Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
HOME
DoesScienceSaySmartPeopleAreCreative?|TheCreativityPost
ABOUT
CONTACT
EVENTS
CONVERSATIONS
ARCHIVES
SEARCH
PopCulture
Science
Tech
Philosophy
Psychology
Business
Education
45
Create!
Dr. KH Kim
ByDr.KHKim|Oct17,2016
Like
Activism
SUBSCRIBE
Email
RSS
Dr.KimisaprofessorofInnovation&
CreativityattheCollegeofWilliam&
Mary.Sheistheauthorof"The
CreativityChallenge:HowWeCan
RecaptureAmericanInnovation,"
whichwas...
MORE
Synopsis
WhenImovedtoAmerica,Iwashappythatmychildrenwouldnot
experiencethe"examhell"thatAsianchildrenendure.Alas,theyhadto
experiencestandardizedtesting"nightmares"becauseoftheNoChildLeft
BehindAct(NCLB).TheintentionbehindNCLBwastomakeallchildren
smart,butinstead,itleftnochildahead,curious,orcreative.Itresultedin
smarttesttakingskills,notworthwhileskills.Collegesandgraduateschools
increasinglyadmitsmarttesttakers,leavingfutureinnovatorsbehind.
MOST POPULAR
LATEST ENTRIES
Meanwhile,testingcompaniesincreasinglygetricher.
SchoolsuseIQscoresandstandardizedtestscores(whichalsocorrelatetoIQs)to
identifygiftedchildren,favoringacademicachieversandteacherpleasers.This
identificationsystemeliminates70to80percentofthetopcreativechildren,whotend
tobenonconformistsbutarepotentialinnovators.IQscoresarealsooftenusedto
predictfuturepotential,butthisprocessalsoeliminatesmostfutureinnovators,
includingNobelPrizewinnerssuchasWilliamShockleyandLuisAlvarez.
ManypeoplebelievethatIQandcreativityaresynonymous.Manyscholars,for
example,believeinthethresholdtheory,whichsuggeststhatonlythesmartest
peoplelessthantop10percentofthepopulation,withanIQabove120canbe
http://www.creativitypost.com/education/does_science_say_smartest_people_are_creative
1/5
5/11/2016
DoesScienceSaySmartPeopleAreCreative?|TheCreativityPost
creative.Thisassertion,however,isnotsupportedbymyresearch.Instead,Ihave
discoveredthefollowingsurprisingresults:
Get in Shape
1.MetaanalyticstudiesshowthatIQandcreativityareweaklyrelatedatanylevel,
OCTOBER13,2016
suggestingthethresholddoesnotexist.Also,IQdatafrom108countriesshowthat
highnationalIQscorrelatetohighinternationaltestscoresbutnottoahighnumberof
innovators.
Get Connected
RSSFeed
2.ManyofthegreatestinnovatorsinhistorydidnothavehighIQs.Infact,innovators
whoearnedlowgradesinschoolachievedmorerevolutionaryinnovationthanthose
whoearnedhighgrades.
3.AmericansIQsandstandardizedtestscoreshavesteadilyincreasedovertime,but
since1990theircreativity,especiallychildrenscreativity,hasdecreased.This
divergencewouldnotoccurifIQandcreativityweresynonymous.
4.PeoplewithhighIQsexhibitadequateinboxthinking,buttheyareoftenconformists
whoexhibitinadequateoutboxthinking.Creativityismakingsomethinguniqueand
useful,thereforeoutboxthinkingisnecessaryforuniqueideas(inadditiontoinbox
thinkingforusefulideas).
5.Acreationmustbepromotedtoberecognizedasaninnovationbysociety,and
peoplewithhighIQsfindthisendeavordifficult.Promotionrequiresoutboxthinkingto
developauniquewaytoattractattention.Italsorequiresunderstandingothers
emotions(includingtheirwantsandneeds)andcommunicatingfeaturesandbenefits
ofthecreationinaclearandmeaningfulwaythishelpsothersreadilyrecognizethe
valueofthecreation.
6.InsteadofemphasizinghighIQsorotherstandardizedtestscores,theaimshould
betodevelopchildren'ssubjectofCuriosity,Preference,orInterest(CPI)subject
areasthatinspirecuriosity,preference,orenjoymentasearlyaspossible.Children
Archive
November,2016
October,2016
2
15
shouldthenbeencouragedtodevelopexpertiseintheirCPI(athoroughmasteryof
September,2016
knowledgeandskillsofaspecificsubject).Thefoundationofcreativethinking
August,2016
requiresdevelopingexpertiseforatleast10yearsinone'ssubjectofCPI.
SinceNCLBwaspassed,schoolshaveincreasinglycreatedstandardizedtesting
nightmaresbroughtonbystatemandatedtests.TheEveryStudentSucceedsAct
(ESSA)thatwasrecentlypassedalsorequiresmandatorystatetesting.TheseActs
havebeensuccessfulinproducingsmarttesttakersratherthansmartchildren
whilesquashingtheircuriosity.Furthermore,collegeandgraduateschooladmission
proceduresworsenstudents'nightmaresbyheavilyrelyingonstandardizedtestssuch
astheSAT,ACT,GRE,GMAT,MCAT,andLSAT.Theseexamsreinforcestudents'
testtakingskillsbyselectingsmarttesttakers,insteadoffutureinnovators.Addingto
theproblem,thesetestsmeasurestudentslowerorderthinkingskillssuchas
memorizationandcomprehension.Althoughmemorizationandcomprehensionskills
arenecessaryfordevelopinginitialexpertiseinstudents'CPI,furtherdevelopment
requiresapplicationskillssothatstudentscanapplylearnedmaterialstoneworreal
worldsituationsandsolvethemappropriately.Mostoftheaforementionedtestsdonot
measureapplicationskills.Furthermore,standardizedtestingnightmaresstifle
students'higherorderinboxthinking(criticalthinking)andoutboxandnewbox
http://www.creativitypost.com/education/does_science_say_smartest_people_are_creative
2/5
5/11/2016
DoesScienceSaySmartPeopleAreCreative?|TheCreativityPost
thinking.Studentsareconditionedtopicktherightanswer,insteadofexploringall
anglesofafutureproblemtosolveit.
Themorehighlyselectivecollegesare,themoretheyaredependentonstudentstest
scoresintheiradmissiondecision.However,students'scoreshighlycorrelatetotheir
IQandtheirfamilyincome,whichisdisadvantageoustostudentsfromlowerincome
backgrounds.Higherincomefamilieshavethemoneytopayformultipletesttaking
sessions,expensivecollegeprephighschools,andtestprepclassesortutoring.
Americanparentspaytestingcompanieshundredsofmillionsofdollarsfortestsand
testprepmaterialseachyear.TestingcompaniessuchastheEducationalTesting
Service(ETS),theCollegeBoard,andtheACT,Inc.havereapedenormousfinancial
benefitsfromthestandardizedtestingnightmares.Manytopexecutivesofthese
companiesmakemoremoneythanthepresidentsofmanyprestigiousuniversitiesdo,
andthecompaniesdonothavetopayfederaltaxesbecausetheyarenonprofit
organizations.
Insteadofhelpingtestingcompaniesgetincreasinglyricher,Americashouldinvest
moneyindevelopingchildrensCPIandcorrespondingexpertiseasearlyaspossible,
alongwiththepromotionofoutboxthinkingskills.Allchildrenareborncuriousand
withnaturaloutboxthinkingskills.Priorto1990,Americanparentsandeducators
providedchildrenwithopportunitiestoexerciseoutboxthinkingskills,theexploration
ofCPI,andvariouscareeravenuesforcreativitydevelopment.Itwasunderstoodthat
notallanswerscanbefoundonstandardizedtests.Americacultivatedthe4S(soil,
sun,storm,andspace)climatesforchildren,whichnurturedtheir4Sattitudes.
Americaproducedresourcefulcrosspollinators(inthesoilclimate),curiousoptimists
(inthesunclimate),resilienthardworkers(inthestormclimate),anddefiantdreamers
(inthespaceclimate)whoappliedIONthinkingskillsforinnovation.Thedefiantspirit
whichisreflectedinneithertesttakingskillsnorIQsiswhatresultedin
generationsofAmericaninnovators,scientificdiscoveryandinvention,technology,
business,entrepreneurship,sports,leadership,education,andthearts.
Parentsandeducatorsmustcultivatethe4Sclimatesforallchildren,notjustfor
academicachieversorteacherpleasers,torecapturetheinnovationthatisbeing
testedoutofthem.Discoverhowtocultivatethe4Sclimatesnurturethe4SAttitudes
andapplyIONthinkingskillsinTheCreativityChallenge:HowWeCanRecapture
AmericanInnovation.
(ThisarticleisanexcerptoftheChapter1ofthebook,TheCreativityChallenge:How
WeCanRecaptureAmericanInnovation,whichisasynthesisofresearchfindings
notapersonalopinionandalloftheoriginalsourcesarefoundinthebook.)
Visittheauthor'swebsite,followKHKimonTwitter,andjointheconversation
onFacebook.
http://www.creativitypost.com/education/does_science_say_smartest_people_are_creative
3/5
5/11/2016
DoesScienceSaySmartPeopleAreCreative?|TheCreativityPost
Tags:act,americaneducation,andnewboxthinking,asianeducation,creativeattitudes,creativeclimates,
creativethinking,creativethinkingskills,curiosity,disadvantagedstudents,essa,everystudentsucceedsact,
examhell,gmat,gre,inbox,innovation,innovator,lsat,mact,nclb,nochildbehind,outbox,sat,standardizedtest,
thecollegeboard
October24,2016
October20,2016
October19,2016
October17,2016
WhatNotToAskAtA
DinnerParty:AreJews
MoreCreativeThan
Asians?
TheLiberalAcademy
CreatingaCulture
WhereItsCooltoBe
Smart
DoesScienceSay
SmartPeopleAre
Creative?
http://www.creativitypost.com/education/does_science_say_smartest_people_are_creative
4/5
5/11/2016
DoesScienceSaySmartPeopleAreCreative?|TheCreativityPost
1Comment
TheCreativityPost
Recommend
Share
Login
SortbyBest
Jointhediscussion
Sandhya(Sandy) 17daysago
"Studentsareconditionedtopicktherightanswerinsteadofexploringafuture
problemandsolvingit',particularlyringstruetomeinthebusiness/corp
environment.Atendencytoreducerisk(e.g.beingfired)soherdsformaroundan
acceptedoutboxresultdrivenbygroupthink,wisdomofthecrowdsoranexternal
consultancy.
Reply Share
Subscribe d AddDisqustoyoursiteAddDisqusAdd
Privacy
Arts PopCulture Science Tech Philosophy Psychology Business Education Activism Create!
SEARCH
HOME
ABOUT
EVENTS
GOOGLE+
CONTACT
RSS
ARCHIVES
JOINUS
2016TheCreativityPost.AllRightsReserved.
http://www.creativitypost.com/education/does_science_say_smartest_people_are_creative
5/5