Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
- Elsevier
Printed in The Netherlands
Publishing
SOME CHARACTERISTIC
Company,
bmsterdam
N.N. AMBRASEYS
Engineering
(Received
Seismology
November
Section,
Imperial
College
of Science,
London
(Great
Britain)
13, 1969)
SUMMARY
The study of the Anatolian fault zone shows that major earthquake
sequences associated with faulting have been occurring in the zone since
historical times with periods of quiescence of 150 years. The fault zone is
a broad belt of crushed rocks a few kilometres wide rather than a single
continuous rupture. Recent surface breaks within the zone consist of large
en echelon ruptures with individual uninterrupted linear features that do
not exceed
a few kilometres. The average displacement of the two sides of
the zone since 1939 is about 90 cm. There is some evidence to show that
creep is taking place in some parts of the ione, of the order of a few centimetres per year. Preliminary calculations show that the angle of residual
shear resistance mobilised on the fault at failure should be very small.
INTRODUCTION
9 (1970)
143-165
143
1944~---+
t---l967--d
I--
t-l94&
l939-
40*
42
I
42
-38
40 -38
40 -279
409 -27%
40 -27:
39t -26
39 -27
39.9-39.7
39.7-39.7
39.8-39.3
40.7-36.6
40.8-30.4
41.0-34.0
41.0-33.0
39.4-26.7
39.3-41.2
39.4-40.9
40.8-33.2
40.0-28.8
40.0-27.5
41-2-32.8
41.1-36.3
40.6-31.2
40.7-31.2
40.7-31.2
39.1-41.6
40.9-29.2
40.3-28.2
39.2-41.6
40.6-31.0
39.5-40.3
39.3-40.3
41.8-32.3
Epicentre
(degrees)
6
6
6l
6iI
8
6
7.3
6a
1.6
7.6
7.2
5.8
6.5
6.5
5.6
7.4
6.4
6
7.1
6.0
6i
6::
6.0
6.5
6.8
7.2
6.0
52
6:s
64
?P
6;
_.-.
1
L = length of surface
faulting:
No = relative
resultant
displacement
observed
from surface
trace;
azimuth
caiculated
by Canitez
et al.
from Baths
formula
IogE = 12.24 + 1.44(M).
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
llh24
OlhZ9
14h41
16h20
06h52
OOh36
08h48
23h57
lOh04
14hO3
15h52
22h20
03h22
02h35
03h12
182144
18h33
Olh27
19h06
03h58
21h03
062133
09h36
1lhOl
15h57
lFh.58
14h31
12h22
16h56
18h52
04h19
08h19
_
9
9
4
4
6
22
21
26
12
20
20
26
1
6
31
17
13
19
18
7
19
26
26
27
25
18
6
19
22
26
24
3
1
2
Feb.
Aug.
Jan.
Jan.
Jul.
Sep.
Nov.
Dec.
Nov.
Dec.
Jun.
Nov.
Feb.
Oct.
May
Aug.
Aug.
Mar.
Mar.
Sep.
Aug.
May
Way
May
Oct.
Sep.
Oct.
Aug.
Jul.
Jul.
Sep.
Sep.
1909,
1912,
1935,
1935,
1937,
1939,
1938,
1939,
1941,
1942,
1943,
1943,
1944,
1944,
1946,
1949,
1951,
1952,
1953,
1953,
1954,
1957,
1957,
1957,
1959,
1963,
1964,
1966,
1967,
1967,
1968,
1968,
No.
zone1
~Time
(G.M.T.)
Date
Fault
of the Anatolian
features
TABLE
10
78
71
horizontal
and vertical
components.
(1960) and Ritsema
(1968).
Energy
160
40
30
80
430
60
?
?
230
40
including
(1967),
Owl
Azimuth
calculated
1.1 * 1013
-
2.1 * 1013
-
4.5 * 1013
-
3.0 .1013
-
3.7
1013
2.2 .1013
-
150
360
265
190
56
5.7 * 1013
108
112
200
50
75
.1013
3.9
108
-
111
420
E/LR,
(c.g.s.)
350
(degrees)
CdC.
azim.
I_
azim.
obs.
(degrees)
--.
of fault
~_ -Strike
10
(cm)
RO
EARTHQUAKES
It is only very recently that the Anatolian fault zone has been recognised as a unique tectonic feature, in some respects similar to the better
known San Andreas fault in California. The series of earthquakes between
1939 and 1968, most of which have been associated with faulting that systematically progressed westward for nearly 1,000 km. is indeed remarkable
and raises the question of similar seismic paroxysms in the zone prior to
1939. The answer to this question rests in the past history of the region; it
would, in fact be remarkable if such paroxysms had not occurred in the past.
Allen (1969), quite intuitively suggests that major earthquake sequences,
such as those of the period 1939-1968, should be relatively infrequent events
with periods of quiescence of several hundred years between them. Preliminary results of a detailed study of historical events in the Middle and Near
East between 10 and 1100 A.D. seem to justify this hypothesis (Ambraseys,
1970). The historical material available at the moment is coherent enough
to permit tentative conclusions to be drawn not only about the frequency of
early seismic paroxysms in the Anatolian fault zone, but also about the relative importance and significance of historical data for the deliniation of the
long-term seismic activity of Anatolia as a whole.
146
Tectonophysics,
9 (1970) 143-165
Fig.2 shows the northwest portion of the area studied. This region
has a long recorded history that goes back many centuries, and contains
a wealth of information about early earthquakes. In this figure, large dots
(1) show ancient sites which, during the period l&l000 A.D., have been
totally destroyed by earthquakes at least four times. These earthquakes
had widespread effects the descritpion of which is extant in the form of inscriptions or in manuscripts. Sinaller dots (Z), show sites that have been
destroyed less than four times but more than once. Finally small dots (3)
indicate sites that have been destroyed at least once but have suffered
damage many times. In this figure place-names are given in their early
form or style.
Without going into details, the data available for the period prior to
1100 A.D. suggests that major earthquakes occurred in Sapid successions,
within very short periods of time, preceded and followed by periods of
75-150 years of relative quiescence. Some of these paroxysmal sequences
were associated with faulting, in many respects similar to that of the period
1939-1968.
One of the most interesting sequences is that of 967-1050. Duringthat
period at least twenty earthquakes of damaging to destructive magnitude
occurred along the Anatolian fault zone. Of these, at least five shocks were
associated with faulting. The first earthquake occurred on September 967
and affected the region of Honorias between Bolu (Claudiopolis) and Gerede
(Krateia); the extent of faulting in this case was not possible to define but
ruptures extended between these two settlements. In 995 A.D. another earthquake destroyed the region along the line Solhan (Haykaberd), Capakcur
(Djapdjur), Palu (Balu), Arsomosata (near Kharput) and Keferdiz (Claudias),
causing extensive faulting, diverting rivers and changing the course of
streams between Capakcur and Palu. In May 1035 an earthquake devastated
the region of Voukellarioi (between Gerede and Cerkes). This shock was associated with a fault break at least 60 km long that extended from Gerede
(Krateia) to Hamdmli and Bayindir (of the Voukellarian Thema) on the
Cerkes river; roads leading north were disrupted and the river Cerkes was
dammed. Eight years later another earthquake destroyed the region of
Ekeghiatz (west-northwest of Erzerum). This shock was associated with
ground ruptures along a line from Erzerum (Arzan) to Enderes and Purkh
(Nikopolis), a distance of about 150 km. Seven years later, in 1050, the district northof Cankiri (Gangra) including Tosia was destroyed. The ground
in places subsided and ponds were formed and later became swamps along
a distance of about 80 km.
Other sequences of paroxysmal seismicity associated with faulting
have been identified in the 3rd, 5th and 7th centuries A.D. affecting the
regions of Amaseia, Enderes (Nikopolis) and Niksar (Neocaesarea) as well
as the region between Mudurnu (Moundoupolis) and Kassaba (Germe).
The distribution of the seismic activity shown in Fig.2 is remarkable;
almost all sites that have been affected by earthquakes fall along three
well-defined lines. This distribution is all the more significant because none
of these lines follows trade routes or centres of culture that often supply
the bulk of the information that would tend to overemphasise local seismicity.
On the north, sites affected by major earthquakes run in an east-west
direction, from Kirmasti Kassaba (Germe) on the west, to Ercincan and
Kigi (Hordjan) on the east. They define quite clearly the Anatolian fault
Tectonophysics, 9 (1970) 143-165
147
1JD
100
3110
400
1
km
N
S
E A
Fig.2. Historical earthquakes in the Middle and Near East for the
period IO-1000 AD., including instorical faulting for the period 85@-101OA.D.
1 = sites destroyed by earthquakes at least faur times, causing z,erious
damage and widespread concern; 2 = sites destroyed less~than four times
but more than once; 3 = sites deskroyed or affected ey strong earthqa&.es.
.Hatdla
#lr$hlap
l khbtrd
zone along which there have been at least four historical fault breaks in
967, 1035; 1043 and 1050 A.D. These breaks occurred almost exactly where
faulting occurred recently, in 1944, 1943, 1939 and 1943 respectively.
Another well-defined alignment of high seismicity starts near the east
end of the Anatolian zone, near Hinis (Teghtap), and runs southwest through
Maras to Antiochia and Apamea. On this alignment, which for the sake of
convenience may be called the Taurus zone, we have identified at least one
historical fault break in 995 AD. near Palu, where there is no clear evidence of more recent ruptures. Along the Taurus zone the seismic activity
follows a southwest-trending fault zone, conjugate to the Anatolian zone,
which presumably is active (Altinli, 1963; Allen, 1969). If projected further
to the south this zone aligns with the Dead Sea fault system.
The third alignment, which may be called the Asia Minor zone, is the
most interesting. It starts from the Aegean coast, just south of the west end
of the Anatolian zone, and dissects the southwest corner of Asia Minor,
reaching Finike (Myra) on the eastern Mediterranean. This zone is arcuate
and follows only scattered fault segments that show recent activity; its
overall continuity has not been documented and it is not known whether it
actually exists on the ground as a fault zone. The conjecture presented here
about the Asia Minor zone may provide a test for the validity of our interpretation of historical data.
FAULTPATTERN
149
Jahirli
.Akkus
39-w
3ffoo
4OOOC
3630E
POO
.Sonusa
\
..
....
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..~
...........
E,-baa
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
hikSCfr
1942 Dee 20
..,
..
..
--I
._.
40-30
+
known to the author. It would seem, however, that uninterrupted and almost
linear fractures extending for hundreds of kilometres are the exception
rather than the rule, not only in Anatolia but also elsewhere.
As an example of this scale effect, consider the 1967 fault trace associated with the Mudurnu earthquake (Ambraseys et al., 1968; Ambraseys
and Zatopek, 1969). On a small scale, say 1:500,000, the map shows a continuous, rather smooth trace, which is shown in the insert of Fig.10. On a
scale 20 times larger the trace will begin to show complex, non-continuous
features. Fig.11 shows the segment in the insert of Fig.10 when mapped on
a 1:20,000 scale. We can see now that this 30 km long rupture consists of
a series of en-echelon shears connected with compressional features. On
this scale individual ruptures in very thin alluvium overlying bedrock,
hardly exceed in length a few kilometres. Similar patterns of surface ruptures have been found in other cases of extensive faulting (Ambraseys,
1963; Ambraseys and Tchalenko, 1969; Tchalenko, 1969; Tchalenko and
Ambraseys 1969).
Perhaps the alleged continuity and linearity of recent fault breaks
arises from the fact that most of the better known cases of faulting have
Tectonophysics,
9 (1970) 143-165
151
i
8
&-r?
/;,,
. ..
,...
.I
-...,.
,..
_,..
. . . . . . ..
_,
__..
. ... .
,.:
,....
,,_.....
.I..,_.,..
.. . .
_(._......
,.,
.._(,,..
:.
..
~...._.__.
_.
...
..
.,.....
,:
.(
,,.
...
. ..
_,_. ...
,......
,.._...
,:
,:
,:
,:
..
320307
(...
..
.
..,
,./
,_.."
...
,....'
._,.....
(...
. . . . .
X.,
0
--I
IO
._..
.. . .
,:
,j/F4bmt..,..**a..;.;..L.
.._..___.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
~~~::::.....
1. ;:.
._.
,:
.._.
,..
50
Bolu
1944 Feb
Gerede
Y3000
1 ..,,
.. .
..-
100
km
40030
273UE
1953 Mar 18
Gdinen-Ye&e
3lW
.Bekdemirlen
. Dutlor
'DdWl-CUfl
_10
Im
1957 Moy 26
Aban
MWN-
~ ulvo
JlWC
with earthquake of 26
9 (1970) 143-165
155
I__
I _______i
$;E
I
RECENT
FAULT
MOVEMENTS
The observed
sense of fault movement
associated
with recent earthquakes in the Anatolian
fault zone is consistently
right-lateral
with the north
side, in general,
downthrown.
Individual
displacements
quoted by various
authors differ, but on the average the magnitude
of these displacements
decreases
from east to west, horizontal
offsets being practically
zero in the
central part of the zone between the 36th and 34th meridians,
increasing
again west of the 34th meridian
(Fig.1). Vertical
displacements
vary rather
erratically
along the zone, but on the average they seem to decrease
from
east to west, showing mostly a throw facing north.
Right-lateral
displacements
measured
on individual
ruptures
associated
with the 1939-1968 series of earthquakes,
vary from 30 to 430 cm, with
maximum
throws of about 200 cm. Average displacements,
however, taken
along the whole length of the various fault breaks were found to be from four
to eight times smaller.
The average displacement
for the whole length ofthe
Anatolian
fault zone since 1939 was found to be just under 90 cm. Obviously,
the total horizontal
displacement
of 16.4 m given by Ketin (1957) for the
whole zone is excessive.
A 90-cm displacement
corresponds
to an average
rate of movement
of about 3 cm per year and suggests a total offset of the
two sides of the zone since Quaternary
times of a few tens of kilometres.
The question of whether the displacements
measured
on individual
ruptures
a few days after a particular
earthquake
are the displacements
that
actually
occurred
during faulting,
is difficult to answer. There is, however,
some indirect
evidence to show that what is usually measured
on a fault
break a few days after rupture as a relative
displacement
contains a considerable
component
due to creep. For instance,
in the 1967 earthquake
a
fault trace passing through a village (near Acemler)
remained
unnoticed
until a few hours after the main shock when it displaced foot-paths
and
disrupted
by 40 cm an irrigation
ditch that flooded the village. In another
locality,
during the same earthquake,
a cistern straddling
a branch of the
fault break on rock was shearedoffby
about 5 cm. Its brick walls were
repaired
immediately
and the cistern was partly filled with water only to
be found a day later empty with the repaired
walls gapping about 10 cm.
Similar
indirect
indications
suggest a gradual increase
of the fault displacements
with time after rupture and they have been found in other parts
of the Anatolian
zone as well as in Iran, but most of these cases are based
on local information
which could not always be authenticated.
It seems, therefore,that
the actual relative
displacements
that take
place on an individual
fault break during an earthquake
are much smaller
than those that can be measured
on it hours or days after rupture.
This
has been ascertained
for cases of faulting elsewhere
(Nakamura
et al.,
1967; Brown et al., 1967, for instance)
and helps to explain why most faults
give little or no indication
of melting (Ambraseys,
1969a).
However, the cumulative
displacements
across a fault zone a few tens
to a few hundreds
of metres wide, are larger than those measured
immediately after fracture
in the vicinity of a single constituent
rupture;
and these
two effects, cumulative
displacements
immediately
after rupture and time
effects on a single rupture act in an opposite sense so far as the actual displacements
of the two sides of the fault are concerned.
For instance,
high
voltage electric
lines crossing
the Mudurnu valley at an acute angle were
158
Tectonophysics,
9 (1970) 143-165
RAPID
CREEP
OR INDUCED
FAULTING
No systematic
creep measurements
are available
for the Anatolian
fault zone. There is some inconclusive
evidence,
however,
of rapid or induced movements
in the zone.
About 900 years after the 1045 AD. earthquake
at Hamamli,
an earthquake on February
1, 1944, associated
with extensive
faulting, displaced
the
Zonguldak railroad
line by about 150 cm. The railroad
tracks cross the
rupture about 150 m north of the railway station of Ismet Pasa near Hamamli.
(Fig.6, 12). Six years later, and about one year before the 1951 earthquake,
the railroad
tracks were again distorted
at the same point showing a displacement
of 30 cm; this time without the occurrence
of an earthquake.
The
tracks were offset for a third time during the earthquake
of August 13, 1951.
Thefault-break
associated
with this earthquake
is not very well known but it
extended 20 km on either side of Ismet Pasa, between KuzUren and DemircikBy.
0 10 20
_m
30 Lo 50
IN
Fig.12.
Tectonophysics,
Plan
9
of rupture
(1970)
143-165
at Ismet
PaSa.
159
9 (1970) 143-165
161
on faults many
et al., 1968).
tens
of kilometres
DISCUSSION
Tectonophysics,
9 (1970) 143-165
y )]
ACKNOWLEDCEMENTS
I wish ~0 express my thanks to Dr. J. Tchalenko for offering
helpful suggestions and for commenting on the paper, and to many
Turkish geologists and engineers who helped in the field work. This
research is supported partly by UNESCO Paris, and partly by the
Tectonophysics, 9 (1970) 143-165
163
Natural
Environment
Research
Council in London.
I take this
opportunity to thank Mr. A. Aytun of the Ministry of Housing for his most
useful advice and help during my site visits.
REFERENCES
Allen, C.R., 1969. Active faulting in Northern Turkey. Division Geol. Sci. Contr.
no. 1577, Cal. Inst. Tech.
Allen, C., Grantz, A., Brune, J., Clark, M., Sharp, R., Theodore, T., Wolfe, E. and
Wyss, M., 1968. The Borrego Mountain, California, earthquake of April 9,
1968; a preliminary report. Bull. Seismol. Sot. Am., 58:1138.
Altinli, I., 1963. Geological Map of Erzurum; Explanatory Text. Maden Tetkik ve
Arama Enst. Publ., Ankara.
Ambraseys, N.N., 1963. The Buyin-Zara, Iran, earthquake of September 1962. Bull.
Seismol. Sot. Am., 53:705-740.
Ambraseys, N., 1969a. Maximum intensity of ground movements caused by faulting.
Proc. World Conf. Earthquake Eng., &h, Santiago, 1:154-171.
Ambraseys, N.N., 1969b. Early earthquakes in the Near and Middle East. UNESCO
Rept., SC/1473/69 (in press).
Ambraseys, N. and Tchalenko, J., 1968. Documentation of faulting associated with
earthquakes. Upper Mantle Rept., Aug. 1968, Prague.
Ambraseys, N. and Tchalenko, J., 1969. The Dasht-e Bayaz, Iran, earthquake of
August 1968. Bull. Seismol. Sot. Am., 59 (in press).
Ambraseys, N. and Zatopek, A., 1969. The Mudurnu valley, West Anatolia, Turkey
earthquake of July 22, 1967. Bull. Seismol. Sot. Am., 59:521-589.
Ambraseys, N.N., Zatopek, A., Tasdemiroglu, M. and Aytun, A., 1968. The West
Anatolia earthquake of 22 July 1967. UNESCO Publ., Ser. No. 622, Paris.
Barosh, P.J., 1968. Relationships of explosion-produced fracture patterns to
geologic structure in Yucca Flat, Nevada test site. Geol. Sot. Am., Mem.,
110, pp.199-217.
Brown, R., Vedder, J., Wallace, R., Roth, E., Yerkes, R., Castle, R., Waananen, A.,
Page, R. and Eaton, J., 1967. The Parkfield-Cholame, California, earthquakes
of June-August 1966. Geol. Surv. Profess. Papers, 579.
Brune, J., 1968. Seismic moment, seismicity, and rate of slip along major fault
zones. J. Geophys. Res., 73~779
Byerlee, J., 1968. Brittle-ductile transition in rock. J. Geophys. Res., 73:4741-4750.
Canitez, N. and Ucer, S.B., 1967. Computer determinations for the fault-plane
solutions in near Anatolia. Tectonophysics, 4:235-244.
Galanopoulos, A., 1965. The large conjugate fault system and the associated earthquake activity in Greece. Ann. Geol. Pays Helleniques, 18:129
Hoy, B., 1963. Induced faulting. Bull. Seismol. Sot. Am., 53:845.
Ketin, I., 1957. Kuzey Anadolu deprem fayi. Istanbul Tek. Univ. Dergisi, 15:51.
Ketin, I., 1964. GBotechnique de Turqui. Commission Carte Geol. du Monde, Moscow
1964. 258-262.
Ketin, I., 1969. Ueber die Nordanatolische horizontalverschiebung. Bull. Mineral
Res. Exploration Inst. Turkey, Foreign Ed., 72:1-28.
McKenzie, D. and Parker, R., 1967. The North Pacific; an example of tectonics on a
sphere. Nature, 215:1276.
Nakamura, K. and Tsuneishi, Y., 1967. Ground cracks at Matsushiro probably of
underlying strike-slip origin. Bull. Earthquake Res. Inst., Tokyo Univ.,
45:417-471.
Ocal, N., 1960. Determination of the mechanism of some Anatolian earthquakes.
Publ. Dominion Obs., Ottawa, 24:365-370.
Pavoni, N., 1961. Die Nordanatolische Horizontalverschiebung. Geol. Rundschau,
51.
Ritsema, A.R., 1968. European earthquake mechanisms. Tectonophysics, 4(3):247-259.
164
Tectonophysics,
9 (1970) 143-165
Scholz,
Tectonophysics,
9 (1970) 143-165
165