Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
For
Zawtika Development Project Phase 1C
GAS FILTER COALESCER
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR INSTRUMENT
PRESSURE VESSELS
DOCUMENT NO. :
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 62Nos.
nos
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
2.0
Comply
1
2
3
4
Internal Material
Wellded: SA516 Gr.70N
Loosed: SS316L
3 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 6 Nos.
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
NO.
REQUIREMENT
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
Comply
Materia
Shell : SA516 Gr.70 N / SA106 Gr.B
Head : SA516 Gr.70 N / SA234 W PB
End flange : SA105N
Comply
Internal Material
Wellded: SA516 Gr.70N or SA106 Gr.B
Loosed: SA 240 TP316L
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Materia
Shell: SA516 Gr.70 N / SA106 Gr.B
Head: SA516 Gr.70 N / SA234 WPB
End flange : SA105N
Internal Material
Wellded: SA516 Gr.70N or SA106 Gr.B
Loosed: SA 240 TP316L
4 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
EVALUATION
Thickness
Shell: 15 (mm) (VTC)
End flange: 99 (mm) (VTC)
Cover Thickness: 70 (mm) (VTC)
Nozzle Reinforcement
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Wind load
Earthquake Load
Transportation Load
Lifting analysis
Earthing Boss
Manhole / Davit
Material of Construction
a) Nozzle Neck(Pipe / Forged): SA106 Gr.B / SA105N
b) Nozzle Flange: SA105N
c) Saddle: SA283 Gr.C / SA36
5 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 6 Nos.
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
We proposed: Case 1 - 5"ID x 120" T/T - at normal conditions:based on inlet liquid loading of 40 ppm (w/w). Case 2 - 10"ID x 120" T/T - at upset condition : 36.78 kg/hr
Comply
Comply
Comply
Approx. 110 kg per vessel
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
6 of 12
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 6 Nos.
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
TENDER CLARIFICATION
To be advised later
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
4.2.3 Internals
1
2
3
4
VGS Vane
Bend pipe
Internal Support
7 of 12
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
2
3
4
5
EVALUATION
4.3.3 Internals
1
2
Inlet baffle
Mist eliminator
8 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 6 Nos.
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
3
4
Bend pipe
Internal Support
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
Hydrostatc testing
PWHT (if required)
Certification as per BS EN 10204 Type 3.1 for pressure parts
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
5.2
1
2
3
Comply
Hydrostatc testing
Comply
(if required - with cost adder)
PWHT (if required)
Certification as per BS EN 10204 Type 3.1 for pressure parts Comply
Comply
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
9 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
REQUIREMENT
NO.
12
EVALUATION
4
5
6
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
10 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 6 Nos.
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
NO.
REQUIREMENT
22
23
24
25
26
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
Comply
Comply
5
6
7
Vessel Supports(Skirt)
External Clips for Platform, Ladder and Pipe Support
Lifting Lug,tailing lugs&Transportation Lugs
Comply
Comply
Comply
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Comply
16
17
18
19
ASME U-Stamped
Supply all materials and consumable required for fabrication
Complete shop fabrication
Inspection and Testing as per IRT & SPE
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
Comply
11 of 12
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
MM-ZTK-1C-WPX-MEC-TBE-0002
REVISION :
A1
DATE :
13-Jul-16
BIDDER/NATIONALITY
MANUFACTURE/NATIONALITY
Pressure Vessels / 6 Nos.
EQUIPMENT TYPE/QUANTITY
TENDER CLARIFICATION
REQUIREMENT
NO.
20
21
22
23
Comply
25
Comply.
26
27
28
29
Documentation
Pickling & Passivation - SS surface
Preservation and Preparation for Shipment
Process Guarantee & Mechanical Guarantee / Warranty
Comply.
Comply.
Comply.
30
EVALUATION
TENDER CLARIFICATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
Comply
According to bulk separator vendor, based on an Inlet Liquid Load of 0.1 USG/ MMSCF (per Process Note 21) during normal operation they feel bulk separation stage
is not required. Even during the upset conditions of 36.78 kg/h, the liquid loading to the vessel is still very low at 0.08% Liquid Volume Fraction (LVF).
At this LVF and the small vessel ID, they still do not believe that a bulk separation stage would add any benefit to the application.
AS LONG AS ONE KEY TECHNICAL PARAMETER DOES NOT MEET THE REQUIREMENT, THE CONCLUSION SHOULD BE "UNQUALIFIED".
WHEN THERE ARE FIVE OR MORE THAN FIVE "NOT ACCEPT" OCCUR ON THE TECHNICAL PARAMETERS,THE CONCLUSION SHOULD BE "UNQUALIFIED".
12 of 12