Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
STAAD.Pro V8i
TRN014310-1/0003
Trademark Notice
AccuDraw, MDL, MicroStation, and SmartLine are registered trademarks; PopSet and
Raster Manager are trademarks.
AutoCAD is a registered trademark of Autodesk, Inc.
Copyright Notice
Copyright 2011, Bentley Systems, Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
Bentley and the "B" Bentley logo are either registered or unregistered trademarks or
service marks of Bentley Systems, Incorporated. All other marks are the property of their
respective owners.
Apr-11
Table of Contents
Course Overview ____________________________________ 5
Apr-11
Table of Contents
Apr-11
Course Description
In this course, you will develop skills specific to modeling, analyzing, and
designing bridge structures in STAAD.Pro. You will also learn to apply STAAD.beava
to create loading conditions that maximize structural responses of interest.
Note: STAAD.beava (Bridge Engineering Automated Vehicle Application) works hand-
in-hand with STAAD.Pro. Its purpose is to minimize the effort associated with
the load application process while complying with national code requirements.
STAAD.beava helps to eliminate the trial and error approach (as well as the
possible errors arising from inaccuracies associated with it), by determining
loading positions required to maximize structural responses of interest.
Target Audience
Course Overview
Apr-11
5
Copyright 2011 Bentley Systems, Incorporated
Course Overview
Course Objectives
Course Objectives
Set design parameters and issue design commands to perform code checks or
to optimize steel members according to the requirements of AASHTO code for
steel members and ACI code for concrete members.
Course Prerequisites
Software Prerequisites
This manual was created using the following software versions:
Note: Earlier or later versions of STAAD.Pro may be used with this training manual,
but you may encounter slight differences in the user interface and/or exercises.
Modules Included
The following modules are included in this course:
Course Overview
Apr-11
Module Overview
This module presents the process of modeling a bridge using the Graphical User
Interface of STAAD.Pro. It demonstrates the addition of a Dead Load case to
consider the effects of self weight, shows how to add the analysis command, and
concludes by performing a visual check the deflected shape due to self weight to
detect any potential modeling errors. When you have completed the exercises in
this module, your model will be ready for STAAD.beava.
Module Prerequisites
Module Objectives
After completing this module, you will be able to:
Apr-11
Introductory Knowledge
Introductory Knowledge
Questions
1
True
False
True
False
True
False
Before you begin this module, let's define what you already know.
Apr-11
Introductory Knowledge
Answers
1
True
And although it is possible to choose the variation called Set Z Up, it will
prohibit the use of certain features within the program. So, good practice
dictates using the program with this default orientation.
2
True
Grids are a very effective way of adding members precisely and accurately.
3
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
Bridge Modeling
The following images illustrate the model that will be created in the exercises
below:
In the Where do you Want to Go? dialog, select the Add Beam checkbox
and then click Finish.
10
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
Edit the Default Grid (Linear) to work in the X-Z plane. Create two X grid
lines on the Right at 80 ft spacing. Create four Z grid lines on the Right at
10 ft spacing.
Apr-11
11
Bridge Modeling
In the Snap Node/Beam dialog, click the Snap Node/Beam button. Model
the five 160 foot long beams as full-length members in the X-direction.
Then, model the three 40 foot girders as full-length members in the Zdirection.
Hint: Remember that the Control (CTRL) key makes it possible to reset
(relocate) the hotspot without adding a member.
At this time, the beams and girders cross each other but do not intersect
(connect) properly. We know this, because the girders at both ends of the
bridge are still full-length members that do not intersect the end nodes of
the beams, and because there are no nodes visible at the location shown
in the figure below:
Note: STAAD.Pro does permit this as a valid framing condition, but it is not the
intent in this situation. Here, we expect a structural connection
between members at all crossing points. Perform the following steps to
detect and correct these connectivity issues.
5
In the menu bar, select Geometry > Intersect Selected Members >
Highlight. In the Intersect Members dialog, click OK to accept the default
tolerance of zero.
Note: STAAD.Pro highlights all of the beams that cross each other with no
common nodes.
12
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
To break these beams and create a joint at each intersection point, click
Geometry > Intersect Selected Members > Intersect in the menu bar. In
the Intersect Members dialog, click OK to accept the default tolerance of
zero. In the STAAD.Pro dialog, click OK to acknowledge that some new
beams have been created.
Beams Segmented
Note: This completes the generation of the beams and girders. The next steps
create the columns.
7
In the View Window, select the three nodes indicated in the figure below.
Note: Node numbers are not an effective reference, because the node
numbers may vary depending upon the order in which the beams and
girders were modeled.
Apr-11
13
Bridge Modeling
In the menu bar, select Geometry > Translational Repeat... or select the
Translational Repeat icon in the Generate toolbar.
Global Direction: Y
No of Steps: 1
Click OK.
14
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
Continue with the model from the previous exercise or open Bridge 1.std.
Note: In this exercise, we will generate the finite element mesh to represent
the concrete bridge deck. In this case, the spacing of the beams and
girders is regular, which makes it convenient to use the Generate
Surface Meshing Tool. In a situation where the framing layout is not
regular, the Parametric Meshing Mode might be a more useful method
of generating the deck mesh.
In the menu bar, select View > Options... In the Options dialog, select the
Tolerance item and ensure that the Split member if checkbox is
checked. Click OK.
Note: This ensures that the meshing process will split the existing beams and
girders and connect the plates to them at locations where generated
mesh nodes coordinate with existing framing members.
3
In the menu bar, select Geometry > Generate Surface Mesh or select the
Generate Surface Meshing icon in the Geometry toolbar.
In the View Window, click the node indicated in the figure below:
Click
Moving in counter-clockwise order, click the other three nodes that define
the corners of the overall bridge deck. Complete the command by clicking
back on the first node.
5
Apr-11
15
Bridge Modeling
Note: Use the Beams Cursor to verify that the beams and girders are now
segmented into smaller members as a result of the Split member if
checkbox setting. Each small beam or girder segment is now connected
to nodes in the plate mesh.
Note: In reality, the steel beams are physically attached to the deck, but the
concrete girders parallel to the Z-axis are set some distance below the
deck as shown in the figure below:
16
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
In the Merge Selected Beams dialog, click the first line of data and then
click the Merge button. Confirm by clicking Yes.
Repeat for the remaining two lines of data, and then close the Merge
Selected Beams dialog.
Note: By merging the girder segments, connectivity was lost at the locations
where the concrete girders are supposed to connect to the concrete
columns and to the steel beams.
10 In the menu bar, click Geometry > Intersect Selected Members >
11 In the menu bar, click Geometry > Intersect Selected Members >
Intersect. Click OK to accept the default tolerance value of zero, and then
click OK to acknowledge the pop-up dialog indicating that some new
beams have been created.
Hint: Use the Beams Cursor to verify that the girders are now segmented only
in the locations where they connect to the steel beams or the concrete
column.
The next exercises complete the model generation process and prepare the
model for use in STAAD.beava.
Apr-11
17
Bridge Modeling
Continue with the model from the previous exercise or open Bridge 2.std.
In the Page Control Area, click the General tab. The Property sub-tab is
active by default.
In the Section Profile Tables dialog, select a W24x103 and add it to the
Project as a single section from the table (ST). Click Close.
the Node 1 field. The remaining fields will adopt the same value by
default. Leave the Material checkbox checked, and leave the Material
drop down list box set to Concrete.
11 Click Add followed by Close.
12 In the Properties dialog, highlight the W24X103 item.
13 In the menu bar, click Select > Beams Parallel To > X.
14 In the Properties dialog, verify that the Assignment Method is set to
Assign to Selected Beams and then click the Assign button. Confirm by
clicking Yes.
15 In the Properties dialog, highlight the Cir 48.00 item.
16 In the menu bar, click Select > Beams Parallel To > Y.
17 In the Properties dialog, verify that the Assignment Method is set to
Assign to Selected Beams and then click the Assign button. Confirm by
clicking Yes.
18 In the Properties dialog, highlight the Rect 48.00x48.00 item.
19 In the menu bar, click Select > Beams Parallel To > Z.
20 In the Properties dialog, verify that the Assignment Method is set to
Assign to Selected Beams and then click the Assign button. Confirm by
clicking Yes.
18
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
In the menu bar, click Tools > Set Current Input Unit. Change the Length
unit to Inch, and then click OK.
Note: The offsets specification can be used to apply rigid offsets at the ends of
members. In the next steps, we will offset the beams and girders by an
appropriate amount to establish the proper elevation relationships.
3
In the Page Control area, click the Specification sub-tab of the General tab.
Hint: In the View Window, hover the Beams Cursor over each of the columns
to establish that the top of the column displays the green Beam Ends
color, indicating that the top is the Starting end.
4
Note: See the following notes regarding the geometry of this bridge structure:
Apr-11
In order to position the top of the column it so that it is flush with the
underside of the concrete girder, it must be offset downward by (12/2
+ 24.530 + 48) = 78.53 inches.
19
Bridge Modeling
START 0 -54.53 0.
12 In the menu bar, click Select > Beams Parallel To > Z.
13 In the Specifications dialog, verify that the Assignment Method is set to
Assign to Selected Beams and then click the Assign button. Confirm by
clicking Yes.
14 Repeat this process to assign the offset specification END 0 -54.53 0 to the
START 0 -78.53 0.
17 In the menu bar, click Select > Beams Parallel To > Y.
18 In the Specifications dialog, verify that the Assignment Method is set to
Assign to Selected Beams and then click the Assign button. Confirm by
clicking Yes.
20
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
In the Page Control area, click the Support sub-tab of the General tab.
In the Supports dialog, click the Create button. The Fixed tab will be active
by default.
In the Supports dialog, click the Use Cursor to Assign option in the
Assignment Method, and then click the Assign button.
In the View Window, click once at the base of each of the three columns,
and then toggle the Assigning button off.
Apr-11
21
Bridge Modeling
In the Page Control area, click the Load & Definition sub-tab of the
General tab.
In the Load & Definition dialog, highlight the Load Cases Details item. Click
the Add... button.
Note: The Primary option is selected by default in the Add New: Load Cases
dialog.
4
In the Add New: Load Cases dialog, enter the following parameters:
Number: 1
In the Load & Definition dialog, highlight the 1: Dead Load item. Click the
Add... button.
In the Add New: Load Items dialog, enter the following parameters:
Direction: Y
Factor: -1
In the Load & Definition dialog, highlight the SELFWEIGHT Y -1 item. Select
the Assign to View radio button in the Assignment Methods and then click
Assign. Confirm with Yes.
22
Apr-11
Bridge Modeling
The next exercises demonstrate how to initiate an analysis, and how to review
analysis results in the post processor.
Note: The model is now fully constructed, and it includes a Dead Load case
and a command to perform a linear elastic analysis.
Continue with the model from the previous exercise or open Bridge 3.std.
Note: The STAAD Analysis and Design dialog provides information about the
analysis as it progresses.
3
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, review the final messages to
ensure that it indicates 0 errors and 0 warnings. Then, click the Go to Post
Processing Mode radio button and then click Done.
In the Results Setup dialog, click OK to accept the one and only load case in
this model.
Apr-11
23
Bridge Modeling
In the menu bar, click Results > Scale In the Diagrams dialog, select the
Scales tab and set the Displacement input field to a value of 0.005 in per
in. Click OK.
Note: The exaggerated deflection of the deck appears uniform and wellbehaved. The deflected beams follow the shape of the deflected deck.
Some deflection is apparent at the free end of the girders as compared
to their points of connection to the columns. The deflected shape is as
expected.
6
In the Node Displacements table, click the Summary tab to review the
extreme deflections.
In the Page Control area, click the Reactions sub-tab of the Node tab.
Note: The Difference line in the Statics Check Results table shows all zeros.
This indicates that there is no loss of load. The full magnitude of the
applied load is finding its way to the supports through a valid load path.
Based on the observations of the behavior of the model, it is in good working
order to apply STAAD.beava for the purpose of optimizing load positions.
24
Apr-11
Module Review
Module Review
Now that you have completed this module, lets measure what you have learned.
Questions
True
False
True
False
True
False
Proper use of the Split member if option can greatly assist in creating
proper connectivity.
Apr-11
25
Module Review
Answers
Proper use of the Split member if option can greatly assist in creating
proper connectivity.
True
When activated, the Split member if option will ensure that a member
is split and connected if a new node is added on that member.
2
26
Apr-11
Module Overview
This module introduces STAAD.beava and demonstrates its application on a
typical bridge structure in STAAD.Pro model. It demonstrates how to set up
roadways, lanes, and vehicles, and to identify design parameters where the
maximum response is of interest in design. The exercises demonstrate how to
identify these design parameters of interest, how to run STAAD.beava to
determine the load positions to maximize each of the design parameters of
interest, and how to create the necessary load cases and export them back to the
STAAD.Pro model. The module concludes with a demonstration of customizing a
Load Combination table and automatically generating Load Combinations in
STAAD.Pro.
Module Prerequisites
Apr-11
27
Module Objectives
Module Objectives
Introductory Knowledge
Before you begin this module, let's define what you already know.
Questions
1
True
False
True
False
True
False
28
Apr-11
Introductory Knowledge
Answers
1
True
At any location x on an influence surface diagram for structural response y,
the ordinate value represents the value of structural response y when a
unit load is located at location x.
2
True
STAAD.beava automatically incorporates these requirements and creates
the lane load components as well as the wheel load components.
Apr-11
29
Bridge Loading
Bridge Loading
The process of load application for bridge design can be complex due to the
nature of the moving loads. Maximizing any particular structural response of
interest (shear, moment, axial load, and deflection) may be dependent on the
exact placement of multiple vehicles on multiple lanes. Modern codes and design
standards may also introduce additional complicating factors such as loaded
length on a lane, lane factors and load intensity.
To obtain the maximum design effects, engineers may resort to a combination of
engineering judgment and a trial and error methodology. This leads to the
generation of many loading conditions and a large volume of output data to sift
through.
STAAD.beava
In view of the complexities associated with bridge loading, STAAD.beava (Bridge
Engineering Automated Vehicle Application) works hand-in-hand with STAAD.Pro.
Its purpose is to minimize the effort associated with the load application process
while complying with national code requirements.
STAAD.beava helps to eliminate the trial and error approach (as well as the
possible errors arising from inaccuracies associated with it), by determining
loading positions required to maximize structural responses of interest.
The approach is based on the use of influence surfaces. An influence surface for a
given effect on a bridge deck relates its value to the movement of a unit load over
the area of interest. The influence surface is a three-dimensional form of an
influence line for a single member.
Influence surfaces can be generated for effects such as bending moments in plate
elements, deflection in all the degrees of freedom of nodes and support
reactions, and axial forces, shears and moments in beam members.
With input from the engineer, STAAD.beava uses the relevant influence surfaces
and takes code requirements into consideration to optimize load positions to
obtain the maximum desired effects.
Note: The use of STAAD.beava requires the activation of the STAAD.beava (Bridge
Codes) license.
30
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Note: It is important to open the new dataset file in this case, because the
In the menu bar, click Mode > Bridge Deck Preprocessor or select the
BEAVA icon in the Mode toolbar to activate STAAD.beava.
In the View Window, use the Plates Cursor to select all of the plates in the
model.
In the Save Deck As dialog, enter the name Plates_Only and then click OK.
In the View Window, use the Beams Cursor to select all of the beams in
the model.
In the Save Deck As dialog, enter the name Beams_Only and then click OK.
Note: When creating decks, use them to your best advantage. By including
Apr-11
31
STAAD.beava
Before we move into defining the roadway and the vehicle, we will initiate the
generation of Influence Surfaces, observe the Influence Surfaces associated with
the following structural responses, and discuss the physical meaning of each:
Node 153
Influence Surfaces
Node 18
32
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Beam 452
Plate 205
Continue with the model from the previous exercise, or open Bridge 5.std
in STAAD.Pro and click Mode > Bridge Deck Preprocessor.
Note: This initiates an analysis of the model for the purpose of generating the
influence surface data. The STAAD Analysis and Design window opens
and reports progress as the model runs. The window closes
automatically when the analysis is complete.
3
Apr-11
In the View toolbar, set the Active Deck drop down list box to
1: Plates_Only.
33
STAAD.beava
Node Displacement: Y
Node: 153
The color codes indicate, on a relative basis, how much effect a unit load
would have on the Y-direction displacement of Node 153, if the unit load
was placed in all different areas of the structure.
Notice that the concentric rings radiate outward from Node 153. This
indicates that a unit load has a greater and greater effect on the Ydirection displacement of Node 153, the closer it is placed to Node 153.
Notice also that the color coding indicates high negative influence
numbers in the vicinity of Node 153. This is because the unit load is
assumed to be in the downward direction (representative of gravity loads),
so the unit load actually causes a deflection in the negative Y-direction.
34
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
In the View toolbar, set the Active Deck drop down list box to
2: Beams_Only. The structure diagram updates to display the influence
colors on the members that are defined as being part of the Deck named
Beams_Only.
Apr-11
35
STAAD.beava
In the Diagrams dialog, choose the option named All Decks in the
Influence Shown category, and then click Apply. The structure diagram
now shows the influence colors for entities that belong to any defined
Deck in the model as shown below:
Support Reaction: FY
Node: 18
36
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
This diagram indicates that load should be placed close to the girder that
connects to the center column, to have the greatest influence on the
Support Reaction at Node 18. Notice that in this case, the color
distribution consists predominantly of positive values. This implies that
any load placed in those areas will produce some reaction at Node 18 that
is in the positive Y direction.
Apr-11
37
STAAD.beava
Beam: 452
38
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
tab to study the Influence Diagram for the extreme Mx for Plate 205:
Plate: 205
Apr-11
39
STAAD.beava
Continue with the model from the previous exercise, or open Bridge 6.std
in STAAD.Pro and click Mode > Bridge Deck Preprocessor.
Roadway is defined, it will only be Active for the Deck that is selected
at the time the Roadway is defined. A Roadway will appear as Inactive
on any other Decks.
3
In the View toolbar, set the Active Deck drop down list box to
1: Plates_Only.
Note: From this point forward, we will only concentrate our efforts on this one
Deck.
4
Defining a Roadway
40
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Note: The Define Roadway dialog contains three tabs: Straight, Curved, and
Custom.
The Straight tab provides a simple way to define two outer curbs, and
let STAAD.beava calculate the lane widths automatically as shown
below:
Curb A
Curb B
Apr-11
41
STAAD.beava
The Curved tab provides a way to define two circular outer curbs, and
let STAAD.beava calculate the lane widths automatically as shown
below:
42
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
The Curved tab also provides angle input fields that can be used to
limit the extent of the load application to a sector defined by an angle.
This might be necessary if a ramping condition existed such that some
portion of the bridge structure was not subject to direct vehicular
loads as shown in the figure below:
The Curved tab can even be used on structures that are not circular in
shape.
Apr-11
The Custom tab provides a way to explicitly define the individual lane
layout in any combination of straight sections, circular sections, and/or
sections of irregular geometry (such as spiral curves, or any other
geometry that can be digitized into X-Z data pairs).
43
STAAD.beava
In the Define Roadway dialog, click the Custom tab and then enter the
following parameters:
Lane category:
Active Lane: 1 of 1
Origin X: 0 ft
Origin Z: 5.5 ft
Width: 9 ft
Section category:
Active Section: 1 of 1
Orientation: 0
Length: 160 ft
Note: The zero-degree Orientation of this lane implies that loads are
positioned along a horizontal line. It does NOT imply that the load
patterns will only be considered as though the vehicle is driving from
left to right. In fact, STAAD.beava considers the wheel loads as though
they are driving in both directions, and identifies whichever case
creates the maximum response.
7
Click Apply.
The first lane is now defined and the Define Roadway dialog appears as
shown below:
44
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Click the Add Lane Right button and enter the following parameters:
Lane category:
Active Lane: 2 of 2
Origin X: 0 ft
Origin Z: 14.5 ft
Width: 9 ft
Section category:
Active Section: 1 of 1
Orientation: 0
Length: 160 ft
Click Apply.
The first and second lanes are now defined, and the Define Roadway
dialog appears as shown below:
Apr-11
45
STAAD.beava
10 Click the Add Lane Right button and enter the following parameters:
Lane category:
Active Lane: 3 of 3
Origin X: 0 ft
Origin Z: 25.5 ft
Width: 9 ft
Note: The lane origin locations used for the second and third lanes establishes
Active Section: 1 of 1
Orientation: 0
Length: 160 ft
11 Click Apply.
Warning: STAAD.beava has some built-in intelligence that attempts to establish
46
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
The first, second, and third lanes are now defined, and after resetting the
curb on the right for Lane 2, the Define Roadway dialog appears as shown
below:
12 Click the Add Lane Right button and enter the following parameters:
Lane category:
Active Lane: 4 of 4
Origin X: 0 ft
Origin Z: 34.5 ft
Width: 9 ft
Section category:
Active Section: 1 of 1
Orientation: 0
Length: 160 ft
13 Click Apply.
Apr-11
47
STAAD.beava
All four lanes are now defined, and the Define Roadway dialog appears as
shown below:
Plates_Only.
15 In the Roadways dialog, click the Close button.
48
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Vehicle Definitions
The next exercise discusses the parameters used to define a Vehicle.
Class Date: 19-Aug-2015
Continue with the model from the previous exercise, or open Bridge 7.std
in STAAD.Pro and click Mode > Bridge Deck Preprocessor.
Note: The dataset file named Bridge 7.std contains no Deck or Roadway
Note: The Vehicle Database dialog displays the list of defined vehicles and
In the Vehicle Database dialog, click HS20-44 in the Vehicles list to observe
a representative vehicle definition.
Ensure that the Details of Axle drop down list box is set to 1.
The graphic below clarifies that Axle 1 consists of one wheel load of 4000
lb located 3 ft from the vehicle centerline, and another wheel load of 4000
lb located 3 ft on the other side of the vehicle centerline. Axle 1 is defined
as being at a Fixed Position of 0 ft from the start of the vehicle.
Axle 3
Axle 2
Axle 1
CL
Apr-11
49
STAAD.beava
The wheel loads are still 6 feet apart, spaced symmetrically about the
centerline, and each wheel load is still 16000 lb. But the Position field
indicates that Axle 3 is located at a Variable Position that ranges from a
minimum of 14 ft, to a maximum of 30 ft from the second axle. So in this
case, axle 3 is studied in many different positions, and it is moved in 0.5 ft
increments, as indicated by the value in the Increment field.
Review the Clearance and Width values in the Vehicle Database dialog.
They are used to limit how close one vehicle's pattern of wheel loads can
be placed with respect to each other if the vehicle is specified as being a
Convoy. The values can be interpreted as shown in the following graphic:
10 ft Width
Front
50 ft Clearance
50 ft Clearance
8
50
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Load Generator
The next exercise demonstrates how to use the Load Generator to position a
particular vehicle so as to maximize specific structural responses of interest. For
continuity, the exercise focuses on the same four structural responses identified
previously, namely:
Continue with the model from the previous exercise, or open Bridge 8.std
in STAAD.Pro and click Mode > Bridge Deck Preprocessor.
Note: In this version of the model, the Deck named Beams_Only has been
Ensure that the current length input units are set to foot.
In the menu bar, click Loading > Influence Surface Generator to instruct
the program to generate the influence surface data for this model.
In the menu bar, click Loading > Run Load Generator after the influence
surface generation is complete.
In the Load Generator Parameters dialog, General tab, set the Design Code
to AASHTO LRFD.
loading.
6
Apr-11
Click the Decks tab and observe that the Deck named Plates_Only is
selected by default.
51
STAAD.beava
Click the AASHTO tab and note that when the AASHTO LRFD Design Code
is selected, Load Factors are provided as optional multipliers for the
various components of load.
Design Tandem: 1
this exercise.
Note: Live Load generation in BEAVA as per AASHTO LRFD considers Section
52
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Click the Node Displacements tab and set the parameters in row 1 as
follows:
Node: 153
Displacement: Y
Over Pier: No
To Curb: 19 ft
Effect: -ve
Click the Support Reactions tab and set the parameters in row 1 as
follows:
Node: 18
Support Reaction: FY
To Curb: 19 ft
Effect: +ve
10 Remain on the Support Reactions tab and set the parameters in row 2 as
follows:
Node: 18
Support Reaction: FY
Over Pier: No
To Curb: 19 ft
Effect: +ve
Note: This will allow us to see the effect of the Over Pier setting.
11 Click the Plate Center Stress tab and set the parameters in row 1 as
follows:
Apr-11
Plate: 205
Stress: MX (local)
Over Pier: No
53
STAAD.beava
12 Click the Beam End Forces tab and set the parameters in row 1 as follows:
Beam: 452
Force: End A: MZ
To Curb: 19 ft
Effect: +ve
13 Remain on the Beam End Forces tab and set the parameters in row 2 as
follows
Beam: 452
Force: End A: MZ
Over Pier: No
To Curb: 19 ft
Effect: +ve
Note: Again, this will provide us with important information regarding the
The Response drop down list box provides a way to select from among
the responses that have been defined for consideration.
The Roadway No. drop down list box provides a way to select from
among the different Roadways that exist in the model.
The Lane No. drop down list box provides a way to select from among
the various Lanes that vehicles can travel in.
Note: When defining a Roadway, if the Straight or Curved options are used,
54
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Note: Some of these data areas may not apply in all situations, as is the case
Apr-11
55
STAAD.beava
Area 2 provides locations and magnitudes of wheel loads, on a vehicleby-vehicle basis, for whichever Lane is selected in the Lane No. drop
down list box.
Area 3 indicates information about the Lane loading (if it applies). The
magnitude, width, length, and center location are provided.
Note: This is a modeless dialog, meaning that it can be left open while other
parameters:
Loads: (checked)
Vehicles: (checked)
Click OK.
19 In the View toolbar, ensure that the Surface Group drop down list box is
56
Apr-11
STAAD.beava
Lane 1
The Main Window shows a display of the structure with a depiction of the
Vehicle and Lane loads positioned to maximize the downward deflection
of Node 153 as shown below:
Lane 3
Note: The vehicles in all three lanes have smaller magnitudes of wheel loads
on the right-hand end of the image, implying that their front ends are
aimed to the right.
Apr-11
57
STAAD.beava
Roadway No.: 1
Lane No.: 1
The dialog shows that Axle No. 1 (the front axle) for the vehicle in Lane No.
1 is positioned at an X coordinate of approximately 58 feet, and Axle No. 2
is positioned at an X coordinate of approximately 44 feet. This represents
an axle spacing of 14 feet, which coordinates with the values we saw
above, when we observed the HS20-44 vehicle definition, and it is
coordinated with the graphic depiction shown in the Main Window.
Note: If the dialog was closed, it can be recalled by clicking Loading > Browse
There are times where it may be useful to have such explicit information
regarding the vehicle position. However the next steps demonstrate one
of the most convenient features of STAAD.beava, which is the ability to
transfer the loading information (magnitudes and locations) back to the
STAAD.Pro input file, for incorporation into the analysis.
22 In the Vehicular Load Patterns Producing Extreme Values of Structural
58
Apr-11
The next exercise explores the loading data that is passed from STAAD.beava into
the STAAD.Pro input file.
Ensure that the current input units are set to foot and KiloPound.
In the Options dialog, click the Force Units item and modify the following
parameter:
Stress: psf
In the Page Control area, click the General tab and then click the Load &
Definition sub-tab.
In the Load & Definition dialog, expand the Load Cases Details item and
note that Load Cases 2 through 7 are the new cases that have been
populated into the input file from STAAD.beava.
Click OK.
Note: The load case details are automatically named with descriptive terms
that indicate the Design Code on which they are based, and the
structural response they are intended to maximize or minimize.
In the Load & Definition dialog, expand Load Case 2.
Note: The individual Load Items consist of Partial Plate Pressure Loads and
Pressure on Full Plate loads. Even the vehicle wheel loads are created in
the form of Partial Plate Pressure Loads distributed over a small area.
8
In the Diagrams dialog, click the Scales tab and modify the following
parameter:
Click OK.
Hint: 90000 psf per ft and 3 psf per ft are comfortable viewing scales to
visualize the wheel loads and the distributed lane loads, respectively.
10 In the Load & Definition dialog, click on some of the Load Items and notice
Apr-11
59
Note: In this exercise, we will study the effect of the Over Pier setting.
2
In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis... and then click Save in the
pop-up dialog.
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, choose the Go to Post Processing
Mode radio button and then click Done.
In the Results Setup dialog, select Load Cases 6 and 7 only (moving all
other load cases from the Selected window to the Available window).
Note: Load Case 6 contains the loads to maximize the extreme positive
support reaction at node 18 by choosing Yes for the Over Pier setting.
Load Case 7 contains the loads to maximize the extreme positive
support reaction at node 18 by choosing No for the Over Pier setting.
5
In the Results Setup dialog, click the Range tab and click the Ranges radio
button. Enter node number 18 in the Nodes field.
Click OK.
In the Support Reactions table, observe the Fy vertical reactions in the and
note that Load Case 6 produces a greater reaction than Load Case 7.
In the Diagrams dialog, click the Loads and Results tab. In the Loads
category, activate the Loads checkbox and then click OK.
10 In the View toolbar, use the Active Load drop down list box to toggle
60
Apr-11
In this previous section, we used a model that contained the critical loading
conditions. The next exercise demonstrates how to develop a load combination
table.
Note: Based on the comparative study just performed in the previous exercise,
the loading data in this file has been modified by eliminating the noncontrolling load conditions, and the remaining Load Cases have been
renumbered for simplicity.
2
In the menu bar, click Commands > Loading > Edit Auto Load Rules.
In the Edit Loading Rules for Auto Load Combination Generation dialog,
use the Select Code drop down list box to view the available codes.
Apr-11
Click the New Code button, enter AASHTO as the new Code Name, and
click OK.
Click the Select Category drop down list box, which will be empty,
indicating that no Load Combination tables have been created yet.
61
Click the New Category button and enter the following parameters:
No. of Rules: 4
Click OK.
Edit the parameters in the TRAINING table as shown below:
Dead
Traffic
Include Notional
Load
(unchecked)
(unchecked)
Combination
Rule
Separate Combination
for Each Case
0.9
1.25
0.9
1.75
1.25
1.75
Rules
Note: The load combinations created for this exercise are for example
purposes only. For simplicity, they incorporate a value of 1.0 for the load
modifier, i, relating to ductility, redundancy, and operational
importance, as specified in Article 1.3.2.1 of AASHTO LRFD Bridge
Design Specifications.
8
Click the Update Table button and then click the Close button. This custom
Load Combination table is now available for use in the next exercise.
62
Apr-11
The next exercise illustrates the process of applying our custom Load Combination
table to automatically generate Load Combinations in the form of Repeat Loads. It
is important that they be created as Repeat Loads, rather than results
combinations, any time a P-Delta analysis will be performed.
In the Page Control Area, click the General tab and then the Load &
Definition sub-tab.
In the Load & Definition dialog, edit each of the four generated loading
conditions to set the Loading Type to Traffic.
In the Load & Definition dialog, click Load Cases Details item and then
click the Add button.
In the Add New: Load Cases dialog, click the Auto Load Combination item
and then enter the following parameters:
Click the Generate Loads button and then activate the Create Repeat Load
Cases checkbox.
In the Add New: Load Cases dialog, click Add followed by Close.
Note: Note that ten combinations are generated in the form of Repeat Loads.
They take into consideration the two different possible factors for the
Dead Load component, and they generate all of the different
permutations of the four Traffic Load conditions in combination with
Dead Load.
This completes the process of loading the bridge structure.
Apr-11
63
Module Review
Module Review
Questions
1
True
False
STAAD.beava separates the load items that represent the wheel loads
from the load items that represent the lane loads, so they can be factored
separately.
True
False
The LOAD LIST command can be exported directly from STAAD.beava into
the STAAD.Pro input file.
True
False
Now that you have completed this module, lets measure what you have learned.
64
Apr-11
Module Review
Answers
1
True
2
STAAD.beava separates the load items that represent the wheel loads
from the load items that represent the lane loads, so they can be factored
separately.
False
This separation was done manually during the preparation of the dataset
files. By default, STAAD.beava lumps all load items for a single structural
response into one Load Case.
3
The LOAD LIST command can be exported directly from STAAD.beava into
the STAAD.Pro input file.
False
Apr-11
65
Module Review
66
Apr-11
Module Overview
This module discusses the application of design parameters and the assignment of
design commands to perform code checks, to optimize designs, and to make
designs uniform. Steel members are designed according to the AASHTO LRFD
code, and concrete members are designed according to the ACI code.
Module Prerequisites
Module Objectives
After completing this module, you will be able to:
Apr-11
Initiate the batch mode design of reinforced concrete slabs, beams, and
columns
67
Introductory Knowledge
Introductory Knowledge
Questions
1
With regard to steel design, STAAD.Pro has the ability to perform code
checking or member selection (optimization) processes.
True
False
True
False
True
False
Before you begin this module, let's define what you already know.
68
Apr-11
Introductory Knowledge
Answers
1
With regard to steel design, STAAD.Pro has the ability to perform code
checking or member selection (optimization) processes.
True
When the Code Checking function is used, the program will return a Pass/
Fail status and a utilization ratio. If the member fails the code check, it is
the user's responsibility to address the issue. If the member is oversized,
the program makes no attempt to economize. By contrast, when the
Member Selection function is used, the program will return the lightest
weight section within that family of sections, which meets the code
requirements while satisfying all of the design parameters.
2
Apr-11
69
Load List
Load List
The Load List command is used to activate the load cases listed in this command
and deactivate all other load cases.
In the menu bar, click Commands > Loading > Load List...
In the Load List dialog, select Load Cases 6 through 13 in the Load Cases
window. Move these loads to the Load List window by clicking the single
right arrow button.
Click OK.
Note: Load Cases 6 through 13 are now the only load cases considered for any
commands that are issued hereafter, until another Load List command
is issued.
Note: This load list does not include the traffic load-only condition, which is
the likely one to use for evaluating deflections. We will check deflection
in a subsequent step.
Now that loading has been properly established, the next step is to apply design
parameters and commands.
70
Apr-11
Code Checking
Member Selection
Check Code is a request to determine if the member properties that the user has
provided are adequate to carry the forces that are applied to the members. You
use Check Code when you have provided member properties that you believe to
be close to what they should be. If the Code Check finds members that are
inadequate, you will be responsible for finding a new set of members to replace
the inadequate ones.
The actual optimization process starts with the lightest possible section within
the specified constraints, and verifies whether or not that section is adequate.
If it is not adequate, the program checks the next heavier section and keeps
going until it finds the first one that satisfies the code requirements within any
specified constraints.
If it is unable to find any section that satisfies both the specified constraints
and the code requirements, the program reports the last section tried, and
the results of that check, including why that section fails the code check.
The sequence of commands for performing a Check Code and those for
performing a Member Selection are similar.
Apr-11
71
Note: The model used in the following exercises is based on the model used in the
previous modules (with some minor modeling revisions). For the next series of
exercises, we will assume that the intent is to investigate the design of the
central longitudinal girder. For this purpose, STAAD.beava has been applied, to
determine loading patterns that maximize:
The next dataset file incorporates these loading patterns, with the dynamic
loading factor applied to the wheel loads.
Continue with the model from the previous exercise or open Bridge 13.std
in STAAD.Pro.
In the Page Control area, click the Design tab and Steel sub-tab.
In the Steel Design dialog, click the Current Code list to view the available
codes for steel design.
Note: STAAD.Pro offers the choice of designing using many different codes
In the Current Code list, select the AASHTO (LRFD) code. Keep this model
open for use in the next section.
72
Apr-11
In the lower portion of the Steel Design dialog, note the three buttons labeled
Select Parameters, Define Parameters and Commands. Clicking the Define
Parameters button opens the Design Parameters dialog. The category window on
the left side of this dialog lists all of the available design parameters from which to
choose.
This dialog is used to specify values for the different design parameters. The
parameters listed are those that are referenced in the various sections of the
currently selected design code.
All of the parameters are initially set to default values. In the absence of any other
instruction, STAAD.Pro will use the default values shown.
Grade of Steel
One common example of the use of parameters is to correctly set the grade of
steel for the different members in the model. The next exercise demonstrates this
procedure.
Slenderness checking
Some other commonly used parameters are the ones that affect slenderness
checking; that is the Kl/r ratio. In the Kl/r ratio, the definitions are as follows:
The effective length factor, K, addresses the end conditions of the columns.
I
---A
Apr-11
73
In the absence of any user input, the K values are assigned a default value of 1.0
and the l values are assigned to be equal to the node-to-node member length. It is
up to you to assign the correct K and l values to the members.
It is important that you understand the system of bracing in the model. For
example, a member that is braced at a point against buckling in one plane may
not necessarily be braced for buckling in the orthogonal plane at that point.
Under these conditions, it may be necessary to modify the default value of 1.0 for
K in one of the directions.
There may be instances where the top flange of a wide flange beam is braced by a
deck, precluding any kind of buckling of the top flange; whereas, the bottom
flange may be supported at discrete distances.
Under this condition, the unsupported length for the top flange will be one value,
and the unsupported length for the bottom flange will be another value.
These parameters require the application of engineering judgment.
74
Apr-11
Deflection Checking
Parameters can also be applied to assist with deflection checking. Deflections are
not automatically investigated when the Check Code or Member Selection
commands are used. To specifically instruct STAAD.Pro to perform deflection
checking, the variables DFF, DJ1 and DJ2 can be specified.
In the case of the current bridge example, STAAD.Pro would need input from the
user as to what to consider as the length of the longitudinal steel beam, if a
deflection check is to be performed. It can't determine the length automatically,
because those structural elements are represented by a series of individual
member segments connected at nodes.
The details of all of these parameters are explained in Chapter 2 of the Technical
Reference manual. There are also several examples in the Examples manual that
illustrate the use of parameters to control the design.
In the menu bar, click Tools > Set Current Input Units, and set the current
input units to Inch and KiloPound. Click OK.
Note: On the left of the Design Parameters dialog is a list of all of the
parameters that are available for the selected design code. On the right
side of the dialog is a description of the currently selected parameter, as
well as a field to enter the desired value for that parameter. (The field
displays the default value for each parameter unless it is modified by
the user.)
Hint: To reduce the number of parameters listed in the Design Parameters
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the Grade item and then select the
(3) Grade 50W radio button. Click the Add button.
Note: This adds some new lines in the input file and in the Command Tree in
the Steel Design dialog. The new lines include the units change to UNIT
INCHES KIP, the reference to the selected AASHTO LRFD code, and a line
referring to GRADE 3 with a question mark icon.
Apr-11
75
Note: The question mark icon indicates that this particular parameter has not
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the TRACK item and then Click the
radio button for 0 = Print the design output at the minimum detail level.
Click the Add button.
Note: The track parameter is used to specify the desired level of detail in the
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the UNB item and then enter 240 in.
Click the Add button.
Note: The UNB parameter specifies the unbraced length of the bottom flange
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the UNT item and then enter 12 in.
Click the Add button, followed by Close.
Note: The UNT parameter specifies the unbraced length of the top flange of
76
Apr-11
default end-of-file location, you can do this using the After Current
checkbox as described in the commentary below.
First, click on the line in the Command Tree that immediately precedes
the desired insertion point of the new command.
Next, use the Design Parameters dialog to select the new parameter
and set its value.
In the Steel Design dialog, click on the line in the Command Tree that says
GRADE 3 and then click the Select Group/Deck button.
Note: This automatically selects the option to Assign to Edit List in the Steel
Design dialog, and it populates the edit list with the name of the group
that contains all of the members in the central longitudinal girder.
10 In the Steel Design dialog, click the Assign button. The members in the
Apr-11
77
Code Checking
Now that design parameters have been assigned to the model, the Check Code
command can be used to determine if the members are adequate to carry the
applied forces.
Warning: Remember that if the Code Check finds members that are inadequate, it will
report that condition, but will not make any attempt to modify member
sizes. It is the user's responsibility to interpret the design results and
modify framing conditions or member sizes if necessary.
Continue working in the current model, or open the saved dataset file
named Bridge 14.std and click the Design tab in the Page Control area.
Note: For this exercise, we will assume the intent is to do a code check for all
In the Select Groups dialog, click on the name _CENTRAL-GIRDER and then
click Close.
Note: In the Design Commands dialog, the Assign button is available, because
members are currently selected in the View Window. The Assign button
is convenient because it adds the currently selected command to the
Command Tree, while simultaneously assigning it to all of the currently
selected members.
5
In the Design Commands dialog, select the Code Check item and then click
the Assign button. Click the Close button.
In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis In the Warning dialog, click
Save.
Note: The STAAD Analysis and Design dialog opens and reports on the process
of the current analysis. When the analysis concludes, leave this dialog
open for the next section.
78
Apr-11
There are now some messages in the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog indicating
additional operations that were performed, like Performing Steel Design, Finished
Design, Creating Design Information File (DGN), and so forth.
The absence of any error messages at the bottom of the STAAD Analysis and
Design dialog.
If the program is ever unsuccessful in analyzing the input file and generating
results, the Post Processing mode will not be available, as shown below.
Apr-11
79
If this ever occurs, open the output file and look for error and/or warning
messages that will help to locate the problem.
The program may also display a message such as ERROR in Analysis, check
Output (ANL) File if the analysis concludes prematurely, without generating any
results.
The STAAD Output Viewer has two panes. If there is any kind of problem in the
file, the left pane will display horizontal bars labeled Error or Warning. There may
also be a Results bar if the program was able to proceed through the analysis far
enough to generate some results.
Note: An error message indicates a condition which must be corrected in order for a
80
Apr-11
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, choose View Output File radio
button and then click Done.
In the STAAD Output Viewer, click the Warning bar at the bottom left. Click
on any of the warnings to jump directly to that location in the output file.
The warning states EITHER FLANGE WIDTH-THICKNESS RATIO OR WEB
HEIGHT-THICKNESS RATIO IS MORE THAN THE LIMITING RATIO SPECIFIED
BY CODE, CLAUSE 6.9.4.2, THE MEMBER CAN NOT BE DESIGNED FOR AXIAL
COMPRESSION.
Note: A member size of W24x146 satisfies the flange width-thickness and web
height-thickness requirements.
4
In the menu bar, click File > Exit to close the STAAD Output Viewer.
In the Page Control area, click the General tab and the Property sub-tab.
In the Properties dialog, select the W24x103 in the section list. Click the
Edit... button.
In the American Steel Table dialog, select the W24X146 section and then
click the Change button. Confirm by clicking Yes and then click Close.
Warning: Bear in mind that as soon as any changes are made to the stiffness of
Apr-11
In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis In the Warning dialog, click
Save. When the analysis concludes, note that no warnings are indicated.
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click the View Output File radio
button and then click Done.
81
10 In the STAAD Output Viewer, click on STEEL DESIGN in the left margin. This
is a quick link to jump right to the location in the output file where the
steel design results begin.
CODE: The first line in the results says STAAD.Pro CODE CHECKING (AASHTO - LRFD) which confirms the selected design code.
UNITS: The next line indicates the units that are being used to report
the results.
The results of the code check are reported for each member that is
checked. The level of detail shown in the results is a function of the Track
parameter, which was set to a value of 0 in this exercise. Each of the
columns in the CODE CHECKING results, other than MEMBER or TABLE,
reports two pieces of data. The column headings provide the key to
determining what the data represents.
From left to right, the columns and results for Member 3 are as described
below.
TABLE: Lists the name of the section (W24X146 in the case of Member
3).
RESULT: Provides the overall design result for the member in PASS/FAIL
format. In this case, Member 3 passes the code check.
LOADING: Indicates the Load Case that produced the controlling ratio.
82
Apr-11
MY and MZ: Indicate the bending moments about the local y and local
z axes, respectively, that are associated with the load case indicated in
the LOADING column.
LOCATION: Provides the location along the beam where the RATIO is
the highest. In this case the value is 60.00, indicating that the critical
loading occurs 60 inches from the starting end of Member 3.
11 Scroll down through the steel design results and note that some members
fail the code check. These members are indicated by FAIL in the Result
column. They are also flagged graphically with an asterisk in the extreme
left column.
This model will obviously require some modifications to address the failing
members. But before we address those issues, let's use this model to
demonstrate some other methods that are available to check a model for
failing members.
Hint: In lieu of scanning through output file line by line, there are other
Apr-11
83
Member Selection
STAAD.Pro has the ability to design steel members (i.e. select lightest weight
members), as opposed to just performing a code check on pre-assigned member
sizes. These features are discussed and illustrated in the following exercises.
assign an initial size to all members of the model. This is required in order for
STAAD.Pro to be able to assemble the stiffness matrix that is necessary for
analyzing the structure.
In the Page Control area, click the Design tab. The Steel sub-tab is active by
default.
Note: In this dataset file, the Check Code command is no longer appropriate
In the View Window, select all members in the central longitudinal steel
girder.
Hint: Remember that Select By Group Name is a useful option if the members
In the Design Commands dialog, click the SELECT item and then click the
Assign button. Click Close.
84
Apr-11
In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis In the Warning dialog, click
Save.
In the STAAD.Pro dialog, click Yes to the warning and to proceed with the
analysis.
Note: This message is a reminder that our model contains commands that are
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click the View Output File radio
button, and then click Done.
In the STAAD Output Viewer, click the RESULTS bar in the left window, and
then click the words STEEL DESIGN. This is a link to go straight to the steel
design pages in the output file.
likely to change the stiffness of some members of the model, but that
we have not issued another command to trigger a re-analysis after
those stiffness changes. Therefore, the analysis results will not be
technically correct based on the commands that currently exist in this
model. We will address this and adjust the commands to correct the
issue in the upcoming exercises.
10 Scroll through the steel design results, and note the following:
upcoming section titled Finalizing the Design, where we will see how
to bring consistency to the selected member sizes.
11 In the menu bar, click File > Exit in the STAAD Output Viewer.
Apr-11
85
12 In the Steel Design dialog, note that the MEMBER PROPERTY AMERICAN
Note: The new entries in the list (the ones with the question marks) represent
18 If the Results Setup dialog appears, click OK to select all load cases.
Note: The structure diagram still displays member sections, but in the Post
results:
The Analysis Property column indicates the cross sections that were
used in the analysis to obtain the member forces. These are the
member sections that we initially assigned to the members of the
model.
This Design Property column indicates the member sizes that were
determined using the SELECT command.
86
Apr-11
Note: There is a command in the Post Processor menu bar that can be used
The Actual Ratio column indicates the Unity Check ratio for each
member that was chosen by the Select command.
The Actual Ratio values are all less than (but very close to) 1.0. This is
an indication of the efficiency of the selection process. If many
members had a ratio far below 1.0, it would not be considered to be an
efficient, economical design.
Note: Occasionally, a Select command will result in some members with very
low ratios. This may happen with lightly loaded members, where the
selected size is either the smallest section in the database, or when the
selected member size is required in order to meet a minimum
slenderness ratio, Kl/r.
Note: The AASHTO LRFD code provides a design parameter named MAIN that
Apr-11
87
Continue working in the current model, or open the saved dataset file
named Bridge 16.std.
In the Modeling Mode, click the Design tab in the Page Control area.
In the Select Groups dialog, click the group name _CENTRAL-GIRDER and
then click Close.
In the Steel Design dialog, click the SELECT command in the Command
Tree and then click the Commands button.
Note: This makes the SELECT command the current location in the
Hint: The use of After Current ensures that the next command will be added
In the Design Commands dialog, click the GROUP item and select Sz in the
Property Specification list.
88
Apr-11
Note: The Property Specification list specifies the property that will be used to
Same as Beam #: If this option is used, the section determined for the
selected beam will be used as the section for all members to which this
Group command is assigned.
In the Design Commands dialog, click the Assign button and then click
Close.
Evaluate all of the individual optimized sizes for all of the members of
the central longitudinal girder,
Identify the section with the largest value of section modulus about
the local z-axis, and
Apr-11
89
Either continue working in the current model, or open the saved dataset
file named Bridge 17.std.
Note: The Analysis/Print Commands dialog opens, with the Perform Analysis
tab active.
3
Note: This adds a second PERFORM ANALYSIS command in the Command Tree
In the Select Groups dialog, click the group name _CENTRAL-GIRDER and
then click Close.
Note: The Design Commands dialog opens with the CHECK CODE command
selected.
8
that were specified previously will remain valid until they are respecified with different values.
Note: This CHECK CODE command instructs the program to conduct one more
code check with the new force values to confirm that the new member
sizes are able to safely support the forces within code limits.
90
Apr-11
Exercise: Run Model with Analyze, Select, Group, Re-Analyze, and Check
Code
1
Note: In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, notice that no errors and no
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click the View Output File radio
button and then click Done.
In the STAAD Output Viewer, click the first STEEL DESIGN link in the left
pane. Scroll down through the results and note the following:
Continue scrolling past the first set of design results and note the GROUP
SZ MEMB _CENTRAL-GIRDER command. It indicates GROUPING BASED
ON MEMBER 458 (ST W27X194). In other words, of the members that
were just optimized, member 458 had the largest value of section
modulus about the local z-axis, so all members of the _CENTRAL-GIRDER
group are reassigned that section size.
Note: Before scrolling further, make note of the fact that the design result for
Apr-11
91
Scroll down through this second set of results (relating to the code check)
and note the following:
Some Utilization Ratios are relatively low, because the section is larger
than necessary for some members.
Two members now fail the code check, including member 458, which
now shows that a W27X194 has a ratio of 1.283 (still controlled by
loading condition 11).
This effect is due to the fact that the member selection process causes
changes in relative stiffness (as well as changes in self-weight). So, the
member forces are redistributed when the model is reanalyzed. The next
section demonstrates a refinement to the steel design process that
instructs the program to reserve some residual capacity in the members it
selects, so the structure is more tolerant of increases in self-weight as well
as the inevitable load redistribution effects that accompany changes in
stiffness.
92
Apr-11
What options are available in situations where some members have failed after
the Check Code command? One option is to perform additional design iterations:
reselect, regroup, and reanalyze. This process can be iterated over and over until
STAAD.Pro converges on a solution. In larger and more complex models, more
design iterations may be required in order to converge on a solution.
However, there is a quick way to reduce the number of iterations that may be
required by using a design parameter called RATIO.
In the Steel Design dialog, click the + sign to the left of the Parameter 1
folder in the Command Tree. Click the TRACK 0 parameter to make it the
current location.
In the menu bar, click Select > By Group Name In the Select Groups
dialog, click the group name _CENTRAL-GIRDER and then click Close.
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the After Current checkbox, and
then click the RATIO parameter.
Note: The RATIO parameter can be used to specify an upper limit for the Unity
Check ratio of the section. Setting this value to something less than 1.0
directs STAAD.Pro to select members with some reserve capacity with
respect to the code design strength.
This builds in a margin of additional strength in the structure that allows
it to tolerate the inevitable redistribution of loads that occurs when
member stiffnesses change. The resulting design is less sensitive to
subtle shifts in load. In this way, an acceptable design may be found
with fewer design iterations.
Apr-11
In the Steel Design dialog, click the + sign to the left of the Parameter 2
folder in the Command Tree. Click the CODE AASHTO LRFD command to
make it the current location.
93
In the menu bar, click Select > By Group Name In the Select Groups
dialog, click the group name _CENTRAL-GIRDER and then click Close.
then click the RATIO parameter. The value in the input field defaults back
to 1. This time, leave it at its default value.
12 In the Design Parameters dialog, click the Assign button, and then Close.
Note: Now when an analysis is run, the SELECT command will use an upper
limit of 0.4 on the unity ratio when optimizing, but the CHECK CODE
command will use an upper limit of 1.0 on the unity ratio when
performing the final check. If any member still fails, the new member
sizes could be captured with Results > Update Properties, and then the
analysis could be run again to see if STAAD.Pro will correct the failure
based on the redistribution of forces, or the original sizes could be
retained and the RATIO parameter could be revised to a more
conservative value.
11 In the Design Parameters dialog, click the After Current checkbox, and
94
Apr-11
Continue working in the current model, or open the saved dataset file
named Bridge 20.std and click the Design tab in the Page Control.
In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis Then, click Save (if
prompted) to acknowledge that the model has changed.
In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click the Go to Post Processing
Mode radio button and then click Done.
In the Page Control area, click the Beam tab and then click the Unity Check
sub-tab.
In the Design Results table, click the Actual Ratio column heading to sort
all members by their ratio values. Notice that the central girder member
has been optimized to W33x424.
Scroll down and note that the highest ratio is now greater than 0.4, but
still less than 1.0. The use of the RATIO parameter has addressed the stress
creep that was occurring.
It is interesting to note that not all of the members ended up with a ratio
less than 0.4, which was the limit used in the SELECT command. This is a
good demonstration of how stresses can creep after member sizes
change and forces redistribute.
Apr-11
95
Good practice is to use values between zero and 1.0 with the RATIO
parameter.
In addition to modifying the allowable stresses, RATIO has the effect of acting
as a multiplier on allowable KL/r slenderness ratios. This makes RATIO very
effective in building some conservatism into a design when it is used with
values less than 1.0, but makes it technically incorrect if used with values
greater than 1.
Also note that RATIO acts on the DFF parameter when performing a deflection
check. An adjustment may need to be made to the allowable deflection limits
to account for this.
96
Apr-11
In the File toolbar, click the STAAD Output icon to view the output file.
In the STAAD Output Viewer, click the first STEEL DESIGN line under the
RESULTS bar to go straight to the section in the output file that reports the
results of the member selection process.
Note that the results listed in this section are of various sizes, because the
Grouping command has not yet been applied. Also, noticed that the ratios
in this section are all close to 0.4 because of the parameter we applied to
set an upper limit of 0.4 on the ratios during the selection process.
Apr-11
In the STAAD Output Viewer, click the second STEEL DESIGN line under the
RESULTS bar to observe the results that are based on the reanalysis of the
girder with members of a uniform size and with the RATIO parameter reset
to 1.0.
In the menu bar, select File > Exit to close the STAAD Output Viewer.
97
In the Post Processing mode menu bar, click Results > Select Load Case
In the Results Setup dialog, click the Loads tab and deselect all Load Cases.
Then, select Load Case 5 only.
Note: Load 5 is the Reference Load that consists only of unfactored lane loads
In the Results Setup dialog, click the Range tab. Click the Ranges radio
button, enter 153 in the Nodes field, and then click OK.
In the Page Control area, click the Node tab, Displacement sub-tab. The
Node Displacements table now clearly indicates a downward deflection of
1.064 inches in the global Y direction. This equates to a deflection-to-span
length ratio of approximately L/900.
98
Apr-11
SELECT OPTIMIZED
When the SELECT OPTIMIZED command is issued, the following steps are taken:
CHECK CODE ALL, then modify ratios, then SELECT ALL, then PERFORM ANALYSIS,
then SELECT ALL.
FIXED GROUP
The FIXED GROUP command is used with the SELECT OPTIMIZED command, in the
same way that GROUP is used with the SELECT command. It creates a grouping
that is retained in memory so it can be used in subsequent member select
operations.
Apr-11
99
STAAD.Pro has the ability to design beams, columns, and slabs (plates) in the
batch mode. In all cases, the result of these designs is a reinforcing requirement
for the specified beam size, column size, or slab thickness.
Plate 205
In the Page Control area, click the Design tab and the Concrete sub-tab.
Click the Select Listed Entities button and then click Close.
5
In the Concrete Design dialog, make sure that the Current Code is set to
ACI and then click the Define Parameters.. button.
Note: The CLB item is active by default. This parameter is used to specify the
100
Apr-11
Note: The value of the CLB parameter is currently 1.5 inches. Since we are
seeing this parameter for the very first time, we know that we are
seeing the default value. All parameters have a default value. It is only
necessary to assign a parameter if there is a need to use something
other than the default value. Otherwise, STAAD.Pro just uses the default
value.
6
In the Design Parameters dialog, enter 0.75 in into the input field for the
CLB parameter, and then click the Assign button.
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the CLT parameter. Enter 0.75 in into
the input field for the CLT parameter, and then click the Assign button.
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the FC parameter, and note that the
default value is 4 kip/in2. The intent is to use this default value in the
design, so nothing needs to be done with this parameter.
Note: The yield strength parameters for main and secondary reinforcing were
not selected. In this exercise, the default value of 60 ksi is used for these
parameters.
9
Note: This completes the assignment of Design Parameters. The next step is to
dialog.
13 In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click View Output File radio
says CONCRETE DESIGN. This is a link that jumps directly to the location
where the concrete design results appear in the output file.
The next section provides an annotated interpretation of the slab design results.
Apr-11
101
LONG. REINF
MOM-X /LOAD
(SQ.IN/FT)
1:
FY:
COVER (BOTTOM):
TRANS. REINF
(K-FT/FT)
(SQ.IN/FT)
0.750 IN TH:
MOM-Y /LOAD
(K-FT/FT)
0.750 IN
12.000 IN
:2
205 TOP :
0.259
0.00 /
0.259
0.00 /
BOTT:
0.647
30.65 /
13
0.368
16.93 /
13
Item 2: Indication that reinforcing steel ratios were controlled by codeminimum limits for both directions of the top.
102
Apr-11
Item 3: Design results for the top reinforcing. The headings on the table
provide the key to the columns of data, which are presented in the
following order:
Item 4: Design results for the bottom reinforcing with all of the same
information as described above.
Close the STAAD Output Viewer to prepare for the next exercise.
Apr-11
103
The nodes defining the quadrilateral plate were drawn in the order A - B - C - D.
The nodes defining the triangular plate were drawn in the order A - B - C. The
orientation of the local coordinate system for plates is determined as follows:
The cross-product of vectors AB and AC defines a vector parallel to the local zaxis, i.e., z = AB x AC. The z-axis is always perpendicular to the plate surface.
The cross-product of vectors z and x defines a vector parallel to the local yaxis, i.e., y = z cross x. (Both the x and the y axes always lie in the plane of the
plate.)
The origin of the axes is at the center (average) of the 3 or 4 node locations
that define the plate.
Hint: The keyboard hotkey Shift + T toggles the display of Plate Orientation axes on
104
Apr-11
Beam 463
In the following exercise, it helps to note that node 307 is the node that connects
beam 463 to the column, as shown in the figure below.
Apr-11
105
Open the saved dataset file named Bridge 23.std. This is the same model
we have been working with, except:
In the Page Control area, click the Design tab and then click the Concrete
sub-tab.
Click the Select Listed Entities button and then click Close.
5
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the MAXMAIN item. Enter a value of
11 in the field to limit the maximum bar size to #11, and then click Assign.
Note: The maxmain parameter defines the maximum permissible rebar size
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the TRACK item. Click the (2) radio
button corresponding to the highest level of output detail, and then click
Assign, followed by Close.
Note: The track parameter is used to select the level of detail to be provided in
the output.
8
Note: The Design Beam item is active by default. The Design Beam item is used
In the Design Commands dialog, click the Assign button followed by Close.
10 In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis. In the Warning dialog, click
Save.
106
Apr-11
11 In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click View Output File radio
pane.
The next section provides an annotated interpretation of the beam design results.
Scroll down in the output file and locate the beginning of the design output for
BEAM NO. 463. The first line of data in the beam design output echoes the beam
dimensions and material properties.
BEAM
LEN -
NO.
10.00FT.
FC - 4000.
The next section provides geometric information about the layer of rebar that
occurs near the bottom of the beam. See the descriptions corresponding to the
numbered items in the figure below.
LEVEL
HEIGHT
FT.
BAR INFO
IN.
FROM
FT.
TO
IN.
FT.
ANCHOR
IN.
STA
END
_____________________________________________________________________
Apr-11
0 + 2-5/8
10-NUM.9
3 +11-5/8
10 + 0-0/0
NO
YES
Item 4: Starting location of the rebar at this level, measured from the
starting node of the beam.
Item 5: Ending location of the rebar at this level, measured from the
starting node of the beam.
107
Below the line of geometric data pertaining to the first layer of rebar is a dashed
box. It contains the design information for the first layer of rebar including:
A single line of text below the dashed box reports the cracked moment of inertia
at the location of the design moment.
Subsequent levels of rebar are described in the same manner. In this beam, there
is a need for a top layer of rebar to resist negative moment for the full length of
the member, so the second level is indicated as shown in the figure below.
2
3 + 9-1/8
16-NUM.11
0 + 0-0/0
10 + 0-0/0
YES
YES
|----------------------------------------------------------------|
|
4532.45 KIP-FT
AT
8|
|----------------------------------------------------------------|
Cracked Moment of Inertia Iz at above location =
237780.50 inch^4
The top layer of rebar consists of 16 - #11 bars being designed for the negative
moment of approximately 4534 kip-ft at the starting end. The anchorage labels
indicate that this rebar is assumed to be anchored (hooked or otherwise fully
developed) at both ends, so it would be important to detail these bars in such a
way as to validate this assumption.
108
Apr-11
------------------------------SECTION
(FEET)
REINF STEEL(+VE/-VE)
(SQ. INCH)
MOMENTS(+VE/-VE)
LOAD(+VE/-VE)
(KIP-FEET)
0.00
0.000/
24.619
0.00/
4532.45
0/
0.83
0.000/
21.319
0.00/
3983.09
0/
1.67
0.000/
18.132
0.00/
3435.54
0/
2.50
0.000/
15.050
0.00/
2889.84
0/
3.33
0.000/
12.062
0.00/
2346.03
0/
4.17
0.000/
9.163
0.00/
1804.15
0/
5.00
0.000/
6.346
0.00/
1264.23
0/
5.83
0.000/
3.605
0.00/
726.31
0/
6.67
0.000/
0.935
0.00/
190.43
0/
7.50
1.707/
0.000
346.70/
0.00
9/
8.33
4.372/
0.000
878.20/
0.00
9/
9.17
7.087/
0.000
1407.55/
0.00
9/
10.00
9.855/
0.000
1934.71/
0.00
9/
Note: There are likely to be subtle differences in the reinforcing steel areas reported
by the Design Results section and the Required Reinforcing Steel Summary due
to a difference in the way the required reinforcing steel areas are calculated in
the two locations.
In the Design Results section, the program iterates until the effective depth
used to calculate the area of steel required is the value based on the actual
bars being provided. For example, if the steel provided says 7 NUM 5 for the
midspan region, then the effective depth is based on the arrangement of
seven #5 bars.
Apr-11
109
The next section of output presents the shear design for the starting end and the
ending end of beam 125.
B E A M
N O.
463 D E S I G N
Vc=
645.85 KIP
Tu=
R E S U L T S - SHEAR
366.00 KIP
Ts=
Vs=
495.12 KIP
0.00 KIP-FT
LOAD
SUPPORT - Vu=
Tu=
1.88 KIP-FT
638.58 KIP
Vc=
653.94 KIP
Ts=
14. IN.
Vs=
197.50 KIP
0.00 KIP-FT
LOAD
14. IN.
The shear designs incorporate the effects of both shear and torsion in beams, and
indicate any required stirrups and additional longitudinal reinforcing.Diagrams of
the elevation view and sections through the beam are provided next. The
diagrams schematically show the top and bottom longitudinal reinforcement and
the stirrups. See the itemized descriptions corresponding to the numbered items
in the figure below.
1
2 120.X 48.X 48_____________________
3 305J____
___ 307J____________________
||=========================================================================||
|16#11H
45.
0.TO
120.
|
|
4#7 C/C
7
3.
48.TO
120.
3#5 C/C
| |
| |
9
| |
| |
| |
10#9 H
=============================================||
|___________________________________________________________________________|
_______________
_______________
_______________
_______________
|OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO|
|OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO|
|OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO|
|OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO|
|10#9
|10#9
|_______________|
|_______________|
OOOOOOOOOO
|_______________|
110
10
OOOOOOOOOO
|
|
|_______________|
Apr-11
approximately 7 inches.
6
section
Note: If we had requested reinforced concrete designs for three contiguous
Apr-11
111
The beam design parameters and commands that we entered in the previous
exercise have been removed from the dataset file we are about to open. In
addition, the Loading Conditions in the following exercise have been revised to
represent extreme conditions for axial and bending forces on member 462 shown
highlighted in the figure below.
Member 462
Open the saved dataset file named Bridge 24.std. This is the same model
we have been working with, except:
In the Page Control area, click the Design tab and the Concrete sub-tab.
Click the Select Listed Entities button and then click Close.
112
Apr-11
In the Design Parameters dialog, select the Maxmain item and then enter
a value of 8 in the field to limit the maximum bar size to #8. Click Assign.
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the REINF item. Click the (1) radio
button to indicate a spirally reinforced column, and then click Assign.
Note: The REINF parameter is used to distinguish between Tied and Spiral
In the Design Parameters dialog, click the TRACK item. Click the (2) radio
button corresponding to the highest level of output detail, and then click
Assign, followed by Close.
Note: The TRACK parameter is used to select the level of detail to be provided
in the output.
9
10 In the Design Commands dialog, click the DESIGN COLUMN item. Click the
for biaxial bending moments and axial force (My, Mz and Fx).
11 In the menu bar, click Analyze > Run Analysis... In the Warning dialog,
click Save.
12 In the STAAD Analysis and Design dialog, click the View Output File radio
says CONCRETE DESIGN. This is a link that jumps directly to the location of
the concrete design results in the output file.
The next section provides an annotated interpretation of the column design
results.
Apr-11
113
COLUMN
FY - 60000
NO.
462
FC - 4000 PSI,
CIRC SIZE
32.029
SPIR
SQ. IN.
REINF PCT.
LOAD
LOCATION
PHI
---------------------------------------------------------41 - NUMBER
1.790
27
STA
0.700
(EQUALLY SPACED)
TIE BAR NUMBER
4 SPACING
2.00 IN
values with the MINMAIN and MAXMAIN parameters to bracket the desired
reinforcing size for the column.
Scroll down in the output file and locate the beginning of the design output for
COLUMN NO. 462. Material and geometric properties are listed first.
114
Apr-11
Pn max
7985.77
M0
P-bal.
6787.90
3097.14
P-tens.
2982.71
-1943.40
Des.Pn
1828.28
M-bal.
4438.96
Des.Mn
4238.25
e-bal.(inch)
17.20
e/h
0.00087
-------------------------------------------------------Pn
|
P0 |*
| *
Pn,max|__*
|
Pn
NOMINAL|
AXIAL|
*
*
Mn
Pn
Mn
6265.76
2367.98
3132.88
4427.19
5743.61
2905.15
2610.73
4497.10
5221.46
3347.44
2088.59
4427.21
4699.32
3711.95
1566.44
4243.59
4177.17
4004.13
1044.29
3935.27
3655.03
4238.74
522.15
3519.60
*
*
COMPRESSION|
Pb|-------*Mb
|
___________|____*_______
|
| *
P-tens|*
* M0
Mn,
BENDING
MOMENT
Close the STAAD Output Viewer to prepare for the next section.
Apr-11
115
The Take Off command is designed to summarize the quantity of concrete and
reinforcing steel in the designed beams and columns.
The take off quantities consider beams and columns, but not plate elements.
The quantities only consider beams and columns that have actually been
designed.
Note that the concrete volume is in units of cubic feet, not cubic yards.
116
Apr-11
Module Review
Module Review
Now that you have completed this module, lets measure what you have learned.
Under what conditions might the RATIO parameter prove useful during
steel member selection?
Questions
Apr-11
117
Module Review
Answers
When optimizing multi-segment steel members, the batch mode of steel
design is likely to select many different sections along the length of the
member as the design requirements vary. What command does STAAD.Pro
provide to address this issue and lend uniformity to the designs?
The GROUP command can be used to evaluate a set of beams, identify
the one with the largest area or section modulus, and then reassign that
section property to all beams within the set.
2
Under what conditions might the RATIO parameter prove useful during
steel member selection?
The RATIO parameter can be used to reserve some capacity as the
program optimizes steel members. It can be particularly useful in
achieving an acceptable design more quickly under conditions where
changes in stiffness cause significant changes in load distribution, which
continue to overstress the members that have just been stiffened.
118
Apr-11
Course Summary
Now you will be able to:
Set design parameters and issue design commands to perform code checks or
to optimize steel members according to the requirements of AASHTO code for
steel members and ACI code for concrete members.
Course Summary
Apr-11
119
Copyright 2011 Bentley Systems, Incorporated
Course Summary
Course Review
Course Review
Questions
1
Now that you have completed this course, lets measure what you have learned.
True
False
True
False
The steel design process in STAAD.Pro can evaluate deflections for a multisegment bridge girder.
True
False
Course Summary
120
Apr-11
Course Review
Answers
1
False
The ease and convenience of the Graphical User Interface is equally wellsuited for modeling structures of all types, including bridge structures. As
always, the text input file is still accessible for instances where it may be
easier to make an edit to the file directly.
Beava's power lies in its ability to locate loads to maximize or minimize the
response of selected structural functions. However, it remains the
engineer's task to select the members whose structural functions are to
be maximized or minimized.
3
The steel design process in STAAD.Pro can evaluate deflections for a multisegment bridge girder.
True
By using the DFF, DJ1 and DJ2 parameters, the steel design engine is
capable of correctly evaluating the deflections of a multi-span girder by
normalizing the deflections at the end nodes and then comparing the
critical deflection to the overall girder span.
Apr-11
121
Course Summary
Course Review
Course Summary
122
Apr-11