle
at Ofen in Hungary in 1526 and destroyed in 1536 after Ibrahim Pasha fell into disgrace. Pieter
CoeckeandCorneliusdeSchepperweretheonlyonestorecordhavingseenthesesculptures.43This
almost topographic view of the site with the cityscape of the imperial capital shows many of the
ISBN9789460184833
291
monuments visible at that time, not only those of the Ottoman civilization but also ones from the
Byzantineperiodandfromantiquity.44
The similarity in mise en scne with the Month of March is obvious, with its strong
relationshipbetweentherulerandthecity.Easilyidentifiableurbanlandscapesareusedasmarkers
of sovereignty and power, at the same time delivering a strong political message, namely, the
recognitionofSleymantheMagnificentasthelegitimateruleroftheformerEasternRomanEmpire.
Both emperors are portrayed on horseback, a strong reference to the antique Roman code of
representation that enhanced the legitimacy of their title. Moreover, both were the temporal
representativesoftheirrespectivereligiousworld,CharlesVbeingheadoftheHolyRomanEmpire
and the sultan likewise being a ruler with moral and religious authority. Even if not explicitly
expressed, the representation of Charles V and Sleyman also emphasizes a semiotic analogy
betweentheimageoftheroyalportraitandGod.
Fig.6PieterCoeckevanAelst,LesmoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcz...,Sleymanridingthroughtheruinsofthe
Hippodrome,Antwerp(?),1553,London,BritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings.
ISBN9789460184833
292

Fig.7BernardvanOrley(afterdesignsbyca.152831),DeparturefortheHunt(MonthofMarch)fromatwelvepieceset
oftheHuntsofMaximilian,Brussels,Dermoyenworkshop,153133,Paris,MuseduLouvre.
Pieter Coecke, who was well aware of the discourse delivered in tapestries intended for
largescale public display at the Habsburg court, translated it quite literally in a set considered to
have been designed originally for Sleyman. As mentioned before, this attempt to penetrate the
Levantine market led to nothing, with the exception of the record that still survives in this
chorographicwoodcutfrieze.45
TwodecadeselapsedbetweentheprintingoftheMoeursandthejourneytoConstantinople.
Wecanlegitimatelyaskwhattheoriginalplanwas,andevenifmodelliwereeversubmittedtothe
Sultanorhisentourage.ThatPieterCoeckewasaprivilegedobserveroftheOttomancivilizationin
allitsdiversityofculture,mannersandcustomsisamplydemonstratedbyscenessuchastheTurkish
funeralandtheFeastoftheCircumcisionoutsideofConstantinople(fig.1),eventhoughnooriginal
drawingfromlifesurvives.
In1553(ormaybe1554ifwetakeintoaccounttheEasterCalendar,astheprecisedateof
theeditionoftheMoeursisnotgiven),thetapestrysetoftheConquestofTuniswasalreadywoven
oratleastalmostcompleted.ItwasdisplayedforthefirsttimeattheweddingofPhilipIIofSpain
andPortugalandtheEnglishqueenMaryTudoron7July1554inWinchesterCathedralandagainin
January 1555 at the church of NotreDame in Antwerp for a meeting of the Order of the Golden
Fleece.46ItistemptingtohypothesizethatatthattimeMaykenVerhulstsawauniqueopportunityto
printthetraveloguemadetwentyyearsearlierbyherhusband.BeforeCoeckesprematuredeath,an
eventthatwascloselyassociatedwiththerealizationofthecartoonsoftheTunistapestriesseries,47
itisobviousthathereworkedthedrawingstakenfromlifeduringhistripandsojourn.Butforwhat
purposedidhedoso?Theunusualoblongformatofthescenesseparatedbyterms,theentablature
andthebasedoesindeedsuggestthattheserieswaswelldesignedasmodelsfortapestriesandwas
only later on turned into printing blocks.48 Several elements point in that direction. First and
ISBN9789460184833
293
foremost, the style is much more compatible with Pieter Coeckes late works, such as the Lisbon
triptych, but one also notices the same creative spirit that prevails in the Tunis tapestries, even if
theiriconographydivergesdrastically.Thecompositionsexhibitsimilaritiesinlayout,withtheaction
beingconcentratedmainlyintheforegroundtoleaveamaximumofspaceforthedevelopmentof
thepanoramicviews.ThepresenceofthepainterinthelastscenedressedinaSloveniancostume,
which affirmed that he was there, just as Jan Vermeyen portrayed himself twice in the Tunis
tapestriesinordertocertifyhispresenceduringtheEmperorscampaignin1535,atteststoakindof
mutual emulation between the two court painters. Moreover, the text in the tablet of the first
tapestryoftheTunisseries,TheMapoftheMediterraneanBasin,displaysthesamerhetoricasthe
titlepageoftheMoeurs.IttestifiesthatVermeyenreportedtheactionaccordingtonaturebutalso
that the project was represented with geographical accuracy.49 Again, a similar willingness to
convince the viewer that what he was seeing had been depicted with all possible topographical
rigourisfoundintheFrenchcommentaryonTheFeastoftheCircumcisionoutsideofConstantinople
(fig.1),inwhichitisexplicitlystatedthatthe cityscapeisatruerepresentationofthecityoutside
madeafternature:LavrayeassieteouqualitedelaVilledeConstantinopleparledehorscontrefaict
apreslenaturel.50
More than fifty years before Van Mander introduced the notion of naer het leven into
Dutch art theory, the term of au vif contrefaictez had already appeared in the title page of the
chorographicfriezeoftheMoeursetFachonsdefairedeTurcz,andthesameideaprevailedaswell
in the introductory text of the Tunis series. Both ensembles started as independent records of
topographical views and events with ethnographic interest and were only later transformed into
worksofart.51
From1540,Antwerpbecameamajorcentrefortheprintingofaccountsandtraveloguesof
the Levant. At that time the Europeans were better informed about what was happening in the
OttomanEmpirethananywhereelseintheworld.52In1544,GillisCoppensvanDiestpublishedthe
accounts of Bartolomej Georgijevi, a Hungarian captured by the Turks who returned to the West
after thirteen years in slavery, and the same year Gregorius Bontius printed a book by the same
authors on the origins of the Turks and various aspects of their social life.53 As Cecilia Paredes has
pertinently noted, although the Moeurs innovate in terms of iconography, the set is still part of a
figurative and literary tradition. It assumes the literal transposition into image as much as it
representsandillustratesthevoyageofCoeckeinTurkey.54

Conclusion
Becauseofthewholeculturalandartisticcontextinwhichfirstthedrawingswerereelaboratedand
thenthewoodcutfriezecreated,itseemsdifficulttoconsiderthisseriesasanillustrativeexampleof
the mimetic discourse in a selffashioning image of imperial powerlust between Charles V and
Sleyman.Ifitwasnot,thenwhowasbehindtheinitiative?
More than ten years elapsed before Mary of Hungary commissioned Vermeyen to execute
the Conquest of Tunis to celebrate the victory of the Emperor. However, the repercussions of this
ISBN9789460184833
294
military success were of limited scope, since the Ottoman fleet quickly regained control of the
EasternMediterranean.
The Moeurs, which can be considered as an ethnographic reportage or an illustrated
travelogue,alsocontainsapowerfulpoliticalmessage,asisshownbythecomparisonwiththeHunts
ofMaximilian,atypicalexampleofHabsburgpropagandisticdiscourse.ByshowingSultanSleyman
as the Magnificent, the victory of the Holy Roman Emperor at the Battle of Tunis was made even
moreglorious.
Fig.8PieterCoeckevanAelst,LesmoeursetfachonsdefairedeTurcz...,detailofSleymanridingthroughtheruinsofthe
Hippodrome,Antwerp(?),1553,London,BritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings.

Bibliography

Atasoy, Nurhan and Ulu, Lle, Impressions of Ottoman Culture in Europe: 14531699 (Istanbul,
2012).

Balis, Arnaud, De Jonge, Krista, Delmarcel, Guy and Lefbure, Amaury, Les Chasses de Maximilien
(Paris,1993).

BacquGrammont, JeanLouis, Lapoge de lempire ottoman: les vnements (15121606), in
Histoiredelempireottoman,ed.RobertMantran(Paris,1989),pp.13959.
ISBN9789460184833
295

Bauer,RotraudwithcontributionsofSteppe,JanK.,TapisserienderRenaissancenachEntwrfenvon
PieterCoeckevanAelst(Eisenstadt,1981).

Bisaha,Nancy,CreatingEastandWest:RenaissanceHumanistsandtheOttomanTurks(Philadelphia,
2004).

Boorsch,SuzanneandOrenstein,NadineM.,ThePrintintheNorth.TheAgeofAlbrechtDrerand
LucasvanLeyden,TheMetropolitanMuseumofArtBulletin,54,4(1997),pp.5051.

Born, Annick, Pieter Coecke van Aelst and the roads leading to Rome in Culture figurative a
confronto tra Fiandre e Italia dal XV al XVII secolo. Atti del convegno internazionale Nord/Sud.
RicezionifiamminghealdiquadelleAlpi.Prospettivedistudioeindaginitecniche(Padova,Universit
degliStudi,2527ottobre2007),eds.AnnaDeFlorianiandMariaCleliaGalassi(Milan,2008),pp.94
105.

Brotton,Jerry,TheRenaissanceBazaar(Oxford,2002).

Campbell,Thomas,TapestryintheRenaissance.ArtandMagnificence(NewYork,2002).

DeJonge,Krista,Anvers:lespremirestraductionsdutraitdarchitecturedeSerlio,inSebastiano
Serlio Lyon. Architecture et imprimerie, vol. I., Le trait darchitecture de Sebastiano Serlio. Une
grandeentrepriseditorialeauXVIesicle,ed.SylvieDeswarteRosa(Lyons,2004),pp.26283.

DeSaintGenois,JulesandYsseldeSchepper,Gerhard,MissionsdiplomatiquesdeCorneilleDuplicius
DeSchepper,ditScepperus,ambassadeurdeChristiernII,deCharlesV,deFerdinandIretdeMarie,
reinedeHongrie,gouvernantedesPaysBas,de15231555(Bruxelles,1856).

De la Fontaine Verwey, Herman, Pieter Coeck van Aelst and the publication of Serlios book on
architecture,Quaerendo,VI(1976),pp.166194.

Faroqhi,Suraiya,ApproachingOttomanHistory.AnIntroductiontotheSources(Cambridge,1999).

Flibien, Andr, Entretiens sur les Vies et sur les Ouvrages des plus excellens peintres anciens et
modernes.Nouvelleditionrevue,corrigeetaugmente(London,DavidMortier,1705);ed.princeps
(16661668).

Friedlnder,MaxJ.,PieterCoeckevanAlost,JahrbuchderKniglichPreussischenKunstsammlungen,
38,(1917),pp.7394.

Friedlnder, Max J., Early Netherlandish Painting. XII. Jan van Scorel and Pieter Coeck van Aelst
(Leiden&Brussels,1975).

Gachard,LouisP.andPiot,GuillaumeJ.(eds.),CollectiondesvoyagesdessouverainsdesPaysBas,4
vols.(Bruxelles,187482).

Hamilton, Alastair, Arab Culture and Ottoman Magnificence in Antwerps Golden Age (London &
Oxford,2001).

Horn, Hendrik, Jan Cornelisz Vermeyen Painter of Charles V and His Conquest of Tunis: paintings,
Etchings,Drawings,CartoonsandTapestries,2vols.(Doornspijk,1989).
ISBN9789460184833
296

7nalcik, Halil, The Ottoman State: Economy and Society, 13001600, in An Economic and Social
HistoryoftheOttomanEmpire,13001914,eds.Halil7nalcikandDonaldQuataert(Cambridge,1994),
pp.9409.

7nalcik, Halil, Mutual Political and Cultural Influences Between Europe and the Ottomans, in
OttomanCivilization,eds.Halil7nalcikandGnselRenda(Istanbul,2002),pp.10491089(reprinted
in7nalcik,Halil,TurkeyandEuropeinHistory(Istanbul,2008),pp.141194).

Jardine, Lisa and Brotton, Jerry, Global Interests: Renaissance Art Between East and West (London,
2000).

Kafadar,Cemal,BetweenTwoWorlds:TheConstructionoftheOttomanState(London,1995).

Kunt,MettinandWoodhead,Christine(eds.),SuleymantheMagnificentandHisAge:TheOttoman
EmpireintheEarlyModernWorld(London,1995).

Lewy, Mordechay, An Unknown View of Mt. Zion Monastery by the Flemish Old Master Pieter
CoeckevanAeslt(15021550)asEvidencetoHisPilgrimagetoJerusalem,JahrbuchderStaatlichen
KunstsammlungeninBadenWrttemberg,44(2007),pp.6174.

Mack, Rosamond E., Bazaar to Piazza. Islamic Trade and Italian Art, 13001600 (Berkeley, Los
Angeles,London,2002).

Marlier,Georges,LaRenaissanceflamande:PierreCoeckdAlost(Brussels,1966).

Necipolu, Glru, Sleyman the Magnificent and the Representation of Power in the Context of
OttomanHapsburgRivalry,ArtBulletin,71(1989),pp.40127.

Orenstein, Nadine, Processsion of Sleyman the Magnificent through the Hippodrome, in
Byzantium.FaithandPower(12611557),ed.HelenC.Evans(NewYork,2004),p.411cat.253.

Paredes, Cecilia, Du texte limage. Les tapisseries de la Conqute de Tunis et les gravures des
Moeurs et Fachons des Turcs, in LEmpire ottoman dans lEurope de la Renaissance/El Imperio
Otomano en la Europa renacentista. Ideas e imaginarios de intelectuales, diplomticos y opinin
pblicadelsigloXV,XVIyprincipiosdelsigloXVIIenlosantiguosPasesBajosyelMundoHispnico/
Idesetimaginairesdintellectuels,dediplomatesetdelopinionpubliquedanslesAnciensPaysBas
etleMondeHispaniqueauxXVe,XVIeetdbutduXVIIesicles,eds.AlainServantieandRamnPuig
delaBellacasa(Leuven,2005),pp.12350.

Parker,Geoffrey,LemondepolitiquedeCharlesQuint,inCharlesQuint15001558.LEmpereuret
sontemps,ed.HugoSoly(Antwerp,1999),pp.113225,51316.

Raby,Julian,Venice,DrerandtheOrientalMode(London,1982).

Schle,Sune,PieterCoeckeandCornelisBos,OudHolland,77,34(1962),pp.23543.

Schle,Sune,CornelisBos:astudyoftheoriginsoftheNetherlandgrotesque(Stockholm,1965).

SchneebalgPerelman, Sophie, Les Chasses de Maximilien. Les nigmes dun chefdoeuvre de la
Tapisserie(Brussels,1982).
ISBN9789460184833
297

Sellinck,Manfred,Bruegel.Luvrecomplet.Peintures,dessins,gravures(Bruges,2007).

Servantie, Alain, Linformation de Charles Quint sur les Turcs, ou les lments pour dcider de la
guerre ou de la paix: du rve de croisade aux ralits, in LEmpire ottoman dans lEurope de la
Renaissance/El Imperio Otomano en la Europa renacentista. Ideas e imaginarios de intelectuales,
diplomticosyopininpblicadelsigloXV,XVIyprincipiosdelsigloXVIIenlosantiguosPasesBajos
y el Mundo Hispnico/ Ides et imaginaires dintellectuels, de diplomates et de lopinion publique
danslesAnciensPaysBasetleMondeHispaniqueauxXVe,XVIeetdbutduXVIIesicles,eds.Alain
ServantieandRamnPuigdelaBellacasa(Leuven,2005),pp.24995.

Silver,Larry,TriumphsandTravesties.PrintedProcessionsoftheSixteenthCentury,inGrandScale:
MonumentalPrintsintheAgeofDurerandTitian,eds.LarrySilverandElizabethWyckoff(Wellesley,
MA:DavisMuseum,2008),pp.2341.

Silver, Larry, East is East: Images of the Turkish nemesis in the Habsburg world, in The Turk and
Islam in the Western Eye, 14501750. Visual Imagery before Orientalism, ed. James G. Harper
(Farnham,2011),pp.185215.

St.Clair,AlexandrineN.,TheImageoftheTurkinEurope(NewYork,1973).

Stirling Maxwell, William, The Turks in MDXXXIII. A Series of Drawings Made in that Year at
ConstantinoplebyPeterCoeckofAelstandPublishedfromWoodblocks,byhiswidow,atAntwerpin
MDLIII;reproducedwithotherillustrationsinfacsimile(London&Edinburgh,1873).

Van der Coelen, Peter, Cornelis BosWhere did he go? Some New Discoveries and Hypotheses
aboutaSixteenthcenturyEngraverandPublisher,Simiolus,23(1995),pp.11946.

VanderStock,Jan,PrintingImagesinAntwerp.TheIntroductionofPrintmakinginaCity:Fifteenth
Centuryto1585(Rotterdam,1998).

Van der Stock, Jan, Hieronymus Cock et Volcxken Diericx, diteurs de gravures Anvers, in Van
Grieken, Joris, Luijten, Ger and Van der Stock, Jan, Hieronymus Cock. La gravure la Renaissance
(Bruxelles,2013),pp.1421.

Van Grieken, Joris, In de vier winden/Aux quatre vents (15481600). De eerste Antwerpse
prentenuitgeverijopwereldschaal.Eenstandvanzaken,inDeRenaissanceprentkunstindeZuidelijk
Nederlanden/LagravuredelarenaissancedanslesPaysBasmridionaux,ed.GodelieveDenhaene
(Brussels,2010),pp.93120.

VanGrieken,Joris,Luijten,GerandVanderStock,Jan,HieronymusCock.LagravurelaRenaissance
(Bruxelles,2013).

VanGrieken,Joris,Ledveloppementetlexploitationdunfondsdditeur,inVan Grieken,Joris,
Luijten,GerandVanderStock,Jan,HieronymusCock.LagravurelaRenaissance(Bruxelles,2013),
pp.2229.

Van Mander, Karel, The Lives of the Illustrious Netherlandish and German Painters from the first
editionoftheSchilderboeck(16031604),ed.HesselMiedema,6vols.(Doornspijk,19941999).
ISBN9789460184833
298
VanMulder,Christine,Depretenreeksen,inHuysmans,Antoinette,VanDamme,Jan,VandeVelde
Carl and Van Mulders, Christine, Cornelis Floris 15141575. Beeldhouwer, architect, ontwerper
(Brussels,1996),pp.3669,14261,figs.11995.

Wittek,Paul,TheriseoftheOttomanempire:StudiesontheHistoryofTurkey,13th15thcenturies.Ed.
ColinHeywood(London,2001);firstpublishedbytheRoyalAsiaticSociety(London,1938).

Illustrations

Fig.13,56,8TheTrusteesoftheBritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings.

Fig.4Photoauthor.

Fig.7RMN,GrandPalais(MuseduLouvre),photobyDanielArnaudet.

My warmest thanks go to Krista De Jonge, Larry Silver, Hilmi Kaar, Nadine Orenstein, Cecilia Paredes and
Joris Van Grieken for our fruitful discussions on this topic and for providing me with useful references. I am
gratefultoMaximiliaanMartensforthereviewofmyEnglishtext.
2
OnPieterCoecke,stillworthreferringtoFriedlnder1917andFriedlander1975,pp.3239andonthisseries,
seeespeciallyStirlingMaxwell1873;Marlier1966,pp.5574.
3
ConstantinoplealonewasamultiethnicsocietywheretheTurkscohabitedwithnonMuslimethnicgroups,
mostly Jews, Greeks andArmenians. Thebibliography on the subject is very abundant, seeWittek 1938(ed.
2001);7nalcik1994;Kafadar1995.
4
Considered as the golden age of the Ottoman Empire, see BacquGrammont 1989; Kunt & Woodhead,
1995. On the politics of Charles V, see Parker 1999 and on the mutual influences between Europe and the
Ottomans,see7nalcik2002.
5
Necipolu1989.
6
Jardine&Brotton2000.Thisviewhasbeenchallenged.NancyBisaha2004notesthattheauthorsclaimto
cultural openness and respectful exchange relies on material goods and artwork, though she presents a
superficialtreatmentofwrittensources(esp.pp.6,19192n.13),whereasSilver2011emphasizesthatinthe
Holy Roman Empire the Turks were seen as a marker of difference, with the usual stereotype of exotic and
cruel warriors. Nevertheless, the importance of the EastWest luxury trade in decorative art is well
documented and attests to the European taste for exotic objects. Paintings provide evidence of the
disseminationofsuchconsumergoodsaswellasmodelsfortheemergenceofnewartefactsproducedlocally.
For Italy, see Mack 2002; Brotton 2002. For a broad overview of the import of textiles, tiles and ceramics,
carpets,armsandarmourinEasternandWesternEurope:Atasoy&Ulu2012.
7
Jardine&Brotton2000,p.120.
8
And not caryatids as often mentioned. Similarly, the title page of the second edition of Coeckes Dutch
translation of Sebastiano Serlios Book IV on Architecture (1549) is decorated with male and female terms
supportingapediment.AcopyispreservedinGhent,UniversiteitsbibliotheekGent,ACC.028738.
9
Like the set kept in Ghent, Universiteitsbibliotheek Gent, BHSL. RES. 1323/2 and in New York, The
Metropolitan Museum of Art, Harris Brisbane Dick Fund 1928, inv. 28.85.7a,b; Boorsch and Orenstein 1997;
Orenstein2004.
10
London,BritishMuseum,Department:Prints&Drawings,inv.E,6.17,455x4825mm(overall).
11
As suggested by Stirling Maxwell 1873 (p. 2) this may explain the destruction of the greater part of the
impression.Onprocessionfriezesandtheirorigin,functionanduse,seeSilver2008.
12
Asearlyas1962SchleconsideredacollaborationbetweenCornelisBosandPieterCoecke.In1542,Coecke
suppliedBoswiththreehundredcopiesofthe1539DutcheditionofSerliosBookIV,sixofthe1542German
editionand650ofDieinventivedercolommenpublishedinFebruary1539(n.s.1540).Schlespeculatedthat
Boswasinvolvedintheproductionofthebooksandthathewasresponsibleforthewoodcutillustrations.See
ISBN9789460184833
299

also Schle 1965, pp. 1823. This hypothesis is questioned by Van der Coelen (1995, pp. 19192) who
emphasized that Bos was a specialist in engraving on copper. Nevertheless, the banishment of the artist in
1544 makes it unlikely that he was implied in the series of the Moeurs, though he does seem to have
maintainedcontactswiththeartisticcommunityinAntwerpuntiltheendofhislife(VanderCoelen1995,p.
143).
13
Ghent,UniversiteitsbibliotheekGent,ACC.028724/1andACC.028738.Seealso:
http://adore.ugent.be/OpenURL/app?id=archive.ugent.be:0D7B5258B86411E08849
E58E37D8FA8C&type=carousel
14
ThecollaborationwithGillisCoppensstartedasearlyas1539withtheDutcheditionofBookIV:Generalen
reglenderarchitecture.ThatPieterCoecke,whoexplicitlyusedthetitleofswornbookselleroftheEmperor,
hadpermissiontopublishthememorialbookoftheEntryprintedin1550underhisownnameatteststhathe
enjoyed aprivileged statuswithin the Scheldt city, whose council forbade painters, sculptorsand printers to
reproduceinanyformwhatsoeverthedecorationserectedontheoccasionoreventopublishdescriptions.In
otherwords,onlytheofficialpublicationswereauthorized.Concerningthedecreeofthecitycouncil:Vander
Stock 1998, pp. 15253, 370 (transcription of the document). On the Books of Architecture, see a.o. De la
FontayneVerwey1976;DeJonge2004(withbibliography).
15
BruegelstartedtoworkforCockassoonas1554orevenin1552.TheearliesttestimonyofBruegelsactivity
inCocksprintinghouseisillustratedbyaprintWoodedlandscapewiththeTemptationofChristbearingthe
signatureH.Cock.fecit.Sellink2007,pp.13,57cat.16withpreviousbibliography.OnCockandthepublishing
house,seeVanGrieken2010;VanderStock2013;VanGrieken2013.
16
Thetitlepageofthe1548seriesoftwentydesignsforpitchersandshellswithgrotesquedecorationsdisplays
similaritieswiththatoftheMoeurs.OnemightwonderwhattheparticipationofCockwasinthepreparation
ofthisset;hedidindeedhaveknowledgeofsimilarworksbasedonantiquemodelsbyAgostinoVeneziano,
EneoVicoandLeonardodaUdine.FortheprintseriesandthecollaborationwithCock,VanMulders1996and
forthe1548series,esp.pp.4349,14245,figs.119139;seealsoVanGrieken,Luijten&VanderStock2013,
cat.76ab,pp.280283.
17
His brother, Frans I Floris, painted the decoration of the Triumphal Arch erected by the Genovese for the
1549JoyousEntreeofPhilipIIofSpaininAntwerp.
18
Bruxelles, Bibliothque royale de Belgique/Koninklijke Bibliotheek van Belgi, inv. S. II 32364, frieze of
fourteen woodcuts; the title page and the colophon, on separate sheets, are also late additions (probably
nineteenthcentury).Asecondsetonfourteensheetsofalateredition(seventeenthcentury?)isalsokeptin
thecollection:inv.S.II148040148049.
19
Seethediscussionbelow.
20
The original tapestry set is preserved in Madrid, Patrimonio Nacional, and the cartoons in Vienna,
Kunsthistorisches Museum, Gemldegalerie. A close examination of the cartoons sustains this hypothesis.
Campbell (2002, pp. 38790) has suggested that some of the main figures in the foreground are by Coecke,
unlike Horn (1989, pp. 12225), who denied the participation of the artist. Several figures that present
recurrentstylisticanalogieswithlaterworksbyCoeckewerepastedovertheverticalstripsofthecartoons.A
technical study of the cartoons would probably help us to understand the genesis of the work and the
collaborationbetweenthetwomastersandtheirworkshop.Nevertheless,besidestylisticfeaturesthatsome
mainfiguressharewithCoeckesworks,somepiecesoftechnicalevidencereinforcethisassumption,suchas
the comparison of the underdrawing of the Triptych of the Descent ofthe Cross (Lisbon, Museu Nacional de
Arte Antiga, inv. 112), which shows idiosyncratic handwritten characteristics in the drawing outlines and
shadowingeffects.ThiswillbedevelopedinanotherstudydevotedtotheLisbonaltarpiece.
21
VanMandered.Miedema1994,I,pp.13031.
22
Flibiened.1705,p.255.
23
Necipolu1989,pp.41921;Balis,DeJonge,Delmarcel&Lefbure1993,pp.3940;Campbell2002,p.379.
24
Estimationfortheperiodbetween1497and1522.SeeParker1999,p.114.
25
For the account of this voyage and comments, see Stirling Maxwell 1873, pp. 2230. In a letter
(Constantinople,2June1534)toMonsieurdeMalines(theEmperor),CorneliusDeSchepperwritesthathe
willleaveonFridaynextandhopestobeinViennaintwentyfivedays.SeeGachard&Piot1881,III,p.541.
26
Madrid,BibliotecaNacional,seeBauer&Steppe1981,pp.9099.
27
Campbell2002,pp.381,414.
28
Ibid.,p.379.
ISBN9789460184833
300

29
Flibien ed. 1705, pp. 25455;Marlier 1966,pp. 3132. For the author of the drawings and the cartoons:
SchneebalgPerelman(1982,p.191226)attributedthemtoFranoisBorremanandCoeckewhereasBalis,De
Jonge,Delmarcel&Lefbure(1993,pp.5479,esp.p.78)rejecttheviewthatCoeckecouldhaveplayedarole
intheelaborationoftheset.
30
Servantie2005,pp.27174andn.68.
31
The travel journal of Cornelis de Schepper is published by De SaintGenois & Yssel de Schepper 1856, pp.
118222.
32
Parmesdernires,vousayescriptcommentjestoiearrivencelieu,etcequemesemblaquepourrezdire
Pierre Vande Walle touant les tapisseries et aultres marchandises. Depuis ce temps les marchandts ont eut
assezsouffrir,etdejourenjoursetreuventoppressezdeplusenplus;desortequejeneconseillepasquilzy
viegnent plus, comme aussi je croy quilz ne feront. Il fault trouver aultre mode pour hwyder lesdictes
marchandises. Quoted after Gachard & Piot 1881, III, pp. 53942 (esp. 539). In the note it is stated that
hwydermeansfairecouler,i.e.tosell.
33
Servantie2005.
34
DuringamilitaryexpeditionagainsttheSultanBeyazit,thefutureJohntheFearlesswastakenprisoner.He
was released in exchange for Arras tapestries that represented good old stories. Philip the Bold provided
tapestries with the story of Alexander the Greats triumphs that were displayed on the walls of the Topkapi
Saray.Jardine&Brotton2000,p.76.
35
Necipolu1989,p.421.InthelettertotheEmperorabovementioned,DeScheppercomplainsthatduring
the absence of Ibrahim Pasha things are not going as they should and that business is bad: par labsence
dImbrahimBassa,leschosesvontaultrementquellesnesoulloient[...]Seullementjevousveulxpriervouloir
dire Pietre Vande Walle ce que ensuyt, affin quil ne se fie pas sur ces pierreries; car ce Grand Seigneur
nachapteplusainsiquilsouloit.CestparlabsencedImbrahimBassa.AfterGachard&Piot1881,III,pp.539
40.Thecontentoftheentireletterisambiguousandclearlyshowsthattrade,diplomacyandespionagewere
closelyrelated.
36
Lewy(2007,pp.6774)believesthatPieterCoeckemadeapilgrimagetoJerusalemduringtheperiodhewas
inConstantinople.TheauthorsargumentationisbasedonananonymousdrawingofJerusalemasseenfrom
the south (Antwerp, private collection, pen and ink, 140 x 395 mm) that he ascribes to the artist. The view
appearsrepeatedlywithsomealterationsonseveralworksattributedtoCoecke,asforinstanceinthetapestry
with the Stoning of St Stephen belonging to the cycle of Pauls tapestries (Munich, Bayerisches
Nationalmuseum, inv. n T 71/8) and the triptych of the Resurrection (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle, inv.
153). Nevertheless, as for the View of the Saint Peter basilica under construction (Roma, Citt del Vaticano,
BibliotecaApostolicaVaticana,Ashbycollection,inv.329,penandbrownink,198x408mm),theattributionof
thedrawingdoesnotrelyonstrongstylisticsimilaritieswithundisputeddrawingsbythemasterbutmerelyon
thefactthatCoeckeistheonlyNetherlandishartistwhosepresenceisattestedintheSouthernLevantatthe
time.OntheRomaindrawing,seeBorn2008,pp.9697.
37
OntheroadtoConstantinople,seeStirlingMaxwell1873,pp.2130.Marlier(1966,p.60)suggestedthat
CoeckecouldhavebeenpartofDeScheppersembassy,whereasHamilton(2001,p.41)presentsthisasafact
butwithoutanyreference.
38
Aedigius Beys, Plantins soninlaw, printed the first completed edition in Paris in 1589 under Busbecqs
supervision. See Hamilton 2001, pp. 41, 45. On European sources on Ottoman history (travellers, diplomats,
pilgrims,merchants,etc.),seeFaroqhi1999,pp.11043.
39
ThetopicoftheimageoftheTurkhasbeenalsowidelydiscussedintheliterature.SeeforexampleSt.Clair
1973,Raby1982,Silver2011andtherecentoverviewofAtasoy&Ulu2012,pp.32763.
40
Thestyleandthewellbalancedcompositionsofthewoodcutspointtoalaterdate,suggestingthatCoecke
reworkedthem.
41
Necipolu1989,p.419.
42
IdentificationsuggestedbyBalis,DeJonge,Delmarcel&Lefbure1993,pp.32,122.
43
De Schepper visited on the 27 May 1533 Ibrahim Pasha in his palace situated on the Hippodrome and
providedadescriptionofthesite.SeeDeSaintGenois&YsseldeSchepper1856,p.119.
44
The buildings around the Hippodrome and the axis of the different obelisks and columns are slightly
rearrangedandshiftedforcompositionalreasons.Foradiscussionontheaccuracyofthesiteandmonuments,
seeMarlier1966,pp.6972.
45
Until now, no preliminary drawing has been associated with this woodcut series. A large woodcut:
Description de la court du Grand Turc Solimans faisant son sejour en Constantinople, avec la maniere des
ISBN9789460184833
301

vestementsdeceuxdesasuite(Antwerp,MuseumPlantinMoretusPrentenkabinett,189x36cm)isassociated
withtheMoeursbuterroneouslyinmyview.IllustrationsinHamilton2001,pp.2833.
46
Campbell2002,p.428(withpreviousreferences).
47
Coecke died in Brussels on 6 or 16 December 1550. In a letter dated 17 December 1550 from Mary of
HungarytoCharlesVconcerningtheTunistapestries,wefindthefollowingstatement:ilaplutDieuprendre
soylepeintremestrePiere.Ifitcannotbeformallyexcludedthatthereismorethanonepainterwhosefirst
name is Pierre, it seems unlikely that two court masters painters died unexpectedly in Brussels at the same
time.Fortheepitaph,seeMarlier1966,pp.2931,35anddocumentpublishedbyHorn1989,II,p.381.
48
Even after the artists death, the statement Lequel aussy de sa main propre a pourtraict ces figures
duysanteslimpressiondycellesshouldperhapsnotbetakenliterallybutaddscredibilitytotheassumption
thatthescenesfromnaturewerenotalteredbythehandofanotherperson.
49
The course of events is represented in this work as exactly as possible [] the action is treated in this
tapestryaccordingtonature,allthatconcernscosmographyleavingnothingtobedesired.QuotedafterHorn
1989,pp.181,230n.32(Spanishtext).
50
ThecityisdepictedfromaplacecalledKassimpasha,seenfromacrosstheGoldenHorn,thecity'sharbour.
Marlier1966,pp.6669.
51
Nevertheless, there are, of course, drawings preserved that are portraits of cities or monuments, like for
instance Jan Gossarts View on the Colosseum Seen from the West (Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin,
Kupferstichkabinett,inv.kdz12918)withalatersixteenthcenturyinscriptionatupperright:JenninMabusen
eghenen/handt.ContrafetetinRoma/in[?]ColoseusortheViewonBergenopZoommadebyDrerduring
hisstayinAntwerpin1520(Vienna,GraphischeSammlung,Albertina,inv.3165D139).Thenotionnaerhet
leven has been developed further in our presentation The Customs and Fashions of the Turks au vif
contrefaictezbyPieterCoeckevanAelst:criticalreadingandvisualevidence,inNetherlandishCultureofthe
SixteenthCentury.InterdisciplinaryConference,Toronto,1920October2012.
52
Hamilton2001,pp.26,35andff.
53
DeAfflictionetamcaptivorumquametiamsubTurcaetributoviventiumChristianorum,Antwerp,Copenius,
1544,8andDeTurcarumrituetcaeremoniis,Antwerp,1544,8,Ghent,UniversiteitsbibliotheekGent:Hi4013
andHi7026.
54
Paredes2005,pp.14648.
ISBN9789460184833
302
Allaturca
TrkischeElementeinTheaterundFestandenHabsburgerhfenim16.und
17.Jahrhundert*
AndreaSommerMathis

FestauffhrungeninWienundMadridzurFeierdesEntsatzesvonWien1683
SptestensseitderSchlachtvon Mohcsam29.August1526 wurdendieExpansionsbestrebungen
derOsmaneninMitteleuropazunehmendalsBedrohungempfunden.ManversuchtedieserGefahr
sowohldurchAbwehrkriegealsauchdurchdiplomatischeVerhandlungenzubegegnen,docherstder
Entsatz Wiens im Jahre 1683 brachte die endgltige Wende, und im Frieden von Karlowitz 1699
musstedasOsmanischeReichschlielichauchumfangreicheGebietsabtretungenhinnehmen.
DieErleichterungberdasEndederosmanischenExpansionschlugsichinganzEuropanicht
nurineinerFlutvonFlugbltternundDruckschriftennieder,1sondernauchinzahlreichenFestenund
Theaterauffhrungen. Schon die ersten Feierlichkeiten unmittelbar nach der Zweiten Wiener
Trkenbelagerung16832spieltensowohlfrdieKonstruktiondesspterenTrkengedchtnissesals
auch fr die Imagebildung der europischen Frsten eine nicht unwesentliche Rolle. Die mediale
Verarbeitung der militrischen Ereignisse erfolgte einerseits ber die Betonung der eigenen Gre
undTapferkeitundandererseitsberdiegleichzeitigeDiffamierungdesbesiegtenGegners.Diesgilt
auch fr die Festlichkeiten und Theaterproduktionen, in denen man den so mhsam errungenen
TriumphberdieOsmanenandenhabsburgischenHfeninWienundMadridfeierte.
Am Kaiserhof setzten die Jesuiten den Entsatz Wiens in dem allegorischen Drama
FerdinandusQuintusRexHispaniaeMaurorumDomitor3(Abb.1)mitdemspanischenSiegberdie
Mauren1492inBeziehungunderinnertenineinerSzeneauchandiegleichzeitigeVertreibungder
JudenausSpanien.4InderabschlieendenmusikalischenHuldigung5derhabsburgischenKronlnder
wird Kaiser Leopold I. mit Ferdinand dem Katholischen verglichen und als neuer defensor fidei
gefeiert.6
Am spanischen Hof in Madrid wurde der Sieg ber die Trken 1683 mit einer zweiteiligen
comediavonPedrodeArcegefeiert,dieunterdemTitelElsitiodeViena7(Abb.2)dashochaktuelle
ThemaderBelagerungunddesEntsatzesvonWienthematisierte,jedochdenpolnischenKnigJan
III. Sobieski als den eigentlichen Helden feierte. Dem in Sobieski verkrperten Tugendideal werden
dienegativenEigenschaftendesHochmutsundderMachtgiergegenbergestellt,diehiernichtnur
ISBN9789460184833
303
wie sonst meist blich an den feindlichen Osmanen, sondern auch an einigen Christen
exemplifiziertwerden.
Abb.1TitelblattderPeriochedesJesuitendramas
FerdinandusQuintusHispaniaeMaurorumDomitor,1684
(Wien,sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,406.766
B.Mus.).
Abb.2TitelblattderComediadeElSitiodeViena,1684
(Madrid,BibliotecaNacionaldeEspaa,T12709).
DerspanischeKnigKarlII.hattesichzwarselbstanderTrkenabwehrnichtaktivbeteiligt,
liedenEntsatzWiensaberdennochinMadridmitProzessionen,Dankgottesdiensten,Feuerwerken
und Festbeleuchtungen als kollektiven Triumph der gesamten Casa de Austria feiern.8 Die comedia
Pedro de Arces stellt auf Grund ihrer besonderen zeitlichen Nhe zum aktuellen Anlass eine
Besonderheitdar,fgtsichjedochineinelangeTraditionhistorischerDramen,diesichmitpolitisch
militrischen Ereignissen der jngeren Vergangenheit beschftigten, wobei auch die Begegnung
zwischenOrientundOkzidentimmerwiederthematisiertwurde.9
Turcos,morosymoriscosinderspanischenDramatikdes16.und17.Jahrhunderts
Die ersten theatralischen Werke mit trkischen Sujets, die aus Spanien bekannt sind, entstanden
unmittelbar nach den Feldzgen von Sultan Sleyman I. dem Prchtigen gegen Ungarn, die ihn
zweimal1529und1532bisvordieToreWiensfhrten.DieseVorstederOsmanenbedeuteten
zwar fr Spanien, im Gegensatz zu ihren spteren Offensiven im Mittelmeer (1535 Belagerung von
Tunis,1541vonAlgier),keineunmittelbarekriegerischeBedrohung,10dochwardieAngstvoreiner
neuerlichen Islamisierung Spaniens stets prsent. Dies wirkte sich auch auf die Wahrnehmung der
TrkeninSpanienaus;siewurdenzumneuenFeindbildmitdenvondenMaurenbernommenen
stereotypenZuschreibungenalsUnglubige,BarbarenundTyrannen.
Davon ist allerdings in den spanischen Dramen aus den 30er Jahren des 16. Jahrhunderts
nochkaumetwaszufinden:LpezdeYanguasbenutztedastrkischeAmbienteseinerFarsadicha
turquesanacontraelTurcomuygalana11(1530)lediglichalsFolie,umdasChristentumalsdieeinzig
wahre Religion zu propagieren, whrend in Luis Milns Divertissement El cortesano12 (1538) die
ISBN9789460184833
304
Trken berhaupt nur als stumme Statisten fungierten, die dazu dienten, die Hofgesellschaft von
ValenciamitgalantenTexten,exotischenTnzen,SpielenundKostmenzuunterhalten.
NachderneuerlichenKonfrontationderspanischenTruppenmitdenOsmanenwhrendder
Belagerung von Malta (1565) und vor allem in der Seeschlacht von Lepanto (1571) erweckten los
turcosauchinSpanienimmergreresInteresse,wassichnicht nurinzahlreichenChronikenund
Reisebeschreibungen,13 sondern auch in einer deutlichen Zunahme von trkischen Stoffen in der
spanischenLiteraturmanifestierte.14DieerstenDramatiker,diesichderartigenThemenzuwandten,
bezogen sich dabei jedoch nicht auf die rezenten Feldzge, sondern auf lnger zurckliegende
Ereignisse: Gabriel Lobo Lasso de la Vega whlte als Sujet fr La destruccin de Constantinopla15
(1587) den Fall Konstantinopels 1453, und der valencianische Kanoniker Francisco Agustn Trrega
nahmdieBelagerungenvonRhodosindenJahren1481und1522zumAusgangspunktderHandlung
seinesDramasElcercodeRodas16;beideAutorenreichertendiehistorischenEreignissemitdenfr
diezeitgenssischencomediascharakteristischenLiebesintrigenan.
Anders als Gabriel Lobo Lasso de la Vega oder Francisco Agustn Trrega konnte Miguel de
Cervantes in seinen Werken ganz persnliche Erfahrungen in der Begegnung mit dem Orient
verarbeiten,17dennerwaralsSoldatanderSchlachtvonLepantobeteiligtgewesenund1575indie
Gefangenschaft nordafrikanischer Korsaren geraten.18 Whrend er in seinen Dramen Los tratos de
ArgelundLosbaosdeArgel19realeErlebnissewhrendseinerfnfjhrigenGefangenschaftinAlgier
einflieen lie, entspringt das trkische Milieu von La gran sultana Doa Catalina de Oviedo20
weitgehendseinerPhantasie.21
Auch in der beraus reichen Dramenproduktion Lope de Vegas finden sich etwa zwanzig
Dramen mit trkisch inspirierten Sujets sowie eine noch weit grere Anzahl von comedias mit
maurischenThemen;siewarenweitgehendfreierfundenundbasiertennurzueinemgeringenTeil
aufrealenGegebenheiten,wobeiLopedeVegaauchdiesemitdichterischerFreiheitinterpretierte.22
Sonahmeretwaindemzwischen1598und1603entstandenenDramaElcercodeVienapor
CarlosV23dieErsteWienerTrkenbelagerungvon1529zumAnlass,umKaiserKarlV.alsSiegerim
Kampf gegen die Trken zu feiern, obwohl dies den historischen Tatsachen keineswegs entsprach,
dennKarlV.hatteseinenBruder,KnigFerdinandI.,damalsmilitrischkaumuntersttzt,undSultan
SleymanI.derPrchtigewarzwar1529bisvordieMauernWiensgelangt,hatteabernachnurzwei
Wochen den Rckzug seiner Armee angeordnet. Erst im Jahre 1532, beim zweiten Versuch
Sleymans,Wienzubelagern,versammelteauchKarlV.einstattlichesHeer,dasdenSultanletztlich
an der Durchfhrung seines Vorhabens hinderte.24 Im Widerspruch zur historischen Realitt
prsentierte Lope de Vega in El cerco de Viena por Carlos V den Kaiser (Abb. 3) als Idealbild eines
VerteidigersderChristenheitundstellteihninkrasserSchwarzweimalereiSultanSleyman(Abb.4)
gegenber, den er als grausamen Despoten charakterisierte, der aus purer Willkr schreckliche
Grueltatenangeordnethabe.25IndercomediabegegneteKarlV.seinemKontrahentenconlaFen
el ombro, y el mundo a los pies, wie es in einer Bhnenanweisung heit, whrend der Sultan in
Umkehrung des Bildes nach Lope de Vega den Glauben mit Fen getreten und widerrechtlich
Anspruch auf die Weltherrschaft erhoben habe. Im Schlusssatz feierte Lope de Vega den Sieg ber
die Osmanen explizit als Triumph Spaniens Y esta es la ilustre vitoria,/ que alcan Espaa en
VienaundhuldigtedemneuenspanischenKnigPhilippIII.undseinerDynastie.26
ISBN9789460184833
305

Abb.3Tizian,KaiserKarlV.imHarnisch,Mitte16.Jh.
(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,Inv.Nr.GG8060).

Abb.4UmkreisTizians,SultanSleymanI,um1530/40
(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,Inv.Nr.GG2429).
DieMetapherdesGlaubens,denderKaiseralsWeltenherrscheraufseinenSchulterntrgt,
entspricht in ihrem Bedeutungsgehalt zahlreichen bildlichen Darstellungen auf zeitgenssischen
ephemerenTriumpharchitekturen.EsseibeispielhaftnuraufeinenderTriumphbgenverwiesen,die
1570 anlsslich der Hochzeitsfestlichkeiten des spanischen Knigs Philipp II. mit Erzherzogin Anna
von sterreich, einer Tochter Kaiser Maximilians II., in Madrid errichtet wurden: Karl V., der Vater
des Brutigams, wurde dort mit anderen Herrschern aus beiden Linien des Hauses Habsburg
dargestellt,darunterauchmitseinemBruderFerdinandI.,wobeiHinweiseaufihrengemeinsamen
Sieg ber die Osmanen nicht fehlten. Auf demselben Triumphbogen befand sich auch eine
allegorischeFigurSpaniensmiteinerdurcheineschwereKetteansiegefesseltenPersonifikationder
Ketzerei zu ihren Fen; aus den erklrenden Inschriften geht hervor, dass damit sowohl der
ProtestantismusalsauchderIslamgemeintwar.27
hnliche Darstellungen finden sich auch auerhalb des habsburgischen Herrschaftsgebiets,
etwa in Florenz, wo man 1589 zur Eheschlieung von Ferdinando de Medici mit Christina von
Lothringen einen Triumphbogen mit zwei Kolossalstatuen habsburgischer Herrscher errichten lie,
die als Kriegshelden und Bezwinger der Trken dargestellt wurden: Karl V. neuerlich als derjenige,
der1529dieTrkenausWienvertriebenhabe,undseinSohnPhilippII.alsstrahlenderSiegerinder
SeeschlachtvonLepantoimJahre1571.28
Lope de Vega konnte somit in seinem Drama El cerco de Viena por Carlos V an eine
Argumentationslinieanknpfen,diedamalsschoneuropaweitinWortundBildetabliertwar.Gegen
EndedercomediakameszueinerkurzenBegegnungdesKaisersmitseinemBruderFerdinand,bei
der die beiden Monarchen und ihre Generle mit tapferen Herrschern und Feldherrn der
Vergangenheit verglichen wurden, mit Scipio, Alexander dem Groen und Marius wieder in
Analogie zu den bildlichen Darstellungen und panegyrischen Texten der gleichzeitigen frstlichen
EinzgeinganzEuropa.
ISBN9789460184833
306
Neben Lope de Vega setzte sich auch Francisco de Rojas Zorrilla mit der Ersten Wiener
Trkenbelagerungauseinander,29zeigteaberinseinemDramaEldesafodeCarlosV30auchdiemit
demKriegverbundenenexistenziellenundfinanziellenNte,jasogardiekrperlicheGebrechlichkeit
des Kaisers, der von heftigen Gichtanfllen geplagt wird. Titelgebendes Thema der comedia ist die
Legende vom Zweikampf zwischen Sleyman dem Prchtigen und Kaiser Karl V., der nur deshalb
nichtzustandekommt,weildieTrkenschonvorherabziehen.BeiRojasZorrillawerdendieFeinde
durch den Spanier Luis de la Cueva in die Flucht geschlagen, wobei dieser vom Heiligen Martin
untersttzt wird, der auf einem weien Pferd an der Seite der Christen kmpft in Analogie zur
spanischen Legende von Santiago Matamoros, dem Heiligen Jakob, der den Spaniern im Kampf
gegendieMaurenBeistandgeleistethabensoll.
Historische Wahrheit war bei Francisco de Rojas Zorrilla ebenso wenig zu finden, und auch
nichtzuerwartenwiebeiLopedeVegaunddenbrigenDramatikerndesSiglodeOro,wasjedoch
keineswegs bedeutete, dass sie die historiographischen Quellen nicht kannten oder benutzten. Bei
Lopes Trkendrama El cerco de Viena por Carlos V konnten diese zwar bisher nicht eindeutig
nachgewiesen werden, doch in anderen seiner historischen comedias hielt er sich, wie viele seiner
Zeitgenossen, hufig an die Darstellung der umfangreichen Vita Karls V., die Knig Philipp II. zur
GlorifizierungderHerrscherpersnlichkeitseinesVatersunddamitimplizit auchseiner eigenen
beiFrayPrudenciodeSandovalinAuftraggegebenhatte.31
AnderWendevom16.zum17.JahrhundertverfassteLopedeVeganocheineganzeReihe
weitererDramenmittrkischenundmaurischenSujets,indenenerohneUnterschiedGrotrken
undBerberknige,SultaneundihreFavoritinnen,RenegatenundspanischeGefangeneauftretenlie
entscheidendwardieBhnenwirksamkeitderStoffeundFiguren.EsgingLopedeVegawohlvor
allem darum, ein mglichst attraktives orientalisches oder allgemein exotisches Milieu fr die
dramatische Handlung seiner comedias zu schaffen.32 Symptomatisch ist dabei, dass in all diesen
DramenkeineklareDifferenzierungzwischenTrkenundMaurenvorgenommenwird.Turcos,moros
y moriscos waren Sammelbegriffe fr alle Muslime, gleichgltig, ob sie aus Nordafrika, dem
arabischenRaumoderausdemOsmanischenReichstammten.IhreAndersundFremdartigkeitwar
nichtethnologischdifferenziert,sonderneinzigdurchihreZugehrigkeitzumIslam,denesinden
AugenderkatholischenMonarchenundihrerliterarischenSprachrohrezubekmpfengalt.
TurcicainritterlichenTurnierenandensterreichischenHabsburgerhfen
EinehnlichundifferenzierteDarstellungvonMaurenundTrkenfindetsichauchindenritterlichen
Turnieren, die ab der Mitte des 16. Jahrhunderts an den sterreichischen Habsburgerhfen
veranstaltet wurden. Stellvertretend fr viele andere sei das Huszarische Turnier genannt, das
Erzherzog Ferdinand II., der jngere Sohn Kaiser Ferdinands I., 1557 als bhmischer Statthalter in
Prag abhielt. Die Husaren, eine ungarische Elitetruppe des Reichsheeres, galten als die tapfersten
Verteidiger Europas gegen die Osmanen und boten sich daher als Identifikationsfiguren fr die
HabsburgerinbesonderemMaean.SotratauchErzherzogFerdinandII.nureinJahrnachseinem
Feldzug gegen die Osmanen in Ungarn (1556) in der Rolle und im Kostm eines Anfhrers der
HusarenzumSchaukampfgegendieMuslimean(Abb.5).33
ISBN9789460184833
307

Abb.5ErzherzogFerdinandalsAnfhrerderHusaren
(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,Kunstkammer,Inv.Nr.5134,fol.167).
Bei dem Prager Huszarischen Turnier handelte es sich um ein Scharmtzel, einen
Gruppenkampf,dervonzweiParteienausgetragenwurde:DieeineerschienimKostmchristlicher
RitterundHusaren,dieandereGruppealsTrkenundMohren(Abb.6).FrdieAusstattungder
islamischenGegnerlieFerdinandMaskenvisiereanfertigen,dieausEisengefertigtundmitlfarbe
bemalt waren; sie sollten die Physiognomie von Trken und Mohren imitieren (Abb. 7). An den
Visieren angenietete Lederschlaufen dienten zur Befestigung von Schnurrbrten aus Rosshaar,
Turbanen und Kapuzen. ber dem Harnisch wurden die entsprechenden orientalischen Kleider
angelegt. Zur Ausstattung der huszarischen oder ungarischen Reiter gehrten auch sogenannte
Flgeltartschen, Schilde, die spitz zulaufend die Gestalt eines Flgels nachbildeten und dadurch
SchutzgegenSbelhiebeaufdenKopfunddenNackenboten(Abb.8).

Abb.6ReiterimmohrischenKostm
(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,Kunstkammer,Inv.Nr.5134,fol.53).
ISBN9789460184833
308
Abb.7Maskenvisiere.

Abb.8Flgeltartsche.
(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,SammlungenSchlossAmbras,Inv.Nrn.WA284,WA248,WA494).
Von den Ausstattungsstcken dieses und hnlicher Turniere haben sich einige erhalten;
nachgearbeitete orientalische Sturmhauben (Abb. 9) ebenso wie die Silberne huszarische Rstung
FerdinandsII.,diederErzherzognach demTrkenfeldzugvon1556inAuftraggab(Abb. 10).Esist
anzunehmen,dassnochweitereorientalischebzw.orientalisierendeWaffenundRequisitenausdem
BesitzdesErzherzogsfrdieseTurnierebenutztwurden.NachderbernahmederRegentschaftin
Tirol 1564 stellte Ferdinand diese Originale, zusammen mit den speziell fr die Huszarischen
TurniereangefertigtenDekorationen,inseinerTrkenkammeraufSchlossAmbrasaus.34

Abb.9SturmhaubeimorientalisierendenStil
(Mnchen,BayerischesNationalmusueum,Inv.Nr.W
1388)
ISBN9789460184833
Abb.10SilbernehuszarischeRstungErzherzog
FerdinandsII.(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,
HofjagdundRstkammer,Inv.Nr.A878)
309
PropagandistischerHintergrundderHuszarischenTurnierewardieDarstellungdesKampfes
derchristlichenHabsburgergegendenIslaminOsteuropaundNordafrika.Nebendiesempolitischen
AspektistallerdingsauchderstarkeEinflussderRitterepenundromanezubercksichtigen,diemit
AmadsdeGaula,AriostsOrlandoFuriosoundTassosGerusalemmeliberataim16.Jahrhunderteine
groeBltezeiterlebten.DarinwurdennebenchristlichenauchmohammedanischeRitteralsgroe,
tapfere Krieger dargestellt, was es den Hofadeligen erleichtert haben mag, in das Kostm des
Erbfeindeszuschlpfen.35
Auch die Ritterspiele im Rahmen des sogenannten Wiener Turniers von 1560,36 die der
sptereKaiserMaximilian II.zuEhrenseinesVaters FerdinandI. veranstaltete,enthieltenkonkrete
Hinweise auf die Rolle der Habsburger in der Trkenabwehr. So inszenierte man unter anderem
mglichstrealittsgetreudieBelagerungeineraufderDonauerrichtetenStadt(Abb.11)undsparte
beiderDarstellungderfiktivenSeeschlachtauchnichtmitdrastischenMitteln:UmdieVerwundeten
mglichst echt aussehen zu lassen, verwendete man Ochsenblut, und um die toten Krper der
Feinde darzustellen, katapultierte man aus Mrsern Strohpuppen mit Trkenmasken. Damit sollte
einerseits ganz gezielt die Erinnerung an die Grausamkeit der Feldzge gegen die Osmanen in der
jngstenVergangenheitgewecktwerden,37andererseitssignalisiertemanaberauch,dassmansich
durchauszutraute,diebermchtigenFeindezubezwingen.38

Abb.11SeeschlachtaufderDonau1560.RadierungvonHannsSebaldLautensackimTurnierbuchvonHans
FrancolinBurgunder,Wien1561(Wien,sterreichischesTheatermuseum,Inv.Nr.GFeS4240/3).
Nach1560tratdietheatralischeAusgestaltungderTurnieredurchkostmierteAufzgeund
dramatische Programme, die sogenannten Inventionen, immer strker in den Vordergrund.39 Das
zeigt sich auch in dem allegorischen Ringrennen, das Kaiser Maximilian II. 1571 anlsslich der
Hochzeit seines Bruders, Erzherzog Karls von Innersterreich, mit Maria von Bayern in Wien
ISBN9789460184833
310
veranstaltete; an der Konzeption des Programms und der knstlerischen Ausgestaltung waren der
HumanistJohannBaptistFonteiusundGiuseppeArcimboldo,dersptereHofmalerKaiserRudolfsII.,
mageblichbeteiligt(Abb.12).40IngroteilsvonArcimboldo41entworfenenKostmenundMasken
zogen mythologische und allegorische Figuren auf den Turnierplatz, allen voran die vier Weltteile
Europa,Asien,AfrikaundAmerikamitihrenwichtigstenLndern.

Abb.12AllegorischesTurnierinWien,1571.KolorierterHolzschnittinHeinrichWirrichsFestbeschreibung
(Wien,sterreichischesMuseumfrangewandteKunst,Inv.Nr.1543,Bibliothek,Sign.AII27).
DiesesTurniermitseinemkomplexenkosmologischenProgrammfandkaummehralseinen
MonatvorderSeeschlachtvonLepantostatt,indereinerderTeilnehmerandenFestlichkeiten,Don
JuandeAustria,alsOberbefehlshaberderHeiligenLigadieOsmanenvernichtendschlagensollte.Der
theatralischeKampfderWeltteileumdieVorherrschaftundderTurniersiegEuropasberdienicht
christlichenKontinentesignalisiertedieimperialenAnsprchedersterreichischenHabsburgerund
ging weit ber bloe Spielfreude und Lust am Verkleiden hinaus, wiewohl man auch diese
KomponentebeidenFestenderRenaissanceunddesBarocknichtunterschtzensollte.Dafrspricht
die ungeheure Flle an Festveranstaltungen mit verschiedensten exotischen gerade auch
orientalischenVerkleidungeninganzEuropa.
ErdteilallegorienundNationenDarstellungen
DieersteerhaltenebildlicheDarstellungderAllegorienallerdamalsbekanntenErdteiledrfteetwa
zur selben Zeit wie das Wiener allegorische Turnier entstanden sein: 1570 verffentlichte der
kniglichspanische Geograph Abraham Ortelius in Antwerpen unter dem Titel Theatrum Orbis
Terrarum42eineSammlungvon70Landkarten,diealsdasltesteBeispieleinesinternationalenAtlas
ISBN9789460184833
311
gilt. Auf dem Titelblatt (Abb. 13) sind die vier Weltteile in einer triumphbogenartigen Architektur
gemeinsamabgebildet,womitdieauseuropischerPerspektivebisweitins18.Jahrhundertgltige
Hierarchie der Weltteile festgelegt wurde: Europa thront als Weltenherrscherin, gekennzeichnet
durch die Attribute Krone, Szepter und Erdkugel, hoch ber den anderen drei Kontinenten Asien,
AfrikaundAmerika.

Abb.13TitelblattdesAtlasvonAbrahamOrtelius,1570
(Wien,sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,393215D/K).
hnliche allegorische Darstellungen der Erdteile finden sich nicht nur als Illustrationen von
WeltkartenundAtlanten,sondernsehroftauchaufdenTitelbltternderimletztenDritteldes16.
Jahrhunderts besonders populren Trachtenbcher (Abb. 14), umfassenden Kompendien von
Kostmen der Vlker der ganzen Welt. Die dort abgebildeten Darstellungen beruhten zumeist auf
der ethnographischen Kenntnis realer Trachten und dienten hufig als Vorlagen fr die barocken
Allegorien der Erdteile und ihrer Vlkerschaften, die damals auch in die Festveranstaltungen vieler
europischerHfeEingangfanden.

Abb.14TitelblattdesTrachtenbuchsvonAbrahamdeBruyn,1581
(Wien,sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,253.433E/Fid.).
ISBN9789460184833
312
WhrendmansichanfangsnochrelativgenauandieIkonographiederTrachtenbcherhielt
(Abb.15ab),entferntemansichimLaufedes17.Jahrhundertsimmermehrdavonundbeschrnkte
sichimZugeeinerzunehmendeneuropischenStandardisierungmehrundmehraufdiestereotype
Zuweisungeinzelner,alscharakteristischerachteterAttributeunddiesobwohlmandieOsmanen
durch Reiseberichte und trkische Gesandtschaften vielfach auch aus eigener Anschauung kannte.
Die gngigen Attribute der Trken waren kostbare, mit Juwelen geschmckte orientalische
Gewnder,Seidenkaftane,PumphosenundTurbane,dieentsprechendenWaffen,Krummsbelund
Streitkolben,sowiedasSymboldesHalbmonds,dasoftalsdekorativesElementeingesetztwurde.
Abb.15abTrkischerKaiserundgypter.HolzschnittevonJostAmmaninHansWeigelsTrachtenbuch,1577
(FaksimileUnterschneidheim1969,pp.CLXXXVIIundCCXVII).
Personifikationen der vier Weltteile finden sich als Bilder und Statuen auf Triumph und
TrauerarchitekturenebensowiealslebendeAllegorienimRahmenfestlicherAufzgeundreligiser
Prozessionen, wobei letztere am spanischen Hof besonders reich ausgestaltet wurden. Es sei in
diesem Kontext nur auf die Festlichkeiten in Madrid anlsslich der kollektiven Heiligsprechung von
Ignatius von Loyola, Franz Xaver, Teresa von Avila, Isidro Labrador und Filippo Neri im Jahre 1622
verwiesen, bei denen mehrfach Allegorien der vier Weltteile bzw. Reprsentanten ihrer Nationen
auftraten.AuchTrkenkamenvor:EinmalerschienensiegemeinsammitPersernundgypternals
Bewohner Asiens, wobei sie in der Bekleidung kaum voneinander unterschieden wurden,43 ein
andermal im Gefolge der Europa, gemeinsam mit Deutschen, Franzosen und Spaniern. Einer der
Autoren der zahreichen Festbeschreibungen des Jahres 1622 schildert in aller Ausfhrlichkeit die
prchtigen KostmederTrkenausSamtundSeide,ihrediamanten und perlengezierten Turbane
undihrenreichenSchmuck,44meintdannaber,manhtteihnenabsichtlicheinenPlatzanderSeite
derDeutschenzugewiesen,umsiezudemtigen.45blicherweiseerfolgteeinesolcheDemtigung
imRahmenfestlicherEinundAufzgeaufganzandereWeise:ManzeigtediebesiegtenFeindezu
bzw.oftauchunterdenFenderSiegeroderinKettenalsGefangene,wiesiedenTriumphwagen
ihrerBezwingerzogen;dieOsmanenwurdendabeimeisthalbnacktdargestelltundeinzigdurchdie
ihnenzugewiesenenAttributeTurban,Rossschweif,trkischeFeldzeichenundWaffenkenntlich
gemacht.46EineZuordnungderTrkenzuEuropa,wiesie1622inMadriderfolgte,stelltimRahmen
derFestederFrhenNeuzeiteineausgeprocheneRarittdar.
ISBN9789460184833
313
IntraditionellenBahnenbewegtensichhingegendiefiktivenKmpfezwischenOsmanenund
Europern, die auch whrend der Kanonisationsfeierlichkeiten des Jahres 1622 im Rahmen einer
Prozession als Tanzgruppe (danza de invenciones47) inszeniert wurden: Drei als Franzosen, Spanier
bzw. Trken kostmierte Quadrillen simulierten, mit Lederschilden und Lanzen bewaffnet, einen
Fukampf, whrend eine andere Gruppe, die aus jeweils sechs Trken und Christen bestand, eine
Seeschlachtveranstaltete.IhrezwlfGaleerenwarenganznaturalistischmitMasten,Takelwerkund
Segelnausgestattetundsoleicht,dasssievonnureinemMannaufdenSchulterngetragenwerden
konnten.DasWasserwaraufLeinwandaufgemalt,diedenunterenTeilderSchiffeverdeckte,und
durchdiegeschickteBewegungderTnzerentstanddieIllusioneinerSeeschlachtenminiatureauf
denWogeneinesbloimaginiertenMeeres48andersalsdieTrkenundChristen,dieeinanderbei
derWienerNaumachiedesJahres1560aufderDonaueineechteWasserschlachtgelieferthatten.
Erdteilallegorien und NationenDarstellungen gehrten im 17. Jahrhundert an vielen
europischen Hfen auch zum gngigen und beraus beliebten Figureninventar der mit groem
Aufwand dramatisch ausgestalteten Reiterspiele und Rossballette, die sich aus den einfacheren
TurnierformenderRenaissanceentwickelthatten.ImsogenanntenKarussellwurdenverschiedene
Spielarten des Turniers zusammengefasst und unter ein gemeinsames Thema gestellt, dem die
jeweilige Kostmierung entsprach; sehr hufig war dies der Wettstreit der vier Weltteile um die
Vorherrschaft,derzunehmendalstheatralischerSchaukampfinszeniertwurde.49
So veranstaltete man etwa am Wiener Kaiserhof 1652 zu Ehren der neu geborenen
spanischenInfantinMargaritaTeresa,derspterenEhefrauKaiserLeopoldsI.,einReiterspiel,dasaus
einereigenwilligenKombinationausitalienischemMusikdramaundTurnierbestandunddenTitelLa
garatrug.50DarinstreitendievierWeltteileumdenVorrangbeiderHuldigungderInfantin,zunchst
nurmitWortenundGesang,dannaberauchmitWaffengewalt(Abb.16).DasichdieKontinenteim
Schaukampfalsgleichwertigerweisen,siehtsichJupitergezwungeneinzugreifen:ErsprichtEuropa
denSiegespreiszu,fordertaberauchdieanderenWeltteileauf,derInfantingemeinsamzuhuldigen.

Abb.16FuturnierdervierWeltteileimRahmenderTurnieroperLaGara,1652.AnonymerKupferstichnacheinem
EntwurfvonGiovanniBurnacini(Wien,sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,79.B.1.Mus.).
Das Turnierspiel diente nicht nur der vordergrndigen Hommage an das spanische
Knigskind,sondernzeigteauchdeutlichdieimperialenpolitischenAnsprchedersterreichischen
Habsburger. DieQuadrilledersiegreichenEuropafhrteKnig FerdinandIV.an,dernichtnurzum
ISBN9789460184833
314
Brutigamderebenerstgeborenen Infantinauserkorenwar,sondernauchamnchsten Reichstag

1653 zum kaiserlichen Thronfolger proklamiert werden sollte. Da Ferdinand aber bereits im darauf
folgendenJahrverstarb,tratseinBruderLeopolddasErbeanundwurde1658inFrankfurtamMain
zum Rmischen Kaiser gekrnt. Zur Unterhaltung des dort anwesenden Adels fand unter anderem
einsogenanntesKopfrennenstatt,einReiterspiel,beidemmanmitLanze,SbeloderPistolegegen
Trken oder Mohrenkpfe aus Holz oder Pappmach zu kmpfen hatte. Die Trkenkopfrennen
gingen auf die sowohl auf osmanischer als auch auf europischer Seite bliche Praxis zurck, den
Kopf des Feindes als Trophe zu verwenden.51 In den Ritterspielen fungierten die Zielfiguren der
Trken und Mohren als Stellvertreter fr die Feinde, denen man im Krieg tatschlich
gegenbergestandenhatte.
Von der politischen Brisanz dieser Reiterspiele zeugt die Reaktion eines trkischen
Gesandten,derimFebruar1662einemderartigenKopfrenneninWienbeigewohnthatte,wozuvier
geschnizteTrckenKpffeaufgestecktundnachdemerstenmitderLanze,aufdenandernmitdem
Pfeil, auf den dritten mit dem Pistol und auf den lezten mit dem Degen gerennt wurde. Um die
geschmackloseSpielfiktionderLcherlichkeitpreiszugeben,verwieserdarauf,dassSeinKayser[]
anderwrts so vile lebendige ChristenKpffe nidersblen [liesse], da man nicht nthig habe, mit
erdichtetenTrckenKpffensolcheKurzweilzutreiben.52DieseTurnierformbliebnochbisins19.
Jahrhundert ein beraus beliebtes Divertissement,53 das man 1814 auch den Gsten des Wiener
Kongressesnichtvorenthaltenwollte,obwohleszu diesemZeitpunktjederGrundlageeinerrealen
BedrohungdurchdenosmanischenErbfeindentbehrte(Abb.17).54

Abb.16ReiterspielmitTrkenundMohrenkpfen,1814
(WienMuseum,MappeFeste).
ImRahmenderKrnungsfestlichkeitenfrKaiserLeopoldI.inFrankfurtamMain1658fand
unter anderem ein Turnier mit mehreren Quadrillen maskierter Ritter statt, zu denen zwar keine
Trken gehrten, sehr wohl aber Mohren: sie waren dunkelhutig, durch das Attribut des
FederschmucksjedochinderArtderIndianerkostmiert.55HierzeigtsicheinspielerischerUmgang
miteinerlterenTurnierform,wobeijedochderursprnglichepolitischreligiseAspektdesKampfes
ISBN9789460184833
315
gegen die Osmanen oder Mauren zur Verteidigung des Christentums gegen den Islam durch die
BeliebigkeitderexotischenKostmierungdeutlichindenHintergrundtrat.56
Eindeutig politisch motiviert war hingegen die wohl spektakulrste Festveranstaltung des
WienerKaiserhofesdasRossballettLacontesadellAriaedellAcquavon1667.57Hiergingeszwar
weder um den Kampf zwischen Muslims und Christen noch um den Wettstreit der vier Weltteile,
sondernumdenKampfdervierElemente,dochistdiesespektakulreBarockperformance58auchin
diesem Kontext von Interesse, ist sie doch nichts anderes als eine mit allen medialen und
propagandistischen Mitteln der damaligen Zeit59 realisierte Antwort Kaiser Leopolds I. auf das
franzsische Karussell von 1662,60 in dem sich Knig Ludwig XIV. als Beherrscher der ganzen Welt
inszenierthatte:ErwarimKostmeinesRmischenKaisersanderSpitzevonVerteternallerErdteile
in diesem Fall von Rmern, Persern, Trken, Indern und Amerikanern aufgezogen und hatte
damit dem habsburgischen Kontrahenten Leopold I. seine weltumspannenden Machtansprche
signalisiert.61 Bei den Figurinen der Trken (Abb. 18 und 19) und Inder (Abb. 20) fllt auf, welch
minimale Unterschiede bei der Gestaltung ihrer Kostme gemacht wurden; das wichtigste
ErkennungsmerkmaldereinzelnenGruppierungenwardieunterschiedlicheFarbgebungundeinzelne
alscharakteristischangeseheneAttributeimFallederTrkendasSymboldesHalbmonds,dassich
alsOrnamentaufdenKostmenderMitwirkendenunddemZaumzeugderPferdefindet.

Abb.18:TrkischeSoldatenimKarussellvon1662.KolorierteKupferstichevonIsraelSilvestrein
CharlesPerraultsCoursesdestestesetbagues...(Faksimile:DenkmlerdesTheaters,MappeVI).
ISBN9789460184833
316
Abb.19und20Trkischbzw.indischkostmierteReiterimKarussellvon1662.KolorierteKupferstichevonIsrael
SilvestreinCharlesPerraultsCoursesdestestesetbagues...(Faksimile:DenkmlerdesTheaters,MappeVI,TafelnXIII,XV).
TrkenmotiveinMummereienundFaschingsmaskeraden
Noch deutlicher wird diese Gestaltungsvielfalt bei den Maskeraden, die sich nicht nur an den
habsburgischenHfengrterBeliebtheiterfreuten.VorallemdieFaschingszeitbotdenHofadeligen
vielfltigeGelegenheitzurKostmierungunddamitzumAusbruchausdemstrengenHofzeremoniell.
Dabei waren der Phantasie kaum Grenzen gesetzt, wie etwa die Festbeschreibung einer
Tanzveranstaltung am Wiener Hof aus dem Jahre 1636 zeigt, in der ganz unterschiedliche Masken
aufzogen:DasgemischteEmpfangskomiteefrdenKaiserbildetenTrken,FerraresenundFischer,
wobeidieKostmederTrkenlautFestbeschreibungbesondersprchtigmitReiherfedernund
Juwelen geschmckt waren;62 es folgten in buntem Durcheinander Jgerinnen, Indianerinnen,
Portugiesinnen und Spanierinnen, Commedia dellarteFiguren, die auf einem Wagen ein riesiges
StckParmesanmitsichfhrten,Sklaven,dievondenPersonifikationenderTreueundBestndigkeit
angefhrtwurden,Mohren,Juden,HirtenundverschiedensteallegorischeFiguren.63
TrkischeElementesindinhfischenMaskenfestenundVerkleidungsdivertissementsjedoch
schon wesentlich frher, mindestens seit dem Ende des 15. Jahrhunderts, schriftlich belegt und in
Kaiser Maximilians I. fiktiven autobiographischen Werken Freydal und Weikunig auch im Bild
festgehalten. So sind in einer so genannten Trkenmummerei sechs Tnzer dargestellt, die alle
weie, zopfartig geflochtene Turbane ber dunkelroten Kappen tragen; diese trkischen Kostme
werdendurchKrummsbelundgroteskebrtigeMaskenkomplettiert(Abb.21).Auchanderederin
den Gedechntnuswerken Maximilians I. abgebildeten Mummereien zeigen einen hnlichen
orientalisierenden Einfluss, wobei die kostbaren Gewnder und Turbane der Tnzer in deutlichem
WiderspruchzuihrengroteskenBrtenundVogelmaskenstehen(Abb.22).64
ISBN9789460184833
317
Abb.21und22TrkischeMummereienausdemFreydal,151215
(Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,Kunstkammer,Inv.Nr.P5073;AusgabevonLeitner,Bl.172und203).
Das Trkenmotiv war und blieb auch in den folgenden Jahrhunderten in hfischen
Maskenspielen und Balletten stets prsent65 und fand unter anderem Eingang in die Wirtschaften,
eine Form von Verkleidungsbanketten, die fr den Wiener Hof ab 1653 nachweisbar ist.66 Dabei
fungierte das Kaiserpaar als Wirt und Wirtin und empfing die als Vertreter der verschiedensten
NationenundBerufsstndekostmiertenMitgliederdesHochadelsalsGstezueinemFestmahlmit
anschlieendem Tanz. Zu den Nationentrachten, die immer wiederkehrten, gehren Trken und
MohrenebensowieIndianer,gypter,Chinesen,Perser,Rmer,AlteDeutsche,Venezianer,Spanier,
Franzosen,Polen,UngarnundGriechen.
DieerhaltenenVerzeichnissederWirtschaftenbeschrnkensichaufdieNennungderNamen
derTeilnehmerundihrerRollen,dieihnendurchdasLoszugeteiltwurden;siegebenaberkeinen
Aufschluss darber, wie man sich die Kostme dieser Nationentrachten vorzustellen hat.
Erfreulicherweise haben sich jedoch kolorierte Kostmfigurinen von der Hand des kaiserlichen
Architekten,BhnenundKostmbildnersLodovicoOttavioBurnacinierhalten,67dieeinenEindruck
gebenvonderVielfaltundFarbenprachtdieserMaschere.BeiderGestaltungderVlkertrachtenlie
Burnacini seiner Phantasie freien Lauf, obwohl er um die Mitte des 17. Jahrhunderts nicht nur auf
Reiseberichte, Atlanten und Trachtenbcher htte zurckgreifen knnen, um sich die ntigen
ethnographische Kenntnisse anzueignen, sondern auch Gelegenheit hatte, echte Trken am
Kaiserhofzusehen,diealsdiplomatischeGesandtenachWienkamen.68Dennochbeschrnkensich
seine ethnographischen Assoziationen bei der Gruppe der Trken69 auf die bereits bekannten
Attribute: reich geschmckte orientalische Gewnder, Turbane, Krummsbel und Halbmond im
brigen berwiegt das barocke Bhnenkostm (Abb. 23), und auch die Art der paarweisen
Darstellung entspricht den zeitgenssischen Theaterszenen, in denen auch mit dem gefrchteten
Krummsbelspielerischumgegangenwerdenkonnte(Abb.24).70
ISBN9789460184833
318

Abb.23LodovicoOttavioBurnacini,TrkischeMascherefrWirtschaftenamWienerHof,2.H.des17.Jhs.
(Wien,sterreichischesTheatermuseum,Min.20;Faksimile:DenkmlerdesTheaters,MappeI,TafelVII).

Abb.24LodovicoOttavioBurnacini,TrkischeMascherefrWirtschaftenamWienerHof,2.H.des17.Jhs.
(Wien,sterreichischesTheatermuseum,Min.20;Faksimile:DenkmlerdesTheaters,MappeI,TafelVIII).
ISBN9789460184833
319
Ausblick
Wenn man die hier kurz skizzierten Feste an den habsburgischen Hfen whrend des 16. und 17.
Jahrhunderts Revue passieren lsst und nach dem dort gezeigten Trkenbild fragt, so lsst sich
festhalten, dass Trken whrend der gesamten Zeit der osmanischen Bedrohung vor allem im
RahmenhfischerMaskeradenundTurnierezumberausbeliebtenunddaherhufigeingesetzten
Figurenpersonalgehrten.DabeireichtdieBandbreitederDarstellungindenverschiedenenGenres
vomgrausamen,barbarischenChristenfeindberdentapferen,bewunderungswrdigenKriegerbis
hinzunichtnherbestimmtenexotischenOrientalen.
Whrend trkische Sujets relativ frh Eingang in die spanischen comedias fanden, scheint
eine dramatische Auseinandersetzung mit den Osmanen an den Hfen der sterreichischen
Habsburger kaum stattgefunden zu haben. Dies lag wohl hauptschlich daran, dass im 17.
Jahrhundert die italienische Oper am Kaiserhof ber alle anderen dramatischen Gattungen
dominierte und die Librettisten eindeutig Sujets aus der antiken Mythologie und Geschichte
bevorzugten.TrkenfandensichdaherzunchstnurindenZwischenaktballettenderMusikdramen,
waren da aber auch nicht mehr als pittoreske, exotische Staffagefiguren anders als in Frankreich
oderItalien,wotrkischeMotivezuabendfllendenBallettenausgestaltetwurden.71
Erst im 18. Jahrhundert als man keine weiteren osmanischen Expansionsbestrebungen
mehrzufrchtenhatteentstandauchamWienerHofeineregelrechteTrkenmode,dievoneiner
schwrmerischen Faszination fr den Orient bestimmt war und sich gerade in Theater und Fest
besonders deutlich manifestierte.72 Dabei wich die Vorstellung der Osmanen als grausame Krieger
undChristenfeindeimZugederAufklrungbaldganzdemIdealbildedler,grozgigerundvorbildlich
handelnder Menschen, wie sie etwa Le Turc Gnreux (Abb. 25) oder Selim Bassa in Mozarts Die
Entfhrung aus dem Serail (1782) verkrperten, um nur die bekanntesten Beispiele unter den
zahlreichen orientalischen Opern, Singspielen und Balletten aus der zweiten Hlfte des 18.
Jahrhundertszunennen.

Abb.25KolorierterKupferstichnacheinemGemldevonBernardoBellotto,
BallettauffhrungvonLeTurcGnreuxamWienerBurgtheater,1758.
ISBN9789460184833
320
Bibliographie
Arce,Pedrode,La/comedia/de/elsitio/deViena,/fiesta,/qveserepresent/alosfelizesaos/de
la Reyna Madre/ Nvestra Seora/ Doa Mariana de Avstria,/ el dia veinte y dos de diziembre de
MDCLXXXIII.enelRealSalondePalacio(Madrid,1684;Lisboa1684).
Arce,Pedrode,Lacomedia,/segvnda/parte/delsitio/deViena,/y/conqvista/de/Estrigonia,/fiesta
qveserepresent/asusMagestades/Aode1684(Madrid,1684).
AvalleArce, Juan Bautista, La captura de Cervantes, Boletn de la Real Academia Espaola, 48
(1968),pp.23780.
Giuseppe Arcimboldo. Figurinen, Kostme und Entwrfe fr hfische Feste, ed. Andreas Beyer
(FrankfurtamMain,1983).
Arcimboldo (15261593), ed. Sylvia FerinoPagden (Ausstellungskatalog, Wien, Kunsthistorisches
Museum/Paris,MuseduLuxembourg,2008).
BegegnungzwischenOrientundOkzident(Ausstellungskatalog,LandesmuseumPtuj,1992).
BeschreibungundAbbildung/Aller/Knigl.VndChurfrstl./Ein=Zge/WahlvndCrnungsActa,/
So geschehen zu Franckfurt am Mayn / im Jahr 1658. / Sampt andern darzu gehrigen vnd
beygefgtenSachen(FrankfurtamMain,1658).
Beyer,Andreas,DieSzenederFrsten.ArcimboldosKostmeundEntwrfefrhfischeFesteund
Turniere, in Arcimboldo (15261593), ed. Sylvia FerinoPagden (Ausstellungskatalog, Wien,
KunsthistorischesMuseum/Paris,MuseduLuxembourg,2008),pp.24347.
BiachSchiffmann, Flora, Giovanni und Ludovico Burnacini: Theater und Feste am Wiener Hof
(Arbeitendes1.KunsthistorischenInstitutsderUniv.Wien,43)(Wien,1931).
Bingham Kirby, Carol, Observaciones preliminares sobre el teatro histrico de Lope de Vega, in
ActasdelICongresoInternacionalsobreLopedeVega(Madrid,1981),pp.32937.
Blumenthal,ArthurR.,TheaterArtoftheMedici.CatalogoftheExhibitionheldatDartmouthCollege
Museum&Galleries,Oct.10Dec.7,1980(Hanover,NewHampshire,1982).
Brooks,LynnMatluck,TheDancesoftheProcessionsofSevilleinSpainsGoldenAge(TeatrodelSiglo
deOro,Estudiosdeliteratura,4)(Kassel,1988).
Bruyn, Abraham de, Habitvs Variarium Orbis gentium. Habitz de Nations estra[n]ges. Trachten
mancherleyVlckerdesErdskrey(Antwerpen,1581).
Bek, Vclav, Ferdinand von Tirol zwischen Prag und Innsbruck. Der Adel aus den bhmischen
LndernaufdemWegzudenHfendererstenHabsburger(WienKlnWeimar,2009).
Cervantes Saavedra, Miguel de, Teatro completo, edicin, introduccin y notas de Florencio Sevilla
ArroyoyAntonioReyHazas(Barcelona,1987).
ISBN9789460184833
321
CervantesSaavedra,Miguelde,LagranSultanaDoaCatalinadeOviedo,inOchocomediasyocho
entremeses nuevos nunca representados, compuestas por Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra (Madrid,
1615). [OnlineVersion http://www.comedias.org/cervantes/gransu.html, ed. Vern G. Williamsen,
1997].
ChavesMontoya,MaraTeresa,FiestadeestadoyarquitecturaefmeraenMadridyToledodurante
elreinadodeFelipeII(Tesina,UniversidadAutnomadeMadrid,1985).
ChavesMontoya,MaraTeresa,LaentradadeAnadeAustriaenMadrid(1570)segnlarelacinde
LpezdeHoyos.Fuentesiconogrficas,BoletndelMuseoeInstitutoCamonAznar,36(1989),pp.
91106.
DaCostaKaufmann,Thomas,ArcimboldosImperialAllegories,G.B.FonteoandtheInterpretationof
ArcimboldosPainting,ZeitschriftfrKunstgeschichte,39(1976),pp.27596.
DaCostaKaufmann,Thomas,VariationsontheImperialThemeintheAgeofMaximilianIIandRudolf
II(NewYorkLondon,1978).
DartoisLapeyre,Franoise,Turcsetturqueriesdanslesreprsentationsenmusique(XVIIeXVIIIe
sicles),inTurcsetturqueriesXVIeXVIIIesicles,ed.LucienBly(Paris,2009),pp.163219.
DenkmlerdesTheaters:Inszenierung/Dekoration/KostmdesTheatersunddergroenFestealler
Zeiten.NachOriginalenderTheatersammlungderNationalbibliothek,derAlbertinaundverwandter
Sammlungen,ed.JosephGregor,MappeIXII(WienMnchen,19251930).
Dietrich,Margret,HuldigungsspieleandieErbInfantinMargaretha:LaGaraamHofeLeopoldsI.,in
Spanien und sterreich im Barockzeitalter. Akten des Dritten Spanischsterreichischen Symposions
(Kremsmnster, 25.30. September 1983), ed. Wolfram Krmer (Innsbrucker Beitrge zur
Kulturwissenschaft.Sonderheft,58)(Innsbruck,1985),pp.6174.
Dmitrieva,Marina,TrkenmummereienaufFestenundTurnierenimstlichenEuropaim16.und17.
Jahrhundert,inDasBilddesFeindes,ed.EckhardLeuschner,ThomasWnsch(Berlin,2013),32135.
Epp,Sigrid,ApplausifestivibarrieraderFestumzugdesMnchnerHofeszuEhrenKaiserLeopolds
I. im Jahr 1658 RIHA Journal 0036 (17 February 2012), URL: http://www.rihajournal.org/
articles/2012/2012janmar/eppfestumzug/(dateofaccess:14.Okt.2012)
FederschmuckundKaiserkrone,ed.FriedrichPolleross,AndreaSommerMathis,ChristopherF.Laferl
(Ausstellungskatalog,SchlohofimMarchfeld,1992).
Ferdinandus/ Quintus/ Rex Hispani/ Maurorum domitor./ Ferdinand der Fnffte/ Knig in
Hispanien/ Wider die Mohren obsiegend./ Augustissimis Csareis/ Majestatibus/ Leopoldo/ et/
Eleonor./ Dum/ Bene meritis in arena literaria athletis/ Csarea munificentia agonisma/
decerneretur,/ theatro datus/ a/ Juventute Csarei et Academici Collegij Societatis Jesu Vienn,/
Anno r Sacr M.DC.LXXXIV./ Vienn Austri, Typis Joannis Christophori Cosmerovij, S.C.M.
TypographiAulici(Vienna1684).
ISBN9789460184833
322
Fernndez,Enrique,LostratosdeArgel:obratestimonial,denunciapolticayliteraturateraputica,
Cervantes.BulletinoftheCervantesSocietyofAmerica,20.1(2000),pp.726.
Fidler,Petr,LacontesadellAriaedellAcquaEinebarockePerformance,Operahistorica,8(2000),
pp.35979.
[Fonteius,JohannBaptist]BAP.FONTEIIPRIMONISEVROPALIAHOCESTSpecies,Dignitas,Significatio
solennis eius Pompae, quam Maximiliianus II Imperator inuictissimus, cum illustri Europae
ostentationeijsproduxitludis,quosegitsummo,icredibiliq.Splendore,atq.Apparatu,dumSereniss.i
ArchiducisCarolifratrisnuptialemcelebritatemornandam,amplificandamq.suscepit,duinoq.simul
presagiofoederataaduersusBarbarosmilitiaefortunatosgloriososexitus,ettriumphumpartendisse
uisus est, die ipso quadragesimo ante magnam victoriam naualem. MEMORIAE ANTIQVITATI,
MAGNIFICENTIAE,CLEMENTIAE,FELICITATI,ABSPVRGIAEAVSTRIAEDOMVSSACRADICATAQ.[NB,
HSS,Cod.10.206]
FrancolinBurgunder,Hans,ThurnierBuech.WarhafftigerRitterlicherThate[n],soindemMonatJunij
des vergangnen LX. Jars in vnd ausserhalb der Statt Wienn zu Ro vnd zu Fue / auff Wasser vnd
Lannd gehalten worden / mit schnen Figuren contrafeet / vnd dem Allerdurchleuchtigisten /
GromechtigistenFrsten vnndHerrn/HerrenFerdinando/erweltemRmischenKayser/zuallen
zeyten Mherer des Reichs ec. deren allergeleibsten Khindern / dem gantzen Adel vnnd
hochberembterTeutschenNation/durchHannsenvonFrancolinBurgunder/HochstgedachterR:
Kay:Mayt:ec.Ernholdenec.zuEhrenbeschriben[Wien1561].
Freydal. Des Kaisers Maximilian I. Turniere und Mummereien. Mit einer geschichtlichen Einleitung,
einem facsimilirten Namensverzeichnisse und 255 Heliogravuren, ed. Quirin von Leitner (Wien,
188082).
GeschichtspolitikundTrkenbelagerung,ed.JohannesFeichtinger,JohannHeiss(KritischeStudien
zurTrkenbelagerung,1)(Wien,2013).
Grothaus, Maximilian, Zum Trkenbild in der Kultur der Habsburgermonarchie zwischen dem 16.
und 18. Jahrhundert, in Habsburgischosmanische Beziehungen, ed. Andreas Tietze (Beihefte zur
WienerZeitschriftfrdieKundedesMorgenlandes,13)(Wien,1985),pp.6789.
Grothaus, Maximilian, Die Turquerie von Pettau/Ptuj, ihre graphischen Vorbilder und ihre
kulturhistorische Bedeutung, in Begegnung zwischen Orient und Okzident (Ausstellungskatalog,
LandesmuseumPtuj,1992),pp.6978,13984(Kat.Nr.5.177).
Gualterotti, Raffaello, Descrizione del regale apparato per le nozze della Serenissima Madama
CristinadiLorenamoglie delSerenissimoDonFerdinandoMediciIIIGranDucadiToscana(Firenze,
1589).
HaiderPregler, Hilde, Das Rossballett im Inneren Burghof zu Wien (Jnner 1667), Maske und
Kothurn,15(1969),pp.291324.
ISBN9789460184833
323
Hernando,JulioF.,Espejo,Javier,LaFarsaTurquesanadeHernnLpezdeYanguas,estudioyedicin
(http://parnaseo.uv.es/Lemir/Textos/Farsa Turquesana/Index.htm; Textos LEMIR ISSN 1579735X
2002).
Hfert,Almut,DenFeindbeschreiben.TrkengefahrundeuropischesWissenberdasOsmanische
Reich14501600(FrankfurtamMainetal.,2003).
Jacquot, Jean, Schne, Gnter, Note sur quelques dessins du Louvre et un tournoi de Munich
(1658),inLesFtesdelaRenaissance,ed.JeanJacquot,vol.III.(Paris,1975),pp.41119.
Kbdebo, Heinrich, Bibliographie zur Geschichte der beiden Trkenbelagerungen Wiens 1529 und
1683(Wien,1876).
Kaiser Ferdinand I. 15031564. Das Werden der Habsburgermonarchie, Ausstellungskatalog,
KunsthistorischesMuseum(Wien,2003).
Karner,Herbert,GetrkteKriegsspieleundderspielerischbesiegteErbfeind.MartialischeAspekte
hfischer und brgerlicher Festkultur, in Geschichtspolitik und Trkenbelagerung, ed. Johannes
Feichtinger,JohannHeiss(KritischeStudienzurTrkenbelagerung,1)(Wien,2013),pp.11942.
Karner,Herbert,KopfundZeltderOsmanenStrategiendesmitteleuropischenTrkengedenkens,
inzitierengedenkenerinnern.BeitrgeausdemZentrumKulturforschungendersterreichischen
AkademiederWissenschaften,ed.BjrnR.Tammen,WernerTelesko(Wien,2010),pp.10935.
Kissling, Hans Joachim, Trkenfurcht und Trkenhoffnung im 15./16. Jahrhundert. Zur Geschichte
einesKomplexes,SdostForschungen,23(1964),pp.118.
Kleinlogel, Cornelia, Exotik Erotik. Zur Geschichte des Trkenbildes in der deutschen Literatur der
frhenNeuzeit(14531800)(FrankfurtamMainetal.,1989).
Knapiski,Ryszard,TrkenkriegeundreligiseIkonographieineuropischenGraphikendes16.bis
18.Jahrhunderts,inDasBilddesFeindes,ed.EckhardLeuschner,ThomasWnsch(Berlin,2013),pp.
33754.
Kopplin, Monika, Turcica und Turquerien. Zur Entwicklung des Trkenbildes und Rezeption
osmanischer Motive vom 16. bis 18. Jahrhundert, in Exotische Welten Europische Phantasien
(Stuttgart,1987),pp.15063.
Kreidt,Dietrich,ExotischeFigurenundMotiveimeuropischenTheater(Ausstellungskatalog,Institut
frAuslandsbeziehungen,Stuttgart,1987).
Kretzenbacher,Leopold,Ringreiten,RolandspielundKufenstechen.SportlichesReiterbrauchtumvon
heutealsErbeausabendlndischerKulturgeschichte(Klagenfurt,1966).
Laferl,ChristopherF.,LajustificacindelimperiouniversdaldelosHabsburgoenelteatrobarroco
espaol,inBarrocoespaolyaustriaco:FiestayteatroenlaCortedelosHabsburgoylosAustrias,
Ausstellungskatalog(MuseoMunicipaldeMadrid,1994)(Madrid,1994),pp.6772.
ISBN9789460184833
324
Laferl, Christopher F., Die Kultur der Spanier in sterreich unter Ferdinand I. 15221564 (Junge
WienerRomanistik,14)(WienKlnWeimar,1997).
LassodelaVega,GabrielLobo,TragediadelaDestrycindeConstantinopla.Introduccin,ediciny
notasdeAlfredoHermenegildo(Kassel,1983).
Im Lichte des Halbmonds. Das Abendland und der trkische Orient, Ausstellungskatalog (Staatliche
KunstsammlungenDresdenandKunstundAusstellungshallederBRD,Bonn,1995/96).
LopedeVegaCarpio,Flix,ElcercodeVienaporCarlosV,inBibliotecadeAutoresEspaoles,vol.
223(Madrid,1969),pp.30143.
Lpez de Hoyos, Juan, Real apparato, y svmptvoso recebimiento con qve Madrid (como casa y
morada de su M.) rescibio a la Serenissima reyna D. Ana de Austria, viniendo a ella nueuamente
despuesdecelebradassusfelicissimasbodas.PonesesuItinerario.Vnabreuerelaciondeltriumpho
delSereniss.DonIuandeAustria.YelsolenebaptismodelSS.PrincipedonFernandonuestroseor
(Madrid,1572).
[Maccioni,GiovanniBattista]Applausifestivi/barriera/rappresentateinMonacoallavenutaquivi/
delInvittissimoCesare/Leopoldo/Augusto/nelgranTeatropressolaResidenza/delSerenissimo/
Ferdinando/Maria/DucadiBaviera&Elettore/delS.R.J.(Mnchen,1658).
MrquezVillanueva,Francisco,Eltemadeloscautivos,inPersonajesytemasdelQuijote(Madrid,
1975),pp.92146.
MrquezVillanueva,Francisco,Elproblemamorisco(desdeotrasladeras)(Madrid,1991).
MrquezVillanueva,Francisco,Cervantesenletraviva:Estudios sobrelavidaylaobra (Barcelona,
2005).
MrquezVillanueva,Francisco,Moros,moriscosyturcosdeCervantes.Ensayoscrticos(SerieGeneral
Universitaria,104)(Barcelona,2010).
Mas, Albert, Les turcs dans la littrature espagnole du Sicle dOr(Recherches sur levolution dun
thmelittrarire,2voll.(Paris,1967).
McGaha,Michael,HacialaverdaderahistoriadelcautivoMigueldeCervantes,RevistaCanadiense
deEstudiosHispnicos20(1996),pp.54046.
Menndez y Pelayo, Marcelino, El cerco de Viena por Carlos V de Lope de Vega, in Biblioteca de
AutoresEspaoles,vol.216:ObrasdeLopedeVega25:Crnicasyleyendas dramticasdeEspaa
(MadridSantander,1969),pp.4245.
Meregalli, Francisco, De Los tratos de Argel a Los baos de Argel, in Homenaje a Casalduero, ed.
RizelPincusandGonzaloSobejano(Madrid,1972),pp.395409.
Merle,Alexandra,LimagedesTurcsenEspagneauxXVIeetXVIIesicles,inTurcsetturqueriesXVIe
XVIIIesicles,ed.LucienBly(Paris,2009),pp.14762.
ISBN9789460184833
325
[Miln,Luis],LibrointituladoElcortesano,compuestoporD.LuisMiln.Librodemotesdedamasy
caballerosporelmismo(Madrid,1874).
Monforte y Herrera, Fernando de, Relacin de las fiestas qve ha hecho el Colegio Imperial de la
Compaa de Iesus de Madrid en la canonizacion de San Ignacio de Loyola, y S. Francisco Xauier
(Madrid,1622).
Moser,FriderichCarlvon,Teutsches=Hofrecht,vol.2(FrankfurtLeipzig,1761).
Ortelius,Abraham,TheatrumOrbisTerrarum(Antwerpen,1570).
Perrault,Charles,Coursesdetestes et baguesfaitesparleRoyetparlesprincesetseigneursdela
CourenlanneMDCLXII(Paris,1670).
Petritsch,ErnstD.,ZurProblematikderkontinentalenOsmanenabwehr,inKarlV.15001558.Neue
Perspektiven seiner Herrschaft in Europa und bersee, ed. Alfred Kohler, Barbara Haider and
ChristineOttner(ZentraleuropaStudien,6)(Wien,2002),pp.66783.
Pfaffenbichler, Matthias, Das Turnier als Instrument der Habsburgischen Politik, Waffen und
Kostmkunde. Zeitschrift der Gesellschaft fr Historische Waffen und Kostmkunde, 34 (1992), pp.
1336.
Pfaffenbichler, Matthias, Orientalische und orientalisierende Waffen, in Im Lichte des Halbmonds.
DasAbendlandunddertrkischeOrient,Ausstellungskatalog(StaatlicheKunstsammlungenDresden
andKunstundAusstellungshallederBRD,Bonn,1995/96),pp.96100.
Pfaffenbichler, Matthias, Das Turnier zur Zeit Kaiser Ferdinands I. in Mitteleuropa, in Kaiser
Ferdinand I. 15031564. Das Werden der Habsburgermonarchie (Ausstellungskatalog,
KunsthistorischesMuseum,Wien,2003),pp.277281,Nr.III.2326.
Poeschel, Sabine, Studien zur Ikonographie der Erdteile in der Kunst des 16.18. Jahrhunderts
(BeitrgezurKunstwissenschaft,3)(Mnchen,1985).
Polleross,Friedrich,DerWandeldesBildes.Entstehung,VerbreitungundVernderungderAmerika
Allegorie, in Federschmuck und Kaiserkrone. Das barocke Amerikabild in den habsburgischen
Lndern,ed.FriedrichPolleross,AndreaSommerMathis,ChristopherF.Laferl(Ausstellungskatalog,
SchlosshofimMarchfeld,1992),pp.2135.
[Ponce,Manuel]RelaciondelasfiestasquesehanhechoenestaCorte,alaCanonizacindecinco
Santos:copiadadeunacartaqueescriuio.En28deIunio622(Madrid,s.a.),inRelacionesdeactos
pblicoscelebradosenMadrid(15411650),ed.JosSimnDaz,(Madrid,1982),pp.16979.
Prohaska,Wolfgang,ZumBildderTrkenindersterreichischenKunstdes18.Jahrhunderts,inDie
Trken vor Wien. Europa und die Entscheidung an der Donau 1683, ed. Robert Waissenberger
(SalzburgWien,1982),pp.25161.
Phringer,Andrea,ChristencontraHeiden?DieDarstellungvonGewaltindenTrkenkriegen,in
Das Osmanische Reich und die Habsburgermonarchie. Akten des Internationalen Kongresses zum
ISBN9789460184833
326
150jhrigenBestehendesInstitutsfrsterreichischeGeschichtsforschung,ed.MarleneKurzetal.
(Mitteilungen des Instituts fr sterreichische Geschichtsforschung, Ergnzungsband, 48) (Wien
Mnchen,2005),pp.97119.
Relatione delli Balletti, et Inventioni fatte lvltimo giorno di Carnevale nellAvgvstiss[im]a Corte di
S.M.C.(Wien,1636).
Riedel, Friedrich W., Musikalische Darstellungen der Trkenbelagerung Wiens im Jahre 1683, in
FestschriftOthmarWesselyzum60.Geburtstag,ed.ManfredAngereretal.(Tutzing,1982),pp.457
63.
Robles, Bernardo de, Breve delineacion de la gran salida de nuestro Soberano Monarca rendir
graciaslaCelestialAuroradeAtochaporlafelizvictoriadeViena,eldiaochodeNoviembredeste
aode1683(Madrid,1683).
RojasZorrilla,Franciscode,EldesafiodeCarlosV(Salamanca,s.a.).
Sabik;Kazimierz,PoloniaenelteatroespaoldelSiglodeOroyElsitiodeVienadePedrodeArce,
in Memorias del Simposio Internacional de la Ctedra de Estudios Ibricos de la Universidad de
Varsovia (VarsoviaKonstancin, 1519 de octubre de 1991, ed. Marzena Adamczyk, M.Pierrette
Malcuzynski(Warszawa,1993),pp.14758.
Sabik, Kazimierz, Tres personajes polacos en el teatro cortesano del Siglo de Oro, in Thtre,
musique et arts dans les cours europennes de la renaissance et du baroque. Actes du Congrs
International(Varsovie,2328septembre1996),ed.K.Sabik(Warszawa,1997),pp.297307.
Salida en publico, a cavallo, del Rey Nvestro Seor Don Carlos Segundo, que Dios guarde, dar
graciasalRealConventodeNuestraSeoradeAtochaelLunes8.deNoviembrede1683.porlaGran
VitoriaconseguidadelImperio,yPoloniacontraelTurco:EntradaenpublicoalRetiro,queexecutel
seorEmbaxadordeAlemaniaelDomingo7.dedichomes.FiestasdeRomasobrelamismaVitoria,y
CelebridaddelaCorteCatolica(Madrid,1683).
Snchez, Alberto, Revisin del cautiverio cervantino en Argel, Cervantes. Bulletin of the Cervantes
SocietyofAmerica,17.1(1997),pp.724.
Sandbichler,Veronika,HabsburgischeFesteinderRenaissance,inWirsindHelden.Habsburgische
FesteinderRenaissance(Ausstellungskatalog,SchlossAmbras,Innsbruck,2005),pp.113.
Sandbichler, Veronika, Die Bedeutung hinter dem Sichtbaren: Allegorie Trionfo Visuelle
Propaganda, in Wir sind Helden. Habsburgische Feste in der Renaissance (Ausstellungskatalog,
SchlossAmbras,Innsbruck,2005),pp.456.
Sandbichler, Veronika, bungen, die edeln Kavalieren ziemen: Habsburger Turniere im 15. und 16.
Jahrhundert, in Wir sind Helden. Habsburgische Feste in der Renaissance (Ausstellungskatalog,
SchlossAmbras,Innsbruck,2005),pp.6571.
ISBN9789460184833
327
Sandoval, Fray Prudencio de, Historia de la vida y hechos del Emperador Carlos V [...], 3 vols.
(Valladolid1604;Pamplona,1614);auchinBibliotecadeAutoresEspaoles8082(Madrid,1955/56).
SanzAyn,Carmen,PedagogadeReyes:ElteatropalaciegoenelreinadodeCarlosII(Madrid,2006).
Sbarra, Francesco, La contesa / dell / Aria e dellAcqua / Festa cavallo / rappresentata /
nellAugustissimeNozze/delle/Sacre,Cesaree,Reali/M.M./dellImperatore/Leopoldo/edell/
Infanta/Margherita/delleSpagne./Inventata,edescritta/daFrancescoSbarra/ConsiglierodiSva
MaestCesarea(Wien,1667).
Sbarra, Francesco, Sieg=Streit / De / Lufft vnd Wassers / Freuden=Fest zu Pferd / Zu dem
Glorwrdigisten Beylger / Beeder Kayserlichen Majestten / Leopoldi de Ersten / Rmischen
Kaysers / auch zu Hungarn vnd Bhaim Knig / Ertz=Hertzogens zu Oesterreich / ec. / Vnd /
Margarita / gebohrner Kniglichen Infantin / au Hispanien / Dargestellet / In dero Kayserlichen
ResidentzStattWienn(Wien,1667).
Schilling, Michael, Aspekte des Trkenbildes in Literatur und Publizistik der frhen Neuzeit, in Die
BegegnungmitdemIslamischenKulturrauminGeschichteundGegenwart,ed.StefanKrimm,Dieter
Zerlin (Mnchen, 1992), pp. 4360. Reprint in Das illustrierte Flugblatt der frhen Neuzeit.
Traditionen Wirkungen Kontexte, ed. Wolfgang Harms, Michael Schilling (Stuttgart, 2008), pp.
22744.
Schnitzer, Claudia, Knigreiche Wirtschaften Bauernhochzeiten. Zeremonielltragende und
unterwandernde Spielformen hfischer Maskerade, in Zeremoniell als hfische sthetik in
Sptmittelalter und Frher Neuzeit, ed. Jrg Jochen Berns, Thomas Rahn (Frhe Neuzeit, 25)
(Tbingen,1995),280331.
Schnitzer, Claudia, Zwischen Kampf und Spiel. Orientrezeption im hfischen Fest, in Im Lichte des
Halbmonds. Das Abendland und der trkische Orient, Ausstellungskatalog (Staatliche
KunstsammlungenDresdenandKunstundAusstellungshallederBRD,Bonn,1995/96).
Schnitzer,Claudia,HfischeMaskeraden.FunktionundAusstattungvonVerkleidungsdivertissements
andeutschenHfenderFrhenNeuzeit(FrheNeuzeit,53)(Tbingen,1999).
Schreder,Marianne,DieDarstellungKarlsV.IndenhistorischenDramenLopedeVegas(Dipl.Arbeit
UniversittWien,1995).
Schulze,Winfried,ReichundTrkengefahrimspten16.Jahrhundert.Studienzudenpolitischenund
gesellschaftlichenAuswirkungeneineruerenBedrohung(Mnchen,1978).
Schumann,Jutta,DieandereSonne.KaiserbildundMedienstrategienimZeitalterLeopoldsI.(Institut
frEuropischeKulturgeschichtederUniversittAugsburg,ColloquiaAugustana17)(Berlin,2003).
Sells Ferrando, Xavier, Die erste Trkenbelagerung Wiens in der spanischen Literatur, in 1492
1992: Spanien, sterreich und Iberoamerika. Akten des Siebten Spanischsterreichischen
Symposions, 16. 21. Mrz 1992 in Innsbruck (Innsbrucker Beitrge zur Kulturwissenschaft,
Sonderheft,86)(Innsbruck,1993),pp.16981.
ISBN9789460184833
328
SellsFerrando,Xavier,Spanischessterreich(WienKlnWeimar,2004).
Smieja, Florian, King John III Sobieski in Pedro de Arces El sitio de Viena, Revista Canadiense de
EstudiosHispnicos,7,3(1983),pp.40712.
Sola, Emilio and de la Pea, Jos F., Cervantes y la Berbera: Cervantes, mundo turcoberberisco y
serviciossecretosenlapocadeFelipeII(Mxico,1995).
SolemniaelectionisetinaugurationisLeopoldiI,Romanor:ImperatorisAugusti,&c.SeuDescriptioet
Repraesentatio eorum omnium, quae anno 1658, ante, in & post electionem RegioImperatoriam
apudMoenoFrancofurtenosspectatu,notatuatquerelatudignaevenerunt(Frankfurt,1660).
Solf, Sabine, Festdekoration und Groteske. Der Wiener Bhnenbildner Lodovico Ottavio Burnacini:
InszenierungbarockerKunstvorstellung(StudienzurdeutschenKunstgeschichte,355)(BadenBaden,
1975).
SommerMathis, Andrea, Amerika im Fest und auf der Bhne im 16. und 17. Jahrhundert, in
Federschmuck und Kaiserkrone. Das barocke Amerikabild in den habsburgischen Lndern, ed.
FriedrichPolleross,AndreaSommerMathis,ChristopherF.Laferl(Ausstellungskatalog,Schlosshofim
Marchfeld,1992),pp.12758.
SommerMathis,Andrea,LodovicoOttavioBurnacini,scenografoecostumistadiAntonioDraghi,in
QuelnovoCario,queldivinOrfeo.AntonioDraghidaRiminiaVienna,ed.EmilioSala,DavideDaolmi
(ConNotazioni,7)(Lucca,2000)pp.387410.
SommerMathis,Andrea,LaimagendeCarlosVenlasfiestasyelteatroespaoldecomienzosdela
EdadModerna,inCarlosV/KarlV.15002000,ed.AlfredKohler(Madrid,2001),pp.64154;Zur
RezeptionKarlsV.imspanischenTheaterundFestderFrhenNeuzeit,inKarlV.15001558.Neue
Perspektiven seiner Herrschaft in Europa und bersee, ed. Alfred Kohler, Barbara Haider, Christine
Ottner(ZentraleuropaStudien,6)(Wien,2002),pp.70924.
SommerMathis,Andrea,FesteamWienerHofunterderRegierungvonKaiserLeopoldI.undseiner
ersten Frau Margarita Teresa (16661673), in Arte Barroco e ideal clsico. Aspectos del arte
cortesano de la segunda mitad del siglo XVII (Roma, mayojunio de 2003), ed. Fernando Checa
Cremades(Madrid,2004),23156.
SommerMathis, Andrea, ... ma il Papa rispose, che il Re de Romani a Roma era lui.
FrhneuzeitlicheKrnungsfestlichkeitenamKaiserundamPapsthof,inKaiserhofPapsthof(16.
18. Jahrhundert), ed. Richard Bsel, Grete Klingenstein, Alexander Koller (Publikationen des
Historischen Instituts beim sterreichischen Kulturforum in Rom, Abhandlungen, 12) (Wien, 2006),
pp.25184.
SommerMathis,Andrea,FestundFestung.DieWienerBurgbefestigungalsBauplatzvonTanzslen
und Opernhusern im 16. und 17. Jahrhundert, in sterreichische Zeitschrift fr Kunst und
Denkmalpflege,64(2010),pp.8392.
ISBN9789460184833
329
SommerMathis, Andrea, Trckische Tragdia und Christliche Comdia. Die Trkenfeiern 1683 in
Europa, in Geschichtspolitik und Trkenbelagerung, ed. Johannes Feichtinger, Johann Heiss
(KritischeStudienzurTrkenbelagerung,1)(Wien,2013),pp.89118.
Staudt,JohannBernhard,FerdinandusQuintusRexHispaniaeMaurorumDomitor.DramadesWiener
Jesuitenkollegs anllich der Befreiung von den Trken 1683, ed. Walter Pass (Denkmler der
Tonkunstinsterreich,132)(Graz,1981).
Straub,Eberhard,RepraesentatioMaiestatisoderchurbayerischeFreudenfeste.DiehfischenFestein
der Mnchner Residenz vom 16. bis zum Ende des 18. Jahrhunderts (Miscellanea Bavarica
Monacensia,14)(Mnchen,1969).
Stubenrauch,Moritzvon,OrdentlicheBeschreibungdesBeylagers,sodagehaltenwordenistdurch
Carln, Ertzhertzog zu Oesterreich, mit Maria, Hertzogin zu Bayern, den 26. August 1571 in der
kayserlichen Stadt Wien, Oesterreichische Zeitschrift fr Geschichts und Staatskunde 3 (1837), Nr.
45(7.Juni1837),pp.1779;auchinsterreichischeBausteinezurKulturundSittengeschichte,ed.
WilhelmSchram(Brnn,1905),pp.4650.
Sturminger, Walter, Bibliographie und Ikonographie der Trkenbelagerungen Wiens 1529 und 1683
(Verffentlichungen der Kommission fr Neuere Geschichte sterreichs, 41) (GrazKln, 1955), pp.
60336,350420.
[Trrega, Francisco Agustn] La famosa comedia del cerco de Rodas, compuesta por el Canonigo
Tarrega,poetavalenciano.
Trauth, Nina, Portraits getrkter EuroperInnen. Orientalisierende Maskeraden in der
SelbstdarstellungdesBarock,inThemenheftFrauenundGeschlechterforschunganderUniversitt
Trier,Unijournal,28(2002),pp.2022.
Trauth, Nina, Orientalische Maskeraden im Portrt von Markgrfin Franziska Sibylla Augusta von
BadenBaden (16751733), in Frau und Bildnis 16001750. Barocke Reprsentationskultur an
europischenFrstenhfen,ed.CordulaBischoffandGabrieleBaumbach(Kassel,2003),pp.81110.
Trauth,Nina,MaskeundPerson:OrientalismusimPortrtdesBarock(MnchenBerlin2009).
Die Trken kommen! Exotik und Erotik: Mozart in Koblenz und die OrientSehnsucht in der Kunst
(Ausstellungskatalog, MittelrheinMuseum, Koblenz, 2006/07; Verffentlichungen der
LandesarchivverwaltungRheinlandPfalz,107)(Koblenz,2006).
Die Trken vor Wien. Europa und die Entscheidung an der Donau 1683, ed. Robert Waissenberger
(SalzburgWien,1982).
TurcsetturqueriesXVIXVIIIesicles,ed.LucienBly(Paris,2009).
Vavra, Elisabeth, Adelige Lustbarkeiten, in Adel im Wandel. PolitikKulturKonfession 15001700,
(Ausstellungskatalog,Rosenburg,1990),pp.42841,18.0418.10.
ISBN9789460184833
330
Venturini, Elena, Le collezioni Gonzaga. Il carteggio tra le Corte Cesarea e Mantova (15591636).
Fonti,repertoriestudiperlastoriadiMantova(CollanadelCentroInternazionaledArteediCultura
diPalazzoTe)(MantovaMilano,2002).
Verdadera, y nueva relacion de la Real salida, que hizo en publico nuestro Gran Monarca Carlos
Segundo(queDiosguarde)dargraciasN.SeoradeAtocha;porlafelizvitoria,quehantenidolas
ArmasImperiales,ylasdelReydePolonia,contraelGranTurco,sobreelgrancercodeViena,Lunes
8.deNoviembredeesteaode1683.DasecuentadelosSeores,Titulos,yGrandesdeEspaa,que
acompaavansuMagestad.S.l.,s.n.,s.a.[1683].
ViajedeTurquaatribudoaCristbaldeVillaln.EdicinyprlogodeAntonioG.Solalinde(Madrid,
1919).
Vimina,Alberto,Lagara.Operadrammaticarappresentatainmusicaperintroduzioneditorneofatto
in Vienna per la nascita della Serenissima Infanta di Spagna Donna Margarita Maria dAvstria
dedicata a Sua Eccellenza il Signore Marchese di Castel Rodrigo Gentilhuomo della Camera di S.
MaestCattolica,delsuo Conseglio,esuoambasciatoreestraordinarioincortecesareadaAlberto
Vimina(Wien,1652).
Vocelka, Karl, Habsburgische Hochzeiten 15501600. Kulturgeschichtliche Studien zum
manieristischen Reprsentationsfest (Verffentlichungen der Kommission fr Neuere Geschichte
sterreichs,65)(WienKlnGraz,1976).
Vocelka,Karl,DieWienerFestederfrhenNeuzeitinwaffenkundlicherSicht,JahrbuchdesVereins
frGeschichtederStadtWien,34(1978),13348.
WatanabeOKelly, Helen, Triumphall Shews: Tournaments at GermanSpeaking Courts in Their
EuropeanContext15601730(Berlin,1992).
Weigel, Hans, Trachtenbuch. Darin fast allerley und der frnembsten Nationen, die heutigstags
bekandtsein,Kleidungen,beydewieesbeyMannsundWeibspersonengebreuchlich,mitallemvlei
abgerissen sein, sehr lustig und kurzweilig zusehen (Nrnberg, 1577; Faksimile: Unterschneidheim,
1969).
Winkler, Gerhard, Das Turnierbuch Hans Francolins, Wissenschaftliche Mitteilungen aus dem
NiedersterreichischenLandesmuseum,1(1979),pp.10520.
Wir sind Helden. Habsburgische Feste in der Renaissance, ed. Wilfried Seipel (Ausstellungskatalog,
SchlossAmbras,Innsbruck,2005).
Wirrich, Heinrich, Ordenliche Beschreibung des Christlichen / Hochlblichen vnd Frstlichen Beylags
oder Hochzeit / so da gehalten ist worden durch den Durchleuchtigsten / Hochgebornen Frsten
vnndHerrn/HerrnCAROLEN/ErtzhertzogzuOsterreich/Burgund/Steyr/Krnten/Crayn/Graff
zuTirol/ZilljvndGrtz/etc.mitdemHochgebornenFrwleinMaria/geborneHertzoginzuBayrn/
denXXVI.AugustiinderKayserlichenStattWienn/demHochermeltenFrstenvnndFrwlein/auch
jrer beyder Hochlblichen Freundtschafft zu den hhisten Ehren in Teutsche Carmina gestelt: Vnd
einemEdlen/EhrvndVesten/WolweisenRaht/derFrstlichenHauptstattGrtzinderSteyrmarck
ISBN9789460184833
331
dediciert/DurchHeinrichenWirrich/ObristerPritschenmaisterinOsetrreich/BurgerauffderZell/
inderHerrschafftGley/anderYpsgelegen(Wien,1571).
Witzmann, Reingard, Trkenkopf und Trkenkugel. Einige Trkenmotive und Bildvorstellungen der
Volkskulturausdem17.Und18.Jahrhundert,inDieTrkenvorWien.EuropaunddieEntscheidung
anderDonau1683,ed.RobertWaissenberger(SalzburgWien,1982),pp.291303.
Witzmann, Reingard, Trkenkopf und Trkenkugel, in Die Trken vor Wien. Europa und die
EntscheidunganderDonau1683(SonderausstellungdesHistorischenMuseumsderStadtWien,83)
(Wien,1983),pp.2825.
Wrede, Martin, Trkenkrieger, Trkensieger. Leopold I. und Ludwig XIV. als Retter und Ritter der
Christenheit, in BourbonHabsburgOranien. Konkurrierende Modelle im dynastischen Europa um
1700, ed. Christoph Kampmann, Katharina Krause, EvaBettina Krems, Anuschka Tischer (Kln
WeimarWien,2008),pp.14965.
Zimic,Stanislav,Elamantecelestinoylosamoresentrecruzadosenalgunasobrascervantinas:Los
baosdeArgelyLostratosdeArgel,BoletndelaBibliotecaMenndezPelayo,40(1964),pp.362
87.
Zimic,Stanislav,ElteatrodeCervantes(Madrid,1992).
Zwiedineck,Hansvon,DieHochzeitsfeierErzherzogKarlsII.mitMariavonBaiern,Mitteilungendes
historischenVereinesfrSteiermark,47(1899),pp.193213.
Abbildungen
Abb.1Wien,sterreichischeNationalbibliothek,406.766B.Mus.
Abb.2Madrid,BibliotecaNacionaldeEspaa,T12709.
Abb.34Wien,KunsthistorischesMuseum,Bilddatenbank.
Abb.56WirsindHelden2005,p.68.
Abb.9ImLichtedesHalbmonds,p.121.
Abb.12FederschmuckundKaiserkrone1992,p.140.
ISBN9789460184833
332
Abb.15Weigel1969,CLXXXVIIundCCXVII.
Abb.17http://www.habsburger.net/de/kapitel/tuerkenkopfstechenamhof
Abb.1820DenkmlerdesTheaters,MappeVI:CharlesPerrault,Coursesdetestesetbagues.
Abb.2122Freydal(FaksimilevonLeitner188082),Bl.172und203.
Abb.2324DenkmlerdesTheaters,MappeI:L.O.Burnacini,Maschere.
Abb.25akgImages.

* Die vorliegende Studie erhebt keinerlei Anspruch auf Vollstndigkeit, sondern beschrnkt sich auf einige
besonderssignifikanterscheinendeBeispieledermedialenUmsetzungdesTrkenbildesinTheaterundFestan
densterreichischenundspanischenHabsburgerhfen.
1
Kbdebo1876.Sturminger1955.Grothaus1985.Schilling2008.
2
SommerMathis2013.
3
FerdinandusQuintus1684.Staudt1981.
4
FerdinandusQuintus1684:SCENAVI.MaurisSociataHebrorumgensHispaniexturbatur./DenenMohren
beygeselltesJuden=GesindlwirdauSpanienvertrieben.
5
Vgl.zuweiterenmusikalischenDarstellungenderZweitenWienerTrkenbelagerungu.a.Riedel1982.
6
Vgl.zuLeopoldI.alsTrkenkriegerundsieger,Wrede2008.
7
Arce1684.Smieja1983,p.408.Sabik1993.Sabik1997,p.306.SanzAyn2006,p.125.
8
Salidaenpublico1683,pp.714.Verdadera,ynuevarelacion1683.Robles1683.
9
Mas1967,vol.II,pp.197.
10
Einen Sonderfall stellt Cristbal de Castillejo dar, der ab 1525 am Wiener Hof lebte und daher auch die
SchlachtvonMohcs1526sowiedieAngriffeaufWienindenJahren1529und1532ausunmittelbarerNhe
miterlebte;erthematisierteseineErfahrungenzwarinseinenDichtungen,verfassteaberkeinetheatralischen
Werke;vgl.Laferl,1997.
11
HernandoandEspejo2002.Mas1967,vol.I,pp.5763;vol.II,pp.23940.
12
Miln1874.
13
Merle2009,pp.147150.
14
BereitsumdieMittedes16.Jahrhunderts(WidmungandenspanischenKnigPhilippII.vom1.Mrz1557)
entstandderRomanElviajedeTurqua,dessenanonymerAutoreindetailreichesBildderosmanischen
GesellschaftundKulturausderSichteinesspanischenGefangeneninKonstantinopelzeichnet;ViajedeTurqua
1919.
15
LassodelaVega1983.Mas,vol.I,pp.17983.
16
Mas1967,vol.I,pp.18388.
17
Mas1967,vol.I,pp.289383.MrquezVillanueva1991,2005,2010.
18
AvalleArce1968.MrquezVillanueva1975.McGaha1996.Sola1995.Snchez1997.
19
Zimic1964.Zimic1992,pp.3756,13955.Meregalli1972.Fernndez2000.
20
Cervantes1615.Mas1967,vol.I,pp.34153;vol.II.,pp.38890,42023.Zimic1992,pp.183203.
21
ElgallardoespaolspielteinOrn(Zimic1992,pp.87117);einweiteresDrama,Labatallanaval,bezogsich
aufdieSeeschlachtvonLepanto,istaberverlorengegangen.
22
Mas1967,vol.I,pp.385504.
23
LopedeVegaCarpio1969,pp.30143.DerTitelmssteeigentlichergnztwerdenzuElcercodeVienayel
socorroporCarlosV.
24
Petritsch2002,pp.66774.
25
MenndezyPelayo1969,pp.4245.
ISBN9789460184833
333

26
Sells Ferrando 1993, p. 171; 2004, p. 49f. Laferl 1994, p. 71f. Schreder 1995, pp. 3234. SommerMathis
2001,pp.64851;2002,pp.71719.
27
LpezdeHoyos1572,ff.3441.ChavesMontoya1985,pp.13133.ChavesMontoya1989,p.94.
28
Gualterotti1589,ff.37v39v.Blumenthal1980,p.5.SommerMathis2001,p.644;2002,p.713.
29
SellsFerrando1993,p.171.2004,pp.3751.
30
RojasZorrilla.SommerMathis2001,p.651;2002,p.719f.
31
Sandoval1955/56.
32
Mas1967,vol.II,pp.795.
33
Pfaffenbichler1992,pp.2124;2003,p.278f.WirsindHelden2005,pp.12,6774(Kat.Nr.3.13.6).Bzek
2009,pp.21518.Dmitrieva2013,pp.3216.
34
Pfaffenbichler1995/96,pp.97,246f.Schnitzer1995/96,pp.231f.Dmitrieva2013,pp.321f.
35
Pfaffenbichler1992,pp.23f.;2003,pp.278f.
36
Francolin1561,1566.Venturini2002,pp.17481.Winkler1979.Vavra1990.Pfaffenbichler1992,pp.2428;
2003,pp.27981.WirsindHelden2005,Kat.Nr.3.123.14.
37
Kissling1964.Hfert2003.Phringer2005.Schilling2008.
38
SommerMathis2010,p.84.Karner2013,pp.1225.
39
WatanabeOKelly1992.Schnitzer1999,pp.11219.
40
Fonteius1571.Wirrich1571.Stubenrauch1837.Zwiedineck1899.Vocelka1976,pp.7883;1978.DaCosta
Kaufmann1978,pp.3340.SommerMathis1992,pp.136,140,145,279;2010,pp.86f.Pfaffenbichler1992,
pp.2831.Bzek2009,pp.22529.
41
GiuseppeArcimboldo1983.Arcimboldo2008,pp.24365;Beyer2008,pp.24547.
42
Ortelius1570.Poeschel1985,Kat.Nr.4.Pollero1992,pp.83,247(Kat.Nr.4.20).
43
Ponce1982,p.175.
44
MonforteyHerrera,ff.47v48r.
45
Monforte y Herrera 1622, f. 48r: Tan galanes salieron los Turcos, que fue menester ponerles cerca la
hermosuradelosAlemanes,parahumillarlos.
46
Prohaska1982,pp.25156.
47
Brooks1988,pp.14854.
48
Ponce1982,p.169:Despuesveniaunadanadeperegrinavistayinuencion.Erandozegalerasbienhechas,
y naturales, con tres arboles cada una. Entenas, velas, y jarcias, llenas de vanderolas, flamulas y gallardetes.
Estaserantanligeras,aunquegrandes,quecadaunalasustentauaunhombremetidoenella,desuertequeel
mediocuerposaliaentrelasobrasmuertas,ylaparteinferioryuacubiertaconlienos,queimitauanlasaguas,
ypendientesdeloshombroslaslleuauantandiestramentequeconellosdanauan,yfingiansubatallaNaual,
seysentragedeTurcos,yseysentrageChristiano.
49
WatanabeOKelly1992.Schnitzer1999,pp.11219.
50
Vimina1652.Dietrich1985.SommerMathis1992,pp.148f.,287(Kat.Nr.7.16).
51
Kretzenbacher 1966, pp. 10532. Witzmann 1982, pp. 291f. Im Lichte des Halbmonds 1995, pp. 233, 256.
Karner2010,pp.12628.Karner2013,pp.125f.
52
Moser1761,p.572.
53
Vgl.auchdasDamenkarussellinderWinterreitschuleunterMariaTheresia(1743).
54
BerichtdesfranzsischenGrafenAugustedeLaGardeChambonas,inKretzenbacher1966,p.127undKarner
2013,p.126.
55
Beschreibung und Abbildung 1658. Solemnia elections 1660. SommerMathis 1992, pp. 149, 283 (Kat.Nr.
7.8);2006,pp.280f.
56
NochdeutlicherwirddieAustauschbarkeitderexotischenKostmebeidemFestaufzug,denderMnchner
Hof zu Ehren des neu gekrnten Kaisers Leopold I. 1658 veranstaltete; hier lassen sich zum Teil auch die
VorlagenfrdieKostmederexotischenVlkerAtlantenundTrachtenbcherfeststellen.Maccioni1658.
Jacquot,Schne1975.Straub,pp.21116.SommerMathis1992,pp.149f.,283f.(Kat.Nr.7.9);2006,pp.282f.
Epp2012.
57
Sbarra1667.HaiderPregler1969.SommerMathis1992,pp.151f.,285f.(Kat.Nr.7.14)
58
Fidler2000.
59
Schumann2003,pp.24354.
60
Perrault1670.SommerMathis1992,pp.152,285.
61
SowohlLeopoldI.alsauchLudwigXIV.lieensichalsTrkenkriegerundTrkensiegerfeiern.Wrede2008.
ISBN9789460184833
334

62
RelationedelliBalletti1636:[]erano[]cosricchigladdobbi,tantalacopiadaironi,&cosabondantile
gioie,cheacrebberomirabilmenteilsplendorequellobenilluminatoteatro[].
63
SommerMathis1992,pp.153f.
64
Schnitzer1995/96,pp.229f.,244f.(Kat.Nr.287ad,288);1999,pp.8195,besonderspp.9395.Dmitrieva
2013,p.322.
65
Trauth2002,2003,2009.
66
Schnitzer1995,pp.30521;1999,pp.22043.
67
Wien,sterreichischesTheatermuseum,Min.20.DenkmlerdesTheaters1925,MappeI.BiachSchiffmann
1931,pp.7184.Solf1975.SommerMathis1992,pp.154f.,289f.(Kat.Nr.7.2122);2004,pp.24547.
68
Etwa1665beimEinzugdestrkischenGrobotschaftersMehmedBassainWien.
69
Wien,sterreichischesTheatermuseum,Min.20/6175:Turchi.
70
Vgl.dazudieum1665entstandeneTurquerievonPettau/Ptuj,dieauf47lgemldeneuropischeHerrscher
undMiltrs,aberauchosmanischeundtatarischeWrdentrgerundSoldatenzeigt,diemitdemTrkenkrieg
von1663/64undderkaiserlichenGrobotschaftvon1665/66inZusammenhangstanden,danebenOrientalen
undOrientalinnensowieexotischeSujets.Grothaus1992.
71
DartoisLapeyre2009,pp.16380.
72
Kopplin1987.Kreidt1987.Kleinlogel1989.DieTrkenkommen2006.Turcsetturqueries2009.
ISBN9789460184833
335
TheSpanishHabsburgsandtheArts
ofIslamicIberia
CatherineWilkinsonZerner

SpanishHabsburgswereacutelysensitivetoIslamicpresenceintheirterritories.BothCharlesVand
PhilipII,forexample,bannedtheuseofArabicandNorthAfricanlanguagesaswellasIslamicdressin
Catholic Spain. The Moriscosa nominally Christian but formerly Islamic population living outside
Granadahad been allowed to retain aspects of their Moorish identity, including language and
dress. They rebelled in 1568 when these privileges were withdrawn. When the rebellion had been
putdown,PhilipIIorderedtheMoriscosdispersedandresettledindifferentpartsofthecountryand
hisson,PhilipIII,finallyorderedthemdeportedtoNorthAfricaandotherforeignlandsin160910.
TheSpanishHabsburgreceptionofIslamicartparticularlyIslamicarchitecturewasquitedifferent:
they continued to use some Islamic buildings, which they chose to repair and extend rather than
replace; and they integrated some features of Islamic origin into their classicizing Renaissance
palaces.

This makes one wonder what earlier Islamic art meant to these rulers. There is little
scholarshiponthisissue,buttworesponsesbyearlymodernSpaniardstoIslamicartinSpainhave
beenproposed:1)first,andmostgenerally,thatbythesixteenthcenturysomefeaturesofMoorish
architecturehadbeensocompletelyassimilatedintotheartisticcultureofCatholicSpainthatthey
werenolongerperceivedasIslamic;2)secondly,thatsomeIslamicbuildingsliketheGreatMosque
atCrdobaandtheAlhambraPalaceinGranadaweretakenoverbytheChristiansandpreservedas
trophiesofSpanishvictoriesoverMuslims.Asaconsequence,itisargued,afewMoorishbuildings
becamemonumentsofSpanishidentity.1Thereiscertainlysometruthintheseassertions:elaborate
woodinlaidMoorishceilings,generallyknownasartesonados,werewidelyusedinchurchesinthe
sixteenth century and the techniques for building them were exported to the Americas, none of
which would have been likely if artesonados had been closely identified with Islam.2 The Catholic
KingsmovedintotheAlhambraPalaceandpreserveditaftertheconquestofGranada.Later,Charles
V spent his honeymoon there and added some rooms; he also decorated one of the Moorish
receptionroomswithhisdevicePlvsVltra,executedincoloredtile,whichwascertainlyasignofthe
Emperors appropriation of the palace (fig. 1). However, I wish to suggest that the reception of
IslamicartbytheSpanishHabsburgswassomewhatmorecomplexthanthesetwooptionssuggest.
In this paper I will try to bring their reactions into clearer focus by looking briefly at how they
adoptedpreviousCastilianroyalandaristocraticusesofIslamicart.
ISBN9789460184833
336

Fig.1EmblemofEmperorCharlesVintheAlhambraPalace,Granada.

First, however, it may be useful briefly to describe the older and broader assimilation of
IslamicartintheIberianPeninsulathatformsthebackdroptoSpanishHabsburgresponses.Moorish
buildinganddecorativepracticeshaddeeplymarkedthebuildingtradesinCastileandAragonwhere
the Arab origin of numerous words for building techniques and materialssuch as azulejos [fired
ceramictiles],albail[mason]andalarife[skilledartisan]wasmadeperfectlyclearbySebastinde
CovarrubiasinhisDictionarywritteninthelatesixteenthcentury.3TheCastilianwordsforpaneled
inlaid wooden ceilings and the intricately decorated wooden ceilings to which they referred
alfarjeswereunderstoodasMoorish(fig.2).4

Fig.2Moorishceilingofthepresent
church,MonasteryofSantaClara,
Tordesillas,14thcentury.
ISBN9789460184833
337
Certain professions also seem to have been dominated by artisans of Moorish heritage still in the
sixteenthcentury.Thesubjecthasnotbeeninvestigatedcomprehensivelybut,inthebuildingtrades,
gessoworkers[yeseros]andcarpenters[carpinteros]oftenhadMoorishnamesinCastile.Suchmen
were mostly nominally Christians or Mudjares, the descendents of Islamic people who had
remained in Spain and converted to Christianity in the wake of Christian conquests of Moorish
kingdoms from the eleventh through fifteenth centuries.5 Thus a wide range of originally Islamic
techniquesandmotifssurvivedinCastilianbuildingtradeswhenCharlesVarrivedinSpainin1517.
Their Moorish ancestry was clear from the Arabic words that described them, but they appear to
haveceasedtobeassociatedspecificallywithIslam:MoorishwasnolongernecessarilyIslamicinthe
realmofthearts.
ThesurvivalofMoorisharchitecturalformsmayalsohavebeenaidedbynorthernarchitects
workinginLateGothicstylewhoimmigratedtoCastileinthelaterfifteenthcentury.JuanGuas(from
Brittany)andSimndeColonia(fromGermany)wereclearlyimpressedbytheMoorisharchitecture
they saw in Spain. Juan Guas included a splendid Moorish wooden ceiling in the monumental
staircase of his Colegio de San Gregorio in Valladolid and his treatment of the stairwell suggests,
althoughitdoesnotcopy,themotifsofMoorishmuralgessodecoration(fig.3).6Wedonotknowif
Guashadlearnedtodesigntheseceilingshimself,orwhetherheengagedMudjarcarpentersforthe
designaswellastheexecution,butheclearlyembracedthetradition.Guasprovidedanothershowy
alfarje in the upper cloister above his Gothic vaults in the Monastery of San Juan de los Reyes in
Toledo.
Traces of Castilian appreciation of Moorish technique may still be seen in the sixteenth
century.ThehighlyoriginalvaultofthecrossingoftheChurchofSanGernimoinGranadadesigned
in the 1520s by the great Renaissance architect Diego de Siloe suggests that he was interested in
bothLateGothicandMoorishaswellasclassicizingvaulting(fig.4).

Fig.3JuanGuas,Moorishstyleceilingand
stairwellinColegiodeSanGregorio,Valladolid,
148896.

Fig.4DiegodeSiloe,CrossingvaultofSanGernimo,
Granada,late1520s.

ISBN9789460184833
338
CastilianroyalandaristocratictasteforMoorishartshouldbeseenagainstthebackdropof
thiswidespreadanddiffusedappreciation,butdiffersfromitinoneimportantway:worksmadefor
the royal and aristocratic elite did not necessarily mask or dilute their Moorish ancestry; on the
contrary, their Moorish character was strongly marked. Although we cannot know if the patrons
perceivedsuchworksasIslamic,knowingwhattheypurchasedandbuilttellsusagooddeal.
TheappropriationofexistingIslamicpalacesbyChristianrulersoftenbythesimplegesture
ofaffixingtheirseigniorialcoatofarmsoremblemstothebuildingwasalongstandingroyaland
aristocraticpractice.Palaceswerepowerfulsymbolsofthevanquishedenemy,likethebootytaken
fromthebattlefield,e.g.thesplendidwoventent[pendn]oftheAlmohadeCalifMuhammadAn
Nasir,whichwascapturedattheBattleofLasNavasdeTolosain1212andisnowintheMuseode
TelasRicasintheCistercianMonasteryofLasHuelgasoutsideBurgos.ButChristiankingsandnobility
alsocommissionedluxurioussilksandceramicsfromartisansintheIberianIslamicstates.Beautiful
Moorish lusterware fromValencia was purchased by noble families in Spain and Italy well into the
fifteenthcentury.

Fig.5FaadeofPedrotheCruelsPalaceattheAlczaresReales
inSeville,after1350.

Fig.6DetailofdecorationofPedrotheCruelsroomsatAlczares
Reales,Seville,after1350.

Castilian nobility went further than merely collecting luxury goods from their Moorish
enemies. In the fourteenth and early fifteenth century, Spanish Christian rulers also built entirely
new palaces in homogenous Islamic style. Alfonso XI built one at Tordesillas, which is now the
Monastery of Santa Clara. A magnificent gilded ceiling of Mudjar woodwork survives from the
fourteenthcentury palace in the present church (see fig. 2).7 Most famously, Pedro I the Cruel
(13341369)builtalavishnewpalaceintheoldAlczaresRealesinSevilleduringthesecondhalfof
the fourteenth century (figs. 5 and 6). The faade has inscriptions in Arabic script, as well as a
Moorishdesignanddecorativescheme.TopatronslikeKingPedro,Islamicarchitecturerepresented
morethanpower.Itsignifiedeliteculture,thehighestlevelofmagnificenceandluxury.Thesplendid
rooms of Pedros palace were designed and decorated by fourteenthcentury Mudjar artisans,
descendants ofMoorishartisanswhohadstayedtoliveunderChristianruleaftertheConquestof
Muslim Seville by Fernando III in 1248. These designers and craftsmen maintained the techniques
ISBN9789460184833
339
and materials of earlier Andalusian Islamic architecture: colorful tile work, molded and painted
plasterworkornament,andelaboratelycarvedanddecoratedwoodenceilingsandcupolasandother
woodworklikedoorsandshuttersdecoratedwiththegeometricallypatternedornament.

Moorish architecture seems to have continued to represent a standard of elegance and
luxury in fifteenthcentury Castile. The great festival halls of the royal alczares at Segovia and
Madrid (destroyed) built for the Trastamara king, Enrique IV in the 1460s, were in Moorish style.
AlthoughtheCatholicKingswereavidconsumersofNorthernEuropeanart,includingtapestriesand
Flamboyantarchitecture,theyoccasionallydressedupinMoorishclothingandcontinuedtousetheir
Islamic palaces in Aragon, Andaluca and Valencia as well as Castile. They also patronized Moorish
architectural style. They occupied and repaired the Islamic Aljafera in Zaragoza. In the late 1480s
they began remodeling and added a second story to this palace with a splendid gilded coffered
artesonadothatwasexecutedbytheMudjararchitectsofthepalace(fig.7).8

TheappropriationofMoorisharchitecturebyroyalandaristocraticChristiansthushadalong
historyinSpain,whereitseemstohavebeenassociatedwithsplendorandluxury.Thegeometryand
decorativerichnessofMoorishvaultsandceilingsalsoappealedtonorthernersraisedonFlamboyant
stylewhich may partly explain the Emperor Charles Vs delight in the palace and gardens of the
AlhambrainGranadaandhisconstructionofasmallpavilioninthegardensattheAlczarinSeville
(fig.8).

Fig.7CeilingofthegreathallbuiltforCatholicKingsinthe
Aljafera,Zaragoza.

Fig.8GardenpavilionofCharlesVinthegardensoftheAlczares
Reales,Seville,firstquarterofthe16thcentury.

The placement of this structure at some distance from the palace in the midst of carefully
plannedvegetationrecallsthesmallgardenbuildingsthatwerearegularfeatureofIslamicpalaces.
In the eleventh century, Almamun, the Islamic Taifa ruler of Toledo, constructed a huge pleasure
(and productive) garden in the vega near the Tagus river below the Alczar. In 1072 Almamun
welcomedAlfonsoVIofCastileandlodgedhiminoneofthesplendidpavilionsinthegarden.Alfonso
ISBN9789460184833
340
X was born in the small Islamic palace, now called La Galiana, near the river outside Toledo. Texts
suggest that there were pavilions in Abd al Rahman IIIs princely city of Medinat alZahara near
CrdobainthetenthcenturyandatthelaterAlhambraPalaceinGranada.Thesegardensandtheir
Moorishpavilionshavemostlydisappeared.9

Fig.9JacquesAndrouetDuCerceau,gardenpavilionatChateauofBlois,afterBoudonandMinot2010.
OnemightobjectthatthereisnoneedtolooktoIslamicprecedentswhenmoreimmediate
sources for Charles Vs building in Seville can be found in the royal and seigniorial pavilions that
Charlesknewfromhischildhoodinthenorth.ThepleasuregardensofFrenchandFlemishchteaux
often included small buildings set in the midst of plantings at some distance from the residence.
Thesestructuresdonotsurviveeither,butthedrawingsoftheFrenchChteauxbyJacquesAndrouet
Du Cerceau often show them. Several of his views of Blois show small, centralized pavilions of the
samediminutivescaleandclassicizingstyleofthepavilioninSeville(fig.9).10
LookingmorecloselyatthepavilioninSeville,however,onecanseethatthematerialsand
composition are different from northern examples (figs. 10 and 11). Brightly colored tiles are
extensivelyusedontheoutsidesandinsidesofthelowwallsurroundingtheEmperorspavilion;the
columns are raised on freestanding pedestals that are not classical or northern Renaissance in
inspiration.Althoughthecompositecapitalsandroundarchesareclassical,theslenderproportions
andwidespacingofthecolumnsofthearcadethatsurroundstheexteriorofthepavilionhavemore
in common with Islamic porticosas in the pavilion in the gardens of the Generalife in Granada
thanwitheitherLateGothicstyleorCinquecentoclassicism.
ISBN9789460184833
341

Fig.10CharlesVsgardenpavilionatthe
AlczaresReales,Seville,interior.
Fig.11CharlesVsgardenpavilionattheAlczares
Reales,Seville,detailoftilework.

Insidethepavilion,thewallsarepartlycoveredinglazedtileandthereisacarvedwooden
ceilingabove.ThemoststrikingMoorishfeatureofthepavilion,however,isthesmallfountainatits
center. Interior pools fed by circulating fresh water were common in Islamic palaces but were not
muchusedinSpanishChristianarchitecture,asfarasIknow.11ThispoolorfountaininCharlesVs
pavilionrecallsthesimilarinteriorpoolintheAlczaritselfoneofthefewsurvivingelementsfrom
theIslamicpalacewhichexistedonthesitebeforethecitywasfinallytakenin1248(fig.12).
In spite of these seemingly Moorish elements, the pavilion does not represent a revival of
Islamicarchitecture.Thetileandgessodecorationisplacedhighonthewallbelowtheornamented
ceilingasitmightbeinaMoorishorMudjarbuilding,butgeometricdesignsarereplacedwithmore
naturalisticfloraltiles,andthefriezeabovethetilesconsistsofCharlesVsmottoPlvsVltraandcoat
of arms repeated. The white molded gesso frieze has GrecoRoman figuralnot Moorishcontent
(fig. 13). The syntax of the composition is Islamic, but the motifs are Renaissance: they have been
translatedfromMoorishintoaclassicalidiom.
The pavilion signals some degree of acceptance of Islamic typology, techniques and
aesthetics at the Emperors court. One can perhaps say that the small pool in the interior was
inspiredbythepoolintheearlierIslamicpalace.Doesthismeanthatthedesignersandpatronno
longerrecognizeditsstyleasIslamicorMoorish?ThatseemshardlycredibleattheAlczarinSeville,
whichinallrespects,excepttheverbalandheraldicreferencestoitsChristianpatronage,isaworkof
Moorisharchitecture.Centuriesofappropriation,adaptationandimitationofIslamicarchitecturein
a Christian context may not have completely expunged its associations with Islam in the early
sixteenthcenturybuttheycertainlydilutedthem.
ISBN9789460184833
342

Fig.12Interiorpoolfromremains
ofMoorishpalaceatAlczarez
Reales,Seville,before1248.

Fig.13InteriorofCharlesVsgarden
pavilionattheAlczaresReales,
Seville,1520s,detailofmural
tilework.
Fig.14InteriorofCharlesVsgarden
pavilionattheAlczaresReales,
Seville,1520s,detailofthefriezeand
theceiling.
Onthecontrary,CharlesVwasaRenaissanceprinceandacollectorofexotictreasuresand
artifactssuchasAztecfeatherworkfromthestillnonChristianculturesthatmadeuphisrealms
from the 1520s onwards. Of all people with Humanist training, he was in a good position to
historicize such artifacts; seeing them as the productions of cultures separated from his own. To
paraphraseErwinPanofskysfamouscharacterization:becausetheClassicalworldwasperceivedas
separatedintimefromcontemporarysocietybytheMiddleAges,itcouldbeappreciatedforitself
and so could the Middle Ages. Renaissance patrons and their artists, who could reunite classical
subject matter with classical form, could by extension have seen Moorish style in a similar way:
sunderedfromcontemporaryRenaissanceartandsoavailableforselectiveandselfconsciousreuse
foraestheticpurposes.12
Although we cannot know Charles Vs motivations in commissioning the pavilion in the
gardens of the Alczar of Seville, it seems clear from the forms of the pavilion that Moorish
architecture, which had seemed the necplus ultra of civilized life to Pedro the Cruel in the
fourteenthcentury,hasbeendesignedtoharmonizewiththeClassicalworldofGreeceandRome.
This creates an explicit layer of cultural dominancethe GrecoRomanover the residual and still
present echoes of the Islamic past. Were it not for their context among Charles Vs additions to
Pedros palace, the figural tiles with Italianate grotteschi decoration would not themselves suggest
theMoorishdecorationthatisallaroundthem.
In the sixteenth century there were aristocratic patrons, like Don Fadrique Enriquez de
RiberaMarquisofTarifa,whowantedtocombineGrecoRomanclassicismwithMoorishstyle,and
artisanswhocouldproducesuchwork.DonFadriquewasasophisticatedpatronwithamarkedtaste
forGrecoRomanart.HeacquiredagooddealofRomansculptureandcommissionedaRenaissance
portal, which was carved in Italian marble and shipped from Genoa, for his Casa de Pilatos in
ISBN9789460184833
343
Seville.13 The tile decoration of the courtyard and staircase in the Casa de Pilatos from the 1540s,
however,isclearlyMoorishininspiration(fig.14).

PhilipIIsappreciationofMoorisharchitectureappearstohavebeensimilartohisfathers.In
the 1550s, he ordered one of the Castilian royal architects, Luis de Vega, to add a second story to
partofKingPedrosAlczarinSevilleinthePatiodelasDoncellas,whereVegasarcadesoftheupper
galleryrespectthematerialsandcolorsoftheMoorishlevelbellow.Healsodoubledcolumnsatthe
cornersandatintervalsalongthearcade.Theclassicalmoldings,archesandRenaissancebalustrade
harmonizeasmuchaspossiblewiththeMoorishornament(fig.15).

Fig.15CasadePilatos,Seville,detailoftileworkinmainpatio.

Fig.16PatiodelasDoncellasinAlczaresReales,Seville,upper
storeybyLuisdeVegain1550s.

ItmaybepossibleonthebasisofthisbriefoverviewtoconsiderSpanishHabsburgpractice
inrelationtotheproposedinterpretationwithwhichIbegan:thattheSpanishChristianreactionto
theirMoorishheritagewaseither1)tocelebrateobjectsandbuildingsasbootyfromvictoriesover
the Moors (e.g. the Alhambra) or 2) simply to forget the Islamic origin of Moorish work (e. g.
artesonados by Mudjar artisans) under Christian domination. Although the preservation of some
Islamic buildings captured from the Moors and the wide use of Moorishstyle wooden ceilings in
Christian buildings occurred after the Conquest, these two interpretations do not describe the
receptionofMoorishartbytheSpanishHabsburgsinasatisfactoryway.

TheSpanishHabsburgsseemmuchclosertotheCastilianroyalandaristocratictraditionof
appreciationforMoorishandMudjarart.Thisshouldnotbesurprising:theadmirationofAlfonsoX
the Wise (12211284) for Islamic science, philosophy and literature as well as practical arts like
Islamic medicine and agriculture in the thirteenth century are well known and documented. It is, I
think, obvious even from the little that I have presented here that the elites favorable view of
Moorishculturealsoembracedthearts.
Atissuehereistheseparationofcultureandreligion:Islamicculturewaswidelyadmiredin
EarlyModernCastileinthefullknowledgethatitwasIslamic,evenasthatculturesreligiousbeliefs
ISBN9789460184833
344
were entirely rejected. The first two Spanish Habsburg kings, the emperor Charles V and his son
PhilipIIwerebothbroughtupintheHumanistrevivalofclassicalculturebutbothwerecapableof
admiringLateGothicarchitecturePhilipIIissaidtohavecalledtheFlamboyantcrossingtowerof
Burgos cathedral a work of angelsand, I suggest, Moorish architecture also. This appreciation
might seem natural in a Renaissance context, but it is worth noting that Spanish Habsburg
acceptanceofMoorisharchitecturewasneitherinevitablenorunprecedented.WhentheNormans
conqueredIslamicSicilytheybroughttheirnorthernarchitecturaltraditionwiththem,buttheyalso
adoptedtheByzantinemosaicsandIslamicdecorationthattheyfoundflourishingontheisland.The
CathedralofMonreale,builtbetween1174and1182combinesallthreetosumptuouseffect.

Bibliography

Boudon, Franoise and Mignot, Claude, Jacques Androuet Du Cerceau. Dessins des Plus Excellents
BtimentsdeFrance(Paris,2010).

CabaeroSubiza,Bernab,LaAljafera(Zaragoza,1998).

Cabaero Subiza, Bernab, El Saln dorado de la Aljafera: ensayo de reconstitucin formal e
interpretacinsimblica(Zaragoza,2004).

Chueca Goitia, Fernando, Consideraciones varias sobre la arquitectura mudjar, Papeles de
Arquitectura Espaola, 1, Fundacin Cultural Santa Teresa e Instituto de Arquitectura Juan de
Herrera,(Avila,1994)pp.316

Chueca Goitia, Fernando, Invariantes castizos de la arquitectura espaola (1947) reprinted with
InvariantesenlaarquitecturahispanoamericanaandManifestodelaAlhambra(Madrid,1981).

Covarrubias,Sebastinde,Tesorodelalenguacastellanaoespaola.Edicinintegraleilustradade
IgnacioArellanoyRafaelZafra(BibliotecaureaHispnica,21),(Pamplona,2006).

Domnguez Casas, Rafael, Arte y etiqueta de los Reyes Catlicos: artistas, residencias, jardines y
bosques(Madrid,1993).

Grinstead,Eve,AbsorbingtheMudjar.TheIslamicImprintontheSpanishArchitecturalAesthetic,
JournalofArtHistory,4(2009),pp.19[http://journal.utarts.com/articles].

Lobo, A., Campaa general de restauracin en el Real Monasterio de Tordesillas, Reales Sitios.
RevistadelPatrimonioNacional,XXVII,106(1990),pp.2154.

LpezdeArenas,Diego,Brevecompendiodelacarpinteradeloblancoytratadodealarifes,conla
conclusion de la regla de Nicols Tartaglia, y otras cosas tocantes a la Geometria y puntas de
compassporelMaestrodedichooficio,yAlcaldedeAlarifeenl,naturaldelaVilladeMarchena,y
vezinodelaCiudaddeSevilla(Sevilla,1633).

LpezGuzmn,Rafael,Arquitecturamudjar:delsincretismomedievalalasalternativasamericanas
(Madrid,2000).

Panofsky,Erwin,ThefirstpageofVasarisLibro:AStudyontheGothicStyleintheJudgmentofthe
ISBN9789460184833
345
Italian Renaissance With, an Excursus on Two Facade Designs by Domenico Beccafumi, in E.
Panofsky,MeaningintheVisualArts:PapersinandonArtHistory(GardenCity,N.Y.,1955),pp.169
235.

Ruggles,D.Fairchild,Gardens,Landscape,andVisioninthePalacesofIslamicSpain(UniversityPark
PA.,2000).

Sebastin, Santiago, Henares Cullar, Ignacio and Morales, Alfredo, El mudjar iberoamericano: del
IslamalNuevomundo(Barcelona,1995).
Illustrations
(Unlessotherwisenoted,photographsarebytheauthor).

Fig.1EmblemofEmperorCharlesVintheAlhambra,Granada.

Fig.2Moorishceilingofthepresentchurch,MonasteryofSantaClara,Tordesillas,fourteenth
century.

Fig.3JuanGuas,MoorishstyleceilingandstairwellinColegiodeSanGregorio,Valladolid,148896.

Fig.4DiegodeSiloe,CrossingvaultofSanGernimo,Granada,late1520s.

Fig.5FaadeofPedrotheCruelsPalaceattheAlczaresRealesinSeville,after1350.

Fig.6DetailofdecorationofPedrotheCruelsroomsatAlczaresReales,Seville,after1350.

Fig.7CeilingofthegreathallbuiltforCatholicKingsintheAljafera,Zaragoza.

Fig.8GardenpavilionofCharlesVinthegardensoftheAlczaresReales,Seville,firstquarterofthe
sixteenthcentury.

Fig.9JacquesAndrouetDuCerceau,gardenpavilionatChateauofBlois,afterBoudonandMinot
2010.

Fig.10CharlesVsgardenpavilionattheAlczaresReales,Seville,detailoftilework.

Fig.11CharlesVsgardenpavilionattheAlczaresReales,Seville,interior.

Fig.12InteriorpoolfromremainsofMoorishpalaceatAlczarezReales,Seville,before1248.

Fig.13InteriorofCharlesVsgardenpavilionattheAlczaresReales,Seville,1520sdetailofmural
tilework.

Fig.14InteriorofCharlesVsgardenpavilionattheAlczaresReales,Seville,1520s,detailofthe
friezeandtheceiling.

Fig.15CasadePilatos,Seville,detailoftileworkinmainpatio.

Fig.16PatiodelasDoncellasinAlczaresReales,Seville,upperstoreybyLuisdeVegain1550s.

ISBN9789460184833
346

1
ThesetwooptionsarepresentedbyGrinstead2009.Foramorenuancedexaminationoftheassimilationof
IslamicarchitecturalideasinSpanishtraditionseeChuecaGoitia1981.
2
TheIslamicdesignsforthemakingofsuchceilingssurvivedinthepracticeofSpanishcarpenters,buttheir
transmissiontotheAmericaswasprobablyaidedbytheimportanttreatisebyDiegoLpezdeArenas(Sevilla,
1633).SeealsoLpezGuzmn2000andSebastin,HenaresCullar&Morales1995.
3
SeeCovarrubias,Tesoro.ManyFrencharchitecturaltermswereimportedwithRomanesqueandGothicstyle,
e.g.Castilianforvault[bveda]wasnotArabic.
4
SpaniardsreferredtotheIslamicpeoples,bothArabsandNorthAfricans,whopopulatedandruledpartsof
SpainfromthesevenththroughthefifteenthcenturiesasMoors,apracticeIcontinuehere.
5
Covarrubias, Tesoro, defines mudjares (mudexares) as Moors who converted and lived under Christian
domination. The adjective mudjar is now applied to art produced by Christianized Islamic peoples in Spain.
TheMoorishidentityofMudjarartistsandarchitects,someofwhomhadadoptedChristiannames,isoften
mentionedinfifteenthandsixteenthcenturydocuments.SeethedocumentscitedinDomnguezCasas1993
fortheAljaferainZaragoza(p.73f),theAlczarinMadrid(p.62f)andtheAlczarinSeville(pp.6670).Other
Moorishcarpentersarediscussedpp.7482.
6
TheColegiodeSanGregoriowithitsstaircaseandceilinginValladolidwascommissionedbyAlonsodeBurgos
148896.
7
SeeLobo1990forreviewofMoorishvestigesandthemodernrestorationofthepalace.
8
TheMoorisharchitectsworkingfortheCatholicKingswerewellestablishedinZaragoza.FaraigandMahoma
de Gali, called moros in the documents, were masters of the royal works in Zaragoza. See Cabaero Subiza
1998and2004.
9
AveryusefuloverviewisRuggles2000.
10
SeeBoudon&Mignot2010:drawingsofBlois(p.148f)andpavilionsatGailon(pp.12632).DuCerceauwas
aninventivedraughtsmanaswellasatopographicalartistsoitisnotalwayspossibletodetermineifdetailsof
hisdrawingspreciselyreflecttheactualstructures.
11
Krista De Jonge has prepared an article on these northern interior fountains (unpublished; personal
communication).
12
Panofsky1955,pp.168225and226235especiallytheformulationinp.189:ThustheItalianRenaissance
in a first, great retrospective view which dared to divide the development of Western art into three great
periodsdefinedforitselfalocusstandifromwhichitcouldlookbackattheartofclassicalantiquity(alienin
timebutrelatedinstyle)aswellasattheartoftheMiddleAges(relatedintimebutalieninstyle):eachof
thesetwocouldbemeasured,asitwere,byandagainsttheother.Unjustthoughthismethodofevaluation
may appear to us, it meant that, from then on, periods of civilization and art could for understood as
individualitiesandtotalities.
13
CasadePilatoswasbegunafter1519butworkcontinuedintothe1540s.
ISBN9789460184833
347
ListofContributors

Plcs(HungarianAcademyofSciences,InstituteforLiteraryStudies)
JanBaant(InstituteofPhilosophy,AcademyofSciencesoftheCzechRepublic,Prague)
AnnickBorn(GhentUniversity,GhentInterdisciplinaryCentreforArtandScience)
IngridCiulisov(SlovakAcademyofSciences)
KristaDeJonge(KULeuvenUniversityofLeuven)
DagmarEichberger(UniversityTrier&UniversityofHeidelberg)
BernardoJ.GarcaGarca(UniversidadComplutensedeMadrid)
IlariaHoppe(HumboldtUniversityBerlin,InstituteofArtHistory)
AnnemarieJordanGschwend(CentrodeHistriadeAlmMar,Lisbon)
HerbertKarner(AustrianAcademyofSciences)
EvaBettinaKrems(UniversityofMnster,InstituteofArtHistory)
BrunoMeier(Baden,Aargau)
IvanP.Muchka(InstituteofArtHistory,AcademyofSciencesoftheCzechRepublic,Prague)
MiltonPedroDiasPacheco(UniversityofCoimbra&CentreforOverseasHistory)
NicoleRiegel(UniversittWrzburg,InstituteofArtHistory)
LarrySilver(UniversityofPennsylvania)
MadelonSimons(UniversityofAmsterdam,InstituteofArtHistory)
AndreaSommerMathis(AustrianAcademyofSciences,InstituteforCulturalStudiesandTheater
History)
CezaryTaracha(JohnPaulIICatholicUniversityofLublin,Poland)
WernerTelesko(AustrianAcademyofSciences,InstituteofHistoryofArtandMusicology)
CatherineWilkinsonZerner(BrownUniversity,DepartmentoftheHistoryofArtandArchitecture)
ISBN9789460184833
348

PALATIUM ePublication
1

Thisvolumeexaminesthearchitectureandcultureatthevariouscourtsof

oneofEuropesmostimportantroyaldynasties,theHabsburgs.Itlooksfora

specificHabsburgidiominthesphereofprincelyrepresentationatthecourtsin

Madrid,Brussels,Vienna,Prague,BratislavaandBudapest,andcontraststhe

supranationalfeaturesofthisdynasticidentitytoitsregionalincarnations.

Thenucleusofprincelyrepresentationwasthecourtresidence.Hencethe

Habsburgsofficialapartmentsarestudiedinrelationtotheircourtceremony,

toseeifaunifyingmodelwasadoptedinthedifferentpalacesinBrussels,

MadridandCentralEurope.Thesupranationaldynasticidentitydeveloped
bytheHabsburgsisthencomparedwithlocalformsofidentity,as

articulatedbythenobilityinBohemia,HungaryandPoland.Thisshows
howthepalacesandtheirdecorationalsoexpressedloyaltytothe
traditionsofthehomeland,socalledLandespatriotismus.
OtheressaysdiscusshowthespecificreligiouspracticesoftheHabsburgs,
knownasPietasAustriaca,affectedtheart,cultureandarchitectureofthe
differentcourts,andparticularlythestructureandfunctionoftheirsacred
spaces.ThefinalsectionexaminesmanifestationsoftheHabsburgs
selfrepresentationasdefendersoftheFaithagainsttheMuslims
inSpainandCentralEurope,aswellasotherTurkishechoes
inpalatialartinSpainandAustria.
AW,KULeuvenandauthors,2014
ThisworkislicensedunderaCreativeCommonsLicense
ISBN9789460184833
www.courtresidences.eu

86 16 541 1 10 20160407

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

86 16 541 1 10 20160407

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

TheHabsburgsandtheirCourts

DabeisindallerdingsVernderungeninden Geschohhenzu bercksichtigen.Schrift und

starb,galtderorganisatorischen und gestalterischen BesorgungderzeremoniellenZusammenkunft

Abb. 4 Diego Velzquez, Baltasar Carlos mit einem Zwerg,

Abb. 5 Diego Velzquez, Knigin Mariana, um

Abb. 6 Diego Velzquez (Werkstatt), Knigin Mariana,

Fig. 2 Johannes Baptista Manni SJ, HochAdeliche und

Maddalenasselfconcept asholyruler clear:thisis bluntlydisplayedandthusbecomes capableof

designasan earliertapestrycycle, celebrating the militaryspectacleofthe 1525Battle ofPavia(a

Brutigamderebenerstgeborenen Infantinauserkorenwar,sondernauchamnchsten Reichstag

Você também pode gostar