Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Market Structure and Pricing: Classification of Markets, Competitions and its features; Price
Output determination in Perfect Competition, Monopoly, Monopolistic Competition and
Oligopoly. Pricing Methods and Strategies. Profit Management: Nature, Scope, and Theories of
Profit including Modern Theory Measurement Policies, Cost volume Profit Analysis.
Introduction:
The number of firms and the level of product differentiation are useful parameters for
classifying various market structures. The level of competition also gets influenced by product
and production related factors, potential competitors, number of buyers and their behavior and
the governmental policies. We are now ready to analyze the various market forms in greater
detail. That will be attempted in the subsequent units in this block.
Usually, Market means a place where buyer and seller meets together in order to carry on
transactions of goods and services.
But in Economics, it may be a place, perhaps may not be. In Economics, market can exist even
without direct contact of buyer and seller. This fact can be explained with the help of the
following statement.
"Market refers to arrangement, whereby buyers and sellers come in contact with each other
directly or indirectly, to buy or sell goods."
Thus, above statement indicates that face to face contact of buyer and seller is not necessary
for market. E.g. in stock or share market, buyer and seller can carry on their transactions
through internet. So internet, here forms an arrangement and such arrangement also is
included in the market.
Market structure
In economics, market structure is the number of firms producing identical products which are
homogeneous. The types of market structures include the following:
Monopolistic competition, also called competitive market, where there is a large number of
firms, each having a small proportion of the market share and slightly differentiated products.
Oligopoly, in which a market is run by a small number of firms that together control the majority
of the market share.
Duopoly, a special case of an oligopoly with two firms.
Monophony, when there is only one buyer in a market.
Oligopoly, a market where many sellers can be present but meet only a few buyers.
Monopoly, where there is only one provider of a product or service.
Natural monopoly, a monopoly in which economies of scale cause efficiency to increase
continuously with the size of the firm. A firm is a natural monopoly if it is able to serve the entire
market demand at a lower cost than any combination of two or more smaller, more specialized
firms.
Perfect competition, a theoretical market structure that features no barriers to entry, an
unlimited number of producers and consumers, and a perfectly elastic demand curve.
The imperfectly competitive structure is quite identical to the realistic market conditions where
some monopolistic competitors, monopolists, oligopolists, and duopolists exist and dominate
the market conditions. The elements of Market Structure include the number and size
distribution of firms, entry conditions, and the extent of differentiation.
These somewhat abstract concerns tend to determine some but not all details of a specific
concrete market system where buyers and sellers actually meet and commit to trade.
Competition is useful because it reveals actual customer demand and induces the seller
(operator) to provide service quality levels and price levels that buyers (customers) want,
typically subject to the sellers financial need to cover its costs. In other words, competition can
align the sellers interests with the buyers interests and can cause the seller to reveal his true
costs and other private information.
In the absence of perfect competition, three basic approaches can be adopted to deal with
problems related to the control of market power and an asymmetry between the government
and the operator with respect to objectives and information: (a) subjecting the operator to
competitive pressures, (b) gathering information on the operator and the market, and (c)
applying incentive regulation.
Seller Number
Buyer
Number
Perfect Competition
No
Many
No
Many
Monopolistic
competition
No
Many
No
Many
Oligopoly
Yes
Few
No
Many
Oligopsony
No
Many
Yes
Few
Monopoly
Yes
One
No
Many
Monopsony
No
Many
Yes
One
The two products are therefore not close substitute and the firm that sell this oil are said not to
be in competition. There are very high levels of barrier to entry under the monopoly type of
market. The two types of firm A and B will do anything to keep other firms from entering in the
ladies oil supply market.
The other example of market structure as defined by its characteristics is the perfect
competition. The firms that operate in this market are very many and will sell closely related
products. The consumers will be able to differentiate the different products and their supplier
hence it is hard to overcharge consumers. An example is two shops that sell fast food in any
town. Their number in any big city is large enough to fit the characteristics of a perfect
competitive market. If we assume the fast food shops sell beverages like tea and coffee then
the products will be the same or homogenous in all the fast food shops. Therefore when one
fast food shop increases its tea or coffee prices it will lose its customers to the other fast food
shop. The fast food shops will therefore increase their profit by increasing their sales. If the fast
food shops want to increase its sales it will have to lower the prices of that commodity in the
market.
Classification or Types of Market - Chart
The classification or types of market are depicted below.
Pricing Introduction
Pricing is an important, if not the most important function of all enterprises. Since every
enterprise is engaged in the production of some goods or/and service. Incurring some
expenditure, it must set a price for the same to sell it in the market. It is only in extreme cases
that the firm has no say in pricing its product; because there is severe or rather perfect
competition in the market of the good happens to be of such public significance that its price is
decided by the government. In an overwhelmingly large number of cases, the individual
producer plays the role in pricing its product.
It is said that if a firm were good in setting its product price it would certainly flourish in the
market. This is because the price is such a parameter that it exerts a direct influence on the
products demand as well as on its supply, leading to firms turnover (sales) and profit. Every
manager endeavors to find the price, which would best meet with his firms objective. If the
price is set too high the seller may not find enough customers to buy his product. On the other
hand, if the price is set too low the seller may not be able to recover his costs. There is a need
for the right price further, since demand and supply conditions are variable over time what is a
right price today may not be so tomorrow hence, pricing decision must be reviewed and
reformulated from time to time.
Price
Price denotes the exchange value of a unit of good expressed in terms of money. Thus the
current price of a maruti car around Rs. 2,00,000, the price of a hair cut is Rs. 25 the price of a
economics book is Rs. 150 and so on. Nevertheless, if one gives a little, if one gives a little
thought to this subject, one would realize that there is nothing like a unique price for any good.
Instead, there are multiple prices.
Price concepts
Price of a well-defined product varies over the types of the buyers, place it is received, credit
sale or cash sale, time taken between final production and sale, etc.
It should be obvious to the readers, that the price difference on account of the above four
factors are more significant. The multiple prices is more serious in the case of items like cars
refrigerators, coal, furniture and bricks and is of little significance for items like shaving blade,
soaps, tooth pastes, creams and stationeries. Differences in various prices of any good are due
to differences in transport cost, storage cost accessories, interest cost, intermediaries profits
etc. Once can still conceive of a basic price, which would be exclusive of all these items of cost
and then rationalize other prices by adding the cost of special items attached to the particular
transaction, in what follows we shall explain the determination of this basis price alone and thus
resolve the problem of multiple prices.
whole and the individual firms has to accept the prices set by the industry and try to adjust its
output to the ruling market prices so that the average revenue is equal to the marginal revenue.
In the perfect competitive market a firms marginal revenue is equal to the prices. Since the
prices does not change irrespective of the output solved by the firm. When the prices of a
commodity equal to the marginal revenue the demand curve and the marginal revenue are the
same. From the characteristics of the firm in a perfect competitive market we see that the
demand curves will be perfectly elastic.
There is free entry and exit for different firms operating in this market. The only
hindrances to entry are firms related constraints like costs and lack of raw materials.
The goods sold in this market are homogenous. Homogenous means that the products
are almost identical and the consumer does not prefer one product to the other.
The perfect competition market has also a very large number of buyers and sellers.
This way there is no individual firm in the market that can influence the prices of goods and
services.
The individual firms are price takers and have to accept the prices set by the laws of
demand and supply.
In a perfectly competition market there is no information asymmetry and Perfect
information is available to the buyers and sellers.
Individual buyer cannot control the price by changing or controlling the demand. Because
individual buyer's individual demand is a very small part of total demand or market demand.
Every buyer has to accept the price decided by market forces of demand and supply. In this
way, all buyers are price takers and not price makers. This also ensures existence of single
price in market.
3. Homogenous Product
In this case, all sellers produce homogeneous i.e. perfectly identical products. All products are
perfectly same in terms of size, shape, taste, color, ingredients, quality, trademarks etc. This
ensures the existence of single price in the market.
4. Zero Advertisement Cost
Since all products are identical in features like quality, taste, design etc., there is no scope for
product differentiation. So advertisement cost is nil.
5. Free Entry and Exit
There are no restrictions on entry and exit of firms. This feature ensures existence of normal
profit in perfect competition. When profit is more, new firms enter the market and this leads to
competition. Entry of new firms competing with each other results into increase in supply and
fall in price. So, this reduces profit from abnormal to normal level.
When profit is low (below normal level), some firms may exit the market. This leads to fall in
supply. So remaining firms raise their prices and their profits go up. So again this ensures
normal level of profit.
6. Perfect Knowledge
On the front of both, buyers and sellers, perfect knowledge regarding market and pricing
conditions is expected. So, no buyer will pay price higher than market price and no seller will
charge lower price than market price.
7. Perfect Mobility of Factors
This feature is essential to keep supply at par with demand. If all factors are easily mobile
(moveable) from one line of production to another, then it becomes easy to adjust supply as per
demand.
Whenever demand is more additional factors should be moved into industry to increase supply
and vice versa. In this way, with the help of stable demand and supply, we can maintain single
price in the Market.
8. No Government Intervention
Since market has been controlled by the forces of demand and supply, there is no government
intervention in the form of taxes, subsidies, licensing policy, control over the supply of raw
materials, etc.
9. No Transport Cost
It is assumed that buyers and sellers are close to market, so there is no transport cost. This
ensures existence of single price in market.
Imperfect competition
An imperfect competitive market is a type of market where the conditions of the perfect
competitive markets are not satisfied. Perfect competitive makes indicate that no one firm in the
market can influence market prices, there are no barriers to entry and there is free exit from this
market, suppliers offer homogenous goods and there exist information asymmetry that
encourages price and costs asymmetry. The imperfect market will have characteristics that are
opposite of the perfect competition market. The types of imperfect competition are
the monopoly (single seller), monopolistic competition (many sellers manufacturing highly
differentiated goods), oligopoly (few sellers), duopoly, monopsony (single buyer) and
oligopsony (few buyers).Imperfect might also be caused by other characteristics other than the
firms behavior. An example is imperfect competition due to different time lag in the market.
Under these types of market structure there are many buyers and sellers hence no
individual buyer or seller can influence the market to his/her own favor.
The products sold in this market are highly differentiable and consumers will choose to
buy any product according to their taste and preference, brand loyalty, level of
advertisement and the purchasing power of consumers.
There is a relatively small freedom for firms entry and exit from this market.
A firm has the capability of forming a tiny monopoly because of product differentiation in
the market. This will happen if the firms have created brands for their products, or have
superior advertising policy.
Some firms will have a significant level of influence on the prices they charge for their
goods and services.
The level of oligopoly is a measured quantity .the concentration ratio will be used to calculate
the market share accounted for by each firm operating in the industry. A special type of the
oligopoly market structure is the duopoly. In this type of market there are only two large firma
that dominate the market. There will be the price lead between the two market who will dictates
the market prices will the other firm will be reduced to a price follower. The two firms will also
create restriction for firm that want to join the market hence creating a free market for
themselves to earn abnormal profits.
Large number of buyers and sellers: It is assumed that in pure competition market there
should be a large number of buyers and sellers. If it is so, the output of any single firm is only a
small proportion of the total output and each consumer buys small part of the total. Hence no
individual purchaser can influence the market price by varying his own demand and no single
firm is in the position to affect the market price by varying its own output.
Homogenous product: The commodity produced by all firms should be identical in pure
competition. Thus the commodity produced by different firms are perfect substitutes. Hence the
buyers are indifferent as to the firm from which they purchase.
Perfect competition is wider term than pure competition. Besides the two conditions of pure
competition mentioned above several other conditions must be fulfilled to make it a perfect
competition.
Free entry and exit: There should be no restrictions legal or other on the firms to entry and
exit the industry. In this situation all the firms can earn only normal profit. Because if the profit is
more than the normal, new firms will enter and extra profit will be reduced and if the profit is
less than normal, some firms will leave the industry raising the profits for the remaining firms.
Hence the firms can earn normal profit in long run.
Perfect knowledge: Another assumption of perfect competition is that the purchasers and
sellers should have perfect knowledge about costs, price and quality. Due to this fact neither
the seller can charge more than the ruling price nor the purchaser are willing to pay more.
Free mobility of the resources: The mobility of resources is essential to the firms in order to
adjust their supply to demand. If the demand exceeds supply additional factors of production
move into the industry and vice versa.
Normal Price
1. It is a long period price.
2. Supply curve is horizontal.
3. It is influenced more by supply factors and the cost of production.
4. Only reproducible goods alone have a normal price.
5. Normal price is equal to the cost of production.
6. A firm with a normal price can earn only normal profits.
7. There will be a permanent equilibrium between demand and supply.
8. Normal price is relatively stable.
Very short period: It is the period in which the supply is more or less fixed because the time
available to the firm to adjust the supply of the commodity to its changed demand is extremely
short; say a single day or a few days. The price determined in this period is known as Market
Price.
Short Period: In this period, the time available to firms to adjust the supply of the commodity to
its changed demand is, of course, greater than that in the market period. In this period altering
the variable factors like raw materials, labor, etc can change supply. During this period new
firms cannot enter into the industry.
Long period: In this period, a sufficiently long time is available to the firms to adjust the supply
of the commodity fully to the changed demand. In this period not only variable factors of
production but also fixed factors of production can be changed. In this period new firms can
also enter the industry. The price determined in this period is known as long run normal price.
Secular Period: In this period, a very long time is available to adjust the supply fully to change
in demand. This is very long period consisting of a number of decades. As the period is very
long it is difficult to lay down principles determining the price.
In this figure quantity is represented along X-axis and price is represented along Y-axis. MS is
the very short period supply curve of perishable goods. DD is demand curve. It intersects
supply curve at E. The price is OP. The quantity exchanged is OM. D1 D1 represents increased
demand. This curve cuts the supply curve at E1. Even at the new equilibrium, supply is OM
only. But price increases to OP1. So, when demand increases, the price will increase but not
the supply. If demand decreases new demand curve will be D2 D2. This curve cuts the supply
curve at E2. Even at this new equilibrium, the supply is OM only. But price falls to OP2. Hence
in very short period, given the supply, it is the change in demand that influences price. The
price determined in a very short period is called Market Price.
Non-perishable goods: In the very short period, the supply of non-perishable goods like cloth,
pen, watches etc. cannot be increased. But if price falls, preserving some stock can decrease
their supply. If price falls too much, the whole stock will be held back from the market and
carried over to the next market period. The price below, which the seller will refuse to sell, is
called Reserve Price.
The Price determination of non-perishable goods in very short period may be shown with the
help of the following fig 6.6.
In the given figure quantity is shown on X-axis and the price on Y-axis. SES is the supply curve.
It slopes upward up to the point E. From E it becomes a vertical straight line. This is because
the quantity existing with sellers is OM, the maximum amount they have is thus OM. Till OM
quantity (i.e., point E) the supply curve sloped upward. At the point S, nothing is offered for
sale.
It means that the seller with hold the entire stock if the price is OS. OS is thus the reserve price.
As the price rises, supply increases up to point E. At OP price (Point E), the entire stock is
offered for sale.
Suppose demand increases, the DD curve shift upward. It becomes D1D1 price raises to OP1.
If demand decreases, the demand curve becomes D2D2. It intersects the supply curve at E3.
The price will fall to OP3. We find that at OS price, supply is zero. It is the reserve price.
In the given diagram MPS is the market period supply curve. DD is the initial demand curve. It
intersects MPS curve at E. The price is OP and output OM. Suppose demand increases, the
demand curve shifts upwards and becomes D1D1. In the very short period, supply remains
fixed on OM. The new demand curve D1D1 intersects MPS at E1. The price will rise to OP1.
This is what happen in the very short-period.
As the price rises from OP to OP1, firms expand output. As firms can vary some factors but not
all, the law of variable proportions operates. This results in new short-run supply curve SPS. It
interests D1 D1 curve at E4. The price will fall from OP1 to OP4.
It the demand decreases, DD curve shifts downward and becomes D2D2. It interests MPS
curve at E2. The price will fall to OP2. This is what happens in market period. In the short
period, the supply curve is SPS. D2D2 curve interests SPS curve at E3. The short period price
is higher than the market period price.
In the diagram, MPS represents market period supply curve. DD is demand curve. DD
cuts LPS, SPS and MPS at point E. At point E the supply is OM and the price is OP. If
demand increases from DD to D1D1 market price increases to OP1. In the short period it
is OP2. In the long period supply increases considerably to OM3. So price has fallen to
OP3, which is less than the price of market period.
2. Determination of Long Period Normal Price in Constant Cost Industry:
In this case average cost does not change even though the output
increases. Hence long period supply curve is horizontal to X-axis. The determination of
long period normal price can be explained with the help of the diagram. In the fig. 6.9,
LPS is horizontal to X-axis. MPS represents market period supply curve, and SPS
represents short period supply curve. At point E the output is OM and price is OP. If
demand increases from DD to D1D1 market price increases to OP1. In the short period,
supply increases and hence the price will be OP2. In the long run supply is adjusted fully
to meet increased demand. The price remains constant at OP because costs are
constant at OP and market is perfect market.
Monopoly
This is a type of market structure where there is one seller that dictates the market. The monopoly
will influence the prices it charges for its output. This way the firms demand curve is equal to the
industry demand curve. Monopoly market structure can be categorized using the level of market
share that the firm has in the market. Under pure monopoly the firm has a hundred percent market
share in that industry. In an actual monopoly the firm will have market share that exceeds twenty
five percent. Natural monopoly will exist when there are high fixed costs in producing goods in that
industry. Examples of natural monopoly will exist in the oil industry, electricity generation and
transmission, telecommunication and rail.
There are high barriers to entry. The barriers can be natural such as those ones caused by
the economies of scale or can be imposed by the firms in the market to prevent more firms
joining this market.
The firms in this market are both the price setters and the price taker. The firm therefore
has control over the prices of output and the quantities of output to be supplied.
Firms in this market structure have abnormal profits both in the long run and in the short
run.
Price discrimination is possible under this type of market structure. Price discrimination is
the act of charging different prices for one commodity in different market segment.
Consumers has limited choice on the types of goods to buy and how much to pay for this
goods. This is because the monopoly is the sole distributor and producer.
The prices if commodity in this market is in the excesses of the marginal costs.
Disadvantages of monopoly
The consumers are highly exploited by the monopoly charging high prices for their goods.
The consumers have limited choices due to the limited choices given by the monopoly.
If not properly managed the monopoly might lead to inefficiency. The inefficiency can be in
the use of inputs or lack of control on the costs of production.
Price determination under the monopoly is determined at the level where the marginal revenue is
equal to the marginal cost. When the marginal revenue is greater than the marginal costs the firm
will tend to produce more and more units resulting into an increase in supply which will bring the
prices down.
Natural Monopoly
This occurs when the economies of large scale production, distribution, marketing etc. kick
in.
It means that one single firm by producing at a very large scale can reduce its long term
cost of production lower than if there were more firms producing the same good.
Thus one single firm can service the whole market place by producing at a lower average
total cost.
Thus it is beneficial for the consumer because they can get the goods at a lower price.
Natural monopolies generally arise where the fixed costs or set up costs or infrastructural
costs are very large compared to the variable cost of producing one extra unit.
The best example is that of the electricity generating projects, which are very expensive to
construct.
The running of the transmission lines over miles of service area is also costly.
Thus they need huge initial investment, but once the expenditure has been done, it is quite
cheap to produce and transmit one extra unit of electricity.
In such a case, one single financially large company would be able to service the public
better than with competitors producing duplication of goods and services.
Monopoly example
Monopoly market structure has been defined as the ability of a single firm to influence a market
through its action. The demand curve for the firm that enjoys a market monopoly will slope
downwards from right to left. This is so because when the firm charges higher prices for it
commodity less will be demanded and when the monopoly charges low prices for its commodity
more will be demanded. If we assume that a monopoly is charging $ 150 for its product and was
selling 20 units of its output. Then if the firm wants to increase its total sales it must reduce its
prices. Monopolies are created by various reasons in the market. There are positive types of
monopoly and negative type of monopoly. Positive monopoly is caused by economies of scale,
firms efficiency and branding. Examples in the real world of positive monopoly are company that
has been able to outdo the others through branding and therefore ending up as the sole
producers in the market.
If there were three firms in a market namely firm A, firm B and firm C , all producing beverages and
each firm has different type of management policy. If firm A is more efficient in its management and
ends up creating a brand that takes up to 95% of the whole market and the others take only the
remaining five percent then there is a possibility that firm A will drive the other firms out of the
market hence forming a monopoly. The other positive type of monopoly exists when the
government wants to protect consumers from exploitation or for the provision of essentials goods
to its citizen. If the governments want to protect its citizens or maintain a certain living standards for
its citizens it will take the initiative of providing that service. The reason for this is that the
government do not have profits motive and will provide the goods even to the most non profitable
geographical region. The services are electricity, water, and transport services. If we assume that
the government gave firms the freedom to provide railway services to its citizens then transport by
means of railway services will be provided to the profitable market leaving out the poor without any
mode of transportation.
This way the monopoly in railway transport is beneficial to the citizen hence defined by economist
as positive monopoly. Another example of government monopoly is in the provision of state
security. The government cannot leave this sensitive sector to the hand of private companies who
are out to make profit. The private Companies will provide security to the rich and will not act to
provide just services to all. If it is the business of the security organs to manufacture weapons then
the nature of this activity cannot be left to competing firm. If competing firms rather than a
monopoly firm were given this tender they would aim at increasing sales without considering the
destination of these weapons.
The second type of monopoly is the negative monopoly. This is where one firm has superior and
unfair advantage over the other firms in the market. The unfair advantage or superiority can be
caused by cartels, control of natural resources by some company, and when the economy operates
under the capitalism structure.
Types of Monopoly
Monopoly may be classified into various types. The different types of monopolies are explained
below:
1. Legal Monopoly: If monopoly arises on account of legal support or as a matter of legal
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
privilege, it is called Legal Monopoly. Ex. Patent rights, special brands, trade means,
copyright etc.
Voluntary Monopoly: To get the advantages of monopoly some private firms come
together voluntarily to control the supply of a commodity. These are called voluntary
monopolies. Generally, these monopolies arise with industrial combinations. These
voluntary monopolies are of three kinds (a) cartel (b) trust (c) holding company. It may be
called artificial monopoly.
Government Monopoly: Sometimes the government will take the responsibility of
supplying a commodity and avoid private interference. Ex. Water, electricity. These
monopolies, created to satisfy social wants, are formed on social considerations. These are
also called Social Monopolies.
Private Monopoly: If the total supply of a good is produced by a single private person or
firm, it is called private monopoly. Hindustan Lever Ltd. Is having the monopoly power to
produce Lux Soap.
Limited Monopoly: if the monopolist is having limited power in fixing the price of his
product, it is called as Limited Monopoly. It may be due to the fear of distant substitutes or
government intervention or the entry of rivals firms.
Unlimited Monopoly: If the monopolist is having unlimited power in fixing the price of his
good or service, it is called unlimited monopoly. Ex. A doctor in a village.
Single Price Monopoly: When the monopolist charges same price for all units of his
product, it is called single price monopoly. Ex. Tata Company charges the same price to all
the Tata Indiaca Cars of the same model.
Discriminating Monopoly: When a Monopolist charges different prices to different
consumers for the same product, it is called discriminating monopoly. A doctor may take
Rs.20 from a rich man and only Rs.2 from a poor man for the same treatment.
Natural Monopoly: Sometimes monopoly may arise due to scarcity of natural resources.
Nature provides raw materials only in some places. The owner of the place will become
monopolist. For Ex. Diamond mine in South Africa.
Monopolistic competition
Perfect competition and pure monopoly are rate phenomena in the real world. Instead, almost
every market seems to exhibit characteristics of both perfect competition and monopoly. Hence in
the real world it is the state of imperfect competition lying between these two extreme limits that
work. Edward. H. Chamberlain developed the theory of monopolistic competition, which presents a
more realistic picture of the actual market structure and the nature of competition.
If the demand and cost conditions are less favorable the monopolistically competitive firm may
incur loss in the short-run fig 6.16 Illustrates this. A firm incurs loss when the price is less than the
average cost of production. MQ is the average cost and OS (i.e. MR) is the price per unit at
equilibrium output OM. QR is the loss per unit. The total loss at an output OM is OR X OM. The
rectangle PQRS represents the total loses in the short run.
Oligopoly
The term oligopoly is derived from two Greek words, oligos meaning a few, and pollen meaning to
sell. Oligopoly is the form of imperfect competition where there are a few firms in the market,
producing either a homogeneous product or producing products, which are close but not perfect
substitute of each other.
Characteristics of Oligopoly
The main features of oligopoly are:
1. Few Firms: There are only a few firms in the industry. Each firm contributes a sizeable
share of the total market. Any decision taken by one firm influence the actions of other firms
in the industry. The various firms in the industry compete with each other.
2. Interdependence: As there are only very few firms, any steps taken by one firm to increase
sales, by reducing price or by changing product design or by increasing advertisement
expenditure will naturally affect the sales of other firms in the industry. An immediate
retaliatory action can be anticipated from the other firms in the industry every time when
one firm takes such a decision. He has to take this into account when he takes decisions.
So the decisions of all the firms in the industry are interdependent.
3. Indeterminate Demand Curve: The interdependence of the firms makes their demand
curve indeterminate. When one firm reduces price other firms also will make a cut in their
prices. So he firm cannot be certain about the demand for its product. Thus the demand
curve facing an oligopolistic firm loses its definiteness and thus is indeterminate as it
constantly changes due to the reactions of the rival firms.
4. Advertising and selling costs: Advertising plays a greater role in the oligopoly market
when compared to other market systems. According to Prof. William J. Baumol it is only
oligopoly that advertising comes fully into its own. A huge expenditure on advertising and
sales promotion techniques is needed both to retain the present market share and to
increase it. So Baumol concludes under oligopoly, advertising can become a life-and-death
matter where a firm which fails to keep up with the advertising budget of its competitors
may find its customers drifting off to rival products.
5. Price Rigidity: In the oligopoly market price remain rigid. If one firm reduced price it is with
the intention of attracting the customers of other firms in the industry. In order to retain their
consumers they will also reduce price. Thus the pricing decision of one firm results in a loss
to all the firms in the industry. If one firm increases price. Other firms will remain silent there
by allowing that firm to lost its customers. Hence, no firm will be ready to change the
prevailing price. It causes price rigidity in the oligopoly market.
Examples:
Breakfast cereals
Cigarettes
Home electronics as washer, dryer etc.
Glass products
Chocolate
Bulbs / batteries
Duopoly
Duopoly refers to a market situation in which there are only two sellers. As there are only two
sellers any decision taken by one seller will have reaction from the other Eg. Coca-Cola and Pepsi.
Usually these two sellers may agree to co-operate each other and share the market equally
between them, So that they can avoid harmful competition.
The duopoly price, in the long run, may be a monopoly price or competitive price, or it may settle at
any level between the monopoly price and competitive price. In the short period, duopoly price may
even fall below the level competitive price with the both the firms earning less than even the normal
price.
Monopsony
Mrs. Joan Robinson was the first writer to use the term monopsony to refer to market, which there
is a single buyer. Monoposony is a single buyer or a purchasing agency, which buys the show, or
nearly whole of a commodity or service produced. It may be created when all consumers of a
commodity are organized together and/or when only one consumer requires that commodity which
no one else requires.
Bilateral Monopoly
A bilateral monopoly is a market situation in which a single seller (Monopoly) faces a single buyer
(Monoposony). It is a market of monopoly-monoposy.
Oligopsony
Oligopsony is a market situation in which there will be a few buyers and many sellers. As the
sellers are more and buyers are few, the price of product will be comparatively low but not as low
as under monopoly.
PRICING METHODS
The micro economic principle of profit maximization suggests pricing by the marginal analysis.
That is by equating MR to MC. However the pricing methods followed by the firms in practice
around the world rarely follow this procedure. This is for two reasons; uncertainty with regard to
demand and cost function and the deviation from the objective of short run profit maximization.
It was seen that there is no unique theory of firm behavior. While profit certainly on important
variable for which every firm cares. Maximization of short run profit is not a popular objective of a
firm today. At the most firms seek maximum profit in the long run. If so the problem is dynamic and
its solution requires accurate knowledge of demand and cost conditions over time. Which is
impossible to come by?
In view of these problems economic prices are a rare phenomenon. Instead, firms set prices for
their products through several alternative means. The important pricing methods followed in
practice are shown in the chart.
imply establishment of prices in accordance with consumer preference and perceptions and the
intensity of demand.
Two general types demand oriented pricing rules can be identified.
i.
ii.
Perceived value pricing considers the buyers perception of the value of the product as the basis of
pricing. Here the pricing rule is that the firm must develop procedures for measuring the relative
value of the product as perceived by consumers. Differential pricing is nothing but price
discrimination. In involves selling a product or service for different prices in different market
segments. Price differentiation depends on geographical location of the consumers, type of
consumer, purchasing quantity, season, time of the service etc. E.g. Telephone charges, APSRTC
charges.
Strategy based pricing (new product pricing)
A firm which products a new product, if it is also new to industry, can earn very good profits it if
handles marketing carefully, because of the uniqueness of the product. The price fixed for the new
product must keep the competitors away. Earn good profits for the firm over the life of the product
and must help to get the product accepted. The company can select either skimming pricing or
penetration pricing.
There are other pricing methods which may be used by operators depending on their
individual operation and some may use a mixture of a number of methods.
Forward Pricing
The marketer will calculate the total cost of the ingredients and then add additional money as the
Gross Profit. This is often expressed as a percentage (and referred to as the Gross Margin) and
similar groups of products (e.g. all starters) will often have a similar percentage of profit applied to
them in order to ensure that an overall gross profit target is achievable.
Backward Pricing
Backward pricing is used when the marketer has an idea of what the market will pay and has an
idea of the amount of Gross Profit required. This allows them to perform a calculation which will
give a value for the amount of money which can be spent on ingredients. This is often used when
pricing products on a competitive basis. Eg. Sunday lunches are offered at many establishments
at a variety of prices. The astute operator will use backward pricing to ensure his competitive
selling price will deliver the expected gross profit by setting a maximum amount of money which
can be spent on all the ingredients used in the production of the meal.
Promotional Pricing.
Pricing to promote a product is a very common application. There are many examples of
promotional pricing including approaches such as BOGOF (Buy One Get One Free).
Value Pricing.
This approach is used where external factors such as recession or increased competition force
companies to provide 'value' products and services to retain sales e.g. value meals at McDonalds.
Product design
Bankruptcy work outs
Cost reduction analysis
Lawsuit defense
Pharmaceuticals engineering
Value based pricing is also more applicable to situations where customer approval is made at the
executive level, rather than by the procurement department. The purchasing staff is more skilled in
evaluating supplier prices, and so would be less likely to allow such pricing.
Increases profits. This method results in the highest possible price that you can charge,
and so maximizes profits.
Customer loyalty. Despite the high prices charged, you can achieve extremely high
customer loyalty for repeat business and referrals, but only if the service or product provided
justifies the high price. This advantage tends to also derive from the nature of the sales
relationship, which needs to be both close and trusting before value based pricing can even be
contemplated.
Niche market. The very high prices to be expected under this method will only be
acceptable to a small number of customers. It may even alienate some prospective customers.
Not scalable. This method tends to work best for smaller organizations that are highly
specialized. It is difficult to apply it in larger businesses where employee skill levels may not be so
high.
Competition. Any company that persistently engages in value based pricing is leaving a
great deal of room for competitors to offer lower prices and take away their market share.
Labor costs. Assuming that a service is being provided, you are likely offering such a highend skill set that the employees needed to provide the service will be quite expensive. There is also
a risk that they may leave to start competing firms.
Definition of Dynamic Pricing
Dynamic pricing is a partially technology-based pricing system under which prices are altered to
different customers, depending upon their willingness to pay.
Several examples of dynamic pricing are:
Airlines. The airline industry alters the price of its seats based on the type of seat, the
number of seats remaining, and the amount of time before the flight departs. Thus, many different
prices may be charged for seats on a single flight.
Hotels. The hotel industry alters its prices depending on the size and configuration of its
rooms, as well as the time of year. Thus, ski resorts increase their room rates over the Christmas
holiday, while Vermont inns increase their prices during the Fall foliage season, and Caribbean
resorts reduce their prices during the hurricane season.
Electricity. Utilities may charge higher prices during peak usage periods.
Some industries, such as airlines, use heavily computerized systems to alter prices constantly,
while other industries institute pricing changes at longer intervals. Thus, dynamic pricing can be
adopted along a broad continuum, ranging from constant to infrequent pricing changes.
Dynamic pricing works best in the following situations:
When it is used in concert by all of the major players in an industry. Thus, if a single hotel
were to keep its prices low during the peak tourist season, it could likely steal business away from
competitors.
When demand fluctuates considerably in comparison to a relatively fixed amount of supply.
In this situation, sellers reduce prices as demand falls and increase it as demand increases.
Advantages of Dynamic Pricing
The following are advantages of using the dynamic pricing method:
Profit maximization. If a seller constantly updates its prices with dynamic pricing, it will likely
maximize its potential profits.
Customer confusion. If prices change constantly, customers can become confused by the
situation and be attracted to those sellers who do not use dynamic pricing. Thus, it can result in a
loss of market share.
Inventory management. Sudden changes in price can alter the demand for goods, which
makes it difficult to plan for inventory replenishment.
Increased marketing activity. It may require an expanded marketing presence in the
marketplace to communicate pricing changes to customers.
Printed price changes. If used in a retail environment, it requires considerable activity to
update prices on products as soon as the system alters prices.
Competitor monitoring. If the entire industry adopts dynamic pricing, then a company
must invest in competitor price monitoring systems, to see if its prices are similar to those offered
by competitors.
Sales increase. When buyers purchase other items in addition to the loss leader, the seller
can make a larger profit than would have been the case if it had not offered the loss leader.
New stores. Loss leader pricing is an excellent way to attract shoppers to a new location,
since they might otherwise never enter the store, but will do so to take advantage of a particular
pricing deal. Thus, it can be used to build a customer base.
Merchandise elimination. The strategy can be used to clear out older merchandise, so the
seller can restock its warehouse with newer products.
Marketing. Loss leader pricing is an alternative form of marketing, where the seller is
essentially paying customers in the amount of any losses sustained on its loss leader products to
enter the company store.
Disadvantages of Loss Leader Pricing
The following are disadvantages of using the loss leader pricing method:
Risk of loss. A company may incur a substantial loss from this pricing strategy if it does not
closely monitor sales of other items positioned alongside the loss leader; the risk is that customers
may buy only the loss leader, and in large quantities.
Stockpiling. If the loss leader price is unusually good, and it is for a necessary item that a
consumer may use in bulk, it is possible that each buyer will purchase the largest possible quantity
of the item, and then stockpile it for later use. A seller can avoid this issue by limiting purchase
quantities or only offering products that have a limited shelf life and which therefore cannot be
stockpiled.
Pricing perception. Retaining a deep discount for too long can give buyers the impression
that a product should have a lower price at all times, which can reduce its unit sales once
management stops the loss leader promotion and returns the product to its normal price.
Entry barrier. If a company continues with its penetration pricing strategy for some time,
possible new entrants to the market will be deterred by the low prices.
Reduces competition. Financially weaker competitors will be driven from the market, or into
smaller niches within the market.
Market dominance. It is possible to achieve a dominant market position with this strategy,
though the penetration pricing may have to continue for a long time in order to drive away a
sufficient number of competitors to do so.
Branding defense. Competitors may have such strong product or service branding that
customers are not willing to switch to a low-price alternative.
Customer loss. If a company only engages in penetration pricing without also improving its
product quality or customer service, it may find that customers leave as soon as it raises its prices.
Perceived value. If a company reduces prices substantially, it creates a perception among
customers that the product or service is no longer as valuable, which may interfere with any later
actions to increase prices.
Price war. Competitors may respond with even lower prices, so that the company does not
gain any market share.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
the products price relative to perceived alternatives. Perceived alternatives can vary by
buyer segment, by occasion, and other factors.
Difficult Comparison Effect buyers are less sensitive to the price of a known or more
reputable product when they have difficulty comparing it to potential alternatives.
Switching Costs Effect the higher the product-specific investment a buyer must make to
switch suppliers, the less price sensitive that buyer is when choosing between alternatives.
Price-Quality Effect buyers are less sensitive to price the more that higher prices signal
higher quality. Products for which this effect is particularly relevant include: image products,
exclusive products, and products with minimal cues for quality.
Expenditure Effect buyers are more price sensitive when the expense, accounts for a
large percentage of buyers available income or budget.
End-Benefit Effect the effect refers to the relationship a given purchase has to a larger
overall benefit, and is divided into two parts: Derived demand: The more sensitive buyers
are to the price of the end benefit, the more sensitive they will be to the prices of those
products that contribute to that benefit. Price proportion cost: The price proportion cost
refers to the percent of the total cost of the end benefit accounted for by a given
component that helps to produce the end benefit (e.g., think CPU and PCs). The smaller
the given components share of the total cost of the end benefit, the less sensitive buyers
will be to the component's price.
7. Shared-cost Effect the smaller the portion of the purchase price buyers must pay for
PROFIT MANAGEMENT:
Introduction :
A Business firm is an organization designed to make profits and profits are the primary measures
of success
Joel Dean .
Joel Dean highlighted three issues regarding profit.
1. Profit Measurement: economic analysis of accounting data for policy making.
2. Policy Decisions on profit standards and profit goals.
3. Use of profits for control purposes in complex business organizations.
In Economics profit is called Pure Profit, which may be defined as a residual left after all
contractual costs have been met, including the transfer costs of management insurable risks,
depreciation and payment to shareholders, sufficient to maintain investment at its current level
Theories of Profit
There are various theories of profit, given by several economists, which are as follows:
Homogeneous goods.
Factors of production enjoy freedom of mobility but do not move because their marginal
product in very industry is the same.
Increase in population.
Increase in capital.
One Part represents compensation for actual or average loss supplementing the various
classes of risk.
The other part represents a penalty to suffer the consequences of being exposed to risk in
the entrepreneurial activities.
Hawley believed that profits arise from factor ownership as long as ownership involves risk.
According to Hawley, an entrepreneur has to assume risk to earn more and more profit. In case of
absence of risks, an entrepreneur would cease to be an entrepreneur and would not receive any
profit. In this theory, profits arise out of uninsured risks. The amount of reward cannot be
determined, until the uncertainly ends with the sale of entrepreneur products profit in his opinion is
a residue and therefore Hawley theory is also called as Residual theory.
and uncertainly by dividing risk into two categories, calculable and non-calculable risks. They are
explained as below:
Calculable risks are those, the prodigality of occurrence of which van be calculated on the
basis of available data. For example risk, due to fire theft accidents etc. are calculable and such
risks are insurable.
Incalculable risks are those the probability of occurrence of which cannot be calculated. For
Instance there may be a certain elements of cost, which may not be accurately calculable and the
strategies of the competitors may not be precisely assessable. These risk are called includable
risks. The risk element of such incalculable costs is also insurable.
It is in the area of uncertainly which makes decision-making a crucial function for an entrepreneur.
If his decisions prove to be right, the entrepreneur makes profit, Thus according to knight profit
arises from the decisions taken and implemented under the conditions of uncertainly. The profits
may arises as a result of decision related to the state of market such as decision, which increase
the degree of monopoly, decisions regarding holding of stocks that give rise to windfall gains and
the decisions taken to introduce new techniques or innovations.
state of equilibrium, but there is the possibility of existence of profits. Such profits are in the nature
of quasi-rent arising due to some special characteristics of productive services. Furthermore,
where profits arise due to factors such as patents, trusts, etc. they will be in the nature of monopoly
revenue rather than entrepreneurial profits
various theories of profit which have been offered from time to time
Rent theory of profit :This theory is offered by Prof. Walker. He says, that profit is determined just like the rent of land.
The main points of this theory are given below :
1. Profit is like run :He says that as superior grade of land earned more rent then the inferior grade of land, similarly
superior entrepreneur earn more than the inferior.
2. Marginal entrepreneur :Just as the rent is measured from no rent land in the same way profits of the superior businessman
are calculated from the marginal entrepreneur.
3. Profit is not included in cost :Profit is not included in the cost of production, it is something extra just like the theory of Ricardo.
CRITICISM
1. difference in land and entrepreneur :Marshall says that there is much difference between the rent of land and entrepreneur's profit.
2. Objection on superior ability :Profit cannot arise only due to the superior ability but there are so many other factors which are
responsible for profit.
3. Nature of profit ignored :This theory does not throw light on the nature of profit which is more important.
4. Profit is the part of cost :It is also stated that profit is not included in cost , it is not correct.
5. Case of loss :In case of land, there is no chance of loss but in case of entrepreneur loss can also be suffered.
Risk-bearing theory of profit :F.B Hawley. says that profit is the reward of risk taking in business. In a business activity we know
that there is a chance of loss very moment. The greater the risk, the higher must be the profit. If
there would be equal rate of profit in all the business, then nobody would invest the capital in a
risky enterprise.
CRITICISM
1. Demand and supply side ignored :This theory is ignored the demand and supply aspect.
2. Better management :The profit can arise on account of better management instead of risk taking only.
3. Monopoly and by chance profit ignored :This theory does not throw light on the monopoly gains and by chance gains.
4. Superiority of entrepreneur :Superior entrepreneurs are able to reduce the risks, so it is not correct to say that profit raises due
to risk.
Uncertainty theory of profit :This theory is offered by Prof. Knight. He says that profit is the reward for uncertainty bearing and not of
Dynamic theory of profit :This theory is offered by Prof. Clark. He says that profit is reward of entrepreneurs ability that he
uses his creative forces and bringing many changes the makes the business dynamic. Every
entrepreneur wants that the cost of his production should be minimum and profit should be
maximum.
Prof. Schumpeter says that entrepreneur earns profit by using innovations. So profit is the reward
of innovations.
CRITICISM
Prof. Knight criticisms that all profits are not due to the dynamic changes.
This theory also fails to explain that how profit is determined in the market.
Marginal productivity theory :According to "Chapman" The profit tends to equal to the marginal social worth of the employer as
the labourer gets his marginal net product from the employer." The marginal net product is an
amount which the community is able to produce with his help over and above what it could produce
without his help. If the marginal productivity is higher than the profit will high. If the
marginal product is low then profit will also be low.
CRITICISM
It is very difficult to know the marginal net productivity of entrepreneur.
CVP analysis is the analysis of the relationship between cost and volume of activities and the effect
of the relationship on profit. Managers can use the concept of cost-volume-profit analysis to
forecast volume of activity at which the firm will break-even or attain target profits.CVP analysis is
therefore, a useful tool that helps managers, business owners and entrepreneurs to determine the
profit potential of a new firm or the impact on profit due to changes in selling price, cost or level of
activities
of
current business.
Costs-Volume Relationship
Costs show important behavior in relation to the volume of activity such as:
* Total variable costs change in the same proportion and in the same direction as the volume by
output change.
* Per unit variable costs remain fixed.
* Total fixed costs remain unchanged for the same period of time whatever is the level of output
within the relevant range.
* Per unit fixed costs are variable.
CVP Analysis Formula
The basic formula used in CVP Analysis is derived from profit equation:
px = vx + FC + Profit
In the above formula,
p is price per unit;
v is variable cost per unit;
x are total number of units produced and sold; and
FC is total fixed cost
Besides the above formula, CVP analysis also makes use of following concepts:
Contribution Margin (CM)
Contribution Margin (CM) is equal to the difference between total sales (S) and total variable cost
or, in other words, it is the amount by which sales exceed total variable costs (VC). In order to
make profit the contribution margin of a business must exceed its total fixed costs. In short:
CM = S VC
Unit Contribution Margin (Unit CM)
Contribution Margin can also be calculated per unit which is called Unit Contribution Margin. It is
the excess of sales price per unit (p) over variable cost per unit (v). Thus:
Unit CM = p v
Contribution Margin Ratio (CM Ratio)
Contribution Margin Ratio is calculated by dividing contribution margin by total sales or unit CM by
price per unit.
SP(Q) - VC(Q) - FC = P
Notice that both total revenue and total variable cost are dependent on the number of units
produced and sold. The difference between selling price per unit and variable cost per unit is
known as the contribution margin per unit (SP -VC). It is so named because it represents the
portion of each sales dollar available to contribute to fixed costs. Once fixed costs are covered, the
contribution margin contributes to profit.
Using CM to represent the contribution margin per unit, we represent the CVP relationship as
follows:
SP(Q) - VC(Q) - FC = P
(SP - VC)Q - FC = P
CM(Q) = P
CM(Q) - FC = P
CM(Q) = FC+P
Q = (FC + P)/CM
Thus (FC + P)/CM = Q is a short-cut way to calculate the number of units that must be produced
and sold in order to cover the fixed costs and contribute to profit. It is also known as the
contribution margin
3. Fixed cost remains constant in total regardless of the volume produced and sold
throughout the relevant range. Additional capacity cannot be obtained, nor can facilities
be abandoned in the short run. The fixed cost portion of the total cost function is
represented by a straight line where total fixed cost does not increase or decrease with
changes
in
volume
of
units
produced
and
sold.
4. For manufacturing firms, the number of units produced equals the number of units
sold during the period; for merchandising firms, the number of units purchased
equals the number of units sold during the period. As a result of this assumption, there
are no changes in the inventory levels from the beginning to the end of the period.
Therefore the volume number used for cost determination is the same volume number used
for
revenue
determination.
5. If more than one product is sold, the sales mix (the relative proportion of units sold)
remains constant. At all levels of activity, the mix of product sales remains the same; that
is, if twice as much product A is sold as product B at lower volume levels, then twice as
much product A as product B is also sold at higher volume levels. This assumption implies
that the relative contribution margins remain the same.
While these assumptions may seem limiting, they are sufficiently realistic within the relevant range
to provide a useful first approximation of reality.