IJSRD - International Journal for Scientific Research & Development| Vol.

4, Issue 03, 2016 | ISSN (online): 2321-0613

Investigation of Web Perforation in Steel I-Beams
Arpit Jaiswal1 Dr. P.Y. Pawade2 Prof K.R. Dabhekar3
M.tech. Student 2Professor and H.O.D 3Assistant Professor
Department of Civil Engineering
G.H.R.C.E, Nagpur
Abstract— The premise of this study is the serviceability near the area of low shear. Some of the examples of such
prerequisite which excite long after the auxiliary erection beams are cellular or castellated beams which can be used
has been finished. Beams with web openings can be very for long span and low resistance (i.e. load).
effective in such cases. Tallness impediment is regular issue Steel beams with web openings are turning out to
confronted by originators in multistoried structures because be progressively famous as a proficient basic structure. The
of financial necessities and aesthetical contemplations. advanced plan and profiling process manages more
Generous spaces are typically required to empower the entry noteworthy adaptability in beam proportioning for quality
for ducts and pipes underneath steel beams which prompts (i.e. strength), profundity (depth), size and position of web
uneconomic floor statures. Despite the fact that web openings. There have been noteworthy enhancements in the
openings could prompt a noteworthy diminishing in basic outline of business multi-story structures as of late,
members' heap conveying limit contingent upon the taking into account the advancement of long-traverse
embraced openings shape, size and area yet can likewise be composite frameworks. Long traverse beams have the
extremely useful and imperative from the point of economy. benefit of adaptability of inward arranging by minimizing
Regardless of the plentiful test take a shot at steel beams the quantity of segments bringing about investment funds in
with web openings that has been led by scientists the quantity of establishments and in pace and cost of
consistently, the outcomes are not extensive, because of the erection. Long traverse beams are more focused in the
complexity of the beam design and the expansive number of business, principally when they are fabricated for auto
variable parameters. In this way, utilizing industrially stopping structures, bended rooftop shafts or stadium
accessible limited component ANSYS (FE) programming, cantilever rooftop decreased beam. While manufactured
numerical examinations were confirmed by correlation with beams with isolated web openings are chiefly utilized for
previous test program. The sample beam taken for study is long traverse essential beams, whose configuration is more
IS standard I-section of medium range ISMB 400 and controlled by the higher shear strengths following up on
different comparisons are made based on different shape and these beams.
size of openings. The numerical project was then used to Utilizing steel beams with web openings permits
attempt broad parametric studies to disengage a portion of the general depth of each floor to be diminished contrasted
the geometric and material properties that impact the failure with the instance of utilizing basic plain beams where the
modes concerned with these type of basic perforations. The service integrations are upheld underneath the I-sections.
fundamental parameters under thought are the web opening Depth saving could be up to 20 inches per floor. At the end
profundity (typically noted as diameter), the basic opening of the day, for each six stories one more floor is picked up in
length of the top and base tee-areas, spacing between the tallness. The greatest advantage, however, is the economy
web openings and the ultimate comparative advantages over effected by the increased load carrying capacity and
the normal standard I-section beams used in general stiffness of the beam.
practice. This exploration study ought to prompt better
administration of the utilization of steel beams with such II. HISTORY
web openings as the significant contrast between the Since early 20th century nearly the period of the Second
different shapes as illustrated. Finally the experimental World War numerous endeavours have been made by
results and FE analysis findings are conclusive with the structural engineers to discover better approaches to
previous studies and can contribute to further researches. diminish the expense of steel structures. Because of
Key words: Non-Linear Analysis, Steel Structures, Steel confinements on most extreme reasonable diversions (i. e.
Beams with web openings, parametric study, ANSYS, Finite Beams’ self-weight), the high quality properties of structural
element method steel can't generally be used to the best point of interest.
Subsequently, a few new techniques have been gone for
I. INTRODUCTION expanding the firmness of steel individuals with no
Due to increase in use of steel structures in construction expansion in weight of steel required. At that point
industry, demand of steel is increased and the most used castellated beams and perforated beams with roundabout
conventional structural members as beam is the rolled I- web openings have been utilized. It is realized that the
section steel bars. Among all the other types of flexural simplicity of mix of administrations and additionally their
member’s I-section is most commonly used as it is settlement inside the structural profundity of the I-areas is a
economical and efficient, but as the sections depth is of noteworthy advantage of perforated beams. Utilizing steel
concern! After erection of the structure the services needed beams with web openings permits the general depth of each
to be passed beneath the beam section which reduces the floor to be diminished contrasted with the instance of
overall floor depth. Services like pipes or ac ducts which utilizing basic plain beams where the service integrations
may be used in the near future decreases the usable height of are upheld underneath the I-sections. Depth saving could be
the room. So such requirements can be handled by up to 500mm for every floor. At the end of the day, for each
incorporating the openings in the web portion of the beam six stories one more floor is picked up in tallness.

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 167
Investigation of Web Perforation in Steel I-Beams
(IJSRD/Vol. 4/Issue 03/2016/046)

 Budget for fire considerations can be reduced when
using long span beams.
 25% to 30% less beginning expense of
Though the scientists have investigated about these type of
beams long ago but the Finite element researches came in
roll in the last decade only. The FE analysis tools makes it
easier for the researcher to solve the complex problems with
In the wake of looking into the writing research on
Fig. 1: Possible Applications of such Beams
non-composite perforations in beams, it is trusted that
different standard and additionally non-standard web
III. INCORPORATION IN BUILDING STRUCTURES openings should be further examined. What's more, all
Steel beams with web openings are turning out to be geometric parameters characterizing the web opening shapes
progressively famous as a proficient basic structure. The and in addition the beam area sizes are analysed
advanced plan and profiling process manages more independently. The work is done on IS Standard sections for
noteworthy adaptability in beam proportioning for quality direct pragmatic use for designers in India.
(i.e. strength), profundity (depth), size and position of web
openings. There have been noteworthy enhancements in the A. Need of FE Studies
basic outline of business multi-story structures as of late, Trial based testing (i.e. experimental investigations) has
taking into account the advancement of long-traverse been broadly utilized and this is a strategy that produces
composite frameworks. Long traverse beams have the genuine reaction of the structural components. Be that as it
benefit of adaptability of inward arranging by minimizing may, this technique is to a great degree tedious and the
the quantity of segments bringing about investment funds in utilization of materials can be very expensive. As of late, the
the quantity of establishments and in pace and cost of utilization of limited component examination has expanded
erection. Long traverse beams are more focused in the because of advancement learning and capacities of
business, principally when they are fabricated for auto computational programming and equipment. It has now
stopping structures (e. g. an utilization of pre-camber turned into the favoured technique for this researches to
beams), bended rooftop shafts or stadium cantilever rooftop break down structural steel segments with different
decreased beams. A composite beam with perforated steel geometric parameters, while the web opening shapes can be
beam may likewise offer a comparable point of preference extremely confusing. The utilization of computer
by utilizing its web openings. Perforated beams with programming to model these basic structural components is
customary web openings are all the more frequently utilized much quicker and to a great degree financially savvy. To
for long traverse optional beams, whose outline is by and completely comprehend the abilities of limited component
large controlled by serviceability necessities. While computer programming, one must think back to exploratory
manufactured beams with isolated web openings are chiefly information and straightforward investigation. Information
utilized for long traverse essential beams, whose got from a finite element analysis package is not valuable
configuration is more controlled by the higher shear unless the important steps are taken to comprehend what is
strengths following up on these beams. Beams with web occurring inside the model that is made utilizing the
openings are used in high hazard business and mechanical product.
tasks as far as the time, spending plan and quality against Beams with web openings can be focused in
general society and the specific organization. situations where long traverse applications, where the
The most noteworthy advantages utilizing such beams are primary thought in the outline is minute conveying limit of
recorded as takes after: individuals. This sort of development help in accomplishing
 Service incorporations, thus floor-to-floor depth is less floor height with arrangement of administrations inside
diminished. the beams ty, at the most fitting areas. At the point when
 Interior column sections are dispensed with, opening in the web of the shaft is presented, it changes the
prompting more effective utilization of inside anxiety conveyance inside the part furthermore impacts the
space. Consequently, less establishment cost and breakdown conduct. Therefore, the effective outline of
less seismic stacking. pillars and plate support segments with web openings has
 Compositional adaptability to fit neighbourhood gotten to be one of the essential contemplations in present
prerequisites. day structures.
 Less segments are required (ordinarily 30% less Beams with web openings discover its application
beams) prompting decreased development and in extensive variety of development, particularly in long
establishment time. traverse structures as though gave in little traverse
development the expense of generation of such individuals
 Least conveyance of materials to thin inward city
surpasses the economy of the development. Administration
fuses can be censured inside the openings and proficient
 Shield the beams to-segment associations from
development can be accomplished.
high hassles due to the low weight.
Specialists, in earlier studies have expressed that
 Half lighter than pre-focused on solid development. the nearness of web openings may have huge downside on
 Great acoustic protection of composite floors and load conveying limit of basic individuals. In any case, the
infill dividers.

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 168
Investigation of Web Perforation in Steel I-Beams
(IJSRD/Vol. 4/Issue 03/2016/046)

present configuration aides and determinations for such
shafts are either deficient or hard to utilize (SCI P355). This
might be because of the way that the conduct of I-Beams
with web perforations is perplexing to comprehend, dissect
and hard to streamline the outline methodology. Along these
lines, it is basis that more intricate examinations are
completed to give adequate data to comprehend the conduct
so that a straightforward configuration strategy could be

The fundamental codes of practice were considered at all
times all through the study, contingent upon the
procurement's for design configuration. SCI publication P-
355 (2006) refers to codified rules in the Structural Euro
Fig. 2: Loading Condition
codes such as: EN 1993-1-1, EN 1994-1-1: 2004 and in the
British Standards such as: BS 5950 Parts 1 and 3. In
connection to the outline direction, it was demonstrated that
the contrasts between the Euro codes and BS 5950 had little

The philosophy embraced to satisfy the need of the present
study is by utilizing ANSYS programming which gives an
incredible stage to examination of different auxiliary
frameworks. It effectively displayed steel columns and steel
beams with web openings utilizing the geometry modeler.
Present study concentrates on the count of load limit for
non-minimal and thin steel bars with numerous web opening
at different positions along web of beam by utilizing Fig. 3: Meshing of Beam
ANSYS programming. In view of the results obtained from
B. Numerical Model
ANSYS, the outcomes got by rules are analyzed. At that
point the precision of utilizing Darwin rules for this kind of The models of beams of different I-sections have been
beams are checked. modelled in ANSYS software in order to check the strength
and failure types of the beam under different loading
A. Analytical Model conditions. The size and shape of perforations in web are
A diagnostic model proposed by Darwin to foresee the basic varied and beams are checked different loading conditions
conduct of beams with web openings was utilized to serve (i.e. concentrated load and UDL) to check the ultimate
as an extra apparatus to assess and look at the consequences strength with different support conditions. Some of the
of the present examination. In the aforementioned reference, material properties are as shown below. A FE investigation
the creator displays a minute shear cooperation bend to of various ranges was directed in the writing (Chung et. at,
consider the synchronous impacts of twisting and shear. The 2000) and considered in this. The heap conveying limit
synchronous activities of twisting and shear powers happen correlations of perforated segments with beams of different
at different areas over the shaft range. ranges (5, 6, 7.5 and 10m), having different web openings
∅?? 3 ∅?? 3 sizes (do equivalent to D. Sh and 0.75h) was analyzed.
( ) +( ) = ?3 (1)
Distinctive area sizes were additionally analyzed
∅?? ∅??
At a web opening, the two strengths communicate (UB457xl52x52 and UB457x152x82) while comparable
to create lower resistance values than the acquired under results were found.
unadulterated bending or pure shear. The cooperation bend
used to consider twisting ϕMn and shear resistance ϕVn
configuration is given by Equation where Mn is the real
bowing minute present at shaft focus range, Vn is the
genuine shear power present at bar focus range, Mm is the
Table 1: Opening position
twisting minute resistance, Vm is the shear force and R is
the proportion between the considered load to the area plan
limit at an opening. The figured loads in the web opening
were checked utilizing the connection bend given by
Equation (1). In the event that the worth R is equivalent to
or not exactly the solidarity, the outline is palatable. With a Table 2: I-section Geometric Properties
specific end goal to assess straightforwardly the bar extreme
resistance displayed in this paper, all the heap and resistance
elements configuration were considered equivalent to 1.0.

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 169
Investigation of Web Perforation in Steel I-Beams
(IJSRD/Vol. 4/Issue 03/2016/046)

Beam with Spacing of
No. of End
opening Openings
openings spacing(mm)
detail (mm)
CB1 10 1000 500
CB2 8 1200 700
CB3 6 1800 700
Table 3: Material Properties of I-Section HB1 10 1000 500
HB2 8 1200 700
C. Model of ISMB 400 HB3 6 1800 700
The modelling of I-section ISMB 400 with three different SB1 10 1000 500
shapes viz. circular, hexagonal, and square openings is SB2 8 1200 700
modelled. And further change in the number of openings to SB3 6 1800 700
obtain optimum spacing ratio and aspect ratio is reduced Table 5: Beam models
from 5, 4 and 3 number of openings on each side of the total
span are provided. The total span of 10m with additional VI. RESULTS
100mm bearing are provided. The loading is concentrated
mid span load applied in increasing fashion. The deflection The results shows the graph plots for 7 different models of
criteria from codal provision is followed to obtain the steel beams with web openings, the I-section is ISMB 100
readings from load to deflection results obtained from with standard dimensions and number of web openings
ANSYS and tabulated to compare the results. varies from C1 to C-4 which are of circular openings and
The material properties used for the modelling is as shown other properties are constant for size of do =0.8d. Length of
below: beam is kept 1000mm and 100 mm post the supports.
Thickness σy σu Stiffeners are provided at supports and point of load
Specimen E (MPa) application.
(mm) (MPa) (MPa)
Flange 16.0 364 491 2.01x105 Beam C-5 is of reduced opening diameter and
increased span of 2000mm beam with do=0.5d. C-6 and C-7
Web 8.9 330 440 1.99x105
beams are of rectangular shape of opening with different
Table 4: Material properties
cross section but remaining properties are same.
Depth of beam was maintained at 400 mm with
nominal top and bottom flange width of 140 mm and the
corresponding nominal thickness of flange 16 mm and that
of web is 8.9 mm. Transverse stiffeners were made of flat
plates 50 mm wide and 5 mm nominal thickness.

Fig. 6: Load deflection curve for CB1
Fig. 4:

Fig. 5: Fig. 7: Load deflection curve for CB2

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 170
Investigation of Web Perforation in Steel I-Beams
(IJSRD/Vol. 4/Issue 03/2016/046)

Fig. 8: Load deflection curve for CB3
Fig. 11: Load deflection curve for CB7
The results obtained from the finite element models
for von mises stress and shear stress for preliminary models
are shown in figure 5.8 to 5.19 for end supports as pinned
and fixed.

Fig. 8: Load deflection curve for CB4

Fig. 12: Overall Comparison of Circular web openings

A. Concluding Remarks
The reason for this study was to assess the serviceability
prerequisite which excite long after the auxiliary erection
has been finished and quality of steel beam with web
Fig. 9: Load deflection curve for CB5 openings. In light of the consequences of the examination,
the accompanying discoveries and conclusions are made.
Stress and displacement of the circular shape and hexagonal
perforations varies in the same range. But as circular
openings provide more areas so the deflections are more and
in hexagonal or castellated shape stress concentration are
high due to sharp edge points.
 Rectangular shape of openings were observed to be
exceptionally basic as they show high push fixation
around the bend areas. The rectangular openings with
circular fillet around the corner show lesser stress
concentration. It is likewise seen that the disfigurements
of the rectangular openings are vast contrasted with the
other sort of web openings.

Fig. 10: Load deflection curve for CB6

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 171
Investigation of Web Perforation in Steel I-Beams
(IJSRD/Vol. 4/Issue 03/2016/046)

 The rectangular web openings of 0.8d have a high shear Openings”, Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 118,
force contrasted with the other profundity of openings, No. 12, December, 1992. ASCE, ISSN 0733-
for example, 0.65d and 0.50d. 9445/92/0012-3315
 Data with respect to all the failure modes of beams with [12] Wiley and Sons Inc., Toprac A. A. and Cooke B. R.
openings have been acquired and introduced. Broad (1959) An experimental investigation of open-web
presentation of these modes together with the references beams.
at first reported has been made. Besides, the [13] Redwood, R. G. and McCutcheon, J. 0. (1968) Beam
hypothetical foundation used to approach and break tests with unreinforced web openings. Journal of the
down the most essential disappointment modes, has Structural Division, Proceeding of the American
been introduced. Society of Civil Engineers 94, P. (ST 1), pp. 1-17.
 It was concluded that all beam beams circular web [14] Redwood, R. G. and Wong, P. K. (1982) Web holes in
openings, although they have web opening depths of composite beams with steel deck. In Proceedings of the
0.8h, their stiffness was dramatically increased and their Eighth Canadian Structural Engineering Conference,
load carrying capacity was even higher than the beams Can, Steel Const. Council, Willowdale, Ontario,
with circular web perforations with small dia’s Canada.

[1] Bower JE (1968) Design of beam with web openings. J
Struct Div 94(3):783–807.
[2] Darwin D (1990) Steel and composite beams with web
openings. Steel design guide series no. 2. AISC,
[3] S.G. Morkhade, L. M. Gupta (2015) An experimental
and parametric study on steel beams with web
openings. Int J Adv Struct Eng (2015) 7:249–260
[4] Flavio Rodrigues, Pedro C. G. da S. Vellasco, Luciano
R. O. de Lima, Sebastião A. L. de Andrade “Finite
Element Modelling of Steel Beams with Web
Openings” Engineering, 2014, 6, 886-913
[5] Gustavo De Souza Veríssimo, Ricardo Hallal
Fakury,“Design Aids for Unreinforced Web Openings
in Steel and Composite Beams with W-Shapes”
Engineering Journal / Third Quarter / 20
[6] K. S. Sivakumaran, “Some studies on cold-formed steel
sections with web openings”, Ninth International
Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures
St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A., November 8-9, 1988
[7] Konstantinos-Daniel Tsavdaridis, Cedric D’Mello,
“Vierendeel Bending Study of Perforated Steel Beams
with Various Novel Web Opening Shapes, through
Non-linear Finite Element Analyses” Journal of
Structural Engineering, 138 (10). 1214-1230. ISSN
[8] Lawson RM (1987) Design for openings in the webs of
composite beams. CIRIA Special Publication and SCI
Publication 068. CIRIA/Steel Construction Institute,
[9] Pattamad Panedpojaman and Teerawat Rongram
“Design Equations for Vierendeel Bending of Steel
Beams with Circular Web Openings” Proceedings of
the World Congress on Engineering 2014 Vol II, WCE
2014, July 2 - 4, 2014, London, U.K.
[10] Prof. R. R. Jichkar, Prof. N. S. Arukia, Prof. P. D.
Pachpor ,“Analysis of Steel Beam with Web Openings
Subjected To Buckling Load” Int. Journal of
Engineering Research and Applications ISSN : 2248-
9622, Vol. 4, Issue 5( Version 2), May 2014, pp.185-
[11] The ASCE Task Committee on Design Criteria for
Composite Structures in Steel and Concrete, “Proposed
Specification For Structural Steel Beams With Web

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 172

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful