Você está na página 1de 133

ARISTOTEL

POETICA
Stldiuintodcriv,raduceE
si conrdx'ii

iner9i.i dcSfEI-l,A I,ETECET

qr
(rR ,l -r2:i. n)
^ R IS IOT F .L

EDI]AJRA IRI

NOTA ASUPRAEDITIEI
MARI^NA MNRZE^

l'i;irlrtr.r^;,1"j

| '::,!l,iiiI
In.-'rkr({\

A III-A

PDtiLe sDt in lune tattrcctta .t. o lit da prctu'di.


d' Poelca,
uEallxd si
inlclccc4 r eirddut,r:r...r?
'unLxtii
gind rtre, dens,
ettptic s.i nlcsc, cnjEnxi. evdnat. sttcitl.
ih tc gii atet e a nnt et oj s kEh 7,. cr."
nc x L tatsptt i1' tcnrcnii cchlrt
puLi.c snL si iDtc.Fcdnlc tle a tsenere' seLihc hc , p.nind
.tc tt n xsp.ct sxuntin d1tuttn'1ui, si ncryi but tr rv,g, sn
r.t dnnt..i dtnEneu|i a irtdli
ontpte hkc
Nrnittjct)
.lcttirS d6nte n nu tt trgite 2c
tt'spcctirx ctunr:ljci a43r)c ad
tatetic, itidividuxti/.art . in rapatt ctr xltc rjpfti de etnnne tle
A ns.ncnd ot ti rt' ttttt lntcpti'rtc ttrttt D, sp..t,tist
i.nt tBnl upxbil si crprih.lt si sdlnleletet diq tudal
tu j L.nianLctr i riixnLclc in njlc
" trticI, eia
ri a intcpd.sr,1n natt tn'lisrst, D M Pini'ti
( t!or,,
1l iudiilt nxarc d^iq canLinrxtu.lnccl
'r nnitone k kns ti Ptrn,ttn^flL
.,'rL
riat,
lnr tirac c.i.,,,ttrr"rirrt.ra'6-o
Ndnnkt
I

Aelr Jd exprdr f,c .e ,.uD, tednlt k pcsletd dc..Dii de


adn+
ta rt dtehts sA,prr!].. valumul isi rinfttil.nultudi
tixt t
xcttulittld reteni a nutil
pte,zntx ctLtic, Paean), tttt.ptrD

NorA A S U P S qE p t T lE l a llr
^

l::::';'i::,:.:.:;:::::::::i2iH::,::::xi,:,:ni::
jx:[i::l:t,:

ir.:hiii1:t,#"::ii#,r!

INOTA ASUPM EDI]IEI

A U-4, 19651

,[ffi*rW

)it o prn lamt, nult dcxebiti de sce' dc


prc
rcntu n Jucet n Peticei tu Atktotcl r Io! prblicafi'!iiri,
tn 1910,
nitrnnnDn Btt^ llc Batdre,eptiTate h cebvasdpttnnti
pti.l stltujtltcu utre dea tmqtt otiihnd doutbi de rni ni s-a
enstpeSAt{
octlitit tu t, h.mt
N studii| pthticzb ind
tinD, ]a dtrat si.t ptuptijlc tulc.
eean xsvn idcilat titttE
h Atdchitutc - uneteinedite,tuc)c tipinb iatpe'tt d)t 1935in
atinb rtyhtc .tin ta'ii t stdi'thte
Multunid inqtee*n kItuii aadenEi R.P.R.,rcanzna
gc$tti jhtalji derine Ecto' posibili, in coDrtiniE frc dia vcchea
irisin as t td*et
schinbtti netnstuatc, stuliul irtodD1iv ,i .tuDlrnrt
t6t
r.fi2ute , sinlitat spornc,h ,cast9 2dtugad!-tu
eb 'ur.mit
dc dpnttici nai nulG etdii tpccixte xswts uDn .]' uabte
nele de cr$.aie xte dactjrcl ctcticc a c.1ui nr2i npEz.'.ttiv
i tc urrcfii.t @ ih,
.ituptt spreztb dmcnii at. sti4t i Anb.hit4ij, fid nadcjnct dc a brc'i cendvz ]a jsbnt htet.r Ertc{i 'n sj hnnc,
votun\sd ofetitasdzi pDbticttui EpEzintii, inn dte sz std,'u
iatuunatd uej stt tdnti in Jniatc. ci pDrctul.lc plccm xt und

CUPRINS
Nd:;pndird!n

!, ie65l ...

..

r. rni!'n,ercld ! pr,ii! 1&ioddr !tu


drrr nijL@leha ln&ruLdrca rcdtod

L4Ea';Lrrniu'

Ln ur ! .

rnPdra i szi!
.r6ry'c!rr5

soiLq r
qsqxi

oba,iu !i &dd,ircr !i h i@FBi. dr t!s{o.


lls:gc i sqPlt
ii$nMah
( vr.Dcinititedci.rhrudd!dir@sddtoti
xv. Dcdrtd! sod(i
DurbiriiE

vn. cd dhdidensr d hFdni: $!i!rld su Di!i. s!6iqul

!i!!4

cdenirrunarn'b'e&...

xr ide4iitraridr.dcf4dti
.!|grollu

npanlrc hrE Eq!


.. ..

p4lsr,eEle4r,dqlll
oit6r e

rdhgj9

xrv.ll!sls!,b!r4

r b!id!4n!q

Fd

'!B!!'s!

CUPRINS

iisde,--;.fF

D$sr

xrx

rq4'ft dc rls.dd slltr !niqb


^ke
xr E!ruddrErt!LU: h*r. !r.r.r, Fnl

xxv,.GDslGi@hgdriillw

!.15 x*p

n Ar0! i a,nbn! rnj!rurodcidb


fl
\irr di& hnrs{!ap.r
rv ^dkid
h$trD!r\'rquhAr\bbr\iIieN(tu,;xvn

INTRODUCERE

lr.

. t'!6j

2xj ixvro216

in ldmr n, od. ne a li,$ tssnn\ srin caa c infiliiat astizi


lui Arttotel Ilai ndrlr(i( - Poe,.r,
cnn n'luj . opuscultrl
cumisespuieobisnuit (prcTjtrii.lririindoirLl.numriopctt
Ihotulu:origio .Luc'd$poarcd.dnce,inainlcdcroare.din
k oiruic!trrtului laototmacomcdioidincarenunc-!rlmas
nici o urmlir. RLics, n,,si,iot atir debim, dint o scricd. relemb
artarltriali Aridobl ln tdsul Da?r rbrtj. in cfc,potuni'l'l
s$ic.redezvolr.toinopuacnsi .reterzil,lis,slselnblcagi
ci d fi Lin rlciluri did nai mtrxc ciirlir: CuDr a! d.vedit o
cer.eri!tri ftccnti, ip.ieTa cc. nii lndrPr ilii Patccer caE I
atibuic dou, cm dc Joui..i intindcre!Errulu' ajhc ptlt
h noii. si, penru cll rcda din trdn (cafrerl, dupl roarc

D.M. PIPPIDI

INTRODUCERE I"{ POA?]CT

pr.bahitirirlirc))einchi,rtramud,.trohirc,
rlxsrci (qlNcdti
trs.dia), ror xtft de indreltdthd lDrrc li p$uDuncrc! !i paircr
ricrduda! rirdd dc*prc hurt,.!
t,ocTicl.prducuilcnnb,coimnce6 r
rar.lcuGitrlscric.ilorccrl.!t cscarllzicolel op!*lor
rn$orclic (sirgBraexcepli.
liirdconnitDitrdc trtrtul dcspre
sr,nrrdidn,/or'A8ryai!/
rolr.ia,4qsopdtrhsreSisl
vrftulur kcur
utrr"!trdrn E!trnrlPrtn? lru! Drk Llin
'nr ?i,e
aklf
I r!.r:rirtu
.?aoqllj!:!
nr ril!.,rtlui..u : re

cun litcnrcsli dnce ciir {urortrll07. Flc singurunc n,3!duic sl ne


rcprcTrrin, anizi mer silarer elonului siicmdtizatd dcsfisutut
do Srrgint,si antrfteint-o forml nd neminocitf,deI ru nai
ruiedicl dccl nc r L irgrdtriro ldma cli(t{ri i scricilor

anv'i,roa lucrirlloiaa-,u ciu sorrilcrisDandiriiin mrrcrcDubric


hTtrilof,n!turc ptu. s Llr r3 lrunK.ipr\ Lrfo\b (ik

{lc

de{rareuDliccrclrrg olrnon i{,raroi rd}DL soisccu


'lc
barditrCnjira conpatibili curubiectel.rahb. decelemai
'nulr.
/ lntanplma, cae hdrrn5bsod{ chilor, d ficur e scnon[
cltE lc9alelui Arisbcl. hilrizircvcmiciei,si pirri panih ur.
Nc ru dms, $him6.clcmcrclc
smcnrcroaDahd,
mrle de

(sedJ.i'fu1#!LLbla4ltr!!'.Lxl

lnrre unclc si cclelaltc tebuie s! n existrl de rltmltrien un


ptrrrcr msteDs.ccrnrina( p.n. din todcnilcinEticarcJi
opcrclcajuNcplrrla mi emu.cu signrrii hbte int un chip
linp.dc siphcft inl\dyo, iao(p'
pistati chiarJc rclcnnr.lc lulAi$otd.Ecr7ul uDeiscrier.e
Fre si li avui u. cuprins Acmtnitor, dacil du idenlic cu a@l rl
P@ri. d. vrne ce,in capiktul xV al accncia,nlozolul siDlur
riniru k c! lEtrru dhcul,armiDu
kDtC. clc anuri. vr fi ro aasd op.rl, c mi grcu dc spus.in
crrdosul$ncnluaricudiocliicnlub. doudtitltr.isepornvesc
hlnecu reprezentrcr pc cdc nc.o purcft f&e despreer: lile
'ni nnpa{ si pdiinrclc nlobgilor, dinr* car udii pnilrc cl
eb se
Gudc'natr,unddir ultimLieditn ai Pocrt ie-o identilicicu
n@r@r{io ri< a.'rrliia rirv
lucirdcRoi{!ri.-ouJialogrl ltriri ci4, flai rdLrriil0
Oricrrcarli icci idtoF?ror I;tolde c{ri.s rsemlnl
tor. pe cm,Aisolor in$rsi ntr s dir si-i opuni Dorcl.ffi'i

prrn'ic{rc\Pdrr9lciraclgnlrqrollurn-sorqic

rrrcci

teiac oglinditlirll luriltl del$eltre h compodir i' Yilul ci,


'k4dr4Ejudid

rlid

i {e

'i

F,e.

F
IA POETTCA
INTRODUCERE

D NT PLPPIDI
amiindonlncobirruibpenrfl o opcd dp$l'nind u,ei pcrio'Jc

tLllPlrllf i\m\'

qr

n [ur w- csturiluS lir in-!R!13[& t rd n n rd ro u p e n in rL


tla or.dete, riitrn-r,le.Lip* \i hI LhiLg' \
rurrliien
I.crplicftile I', oncc ,L!! ipotei. - nind vorba'i un cdset[ior dc
ralir rui Arisrorcl.-acncpdictrlrritiri 3eLlmdEs.l.rne plln
lunr ! u', Lmpa n 4 t td n ! ' n n lilrrt r ld rrd r

l!-riqi d.re,,

om'd*;[
"r,inLci,

n(.-rc i

lcclii: intcbic cu rrit dd


Eblm uidc vor a roy $rulc
'canc
llrasoi, cucir, diiiinfomal]llcdc car dnpnncn6uDr aciivitilii
d. dascllalni Arisiol.l,.7ult!clarintrttcolidcinlclcpciuncin
doDil.curi si in doul pcrlodc :rlevicrii''
'' PrimaDdoadi. orc lnccpin rtrol rnnluil48. n'drri duDr
n o r r r e aluiP labn,sidurcazici'r c is a n s s u rn i, s e d c s ilio a rr
nancinAsiaMicr h Asos,in Toa'la ,prtunrMvriLcncCea
ic adouaeuoiultiniiari aiic\ii nloblu ni(r34 123ter):
anidc lebrillnNncictabrc lctc.uii h Alcnr'in
unsprczcce
scoliinoLdctnlclctcrnc
dumbravaLycctrlui.dcvdnitiiccntul
intc dcestedou[ Fnoadc ilc Inve$niN fubl'c sc srueu ui
h
cei mtri m' pelrecud
monrcntimponadinvi a L:lozotului,
a
ctxn
p$9tuni
iiidlina
Pclla.iiclrmri
FiLiD,in
Cuncareleni
c' rvc! sI lic Al.xrndd .cl Mffe

Elimuri.cl,.nobdcdB dcrl{ c4lrpJ 9es leqlqain

o:e^ijtrde;r ! 'J R"unr 1-DUb[Ji


vr r:L(d\4.C!R '
'
r
d
l
.
/
i
r
i
l
.
on duol mareidul IiEru cc(cra!, itc.mpmbil mi fdilitr unor
n nie;1 dcceloriciliui rx auditoriu cr accnca@buic si fi fo$
rjnubint uitrl ditrarn invilinenhluL aicnirn Ar tubr ch'ar
;cti: din rn'nii ani ai rca$ui itrvidmlin! (334-330lpoxima'
iir), dtui iineinssd{ dc httul ci in rcel rone AriMorclsc
giscaI)riN inb o sic decarcertuicu
in
(nuomviraL,bruFnLo,irrL.in colaboErtcu Carlsthencs)
.cntrrc DMie.incl la Cunadjtr ?cll{'4. altelcin&nire cu sicu
.itr tnit"n ltrt.- r.,"-.*"i.
^L6aoKcriotj)
filobsicil,ace$
o vanicurioziha
Deper. de a salislacc
rczunat csnotosic,inlcstette sinlrror hlcrcgerer anud-!i!!
P t rL . . nr p u ' c ,

ffi

;FffiiDftr.-Di]iml;;ipnifi;iiJc_;rlris@

F"i

;XF*,-jjjj-j..jffi
Dish oi, ru nrnn4zi

inp.nrnh aceici
iijffid
ideilo
coNratiri;cid vEmcrrDdGrcala vcdcnLinaintrsuluiscdoredenc ccanri siguri calcde I'rrelcgcE3 pnrprd.lui dochte,
raloarca dorodolosi.i a ,pbpicrii rimine lntErsi'"

l5

IN TRODUCERELC IOEflCA
: jatii inlin'o dc blc, crcnpldlJlq
'
unu *i.c ri rclil!Lt. scinliiliscaTicd lind ii trlrifradicscniii

,.j!ir{i,f: | +r". ,'. D" mdc.;sn.p;ntu pr.!on.naasi ihir}


rictru-{dctir. irdclcrdoiami.cirdrsilrirnignouc,ru\urniri
crrcirrlstrL urmrrc$c
srrcpsducr'nccanic
@riiarucxrcdm.:i. rrprcr
.mcmgi. ArjstoGldcflrcrb sidiiror
'niimpuri
rcca{i c.nce!!ie,
adandcaobiBcr
ar3c!iviritrminerienur{
rlhrrruerfi cirii,4tudDenb*iscntion nnimplrilitruedt.
.i.jd.mtseqrarij.
F ihb ?at

..modirdcre,.a.cd{Iclasiti.rrcc ado$atisi deAr(torcl\cu


desehnercsedialtcii, vremcce.prinrr_obi?dircslL{sgca
s n ! ! t o F R L e h t r n L li ' a t E o r n l e l ' L
{ n mrlt e ' a : a ! s '
ri u hii srzlinruru'mLmc'
l ll fl,u llJc.trie d. Phronnry:
!e .o.r. tr. rn;L dd"o b e L b
rd" i I1.fr i|'ie

a t.".

.r\L . $ ld t

e: ,lim J

r r 0u

,"

o..o u "n .'.

".'

'm\riDu.tld

.!f c 4'r o4r r 4'q

PUri

-J'li
p'tue'r ur
l r 'nr -

L' l oteh
n1'bJ
r'l
o dr , ' u . . 0
'D'"I('
i" in -n k l u i @ ' n F m h r '
^ . " d lrtnvitl tr n'E(flru1
Amra snorniccifrerinddiscipoltrlui
idloh'craren.ivechc.rm,ntprilci slstrbliiicTmisun
m.dr h Plrtuq-0rctu!n us n{a

Si iari,d*ugand dinaccas[ihndmenhli diveBentio dh,


torrrir dcicmnilirdivi.iDciudr
uncircrnnnolo!ii
idcnricc
si r
unuipud.rdepled.onui\odcinc !i jitr&lcrnicitinr-m lct (mcarecuPlatonsi.apuur d. icami .i * intillndrc h .ccr nlozof
rCetrurilorlneraG.
o adevdndclatiricaE
dqillrolulDe.orc.l
nnibiia
in
[{m
di.
eltr
se
Rie,
anu'ne.
cI o priinlcrb
Faci

"

rds! 5itumn)
clriedeo,odud'irsLi!<(ihDri'idlrin,lecruLilc
carridulldcdb
.sarrd $b /cnumncadi\r 6'd:!$'ied<
(,,uri saui! inrcglmcimrr$[ci
o a douxutlonc
drrii
6LrilF,. sui, draly.l\ias:inbirisandrimilciocnpo
vcnib lco.chr.liohlri.trchviunilcDne Jc tulddilnrmbiloi
li \tidir..i. ulLi'iii!rLsurn. {r.]ndLhDLDnroLi')
uDv'L!a.cd
p ncld douii rlpuri
nruti\d:] r. lyi
sn in 'L teli 6" dr@,leov {tr.*pop1 v o . , n t ro < I ' P c n t t r

orrc
n,!i
, e ' _ . . _ . 'h F - . ' d
:'""'p."
"
r r ; D ' D' s r b r ' r ' : - o r r
/ n 3 6 p " (r l e e
S li !
\i
aif
n lhuni
i"t
rr" . rl, f ir ' .
'rL;p

-.-"

' ' Pr . o _ " 1 :e ' r

-Tt"#,,lift:*+;ffi]
-F.".'."

Gfiiffi.

.,1." *
ri" .".:".
-. |imi
: n -. f l
' ,' .JL

stlilhi l fdJ.qtrLgl d$'

io " ". r " " r ' p u '

d. dPr "

mo'il. s L L

r dt '"j

'

rrlr

"u'

'

D M P1PPIDI

L \ POFTI'A
INTRODI]C]]RE

lirin .alificrlivol3 arrh0nc postitorrcpETiD|inJ cclc douil orien


rrd:,,r an Eni poeztr.-.itim._dupiicakcrcrclc
indiidurle
arcpocrilor,tuih $norsc (o!ydr.po!)indinerdsi imiE ispdvie dc$ si raprelc.ito.rtcsi.
i{cete dcIind Gtrr.raor.poL)pe
rrc .sncn ii or Eciopiili: glu ! ii conpuil Jin capultd.ntui stih0ri
de do.tdiii,prccun ccitrlii cendnisi laude. tl
Dov'drc: rf.t fku[ NUnhr.B rJDon]rcalura,n.k
r ,rc tc tu' f hion- mr,8rru;
j k dopL.;.,,ti, F";.r.

!r . r , . 1 . -

_ .1 ,!1 .

cnn an trnt pilejnl s o dlt, dupil allir.i' lucrer


FuM

Liizo6

J!:

iu erpr mJ llnl

dint.luminddrrumh

l. e d . '
-',r're.rc ..1
r isu r rcudRnba4(tord.!il\i\roie
e ! J p rh , |l* ' ,]in
u mDc / e io
rccft puncrcalhinrci nei'lctcsc,,nud exptjci h oc tcl, dup!
aipra condrmore pldonicr. inruvcori, lui a,hrolct avca5t
/ lnainiedc rprsit0sitrexpuncrcanoDtDi
pund.itcvcdorc.
ru e pete rlri fotos sr rdinresc, ttr pu{jnc.lvinrclrmponmd.
c,tk d. r.!7d(.' dLii.deLrrltrtonr
1,.,u/uj,tp!Lr\! loc/!rr.
ffi-PS*

dcJli

"cqsibil!lgma
u u,;r'{r p;rL.r;" ,cn. + .4 c re' irJEr ii

-^ru.rordr'
!'nJLre:prciru'irnN
fni

crt36, rcc*Ea

rivrrlru'!'sr i m0dtr,'niEFinopr
l"sipe urii nnmbri tencr! nn'bi!!

nnm i,,le ra b 7!iFcL,ncr!$i:ri!r].i

: 5!!ar!rm'i,re i ;jn,

r!r'!{!

p^'!m'!q

rnt or;D r sbsn hl Nd s e,im,des. J r8u'mitk


nlmdc i! PhLr s rdDc! u \ingh JJlle\pu'
rlla;{.!{r
ncrc. hi si DtutseavI t Dulcclci mai.biccrv'
'ereran
ii
;'ivcsr" D.in{ *'i" ie h"-uiri, pozilirlu An{obl
irel diDddc de a ri pAii si_siexpn grnd0rilc
dxindisri
?i!!rlf
AUpr, ML -,le.4rq\{q;!
ldlsr4r Lcr4tiillhe{
ln mlntrNurr;,'d r Festc L': in

(l)nr denr trii r.L stur,, t' {ue. rel!j4f!r!!!4!1l!!f


0 lu:4rc'sm\!!li ('t
(n,ld1Lde r.!,!!ai!!r!r!Dr!lfiltr

rprupth dr ioresr pdun cu rc


N tu-ir d,s.'r'
.;;i-ii
'rib.
i GR!'c . pnn cluul l're.seil'trLlr I Lt"ul de'trr;nJ inte
n'pi 4Lr'ooO'a<
neid.nc. rui cuseanr.nullumitidialogdlui

ji' ' '

l3

o(P.p \,,b

ll5;

dl

4h.*t

,\io.;o\

INTRODLICERELA POEIICA
corlnr!.dup.roxleFobrb'trtillc.iiciidctsrnExscdc
ta
CunFdin Pclra:rC.nsccvnr
r.c\ruiputrcrdcvedde.cdc nu
crs.cun sc vede,udsimplnaguic
c cncunN.arttl.
xuronl
Arr,rr r I putorsil ncsocoreasciobi.cu dc re]trt&eton prvind

Irrrr.{ 43rrru r-rnritbJ t!!! r. nrd .r o jrtuRi

F ..

tu-lt c! !n!:1inr{!!lla'ur!d p;"" rd.r, .


;+" .^,
"* eio sdnrir
rum's rors,.d\l.rer,,r,.u.4; tr ro$p.iuu
lr.n:i6nn!.Ls;r5r!u mu'l JlLh mrSEp'di dertrr ntu,, n
tr r or r r,?oi.:!'B4r
\w!iirn'fl i r!n'r.JD.nrut univdsJl
arpcz*i-Gadardc$pntlldmdtdephd
D!tr! ,, r,iElai
conprnre cu d.ri{: accda din mi ,icuti si cxD.idcinram
cu ilr.
trEi i.[iirt
G]rzui pddtft.
e; ,1u. iora,"
"u''nr'),
p|Ll pu\ibir..in, \rk !urre(r

,.".,","";,r,,r,
mnrreacuc,toAnnodrtrDundcccleldeadtuscnrdcobiec,
Fplatonicci,nlbrivapmzieie.inschi,nb,,milbilr.ca mrt1,
IIbrncusir !l utrcicrLZe'leliclt,shsinturitr \ov;icsJ sene&
dili.uhillilclcnbu areo.olin
bnE irvinuiscplarorpo.zi!
drama!.i dc tipsiidc cvlavi., poDrupicdl doa ri inlirsn pe &i
i't o lunini dcravonbilt? Aui.rut p.crlli $ sdbe$te sil i
.purl I rrfin k prill!ag!!4!!!!!4!!r]!
r.tru!
jrllgcl]]altr lin lectrni v rb
n dNu]lr q!!!!r!!!
rcli!i!r' risrk'lirnu{
j,r de
U
nii q-nad!,
Fih
'ri;
Lh p tusn de e$ndJ.ru ddrn{i
! lln i{ iriv n mt n L r!
uhch vor wilmowir rvl@ ctrduriT,a ptrtur o dctini: ,,uncrir,.
pc' de sre rllliror dc lcgciJi crort. phcnr poeric,njjit

$rblin, pctrh a fi ilfitisd cr pds


sanctuadlh'i Dionysos,deun cor dL.et4eni nenfii si dedoi sxu
c,r a
!t.'pl'.'tudi<"q
r!.r&c.r'hA'
,
!
d
L
r
i
r
i
r
+
!
4
{!undetr
4oL.
hll!,Licbuorer d. rdqdtr, sr(n !h
\r
Dnner.elend.Jl!Gr - d! adLLdc
.
t
r
.
r
s
.
.
d {' . i.;pn
i
"
.
i
r
r
i
0 4sm
/ 4 t j' c
'
.
1:!+!;1=
=i:i:l-!

ri4:"'s!!!

dv.dc prcdilcclicsubicdelt
i,Ad{oRlru

p!br l;\J ni!lrvd

rcsri prdr nn:mn'nm Ri\rrmvl l"i \c clF re-!l4!!L!L


r!!!!!r!!9a!!Sl1o
x!M!!jrl&dr!e! li c o n'dcn'anaGci

ryglrlq!.r4lq

e!hlE!r!

!!\a

Il]qali:rlraeedir - a?u cl. pilisind o clid rclul coktciaului


psntn rcl sfituirorului - sl nu iDlid$zc ormcni nc hpnvil
rrccaDdde la o iar dc tricne b lna dc ncfcdcnc, cici dr lcvr
d-!todrul sI *nrnersci Lrica.d.ifriLa(iIro< roi ddpo.),ci
rcpulia(rLardr).A{ijd...nicipBncmcmi.iG.anddelrostuc
!c rcreicin lr una dc ludonq din roa sittrdiilc cu p0rintr
r!csrae eanai potruicii cnroricitr8icc,neavinddan'l s:i
nici pc el dc o'nc
prtiv.accoiciDnuldinsetr.i'n.rtclccuvcDnc:
risii {'d;,oponovl,ni.inila,nici fricJ'\
Y Nici piilclul nchri zic, nici cl m(nl nu crau4nt 'le gtu ds
rsfi',s cumsrruhmrdinrrcinviinirilephb!j!!ar'-pr?;r,
nc*! dc r sebiztri p. pea .ci mai tulin alid,rii a sulldului si
'
.l! r idm Davunile..
oii.e hcJt Ll.oli(r J Llurct/Cc' msi
/\ -

INTRUDUCERE L A PC]ETI'A

D .M. P IP P 1 DI
i.!^i

itc R\. r\.olnrruu i^!!!!rri ftrlufrL{


rJliLr,+.
orholosni Ari\!tr!l 1lr!r ru rra

+Prmcsd tunctsc rdus anlel in disourictru' rllul de'at


$eoptr'c fur ru6D'rlrlJ'm s, pu{!!!t!-9i!!urlq
r Ll.d$ \ ! I1trd r ' De gd quiLr, { \u'r

rbrLl. muh-dKdbb)

pi6ir'r.i-nm-eamrinittur!fi
iinidaiGft Eiafll{-ifi trfi innac
,mn{clqL..
r,crr r
Prul,
Plr.oD.
{l nrr.cNrimrcrc,econsidei."-i,ftrrit,idLnr up
pLr!rtr! {Lrcrniinlifn

F$rpmftr.:

:v!rn{'i

ft;

;,r=":1.t"+;-.ff.1;:il*il*#-_1*.
''

.
u.r" .- -1
p rrm-e J J " r"
,.
':'n.'G.:
'
mr io5prjin!r\itruri."st0sq,!Fdt'ee
1r cbxa ils\,!o
hrebui|!n!, bjaljtipJ]c CLr]]s!!\intr \i ! .rrr.
,.punl(dc dccer cee cM!\'ii clq.
r'ffilirit
3 nrrorircoir prsirmtu ..saluiffe,in iuniii
cma inLiu"ii crrendc dc ps,a drmalcr, dhtunF c mici
siAri{olclolribab,tuplicindt
delinir dccldnrirrsediel
rdccatururuiprcificaroral
frctiunii,dilchivnevirimibi rt uiui
pnsosdcsnnrindrDhatpincasprenrisftiiLol,llibnr.

rtr.'p.crcs? - se mintri4lnci dc ir irceputul verculli {l


'r-!ati
XVll lea.DdietI'lcmsiri(3 orclinsul'rluncia\cmencarE

lrrctur Dr*rniiah't-rtru \turFnkJcrhre


iEluri4rrrr!!!3!)tl\!dr{ourr!!!tMm

dcgeplnr
'l LrJtinrd

orclercr0 nr*b.r!s0r
lnrD
hrr mr'lun!in!;hn
'c7!
consiincnslretorsfoniri:.infiiFrelic!1\u'nftarpnnor

t cIe. ci P$ine allolc. r rvur


d,nls[atagicrri.Tihbanlolog or5i xdiiicikn,ditr/ilclcncG
nlar.nicilor PGtos si Idnbl i. hor pan: in zilcl. noa\ft- d lnta
;on$nuj subidul und lucriin spridcri Nevon sii lrcc rsnPri lc
in . d L l r u m
l rG,nr !l!1n'!J F'!'
cllntrpoalcn vo.basi itli
cdnlorc cuclc,sein{clcge
lci
'nai
Bn &ideor ,!r1lelc!r,41!rl!-dni efonlcr r! qitud
rrcletrdclc trneh'hloedfirii m
alLuldirrsFdclcpsblcm'roni&rsfamilln7ac!dnnls
Cuni am amlniir o in tcrdl, ccar! vechcitl a lncncii_
nbr deinr.l.gerca rcrtultri[istordllcsi, ro(odrI.dBlimunrer

tF b; r r

,i

rih!,
-

hid.

e4"Nr - ,

{{L, ,

r"J-qL

'

Lrdq

'-"..

'

D M PIPP1DI

LA TDFIIC4
INTRODLJCFRE

lemn'ctrului,,punicirir' e tcgdii dc ntrnetcnsopjai.itcjtor


PLodo\ ra'nblichos.
cetdi,riiiin c.nebttiut h sturn fti
' dc rl doileairrl)
Plaron,ccl
{nc( cucai.crcrftt4io\,D6ipr
r,r.rt.
egi?rolo4 trc-a' risd o ilturprerare nn,tri vnne
socotGrsidcnloast.dtrcac antzi inccpesiliuprtfunica ui
scros izvor dc i"ronnaric. ciztrrr ri unre in cur$ Eyului Msdiu
si chixril lremitunij h lcl cu b0nlipaneI lircnruiloi ct.sice
Grnguria.rbLiI[r a j tirdrlr orre
s4olnrrr x-lcrabu l tischr Marr sco(cncas o rldtrci. dnDt
o veniuurinrcimri vcch.irl,air!" Nd sr edcncpE oriG
zrrrer crudfutor
si a tncn!to. rri! in $cotutal xvi ter
Din ncc$ velc darerTio \cric Dc{ertni ft hdu.cri j
cohcnrrn.cerennimulb tulicnosr,ir p+inite cif..r cfinid,
lnsorcr'crarasctiei ii.nr tusluricner,mnroas! r;aroL<
Iiiy naoqrdruyNmnsiIILcjur\crc.icmlifeln .inrupr.dn
5isisrcmaIncirodari.dcuninuDbnuporsrvon,i Dorbr,ls
pnozlur' lc rcr er\iin cdcr lni ciu\eppen)flmiD] ra lDc
d.r'Ur resrnrdrn. in .rc iffturima eiidirii m$orelice in
rrr'&a uneicotrJrinftLrrrEs0DpneiDc umindnnDaiin
Ihli,.
de la Fran.cscoR.boncro..cr din6i .omed!tu rl
stagi urnt.Fnii llToLqua.o'ltso. da.r-nciincennioir,n)
,\nslqn, stan sini Frdlrr'.
Ornmde s-a tnrinpni, tu Euopa. n, ctrAUl ver.u or
xvr xvlllplrbnddtulionJidercndiaricta\ici$i.lnob:t61.

r.: h q rrrrt u rrit , ; n , s D

ci se1Falcdcsopen, subo lomil \


I'npomnu tddau tcdrdiui (ngsdiei, ind@
ruronlui ftrdd
Ebi) dc ddmnea lirerarunnu i cca nrj lUiin scmniljcaiivi
d.vadea a.Gteiapopicnlcotrddc.Iimd 3 nor,din9undurds
\rdcrc c@ nc nrcrcscaTn,e l@rul .[ utrii din m;i dnmahrsi ri
&elor ii pun - englezi,tance/ s
D{lcrrmneDrad\iuuprilcjdiridcr;0dp'L< rdv'o0+dro!
imercand,pem:lsuu.unoiinlelorlunloLogica,cxpliraliimri
mulr s mri puri' htriezinc, dff de licc& dd! suge{ c.
Famoasi. inte todc. e drctrdr n,chiMti ,,puilicitii' in
Han$usischc Dtrrnaoryjc tr l\\i trsins4rri dd nftrcsrrc d.o_
Concilleastrpu,lfcdclo trs'
retivisurr considcrariil.lui
strhicctului4r, oi inief
Dis.u.rD
consrcnlc
diei- in cclc d.ui
a
lui
Milton,in pref rpicsci
prviils
divnddic
plckrc! n, umk
Adcvlllah cmcrarc tlologlci i psblsmci, in inrclo\ul unei
riSut rc si !l unei inlor
'neknlc

d;{irt,.'r

(.i.t*.irqhldii,

LA ,'ol IICA
I^'IRODUCFRE

D.M. PIPPIDI
crd l intres'i
inccrcarc dc cxplicarc d duftirici trecdici
lilozoriir SrlginlulufLr rrii a uih lumin,lsofcnrcdc indoirr
radiiiecdhadici,'eligioasisimedicali avertll ir idslrliintil
abir in sccolultLlXIX lca.Dc pc l. junierca lesui vc,. dftazi
c61edouri {udii desprcctc sc pod. spuncc, au deschn calea
cxcgcTci..Dicmp.rnca.,purilicini : coDunicaEalui Hcnri
w8ll la CongresDr
din Bah.in 1344,Ucbd dic Wnkug tlcl
T.,odje nz.l' Arisro.elese, si mcmori ni Jacob Berd.ys:
arnl2iiEc .tu vdlotdc' AbhxndlutE .!c. Atistobt.s ,b.t dic
lvl*ure .JerTEAadte.publni in I 8sr si Eiiptuil nd tat r_r
die anndelh.he Thcuic tLs
DnD3ar. inspndi dc analogiap(cticii ,,purific{ri i ltr lirelga
mdicini gEa.ivc.hcCdoopo!<*crhcDtrllolositn'scrierile
pci@ qrnpuNr dccliDinr. r
hpdui),
hipocisri@
'Dnonbi
arlbuinddealDinlcri ltnoncnuruiponcn ncddiiilixfhrorelici a trsediei o viloarc limidrir.arc carua si llr.nlo cutroscut[
sub ntrnelede,.!coriapard.gici r purilicirr, inlcrprerrrer
w6il Benays (itr romul3H elui din trmi, Dai c0 scdni) $i lr
oneincr cBlormaimtrltcinr.rpnriri lmptrsc in trltinclc deenii"
CeerG nu insermnlrorui cll imagiratircdticilor$r li
opri.aci IpobzclocclcDri indiiznelcaufon fomulatc,cu mai

dii.riidd

p4\rif

rr,tr,d

nulr hisr dm indrPu[E. dc aproapebd cai de o suti deu'


a0i!delchi.nint{nchipsd.lrulculilozonarbilri
iDcoscs,s
se.dmrd, cr 3i ru crbz
ape,ici in a.cdlll drnunl carceoric
,l;
un nunc. inc*ora abddui Brcnond dc a nbnilica pro
ndtrlcicrnctft7ad"
cei ..Durilicinio.,ircrpeiir!.la
ri
ufu si a.ersj .u iiib Tnc .DislicC Lr ltl .u nbzofii.
rsiziBErrnd. JilddiLc$insAoicoethcre. vodin'ldcspr
rd.Aop',<filologiiintili n rtr iiut
ln irrcortrrer rexrulni.trliccevi d1nlclul lor pnpiu deinte
lcscrciijudecat i anci in ai! nirvlll..i,in 14! cononld dc
intelicntl si riibl]rft dttune pcitn r dr lu.nnl cclorcrtevr
,iid; i;chi.d. pobl"-ci dc A'inorel.nu nc pubmimpi'dicr
d . J -! : " d t u p n ' . p r l J n h dc i i n ( ! t u ! \ r 3 ' t r l o f n u\ s n { i I h
s ' i g r i r r L u 'l i r i n z m l u i n F d ! ' n i r r
la.i dc ce, inchcindacca$t
(ilmi.i&ci in chiPneDrevcnir
tur:d erpuncr. a nn.i trcs$rsit dis!rte)1, nu pol lisa

D M. PIPPIDI
ri $udiilordisorelice(t1,h
(lc
cklnl lor,Foblcnoi,,plrilidni ) Aulu{o R.!'en', rle cini
vlrrc conbburii imbosilti(apirolclc celenri inturecde ale
aFcon$ilui
c$criciie(hi.Srdoni!{ riia'i"ri,r4!ui tnviitardd
qc'
gindullui Arinotl in rhoslcn spinsal]lr
1tri,inurcde
lorrc lcsriluniinsini our r !ri'! sil tDtrl sudiul Ptrr.et cu
id.ilc litcrrc ptuIcsr{cdc Plaronni senmcheT4lilesiguralc
u.ci s.noNo mdodc ietori.crLDin nildaci sc vor itrspiradrr
purin.lcconsidcntiiouajuro l ciroF lr lmtele ingld c dc
spdiul rcrrids voi iiccror. l! r
c\cnrirlcalctuibosci etrigne
Cun,mD[i nohro.inteacit.in rcxru]ajunspanilrnoial
?ocd.rilcn tocnuliuhir Jc Anlo
e Nn'eiitl&utr ntrsu io.,lr inccpdulrapil.luhtivI ( 1449b
intindcr, iD lrd inplloblt cu rcluirc soitrridc poLi.?lxoscbr
dWIficcad l;nleei.imitaricin.hlFuridcormunnidnn'..

LA POE?ICA
INTRODLJCERE
')i

rftJ \ivi^cne.qlrrrr(,

,;,-,6;G;;
r.r{i.< ui}(0,< ilotoF, ,r3r'ri!o. rlito
ou
ro p iq t k i o r { 1 ; r . i 6 , i v t v r o i r p p G L < , 6 d v r o v . o i
ro]
6,' draly<[irq, ii !r;o! Kai oiLrou n.!4buoa lrr
.0[!i l 0y'o0lB'r ! y( 04{0Ly'. .

desprdn'caircaa v_r I
Ccvrn nulie mi
'tusedatr
Poltddi, niF D .apitol ii vind loLoriu mu/i.n n' .'l trcNlicundc
cr
cilid, intc rlrcLc,!i mcl.LliiLe
n!drrLKd r ivoor.r.rrd(gl1'rdind.ldici.aciiun' on snh
ndrcorgiu$ice)Ndftrlsi,,plrilica $ lct.l.pritrinriiuntape
cmo.icrcrii a{'p[.,milosivilor,hco5ilorri a 1irilo Drso.rlc
4,i rrLt.i< !4
hdeobic: ,.i< ir.rirlvaq *ai
'orq
'o'jr
i
si
Cll.lnt un rcn iD ccllllait,. vorbr dc
6lua naiilrr!tq
tulosircrtnncnuh'i
a.cldilemmi,odovcdcrcrunumdcg
r li!ozolLL
trLtodD,
e{plrcni
Flcrnrlll
djit.
r;iiio,<: re/ullll
crct
dcsPrc..PU.ifi
aci
rcProdusc
.rE.lnInl.dc trdrrnriln!trrcl!
tcbu'c
muzi.ri. \ric.in !Elasi!ipirold Pdntci, . cc rntrnc
inGlcsprir kj0dF, < lrll a.i ii tugr:Dr LiinruiivoLvorbldc\Prc
cr nr ctutlu dcsflc a)ori.iJ "
i,i cc .xpirol al rdcdli tc vor Li gl1
rjuispAni
nu-ilcsiedcspus:dcvrcmo.ertr$inrlltrcs.inlorn'l
lrn i O, ri.iur.!z n rnputcrlurdrcprcxplrctrlinl3d iln'c
dndclinilirtrgcdici)nuncrnnimdccftsllr.supunc'ncl nvor
firvur locnl jn pdcr pic ull I luciirii: capir trlitrchinal
,;,,.,";,",,,,",,.,,""".',",."'.",,.

INIRODUCIRE LA I'T)EI'C4
Ndici. drc ar fi $r.iM.D p3vrhlcn..lc cinn arguDcnrc,
rlune de Ro{agni,s'nr de{ul d3 surcro pdrnL ! r!J"d{de
xc.spthiler5Flrlir$lir n,!ii!N,0[unui aminnnroncpu!r$
dc contold. cccr ce se cuvincturiDntdr rrndDal. cildc dc
P.r,rttc,'ndcuscrmi,nbditata,.pudicini pomcrircrcol.
d .pfincarcr'avtrLliin vcdcruni (hritrilnhsedi.i inrrew 11
.crlr ri Arin.tltru pr.ea Ii lictrr delsehift Frriumid.a
c.ld mrirul'r omsn
gl.si. putendarlnhsi irr.rfdrn
(iv! iixi crpli.ii al]rtni.ti ltr
!rdn rcruil,Lllf fdmalei,aliicalcloinrelsgereI ar.n,iro
du.edecarhrczukrrcsupNcn'doiclii
Scn'ndarcI.du0ihlo^tunon .sersiliilrnicazdonci_
n asculrioi,inr:]unrcrnu,cjic$dco\cbn \cnsibilirs(pr.
rc,l)rnLcuh decnafi vc ,,unn ormcni
trnft anumrcrcmpcrt
',ci r nrd lo$ vorba sunira,niipirilid.
i..adtolnl
de
cm
.nnn
rccasri ponrn. decl rliii. Dc a.cu i: \i vcLlcnr.duPi ce $ ru lilsat
pradiimuTicii,potolitid'
mclodiilcsa.ca ri cumr h
suLlclul
rv l)a b de o vindc$resxuDurricrc!'. Si.nrinQrft:.,o
Acnenea !ref$3r sc pcl(cc in !t'ip r!.csar tDsurst'l milo$'
h 'ldti, in nli
ubr, ftorilo. .\l fi.ilor pasonllloiodcobtrer
'l
sorain cx Iic.rto o inclimt sprcrsmcnu smrinurc T.li iLxi,
doopotirll.hcaarclun soirlcpuiliolrr tLo niu' e inbviilisri
dcdcslihft... ir.ljirliitenne',.,,puili.d.r"aoFmsniLir

lnlsa li c&c1cri7dl cr un pm.cs ir pde medicd, ir panc orr!


ltumfi.inir, in monededctuplc!i's$ cm.!c. mDe
'srj!,n
clc cc-i reti, aiungindsi s.
i pu care dnnrtr inccPu(
t.6 dea puncnr lce uri inu'nr
1li A ri$orcl cu invltiitura lnerrr ptuDoviduil ii nc Phto n, nu
p cDlisanBrlcrdllindrctrlabr.orcspordcnrlitrfta.enlino
nrn dc limpDnrs liunti.:i si cca mli grav:idint. invinuiile ln
dtopsrederubnl srrrrlu,nnpotlvarici vinaderfb'^ip.
frdca ndiomli a suaatuluisi dc
josnirclcg!6dctE.eEsidtrFrelnt ad$ir,lindc!Pllt,tr.rer
rcgiunenesurti^ia sufLeitrlucGnuvr.asi$iedeleee(vd[or)
nnilene,lisoplinrt.alepoftci
nn rc.lrllcllluzld{itinJc
(ir,0!rio) cinclinaliitrsc rinsuic,rdnesr.xsIs rcsclcrscli,
rlrl iisu CoitihuiM drLiDruiecatr mhiului c.lic r nl,n
nii.r..rlcrded.itiriiprcxiene odipdiciPauhsnttneniclc
nre'crtc dc &onltagic sru comicllc dtui dirrnn lc nmtrid,
p!.zix. $ in sp.cialForhdnDni.i.nn ln.o dec s:ltnYcNci
$l tl inlcrcrsri r.cAri itrdoiti priuncrr. Ci0d e voda dc tragcJic.
dii' virla
buoio,tri.cc rrc 0oelridc.irnotffirscazi inliimPlilri
iNhrPl&
mui fcforaj Legcnddr,
slriicn
crrcsnrcncvolrrilse.leluirrc:is
Ifterob{urididnoi
mezeprinilkirdesrulr(I siiriri
vcsclnecrtscmnc sim$rlmP'nildercriun.alEzlie.uiortrc
mr. irenrca ac.lciarl I .niL mdisciplinlc r suflctului1 ljt-h
cu si in cclil!11.priinetdinpid ce tecccchili&ul liiudtic al
ln laltr une,a\i r.clcilahc rnctrinrifl,
judecrd
nupulc fi d{ir itrdepitu&' rpcde
nirudjma omultricn
s houdtil a prici'n dc tubutut

D.M. ?IPTIDI
Cu cu15iniisPi,amrni nni c
tuniFreatplicii L"i A'iorcl
int un ptrtrcrund' sliibicjuicarrsumcnrituplaioniccc vidni
noi spreeft{rilc pulcF
ln! adevir.dr.l rylecrcr licciiruja
'hfte
din Diillorcclc
n
coh{cennul
nicccrcrisidtririiLhc,l,rcraldft
nntrsi
doYcdl!crd'tr
dc iq)li,iirc a rce{cj ieroi suucrcdi.n$i
rcrii o$ziomlit sr&liLccrcsrti
Diiq.tivi, rispundcrsragirnrl.Da.[, pedc. pdnc,Prsiunil.
nu srorrcrlldmrbei Jrcii.tcdcrLriFnc,c'n.lirpnbjumdc
oFra dnndlcl. trs,ci on onic!.cpnr c!inslsio.hclrDia r
rszulti in.lrlpul ccl tu'
ca Rciuiiide simlirea sp.crarorDlui.
.vidc'r oJ.dcpan.dc.lver.rtzdratocxaspcrarci 0rsurro.
deeaianirc.ptrriciplealilcliurerlnchipDft dcpftr ulccu
sinco nbrnc a lo', o do'nolne.o imnllcIe.N0 Pnn'cjdiipcnh
Liniso suflctrltrisuu darcnoliiic @giceoi comiccrru priini
ft sticarc r unei amonii llmttu an voic de annsii in., i nai
rmvoi3 d. piiFt, ci pdcjui fcricit de onon. a uncrpdnni
lissri.-cuolormuulecaDrmNurFilcjnls oLl({.st d'r..
src dcvllriuitorc llc utrui pn$s dc tnnlt iidn'ntr pe crLer
nctiuni sp nisuri si cchilibru
Sttnsr leerrd in crre n-! slirsri.Jilliseriniimpimrua
c'cd,ndi bincdc.al
Dlxronici5ircplic!luiAInlolcl a itrvulLent.
orn[c rlri nEtodl,scnsrlri In]ntlc Lno ernluiaclid'n\eh
8crca licnl si curgi arau(cncxli ln Dilcmn dnpuri dc.lle'
Itcrnif @rdslilc:chi!.7.rnnicnumi seprrrlic!)titibntrlr
!lricircr !c(crlrii(tr si ia nircrihier rcztrltrcld cit IiP{ 0rtrr
prnddc ecar.cceFrrdcccimri ouilL,denaludsof.idiscu
iicLobarilbiedivisi,priraccr$r,ooricohi.recni Lips dc
jm mui tci n l,r ji el si pcnh
o 6.!ncmr lriinii.lcecuLauin
el noptr!@duccddlrcoloundcr
rilm:ciri. nr
Ntin convinC:i.oarc
rihitaf dupi lxrtcrr s prgiltsr gl.sabnlor.
rrrca niniclr I rlratlN
B(noM.rm,n!rinitri c, on acc!.';rtei alnli'. rpldl dcRrul

INIRODI]CIRE I A POE'CA
.J rcorrllt , ene,Ct. nD I
Teodorsu ,_ni.z *i dcsPreA
'arore/
dccal mrnitcnrlri extftmc rlc urei rcndinic dc nontrm,iiic oil
n$lnic,accd.rreconsisrrlnptrncrcrpesemrgittrdito.rdn'
rrecutr idellorsi sciri'Nnte!orcelormri sdin. de vFm.! tl
inrroju!rrilsin.arerc si_!u.o,nPns.pFle.Accnuitcidinte
ii &rodm sntrllirciudlr & r fi los $licitrli siirccDorst m ]n
kjoo0oL<-llintcrv dccilivraditicuc!a1dcNIinijndrcptll'
rr
l&rui rtir d. deprirc firrc cle .ir pot ti ideeacocca|']l r
purcii libekrom I afti si lEc.ra dc La.unoa{crea fttiotrdl la
cunordeFi ,.rjr' (trni.i0.rezii lui LuigiR($o{ ccalalti,a
Flri r onas
rhatelLiBrcn$nd6r).
dni
le1dc! vedcr'purificmr'n-r li decat
abiradint ,d Ft dl
in cnotiunccncrki,pin tr.srigunr$ r4htici, r
,,prcrrccrea
Oftii dc anevoicar fi dc spuspen! u c va li mcd !n
ralirdc gind0llli Annorcl,unlucnporEllc.nsi&dsigur:ci
fr.toda iolosil! dc cercdltoi'i cn[i (maibine;s,lipsr dencrodi
carei clrx.teizdzl dcopotiri) crapudnindl$ril st le
'sjgure
doite.i" stui.h dc inform.tiicucrc ic lufr,m,in
ruztrlreicle
I NcuDdeadcvir$l
aFvoinu de r tulelegcoiele rcxrcDrcsuPnse
si I op.6c r
r
n
Ircbdi
citrc crc rrruin. o pfl dcnti .lcmeDtrri
r tibui unui gendiior din Racul rl lvica idei inrcnlii atardc
'\i
tuMa'nend $lrim n! numfl sicnului lu PmLic.itr m,sun in
cm nc c cunoscur,dd tutrcgn sndici ricc Aceeaii clsmcnur[

r3

IJ M. PJPPIDI

sE rn x prir.jL'rsimiorp si
scF.e dc nrruri \i n'lesFxscirec
ril.dcJickr,indomrniulspcci cincolcnomcnul,.puiricirii
.

rcL,xsacuDscdesFiDde
dir Pa-qi
odd. iidgnh'irl,itr, futrcriura ca
urflnadinchLl]''l.cl.'ri sn.plurrti rsl)'rljrs'rennnhl dc a
d,arr'i dc cordiin[cu tlltii.il
..r1ii rlc
!'t. TrDriul c
-!ctrLuh'i
teDciulaf .l.sdL sclrsl lcstr.shic
lui tiviDUi'crdctrdc,litrln"_n
sD1retFnnDimdon'olire,o
dirr
di"c.rirnid.ricrt i nctnlrcIilt.5tcs:i1)isufurcr'.I Afisltd
si3..dtrtrunuDrininlruDiti.,!nrildr1,
tavictiliutrtic.
ttrfttis icatrtrp'@csdcltr'l)czircr*trrtnctrrclorNcrlerFd
c1p:L.n
la o rciirnc ii.n':i (Jolosi
r. d me rea s c M
!ia,!iv,a01r;'ov. .
n'srelff lr Llaphnnurii c.tr'Fibill.u e.l'ilibfll i"bnoa, dii .
l".nL Lo,l].rtarr.dciimil]nti" I'Lr n' \strDril.pntrt.rdcvli!rri
orEftrlc dr rclbiln!( r *cirnn.ilf lof c Lrn|
i ru $tr(imcdcc !,colir.& tLo/ot..bnnr"rrdcsucc&
tr na Ns. itLnmri.iipd sr"ji

INIRODU(FPE L\ POETICA
tagicerftica.mll! 5iacelcoq)lex 4'\.i4po or'
scrrin,.trtele
cuvinbluFr.Sintlnnt
..omcnitno6diitunrnuminrFbs
,.hnDcpiielehscle.nila,ln(lioDreniisrit.ptnhAr'{orer,
.otrdiiiilcnec*m dc itklpirii l.xcruncafidivll o!rr.jda
rrcaE.in riolinianll.se rdu.c nilr. noiafundm.nirlli a
t![rt0aa si 8re\uLEzultddin
- ftritcarc. - depr
sescdc rlhj'nd domcnlult$:insil trsedici FldaMi(vctr'
rs0llrpaginilordin rorn., mde sc pomencncdc. rtodDor.
muzic!11i6.dupi indicriii kotrsedrn .hir r.ibl Pd,.er seDodc
voibi dcordoopo,<repo$lui fcma'ibm ctror hgicili/r'
dr.iLntcryeraulLLiRoshgnicluidau.rsrdmmLsp&.dso
dt]a0oLqr coiiediei'8Frdindoialii,.u va mainulu inddT
ncal!dinpane-iGxu,poalc.dcevanlimul(nouditrprnc n0.
pentu cl nu purcmi! cun !a ti ros trrrariiproblemain
'xpirolclo
pic trrcdcP.'r.er,tuisrorcl rii pulotidti'rdccldcLcbineticli.realc.,purilicini lrorice erllnlinuiricrildict Chiu
s$ rona f*eDenrri ii .m amP
cl rislundc. tiuir itor objcclrlor cclor Dai lnvc ale rctul d.
loF
acuzar
thloDir. cr urmd, identictin aFnti dsifi.ma
nclor poczei,ddcum scinril'rc5tela.ci doi filo4liuv. c roral
diferioneMuinsdn licda ci.d
incadccmi',ipdticip&eanoAdrlroa.DDncncivl..,rnira_
d ftocird genl'rc_
tl mnsoadodcum srdul d. tprob$iliEt
Er: I irr 0,< Pnr oicc)enli, pooziadBnali dr fiCureai pe urt DL
teatli ir icrfthLrld. PcDm Antoiei. in schinb, r izric
absulutlrprEsuluidcimire 61! 6ld rL[rio.!q I'tocmal

.15

IN IRODUCERELA POEITC}1

D M PIPPIDI

itrc,.ma deHbilftrrc slectu.i tniLpnnciprlclc.n inli


t\at in pasiiile pE.edent sonponl o conseci"g asupfl ciE a sc
crde si Tibovin, inainle de a tc la c.rc.rftcr alror mpectcllc
d,i n
r 'ei.e3t
dcarc! lircErurii3aoitrdclcrtri.ift
flielDicir leBiuiti.si caE
cd!nlomcn.rparcbanal.dr.LriidLLlrltddirioiddcrjDdc.a

ir faraaceiui hl$g si r alcici coi$mte, Dn h.onic rind


i l$ AristorclcoboadFrh nnaia
sinLi{orici .Jn gc&ol!_oibind.
nN.larsp. rtuimulpsihologiri
cauzclccc prfi
cnim in capiblul Iv rl Pretuej. doliut
7a
simp[ cnunh( r
dd n,Jrcl1trne,, rlr4rdlui r@,Blrq: ti
rcdft , cmcrcrisrici..ilr.idcxrrin
dcoscbnl.coNiiuie din padcas
lmDotLiva
doctinelorp.ntu car hdul poericeraum4er utrej
()nnirdii pdolqi.c \!u 3ulci itrbflentiisuprrpaminrene.
Drr
pr.ciTililc@
dirudinerluiscdcspriodcrora{irdclinFcJesidli
urmazi. trndcsedart cl1-dir celedonl can^ prira c,,'lml

.,nomrlitarer'e$erienti poeii.e

cTdi:lrupa

p.itu .r dercmiill ce, bai inreis! Drnicipdc, tagedia c s.nul


ca{ intDp.rzi ana lirc ril id scopulei cel naj ,_tralirLi

f/'

-.1,

Dl r{
q.,J.
.r'!J.
"rLJtr.'o . . n . e lil, g ' e . : d .
poeTieisa redusla proclamrer.andc hi ci strpanatu rl
avcr$ dnenll o $olicirc.uh'itl.riiitr giMirr anonlnilui
Io,..Zctrlraru hintilcpdrilr-sDlrntrFsrjrlacdsnidialog
...- r ..1J r'."r" un.. .|. lf , " i . ! h i. i n i. r.
'
penh ca. asculLin
dumneTrietti.
ac.sriastun cuvitrtele
uedrie d. lu(e anint, - e', alectu
r '..r1/1'lin"uti &e lre k ' o F le ): ld n
an .utr.
':ir:l.
.\"m !..,.( tr.F4.

d.!lind. !.
It p ..i r

v . ! . r3 ' -.

f, p u i r. prR

rr_

i :ntrl :f

' iirl. i
J.n

'n!ard

(! mi{p!^,tui$,

?hildl .Lleiul

-Negisim r{lc1 in tita unciad.vtnte reoii despreorjELnqa


pdicilhoori. nrftliiarr,cunecu
maipurinlimpcdcfotruldrlr),hainrcac!rcir
hPtrrn:.drr
D es.sillborioarerrlndna {rr

,*..^. o*r",'

r" L.*.t,:,."e,'.r'

i *-

ii

-*
ascr cancJtrhc o.Rlrivft rcsriboni.actrriiateapoetjjie
o alivirare llrur2rir. cxptLcabili plin tibffa inlL.rift . unor
aptirudini gcncnl-oncncsdl a adivitate {o,.an4 tn nlsua in
carc pcntu r se nnniredr n aE nevoic dc inreu cr nici rdui
rrtor sxrcn,si inci si maiptrrindc!uDcircvclaliirlnsririit..
penm .-{ e flcut
erilikruozqal4
riti !lc sufldului. liri a excluderaculririlc ntioMlc.
A.clsild{ uflnl tasibra nenir si nc rctini lddr mintc.
Ffti r nini, ink'addlr. f,suprrloniilii une' concepti alimrtc

D.M. PIPPIDI

INTRODTJCERE
LA POETICA

,ci pcrd inriia oad lir hroria idcitor lidft. n! i liFn dc inrcres
sr animescc! aurortrl
rftrci n r ajurstavcdcdlcrbirexpnse
dc.!. rpic sftsnul vietu, candacdodcnclenisiics prj cru aJi
pierdetn frtui luj p$ignt dc uc ii ap&uscrl:invilunc in ep.ca
I rimclorscricn.M1"ca. bu$oari (ghicmaviibrutuiprjn und
s rliul din niltollctc h caE cer v{hi rcouiceauio chip obN
trulr),seotid dc cr ca manitasErc! mci porei suprrrircii in.! in
vEmcr caDdscrirEn.aEud.rnia'J(ccr350i.c.n), isi teapidrcu
timpul caracre pnvibgiei cr 5i hai iniinb, onnnu! si1-i apari
stiin, de raliuDi ddr,cun ohscfll un cerccrltor tocnr al acesrui
3spctd gatrdnnshBif,tului, dcllnc dc a coNriitri lDNfl ea un
ridu degrdis. areEfl-i ndionrl o srueu{ tn tuliunea inlcriodt
,qunctululi! Drriprr!
s eroh &cr mArosnutu Dnnldsruri
fiz!194d d,{dk (; mn; s;;;sbrr *;.-o
priurs" rtui
paE
d,c.{,
$i
c0n
veosifril.
di$lria cirun{snrirr.[ a
|ovri,
oluttri liorci in orgenisn,dezvondi i.r o sijunc d lloblsnrcJoi
oglindedem[.oi iD pMc idoilelul!. Oamcdinai citm nr
capirolul XXX. I al acesci lcricn sunrde cete mli nulrc ori
.Alrfclsptrs,inecoDomiao4anirnutuitorprcun,.'nelancolici
plnc$c ficrca ncalrr. ltectele asesei. asnpranonlu,ui sc por
Genni cu ,le vinului: u vind. imprge h padni, la drasoste,h
rcbunieCandfieraneag.ledcfclulcitocc.omern osiprtdispls h lcsinfti cende liclbinre, exubersnr$ imaSinariv;cind
c dc.-'cmncfirtr'r puri!irr .umprdr li inkepnnabr
IisG 'dnlp(Lc,duDaacdrro
rrr. t u n u n o n \ e u u

rurI r Drsjudecaasnp'aparcmirilii Ptublenelor irdeob{e


ptublcncixxx.l
inpaticular(in crre indiciincindoioase
i
i
l,Lsis:isctoNno6clidei 5i rLdnldecitai$oblicea),ccMtrl si
ob\crvln ci. in mistrh in car6argatcaz! rispundcrcarntonlu'
ia inl:limii dar:i o cxplicariooriodalil uor disl,ernu.rcoii!
pozirii sulc(ni in .ec gtrdroi mi
xnifei?n uEi ptrteris$rmaruialc.Sirgulrnzarerlui lali de
ditir pEdecenri ilns.iri nu !c rcducainsi la a.cain simpli sul."
nrunc dc pc(pcsrivi. UMe min!q!3! !{r!1ij r94l!1ti 1!ul
A{slEl annci int adcvturuni l xruprx Pmcc\nluicomPlcxal
.turtici lirctue c ca0d.lDcrpito!'n xvI d Po.d&i,.l ui dc .ipd
tditonal rrdnmahrului cxhric.rNnlio.euipenhinriiro'tri
trtr!ip dc din d crn,pccar.ildillngccueptcolde,,rn'onios
itrzcnr"f G,j.l,rrj<)s rn cm hbtric si vodcnrIc crcui$r lusid
sauccrb l{r .,Mxirrbuie ifflii obsc\_rcl.nLrccrpihndcr
crrerrdinl,ecerindalopDscululuiunde mtzaudcinvi
timift. capmblsa sid$ivatrscr*iopeEclurttrd3"tilnsuii.
innlisu$rdribiluh,l. ditudinilepronrjektr.lnt dcvrr,ddul
de r miscr in c.l nri iidl g$d ru I
dispoziiia ftcrcli a r.ahnlor lor, sc llsi $ilpitriri dc priiDa
liccilreia: lngu cel turbud izbtrrcsrcsi tulburc cu !Jcvll*. rsi!c
auii, si singu .d r$lios $ I nenl
parclr locul lui nli riind in itulivizii rnnoDiosi.Trstur d(ii
incxaliltlr rn,d.Iccid,ntiistrntlicuti sisc aptchoi.Srci
siruaiii.cali vrnc ccililti str icJiridir lir"rl
Dacl.h ace$ererduri.cxislcnhnncicatcgoriiLlepocli ,
clrornaftieraLtdicill
nnidc!h.leeldeciialefllLtrni'nu i
rrc.uricuycdcicr,lfntu indoitolmorivcii c unhprdcobscr
r'!ie si cr o hdiric nnxis..trl.r:1vli?urcn' ri Dr foctii priD

1 {u o ro mps ns at;tr;ns k ru,fi "' s " " . . . - , . ' . ' , ; f f i


t unbe,$g licr ficdinte Omrnii s$Icl conlolrri sunlnri
'le
colqie si pItiMlc.
rrrrinal. stl.-dl;. U;ud4a cuse $ inilE
cire,5 ri rprcpiedc ncbumc.dar {e 5i ftzuhrrul feicir dc a
dc^nr i. 3i ltrctrl4i decrc.ricancvoisarirsedetui maicatme
ti mri .unlpinilc.loetulMamkordir Siia.uz.,nisqsNre.n0
conpnnuniciodarlmai
bidcdccar
aruncr
crdql iesea
diDminr.

t3

D M. PIPPID1
excclcmi,sDpdonraGaredDccuriidcAnsbElcrcarorit.rluci?i
{in bot{riI .pozilie o prclcdmctenditGraie attld{it dc ptaF.
sduPiDdat lnbnci o sennllic{ic asutrs .i*ia nu poareinciFa
indoial:i.La rel N fnzr din q)irottrl IV, dup, cm cauele
l,@zici
r ri
'rBandooi cruT! ,art..judecar! abiarprodusii (tumuh$
parcid'tritrdnplrssi dealrtuinrsr'
detccrtros
rrn.'n.t1s)cr
prinliractiuneaSragiriintuitporivrmeiexplicrriiaacrjviGrii
poe.ie ficuc si i dnli poDostrtuiei dbirsrrmorbi& in acr unea
d re$ilitdc a pcziei condamnaredc Pldon pe fl pic,nj in
dun&d crron invj'uirca dc natunatliale nn era Ea lnai purin
8nvi, proclaDaRsdc cift Anslorel i cancrerului dmal at ex_
penerlci p.cticc trm[a si conrerccic.rjitor ei cevadin prenr
minfii,atacun (nucr! exascre djn pdrc j)
eiur spcnlaliilor
@eat rcndinllava si I inipr're5srvadih..j6n{dc..un rdd.
In faF rc$ei dirudini. o ahmalie cn r.eea a ab{clui
lEmond, pordvn ritoin Anloiel n.d n scri .rn sjnsr raM d.
mde sdepoarirage.on.hziacr.pldsindprrdoradirionale
cn pdviE Ia i'spimia pehlri, ar ti idcnrific4.uDoajdea tdjci
s cutroisuea nl,onali"D. ftbuie rcspiNi cu hodra*. E qE! de
intetes.inFa&vtu, ln e tcl aniod p@rtci r ti pntui nrki idd
unci ,.Gh.ici, dc tettrts.clcix p. caE o sndiem,dr.il i-d i
rcelurpineliniimrdndomentutinspn4icipenisiruliir uj
erementincortolabil, pc caraccepran. caacre4bj n{ional al
cxpcnentelporie I r ri inr.dus in tibflt joc:l nljoMtunrutui
ln rerlilarc, nc glsim aci intniea unciadin rcctc cotrtadicrii
dc carcs indnea s raginhhi nu-i . tr rotultedde lnte exigctrlclo

.4'rrd

drro

Jd4r icr'@t.

N.* v,a 16i

INTRODUCEREIA POEIICA
urtri rirdn i'relecrualisr
ti proDriilcsalc.bseflatidcnsiholos
inokl sedescurciancvoic.ii hotiliEa d carcploclaDl sup'
'
pocril.r lNizi nD n. frcc si uiriim decat pBJuditete
'ntrihrca
cxi$ctrhcennpe.a in pdajullrca.enc elenm iinomclc
Tnnspdsiii'r rlli brmeni, o contrdiclic a{nrnitoarc ae
dczv uis in ploblcnr minni ,fti, mi bnc sptrs lclului uninr
'
dc amin gorcnl 5idBdrlitenrliDpdri.Dlsr ImponanFdeo
scbirirlcmmenulLi,,punn.I'ii$diculircevrnai.m[trunliri
pc cN i'm N.s&d!o ru tcbuic, int'rdevir, si nc n$eLeas$n
htrului.i,in d.hii lDiAnsorcl,nnr;0otoL< c scopulultnal
nNziei. ci pliteFa (ii6oY,i){.
in nmeroa\c pl&jc alc Pcrc.i, lilozorul vorbcnc dc des
IlitrcrrruLrindlicdin!.trn ie cdirili de{il. nc din annDiiGsi
rurii sru invontiui poclce Aa$d dsdih u nnii! iaii cann tL
(ri\.<),cilrc caEpoerrlindcsiln
l)e sincre.)tui Drultdc.tr a! . xccalii i6oni i.l tl oric{rci
tuerccxsipor brregcn$leliieIm,ci
'nrnilu$iiriadisti.c
pani.uladli(i h incazulsPc.irlrltalcdiei,supeionurcaci
dsul rr ccbnrxe varicrili dc t].ezt (itrreneidr, cun.n dd
pnpni glndion'h' nonru) e
pnlejL ro arlr, pc .otrsiJctalLi
dovcdlrlllnci pno rsuDcrtul plll.crij cu tortrl spc!ialc F ctu. o

D M PIPPIDI
pocuiilrr. FoiDuirr de o imiratje.drcc opemdr.marni orin
nlimrcxsedimBnrekrdcnitrsitiicttl
c'ne nnpi.geitrlr n deprtr. aceast!orutizisictrurl s,
pnrtrek dup;tern'chtP!Jr..r. n4un p kkir aru{rc ,jrnle
L ,nlr r e 'crtr.i a dJr i op!\ Ltulrht u k L j! , , n k g rlr. t r
acc6r, inrrebarc,rli mnxc itsptrnsud nu roclM coD.odanre.
r Fun prn Fsaj. buMoail, ss rorbcnc dc a ca dc sarjs
h.ercr mu daridni\curolemomcLfi dtirmutui!' Dupiarrut,
nar Dxplicit..ipdicniadisricin tr ri dccirsarrsttucfta
und i,!
nincr miDcrio:pcnro crur', cm sipunc in valoarsunr di!
adtu. tnridicinab 3lc ini ononeni. ca si Enrru
Doftjnle erc
'Bi
iubiroruldcrni,kricndctrarcaitrxirrc
i oimiruric,ni nutron
m r ip d i /buriu Dmulimrrru!'i nu n r d ii,r hc.L!oprtJno.rtrslen. p e ! n d rrrn jL i, ] lu
n er r cnm Frr tori ,.a5r I' nd.pft. e re rL { e h . i, mn ] (J ,
in\enrnr Jozr'le
de.!'r turer!niet
rJ' or !J rnr$ ie LlJm.cJndLtevJ ilrd rmi!io ri runor!!
obiecrdinior,jDetuccasciibu.Dr:teieprivescop|nshuiE..
-desru\ct.tudntutr-n conhnu{earlinduritucirarc
..Denhca
N pnhjut s! invelelrivind si st,rt dcaseajnidc liscc rum. 6uni
odo!curaren'f4i*azipccute.athinrcri,dcscnfimrDsr
tie iiur dinade,plierca rcsinrit nusc va mri debn jnidiei
ma'
srtr maipurinizburirc,ci dc\fii6nii cxccutiei,ori cotori_
'nux
rului.
oi cine iric ciin alie piioini..q ln stiiBii, nu p.arc r i necur

LA POEITCA
INIRODUCERE
ctrvedcrml:rDNlcl.lnh o s.nc de alleprs{c. dlri, concepl
crDiri (n0odinutarecriv.incuul spc.irl dl tagediei.inira!,
ncliindnumaiiniriliaunor acliuni.cunsuridelinid.!5 ci si a
nn.r sld sdlctctri, - in misura tu .ee fericnm $i tefeticira sc
pllccrca l). cm o ftsimtim 6isrtnd la topF
vildscprinLpD!',
ntrma unuirationmcni. d sinpatic' cu
tru
$
dato.r@
6nrrca ei
cN imp:iis-rnrsufci'l.l3 Bro0luitagic"'.
Faddeeroriastunilldeaceicsufentrle, pilcj,pcD!tr
noi. dejal.. dlr tl de intcs, nulluDrne,dupi lim obseflatic a lu'
P[ron,'r rari de pliidcre! prcinuirl dc dczlinbirea snrimetrElor
dc nilil si lica, in cd sutrtemindcni,li sdrccunor(d lclut si
roiul t.gedicii'! lati dc nezntibilr poinirc carc ne idcnritcl
porrudu .lctiutr,icnzbucitrnulDrtnasdnsrurul,pcntuanc
ils! q oi usuftti ti r'nlpicari,reEmcttuL decnrginddir oicnrntele
,pxrcriorterlcdranrci- vm, muzi.il,motrhft sczn$ |[ ni
impodmtli. Mutua \i nctul \nDr.lnii indoirll. Dntmi.c rilroa
cc dc desllildc. dtu nn rondilii ind'spcnsrbilc rle erotcr podtr
niE. Cir prve{c olcfrei rul spetacul$ (montara eu punerearn
mri
obsc lArnbbl,-.Jicel
icctrl),..Di.ar ci !rlgl!r,
rw
dc nd0$ po.tci
Duli ,ni{ic ii celnri stl11n
cc
impinscm
mri dcpanec irr Poeddt. lptre
Pc bllruil
astrel lrmuir cl ltrtr dife.nclc cxplicrrii ale d.tritirii pErirc
ins[ ln ce chip
nu pode li ilgiduiti. c! s! r_ntelcscm
nq{rivifx
gandm
ld cond\ijtc
posibil,
dc
aiurs
s!
ne
va
e
lucrul n fosi

D.M PIPPIDI
spocirrcitrcarAisbbtisiclabdasisrcmut:
tax.tiunqpccrre
cu Jtunr,$ vo'ntir-opc lDi urnrer ro rc7sci imporivr
condirnnrrirDt{oniccr poezieicoisidemridiMcc$puncrdc
!cdu., crplic4ia ,tr.lcci!?li r pllrcnl enc[ce v:derie pru)cupaGadc r piira pozici o ctr marnar dozlldc clemcnrnoriG
.rlLur, diri vrcn. explicariaarorivi - daurqind dircc! dii in.lra
coi$iruiajca sl 7iorF.o concluzie
impuri.
rJ&ll,rotu$,listndlao pdr dncrepant!sircrindndd.xr
'nn L .:.i i !hi lulA n+ tel,e !l!n!i( o t i. c rd . n . rf t io k b r
n i . ! rJ rrn rie { c t 4 \ ra\i rrn.dspnnsuldrrcbui srlieaccsr:peftmptaron.plic.rcx
aircl obrind! e o dcsfihE vittntrotr;;;iidn;ni6tkn'::
p.ntuAi
dj;ur!;idphacsu[inc.j]iinnsft..oasejt;iieo
pricerenutdf cjdnicnccuninric4hilibd suncluh,i:
dcpancdc
I f .'L l{mnrb i,P td\\(:,ridrc
hm a r * tr 16!!r 4F'o0,(

inconsnlurdiiledetiddci. al ctor ro{. tnn si inles


Erscl inreleScrcr
driruJini ld Arisrorelin indoia1)n)6tcni.

LA R]EIIC'{
LNTRODL]CERE
nduri' pcriciSirloculupccdcmertisll_Locupcinvi.l.ohrrii,
p$ccsur
-rn rvur prilelutslpohonsrc in mii nuL nnduri
cu
rdDl
ctrl'cL
pcnb
,micr
se
confunda
sonnud caE
sindn ni
rvea
s
trudc,sci
lircn0 p. ce. dupr Hdon, a!!nl Pm,.lt
rirrdL< ii ctnir (cu utrechival.fi ficut sli cxpnne nn'nr o prtu
din stomds intclcsa cuvarNluigtc) i_anrzis 'nnn4t sau
,,tope7rmarc E f,onentul si arlir sDm ctr dli mulc aminDtro
"
pnn rcc( rerincn fundrdcntal pcnrfl
ce r.buie sI inrcieectu
Inhaga sEiicl vechc- ti caraldt .rbuic s:i atibuim ln cadn
snbmulLixri{otclic dc ghdtc hci.orrn ca PocT'adesprcr
cii rlrin! escnli.i sc spnnB.i ar riinntaticrli ti caE nu i
loetc dccarltr misun in crE e miralierrra
PobvnleluLuinontuncr judecd,.
cuvaniulo $gerzi c acccaI uDe
hodel dcrcmi'd Mri pnlirrcxadr.rer,cinr.lcrul p!ose rm
vrzui ci I acord:]t rmnu Luillaron, cinix c'slnlc dci ii {ireau
.doDalidi.oDieirrt,rilii nrotrjurilole,lrrlndul cj coPPrm
pcd;ri
F.litrh i'".o$ibile altlcl dedit Docalcalilo
".'ai
n,nc,,lB.cums I rihlnEtrb, n
dooida prccsuLui nimcric Arniotel lnxinre dc r rvctri lnsi
prgniilcP@tt.et nucnodcrtua
asupLaintelcsuluiidlalicini
oricilndponbnc din prdea
nnclc
.onluTii
tulos si semndcz
cidoruld Eprcvcniteltaratului,si.nrpradiclctrliiitn.i dcs
sivArJnocu cit prqiltnx tui liLologici e mri nicl
o Nlcl de conluziee actc! crrc frce din pro.esul mitucdo
o expEsi.x subi(riritlti adn(rlui.xfnDrea rnci pefon"l ih
hai singulrrcPcnN mnsiccls
h tirl[nbci
'nai.nsfilcsi
dcntii a sc vor vddcala vtuhc. pcsdpuNQ c iot cc p.aE n mri
sdi, de gindulluiArislotcl. ochiicinti! crnsiul dw{r ei
Dorzii o consituit do misul in cae enl dist!Lli iii sisc*c (n'a1
kr in orurL Dcnn derrMr in aLitcrrLre
ainczis.
'F.sigtsclt)

INTRODUCERE L

D M. ?IIPIDI
privi'rlc. obscrvier.in &.{ni ordinedc nLci,- Honu mai
tcriu'c liiudarsi prtrtrci - hri binsde.aroi.c rh p.cr sdccm
rrubuicsi I rf roculr'n economiaop.rcj. pocrrl c daio, st
vorbc cl catmaipurinin numcrcpmpnu.pcnh cli .u asratacD
d'nelN inirib AliiNrori DU&cdecrrsis scoartidtu pe
o la iveali! dc imitar,rtr rDilr d..ai ldin si rr. Honer, i' ichimbj
dupi o
dc oitela !.Ibc. pe dar! purc in sca.i un
bilrhd. o'nkodsccrc
rcmcic ori vreunall pcxonrJ LLr6
Dc o Mrurl ditcnu, darnu mri pui,r errvi, c si gqed. dea
conlu aioitatirculitunac.ivirrlonlntruici,dca,idibui.ctr
arbcuvnre,dm'l plismudluncilrmi dc v(,lld lcgituricuruti
Ereatlriti sru cu ceahrric dcna[i. acriil conluzicc si maifc
venridccftcerteccdcnri,pcdc opan6.pcorucrpo.esul hi.
nc[. co,nDoi.tctcdiv
ohbul mt,horxEr drehft atntui.ltrdc
lcv, penincrDcdcrnjilol
.numirorannMrlialcl,o.r.?txlmpinssiimrrgeF'nuhi cririci
\ifiliricsksinh'ltriidci\triloedesiscmuls;ucndic.imporivr
utrci,\umcncainrc+'erli s. iidi.i, inar.redc rodc, inlotc$t
cog.niv dc c& rm vtur .i tumcnur nu poab I dcjpinn. inr r
d.vtr. punh arisb.el. imnadrc.un,,r.rc, d accn$ rciese

lihpc&nn ni-diirinnunFiipit lur"rinsp-d,,"t


"i"cr'.
Mdc sc\punec[ dcsf rea olerrr dcco cmprrftauEi dtunuin
upnnsut
capirolului
Ix, dupi
rermen!ch'ir cnnorircrcr
p@ricir ti,.mri filozolicisi n2L
rleasl_de.atdnoajrcrc(isbnci.
A\xfii'rd,-sao6servarcu
dEpr
c(vanr, dac!pocziaccun.aiiee,eanu
podeli ocrcrliciMc
pcndcnrr
deraliralc.Drcte.Dnor
snbodoMrlhs Farltili{irincdeer,pcnruciporivillslului
crcni.dcgardi. ori.c Inni dccunor\rcftc in tmcrie denorD
p!cmortfl e.rit\iciireiatnLlcsl
isecdnlomcTerLrs.

POFIIC^

lmirrri, nupolt I drlibcr:ldcsri.al'Drczic,,qrcrmnu


i Crsi imliztniqclNnl,ft
clinsiillinre,urcipcr{r'dn
al lilo
btricsI rc n$ucc,n cu gindullrcoDceprulhndamcnral
c d.vd,td, trnpr.cesdroluiiv a tot ce
^ficiad{orelicc,crc
sofi i'nlci Narminftaer,dupi
cxislli.ocotrlinull,s@trsiurcn
giNlnorul mnru. trtr'i alrcNllccir o caclgic crc'iom,inzcstari
cu un soi dc r4luic i'sritrolivt.DLitrr circi dum sridcntclc
ntividurLetun!oilltr/irc cdrrcun lcl propnuTrlul rccdr,mi
trhsxuDri Duh rsc!trr.dupldilcri'dcnivcls' rlc crcalinni,
dcvinc linunr r. nl1surll.. m ndidln p. {$ Intci Inruntul
fie.rrui se.rorslexlsenlci,dcdrlpdc, micmrc Dcinrclpti:
fiec. locru llzuis5E cllrrso lbnll r lui propricii nu'mi tu nisun
tum4 c]r icrpdnlcscma,
ii c@ izbutelEsldiigleca
po.re
spuDe
ci1i{inDliDns$lir)'
- se
ActimeanarutiplabndrrcmuiticurccarunuicDalor,
care.cu rlbdrie si prLsrEnil. h.
rcin pdc s d. rproapc,4nc
pot
xle
iulni
s'
nc
ap
inltegl dome.
lcnonrclori6l!rc ccononiia
l:Illrtroturtr.Lft

rti

laft f,u D!d! Li J$r.

rild*rr-r!

p!!{!

e.tra.'v

!t!t!tj!l rlimbE\i,n_

srtiistc unricsh si oamndirctltrri.ati


.:r,n,.,r.tk;

:li

c vor6,i-c! dl,

qin(lp"pnn r i
'rra ir!i\irinitubutr

jrt tlilg!!Jro1sisisotrcinijlor.cl prtdiccrlc xlc


cDnoarte
rcaliza.Aritudii'ern'enralla mcibn'lui implici r$lcl d a'lxpte

D.M. PIPPIDI

LNIRODI.]CERILA POEITCA

i*'1..1 * * , , -M
-. r! \ ! n
pnrnirde.nr+ ro (. \ ir{
ditir Drc.labilir oricir.i Dlsc@i.i Dn rcspccrulnaiu e si
dntrdincardisbrd,allcuftitoonctpcad$orcrcarour4ul slu
maLnodcst 3l oidi ntrm n poalr si de cm socialncnrcc aliir de
rlsrpDrrr,anNtul nrzuieriesldu.i tui dcpanspornneaspE
ln cns deintiFDnc in rumeaimonlurri.dcr,4:ci in
'mab'nc
cazulec.ltriri opcrr rui isi pnpuDe*il nla&i nodrlclc olcnb dc
Ndrir, dar nu si le nietreJ nnpokiri. nici si sc dcprncrc deete.
ajur8emrsrcl {inclimmninrclcsutdeti'ii.ipturarcdc l
tr ;r ^'t.n /.j,.
."
h".,n"/
rr :c;iidivi'rr.trr! r('letrdrltr'*
cCrs!!1{1b
( id cr d c\&3ir"inx,mio. Jrrrir.rden in j? ! . ii! ! , rn i
c triTuicic pc crc nahra
cxuri s o Ealtf,ze. da tc circ nu inrordcrunaizhuiedes-o
ajunei O r{itl d. lomi G16o.)sc ascunde
in ti.cc tc'omcn
iTolrt Darorb *ri (xi c s o dcso)rre. sl1,lder . cxprc\ic sedin
drisii si.pnncrcrrialui.srcofercindividralului.ul.srcuni.
vc^rri,vEmdDicuruicer.ninprc srullncndt.rrcpj.riroir
Idcizursp..iaralpeziei.tx.dcncputemrdnnint rrcc
riri teanri dc gru{.itit. obic!!!r!Du{i3!!i.in
in capjblut I rl
Pdn..,.runt...r.rrrc_DnLn! r,,Drcumcncn,r,,.eer!cr\L
F; pu tr e..u ! ,. ir' r". ,u
" ",r r; F f : , , 0 . ' p . r

|
Arstor.Llaropq:
r!!t!ta 'r trr rde! tr!!(llug
"!!{rlllj
d,itrs Jnn! oile gc!
n ,4etesull4-s!-qt]:l
1,!9!!e'd
rce r rudne.Ie.gnnd.su
rt r* iic ,r r L \ r ' , - a i . h a f r j ' : , - * y Y 4

*,i-*r:*l::,+ffi;til
D r ond.tr i ' l Ll r o" /'
..lil- 1f l '
o.,r u i l r ,- '
Ad\bkr rD.rDrurullx

I ;r i s ouiiic;&ii'rftr_mirft

ll;ffi ,lllx
l".iiil:
Hii#Hffi
"i';::::
(Jc-arpune
o!
cimvain sihuli oarl
nn{ipurini\bno.vc$ilicrdoribr),cip.nd.Iunul i iri$ui
rrDt . u ! , ! i i n t r n n r b F r r d n . f B p R ! e \ i p d ! t f i n | l '
m'rux untr!r. ru !r,
si
m,i-t,u*,d
-.,,t,-*.
d5n6t@."nl;^r*i
i'b,).-.

"-"

bilnltiLcpcmancnlcrlc riii ome.el[ vnuali.llle surcrc$ dc


uneitrtunititi ercmplrc.In btic. c!5i in riu,roii si es ele
cllm decftati6,kc_
tragcdiei.rc.aiisupremlsxprcsicnpllcni
bNsiscidicclamnivcl.prceDrativpcnhinrtualromfl,tr
ti hins, cn si in rliu,,$mdnabri cu 1icurc drnft noi, Nbuic sli nc
depisciscipin xrnoniatiJiituilorti !.in ialunnoralil,,De
vrnc ce trgcdii e initarca unoroancii mai rleit ca no',
obscrvi,4i$orcllnb nn rnnr"!,- tebtricunatipilJr burild
pdtieli,!ii. carc.silindtr-scs, deamodelch id4iFrer DdticulMi

D M. IIPP]DI

INTRODUCERE
LA POEI,ICA

neciflir. tctr du\i,


t t Dorse,mi.ai ci alomtMror L.
rol r poctul.nevoir
sri,nncoanommariosiori usnraiici.lricu
ric nic cc d cusn0i in tuealor,tcbtric \r l nrfitiscTccum
$rnl,si rorurifd alci.. ..L1,
Luncr Doeziciicsituerzlelrctpc un ah pkd dc adevi.
dccatrccl I exp3ricmcr
Fiprunbei0r(icipii b o.cstiblc fraj
camcbrnlicJdcciitrdilareatnconjuriloartr Llc si lic ca ror
o{ntcd, c9lljll3icqL$!aD
r 4bri pat. sr he onn'c'ij: na\

li ,cc^ri ordnE de idei, s a scis Ji sa GpeEt deto! celi

:t@priL. ideeJp.!{cotuprc.

id ,l c(|,i6o.

r sl\aip.

caredisrtrLl-. imrvl^r 11ct1tuir


incsaci \!-i dcrhnrr.,,Detl
sc rdu.cdi$trruiinyinunercitr rtititisllidct cevojr siinti
!se7e.-{iscnsincrl)nolulLXv, aEdrcpr sirlspurd!cit.
inlftisar,p.dc,c"n hrun ritc...-irr si. d r.dlo,,oaneni
cun'sunrccipicra!dszcuxk,sc podc sinu cxidel.u arillmai
binc, ins, , cii.smai rixn i i. |rnrd ci
rchuie dcpitsitr rl
'nodelul
sedcspiiidcdio nce$erindtrrio pdiculfirarc. credei
P!! S su bitrkleiJ rJul'ni'arrfth r t rc ' m' . u \ e d x J \ u Drr
L,rrrjlnu, N,/
m opl mi,.h p
,;*
"p-,:ii;^;,.,,,,
riimnaft hmoaslsicit,psrrua-incriranumcre,rcbuicsr
indcprDe.scro seamldc cotrdilir ccr dinrti s ceamai im
p.nandinclc acccacuc Lerztrmli I le inplili pe kxrc _ c
r .nL r ,ricr tr,i'ier ! n! J !ne,lrr(trL . o n o t c rca in Rs r. . t r

\",tere
r r,,;r-,ru" ,';i;.',;"-','r*r r".;t.,rr[. ,,
darsit ir.
'-J

_/'

sunlimenElesi cdaclrclc nu coNlr,ic clcnrnb :lc pcziei decit


ni caredccurgsrtr$*Drinrprn' hpb..Jngedir
tu m:1suir
scriecl in capnolDlvI (1, crrd $ne .,rngedrcl,rmbuc sI
,DLlLr!m Docrni..lculxtr)

""' ,1 ,,

re.& eL
1fr,.;,,,,"r"".,",r.r!rur'nr,prr.l eL!r

vj4unifiind Mlizma uneilaprc,i


rs.ccI.xDcnii suntint{nttl satralrul
duplcrfttrclclor,d.r
jsprivile
fcri.iti sauneLnciridDpll
c. sitvirs$. ,n[atia n o 1:'. r. si jnt0chipc^ caLJ.lcft.c'
nnbiacilcutaiesaucuta$ ca*crur cr sil slvirsorsciio irPti
Faptclesi suhicd!1scdovcde\cr
rotul c nli in*m4 $ r.rrc "r:1.
nolcazllit lcglrurl c
.,Se\imt
Ronagni - cil . rstfel de ati(ud,nc(rid pri.im .lrcil Arnbd sc
rrarliindiL'cnrturlidc oiice forn,
..idiruii dc opoknc. si.r a{ir hli indirerenrrari de hricr
ptup lzisl) ii e iDftrsnDu nunai de .onditii d! f!p. saude
car&teol rdsviral rl rnei eie!s{i. pritrcxcclcntimitici ratr
niropocrici.ci,si ur tremnccprlcotutic 15 Obse4r(ir vr
'lc
xplfl jNi oncni ti.c scanilcl. dupl un impodmt pasajal
R..d.it. pui itr luminidc rcelrriinyirrl,pn)tozilnDileitrcrre
se exprnni o {nrt alcdivll (rtrglninlc, rncphe sandoinlii) ti
.arc. pcDhr!.cst noriv, i!s,gi\cs. o ld8i iiEbui4m in v.$'m
sc
fnN,xsli siinpoczjc,ntrar,lcnttr Arnbtel.conriDurlog'c.ci

5l

IN IRODUCERELA,"OEIICA
rcduclasinplDI)l
xloabcvcrbalc
Itronhn{clc,popoTitiutriLc
. mbe srDd! jcnprvc (dc cl nuDnc.i trunliarilc) sunirngDrclc
r.Lexs.urzind subnrvcli{ul
cuvrrcl(trtroso intrlimd*rd ri
Nc glisimrcilrobrtia con.cpricip.rrvnctrci,,,p!!rul c

r.,'.]]]l:j:i:-*f_--r:rjl:!:,r]!

"N.i;

incm exrhlclencnrtr-iobieciiv:
r.rc.1fc{ r iltunpin nrij
lorcchca isrmp$p.ii.sull.iulldiiu ui.ddpiiraluldea
ghdi
arsrae;iNhi,indcptinere
ohncri'nicto.cpriyimri cudrdocuar
.
i\r lnr..
r-,p-,.ei"..J.""r.o e e " d -. ,
"

i:-si-l'-::l:

9iE e'nn
- JtrD;

, d.
m-.
' r'
' " ij
lociriinaliorcuvitrr:)lgs[n,porrvir legilorJnii,pccm
drrur
Concrn/rcrrtcihptrn.,inaq{ecoididi,ccirmionk{

| ,1r...,,-,r. r.. " 1

+ j: ! s r l/ s

I \ n i . :,:!r.!. r r, 1,
5'o 7
nloeT( rn
hrcrii" N.esirarc.r aredertungutpaginitorpm/,c.i.rderc.
nlmnre alc lcsr urii diDrrcLtirirnctcpird atc .F.ei hcrarc
hbuieint.lcscctroverosnniirrrioncc.sirarcAtho/ogio,.n
.r or \i '.. r-'
:u... lir 4Jr,
rapd{tr unormunirc pcsonajcd lcgilr pcirnxncnrctdcsoilerutui

a.^

..,,.r'.!. \rL!\mnut !trlL!

L; *-irri ".,,,,.
iin'triln
lcdrin ; ".,."".".,
r.g,ci nusig:isesL
rtcnr co mairieuroasil.pticrc
dc. nr
-..u,;;^-i;;
conrumrur nn. rilii a ptulaeoni$ilor dnnci B lirbaii \nn fenc i,

rincJisa! bltini. pDrcniiciripln,itrhlui sar simplit'uriron.


lcejti exponcnriai trncioineninsupuscincer.[aLorsunrunuri
srJi hrnnrc nclcncirc! lnt nDch,pin ndc a l!.e dir tucrc un
ptergukrcrlnu
oD reprzcrrdiv.dnf utr7-hnciumindividual
i
np.nsabilllpcntuc!tnDrtac'ft
E.o{di1i3
dc$1rob-sbsc
.e hliircrc ctrsufcrinlalor si si fucii &ud sp snleiclc ndArc
fi e lelul citrc clE tcbnlc si Iindi pmttrl, oi dc cite tri cu pildc
l[Drnurarcd lc3cnJl neindermnisi cueeginlab'ndc.a$
nu r resnic sar 1acuatul .u cre tebuie intimtar.l sti{ca
sc nd int.o vrcnc caDdevoluria &aftei gr*eiii poalc1'
so.otidinrhcidisi lv:lnddespEproducrialeeunLorv\i]v o
cunoatrc ocst:l$nDaicomPleiid(Ar Inoa$d. A dclcr.ii
e!!4,ll,f,9!!91
sioaria dc a si Ja icd{ hincde .ee" *
-d.ituh
ojcbrh4&
d a'uncl -<idi'rordcama:
rlul+rr-r !n!ql(!
,r. *l!*""
pr !!:rq{ur{i!c
Lrc!9@-!r:&:j.,1'ar'!
'i
i i - r c n \ f i n L n c ! . i n n N l r l r r dn r r t r r L ! c $ r u '
! rmrJ r v \ d v
darrn,elcnutar. insotirlidc obsura.i ! dc prclizin xsupa
dttdrelorFnrjvitcsideTlinruhslenotrsr*crato lur,itcrrc,
cu'lophic,coniinuisli\cvadlocortiburic dLclpjrxll itrson
uncic$cti.i a trgicului.
niratel! consatuirea
Dni rccre pEciziri.unsleP.ilcscpcnoau prolgontrturu
muiionlorDrincrlidri dorale.pri" btrnai
GuDeriorcommului
$aflndcrnli si dn coidltialui stujdir':{).altle, dcslisurma
acliunii, ia lcgdttrli !tr .r sodi slatul .r inrenpfiiLe t, sc snc
cedil..impotivaancedni.dardecnrgindDn.lDd,lrelc,moti
vat cu considcmrir.ii. .din Irprels i,finpllbt&, sineue scercrnr
s par minunat citc nc l!s! iDpftsia cI s d I' pedul cu
un sc.dmolircsc,rnpElotrrtr
AsrrcldcncomrnJiin
unoipulliccualil mailcsncdecue
dDi e nd pr{ieio$i sicu.dt ideeape caic si o i..e 'lespre
inligledcpisiti dcdczn.'liDint.simplasiluiF aseDtihiliutii

52
,l'

INTRODLCERE LA PO61"]:I
c deaconsnd ohrecrul
fro.
.trplrrilorlui Arior.l,ni.ir..liica ri nitx sirnne prtr
'niltcti
scen'!c"isepr.puliiinvidiabilehochiiunupeid.'nddcarca
ntrmc,'.i ..*.rlria uncisoz&ii", pnNmarip. cjtui spcdrcc
lulLr,edccdrri.,ltuireglludctr krsedia"'rr.
Adcvlrdrctc $nonenre tagnt ftb

l,,n--iTi;ro-il
r"
;r,a-nrri-*6d.

r m
mr ir c \.,Jclup* n ro*q ri\'i,

triur-rilii-e ph $htuh ir.r nd n rihgrmJJp,K


rmk
crc.si.s.rinin(ft momliircvcnimcnlclfstedconcerisurcr
rl ectiv E cccace conltrl adn'nt dtunr{ri.c cxlcrBnl dc oFrii
euhi rt$ecdea nd {rii dc
rgrri desprcr.iror narud ruron p,cr.er ia r{Lprti_sisinc

cal.nitudrtrl.i ir a.riuE3erou
isor.a mui rtrnramcd. Pctr
lxlerzl cu coctda ftd dc orc nu porrc li cotrccpuliiniri o opcrii
deanirpcphnloeic,.uur silogis,npanLcularpoczisirrj,mdog
c,trcr,., doi,c. si ticni \i expr
rbsolLruL &cl l,.J,lrr {tr r.cl ?n
rcrittr,iinrgnini
he rcceDratnnimpllnlcsipcacroriiurci
Rcgr[lrc cebuisie iibigae re
csrcroclc pefonrjelor,.,r\r1elcrspusclcsarllptclc ficcllflh
si fio d.rcrn,inrcdc rcnrnnllitat
slurreTc dupllrlra dnpi cnbntrl vcD\imiluLd\au iltu.csrfl'lu, ;i Lr rlnLlulru'...drtrllLl

r:li1.l:g!!r9

sr:!-!,l9!!!rlroLl!!uI!

Krrc

N hrbu,o. si sirrtii locnicirnclcmc'rnrtidrl rrr

cvcninrcnrclcaurdecu4c
meleditrrlrclc.prtscrpntr
tr.rronli
(tu subrrr[ cdicrcrulorSoric!top.Id dknrlice. atcciini
ptuli secd rla tit imbinarcJnliir. pnn nufureadin lo. I unsraori
pm \npnhda ci i integDl ({ rii ftzulrc schmbd.n (u.bu.rPs
udirarca6lrelrc.s, ii dici poden inuri drepr...eetrlt.
3 tagcdieiDeF{ sc I'anilciii in strbiccr,i.chipDiic'uD!i(ktr

recuno{ul dc
.diBLdi.h pocric si isroncJi suporioritnea
A*r.tl pocrtrlLlasupracomplxiorului dc ctunici.ln opcn .cl!i
aune'sineure
ditrrmi,.,urftrrcrcrruc!trtrcirtrgnreaciiun,.ci
cpNi,mricxrctrtdtrmrcvc mcnrcldIqrcctrEiiiltrtrttrlumi
cpo.i n' legilrudcu unul sauDr
n,tirnpli!trrtinp()nulincrc!delsiuNl
lalldeceLelrlbrl!
Cn rlrc .uvi'tc. cita vremepR/ir nlzuic{c si infirisca in
.|gxd.a unir(c p. .rc lo-olrigtrri rufurcoa lr lcecr vcf.si
nnluhisaurrclesanlui Jnllntunidclapt nsurosdcrcnrinrrc,

D.M PIPPTDI
isioririi dpdc iilo6tnlui cadomcnnrl
prin sxcelendrl con1n!
3l
idehpltuilor
lipiiede
o nehijkrcirisi svidcnte
lcsiserrului.
Prc.cupr@ de l4icr r ctuei nNmnilr c c rlir de mffi in
pagin'lc Poe.tfi truc singuraa cirei lndinnc sunremindrpriid
s o rftpriim dc h ope dc .iii cum rn avut prilcjtrl so rlev.
aurM d. cosmla nlionari, cea ceDubl'.utc indcmm(si dcs
copc,r n, drunre un ralc nn'at, cares ajftc si-si linpczcami
,mprcsncrrsrledeslccracolul
rasic Ascn.ncaritc nuscdcr
viru,c i! povcrcHhunrploclrmab.r i'rc!ii,nai!uritrinr un
deznodnnhi chibzuirsi impdi .isptil ti podLpscporivn unci
conccplii o'nenes.ide d.plalc. Pirn. s desci I imcnruI complcxi
tiui rddtri, Arnrotel e aptrllrtrtrl suhiectelorni crto - din vm
mfiincmi,lc
genlulelcn I concEriT:tsito3li,lc cclc malplo
pnisli cut ntrf suflereLe,al
cclfin.rEnlniic truvhcsii a(o
NL*
cnoFi eu orodu carrsrorei.
Penh Dt.\cmnir,cuh 'm$um
rriscdiciscdesprirde
dinpanicipaEata snliitrtclu!nui
cnr pnn iamtru scniimerretor
dc mili si ftici. l r ul tu
Jllcurcri ncpind:idc crrihica omului a .irri durF o nnpiniinn.
raliTari ouo dscutimc
rc D a ro$ n{[ ega]arii.
.,sru(u cclci mai bure rrae.diircbtrindsi ne. co'n
plcxi,-diiruicJrc!:pilorulxnr, ti ealns5siimirdiaunornr
ttunplirin' mrcsi i:incaKi In.a ti mil!...ccvidcnr,inpn'nul
rand,.i nu rcbuic si infiriscb ormeni de npravi hcind de la o
sbf dc tcn.ir la un. dc ncrsrcns.cilci.s ccvr o ared3rulsi
!im${l
tri..,ii.inirr.ci EDukir AJijdci.nici pcnemcrnici
rc..rd dc rr. $rrc ft Delei.nc l! trnadc lBrider din l.Ic
.a7unlc.D purinrl,accnr c celm3i podvnic cmoricirrgLcc.

INIRODUCERELA A)FIICA
nic, ti cel de one,ie, Dici miia. nici rflcr
Dc alri panc, nu tcbuic si inliliJczc nici pc vreun pncibs
cnomcnc o rscincncajDrii8r
ntrlruhcse,edept,se'Denrdored?r':esriinli iinrccdasi
misurl ri demill si de iiict. Iot adevir. unao renmtim lentu el
.rzur in ncnotucir itr! vinl1..callld pDntu ccl h lcl cu noi...asa
cro int6mprrsdc lcrul rirar nu va n mciinduios oac, nici
iiJricosito!. Ceeac. rlhare e o flr inrre lcesta anendour.
ci.eva ce nici rtr sedeosebiedeceilarripin v,ntrte ori deprare,
nicinuajunecJiNn tucircdinrilulalesaujosnicic.oi dinpncina
unci srcsli! pc dcasupraon cu vazi ii bunlim, prcctrn O.dip
9iTiesE,orirlti blrbqi leslit din nemuicrele ld"r4l
:c rvcli atardcimp.nani, sinph purgcE { siludilor aoalizrtc
de Adslorcl hsr si sc imdmsr cr, tu gindur l]rozortrrtri.oDe,i,
(ri $Li\dy0ponov)nu lo& li d.spsrlir{ de o nDanlt nonli.
a citorva r6nturi din capirolul
ca s in cclc cu rctiunc sinplil, p@rii pot obtinc cf.dul dorn p3
cderninunriii specrarofllnt:st de spint ptel"ic! deopott!
enoriei tasi.c li onc,ic;. A.cd{il cdodiricc rc izari de ciG on
un lcsonaj viclcan{ plir derinrdc cpicilii,ori!trul viteaz.
d{nclcliun,dbinif n4r.C@ccrcdspnDdcdinhutcxtsidnr
cclllatecIS n'tp!nov expim[ nutuftra spec]au
rlhperdiril
jn sufleid privnorului unui specbcol tagic de Ealizrer uui
echili bo intrc lq lll fi r&plrt* ,.sonrim.n rul dtolriltil . cun spurbss,ani,.,r'morc
perranor
mlir!dcivaloriundi .Id@anu'isrllinildcoDr.ri,nodnri,in
pentu senenulin sufcinli,
crc, alttui deinGresul6inevoiror

D.M. PIPPIDI
iini.,in csaliimisrt.rspwrul pcntu. nounl mo ll !pli.
crbLlincrmuluioDene\ciEgrr'z.
RceDlilcdisrorcliccllc donci xu { tiso.orirc,hilDrcds
dicc.crrll-ljilcunci DiDlisculnc rsnpn prcduclieisceDice
gMcniin cpoq $plcnei eiinnoriri Din!c.npuncl dc vcdcN.
conribulir sirgnloL Lr isrodr rerttrlui a.ric e neprcruitrsi
aminunblc olcnt dc Pcdl., asDpnonginild tilutici tupczidl
snlgunlizvordeoarecanni' e-JrcitrurhiftsirgutuldcNn
von$cinrctudor4.Diicol.d!i'tcrcn isloric(carcc rc.etr.fr
st ns dcspdrlisi),c(acc,
dc-j luqul ve&uitor, . lsigr.t idsil opuscululuirdsto.elic o fri'
vcchccr'ndcrc{r'i durorilurcd
Slrgkiluluic!dlrlrordclcgilnc
dc d conpunc in eenmile ta8ic Si epicrri Exele la ctrresr
ajuns,in rcdir dincric. ri prca
adi sirul 6rpa lo. D{i1 anitrrcs{ortrii lsjino'sa rcguli a ccl.r
et nnititi si disfltir deeaprilejtri(i, on spe.ulatiilc Rcnaftdi in
jufll ctuului trgic idealL!'. o hc petrtrur hveden, p deo pft.

INTRODUCERE
LA
'DEIICA

cuchdicnerl.,wlsbili@rcdelor maidesemi prcpb rlo Pd?!j


n! p.atc fi pNi nici astizi la ?ndoiat{i1?.
h coFivenc plinu pn,pozilje.srrpla minrire a conceptjci
porivit crEia fenoncnctcauu .16oqri lor cftre cr niznicsc si
in atirgcrcr cintr sc rallT.M!, cnn d sftmia dupl cdc locoaii! zilelclni tagcd,ai efi g{snlomaidealtr*.sunrde
ajuN p.nh r nc tacc si inrelegemcr. vorbird de opcftlc scenei
aricc cn intcrcsul pe cxre i l..m vlzd, tilo?oful avcain minrc o
picsi Epreaniriiv! penh inrrcEulsendrmatic, o piesllpe carc
iu in.crr *o dcaca pild, ii tn raponcu crc ili lirmulrjude
cidrcrr" Din r.e$ puncr& vedeE.poeri.4 D.arcIi socorirrcaun
comprcxde Egutl in {dto a Eodtrcccfccrclertribuirci!.bip
obLsnutl'gcd'ci, abstde djn malizanncidrrm rtl, ta dcsiv4nea c{ir,,f'.cne dirt.J'se presuluncd
d fi conribunbi
a(Atcir ralenbl tircscla. Opur ld AJiiorcl k r.r{liJeazi
cajNilicda nrion?} a hgediitoi elitu elc mai iTnrtiie, ii^rtel
nu.i
&sigur o lxbin.ec a spiritoluiin cm a fon conepud, daci ince
pind cu verlr ar Xvl,lcr, oliacrdu i pucpthric ave! 3i fi.
acccnruatpani h c*dEcrrrirecunosdte
AIE e chestiuna dc a sriin ce mnsudrcgulile Ped.c; dcpt
$sccanpulliceLruri@.IcnhIncdh
nele le3iatcru
'le
p*zici
rrurui ori are
indeobta. Rlspusul 1aacersri inrobric

Aistorel.lJcde !1l!.0!.l5ri a nnpll 4i cntuTjs'nullui L.sing


pcnh o.pcd br arii dc infairibiri,inochiilui,ca Elene,.e/d

{4 ! r

tuh

o h'e

rni Mrid r

D.M. PIPPIDI
rtturideconceptalieiruiade\tEDatuia p.erci si-ifiFscca
lnd trItoni onsinilitiitii 3i ai subFdirnitii liri linire s{ judee
nrvechia . doctint in erc locul c/c,iidt e tinnl dc iait iie, itrjo
cul ratrtz,cl c sri4lcir dc otrclii! ca vtrdii,,7d slu ,ecrs,ul
Petuucinc,torusi,pocTi{truI ode li despl itideiorlil:tap.
caornccd.dccidc unco\iNtdeadevli prnhcire.pcrtd
a fao si vibtozc codiJc $fl do$i protnn&, dincolo de indivizi,
poezir ftbdid si s adsczc oouJut,invlrhu Pocri.ei,p.tilit
.lfir obimr rl inirarici au a li considerare,.lucnti lutind sr sc
ideigrea{i,ori_
rn6mplc,cxprni,lchrzaunorexpricnicSi
rrrui crcnri.U r dci diDrolde2lmji!

Puiinclcp.Binipcarcccononidltrcriiili nni itrsiduiesi lc


iniercs.nft
inchinl,oarn/tt sunrdepdc dca cpuiz!aspcrele
qjlcn
r
autonlui
ci
nai
purin
r.rivirdca
rle Ptrriu, si lncl i
in
aci
dode.
Penh a daimgiDeaexrcu aaponuluilui Atstorel
niu.- ceaditrteicontibuticsisromltkI la puizda con.epturu'
cndcii literm ii uDrdin cclcn{i Plironziiore a1ctutuioi !'ln
duPI
puilor, - sctem sr li cNcnnccrcehrisubtortcaspedeler
pdn
lui
fat!
de
p.ner gencnli, ogliidind atitud,neasandito
cipllelopsblcncalcanci.Ia(ersp{iali,-pfceptinic!. ln
caF epopea
ir ndi dcs dmmrsuniarrlizarcsi discuEE,Jnti
pemdcnrc
si ln prrticnlritirile 1oraccidenEle,cu o
slturile
nnnumxiidancimernlc
migalilti o linelcdcnarurisi cinsteasci

INIFODUCERELA POFIICA
idcnr,6icad4l ti miul
uienes! ric.csja. N{dcjda
ddr li d4, totuli,in paginile
Comcntuiutui.
datrsiiiteindislcn
!'rnr. uDclspomicscnin a kxrtrlui,mi mansiiicdc a6teaomi
{trtr1irllcunc Asacnn'con$tiinra
hd.jchctrunc pcntru! ei!i
cxprcic crcdiicioasi uoor gandui I ci.!' otrcvoinrr d inte.
|'dN nunai d a n devrlSrsr,imi d, cunjulsi asbprjudec{i
ciliruuluicu scnini[b.dac!nu N incredercr5r

POETICA

.a

'il

llu
$

k
Mi-e fi sAd s[ vorb6c depre poczioin sire !i d4pF
loluriloeti despspulra dciffeuiE a fie.nrob din ele;dEsprc
dtpul cumtcbuie lddnjt! malqiapcnb u prrshuircasr ne
lomodi; dinc3teii c fcl dep4ric tlcltuilr. eijdcri dspEl@
CG sclegl deo aenono!@r(fu.-ltrccpAid, cm nsc s
Epopeca
5i pcu G hsj(,. cae 6!g!14 5i+!d1.11!!i4i.15

jloiul de lDcflri (cn tuic$ue tnt{ar, ori Nmi din depnndd)


gh\'i rorrr0ti i\rdLe poml'c MG
ituDicm muh
'n'dcu

#:HlF$*,"':"lP*#"'*iffi
sffi
t''iGra,(me clnrulcunai'n
*i n aur*
ffil-66*
"dal' slu d{gFibrrn nlmoi ihur
- ruls.$ dor nmu t melodj';
Itd nolodis c{ci si accrtia.mj!4!!i!u,!iB!eiq !!!!!(ni,!!i6

cqslesa4:}:lsE:

20

A RISTOTEI,

POETICAI 1447b l-lll

1443i :ll

o'lrr!i,hic),pcnonaj.reinohip e vorli ori maibtrN ca noi un


;rl
ori h lel cu noi, cuDiIac si picbni: $ itie Liomcr
'tlc.
lr' l)ln i \ I | a u ! p c u l m c n ' m J \ h ' t * ' , P r r ' o n n r r r m d r '
F - L r ep n 0 u n r i c ' r r e ' m
pinfu
rce$c
d6sehtri si vr I' alta dupl
va
tlL1ri;ihdilc
'mindre
i
m
sr'' l"rrtr incstrul
(
f
.
!
m
l
M
i
r
d
L lt rlu h ( d u l u 'D

",,,,i:','l',i,ii'L.i"r,;il;ii:ra,,,"H###.,i;ii:
. rc (n i, R rt u a .
0J ir{ r/

rtry(

,!, rn!. tu4 in,htutap, ,r.


NN

;;i,;nsd.,,

.i:ll;iff; I *,ii,;il1l.
1:ill':
1,,:t.
t,:j,llJillti

.+i+q
\lrul!ef

ilc

.r-,!d,.rdtrr

p. Jtj, .^,,".,

i n.,, - " - ,

da;

;--;;;;

r, _,,,,_r,
^ t ; i;

:lr";#ffi*;tl+#ti
I t;*;;;;::lJ,;
,".,"r.,.,,,pi,,,,,
un,. rohun nrj

i;i;i ; :;;,;;::;i;l;;[:,l.,li

LlefJfl

ir! r lL .,'

r.,,", 1

.'rk",,rn*;utiu.,';J"''

I i. Lr' cc 'di rorF


I l,;!r, b0nlord.inchipuic pc orDeni mdibum.Clcolbn rsi cun
parcdrilor.
li Nicohres,
Mtrr,HcPnonThasiannl,nnscociiorul
privc$o
ditrambii ti
si
in
ce
rturul t!t/t dei. mli rii. A,ijdcri
ionii. .nFvrpurindrealtxnnnrf.r'nfel'ljhiArgas,'riallui
Iitrrtrhcos.orialluiFibxcnor,in Ctalorrilr' Pi'r rean! ses

lrL.frk L, ar,,*

j"+,
;llli';::iI liift:ilHi
i].;jij",,.ti,il:lJl.i;;., :sr
j;1,,j
l:::'1:;il::::1i:11.'
- ] lf
I ;t:l l:;lt:,,ji:;:Tt.l
I :l
'j

" ",,,.,,,,.r,

;ill,,t
*:*,
jli
jt:;:,li,'"11;i,r.r:.^iI
jlit"T,i's*
'ii"tl,:*irl*t'",i
jltrJl
"Ti
accsk! rrnr.crcdru. deoseftilddi.rc
dc. r-.
.
nrrorceroctr!m siival$c i,njLalr

...

!um$,rrx$ne'mi!lk
^4!

\c hi.,n d . im! i

duElrlllr

h..;r!L

cntr nlllisczi pc rmiJi


aflr indN,du liub n* ehLn'!J - !

itrprin{mliunc
ri mi!c& clry+p+*:i*Tej!q.,1

+",h' t'ii-l1lt!l!!-gcllS!)!,!S-!!rsir!.!, e

.i,i:+ttr,+H#fr#'J:i+riaf"
r c*
i" r "i u ..- . - p .i - .r .."n L i . m tr n c?-',,",'"'6';
'r

II
\rcmr(

in'b' ! s,c a canLi( rtelJ povs


mirrohl;GGii;;iiG,
''
onp^tMdtr' fto'
rctc-.ubLnDtrSneJJltxB.umf@Humn

nmlihf

lr

.- - 1 .._ r _ i r

c $d.I,r lrnsJ r$ru, o {!+199:qti^

d.*.btr,.-di'.

"a!jJ-$-d:-Ji+l1'.91

n rn u n e .

lccrcnp&:\crd,pirr.dcosfbrndtrsenrhelolrcDritr

lnc.ir.iLrropnvmc, r r!

ln ral r ! . d c l c 1 u l l r i A n i o l , c a d v r c m e s i u t r u l s c c l i l a l i i m i r i
i p n ( ' n r s p d nu o r L r t n t r r
lrn ic , n n ' { i t o ! i $ u n c A s h r f
NmGc.rlgrj: pdlgs-sir4l&!s!'d
L,r*nlirca!r\r,ses

r'fi.-iGrdi6d.*''.".

ARISTOTEL

F OET IC Al 1l 1143i l 2 T v l 14e r l l


Drdl imit4ieii;i;ilpnDtrmdcir nrcrnecanir.siralcl si

i,rum, r,ndnh,l\ Hr.!J, i

, ,r... ror Dr fu r,!1. r trn, ,r,f,en,


j.
lrrl
Irflonn,r).L,ri\r
",u":
" j.f rot
r!.rerJ.,I rnrc cao i Dft
^ea

rile

nr

dd n ptuJjm.(fh,{,,r.
\*.".,r
,f!! i.dtri tu,.r^,.!",
-d
& nqsruftlcdeL.\.r

iqrL &ir.(trnrqr,!,ldr
d!l, ,,, v,
,& e \rm6pdL rf.trneru4!r,!crm4!

.,._t,

."

*t

d,..r,,
cr{]id!\D!

.,

*._.,.

IV
,

ii gek,,r,qh,i,r

'nr"
r..;;-trk

n n;i,-

"--'t4fiW#*d;:;**"*
'uuE,.Jl

rmoqrmJ mtrenusiiirnne\ qt!Llidr!

d inr\e

:jtrffi #Fi.:,:Tlff
fttffi +frl_":;
d( m:r rdni'iL i\ un,! u L t e d \I n " ^ E r" t , . " ; i,
., d. d_,"

t* :*tr"r't^" **, t'n;i"i,,r ";"-,.


111"11,''t"
""ll1l:-llgS!!4!r-!,rapa!

1r".,-"!,

;;

..i.t
11,::1.,
l,-. r... u,^r.i , u , l r,,rrl,.,_;1.
LulJr
A trmds " Je trL , mt l. n i! -;.,-"
"

".,,.

:p

imni 'fimnnprtii

(. 1 -l i i " l s ' , r .
[
l._ T,o' '' D .' SL $
-n t
\Lhm
Ll!
dujJf,:.nrrnn.eil:lii.in
uprl
llrtrlu'
!tr{uiJdm
3
.
e
$ r, J ' , l c l ) e r r e " ' p ( r r d t r
d l'inrod. H.mer, nu * poncncsr
ciirrd mulli. Dc l! Hoinerincoaccinsl nu llpsesc.cum r li
Mdg,ressl rcctuir si rlrclc lr rcl. in careisi hcc iPdili" si
'no!91_
dlcvrr, pani x$lzi nunnt ,n'bl, dtrd d+ntrde'er dea si duoc.
n'l rtuirinr.pilrti 6del coDpnsclla!0iGry).l" relulacesk,
di n ceivechi,unii.jutrgeaurul

,r!d{d

r r"u uu! ri;al

, rr!

tLtr'tr1
rrtunrs r !L nLnulL?b! \(\ Jldrhiic.:t i:\un e s!n'
{'nFlq-i 0lr!nirl!ri}r6!nloi.e,r'nturi!!purrtr\rdtrfcruu
dlr
\ Lcc!r.dcslviriinduiipurin c e plrin nnp,ovizariilc,ar

in eerul Fios (in cac sinsr

A ch rx dovedirnoetftr

! tri lr!mo$e,.i

rde!litr

in,i'.',i d,r r ..t,l .,n:)


r'iro J,rJ,aq:]]lvireaLrfDq !!,
M/trgrd e ceeadi

'rd

rrs.diile r4r dc l'dr

i rnmedf2nni(
t4,19r

i do oJhco

ltulinxli sprcuna sauoalalta di' accic forne trlep@z'ciru


\e
i ab."
unr ud h..nl.,l
lt rlr' \ , . ' e

rrrn 1. .eoopgjl4!\J:a*

'"d"-"+9!
paii *iizi r;;!ii'i,iii
on & pede r ntcltr crdc
"-A;bi;nn
/ rclo-ipopni, ncj e!l!itr\i,,e,neprinprismtFpreadtJil'or
Itrrcrku.-r.e6d i ultliotcb{c.
I'ic.p' |.rlu'D
lic.'

.*"r m n .

:,{!-.i..tu--lalcr

'

"Jnnlribi.
rnf
cclc , panll"
alir.elord. cilnacelicenrioasc.din
d -p

'o

l'e.'l'l

ba li. iJ

Rt \ t o lE L
qxlr-- l:lJllrr.j\ nr!4r Je. ur!{ ,
n".".,",;*;;

ji:i?"^:t
r:l:u,
tr
:"'li:rr,;:;lj:11#jJ:rlj,l;
,","'l'.:flllll l'-

o I h,'d3.o.'oJer-

;-ii:r-W*:i'i",;;,1
i*',i
ll.i;:' ::',;;:"-'
j:l:::l;
;:I
;::
-i*,';['"t-*

p o ET tcAi v t+ 4 a , t4 vl

l l q t,2 /i

ii'rrrc.c.ice didc.tr!$incneaspcd.coleo lllccaudri frtiPntrL


li' n cfrtr Dnpi cc o.mcdr si_r rlobl. dit oarccuh Jnlirisrrc r
1,\cPo'nencNci11pmtiiconioipnrpriu,!
onDric,auinccprt
( inc r i'trodtrslol.{itrrr mi{ll,r.orir p$lolulri. dnc a Lirn
tru'nintrctolLlorsi rouctclelal{.inihuDte,nuscnic Dcprnde
id du rcomouocsuhicctccomiccv e iNi dc h EPiha'msi
!a ft.uidrsi.ilir'Dmacarciicnj iii?indi
lannh inceDdNL
Lnvccnvaimbi.li. r pitrs si tarczc rcDecu carcbr
;;drlsjnd
. scmril ti sl inchctc subicctca l$r C re'

fg.;*:'r:mtT{ffi

il;;.;,i;t; ;i:.;.,":,::tJl
J#fil,t:i::11,,illt::l

rl^j'r:
ir.:,:.:
rl"+i,
filfiii"iirTuf;
l',Rffi+ffi*:
i,ffi"qi#,
i,.:T,
r,...,,+--.d,i:.j"tir...t;fij'ftj:+#J,'
\

t''+,++l].EF;|n"''r",!!riffiffii#j';
p'"'.*",'**e.o"
. ;;aa/";ir;-, ;.,;;ji;i!
.,,.," "i;ii;;;,;;l:;':
;'lj::;;;:"1:j.i1l't!'r"",
p,,
...,;_t,".
":9!.'
ari"";;..l;'''j!1il;ilil:
"

,,",,r,,,.",,r,
.",."r.,,"
-..;ffi

:;;:;::1'#5i:,

t5
DLntcpi4ils lor cdn$iturre,uncl
doui.drclcpiotfiitu.diuirdera,siie$ieslspdnlidcrtro

**.,***"-,,**,ri..rs.,cspcolldLq

ARISTOTEL

POET1CAVl l44q b 2?

450 b !

:i I
3*:P'"",Sii#'q."ii':...:j:,,1;:,.
trn{ffT'ffir*s*##H#ffi-;
#P..ffi#ff+ffi=*:iiffi1
j,
"",,"r!rjr;;;;;.:::i:;ilf ft ;Hi,?::,?:.:l
=;;;;l:::i

:ry.,r:@d"",-;*.;*_fi
:t:::1@I#;-"d"";1",
**,.mn"F*Fii.nr..-|h;;

i-eEiih-.l;hfiE
Mc cuprn fiindini,4ia u.
*l,,..",,_,,
J,:;;;";;
:l;H:.llLilli'-Iilj
m)bi duproir.,(nr (irud\ah r,"r-,",.,.*a;;.

;;,,;.;.

,.st@ollffi,

q"

o.

rdstLricrrr: diune

"tnirdrrr

d.' tr ir olb' LL ei.trr.trr'i


eJ,'lc c trnd multrdmLK Llmmrtrrg' recen!lunr[p\ihde

25

.desprcloanc
L-acr-"*doit.mr*p-tspunc,in8cnr
lui
Zuxr rrti
c
snu4ia
picrorilor.
nu
alra
riidulLe
multirmd.ln
csldinuini liitrdunex.ele pic!!decrsbft'
dcPolvgndror:
i'.
ru' z.ori* tip"irea. i"torh modLeCincsrr aptrci
"nn
ll'
ndt{errc
lLo ! [ordrt]!'qllcoelmJ
at,Llr.e!u[
c con.dded\n!

r!'c {Lbnpodu

nhd, m. pc, \ntuk !J drhnru'cj!l!!!q.i

Jc'n \r!5

rtmpr md.trn'd t' t:gcJf d;ngr.. ri !!cne pavnri olr


iizcstdli cu subiccrti cuihbinrF dc lrprc.
' Mai tcbu,. apoi ldIngd.! prl!!-ip-9l9l!!jl!Eqi!14

rElldfliinft E urrrkL\]us!r!""

d!g#99

!aunrl. Jc rt.unoAtrrc-suntpirlir! nLqi\L!!!! uo'r'oa In

,..GiffiLp,,

.affir"r-

ulmk' sme

n.ri in Alriv' rcr cxrsc


mai cuilnd silpin i pc exprs ic oti
'nc
gone'
rcrl.n. dectt in imbinrm ndnP)idlor Grangicic aporpe
ruh b \ & htr rbr r se p@reLk spuie .J \!q4!l!Bi!!sl4!!l

kq:c

De (cne
,,,.,r-"
ptuu0unulo,
plqr )s rurtu.Jn
r! !u.Jr in
r-,-, p!er,
i
poe sph.

""

n.:tjiletor
.r ,re tr4rcrome \p{,dr! rt( lcnnln

;;-;"ffi,;#;:,.,';.;;l'j,;!:n:
;:ilx;j:,":#i1:

:::ifi#;##i*iifr iHi*i+ii**"1:::i
punecincva
laolalri.i rr izbulisId*pnvibnlui daradesrlhc

ciirccrnai smprudsm nemron!)-qqEgB:lgg3-vlr

:::lli'I :iT l"b"!"'-"-"'';'"h..".;:;;,;;::;

. ",qnr.n-ran*m.r_:,

;;_:n:;; ;.,.
r","* _*_ *u i._" ra*" r,ura,p".;.;;i,:;-,:,.;
^",]?ii

sru
.".1 rresidnspccialc.
Poririce

";iiiiii6iEii
rdn nh
-au
tuttricc.(ccivcchiiun.rulFcroiilorsic0vitrt%cai!
e"c"er
{tumh
, . ,.,,' .,
" '.",./<l i :5r'i n
'

q
POETICA Vl l45U b

ARISTOTEL
@rldcarcorlt'dinesrusc.puriLcp..e or decaEori snudia
nui ri'npldc-cnul le urniir$ sru lc cvni. N au,pnnum!re.
c ljutrsdc trmuit rncoro sD
indHl td sru c c. se left$c vorbnoflrl.Dimpobivt,intatrn!
judccar! in spuslc prin crc sc d.vcde$re.i un tucn e.n$ ori nu
exisrd.sau
s poclmi o ide g.Nr,ti
Al prtulcadinG elemcnrcrc
cccrare c
.!i'

nn nJi !|ru-o. if,bkS p,'i,gdr'

,!."n'

Iun,n

nn..i D .,c.

r r Jr

nqf!-i

nuprcca- ti-*ir *re a" i'e"l rci, sitcc(crimcerelke,


buios{ncidbiner frprel.r,dcrrcmc.csubi(lur. cetdinieiti
rcl mri de odir \'l.mml+ brscLl'd A* cadtitr rlh h u!B!
e d,i i'nj!n-l' rej jrdunleirplE!:si hh{('.n rlrddbfiiE
'li:

_''
d'

r sr-u o n m
. doerlen dr

i\la'ld
epfl rl
r r'!
f!.ant'
.DLe 1rD-lclc
ot..."t
'r"
crclcsnedcupnNcugandd Cat p.vc$e limitclc

/
,

,r'.. ,t.
cr, on
r"\.c' in!trdfl . .ni,Po_rucd"
n{.,p"Jbr'orlmti.e,fuo.
'r'.
,icc ri $ lica;

VII

: cnte r:l!'\'-

id

m
r " . '. - ;' r ".u
".."-" e 'r-, rir\{r'(
'i
r"lrctuemri'

pAltrru cn

,".i
purmnrrrcnd
mJ| 6ri n Jcft!1d6nfl "tr,,r;i*-*r
ed
n-r.n"Jc r, e . e ' ' -. .
de- or .'.
(,I'{
L'rr l' ui trtrtr'aB
J " . . e ' . . " , ' . .r. , e , d . . o
faJdindd,cclr
raroroluie nai podvn dccit xl pocrului.
--l

!Su!4!.

1 !'/'u(d.rrr

- r ili: - ii r t"' ,

voroa dc pi.za.

,,

4!4!.!

{!!!

:ri-rr!j

d n;;f:-,m-n6--!.d.j'

.uviri(1,r. a..:siin cscnbc , re \rr volb.LLlcrN!,

!e' mi4sH
'rl4r4c
nn'$tc cicnmdr sFdJrJl--rae*

'

, , t h , . d t . . ,u r L o 4 r i . r 1 ! r : {
\
u
'ru'n
a'v j'!.brriu.lr::tu
| |

;'a#:*+

r\pfi

uLid \(ruimN,

,1..cn

d'.gl

VlIl L45l i |l

vEDri

,l;:ffi

trL1ine
fi'n!lo
I
L:
clr s'c or udril
'IJL]io''.''ho.'l'".U''.
o Li.riti du.lrsind din liE! lucnrilor

Lnpl.nlor'1u l
n . rrrpL .
j
u
n
c
"
lr n r',
lc f lo :
'
r' n'd nercnl'r'.
'
i
.
"
.
,,d.
f.
-J

'derc'i

i'

ryqlLerla

VIII
s_&iir,dimpotivr. c e4 e trmcdi obisnnitdup! drccv!. tiein
vdurca mci ne.csnili. fi I uneidcpdideri.i dupdcar nunai

trmre/r n mn Mijrf,ceo( hr rdLltrprrevrr c.tdrJ0Llu.L,


unnJirr J r.n E-r @ lubtr!at

,,*:i;ii:l:jH:ii,tkffi::
1l
irtu tuinr,3,c v.
' . iL

'

''r'L

'

a.'ur D &c dgr ir aaP"

?5

r(rr ll(

ARISIOTE]rliptu.cdrrpocrii!l'ds rtraptrclrsllscne,crrudller,lrLn,,.
.arc. ?rddd,r.o alicpocnedc soiul!@{a, cu gindDlcr1drcr
H.'aklcsrrodonul.o.p!ddsp'cclvrfi icanc{lrtrtun'tli
Honu. in schinb.carox.clcylin a(at.rdre pflvinrc,ptc I h
vl7dbincli,cl,4urrttcde opracliciidldi.ideoscbitl.iedB
l(fd d!-t ton nrrjd$ r ! mNn; rLlar ,n!!i--!alg!!Jit
'r
ronndc '|i .{ f;n[
i!!ri,nJj ines oL prrtn'ihcmulu'

p . . ; n r " r.F ----,h " .b ,;*,'^ ,1 " ."*b,' ,,1,"d*- .,

, { bi;Ltrfp,n:itin

oni,.!=-sN4r!!!rLrc

Flir tri

'.pdcdm\.rrfrj'rin.
jul!pissJ!!]{r,'v(6ml

u n r( \ l ir re s i i, r
o'i.i LLt nrJ rtu (' r
!ir - \l N
'n
!i! i or r'in
nLe
r,,"i.-.i. kl .b, rc !: lr n murtrd
'
","
supnnrarici,lnksultotsItzulr.scbimb{ofl iulbDi.rC]]cinu
ponr.fl (icotit prnc rnru' int.s rccxcc lic cic,icclnuc

l5

n adtr( !r5inc

'Llco{hnL,

nihil;

ir'

IX

sccxDimt in ps/il \i altuLin vcdrii (de-rr punccincvr nr {ihui


ktm,vcrsiliFri
ulropcraluiHcrtrlor,ac!!tr srfi mrp
iar
lreveainrttplrt.
laPt
ci
onul
ltrfiliscazi
o! br).cipentn

vrlr !!!!L4:!I

l1ll!!!

*idl*iiri-:.'"r'-d''':fl#
:::llll';'ll'l:'fi
'"1'ry*;

:ir-:]i'l;;**

.'ri[[$,i]1ffi5"
,:iii
t*frifq$lffi:"."
*46q5*

tffi

r*i,i1"j_*;:l";f
uu"'i
:llJ:*qffJ :X;:.,;;4" a"':i':""'"

POETICAIX 1452c 1-lf

ARISTOTEI,

la52 b l,r

XI

reoUdi, dtrrJetuqild

hqld!dc

Pg!4h su 4!!g!:!1!s!!!!1c
c o schiDbre r celor
pcr{cure
in co'hriur ror,prcumsaarlrai,t eersr!,spuDcm
t. necesarului.
ca in q!k!
undcsl cc llDc si inlcscrcrscripcrcse si s{-l scalt dc rcina
lcgtrdiii .tr ma'di \r, danlrp. furr rdevr' arai idgnlntrc.obrin.

'ljD

-@.r,-.ip;

liirffi,finGr--m

r ouma.\irc f k-, inlie\n.l

ffi

i1.nr ' l . D r , .. dr \T j n- ,..,L.,. un.l ,,hn


J ..tu..tr , I
eveninentelosenrla'4li1 s! nodl ccl din nmi si :t scapecel I

vidovot dem$rtea lui Mtys, clzin


Aseherealucru.i,lntadevi.,ru parascpctccclainrinplare.
Flllsr,asadar,ntisilca{lclcor"*tr".ud-r..^b"":j

Cu6 o xFti 0unclc.rcunostcu c o rRcerede1anesiinrl

Mli sud is! si !lf.l

dc reunoaicd: ccvanr lelul rdtrr s mrb

no$rLr.i--iiirrninFi;IiiE

r5

qmc{,!i@Lr n' !n' rr.rre de?nodimilr{ qltcr


zt lld it\bniri dc situariisi lid ccununni. dtrDio dcslisudo

ro4rrgtunrcJlre.

lf:ld

or nu L.cd!_

'l

uctiuniinniidif,inaEtu aci{escntimntc,
n(iRir!-!!!1a!l!!l!rl9E!::r!rlg!!t!r!Elclql!

pcMarciscporbi amdrc{ Nmainnrs, sunoasi pc.calalli


sI
Gindc hinclImuitcinee 4edlx din um{), di ci siruaria
.cff[ ecunoqstee rn'erdutu . I!:qia, hniorrr, sctacccu
oosc0ri)uiorcnc prindnirctor $isoii! c. silr cunlascrinsi s
D.itrurrlrmcmc/r\uh,edlltri

..hn;

lrrd Jak(lir'atu

br chirr si neresu.

ri coourornere
inr.

!I!!ssq!q. r4!1s+

si u; ii ctr]3lri sl d{Ngi din fapblc perrecot inajnrc,fr in chip


ncccsd 1r vcrosimil. Cici c dcMrrc dc a fi totu0adacii trn lucfl

-e..

n d$em!;

d,,ffiF-ffiffiri?

tre iclul5

POETICAXII 1452b l5-Xllt

(q'

1453a 29

. tr p! ti,1!.I!q9r

&!!nc di't !9!g!!:!!l!

!!! lrri

sl pB.,c lll!!!qn

F,r4"r{.!-y$ttecr9.r!9!!,rur

$ lmcnrctcctrvcnitcnici pcel dconcnic.nici hila. rici r.ica.

im[g,:;r*#:.qffiffi*#:il:
i{ru*m*ir
liffiWs
:if ::::y"Ti"l',:1ilil;jili*-;;;;;:il',::il:l

iav!'lcmrc!{ztnddidf.n(i^ in ienorc(il! O6enem, inlrlsi

drepr.rnrmrn!LL
umrncL.c rrtmr ioe rnsec6i
mu\uii.5re.e

fi!tl4!!&-!riE
i-dcti., Inr adevi., um o Rlimtim penh csl
![rdrinnrnocnclirtvin\.(c!l!11;Fnlrual k rclrui.i (nil1

+-rH**;,,1-';,i,.*:rlir,l*
jl"jilf :lj::##i"J':lt:;
ffi ;;"i;itr".,
:",,*:
;#,1
,5jl!!ar "".J.',lil,"#':"*,,.
e@_6o Er!4 !]nrtr i
:+l]!!!l4z4ll{rit@!rii

*n;:;:::,1;;
rr,l#:ffi1lH$;:rji:i,"i

(4

a llF l l c k l u l l n k L n u ! , r i n . i i i d u
cr"n
Codrc'henccoli{nhrAtramrid^r!.crv?.e
BJmscbeicdee'lalt' Drin\inuk oddrDhre.nicioua unrcin
su j..nkic..i Llinpn.if . !nci grc5eli.p
ioFni'!dinr{rhtr
il!i
rb.idpa.um.dba\i bhAba.prrnioi!Lp1irtrnc,on

au,illlriu
U'@!
\t
O inlnsrbinenr.hesa[Lrcbui.
i nuducid.rr nrnvru]lrlqqk
fllrc. (
,rGh'mbm, desruatu

'
l''r{rivl d. L lc'i. rcl: oenoro.ire
lld n J s c u E .riu D c ie a s c l in a n . , I
v ur n c r [ f - r d , h n n d l i q u r 6 n J J ( i d e u i t r ] m f I t r
o v tr d b . * a . e \ d s i i h p r . ! b , s r L l n . D i n r t ri r i i , a u r o ri
lifaubr rcluldesubi{Ei ltrrreinr

! i' c a t r . r s ! b i e d i s p r ; ! l h . n v r v Jl i m l l i i . ! u m \ u i i( h . c $
Fc{c(

d$nrc Akntui.olLl'p

Orcsb Mclcig,u Ticic,

klu\ ti$d eilJ li.!rrod Le' foqJs sI hdurcn .l\Iv!r'

ffi

*-"ryr

:TdAclii r(s mlid(,ivrqn! lD I


!ruluifl ndcl Llcinrls.Cci!i lniii'!hrp.Euripidc$
lui,\tu15irc.de.c
!lrlcl h rtusc,liile

n! l'(

chc, rcpcli srcsc a cctorl.lti. Cm an nai spuso.o deneEr


prmdm c bunt,si dovdr cc! mi cvidendo snsrituietuptulclt
|E rcctrl li lairftc{ile drmatie b
rIi krgicc,cilndsuntiucatecumtebuie.Catp.iva\b DEuripide,
3l

ARTSTOTEL

PoETICAXII l45l a l0-XM454

licruie$c bine,e dd! r li cct

l0

15

Adotrainoirir@cah4ii .cadnnei,duprpireEaunom-

seras in.ar4i i sr lrcftzc dupi g6t'n p;vir;nbr. inrr:lgc.


JaDkdpe.

muJru-{r

t nedips r&ol,Jcpdrcf .,r,i6-

riiffiEiii:i]nd_(nnFr,,j-ii:.lrenot
i", o r' lumtu
iico6;aEFlsom jctc-.i'ntrdrrr-iiitca-flaiirai6;6,!i
Eghr, pirrsesc la um! s@or tnpriEtenioj tlri ca vrmd
nodrt dem6na@luilait.

s{

aI

d Noll! rEbuic s, sc dcsl:\oe ndpird fie inh p.cdn, ne


Jdtnlr'. fe nir ornen' !c ncsinrr! n'o pndcu,trici

lohpnnderi nu@i segendEt .i


mrll. C,i undntmad
.cta
impotiva
u0ui dusnan, uitir n-e nifric
tdidl
lodror,- d&i dcflpbl insutiarsurdintei.h re1ri nd e
r doldircrcnti. CendiNI lovnu cdc lnrrcfiinb dngiuDr
li - cumar fi u fiah r;cn

k id! on d dc liod si+i uciLll

lo,mitrofqiorp.rtu3 {u.d m:n, nul,onfiulpmamr,

(c I
di. k c. ilrr fiph de rluladr!.-a(cq(F\ sirua!rLc
Nu
e
mnl.
p.in
um.E,
si
3e
scbinbc
ccva
in
sul
clurat.
!4|h
tr
Ii
trcidcna
dc
cdtc
clitcmoshi
lllo lcgondare.cum
id. di a Erifytci dc .ih Alcd4nrPoctul e darors! n6s*!

,4u rilu!i noi.darsi$iesi sitslo*-aar-ofiiEr.-crui

E-prin Jn d'ip fcnci/. o snDmm

( X V/
Afadm in suncrutF !4mlui. roue mhDoLIl $idnr

:1'

b!-&e6.,nLrjqd Rbtric es ?tinth<eadincr,i hE (&, \{t!


\&ii.r' unlrnrulint.lmpllrl^ -s q . n ri. d n . ' . d e rn d u io r/ c

- pqv@i

C;;i-i.;El;lir-d.-;;FaTl'fi

.;:rGtnr,d - p.

( d - 36p- k..lului c.'a- pu.' n r. i. " f . ' rc -d n o ld d . mij.


lo relc pu{ l, dlpo,uc de ,{9rJ .rr D'nab p- cc e ncdkr
.Fcbi ,lului,nu urnlr{ rr forooa .Firnr . rym, e dr
u r - i gr7!vii.d-iuu! o egru'r. u u a s , d n o . . f rb (rp r. d .
hbfc .o mm h.i hgedii nupurF fi. rtr ndc\e,di.c tL.Jc
desflEc..i-utu'.e3 r4-i ( p'opne plo,htllqir
nhd\d

+Dt@j.:a@n.cq,

iur0ul un

#ffi1.q.t*"-g@s.
Di,, cec tit nptiri sepoi
imprcuri, sr oei@rln c(.
arupr
mdm3udrrulslpdicumplirc;ricsind

osrrm Acltunide

Unlol dea aduc la indcptoneolapti ldlosnd. sciitorii


vFmuri- c cird Pe6onajehsrren

rttntry i"ini;iiiFliiii

pcirmv

ii-o.

iF lnr'lileao omortndu-sicopiii.Scmi p.arc idisi ci


il td0Iutrrlu ,zrr 5[ gie cli il lace.si abiap. urmi s, si dea
rlelqlrud cuprc$upsddnlmm.cr Ocdiprl lui Sotbcle

rsLnr s Ft4g_!I3q!1 a!Lr9!li!r9c!!-z!:!:t{vttr$:

tot&oaE tns nrbmolan,n lrLlrultaccdrri-.un lacc


Il do @oster.rd c ur al teilea caz: cend,De puncbl de a
tl dtn nctuiD$ o laplI ircpmbiln. cn'n iti ddvl'm immt
Alu,{ dc @este!"ald situlie ru i. Ceci un luco feo ori
hcc, c! 9riinlnon ftn {iinti. Prc$, idtc barc, o cMUldG

oub ln cumttinlf dccaui iti punein ninre :t sdveriac,


,$i rcnunlr.o emE! si'mBee p.nibiu. fird sI ft $ ra, dln lipstrclomdtolui duos. Nu-i vorb{.trici iu pr r@
Hctuon,bun{od!. ii
$l ur. dc;i-ffi;picjurtui:
l/r r m . h d , i . c r

{ A d!,1"4e..-r 4letuul:a!uA!(

rq'

ARISTOTEL

POETICAXM454 a 2 xv 1454b 19

@ra. cu triint{ ori ftri. inft csb4 nsi bui{ e snufii @lui cft
lrpruieie &r! s! sric imporiva cui, $i ;i ,lI scana dupi @ a frp
t!it, pc deo pat pedu cnn-m in eanimic rsprng{br, pc dc de
p.nh cd r4unoa'rcM c m eleneni inprcsionant.Cc. nai bunl
e lnsl ultim: ca i. CBIo,b, trDdeMqole c pc pDnc.nls, 6i
ucid.!lul,Lbrn.olac,.i Ronsh; ori ln /r4cDr':r,
uddcsda
nr sd ! omm ldkk. un m H4le mtre nul \fM-oEk
nMr
roomi clrd s prcgica so prdea.
Dinaceaslpicin,
cumm n{i spuso, ra8cdii n0 sc p.t
sdie decei cu ispdvile r foane pulinc fanilii. inr-.devtr, in
clut!@ do snu4ii hgice, inrimplmr mri curatu decir tus
tesugul j'! ftcur p peri s, irEoducl ln subiecrlc hratc
noenle
ocsa. Ci umrq: aurtzui novoili s{ caureumc
'lo
a@lef,mitii ln ce 3cperEcneri ddct dc tr$npl{ri.
- Desprlnllnluira lrytelor, ca si dcspn chiDulcun hbuic
s: ne subiaiele, s-. sptrsinsi de ajuns.

nhionichlui

PildrdcurddlosDr uqsdcladrEburnd,

]MoFhu ln o4!E irccddd ncv6dnicsi neporilir, dnguira


OdlEuln 5d/, n tidd! Mcrm'pc':tren6bhi(ir,

I4g!48

rucr'(mdi' e,,adc
smeesrdcr
d!!ihn
tr#und.eEm3

llgu!:ru.qeSgrq&'. * ri,^ iq!+lrr!tusrg. Fr

Uohulc!i mlrt*.!

mcrule vcosinil

aukrcsNf"pr.r.!.iGEonaji;:i?"

a"c-i*t" a"io.

lltolcsrtrdenevoic,i jtrIti o hpri si D'm,i,lup! ala dupn


iul v.bsimilrnui sau,i n@rrului. Evidcnrcr, k raDdultui,

t5

olnlul inrisii ftbnie sI soddosc cdaclcEror eriloi.


Utuii cflenrii divine, ca nr Mcd@. di in cDnodnlt todhbDic fola\i, numai
Ircilor din t&d'. Iore$!j4!!iui

ffiiiliiiil
#*:j,ffi*fr l"tii:it";:llrl

ootc@ c'. - e nu-ie dd onurui


qr!=i\!i v4'ik. (bjeurik,
auioaremzerordtuur
J. ! sedeab-ur
iornrbtuia!hp
buiededhdEni-rL facalo. ro unclem.nriiu!
'nuft
h sl6a (t]unir,(um e inEMnns mtic
|rd.r[,l,.ouo

S,r""mP-:ffis

l.lorhft r&capMKurri fitr:ruE k h(


m tru
'uto:' st inilc
|6! m{cn cI ascbtnibac. L tel ti p@lul, neron

tudineac si ca alui. A(66 cdialg selnrlltu$e la pcnondc dc


diF crlcgonc alcasl r@te n t o femic, ii ohiarnn b6. micd

ci r.:qjE-!_Eg-$4! !!!tM@gd.
iartubulpedc a iheul
nchbnic.
a - .
A dou calilatedc anlr lh vcneFe pltrivirl. E\ist! o n
htu6iF?sd nrc biiblFlts{i(

i ( ruzimeaor (p,iirvsqcu

I R ? cn e i , A tre ,scd g l n e m4cmer t' sad.cdr Lphtd.r


dribui unuicancrrielei6 rdrlturi {r{rareinainr.a Mh e
ggdsi@.c
d*r,\bi".a,ramiEfjci arfi si fie ncnabnic. !i
qlitrfr!it(a (d- 5,ide rire,rncl hbujc tnlit'!rdd6m.
'n

nl hlnioti,oriuqurarici.oi
cncine ie e alrccnsunriin
lo,|rchuics!.i tnAiiM.um su]. tr rotucimaide
so'.Dsa

u ficrt cuAnib Asadoni Horer.

,Ij tst! ecstc. ebuie luat aDinte


i,!e dqsupla,la At;c,

loriv! simliiild in chipnecesetsezitcdcpoezie!crci ii


[,v0 lo! s plcdruiGre,nuo dalr,D6prc clq,in.r, ra lorbit

uflh(

cdle n@r4_puhhsk,

l0

ARISTOTEL

cec dffi

20

dc* d"Ltffi

xvl l4s4 b ,-XV[


POETICA

A
--1t 1
m$K "J " ' r , i" L r , a . - .

't-

rcr,dnrt:unrdiniab*,

di;r", ;nr",p-DFii--fr- ' . * , it,


p*"..

ru:i;ftia

dcFcc-"i.

Clici'. on .stek e' ia.oor. dc KTk'nos tn nlyc -.lah


dob;ndiF.larildulloiinD{ ik in *mrc \lobiodiEe mD. llc
rsu dorcnr,{ or'll!!4Jcum
din rrm, tolo iti dc o cov.ln. Folosnca r6ror scme c !i ea
cit6'rat! md izburit , caictGt hri Dutin.ln cLUr ruiodisu.
bun{odl, ftIcr cr rccunoscurdupi acceai ci.atrice, altei e
rcunosc0r dr doicr si aitrerde poranr !nr.a c{ scmcls anlm
d!6rc sFc incrcdinrrrc si cunoaftedle dd@e$ tip s!n.6ai
pDljD aiisrice! anisnca sunl nunii cel. dccugand din insi$i
dstilBrea aciiurii. a tn s@m B!ii.
Ado@.,Eedi( c!ob!d'ui'il h R:Msrh{r
jgsjts&,
DarL.IDrte ! ei.
!ni- rolna, Jin &cJrii Dflcre $,enolu.
'le

ffi;;;fr,nzj!6-,r-6ffin.{G;,J--liF

||xi \csirdea(r'

1455a 30

strr mearLaitdfi Li,arummi{ dlr !r

JtrtLitti cu . Alijdcli ln Zdcul lui Theodals,ude llt

se

pl0n3ccl.vcnirl:+imrordia*, fiul.c pc(alc sdJipi!dI

v e'l:
, $ i r ur Lr si n F ,ner de,unde,l

!t reni. ,,4i(ioer fo{ dil5{ mudfr, dc lureo !m fus


ToLun felde R.unoalreree !icea implend ctr o
|!.lci

,l!trli 8rcSi.!din pareaspectablilor.ca ln Odisu vesrio.


Crd, Inr-addvrr,ferDr cr odiscue si4u in se s! lncdI poerului
rrcul,Iinimnialtul,oupl{smuirc
ti ipor@pc
,o lrrcnaiazt dlma (nica cl etuLdselaud, r pl@r srbutr@Doc@D nai v!,6e): a o

rimnlulmoriv
cltn lelul{eb $oul+,r fi puhr rec
Elionment
r
un
rcul
8ftrn. ,--J-Dlntc bar, er rai bun{ e n/uno!'
O.drp'rl lu Sofo.le, on io Jr,genir,

'n
I roluralc! croinas! voiasc{. timito o scrisodc.Sidgu
crilcdurfcl i ruo!!uird! i!!u!intlc,'lrrod!ld,
N0idctlrbi ln rlndnld doilcr,vin fle peehsjudrc4ii

.br.d."r,!"

s faceffo{8r!
cu ajurorulscrisoii; in shnnb. crvintelc rosdrc
dc el sunrndi cuind donb de autord{ai inprsc dc siualic o
{menHproedmscapopicdc grc|crrrpom rl,cl.i oeete
ft fi pdur bt rrtt dc binc prh cn cr ii ccva semneertedo@.
(4ijdcn ii,,gla,ul suvoicii ,ln ?eullq! solocle.)
- A ucir@teedic e oril. 'uid deb
kror rrczi'edc kdrra unui!!!u \Ju rrLUr,cum
seinr:n'prrii
Cilr?tr'lui Dikriogcms, uDdeeul izbucnefe tn tlals, la vede
Er icoanei,ori h p.v6la lui Alcjnou, undc,la!u201citrdiqului,
Odiseuldcrimzl ii cl, lduciiduni ahimc: cM cc d fn sl fie
recunoscutl
amrndoi.
A Drra . econe e daronrr uFr rudeoaii.cr ln }Io.JbE

m " Recuo.ne nq!4194


jug994ii. Ji r /,tgcd lui Polyidos
soti$ul;on ddr nduril ca

ajunscfecu tr\ddo5.0ni a pd'nui,cm nuoiirh{


'le
&Esriasru suptud
vlrodlu: la 4pEanh
fi pi6 a ciznr.

Mul rrcbuicid*i cap!guLji:9!r1!!iv4!9n!!{!$ddF


!:!l nrsi. in mrsunp'.ihilulu.{quq'!r!epson4eltr.
o-[i, Jrul .lc r ni(a tn el mi in,]

ARISTOTEL

BT IC AXVII 1 4 5 1a 3 l

G, lmpfiisind dispMtia fiEsc{ a cftaruilor to, sclsrsijpelili

XV

l 4 s6 a 1 4

XVIII
nnclctli'Eldnr er ak{ui.+ lbF ;aFsElii-.buda

10

nrvocrtepcitro intai! oar, hbuie nMb inrii in tirijtc lor qcoe


ralosi nlmi in lmr nnpiiirc tn epjsoidc!i amdificar..ac in
sconad a Fivi m snbicctin riDiisenerate.
o podc arra pira
Il*cniei: o fad lanrrr, popucrtrt de, n jcnfia. dispakinic
dinainrmsaqincabnld ii, sll4nnrrtu,ll{ tdr, uodcdrrina@
{st inii s, fie j.ifiti zeiloi,.jusc s, carErcrrcina dc$criti
cabe. Dnp! o rrtmB,s rn$mpucarra&leri sI vjnr soh (ft,
tol c! po ncadea sdducen cm d.t! dcu isu ponrftunrutv
sF.jal, cm 6iin * sc@mnrc, sunrin ird! desubiecD.
Ajn6
pca@lcncrcasuri,i rrinsj io criF cends, tiejqrtit c euoosdt
fiernfelulitrchipuitdcEunpids,fiotu feluttochipultd. potljdo
dupi a@a cr spue, tn hod curototiice: .,nunn@i s@i mete
ir lbn dars! nc irntl. ci 9i mie..,dc uDdci scrase man.nirea.
O dar{liniilc genddcfixateti numle gdsj@.rIninde,ucratcpisoadcle
in Frr. Accreaeebuicadaprc iDdividu.jmrijrojlor,
4m ar r, in azul peronaiului Oftnc, opisodutnebunioidin
pricidaclEh c priDssi atnantlirii prinpurificde
i"
k enrr,cu'k,
io cpope,r*nr
.incDoDe.
r*mai eteri
'.g.dt9!!ts&J.
Artuir
ifi :-ru-;;;:3ii,t(fi
rMermes.
snb'ecntl

iffi
0.rriei.;.-Eu.-de;;Ei;l;;
btrlioard. tru i {EIdc tuno

p'lElll4ilqiindruoE:u. sidru s ptudjr,tc


-9t-94E1!e1e

alpiavdimliror,3cnintuie F ci n dnicqE. spbidutpm,


pnu-a! c acesb!etol sunre.jsoade.

or prin ll!]r!r!-.luinhsi.

Drka del.

I uidc s@rrsFsonaialor * schnbe h bnc $tr in dr


!4odlna!t, pa49adq4iq:epntul *hidbini p6" ta
E Ft rcut! lbatnr.,dinprtnderca
copilului!i dovediEa
lri dcznod{erntulidpe o rnyjrul. deomorqi@rge

,!ce-ll

Ud'jlc\unid.

l0

pah relr', clE sud !i plnik de cd m

i@!!tolcx.{. n ;&ift--ez e rlclrir,

'

nhq, dnu4

k F $rdiit
i Fltdl&lsi -Lhq4Eftulxi6q
Ibftuj @ de-apat
tftt ,. eu @le a d.tur ac,buii-st-pnqo
r cclui 6 scie e sI lncerces{ E^ifu

tdrc &eslo

ht r!u, dactdr,n E pcelemi mulred mi inpon ft,


Lh[ fal, &.hipur (m rul clovcrilipoeriiasrizi,dnd.
o!Fru glsrsdtrtr ercele!!ink-nnC.f,eu0ltrll,sem
li8uGlr
brtr DFpre dlsr
'nfta..tDeorcaIk*ma
ilt.lcrenl
nuDolnglduiri sprDm

u[
dspc o hgedie
:!idl@.
,odnu.laIlcualla,cnhneinsrduicsubioh
lrl$ !i doznodlD$nrul
dandtrda sut la fol. Mutripoli
,P d rnnoadoindie!, dd 6 dezlcag{Fo$, cAri vrme
ul eost! rptirudini!e cnvinpusedeae-d.
a0fie ibplcrd

iei o shcrur{ J? epoM, - Eru


mi ndte subieb, cnmeJicind

opuci r! pudt ir scenl hnog subiectolttrdd. In


'tu
r .pi.!. nultunid intind. , fic@ prc ili dobindc9te

10

ARISTOTEL

n'biccl idtcagi Crd.r. 2 ?oid (.i nu duh.i cpisoadcizol4c , ca


Eunpidc)sD povc(cr Niobci (.ttfcl dc .um a k.tar o Eschil). od

In hgcniilc ctr pcnpcdi.cx si in cclc cr rcriuncsinpll.

,cc Agtrrhon:,3c
mulr. ori c vcrosinilsilscinriimplcsi lucntri
Coftl t.buic iocorirsi c1,croricmdincrci,rn clcncnril
intcguluir rehdc,prinumarc,rllirprnclaacriuncntrcain
picsclclui Euipnb, ci .i in picsclclni Sofoclc.L. po.rii mri doi,
buclililscintalcdec1n aun nolril lcgirudcur0biccrtrldccitr
cu oice dtl tucdici dc a.cca * Si.Add o sinplc inrerl0dil.
d0plt pilda ddil iltei de Aeathoi. E, insll. lreo deosebileJrtre a
pnnc si sc cinrc 6cncne! b&!! d. unpluturil si a ftce dint o
tagcdicinrlr.licrii.dc izold..liechidephoadcintegi?

POETICAX\'Ii t450r ts xx 1450b 25


E lihpldc, pn nnn(c, di siin cl3|1iftcn acrutrii&marcc
d.
cilc
orincvoircere5dsc$ineas.d$nrimnieted. nili si
.lricr. ori sr sccrezs ituzirinscmniliri,rua vcrosimnnidi
sonren
lnuFsincslujinde..cleisiprimiii. cuaceasltsinsud
dcoscbircci.inace$d
umicu,ercdrcterrcbuiedsEoducl
riri dcsrusindcmci u fel. citri vremctr celil?tt dabn, d. a h
obrrc incubbi vo$norutui, pc calcavorbeisi ca o urhaE tr
vo$ei Cde ar mairi,lnr-adevir,dul .0vnnt oiuttri,dacr
rurunred prra plrcurcftiri inrncrIr cuvanrulul?
Din cec d fi despusin tcs u cuer.iul, unaspecral .cr
cerrriie consridirdenrd0nb vorbinr,a crtur cunoEructinedc
donicnrutdcdamaiieiii al lor cc irpitrcsc acsstmcn.strsici
irvaFoe.ipon'nca,ce
i iu!a.e-icxpuneElj.meninFrd.inft
bd4 rssphsulsi bar carsvormaiIj fiiid Din ftesd pncinr,
lic c, vati cunscaad,
orj br, rcsrc rmori. nusepore ndicr
lmpot'vrpN.uluinicion'vindr m tetrd
sittictinur{tn scbr.
cici cinearpuEatuadebud vinapccdc Roragorai o sirscrrcltrr
Homr. cind il nusbi cr h vorbolcr,,cani4 zcia, miDta..... cu
8aidtrlci rmul o nsi, n r fi.ur dear sr porunccdci.r(a ponm.i.
ziocac1,c a pue in rcdeEcDivrsi raci su sr nuraci e;a.)
l.c, decesubiccrnlrcesra* cuvinclrsarla o pd. caun0l
ccnurimdepcri.i, .i deaxcNA.
ir

lxx'l
'1.!-a
celslrlc
S arorbit.rirdar.despre
rJrcLlici.rhnc llncou'Dit'rde rki nde!rseoc.
Ccd cc r fi dc spN dc$r cugcr{e hi m locul nt cil4ile de
rcroricil.Dcrttr.iorsmcrcrDrcocutai.rsqropieDai,nuhde
rlidcclscranhb
dc!di{idi"i
6\ ( ?,

!4/

s !

4 ' rd rtrl

Eldcntele lraiului, in inrrcgul lui, sunruoilroarcte: tirsra,


silsba,pdocul! dc lcgihri,Nmelc, vubul. flcxiunea;jpoL"tl:! e ud $rcr indlqtrb' ,nuun.eretdcsuner,osa r/
u n u rp ! r ; 0 t l , i r e i n r e i r ! r c nu r u i i n d r i r e ' g , b , j . t n d N r z h i k
sn.r
si suneielcscoascdc
dobibaccjsirooJi nici unt nu
'loe
meri[, d0pr mrne.ruhclc de licr!. De tctuj lor, tirrcte sunr
vociic, *miveale si Duc. vsira c ceasE tuc suG. plrcapribit

l5

ilii"
ARISTOTEL
rari o prnerein n4cm s buelor si n limbiii scftivmali. cer caE
llc rurcr pecptbil rczulbt dirt o punclcio niscarc a huz.lor !i
alin b ii,0rccuDttrP ;mu!.i.ccr. f t . c h ia r o p u o c $ in h r$ cm abozclorric li'nhiisn,euri torntrconsnuieun suncr,dar
i dev,nepuccplibiU, cun {

.i A L.erh.- n, - ",.. . i , " . - d " p , _ - a : - ! ! ! 5


degura,dupt locnnb un& smt ptudusc,dtrpiicdiFrca de6pi6
eu a*!!. p,ni(dxirlt' rci-o((
dc Jitcles.l
Si!abreunsunctliDsir
ritei, c;iGet crpur fi. bnniMii. rcrrczi(ri o sirabi, fic fti
A, fie insotitdc A, cain rPA. Prccrarr dilcrirclorlor deosebiri

POETICAlX

t450 b 2b-\Xl

1157b 7

dcprb,catrddaci-ivorbadcunul
sauminutti,cainexe,nptcjc
.,om_..,.aDer!". candfehrlc dcrcinc. dttrpundsl devqtcrc
al idtrcb:irii
oriatpo ncii,dcDildi.tnr aderrr,..a
men?.s{{
,dcrsi I Eprezintirdret deflcxirtri dc verbului.
ri 16zi,iJr un\! mr 6mn6. iz-rr \ n rnkks.Llr0,ru
ani
/jri .,creon
ne4c. , nunelcctcotr(Nuoricepropozitie
c tumali,int-adevtu,
dinnuDcti vcrbruncod.
ontuti in dcftnitia
omurul,etugiduitpropozitici
silic si rrr!vcrb;chia.Si4un.i
itrsi.nirc opmrc,kniria3titctatrtci.)
hopoziriapoateri unsln douiidripuri: fic ci prrcrlrc un
siogurludu,icnulinmtntcgiruni
ccuneieidrcete(sjmdrc
propouirii tt di. buniorri. c rna p. catcr bgntuihrr defiririd
omdtr"peituc, privesbunstn!urobimr

r dii!ulrdelegitrtr .u!'ndl,Ds I d e , Dk lt s . iRn irln !

r,"F.r;;J;uii..;.b.-{L

10

mai muxe ,lrc surcLciliictrrii ri I ic 4ezrti !r slisit $u h rijloc,


dr ncp(lid n lntebuinrdi lrinc
stalibr., dc pi1dl1.
uiv, iiroL. 6i Sau0nsunctlipsitdeinieles,
cse drn maimulrc$nete c! tilelesarcda lsildciunsingu
cumrfi dadi, r.piscclclrnc.
sunct.unllsles:
cul0jehs.ncinPlicind
Numclc.m iunetcompus.inhsrar
cdoL
n
au
inrolcsprin erelnssls
nici o;dio-lic dc limp, dlc
lir,li
ln cazul.elordublc.nu no slujimdc clcncrtlelor mmponcnte
cr ii cumr mri ivea iqel6 popiu. asdcl,in numclcTreodorcs
(,rr,4it deDmft/id
), pdtea catelnse'n.cuii ,.da nu ti4 m
risblr c h $nct c.rntus, ioastri cu iorcl, inplcald o
indicaricde tinp. ale dni pini n rtr prin clc lnselevEun inrclcs,
lafcl cu.lenumclor.
int'devrr..,om sau,,rb nuclp mlideer
dc ,.oind , ltr schimb,,Fcrlc ' sau,.r nEi nc lasi si inrclclcm.
0n!1clruvolbrdetimpnlprezcnt,.lruldetec.
FLcriuturtriveite liB num*, ric verbuLEa slurcic si
expnnc, cand(klil d,rlclul .,rl reshi.r'oi ,,ee$uit t .sa lu

XXI
]!4!l c !

deJ os f\r m .I{$

\r r b! s r ntk

ms.

'yi (p!ninf ). Dn eledublc.unele


sur consnuibdinr-opde
cu inlcrcssi axr fi (cuno$and
ct dijincta ru sc ipljci
eraosntlor crvanhlul comput,albtenumaidil ptuf cutdrctcs
Ar r Ei fi " p
taph\.m utrpr ,t n,r n, n,te
'- um
- -dia$fitr-;
hnt( .c \.
J,nc.r!r0uch!
iL re
nilr-Hcmnk,il,!\rur$
Ond nune nai podc ti iri!

obnc& saupnvjncialilm. sru

{!f
c.nrida obsc numeleiircbujnhr deioatl lumca]pevinci4r!!, pecet irhbuinlrr numli dc .irc unii E evidd, fi

trm& ci mr!!e!-ryJ: lflnli:r

q!r9!I.".'!9!!'

cl3lt:ri Mtu.' prnnreiri.amni. :inyoy.depnil,t,n.."


rnd'alccrul
cipriofird.
e pcntueiun.uvanrobsbscj
penrunoi,
u! provncirr'sn. . .....

J5

ARISTOTEL
lEr4rs

e kcglJ \!Fr

MUi .h'<' : rume !i Jl!!.!qE!I,

r",r. e, ls$r.-rrsj!!:tr!l!jr!!
IIllrjjl]l4u
" si.pui prin
', vR,u
de r: sro L sf!!i \
cc

25

| rc
'fqefd
intelesBdin cxcnplul: ,.ri mi a nat conbir". int-adevir. ,.r *a
ancoraautruldinfclunlcdcrs! Pild!dcftceEd.laspcl{Itr
ens ,,nn dc hprivi rrumoarcstuasik Odiscu , utr'le,.mii N
intctcsuldc..nulb ii e folosildcpocrlnloculrcrmnuluicarc
rnsomrcua.,mulc. Dc la sp.t-{laslxgsunr tc.cnh: .,iuretDl
luandu-i'tcubsrzul ri"tiindcubodzulldtrduplmrf ,incaE
pcnru .,a lua , pocrulintetuiDlorzl .,ai'lJ , ir pcnttr ,,i $it .
.,alM,mendou!cuirlclesurdeFri'lica csva.
r Trecerer dnpi analosic c dc careori , lnt o scnc de prtru
npon cu
b]mni, ce1dc d doiler seslseft cu ccl dinr-iiin
'cehii
al pelea faE de ccl dc d ftile{ in accd cz, in locul calui deal
dotleasc vr putcainnobuirlr rl prtulca si.in locul ceiuidc al
parrulcr,,i doilea.CaGodati.pdtii mi a'lalgI ii hcn0l la c@
Ca si dru o pildl, cupr
sc rfert cuvin.ul inlocuit pdn
'reralod
pe lang, Dionysoscu6 e scutulps linsi Ares.Poctul w tutea
dd noni cupr ,.scntullui DionysoJ ri sculul,ruPa lui AnJ . sau,
ro! ri3, btuanetr int-o vi4! o ceeace t sed int-o zi. se u
put.add 3pmo,lnloc de sri,,,brtinol.r zilei ssu,cun t:ltce
.
Empedocle,ihlocdcbtuenqe,.,setrrvicF'sau.,mdredvielii
po!r.
si
blmnii
anrlosiei
sc
lniiopla
Poh cire uul din
nu cxi$c un numcal ld, prcpriu.!i meldoF tohti sI sc lact
Almpritriastnink,hunioarg.sezce,!sem:narpenh.,armpristia vipaia softolui nu sxis(I cuvin.. Cu ro& acc{u. ideea
sc sisse cu soarclein rclafi rapo. $ smindul tirli dc sidant. de rceer sc si spun:,,senln ind dumezeias. i vlrpaio .
Aco$ soi demralor nai po! Ii folosic t rlhinrei: rtib}
ind. uunc, unui obi4t oarcm nnftle mchfonc, dar r4lduin
d!.i unclcdin cal itilc 1uispcciliceCaiicandcirevr,vodind
Du,,cupa
lu An . ci,.cu!! ftrI vin . .
desprescu..i,r?ice

POETICAXXI 145?b 8 XXlt t458 r 2l


Nun6plismuite cct cudcsiftarrncnclohsnd. aujj,datpc
clto i saroruccnc
poerul.
Scprrccrrrlisicar.va dinac$e!.
prc.u'nrcmeNlapyLiy.<
lcnh c(me, ondrrr)jppcntr prcor.
Nrai,m ,p, nmrcru-lg:trjt\ tri!,. ruis(c dL!re ono
U'g[ \''Use'nii u!|U\ |$i:
'
r ccva.Excmplcdc ltrngirc,
ctrv'nlcrcnot\ro( tn loc dc rdrd.. oi nrhrts! in loc du
fld\i6o! i dc sclncr rpi (in t( de qLort. 66 (tr to. de 6,i F)
s.u ii,tL(penrtrdrl,r<).incmisrihtrt:
Bi( liy.adL,jrdoripo, d,r,
un Dmc scTicestrid dc cireori. dinr o vorbi obisDni,
o pdk e eMd nschnnhAi sj o Da.. prcticurt Ca in cxenDtuj
6fLrp'rrrdrd [d{dy,undcs41rq0y rinclrEultornjeiobis
Pivtc in ele inssl.. nuncte sunr rnctc q!!q!lie
alclc
fctunine,drclcinhmcdi{c.MascuLidcru.rctrc{it*cscin
y, i,
<,srtrcorsolnico'np$r0nI(dourhbluirrlj{{).Fcminine.&tc
alunsic lna Anlel , ca'na.cl8i numir dc Gmh rl ii sc inrirDtil
slliopc.rufrlsculinct penrur;niininc,inhcerg $i i rebi,ic
sootic mx f' a.eN Gu 4)
lo consodiinu sli$cfre nici un numc,nicj trk_omcat!
ln Lsra$e$nrmi rci ri\1, K,j!],,, naEpL
huctri:rtiu, y,inu, yd/!. tupu, doru
lnterfrcdiarelss&'nescin rcesreErninalji $i in y, p si <

jij_ffiffii
q".iTlf
il,Tiii:ii,l;1"itr;iii.:'l

oEqli dir piirare.rocmd&{a !i co,nm,cun o.(ri Fezii


lui cl$L. si lri srhmds ln rchimb,i.r,it llqg)rftr d. url
'
,,\ec. grnurrrvllrlr
frms,

!n

ia;;;k

p;i

l5

ARISTOTEL
inielcg tmvincialisdclc, mctaroEre..uvinrclc ttrnsib si rot ce s
deprncazi dc uzurob$esc Dac! cinela sar apno rohir si c.'nnb, rczulrard r ti o eniSdi
or m brbarism.lniemi, cendn E rolosi d.c$r ncrllor! bdba
rism,dac!ear Hlrangc hpnvincialisnc. Dod canclerislica

" f,,

'ffi &tilll,i:Jffi ,"*ffiffi:#J',"i


ln8idnni dcnckbri), caln vcsDl: ,,vizuran omtipin'l cu foc
boupspeieLerltuia
ialreleIafcl.Candcmpuftanui.icr
hitl decaldinprovincialism,avcmbrbdism.

cjaclllaiqs!-seglf !99@jytgqrs!u\!ri
unere.., povinftdt.mde.
{Isqlllg!t-.9:19{l!e,9!,

rebfofle. oodoab.l.n roare.elelilrcamrtrLrcrrornsddu'll


evik baDrirde:si ! Drc4lkrca.IolosiEx.uunht.roh\hri ii!tr
Lrrcrmft .Lr dohrdmB (tdun'..r s' rraliElEnijl:dr,
N
pqin pot coitribui !i luDlirile, scdlrjre i scbinbirile aduse
cuvinrcloi laprul dc a ri aldel desft in volbirea conurr dcp5lbte de hfttif@a lor nonali
de lnr{dcvlr da lst
i.litue balrLira@a: in acelai timp. ln mlsuia in ce nai
p{st d{.abcvrdinfonneleobiiruilc&cxpnnft.Dutigse e
Aia liind. nu cu drcper cdricr er ccriii.6 a@6d libctuh
de cxprimdc, fictud hu p. sea., pciului. Euclide el Btuan.
tutc auii, ca spulea c6 pczia d li lucru ubr dac! $4lng{dtri
fie.druia sdinrind{ vorbeledupdvoic ti caie, id ddtdcre. Itcaa
pr6(ovfq
'En,xr;ply 46qy Mapa06yiis
onKdv -y tailvo< rdy iriyou llr;06pdv.
Folosica pEa vdditi a acc{ui rol deexpriddc c cu atatDai
ridicoli cu cat ndsura e un elenen! cd0r in roaie dononiite
eaiului. Doa ls ac.lEi tezulla.ar.juns si cines-arsluji de
mt,Joft, de provincialishc, on de celelalte fornc dc vorbiE,
rlr! preocupaie
dc poriviE si cu tnienli! s! {irneisci dsut.

POEICA XXI 1158a 22- 1459a a


C5r: lco eb T

.io.f

:ink modcmi. libcnitiicriri.d. dcE0clidc.


3cporrcvcd in
fd/ul pcn('.p !.. Eclnd lo( in \c'! i uno..uv. r" ob ! 1.
L ' f , l\. { ' L * , m a d c d , e p k r ' p 1 e l o . r o Bt r . c ; r ! d r r ' .
. l: n l o . , . d . l r . r v i a c , l c u / o t
'.tr.vh,il'
n.lc fi.
' *p. i ' r ' e . 3 , & J o p : l l J .
d
e
mc . ,I o ' e l cf.i e . e l e h l r en n e
"
ln o o i d r ' . i . - e ' v ' h c
lnt u! ren ianbiclntilnitdeopotrivllaEschilti,aEudtide
facc cr vcrul nnuia si ns apar, lix
,....bubaccnininiocia1epicionlui cftnud...!
r u p ' 1 , . ' o r \ i n b . i nl o r | . . n n
....!! o'npu.1.el, 1or deni rr..un rcliedrr
d (" . i n c . s r l r c d r rr l l . o

",

.jclunat 0rl!tu!rtrdlin8-ooltupmicx
On
fa. gdleie ,ln l de,,tltrurile vuiesc .
'llmunb
i! rcccaijonrincdc idci,Ariliadcsotiinuias{ irlnrespc
4 . o r i : d e F g e d i r e l r a v r " d e dr u
, or e\'r iit"o 0 ir),6
!', q
: rlo . d e ; o 6 .
'q
ifftr!i AxLi\xloa{pilnlmdcnpi ArLII;o<ticabaliclc ln
realnate. tocDa' raprul ci toate ac
, c' o igi a cq il[ri
'l
'l
lucru de cae el n avs habd.
A i! si resluje$idupi cuviintidenecre din nijlacelB
dlt.ic
ri dc nunele duble Ji de pro rcidnme - e o nde
cJnak;cum rcclnridcprtcinsnJdulmcet elor.Dintc
r. , , e. l n g , e l . , . r p . 3 e l n v l b J

L5

ARISTOTEL
rerc(c plcdrp.ziiii: .ici a racemebfo@fnmosc inrlrni a sti
savczii*omld cdi rclGTi
ninto numc,in Scncr:rl.cete
dtrble$ porjvescnai bincctr
Lrrin ib i.ck J! orcut!jtr rc$.tn
f i u , l, , ie o a r ro , n (. . \ ,
potriciircinr timerii irmbici,din
murrdcSrardrolbitjpor.ilib sunl
i";buiikr
"i"gure
""-elc
r n' vorbimrcuvii.rul .bncsc, mdlafon
\t pddorbr
Dcspr n.!edic. $n despr. imnrlt! sivairnii p .!tc. ac!
lirc irdc$trlltMF

XXIII
Trc!;ndi.!mlJ'n rJlrIn rormrd c rc lr{ e ! (a i.
.(
ele n r h nrnnrtrjnLld\b,& Rl
rbr (ed5t!ir! ( Llnm,I cJ p.!aa LU $hi&re errleJ,tor
a fi.Ln. rtrptuui. \i"euc. !r!n ink n {mnhr nri,l rtr
s
unrfirn p.nrru.r umiinrersii,caoric.
'ncpur,uD'nirto.s
orsarjsm si podr pnkLe dcdlilrea carej c or.Dre. Evidcnr
irr:tti.\;r drutr J \ubtrdd f po!Z",
*r-,1r
J s!hncrcrtr rurieL,in.i!
^*_n! c- r
in n.d "r,""
n!!eqr.eronerk
un.i.p
ii /esnura! utrur;irn.n-d
Ddr
",
pe h r rk , n(i,dein,im!rm.rf
rt l. " n r-rn . r-f u !
;,1
r 1b J. rcrctnk a\L crn, birurr , * , , r, o . r, s . t " -* ,
rif, S . ., . J 1 F k r, f t o m it rr& . c ,"
vr m . r:rJq f nru rr. t dep', , "
9 * . . r, 5
1,..,
" t . i,
d
r
!J,p:JJtut.ftrrddmet!\i
t{
rt r! o r r.
mre c !
i hr m drpNr trurac!tr0siajtrc i. I rt d e . c , a ra u , mlf ru i
sfr\ oi co'nparai
{ ccitali, Homcrsc udt ncser dcstilifn sj
rtrrlcNrtrD.ivinlirmrn ct ntrr rpnciist povc{ertuii zboi;l

POETICAXXII 1459a 7-XXIV

1459b 19

dIi fo$,dcburlscmll,prrvr*
Sirnevoiedecupn.sdint.
n
singudpivir) Chie deitrtindere
c4 s r .pnt, pmtul s a ,ies ca snbi.cl o linsdr p.nc n ilzbo.
iului.i{r dc mulredin celeldreseslujeneca desimplccpiro&lcj
i! rclul sr*. crblos'n coribnbr s
palcjsI ii vdEze poemul.Ceilaltipocri,in schinb.prcJcdsd.5i
llcag!unsirgurpeson{.osineuliprioadisiosinsudacriun.
in nai n,ultc pi4i, ca auronl C,p.,;Jorsi al Mi.ii t r./c sa sc 1459b
rrc oi1.din ,rda si dn Odis2, abir de sepot scoarco tlsdid
sru doul din timm. cali vremedin Oj,rt sc porscortcmuhc,ilr
5
lJt dr..r Mj.J nrai bine de opt: hdedtx amclut. Fjlattct,
'litr
NeD brcn, EEW ! t os, Adisu M setu, L n( dmui cncI c, C.tdL;r srrsit |rbreEx
mribiikn,sjnon si Td.ncL.
rc2 Tnd.

XXIV
sl intiliierc a9ll93!1tj]!:
Md dcpanc,ttebuie* 9popeea
glipc orc le rtrfrlite r
sr trc.d a'lc dvntligt4
'Tr94
c!r
sl
vu(lqqllr *udll!4kreu!4!4\!
:!mur:in!!i
, t.m .nr utt,.Fh ur o.- r - r 4 e
**i" d. 41!s{4!qtiqjq,
dcElq
a6Gd@i-noNai si dcsuLdnle,dupicumaE
cxEimarclrumoi5! Toate,lnsuti.i pusein raloae pnrruinta'ia
oidin chiodcalvaritde
HooerIr
luicasafclrlc{NniNarrisd,triplnl|iSerrsimplisiprr.rici,
pliM(lcrecumaneri)tidecancrer.
ff anricaacompicxli(cdoa
Firi r mri ponenicii,in narcncdc limb[ ii dcogerarc.aurorol
EDomlr scJc$u6!nu rotuqi\t!tucdi."-.!nde vorhrde
(n

n( I'rlvc{! i'rLjndser liniL: iide{!li'oree

inln rn \l sc inhrni r7e iiu r\inslri Hr.

AFISTOTEL
\ r ^ir!LJ{uiir A c$h n;\mr \ rrJ n , g c d , . r p , rmc t c
a rri
ha, t,ut'nrutreiLlc.tL
J e |!q, nfJ
dur{a hscdijtorrucabnr o siuri rcDrcrnoijc.
pcnrutr n \pof ilin,leu.efl,.c.,LtKnrneJ!
u0m,rtc rL
fl rmpn({r.trce
N ldr t4!L!. hpn! (uf . dr prrinjadc
i,mr).denr
nruJr.
d n irptrj e ,
rlnr n\t ti.ek NreluLc pc \c!nr i.n-rdd..r.
*b,,ll;
e p ,pe.tn ahihb.rdLlec\mbJd e . p o \ c jh e \ u LI n t j
s se
f
rnE!kzc Inrre din inr.imptrrtrp

n ft[r.si vdr z . n irrs u a ! r] rlo n ir


.einhos4!An \r.txildctls*h
h unctcLlcitkk,firi vrcnc
jrJ e n d f l0 , \ J L le (r
- d,i pn\rd.r v'u! rcp.Jc un , ru rm,
C,1'pn\\{e,n rut rLll].Idd( u,eF,.etuLllte\aneiri
ua j.me\ !. J
sr mq",Jr o
-e,liLl'
^n$ "_.Nr.ra""tr
jjtr rfpmrn(tJu!!l\u
tor aLte
!tu dinb
Lr!
n,n oL l[ rmu re z r5 n , id n Dlu
'kLle
oe.r.erlrotr
\(J!c! rnsjlruF_ r ,.r rof o(rtuoirE
u) r h i[ (u\inreturr4 \
ndc ruusi Lt&,(ctrtJre r(lh deoF? r
M sarimhi..m,.rrn,h ! brhrhr h , ri. { p rd
m; 5 . _ & .
4 r r @ pfod hlte pf \rtjrihJJ n r L f a I p ln rt u 3 q , d f , e
sandr$!n4pmiui

noond\ dc\erhdorf
h llr!!adcr6l
rd rlin \ in ie , n t 4 i\ a J rs e n
mrrn p {n!ir rh!tur senLt!!umN?0.
ocmn de l;uLl,lti n:,!J rrr\ pn,ilr. H ,m{ nh kbuk
srLrs ncihrJ- mr bincdtu.tjor.eJ rrrrL {,e!ftk(bu!
\r .r .1,!r n eludrr" !es.. fo d ! r! d r rq \ o rh ! x \ d c i
ma'Dwi r rtrmorcPropI1U,pcnh
rarorAtraut ri nultrdecthiiscrcoarririrnnr|tcj taivd,lirde

PoETICA XXM459

b 20 1,160r 35

J Hone',! \' l' n\ du_)i


'nb
L ru . n c J . i . ! a v o ' b e . p - d r ,p - n . i n r e n l l r n b i r b r . o e r e i
u piidetddck..
In!-^ {ra'4
u. pc^or j
"!'

r!.J"E.*d.t'1,1.'"-

jitil:i.-,".* L5
+?ffi.*1il11:"ti

. , d r r o . u rm 4 . c . , r n o , n 9 ! g ! J !

tiffi

\'i:;Jrri $ np&r h' mrrrc Arrrr 6.rd L re{mn (u(dpul


I tarr risnl; in epopee,scrp, oh
pllcuti dovadili'ptLlcI roi sel audopovesttccvr o
ahminreri
hc adliugiind
ri dc l! ei.carl ti desltc rs$lritoni.
Toi Homu i-a inriitarp!..cilrl! ce
!usoloerlr !rcduq\pLnrLLi(i'lrLnin(ii.r{ hrrrLlev;J,de

ci.nc vrc'
lucru.m cn$isN sel.Empll,oamcniiisiinchiptric
6c.e aldoileaexiii, pimul tEbuie
plat si cl: $oorcrli evidenrg.csiti. Din tcelsi pricinr, decitc on
pnndfiprcon'ir.iul.mullumirictu.i.cxistieuselftanpll
:
lnchipncccsdalruladcvlrsr,sutrionlnp'nsisileluinimpaun
peikucrninrcr,niindciccld.-al dollcrcxistI.selrsiamisiri
si crcr ll ti Ir exisbntacclui ditrtii O pildi nc {qcmoncrju dc.ari
rrcbuicprcIcl1o
Dcciilnrinphn posihilcmcvoiD
'le.Ztri.
nai rkind idreq)Lfilc imposib e d inlirisma dc r li adcvdrdE.
Subrcielc,dc ilri panc,tr{ rcbuiftituiredin pininadonalc.
Cclnd biNecaidnucnpindnioiuneLenentir4nrd Drcltl"
einxtrxacriuniipropriu.zi
cnlccu.epurinrll.lodnl
i@tion,lulu'
(cr,ln
.tdjp,
ncdumeriro
crcului
,supn oonii lni Lah9, irr
se
nn in pliol desftfunr r faptclor.cun e inonsnca ldurilor pince
ir Elaa, oli in ,\r's;.rit. DefoMjnl mur.vcnit din Tcsoapini itr
Mis1r.A pEtindccl dthiited ra
bui rnrs(edin capd loculu'.
rcriunii un rspcc(
pa. i, tuLtrri,cinovanrearci si izbulc$rcsn
'ler

25

ARISTOTEL

POETICA

trcbu1eieltuardebunicdors,ledtcirjnn
Dhuzibil,2bstrilul
nurrelc mrioralc povciie tn Arses2 in loelrurt cn debec er
coului d Ii pinr in&.cprrh'te. tdale de D pcr po{i nutthiti
aGioralk dnri, Hobcr iTbureircrotosisr le cundi.ficnnd
Cniul tcbuic .,lucrar"tn pilrile undc{qi0nG tarqcie si
mde m s. d, expesie nici ctracructor. nici cuscrtuii. Athi ri.
!n 3ra1pra sa ucir in.un4r deoporiv, rtietut cMcldlor
!i al

XXV
Despe pi)blomc \i dezlc!tule tor, dc circ fchn sunrsi cec.
sepodelrmuribinccineprivcnohcnitccrmumeazi.

D::rg9!!-rrggl-s-$-r-Er.!]rs-sg!l,&r,e ! rr
.I!**If
+rrrl!ll,r!lAe&1,4"*
"nn--q4!E Lumrih
Rgj:u:+I1llglgdri.
&cicr ree\odmiin
: n q , mrb rstri rL 6 u l n cd r{n

lll.

:""-91..

i" tuc!!:]gEy_$irraE

!4tq!!l!!!!r!E

]cAMJr sunri|n, o r?mr Je mimrtii ,h tinbr. irsrdune

Fclib' r*b,"

20

d. 6e.;;;i?i:;bii;fufu!t1,,

",rdsi\i i pGu!.rum ndes.rtJr r.


n! e4cr!.i in porid!r
hlreotL5
dI fi pMie. Crcgclilcprcpiji acaieirdinur
strrtdeJoui
fehn: meleinpolrivanni ei,atrctsinr6nrrtlloeo.D&tavena
rsecuonepuriilidc annillmodctutalcs,g*Jaetnporiva
po.zici; dact tnsr plcarut $[ tn taplul dea nu-6]n ats binc obiec
rutdeimrar._cud&nucal.csi a di$ in relai finp ud,
dotri picioa@ledin dEaprr. - ori privcire o mDmirt s(A (msdiciir
c.n u n.rdlbt.
durLInn, r,, . r" { . . rrh c , u n rrp o
sibile. srseata iu c imporrivapoeTici.As, tjild, dricutltjtitc cu
,
r n n , in,l'., re.epn,h-ne!"b1" * , . p .
t . . i. " ',"
Mii inrij, etc rnporiva @j nsii\j

inlrtisezi cDnvalucfln inPosibilc?Slla4cic o grciedi


crcsdlatrd frri crnti.ins[,dacil poctulsi atingelolnl nmirn
si tac!
lclul rc$ izbtrlosre
-(cmxnume,sasput,$udriin
ui
vrco
grscs.
inposibilit4ile,
maiinDrcsionanii pancautrdesc
ptrrut
ald pde. Pild{.rusrire, lui H*tor' Dacr,bt$i.1elul r 1l
li ari's mi nnli saumai putin hinesi ftri ciilcdrea'egtrlilor anei.
grcscrla nu e rndrcprllid cici, in mt{M 1'nc'rc e tngadun.
gsal. tebuicevi[rtcu iobr'
Sc nai loaic tunc si intcbarea dc
goriitincgrcisahdlicati:c cuNr impodva C.6zici,on c dio
Int-adevir. c
ccle a cisi lesfiuill cu ca e ntrmaifnttdpl,barl
nai nic plcatul .Di !tr stic ci o cIPdMri n ue md.decet 'i cui
&Asrfvi o potivniclceild imitrtici
Tor asn,drciserdme pdtr (ilDvi.unci.l n a lntttn!!
lidclcevroiarIi ntfTc,{edrcpn t[dspund:1ciI ai'tlil$ri.
poab,cun ncbuiast lie Aircrmsofoclcspui*dcroiihrici
, . s ! rr c u d 4 i s b n i s ! l i c , i a r d 1 u i E u r i p c . c u ' n s u n t a i c v s t '

25

Daci,mi doparte. obiedrci lu(tr1int isit d.lmr nu i


'd
innioiutruldineestdouircluri,srpuEadlpuddcctcasrcDn
Cdulpovc\dl.rcuzei,dc$rccaredida!
si-linchlpuicoamcnii
s! sc spuni nici mai binc. trici m rdcll1rat.cl podc cuD crdr
lumca.
Xemlan.OricDm,rispulsuls,.isacrcde
Eposibil.i{tsi,c!dcspEmclcIePrd !n,lcDetilorsiltru
& poaiispmcct un maibunsdc.nt$nb'ndcpn$i sl lo vcdcm. 1161
ci s[ sspokivoascrcd cc cru siridd]i. o nr vcdnl d6pE rmc
.,...cuiulilcledtpte,lnliptnr ininer")
r\ecraarurci obiccnd.peod*lmai!utirunlld
Cande dc hotirir drcl un i&ru \Pusori sivirsit 'lo trDlEts
!,ori e nonos o! ba,slndulnu tcbuic si te 'ncrgi n nq ra
c
r"prasru uu'u Ain As"uro. perr o I v.dc! in e
'?lcasi
'nisurll
peNJara
ctucrr
on uriirr.d ! l! clo x siviiqn o saua spnso,lr
$ rdrc!c'li. himp.q$are. lr condiiji.Lrpicinll. bu oarijr_t

ARISTOIEL

PoEllCA XXV 146l a 8 146l b 15

i \. tt,, c tr3,o.' 3,,J'

ri

O
-ru y ru r I iu , , , u d .t jn n h L f t .
.
,c.u rtt 'lE .-rd..,rlr
ro,.B u1dudi.pr.. d c a . , n r, i! . L r, . .
u n $ i,
^\
p( E Uiqn!f rrs;ndirla.!drr d s t u rL i, u t e o ? / , n r
A$der
.m u / i -n-\p( D,ro,...|d c: t . r: r, . . , . "
\ -" " . . Du , "
,1 cr: ehl,11" 0 ,r !, u,!. r r . h" , D
& , c . "n" , t b n , , . o u n
,trm i, J t 1.p,

), ir

Fj.n,.

r u ico,.3hr(41 I mi,ee,.iu_, \ u b . d e 4 , m
mro rc mh r
Alrstucr sunisp$e hcrafdic,c! in ve^ndtc:
.,.. ror c.ratlj.ri zejtidrboind.
dornHu noercr rhagr..-i
r .!r !etr! rimpielt.j pr(! r d d u s c
nc
ru r(la ! rn t e , :
.. ...01r5ejnhe.!5prcc rip L a h , * i( . * ; " ; . , 1 , "
sDD ! radJor rl nu crturnJ. tdfu..
,.Iuu e tn ( I J., mehfoncin r.. J!,,nuhi.frrrtr.:
i
.e,rordr-cd'r\JdeJ..c.mutr, . L " lrt . s it re u id . : d r\ c ^ u l

r
rAs
.

Arhkccunh.i|rnnprcsde,(utuorurctuLHDD'J5LlD
n rlrm
vcr!unte.
'rru.!tdded,i
,...ninei unnsi dobindcascr
stavi...,.
,...,paftdjn cl purezcic deplodc....,.
Airete mutlumd dne,bunedc\prr

pcedfilu!
r.ru mun,o:,e
n .nunrcr5'\:ude k. Cctc,n x n k ru ra re
l
Alalr, tdnLlerm: taDkksr , nLlorelnrc
Jt vroer erbre.
. .rforim?t hjmtt. Jourprrl,ileoupr ; ..,
_
lndc. n I h'n! \e porc inhtcle iiJuur t lurj

Altele, in srtusit,seltnurcc in lumiu anrnibr dcpnndcii


pi i sezicevin!in acclasi
ohip.
pocrulponcncircdc ,.pulpsrc
dc c
ru$in,,blonzad" pd ei cc l&toizi ficrul.vAnd dc o libcna@
egal! ctrr cclorcc spnn&spc Gxdmcdcci,.... toani $i lui
zeB . cai om aii sr beavin Ac
Canduncuviotomcm paE a asdndein el o contrdicric,
kubuidviruroarclcludcinlcl.sp,)!rc,vcatnfnzalDdcs.rui
tns*cmplul,.,roloopntu{ alanced!bDn/.bun&Dd, ciitc
ch1pu1sc poab lux .,ali opri aolo
PunedD-neinftbare, drcd lucruri
cele mai nulrc srnscs:i intclcscm ctrm tcbui.. sple dcosebn.de
rtifdinea lrcm racealuzLe
Clan
cri.i.i cno'nir ida jFbE absu.de.aF, le detrebaa e, insisi ade
vinrc.pcrtu.ain.clcdnrumi,r, t4idn'dccotrcluzii:crit
.didclatonntr$potjvc{c
veriIcatincazul
lu' lcdios,pccrc
cupsprir Lorrmhipune.Frpr
!po, ciudarci
au ilceput pnn r-l d.de
rc$ spaiian.gr!
'le
Tclemh nu-l inL,lncsc h vmi(a in h.edcnon Podec! luco'
rile shu asr cumspunei din Kehlonir: ctrmci Onisd si-d li Lu.r
ncvdili
Nunul ,or ii c! !!ele d
'lin
lcaros S dpuredar.aicdumoirc!si\cli ivirdiitr-ogrcieau
in gcncnr vorbind.rabsma imposibilului i6i giscdo notivar.licin ccdnlelcopeEipoe.ice,ne
in i&rlizrr de nlui.
1E in credinrr.bicrsci.ln lcglturi cu ccddrclep@ziei,nu
tcbuicuitrtcioiolosb irarelsne de mTut e Felerabiliunui
frptrncvoicdc rc^r,chiarDosibil.Osmcln.uhsunrccjI.ratr
dezeuxis s p@b sr ru cxisro cn ar mii binc. insi. ci{ mai fdmosi,pcntucineLelultebuiedepqn ldionalul.lldndul lui.
di ideri, prin arirtua ci in anmirc inprjuid
ri vorbr dc imtionri. inhcal e verc

nici nu mi p.are

ARISTOTEL

POET IC LA{ V t4 6 l b 1 6 - xxvl 1 4 6 2t, l 0

candc !o$a despuseceF, .onradjcbni.ftbutc cxann


Mrcraler.rin dncftiit.didsdicc.-dlci crclbademt,si lud,
in accaasi
lcgiruil de ideisi cu rcchsi r-nrclcs.
_ Fnrn I vcdca
da.i t pmrul3ceisile oNa in co0rdzier ne cupmpriilelui
atimalti, ric cu rudecaboicini om inrctrgent
irviriroa dcmtlondiraGs'udedu;GeinJrepribrr.ridc
cle on pmrur !c .tujetE firi nevoictie dc ir4ional (caEnriDidc.
d.ineflenli4luiAigeut,ledcriuorc.cmetulut lui Mc;.]

chipnlcumsirarsescinnrtr nu sepoarcnuni dedits6solan.

ciricirc lci cxaniMe prccJ r5adf dn cjnci lehn dc $ni luruilc: or ihpsibilc, ndionalc. virbrb&e, conhdic.dii
sj
porrvme rc8ut'toranei.ti dndut tor. solulire scccr
larnc pc ic
ne rrsd unci ptrxE & vedcrc
iisunrdodspE e.etrrunii.

XXVI
c'ncvrsir purerp;itrum inrcbeiea
dr.i nn4ia cm
I n b n .:ro mre p .p ci e \d p e fl or !( rdjgc..ur
c
d,m punv;
,qrfrr cs-idirF:niFE7rffu,-niEintrft

a o:q14.ry-!:lM

IllrglcM!

i=i;;jd-'

knr

i: lnu ad*r,o5i

.um pnvron' r{rr ins& ri nnleari ftd:drdsir e or ei.e


sdvinescinirdia scdcdaula rorsoiutdcni{rri,la relcu Dro$ii
.inti.eti din naut.e sefrcshejncariinfttieh aruncarcadis
culd.ori htnuiescpcsefutcoahidccarcoicaDll.r.lr, r arcr
3hu lucnnh si cutrgedir Cnsurut
ci,e slDF,. cu$nt pecar
adorn de alri&rl il liseau urmasild tor in nescnc, cind
MlnDisk$ nuncrlE Caltippidcs,jmainut., psnllu
tc cutaiia
ru,exrgDiirisi candfaimaiutPindrnueradiciernsibunr in
iluanr oclordin trm! hr dc oci diDki s-areisi {na hri.[
inteagihlidccpope Bn.semaipErndecie;dnuhis
arr
a&c$.d trr!i pubticsuhIjE,insrrtcsi& disDensczf,
deImbarut
ge$unlo.i cili vrcmcheedid rr fi p.nlru oa,ne.jt deland:ri d..:i

'
Accdorininuiri li s!.atc d$utrde,in pimuLdnd. clnu
privcs.poczir.c, medc$eul rloncc$. cetl vFme d. 8c$un
uaazi si reci{4.ii' ds epopci.cr s.sishtos. oti pdtcjpanrii la
ink.siLe muzicdc.crMn ithos din Opunr'lnal doilcarind,
ct nici ecdcllarir nu-i lorti d. condamnai. d$i nu s
condmni danrul,- ci num.i galionlrljr acrodlorpssti: dc .aE
eminvinuitCallitp cs$i decm smr inviDDilj6tti si !\ir. din
eic.inirdfcmcild.podrrcondilic Lrro! cuPezircpic! de
alhinbri. pocziat4ici isi produceeLcril si l,r[ vrco mismi
simplacnire dalr linpcdc dc ce lcl dc t4edic c vorba.Dri dar,
in ccllalrcprivints,tuedir c supeiori.poFii,nu i spuec,
invinuncr pomenn{ i se adrcs-]1 nunudec
Sup.rioari mii e @gcdu 3i P.trtu
rels cpopuii.- i sc nriinrplil dor \:i $ nuic$ci tiini si dc nelrul
ci, mrirrcpe de$upraunclcrprecirbileclcncntcPmpni..!
Du;ca5jelemcntr(cnic,nullumiticln.trdcslirxrcapnvronlni s mnideobil sporlr!. Mri re apoidaol si.tarc t$loud plinc
!arcpl.?Drarc.Jiriamairorbidctolxdor
'lorlicf,h!irnetl
dece.
alirgc lclul fircs!d teclmi nniFiii in limic
'naift$raNc
cc
pulu.e
mri
multi
decai
(Cc
c
conccotrt
alccpopeii
Plilct
r
gandim
hces
e
dcaul
trDc
seintindcpc utrrmpindclungri:
inrimplr drcii alt.Lrul lD Sofoclc!r ri pusin ataGr vcKun cib
mrprlir'!
imbd.aliinhmlcpici.nnihthmdclhninG
unnare.
Dovrdi, farrdl ci dnrorcare.popccsc tor s.ode mal
hulre tragcdii.Asrlind.dacrauioriidcpoenccpi.e'aralucr
si c{tlorreTe un si4ur strbiccrnagi.
aiuncir ptu! tuar. oi daclli r dr lMllher ceruti dehexamh
arc mri pulini mlare
- xpl cbjori. Caid preiindcll opopcca
implciii
dii mll onlte acliunj:
.i
e
decertugcdir, vrcan s, spm
asr cnn lrl,d2 si od c., snnl00n
p:idi.licclre cu lniiodcrci ci, Dricr ci lceft doui .popci strtrtcit

ARISTOTEL
in mas risp o s b '! l! ' . rm b lir r! u ie i

b r c \4 th

\ tnimr,
-oi.um
!q!!!3!1!4!t!!!!!

-rudolci
rngc
ngclclul
inrr-unchip!4!g)
Flulirtrln.h'p

ri . u r

s 1 t u a . , o L ire l. : !

formi dcdri

rd..r cpol{rr.
DcsFc ragcdie ii dcsgc D.!rc considemctn cle i,sto,i
in elomcnrclelorj desprcnumrut $i drcscbidtc acesbra.desD
pI cinile cc lc fac bNe ori Etci sfijdcd despE dinc c{dns; si
lc.pre drpu05mjtcJe dq.-Rte lpu\ p:nj tu sunrdcaiuns
D.sprtpcz1 dbtris.ohqtre

COMENTARIU

3.,,Desprcpoczic In si0e (,Epin rnril< ai'ri<).


b.l si XXV 1460b t5,{m]lrf! mac'
Cain Fsrjcllv 1.183
lnreresul
dc
nu
do,,mesb g P{,cric. c6a .et fropunc
'pezic ,
rFd'r!efrcbzc,inpinrdre,An{oblc]gl!Its$!B-p&
rn: iiLlJn.imiL ) .noi

relG6;;Fb,p*,ri.r..

3. ,,Fclurile depmrc dc cds intclcecsi vorbcasc!

r.nlsuntrntuh DrinLlunlcl.l-14.cDoDeer-dasedir..,n.

d !.,1ilrrnhui!rd,usrrs
8. ,,Pllerea de indunre

ma .p;nffi6@rredl gr

h popnu . wsa[4!qc ,i-ctuc n l\{I]pn!rr


'Nmd,
q4!!r!i4!!!el!! iIImr rczun{!q!lllll!q!a!!ry=P
d.slaurca oroon, he.1ru' een Ll. Dorzic. otL(ia !6o,r

cr r",-?,-^;p.;1s,.m,i den;ffi-Dn!

ar\ rlsrb

23;XXV 1460b 24i x)(_vl 1462r I l, 1462b 13-14.


9 M!00<.rrtlu! ai mn,.mdcri
I'o.!../ icc.piirni lclunb. duifi;G-iminuin' de Vrhei,
Bcj4tge zu Anlaktes P.etik, w.236-219 Cu nuantelcsrltarc

in nrginca liecllF lnrebuinr&i,inrclcsullri Scncrllc ,.snbletJ.


cjqjuf :&okri$a dc r$rc dcituid nF? liec&ci ctlii

D M PTPPIDI

LA PoETICAI 1147a
CoMEI.]TARIU

r0.,cr1c sr cc ret de p it rri-. E L e n n rc t c c d ira riv c j


clnr rlve prQiri riccifti vdiertli depoczicrr canl spL.ixtil
rag.tu ,. piDele sudr!trJizdc in capvt (145t)r $ si urn.),
cclelalre
rnclp. xx ( 1,152
b 1,1!i um.).
1,1.,P
oczia
dirirrnhic
ii. L n o b a q is(c e . d in riialu j
x
ricnriuncdarerlldinvcrcul
al vtI lo!SscimilncsblrArhiloh.
tr 77Dio\i cf acumsihiDarasarnscipticdnrlrNpublicdde
,E $B .p i< . t 9 5 2 . ! t . l:
9 5 (a lt cd o u t
ta8'eurc. mdvcchi,n' IGxll suppl pp tll-21,1).dincarc\e
inbregecrNutrLlsi
rlicompucinrulinleglD,irutnhJu.crca
inprbiaunorduridionNne,paDrhovrme,e i$r.ipoirc
epEtc dc parieDiin unnacoostrutui urui oiicol), drindmbrl Drto
d , fo{ u (lmpue( \1\\ara! (r rt rr, o s . l! ! { id . d x t rl
tr
lJ'lnJna.\airJ]ife ui.ir,tu (rftnri-"m-a
n-r,
r,r.
e-r
rxrdhLi4urui oror&r nis..ctrii hi o {nbtrniidc nrodot 123
lui Ariondn Merhyme,I clini aclvndc !k li dcJlisurat,
dupr
spD\rr.cru'N irroic,tn CoriDr.Arihuliac nriiriridcDinuna
rBxiconului
strdr.cnpunetu sumr tcgeDdrnutci]nrircrmci
luj trllrc- f rFJ-rdjj r pdro!
.rp<rfi)rde,,aii
.iirunpnnulcor,(4;ro< !d@y drijdut.
itr rnpjuiiri cm ntrm $d cujoscurcsi fu|)ra.irora nu pure'n
(Asuprai'r&rlrelini brrdri din srdr,casi
licc dcdu supozirii.
d lu' Anoo indeobnc,v. Maro udcArcinor,rc r/,3irj d.rz
Tr4./ir, pp.2taF226) Cr vftmq di" linc. cun luscse|lnEpur,
inEuiiM ceroda p.eii rvea sii 1ncadin diri.lmb u gonp. jtrnrLtr JEndn 5 u,!urtriinllos a u' Arndcr ..ir i{! (pobl
\r x 15 0r3b 13rA \rJc einDrn J , n ! e r. ! rt v -t i, n a c : J a
cxpl'ci ftpkrclc mcnlitrni al clor obi(l 3 in P@r,.a,ilir0d dc
krg.die n dc.or$Jic o ccrcctareannnmfri a lru8tudclor dc
d'ntumbi aFnse prni la roi si o inccree do rcconsnunc { cvo,
ltrti.i gcnului.lr A.w. PlckirdCmhtidCe,Dithynnb, n gcty
xnlt Caoedy, pp. 5 n1 er. \i DitinnttuEnr| Ittun'ontal,e c
/ram,rr
A cur! di crtrlo Dcl chrdc. NaDori.Ld.
l.1.iicea mri mare pr.c d in n c s ie t r! u t
c in
r {r uroi cu frru[]
ri cn . irh rra . . . c t rn rs z n lrld in

ttocizrriLeriindurilor23 24.c vorbade muzicl nstun nrali


Drri. ii nu, cun s r puts crdc, dc obiisnnitulacompdFmenl ar
ve$Dnror.Jnioc.Cf. A. Fr.nkim, Minclj: ti,)t2icx. 1912
p. :13Ji urm., r dcsprccirl[ra m.nlionru ln chlp (pctrt h text.
Thtj.doE Rcinach. l-, lrnrru d,ns I an lrea .'Rcv dcr Er.
guqucs . vlll, 1395,pp 3rl l?3. :i Crrlo Del Crandc,

t,

r,'odo*.p '15
*-,
"-ru,in
"q"
t
x
-r,(rti@r-.,
varorrc"
rrc>i'Ariioter.
du
"- " r"-L_'; -"" "te

l+#;:Hlx;i**"..,':#**lL*#s-r
plaronici. rm lvur p cj ti $iJui tD lrtdte4
| l6 (o inrcF
3d
Jto,".
.,clrs.
prcraE dcosehitlt| I Tarc. Prro
,.t
w
I
verdcnius
p.
urm
cf
si
1923,
16l
xxll.
i
Qurncrly".
Mjnesh Phta s lactntE al rtstj. innab" xnd ht: ierntns la
us.Leidcn.1949):asuFa..inihtisi" la Arisioiel,in rixa,lt r
lulr&i cihte ocazioml in Jnrtul!..lt !r in a)nert .tu. vczi
,rn_rLr sa',r,/. ,4tsrotlc. in ,Studi
urbdu Gtli, ra n'.d
IElia di FiloLoglrclrssic. .N s, lV, 1926.pD 237 313 fi
A. Frcnlirtr..p..n.. rp 19 22,$0pra'innatc in sandirea
t dc'
cnciici r c.l.rlechi hdobsc. H KollBr,Die nt
'esr
u.].,
Rem,
1954.
t
e
u
a
D
Aatilit. N' ch,hn;n !, D t 6
E..{rsd,
Comp alir pNr.i cu anelc
l3.,.Culori si loinc
plaeicc...ntopte suhsennul ,jnilarici . cm vr rcvcn 'resn'
in p.gitrilcP.erto;, c $rtonici h Pl!r.D(RdP,lI173 bix 603
b) !i vr rinine nclitsill la rcorclicicnii I o{erion ai hmosulli,
J0laA,tlui Houriu(uillr,rapds^: v 16l)pitrhtuor.o,
ul hi L.$ins. lntcrssdi inuc rodo, subacei ftDon. e o rnltra
cribuiti de lltrhlh lDi Simonidc ii .eptudusl ltr D. sJo'r
:Lrovi611 dv riv luvpd{'iav noiN',
/i,re'rcnr.,3:
'riiY 6i roiIoLY ('!Yp(tl'rY

D M. PIPPIDI

LA POETICAI ]417 J
COA4ENTARIU

un oL rporcK N[nrt( 6raoipouol,ri[o< 6 d!4,or;por<


!' rrD i! ! {.s'ngorLles,t!ms!e_.
rElrrd !] :A?(our! :L.
|].ca]' ludlriba
. ..rpnicirium.
,rrr...;ndj
xd:, lb'tui unz LrearD cJe"nrqm
mtc;Ji;r.;,;.
lalul imirqid,darclut rmindumncr.ctrsi,)
I9.'cu mestctus inviis r o ri n u mri d jt r rt e
p0ndere'.. i4!{r5!s (rir!r) e capllirar$
dc a robdndi
nii!meI pom{,n,u J .&ur l! sjtutu.ru 4la
i!!rDrl{Bx4:
h r! o.esc Ll.prrdc,ej (ourrs o)
dlrrcai ndt,?Lc! ,rurotuLunormiilutre
!:q4_,!kr dc d J
'nEe

,i5,r:{dt

rtr4!L ror-v!n!4

ob1!i!ljrcjr,rrl1!l!]r

rre,rei6id;-a-r,.r

JrT!4Pr?!I!.;

,.:h",""i1,#*;.:;*:i#"?,::*s:t#*il+s
#ffiiiffifr.Y$r###m'1
,inrrp.(& E, ,t
o4,r

.,,r,,.",.";,

i'i!*I.[:,r,
*tm*R**ftr;

,., ,"",",j

r..cn uurnal! ur--,"


! ce r mr: u u n , .E f ! J a t r. 2
'J!'!

nal

rdlL! &i dplovid(rf.platon.Rq,.,Ilr tgs a,

u:i". i"
";
iubrui) h inreterut
mcrlu rt rcmnnutu,.
r rn!]
d, i;
d! ri, d r!i atrh\o.i.
o $(c,,,,,.l",.fiffiida,,,";,"
-tr
r\r,d! ratl4 udopu , r..aQuh0t, rx i.a6 rhiifin,: .r
cs nuncri.rFtu ierponm $nsm1,
unu
o *"celuned.sitabetunsisi(une,dc
rinpi"u
lo.resi"u,;i"
de no drhi
Arrp rnQ ne(ei i,dd?o qn"btrre.., d.d,.. u,;i r,"i
\ \ p r cn :l i rn i ri l d r! {tb cg e fn r,.qucl
ecm edoLl.r dr nIer ,
onc.!hr Jppt,." ud mur n,cn! L_Let
lumo,l:

rr Jh,
pr i, rtmefu.u,iiort
, tu t, **;,-,
r m i i rc' r0 h tsd ti l crr^" rp ot "-_
Cr !Bilir ni r dfe!."
4 t u r l rtr.t, l 4 0 rm.l L rttrdu

Phro eEO o simplr{Irc$iumde nor,cu are.uvinlc.ecace


rtrnnin NiTi DeloJte i.Annonict..in imctesutnoden
al

ourdovio sru
rsrmemlu'.i :c spunca.dwl
'_niprqurin,
Cl A. Creac! rnir. d,lr l'rr.
d,tul'ovid (Aridot.,Pmbl..v\I\ 17.
!i..qder .l I( P,as ,19]r ) ,p.27,n.3) .C uF r i w el ac r tac i ar ea
alarolc,dupiAr$or.l,e dccon$lrarincil
'nMUidc.,,ihira
27-28...1n"t, ! Jrr! r! r!. DrLi

p " d "-a^,.nl ri n;A *d--,,,"d"-r-r..i *-o"."


(cr M.Emnucl,
cllruiprctuir,lasui. parcsi Ii tusrdmsebiri
ta tdnsc ert.que. Pais, 1395;K La(c, Dc vlr.rjonrbls
cn ctun c.pitt gur4uc, cic$cn, l9l3; Wamcskca.u.
Tlrzllrt, n, RE,lv A,2233-224?)ti r cilni bndioii dnDabcnimcricii c in q etrrc randuns$tinidi derutoii, dela Pl&r
(rc!.,11655d:r([rjtsaro
nli rd r.!i rd< xopiaa
'p;rdv
3,tLiv1!v)
iv apd{roL rdi rnxd< Kai ijo{. sL[lirtooL
pinillal.uiu,rcslar,6? rd i; i:l\oviih.di r;0[ 6.i+L]
inal)iu.ra (.indFbnc,d9!5ul
oi irorpivoso' i d-prrt',<
ie,_e.rrrR !l,4tuni ) Iri"
i,tu e:blisrqq! il!tl5lrf
&!{Lla* r!!3 .: sedspr irr si \l Jiung!b n,a rtrl.N' r.!
in cpNr intcriali. lrionimr (L. Robcn, P,doot,er j,
Oncrr..Hcns , LxV. 1t30, pp. 106-122,dc
fli.Ix.tdn
cu v. Rololo., P,rr)Dt,o srudte iesrt,Falcm.,
con,plcrar
195?),al.!iepdodu inbu pancMeio- trcccunoscutd'n
aluzii dzii. CL Arhen , ,Deip,oropl . I 22 r; Snet., CalA.. 57.4:
,,I)rnrommusM.esbr tagocnim salhunqlam olin Ncopkncds
Philippnso.sisuses!.
trgocdusludit.quibN rcx Macedonum
(,.pmroninul
r
inrclprcrat
trsedir, pc ca* o
Mnc{cr
egeul
juclsecenNaacto Ncoplolcmoslaj@urilttuousulcftona
fo$asasi lFilip,agelemactdorenild )si,ingcndal,asut'3
,c.{ui gcndc spdrcole h Roma,L Fr:cdl@Dder,Dnre/u,!.,
als .ld SjtterCesctithtc Rms in dat Zan va AryNDs bls 2ur1
Aus9anstcx altonjhc,Trn\te aun h.s von O. Wissowa,II
Muuscril.lc
ldcQ c subJrleLersl
28.,,Arta carc.
podi: i t irorrcLid,ceeaenuparclido.atoeloslsilngscc

COMENIARIU LA POE?iCAI ]4,?/ 1,


sfreoraliin tuxrDupiipildaInrucb.Neg.cd Drainrutrjednoi
6bn ovaNd trdrio. cde riptcecdih veniuncl
Wni
29 i,crrinrc sjmplc ([d]or< +L\oi<).E vorbrdo
nroz: i up rilir.u fu!.: d.ftrb dc corln\ cr,,vitrbtrc
t o 'r' !-a po, ( /lr /
d
, B$rm t9l5),|.r )qo, cf ptiin 6!4:,r\,
-yf\.rn&ret
Koi liy iuord/ rai r; rarp.,, i ro rr il rdlor yiy,w ,
y]_.dcn 3jn@l{)ozio ,nqlodia,rnnul si
fd
mtuln
^{nd[.vo
css rl!]!rlr!
sdMLurillqtel
nuodr ar'!!u!0.

D!mr f .i.iJ/uyu!o.
r!yro4L
e o !niicdud I jr R$4i]5, !oir rmdi Lrc

tadue(r abi si lnaniD adopktndccdnorj.car pnvcsenbca


!c c@ o e\primi. lipsr nDcidctrunii cdhlnc dcoDobivii
prc.rucliitor
liteiarein ptuzirj io veru.i, cudenrnobs;t.j
,in!rr: r'mhr Acmaidp!.edj un ?\etuie:
kmcn ii ctr!trnbrt

l 0 Mi m I u n r so rrn u- r tr \\ ir r hus

s{ xbn

\ r:9u:l!t.d!(!!!:!lrrj:!r
t'r daJnnito. reacEi
r iaru,
rri
ja!4.trdod,
su'Jeoboud,r,,ra"r.,,"
n;-d;;;b

;.,*'*"i1H;;-;"#tli#1fi
#Hl jii:1,
liou suntedbtr Lr!celrst(4b.t canrrc ncrte,orurtnr

m,r4. vor.I (Bcdro.


t 39r),compton
a" oc-i"mnt . s,,"r"
nc'tuh coaich,:iiak \|.1912c)
.uol
r";
",titi",n,
Ae$5ll'Jm Olivier, I ,/l' ,,a.,.r dcllx
"_",e"t t
camedi, "!nc|
n in a n!tzs).ttkc

tuta Mtpt o . " . , , r" p , r, .

i, r: r 1 . r. ,

r!!ir LXl,t9li.pp :l-t2.vft


inlrrenutpubh.ar\leMcJcd
No Ar\iCttuJno \ret i,.srd, t b h d n L t F
l t o t o s , rCia s t rJ
x, 1933.D.ltQ).Probtencbpu*,t"
a-.,ra.,
"po;ti,.ia"
ecnnltri,niraponuibrricu comedii,su{
rdare dc F Bcnini_

srudisDrDDo, Pisa,1915jcl MclinaPinroCobnbo,rrtDo dr


Soroe e dl Sdn@..o,
Fircnzc,193,1.
l l . . . l r i a l o g ' i s o c . a c i " . S f t j c i i d l { l . g 4 c ,d e l . l D l
hi.edn.s.uicl.f olrto alc lui Plaion.i rld ahordii.ipoli ri
DnpinncitaiptnmrdeDiogencLcnios
.,lil07.ttrltridcsc!l|:.
(pod'cdindiai.gu!
gcrll
n!pi n.Ll]',;y),fi jud.c,Esrasirftu!ui
n'E
prczr
se i snuatld cal jumti"
nrodudiilepftrice si
obisnuiti:6rloin AAororilr< rrjv ,,iv xo'ya! i6?dvarrroii
noujlqro( .iyaL xai r<o0 rdrou(ll124,3?).Null.i
iia-(tu1i
omcdc mnic va ti pomnit dd ac
pin cxeleDtl. dtu]qii Itain.aplui a cl1fli inta$igcntl izgonM
.,inil4it dio Cctmcadcsrriirsiti.lntentrn rsciprr,in dice
cu, elnvechj. c!'n sepoarededuccditrr'o 3ilzic r lui ALhenais.
Il505D:-orrrpovtrFdl\Iuv lai rirv NArr*ijy noirovGcil.
Plrbn),'nrd. 6i roi< &aldlDu< rr[rr(i]< ypd!id<,;y ri<
l6id< orj6 o'ird<.tp.ri< oflr (,,izgodnddin$atulidcalpc
Honcr si rrErgr pczie inirativi, Plabn r !t:ns c1iNil dhros'
dc caddd imilati!, firi r trvermacarmerirurde a I fo* nrscocilnl.himiicouid,tu'cnomon . 1962,p.rtr:,,on lhc purly
polcnlodl lcvcl thc P.cljd tdns on ro bc a vcry clcvr piccc ol
work iDdced Ansode\ nost dn.c. rh $ ar Plato is bk wrty
sugge$ion that Sor.tic dia[su.s {e much ttrl} peric thm
nomimetc vese, srch a5thar.f Eq cdoslcs.EvcnhorcArniodc
doesnot mcnlionPhio bt nmc, bul obviouJt aoonndox men
b,-r ol thc Acadcmy could nor have helped bur rcad this, md
inded rrs etrtir e$.y, as a tclli4 xnd poinrcdchaltcn8eto itc
ftasrclslamousrejeciionof
poet.y DeseDeni,K.Gdd,ln
,.Hemel.XCII, 1964.pp.125-123.
15 . . , N ut c n r r u i d i r { l i a p c c a r c o s i i v e r i c s c '
G'lx da erd rirr tst[ro,y noLrrd<).Pocranindintrhimei
eser![ riIro,< (144?a 15: 14516 23-30).:in!r a.cla so rr
t0vrudnioi dc numclc dc pocl cdo sivar$ic cu rdcviidi o
nnnalc. Irditcrcnr daciiin vc$!n {ca Ha,remo4 aci poncnn) or

D.M PIPPIDI
in ptuzi.
solron i xcnarhos. ReviE a splF cil aievrlrara
tru-i lc!4lr dc v.rs. cun avcas o dNcdu$r htil *nlri!ilnr.
une.iodi alitcrturii ri olhnlvdti. peni a$izi,tcomlicicn,cu
vrT.iairtrbiectulu'.,L.spr6riotrcrru5!s!.! noi alrincnrc si
. ta fstr!4!tsr.!:! Icnjolo, il
pocttucdd lilosolare Os alta dtrrinzionc.1otrdxdsdlr
distitrzlonelisic.deisudi
dicolariedellelorcrffjecolloczrnr.
cdelle loio ssquellcdi nhi c mctri.nonmerae non Dni'mri
Denarcad:ro; dsulbto,;ii d'i;na
ome Fr osni J'n delc
lomc di cspressnrechev6ni.no F$m,lo in dtmin!: tc qtrdi
tano i nedesidi suodi,lc
mc{icsiDelomc /i collocazioni
c di scquelc,o solo labili ed
j e cn.a h dificrc
illu*triodiff.rctrze
e dellrpmsr{icalrquc{lotrcii pop.sirosi pubdift chcsirru'h
bcll 'c temir ah sin {tr qnrDdoArirblclo nead.liral i0sD$kr.ize .
o$odandochc vi $no tilosoliein dxcoro lcgai.. mcriro c
poesici tr dis. o*o scnntui nc d $aropo$ibile, nci tDpi nodcrni,
npiSlrdr mi conqnrlchclchniL di ritovmenti (B.Crc.e.r,
l3.E npcdoclc di. A c r r g e n t (in s jc ilia ). rin o rr' n
vcaculal v-lea.rutor.l unl|ipocm{iinrili..noi 4,ndb<,flal
axuirmi$io,ft8dpB.i FncmenrclclaDicls,Fzsr.d.yo,ft.,
Ir,pp.l03 r'71 Cf si ErorcBign.ne,EDpedr./c,Toino, 1916.
l9 ,,Naturalist, (Qu,Lo[d-y.y|rarror i r4r'ri/).
Pi r ercimpini,niisideP laron(T , lc , c r, 1 5 2 c )s id c P t u t rrh .
Dcad,lpct^,16c rd t Ern.60rl\ioG inl rdi nop[.yi6.!
(oi oDraKd NLrdr6ro! oi lyuroro-yidr o.dlyr6d< r;rdr
( tdL .(x!rFivor ro!d no,rrrn <
rd I a rp o y K n i rd y
iyrev, lla rd n<iv 6ndilou/(,.vcsunbluiEmpcdoclc)i
Parmenide.
oi poemullui Niclnd()\dcspr Iirc,ori inviriftunlc
h'i Theogris.sunr
coD,Dunericc
n !u din l.c7ic..dccir metd
sicnfurn,cu ajulon drmn sesirescsi erit6 plalnudiic!.).
Cl hct..lrsr dn, , IL 123:
'Empc
inrerp@rrsn inrerpbirosophd ncrcs,qdn dc rcrummruk
ucn'bus soripsi" (iEnpcdmlc, p cri nu rtii de r.bnie si-l

COMENT RLU LA POEIICA I 1117b-ll


nuderi piDre pocb on printc fibhti.

l14R )

demEce r scis tlcspre

Pettrsic dinvc..ul rllv lea Putinclc


2l.Hrircnor
sin d6lrc cl sunrrdnMiedcDicteiich. tn RE.Ill202s (ct acum
si L. Cmpo, l drann; r.rirslri delk c.d.ri, p. 35). Cabv,
Grt{dnn
tragmerte rre Ccrfrrrut!1, itr Na(k. Tngi6.ht
.ii
Fnenentl,w 13A-1a5.
_,.
26.,.roczi! non,Iof ,.N.ntuyu\c u}jt411.!sLc-:l1l

(n ti Jc rdrlnult!.
9rl!bqEf:-c:4-d$r!3le m r r r ecm{r
\
e
.
t
r
r
(D{onnr im.rnoc
m
,
i
c
t
r
r
!
L
\
.
d
\
n
t . n ru
flaut sru chihi. C{ddcnl lui eLisos cxplic, Dufrcrortclc rcguli
5j prcsciptii al ctuorlbicd erx.5i aesica ntrmclcDt crrci podr:
v u ro (i n e a n . a i ' u . a J d r . . . l e c e . d a h n r . P c n u r n t ' u n k
tnt'n"
ansht
cf ctrr. Dc cnnd.N,Do\;Fd';i
'tt.
t1.1936,pp.l19
l4n
dctk Lqtdit edali rqei,N^t

II
1.,.lmirt

oaneni

(rL[0iivrdr ol
in a{iunc
A,lun! Llinqele rcidiltrn'e inh

: h ' n u n r c' m r i r ' c' r 1 4 1 7 :r r ) t;;m tr i n r .";;.;r - m b r o


RcP.
poerie'pd$iajc l' 4tium_ (in-!r!&{g!4jq!l4o!.
x 603 c, penh oarcdtlle imtativc indcobee n'au drl mnrc:
npdrro/rd< d:vo0dro!<sri<ird' ir rqrtnF0,Msbel,tumi
rtr,.!h ilorfr: !rollenr.

b"i.;

";i;Gffi.ar"ri,r

m;h,

k rr u n e i { r u i c r m r r c i c d u r L r ! s r \ l r 5 e \ c ( t a 5 0 b 3 4 )
d.-L
tu;;tu
snRr\t;o;n"
MqfilnlrE'r
'p'.
"d
-*
curand
dcci
sFc
lumca liDnfficl a crdonlu,, sprellpt na1
cimtid (iftuc&,.ii ldicica si .ctcriciro0 decnrsdin lilpb_,.nin
in cap.VI 1,150a 17 I 3), sptuncp.r$nali7are mri cdind dc..Ar
spre.exprimdeain numcpropriu (laa,0a6).caumto,Lipsa

1143a

D.M. PIPPIDI

COMENTARruTA POET:ICAII I,1'8 J

dnDlatrulLudlriiaurcidspinni spoalinchinftepmTicillri.c
n a.e de ce si ne \urlnind; (Th. comprz, td pc,s.,^- Jc la
Ga..,trd ReFFn4vol.m.hnsinnc'P.tris,r9r0,pp..r42
r46i
Ronagni,LP.eit t,ru LXXV-LXXIX).Ed&dcpnsos\lnc
itrchipuin ci ltrnl ci :tr fi fon ln pdea pidd$i { lu&lrii. cnm e
dc pn$s si presnpunemci llpsa s ff fj d{uind .dicicnrlui ,.dc
idrilrarc
al tdrrului. conceputcr o @rcebr a gcnuilor cclor
d.i gn$dc in vcacul,l lv rea(RLgrrnii, !, ttrrn: Ji Arirorc/c.
p. t42). Asupripurincilniciriitiapoe/ieigreetri indeobne,in
opoziJie
cu poczialaliniin.u cermodcmi,cr R.{.8d, P@!r
.(icsrcrLrdrrricr..Riv diFnolosir",N.S.v, I923,pp.1-23ti
ceDiageca e eetio ttuna rclt pms;?,rlrd,vll. 1929,p.305
!rm. (mbcre iclplrirc ir volunul cksnci.i c spinb n tJ.no.

7 l : r i o n y s i o s d i n C o l o l o n , c o r t e h p o r x nc u
Polysnotos Despr e1scnc Plinid cc1BItiitr, N,1. H;sr. XXIV
ll3:,.Di.nyens oiliil aliud qra'n bominespinit. ob id
amhoDqrapho\cosNnird0l (,.D.tr+ plcrdalrcva duoe!dmni. din cm priciDt. $ lon po*cln zu!tuvtrldc-(hcni ).
l l. Clc oIon, scnitorarbiDtcrin
dalnidc.p )aXI 1,153!20.penhstilulslucomun.Doileurul
srelasicuomonimul ponenitdebxiconulSudrprinhpctii
iragici.c aNv.ic dc spur Oricun.truner rinat delr el !ici un

2,,virrnos, ol pIcn! o ri" (! ro ! 6 q io u .i] o a n ro u . ).


cf. clr.!., 3, r0 b 3 si inre$ftira rui s.H. Butchcr,irisrorl.:
Thcoty 01Prety tnd FiDean,p 22a ti ltn.
5loiyE noros din T h r so \ , p
dnor in .nnpul rlzboaiclor ncdicc. Ponenit de A$bbr tDcrp.
vr 1450a27!c&'crlirlliluhind.,pidordocmclcrc_(dlo0ij<
r r 001,pd{.<)tiltrP or.V lll( V )5 , l3 -t rr3 7 p 3 n h lru Du s t c r
modererd&i !L1rl,;flaJourc< B(oFir roij< yious, arld r,;
noru./vdrou ni i rLl ;lxo4
YF4io/ il rLiiy
'nr
,llarlLar.r0r'iy tol,r i0'r,j<(.,truolcrlclui
PausoDtcbuicsi
sc &prindl a le pnvt tineiii,ci p. ale lui PolygnoG, sauale
oricirui ru picto. sru scurlJ'orncnc' in todau cdrcrscroD.
AsuFr opmi lui. ni seneral.cf. C. Mauns,,cs .lc1*r,1.uvE de
tapen'tueertcquc,PLti\,1939,rtp.
l2 -,11
!i 47,uodc$ incc{cit
o*plicxd.rbmennlujl'0'|o,<
6.Fxuson din E r.s.m liid rd c d lrO c c c lc n ru l. a lrs a r
ni trmi-i n,ima trnd ncindunt zuslv rl realnllii, iD aspecEle-i
cel. nii purin c&cuntice (cr. cihrul din Porr.r. rq rcdur n'

12.Hcgcnor 'r'hasiatrrl si a pchcdl virh 1aAlcna,itr


rdourjum{lllea*c al v lea(Aihen..lx 406!n ri xv 692:
cf. a. Kiidc in RE, vll, 2595-2596!l L. Rober,REC.XLLY,
1936,p. 254).Ctrm inlormtiilc nortc trolni dci o indoiili ci
auiori tu genulburlsscau exisirt de
AriMotcl nui pur ign.rq pctrin r cxflica iidul do ,,trlscmnoa'
p. cdc i-1 atibuic rciul rftbuic si ptosupuncmci vd li los ccl

13 .,Nicoharcs. aurornl Deiliadei . indoielnic,


dri mtrl si rcclad auro l dc concdiiNi.ohrcs,lcciod lui
FiloD6, cotuD0.rm cu Aristofr (Ktk, cmicnm At icm
&agDcdd L p.770 nnn). iudccenddlti mtu$ opcei tc @ i'o
atibuicAi$drcl,naiEdbabilcvo$adcalt.incvr. A{rd<
('C4$dea l'icotilof . sru ,ia cva) e leciiutrer nanusciisului
Pdisinus l74l, prcLdbiu, pentfl intentia prodistict pc cdc o
(,,Poem
6cunde.vrrrdei
^rrLd.
Dclioj )olcnddccclcllltmnusqisc.
CsElveto E vorbr un poerconh mponn cu Aris rotel, aulor
'le
d. ,ont dc Forfi .ilidt, cu coi p0lin i'tcrcs.nli: roLrrir
Nxorp,ijy rd[oy,ouni 3cspuncinr uDlftgncnr d lui Finias
din Eresos(FrasD. ,eisror. cft...,
II 2ee Muellet, in acen

ar'

I
D.M PIPI]DI
15.T,morh.os din M i e r p a res l I i t iii in k c rn L i
450-:l6lJ,_.n Auror dB nomi si dc dilnrnbi. conpozittr \i
indriznri,fiima 1ui pnntF
rlomdor huziorl di', cci
'nri
conreDrporrncramm(.LAni,Md,P,r'.I l0,9q1b15,.i liv
ldp 'f,s;6o< [i triv.ro. roMiv
ixor.v) si. judec!trddup, lngncnrclc .juisc piDi r, troi,
indreptilrti. Pre&x inkc rodc c lurgul ftagnenr din nomd,DL^_jt
dc{oD6ir ltr 1902int !n momint din AbNn,pe!tr papr din
lxiprig,
vrmoclctrieici (cdnd dcwila'no*itz lvloellendorff,
tt)01= Dicttt, ADthol.Lttitt Gtr.u. II l) Asupn lu' 1'mothos.
in gcrcial.rehnglrrudn lui w amovitz,cxrcl'ecdccdiliaci
tali.semaip.rrcvcncaPicklrd
Cmbridgc,.p lrrd.,Dp.6ft3:
asupru,.rvoluriei murcalc sivirsitc dc el, CanoDel Grandc,
li?Esriorc ,i!ri.,L lotpr, !D.i pp. 9199i a*'pE emeth
mrxi t.gnctrrclor,rcrrsi3trtr, Pesja emcti.x ncllnGteir
rrtta, Nxpoli, 1937.pp 53 n3. Trchuicdc rscnen' rcrinutii
informaliaadusi deo nrscnphc.noifict publicdildc cndnd
(O.Bronccf,,.Hcap.it.l95r,pf.l92 L9sl,dupllcxt ii.llin
scc ll c n buciri din olcrlc lui Tinotheos h.crtr pdc dn
unoraiin' inin'ncntirri.cft lc citrrau0eomuzic,
repenorjDl
noui. corpusllpcfttr crum$anra, K La(c,in.Ennol, Lll,
1951,pp.125127;J 5iI-.Ro b . n , in , . Rc vd 6 & . s c q K r" ,
LX vll. l95r,nr.ltl! LxV lI, 1 9 5 5 . ir. 9 9 51i 9 6
15. Fil.xcnos d1n cy t h e rr (4 3 6 / 53 3 0 / 7 9 ). . o t r.
remp.rrns cmul LuiTimorhcosca sutor de nom' n dili
mnibo8$I.P!! clcinLlmtii dcspr cl.la Plck.rd.C0mbridge.
l3 ,.Nr7uind (RoLirrr, Ntr firr dcpr,rc. poarc,
cuv:inrului
r a$undeo
ctrdcnan(p 103)prc\uNncdl3legerea
nuinr indircctilrrdlcs tili.ilurin$naii do FDriPIde.pentru
cerasddiri..erarm,linnldaonorcrci..mai huni dcrilEr
litarcr.lnscnspohriic,*p.rrcx'li
ftci(N re.toncdi.no
).Lxre
*is[. i]icdr si a d. r mr urmituinnlex uior ps{rujc , mairlc

COMENIAXrulA POFrc,l lt talNa-|tt


J(nK ! llir>r{,{Ll. ! rc?ilee I,t
Ld
r^ ' . r r . r r c : g 9 r . o n u r i . i \ . , r .

1413)

rd4,Taoj.r.rc

J6ptocom!,lic in\lL!bn!, ,r.i nri LrepIr Apr id'.e e ll).

III
l 9 20.,D upr c hi pur c u,n te s l v ar tette i ni .
rrlia (rr<i{doro ronroy rqridcrro a'r
'().Desraa.csri
a reladeosebiE
in{eruirei'.irqiei (dq ! &elc
dcobicctsiJc
Diloacc),amavurpejd sr vorbesc
It Lro.tuer, p I6rm.
a proDusrdePlaton.Re?. nI
392a 394d, dr suhriDnnd
se,nniicara
n,riclpnDzitode!

trc]iniratiuDhqdodCtuccidamariconucl nnriic.n appellani.


in quop6or3cloqucdres
indoduc
ct .onoedi!.labohed prihaBu.olicon.
rur cmmtiuumquod
Gtuci cxcgcturi.onucl @.!gcui.onrppcrrani,
in qro poetaipse
loquitorsineulliuspefoMe inrdloutionc. ut e Mbcnrtcr libri
Ceo4icietprs Fim qudi, ncnLudd cMina, nurcomDu.e
trclni{tun, qtudGiccc roydyu.lurrdr di.irur,nquolEh
ipsclo'tunrcr pcison.cr0qDnrcs
mkoducunrur,
uresrscril)lr
I lia ! r O L l y s J H o m r d r r A . n . v c r g ' l ( r ' e r n , l { t r s ' i
oucbc \m'r.' d Jcli, \ru ,nna! \ . Dec1r sa.nTni-disa

_d,,ffiir"" ."" ,"*rr.."

*
r-, *.
".-.
"rrs-,
si conedi' sauir p.ina
bucolicn+I'i

vuhind, m il.ljrgedii
vse,h.( riDq,
u.on . n dffirb.sr omrulnncr.r:dn rofl,er\cu.u'drc
p*-,".. r
,i.ifr
,k 6.,;tre/tr! m |.' i.
r-.ri
" dr . p!ra. on in ptumrl lui Lrrhur @rromnl
j$nirrar. a celci

D,M P]PPIDI
\uci!.n!

nlcic

rdvLi, \duuu

.:h ' ::.hl


:ni,,l ui.r,,,*^ ."., - ,."'
-fi ;;a !A;;, hili--*."-Ecrdrr{ivureiriu
) (caD

ji gcerriasupnsnbiccrtrltr',la
l*,1 423Keil).AlErextelali0e
J.kyser, Dc ucrcfln dcpocrjui, pp. 10 l3
(i<
22.,P istrA ndu si prop rir in d iv id u a lir. . !
rdi
E
prndulunde
Arnrod
sc
a,i,dr
!i r.rd0dl\dvr')
'dr
dcoscbc( dc Plaon, h ehii cintri! singurc4clc vlricrili dc tc
zc,ooL'!r..rtrkle i.arornn u rru b r Dro o d \ rru rb L A (;

*' *"-,i."
uo"l- r,u
'it
"i'"
".i"ar
-^i.
-.
ii;tr;
d.; trn.n"i .-;, dnLru,i.;,,; r.',rn<.
"

rorro(cJ kL r o'rlroL.
y]ovui4 ri! (.idro!pocttrliu\rrrscundcn'c'dccnm,pmT'as
nararialu, 11, cu (o1ullipsircdcimn4lc") (R.f,IIl3el c cl
Pipp\ni, F.narcx ltLtat lirdar. in ,nr?ri.,r.. p. 5:l unn)
VtoLlric deseinMlat.de p rum, e ci Arisrorcl cl inv'i prc . su
cand
apropiadcpun(uldc vcdcrcreprezetrtrr
dePlaton,aiuncl
ytp
scicatriv
6.i riv roLrrirv il\dxLora\ir.v
0i ydp
?drl rorrj rdiird Nuri< (XXM46O r6 3) in ftJildc,
conradidiac trumdaDa@nrlccca cc sccxpnniir acendi.
a
urniircrr i .udcinniGtiaDxntivr(platricr 6'ri-yi)oG)n
fi tl er imiralic,c, vcchcaconvinlcE a Stlgnifutuidcspre
r'nndn* cpolEii .u taged'r (rn
.,nolrilcrpmziei)siprcdilccrirluih{.udsidpentrup@melede
cdlcrer DBunpinib drxnabc. Cl. laudelsadusc ld H omcr,in
continudr rilnduilofubia pNdusc, pcnttr Dcrttrl dc r nu vorb'
prer inultin rumc proprir Gr alti poeri...cetruhc deci! tl se
scoariii,i na'!ciLrlveru :oir.i lLiv 6, aroudlrvilovrdL),
ci.,dupiointoduccrcdccllrcva
v(rbc.pc&ri1ptrNi'rsccnrun
reNic.
ori
vrcun,llpdsooaj":'iriyd
bi1rbx.,o
4iF!'Laodrao.
ji l;IIo n
(Lxlv r4dl
Ltoijr .ioiir( nr6pa i }!'c;o
't"oo<
2li,,Dramc . lntuti.dupilcNspdroft veii dolr6!;,
(dc ii,nctri fus:i h nidoirli) c conploNi dc ,^nsor.l !tr

COMENTARIU LA POE]'/(A I,II ] ].'I T


I'rlonnxtrcl,i,rzilclclui.ctimololincrcirallidc..Joncni(rtrb
trccrdilvlel n\dica!ewilamowiL
rclcin(i la Cuna c di.ului cotrtenD.rmDieuchdasdin
I I l,ecandcicllCh.nc$)crodovldl.
Mcgrn: cuden,an,p.
obiniici r.arhc 5 tagcdici (u llas b I 2). lD .e pnrcic
cmrcrcndctrvirrului.o n g!lorsil
(.31'$ Revicw.v,lv,1900,p 333um.)!lovcdircifolorircx
hri I scnibii .rici nu i plearlspand
,_n
poezie.
Ongi.ealui doncitpo[c li dlr.onsidentlcaI rob$il]1.
scsasre
pmbrbihralec inririri dc nuhirul considd.bil de
ti
rflil!(irc
in Frlilc liLio rlc heedi'lor rjnNe pini la no.
d.risftc
dr,D 148-iisonx
,,Acudinely scncPic*ard-Cmbndgc.,)p
obc,rtleas.reasonrblyprobrblcrh.tsomcolthclcdttrcsorrhc
hneultgc
d Adc t'ecdy rc iplic
on rhevholc.shcnsc put thevri
Ilan clrnn b havein $m. scnsc,rilindcd t.g4y b..ones atr
cxiFmolylikclyhypaihcsn.
3l * M c C . r i e t r i i d i n 0 r r r . r l . c t r l u " D i n c l c c ' r
contjncnhu rrccizdcr slDje$c s[- i deoscL-i \ NI dc n'cs$i sr ii
din Sicilia Desp.e,_nsennlhcrrcoiciindicatiipcrhdrhrea
Arr'ci. .m D.Deri ii .Lmd,.er, p. l5.
3l 3 2 . . , P cv r o m c { c a r d l a e i e i a c i r m u L r e d e
.Dnpiaiungmad ndrLiThcdlcno\,sprcdifsittrl
nocratici
vcrului aLvII'I.a. Petuurnrnunb .c.c\at:1,lLianc E eL\reI:
Des anqinesxu\ lucncs nt11iqa6.Pans,1925,p.323 unn :
H. Bctrglsotr,Gde.r6.re carrri,tc ra d.n tuttnlch bisih dje
rdnncficiadn.zcn.MtNhcn.1950,ppl0r, I 10.
:rl Ep,hrrn Ptrdnclcmiinuriip'rriscrcfc'ibaicl!viala
actiliurca
lli E ihrnnrc$unci
i
r'! tr ). - f@le
lnsi|dGeron(485 -1711irn ) si Hierci (473-467
lu
An
ti maiiiaifu ,da.!annnara
itr ri pon dLHi.r idcsc inrcnr iari (vezi nolaurnllbr rcl Iltnpe
rlir prob$il ci o llnc r a(ivirll
rlyblrir. dc vrcnr cc tlLdiria al ciirui c..tr $ rtr.c rutod a,er.e,

rY

i
D M IIPIII)I
atibua
nenrl dor n nl(ocit conedirSilc v(nc
'ncsaierilor
G reslx ti I rveMicau $ pe urul din {i nr (Nlclra Hybla a
bn dishsi deGelonin 481ir.n ) o drolic animlirl r tr,$
reL.rpnvrbarcrr biognrirplErrltri.o o, iA r l emcnrclor$o
tictLrltocririci. rccrtri g1asnou,,
ecnli'comunsdenavih di lud1i Bion (cun seexprihilMclin.
PDrocolonbo.r! ct., p 7?).inopcndomainulreoric arir
luili.kardcambridse.pp 35r,1E AsnprupLclnfDlocouri
hcndirceE ifi-o scric irhaei dc lnsmcnb tuozoti.c xtihune
invrrrruiiDihg.nc,Rosragd,rEtba di Pii!!o.a.pp.1 a2;
E. Zcllcr - R. Mondolb. k /ilosonx dej Ge.t net su. sritupp.
sbrm.Prtcl,vol.n(F,mzc,lql$).pp.Il8-321.Defrcareva
rngncnrc r{cu dcsc.pn.c. crre intclcsc ctrnoeiDtclcnomtc
pnvirorrcraadivnrbapocrului,senz
phjtoloEi.xAditantanr.
33.H ion ilcs In $rm rr ro rit i b io E ra licpi e c a rcio
imhina.suda11]midcspn
fi ioiidcscrarri ietitnrvriSrbrrxrn
vinlc.in,133/3?
sau43?/36i ci.
34.M as nes figurcrTicrirrilgilror (pcih anul4]312
l.e tr.)iniisdiptialGll9TTkdar.t.observadileluiC.kaibcl,lr
Ad. wilhelm, urrundc, dfiDrrs.nr Aultnhtunecn jti Ather,
34.Jar cu k.eedir, trn ii d o . c
cudcman,pll3,mnccidesru\iH' rfi raroculeimi.lilndcll
inrcn,pcnsrsurf,.esc,rldeiro, obLectiaru0iisen,rc.onvin.
gitoue exe,npleledecoNoctii nanealc $rnl prcr numcoas in
Poct.! -Maigrc0 d. sptrsc la cc sc va fi lindir Arndcl.
ponrnindflclcnliilc JoricniLor
din Pcloponcz.
Poalcla radiria
(si.
pnn
crc fibu,a lui
unnm. mxnicnlot dmfta deI
^.on
ficompscoadiotiitasqlrl(sudrsv,
npior
ril.aL roi
r@ruoir 4.irou.nFrn<. cl.JornncsD,rcoNs,c.,,,err
tr,g..moscr.r...Rhc,n. Mus Lxnl, 19011,
| 150:1n4 6i

COMINIARIU Lt\ PUFIILA lll t413 r


Mrouryoid<iioilq1d,
ir i! !dr!/ iy rri. irrrpddoIi' ( F,]\].io,<r6i6"!e.
Mr prob$it. tr sptrsclc
cclorcBsus!ncrtrcri{ctrrr.I sik]or.
. r,t r I . u ) \ . L j o . u . , . . . . ! , . .
{ir.;r[a .L :r.riho, tri!)y ri! 'a6prfro! Qi iij nodq]o
io.a aLiro'irpalkoitr, {opoio'iripiqoy, rd! siy ALdyu'oy
oi, rqriyri<, riy 6i -a6!1dror ..sicyonieniicnxrcrDpcAdieos
l'r fcLsichip.cinrindu,sisurenDFbitrcoffihsc PcDionls.s
iul divcau, df ir srivcxnpo AdrNos (He.od. v 67.ct si
-r{ ri" ' n s u J ,
, nllscoctoirl trS.diclinpcsornalui Epicen.t.lca.eanidir
tr.nilkad'tie.sii\r\t,c.i3p.rcxrulluHerodorr6irrrmdu5.\c
ntumo'aziip.rczadul ii lrrc raeer r aftdes0d'sdinlocunrc
tu' b..tr,r e.,J'fl,.,
co. tr
dsFndnii in GEciaacnlruluiltriDioiysos,r caremtrilitriu
nnutsrtr
pctrkuinGjaoalr dc
willian Rldgcsry ( ?/'c o'lrn d Tfl glttt with spccirt Reteffirc
n, ofter Trl3ed.rr. crmbridlc.l9tl)). ii uLritujumilat ds
lcacrludlpcrodi.,currcufre
c no,de o nnrxgli sdic dc
itrvIt4il\{.P.N s.nj DerUJira,rgdcr Tnrsaid;.,
in,,N.0cJbb
r.kras Arc4un,,y\tvx, r9t t,lp 609-696=opus.ulrr./.cQ,
r,Lund.l95r,tD.6t 1,15
iCdo DeLC{ddu. Lk,no rlJ. o.rg,n'
./.Ir r?gc'tu , Nrpoli. 1t36, pJ) rr15 (!t.. dc accrrs:
TPA|nI IA Er!.,7, e 3er.J Jclft r"sedd. Nr ti,1962si.
,.t, h--rdne v.rn.,
,n,
fr h o,ri.., . ,,1il-p,
I
<
:
t
r
T,.t t-'
\',,,,.,,J,,J,
L . r^ -r r d '
4
E"..p
. v.r.8...
J.n.. /. o.., i,r.,..n.. 4.,...
lt . , . t . t ," , , t .
.h,J/'rr,
,"d
qr
,p
l
3 : ,'
I
p
i
l.
l:
i
.
{
,
'
n
i
u
\
k
.
r
I Li .1
nn-r'i,
r
;
d
:
n
F
i
.
r
r
'
.
r . . ! - e' .. r, '- ! r . d , l i J u . t rr
-na 6rii3!nic. ci d.a6o t. ptuhlimcLresonnoqd.nrtrr u,r
Etenlcnt haLta:.! ia^

n. . . ,. ., L, ,.,io4JDn.LUL.
.rluurr. ..Rcv d$ tLlgrecqucr..

C OM EN IAR IULA M LfIC q IV 1113h


LXVI. r95r,pp.3?7 395iH Jcrnn\dnc,
r6il , pD 5O?-510i
c F . E l sc,T '..'g i r.l T pAr or ^r A,..HDncs..,
LxXXv.
r957.tp. l? -.16i
R Canbdla,rDjonin di piloc i prcedenti
derdr,,nr34...o,'Acme".X,1957,pp 2l-26 (lsupnaccle
iasiprohremc..t.
si T.B L webncr,in editiar _, d ci ii lni
Picked crnbridec. Drny.,,'b, T.rgedyanltCnrcd!.A{o!t,
1962.pp.3
4),rDsm6n.HParzer.DieAnt
nsedetgtcchhchcn
?lrBddte,WHhadcn.1962
35.K 6 ! d r-ir.oncnoriu uilyprlcrG.lr,cxcDrlc
nufrebas aleinftbulrFrii cuviinluluiitr suroii arlcilacdovrd3
cr, cerputinin sccotul
al v-lcx,x!rIr on taAten!dccncuhlie
cEmr. d&r1dudr inblesutpc@ i-t aribuicarsbrct, ccl purin
cuaccrade,.catridpcriteric,Dahrh" (cr.arinora., t/rbd, 5).
37.,.Nude la roNt&Lv"litmotqiabunretolutja@sh
r.nd.iv 6pArVczi.mnsus,mkt.l.t43r2B

IV
5 .,A nerdoni c!uz c t ire s ri. Cn n s a rf la r in
I'balucelc, p. 36 un.. simptrcnmlrft a ,ce$ei.tuacGrnrici
icprcz il,dinparbrlui Arnrolct,oluaiedepoziricimponiva
dslndelor Dentucdc hrul pmric cra rje ud dd al cerutui,fic
umara uneicotr$itutii parolosic UDpasmi dcpanepe!.cddt
crrc va I frotin.ap.xvll (1.155
a 30 si urm.),utrdc
prcrunea
dtati poeljlorndu.i<,ni conparariccuceiaiorcrr0i.nu i
decatlm{rca losicr rptrrdului dc v.dere artsd dci Pcnh rN
arlcln! asupradesl$irilorcc si ru loculacolo.in do Fdea
inkrlcra rorusiotorlra in crc setituDoztAdeoEt li{r deplaron
pdn rimpta alimFf a ,.r,ili'4,i
facuuitii 0oedce. nrr
muruncsc str.ninresc riDdurjt. din Io, rtrdusei shcnrire
xnrororDiq rai r0,j< !dy1 . o , ro ic o io r4 iy c , i[ (i<

o,i'o, !1.iv 0i r.irrc


o l d iou ' o ! r . . . i 6 r i r v , d ' L . i t
\ilDv':r oii,o norroi nfLa, oi< rcoc rii ndo(d(!. dlr d
e.t< dLrrd.iorLv 6 rilo/, 6LnroLtro! 6i O0ilvaoL n|d<
ljraq. (5ra.n) I&tcca.rc{aoriarircarlcle(apoi',s.12
h{; l'lrrclr..2,l,1
a f i u .: Md,, 99 cili res., 719c) o8hnGsc
un.i
nadonllit]4,acxpcnciplP.cri.c rdidc ca.
u[vrgercr
lrcudiculrintt 3i lu An$okl, dlpr
Finshr. ntr liii od4rc condes.ndcnll ..dovdlr l"nFd. x
mlsuriiir calemi.bx rcccti pllunzitoarc rld Arnolcl crr
{rLni de zbodl sublirnal gcniuhi tlatoDic_(Prt, tr .1dt
rrird.rsci,e Pdd,'.,l;pzig. 1900,p 19l).+{rcmaio od..
rnaiii
imaE{siguddcstucaunnirdcvlrP.cacvidcDrD.ntu
Nblriat AsW psblenci.,iNpndici hPlaton.crsi.rlnDdirii
lui ldlll d. Foene.in scnc l, cl Ff Stihlin.Dic Srer,Dgd.T
Paesie
)n dt pht rkche, PhitMphjc, Mnmhen, 1901iW Ch6e
Gcnc,Pl2rDt Viet.fP@.rt, in.,HxNrd srudiesin Clls.
fhilolog),xxlx, 1913,pp.1-?5io coli4Pl.ro,.rlaPoistc,
Er. et.ques,xll, 1923,!D I 72r H G C ancr,
,.Rev.dcs
P/,io,'d dr. ti.]]l.r, Fnnklun r. M, 1934iW.J. Vcrdcn'ur,
z a lo ' d r& l o J s f , ' M n c m o s y N. X l l , 1 9 4 4 , p p . 1 1 31 5 0 r i d ,
Dct BcEtitl d{ Maniaii Pht ns PllrjdrJ,.,Arch f Ccs.h.der
P h ilo so p h i c . ) a l l V . 1 9 6 2 . l p . l l 2l 5 0 i J . D u c h o ' n i n , P h r o , c r
J'td,?!c & & po&.. REC,Lxvlll. 195i,pp L2 3?IP vicdrc,
tg.t)
PlatoDcnittue tt&.n4Pfir,
5. , , D a r u l i m i t r t , c i ( r i I L [ . i o B a 0 F ] i d n l ' l o i a E , c . r
r'n@fcendc vorba
di ridin caucle anunhrc.NeduDrcrnilc
'le
pftcizrL cdc e ea dc-a doua Dc h vBtor $i RnEr Phn lr
Byw&rI RoMgni,tujoin crconodatoriloiidinisictrdi
ci r li,,plltocrcaF crre odru imirariilc (rd xa+{v aoi<
riivra.),pomen1alaslirsitul
Friordci Fclulloidcr
sLpJi[doL
vcdcani sepre insi cu rriir ddi Duh pl.uzibjlcDcl (cuma
adrro vahrcr, aeidg. zu r4rjsbr.rlr Ptr ,t p. LU)!e6d Prc
!ins! caui nu i dccir rstecrBlprsivrLcclcidnnai.hplcrd, cu
alricxceql,Ie caE ]o, avcaprileju

coMFNT,\Rlll LA POELIC4 Ml13

D.M ?IP!I1J]
dxrprclerhj rirdcarekrrccl(trevi{trdoua.au,iinr.,insnr
ruraln.rroisiatritmrlui , dninlni. ia&fl in fn\t$tc 20 21.
l.r l5 ..Lrc a.c.a so s i b (c u rj
" Dc s F ei. e n
rsPcd .oglrv d
rc$r. in rugr. nr
r,hrrE e.| 42 mn PrlinsulrarionrnjcN
drjbuirDrtviron,tui
sc r.gi\c{.in t?/,er,l. I l. l:l?t b
pri{riiirvelrsisirdni .ctu e s c . ra d e l. d c rc c lrs jt t s t irre
\clcpficuru,huni.{iick deaimni rc.iicv.rb.i.picrnrti.
de sculpruri.do poczLe,.i indc.hrc dc.ricc bu'a rnir{io. si
chrardr!ii obrdul nrnht ntrc Drincl lrrusi nti.n cid Dtitc,e;
.usin,mod.l,ciin'erccti Lcltrurxic(imiilic)nrfi
[scri]lcurrre
(rcnr,depcurm.tiR.i,,ft ftecrcdarinrvtil.:rn.evr.,
(ir.i 6i
rd s(y8;'ny E i6; &i r; oa!d(ay
rri r; aoLd6r
ro r. rq q f u d r, ; d n +
r! . + ! rrj
irL dyiroyr!n.rid
uri roL lf rri, L , i n d ? t ; !
.i
i8J oiri r; pqrrr[;y!r
oi !;r
ini orrr) !uir.,, dlu or [ ! 7 ! rr.
ro , L y d , r r0 ] ro
r ftn,o,;0! roy0!k0 rL ou a lr0 iy a )
2lE l ..Drrrl rrm.tric i s i rl rirDin o i" rD.
ponrD!! rc.nu' d3r. kr 3rr dc lnesc ca rccr Ll rmiu!iei.
ruses.*mnnllr inrnft dc A,nd.ld.t hbn (14.,65t d.66.1
e. 3r6 r Cf. S rihli'r_op .r. Dp . ll! |li wilt rjn o wo
Mocr.rdorfl.Pftbn.Ir.Bdin.lezo.p.r0N) i,run,ti,rv
si
IicsubliiitrrildeA
^'n.nrlq,dpinrlntrdnlLuFilodrnr:OJo(L
r0i< driturokj ttrqLirao
raodne tr4q!ic8
iloruij
rou. rry FF4'iy i, i rji< ui6ijq rrr dts,rrnrou
roro{i,Fhso,.(rcNeo.arr.lsib:
ih.1.]jc cedk1tu.,
Fn 4
ak , R$jn, r92:t. p l5|) Fugm hc.tiuru dc crE sc
niv,rr,ri.cvcitr t.rLru trtl{t.sti m nNclsrsn]'i frDrduicti.nr
o!lriishgnituhi,a.ersrLoi I douilrrici,r:i
g.!cdore r pmzj.j
rr {cn se's.swtrdx. r_crtcrqrcl1,s/c.p,19r
8r rchsj.D
t6 rrA h.! s L . rr. l) 6 9 i3 r! rx m p rr$
'nlsii0

nrs\{rri

Fre!rciii{ril

l)

ilciruridindori .nrc(snpdcsi$ccuntrTeIdunr.na).drcx
ccpriav.isui,lo.dadico.itcxn,
indiviJu!1. !1. l.e

ri I o r ". lr evoluriapoczici. re nrrch r44! !ep!q!!!r!!rL.


rQt ll! tlI !lt!,jt!rl,r.
,iJErrtr i Lr!!fLLr!J!!l!!r

drilrlns rift
cede AJ(rot.l,d. nduknrnlirscdorilrr
iLrdi! urlu..dco{l,i"dujeinkcctupdDrlurft vupri" vnNc'
(cumri *a stnrn,cap u 1143alJ),acer{ipnmidisdminiru
uvcdsi rih; ca rerullt oiefrrtr ltilcrrii r ..firiiorernrsc
G rrrJ l a o L ) , d c o p d s , t 1 r , . I r i l o r d . i i D J G i r ( x i o r q d ) . d e
rlu. Chsincler opcrlor lirmrc dtrfii ..rlrurul ktr 6tc c c0Jcnr.1
ldPl{otr(t g,vil3i0c.3l7 4vlll 8r3.: 7itur.r.,l52e).Ideea
crarorsiopcr:.unroslindindn[urrnnidlx.eluilalr prcmull
maivc.h. oricunr,Ldc spaMiir,judc.iindduPlinflicllilh
nerdepralc
imbrit.trreLrAr{ofrn,ctL: nr \. stic5tesi dcr o
'
xpi l,ir ronijr dviF npi< rd 6rdltrtr
a 6.i noiv, nd< ioirrd roija rrdro!< ixnv
Arr'nq
ir noi 111 6pdrora.
6.i rlii/ rioro, rd rnl ir{l
rs o ! . i c r'rvorki
l,,Sccidc * Felul si ia rmint lx dnn.lc p! .d 1cprlircirc si
ri-\i p.lriveascipuninbdupleLeA{lil,drcli 0nulrricdstric
aLccinrl]eromjeMr]cnrci.fiida
Jin tuftirire acBnorr': Thesnnth. 149 152. Ct Actbt?,
.410113).Fnr! r cideain tccrd e
noNrt,S!rb. arexsi dcrid.ii cerc intcucrzi ocxprc!icl3d'
dccco!tu ct{I2,5):
dri,sonn .int urtrldinprimclccatltolc
.,\'IcnnrL
l)l{tultr' e'ndi\olubillcgn
nu , .u pdrn'!lrsi qDn-sirrt adcvllr{.drc, im'nlc troclr !''
ri rui
adcvliril (ir 6i ,oLIrDir (dFrri) ouriG!tra'
('
dv0!;n0,, rai !,1\ oiov r.
rpdrpv r.v10ivr. iiv6ta dlulidv)
26 . , s r h u r i d . d o j r d l l " 0 t r D ! q ) . v c ^ n i e r k i d c . r
norAnrjl,ti {i FliNotrxx.,hr

I
D M PIPPIDI
lcgi(trli cu rcci gcn. f.wclt
icior wcmerlaeed. mri
ntrldcca{cuoflcarliuldlnctlccunoxftpoeTirgra.i,nc,an
\imri F e iidicpr iri si curgen raocrfricrtic pir./o!,?r'.
coNnbriin,iurcr o exprescrcmrjr,,ciriia{biccrivmlnaniarca
Jtr! rir,{ cir,cprilcLr.d/)i{ f c rn r\ u ! u t rf . n rrrrf u ! t s p ]

noeuL\LroDlnr 0r.r rmiu . \i n\trr rn rq nid.rclhncJ\r


prileluirl dc slirhiioilc d,oDri..D, ii tr$ cuiind o cxprcsic
unin'niirbrne'dispoziliito p u lrrc d c c irrp t u d t rs
l ttu
n cu mn
mnii nnimpliioric, untrjiddividibtrr' (P,jdc'r.Lp. 197).in
ac.caii ordincdc idci, vc, v H Heftr. yon dn i,},s;.6ca
Tanzzh *.njtheD stiel,lscn(tln,1r.t7,si Pcrcrcuggishrg,
D?r sry..l/)i. Ztrilh. 1917,pp. 16-rl
27 .,Cidriri si I rtrd e ' (t [ / o u < ru i iy rd |a ): rn . lc
sprcsrrlr^'or..cl.rrldnnL UriNn c o o rm. n ild d c k a n r
cl Prdor,R.p.xr!0?a:nrrov(ooi<oi +r;[r
biq d]doi<
2!'Mrrgircs"
PocmcoDi. derxlirxtic populri. rvind
iNl lui fiil li Atibuii lui
lr.ncr {lc o pa e a qniciivulhi.nc altiinrur oxfcucpigrot
( suus!. iyFt!( @ i rd/ . ic ' o rDo y d y a o ip d [ (ro l M ).
Pu )clu fids'ncn1ertunasc,rr Kn,r c\. Epjc.C.tu rnlncntr.l ,
p.alrum.si Ancn.rr.,,./oFd.v
(ox1dd. l9ll),p t52un
cI L RlJemx.herinR!,xlv,l70j
1703ii H. Lrngcrbeck.
MrjnLJ v..J,., eter 8'5.rril)r'!
ud ,(r,,.o".!lrr.',
nr
.,rlarrrd Siudicsii CLus.Philolo!y',Lxlll, i953.Dp.3:1t;4.
It,.lambic dnp:i dc P lrn d e r
a [,ccsidci!c idEro<de lr ia[9i!.ry (ciiii vienDa&vi]rcrc
contrfur)ecomunilacc'kd'i cI r)roh 6.cflnr.rr,t,p
435 l{c,l ,,iann,trs
en .uincn mxlcdictrmplu mqm rinetro
uertr rppdkhn'cirnrcnrard rtj ldfli{rLr.qucr.dnralc
dicere".ALrcviftLr(timorosicI cuvirrultriitr{ insii {rbiliti.
c4!!cfor1cfi $.o!rrgft ccltr arvDrintonbdtusernniil.nir
dr..duli,mro" |rcxr. ioxr'jbuic Arirorl\ Dionrd.s (luF

COMENTARIULA POfTlC-4 l1 l4t^ t'

IUa l

smbnid.hri:ntu i inspnaidcvrro) Inimnd Prctrd.hontric


clre Dcmct.. v 195u.n., ldrPr e numclcunci duji'.m r
wicnci Akrdcnc . 1913.
(l- Rldrmachcr. ,.sn7-ber'
^irci
cLXXXVll. Bb . r. Abhdl . I
iDorczanncipcrcchidivincldrPoi- l;I r)si,d$inutcnai
acc$i l)en.nrjin fr i!6iilccleusircparcsi11
binclimuar.rcltrL
los ir*mrr
Cr Ch. Pictud.a?piJOJd/c Brlr.r dins l.s
ntstaar J Eld6n. in A',rres /'Hitoif du Cfi'srr,ism- Prh
Amncrdm. 1s28,ll,pp 229-264
3 . 1 - 3 5.. A d e r i r r l c
supfn.pecarcdc lllmLnr.rin0 roviiicsi il adnci sl Phron,
Rc p , X6 0 ?3 :o u t r o i i v ' o [ . Y
Pr.c1linirsups d'ipultri ctrm
rprirov rLiv rpdla30n0,Liiv.
intclcge?At lotc l .di! mxrictareaootej|triHomcr $ dru ln
A l b c g s l r n ' . p7 0 :
36 . , N ! i t r v c c l i e a . o i t o n i . u L
,.Ncl ttrtirc Oncro srrcbb. $,
comedla.drdinpc$otrh e dflmmx.icr.Frtbi rvrcblr.dd,
huzione utrirnr c .mrctu di anonca trnsoSgctromp.nomrc
r dilicEiTa di qncicomDcdilgfuli chc.vrcbbcni tduro
c di
'no,
arloinenti dallr lavolr F,vcrn.cioi \cnzr urid e rctu svolenncnt)
cd, invctiYt"
diazn)nc.csogse(pciso.ali
.
9. . . A l r i i i n t r e b r r c i 0 d o i r L x a sc xi p r i ' n [ ! , . r r l s p u n s
h nnFbs0 daci i' nirliul itr crrc scliser h vscul al lv_lca ta
gediapurolisotuiiiajunsibNtrciul lnaldovoLulicici,[paF.
laprii[privnc.nrcotrtdiclic alinnalrci,dupiinultpdr
ccd.lisindtri1 nrmciadcvlrdl rca\i rnscdic$l1,.inccrIsi
scnd trNlormc (l1rr9a15 lr5) I crhrtc, ctrDr avuts.}
s oadre vahrcn,op cr.pl rr 16.sviiE e'{!rr!$r.rru
qdet,:irrlli.lplic,re tragcdi.i,ccijvaln,id'o iLlzl. llIule
trdJ i imcL!mriPtrrn
'r
Frl!!]!:4!jjB\r!s4
rNlnmc n{.N 9.,' deo$br
d.{J in lcni h saie eatnsiisi dlutr

D M. PIPPIDJ

LOMENT RLU LA POFIICA lv /.11l).l

ilmb.buitoariicr acaana,po\itriIrarcac!-dnrirend
m,i dc
xu.Duomcxctrstr
tirimencanl|rtpt4iriinr.h{Q drc!hsedir
i)'\rll Ll',blindonhr.a.Li! Jnhg,r.,.,,,.r.
e rorcD;r
e-10 .t,vrr! drur+lrlL!t!
pr .rl!i_!r
pr,

\ i/ir

t.r

cer! Llu,ze, d r n iJ _

mn , , rt

q -mri

pnnh ceremr p'$oss 5imi Dcvoicdcn&a.erar,tcpfrlr.


kp(,md ?v"r .'-t!!
cu!!k(tn,
_r!r_! \ t u h rn r" ; -; "e-L.rin.;"

_r!:
:..p.. 1: -'",
rc.",
,,"p',,',A
G;G-;;a;;i;;;
'r,i,si"depcndcDrdcobsc0i'i',r"
"ito,
pe.hcil

orcnbdeu"r-;,

_,

anul - prsajul inrEg c $\ceoribil deaDrccrcrifetrnre, duDtichDul


.un sudcn ikriMri si i judecj,nvd@c{ mdodci;aurc;ri
c'hEadmanudetor.candeWbadcrnlnuirc(dccclerF)piarc
dc propra vrenc.
cu sc$'0. Drrcd.i An$obr nusi-adar
' cirez.
'n.i
oncnedarit-s
i/voarctc.paencind.iosri DcciTiinhisc
inrenrirzt peccrc.rid trr!oulc. snrcnrriccj 6uDratrccururuj
rerrux'i a!c (v. r,bd,.frd,, p. I,r) DincutllrcrinrcDcdindc
vo'br desp$ pini undcror I njc* jccje .crccilri \i, mri rtcs.
i'r cc
dedid vcrcutuixllv lea.cndnutccl,nriqf
'n{sri,lr
Nn.clos
purcxinci Dtzuiri tr.on$nuic prci\lorir d.,jnoi. in
acesriid'n umrilptvinripr'on10isroricitornDdcni
$]nrdsDr(c
a u unirome Dacij p.nru un witamo*j, sru Ryryrrcf,iron
'lc
.Lrr!
!|n](t,rhLcLr.sL E f riu t d . , t u n n , u io in , r e t ,
!irncnLi, rd ! is e 7
r, n A n n o L l.s
cdnre$ionorignonncaasroc.,rdyi, 1449xtTrharheknons
Dorcoloic hiiory Dl rngcdydln hcacruallyrclk us.andheis
n ,izqdr!ltl'e( bc ng x,l \e n , , u
rkc i' I turiJ!!lrIr jc\r dr u J u u d , { . o J t u M i Nr/ $ o l
(.NcErbb I ktas.Anenrm",xxvlr, t9t l.p 6t3 =
o@rc,h
sere.ra.
Lpp 67 63:.,DicAu$is." (l.",r.i*rotr"" iii,," r,
Lrfnrn! dcr Tngndjc sind aho Hrljorhcscn,dicauchwr/u
l{trl ,b!'c!h' cr !r. rdcnrr
da I rqturr,.hi,u.\.h e . , . h . c e , , , L nhq" , n
arl!
; ru . r, a ' ,

iini. c.ioculunel
'trcm.ipuJinNlbudttr.lnhrcccrcariruJini
ccluicre. uiitrJdrhutrc
r trciascinfidseaz,!
delannc.AtirudiDc.
'inronMrilc LuiArisolcl oii de ce
izv.ar, trtrcrcludc ? p.nnt ci mimcaiubnorc de sftm a
fibzorului a ptrutrconiplcrap.in specnldicncajLtnsuil.unel
irturmariincclmai bui !32$ntr
trsitrgrhdlLbciyof
alcltriPi.k4d CaDrhridsc,,.hcwsttubrbly
[1m
rhc.riri',s\vhi.hrhos.oodemsch,nrnrvhoasxtrsrorc.cpl
(Op.ri..pp
l23 l19.
Niirrllihlchav.ceminlyDorrhindoied
Cl. A. Pcrcni. Epranr e tflljcl,',|. Sn\t;o lrt dnnnx atuea
ar.a,a,.Fitonzc.l,r:r9.f 6t) senoalech'rprcsrpunccr.ir
cla Lcarem
..lihd dc! dc rcorhzrE" r fi lozohnd
'nlcftsc.zit.
depait si n sc prr. ciJi pi{rcuTiiintcrga
rnes dci0lde
'
vsloafrDreiniundu,d nuheTecld. nd in unni.rimic Egg.r
cmcicrizr rccooii1un. arisbre
. , No tr s 9 ! o n s l c r s p e d d A r i s u c p o t r r lh i t r o r e , n . n s s a v o n s
rvcc qucllcpdictrcciir l.ulli loN l.s vicur nouuncnbde lr
choiol.gie ertlc la liftnrurc g'tc.l
h pui$amedu sdnr an.lYdqu..q
p.,ntde l llir DdconMltc ou & lui l]lnc dr. dr\ N in(ilil
in\.pxtuit
dc syddme.lespl!rsii$ rdDoLsnlgcs l'lni.nc
'lc
dcl'i,Nind d,mnation.quipcuiav
lc m1, il veurr buh Iorccrtouvcr.c(c syhilri. drns les
ds lr litrdururcgrccquc.Iris ors. il nc
lren e's
'n.nunrcn6
s in q u i i r c l l s n l e d i t h l r m b c c n p o s l g . u r o d x l c a u { c h N
iaDrb,trrc\.(
a!r ch(!sl)hall'quc\:r.c patuirps nle'nesotrscr
qoel'trurhctrrciridn MrLlil;J ptrl
ponics csris d! la
vaddL ltc.nde. mls u pcnconfusc.dcs
poCsi.rces
rentrtivcs
sim ufes tour Pmdu'rclc tlnmc,strbrr
lrcomddlc.surllusieurpoin( dch Gt...ef Si.ll...n Aliquo.
dansic Pdloponis.;
!:\ dihih d un
r.u\,tuc prr $r rcnor!n!g..
m6thodc.ll .rot

coDrcrd.r lrir\-

D M. PIFPID]
tunsdq&n.asd,unnnonrcmrrj xu tieudA dnlis.il rn,tv$
desrhlrac!o.s. - (Es*rrr.pp 249,250)
l| | L...lvlutltrhiri in d , u n ilro rit o r c o rt rt u j d e
diriranbi- (drr rrjry ilarxdyroy riy 6L0Jpalooy).
vaeul
vor artduccni sovrlesllpEjudcoc
com,nDii unuil;n
^q,o rnr $nic
a lntri ob .urirde lontrnuii Jcl t.!.dur
nrDrc
{tr cr \l n!!'tezLlc.rcr. i n d r. , n rn J ru u t o B ! rh c r
rexrtrrsuoir..snh
rhc 44ro., of th3Dihyramb..dalel_Hdv.
PoCriq'e.coll. dcsunjv. dc Fnnce.paris,1932:,,hnasddjc
rcnouelur 3Dr.uadc dj$ymmbss.)Acelcrlicuvnledevj, ta
vilgimisli Ir rleed/r rirdc tJ \!r ori!,nr J4 ./nror,.tcl
Alb!-!!Lni ,Ltr .,/ura ./r. Lr,!c!.r,. n
didambo,(cl rj K.zicBters.tr.rasodj!,tnREvlA:cot 1eo9
u ni) C!e,(nLJ.ct! dridnn r imp n n if i t rRo n a s o rL . t t r
deSriin Fillicr,)raducert,crcgoduscpETnri,bar.ctrsu^,1
hip Deiidoiortsi DroDn,sti
exlrioc Eevidffi,nrMdcvtr.cir,gcJianns_i
uivi njci
dr' acuvnar* audnordc diriimbi (Bu{cher,H d}),tri.idir
lcoa a cidiitEiit.r simpli (valglmiSti)r pcndr ca dnm $ ia n]dir
, l; { nr\oie a !r je dr ugu . iK s mn u s : o d d le g J . h
ifuepd.dc.iLinh.or.deoFn!.\, !i m,r!d,Llc JtL ob;.uxt
ifrrp\lv al rexlltuj, tic.ii ah inchDa,it vcden in el Dc
obin'uilntr.puioio< (R.$asni).ne. m.j probabit.o,Dldiie
nofi, distiidi de 6i dd 4ottriind Liprul! cu .1. E Lrl.lcsul
iui
edpxny'. nuneroaseparajehomcnca(culirludccrcmDh,
r/
XvlII3l6 roior 6i nrr.i6l< daryo,jitiipX! y{joLold:XVltr
49. XXM20) ii c singurulporivii cu tntomatiaJupi {rc,
rnf-unmnijcnl?ne!,e\k p e!tr (r ovJbrernhuriLle ra,ltue
r u,The,nnlj.orulu'pf
nrr\ rs , h J L lju g d u i, : u o i, n n iir
u.v royo< d xopd<b.(6poB rr(. / , , io ro o y 5 ! o ; d i, < : r,
or 04,rny it.iirr ir;p ro , j 6 u rn n a r. o 0 rL r; y y o o d !
(Di! Laen.,xr 34,s6.cr.ctrdernan,pr33;
H.relnmai;. in

COMFNTARIULA POFTICAIv 1,1J9r


..ltcv dciEr.grccqucs,I-X_VI.19i1.p50,r-5l0iH.Kollcr.i"
.,clolrf ,xI, l962.pp 133 195).AccniroKrrri(cdcalrniitcn
Drcrutusde rextulPrrd;, caE r
ntrmrirtrl$ldonldnc h utrulladoi (1,149016-17).filr! sr fi
fimunt in prcrl$i] apfi1ir .!lui di'riii ach (A. Lcsky.
I/tptunb, itr srdj ia oror dj Ulo
p p . 1 6 9 - 1 7 6 r G F . E s e , T i o k p L , i ( . , . w i c r o r S \ ' d i.cLi x x I I .
lese, np. 75 l0r). Expl'crriatr( p.rc 11dc..rr.cocr ci in
cxpnn!rc"lr.ori.irld ArntoGlfrtnosd t1lirro! erarocoiir
rckr.si unrmc.c0'niccxtri'n!Pi.k'r+Crnbidgc,din.lip!i[
(notr sotr!).in rbichlhcchorurdnL
cm,.hc dolivcftda spcech
iorjoitrn m,r whm hc bccmc.n
non d mdrio6o{y ol Ronhippers- sDchwhqe thc nerronn.d or
d[futr|.(.]p,dl,.p
Boni,i.1qrl,f l7,pcitfl cai...dicTardesThestnu s.n'cr
zcit...*rc5.di.sundcircr{r*onc
unTcil^r{r7cidtrruh
enspcchetrd|iedinls'g rcriicne
mchr ms dcn rtonlcn Blnden der Responsior bctr.it.. bis der
Choniihren,'po krircs m sclhi lindigcn Htpoxitcs $u c. bis
^
dcrrrJgls sicgb D'e Enrw'ckhtrg
Sprcchv.i\ . s$.hr gctrN dv i'Jcrctr Ch.r, Ch.'tuhicr,
. Dr\s Licd
Schxusplclcf
Arsdrulkr und Srilloroetrsnrd, 6t esr ErBelJnnsptlerer
Enrvickhng.Sinlcn und Srgcnsind ltt uns komplctucilirc
Cegctr\uzc.lnr dic Gric.llcn.gcr
n,chf ) Mui dc drrilid,i'nro.anc n' nxl'nultc rlidu'i oirxrr,
puncsliscvrriinit.ir!ovrs opl!ft lihrc
Mrno Unbsreincrpfu
dc rts}{ioi .Duii c]] rrc or de LLiftrnbl Cu alle cuvrta,
digLncahgediei fi degisi1.dupirccnccrclittr,int-uDindoir
..f.unultomuldinrdyo,,iruldin!;'!io,...A olclcdiccchc
, trscrir dcrivr drsli ildprovr.q rijv tL0r,pdroorum
pr',..lni i oi, Ootrcpi(,hlc'ni)n.l \uo crnb (a)' rmktr' dcl

COMENTARIULA POE C'{ IV JJ]' i


J i.
tr't1 ..ff r. l
'b,
otrieieurco
mrr pd .lorcto!c dx ArDrorctc.I
survojiaDr
ld0! r' . . , " . r. . \ . re , . , t rh " rou ,
d.Pttu.o0 conireDru qulche modoun.unni.oucjrci I
'n .tr . t . 1 " '
', I
. h . , . i, n " , h o :
"'..F A ' r,'..
"
'
dxgli t6dproy1.<,vtcncI dir. ohc4;ppy,4
{sftukprni..rrre !rcsgiancnrodci rpaluaoi di ftunlc ri
-,
coftuti dcl
{lltnnnD. Si c{isccnrgLio.ora.porch!tn Sudr! DroDosi(od,
ariolcsiprlidi r@r(d< fDdDo.tDai ius.p 112):eslivolc%
pfcikm.r.dre:. pay,!6oiinvc\tiidcltnlunzioneDrnjcoledi
i a'lro!1 er" toi! hi ttctt' tgel i a,p. D.L\.
lt ,,catrrccc liccnrioa s c . , (iin d 1 , ; y r, i 4 a rrr. ; l
r/v.tuIcelh{icxpticndeoEdisptricmnrhsiirtricupmdu.riilc
t)onDrret{rnLpu\eJlrd, Arrrc.vmed,c,lr!turce,\rhen4u\
xv12td
6t2tr.tr tunLru
l \ercllJl -tr!r,, D! tu\ittuh J ht \ \ J lu l
l t e r \ . f , I Dn
'
t,ru( ii rn!nrelculrrcLl\ i!e{r
ltriilc qrilo n m mamr mc.. L!
nrd4 rc.r. $rr\J f.,n |lu iri v (b lJ c . t u L lt rrt r! D, a llr
die lrd. e srcudc horitijl.ricd{. drcrl t nrtro.rrcj vi l] nju ! h e , I rc r! ; r$ rr, l (iB
drc $ n!cr!mcreJ!h!rjrd.c r, n h d s ! . r, rr. 2 4 0 ). 5 1 t r
n
d4 i ' J r

| d J \p !/ | e ]n L ] trJI

Asupnpnbleriui.in geNnl. vu, o. Nrvare. /f,r o.rgiDes


e.l,
\utrlre te,tnutr.,1.l.t6rL\ti!.,nfl ,rc\EL.nlidrl
vIr
5 P e14h.'n P cv. tr!h.utus q E . lv t (2 r lo ll. D ls u . !
nri dc rdind. c. .jirtr!ftndc. in ,Enkx", L}l.T.196r. DD ll4
\iR. F;qct.re ii /.tr L/r I / r c v n rk \ d , d . , p { i\ . l9 o r
15.,A incerir s; ic m a i rra n s f o rmc , . v e z i. mii
r i hun l! !,!lr I

Cr rn.tc e^.oir

cJrc

trDdc.spre
brtltulc. nu tovdnesr i raci loc in drrmck salc).
rcrtrl ttrMek' mnftmi pMiziriLe
r1134.56:6(trt!.vGcn.iroKflrijv)Aioxu)\0<, riv 6i .pir.r'
Io4,oKliiqrai or(trrrjpu('' lrr rpolo6iav Asupnptublctui,
itr gcneial:O.J.Todd.TPITAr'!rNJ:TH:,.1Red.rsldentrcn,
ii.,Cli$ical Qnarcrl] .xxxx.19J3. pD.30-33isiC F Else,
'rha Cxs ot th. ThndA.to.,tn .:rt^n\dons ol lnt ,Amcr.lhilol.
l945.pp L-11r.
A$'rirron,Lxxvl,
19.,.Docorul sceDic (oKrvorpa4,iov).'tcndinh.anin.
riri in norapradcrrlr. dc d rtibui I
uidrrnricii.i)t.de r 5i I' arin\
lictiorilril.r adnscsp.cracolL
Iorfrr.lrsi.i1(cf Arhen.I2l.).rlirui.rnoconrl!iilicJiclN\
itr sernia aubnld P.drorde vit
izvorr Dai fcchi:,.prinumAsarht.htrsAthn'h Aes.hylodo
Nmc t{gocdirin (Ermr tecr cr dc ( comhcntaiiunr.liquif
(Dcarfi .VII.frucr. l 1) D.\Prci
hcere, v.ziconcnkriul lui F. Prr
d6prcprrblenielelegatdcro{uls,.oir c(lr\lcncihrcrtnl
RrIII A, J?
anric.jjrickcnhaDs.li
drnr /e' rhirtaigic.s./iJiques. ii tttl,,gar Pru'l, fais, 1949.
II.!p.892 $95 CLP. M.Schu ,P/rtdett
'tdesanbnFs(rL!
pAyful6r,Pnis,l9:11.p 9 unD \i l.l.Allcn.
Srrlc,,1,dqrj.i$
oI LheCE.xs and R.ntnr tntt n)ci. rintence, t')64.
2 0. , P r i n o b i r s i r c i r a r i r i c r l ( t ' d 1 o , j i k
i, i! I . ! r i . i

mnku^r{!Lcl.inrcdidrrnbuldi..rmou(cdc

, ; , r d.. .;n.-._in.ii .iri

J;tulh ir.

hg.dia ar I honaDnn ETttniCin6il

t4 rl"!rs4 !n[-:in6inTa_Mr,r! n:!!!r44!!4s

!q!4jq_. mi!u( ccami potiv't1 cu ev.lu[il3 co,tsnlic! dc


clririlq-intcrnreiicreutatil.lclabdc rcceF rer uE' asenc
no iFlu^ rbir drcimairunevoic a li rlcvat (F. Susonihi,
ihqEcon)edlEarr.ze,.,Rcv.Phil,XlX.
Dt kituktcttia.
pp.
1895.
197 20!r;H

:,r:!j,i.!r,:i
:I i:!;:,:
:,;:.:,\"
Iti
::
x,Y,",
:
:
^:;t:
.l:-f,:':1;
;1.""::i;l
:1",: *.iiilli",l:

COMENTARIIJ LA ,DOETICAIV ]4.19 .


!'to drviNclc 6d roit tr oorlp'ioij n arvrr sii sPunioi
lrtrf irsadcrvoll{dih&aNisdnicicir1ilblositlu'nri
rdr s2id., si rclcrindu{o la proptu sr ipotcziidcsp@li'l.irol
co|Li', zilclc lui A ,n (nai sus.pp i23-124), Untedieincr
nuorcrzicin.h.,s inct rvuri in vcdctodc Ai{olcl arn fo$
d s n u q , o n! L r e o o r u p o .
r, , " " -' , " r
'"i*-*n,t'.",

;
r;i;*,*,,;""
i
"'i*i'*it,.,
I*"ii*::

iir
i';;r;
"':.i
j1.::':"',;,,;..
r":.,'
"i+*
:T.,:;
: .";*":::;
,;li'T'lHi ;*i,::fii*.*

n,;".rlilj
;ij:r:rffi#i*;i1H[Tfi*,,,

;'l.l;;:ih.',l"*;;.*l;:
ii'.lil}:*ri'ri

e lapin scvch lcgeeidxeroicapolclnno


hvIlafulndiin,
rapporio.
E p0n ,mhc cscre che qucio
in
streto
rxrmsi
conraso fru scrioc groftscoihbi! indivdnab c &ccnthro il
NUhcntodelhcontrdizioncdei rniti:mn diDertichi n chc,
&tr
Fi. lapd.dia di queni,L qurlecornpondcr unr scnsibillirL
ns pun'Nnre loeicr, tdvcrl la sua
pid Iilosonctrjcligiosa.
nriEionsnelladismimdrtal'ircrrtrrrv$o1aco'nnc'lh I
$i,maidcpdnc..NonilDnodunqncconrcncv!trttibnneschi,.
ra pintuno il cul.o. ncl qulo h prsnonc tx{mdava vsBo
cccc$iitrtrlichcprsrvanoan.hcDcUdprrolalldarua{dvi
supratuodismnum", nuncxrz di,nonir chcptroivcb,usi
gli
sulmit.mntib$ndo.Glrctclsuornoquclptublcnrcl't
(Ot8,tl.
copoprio,cchL1.vedevrncllrsuaMsicriD$luhilid
p.251) Dinprodnclirnli r.cenii.vcrinci H.Schecknbcrg.
Aca!4. vdr W.td., Gt gr..h. Tntiitlic tus den Txrz,
Dacli,
23.,,Cind dirlogul si a licut rpr.itia
prvcttc
inrsdu@m ,,pomulu'
air cum parcpobabil, rluzia
acroidecrtc fhesph(vc/noupuodcnriili tcxol lui Diosenc
Lrciioscira$lh 1449r l0 ll).ttobui.siprcsuPmcnciinloc u f t rr B t a m c t D l u i t o h r i c c u t n m c t d i m n b i s s o v a l i d a t f t l

i1ilffiill,H'j.:;1,"*riii,Tli

;i:il:I :H'.;ry.l'
:lrilltil I ;:l:l::*;lllll

tj.,dfjir
i:!i!iiiJl.*tiiti:1t,j:".:
,

:.;;;;.;,jt,i"lJl;?llJyiiij
"^". """i";".''.,

24 2 5 . , . I a o b u l c c c l m a i a p r o r i i r d e g r r i u l
o b is n u i t . C r . A r d . x , ! d . , 1 1 1 3 , 1 1 0 s 1 , 1 23, 6i o l l ] o <q r i r l i
ioru ir ri4< n riv rorl\i v (.,itnibule insusinodtrldevorhlr
oi?loDi
al.clormulti ) si Ci. , O.rr.l9l:,,(,anbicdsnuncru5J

*"
Iit,lti':
lji i ;tJ.lji:t,:iiit"'.
-'.";

LA POET.ICAV 1149a- 149 b


COMENTARILJ
b2l 2l),Kotr!6it
LlnFdctu,ihar.nbliciatrlcdiei(VI 1,149
td'i FirrrdL< trp.i4.os 1roio! &i droip!! tL.'ioou<
r{[iou, xopia iddror 1,iv Iorior iv roiq i6.or,6p,ivruv
rai dlr 3f drow.ri(.6r ir6ovir.idi yild.0< aadi/oloa rnv
c i''n.na une'
Iri/ ro@nrlv na6q&rrr (ii0'po v (..oomcdir
rrirni hulii i NisDrltvire,deo o?u{c i turuto.< ni gd in'po
dobt>osebitdupiI'luilclia[fti prni a.i,'mirtc inclnpu li
s
dcodctrini r.riunciarnrpovenidsi crrc.pL.rLeadesfldrii
Iri$rur,sivirstcurrltirc,{c{dpatm
) cf.hnccoopcr.n,
Athto.dtz.Thcatt 01(nncdy,||)Lh a' Athpkna ot the PrELics
ntula Tt0st'tion oI the TnctnnE CatJlrlrIt!3, p. 223,nrm.
33..,Ridicolul se poarc dcfin,... Cf Ci..,D..dr..
II2l6:.,lo.usautemclrclioqunsirilLi.uli rI])iludinccrdctdr
hitatcqudlrmuintimru Haecenimr cnlutrclsollEln'rxnne
quacnollnrctdcJgDrniiufptudinenrhurmn.nsrpiar. en
criamdctomidt er corpois uni
iocandun.*dqMcnnusidcD...(tudctrtrsptcc\niur.nequid
(,.slcrxt..arcoun\
insulsc..ncdtrs.rdilniocussitaulmmictrs

*+*#ir*;:ffi

r;

*#ffiffi

ril

ue ni.at rcD, t qu) . ptoda4b.


h rl
'e
txaulr..juaerd.iurhatlpe.kit,ehaDi

.,1'"i.),1t5
t:ilj ii,llltllltit.."":'::i:)-:'
x,Til,".

,ro,fflrulnLli.4, r'.

il [tt'i,1!ili]'^,#;;{:liri-,

tl
I

ilI

V
-

. c,i mer

liiilliiiii,i:i:.l",il',iil.i:.:
Is^',, -G,.i;i:;

n \onlutrdr!u

r!n!

llrn (n fiur:.

e provocatmii.u scrnl, drcdnn sxduiv,(]9


rr:{Lr.cMdc\.
o rnun iu triln ii lhiD nu D,.r nanr .
d.ldieT
trc ruoni LUe,IiLl.vnr,',h.!dm,
nicitivialc.tricicoboiab!rnivcldlnihilor.l) Asupndochnci
comiculuilrCi.ctu,ingcncml.v. J F D Alion,R.nr, rlerrry
Tr@ryrd (lr6.re, London.193I,n. 162Jj trnnr deco'nPlcrar
cuFr.KtilIcn,in,,Philologus,cvl,1962.2q59.
l4'l9b
D i t rN n c m u t i n c a r en a ( l
1,.Si r.ordc....orDl
akniatrr htu N'b.bliduirca sr Epftrnhriilc dnmdie (ln c ])Ii
v.sc.ucdir, dnpii{odcll)bibrlilllile,arqnnd din inu1.136
a
i cn..&h pimci vidoln x ld HionnLr:v nii susNta la 14.18
33), once rnror dodttr s, i vrdii opcri juld:i cn dnof si cea.il
invoircarugnhtului. s.licilinduncor rori v on (iv (ALn.oin'.
Civ, 5ll). Ac.nh.r te$uia

D,M PIPPiDI
r o!llrE L \e irrLlu(iprn n u m
i {:.i'ui i ii'9dr. {i Jc tirtr! p r; u \ r, , . F . rn h , t r a s ! p
.rSMizitdinlrcriales rcrtururar.iiin.,e7i h,crinb cltrsn ie
n,i A Mtrclle.. r.rrb!.n del gr;.hK.hcr Bnhnenahciijnct.
IrerburyiB.lN36jO Navmr6.DhDlJDr jirde rr rbsdr
tttu, nri.<ietlc da h6ad akttin, pms, 1395(cd a ]t r. 19201!
A E. ll3igh.Zr.lnii 7,5erh.$nd cd revGcdbI A W. lickard
crnb.idsc, Oxlod. l!0?: O.A.w Ditk.. Tnc Or-r ftearr.
.!y.aiin..Annuat.r rh. Brr schoolorArhcir.. xuI. 194n,
pp. 125-192!AW pi.k?Jdchbnd,Ec..fhe,Dr.aftat Djonvslr
r,,
".lrrc,s.oxnnJ.r946ct956)i in. ThcDzn,aijc kstivsh.l
A,rc,s, oxford, 1953; T B L. Wcbner, O.e* ftcah
2.,Inirtrn rerTtn" in comprariccu rx8cdia.ate.imi
Eprczcnbrl sc |dmnc.$t1zicr ai l lon orguizareoriciatin
0xnniird
veaculuiat vt lc!.-pofu 509.in oncc caz502
(Pick! -cmhridgc, D].tyinh, co,a1!, Tged,,p 91)
4 .,Crrc I rixnr n u n iru t rc r. rilo f "
Du p t
r!!L,3ia< (Kaibcl.coDi.o.
OD..o. FqDrld. p lD,&shxr t n\lCratircs: ot iy rii
arfui
rd np.iornd ,rdKro< (ioiloy
irtr].y;!{yo<
6i.K @rire< mrltrrrrt r;y n rr; , o y r; iy . ij rlru s ia
r podunor1r ,+6r, drioa . riy d ro z io y
5. ForDis. Poerq)micancuza,, conrenpranml] tilnir
6. crarec.locr corn. rGDiln. rdnor .rrc tuDrirarca
vcacururt v-la Arkbfin, in clvrf,t (5rr si !m ), rrc pcnh
oio< 3i Kdrll< 6Dd(
i]ri,\ro kai oruo.r,yroLiq,
'rlrjj/
ii. dnd orrra. 6andy(
i|taq dNori!!y dnar.ln(y,
Kpos0ordmu
r;pom< ldrruydoadmdrc htrrci(c
'ird
(.,crrmanri{ciircnccaTlnn
ai|fnnrardinpxne.vicmb.crtrc
c0 o chehtrkitidc n,fti. vi rtnird rcrsr,ir!r. nnpltind din
!un ldelicaricd.'n.jspnituicrandu j ").

COMENTAR]IJLA POET]C V ]14' h


(ir' 6i
l2. . , T o r a s i l c l i n p r i v i t r l x i n t i n d c r i i
ri []iK.0.Evorba&opo'nvidc l0nsidcrDrterirlir oFercro'
ti dc dnrrtarliunii dese.a strbiccl.ccadnttii ritud i. mod
functiedecsrdc-adou.ct..nardcpanc,xvll1455
nomd-

17:xxvl1.t62b2.
h l6ixxlv 1459h
unei sinBure roriri I soa12 il.,,in lioiclc
rc1ui .Cunrtia\c dcsDld. l:'nundin liiel rcxtului.evo$n
liidc o simpli orstutm a uncidcpntrd$i' dnmaluryilordnr
vtunadc ratrgcnici graeJti Cc.accnu i_xJnpicdfit pe
torcticicnii !ibmr d,tr vremcdReiesrerii si iotclca8l rpu$lc lt'

*.W#il:l#-##i'#

gr_ cHJ. {r'{


L t rc : , , . n l ; 1 . .
p LUoDrd:G Torrn'n,
Litcnt! Ctiljct\nrn) hc Rcnxhsui.e.
CutqE Ctlo.E aediz.dvcduta.t 4?'1
Stdi, )cncnn'.t n'ti"
{L ir Jmria. .lrsiquc, fp 2ir 2s8)
trm.. R. !ray, Fldrh,
h ulirare, sinsm unitxrcp.mcniii sQdali dc Arnt(ncl c
unjurddca!rime(t.crpirolclcv]].vnl,xxxl);trniulc!deloc
t s it rg c o b i ' s d i n t u r p a s r l I i t i e 4 r c r r t d c . m v a l i v o r b r
mideprac (xxlv 1459b25 26):dl pivc$ u rtrdc tinp,
nlicd.I. ii!'un antrmts.ns.oPor
..rs.Dl,ei arinorclicer txgcdici (cdm obscNl. cn drptare
Ro$a!'i in conFrhrtul sitr), tcxlul n o inftitir.rri dc!i! ca Co
nap'tro' nno aiov
ntuinrinuin(elcrunatrdtri:sdi\td'd
italr;rra!.
rqio6or iliou .lva, i rrdr
I4.,,La ltrccPu r" (rd atirov). l)etpreasmcn* drumc
dcpiitind duotL obisnuid { diuni talicc si Pudtdu k co'nprft
\ubnpodulluigjn,iicucppc.i, frvcin nid o sii^..Nogllsim.pn
brbil,.dxiin mul..iminbamcii
dc cotrvingucrinridlrditatl r les uii orign'rie dinh tascdic )'
.p.pta. dirercnlirrc ahll jnt'ur ti.7
dintii arnmeinnmaipft mplriro

D M IIIP]DI

COMIN IARIU LA POFTICA VI ]Q9 b

d a rj i .tr!d (i rx!
r\\! r 4r zr r B tlor hr ) if,r r nql
n cd rm ( l u i A rt.h E
p ru o r s,trr'n l i e ip re\uflndhJ
r .L, mhor lnti,r
u"
!t.trn'erd !'LRtc. .l3311mrd_rrc, d ,eh rru..iu^l
rarlE.rll.t!1 aro.De{d^
6!hr/.Lrrnr ,..f"ra t,t23r

|!J)
n dn,iL]oU;
i tcl.
Din!c e )Jf e \ nlor!r rr rr Jl( rJ
umfrof..!1tr\r,t !{xrerc (. lmbr.
rrgd,toJ crcm!d'rtsp{nruts
nru?.J.!nn(hpiur
lolro.
pr,)tJ,,

l"]j'j,j'.

r ri-c! J'r

' ." *""''

* *.

'|o|J'

\.|!'d/fl|J cf' L\,Iv

VI
2l .,I4ai r;rziu".cr arlrod,.en.DD.
I I j2
:t D tn !! rr ,r! . I
,.,. h.r ,, u"Dq_.
"",
i d r r tr\rr \ n !tu n r !rt!^k r qlJi.,,r
"
"r
o,,,t.r
,_*,
p rt! rrn r! /!p t!t r" , r .,n,r ,r .1r r +" r , r l.",^,
,.ru ' /Jr1 1 1 r1 :l 4 _1[r ]r ) ..r ftr c\idltr
" 4r .,r
rv 1 4 4 3 bt4 t.m.sd ! i i
Is,. r pr .
"a*"r tv
- "- ^.,

tir:r cr ri B a v. c,
o.,, pa,i,r,"r. a. r,
"
"",g,"
n I f.r,g-_\

';i;lll#l,lr1i1'"
" '''
z5-2i

!.dk..

s./\.,!4

Srjri',Ll
n l' \ ll.i.
LtL . .ou rr
.t! !er tr.riL m!nb,tustr!rinne.qt, dr

.0fbu?r Ptrtr,! n:iJeejndut!nL


du,*
/ri 1312J 2r 22. r,po^i
-, ,i.,
(4.oi,!0dpns,r ii rlnPoD,rm

""

";^",...

dc vedemrunniitu disrosi or sr
nD-lheitl siNrirl si nc lovcmci- lrc troi\N l]c cimvadinri
nasti ina{nvitorrpropid (n lrg5b 13si0m.:l\Jrir rL<ili
Od,ri!Lro kaKlijO0o1116i i\unr!n roii dvdiou rulxdv.r,
d rav air;< n@o6o{ioa.v dv raedr i riv airon rLvi,
alNir!
Koi roiro;'rov
{'divrraD. Poinindde la ace{e
deliniinsj fii.ind din fti!ii,.. nrill xflLcxtinoui ,rrsin,!!i-n
prcpuss[ dovedcarct. intr o cclchi paeir]i dnr H,,Jxlr4,i.l3
D.eDrursn. ci Pcrc.herde em
dcfinilia hgelici w dulc. id u ti,
ahcr{L|es
- {riceL rufdemBcliflt, dcnsicl Arkr.relcsvon
demMnh ctrgcnRlu hat.Efglarbtenlimlich.dr$ dasUbel.
welchesdcr coscn nd unscBN{
weDdigeod dr ]]eschrl|nhcit sci
unssclh! odcr t0r einesvon dcn rnsnsun bcftirol'rc. hincr
^
w. dieseFnrhl ni.ht s.i, kdme alc
SodxchrcA,nhElesrondcm Mi.lcidetr.uid trurhieku!*id,
dic NahrcUrsdrc bcg'ciflicb.*aruncrin dcr lj*liiiutg der
iu die einrsc liu(ht nrdnre
T'agiidi. nlichndcn Nlirloidctr
rh
dac
rtrrchr
hicr
chc
h
Nichr ob
L.idcnschafiscL,*clclc blld fr it. lirkt ohm'hr,
nnabhriolige
creget*srlco kdnnc..soM{n MJ.nachsoinrErkLirse dc\
eLn\chlic$iiwc'l nlchLs
Mnlcids.diers die l'urhr notwetrdig
nrs Tuglcichlnscrclurchr eflmken
uDscrMn[nl 6ru9t,
'h
k!trr" (wc.,L.,cd.lvnko{iki.V.tD.252 25r).
ldciudaascnlimiiciftnrftrbilctj rc.ouluhrorabilsisit
lrunii comcnhlori.sepone ohicc
milc',c(r
derami.l ncirnlei arisroreliccx
vuLcrerutrcleoiert
chcle!E6orc
cc Albcglidi nunc,!t .,lr valuhTioncosgcrivi
coliiedaunmalcnonnusonor6ir.voli (.P..i.,p.75).scnli
mnrul oohpleicaEenJlavrdcic dr,ii Siidnl s|l3nihlui. un
a\r.ci ohicdi! ti. nor! rltrNti c. ntrpr ll tudnsch rsineEa
cgonli pent( sincsj penturisI] s
Rcult.lt. r.erdi notic $blirir.Iln chipulrcl mri tmpcdcin

D M. I'IPPIDI
,.t{,l
(rrr!d
tuti0r

t,i i

COMENIARIU LA aOfTlC,M

\ Il it4
n n n rd lr . i, n Dt r,
JN
!rmtur.nn derL n h c L lin r, j,
V i c ro rd . u J e n r
e rdrr s rr, ! c s F k
.i r. o i,r.tr
r
r e . 1 . r. r.
t r{ ! , i. 1

'

r m 11 . m..n . r , , r , r . . . . . , . c . . , .

\nii

.cnd.krr{m.inruttu m!
nJ\rJ_\ L lc mrjs ' J e ln ! i. ru ! . , \ u r
o^ 44rrn,, : d or
.^ / n @r 4 { y wrt , ! 0 0 ; , 1 rrs r
26-17.,Curttirca rc c s t . r p rrimi-(rijy ri,
rd o J
,1 ,'."r'p-.
y) pcnh inr.rrlclml xcc$,r
K.i0apor
ou
qirr' uharremk " r I e.,,rtuLl,..rer | 2rum .uh hrru
amanudol $hn trdr cri ii rshu
i
a r,a,..;
rD dnorcmai coproscsinrat
jnro,Dlrcdirciirerr{Lnrtnnar
"--";u
u$ddi,dcsi r0der.lMsdepirDjr JoovjdunlacioinreDrerai.
d.d,nlnriu'.!n
j,nb dnr, , , J d , ! rn n
m, r; rt " r" r
",,
dl)rnedpmhsrri
P m,[{ '
nfm e, \ rJuvtrft,nlen.ir:?!ie ft : tlrftn, hc
rcd,(ndc
h,+s n lhr !,arlr
\ der !n!rseb.i<n crunJ n e
4.u,u o! uid *rr *!htein.o d , c , ! ! h f t mc f h mb k , h . n L , , n
d/.pt7t
!f p t.2 isrc t u mr\ e r rs n e b ri! \ . r p c t rrt r
! trrir'!rr.llirt \J tcLi. tuc^ Ll Lor\r rft r, LhD
\DelJl
prrhn,o in,rr{ric..oi m
* r. s r * i*
r-! ij, . -. * , ,
*.
l!.iircni$
r, { , n . r. 1 r rs r D r s rc r.\
pri.r05 l')9.r ao).il.e.&!,rt LL,n*,.n_
a,n,t,"."n^
ri5 z!.ff D d mc s . , He rf t r . |\ ; \
r qr'r pr.3t o? Fr
v t 1 u -lb 2 . M ! i.
rcnrnr. k o,pr./dL T,3d', pr. 9l!tO.ri E.p flL|Enouhos.

l,?,,14l)

l/ .!r!r!tr dd p,ssro,s d'lpir lrJ


3.
lli Gould.itr'Gmnnr', 1962,p.4),12,n
2? 23.,.Nuncs0 ,.g!ri impodobi( sr!iul cn
rirn , ! n n o n i , c l i D r " . ( r i y u 6 i t i s u o 0 i v o rvd l D r l r v
Ziovra iuoatr .di dp[oviav xai rrdo<) Cum obseni
inh rcdepasajsi l,l-,1?
b 2i-25,
n. l. deosebla
&lnami,p. 151),
strdcclc'ncmcconune aleccl{ mi 6uLteva.ieiiii dc pftrc sunr
drarc,itn
.nelodir\imisura_(irord<, rao<, rarpuv){l
ii aceerci.int un cizsiincel:1lah,.dcln,riEeneraLii,p.tivir
!Isianijloaceleiniratc, puclicearti lr0rr<, Irtoq,
'isona
mpqrd,i\llqric r l \n!r
rl 4 rrJ : l - 2 2 r , c r 0 r c r i ! n
uin krmcn,d'ft d'i nu lmnln, i,tr
(144?b24-25)...alrb,dclladcliil/nrtc eenenlecorispndc
il do (inquu$ocaso,tritrndosidi fomc dnmmari!l$.drna).
il,r/.,s(= ntno + xnnon,a+ pa,oln),il nch (= rnho) rclh
dcririzi.nespecilicara1l.prtu d
ncl6 (= rni)iia+.tno + pa)la) .incelde d doilea(laaeb
21aa), .,a\ nho c btt,n".Di, dellr dcl'nizioncSenenre
.orrispondcn ,ho {in rll sAo mctroe daMa), armonil c ,rtor
dcuasp.ihcr:ellapDk dcl[ ddniTi,,ncgcncrale,
'l'E/os
dcllaspclifi.a . Cr A M lvcbic.DrLc, wonls, M,rr.,,d
:ll).riurm celtEi el.mcntcacilnttuG ele$cntulsccrc
(ii rns d4i!!< rddp.a),caninl(!Ioro,ia) si sraiul(ii{s) ru
trgcdti,consdonri
nrcon\unI aniculmldcadca Ii'*rcn.rd
ca spcciicol.i, oDoziliectrclc. alt! tei elc'.ctrlcdc carcvr ir
(iod si judecr'r
vorbaindati: suhierd (pn0o<).carac'crclc
(td!da)Do'Ir Ricotcca..iniemc;dralrccuvide.popd'eLg.
34 ,.A cirtri inriurir.
(i; rijy 6Jvarv Sordv ixa f,doov).Urnezinrerprcrrcalui
Ro$rsni(,.ci,)ilcul
cltartodtu(orlltrsupcdcic
).fr"iconr.mr.
crcd,.u rpinN intcgil0i rdrgnf decaiintcrprrarc!oblFu.
itd: ,.ceraa ctuui scmnilicaric
c lcste dc desD'nr' (Burchcr.

COMENTARIL] LA POE]-ICA V ]JJ') I


v" e m,g t . n ...,
vn,f.,rr't.i,r../,..ht
d'

, . rc . . t ! . , d , it u , 1 3 , L ,
o1 . nh . . , n s u r t rq . J t -. i' n
,.,

n4'..'.p. )nl

,rld,cr . rd . r. rt .
.ri

r' r \clx, b...h.e.. c -\ . o

to,

\. _s0nc .

DLnjL t ci,r t d ric ! 1 mr J rn rc ll5 n


n 4 r.lu& q.ir e ..ttJrutdc
r (p ! n e ! f b c r. Md h rlu d f l, , !
jr!r,e Jli; porh( o tu
5'
. . r / 4 , r b r r |, rln ! e n c ra r.
.AErxret dn,t rh tdt.
I fo.x... in,lorm o L rh "4 r. , , , r, . u " , . |a ; , , , , , .^rq.r,t
l], |
p0 Lt,
'5q
B -14 Ci Ll. n
mmei / LA b!e' r

.l

i qn\odl l

px.rnJrruiqlr it \rernr c rri


no.r r. Fr'llrto ti-,n\i, t e n r(ru n e l, n d 3n ! d n ! o u s l, l
rcn , is e , r.

li lill;l"i",li'"""-"'
,, .15

.Mdi ri\cmr,ri

rrd c

rmb rn rrc ,

. u | a n ilt u ! .

rrr, .

,..

t2 Ro\rr/ rf,,g!Ll r. I n o re in , t r. ^ Dq
! r(a rl,
t0rurrLf tu I prji .je dalru m r, h , n r, . le , , q u n ru uf.l .L

*" a.,-,""i,*",,rx..v
:,.T"11(ry,^"*d.,,.,,
r3 _ r! rt)rc rt! r+4 i .u !r .inFr .r .l?tr r hte

e/ule

k l] lc t o r t c e l e l r L t e ) s i i . E t , I t ! , m . 1 5 . 1 0 9 ? r 2 1 { J ' } ; r
irra rd ro,rd rp.i 0!6! ndvrt< (.,ael lutru . i0 vedsd
26 Zcoxis ditr Hcrsclcr.nn
A ichir ii.itllirinadourtunihrerscc.dv lcr iDcdpXXVI
iasubicrclc,
1 4 6 ibl ? . A r h . o r e l l i { l , t r i c b n d i n t r d e a s i i d e
tund.indspnnq.laDedcacBipicrdidcz|uns,scpo.resllnu
mollc,!.c!$!m
.xi$c tuo!lcj i sctigiduicsc.,insusnilc
pdcrnsen,m rie ci are.rir lui vr fi he$ id chip exclutivla
ne
drlitllilccncr rcdcmodclslor.ficcivrLi!iur.riilcimp
30 , , E m o r i a r r a s i c i . i n i c x r : A r i ! , i i < 1 ! o ' ' ! r 8 i o <
rplo/,,,ctd!l rigcdici . cxft tr!
trgi.c nirnnca
d
'cnrimctrtlor
dcliniriavl1,149b26-2?itr&sninblcs,ipyovpoxr.tiso.olir
(cf mb lr 1417r8).
sino'lnn.u6!ivaB'<
(il r;
36 . . , D o c a t , _ . r m b i n r r c r i o I i m p I i r i I o r "
elefreireale
ndrFd,d ou!io fqoooo.coDrpndi cu coLeldrs
&rmci, conshnc. irtigii ! ri.Dr l)etrir{izi lriDciprlaIreo
cuptrea drmahrlilor. Diift hldur
cscrmilicdivrispunru LuiMctrln
Pluiuh.in rrc,intcbn.un sl c
vinoirl oon.u6.ttioluld.drrlci pic
{.bili.inbig!,ti cll rlmenedoars
oiy, Nl;vav6!(, rd ,ov;dLa..oi oij rijv (![Lt6idr oi
r.roirr'4
rir ai dnoipivdosd,, Nir roi< 0.oi'q iy!).
rirv
kd[{3i.v dr0v{tr!,o' }'ip riL6Ldo.o,q,6i
reroir@
6 a lri r d o , ! x i 6 e i t a r a t l D e E t o n t A d ) c ' t c ' s r n , a ,
Univ di
34? ejcl C. Corhrb, N,r.s,r,p.cd., MerrlEa,
p.
Tric$c, lsr di Filol. clrsica, Vl, 1959, I um.). Tot as.,
rturuisircaluSchillcri.t{sc
odrcdlrtoHunh0ldrGi.at1h
p.
Gudeman, 3{}3):,, .. nit dch PLxr{e vor$ Llew3r/e,{r.ir,ii
pcris.hc Arli.ir serar"
auchdic.iscnrllchu

t5L

an['
I

COMENTARIU LA POETICA \] ]4']


e ,L, . i.J.

n i. n i {

::;llllllft:+++*,;-l*...i:'l*;

cuddnh stiprspm;L .i wtrb.l; ,.:t __"r r. .;"",


r" .",J.
,mnea urc' a.!ui. !innnrs csiorceosjvir$sc.
rlirntr
mJimul nn'm

px mLlclir.flfu \p,"^ t _,tr_*,,t.."


e n . , d , c L l! inrt \ . n \ h rn t rh l
tr(imr qmd utrdvftshcNticbrn dic frl$hesrn..
vrcn.n:hr

p ,6or . rh trpa& !rh.t rir . e e r


rcP r!ri uL. !.{ pr\d.nuc h $
pro.e* ip{y!hr!a !n.rej * . 4 n ! o u $ rrd . . L lle d \ . rrird .
c\e, \ $r nh b! ie
rqins

lfti:;

s' o mb tJ l1r,

-'

".Mr!
""

"'iv(nv'idr

,."^"",r
. rB

'r,t,-"r',.i

o q r h t s r;

o.

1;< o!\'rd' rqi liuxiv

csrrur l si potr ivjr . cn cadr[orr!yra) rdea rcaincDi d.pdc h


!.robdc nni dncdr darisentinifu[ni
7-\ C. r de ,7
i rc-\ { mu rre)On!, m
nrmk \
r nrd!pnnsjfl,t'i!

rii!r

n ! ! I e r, . r4 i' u ,
. rL
lu o o ,
ru u o r. , r \ it u 0 0 . t u . ra . r re
!u!rr. rn'; la \r3r
Lm , v . h ! , . e rle lln ri \ o x li d . :
'!
u,rore ct oui'l
x I bx. .,. m!t!q F (!! L EhDrJc\
srrmdrc. D4l a..cdr oiabri{,
e.,.,i r *um i. a.,i"".iin
rr qur d{p'etr br rrd b\! n r
I
!,tun . q d , l! { ! n r , rn i L lk m.
.)np,4ru\' -Dsp^ o,4kt u
p
u tr!{h J!filLlJ in..nrrn , c ! ,
u _ r, r_ . .
^ , t . , r. * "

.. t' {'i.r I
l
1 ,r'hB Lp tr/ L' L
.i .u.deLldlblri, t-t,.r, b...,
r' p 1 i n
., \'
L
|' q . iL! .
ripr 'J.li
'.otc
.
r
t
'
I
,
'J1r'r
l(! d ! I d
'.{."li!!i,,
I l rnbic c ideale.n.tr
o lo $cnario occrsionalcdellxsu
dio\omn6iiro,la.hrusa
,l^lc F!den,J,..,n t
'fl
pEehic.ctcrilbcncdclpopolotfco Erchitoirchit !rdrcrc
vcmnetrr pot'rilo deltr snarrgcdir'..
r3 ,4 .,CDman mar spus.o..Cf vt t949b33.
.,
oe , 15u,i.,
c.d.e
rrirn t d e r e D r c 2 c n r a r c . n i c i d e a . r o r i - . L a r c l . x x ! t
1 4 6 :. ' r . .
por/. ,,.sia iI,o
v ^ o a. . f c ' n . J ( t l , . . i m p t , t r i - " a : . r " G d . ' i r .

14. b.--':q--i;-

4E-',

qii f-i

.-.

t . . . p , \ - "' f . r . i , J i " . r
-7 -p . t
h$er dd ,lu i. ,
rri.he L-.re.'lt'.,t'L.n.r
\Lp
c t,- e.et-.1,.
'
i.
-. | . ddnLn. ,'e r. ,.orJi
m. e ri n - r . J . v . . .
trMpmsi rotr; quellapo.siamrunrlrtucosr,bcnaobrudacn!
. , r. d, c a , - , . d , . . h . . r
ndon dci loo ve6i. el e$i lcsi non li c.irdno votcnlcri ..li!
ch6csismnochequcttdpesiaiunavocernor,rcui ncsuna
:l
13...

'v.'

''''

ild, lder e,

UjJ I
L

-4

r'

d iim Jn

udd. , . - .

'1.
. , re d . - . t n , r u i
mi , . i . , p u . - " d i p . / . '
r.ra l'...Jru',,
"
'.ude...h
ru . . \ n{ . e u D ,i ! , t u n . i n \ - n . !
.h,t.,",u .t{xr
htAa.,rt..
tci,11 .12 :r. .l
P n 4n o n . C L { r . c r i , r , r . r '

COMINTARIU IA POEIICA Y/I /!'

VII
.^ c ,r
^1
':
-.'Lq]!r.
:

.
mre r

L b,r ,. , | \r.4r!0. . ,.r


nr ,i ,,,,,
,., o , ,.Ld.

.i . , ..
I
\-.,
I, i
.,n,. .
'
i t,1 r.i rf
i ,:11., I a.. .faJ,.U to2L

(,e :{ .t

Ll'o

o,i !16r,

dr.drr

o^o

,,
-i

6. I j

d\t\.| ..U unoD ,.

iil

o\opnm,.d h'iLtrct!"knis , . " * . ^ , t " c l, " ^ . . . , 1 " " ,


(nr\,

lr

1l

1 4 s 5h t 4 ! rm

mutk . r it ! < . r, , "

::Iilfl''*-''"**
l5-r-

lRu bA nil Ct rort r, . X ! l

pldr

.f

, tj \Jn t!\fr

J. nfi.c

r rn

",^"
kt

J," 5'

.,,.,,.,;

iL!druri

"..,r.,,

, lnci ! ri,, rlJ,\!


! n(trr{rc
mitru!
rrlf
s!in!rd,rr!.
i.,nk,tu
\rno(l
,1.
r
D !L \f(L j tureftc I {u rtr[ sp r r,r!
.c,,(! o,ei,irf
InTr{fJr { ui rnn rtr, !!c
n5,\

,,r.ru ,
!uio!

uor

I rf!

n , r{ ,!\n !

"g,,to., ".n"

.l y

,rr ! . .i c r pr,Lt. r, x , r c
Nr

,Ll-

q'r m\ / rn n ahnrr

. i, r " " , b . . . , , i, , r . r , ,
"
.
,
r, r1 4 rrr4 J . t
i. l_ ij
m

l? l S , . F r n n o s u t s r i i n m i r i ' n c s i o r d i . e ,
(1!r ldp Koriy ay F.'i0(r or rd{a idriy).Dupiun@tebo
t s rrd' n c d d a x l l a a M . r " r . r ; ( r . t 0 7 8 a t 6 ) , c a r l c r c r c t e
didin.rivc e lnmosuluisfi .pcnru AutoEt,.dincr(r;n.).
nisun Gu!r(rpid) si calna{cade
a fi d.refr in( (npL.Iiyo,).
ArcNi ordire o glscnc ritozoful N nubai nr $cchcotul stcretor
ccrcii.acir.rconien'pltucilumpl.&orcligirir|ladnnr[s(De
/rn anin.,I t,6,11h 13),dnrsipcprmar..a.liruvinrti lpdc
dcrfiiurlrdtr4c pohvn unci ren(hiclinrarpulin viiJircdec6t
!!er crc dcremni dalil dElor. dr nu maiputir rcri (Pt}{ ,
\lll t, 252 x I t: De ecn nnin., Ut 10.?60 I 3l). Mai,nuh,o
odincrse$ilrirddci sep@rdc\c.pcditrinsiri vjxl!seirtil
Ins.trlcbirc gospoditirc,6miiori.uDdckseleiipinir
1(
''
1dr yd[o< ]qa!< ]i< iorL rdi ri' (ryori,y dyo]&iov
.irdfiay (i,o' (Polr., vr 1. 1126r 29). asfel iqcllasi,
,,oldirca annobricr sc infttiJeri cr !n rapo4 (t\o'y04)inrc
.lcrhcncrdu e.ceoacecrplicipeDh.e,ib?olrtodc$oner
D cuseanlinsDdiulnareMri.ilor,alciiorobiccreconnnuil
dompodri dc csarnde or dc itrcglli1dc itrtc cednt. dc pnporii
nutuiiinnahrrii$ciccr.,ciina.dvirareati.ctuuion,pscarcdfti a fi sr-i adbuin prr.nirarea uncii din ?rcbr.,rJc rlNnisc
subtrulrclclri vna sro vldi dcsliisnriDd!-sc
dul urrrn
lp.cinc(xlx33,920b34 921a,1)inrturJnccclckicar@rcrc
8nintus, Arirokl ponsncirc utrmn o aDtrnia
(rir.0D<),
'nfrinc
diptupoiie,caunrdin.o itiitclmnostrtui(a.h.I,l'mn'.lv
7,
ll23b7:fi .d\\o< ty ry.ilu .;u(rL, oi [(p0i 6i ddrlioL
ra L o ua s i r p o r ,r i r o i 6 , o i i . c t . t r e r , l , 5 , l l r j o b 2 2 ) . c a n r
cazdircodinii. nirMi si timircr,srcrudc aplicrlica ded dcpiisaste
orcar decuin,sm pirea
'romcniurc{eric,imbdr\turd
Enit din Arni.a. pc c.m a,r
naiavotprncjurs-ocirez(vx4,
1326a3!m.),opniianh.futui
,.dici drpr ,.ide!I..idul .umra
cct mai Drc rtrnrr dc
rftuiiori codFarib cn . b!trd ,nini$alic.iD mar#e drnftii.

COMEI\TIARIU LA POfNCA V/]I ]AJ] I


rcesirlrncaopn,s, fie d0ih mo<_lejjc.adic!.denlbdtsd
nr n rc:.h.rur! mtu ir; lt r t ra
^
o fr.LcrriJ|
mri _JuJMt e rl. rJ J ! n n u d u lc t . L rn lh e
(r!d !r r.eAb

!rfi r! d,

mi

tu\im! inglLruk cl ri\irenmJ


rtrlon'h
|1rl;rro
rurdoo.,ou4or4!iuL
!w4. . r( )oi u!{rra(
. ;,Ljlre lr i!. c Ll.^! btr mrnJ
, ! mrrm, )n I'.!!D ,un.

['

.ol!r.

ri epu: JL mr\imr mflnm a,eahtd,


sru(,,n \\a!utal

ril'

lir

rct(,cikre

Pr \trmei \ind \.i

9 ..ctrn sc zi .e c ir sc ticea
indoicrdc,osir{ndpeq,reni,t.dnccta
l2 ll

C rru r,,

I I n c . ! \ J f a -1 , o ru ro . d , c ;
tr hj m! ilrmc
_.,^.
-p " , , r, , , t " " "
mdN\k
LjpdoE J. p..kr
Lrrl i I, pnmrtr rcmu s,
'r\
r!.^rr!io't

ro r !^v yL'd[.yoy (.,verosnnj]tri


c*cce.a cc rcintarnDlid.
J !e h , ! r. rr L r"/ ri. , i M. r4 h . I r 5 ,
::,:.T'1.1,,1,. -,
.r.,v (,.tr(ilcsautnuingiiduicc.
trDlucnsncal.tcldccrrc$c).

VIII
l6 . , . C u n r i s j i r c l r i p r i c

trnii_ cudeniap
nresnpune
mul0 reoticied din stc
kt'iii, anlorionlu' Anyorcl. cu mai nnh! drpurc, crcn,
Ro$lni o ptrncin lcsih,:i cu plncmlcrdezvolud id dursul
urpirolDlui,
undcacclrsivcrh(di.!rat revinepcnrtr I ircnta
$.oieii
aleperiroi
3$ircro
2 0 . , , C a r eo H e r a k l e i d i , c . r c o T h c s c i d i ' D n ,
rrop@iiiindelelrcili.uHe(klcs,inrinrcdcvremerloiArnbrel.
iTvofelepoincnes.dc l(ynlith.n. Pmlasis si de Pcis,nos
din
Litrdos.n senJcsc dnb0ic lui Zopyos, Diphilos si Pythosdakr
24 , . f i c d . o p r r c t i c i r r r i s t
I
a
d c l e t r . u l l u i I i r . s c ( i i r o L6 r d r i r l r / i i 8 r d g t o r y )
Lacorc fomularil. ificbrc{ c MrLdin c.le ce ru prcocupaiDri
nult F rcoruticicniilircrurii Andchir ii, de la Epihrn \i
Denodt piinii I ruk'd motrim rl darrruhnrAprc s!hr,, Cum
cs li.sc, dsl)unsurile
auvand dWi vrcmisj dupi Fnotr3lirrrs
gitrditorild,cuo viidniiprcdildieacodaliralcnrului
(Epih,n
ap. Diols,Frsm /.r Vob-.okr.I, B 40, p 204:{'Ljd,r ira!
dNoroy iorr 6.Jr.poy 6i lFvodra,l) ,,ruourotrmurccl
fr.idcp.crcp,cdispoTilir
nduririiinrrdo cxrird,itrvr1iloraj
ct.Pi.dr, Olyn,p,IX 100:rd 6i Oua Kl.irLoror ;rav -..cu
irc, ), DitM lx doctida purip.
rcrci.iniprciuirorr.crrervcasr cedlb0nitor!tulidcoporivi
(Ncopl.lcmosdin Parionlr
daruriIirctrl si o teelllle specialll
Phibdenos.rr.pi nolrldrov V,..1 7.r 8 un. 6i 6i r. r;
roJ ii no'.ir Ki roir d00u<rolii rildooono,r.oir ..!etul
elevrrar1rncv.ic.pcllingli$ii.rrvcnincr,i,!i dcpsnn$... r
cf Ho ntr,rdP^,,cJ4i)r ,rr{) ,atu te,ethntrhilr.rinlnar
nt sn'e&dtc nctt, / ncc ru.Jc
rn
,.\ n8.bd unii oircnarurilc
lirsisrtrmeiesuctrrcr6er/ipoeTiavrdricrdc!cc! drmclEu
urcatip\nrdc.vj\i1609di,

D.M }IPPTDI
nrcjr,'imr!l reflupLr " L v,chrtr,lji t( Je(, kmc deu
ruaul
.,yonurnr.erorg'c(ariau lia rs L u ih re t u t \ u t s h lrv _ d u 0 i.
M4ar4. Err11M I L,TnE ii,rirc{edr,ls urLh. Amtr
pirbrasddrcd
:\L. tcds.pp t35 20r i".tut sp*"r r"i
non0. oprn'acomuoi in(|in: 4 cxptqe Lts,vrnfr
"r
oRtrr
drbuind nuo. ?dcvrnre.,nnu,,Jivme, I um n rv;r d
q.L'-rnc Dehldr,
";ddli
o!rtp.< duoo. ;or!!
(4Nd1< d!'y uqor
'nh ir. riu o ro n o lro rlv . . Ho n (
rundprrdeoJircLlumea{j,r
inJ !,r u ditrir lmonioJ,r
nruundrrortuur@ick . l" . E n J e ry u x o k . , , u , B I
n t4l
rr..1 uratre La.oar,,ror
d. I etthauflrsn !h.z ks
prr.sopra pdr(.'4u.,.
pMs. 1934,D.2B urm. j D M
p,pp'd.in.Be\ che.r'.xv.t94r
pp.79 3rrl.in te^rtud!u
re,!6probkmr,v(/i m,j Jcp4rcomcnr,nu J yvjr
i155a12
2t 2n.,Fapr(t dc , n f o s L rt o , r p e , n u f , rc le
^rirnar
h sk5 dcdri / irk \ rx lu r t n rrmp : f { mh h u a
@nlre,inrrudc tn r;d! ;l xtx cr rt o.rs,
letsMle
ryHh. r pohhr I (r&.i a rk,ukt vafi rvurtJd5rojtrc
o edr,.
3 po.muluihomen.ri oft . v;o)h&i, n! r,
!.(sut ji d
cp6ldur.nftg nu.id(A'o Mreaol:rc.E rn,turde
uniedmn
rsr3enqpm 1:0 r.qbt u : i& c . p L , J . r, ii. L lc! E me
e _ in
rom, d. erhr cpnoduiit s , ru io s c u rn t u p t : F n , Rc p . t
rnttutu.tionr I o.trsft Pei\ 1v4
r.tp. 452-459n.tn scner4t.:suprr.rEiit;homeDC
in oDsa
W Altei. l/u,r.
The Onan and thc
rr&rf,6{Dn,o\fd.l t02.r,p 25Buan. D S MJgotilltr,ft.
n.h.t.t Aniou. o,farJ, tq21

2 6 ..S i murrrc? n rbur ie, Elnodbr .p.ktu,


inr ir er
pqtunrsnrc| mr. cindoJistuqj,{6c cisc\uqBlr Llctic\Dc
o,ueq rr(* d, |]etu: dclirtsn!,re.(rtrwi ru odc 0;!nrnrtcin cJ,r,r cf xrnkcj.E!,
piot. Ctrccot F.4'Entd.
I tR

tA PlsflCA lX ta51 r
COMENTARTLT

1.15tb

IX
\

s r s .i nr l m l?- 13.,N u i nt,l nnl r r ( c ,' p- ur ;Lnd


(oi
dld
du'
nv
r; -y,;uva...
lc
lavoLro).cr. Ir.ropci.ru
a.tu!, p. 49ji, rtr scndal,
tnibloma$poiudlor dinrto
cutuc discutalIlnacc$capirol.Burchu,
oczicAiistorie,as-a
133-249
p.163-19?i
vdgnnisli,p. 14si trm; Bignami.pp.
c K m . 0 , L l L n h e B r u t um r D o u l ,\ W C , m m c t h . C r . e k

l&tuics XXVD,
AttitndetaP.ctty utd Hhtorylsnhj Classical
crleky loia, Xurtvoi Fi,rz,'n Uitoir er rnr rtcnsdrnr
Hardt.Entcridnssur I riquiic.lv),
trtqn C (Fonddtion
andcuqesGenr\, lqss.nr 35 ra5 (J! Jlclali E
'tndInh,I dESnenntd Kapiteh van lJrtotcld P@tik,ln^i.t,ne
Antjkc

ud n dene Tnrunt. Nerr Anr,Jndlrhlrr.Bnrin. 1c62,

.4rn 457J,N. Zc!c6. we.enrnd UBpdtne.tcrua\i'.it.n


/".hK.hrlhua!,Diss Koh, 195e.pp.5670.t.w wrlhrnk,
TnEed!. ,Hdor s l\ L960 pp:16-)11:
I lls rcr y
'
D
J
C.O t /int , rE!'. H,vvry,n!l a rrr.re r Srh!o/.in , Prtucc

5i.,et] .n! 13olN.s6r. re60,


ditrgcnrrl'cCrmbnJssPh,lol
E\lxi st 1a,,Potitjquc ,
I4-r 9: R Weil, ArNotc eflblain.
(LcphilosopheentuedLl'hisloiio)
?eis, t960,pp.163 173
',.
I,15lb
l- 2 , , l s t o r i . t r l i u s e d e o s e h . s l c d c p o e t I r i n
!ceea cI unul re cxprinI ln prozi Si alrul rn
v.rsnri... Gi ri) Lr!rpa riyov i d[{pn &d,lapNou)
htivir prcizldi dupi cdc pocrianFi nundd*ar leeaa dc L1d
lira veNului: .f. 1147b 15si um. si Conrtratul $b &e{ Esq
rrptc
4 5..,. . ci fetrrrD c5 untrl inflliteaT,
i
r
r
c
c
l
i
l
a
l
t
t
i
p
t
c
c
e
5 ar
l
n
r
a
m
p
l
.
t
e
.
rie v ea
p
i
v
(
d
\
r
d
rd
rdnro 6u4+{, r{ rd!
p u ro a l n r a ' n p l a
r.drtvo \irav, rir ti .i" dv y;voLro).Ce.@ruii$!m
orciealirdtaistorici! {p0txconsiruinofi vul!nc'oporcdc
po.7ic..,Chirr
de, s arinrilhpla(poetului)si si clid.dcil otcm
pc luciurilctcure, ni s! spnie' i dcpdc, 1451h 30 ti um.
-i' d f i d u i i . d L n a c c . e i p r i c i , n x

T
D M PIPP1DI

LOMENTARIU I4 POETICA]X ]151 h

op!.ca mclcdninfi mpliritclorrctre si riea$ d,h cnrcro.


rh'l sip.sibil sl fpdEaci it.din rce( punci,tcvcdcE.cel!c
loa,.AdcvtirdrdcosehiFnr
(cuf) scpore cii r' c4. xxln ].159r 22_24)in frDtul ci in oDc.
,clrlhflr...\prr\rc!nre.
lmr n n A rc a (t u n . ru ili

,'+15.c"!prn"r r\ "r I (r!x e'r rmr-derorp.re. uc i0rf


ru,tri.epn!
ksrbrr!d uiut5r

n n mriiFoolux
dtrll
'n
dciibiliirorrIr'p!,turi,re
to\
rg , , -,
r" n , r" . ia , |k .
frnlul muir: st I e r! c!J ' ! t r d t ' mr irlr. u lir o c n k ! $
HeoJuLL,unr,rj
* i" r, r. ,
. i; n -" t "
.rr! fin \ \i.ilrLr^*i,Llep o \ rL le n-,L
r. . " .t,r! lin s ri, _ r rDU
T,rme
3ao! rpDy0ir - sc irtitnc|re i.r,ui crpirot it ls.o.rr.r mda s.
rlrib$einrcrcpcnmii
divi.era uiarrdupicmdobno..ctelirsi@
dcaprrurcsmrrnsc.smlt)lolilice,crrtju,"u,cfi&I. pri.;idi

, dc { inm! bs! ine\orcrrt rc cr. A rturctud,rl^,

d!r,

,! jdque,. JI, p. 639 si, nai dc cudrd. D.M. pippidi.sri /,


t'hitr\.trhnr.t tRrcK]'H(tu,]ate,in ,E r.E-(pr;;,.r. Db0.
pp 75-')2rDmpoh\r! nud ; r0 ! r r" n , , m, , . a " . , ! r, A " a .
preturcr.hr, rlc sragnnmdoNrcarccca rtutTtrcjdide,r
.ir'ci rcndlqldcadespindcdirtoulllpticihrcxcveninerr.t{un
urryc :/jsroicr rrlrurdcsiSusi rs!ip. cuminccrc*odovs.
Jc.. inJlrr.\ (\ 4p.rr../.
t.t 2J7).sigutueepl,(Jrc:r,er
rritudn,irlLmiircnr'exp h . rh t u d rp d ! d n p rc f e rnqpnt u{ or t u l
r.: \ !rinTrqiitiLle!ng; n d rn rp o t rh .u n rd ra ria , J mn . c
rc'drtu)dJ.lnnLjtj!.ir^ rn .
6..,Mri !lcasi., ( d n o u 6 a , d r{ o y )p e n k uDrc c iT e c r
Dlel.sliuicf. Erlr Nrio'r.Vt7,Il4l a20:;roro, lno .i 1.
riy r.Iruir/
iiriry {,pdyroryororamr;1ry oiror inr
.l !i rd dprdroyli/ iy 1 6 i; o r! . iy o p o rd < iln y (, , 4 t i
rbui srcradiotrcvaca {iitrF potirLclsauinletepcjuD!sunr
,nh 3dcltrrlncntridc$ani1,daci,!mcsi conviDserca
ctl onDl
cup!tr cea'raidcplcrdincftee{(rt.).
7,,M!i mtrti univ e ' s 4 t u r. (F \ ro y
rri ra o d ro u ).
cf. De inlctpt.,1, 0 1 J9 nn,: \;!b ii tua,t\ou 6 inj

n\.!'vor niCuk rrrilq-ldsa, (o0 iKdoror ri i; rIi, !iov


iiap,rnoq riv rnv taodlou, turlidq 3i riiv Kd iradtuv
(,,trM1csc
urive$al ccer ce sc cnunri dc![c cir mri mulli.
(ntl,,,lruii
t, rictr1d.ccrdnucorcspundercesicidcrinrii:
pdiculirc
)
otrl. lhccpdc di dtc ur iveralBi "Cdl ia$ dinrr
Dc pat. uir'. | 641,21: Ii; 3i Kdo.il\o! roLv.; rd'dr
nl.ioorv,jrdpxovro *a0dlou iil0rLv(,,univcdalel.srnr
ol\rct.i: cici numimutrive$alcccr c.itrrlhim la lrar nulri )
Apmuc tr lcl. M.rpl' , vll l0l3 b I l.
3. , , A i n l i t i $ r u n i v e r s r l u l . S e c u n o a ! r c r u h r l c o _
niodcmc.
vianoral &enu sccc tu fonuca dod'insicl&sice
,,Dict6parh iso,, tondac$tr h lr nrlals r$i8ndci h poesie.
cllc.omicml intclprdrdionvirnabk du DrlurulisNccirs{uci
c'cncn\.n iomquc selivrcnlbureslesbara161irran.{,cllc
ost! la bascde tourcslcs ciiiqucs -scne Rcn':Br.y. car.i
Drai,.lcfcsdrcalecft! ind,
Inchiiiuill din crpnolcLccclc
Jc tu do.rt'c .ttrrtq& en
L
lo.trr'r',
mulh rindud citrre,
10 .,itr citrda numel on nd i v i dur l c adiusarc'
(dv0'[daainr !o![ivrtlno!hiililozornLtri,trcavo'bnDlDi
u.i &sl)E tnzic in remeDiicci niai scncralit1lEtrh .m .cdu_
btca pocticlltrlzuiesb sitcxpinc univcaaluh oo-$iE ca a.eca
! individualtirii dtferiiekr pcrsotrlje |]'in dibun.a unui nun'e
Iicclruia trupa icipi la pscasul rrrcpiu as de dul'c, c o oPc_
ln
12 . . . D e r i u n s d e d o r c J i r i n c . D e d i e
trvcdrvl
$ncd,rdin roalcriinP.il.,dcdlnd Ci3rcs.,.Piriisind
ianbicll. r prins s:i tarc^ reinecu catuctf ge!enl \i \li inchelc
n$iat. (v 1.149b I 3). iar nu roD[i n, asr zis. Con'cdic
hijlo.ic...niem!n.n! cu Ar{otcl,.un, scntlcl8gedc ohic.i
cr. Dordr{ h coin.nb rl ia a'd.r, lui Tcrctr\lu(citrt lr
Bignxn, p 232. t. 2) .n.m'tu pe$otrsum. co'nocdns
'n
nuJr[rar. hrbcr. dchoi r]tionBn ct crliiFlosirmr .t.nim
inerraconnngec,ucrno'ncn

D.M PIPPIDI

COMENIARIU L{ FOFI,IC,4I-{ /4J] D

)i D o'rs h ramrc rut ' b (, a


pro{*r",.o.

g . i; l
-*;
j--1e:,idiaji;

s#""il:::i.tl";JH***:HS*

-.'riic-arcneRrir j.rorBur.h,;;G;EA

il

--F-ol-rn-j--!rc-7rr-o,,o

._,;
, , r""d^ .,;.. ,.
".,
elf j) ,r s,sali
inhr r
p 3 r i n fcl rl m n l f ..tr,.d.r tu.,
p..,r
,"
".,- "t.",r
".- r .
I ,i h . ,
hd.4,.^
id qh..,.\..dtlo.

:dnN0shjroni,t

i,d Lor.,,,.\cEir.
n_ar.
o r/! /o, -nrim(\,r.hJ.4rd..
ror\$e:
rh,y d !-F.tdr rTp
rd.\ o Btb,
'son i. ni,,ao
n..L.en h .y.sh,.hnI lcc. coudel.kL
In r'
h I h.. ,n(.fl3.ctr.
InF,c\ct,prcn.o.!u, cJ/,
'8-dJ.

ir ,,b r. r)
J6 ,.Le.ir

.a..,1,

Lte (re " (r

, r o a ! d ! r.A lf rt \ D! r. v c ro .

2L, 4nreut l u' A e: r h u n , in t e \ rt rn n e t h


e p lrt ic r e
dur re cdllri l0!:L .d hnL uh\
a,s . a. r, ,l,s*
i! mc k v u rr. u t ! re f v rrl
-rbra!'..inLlA !0a.LlcrJ 4 d ! c--r
unc',sau,porb,atuRi aul cuoDajtesc0dar,cend.Adr:
daiivut
iune ! ftupdu Ayor r.!ijcr,utu tu c!d!m,,.
Jmpfttrij ( r
wrJmowi/ U;n\. prcleidb,t)hrrui,
M,'renrnnrl 4d,!( m(L t rn o rh J lT rr. . d t rB t u n c
schcn.
svrunr(dsrrssrl:\ud!/b)2 n u . * r" "
a r* r.
rp r" -, r.
n Db n ri A !J[,m,donld id c , . c o n (mp t r, o n d , . mrrl
,urr!np're.L !n!rdin rae t rr,a t !
opcraruAnsrorol.Iubiddetnnoia
ridenlilrmodcst isriccao
prtuJc r f.tutu,tu,Jer f c \ p , n , f
*!r
r0 a r. / f k lt t r
Pfion,runkcii.tui,nrd rdon5cn!mhr.d.*u(\JnLfft
nu
o drli nrrcuitc ruscroarc alc ttri Arm.tan,
hd.ossbi in

2l..,Fir!
... s! i dcrlctc nri pulin (o'jiiv
(cr.,,151b26)crnn
irro! <ndldiva).Desftraraedttariaci
poaic
spDrc. pooziciin
Dtr.$r do rircsczl tnscdiciGi, se
gcnoral)ituit nu md m nevoiesi lic sublinht. C*a cc o dcrer
mtnl .trdsavur oiile ul \ urriu.e.umurirnc, tn,pdttiLJ,
.-ioGLd. a;;
s;,blA ii m, d" .fii;ur
dspozirF sndd.rl
maturEL riodur,sL$'l mr kEnuiid ih\FduGiu.i"bn
t,llg!!s ctrnimi(if,ksdilrdenroririLtrcrs! ad bba Peso_
tuFurpsei! (cu. DimpoLi!),(u
din acclcpa8ini ssculitdanalizi cutu le lamecul dcosobi.rr
'lo
op.rei sale, .,ld senlinenls qm nous font lpouver la jor ou
I'ioldrunu d utr pesomrgc rgel neseptudunentcn nousque pI
I'inrem6dianc d une nmg' dc ccrteioie on dc cetc inlonmc;
I iigdtriosl6dtrprehicr onuc'er consistai conprne qk
dms I q ptrcil dc nor Cftouots. I imasc Cun! le seul 6l'incnr
sentict, 1asinplificdtion qui conshtoFit i srppindr puEme
!l simplementlcs PesonDagcsiclr $an u! Frrectonncdcn.
d,.isil Un eft I.1,si pnlordemrt qucnotrssymparhhio'r5avec
lni, pour unc elrnde pd cs pdqu Pr nossos. c'ci_A dire nous
Esb opaquc,ofirc nn Poidsmdn queroh ssNib'liranc tcur
loulorer. Qr'un malhcurle ftrppe, a n'c$ qu enum p.l c panlc
dc h Dorionroirlc qdcious ,vons de lui, qucndtrspounoN eneh
!Dus. bi.n plus,ce n'e( qu cn rrc prni. de la norionrorolcqu il
rdcsoi,q!'il poudl'e! lni n6tu.Latouvajll.durcmancior
t616d'rvdI id'icdeftmplacdcespaihesmpdoatlblcsIl'ane
c{ a dne quc
parunc{tDmdreggalcdepdicsimdatCdelles,c
quc
losrdions,lc.
no@ nmepentJrsiniler. Qtr'ifpone dis l{s
6oorionsdc cs efts d'DnnouvcrugcnE noN apPir.isscDt
.omre vmis. puisqucnouslesavonsfaites n6!rcs,puique c e{
qu'ells ti.nncnlsousleu dePcn
cn noucqu ellc\ scFoduiscnr,
dlnce,randisqrc mtrs kinnons liivrcNcmert les pagcsdtr 1ivE,
l0 $pidild dc note rspidion 3rf inrcnsira denoirc Egrd Et une
Ioi! qucle o'mncicr noDsr nxsdan
,cs Crarspuicm.nr inrdrieu^. routc i'notion en dijcuplge.on son

D M PTPIDJ

COMENIARIU LA POEfiCA tf t452 a X t152 n

[vR vdiorsbLdblsrtJfrqun,] unEvcmJ\d,dn


rclc Dl6 clatr
quccu\ que d! 3tr,N m,1fm nrq Jud
h rcuLn r drtrr
'
oav4Dge doA
1liciqu jldc!hJ'trc.4nos pflr,Jmrmc hfuf
,{5 ks hlnher\ {6ales mrladA
tos blc. dunrnoushu
rnonsrus D \ic dcsdne ; onrtrke quequ.s
rN,etdlnrtes
p,L\ m(Dse\netuus rruienrFm?h rc! ( prce
otrelitcnbnr
rvccrJqucrkisrnroLlu n c n , n o ! ! e in kt ro c rc e p lio r
. . . 1 D,

**"
.lili;t
i;il"l',ll?,lJ:;;::r;l
"
2 r - 2 ""'itlt
4 .N u r n , , ,". ,.p *;,*i"
r ,.u ,,.

,r ,.

t;ll

atrr'k
\uh ccrre o, e r r! d c rrrL t , I e , (o u
io rr! <
.LnL (Jlnrtor rd, nopdo60[iyor
Bnooy).Ececaccva
rcpera,dup. pdipddicut Ntupiotcmos. Eoilriu, nr
Epnr. .jr,
aurntn,ir n\trcE Jntri ..nMinh
Lnlc
!nLrrr;Drn tuLru!r r.hrJkr/.1.u un ,ndem
Jc a
rov r4d&6or;yov rJooy GtsiXtV 1453
b22).i,r

ti i r c ar l r !to" .c f v x 1450b2426i

stbi e,,enie'rrr. I fscc uz dc lacut"""


roQ, (d., cu m rind md us: rd r{ "*""_nprirrcia"
:r 23 . Mrr cur.,nd p t is mu lUr

ilii
ill

l( r6v nvdJvov. rdvto )dp odu0nordraiiro (,,...riPeri


lcliilc. ii n!triDireacroilordc princjdii ln ultimclipi: toat
lcc$oa sunrpri lejri dc minunaft ) . In axc pasajc alc P@ridc,.
(X] .l54 a 41)a\_v 1460b 25).
I e nii $unc ,i trairrrk'tv
?..,Srlruia lui Mirys . indmtlr.oroElairu (po.rc
dupdAnioGl, cu usodcddueit) r d. Plfidh. atoscr, ,trn
uindi.rr,3,553 d, dud 3m cidera naruii i6li psdus ln cmul
mci cemonii, M,riou roi )\p'iou Kor'i ordo'v
d/a'pa0aho< dv6Fitvra xal.oij! l, dlopa oia< dr01<
\rr.oiy r{ rr.ivavrn rdv MirLov roi dv(I4v

d r s t rb rc c rc

I ruv,;rp!!) Cr.mx\us io lr. u h t t 4 , 1 7 b1 5 .


33.,.NeiTbutrtc..c ilc k a r [ 6 , , c u c u d e n u . n rb h c i,
p-ehdrerc,
ti tocde n n r! , . I q ru m: h J n h . , 5 c ro r.
'abj !.
fi\orh d rh r, n . rf . r t 4 5 2r ll e u m

J4 -r5 .,,E p i so a d etc.


Gn(od6'4). vatorcr tchni.i
c pEcjT{ii in cap.x ll 1 4 5 2 b Z 0 -2 r. A . iin le t s d
'cmcrutu
.

4.,,MinuDarea-(r;oou[aorJy)ccrellll

c i ! lrrk/jduiem

arlr, rs l){ o ! ru u Cr p / u

{D

m:it r

de sirtriLii ti rl,, re.u


lt , , F ) r l
r!srdrii
o
u
<
i a!rlr'dpLoIouJ.S
u ln J r lr c *
n o rt rcr ' ( o v un a , r .
lrlb lo r l d e f i n i ' ! i r r r p i o r u l r m r L U ' , 1 4 5 2 a 2 : ( m ' l r ) r r m
15 - r 6 . , D c z n o d i m a n r " ( r ( r d ( ] d d r . ) l n i n t c l c s u r
dcfini{jeiVIIl45l r l3 14-c,.imcrrdclaciarcnclcionc
h uoade nctcricne, sande lr uM dc ncfiicn! L! rltu dc rcrifnc
Gl< ,jrvxiar tr suoruxia<i il ir!{ia< <i< 6uoruxiav
2 01 1 . , , E d c p a n c d e r I i b r
docurgc din rliul. ori 0trmai vinc duDr el'
(!-radip{ }dp roli rd }iyr(oodt rt6 6L'i r.i6 il I1d

in conccprhSraeintuli.
rd6O.E cc}lcqm vir LoildcoseLi.$e.
,tu.
r
d,
r,:it.,.
., !{. Jc.u,srF uneh 7
.. '"
Dpli ", 6'
-.'
;""/"., o.\id^ F'm.iDr'11
F
,,i"0-;"
'r.ili
cvcnitu elein desil-tur|k muirumili{ iaenrEzc
]fi&i

l, t rT l
aSrt|I.ri

li tupon! i't .drc 5 d !.6, un(l t,rj rtesl(lrl('

rl

q.M PIPIIDI

LA PO|ICA XI 1452a 1452b


COMENTARILT

trl*:,";i;i;til1-'''';;;. **

diEnapetivnn u;t it pmbn


spkndide mhds et iD onnc fiea

XI

,sugc, gltc.txn iu&tu nrro.


,,sdrye,nc tonlnstihi nnn6 Mde
no' rn6 deto4so.dd cr sG/dt s

rii,ii
5$
sii;lg--:ifi;{i.

?j,,:
rri.r
::*'*:i,fi
:i
:r;rni"ir*if
".T.r.

i, .atc! quo tc nPiDntct tuae


lun fad Nox ct vuus; j tcculla
onnned

ta i

q nofttr

\.Pu.ta

scztrnquiclnn
3:r. ,,in ocdit : osdi_rsc. ve$unb 1050 l03s $i
1121 1135,undcesul.viruiidnrdezv unerimplcjuddlorin
d lusosccrcscut,!fl! derndonli crinn si c pcciptai in abisul
rcnnsctuilor ! al dsperlni.
34 . , . L 0 c r u r i n c i D s n l l e t j t c l ! + r x d ) E v o r b ud eF
cmuibnbc!rLjuronlanunitor,,scm'e(o io),$uPnctuo
vsftveniiicop.xvl 145,1h2lsinm.
14\2h
Rclcddlr e la l/iscnit i. Tt\t a
6 ,,rligcnia
^tti
Fldpidc,lo6urilc 725-?95,undc6ina lndcdinrcazrlui Pilade
o srisorrc pcntu ftrtlc ei. Rccutro
Ir reni, il rccunoa{c qi er ocvr nri riitiu. dupl ce Pilsdcimi_
nc!z.! scrioarea dsinahrulDi subochii ci (795 326)
lO..,Elcnentul pateIic (rdsd<)lninlclesultehtude
momenrdtrtoosrl&mei,-caE uoli, nulnacclpihdogLc.fn

#ffia$+ffi
glril+i"tl"rruffr

niq*#';idi,ifr

n+''ffif*'m

l2..,Dc rolul mo4ilor inliitiirre pc sceor_


etc. Lr.ei trci marj pet tasici xLecrror oP-e rc au ajrns
omon csubochiispeladilorsunrcvnab(o:itreuriisi|uciderc,
in Ats al loi Soroclc)Lrstrilc'rs.vorripctc.urinsrrsa
aneaT{ cr Eschllrr ri
inntJcNna,dcveneccFilo\'dt!ci

ii
'i
I

cotvENrARlrJ LA POE C4 Xlr 1452h XlIl 1.152b

j;:".."ril:{i.iff
li{*:ffi .f:lFirj*
lx*,f*r*"*T#i,;;::'#*,,.[mr:l:-- XIII

unp&t 16, alrtun d{potivl din buciri d@iede codfeuti din


Pcntus&srDo'(,$higgeh?lcocs
shle.n'k!cdecmlinhg.
L ic d ) c t . K E n z , o p . " r . , p l.l 4 { n m

N. pnq6 .a7rtu popta Medeatndjd.t,

XII

#f#*ffi
l +t5 M! | i n 3 rn k . cr . vt t450a
14.
s
i L i o re (e 'c

dc
Seir rDriizaacriMiit@gLcc,intcruprd
23 tinrn
bagi.
numlt
id$l
r
ea
.c
Butchcr
.,rhc
cap Y,ll, cu ccctaJea
hcro (cf, in cdsa-i in adtearindud cnrtl, intes capvIlI.
pp.l0z 133).Daoi turinb, considmtnb seRditddlj, oicnrare
rotm n ulr spE descrido t gedicidcsirariilc. cittigi tu pra!
zic ced cc picrd i' ecncrditars lnccpo partr prcptisricl a
Poetc.j. Asupiascmilicalici {Ltnci r rccomn&iiilor cuprii$c
ln c{p. XULin sp'cial,in Flcmicr ld Arisrorolcu invitirtuF Dlr_
loDicIdc\pr dn!, cf. Lb&M4
t 2r'
_
3 2 . . , N u s i m p l i . s i c o n p l c x i l l n c o n d i t i i lacd r a t c
3 3 - 3 , 1 . . , F r o p r i u la c e s t u i s o i d c i D r i r a i i c ' - o n
ni F, rpcrd dc a$rcr od. inccpetd cu delinitir din u!. vl 1449
bI 2
b2l.Cl.Ix 1.152a2ixI1,152
34.,,Oaneni do ispravi (irno(i<)lnscrseiclu
sivnonr(d. 1453r?l:6.. dFri 6rd;pov roi 6ud1oo'jhl,
ln opozi{iccuXv 1454b 13.u e!rkLri<tiebuiclnlclcsc.
itdicrnd,cnal@.uvi'ie,eroiida$rali
cchiva:otrtcuprrio!<:
(1r
ric
rele) supcrloarc celor ale conunnlui
ponin
buno,
cu

$$;"a5['rgffffilia#

P',"';il:;i;#,:.
li ::iit,ti:ti;"}il1":il
l,

36..,Rcpulsia (a6pdv).Culand c lolosildAisbtel


numaiin Pdtcr. fi numt dedoulot (acrs!)<IV 1453r l4),
potivnici dilci. ca inlclcs.se
pcnh a carfretzr o dispoTilie
apopic dd(in mai cneigicl dc ra/dv (.,spaina ). dcsprccar. sg
ciEieinRle!,Il3.1336a22 24:a; vdp sdvdv trDov roi
r; ivavrio
il{voij fti trrpordrrdv roi irlou mi rolrdr(

,li'*il*m'**{i{+iit.,t',',*

D M PPPIDI

;lT:i;;'il
fltTig.:f
liTl:.t;,.*':,,:r;

CoMENTARTULA PoEIICA XIII 1452b-1453a


totononic nu mi sc !@ de ajunsogtindilAin itrbrprcdrilc nnor
vohlon(dic mcnschlichcTc il nahme) s.u Bywarer(,.d'ehmm
l@lin8). Dirft {udiilc inchindrcchestrnii, cf. Trcmp deRq@r.
est 6,rdv0ponia rgnificatiore atque us4, ia
Do uo.^
'lrre
Llx,
t931, pp 2?l 306, 3i Umbc& Calli,,
,,Mnonosyne,
dor&tlo dr OLfdv0pdro/ se.o'do h Padicn di Arjs@|a,1t
c Rond , xll, 1931,p. 243 t um. Pcntu cd ,,rl
'Aie&
Siv;lapdrov, scnrincnrodi sjmpauaunLm, di inrsssaento ai
. nppreFntrti sulh sccm. a il
c6i dct nosto simils, disric.nc
Mesaio londo rpiritarc s{ cui trscotro i due prtc.lan
del' Ao< e del44R0<,chcAri$orclcaseg0aallr
scnrimetrti
talcdid comc di e$a c{atcrisrici ed e$crziali Ma ncll oFra
d d, il ctri compnoa divero daqdcllodell ericao dclla poh'cr.
sonpa o s tansLma al !uio, ii sigtrificatonoFle chedi laii
d ptuprionells vira
scdrinetrti,dcll ilo< panico,rrmenre,
(p
p@blemi
vezi sitcrsl
in
legitdrt
cu
{ccast[
comunC 251)
din Prou{ rprddls in conenraiulla l45l b23.
5-6.,,Mila penrru onul ftrr vin5, friou pcntrtr l45l
cdl la lcl cu noi .PrdzevizibilsuPc rlirdcbuiiiscrmd

t*$'u*x**
*r+$*+f*r$-m

It
lil

*ffififfiffi
_

9 . . , D i n p r i c i n a u n e i s r e s c l i ( 6 , ' a l r d p r i d vr t v ' i )
Cf.ELt.Ntco''.,v.3,1135b16:drdv [iv oiv rapald]o< il
pxdpr yivrrqL, d{Jmud 6rov 6l lir lallrdvo(, dtv.u 6!
rarid<, dsiprrK(dllardva [iv rdD d@v ri dpxir(v d'rrQ
i rii< alrad<, drrxi 6 daav i1o0.v) 6rd/ 3i Lbd<aiv
pi {po0oui\rida< 6i, d6irl|la (,,cendlricinuim o utindc pc
n;asEprate, spuncn ci c o ncbigarc dc scmi; caid trr pe
rca,sbprrrc,dd fdrl gind du. ii ziocn grcioah (cici ori dc cate
oi inepubl vinii e in noi comibm o lrc$alli; altmiDterio
ocbisdddcscam[)itota:r.deilapuecunn I. dd liri a n skt
s!.hjbzuin,rivarsin o mdreDtate.. ). ln brE sjhariilc m.ri2t.,
e! cetr, pc pin0l pldno clcnentul inbntional De acdr si saic
ddpE!ce{pasaj Cudcnan,p.242:.,..Fiir" Arisbteles...sind
drirr4a, aldprio, duaprdvokcineerhisch.n,3ondernie'n

D. M, PPIIDI

*,,::,::ll:"""
iifi :ff,J'::,I;t"Ji:l"t.J.,,J

COMENTAPIULA POEfICA XII l'153 a


lnkcrturd.u.(rrse etol"r xV l45ad lr 12 )!\v 14il
17
b 2 0 . inl . S r t u d . u ' n r " ^ . n r i , . . " ' r r u r x v l l l l a 5 6 r
2 9 . , . C c 1n a i t r g i c d i n t r c p o e t i ( r p d v ' i o r n r o <
r. rtiv no,r6v Odiv.oD Debunlsin!.ininrclesulcrccet
!L
n a , h o * i (| m s r d r t ' p d c r G s J t u n r t i ! ' R t r ! : u r u r u
lo u , u lu, f i q L t , L ' o ' ql 5 , r ' d n I ' v 0 ' r r O o 0 r o ' ' r a r o <
i EiNai6i< 3J0 ralri adBn, PYio<
oji i no ' rrF <
iiady!6iioo!. |.j' ra!ro'c !(
\i{dd *l m:
EuflPrde
siJDbtrlirPi d n
s
'uhirc3
(
k
l
!
l
h
pr\iur' i i r
rr{ @t . u mn d n r t r d l a a m ! z b d n \ u
Lno rrl,in.X l bR..,
und' rrl/c
tu.k pr ir'pl
tu.," i,' q.
-""u-..o*"nt kcJLurl!uricvo d'?Llee inteltAc
-,""F='p"r,*.,"-(r'i"tuD d...r"rc dhD I nenrr (GutremrL
idJc.;b
('mPl
-i'ro"r",
r inlocu'sul aLirulrto''liroroc nrn
mr!( Ddos
ruicodhr intr o
ff ;r;@r*,*F',)'dd'r"...iir,ItrLrc!d!
nu
riulduir\ (,
drdrr.uEckcrmlnn.l: 13 nntr L3l7
\' h !i
n!
lu' sr.(
l. e,rckt(le
EuriDide
'mniedrt
vd;,( cnlL il lu, surlde ! 'l ltr' E{h'l chitr de; nu I
r
inze{rat.tr sublifrr gnviuo li.u libra dcsivirsnedislicl
mt_
drcna
@r.r doi.rcnc@sori.i!r o poc.'nmric is,ihrcad
uDchiDnai ftzlnoal. cu ur simr al omliej JntnciNr cxagenr'
Itut ildoial{ cuno(a p. arnicni d.stul dc bnE pcnku a inicLcec
crbcmairclaenronulftcntsitlrctnuisultmnhporanior'
{u $ !3rc
sl,po'.u, nnd te.src S(Et rLnumclpriekr ar
A r lG b' l f a F a t r \ h i p d o * b r tp c\ ' t r | l L l m i n M c n s r r u ' unrsrremz p (Lnutr'LLesgrl](
oo4\ir.(Jschl.lcl,{ htlt\E rcruLc'u urur ui!irttdc tuc
ina,nks-n r khur nrr fe rne,
m lo55 p Jrol
x.Nmh' 'lc^\ffu.hemr E i rDno,Bs
r'grtu ui\\
CI qE NodhrlLr'D.Eu"depcE,Dn'rm'
HdleNcs,IIL r 373,pp 279-319i C Dia\a. EEipittc 'ubu tu h
VIll,1961.pP llT 14r
'dr,!a^n tuliirue.in 'Nmci

$1;11r:1{;;ffipi4'
,r - .n
< . - , r , r r _ . " - . " 1 ," 1 ,1 ," .r4o,.p
p

apo.

ff::'i;::t-";:;;:"-'""'{:ii;j::3::,:'i,::::::;:

::,T'i'';::,
.:'::
Jl';:*:l;;J|ruli;::;

"l-',,;*J;l;,::
::.1""
;l"i:;,:,:"
",1i,
., ." " " ,

" .:j i ;;;:::" " ]" ^ l*:p- ' i

I.3Dr ,4' "

J1 o d

:: :';:.i:
:;'r::l;1":i;:: i:"']ili,lTi"I

;,;;j"J:,;
ll,";i:li,q,
11
ii;i;ir

;1ffi5ri+":mn[#
s.il,r,
i. :1,:;r.:.x;:xril,.]ij:1il,llf
*,i

p., a, a,,
;r1".7a,-1,,t
",

i;l'.,"1r
:;Jj;i,l
l;**j
:r;
i
,""."-.
-j.;i:,:.,r
xt itiii":i"itT.1.li:fi;i:i.ff
"",,.,,
ii

,...ii;""i,,?'"""
"' '"''..'-', ' **,,u'
..

,,,,ii."}:#:;";
11i3;'
aru/tr.poa,c.
(onldi

;.ll'^11
o"*,11 t",
et," T..r.:',.,
,x_1.

p-.4i" , *r',-.ru,
1,. "*,:_,.
",.,r.0r.r

XIV

iii:;, ;'', ;D'


""."..:;1;;.:"ili:
. L horc!".C1 Dx
u!nuhtdvtqqhl

L,Lca,,..

**flffi

COMENIARIU LA MET]CI,

X/Y /JJJ b

rcao crliocchi,lo ip.e inon*iamnb c pas,vrmcmc.alhsci


narodaquellavhionc chclo ui8ecol suobntilo d, pasioMle
23,,U oi dc r c a C l i tc m es hei d6 c i tc Or es r c
MoDenrcdlninml al t|8cdi ci AItizilor ir lorro dari lcgendci,
duplca!sepft. pcnh intiit mi deSrcsichoos,
!i {uNicl6icl
pdntil.gia lui lscbn.
24...O'ia Er y l i l c i dc c {l r e A
lo8ond{din ciclul rcbatr,AlcNon isi ucidcamm, poErylile.
penttr vina dc a fi dczvihn locul undee asctndcaso{ul.,,
Adnsb. Dsvopdi, a@$dii Slshomo,neals Tmir.
1236
29.,.Medees.Jnragcdircuacclatinunc,vorsulile
30 .Oedtp a1 1ni Solocle . Oedtpfsqtu crc.l&l
!dinF, ercull9tucidep;rint.lc in cusul uneicenep.tccutc .,in
ildaactimiipmpiu-zhc r danei, potcrni id vdsuile 300i
31.,,Astyd{mas .lbatd A$ydsnascclBItan, auror
hSic conEnpom cuArnbhl. dcrpft c{rcscspunocne n sdh
dcheediiict.A&.n..t 33f 3,1a.
nnnai purindD2,10
3l,.,TeIesonos'.FeionlluOdiscusirlcnccr.desDd
cdc scpovenogeci, 1nmisdemaicha s!+i g{seascltrrrl. il
Dupt inJomatiilede
lciscsoint-o inciicnrc, Bri rl cunoasrc.
ca dispuncn.cpisoduld n fN. prt ln sceni de Sofodein
turdir'06!oo,j( drdvoor),,if,
ii nai 6rnu,dcApoll.dotdin
Ta6. Din op.n lui Soloclee E ri inspnrt F.babil Njr!.i tri
Pacuvius,Uudlri deCicemin tus!. dr'sr!r., II 49
ncc0noscud.
S.!r
33 34. ,,Odiscu rltrit . Tragedic
(rc,i
putoasl nvoll)adc oduooi'<drdvodn).i! a lui Sotbcle
nou prcccdcdril),citr6 de An(obl din ncnoric, cu utr tidu
modilicatdupi conrinurutpisei.
36...Ahr i dc ac c s tes .r l t: s i tuar i c nu- i .Afi r drtldl!rc Fineisi deiiza imcdi
draft.ricc inlililaro surr itr rumtu dc parro.Cotrtadicta se

*fi$?$**ffi

COMENTARLULA MENCA, X\

,,il;1.*+:'',r:,i*fffl
ft"ili#.,:,It
i,,jii :tt,,
;::ri;".*;^:

*tl'

; ** i{:::.;:";,::,
:u,;;,'llr,l.liij

;",;_
;;*|1!;-ij;:iri:iri;":i:

ir

,,"i ;,f;' :;;,;;r rr,t.|,l,,H.llf


'flT"tii

lffi**il*"r*ti

i:,J,t":t
;i:111,j;11
Jn-n::;nlyjlili,
,;
il;",',";;,i:f::i:
i;,i1iil!,
iiiii;t$,"i

"xlkrul::'iilT;'::fi

i^':
I tii:il:

\p L) o . Ct X lt t 4 5 lr t N_ t l

I 51 A

XV

cofrun,
1r.,,AlcsD . inirblesul dcsuperiorEnivclului
c u m$ s p u \i n . a p I l l 4 4 3 r l 5 s i l 6 - 1 3
1 3. , , A . s ac u n r i m s r i t a i . C l . V I 1 4 5 0 b 3 i i u m
?0-21,.Micar oi femeia c . o liinlI irrcrl_
oart . Aceer{ipisrc sc anlib ii in Pdhlca.I 5, 1254b 131
rd dmr np;< rd oillx 4Joa rd liv Kparrov r; 6i X.i0ov
('rpdnul de la
1alcmclI c. dupa fir, . Elalh de la su
Pcnhr
o clsdcrizm mai conplcill,feneii,
pcdor la infeilo/ 'nascul
).
I161
a
.l torusiRnc..I 5.
l 'i.
rcru nc!!ebnic .cf Potir,I13.
2l.,,lar robul
l26oa9:dlr0v };p rrdnov 1i ilan&tov ro0 60 0u ;pxd
rdi ai dn0v ron 0iI{<, R! dv,ip ra,6o'a rai 'dd'v
t/un.tsr( riv rd [{t a ria {'!xi<,
8u{pdvro< 6 [i, ]dr 6o,a\o< 6lu< onr ixa ri
Foul.urro'v, rd 6i oilr Lla [ir', dIN ;tr!pov. 6 li raia
ixe Iiv, drr dr.\i<.. (,.onu]libci0.snccnesciavuniin.lt
chipdecarsofl n.vesbi ori rdulrulcopilul r micrr c! plrlrlc
sufleinlni sunrlc.lextl rn brrc dcesc lijDle. ele Bxistliin necare
m,dtn m
altfel:sclalulcliFircu roruldccbjb?uinll,fe'miao
]
ho6laE.lrcopilcxistlam6rdorii,darncdczvoltaie
(rd
Recotundalre
dprdrrord).
2l 22.,.Porivirer"
oludtiti deflodirinFr^r..JtcAsd,i.l5aFl5? (cf.3l5 ll6):
tihi norts,
actdtiscniBqre n tatu suDL
nobilibt:qte dect nttwis da tu\.1 tunn
(..insc.nnli1l bine deprindcile fi*ri v;ric si di t[t{iurile
cnvcnitc.aadcrclor schimbiode o dafi cu anf )
23.,,Ascfrinarcr"(rd duo@v)Dupi o lcchc piircrcr
in lnrenlalui Ansorel.,!Plui Comillc, dopurii dcGudem:n,
pcnku
dareLetrdirici. ccca cc
dtnarea n r fi dcctr a(I)cciul
numima{i,.ndovirul kt ric rdnpiVahlen,uflnddcRstl8ii.
rplopisrca dc naluri. Accrsi din d'nI l.reqmrarc ni 3c plrc
.fe.ite ccvanxi depanc(145'lb 3-14).
lntlrtri dc dcsltrsirilc

DM PIPPIDT

llhlLiii]
i,tX'";1,i,?t
iiliHf
,',
-,,,'....,.'',",.,'"';.1-,.r"

1,l:
"r,,'.',,;tr:',ii,;;

ix"::;'ffi!]::::::.;J:
i::;::::::

::r"j;::r
il#:jri",::r#:i:l;Hi,;li'.
-" ",

i ; , : " " "i:; i . , ; ' : : : " , : .

"

e L r :o ' dA.cce i.,,c..e


.

^'i'-,1,1;d;;i:::jl;i:1,;";JT:::
:^itl

;:r*,iil;ftri.,#
;r:ffi r*rfr

i..,l,l*
rrflj
ii,*,1
"ffi f1"ilf

*'**:g*l*i*;l
rtffi#*r#*ifi
ri#,#{$,'{.;fffi
,,.
;;,:;;:;:,
":#":::J",..",i::;
J;l;l;llt

iir

CI]MENTARIU IA POEI]CA XV ].'54 b


cFu li.uti si ap.ri F. sccnipcnrus dadezlcexEsnurdilorcolor
425d:ol rpale6mobi, tno6;y rL dtroflio(y,iri rd<
Korrt|.rilovdtoen< aipoy'<),imporivaciciaavs
Brtxaydq
N deB jhtusit, nin .isnns ui.dicenodus
(EpisrdnkPrio,t,r9!192.Ct B.Stompo,,?ch.r
'r.,trr,
nctk tzsediasecz. Pd.n, 1923;A. spia, u,rcrsu.rd,gen
2a DeDser tn'cltirt bci Sophaklcsud EDirzd, Konniinz,
1. .M c d c c a . Tnscdialui Euipiderr ce, duplrucidcrca
rivllci ti a copiilor,croim scap,derrTbun,@lui laconirttrin
du{c in vizdrh pcuncalintuipar(vtsurile13l? !i M.).
2.,Epi s odurr nr oar c er i t3 r e. i t o a..) nl /;da,tr l ( l
um., ArcDrimpiedic!l eiecii de$0nj4i si ia dnnul p8lci,
munratrdrr c!6ir Troici.
't...rr OedipuI |li Sofoclc .ElemeDrultrlional
la
cuc seIscarluzied lii dupiXXM4a{ a:lFl,, ienordnla
erului
cddiriilenonii lniLrios.
'lsp
3.,,l m i r ar er tr nor oaoer i m di atc s i c r ndi ,.
13,.M!i

'lc

aoi (trr(i<). Vczinrisus,nolll,)fiI

14 .,Asrrhon" Citneaetudoielnici
Dcsprc
Agrrhon
drci int adcvlrerolbr depoctultragiccuace{ nnm vzi,mai
sB,nobl al Xl 451b2l .
I7 - l 3.,j n s c r i c r i l . n oasr .e p u b l j c at c . As upr d
rnlerosurui
&.$ei dmnei. veTiIntadDcctc',pt. t2-11,\i
A. Jatrmne,Ir.rd css.rertt dt r4r,itoEL,|tr .,Alli dcll'Isliruro
diScienD,l}tdccdAni .Il3(19s.11955).

COMENIARIU I.\ I4)EIICA XVI ]151 h

XVI

{Tmd.MMtr:..... lc muMlo Prn


mishlnl slll vetreD./De mnai vcchcdctc acumbimna / si plpl-

::
;r;;;,."';;;1ig,
i1$*r1,!1i|{r;ljpm

2 3 . , { i , l 1 l e l d e p o r c a r i . . . O t j 3 . , X } 1 2 4 7 2 2 1 , mi

,_";;:;fi:il"i":
:i.,ii:,:;,i.,,,il:,:;:;;T::ff
tl

il

rl
I

ffi

(l 6' ;i'. 6i, rdi oijF dropa6;< it\ro' rL s.i1d,


dOpt I Lu ]vijrov rror!0irdv I ivi ousd,.
oiliv. riv nora r( oi< ii\dc ror;. dsdvn
napv,lodva lrod/ra onv lidoo An'o\ritdr
Crnd.Mmn,,...si.ilcusudUlis,/v-sltutrscmninvederatcu
.m / si mi cunodcli si si.ni dali cza: / e ranacc ni !1cd
dhhtul / cu .oltu-i alb cetrdcDti'sci cu lin / lui Autol'c pe mun-

r o i < N i n r p o , < )E
. volbi dc
3 0. , , S c e t r r B ! i i ' ( t v
rcc0no.lrea lbia I onenis r lui odi$u dc citc doic. Euncbcr.
Vozinai susnoralr 1,154b27.
30 ll..,Nrscocitc dc poea.Cu alEcuvinle,md$
cuqand io chlPDeviabil din sihpla desfi raE a faDtelo..
rrgc'i' Tsui.ta lui Euipide.
31 32.,,in Ifigcrir"
pomcniri si h.i in.inte (xl 1452 b 5 8) int o odinc dc id,ti
rsnrnibdc.
ca ce Arhbbl ti
cilitarcdirrici ! celordoul Euno
culnimnt rl dE rei: nno.r Ingcnieidc cikc OEnq d loc in .tup
riE$ in clip! cenderoinaincftdinlc
pcdrfl ai ei (versurilo74? { unn.), cati vrene dezviluirca idcnrir{tii lui Oftst c dontl {tecnr si inrinli ctr aryDncnrcpuP it
guralui de poet(vcfurilc 300 si lm.).
35 - 3 6 . , , G I a s usl u r e i c i i i n ? c . c r l l u i S o l o c t e " .
Drm lui Solocle(N{uck. Tns. Cnec.Fnqnt:. p.212 n6.)
punc! in se thra povene a iicctor lui P.ddion, Pocne si
Filomcla,dc c&ci ninunte nc sunrlllstraE ln csntul 3l vI lea 3l
hi Oritt]r, ven dle 424-674 PiDgIitd dc
Mehnonuitot
ctrmmrllci To*!,apoj mutilarl,sprca nu si pureaminurisi

*illftt,i#:;**:ti,,,r#,

,r..r.,c,'a,s {tr,s6
;;'[l,:l:1,,:fi"""",
"- ri&_d dp imoy toirda
dhxd,
ou^ry, a,i, nor; r0 oij<,i\qe

r3l

d",.d.',a''",.;
li:il::J:tTi,:ifi:iltJ:1""'
skni,a
batbtuin rtssnati caniLkb1a
purpurcsqle ,otns tjtb jnbxuit
atbjs,

udluereidt dannJc
s.sLu togtt \s7s.t91

,;.Tlr:lT,tjil::ffr:#;t:il;jil:",;:.
i;:...il]::fr
ll.:,;-,'

:r.rir;ri'lri:i"tiiilr
;hil
I
;;
;;,;;;;J:"1;';.;.i".tril"il*,.;,":::_

|A J"OF17O{XV ta55 a-XVI ta55 a


CoMENTARTIT
9..,in rtd.di lui rhcodcc rc
vczi nai r$ norala )J 1152r 2r. Dcspd o hsodie a lli ioriruldi
10..,1n Fj,ctdc . Tngcdic ncctrnoscuri
{ mui auror
necn.oscut. Nu sc vcdc lcsi{ura posibili inh subicctul ci si
legcndr rc3oltri Finc!, pcdcpsn dc fednauti pcntu rinnc,
r3 14..,4.1iscu vcrrjto. Dt,ct,or"(
o6uoon<
{oM.y}Io<). AliE tngcllic nmunosclla a unui ruror nc.t
nscul. Ca subifrt, rcbtris si sc fi rpiopiat dc cupnnstrlulrinclor
13..,ID Oedr'p,J lui Sof.c1c . atddrptsc, vcrsuil.
1l l0 ti trn. Cf.}.1 1452r25si33.
llt..,Iriscnir".Itgc,r
Trrn.irldiEuripidc.Vezimi

'-". j,l'1":ll";T':.,::,'"::ili:
iill.;;.."_
l..i'

po\e\E i

--2

ru, A l! io o u

O d , i v rrRl

XVII

r;rrl'i:"r"-'"s"'"'"ii
;il!:tt*#llh:r
$r

23...S, si tnfiliieze irainter ochilo.". Revine


r spuF clpoeNl e datorsrcatrb I i
alc drMei ls c@ lucreur,tucercin
nai p,a*ic nn Dumri Desu I rchunii , dar p6ni si asFctul lizic al
peFomjelor .hmte s o FalizeT:. I n r8asri ordinede idei. nu i
ftrl inrcrcs m[iurhkcr unui dFmnurg ca lben, t! legituri cu
crcarc!u!ui! din cioii srr:,,Auchiiu$erlichnu$ ich vormn
habcnbh auldcn lc9ten Knopf, wic cr slehtund eehl,wie er sich
bcninnr. wcl.henKlrng$inc Stinmchal (citatl!O.wrlzel,

*,ilt*,ruull,',,*I:*m
a1 .lttE enta

ur po/ y id o ! S o f is ru

jahts+,lj:rr;[#:j:ii''.',
jjl
;..#:r#r
j:
.

p , i" n ^

26.,,Karki tros".vczi misus.noialrxvl 1,154b22-23.


2G2?.,,AhIi!raos .Nn Jlimd{.it{gcdhhkcagiq!
a*tcl i nuld!|, nicl cdrcva fi lost dul pcs.iljuluj cu 5ce$
nume, .unosur mai dcs ptjn draDa Ini Eschil ,:'pre t-portva
se
Tels,veFnrle 563 S25.D tecrpten'ilearsiene,sinsuel

:
;j;I E?tf#'"""'ii:1,!Ji,j,"--",*',.';:;;;.;;

CoMENTARIU LA PoETICA .lwl

in:c9dcilc deceird.re.,inelcer
. rul );rolp a! alho dudpu(arcm,
.A!dLaDd
dlr i! r. dprcro,.
!arnr
BL,!_

;H];""rif
i;;ri
:rl.;ll::l:[L$lt,ijiJr
,

'I

l,-'."

" o p , _ _ , , *_ n ." *n ".

I,i.l:;1":fr
li"::ifi.:,Jt
,:;..I :li,'l.jfli; fl.T;;
lTi"l i i"l,;1
ii;"11i;
i,';t;;ii:lTli,,t;
_

29..A r rudrn,te Icrs,ii. Uc t u r-

A c c . J nre c . m.i.

Ii:rd:i:#::;l,,
r""..#iiif
:##i
:'
j:;
lf llll}

;illifl;lillt;Il ilJl,r::H::T"::,;:
:it;#;J't,lt::il:fl,.;
::Tlt,i""liilJJ,:i:;t!,
_,.1
,,"jI,.:1;;i::i,.1:.;"fi;:;,I
::l,I"i'
;:,i

ill
rll'

:;#;:i:t t,:ili:,x:l:1.jl:,T,t?,t:':t
:"i;1;
dndd b1tsadidcnt, ih nedbns adsunl
nbDnt utttu. \i u,tu ncrerateL,tutu
6t
wnuntp\itih). tlntu"n krrihD kncu
t cteph( kt pejcu. n8tc s nttlltr taouens
sut doniab. sut ndcbo

i',iilT,ll"1"l,i:
ili .'":;iil;i':
;"ll;i:1ilt,r",:Ti:
,nduru',urn\uuNund,.rdlr hi !-n*t
_r-,r.r..,;;;;.

l4$ I

oTelflrhN$uPcrcu;rrcl,dcnnveistisi dli grs:enrmcnrcto,


F{4qhbuic si lc erpini. ot voi rtlpi, on voi izbucninrds...).
j3 {,.D c ac eadar ul poez i ei m i s c par c r a r o
ctr lllui m ai c ur And i n i ndi r i z i i !r doni os i nz .s [ati dec er i n c ei s c oi j di D Ii r c ( 6r di {,u.i <i r r or r
nri aorr <l'IloD i udykon).uDutdinparajelecetcnajdn
curarearcrodi1, din pricim radiliei nanuscisedstecinoasc,
c!resupnmrp. |'arloy in dndul32siprezinril{rdolroi in toc
dcr.drarx0i tn randul33Ameo
eprarlnc,,le to! cdnoni,dr cenrcdcoporiivldcbunat4etcgeEa rcxrurdi
si dereddilcrui A; eorct.supraobaiieipoeziei
(cr. notr la ]v 1443b 5), sunrintesnitede vcsnrnBad$r
tsliunc, irdrar*oi (orerirr dc un sinsur maDusdis,
Riccntljhus 46) a ron crcdirari d Magoliolrr, ,,Ct^s.
Review,Xv,p.54.Intiodtrerainbxratdld\xdycpfope\ide
Gudenan,tnlcd.iar pc cercerinlcrui Tkasch, ,; r,biscl&
u.bdstzhE .tu P@tikdcsAnsocler, p. I t 7: rn a.etasisns,
v.acumsi C.F Elsc,At{or.t poer.r.D a36.in cepiveic
fondul,asacum m nai sctso (od sus,pp. 123 129:ct.
ApendicelelV) ni sc pr umurir cli laconicarijrmslie a lui
Ansbtel pddcfi judeca$&ciir cao lu4q!!c Fzjtie inporivr
ddinelq

penta cm
\q!l

noflt

lFieri,

d dtr !]

Qrultti. ori urhaEa unei consrlutii parotosie, decarlib.n

\:a- :!w l l {l l N 1 u !

hrrtriE a u0or0pLir!Lrini
0rrJtr

d6a'nrcS aliii,iha

ft

pnreiiarevaranduridinptrlinicutro,

rcr )i fiJg]ft0L LrinDemrnrrcprodusn ooDts vtn t45t l 24r


In re4n ord,nede
uo
'dcr.dttJUs
cc sic perul sub
inlcmnul entuzi^nului si inrpnrdei
'c@
divinecint ldcvl'rronos (BluDieh:no'rri< 6i't dooa tri,
dy lpd.l[ a{r, iyoouoLd[0i]rai i(poi, ry.tlar.< rard
ropra aoriv. cf.cicero.Irrdlraob,o.I r3. 30:,.ncgrrcnim
enc tlr]1n Democdtusqucnqtranrpocran nncn0n csc po$e
a comenbnur lui A Dchrc. ,s caeptiahs & I entlnDixsnc
chq tct|hilt&,ph6 pn:erztiguer, I. 23 si rm.r d Nchcni.

D M. P1PPIDI

LA PoEZCA XVI 1.155


r 1455b
COMENTARTU

Fr. Pfisrr. Etnasts,rtr PriJ.;.dr. A' nb mll cbrxbDLun.Etcnnzungsblndl,Miin$ei,1939,pp.


t?3-191).lcnhA $oEl.daci
cxir@nu uneilntcsi cabg.rii dc p@tiinakalt cu o ndld exrr
hQ nu pucr li risidujt!,lor a6r dc widenr era!i rapid ci acelia
ru coNrituirn d..i! o cxccpricjdin ce du $ por rrgo .otrottrzii
vahbnc penrru adivnaba lEtici indcobne (Cf J. Coissant.
itsrorc cr td nrs.e6, pp a6
-.17iK. Svoboda,1_r Jlrque
d /,1r,3orc.pp
5l-53) lnre 4lo!i< si trcrdrLf .ij tnhDocrii
.rcrsc,eDa.pd ntodi.,p6 di.ciptina
cd@ a gudmzia.ij roi
,,perf&dc c o.cnpazioncdi mcnrc,.(cun h spune.pe urmctc
staeintului,t@ailo Bnni, nmolr hs.h-phjLxodikc tn sctti lb,
hcss.yo! H. Babn.rripzig-Bcnin,l t3, t. 59),pduifu lui se
indesplii sprccci ditrtli si eer{, jtr'lccari Ndru s o rariti.e, in
ourloravmm,oscrieinfter3idcpocris:indno'i,del.Honru,
nr vdsur r09 rt Epis.u/ei.ih ?,io'i: ,.sdihndircrc secre est
cr pdncipiun cr lorr' (ndr epcr ntrlorr. ti inrclesdecatcr un
pnncipiu ratioral. 0p$ lacuxrtilor tuisrif cxrlkte dc scddod
l DBmoctircL,hri dq@. apmdiele 19. peniitdvaldry:.,ce
I e{pasrvcodcsabsencescrdlsvesqrcl,onifrpo$ilapaote
dc n frtc,cux cr de si r es aiusrcncnN La vdihbte condirioD
d'un vdilablcpoarcc* c qu,ity { Jc ptusdnhrct dc t,craide
I.vc. Jc tr,y rois que cchcrchc. volonirircs, a$o0ptise,nent dcs
pensed,consenieDcnr
dc l nne t
gines exqui*s. cr lc
'les
donphe perydrucl
du srcili.d lyarie-re-,
L!. 56. cf.p. 1031
.,J aimc ccs amrnrsde h pdsie qri vcncrcnrrdp ltrcidene la
pdu lui didi.. lr nole$c dc lcu pcnsis erle Emchcncnt
'lalssc
dc lcrrrdson.lh sNc bicnqu.clc n exiScp* le sac,lzo
del /,.clbdd ) Arupn dibrenloi dinrc poericr tui Vrtiry
(rrvrt) rr reci a lui ]rrenond(inspnatio).
vc, judicxffete
.bsc{ao' dc In' Add.d.Titgher,Srd./id &f,r.:. RoDa,1934,
pp r7s 176Asupris.btcmci.rcdioilne,inceEnn,l s.sond.
Lt ptobttne.tt s6nje.p^t\\, l97a.p 201 i um.j Roll:ndde
Rcndrnre,l_,cxprr.,.! d:,iu., paiis. 193$rp. Tnhrrd, t-c
/,r\rdr p.,irque. P!ir, 1940iin sla$n. Livi! Rns!. Esrcricr

pdzitJ,iric2,Btrctrftsi, l944,pp 1?8 lS5,adfliincheieE:


liric! nu sre dtcevr dccatdctcmindr N ntlo{a
'Ahcfe
st{riplinedeb$tnnesivib tic,caEneinbtu.e
mlionalcaurci
inlondulesertirlaleri{cntci,rcchc.niinninrcolrumoasi
pagin[dir JacqEsde LUeielle. dc cupds ascn]ln{tor .,ltje me
prjsr p.Nd $udain qm L'insdi.lio_Dc'Clrlt ccla:notrun eanspod
labdeux, non l ivrssc Eindiloq
sr\ dolh crts r?.ulk
jqcgg4-4-pujrj$
!!!-lb!$-t
pasrsr. nir\d.in. ! reN,lon0 e
elle cs bicn cn noN ct cc qui la pnoque, c'e{ notc p.rvon dc
cooccnbrion.nolF volont dc pancnn l h connaissai.c
vCnhbh dunonde (!e,Dert diu an 1chlagc h Glce.Pdis,
l..,Pilda rfigcnici".Od{lnainlltevoftader,gcDi,
ir dnmii, c volba dd Aiddis.
5. ,,Jcrrliti Zeiiei
Arisolcl ii tcoc nrmlc suhilcer. podvn inbnrici dc a n0 inua
7,,De trn zeu .apotlo,duial.! i frrcolOsrett'g
pnnErdlibnr&pindi.Cf.vc$u
lc72iiumr.,912.976iinml
.
I 10.,,Fic in lclnl ltrchipuit dc Eulpidc
c L x v r 1 4 5 4 b 3 1 3 4 . 1 . 1 5 5 ! 1 3l 9 s i r o t e l e r e s p e c t i v e .
10 , , F i o i n f e l u l r n c h i p n i t d c P o l y i d o r " V c d ,
m.i nN,rcu IaXVI1455r6 7
. V c z i , m r i s u s ,t r o r ! l a
l2 - 1 3 . , . N u n e l e g i r i I c
14 . , p i s o d u l

n c b u n i c i ''.R c l c i nr !c hr r :!c r ^

p r i n p trri ric! r. . ri&ri,


14 . . , S i r l n i n l u i r i r
vcNurile I I 17 si um
15 1 6 . , . l n c p o p c c . ! o c , n r i c l c i i 2 s , s n r i l n n
simea O lugdr .onllr4ie. di
cpope ragcdic,Incrp. v l4,l9b12 14
'i
T{rrit

1455

D M PIPPIDI

CoMENTARIU LA POEnCA XvlI

t.155b 1156a

*'
sseMid i sotroI aspcrospccificlmoft tagi.o. it npoto (dico)
'.U:,.'.'
-,';.l:""1
*''
'u'''-"'
LnAtr;r.a *ai iivayvdploL<.
ull iprd,tlelhTrascdiasono:
"*,',
trn,on l'altrcontre$r(clr. v'l1452b I sgg.)e co{ituenhm
i,-;;,'ji,tirL.:jj,:;:i:1":;iJ" llbdo
" . i ;;1,
nn unicacdr,o$ia i naFi rrlv b-dfori2. il ndgo<,di cu'
,3
p"
,"'i
pi"n
Adslolclc ha rdio lunsa e dndnh tanazionc in xtrIi 3.l ioo<,
.:Tl,it"
" '
I:: l':ill" '.
s u c u iilc a p . X v : 4 ( r i r d o r o v 3 ; , c o n e c l c ' n c o r o u n p o c o m
XVIII

"u:
, *':liJi",l
;J,'J,",:
:li::;;::,:*?.::,;
::1Tl
r

"r.r,,", r"g,r" i",,o_,.,

H:itT:l':il.",:',irt1lt'i"",.
;:i:llHfti.,:x::tit
:1

rtropD/ \;t!!

14 61110rLcr xr|v

t4hor 23\ lid

', . "jr:.
; , i .Tl '..i . ' l ' .L.t,,r,rc' , T
h \ U .]e !' e ( .Ve .n l5 !s.
s!n r L lenir r ! r etnr . Cl.,\lt"h
se
,n.urD(ft
, ^
Aijhr. \ F a,(/ \.s \ rt .ruEa4 er{rs x\ LL

sotrodinc)rr it{r(, dclk qudlchr (lctroin xv 1453bI sgg.chs


unch. dr esr d possibilcotuncs l'ip-y0v della Tftlcdi.,
quantunquBil v.lcdcnc si! segrc di pdctdmcm valcdo (p ?2)
. 456n
] ' D e t i p u l . . r n o r A i ! s s a u I r i o t . C u r h c o u v j t r . d1
tiaScJii al ciror Drz r ri alciruit de o inlanpla( ror dlir dc
zguduibarcuhc.lnrihuldcmplucira..nebu aisi'tucidccr
lui Ahs (ve7.itrsLrlia cu adi n nc r lui Solbdc), it in !l dojl@,
r 2. ,,Ft).t)dele ri P.icd . Snbiccbimpn'mnirrc,
probabil,lesendciorin 1c! rn .u Ahilc si ctr tuhilir lui
OoL!'ri(( cniiriinhtiotreBdiepridutirluiSofocle Ciircnn
IlrI.jq prali *risSofoclcti ErriDid0.
(ii{r'<) Cuvltrt corupi
2 ..Tra!ddir spccracol
conjatua ;U< a Ini By*rtcr.
' lut Fo,lis,
3.,.Fd.c/e
luiFo.kn
c lro r r c l i u n c s c p c r r c c e i n H a d c s . F c r c l o
c u liintc hbnL.rse Snen. si Gorsonc
svusc$ dc lrptnl ltisctr. -. Mnul lri Proneteu, de to! cunorctrl.
lus.sutar n,ai c dc vrcma cind rcu Andokl, inrt,!n. de
L!.hil.inr4 dlqie fxnn.a\i, din ca'c n! nis aPi:kdd{ito
tloForE) - D.spre
patu: ProDereutrl:iDrun(nFrr0rn.
ltrnor
inlcndi sc poatc
se
pet{er
nr
dftmclc r citur @turc
pgtrpuE cr puncanin scd li lilDrr ri i, ihag ini nspliiti tl(r!.
iD nuc si seneisdl i. stllcrdcp
criri.rride Arnrodinu ur cxp{ol t(..dcnt(.1 xlv la5r h

#iff.:;3
ifi,:i'i,i"1;,i:it;?:
---..",'"-,,
;iilllll"i
iJ,i.,ilillill
f 1ll1i:i;:ili#t:111
i:"':
J,cmq!d,u rrJt, \tn.nn, 3c. e! . L rr4 d e
L \ 4 l1 5 s . |, t u r j-1t;:i,5.1
;-Jii
h,l'lli,:i;l:,T:,:t,J:,',1:1':l:;iti.
i
.unL,j

rjJf,

e de r,re

trDr vur

fijtiiti;:;i
:t':t,;1.:;:iil.;
flI;f',J,iii:''i:?'
| ,u nin i. m/ n n(\u

d(ltr ,ruDnJ

.,.u o. _*,,.r", *ri,.


"r.n

ll . . C u m a n i r a i s p u \ - o d c m u l r c o r i
ll. 1 q h 9\ l r d : I X 1 . 1 5 1 h l ri n r

Cr v

.'.""11,i"..Iiffi
:iil^.k;;,;:lH"'",Jtr;:

COMENTARIIT LA POF:TICA Xl\

trtil;tt'i;;'ffi:r$l.'l

115. r

t15D b

XIX

33..,D es prccc l c l atr c c tc m c nr c" .i . odi near attui i :


cspEstrbicct
O,ioo<)incrp.vll-xl,X -Xry,XVl XVIII
spFcrEc{crc(:ir)incl'p.xv
cu priviraalrcdouiiclr'nenc

., ir^i"r:",;::yl:"*.:".
1..":1,,
".i:,;t;:,
; 'J;:;".,r ;l:"liitl"_fl

lil

ilil
lliri

il

,,,-',;;;,'lLi
rri

,11:iii
"::lJit
a'a, oo c'a'.o' !,,F,..
"

dr, r<.rm(

aJro ru u r . i} . r t r. r' o 1

jjli;;"jj:; ;ii;:1.:;T.'lj,:,
:;':',:;":;"";'
-"-,.."

a { q iru t i ( , n t r / i c L \ i . l c m . o r us n e ! e d o \ L ! 4 o n o , , o \ 6 ! , r . ) ,

r-aarlltlt,li cap.VI 1450b 16unn,ci nuinri propriuzistD


3 5. , . 1 nc r r r i r e d e R e r o r i c i ( i y l o i < n . p i i n r o Ori<). ctr n$$ nepodvni, cxplicat'ile, pnbrbil, aia cutu pft
supuncRo{rg.i, p. LrYl. prin aceeaci Retolia dyca l:i lic
conp$l in nmr P.ctir, plmul de cetcerlri ichiur in Iendurilc
33Siu'n cotespuftlc
clnilor I n are@oruluiijudspinii h rci
Cr. I I 2 6l 4 0 : l ! 3 2 s i u m , t n i
6i 6ir rpiu;oriy n 6i
rpd.y[dr.r0iya' rai rir rd]or, i{!p liy ]dpaoa]dfoy
rdi rv!BLir rai iy0u[r]drby iai dr!< rrity na\ rij!
ha'vo,a/, t0.y r.0rdprjoorry (!i lil arrr,i I;oor<y,
rrpnooo i[i] ro'o0ro (,jnruoar*rhicclctcc. urmerz!jri
tlrate in oricc Itrcrrre despic volbirc sunrin nunrr dc nei, sr
zi.en cil xr li de ajLmscelespulc Dinil .ci dcspn pilde. cu8 rin,
cnrincmc si, indeob$e.dosprcj'trLcoiri,prcum si desprenijloacch d3a.ennbositi cur.$!ificlcsi dc n dczlsgseditilc....).
3 . . , 1 ne l a b o r ! r c i r c i i u n i i d r a m a t i c c " ( i y r o i q t . 1 5 6 b
npd}'pdd1y).cIAlb.geiani,pI I t: ,.Aris@rctc
didinsnedunqu.
azioncj pcrchble coNiMioni
c iscnrimcnlipo$on.rorgcr opdf.niliciode,l!p*ok o pcr
|ctoqucnzrdcn azioneiDr p.i.hd trei dne clsi gti s.opi da
ragliungoreninogli$6si,cg0idBbhorocscrulccar\cpcrcni
vcng..o pono$i, e porcniBsurli s.io i principidctle due

,"'
l:::,::
,:;',L
i'i:;;,:
u"i.',i:"r.'
'*'',.
r;."irw;,i"r,:,,i
"l"id;
fillthii*litt,;:
rtrd nut phr6btuodunrh&LraDtc

i:;ilJ::'_
:_1.:
.it i:lJ;';l'"T
ii:11.
. ,I.:i,T
11
l:
.'".",
,, l:,#i;:liii"i,l;ii,'."..
^

,r a i n r ;

^".,,.. -. ^

;;,";:J[:
l".li.l?l:i:['iii,]:,);,jj:t,,;-;;i.

10.,,Moduril. vorblrl i"(rir !rjlrra ri< \ito<1.


Dutilor iricumnimi.r.esbrff 1lloedco\cbircpetrr0inriia
orrl dcPoragons.Ct D,os l-rcn,lX 3,53r 6L.ir; r. Gcit.
np!roydptr.) rdr l.iloy trrrii!L (i. rirro@(\cil oxrirara)

D I\4. PI?P]DI
!xoi\riy,ipdrrtoLy,drdKNoL', ivr0xrj!.. (,.poraroras
a rGr
cl ditrrii caie! deoschir
cctc Dato oodun ale v;nir: ru,r
inrE hr(r dspuB lr pqM.r . r , , n s rd a n f A , a u Du j. ,
.'rx!\i/dixitGcil. Ptui{sor6),pd$sordspnr4r".asur;itr
.etu!'dr!r rii!!isbc'i in Anu.hra'e,H skmLJLt,cff ;a dd
spru.h,iiren\cfian hci J.n C,..hsn d,t] foD.d
lBcnr
1390),dcsnreprnbrema4cd 0rt,,prulc om rb N Drdoutr
kronrrnra.r. Bu.urr' to,15,p.,
15. .,... it ntrsrr!". porrc in sctlerca,OIurKd

,,ci n r! zci rr. nenia ..- jMr l4ya' { 6,o.;.


sue, pnnulcn'hrihat,lr.id.

t9 ,,ci de a lrccvs .De nc$! trgul,lcclaortci (rii<


cum{i sois cu citeva landDi n,i !r

XX
2 0 ..l n i n rfe su l tu ,

Avdr 0r numfloh,\nu,r ctc

relulridph cd c tireF.Asupnrcden|qld Atuiorl in mrsjc


derimbi,asaon 3untexpu$ir cap.xx_xxll, cI.A. ?altjatu.
in .Rncdrelrn.u{'chc.Ix. to54,m t-i5,v v Klnlaihd
in.sruLrn
cl.!.e lt. 196r),np?7r4, F v3trFskf.rr5,J..
v
2l Dupi vsb (irtrd), manu\fisctemczinii tcmcnnt
dp0pov(,,dicorut), pe cG majonhte; cditolitorsi a
conrci!Mi oril!onrtte. inrJ.r p\ o,nhrpotre.,nrcm.kr
o!
! p td q r,{;tD i .n )!L l rn
H a t!mA lr r r !np
t;ir .
Ito t.4 r.d\ Qunr "..h.2.n.s
hr n( r 4,t3r sld
carcgoricitdlmariacdAn$ord n a cuioscur
atr.,Dturialc
\lrbi ii k.n p.qr! h rmitr. d!r6(!G
o, 4a. i4;o.si
!j r!r!n(t(.rea
rir Llcop6p4r [ tu{trr fhk lhr trju. .

COMENTARruIA POEIICA {{

/4J6 b

a'levdraliicreaioriai lingvisti.iiid Aniichiiab.Cl. Srcinrh{l.


Cdcb. ,cr SIr,.n'rlse,sclall2,l. p.25? m.i Max Pohicnz,rrc
Bqrij'd\'E.la
tbcn.llinditchet Sptzchtehrc.ttch die Sbl,
22.,,Litera .Nurninblcsuldcaimbolsons,ciIt eel'ie
25 . , . v o c r r e , s n i v o c . l c , n u r e ( r d r d o v n v
Koi rd iridrrov rai d'Cd/o!).Drtinctirs.intaheSre,lndnre
de Arinotel, la Plaron,c?ry1.,424 q ...6(i n0riro/... rd
4ovrivro6Eris0a!, ;t(ra.. rd r ii4ova .ai tood'ld...
rcI r; dildlvivra fi/ on, or trivrdL t. dQ0oyya(,,bbuic
!i dcoscbimmri hiii vocrtele,apoi.. cleDenielecuc Dtr
compod, sdDcrod zgofto.. ... al oi pecelecrre, ftt !i lic voc.le,
nu 3u$ Dlcinure). Cf. Ptu]cb.,l3 b{, utrdc,polirir rclonsi
crnei i, Pl.br deoseb5ie:L vocalc(rd d! ! i vl a): 2. ero:lenb
ce nupprezind plpriu.zis s! @b. dr produczeonor (rd ou vr<
F!y oi;, $tu)lor 6i [rir0vro rwo<).rltfelspus.scnnvdalc,
ndnio mcod ci rd raodi I mutel. (ccca cc nu producenici
sms',niciz!omor);rd di$o!d
26.,,v.ca1r... . Pcndtrvrlo!rcadctnifiilorcermftzi,
puncrd
din
de vcdereal lingvisticiinodcnc, cL.t. vctrdryes.
!o lrrg,ge. Prris, 1921,p. 25: ,,On divhc d o indnc lcs
phonUncscn c.nsonnes er en voycllcs. Prdique enr. ccft
disrinctionpc sjtr.tificr pd h ddtiniriondeIa syllnbc;tout.foh,
lcs nen6 phonamcssont souvcir caFblcs de jouer dans la
syUrbele dlc dc co$omo ou de voysnc.S\l y a cntc dcsdcux
difldrcne de fonctior, il n y r p^, cn cffet, differcDcedc narurc,
errr lini{d qui ld scpirc n cst prs brnchde.consooncse. voyelle5
ldr pa.ie d De dttric nabtollc donr )cs cxtdns seulssoDr
nermenr sdpdl$, (Rou$eior)'
26 , . F i i r i o p t r n c r c i n n i t c
(tfo
np0.ioriiq). lnruplcrat! re rtrie'nciazrpc
linbii
d e s ln s n n c d d c i n l r c ] l i r , , n , t . , l l 1 6 , 6 6 0 r 2 d n . r r r l < 6 i
oJk
rxdrrr< [i ronnrla ondir<!!6i riiv rarijv iI6r

q:V. PIPPIDI

COMENIARru L{ POE?1',1 XX I.lJ' l)

*stri+rxqffiffi

^" "r""",,."*.r"*",*j;i:
lilfi::tl,ti:[ij:

o ,* l ," ," i i J i .:" ;." : )t r'u\ oo. a, 4. o\ 2. . , p, u,


"'' ', ,"' o -.,,,-'i"l"11
l' " ," ,,...r ' " .,..---: : . : : 111': ""'. ".

;';;J;il;::#1::
IiTfrf;1"-,
;;;,;i,"-,"
trm.,v!\r a .z.
," ..1*;i, l, ;::1,,,"1"t::-'1'r'e

j:fl::,;' ::;
; 1'l;-;;':::::l';jiT;i
'""::"t:
p . 1 6 ; ;-l
'' -'b e * u p t l . a -' o e j u F ! \ .

..",,r1"3":i.i:',".
.._"-,"..,,
;Jfi.iJ",xl::
":;.;:,,:;"";
"i:fil
1l.,,DuDa r,,.

", ,^..

,,",'"i,]'.i
Ll,'^-:"1
.',-:",^,

.!,1; :..:::.:,

a / a D.

3 )4 h 3 _ r I 6 a 0 io L

:;"i:,"::ii:;
#:'j:jj;ljt
l;:':iri:ifi ^J""
".,

",;"

;,T;:;
,;l;':it-"jj .l[;],ri,;,.""ffi
12,,D!Da rn"" _^
-

r@,"
,,,c;,*,.,;,;;;
ill"lilli:il.:i;iJ"r:

g!ave san medii ('l{ir'lrL rai


rai
14
!io6).c!.licouvinb.duPicnpoaniun
0opJartaL
sanc'Enmllex.
lcent ascurir,8mv
delingviltiidin
35.,,Silaba e. . Dcnnidanuc tnsulstie
qui
p.651,,ce
c$ tds dclicai.
zirarcnenrc. cf. vendryes,.,pd.,
c'e{ dc nnluer,e pointp*cn on hs syllabescoMnc.n.ou
finisent. M. Roldet erseisncq0cla stll,barion ofrc his aDccrs
<ToubsleslohqueIon
sdvantlepointdevucauquclonscplr.
pa*cd'uncryllabetnnealh,ilyr,dn,nncvdiadonbrsque
q aff4re I lr ron lc rcginc dc l'expnfton,lc nouvenelr
audirve".Ccncdplc vffiation
diculdoire etla pscepribilitC
pcmel danr un ccnain nohbrc de crs dc fix$ la linib dcs
syllahrr: daN beauconpd'aufts. la division ci arbiLnire Il senit
si puril dc chfthcr I la frxcr qE dvoutoirdgmher i qucl
p.int pi:cG setouvc le loM d uncvdlic ci h dcuxoonragmr"
l 3 . , , P a . i i c t r l a d e l e s i l u r I . . C o m e n e l l ac l a $ i l i _
clzionecomplcsivrdi stb Ic prri dcll'olo.uziom,cosincnc
darmnoin]por
delinizio'idcl o,jv6<dIo<.Aristorclcpro.ede
tanied pii nnFna c. Ld pnma deiDiTionerisudd! qulle
pdiccllc di too nNmsnto:dgulih qu.lla sptcic di 0J,6. dI o<
che('c.o il criano inbno) q! intcdiMe nd contibuise .he di
pid voci si lomi u! unicavoccsigniricariva".Sd,cio!, di I il' vci
in um poposnjonc si i lak ui'unicr vocesienilicativa.N untco
conccto, quost no. a ccnahenE per msnto dcllo strddcltcpr
ticslls.lnvc.c 6le medb. tilc proftdt l{)Pdiene ad un llta Ue
cis di oLivso|oc,alh qmle on psa Atsroiclc, ncntrsdalccm(h
delinizi.n.r.hetefti va bnuk itr nrcto cortrb cdnh prece
d[6i, coc cd
denb.EdihsDccicdellepEposizionicom.n.pi,
pLt vocr
quli
legano
clltrLiramenb
alrrepaniccilcanaloghe.lc
uDunarmesigniliotiu (Rosasd,I!Peti.r
signficadvoiir
dr,tunio.elo:, p r20). Cf. si A. Ditrns, D;c rritd.eftcr.,
Ddinjtiarcnwn oJr6.o n< ont iipopol,in.,ArchivICcs.h d.
t hilosoplii..l11,1390,pt.]6:11691

195

D.M PIPPTD]

CoMENIARIULA rcEnCA x^ 1457a Xxl 1157hb

.."
:"3"Ji
X'iil't1":ii:::,::.".,,.:,.:"',;*"
*,,..,,
;.r_,.;;;
\m\r tipsn,,l.rrde.
"..-,,..,,,;,,,",)

ti,pro ,r",;"; #;r.;.;


.,:'-,,_*
h.,;J,
;;,;'i;;,ij:'?.,:.,f
:L:1:
;:;;;""
j-:ii:l
;ffi

;,.'."::ll::"l"jl':-:r'1'.r,
iLU'i'd!,,nooh,"r,1,6b2,.h"j.il;ffi;:li,iT
"*H
iii.i,'.i:Tll:
:" -- *^',"d,;;;;ff];fli

;..:rri:.:r,.iij':i
ri-:?;
r,::i"i;1
'*;1: *'.;i;::l:
{i:";-li;i:1,::;
:1:':il';
: l,'*iq:,:.."'..:

li::;:;
ffii;

:.i:ilj i::
I;:'i;,J:""r,1
:,.'.:i:,!"""
r.-",'i:."1
.'",^,
.".,"".,^,,,."i,.,",
::;;;"j';:l;;;
;:iul

*rrr li:i,ti:,.;."v.i,r,';rl
;;:";l';l

lnzlstd d inleles dscifli clcne esepararc!uliecarcintc


lostrlsid).Cf.vendrycs,or..ir,t.82:.,onpcfidennirlaphltuo
l0 fome $us l,'tEu. I idrgc vc$3le s expime et se Pe'\oi au
26.,.Delini!ia onuIul . Drti chir dc AJi$olelin alh
s a e n . C l . T o p . , I ? , l 0 l a 2 ? r ( ' i . o 'n < d v 6 i r o ! / ( , . $ i n , r p c
dcstrucudodlpicioare
)saujbid.,v2, ll0bltr ltiov nl6rrrr<
&( tu;v (,.mimL capabils, pimsscl r_ivitiruri )

XXI
FIciiJ ah$mclidc indlcslia Iinrp
rl ,,Nudelc
'lc
notdi ln .rpiblul pfodcol c{ DnlcipaE cfadcn$i.I a rcrbultri
(vczinoh l. 145'?
a l4), nini. nuscopunBcaac.sb s! intc !i cl
h crregori. cuplinlitord d nunclui Cu accn nrFles e rolGi(
o"vot'din crp XXI 145?a 2?, bDtrlui
13 34,.Cun.sc:ind.! djstrnclir nu s. rnlici
c lc me n r c l o i c u v i n r u l u i o . D r p u s l d c c ! m a l c u d n d
decii lircldrextnlui,crc suni: nliv o)ir ir r{ dvd|[n d<
oltdiv0vro< rai do,jroul, lnsilnaccapriacid?vea.dibn.
un lDftla\ inilnnhl ctrra.ftjtri"). Reani ltcdtl 3! lnrlrcxscii
arimtirdin.apitolulprccdc .l45?a ll l'l
3d .,Mrssalioli (a[v Madodlb{iiv) conjcd[lrlui
5l
Dich.,.Sither,plcus.Akad.dcrWisscnschJten,l333,LD
Mmu*ircle dar 16! [(]dr,oli v. ccu cc tr aE noinil
r.,,Obiie5. (.iFov) Lr drati!, Flht .tte Pieti,r4

r':;'i:h#r!,imriltti"i::::tiii+l

:#;i;""1illlt:liT
l.:i;iillll*f #; ;:l ;:l;l

iiri;iil,Ll?#;i:d.i#fi
:;i:I1:ffi

3. . , P r o v i n c , r l i s m l ] r i r r d ) . i r Q t . X x l l l ' 1 5 8a 2 2
isemai sp dcsif(v(dv (,,rcmernrrnf) Cun insi Sadul lui
AnsoEl n! ncrgc ll drinte din I
dirlecralc!...cr.t, raduEretr podvit! mi scpnrcccr rdofffi.
5 tiyuvov.Cr IlendotV9 tr'r.irv.< t ir' idIiDUoL
,,\i)u.s oi liv! tr;p ;iaooal\il.

r451

@MENIAIru r-AmEltoudl

gl;,;.1;;;",.E
J_:
i:ri";r.
l{iiii:ir.i:":,,",Tfi
:

;"^l
;;1"-;"1r,1
; "**i,ri,;";1,:

l4tb

t4l8ai-Wl1453.

cibt si i prebdrlei l[ lcglltud m sp.cnl4iile lui Empdocle]n


lu t viclii onului (cobpaiail ctr vial! 5lorimprnlor'cnm sc
Oo& dcducedin vcduile de inspn.lic piirgoreici.le lui Ovidiu.
199li urm ), vezi A RosragDi
ln catu! Xv a a Mcldof@eir,
Pttrean.gp.246-2u7
ll brba.li
29 . , , S e m a n A n d ! n n c z c i a s c a v i P a i c . N u F l r i c
dc cine f puba li acc$ entsiih. DDpilGu{tcman,d. Pin'1tr.
(l4sl
capiLolului
3l.Potiritprcizdrilof dc Ldinccpuitrl
b l r) ti ordinii lmdein e&uner, dbuic slPEsrpuncn ct En
duilc lipsi din DaoBcriso cupindcau latdcr numclui'F.doabl
(r{toro<)$u,cn cuvinElelu cice
pftpri0mrropiiocomutdu'n (r.orar.,Ill 167)
Id
35.-EDvupa Ci.ite nesis0ri:ipvJlo< e coDjuctuta

fi*tt+*ffir:tituff

*N-ffigffi

;ti!'"1.1"i
,illl,iliil
-",:t
.,',,,,,,
1
;l:;;$
:."1"",,,i:1:;,1.,'."".
",,

j,ji
* i:.tr*l'ilx;i:iir*i:iiri:,i

rida.I II
35.
^prriipa.ln
rdrN<.Fev*alllunglpinnaruri, sc!fl.
3.Ir'jl.oa
(penh ii4,L()suntPildealc lcNm.nulu
4-5 Kpi, 6,iiii
n0ni!,cu nn bmen sbdnicit ddpl Aiieobl. rpocopi (dr !roa,j)
Cit privc+cemisrihulr
sid -yivr4,.. crc (,p sinsu*pnv@ Frn
ditrrmandoiochii)euncira.dinEmpcdocle(t433 Dieh).
?
rdrd urilov(,,pchsen dtopl )=tiaJx,
^{Lradv
V 393 Formr6iLrqd,conpararivullui6.t,dv
(rd:6i p(ro{J) Ecccr
3 !.,,Altclc j!rernc'lirrc'
(reun',').
ctr Ehivllcnlul ,atin
ce Du'nimasl5zigcbul Deut!
tmetrului mainotrdecalAristotel-on6ar.pDv
15..,inr sfi.rcsc numai tei
fiioca^l{c$a i
in cazulundior ?1cuviniclor Gminac n, !, rirlrilc lui Adstote,

i+?ii;;1;.',.;;p*]iftffi
l:tlJ::;li:lt"lj;:tlff:I.'-'
"":j,;iJ"l
-

. ""i:,i,
;::#,;;:';t:it;ru::,1:
l:Xl;*";:

xxl
t i r i s ! c a d l i n c o m u n ( o d $ i lr a i
in Xr4. lll 2, 1404
AMa$i re.omandalic

q.M. rtPPlDI

:fil;::l".ifl
Lr
lfj f"-"a
r:i::lri::ii
i,i,
" i""*""#,.j:".
,,, ,".. :;.ll:1
"'""",
1 '"

_rom,

,"..

",r,r",
-.._,.: : , " " : r " ^ _
.....,..-,J..,,.,
k,.;..;;;,,,:
_lt . i". :" "-'.-.

:i"j",1.?l
1r;x",.;:it
t illli:j,fjlm
i; :rrnrlrri# i itl !1';i
=,lI;:.11
r n.p?nDdtrG

Mc"o at \4 tt h,t th- ,^;;;;.;


;;:,::.:".
.
r .q me i ro .r rr o . p ,,i ro r .qv.
v,.i ;;":.
- t:.,1..

;; ;l';;:i"l,.lJT;
y.:;;'P."..J.^"|*''
i",;;:
:#'I3:::,:,
*"'"l'.'';,"
.';;:.;;:;:'':]'^'*]'r
*^
; ;;;;: ;i",-,,;:,IT"1.".,il
^.__",,,..,
' .',o'...'.
" ";i";;;"1.i:"1:l,l'.'r"ld"
ijl'l;'i'
l..ii"ll ::"j::..;:ir; ,:.:i,tLl,'i

::lj,ji";'T;,;l
'."' ' ".,".,.,;;,;.;;-,:.J
,::::1,::':.b."t,
__,r.,, ..,...,"
;l,."lllil"
" .J,:,ii;tT
-:ili:;:;;,1l,:l
l:':1,.,i
tT".':

**r
,"" tiT:il:;:,,,::'"lj:tT:*
"..-.""i,lja
Pe scoa lui dv
"

,darofm. v,i!",/e r;rj

l a r i ti .'rorheni

"_

'!uc

s r'i i tri ( { ( v r . o i<v)e z si in o r a r r x x r

CON{ENIARLUL\ ME|ICA NUI ]45K J

1458b

daJdrov i alixovov ndoora/ordd (,,ctriemreoa'iloF


su prczinDo,mpo\b'lrLt i'LEmen'dnevu.tlc LlmMr )
Ghicn rc lorrc der
om crc
27 23. -.viznr-!n
inrilditi in bxl., atnbuni indeob$c took' clcobulina (5 Dichl.
Anthal.lyf,czGacc4| |.p 1!0) cdh cxplict Adstoiclsi4ur
in,Rlci..lll2, l4{)5a 35,cvorbadeorcrt0zi dsbtunz .lipilt'
(rmci mckloric pontu ,,.plicrd ) pc sllElo sulcrindulu'
1458
(dnorondi) Nu in acccpriart'btiri
t..,scurtirilc
(vcz'.
m'
rcmsmlLi deSFmaticii p.sierion: suplinaE d linal3i
sus.noral,I 153a4-5).ciininlelesulldgalluiiisrprvarovd'n
cap.xll1.153 a2 snm.
rn oPcEcoerce,
6..-Ficand haz (tLdrduq6o,ivrq).
cit s Doarededncedin ccledotri nude dbic marepdc
dloi
'
6..J'i rcrma poelului'.APctildingcncralii inpn_
ndrind.rluiHoncr,,,poctul PnDdcclcnti
Cunepu'
?.E!.lidc cel aatrin Pssomj rccunossut
prcslpunc
de
trn
comedioerar
c
votbr
Gum
.ini1 dc b.ririt der
Roshqni), deu nagista! (cum$ecd Bvwdd).5ru de lilozornl
EucliJodinMcsrra,elval lui socrarc(cu'ninclinl srcE I
9- l0. Efurtprv i6ov !i orjr dv t id[]o< Doui
hcxme@ $ansacc,ni careo $caedc vocrlc scuncsunt tungit
rbirr ii in carc.cdn bins o&c { AlbcCgirni,,,la pompa
dcll cspE$bnc contsb con ta vKuid dcl onrcnuto
l2...Mlsurr" (ri Iirpov) Accani drerpBls!r[. caE
rinc rn loc ari. de inscmndrln gtndneaannotellci nur o
nts{ocnc a ilozotulLi: ln odinc! elcI si in 'fllinca cstetici, id
inviutoF inrclcpiilo. \i in cFrliilc arrisilor, apropirlj de o comn
nll reou\ic oenh cxocseledc oncc naftl aspnrti! cstc Ptr
DonI sicnviinri-cieep;rpdv sinp;trov cunrdint's]rludlc

ffi:*#d*#:#+$*iffi

i".bleni.,lo.unuaul e*" oc lr lamdul rtsiv drdv,


dcvizr hLiSolon.pinrl la ta!tuli! lui Escbjl.plhnsi rodi delrica
deU$iti: dc la lininc
donRNs cr.o$ udi de zd si pcdepsir

D M PIPP]DI
8u-b( Je Pi( mnutuprir t, fnr! dnc
e rndutur lurzcusdr
vnmp'{.Jqrc ,mnuiimtier,r ,n.hndeLrar,h,mr
nuoptn
e mqd

erut(

ik tu, w( mer Jreg.I, pxdelr. I.

..i"' ,' i t
- ,i - " ',."
" Lv '
o ols.ans
Pe0'fo o lrc intcneiat
ll. - .i n tr i m c tr i i i r m br c '

r9,.L: s.hrtri ta E u rL p d c -. A t u d o d @! c d , it .
,
racaRseb.c,lrre e:u p,edur.

u0! 6i !,in/

drilo< r Kai

lnr 6! !,uy p,p(

r( la l d 0 0 r! r0 < ra ! d a 6 n .
r.inr 3llcdNetq rcmure

23. Acecsi obswalie dLrprcvosul:


Frg& rr apdi.aa,
rar.dii< tjliry

r rpdn<4y

r0 ,T d rmu n l c vu i e sc..Jr r h.xvtr 205

r,J;;
:Jji::,:l'F"t
i,H:
llf Tl;*-"'*.".,,'
['":,:Jii#ii::::l
i*:txfil.:i:J1:il:iiil:
.

5-6..Cu mdri !c

mi,,lc p rc r

L la ru l f rc rrro

' l 0 0aT.p^.' o!< y!/roci ' .

ro,rn.r( r.&c inrhdbk deu*r o r"


r *""
^
u , pE (um'md;ra|i
,^

/-, rclq'rc

";,.,i1
Mi{nh d s rrp f la
)
preJ ispo,,f ir, r(u $ rq c l Cr. x v llt 4 5 5

202

l4J9 2

L r i 'o l o d 0 ' F i r r
s .. 4 s t i s r v c z ' a s e m ' i i r ' l e
0r Frd4'+o4<
T o (A ' r c l r ; T o p . v l 2 , l a i r l i r r o 4 <

:1::
;i:::t",t'i;ilf#
:i.H:l:
ifl :[:l;'j;:i:fr
i";;:;ru,'tfi1ilTtf
::l),tti"llili,,l,ii3lTt:
I
ruqi!3gli,

COMENIARrut-A POETICAXXI 1459'-XXII

tuu!oc M r gk m d:

XXIII
rorma de Po
r7 . l d L t l t ' 3
'
n
i
L
;.,
r i r r r l n i r i < \ ' E p o p a sP ' $ r c
!'rF!
i6 ' . -! " . " i <
dc nrrLui rc
rormr;TrNr o Lleccb$t 'rc rosed c ti!e6u

r t!dr ui r e J r :m r r ,.r , c F .v | l ]450b

* ' o t u .a ,

' r r ' tu ss
L m r p( L ' ) o ve
(
"r
r
"^
'
'
'
264
Fpdu!nu'ons
|41l45rrbrsi tttulLli? ann,Ph"lr '
.,' ..

r r o.s tet.r e, c r r e_i e Pr op''e r r l ! 0r r {ov


2s .Xl l l l 4s l .l '( n IdN dr eB p 4r
n6o,r r' .c r v l 1449b
2l .22 C ! a ,uhLc {tel or i s tor i c r ' v c T rm s us '

vn,oo
'' lliil'l"f'",".,.' vremccrH.6d.r
oir& rnrpr ?
n 0 o c6 t i a l r o 5 ( r ) u u o ' ! ( o ! r ' 4 4 1 i '
'Alsuv rov
roL oriPb@
..
r^ar.i"^
^ ' t irrd v f l q o r l v l d u
'.
-Eiiryd
tr td4i{
r-" 0 " ^ " ,
'
"
r
in r(8t' n in cd !d'n {
\
r
iol6npldd
(sc
G
|{irrj
ouo
iheron I ioqm nr sk ha nc Hmirrir 'rcs'oc'zu sften

*"1:"*1:iTI,""i'ifl1",,-.cfvuLa5,,22.,m.

3 5 ..O s 'naLr . P!r r e ! r 'z hoi ul ur


Atul cr l v '. A\'^^u<c un 'oc
drpt nuclculongine rl lnrrcgr cpopcl'

M fr J u

D M. P]PPIDI

LA fuETICAlofli l./5r 6-i\axtv r45, b


CoMENTART

j{ii#:*:
#::;.r'":r'#;;r
rn#
;ri#:r
F
' ob
i" Y , ; , , 1, " : : . :
" l i -\n ,,4 r,.,1 ,,

"i".o&nD, ..,,
j: ;;
;;,;"": r."::,
;jo-:
".. ".;
k .H-D,.,.;.:.;:i
:: ,,u1:.d"1'"
"".'''""'.il
, , i 6 " r;
_".. ..
. .

.,,.: ., ;',':.o' "


*''" '- '*-..""n""^.,.;;,;,.
1"1
Ji l'.]'.''.
.d.vr4,o,J,.-rh ;;;i
;.;l;^ll:T _.,',,."
ttt"""
;
',,t i.:.;...";""
"
""
"; ;-",,,,,

J."1i,'.
" ";,",,
- ;il ;".ii-:;1;';lT;:,
j::::.,:
,:-';
:i
l:
Tj
;jllj:;:l"l;::
l"::
"1'"1,
""' ^";;';l;;ll lli;;:: lT ii;
;;;;i,".";:"
i.,lnoccatJ

dttuetr..t

(niou nipd() DcspErtuSedii


7 ,.C;j{lcr.".oi.i
pove{iic
it poemutluiaicli!o\.vez',
de
cvcdinetrtlc
lnrpiEt
mu is u s , n o t a k X v I I l , 4 s 6 r1 2 .
(andtrr.u<)Desprco
1.,,1n to' I a arc a c.riDiti.,.'
nn
avcnDnioslin,i&dsuDrasubic.rulu'
frlcnic.ua.esttLru!
tubrbil,rntrm,.5nn\ orhi
dcirNodul,L'na:dtr illt LciJl /rids', p mt0( t ii !:p xv
3..,Si, o r " Rolul arcsluite$onaj in cpisodulcrlului toilt
..xpN cu bre aminunrololn cader a l!. ! E e,zd ldi vergilitr
vcsuils57 193$233 26t.
(Tpqii6<). Prldedc t4edij intndsand
3..,Troicrei.
dn
Tsix.
dupi dnhscro! Drtiei l'tr, ni sxu
sufcrinlclclcmerlof
lui E0rilide
Toi.,clc
si
ii
te.uni
ptutat Ir

,., ..

^"\

r,tl
,l

l.l

(.,'

1 4 5 5b 3 2 s i u r m .
3, . A c c r e a r i ! r r i c r l r i ' . c L x v l l l
I
u
i
.
.
.
Ctrr.estorpcicn
p
o
c
b
c
l
c
d
i
r
l:l.,.Fiecarc
amlizl
sunrrc.compdtpaginilcdcpittrnzl!.rre
lsihologicrsi
escdcr rie anminulni li2rar ./A?rc 'subrr, cry' L\, din c{c ni
nultumes si cn.z hchctta: .,.. Ii2d, liind .onpusr int o
vonc cind spinN lui Honrersc gl\cr in culnro puteriiio i
e.6dopcri r cir*ai un cdcln dftnriic si Idunos, cag rnnc
itrceandmmpdc4ldrim{scv}dcfcuncanctcrnlrat,cm
I rm purcacomparaD.
c al rl hitin rii. Asdal,ln Crdisccr.
crc-sj
.tr
\omlB
la
Nfi4,i,
Hon.r
$sftrz, mirctia. du e fftr
aci nn ton ca aceldin
mai
folose$o
prtcrc. irt-adcvir, cl nu
pocnr0ldstErion,niciln tiDcadc l mcrcusustintriisiflrd
cldcn. nici rcccar mullidc depnhni ce seevari unclcd[p!
auelc,niciv i.iuncasi vieoma cr n dhcurinrilccotrdeamnila
lapte. nici bcllugtrl de imasini lud' din lrmc. lucrunlor
.v{rarc. ci in Odr's!c,, loiul rcdrDetrJtrsc la basmI ra poras
tiFr Dnorr:ilicin dc 0ene^t. vcdemcr nirelii *!{de, n&cmri

rlit jri:
fiTip#-ii*it1*ff
;:l:rilnffi*iillffiili*1""t,'."T

",",,:,.."i:,^f.l,i;.1;::1,,,,"""r,..,"_ti.,,".p.,-^,.

* *fri,;;?#:t
ff:ffg;JtiftXit;.iltji.,t;liiii

:nrf"ffi
Sffi"*ift
:i;rJffi
f#,Hi"rHr.,fl
:"1"

. XXV

( hreh.tqlursrmvetrunrtr.. , , n

COMENTARIUta PoErtcA XXlv t45e b- t46A r


i-t . g . " t , . s o J , rn u

jl":,i:
I:;::';:;
::i:.
..,.,1, tlolcr .rrmd.BJrm!,.u)u
":#:;':"n;*":
._....1

o,r,fHrr)
Din hn d " n . r , . f . , r u l, m

':"".-

".,",,
i; il:i Jil:l:;:":
;:;:ili.:l,11
li
"_lJ"#
j

;,:;".j ,;:;;,:::",1;
;; :"";r:j;:.:"

^ l:::;";ilill ti;::::-t"L';il;lltiiT
;";#;llil:';
::;lT"{H:;:..;i.."":l:;;
r".."""
...,..",,,1".;;.';;;,"J,_T"l:

r;"ilj;:T":ff.T
l,j:;.""t
; j:11
il 1ii.,,1.;

[:il:L::,::":.1;ti:
:lt#ifitillxtilii:
T'-i]T
:r:.:
_ r ,...i,.1 .
fi"l;i'JlT;:ji:ilH#
T":ll:;
:t*::j.:.::]i::
lped ons,iruErncp!tur! rLrtr
o..,,,,.", r..i,J;.i ;.;.;
|
;""i:_.;illli:X:"ffiX]'ilj;:il'f":T:i
l:"Jl";.ii:l:
;;d;: ;#::l;iftllji::;;;[t'#il,]"itT
nunu,nr dmri'e,"'
aru r o&s r , r e , ' o r h .!i h ( ' p,., z.^

ilili:;ffIj:;;,T

5'*

0nn

1 9 .,,C ea, ri trr:i ..d V 14- 19


h I z t5.VUt45tj 2 I5!

2516..,RcstAns! la cele Pc
(rd id rijq orrvn<). Din aaaii sinpli cots.,&a a lui
Ansbcl, rorcticienii irdicni ai Renatroii (si, dupi ei, cci lidnqr
ai vorculni al XVII-lea) aveausi scoat, faindsa ftguli a uni
rltii d loc,toratetdeputindstorelicl,in.iudatexlclo oro
ot, c. SiCull unft4n de dmp.claborari cm ir acocaSivremc
c l, R. B r a y , o p . . j r . , p p . 2 ? 52 3 5 s i n o u l o V l , 1 4 9 b 1 2 l s i d
asemcDi,lMrarea mai vccbe ! lui ! .lcrusdch, Ueber dtd
sh ta rathchan Einheib t i n Dm1 t. bip:zt E. 1aa5
23 , . D r c i s d i t l c g r l e c u a o ! i u n e s P r i n c i p a l i '
(otrio / ;vr d,) in sh si contibuie. atadd, 1asporiEr uniilti
dc inbn a cpopii,dupl ardlila din ep. XX'II 1459a 19$i m.
23...Amploarca (4n<).4,,pr?do AciolplicmIa
dlnir
ln alr lnnEbutntlri, cu lplictrc k sd
29.,.Mirctir" (u.1dror0<radr).Ca!iryr0<,ciliti.ll@i
.{rinsul Mdi tirziu dvoosI ajunsi rcmcDul &cut rr caftcte.izckstilulnobilii blifr.LaDcEeaios,bunioad,Deelo.rr.,
l8:[lolonFrrir'<. r.[rr nqioio<.Cl.tiDiorys.D.t/s,13
12 .,Rod0l expe'icnrci" (dnd rri< iipa.) Ajuht,
cr 9i mai
dcndrrrll(SJ0E),cumsaspEt!crp.Iv1.149a23-25
l .,Pcntr0 drn! Cl. M4-,19a 21-23
1.,,Pentru rcriunc . La fel, Honliu:,....natln rcbu:

agendiJ(8,].oIi!t!.'r'.33).CLCiccm.Ora.oal9l.
b 2l.
2.Hrirenon Maisus.noblr I 14,1?
4 .Cum rm mai spus-o , Cf M449 a 23-25
G ?. ,.Poer nl c doi or s I r or ber s c i c ar m ai
t tnv i '
pulin i n num c ptopr i u . As upna@ s h'aPec al
45-46
si
poene,
r'
L
rrodr.cru.
icc
despE
c
rhioicl
tp
lItrii
,
ca.
in
Clr$.id
d
e
reaediilclui Roshgni,Posi: ed4fct cratt
spi'to nbttdho,Tanno,r9!9,w. A2{3: ,.,..il ctruid supremo
cin ched piU
il qudcAn$oGlcuivr. dirtinguerc
mcdiante
pcia dc crdchei tuio pocsir,d chsil pock dorei) ircno

#:*i ;;:ti:i:r,rr*'1i:;H;j:;r;

D M PIPPIDI

iirii;illir:rilrii;:i:irir-{rr:;:lli

;:ir:.":;1
: :;,';lti:i. ;li.l;l:l:;li::s"1,;:.
;:i,;:;t''T:;::..;;":,:1"""";
.;ji,: "e,"";",' il
,,.,1. 1.1-"""'
.

I:r IrJrr!n,l!

.' ,

'o.

i,0 d 0 d o , .,

'/

i:nftl.iilrr::rl'll;i$riT";
ff:';:;"
:iI
*"- " ""rfi";tiiii,l"ffi

t "].fi
:il,Tt
Ji,i,;:;l.ia:t
"",,il;i*liLiili ilt'^lllJ::
0 dyiy.u rapijarr 6ios ,ArLr\J<
^aoioL/
i {m
t:]q!rlJrn uf. \j mru t A h , l. . s f r!
dk l

,,,;i;ixl,iiJ,t;.il
i.ti";il",::
:i;" I J;Ji;

jh#li*T:."i:l;:
;:.um:f:r*i':lj
ruqu.peczE r4dnrr:n! m jkru p. crr
In tt nm )

ill.li
:,fitlu __il,*,,iil"fl",ti:1.";:::
::i':1XT,1
i:
--.ll;:i}j"-.ili"lj..,Jii,""tit.l?1l}

U6A A
COMENTARIUtA POETICA
'OOV
trnFrLv iuoia

i6[.v U't6.ororrd lir{v


i6r.r 6 .ir' t0ilb!.v, dhoac ntnoadodl
(,.. nc priccpcn- $nt Muale caE vorbesc- tl povciim
niscocniridohr hciuiil.rinlinpl.rc. Si naii{.im, decaft ori
vEm. si spuncmti vo$e rdevimte ). cf.odis. xlx 203 si,
lndeob{e. pcnrs caprcitatca lui Hon$ dc ! inrgma sihalii
ln' Dion
demcrc. cclor slc. sru de r zusrivi.dirarer,ju'leh
Clisost., Or, )d 315.De rscmdni.S. Arenc, Linva.uione nta
ttr.,Rjv di Filololir".
Musac 1r,,vcitl nt Onto e in Esio.Jo,
X Cl,1 9 6 1 , p p . 2 5 ? - 2 3 1 , 3J 31 5
26.,.itrr"otr' Biii_('d ir r'iv Ninrpov).Ni'rpa
numc.n cei vechi intcsrl cenr al XIX lea al Od;-cct, dup!
episdlul b{ii descrisein vcsuile 336 $i lrn , cnd dc Arisrorclin
b 3{r.Irrogirnul
la crre F ure dMic pdc I li
cap Xvl 1,15,1
248).inou6ul
cutrir$hdirLosuldintcOdiseu5iPenclopr(165
c
infiti.ar
$tlci
strb
cloiaeoul
coovitrgsde adev&dlsririlormincin.rscpc.uc i lc dn dcspE
tsprir lLrisoani, dlsoilndu i nnbricininlo puanl de odiscu
cr pril.lul dn.i Ee.iN. inlehri!.
2? 23...Dccaiintampllri posibilc rncvoie dc
crezut_ d..(r4odp.irod' k 6i dirvdrd 4r'ila larlov
ij suvar; dnioo'd) Cf. Albessirni,op..ii,p Lxvl,,,Ncll.
combinrionedellesucsntrazioii.icllaco$ide.Moncdd suo'
pc^otrdggiilpNra puOmekrc innanzisiruzionicpd..na$r
chs nclla ralti a imp.$ibilc chc si rtuvino, cd egli Pubanzi ldi
lgnc in.ondiln)niINche checonridiconoallelsggidcll cspc'
rienza.Qudto imDo$ihilc p.d PunnonEnosi soloquando$bia
vrkrc d, innlgitrco mn diverid scicdifica,e sia usaroallo
turo
scopodi rcoderepin cridcniclr tcriri 'lo1l'anooe,tercha
puiiNldddarbikio
Doera, csrinonI nd.ovcrbb'aconsi
'm lre che il suopc^ou3B,o
un
.adt!rc.
dcuo lrofotrdancnrc
p i ..p!i dive$amenrcdal nod
cd,nde in um dah siruazio,c, detemrinaziori codesreche non

D M PIPPIDI

::Iit::l;u:::ii::t#i:::itr:1,.;;;,.
-*

LA POETICAXXv 116nb
CoMENTARTU
'Orm1r!',conpus!inrnii peft cuti1acnrEadinPellacrPtceF
ior !l lli Arexandru.Cf H Hinrcnlrne, Unb6uchu.Pen zt dcr
desAtutoblcs, D\s. Hoidelberg,l96l .
Em(4)den
ll- L . 4 . , C r i r c r i u l c o r c c t i r u d i n i i ! u e a c e l a s i i n
Do lirici t i i n p o e z i c " ( o n x i r a n r i d p 8 d n F l o r i v r n <
trdlrrLrii< Kdi rn< ro,rrLri<).o qie inteaei decriic, rtr
salukt acea*i pmpoziric ca pe ceadinlni ahm;. a rtrronohici
arreidin isroir c$cri.ii. Mi apmrto de Ealibb mi sc prc iDrc.
pFrma cm vedcin c. nu ideeamodenl a indcpcndcoro,p*2,c1
& oicc considcdticoenosciriv! saumomli,ci o ptukn&idpo.
lnva conturci dc cricrii dovedit dc c icii invdsumri si gi.
ssasc,'!rceli dc odjn iriin!,ficori tehnicin.dbn cim adni
diasruildle
sdtor ci* un lir dc rmb io educ$a linceolui
qudrc.onfusiotri obsefli.u drcptlteAlb.gglrni 'Conto
Arinorelc allerma che il d lcto dclla pucsidno! .onsisre nella
iicsdk co(npoldenza del pensicroid alcuni d{i della rald. ..
tu nella ca.tva imnrziom, +andd il poci, non s{pia rendera
convcrcimislimzae ncccssilli 3trojeventi.si no{iFrd chcgli
ercri dcllapoliti.r, dclli frcdioirrrc.c....chevnivro ncAn
comeercri delh pGi!, ribnaN omc cnod a.cidcnrdl', s4no
code{o dcllcdilficoh} dcllado$riM dellapoesiaconc
'nidzioE, pnrncllaf.m daraledeAriiorelc (.p cn.,p.126).
13..,Cun !i li !n c a L De meBulcalulti e ocupl
a 24 $i urm.
Aisbelaminun nr De nrrsu a'm., 1,1,712
2 4. . , C r r d r n Dm c . s - a s ! u s " . l n c a z u l p o c z i c i t r g i c e .
cu cle epopecr c asihih.! fi sub {es nP.n, inFcsionas!
(ia60 b 25). pnn stemha
specratolui: rd trrrrirra!
scnlrentelordenilt si d.lric{. Cf. vt 1450r 30 3lrXM45,1
a4ixv] 1455a l?; XXIV 1460a12!n
2 6. , , F u g i r i r c a l u i s e c r o r " . v c r , m d s t r s , n o rlda

u*,g*uffi

ffiffiffimffi
XXV

ffi*$g*,*ffi

30-31.,,Oclprioarl n arc codrnc .Obscflllasect


rcsc ti ln Ais.. ,,n., Iv I I , 5r3 b 16.Cl. Plin., Nrr. I'n., xl 123.

COMENTARIU IA POETICA XXV i']6' J

?2-,..rumI

cD.,_ . d |. , , o .
J , , , rt .
t
su\.r4nobil .i.,n4 Ll.plne , lln t b 1 2 rl
'r..C m \oLnc. s ! t o . jr,
N. . r, mu . d , . ! , t i , t r
.. r^ r..frri\N.
qrr
I.rdu c
'
I ro{t'smui6 :ta.s(mtu,
, t rr. , b h t r, j J c p h t u ut u L rNn
,.ureoqu(d (hd (sflL Ls ) J h ' r, (, c , b J n u q u 5 )
irc ro l
h9.'I .. qla es trdcrdr c\c. ( \,J ,^r.
nr(|. E K*uld. ub.ra,en,nE
-q:::::.::,_.i
bh.h.n aurrtu.k ter
IMIv
4r,pp_r,j'rb
ded<h &h tn{rur V t r3ar,pp.te_5rJ
nx \c purc {trmJ nin. nsur .cdprvr.F,Ldsor
nu-i;ms I
n v@r nrc jh qrc\t rjLrcjh( dlslr( ?er.fude\prcrodecire
run,r.r pomenr.,r& tsidc( e in
ercu s9ur!mtrruumid
ror ro !r' oir' uo6r< ourK or'ni
,dr !i& rq.oro,^t6d\ dp , t , & d ,
d F p m F ro r;
..'.^-!.,"",.r","
o
!
ro
.
6
p
u
(
o ! r u i6 . 6 0 , d .
l l,l"l
o ffr,ro0r ri!,roLlsc\r En p 4 , , r
a ' rs n , !
le , |0 =
urrLs
d. tu^) | p t17. a l4J.
^Du,fDAn
2.,.yrsul
desprc armc. rrird,.x tJ2 r5:ll
.. yra ii o4,y
da0,ir.L oaupuriipo< it\aro...
4.,,Cind e de horiira r d a c i u n lu f t u
s D0 s . ri
sr !i xgum.detc dc,trdh njiril r
arsorer rra!cj pdr!rrLNnl,f, d(utrJ!euopt&,ncomDr!bJ

r oo rn rc 4 h 0 brr_ l 4 ,ve .n.R)


.r .Fr!h!5

.re, *r, o* a"

-,i,.

i.

ofl b!

r,oi!< ri !r ,aro<,.!\drnt.Jr
rcs.h dc hl]r uiu ButrhLr
rcoid, rqtur ovinh o smr fidt
! e \ ts, ! $rco.d ..oGr.trll!

,.r''"..1......d...d,"..,".1:
y)' nhb!i l Jkr| i tl ri !' ]U i |

nai dqdc pentn calilicar! faDrei sru v.rbci in 'liscntie.


trdjccrivcr .rs! vrloar. in Pd!:aa. e lnannc dc bdt honlrr
l 0 . . j n r i i . a . t r i i G i D r l a <r i v r 1 6 r o ! ) , I n r t d , , I 4 3
ud.,
dorid s: rrzbuncinsula adlsi lui Ch.ys.\, Apollo nrcaF
!i
lL l2.,SIdr cra lr lnfl{irarc .rredr,xll6r
6< 6i roL .160<siv hv rorJ<, drld roolirff
14.,,Abcstocll-l mri trrc...,rirdr.IX202lAhilc
!ornrqov 3i {apdk. 6irro. a Lvrrvov iKtiorq'
r6..,Toti ccilalli... etc.vcsDdletprcduscscibscir
inputul cantohi d II lea al Uiaderl
Fiv id 8.oi r. rni rivip{< ndlropuordi
'jiIIoL
Citend rnsl din mcnoric. cr dc obicei, Ainod coDlundl
msr psq cu idcpltnl aknlnfior d cendui x (undese:tunc
c! ,uDai o pffrs din grc.i erau adormiti), cccr c.'i pclDire si
r]cvc . ..ntadi cljc inte alimllir rrsDicaudur .de,.zer s,'
dzboinici sau cnlundrti in sonn J veghealui asdcbnot.
p.me,invc.rrile
Il-133lccantuluialX.lca:
''Hrd dr' t< n8ior ril TpoLrdvdop'ioa<,
oar'rc({v rrpd noud, ad rakro n'ds' npd,
o'llrijv oupirrov r' tvonilv ,i|laidv I dvBp.jno,
inainrcdccr{li
.,Candsc uiu la lrcienii
'dmasi
El s. uins de multinea de focui erdeau pc cadac
qi dc cinrarcadiDfluiBr si Dd si de Iaflr dc dmnr"
. VtrI439=
2 l , . si n g u r i n - ! r c p r r t e . . . _ . r r ' a J aX
oir 6 diruop,i<iorL I.irpdv okavoio
22.Hitpias din Tasos.Pqsomjn4unosd smgtr l
Hippiaspini {c!m attsrarin prc:opoCnfh trsirnd c un dcmmrat
rngiar la Atenadin pncnE luper' polirice din iNulI, eKcmtrt

D.M PIPPIDI

'rron r l c. . , r r . :d , r / , ^ 6 . r ip 4 , . . , o < 4 . .

l ri ::.I:^E
1.
^^

Ll LA,oOFIICA )t{V 116l t-1161 b


CDIVIENTARI

,--eJou,n
-.1'

T.-ll,t" :

r ...q ,. h .d r r i) .

,, qrs //rJ
r",.d
i,r,.""
* . . O , , . g r, * . , . d , . * * r. . i
r ardn, d M.ruFt.S - prs. n . a : d d . .
J 1 c d ir. , d e . rr
( ltuje3/' ro?ltn(ti crrc rE ptublbr
, retcu a tur HIDDE!)
adF.n.d_ 24,. va u , , r. in q

rl
,l

"h.eed.r k
- trMdnr
r...,. ..o,a..i,
o.".u".".r. :",ri".
..! orb.. ( $ I \ r! . m
p
e
,
.
c
t
f , t o , .-. h i\ d , . . d j
3u, d
mrn.r! d Aft!oi,F tle 3,trm,Go osemcne4
po\ib,tbL il !n.
umm pc hrppE\\Jdtrdd lpnnr v\n!tJdep
a red( renrl
mohfiorc,leI1 urmrdEErisou

aeraamrsm,
crrrs6up* vuuruicr Ees",.
E-v.. D ldTo
pobk'inor rjLlKrc
Mrgol,!ur,llr.Itdre.o]A.^hdf.or
orLl.ts21 n 146rm

.![pd) rd.cuiodprmun!k tut v oi


o, neadtr ou HrDD!\
oDtrnea
mmFk\ 4Gkr plni Niz, a. .a r,,t.rr",r.
rrxl t)g r
,4 ,Mutlumi{i unc hu n e t c s p r. , ri
\ r;
c or idrqFeo.c! 8tk oviok.unfl huncf!f,cLu4ri
"
oru0 6! 0r'rr l$!or'ro ra npL! pa0o! aod4i

11,oL

?6..Trc.ura n,r bin.. c t r. ln / rrd r X 2 5 2


253.r
cnFurudu.rrrdj'ii nrru(\ odi\eusphe ru%,r\,rttr
nqpo,xd./ r nrio/ y,)a
rovdloP
o'pdu''rA rot6
(,trkadrerl tLlcl;: tu,Mrmu .htur!mabneLl|,l
!N/Drdl
4c nofl,! numa. nft L|G{lm ,n! rin6nc.
crcd,ere;J.
r
r {f (J In ( kr.dupjrfim,FJ ! r I

,I4i alenoplif (d altecuvinre,nt mtrltdedod ftmi), Odietr


.adiclultimtine.
Durcapftrindcci,Jtuidn$nc!opft
2 3..,Pul par ede c os i r or " . U ;r dzXx
, l 592:r v N i {
,!or < J r r drr ddd'r i pdr D upi c um D i x tr r i i dev i n!i api i s e
spuncobisnuii,,vin
.roranlel iajului(dcoositdid!mcrsl)din
3 0.,.T o!r n! v i n l ui Z eus . ti ad?, x x 211:
3 4.,,Ac ol o opr i i D - s 'r " c r ctt'd,, x X 2t2: r i l
i ldxso ts{rivlv (turexrulPeri@i:xdI.ov)i}xd<
36.cl rucon. Dupioiporczir lDiRo$4ni,d fi vdbadc
cunoscurulrapsod nrierprethomericClaucosdin Rhegbn,
pomenitin dialosdplatonicIo,,530 d.
r lcriios in od,tmr.ll52,Penelopa
e inliisaticafiici
5.,1a vcnirca in LacedenoD! . Od,ie4lv I timn.
9 l 0,J $i gr s esr e m or i v ar c a
lo ..,i ni deal i z ar c ar dc v !i tr l ui ( r pd<r i oi x r Loy ) .
Aspidtiasprc,,naibins
cmcdzeazi.dupiAGtocl,intcasa
vi4laui ur i i or gar i c eC t D .gc , ax r ,I1r l 7a15:r dv 'l
il 6Ldrd iiky.aiov ro(i i rd rd o lor;De8e,
OJoL<
etenpt,\\3\6b21: tv daao&airo0 0.Irioro<'lpi).o0ai
Oor.v rij/ dJoL/;Prys..VllI?,260b22:rd6i 13iXIov,ii
ia0ld[0dvo[.v tv rn 4noa rir.ip!{v, dv i 6uvardv ctr
obPfladile din lr@.rueE, !. 47fi urm.
ll,..oi m pos l bi l i l atc l c s nc d
rabil il crc.cl. xxlv 1460i 27.
l2.Zsuxis. DespEoperaaccsluipictor,vczinotah
1,1]s .,,Int!c e. c r c r os i di l " c tc .I pr uc a l ui
Asathon
Eprodust
mri sus,XV r4s6a 2.125.
2 0 ,.C r E!r i pi de de i nter v enl i a l ui Ai geus .I0
215

l46lb

D M. PIIPIDI
2r. Din o..\r.
r,154a 23

A trelu Q , E u n Dd cv c , jn , !

COMENTARIIJLA PO'IICA XXVI ]462 b


.nr

XXVI
)r_ta...o ,fl- .J'- nu ,
, in , . n . , .
, ,r r
'
.
.
cr
dnj i,?o4o ,,|u { ,
cI
, , o / . r, it r\ D r. r: l
rnur.rrtu\-det. , dr.i.
nj. bni.r rno"u vqjn,,dn
e
trnnumJ ir,mr mrmcd\rI kaecdtr,(!, p
e
@Lc
dvr
-za,
on(cn4(
rh'4t).db, tupr. j_ . u g u , { r, u d , . . r !
n,.huL
@ pezc &.r{a tm,rt p:d ! ret Lrl fitrd.LD(enskL.

ill

l,l

r2. .scrlr-. cu muril pmbrb,hlJreun


Ll,tuambdl lui
io l rX n t 4 5 4 rlo .
r+ Mynn,.Lo\.orgindi t o c t r, k j\ rn E lh c . a . o n k m,
PUrm(uE nh!,{e{rMrtomer
nu !r In!rc ! rrgi.(vrr?1e{.h..lu)
l+15 Cr ipjde..
imr
,r! AJcibadr (ycnuph.,co,! . t1r.
15.Pindar. pesomj nccuos.ur.
7 S , \r\rrrro. Rr|si! i! . b 0 u (u rh
d rc s ln
opu n L T o rrd rd e n Nn (u o rlu
_.

ll...P oezia rragicI isr p ro d u c c e t c c ru l


s i t ir!
|' d( m(rr!t ! i, D! h s \ d c ru Ct . . d c
,._l5..P dr
/8.r.,
r ,o r,$pr
t009mm, Eu n p .r@j/ . 5 c 5 rm
I of!'' b b t o u l p t rn e d e re lre f . .
^ -rl.,D,r!rrc
u s d e B u k t , e r. . ! t riL ln e (o l
,mprc\nuni de Hily
L, prupnde LletJ !!. drdc.: d.

pr odr c c nai nutti pti


1462
c.re-(rd y,ip dopodro@ri&o r). rde e dezvotratd
cum,i
mul@dn nunrein Prchl,x\4II 91?b 8
2..,Od&ur lui s o roc I e,,.o {iatnmd dux,rcferjma
e
l^(*drhEAe.
9 .,,D i n m ul r e as cm enea pi r l i " .C onr ui c c r c ac u
)LXIIIr,159at9um,enutudapae{.lnEarnrle,chEvedc
din lr<rv r459b 26nan..Arisorel n! uir.ici fofta ci mBriv!
lnglduiecpopeiio cxrensiune
l ce n o podc aringcr$ecdia,
ftdBi rasinplai'Ji!\3ie a inrrnpt:ritor deslisude pc.cenr.
l3 - 14.,,C i c um an ar i l ar o ta v r c ne" .l n nai
nurb rendDn.
ct rwl t462a l3 s]IatLducerca.p.4r
1 9..D * pr c poez i r i am bi oi i s i c onc dr e.,.
Cuvintcplinrc de h sinslr maiuscrn.Ricca.drsrur46
(cl.c.Lmdi,.,Riv.di
FitoloSid.,Il,1925.pp.55t
555).As$ra
pI4ii piedft a P@o&r'.inc& rebuiesi fi IGr barabsuhi.rcre
adlel aruntato,
rczi lrrftiJD.eEz,
tp. ]l 12 t, nai depdlg,
AFcturiccrc
II, u\re. ponindde,! o sdicn modeniinctrin,r.ilsa
nunitultrj lra.ra.,s c.,iririrnr4 sehcearci o rcoonrnutreri
linli hdi a co.etlici tui Ansbcl dsspr cohcdic.
Tcxtd abia adinfi rc,e ton pisblr dc trn oan0lcft
msccrdeudinscc.x (no.r20alcoteclrciDccoistin,6rizi
ltr
BiblioreaNdionaDdinpris).Logtjtuna@sui.cup@rt
rfon
nordi penh lndia di deJ.A. cimcr (car I a |i ednarin vo,
rrnur inlirur4,4r..dor, crrer s c.dd tn'nuirnrk Bit iatlcc,c
Resr'uP'tJ?,sr:s.Oxford,l 339,r, pD.4o3rd). ddrexrnoul
problcnclorpc c@ le puninone abincu sruditrltui la.ob
Ben1ys.Erye.zuDC
zu Aniobtet,pocrrr (,.Rhcin.Mnscun,,
VIII, t353,p. 561uih , reriptuitln Z||.i Abhanltu,scnijbet.Jie
r*beliehc Thtutic16 Dtuns.pp.133t36),umrrt,o,rceg
dishntrldc c. Kaibcl,Die pr.reSorc,allEpr (nMaArA:
(,,Abhdl.
d G.\ d.wiss.zuCdiitrCen,
Fhil hisl.Kla$c".N F..
rI ,4.Berlin.1393)Ji dc J. Kryser De vetr,n tuc t@ticx
q,,.y,ordJc e..@.dis.t rpzig,1906.

D M. P]PPIDI
..U|u,.|elcu'd'uT

;.:;",;jii'l";,;,;":';;:lL^
;,1).\:;,?l
i;
iii:.'ii."'';J.lii',X',...#,i,"',
rij:::,:j;.:
t. +" r.,^.,
I#,l:'tiliili:'j"J;.;":r.,
-'".
T _'.|.lrP.inL .{n _
do dl, rl
u \aao.crJr\pre.uTeJFrrnu.. ttr. rkr, |
-4a Alri er..6,un did . re n e d c . n , r . . G m. J
Jte t;,

;IT .."''"''!'de,.l!r'U'od|U'D ' r. n ' J ' d ' l

:ii" ;'":';;"i:;i:"i_
,,^,1;::"J'"Tf,:
:;::*.:,;
;':;,,,ill.:l,liilil'*'"rc

stustr"u'ui
.: n ctrak

f6bnntketnmod tc mr in p lu p . n n (. . rld ru n d .
.
kmn ( t6 qigr:rjbuie t! A rd . rc t (ri
ma s rn rrc a re n u
'
phre rcr(n tr rdcir EJtrfu Urermpmnnr
epufl,etenfrilc.
!!,1rr nd!cRaphnuesh!qzrn,t.
gcru/u dr4nrn! r Drmu,,r.a cad' apJric e uclpuri tu
rnri caid c ror.ompu\l pm0!,

,",,,,^H"Till
lnxit:ff
"jJil:H"J"il:"
J,',i
;illi.iJ;t
;ril[;1.H:t[i;,':T*."
:;llt; iti":*'f
:Iil--.it:
r,ta m nrim! hsrrtrj rlirn4irh rrabtutrl'i jiv4drun
lur

undtuunurreu,ie Ll prc\mr'] nr rtlode,LD


usordcimclec
o-ru,.. kimer reaLlrcbtrr tcrrtui in dr.ur
e. LtuDa;,ra
Ianlratum an .tunt FasneDD\Brr)n.1qst))

COMENTARIUL\ POETICAXXVI 11n2b


FfulnrcduJom,Delprccomed'e'

;;di,l
fi ile!!{$tr
-"b
inpl4ir! in didacrici si reoreticil),cca
rau
in cae posolajelc strnr
'lraha.ici,
cm imbrrthcaz{6mdia, &agedi!.nibii
2. Piin compftimir ti tom!. tagcdi.isbvefre prtincnrclc
splrmomealc strlrcruruirceeacc 0rniiEne e o droapi[ htkuli a
I Comdjlr'mDierDei&duruh:2ir5'f.\pr)vir. d.u
<n gni i\nl)odobi'-oqhtrdu|]r JeLuril.nc_
crrci plrli . ci, imnate hchipun{ dc oameniin acliutre iar DU
povs r. Ji care pe crlca des&tdrii !i I sulri sdvir$clre
cud!rca accsrdparni. prrinbte oi e srt.
4. Resdc {imit ds erpnmrresaudc siltratii.ir 0nnd cd.
porrcli prircjuirde o pokirne do vorbc(6ruyuIia). dc vorbe
avandmlai lntclcs (ouyryuaia). dc nec&eal5,ddvorbefonmrc
unclc din ruclc prin a,lllugier sru inlltunrca vEunui suncr.do
vdbcdezmiedr&rarc,dciorbnabir(c!ehsuls eva6em[iiror). in sfi$n dc chipul cum sc vorbe$e. - Risul dc pc urnr
3 urriilor pone li pitcjuii Jc o asenuirc (cu cev! mi rru sauo
cevanar hun),de o mlgnc j dc o sibqic fld icsiR, dc o siin4re
irvordili rhssd fii! rrmin, dc un cltci nea$rcprat.
de bDdiotd
de a i.Jitita Fsoddclc inr o luin[ dcrrvonbili. dc tr! ,l!nr
rclalocullui. du un om din cci ctr aurorirarc
cm nesocorctrc
niematc ilcryind dnDrflcacuri. dc o vorbrrcdczlinarl,
'nrcrcsc
cmn rreni.icrp tricicoadi.
5 Cdnedia se deosebcJrc
Jc 6arj(ud cad remc aceNr
inl,ereazicusulrir.ne tatr,com.diaieLdrsci,Lcccac. sc n!6 ZcrcfrhrulumnniBsindnn zczcpicarctcsurerutui$i

2r3

D.M PIPPIDJ
? Aia cun rebuic si exhlco dHptil hisur r rricii sGnite
derasedii, rcburc sr exisres o drcapri,ltsud a dsnlui &inn
3. Elcmcnbatoricirei comcdiisuftr subiect,clracrcr.
ludccrri.9151,nuzicr.spocramt
subicc!enic e cel broddpeo eriune haztie.
CamreE propdiconedieirunr:at bidnmrlui. d Drelicu
tului$i J lrud.ircsutui,
Judccrt!scurl in doui chipuj: phri ,i doveziDovczit
sunrcinciijuddinc, tnvoicti,
nrrturij,cu ne.lcsi
9. Limh cotudiilor c er obrreascrsj dor;nd. anlorul dc
mmcdiic drlor sr prntl ttrgun psEonajcror
lmbFi prj4e^cr.
datficitrdul peficcc s! vortodcr dupitocui dconsineCtuttrt
e@vacctnsdedannzicali:d.
aci3ccuvindlrtuarctcciree-l
crEuz.sc.Elcmetrtulspectlculos
c deo b& trtitirabin s;crrl in
droc,candcvolbadcin.6url$ncbhGn6c:npi<
rij; Uuro.
riy orpooyicydnmuscfiselor
nunj se
'!'idvcrBcnays;
pft
intcliSibD.subiccr,rc rnc,cad setbdlnesch rodcofredi erjudccdi, curterc,3leDctr! sp.c(aculc_ mmai tn uoctc.
10.P{4ilc.one'lieisunrparru:
oo ttrj.
Eotog,inrcfrerlja
prologul
o pdea.omdier& rincpari h inrrca oo lui.
xoNfdr, cinrulioronatdecor,drcil areo (ecaic inri.dc4.
Episoduleesceecupinshrcdonrcdbruri
zlccorutrn.
Exodulcac iDrenenliafinari { cordui.
I L Folunb come.licisun. vcchc(cae cxuercazt norn
slumatl).no0,(caE,tcpndindHe
dcaesielcmeni
iictjnrspE
srrv dc). mijlocic(unahcsecd rmanduom).

rtli

APENDICI

cncsc:3d rp4r;rpo! i <r6v r,ijy i r,jy,


r\}.idy,cu Grdmon,conptclrr. cenri dc
tv ok kI r't, ktiutrea n$. xr'c,rdi,iB 16
ii P?risous 2133.r.lo. de kord rd, otait dc
rixprjviaL d< .i6ory a ir.iv : d<,pm
h,oi<.coenendaticatuiyahlen ordinca
cuunrerd e sDtcnrl dercsiuna rsbil.
,Ay0.i, cu wctcker,
aer8k, wnrm*itz.
nr.16y (pend arrdy),6nj{bn tnicudm.
rofLv tonoraor<l:i 6L,riiv, cu Twidir! si
tndr'oi< (P4isi,ar
l7,rl). Maidnatea
c'lilorilor pFferl ,jroron, kqiu;ca ms.
in,.r 4( iq(i,tfu po6.Ly!ao$40orrrro.l
oioL rd!,ru By$arers Bdchcr.
.i6,t 3i,ni4e dydy/bpioo<,cucudctom.
,l'd\Ioy, i sdyLio0,oucudcna. ti Ehc,inre
nEllli Dcvcxiuncr r$i. Cf ComcDhriul
p. 134si,maidsptrE.Apendcle Iv.
,l dirdy 6rir0oL<,, rvoL< 6, rr d,0.. cu
Gudcd.n.tn loc de: ir ailiy, ().jd'o 6. r1

ARiS]OTEL SI ARISTOFAN

II
ARISTOTILSI ARISTOFAN
lojufl boict [j$or[.c r c.n,.,tii

i
smr mi binc de pdnrzcci de ani dc c6nd tnr{c@
Ifti
iidoiau urilii,dqr c ciei meri.cbj s au pilntdinbrdcaua
exagcnier-pturesolrrnodLaneCooFrdrcp$tndiscurjc
uM(r1tr
acelepbblncpccrsfilolosjj !u cAbodadrendiltr
sitc
ocsopcE,lcnrdI s aco apliilmrdeatcsisj.$tNi..vErn
s.spun:chcsriuEadeaI * lcl decienDtcvaIj rotsira*lotcl
t Drtr a ti itusra reonamnicuhi.in pdlca pie da ! pocrer,
sru, cr sami crpd'n maih'nurir. .c Etd van cxhhr inh acc
hieoriesoperaldiA rlofar.depitdi?
Lancea{i din urniinrebmc,rrspu,suntcn- tiDsn.de
cind criticii sc rudcs. sI d.onnttuic invirirln tui ;$obt
dcsprccotudic Larc clsper cibszi cabva,
-in sercldl dcravorab'le a(onrlui Pjs:t'1o4 ii rocnai Dcnrroa
l)lorc$ ihporjva
utrcijudcc4i soNrit! ncimcneia{r ie dii osbnqh si corscft un
clpnoi rlcirlii la carenrrfcricaizujrii.piliitorcctorcc I au
prc.cnat.ropriulsiuoxdncn-prctbrs.rpundjncipuuoc0tui
nu tn !c parcooovngdror.
De acccrnu S.viistrvin asuodi.
supuneiJtrIc,lwaobsc ari,cuarft mriblcnroscucat.dtrpi
JLnnhmer.d'nery N I I s:r'dir prii sdtzi s:i_irare s|rbjciuDea.
tABhard

tu ,rdh'linvhLtu:

n kd

Ca intde ln mrtcric, iit[ rprecie(! pe c{c Lrnc Or)!3r


p e'n
unuiqitrcdeuli.lui Bubhcr:,,No
crcdea oputlareprosd
Ll.
h
l
Ari.rlLclvl
utnn'l\iLic
lndo,de lJpLul'1,.r
"t(lithfli
pureEd. mrc'nruca dLAn{ofr'r.,ii!ts tio fiizi \p(u' I
pc ru r o inlidll - in J,bdos@ la Pocdi! arsknclici a hr
Ing@n By*ater: ,.Dactidvitltul
ajuns,amli sisn &i[ lDddidi ci scpotiKst nai binc comcd'ci
noi ditoperei lui Arinolm r. Abia draftbuic sl dev ci, ddcii
d din$i poateinhdlwa da loc la cotrfuzie,in nlsur in cdc
prcdpurcln cruzi s.nribilnnt a lnisnca r lni An$obl.lm
dcrftbi dccarvedcnk-i l{dicc asupraco'nedi.i, @ de'a doua
e ctr :c poarcde limpcdeti de Prcisi Ada*a nn I ihpiedjc, p.
Lmc Coopcrs o intelcag[ cr ri cun ar pdvi nericlc lierm 3lc
comcdiogduhi. ceeacc-i cteazi obligrir de a lua apllrca lni
Ari(ofdi impotiva unciinvinuiri cs i sc l!rc Derlapti $ .m r
n,rtu adcvllr.daci r av@sentulP. ce i'l rlribuie invlldul dc
Ul]rmd c ci. de a lmeul lnhlului $diu decaE n! ocup,
cjtirorul arc iqrEsir ci nici unul din dSurontere nvocrr. iu I'
.ling tinrai rodrcpar oa*cun stlinc problcDreiii, iD rclliEie.
reD! h sm$irul dcDoast{iei,legltu cu !trbicctll dmift discu
iilrill Nici mcrod! cffi snsisd in nunnnu p.srjelor rnde nu
dle lui tuiioldn solnielndtcin scrienh fib7ofdui. pentu a de_
du.e Biaduldc tdiliarirarsd ccsluiactr opc comediosnluluii
nici ac*r a iBn$ni dciudecrri lavobilc dsuDraacesbi opcrc
emrnind de lr dirici d0t {te deoscbilitntc ci cal po! ti Platoni
Quirrilim.Cie$ii St ]on Gu" dc_Au,-n ru Diric i flce ctr
sircun chcriun cd d fi tcblilst ftlin, atenliaautofllu1.rr
Jc a irr in c misurr o picsi M Ad,,Db,t, depildr, cn licut{ s,
ilu$rcP con.cplia ,rislolclici dcspE concdie? De la incepurul
pini la sltusibl catiblulni. domtclre aslcl r'n el o pdmnc !

D. M, PIPP]DI
i qfu/r mra ior'e.ut r\ n,. , i.
iJ p ro o ib , ,a t u .A , . o rt l
41u-crrrcr on dLi.. r ! . p , o p . k . ,
r{ . ic . d a m. u r
rrLl.h.JeF.. ,-l.rc4. J t o / o u t u , . . . , u . . c a u ,
,tr
'u 0 n(ar
pu
Arn,t p& : ri urbr ri rJnnlk lu ptubi
penru HumcrtiincIn.ftr.,5pre,cdto
nu t4r rhored(.trsr+l
<\crcrcs(J duntumuii!r(t u irJ rc a (, . u mp 4 q n
I
(a ,ps:onc&e'
trn( io lldgin,tcp!e,c.r nu
'neori!nirpMe,
vrersrplnrnrcitu!!A
n,ord 4 lid f ra \ E f ra c b . J re s n n lc n
o ernrmosrkruf.euujnrrl
, n lE s d ro , ; b .
f (iu r L t d pm
nndrr smgtrf4inr(bd
ff src:r f, ueb! rs L o DrnaLtrrc
\{per( sr. lnsura pc !aE nr
5L, p6,. ft JR;.ntrr3d"
comprehmsibri!ftn!dtrpr46hobsd{,dcmentur
d vr,l
q.s, u.. h.{ne JcJstuln
io rrs rd e c re mn h rcn . t r.
uir(oc : 4vdrpnrejut,5ok:(j c! ! jrrcc4c
tusemrF
_
r c flnn itudnd
ne nbr d c I
crmcn(Le \onsLruri!erk didm, _{duir
rc Hrc AJ'sloFlll
nun,.|LnF
oi 0rad < t u u ! u 8 o . , o t t u I RJ f ' d e , jr
ru {ubrdu '!d'u!
A{Ad tmptu,, d(urle jn mod IEs
tlD
cofccprr dupr lrie uncc \rr,c pudrr
& fi .ituhkr 3i
,rcpr7ed3rcd (rridLii.d!m,R?hLt,porbrl.nor,\trle
or
lrtujnr ! ! r' m( selui I trLlrc5cbi
tlrma. ri,nLlo imn,ii. a
rcur.Lrrcru Ecilrei\iciun_c: cr f,ioqs.tuqirelr
rrbrtrr
n(xou .,E!trsmr mei hpr., iu r unc,.dliLU.,^,rendiohdc
r nf dn mr'eil.,itrcpdut- n ,nrfd!t.7nnc&e,
raardn.!aJ
r oncrrercohedl,apu fncalr Lmc
Co"n* ! nrc j et d;
vrcm. c Drrun,rr (iprol J .ritr
otr r sficJk sd \arc:
. rNo.m!.i h p.e7i, kreLi\rurrrd.ii 6mLl,c
aJ n!,el prrc

AFISTOTEL
5I ARISTOFAN
!i li socotitintiea sduc$nonia ans,mbluluica finid DrjrcPrltLl
elemcoicanrilativ,accl dc c(c bare celelrlrcd.p,nd.."1. Din
piclb,mastajudi.iosllconsbm n*l impicdidrsip'esupunici
teoia omcdici.,F.uN ligun in pde!pFduii r tdbiar. hbulc
si fi fon ,.de a.lunsdc ct!{icr" pentu a imbrilr$! deopotL
prcdncriilsvechii * noii omcdiie, nici sil dagi cotr.hzir (pc bab
dsr rcmeiuri nu se giindcSEsI ne o spun!) cll, 'luN rorte
pobab jt4ile, idcal0lSugintuhi in mrtcdc decoDedichbtrr sr
n f.( ,,nncomponil inh calirrlh eld nui bnnecomdii ile
rcchiul$finouluirct.no "'.
Cu r.1 dpc.!, cNcnit aubn r i a$tat srld1iasupncsericii
celor vcchi. du poi si nn observcI a lace o a:cmcnca!tumrtie
inscmnl s uih ci, dupll Atsbbl, pcnN r rjutrgc ia rormr i cvo_
luu din vcaculal lv lcr.mmcdiaGai tasedindcalrditrtn)
cuno$useo lntcr!, cvolulic'r . porninddc l. Stusolaneleinpro
viTrii numne.dan.uriralicc'rzsi ft.end pnn knsfom{n pe
ce, in nomcmol candi$ sdh P@tta. rtrldul nlltnri$a r nu le
roi puteauonsitoirr DespEintiidsfa ceanainotrI I co6.'
dici,Iilohtul N nespdnc-.um o hf pcntu tagcdiatiinpului
s$u-drcl i prrc a li lrins tinh dlriil a tchimbl orce_icau
hturzit, acea4itoc propic p. clre orice liinti saulucru asPirl
so rcdiazeLa. P(ctilrilc ltri dcspEdrmi in gereFl, ca si dcspt
lcgdluile dinrrc tagedle si sbedie sunttot$i suhctnlc pen.o
eenlseasupra
ca .plicenda@sbiadinurhicdtevadinjudccll
pdtn
ci
i
inrept
Diilm
corect
n
sigud
cclci dibtei si
srnddl

n*ii$$l$*r**ra*;-*s,ffi

D M, PIPPIDT

#*'-ffi
;."rlir;,iir;,;,,:r
]; :.;i:ru* j,li.

ARISTOTELSI ARISTOFqN
Rindurilc aoc{ca sunt{te{ul dc limpezi pe$tr a nu arcr
dcvoic dc cofionhrn Rerxi din clc ct, pa&ivir Dnciconocp|n
pcntu crre druna sc irliitisr cr lb
1o1m,
po e inbrio Nozia ti. ni drmi chir, &Lain rlt*a
dcsiversni I utrtri D$cs de nnnalie umlrind sd repreTintcpc
id
o acliutrcrosttifi dDpi lesile tdinitutui
ri n4eselui,
a o l,%c.ri.ci cra Inclinar si aFcierc in chip desebir com
iddr. A[cl
diilc r .i6r srudurl s apmpi mi nrul. d.
'l$nta
spus,ctr.iriit-. co'ncdiccm mainulriintig! sauscl'une,ctr
ar i sc vr n inmiif{ n*i dc'nnl de a na alntrd dLd$n'a tiPrs
mm dn ddcn$o, cu rlir hbnic si i seIi Din. tui pededr''.
C(c 6ahrI. din re* puncrJc vcdere.pozi!a lui Aiiofan
f.lide iut i conbmporaniai Shltislu1, pEm*ori ri comcdiel
noipc caledecon$ituirclFlrI r sh sI lnccn spcculahlsupm
sdctrii comcdiilor
salepLerdutc.cncindoielnisc!,h'ccapde
r og-rei ca ne a 4um si dtc hcbuio si lic caamai EPre^n.orivil slulsubicctrldinecoronir licctuc'p,esee maipurii
tnsemnatdccit acel!L ,divodisncntclor' c[c, la licc. pas,lntE
nLpdestjnnra htign. Aceanac
mi mulli critici $nt dc ic.rd L' ti, dacr Lanc coopr sc ft'le
oblierr a se depiinadc cceace s
opinion,imivoiineddujsrnuhplrriicschodrturdcaopn
clanii a.crsti olnriegEsitll.'Elcnc ulfu sncnbl ri odcftei
pi$e a luiA.i{oran $d. el ltreoarll pivirti eomarcid@
hozlie.cr.e derernjD, dct iilo: ln md mm nisud decat*ip!
deimasimric cu ctu. o puneni sent. accanac aacr cc oglindcstc
tirirscnn uisilu re.Afi.miiacrtirdcadovinLi cartriDitui
nu-i va lreceprinnimc s o ti!:idtriiscii.Dtu odrtiD,rimrli
ncc.$aelrdlcglludctrproblctucroncrulltertenria,tia$ c

[t*'**r**r,ffi

*$n#r*r,'i:ffi

D.A4.PIPPID]

ARISIOTELsl

l#n:"nii."ilx.r"t
ilni::iii#iji!lxti

iitil

tnde$llt uc pcntu a fa.c cEdibilc idanpHrilc si lip.utl.


ocljunii inlnisaE pe sceni'?r.
Rcgtrle carc csrmuie{e cx$ctetlc pcdonljclot e rBca!,
cfc .rmuie$e intig.. tozulEinl F cdc-l umlih c toL vr'o_
rirj/0t sru
,,tfa lel ca sPdsolcsaufaFele fie.tuuia sI
"e.ss?.,1,
ftedebmindredcvcssimilitatesdeFvoie si.idisi. o lspti sa
critrlvcresioilnluisauncsesmlui 4
uneEdupld!!duplc
k randullui . .dcznodimin.ulintigii tmbuics! E datoEzc
cmdel.rdo
or, !\i d unci inrcflentii diinc s. cea cc nvino
a lpunc cd,rtui ds cdri excaplionild,.,ininu|ltrna rrptclor nu
_.
ftbuie sl !i faci loo nici utr elementinliolal
stiruinra cu ce Adstotcl rvino asupmaccsEi ditr Drmi
popozitii. p.ot3nd o dati cl leul ninculosllui c in qrolEe",
alri datt cil lntigi dc ldlrldccstr ucin-d hbui ludc in consdcr.lic1N,
e semnilicdtiv{lentu alitudincaSt3gnibluifatl de
liDr,sr4 cl.mcnt { cirui inriurircasupEsPccraroluiorccu
noa{e. dr pc careI r vtua lisar lr o pane dc r0ioni drsndici,
ptni dolo ol i sfiruiesb pc acertiadin lni si pElde'ltrtardn
nh posibils,mcvoic dc crczur',pcclc,imposibft cu iollritdrca
dc o n adevirrrc (rpod,p.io0ai r< 6<i d6',vdrr (irdrd
uduov ij 6urcr; dnioavo)2t.in es$e cond,tii,iporoTalui kne
C@pcr dtrpi carc.dinh Mlc nicsclcl Arndm,Pisrteun
avu(cclc mai Nnlie sane si1plsl lilo2oluluia mi selm tudc
putitrplauzibiu: ii, dc buni scrmi, m argdmcntulcI un dlo! c.
si sBLi tuir.r
aurorultd trlui DcVr t$,1/Dt'r./ortcblie

r'*ru*ffi

t;T:lj;';tiT:":
",l,il"t:;;".;:,:::l;:;Tii:,

;+i**#-tffi
illllljiuil u1r.r',
""'*

*3r**+*fl:ffir*r+*m
irfli::.,,*.i
;;lii jr

u]* *j,i,;iUlll"! ',1:;ij"i;-";


ri:
i:11i";ix;,il
i

rrcrD M Phpd|.dr&"erqri4lr

h. iid,iit.m

fl,.;l;jl,t:'-;';;;';;:';i

lT,.i:J:ili1*;,Jti1;t*fr
^",..;.#;l;.,l1iili?:":l::itfi
:ai::l:
!31

v!tu

D M. PTPPIDJ

ARISTOTELS] AFISTO'AN

de$mq]srar
X1"J'iiii,"i:;[T:1"*llllt*dcslisuslc

t:r.:"T.:;,.:l
:::;,il1i1.
;::T;"
".,:,:;i
lj:T :.:i :i#i'l:Iil-'T
;J:;T:.:"
i,t,;i_r:,
ll"Jilll,tly;,
iiiil,lilX
li,.t:
$"T.I:t;i:;::_
*r - ^ p ",:; .*- ." " "
!, urursec\pirnr ib prurr'] J rr

. { f , in 1 . J e n $ , ; r. . e ,

;T:l;:'";j1:f.J,',Jr',
:" "'..-il:tl,i;"r:1:i

::,::::JilJ'1.";:i
ff;:ii::it*"l
t:::"r#:::r

plih.i.t,*ri,

ioDlir&

mri n , , t , _ , , * _ t " r

*",.",,.,

*'tltlt"i'i.'iiiiiJ'Ti.il.t::.'.1.^::t::,:
l1lt:r

xor \r h(. si 160(.1 vu q lrp,,,,,., _;


;;;;;, i:il
_c ko"-,Is"*;_.

;i:T.i::*t,1i1ii.,:fJ:t"#
T:;ll.:,;li;;:::::

rcstmea
!ed n(u n, prrm r at! brJ,le,e
Leer .c ,c sraromn.sa,n xcnc tundu

,jrn, _n"-"

ilil'iffiH:t#ff
nlTl:tlit..,,i,
H:friJii:
r! n om(rr
rJrk sner+, ne uo trhaDDri
{cmrf
-qnulr
j1.fi
j:*itT,lr,i
;J#:;i:;i,;,riiilTtJ
'j""::k"ti
::
*iiil,ll"4l.rii#,t"Hri:"liiiiililii:r
"h

q-e cr,ry

rGn.rls

cs si in dD, ascnlhtu)ri d fiecrre diotc noi, ftbuie sene depa


|eascr pril amoni! u{s uilor si p
adevlratpcnh trye'lic. ri o!rci crci, in loc si ic cr iori om.nii.
suntmi degrahrasacufr f kcbui sI ne bf oaneniiia! rccasd e
adevnd si pentrucomdic, .ic ctuci pc^on+ t.huie saimhace
un cracbr dc Scner:liEb ln {m i lc faocii l)c clo rePrcTenratire
Fld r li sEnit pri nult asutra accsui ptrnct, id panea
plsrari , Ped.ct. Arnbbl nedi (n$i sun.ierte iDdicali pcnh
, j puba rconeird geiduI Asrcl. dnpi ce ne3phc c{ la diginile
ci pezia s d l, inpinir Dotivitlhiipmrilorlunii narudl.nobile
andrapblcdahenilorrlcii,oltiisuflereledcrind
sigdrc-jr
pe c cld vulgsri), hsr sl $ inteleagl cl pdnslc manifiin
,le Muzeiconicc ar fi fostni-sre'ntrsdn (!,d]]dr,oudbcu
rtrcrn psnon.lc piilojuire de gc$d s.u de aritudini nprc
'intc
heNibilc din punctul dc vcddc al s
conpusoinvcnuriiambi( fi dlinuitpa.lmunpdrde3eiiu,
aurorult@ Dluicsiconi. Marg
sl admncpcntD
nLnilor
sii cale!viitoniui,dindu-lcposibilitrter
inteia odl a icipalir uneicanedii . Accsa - di 3cspuned6pre cl
lncrpitoltrllV,.aNaE.hlormc&mati.enuinvcdiv!,cjce
nrri ri y(l\oiov 6pauirDno,rior<).lnt-adc
mic0l(on4r0'1ov
vir, id rapon cu c.m.du. Mr4ns e cccaes tagediile tati dc
ornm a. li vakDrcalesior inrorm i lsuprain@Cutudlor
tahlui ln ecncnl si a1ercatuld somic in Paniculr (c dc ajuns
s[ spnn cI Aisiolel rtibuic parcmnatei lui lttdg]ts a onlui
,irdct fl ci o bun, panedjr cridcr rcspinseEonlirdrilc h'i ca
lipiir. dc rcneiv), el. rd in oricecazrcrnd dc a ne lacc cu'
noscrrc vcdfilc filozorulu asusa unui subioct din cclc nai

dnrein .r.b .m,ro\m-\


lnpd

sl
ARISTOTEIu crL n..r1- rcnj rerl

:j::::'11,1';::":i
::;.,..;11:,JT"j.:u;:
"
I
Nm< sr trDMlo(_tn o{ s ( s mp t lt e rc u E n
a ie , o ru rd i

::":l.1"
t:;*i;::;*i"":,t:
il--;: :;.,
::.;'t'Jt::,",1;:
i :ltl:::^;;:iJ:H,j':ii:l
rumr- . l.ru,,rnptrl fzfl J! I fi ,'*r*,,_r,n*nr"r,t"

aspira!d$aE .:i1. o g+
cuizbucnnc! d,.boiului pclopotresiac.
ienrcroElipecdn0clenes.rcp(dicetrd o,d.sitnr{Md.ldc.
E.ccr e i di aacrtol 6tfl, aPblpc durcos. cm o disringcinh
opcrclecomiccilc tooror rimpfilor,c ca ceftc .[, liinii dn
acrualihre.Frrii pecereaae$ci r.rtrdiiili in inhagr_i shcltrri:
subiectelei pElraresunlioribpliiii dlrle Curilii. rtr anii plihu_
iinicelcidi aiLigi lMidmi idorinilepcctuek 3ptuadsllDtrcs
aspnrLiileuFi bm pini ! so.ictlli' acnicne.r'trgtunfi dc prc$c
tFr crrasroteiapmpiaLci
I csamjelc ci se lumcsc Soc$@ii
aln$ s:laPropie'nasa|G drtrnnnd
Clcon.
E
dc
Eschn,Eunpidc!i
dclildudlc di'r Poedc,undeseMomddl oo'nedc
lmpqrc
snfului si $ dcNcbcls.! de0.elii imbici tc,rdr{! s, c.DPn,
c, sI inrclcecD ci, oricii
pc se'nz u'at nnrnili j.divizi,*nh
pc.d
ln
vrfi
loi
ddnjdia
& nare
- atb pnvinlc Ainod t
in{rc .o'aplii i desprc
lli
Arilbfdn.
pntur d sisti l)cnir ceniul
di.edF
cE prer nE cr s! nc
Fnic si .oer r rcenoia dii urml
md ind.io i',coto ii vor n msB prcturinlold".
Todui acclstl corpric a .oniculdi, pc caE rextc ctraie
sc gtses
inxintc N ru pcmis so lntdedem in liniile
'csml',lu
cd
llinu
int o deriniiic
lc lonnuldll .u o linpczinc tnm,nili
rGtrLlchnr,vmomp,r'b'liduLl'nLrcdr'sinJitl frc!unjzd;
! . , 1 r t i n t t r d s : lL l c rl u z i : \ . 1 i " - n
d e r' l o z u f
'
\
,
D
t
i
d
.
tasiner tunrczicirhroim!ri.licind din rcrlndu Fctexrui unor
;ca eicrod. impmvizarii ri delnrniDd_o pa la crri.aurl
Podvn aceneidcnn\n, comcdid,c
dc pulitrcascopidIlrer
unoromnincciopliii , n{ rver carusi
de
dijlnnai rsMtcloro{c te onatuilinferiorri .c' nuDa',3
io* * t". a;;aimt. pno a ueohi'kr rivrdL (ord radov
.c(iov, d$ A roi aiorFi tort rd l.roiov Fj ov'J).Lzratr
dul s1u.ddicolulc dsfiniidc telasi rcxrca fiind ,.u! cusu s o

*l+s.rifl
l:r.H[:+"t:$:,.#ixkr$',ii::x;

iff iff :::llfif.tfii"lI[..lifft?.1,,,"


i:i*ili

ec vcocrc!mit,une5pe.j3tr 3cod; a"sorr


tu c-re. u!-",

,,:*:iirr.,-xtr1.
##ri!.;'i,'fi
r"t""",ilr
#:Hrl":"[*.il[11"{;#ff
*:".'r,.:i;

lli;:iL-i
;J,:U.
:i:fitTft:';i1:X,
J,,Tt[:
::t
,lrmpr& rrusmik. rcn,rJ,,r
t

'm0(r

}t f4ru,D

ht,,r/r,u

^, -q*a.
3/rL,4.

* i*t

:::li:i$:x:fi,',tjfi
;xt.i.T"i
",,",:i:TLi{::lirf

;*ri*:isi:k#rt$#*;,r:
r
j,li:lilitr:l
^"".',"."",'-,.c"",-"'.'"",..

215

il

D M. P]PPIDT

iiill.li:
ii;in,il":il";:r.:.tr",ilr:i,,*"

ffiffi

l
ARISTOTELSI TUCID]DI
Itr nlrgiic&.rp lX atPeticei

hh problemolorjdlo,.c dc inicrpEfta fainosdni capilol


inchinaturci comprdii hft FTl si
IX sl P@r.jmeotlicc,
dinrii asupn elui dc-d
isbic ti posfum|d superiornaba
-luia li retiDtrtdcaidns
atcnta
doiler, cxisiiitrn.cenu mi s. p5r
@ietlroiilor ti rl crEi interesru va scipa iihlhui. cendvoi n
rlhtcievorbadeposibilibhadcrinpicajud{5tilefom .rc
ln ael tcxr dcapr nronc ii generalcu .xcrplul con.rcr olent dc
Rdzboiu/pelolD'e*.al lui Tlcididq .tdel spus.dc otinia F cm
Shsinol va li nutit-o fall o oper, ca accaa liului lui Olds.
']e
Abia dei nai c ncvoic s{ mintesc cr, t)entu autonl
Percei. c..r ce dcoscbcircpc nb
luma ci uDulrc cxpridi in ProT[
ddlapolderpovesti.p.imul,,,Iaptcricvcai eddate".i&al
doilca,,.Iaptece sar putcdhdnpla : r;v !L;v ra 1vd[,4
m
riyav, rdv 6; oid d/ livoLror.inplus,opcrahroriouldN
a Kop cxpunefta.,udeilcluni, o s uncicpmi.mi exacta turunr
cvcnincntelor petecule inirntnll unci cpei id le8iturll cu unul
satrmri nulte pesonatc,uiclt dLlnbmptiior r I rapon in cm
s&elsiumlrrudccclclauc :,ftcaccinscamnlcil,lnrinpce

ffi$*fill*ffi

AR TOIEL SI TUCIDIDE

'ii
1r

ll

ir

lH:;Jfi"fjtiilt,i ;1i,.il1x",:,t;
:i:;ltfilil

jff ni!
;l:;';;,';:l;:*,;llllffi
:T

0cestapErnti pcnh ei o o{ccdc inscDtrriab ci l:'ptul t


con$ibi dohdr unsi rui Itrbudi ln nniven_6
PLdtu Streirjt. dnnlotivi,logrca *biei c mii !!tin rldirll
lo dGi:trtr@r evenincnblor h,7trdul jorci un.l &Niderabil,
iDrcligibiluldtenczi nu o ddl cu ininblisibild. I> re6 penh
cl isbriograiir c opNli pcTjci, qr dn e opusi 9i trin'bi. Mrtna
Mci -p! a spuc.mticipend6upm mi paerni! lui Schop'ruud'
$iinlei, conccprulA'nendoul sc
- c forma Gi6o<),n**i'
qiv.snicn, &.leaii condiii
vcinic
in
dca
.c
tricJ@
ratiF@l
ld schnnb.obiccr0tisbriogratieie hpr izolatln unicraeasi
ca@bol ld, inrintE!!. c eace s indlnette o dari pcnh a tru
maiEvcni nicicedd.Dc utrdecondo/. cl,.poezia c mi filoz.Iicl
ridctrn cracrci nEi alesdecir isrori. (O'IoooOiraor rdi
noiNL< lororia< idrivr)!dcudde,ifflii.ln
'nou6aLd,!p.v
odinc.
dc idci cc oe intercklzd, nnpsia cr Ariiotol lndinr si
nego isoriognfiei capacitaca {te a rtin& accl univcnal care
.onnndc otisiiuridislinclvracm[iilorspnitului gEc s pc
supturnninopcraror
crncplmalrccuno.tcnnHmlstr

*-l-ri*,1;l:ri,t,'
i1ip1:

**i$'1ru*ffi

F&i indoiali. nc gdsimaci in lala unei dilictrhiri, si accas.


e sporiudclaptulciin dome ulcind Sb8iriol itisdia Poetrd
linre 334 $i 330 i.e.n..dupi oDlnlaccn mii it&eptIliti")

''*n*+*fiN+tffi

r:;
lr,:-i;l:irr"":i.
; li ,r*"i;,,.l:.:.i"rjr".;i:

-,u***ii++r++lffi

f',,'.:,
:ii:;'s?"",'::
it:il.lii5*;n
:*,t"l,J"r

*;t;:#*ir!:t#
;t+,r";,i

li :r:r:
r; ;il ^;:;:j:rtrj;ii;:{r|:;rr:
rl

|l;^',1"'ii"*.r:11,1.
_,".",
",;,1;r;,il"#

APISTqIELSITUC]D]DE
- cDsnsun crccplic a lui Tuctdide, Fobabil - o ncinhrupri
c[urac dc darc.o hcom! iDstipaniE dnprr luriirnc.nju]irds.
de clc nai nulrc ori prin exPnndednecd (nu i odc nccsE
lnleldulinirirLal Iqmeruln'toropiar)
Cind, lr rendul siu, int o an0nid pqioadr a victi, cotrs!'
orsrnizirii
dc ocrcdra sisremtie in torG nmur c cuno!*
rarl
r{ii, Ainobi v! simlinevoirsi scin
Nea si ic dn numlr iDplesiondr dc connibulii dudnc. olcol'i
dedocdDc c cpigratie s libruc dc$imc 5I slulasci k cl{boncr viitodclor snrlca. Petriroa cib m exemprucundcur. sc
$je ct iminlc dc a s$ic Porr.r stagiritul seosten'scsi rduic *
sI {udic2c nu mal pulin de 153cdns.itutiidc $rrc erccst ii
barbrc. Cdrpd imcns .hiar penh nijlo'cele nosh dc 1ucfl.
dusla bm smrin cu ltutanl cirodr didte ei mri irdstari clcvi
si lui. driri dproaF i! intesimc pierdur. Din rnd rlorndlii ll
sl]in dmpilAnd l$b deprmi'ri la.oncusudlc &ddri ii gLm
nicc,culclciidod?rnt!i prcvcdc,ediii citicc si cotocnkrii'
Acrivilac $nnom, cm dovode$t
linirii a ocrcctlionlui, sauaprittrditr lui dc r foLosimdtridc atat
dolcludt,dr ii accdb tebuiesr ncrlini in chiptlccial lna
o coneptic pdondr r raponEilfdiikc invcst'grlje
danirre
si rpccurrlje. dintc ai nunti sinrut.
C! rersti c.nccpric lvea sr culDincb cu cldhotlrm unBi
filobfi ic@Ne{tecitoltiinliuivc$ari.csriutindcohirc Gea
o dtrsil rublini' e ci. in .adrul necida din dnciplirclc ln 3 ciNr
rcls niizui{ sl opnndiinhs drGniul rc:lutni, raFondldc suboF
donrrc r'nrrcpdbculr si gcd.l e lIltxr cu d nsors pc caD
consritnfta prcgerivi a mtxlc' Nea$o aacntuc^ ro(nar nn[ I
crc scvcri{icildcoDotriviinsriinrclemsdi cr i io rtiintclc s@lale
Pinrc eNEa din umi politic. deine, dtrprAnbkl, un]d
aril dc inscmndiircnt prcclamind-o tupLor,ir! *ai Bil\rdrd
dpxs(ro4rr) Gcil.ldv tr[rrriv)
ii aprcciindciptn. rr

*,1ffi*+fut*lri+

iiib' ff rdill':::$.'rl{Tl:}:il.'r;
l#;*,*","rffi1;r,,':-,.l:ri,,r
:lll
:fi;ilTilfi
l::5iJ;"1,:::i:1,::nt:
t siti,*:t

;;Lr*Hir,';,-#+n[l;":'',.""ilii#]iI

( ihtbure

qFISTOTEL
5I TUCITDE
onc dl'j {hdJ sp(crdrr_ Jurmnn,tr, ii
D

e !i

4X@edr, ro rdurr< fi;\o< r{F;xor dy


d liy
rdyj5.
La o rshtu
a @cnd chopiit de a ti locorir, nu trutori inroF
mE,a. bLr.duNcm
|. pmlrlt,reI rcJ:.a polr!?i. fitozolul
:rr @nisuBr ij rdtvirJr dr arnri(. adun?id
!.otaqotrmJ
!r\r'huile, l58Llc"rrh.d{mL J snotlll
rdr
m ;pd.tul
I r 4 r..o'!?(!p!d
dJ[nd Jii rti mn \ri m, Lrexburlrc
rf um poqen.mi p/rerllrr,6r.{hr coi\ enuc n l.mu jrk
BtuF

runrcdrnhpnji'lcrr is'onc.
C,pt rrls(!pjdce!orrd . t h e rd ^ ; le lG n b , \ in le . .cb' desubi(!trrclusceniihrJc
q otse nrctr\r dr drauiir rh4
adumE @Nurhlivi Dinrc aeiea. hnxe smr
sudirre cu
Je mhrn'rr \i !! pnvn. a fic.n Llji et! an,ro(t
srak
.nr'sd,r umlrli po| Lle ,-! ,n(mc I !p rrlc
oc nuLlrul
prrt:h r arpDblencidEluhk,
tc utjrumsrd
mqtuLleltr
de eispccieJ e !rqiiuhsk.r ruh

o vrdcEd! rnsqnblu.p\nh,JJ \
(i ia4!e ncvuics! if,eP n, nr
derorLren.ncrt'cde!ererr|l!porrM("ir a,"]ror,,,;,
.,i.
kpd mi< tlrdq 4p4j/u! ln o p , ro ! , 1 , o , rp ! .
rr! n . d
rourLv 0u!pour'i!) s j
re vnbJ e mmpetcdJii tukirr mi
!i d'd ! \pclul,rtr nu n d mri rrh u J . ro ro t rd rlc t !
'fu
pr.Fr
ccrab. daK at rlzhotclor susrinuicdd a ri, Dr;c{m si d
rcztrlktclor .briotris cicr c tronll ca pr,cjoi 4cn;d!oa(
s!

(dni
riv
Dnkjnrasciidc riccr dda umtui ernlnrbm
';,p
6[oi!/ ra drdLdn;O!rv)
Adasi uldn[ pbpotric sc @ren
d.spnpsibilirdtruDei
pdndcdinc!c conringerealilozolulul
abtrrql
din cunoatlcEa
$iinrea .ocicririlorurNne,in ddc a!
Loivin aft rr ochii lui
reneinicrahcdr!lui icsil. deTvollllrii
Aisotel, accananiinli c polibcr,dr c evidentcl matii p.
cm o prsnpunc si pc cdrclii i'remeidr rzlltalele e olcnli d0 o
disciplinl disrincti, cao c i$i.ria, in indoirLdinlel.s de stii li a
ftcurdluimtionais.idcdiiili a neeirilor st e Dac!rnaiI'
dLo dovadi in dccdlri privtili. er e ofcnd deulrnnl p&
'evoic
gnf ?1rceluilti crpibl, un{lc,P(c[ penh a subliDiainse'nnrldcr
conndorrtiilor de pant a.i, liloa)fnl scner'Penh a intocm' lcgi.
nu i de rjdns si1sFbildri pc calcuuNi srudiuspcc0titiv :l tecu
tolli o mude con(nutic scpodvcil maihin' dilii. ci mi !c
blie si cunosticon$ upncin vle.r!c la db nermud$icoidiriilc
favo'rbLlelic.iLia, pcumsi Ficliilc dc raruri si contiblie !a
dcsr.ilmarcrkn lie c[ e voru dc pnciri tuerne saupotivni.e'
naio60,:
A$llrd.eevnbntc!descrtunbdc.iutoie(1ii<
.un.scuri
pi
dc
iiriogr.
fi.
aldcl spLs, ma lonnl
srcc o, sutrt
cum
dc.scbir de lbbsitoxrs legislaloruh'i.d5o
Penrn dclibcildle
poliuco se dov.dcscutilc ccrc inh .clor ce sciu dc$re
cvcnimnblBded fclul: rot< 6i 1d( no\nLrd< oroou\d(
ol ,4, n.pi rds rprilda .ypdQd4ovLdtdpidLr'
incuvinrcc. suntrlctimpuluislu iiporninddc 1ao0o
u'nit m.m.nt al deTr.xirn
celci
tui
bu0erdmc dc oignni/arc
liuiaiea
eaudni,grccni,
Ariiore] glsenc miildrul dc ! n. lice
poliriclisi *tirln,
cmdscurlin rcstc prgini solulir dcliiilivI r uDiprobl.mc
dcsprecrre t. clc .itrre din f.crj.. nu ne dm dair iDlormalii
$mxe FiecI vcdcdloslcJi matdenudierxur.lsasi.lic
ci rcEnll 0. caresc (lcsi1$un dactrlia id laimos'l
nricudnd
";;,.,,,,,.,

.,

",,.",,,,.,". ",

D M. PIPPIDI

MTSTOTEL $1 I-IJCIDJDE
OlorcsnDsi rcnnortea precuisori.Propiil srredeclsalii dc
prircipiu, nr 6rsua in src pntemn sjguri dL a le fi inrles
coHr'r, Dc lndeam, sprcaccle4iconcluzii.
Onul cret
hvinuia po logogranc, ilbcsc lizzele de efec.hai mulr decal
addrnli orul crrc sedindrd dea ti trsalpo$ern{[i trnrri0a
t< cli
dccerh dyrivLfud t< rd napoxpiF
'nai.uretr,i
Ind on vendicapcnh siDc nult dccerneirul
'iKon.u
'nai
dea li conse'n5icucredinlilepisordcbsanseode
dc unuiiizhoi fr ncid. Inscriindu-lprinre Sandndnipotirici.siagirnd ii
aducea
nnomagiurevd dupacun, judccardo asprinco isro
rio8ftfis cre sem'nFm* s{ rabsnirl lnrorinii .,ceI l{cur oi
pftinnAlcibiadc,nuttucadecelsl-drezc
cphnealentr0
$nsutadcmi dc ae{ nnne:&eer ce - diDcolodemutimca
cren,ncntclr aspndsl cxplice rr&sfotuink sctelllii ti
crreia.p3!d-nzilclcnodh,cunoashs Ltotolui n-aiDcerdsr i
inslne n*tej'lcadcI inrclclc vinonl.

*nu*fiw**m
***s+le**+',mt+*

ffi$$tr$ffi
n*d**l'l{*****t:

li

r,i

INSPIRATIEILA ARISTOIELSI HORATru


PROBLEMA

IV
PRODLEMAINSIIRATIfi IN ARISTO.IEL
(P*iicaxvrl _ adPisones3oo)

ll

Dhrc du't( rcihlrsL


Jc e! \tut(i tu, HoBru Ci@
^
risorl,
p!trnr..(J, !c i0\reLtn,.c\.rlc sEiur (rcsetutr
De

sqjbenti rc.te tnpn e! etpin jpnn, ettd,s.


ln
prczinllatrel.si
tr.ilonihrcrexDti
... rcalnaGlucnrjte$
.r!urpl
rpredr mnqbor dr L r" q..,t.
,, or,L.,r.."
L{,J, r nri!^.i:bnx.,.,ls.i
xr(ms
i !6mplld! ck mr ntrtreor, ,nv! ddntrnlakJ

.p ndddpnnFro
R rilJiq
i
na!, | ronln Cu rerJi
dbr J,!) rlbtr,r \ o soli
ou
^
!mrc!( otu\ cds depdm { (, d mcnruti0\4,
itorq(.de

,r urcu L rmm\cb o rinr pome


suin fflNkmti[
nr..prdrd] opu\urulu hof,ih M;r
'
dtrndhRr5r
tr. ishD. J" o t , . -.
ndrrcrh rc , rc$rnnd, ,lup:Jrabr ! iFt!
" r. atdminJk
. * . " . -* .
u krr
iD.ilc nn ritu u n(piErrh,nLlo
A.sbJ \p!{.i JsltilJ.m hnul r,p"g"tur._,.awa
No.Jcnrn. mx cls J!pr ouncrcdin
rujulllbe
r,ns$ s rrrcnm,rror ! NFpr .nrd
dpr,,n.

Phllodc'n
;sipit in cadsaa V !fl<pi norr[drdv a epicurcdlui
din C'dra1, e considerd lndmbsreca l)uncbl de plccareal
'rlti
mi imp!4in a opcfti, @s ii, cre Honliu,uNrnd dntlan !ad'
(roiidt<
liml,dWI pmbleelc kalalein simcle dou! nnpi4iri
chctutiroi4a,Jup[3]iird ro(iv saum) tu(pc cxpuneEa
nilor Eivnoare la lnsNi orcatosl prci, no!r11,i<sxu an,laxi
acescapitol,E int ducs
Venul 295,cu crc sc dcsohidc
dc'adiepbr in plinl I)o]cmici. Dc la primul cuvtut sslunc
'mpo.
ranlr pnblcni a ctalii posriccJi, nlod cr Hodir sc fereib sr
piolue deindautpropiul siu rispuns la erm idftbfrc dGpE
blul gtriuluiin snvariisr .,acrultriMuzelor', sinsu.;dicolul cu
unorrnuniri DsPtrlli cd e complre a eoperi
'xceelc
irynin
nisu, qntaLnunrtus ub
cEdit ct ctcl n sn6 EelitutE 1Nx6
Denocdtus, b.na pxB no mguk yn.n crdt,
nonb{hxn, sEh patt L.a, hzkea dbtl '
d n dc atBnspenh a te sugcraniruJind sPrccft sc indrerpti
in oe6u ontovc ! Trcbniespusbtuli cl accNtii diludrm se
stildnieic s o indi.. ln chiptrl cel mai liDPedeo suti de rrodun
maijos, in vd{uri cde 1apriba vedercprr. sc nul$ni si rcpctc
pe .ele rprodu*. Pr.i pctr!fl r evita oicc et$rI tn|Ip*src !
inhnriilor do carce insunclt, Horalitr podcvf de daraaccdtr

D M. IIPPIDI
didacric.fdmutand in pdnul rand poblemr pc crei
s{ rc?olvc,apo' rrspunsulpo cft | ,ocoarepolrivir:

TNSPIiATJEI
LA ARISTOTEL
PROBLEMA
$I IIORATru
Fopunc

Dtttrn b@t ku&Ulc mh


aDde,
qtt$ibtn e!: eqotu dutiuh sjnedntib D.a
nectudc quidpnsit uide. iryeniunt.
Fonta noncrt,rorurl. dupi cc slr brM ioc dc eorczc.
rantii uej tnvniibri ncure slticuat:ca ote Dlt6ibu;
*h
r4antc, lrce si cxpliceh fctutsencrE iseDaErri izvonl
prorbd arbolitiitd pocrie (.{fl rduc cnalihtrl: ,,lel,rn
.,..p.9 tr cc anune. dnpl plruea ld, conribuic la fom,nja si
radesrvi$iicapoeruluidcm dcaos.Nre: qui.1tat fmctu;e
p..'up. in!{ m \s\*pnn6 pRo0f6n pn\nJ iJenr de p.r
r&re rormri .d ftbur sinc ! o
reen.4i,tnun.qudutru\ qtu tcEr qrul. Jtrt, .m _ na
oc poturcn Inu,ni{, rLlei d (t .u
lis:d!idilelnr'intr ronut:b.-vcrs,i cd nH cr,,d; trh
Bdp( ruda aminrcpretdii mcqrFnciDiu, cioid oncvjuFa
rapidardii :nbttntzi cancicnr dc lcncnlil.rc:

,*"i:"ll:':il,ii;i':Yr5i::;lri:.i::{i,:,f
i."i:i:itilifi:.ii
rs Lh.
$ i.\

!D !rJ!i o

r.n-!. r s, rd
^r^,
!{.r,F,,!=;'di @;

:tfiif :i[5.i1]l'"1.:T:::Tllf
.lj ;fll1::r{ft
;rl1ii;j];:,r
di .

!!

uj .

. j ( ,i Ji l i i

l qL

it'iji"iiiil."Tl":;:l',t,":.,rli _i,.i[;:'iI J*lil;;f

sibddi

nde sar[rc dt.t tr;hcipiun et ro:

Cume ulor de lntelcs.dc lr Frinr lcctut, obscuiraEa vc!


sului st!.lnainic do roarc,in mevoinF de r intlegcco.d
cuvenlu|srpsD. Bin0i a acesleiditcultlli nn pm sr I incolrii
lotusi in niDrcr .onenraldiloi, cfc - lnccpsnd cu oElli !
3mrsindcn rmisch, lfti a-l ra pc Ro$agni - au dal aes&1
innnitiv inter)rctIri aproapcidcntice. Asdel. ln specjalpcDtu
unoistol elleljo. ajunsrn acc$ pnnd al expuneriielc Honliu
d fi lrmidr si cxprimc necesitabapentu pmt dc a cunoastecit
mi binc ltrdilc de cde.9i propun
t,mD pcndentomia... src.cpta inucniendi,cooponendi,
clcra? seintadn el, cu pi vift h vdsul 309.Pennua
'lspundc
dch'lal{: ,,. a sspimdo.Euolrcndaatluc cxplo'dndac* ro@uir
buh.na: nam cx hac um inrestigarion Fodi. uditas poetica.
Faccipuc id generedrmalico , rd
specixD privtc 1ainlclcsul @ane0uluis,pft: ,,Ecte cogiie
rtqm iudicrc dc omibus Fbus: cu
pncdirusphantasi|cr inuonicndi
cus{tetPoerrhocnoninc dignuj'i
Cins priveite lucnrild dc aFo.pc nu ponc sl nu obs.we cn
lnre dcslutnih lui orclli eodul nr c intu rotol deslvdrit. Ides
cupnnsi in pnm gbs[ parea l] ohlisatiapcnh .utml dranalh
da posda o vati crpcnen$ a $ilcrnlui omnesc lintelepciunc
cettigar.fpir dtrdin sauprin conractulcu vi4a). ltr rimp @ lxi
nclc rindud cnat irdcapr, gandd hd cniand spio nccoeiirrcr
pcnttr pocrde r li inzesta. cu apriudineade a jud{a binc, ahlcl
sps cu dml imiscur al nnci chibztrilis$lrode'.

D M. II?PIDI
odcarcvr ti to$ opiniaadevlnria Invlrarutui
rnintn.

,1
I

lr

,it(rmlde oh.end (i J.c:nr tl!


urmdJn& \omcnB rodimr t u , D, n rre r. e 5 u c3a $ iu (i, c /
&.it pc cci mai insemnalt.Kjc$lin8 si Frcjie r aDspie de cca
dc r dolr inhr|R'e dung .r,l inrctespnn 544..Eroschr.
vmunfrgl.'. r'r ceu vemc RGLBni.drndndio alerqipn
ntrti o &g6ric r lui rcnm. p(ft ri cu horrJsapc.e, d,ntuI
asemcie:e,Jirdrt,iluiFto d c n , t s n rru
(re in (id rn t s i*
i$pintia direcl{ a vesului 309 sd cuveniciurarr tn invrtlrun
iui Neop,olem
daprc .htrSaurp.cLutu,de, oi6eda(unon,nc
eb(i( loperlic.i fi ologlI rrslirn.oNdld f;h
ro! rr Dr{@l
hoEld m u crctr ora.6bi docrim inrftaga mdplc s ator
vccfu dcsprc pere liind domin{rr, credc Rosr4ni, de ideca
conrrulutui.jaconrinutu|ftird pdnnaruEtuituatiiaE_nroncii.
mdr,rarunli,icvoiadeaapofuidaacessrftaliiaepcrh
a exr.se drn a naieria peti.ii a puint s! $ imrui, tui Horirin
a\acumi scinp0sese
ponind Jecidc 1ab7s cj
lui Ncdproteht:.
o srossi pEsfii@ ttiinfifi.u rbuic si-i r ap&urauiorutuinorh
cao conditjcindnpensabnitr oric&cr cre.tii p@rie, Rorllsi in
ceeci a lrnun i.desut vc$'iui epEr rcdn umuir
';pdc
csor sags@'.
laNoD.l ensosencdcodj irvcrsenmiqMoro
ncl

NSII&ATIEI LA ARI9IO]EL S] HORATIU


PROBLEMA
kns spmiriodi avdc un isflziorcflLosofica(chedpoisem
pft pcr oftzio ,?orofia pr li! c ,,onle. coNo,4ione e viatico
ilelhvira)EDcll mscnsooncll'dlhOnTjoitrlcndcconta{t\ci.e
all'opinioneddocr cd plaronicacn . l 'lNaDi! dci pe! Li
rcenuiralioomm, a .irui subdlnarc
scsprijinl
Eleganla
Doo vigurorsl inlclcscr rroici d problcmci. nu post s{ nu
inpEsioneze.Cubateme{ca,crircadldorLtrsi.ilorluiOelli.
c (cm M frc dc.AtsiEsoduci
cainsall1lorinc4relltre
Ini
Roshgnii{).
$dcm ind-pririti
in chipul .cl mi lidel leDle
s! opunenslosclor.bia anidrit obi
cni, o dc
m, de raptolci inh vdsul309 ti vesudle umli(r
p.
p
cae
o inrcr
iDdiscutrbill,
cd
axtul
o
sublinisl5i
t@alle
poao
vedeE
E
adevltuli
cl,ln
t4e cu
tF@ on$iincioast n-o
afe! dc Kie$line Heinzir),nici m cotunbd nu sasinfit obligar
$o respecterea nu se impunc rotu$im.i pulin, cu .ondilh de a
um.ii o ale4je inlinhiEa idcitoritr paajul ce ,e inmerzi
ln acr*l o'din de prcoclprri. an ftai alut prrejll sI
rublinicztl ul limpodeal secti!'ii cde in cpccu vdsul 295:

fu.4&'.eM@dosh|4cd'iq!!dqi|n

251

D M . I I P P I DI

il

il

dupi ctrela vcnu imsjudivc nnpobvr adcptilortni Denooir.


h.,acndnrre,
prcbrcn.lfpt cr. Hlrihu A Dtrjouesr r
e\sic4l\!
r)1 ti13t.rn o i. in . q , in , rc ! v c r! ro i. f t a t u re J
q{etudtrIaeshr
rruhkme.jnrft !e e Jouj Durcra,., Dr,
mDrc.ibLlGuLb,tr!or\|.trdtud5l rc h uni ;
ntu,riuur
oemrernrehKesism,tft.nutrp4( tesl fr.joqndsa6k,
'
p c , h , q rp n n d rs e ilu t rrrL
rvcRdude!ddctrltnm
edr allnq!J.unturcn inrebrrl
E cdc accia rispude maiFecis,inrelesulemkdhuluinzh
pntrft,rn \. r .tulr *rn\j tcgdrufJ
.u q EUt109al,,rLrx.in,J
tcbr.\ublin JE i iid(d'it/iv
i
spuf,prrrcr timunLd,ndrpr4,r,,,.pe,""pi"r.tr"..nl
aec{ ...}e ! P v.n,th8\rjt ir
n
rrh.o, utorm.Lrrrru
a!t. ..crc I h.ururcr sund!t! I c.ej 1i.c
un'm hdpeicd:pr'rc;
1 R^ p u $ , , rh A t * L io rre h rir I
lbr hr; r jtu, p|nrru monerL
sufn gnnili.r e l"itrq^c otl,ne:Ltcr,lc jn.re*yrftr,j
c dc alnN pcnrn ai'dicp(,ri invinuirc.pecde oaduccnjnee
n'orsj rnrclP.eriria hriRonasni, xnunedea cDnnde
.rt
in;.
ingud.xplicrrie vc6trtl0q si pc@lc-i umMzi.;e roi dh.. J !!tcdoui pi? rrjPc.Jre p L'j"
grdllu \i! Hutur! s rdLltr.resj re{\jioi
F tund poe!Lr
, nrcNo rnputur kl! ! ji,Jenu, il! iivJ_
k uruiihl$o privrrch prccrLjrfl[roz,ucpe@rr
eu( m,
cJ \.onruem u socutrru,r.esra ple0tu dmin
DctteDtjn
w sbrc si pcnm in,.,nRbrer p!l!u/., .rh An,r
! tr nn;,r,
Ezr\r!;e\nre\j, tnrse.mio c ! ru h rs b ia , n ! . u mc t ir
n
Ltrmlurc c. unJe\ RB lruNem! pus Jc etusbt,utlurdrld
rorneisucp.erin. 3i:l'.lndu.{ m,rtolceh poui\n.
;enku J
dezvokr\j edinc,!inJ noeurj
ForoAetcN!f ( pRz iJ.$r moJde,.nb cri.lrn
r d(JdciorluiH ra!jus!nru $ r& , n rc re qjn
. rrrmu t u o , r. f

152

LA ARISTOTEL
PROBIEMAINSPIRATIE1
SIHORATIU
lG dovadacJ nn@gl accsta pde a opcrcic consNit[ potivil
lnci n8uro4o ri'mtriirr. in rl doiler rend,sccvn[ ulonlui a'tct
dc r scIi cofiun in modkmcdrabil,lainEfld
irri.riNiiuier
doo suli nc dndui..rffiDd solrlii dilenb unci problcmodenuh
rezolv c in disculiilo rcorcticicnilor l eran, si anunc ln sensul
rplrar s dc cl spE slAlsnul oprsculului. oricat dc nee or f]
Nbnhcr lui rmtuisch,6l e pm ina adcvtucdsingud andogia
cu lkrar', dospEsubrn,in cuprinsulL{ojl nentiuncadulirili
p. acliaoperi
dJo.<- rixvr cao.ond,ticindispDnslbili1Dcnh
libde rcyE in doui liodui, nu e de4uns pcDtu a nc convinee
cI Hontru, ftlnand si e1ii doui locun disculir r$ti
Problene,
!-a Gctrrdent si 5econr.rnezc rnci tadilii de $ od!'' Prcsu
pmind ci o ..Ntange atat dc biAri s! pu.ut inPunc ninlii
sutoruhi no{ru, ccoace nu mi sepe cu nlbic dovedir,dmiDc
in.i ncliimu rl GliuEapenhcrto,d0plccn' ve$ulr09 dc
pc c..lmisch
e grra s o
v c ioscnnlrldrcr utrci .jnvilittr
petd
r frce din
p.ntru
/.s,
xs.$a
lnlclcui ca ud cchivaicnt
-si
ca,jzvo l" oncirciotFrcdesexmi, inepind curesul,r)B
pddsc$oaccdsitozitic perh a adopra,rnpliicend'o.teota
laditonrli..,gcrlului rsGirtcn,,nesbsugtrl.sau..aslrolc
sescDtupriii siii lcmcni. ,,i,., comple[ti prin es.
O inrcrprcrarcpodvn clria vennl 309 n-r li dccii r{s'
punsulrmi.ipar h nnrcbror ,,im ttse
vadueincvil$illaaoninp!s/' Aorcceptr,insemniFiface

D M IIPPIDI

PROBLEN4,{
NSPIRATIEILA ARISTOIELSI HORATIU

lni Horariuo ne&+!arc cn aiir mrj m&c ctr cnt,chiar firt a hnc
(rmr Lleoprfl
ri enlhnde routnm,|]str repAtule,.
5,pe!c
,..&| pd(eie lJ rrJ\,ul sju N.opkredr0. e n.j
Drudr.
n'cicind pdle.jul dc r prelmra irponxnF pi,rodirr! i; oricc
cmtic pftricr a insusirik' inn&curcri. Dar. om. nu cra nsc si
fe3)Jtsr nu rrcbue! n { I ] , iJ . ld q rmr d c ! ro b { rJ rru t ! d
dln'ft(r cr iioeJLnra"
a f c ri, n e ru rru u 0 ; h
r r; h b u n
poerc dc ajDnssl ai o scri@sr pEet:ftc tuozonci. nici trnutn_a
lrrr cu calc si ftlcv DcpobiviFa?
AIdE Nnai dac{ unci aseheneanedhenri sc cadc s!_i
abhulh inrrprerma reaRatl rmcndui epe4 dc unii 6mes
rardi, dupdcarc,ps led8, ,,ilvrrirud" s.u
iltoToici".
'pGetriE
3as bmcn r i' jndicarsi o aprirudineinDtscur!
I surlcrtrlujjcevl
asc'ran{rorcuceea.!nu6ih jjude..ri..slu,.btrnsinf..Aen

puncldcvcdctua fo$ suslinu.in vrcds din umr. dupt Orclli si


rf,rojr. dcRdragaisi Imish. Ntrhi porrotDsiifrpicdicadc
aobseflaci drcl, indiscdbbil.
adc
p$ pacc ucdcrr
diEclre.timidnl
biu contadictie cu una din tezeleesenliale{e,nteip.et{iji lor
.lntele pdi6a identiratede lnleles a celor
'piicipdc
'iou!
nndeptentu opcs,qri.l ald IamcLqb pacLm
drcn le acorespund,
in.onrinMn{ crpun*ii, pErinsaiDdi zibilitrtc a oiireatului ce inpe cu ve6ul 209 si cm, dupi trnii
auion,r $c penrb vcBul2l3,dupl alii. peoila vcntrl132.
Drc{&ceprln Dinsdin acc{cpmpozitii.edelasinolnlogic{ Tor aler
lcs
ci.s
de-rdou, seimpumcr o consecjDtl
t
vesului
]07 cr
& clidcnt e iNr ti tuptul c[ Inr itrlerprerrr
iffemnind ,dondc si sowcd.do i nezl sau,.ede si edncble
fomi tl pch', ca si vorbin ca Ronagli, at fti cnincnt Epicnului s4peEdrn rcnul 3@ oie ,1 sensd.cir rcch dc ,,nilitltur! sau'prcgrbrcfilomtici.Elnnpede,intadevir.cidaci
vcnul 309 n-rrc d&!r s$ul do a vsii conriderqiih anpn edn
caricililoblioc cxpuscltrrc(uilc 310 113,decmlnacsrcu
nici n ar nai putcaIi d6tr4i!, trinosul {,!84. din $4 Honliu
nu $ovricr lrcc ,,pnncipitrl si .,sudr" di.nrci cxpcricntcpoti@,
n-sr fi decet,notivul d cre sc lea
la@ din el m dd ltrnrscutsauo siinpu fi$nsi@a ninti. inseamn,
a npc - din chir clipa ii caE luse idchogat{- miEte lacrice
a krurilor 309 313,p3 cffi nufrri o inrcrprtrc coDtc{.bil{ u
voN'tui 307poxrcsojusblicc si cm
s.uror in.oqncil ldpc cNm Ib

D M. PTPPIDI
a$tct. oncumaminoercnsdctininin difiouual.r, eanu
pdo li o6l'u. $i numd ci s r pu@gis o sohbcsa$ticfto@.
.!ri: vEmennnhortrib sr plr|sin rnumircbzepccareruron
rarcaslstinorilortorleapururjm
cxamenarenrsmrscie prina le dovedjtrpsanc consisEdt.Din

rum;rulrc(dJ :dnE a!dpril


hueioliluruDerluTiJ.icmrb h uu d L fpt , md e ' p e ra ra ! e r
ex{cr tutresul pirrii a dour a ve$!n\i 3Oj: qui.t atatfomtore
l'crfl, Din discudacrc p@edc s a l{an d o a*mma mnc;,
zcemfspimrron{ardetitrarexrduiicardencyoirdc,shbill
!tr iigurcs ptr lclism ltuc vennt 307. de a pdc, sj vqurjtc
309-313.de.atalr{. S-avdzur.dc
privi rnr!4uiEa jdcito.lui Hdariu gi:ca cxphcaririr
\j
eftdrrrs
dc r coocepe- cu privire ta rerncnut s,per. din vc !t 109
o a.ceph@ caE !r pemir si seonsid.E pmpozilh undcaces
velb neurcd2icr indclendenrii
dc celeumiloarc.ln realnde.
pDh clncli d! cirusr delutjn.sieneila si courc,aces$i rcceD.
htrncc\nd $ rli.hi,rksoed. L t c . c o p . rir. L lJ . )r, c o n rmt rli,
hotu!! o srt in!n! r-ui0rri!q&.r
hrirr tremi,sdru{lu
z'c Ia ideilc lui Dcnodit c! pnviE tr inspnrlie n-d fi dd Dnbiul
DneiDeinrelegc botare ln consecintc.N aven dca si ; n;_
llm 0niformiraba
doarridror oxdrme pini aoi,pcoru a ne
&seamrc, cceaceaimprctionarr eose6ipe cxcgeritn {i
cancatord rezunar al unei docbDc aratdc conprexe c^ acecr a
Iilozortrtul din Abdcr! n! i altcevadccat hotiiabfea oDoaric
rl,nD-a6. posllmd dc knnl 295.
,n (f nD. nrmerrnu pr. I se rip(o.upd ltc t?ntulci
&ear, rdzrcnefprrqd gr ro'u{ eeviLlcdcjr&mr tuoourbg
at .xch|tit tunE Ediconc po.kr Drno.ros d *; cm i-,
prqurluHtrs!nooo
rr&impor,vr,,trrEtrtu,, Llmpom:
!.3 ri (ompr3!r c! dcd.tj rtrs
rilozoli|luirbnist, trihrt cm si-adatoncnerrasi1srudjenj
.ol0l hctonlui firologtc in nmtia anis.icu.ajuneind lI facndin
accNtr apab.jul unui rsnpcnnenr romat, dcosebirde
Fsionar

PRORI-EMA
INSP]RATIEI
LA ARIS'TOTEL
$I HOI{ATIIJ
sideenoriv,r,oalimrlicr$rdcConcrutrcarcccaditrvcn;t
295.pmclam6ndsupeao
bbanNntiriroJhnrls0r.nDicxpc
pEvinicititoriiimporivruncido.tncsu{epribilcsiincu4czc
tendinlr lor {te r sc lriztri prcr mul. pe Eletrt, Hoiariu n ar li rvur
nevoiesisclcledcDcnm Dintejco-dinbrdeaui puse
Hi i,geriur mi prcsur dc 16. n4vea d4i! ere0t rca dcgcni.
Pentu un cititor al poelilor. ca el, ai Ii los po{c fti lrrsc si
irrocc itu o R*mcEr Jnprejdnie naxida lui Hcnd:
oiro< fty ndv;p,,fq<, a< on,;< ndna rcior?s.
ve6ul tlpidoi al lui Epihm:
Ou'oLrLX{y,ipLdr;y iorL, 6Jr(Fy 6i l@yodyayl2t,,
sNmaodrclccuvinb
arcemnrurui
sru Pnrdail

ALd. nri< dpv,ra o(tor,?


circrzd!uoctcinrcmcietorului tsriei .tomisrc, do vioi tftbuie si i,e i4tul c, rn cx
plima rcnonennluicrcaiicipNrice. iS! c0mtus.sclornulari dc
accnr.inrnu lrlitudoiatr etementc
tbporiva cinm Hordiu

,.,'i Pn !fo :"4 i L r n n t( d 1 !!

D. M. PIPPIDi
Dr, eea.l p' F.xa \u'd. n , 4 e ! e , rn , " . . . , , n i{ ,
,ufd:, tuodd4 td! r. r!. n , n i. F 1 rj e r4 . , q " , J o re r.q
I
n it u F , ic F . u rt o , , i . n J r.
oe urnimr.A$lum,ltovcdi, uAIrrUd DcaLetnmmn"nh
!rd'u'0riLlaltA .o,!epLun\ J e / , n t t , t , u . n c
t u jc " Dh o
!op,6pdr&d,iruc\ j puninLlu in
ri s4d s ru,Llamenrr;sdin.
jdtrsd.flho konL iprcz! fk
rute o\ n crph\sRr crcrlcr hrnrc
codiou:a ll !ob!idn,bit) Demo.nrajuosepn.bc
e, Dqdu(.i
prerr dcaok ruturlr\ etf pccdc o at.ito
e F/1( J normrt,r
r oprc,\rqomuni\c.u uma aprralrrari:! ltrJ6tr
rcnd, r
\ tra I ci e k/"dir {r,os /lt ,r..ie?t'6
Denour,r, df r o!;a
@. rTpLuerrtu,n! I L mr]]bredectm(tu/r, fiR:q;Mu!
e{sr rmporNr !JniaHd,tr r
r-ri, (unontr. fut indoE! s n
unre-r! m,ipuridilseno., re
t i. u n r p u t rr n n e . ! ra re r rkiuldjnTomraLurF\rnr-\ ip mL j(J mf L jljJ d a ra &
.
c!tuz'ri sc licusc psrc vhcuri autoflt BarchedTtj:
necnet reba tcgh,Ai sun snotuatus dEkt h.
nanbcnetacatis trMjn. pota cntb:
):ta dat aot es. deB estjn pacttu nostu,
hrc. 11u*wedicn Mn.i,o.quc deaze.
Asdcl inepe sr e limpeTsci ftica poblcmr a cirei
dezo
joccbr $o f,n&rm Ddcj 3!rumt
n.d
sr(
c,,tu/u, re.u/c.
hrDuei. doflnm luilrenud d e l r& . d , o g e i, u t rd rb !
pnvresid rrrsn it !nui nutu
pihopaji,.{li(aur 0uhb! eoGriuras in nh.'rulma!r.R
pun.r!l Je . mf,! v l3 r;otr! I {c, *.,
__,,
"1,^.'i,:"p,
dr,trnrtp(rdlui,
"
inrenratu,ctu

:,1:rTE"o '* "-r"i""^'"ltl ii!1,;


iT' ' '""*
253

LA ARISTOIEL$I HORATIU
INSPIRATIEI
PROBLEMA
vcndi fundmcntrl difeie? h eea$A lntrcbm
ftrtil|Fetcr
nu cred c[ se poarcrrspundc ln doua chipuri. tua sc ti fa.e de
aldel ci - pin{ qi eresslii cci nai orcdincioii incPrettun hdt'
liomis nu sovric sl v.dllJn rc$ul 309primul.lcmonr al d.ctinci pc carcHonliu inlelesc ao opud lui Derocrit Adr do& .i
- it aci c punctul! c mi dspad hotlrt depd{esoni nci in
tinp ce rccsta du scsficscsr punain contdt sli$li deun od'n
atirdLdiledtcaerodiriasids.clilibnlpsihic,in.cn!privo e.
nI socotobligdra-l lace p. Hosriu s! vorbcescl&eeasilinbi cr
advenanlsin. De unde,lDochiinci. ncvoiadeaci(nnrcrie
rturia sa dcsprc ,,izvon poczici la u c vea 309i de uftlc,
iarlsl. iirdcnnnl de a atibui lui sr.r o scmllicqie psiholosici.
cititoli lii mintdc. poab. ci dinft comcntabrii 3le crror
pireri lc-ln invoBr de a lmgul t+inilor precedentc,singun
Kicsling si Heinzcps s fi lndiDa. spre4e$ Duncidc rcdeE, dc
vnc cc Fopun pcnh rerbul s,pct inld?rorsrcr ,.Einsicht..
Vcbunniekcir" Crh sn rcccll &eatrr sttrtic, ccl p$n on riilu
Invizontr. si aduclnd omali ui mcira! ascutimii lor n.obrsnuite.
nd
nu mr pot opi dc ! cdo,tn cc mi pavcic, ci seloare
'ne4.
precizind
in
mism
inllduitl
de
textc
dcpatrcpe aeadi clIc,
accadi k)n. ! ialiunii po.iizmL po csc Hora9n semulruhcaie
$oopunlluiDcmocrir,dlrpcftsrdn*alnai erldii'didse
In acestscop.s, I
oncne.h $o romulce cu frai nux,
'isoarc'
p!r:5im un rimppc pricbnd Pisonil.r ti pcnNelgi obscnndn,Sr
!i dcschidemPocdaa1ui Addotci 1acapitolul IV, acolo undc c
expusidockinonlo7ohldi cu pnvirela onsinilep6zici De lr
noath cu o roni pc
piinelc cNmtc,.(a ccseimpnncarenlei
cm dprsir g@l Dufaccdoars o acenruczc,c aldtulil obtu
iici,.narunle r pczlei. i7troriti. ctrmni scspu0oiDdrii. 'litrcxrcdonzarca! doul inpuhii elonenid rlc natuni undnc, insiinctol
nnirdci si rcclalmonlei a al nhului: ioiim' 6i v(vvnooL
riv 6i\o< riiv roLrtr$lv diriar 6no Iv< (di aircL
Oro'Lai 9i.cvrmidcpdc: kdri +nrL/ 6i dvr!< rnriv roil
[LriooaL{di ri]< dprovia< &i roi i,uoroi ... 4 ';pril< oi

D.M PIPIIDI
r.Quol.< rpi,q ddrd sdlbro, kor; F,(pdy npod]ohr<,
.1('y@a/ m/ notrd,y k 16y dufodxloLco&ror}
rn eDp[entrnta. r aeeo .a,zc rftln]e !i, inr o ni
$tri inc5 si nrai mrc. tn {ininL! on carc rc subliriazli
.anc@tu| sdc.r,l oDerdc al llsusnnor E cre cxDcncnia
poerioirc prcsupunc
(cr. 14,1{r
b s 6r rd k ,,ro !r;too;,
dnrOuro, 1oi< dyor;'o'< i. riiooy iori
) niscparer
tocu.oanc . ru4. ds pozilic diD pancr loi Annobl fatil de
docdirclc iniemciire pc rndnise diternc sdu conducitnd h
.onciur' opusc.Nici nu-i ndoic Je prcr h!x,
eiodne Jc
drmjm.ri pentu a nrtct*c cr,l)r eriunetr dc s.bitibi. a rcezicl
londannre Jr P iron p!'ru \atr.eJn Lrn !!a,i4 puungd\r
tr trir,.e! rc
qsfr
\ ! t lc : I c is ri! !
'E r,inrtirrb.jorlo
n
rc
d
ii ciuLla\erdtrrulur
ArrJrm,e w mutr!m!{ me tuE!Du,
drigtDalcJespe risrdl< - o senrdficr[e flo/_ofici a cirej
c co'npiraria sohiFr, in cap.tX inko poczie!t
,cxpr$ic *rdrt|
rbnc; nuc, zlc,nsvoicdc null sititrril)enrrua inrctercc, ii
rco'a c&xtlur poe.jccfonutari de Dcmocrii rt imDrtutsiili
dc Pldor eru n4ticarc d!{utc elenmk inpornu ciren
Ansorcrsc shre! oSlisars!-fi iDd,eprccrihcx E nci.dobscd
adc,unca hi ur pnrcr fi ca*ielrii untri mnacol dc fctul
,nbivenrici dirinc po{ut{c in temcni cxpti.ilr de fitozolul dir
Abdcn si pe caE tic 6i in renFri mcrforici anlnt t r,,
nusovrta,hrendui, $o invocD,
in Irtrnoasclccuvinlorbbuitc
Iuis6raE: raird 6i d 0(;< iidrp0ri[yo<ro]iroy (s0il.rrijy
roLrr6y) r,j, yoiy rorjloLq xpnrar 0ripiraL< rui roi.
xpN!o60i< roi roi< (i/r.dr roi< orior<, iva i[.i<, oi
droioyr{< .rrjIo drr oix onroL<LoLyoi ro,:ra riro,r<
onao nori\oi ;au, oi< hi< rit ,dporry,dx\. 6 0.;< o,jrd.
.rrLv Xalbr, 6Ldron'ly 6i toiyl.rdr npd<
ia,i<3i
',

PRODLEMAINSPIRATIEILA ARETOTEL SI FIORAIIJ


E ds asemdeaclidcrt ci aurorulIr .
dor.hililrrul psibic,l poorulnipenru acxplicr oactiviratcllc
c[reituadc.ca utrrrs rmoi oasininorbidc.r 1i IstsodLcs{
!re'lnrrem"
t u . ! n ! is . r g l o n J f l r r p / b ' r t r d ' i u d u m i i mr c
r'
lmlrre|]d
M' butrlrz i rtTea:crr, \trfldck lJenF
!
r
ss
. Drn * r. b r i t r m t l f , t i n g ; L l r L L i i . r ( p r e \ u p u ' ( d ! r
ob5rsir.lnDdnhunoittle drsdgcrn tiiidtunEAnn E
bntsrl.catrd$lruirrsnprac{a.tc luinonna!Jcrporienlci
; mrn e , r u n n u , t r | r s : P t u d s c" r d & 5 k ' r x u D r e v r d i n
o' b'ur. !r mtr8ep;d i r5'l
L,t ire
fl
i,**
"r.,
r'll'hdrd Jt
"t^*"
^"
dd(Lq
it," rir'r"'.,r"
-**"rc
ptu\$tr ! de plfllrme I pJiF
eLuE
-.,r
dllDde. nrmnhbi
nib; , indd?ncdi in.eicd dc a minrui tascdjx huliti d' rubdl
sr,i,tridc tuvinuifta d! rrnt.Fr in {fleblc sp{bbnrt.,serci
d.locrimr'$i'romcadostrldin$ pe.,tnblcprtrlcdalorsirc
lnc'r'
lnibutr crmd din.
'nr n r ' u i t p r c / c r r r n r B l e s d ! i m i * n c
c
.
i
d
C.. i i r r \ ' k
din zilcbnorshra eacftTui ltrdftptlltitsi iadu.ildi Arktotcl
invinnncr ci d li iDcercd si intmdac .cu ajturul tucullllild
nrion!Lco lilozotiesi o tchDicii
h;d . netuclcs sc p@b rr@ dor obscrvati' ci, ninsheritorft
lsi_ltulburc
matDenrorlrul,acuz{ian!rnNuldesisrdr
-p. Sraittt. cio,t t,"i
puro
adlus
,ilr:i
*iti" $codu a
"."tntl

SI HORATIU
A INSPtsATIEILA ARISTOTEL
PROBLEM
iidrialr AjFrorcln as!ns !i nosrrjnd Llcr0dee.e p j
rii
rngequn.rulirc:
t e h J I o t ra t c . t r. . iv , F ,
d.p,o,
,6pimln, d fi i.n!^ \prigrtr
r fl'noaircrL
rorrj lunodqir nru
rarc'ri,-rurc c vorbaru nu mxd r o a E rL rlr, d iB
d eo ; t r
irddicli..E e(! dc io'erer., n urd A rr jn c e . h ro
e d I i DUrr
popurc inbmeicrorut L)ceului dobuan
,,rchni;ii., din a;ifti
ap.rab sc Ia@ o rin!, dac! dc h iDccDurn-r ti
crdus dii do
neniul inspn4ici,F liingr idcrvcnriadjvini p.suhte
de hj i
utr o.o rotrh
nrdeccsfi. etcmeDr
ruruiirarionalre\poLcdepufl renupurcdqr r;
I inhducJin
llL j muondqnk/ors1!.Deh m; (rmr, o d rb ic t f 5 e ! d v n
rr!trlii&c!oovinlcntc ivir.in m
Je!isrcm!ld ne(arcnrzuDs r-t .
rc ps'i!l% Trchu'rinDr.,or jJcar.u rn ni mulr
rudui
rt, crnu!i odJdch;r'n k vdt pufulr, r\ nnou
oonde{e.
\l?s:depoeqrriryoJrijr r.rlbrrtr:Dhamidtr_:d!dth 4.
4lcidlid 116tn!\h,* r. u n . ! h .
n f c l rc ' a u y d , -n
'r & i',rc
r rc 0 durdur6nirtuide!rro ! re p t re n . rb , t lri. , , J . wc n c c
atonciceldsubiecrilobligrsnaprciczcrrenciercsDcdivcale
poctrlor,.lucizf.si pe atc cetr.,cxlaricr.,
rilobruinu d: r.

hdoiali sl-d {ordc prcfctillr celor didai Prriorsa otutune


!d{ lN. plsrrati dc nn p6rj al Paeftlt ndlr vtdc l,cunar. p.
@ sinsur{ versiumadbl ic'a tut purin6 sI l tnh8nn ltr chiP
srtisficnror. E vorba dc ndutilc din c.D X\4I (1455 , l0 .si
un) in ce, dupr ce aratt obligal,r pentd autoruldrmalo dc
i s. idenrilica ln cet nd m{rc mrsuri cu peFonajcle $rc.
conrinurctrum{bale&slu$iri: nLoavdrarory;p 'ird ri(
anri< Ono.o< ol ir roi< rd06iv .torv, Kai xasdivL d
xa!a(,j[,o. Kai xo\<tdiva 6 dpt(o'[vo< dlls'vdroro
&d (,)O!o,rcii rorniri on +drrdD i raNo,r' roirov
rdp or r;v nrraorol oL 6i &orlrLr0i .toLvr!.
O Elarac lie ti snmar, r dkculitlor prileiuiE de accsc
.eGvaranduninft ediloii Poeret, inepand din sa al X\4ler,
nu $ e lvea &i rc{ul3e. Mullunindu_n! sI rclcv pcrroctr
concodanF r .dcndrliei Fuov cu londd idv{ftuiii lui
Ari$obl dsspr gcnczap.zici, ctd a li Ptrsdc ajuls ln lumin! $i
lcagl devu$1 309din E?tsi,Ja.rtPrsor. si rjulorol
linl ffi{
pc crc nll p@b dr lr interpha cosl[ a a{uia Pnh
mi!e, oricum,nu incapcltrdoirl, ct - roDurrind la alrc dezvolrtui
ti cu otscddta zrltend dint'o
mt sI crpnnc Honliu in vcrsul @ nc crinc aronlianr_i decet
pElerinFninilesbt .lrrdaudeshsintpedtupmd,,amoilos

,.*.lf;:lif: n:il.l:t#trut::l13.;Tllx,il"it:l:tifi'

:r^ili;T
r:i,i-ri
;:ijili?hiljl ffi,i:iil':#:r::1i:;
s-'

i,6\he"i/-,i',-,,

:l,l'l.,hl'.iiiif
*:#ll**lt-,1
'1['"i:11i;:""ft
[ri;\S1,::.1,
li. i;lT''"'jri.xtjitr.rl
":

I clh r idt r r P

let n

r-i*,*hi,;i**i*r,
i,:,,

$-*ffiffi

PROBLEMAINSPIRATIETt"{ AXISTOTELSI HORATIU


{le ctuortteiruri dcoscbitoffeinseeri pc ru tua'a ori nMe
dAisocl. inrr adevir,attt Dctul 'ln7.shf (aldelspus.distul
dban pcmijloacelesal.),cati pGtul "inspnaf rplievoel' dc
Hoiadunr o scricEstedod Epis.dkictft P;sotj.deasll daa
nulcntu r fi opusi0iul altuis.ci tentu n scindicr ln ci doua
liPld dcdsd dcoporrivltntahibl
...rcaueenin conctu&tercaun
dt"e css.szrsftqu', siqri r.iibt !, ,os
ffiari

ptLpjua, puLcshunc cse PNb.1.

irycnjun cuj sit, cui nens diuiniat atqre 6


,
tuttu son{wun. d$ Dn;'is huiusl1d6en..:2.
Ci, dai drzin. h coDdilile BFcirlc &curgand din hortuifta
dc a otsn conparioljlo' sfi Esdils urci dc a scrisului,petol vr
n fost adu sI accentETe inpondla facultillilor r4ionale iD

ffiilitfil*'Tlt*i=ffi

j*k{#n*$t#il1#.l#,;ffi
r ujry. r i drlr s'iEhr, P{t. tr,

ruffi-

',

l,l

tr$*ffiffif;'ii'1ffi
BIBLIOGRAFIE

attiq4

*
j:::li;;::l',:llllll::':1.!.j;r;.;;;l
:1
i,lT"il",ll'I'*
'f; ::",t"i.Ll:i:l'::
l:*F;;i,.;;;::i:ri;il#t:1";lf
:.1r-:t;;;;;i' :;;i;liiiil:::i:ii'::i
il1.1i:"'"ru'b--'
;-:.i,,,:

a skLl\ ol t$ Davetop)c"t.\li.

RENa BRAY, t,i roDrior

dc la doctrc

M,nRD,AZU.oj'lllctiitrtjl,.,'BEuc\d,

@ q ' ' ? tq lt' ilb iig { l!( 4 h '

jfl,,djsic,irnofo?d.sdz'|a.5.D,6

l;:l'1fii;ll:li:"-;i';
l;l.tjli;l;;;li:ir*:t';r.r::
j,l;:lli.I il,il,iTfrll".':11'::'ff
; il::ii':l#":1;1,:1,1
;:l,ti:"1;
jt;:
i;:ti; t:i,"i'l
l,rjrt;:...
iN,J,l:J,,:
5;
:l:::t.* :!;:;;::.
",*"*,

.dir.i.,
.,,.",".'|"
;

"-tr,r.
"".|,"""".,..,";
,ltil:uiI';:
iill:lf j:.l:fl
".:lln*";;t.;utiTl:
.ti
t
i.li,'ill:l',*l
;lfLl";l;;::f
il
t:'j':''ty.':,;;i;j,;;
r ilr,i;il^;llf:i';.1::'lltl;
ll,llll.ll
,lll:.
ll"lY
r-.;
;fril,lli:;;,1:l;
;lllli:["T"',11:t:l"i:l::t;lt;
,.,.,".''',.".,-"
;:.;;:;ii]:iil;l
";;,]

Você também pode gostar