Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
com
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose was to investigate the altered hemispheric asymmetry in patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with unilateral
hippocampus sclerosis (MTLE/HS).
Materials and methods: This study examined the hemispheric asymmetry of regional gray matter (GM) and white matter (WM) volume
among a group of 13 patients with left-sided MTLE/HS, a group of 10 patients with right-sided MTLE/HS and a group of 21 age- and
gender- matched healthy controls by optimized voxel-based morphometry (VBM) based on magnetic resonance imaging.
Results: Compared to healthy controls, abnormal asymmetries were detected in the left-sided MTLE/HS patients. The left-sided MTLE/HS patients
had more GM asymmetries (LbR) in the temporal lobes, including the inferior temporal gyrus, middle temporal gyrus and parahippocampal gyrus.
There was significant asymmetry (LbR) in subcortical WM of the mesial temporal lobe in left-sided MTLE/HS patients. However, no significant
difference was detected in terms of GM and WM asymmetry between the group with right-sided MTLE/HS and normal controls.
Conclusion: We should approach hemispheric asymmetry in left- and right-sided MTLE/HS patients differently. The study also
demonstrates potential future use of VBM in detecting hemispheric asymmetries and lateralization of brain functions.
2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Brain asymmetry; Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); Voxel-based morphometry (VBM); Mesial temporal lobe epilepsy; Hippocampal sclerosis
The seizures are not restricted to the mesial temporal lobe and coronal slices)] by two independent physicians (radiol-
ipsilateral to seizure onset, but involving the other brain areas ogist and epileptologist) revealed unequivocal unilateral HS in
during the seizure spread [11,12]. There have been many 13 patients on the left side and in 10 patients on the right side.
past structural and functional studies demonstrating exten- All of our patients had MRI evidence of unilateral HS
sive involvement of gray matter (GM) and white matter concordant with the EEG lateralization of the epileptogenic
(WM) in MTLE patients. Changes in gray matter volume zone. None of the patients revealed other structural lesions on
(GMV) and white matter volume (WMV) were repeatedly MRI, and none of the patients had undergone any prior
shown to extend to other brain regions surrounding the neurosurgery. The patients were scanned on the same MR
hippocampus (the parahippocampal gyrus and the amygdala) machine with identical protocol. All patients had been seizure
[13] and other more distant structures (several neocortical free for 24 h before the MRI.
regions, the thalamus, the striatal nuclei, the cerebellum and The age of onset and duration of epilepsy of each patient
the brainstem) [11,1417]. were recorded. In the group with left-sided MTLE/HS,
Since the introduction of voxel-based morphometry (VBM), the age of seizure onset ranged from 1 to 28 years (mean:
VBM has been applied to study the brain matter changes of 14.3 years, S.D.=8.7), and the duration of epilepsy ranged
MTLE which shed much light on anatomical changes in the from 3 to 33 years (mean: 13.1 years, S.D.=8.5). In the group
disease [17]. A signicant asymmetrical distribution of with right-sided MTLE/HS, the age of seizure onset ranged
temporal lobe abnormalities preferentially to the ipsilateral from 7 to 39 years (mean: 22.6 years, S.D.=10.3), and the
side of the seizure focus has been observed. There is also a much duration of epilepsy ranged from 3 to 21 years (mean:
more bilateral distribution of extratemporal lobe atrophy. 8.6 years, S.D.=6.1). There were three patients with history
Despite a large number of VBM studies exploring the extensive of febrile seizures in the left-sided MTLE/HS group and the
reduction of GMV and WMV in MTLE, less attention has been right-sided MTLE/HS group, respectively. The 21 healthy
paid to hemispheric structural asymmetry in these patients. controls (11 female, 10 male) have no history of neuro-
Because of the vulnerability to seizure attack and subsequent logical and psychiatric diseases. The controls were scanned
functional reorganization, different patterns of volume reduc- on the same MR scanner with the same protocol as the
tion and hemispheric asymmetry may be present as related to the patients. The demographic and clinical data of the patients
side of seizure onset. and the controls are detailed in Table 1.
In this study, we hypothesized that the refractory MTLE
may alter the structural hemispheric asymmetry differently in 2.2. MRI data acquisition
patients with left-sided MTLE/HS from those with right-
sided MTLE/HS as compared to the normal control. We have High-resolution three-dimensional T1-weighted images
optimized VBM to investigate asymmetrical abnormalities [3D spoiled gradient echo sequence (SPGR), Repetition
of GMV and WMV in MTLE/HS patients. time/ Echo time/ Inversion time, 7/3.3/450 ms; 15 ip angle;
1.01.0-mm 2 in-plane resolution; slice thickness, 1.6 mm;
90100 transverse images] were obtained for all subjects images were normalized to the symmetrical templates.
using a 3.0-T MR system (Signa, General Electric, Milwau- Modulation was then performed to correct for volume
kee, WI, USA) with an eight-channel phase array head coil. changes. In addition, all the preprocessed images were then
afne-transformed from native space to the Montreal
2.3. Data processing Neurological Institute (MNI) space and then smoothed
using a 6-mm full-width at half-maximum isotropic
All T1-weighted images were rst skull-stripped using Gaussian kernel.
the BET tool implemented in MRIcroN. Subsequent data All the preprocessed GM and WM images were leftright
preprocessing was performed using Statistical Parametric ipped, obtaining corresponding mirrored images. Asym-
Mapping (SPM5) software package (http://www.l.ion.ucl. metry index (AI) was dened as:
ac.uk/spm, Wellcome Department of Cognitive Neurology,
London, UK, 2005) running on a Matlab 7.6 platform AIGMV = WMV = 2original imagemirrored image
(MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA). All the image processing = original imagemirrored image:
steps were summarized in Fig. 1.
The skull-stripped images were rst automatically Positive values in the left hemisphere represented LNR
reoriented with the origin set close to the anterior asymmetries, while the ones in the right hemisphere
commissure and then segmented into GM, WM and represented LbR asymmetries.
cerebrospinal uid (CSF) in native space using unied 2.4. Statistical analysis
segmentation [18]. The GM and WM were left-right ipped,
and diffeomorphic anatomical registration through exponen- First, one-sample t test was performed to investigate
tiated lie algebra (DARTEL) algorithm was conducted to asymmetry patterns within each group [Pb.05, multiple
align all the ipped and nonipped images [19]. All these comparisons were corrected by false discovery rate (FDR)].
images from all the subjects were used to create the Then, two-sample t test was used to detect abnormal
symmetrical GM and WM templates, including six iterations asymmetries in the MTLE/HS groups relative to normal
of average and registration. Then, the nonipped aligned controls, respectively. Age, gender and total intracranial
56 J. Lu et al. / Magnetic Resonance Imaging 31 (2013) 5359
volume were further considered as covariates affecting the beyond hippocampus and mesial temporal lobe in recent
brain asymmetries [20,21]. Statistically signicant threshold years. The reported involved brain regions include the
was set at Pb.05, corrected for multiple comparisons by hippocampus and the parahippocampal gyrus [13], several
FDR. We only reported the clusters with no less than neocortical regions [16,22], the thalamus [23], the cerebel-
30 voxels. lum [15] and the brain stem [17].
VBM is a computational quantitative MRI analysis to
assess brain tissue composition on a voxel-by-voxel basis,
3. Results and it has been performed to explore GM and WM
3.1. Basic characteristics of the patients and the asymmetries throughout the entire brain. In the present
normal control study, the preprocessing steps of VBM have been improved
with the DARTEL registration method, which was initially
As shown in Table 1, no signicant differences in age and proposed by Ashburner et al. [19] and was then proved by
gender distribution were observed among the left-sided Yassa et al. [24]. This study aimed to use the optimized
MTLE/HS patient group, the right-sided MTLE/HS patient VBM to detect the abnormal cerebral asymmetries in the
group and the normal control group. No statistically MTLE/HS patients. To our knowledge, this is the rst study
signicant difference in age, gender, duration of disease to use VBM to detect altered hemispheric asymmetry of
and seizure frequency was observed between the left- and MTLE/HS which was relative to the side of seizure onset.
right-sided MTLE/HS groups. In the study, the left- and right-sided MTLE patients were
matched in age, gender, seizure frequency and duration of
3.2. VBM analysis illness. We observed altered LbR asymmetries in the left-
3.2.1. GM and WM asymmetry within each group sided MTLE/HS patients relative to the normal controls,
Analysis of brain asymmetry within each group revealed while no altered hemispheric asymmetry was found in the
an extensive and consistent pattern of GMV and WMV right-sided MTLE/HS patients. For the left-sided MTLE/HS
asymmetries over the MTLE/HS groups and the normal patients, the involved area of GM included the middle
controls, as shown in Fig. 2. The positive signicant regions temporal gyrus, inferior temporal gyrus and parahippocam-
were shown, of which the regions shown in the left pal gyrus, and the involved WM area was located in the
hemisphere were larger than the right hemisphere and vice mesial temporal lobe. A number of possible presumptions
versa. The voxel-based analysis of GM differences between are as follows: First of all, recurrent epileptic discharge
the left and right hemispheres detected a number of GMV causes bilateral tissue damage, but the damage is greater in
asymmetries including the well-known right frontal and left the hemisphere ipsilateral to seizures that originate in the left
occipital petalias. [2,3]. mesial temporal lobe. Left hemisphere is the dominant side
in most cases [25], especially when all our subjects were
3.2.2. Altered hemispheric asymmetry found in the left-sided right-handed as in this study. Seizures originating in the
MTLE/HS patients but not in the right-sided patients as dominant hemisphere may cause more excitotoxic damage,
compared to the normal control and also, brain tissue in the dominant hemisphere may be
Compared to the normal controls, the following abnormal more susceptible to the damage. A number of studies
asymmetry patterns were detected in the left HS patients. In investigated left- and right-sided MTLE as subgroups using
terms of GM pattern, the left-sided MTLE/HS patients have different approaches and reported different distribution
more LbR asymmetries in the temporal lobe than the right- patterns of brain matter reduction between the left- and
sided MTLE/HS group, including the inferior temporal right-sided MTLE patients. Riederer et al. [26] reported that
gyrus, middle temporal gyrus and parahippocampal gyrus distinct neuronal network damage in MTLE was more
(shown in Fig. 3, detailed in Table 2). In terms of WM widespread in patients with left-sided seizure focus. In the
asymmetry, there is signicant LbR asymmetry in the left- longitudinal MTLE study performed by Coan et al. [27],
sided MTLE/HS patients in the subcortical WM of mesial progressive WM and GM atrophy was found in patients with
temporal lobe compared with the normal controls (shown in MTLE, which was more signicant in patients with left
Fig. 3, detailed in Table 2). MTLE compared with right MTLE. Additionally, more
In contrast to the left-sided MTLE/HS group, no signicant cognitive impairment [28,29] and atypical
signicant abnormal GM and WM asymmetries were language lateralization [30] in patients with left-sided
found in the right-sided MTLE/HS patients when compared MTLE were described in recent studies. Since the involved
to the normal controls. areas were associated with memory and cognitive functions
[28,31], we speculate that there would be more functional
and anatomical reorganization in the dominant hemisphere
4. Discussion than that in the nondominant hemisphere, which contributes
to the difference in asymmetry patterns between the two
Studies in patients with MTLE/HS repeatedly demon- subtypes as compared to the normal control. But in any case,
strated structural and functional abnormalities extending these assumptions are based on the knowledge from previous
J. Lu et al. / Magnetic Resonance Imaging 31 (2013) 5359 57
Fig. 2. The signicantly asymmetrical regions in GM and WM of the normal controls, left-sided MTLE/HS patients and right-sided MTLE/HS patients. We
showed the positive signicant regions, of which the regions shown in the right hemisphere are larger than the left hemisphere and vice versa. Multiple
comparisons were corrected by FDR, Pb.05.
58 J. Lu et al. / Magnetic Resonance Imaging 31 (2013) 5359
Fig. 3. The signicantly altered asymmetrical regions in GM and WM of the left-sided MTLE/HS patients compared with normal controls. The positive
signicant regions in the right hemisphere are larger than those in the left hemisphere. Multiple comparisons were corrected by FDR, Pb.05.
studies and require additional studies for conrmation, for language lateralization. Ellmore et al. [35] studied the
example, correlation with cognitive decline and longitudinal possibility of using asymmetric index in the relative density
comparison of the two subgroups. of WM pathways, using diffusion tensor imaging implicated
Interestingly, the study did not detect asymmetries in the in language function to predict lateralization of language.
bilateral hippocampi but found asymmetry in the parahippo- This preliminary study found that laterality indices computed
campal gyrus, which is part of the limbic system and mesial from asymmetry of high-anisotropy arcuate fasciculus
temporal lobe as well. The possible reason is that there exists pathways correctly classied the majority of patients. Our
the synchronized atrophy in the contralateral hippocampi results may serve as an important basis whenever structural
which is associated to the ipsilateral hippocampal atrophy. A asymmetry measured using VBM is used in lateralization of
number of studies have found the volume reduction of the functions; the fundamental differences between left- and
bilateral hippocampi in unilateral temporal lobe epilepsy, right-sided MTLE patients should be taken into account.
especially in the patients with hippocampal sclerosis [29,32]. There are several limitations in the present study. First,
Due to synchronized atrophy of the bilateral hippocampi and the sample size is relatively small, which might result in a
subsequent subtle volume in-between difference, asymmet- reduction of statistical power. Second, we are not able to
ric index in this region may fail to reach signicance. compare the whole disease progression and treatment of
Prior studies have attempted to relate structural asymme- these subgroups due to somewhat incomplete clinical data.
try in cortical regions [4,33] and WM [34,35] between the Further prospective study is warranted, which would be our
hemispheres in regard to important functions such as future work.
Table 2
Signicantly asymmetrical changes in GMV and WMV of the left-sided MTLE/HS patients compared with the normal controls
MNI coordinates P T score Cluster size (mm3) Anatomical regions BA Side
x (mm) y (mm) z (mm)
GM 57 2 36 b.001 8.63 456 Inferior temporal gyrus 20 R
60 12 14 .004 5.62 37 Middle temporal gyrus 21 R
29 14 23 .007 5.35 231 Parahippocampal gyrus 20 R
30 9 29 .01 5.04 45 Parahippocampal gyrus 36 R
WM 20 36 8 .019 5.98 101 Sublobal, temporal 27 R
Note: the T score is the highest value in the cluster which it belongs. Multiple comparisons were corrected by FDR. The clusters larger than 30 voxels were
reported.
BA=Brodmann's area; R=right hemisphere.
J. Lu et al. / Magnetic Resonance Imaging 31 (2013) 5359 59