Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
REFERENCE
REV
SCSASABP4
0
DATE: FEBRUARY 2000
PAGE
OF 8
1
REVISION DATE:
FEBRUARY 2003
COMPILED BY
TESCOD APPROVED
FUNCTIONAL RESP. APPROVED BY
AUTHORIZED BY
Signed
Signed
Signed
Signed
............................
I A Ferguson
..............................
H J Geldenhuys
TDM
.............................
P Crowdy
for TESCOD
.............................
M N Bailey
DTM for ED (D)
Contents
Page
1 Voltage drop Policy Note................................ ................................ ................................ ......
MGMlm/as-1/May00
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
2
REV
0
OF 8
Load = 3pu
V = 1pu
phase
I2 = 1.5pu
V= 1pu
Load = 3pu
V = 1pu
Iphase = 1.5pu
Vphase = 1.5pu
= 1pu
In = 1.5cos (60) pu
I2 = 1.5pu
Iphase = 1pu
V
I1 = 1.5pu
I1 = 1.5pu
In = 0pu
Load = 3pu
V = 1pu
Load = 3pu
V = 1pu
Iphase = 1.5pu
Iphase = 3pu
V phase = 3 x 2 = 6pu
To supply the same load using different technologies, the current and voltage drop increases, when
the technology is reduced from a three-phase system to a dual-phase or single-phase system, are
given in table 1.
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
3
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
REV
0
OF 8
Dual-phase
LV (3-wire)
1 (base case)
1 (base case)
1,5 (3/2)
1,5
Two phases of
three-phase
system
1,5 (3/2)
2,25
Single-phase
LV (2-wire)
3
6
12
ADM D N
AMEU:
UCF ( N ) = 1 +
DCF ( N ) = 1 +
2.8
and
2
N
for A D M D 5
The present DT method uses the British DCF with current limiting, and the AMEU UCF limited to a
maximum value of 2. The preferred DCF = AMEU. The preferred UCF = NEUTRAL, which simply
uses the connection unbalance per phase to calculate neutral currents and their associated voltage
drops.
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
4
REV
0
OF 8
ADMD = 0.4
DSP = 1.10
DCF _ AMEU ( N ) = 1 +
2
N
8
ADMD N
25
22.5
20
17.5
DCF_AMEU ( DSP )
DCF_BRITISH ( DSP , 0.4 )
15
12.5
10
7.5
5
2.5
0
1
10
DSP
Notice that the British DCF is extremely sensitive to ADMD and must be clipped to reflect realistic
answers.
Approximate domestic current for 0.4 kVA ADMD for N=1 to N=5 DSPs:
N = 1.5
DCF _ AMEU ( N )
ADMD
N =
0.231
5.195
6.926
8.658
10.39
12.121
ADMD
N =
0.231
5.195
6.926
8.658
10.39
12.121
If 8A limits are imposed then for N=5 the current l = 8*5 = 40 Amprere.
This means that the DT or British curve has NO diversity for the first 5 households, which is
INCORRECT.
It is therefore recommended to use DCF = AMEU
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
5
REV
0
OF 8
UCF( N )
2.8
N
3
UCF ( DSP )
2
1
1
10
DSP
3.8
1
2
Error = 90%
At the end of a LV distributor, with 4 houses on one
phase, UCF = 2 is correct
2.4
1
2
Error = 20%
At say, any point of the network, the network has 4
houses per phase, therefore balanced for 12 houses
and UCF = 1 is then correct
1.8
1
1
Error = 80%
Using UCF = AMEU therefore has errors ranging from 20% to 100%
For netoworks with neutral conductors of different size to the phase conductors, the result would be
subjected to more errors.
Option 2: UCF = NEUTRAL
For one household UCF = 2
Error =
2
1
2
Error = 0%
Error =
2
1
2
Error = 0%
At any point in the network then UCF = NEUTRAL uses the vector sum of the phase currents to
calculate a neutral current. The voltage drop in the neutral is then calculated using this neutral current
multiplied by the neutral impedance. For networks with neutral conductors of different size to the
phase conductors, the result would be correct.
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
6
REV
0
OF 8
4 Statistical calculations
4.1 Background
A statistical approach for voltage drop calculations is strongly believed to be far more appropriate
than traditional empirical methods since consumer load models with diversity can be modelled more
accurately.
A per-phase analysis using vector algebra in complex notation can be used to most accurately model
the network.
Loads can be modelled as a mixture of constant impedance, constant current and constant power
loads using variable power factors (a typical PF for constant power loads is 0,6 to 0,8 and for constant
impedance loads it is close to 1). For simplification a constant current load model is recommended.
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
7
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
Z b: =
REV
0
OF 8
2
Z pc
Vb
Zb
Z sc: =
Sb
100
X sc: =
Z sc
1 + X to R 2
R sc: =
X sc
X to R
where:
Zb
ADMD NCF(1)
R 2 L , (ADMD in amperes for this example)
Vreceive
The following figures compare the voltage drop over three service conductor sizes using 2,5 A and
20 A supplies.
2.5A Supply
0.70%
Voltage Drop
0.60%
0.50%
4mm
0.40%
10mm
0.30%
16mm
0.20%
0.10%
0.00%
0m
20m
40m
60m
80m
REFERENCE
SCSASABP4
PAGE
8
DISTRIBUTION STANDARD
PART 1: PLANNING GUIDELINES
SECTION 28: BOOK LV FEEDER VOLTAGE
DROP CALCULATION METHODS
REV
0
OF 8
20A Supply
5.00%
Voltage Drop
4.00%
4mm
3.00%
10mm
2.00%
16mm
1.00%
0.00%
0m
20
40
60
80
Se rvice ConductorDistanc e
BDMD
ADMD
(A)
kVA)
(kVA)
2,5
0,6
0,2
20
4,6
1,5
60
13,8
4,6
With BDMD = ADMD DCF(1) and DCF(1) = 3 using the AMEU curve.