Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
1990
by The Journal
ofBone
and
Joint
Surgery,
incorporated
JEFFREY
B.
HUSBAND,
M.D.,
the Department
From
F.R.C.S.(C)t,
AND
of Orthopaedic
Surgery,
ABSTRACT:
A lateral approach
was used to release
a post-traumatic
contracture
of the elbow in seven patients,
and the results
were evaluated
an average
of
thirty-eight
months
postoperatively.
Extension
improved from an average flexion contracture
of4S degrees
preoperatively
to one of 12 degrees
postoperatively,
and
the average
point of maximum
flexion increased
from
116 degrees
preoperatively
to 129 degrees
postoperatively.
The average
arc of motion increased
46 degrees.
All patients
began using a continuous-passive-motion
device immediately
after the operation.
There were no
problems
with
wound-healing
or formation
of heterotopic bone.
HILL
HASTINGS,
II,
Indiana
University
Medical
us (H.
and a static
fail
or dynamic
to restore
splint.
adequate
When
motion,
non-operative
operative
measures
release
may
be
indicated.
In the past, flexion contractures
of the elbow have
been released through an anterior approach
with lengthening
of the biceps tendon,
release of the brachialis
muscle,
and
anterior capsulotomy38#{176}. To correct the less common
cxtension contracture
of the elbow, a posterior
approach
has
been used3#{176}.
We found few reports38#{176}on operative
treatment of
contractures
of the elbow,
and these included
relatively
small
numbers
of patients,
mixed
causes
of contracture,
and
1984
and
1988,
Indiana
Center
INDIANA
Indianapolis
the
range
of motion
of the
elbow
a program
of postoperative
therapy.
The
severity
of
the contracture,
the number
of previous
operative
procedures, the age of the patient,
and the presence
or absence
of heterotopic
bone did not affect the selection
of patients
for the operation.
All of the contractures
were the result of trauma to the
elbow. Several patients had had associated
injuries, but none
had an injury to the head or spinal cord or a burn that might
have contributed
to the contracture.
There were six men and one woman,
and the average
age was thirty-two
years (range,
thirteen
to sixty-two
yeas)
(Table I). The mechanism
of injury was a fracture
of the
distal part of the humerus
in three patients,
a fracture-dislocation
in three
patients,
and
a fracture
of the radial
head
in one patient.
The initial
treatment
included
closed
management
alone with traction,
a cast, or a splint in three patients;
reduction
and
percutaneous
pinning
in one
patient;
open reduction
and internal
fixation
in two patients;
and
excision of the radial head in one patient. One patient (Case
2) had
at the
School,
H. , II) because
closed
Materials
Between
INDIANAPOLIS,
was limited.
The operation
was considered
to be indicated
only if
motion of the elbow was so restricted
that the patient thought
that function was seriously
limited, function did not improve
enough
despite
supervised
physical
therapy
that included
dynamic
extension
or flexion splinting
for at least twelve
weeks, there was a flexion contracture
of at least 35 degrees
or limitation
of active additional
flexion to less than 100
degrees,
soft-tissue
coverage
of the operative
site was adequate, and the interval from injury to operation
was a mmimum of five months.
The only contraindication
to the
procedure
was apparent
inability
of the patient to comply
with
Contracture
of the elbow
may result from a variety
of
causes,
including
trauma,
heterotopic
ossification,
a burn,
spasticity,
and postoperative
scarring3470.
Many contractures can be managed
successfully
with physical
therapy
M.D4,
for
sustained
an open
fracture-dislocation
with
incom-
Surgery
and Rehabilitation
of the Hand and Upper
Extremity, operative
release
of a post-traumatic
contracture
of the
elbow was done in seven patients.
All of these patients
had
plete amputation,
and treatment
had included
grafting with
the saphenous
vein to reconstruct
the brachial
artery.
In
another patient (Case 6), treatment
at another institution
had
included
open reduction
and internal
fixation,
prolonged
been
immobilization
initially
treated
elsewhere
a commercial
party
related
have
directly
and were
referred
to one
of
in support
of this study.
of Orthopaedic
Surgery,
Health
Sciences
Street,
Winnipeg,
Manitoba
R3A lR9,
t Section
Sherbrook
Centre,
Canada.
GF
311-
VOL.
72-A,
NO.
9, OCTOBER
1990
in a cast,
and
electrical
stimulation.
In one patient,
preoperative
radiographs
of the elbow
showed
a small amount
of heterotopic
bone that did not
appear to be substantial
enough to cause a contracture.
In
another
patient,
radiographs
showed
traumatic
arthritis
of
the capitellum.
in whom
epicondyle
A retained
fragment
was
seen
in one patient
the radial
head
had been resected,
the medial
was ununited
in another
patient,
and an ununited
1353
1354
J.
B.
HUSBAND
AND
HILL
HASTINGS,
II
TABLE
Preop.
Case
Involved
Domi-
Age
Elbow
nance
Injury
F, 30
Supracondylar
Sex,
Mechanism
of
from Injury
to Operation
(Mos.)
(Yrs.)
of the
2
M,
M,
13
16
M, 24
fract.
Closed
reduct.
percutan.
humerus
Open fract.-dislocat.
of the med. epicondyle,
rupture
of the brachial
artery
ORIF,
Fract.-dislocat.
of the
olecranon
and
med. epicondyle
Closed
Supracondylar
Olecranon
fract.
of the humerus,
fract.
of the med.
epicondyle
5
M,
42
Fracture
head
of the
M, 62
and
Healed
pin
vein
cast,
traction,
; cast,
Malunion
Excision
head;
ORIF
of the radial
cast, 6 wks.
x 2
M,
ORIF
35
open
reduction
Retained
radial
the
Healed
of the
maxiof 35
(average,
1 16 degrees).
The duration
of follow-up
ranged
from twenty-three
to sixty months, with an average of thirtyeight months.
We examined
all patients
in our offices,
all patients
responded
to a written
questionnaire.
and
: cast,
anesthesia
to facilitate
with
Marcaine
(bu-
postoperative
mobi-
lization.
of the humerus,
and ends near
dissection
condylar
the level
is an extension
proximally
along
proximally
of the Kocher
the lateral
proceeds
distally
the subcutaneous
is carried
Lat.
T-condylar
36
Lat.
Lat.
; traumat.
Fragment
coronoid
of the
process
approach2.
supracondylar
ridge
to the
ridge,
with subperiosteal
stripping
of the anterior
aspect
of the capsule.
lateral
supra-
anteriorly,
Distally,
to
the
After
freeing
the triceps
tendon
from
adhesions,
medially,
or laterally
blocks
complete
extension
3).
Next,
to improve
flexion,
tenolysis
of the triceps
is
done,
if it has not been done already,
and posterior
capsulectomy
is performed.
If the elbow
cannot
be flexed to at
least 135 degrees
at this point, a source of anterior
impingement is sought.
The capsule
and any scar tissue are cleared
from the coronoid
fossa of the anterior
aspect
of the humerus.
When an enlarged
coronoid
process
of the ulna abuts
the anterior
aspect
of the humerus,
the pat of the coronoid
process
that is proximal
to the insertion
of the brachialis
tendon
with
is excised.
The lateral
sleeve
the use of drill-holes
stability
a suction
tractors
are placed deep to the extensor
capi
brachioradialis,
and brachialis
to provide
plied.
A temporary
tension.
longus,
of the
is
the surgeon
retracts
the triceps posteriorly
to expose
the
olecranon
fossa. Additional
extension
may be gained if the
olecranon
fossa
is cleared
of all soft tissue.
Part of the
olecranon
is removed
if any enlargement
of its margins
interval
between
the extensor
carpi ulnaris
and the anconeus
is opened
to expose
the elbow joint laterally
(Fig.
1 ). Reradialis
exposure
capsulectomy
elbow
is brought
into maximum
extension.
If cxis still incomplete,
dissection
is carried
out posteto look for soft tissue
or bone that is blocking
full
extension.
(Fig.
Technique
incision
The
posteriorly,
Methods
The
and
fixation.
degrees
to one of 65 degrees
(average,
45 degrees),
and the
point of maximum
flexion
ranged
from 100 to 135 degrees
It begins
Lat.
of the
tension
riorly
block
arthritis
Closed
reduct.
1 wk.
months.
Preoperatively,
the
from a flexion
contracture
hydrochloride)
Lat.
med.
an average
of fourteen
mum
extension
ranged
We use axillary
14
med.
anterior
part of the capsule.
An anterior
done from the lateral side to the medial
(Fig. 2).
pivacaine
Lat.
fragment
of the coronoid
process
was found in a third patient.
The interval from the injury to the operative
release of
the contracture
ranged from seven to thirty-six
months, with
Operative
11
to
fract.
fragment
head
fract.
Fract. -dislocat.
of the
coronoid
process
and internal
of
of
supracondylar
4 wks.
and
Lat.
med.
non-union
epicondyle
radial
of
14
Healed
fract.
of the
med. epicondyle;
small lat. heterotopic
ossification
humerus
7
supracondylar
Traumat.
arthritis
capitellum
sec.
osteonecrosis
wks.
wks.
Locations
Incisions
fract.
graft
reduct.:
ON
Interval
Radiographic
Features
Initial
Treatment*
DATA
of soft tissue
is carefully
repaired
in the humerus,
to restore
lateral
of the elbow
(Fig. 4). The wound
catheter,
and a light compressive
splint
ThE
is applied
JOURNAL
with
OF BONE
is drained
dressing
the
AND
elbow
JOINT
with
is apin cx-
SURGERY
THE
LATERAL
APPROACH
FOR
OPERATIVE
RELEASE
OF POST-TRAUMATIC
CONTRACTURE
OF
THE
1355
ELBOW
I
THE PATIENTS
Sites of
Osseous
Procedures
Active
Extension
to a Flexion
Contracture
of (Degrees):
Other
Procedures
Decompression
median
nerve
Additional
Active
Flexion
to (Degrees):
Preop.
Postop.
40
45
35
of the
Change
Preop.
40
Postop.
Compli-
Duration
cations
Follow-up
(Mos.)
Change
120
140
+ 20
+45
105
120
+ 15
43
10
+25
135
135
39
45
10
+ 35
120
135
+ 15
60
65
10
+55
110
125
+ 15
25
35
30
100
115
50
25
125
135
+ 10
Transient
ulnar-nerve
of
23
paresth.
Olecranon,
capitellum,
head
radial
Olecranon
Olecranon,
process
coronoid
Excision
of the
epicondyle,
decompression
ulnar nerve
Olecranon,
lat.
Excision
condyle
med.
of the
of a fragment
of the radial
head
Coronoid
process
Olecranon
Excision
of a coronoid
+ 5
+ 25
15
41
34
fragment
Postoperative
pital
Therapy
Immediately
after
room,
the
while
the patient
Marcaine
moves
block
to a regular
hos-
the shoulder
adducted
the lateral soft-tissue
minimizes
dis-
therapy
or three
still
comfort,
a physical
therapist
places
the elbow
in a continuous-passive-motion
device
(Richards,
Memphis,
Tennessee). It is essential
that the device
establish
as complete
an
arc of motion
of the elbow
as possible
while the axillary
block remains
in effect.
Passive
motion
with the machine
continues
without
interruption
until the first change
of dressing, the morning
after the operation,
when a lighter dressing
is applied.
Continuous
passive
motion
is used for at least
twelve
hours
a day for the remainder
of the patients
hos-
pitalization
In addition,
are made
two
performed
At six weeks,
through
a lateral
incision.
The
biceps
tendon
was
to increase
extension,
and the coronoid
process
was partially
excised
in two patients,
to increase
flexion.
The capitellum
was debrided
in the patient who had traumatic
arthritis.
An additional,
medial incision was used in two patients:
for decompression
of the ulnar nerve in one and for decompression
of the median
nerve
in another.
Results
The
patient
is discharged
is comfortable
wound
is dry,
that obtained
from
the hospital
when
he or
of analgesics,
approximates
elbow
is placed
in a static
tween
exercises
that obtained
at
used during
the
this was needed
perform
72-A,
active
Orthoplast
extension
splint
NO. 9, OCTOBER
1990
range-of-motion
exercises
follow-up
with
examination,
tional
arc (Fig.
All patients
5).
responded
in writing
to
120 degrees);
had regained
posta func-
to a questionnaire
that
operatively
score,
to 4.9 points
5 points).
The
postoperatively
patients
all patients
motion
of the elbow (average
II). Preoperatively,
no patient
had a functional
arc of motion
(30
operatively,
six of the seven patients
be-
and at night.
When
extension
is less than
operation,
a dynamic
extension
splint
is
day and a static Orthoplast
splint,
at night;
for five patients.
Patients
are instructed
to
and passive
had an improved
arc of active
increase,
46 degrees)
(Table
After discharge,
the patient
performs
active and passive
range-of-motion
exercises
for ten minutes
each hour.
The
VOL.
a week.
lengthened
in only one patient, to improve
the flexion contracture.
The olecranon
was partially excised in five elbows,
asleep.
she
the
times
assessed
was developed
HI). Pain was
2.8 points pre-
(maximum
function
possible
by grading
1356
J.
B.
HUSBAND
AND
HILL
HASTINGS,
TABLE
to 6.8 kilograms
throwing,
doing
usual sports
proved
from
activities.
5. 1 points
operatively
average
score
preoperatively
possible
score,
(maximum
for function
im-
to 10.4 points
12 points).
post-
II
RESULTS:
AVERAGE
AND
TOTAL
II
FLEXION,
ARC
FLEXION
OF MOTION
(IN
Preop.
45
12
+ 33
129
+ 13
motion
71
117
+ 46
fiexion
of
the
of
Change
116
deformity
Further
arc
Postop.
to:
Flexion
Total
DEFORMITY,
DEGREES)
elbow
Complications
There
was
one
complication,
transient
paresthesia
spontaneously.
Even
used
immediately
tolerated
it,
dehiscence
after
and
of
there
the
Postoperatively,
in a patient
who
had
wound,
there
operation,
no
all
problems
delayed
of the
with
healing,
was no formation
or
patients
regard
to
infection.
of heterotopic
bone.
of motion
from 30 degrees
short of full extension
to 120
degrees
of flexion
(90 degrees
of motion)
is considered
essential
for most activities
of daily
We do not believe
that the elbow
if there
is a well
contractures,
with
forceful
manipulation
nipulation
ditional
Discussion
Function
extent,
motion
of the
on a persons
of the elbow.
upper
ability
Loss
extremity
depends,
to position
of motion
seriously
interfere
with daily
activities,
but
metric
analysis
has suggested
that full motion
for most
activities.
Opinions
differ
but,
generally,
1 : A lateral
2: Anterior
incision
retraction
is made
of the
3: The triceps
tendon
is retracted
4: Repair
of the soft-tissue
sleeve
post-traumatic
contractures
posteriorly,
to bone
be
managed
alone.
motion
successfully
with
FIG.
capsulectomy
is performed.
Osteotomy
partic-
measures
and passive
range-ofsplint.
However,
we
FIG.
a posterior
stability.
ad-
non-operative
These
measures
include
active
exercises
and use of a dynamic
3
and
restores
of the elbow,
FIG.
Fig.
Fig.
an arc
to the formation
of hematoma,
heterotopic
ossification.
FIG.
Fig.
Fig.
established
contracture.
Long-standing
mature
scar tissue,
do not respond
to
in the operating
room,
and such ma-
predisposes
scarring,
and
Some
to a large
living6.
should be manipulated
extensor
muscles.
of the
THE JOURNAL
olecranon
may
OF BONE
increase
AND
JOINT
extension.
SURGERY
THE
LATERAL
APPROACH
FOR
OPERATIVE
RELEASE
OF
POST-TRAUMATIC
elbow
in the
English-language
literature.
Five
SCALE
in four
of them.
Wilsons
also
extension
incision
In four
flexion
of the patients,
including
one
ion contracture)
remaining
improved
two
an average
patients,
an
in whom
the contrac-
contracture
Extension
had been
(the flex-
of 37 degrees.
extension
In the
contracture
was
re-
Lateral
lateral
Points
severe
(much
pain);
medication
(constant
pain);
of
marked
activity
disability
dissection
incision.
and release
The flexion
was carried
contracture
out through
improved
of maximum
Pre-op
Post-op
150-
140
140
135135
130
135
135
125
120
120
120
110
ioo
90
80
I-.
70
60
40
C.)
30
50
125
120
115
110
0)
:.
1o
100 150
65
45
40
45
-
36
3
30
20
<
FuH
25
10
10
10
Extension
_0
+5
10
10
C
0
+10
U,
C
0)
a
a,
FIG.
A comparison
VOL.
72-A,
NO.
9, OCTOBER
1990
PATIENTS
0.
I
of
the
preoperative
and
PAIN
extension.
and Niebauer
reported
on six patients in whom
of the elbow had been released
operatively.
ture
RATED
with occasional
some medication
Complete
and
both
Glynn
a contracture
POSTOPERATIVELY
Moderate,
activity;
limitation
increase
AND
Severe
One patient
had a posterior
incision
as anterior
and medial
incisions,
to
PATIENTS
in-
posterior
capsulotomy.
and release,
as well
Ill
THE
Slight,
with continuous
activity;
no medication
frequent
1357
ELBOW
None
Moderately
conwith
THE
of Pain
Description
patients
study
WITH WHICH
PREOPERATIVELY
OF
TABLE
found that when such therapy is used more than six months
after the injury, it does not improve
the range of motion.
An operation
is then the only way to release a contracture.
To our knowledge,
Wilson,
in 1944, was the first to
report an operative
release of post-traumatic
contracture
of
the
CONTRACTURE
postoperative
arcs
of
motion
of
the
elbow.
a short
an av-
flexion,
an
1358
J.
Recently,
patients
B.
HUSBAND
AND
Urbaniak
Ct al. reported
the cases of fifteen
a post-traumatic
flexion
contracture
had
in whom
been released
through
an anterior
approach.
Anterior
capsulotomy
was done without
lengthening
of the biceps tendon. Postoperatively,
the elbows were immobilized
for two
weeks.
Over-all,
the flexion contracture
improved
from 48
degrees
to 19 degrees,
with the least improvement
in four
patients
who had traumatic
arthritis.
The average
arc of
flexion changed
little (a decrease
of 3 degrees),
but five
patients
palsy
lost 20 degrees
developed
of flexion
in three
The
arthritis
or more.
A transient
nerve
patients.
the contracture
of the elbow
degree of traumatic
arthritis
usually
was
manifested
by mild
was
was
en-
HILL
HASTINGS,
II
been
fixed directly
to the humeral
diaphysis.
Release
of post-traumatic
flexion
contractures
an anterior
approach
can increase
extension
markedly.
through
There
of
the
anterior
structures,
which
may
predispose
to
recurrence
of the contracture;
(3) the potential
loss of important flexion; (4) the serious incidence
of postoperative
nerve palsy; and (5) a delay in healing
of the wound,
or
even dehiscence
of the wound, due to excessive
tension of
the skin about the wound caused by the use of immediate
continuous
passive motion.
The lateral approach
and the technique
described
in
this
paper
have
several
advantages
over
the
anterior
ap-
largement
of the posterior
part of the olecranon
and anterior
part of the coronoid
process;
these changes
were readily
apparent
on plain radiographs.
Radiographs
showed
more
severe arthritis
of the capitellum
in one patient and of the
proach.
Anterior
and posterior
exposure
is possible
through
one lateral incision,
through
which a complete
capsulectomy
and brachialis
fasciotomy
can be done. Additional
extension
radial
and by excision
head
in another,
diocapitellar
adversely.
joint
One
did
patient
but
arthritic
involvement
not
appear
to influence
(Case
6) had
mild
of the ra-
the results
arthritic
changes
at the ulnotrochlear
joint, secondary
to a previous
T-type
condylar
fracture of the humerus.
In this patient, the medial
and lateral portions
of the trochlear
facet of the ulna were
found to be fairly well aligned at operation,
although
there
were early degenerative
changes
in the joint. This did not
appear to affect motion adversely
at the time of the most
recent follow-up
examination,
forty-one
months postoperatively. Restoration
of flexion remained
limited because of
loss
of the coronoid
fossa,
where
the humeral
condyles
had
can be gained
coronoid
process
limits
flexion
by
humerus,
bone of the coronoid
process
can
Repair of the lateral soft-tissue
sleeve to bone
bility
of the elbow
and
allows
safe,
early
abutting
the
be excised.
restores
sta-
motion.
The
lo-
References
1.
CARSTAM,
2.
CRENSHAW,
Mosby,
3.
4.
GLYNN,
HOFFER,
Operative
Treatment
of Fractures
of the Head and Neck of the
A. H.: Surgical
Approaches.
In Campbells
Operative
Orthopaedics,
NILS:
1987.
J. J. , and NIEBAUER,
J. J.: Flexion
and Extension
Contracture
of the Elbow.
M. M.; BRODY, GARRY; and FERLIC, Fp.ED: Excision
of Heterotopic
Ossification
18: 667-670,
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Radius.
edited
Acta Orthop.
Scandinavica,
by A. H. Crenshaw.
Ed.
Surgical
about
19: 502-526,
1950.
7, pp. 92-93.
St. Louis,
C. V.
Management.
Clin. Orthop. , 117: 289-291,
1976.
Elbows
in Patients
with Thermal
Injury. J. Trauma,
1978.
1944.
ThE
JOURNAL
OF BONE
AND
JOINT
SURGERY