Você está na página 1de 6

Art Therapy

Journal of the American Art Therapy Association

ISSN: 0742-1656 (Print) 2159-9394 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/uart20

The Effectiveness of Art Therapy Interventions in


Reducing Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Symptoms in Pediatric Trauma Patients

Linda Chapman MA, ATR-BC , Diane Morabito RN, MPH , Chris Ladakakos
PhD , Herbert Schreier MD & M. Margaret Knudson MD

To cite this article: Linda Chapman MA, ATR-BC , Diane Morabito RN, MPH , Chris Ladakakos
PhD , Herbert Schreier MD & M. Margaret Knudson MD (2001) The Effectiveness of Art Therapy
Interventions in Reducing Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) Symptoms in Pediatric
Trauma Patients, Art Therapy, 18:2, 100-104, DOI: 10.1080/07421656.2001.10129750

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/07421656.2001.10129750

Published online: 22 Apr 2011.

Submit your article to this journal

Article views: 6222

View related articles

Citing articles: 44 View citing articles

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=uart20

Download by: [UCLA Library] Date: 27 January 2017, At: 18:43


The Effectiveness of Art Therapy Interventions in
Reducing Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Symptoms in Pediatric Trauma Patients

Linda Chapman, MA, ATR-BC, San Francisco, CA, Diane Morabito, RN, MPH,
San Francisco, CA, Chris Ladakakos, PhD, Oakland, CA, Herbert Schreier, MD,
Oakland, CA, and M. Margaret Knudson, MD, San Francisco, CA

Abstract presence of relevant stimuli (American Psychiatric Association,


Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders IV, 1994).
Although post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in children has To address these symptoms in a population of hospitalized
been extensively studied during the past 15 years, little research exists children and adolescents in an urban Level I Trauma Center, a
regarding the efficacy of treatment interventions. This report describes program directed by the first author was established in 1988 by
an outcome-based art therapy research project currently conducted at the Departments of Pediatrics and Psychiatry at the University of
a large urban hospital trauma center. Included are the theoretical California San Francisco at San Francisco General Hospital. The
rationale and overview of an art therapy treatment intervention program offered psychological treatment services as a standard
called the Chapman Art Therapy Treatment Intervention (CATTI) component of care for the 1,200 patients age 0-18 admitted
designed to reduce PTSD symptoms in pediatric trauma patients. annually. Seventy percent of the patients were trauma patients,
Used in this study, the CATTI was evaluated for efficacy in measur- victims of gunshot or stab wounds and other acts of violence,
ing the reduction of PTSD symptoms at intervals of 1 week, 1 month, severe child abuse, or unintentional injuries such as motor vehi-
and 6 months after discharge from the hospital. An early analysis of cle accidents, falls, and burns. The other 30% were admitted for
the data does not indicate statistically significant differences in the acute and chronic childhood illnesses such as asthma, sickle cell
reduction of PTSD symptoms between the experimental and control disease, and neglect.
groups. However, there is evidence that the children receiving the art Children were seen beginning in the intensive care or pedi-
therapy intervention did show a reduction in acute stress symptoms. atric ward, and were offered individual trauma resolution thera-
py, group therapy when applicable, milieu activity therapy, and
Introduction Child Life-oriented services throughout their hospital stay.
With very limited opportunity for follow-up psychotherapy
In the United States, pediatric trauma is the leading cause of services for the patients, it was hoped that early trauma resolution
death after 1 year of age. Each year, over 2 million children therapy during hospitalization would reduce PTSD symptoms
require hospitalization after sustaining traumatic injuries. Over and behaviors that may lead to disruptions in development,
100,000 children are permanently disabled, and 8,500 die each future psychopathology, or recurring injuriesthe proposed but
year from accidental injuries. It is estimated that 300 children are not systematically tested results of untreated PTSD (Hubbard,
wounded each day by firearms, and five are murdered. In addi- Realmuto, Northwood, & Masten, 1995; Tellez, Mackersie,
tion to the psychological costs to the family and society incurred Morabito, Shagoury, & Heye, 1995; Terr, 1990).
by this epidemic, over $15 billion is spent annually to care for
injured children (Baker & Waller, 1989; Deal, Gomby, Zippiroli, History of the Current Project
& Behrman, 2000).
Physical traumatic injuries generate emotional phenomena Art therapists observations of hospitalized, traumatized chil-
that include a defensive behavioral pattern, a grief reaction, and dren indicated behaviors consistent with the DSM-IV definition
a psychological retreat. Additionally, some patients exhibit PTSD of PTSD and the criteria used for this diagnosis. Re-experiencing
symptoms including reexperiencing the event, avoidance of phenomena were observed in post traumatic play, psychobiologi-
thoughts and feelings about the event, and hyper-arousal in the cal reactions, and recurrent intrusive images. Avoidance symptoms
were exhibited in gaze aversion, withdrawal, dissociative episodes,
Editors note: Linda Chapman, MA, ATR-BC, is an Investigator, apathy toward primary caregivers, refusal to comply with treat-
San Francisco Injury Center, University of California San Francisco. ment plans, and regressed developmental skills. Symptoms of
Diane Morabito, RN, MPH, is Research Coordinator, San Francisco increased arousal were observed in nightmares and sleep distur-
Injury Center, University of California San Francisco. Chris Ladakakos, bances, irritability, new aggressive behaviors, exaggerated startle
PhD, is a Research Psychologist, Department of Psychiatry, Childrens
responses, and anxious attachment. The DSM-IV suggests that
Hospital Oakland in Oakland, CA. Herbert Schreier, MD, is Chief,
Department of Psychiatry, Childrens Hospital Oakland, Oakland, CA.
these symptoms must be present for a period of 1 month or longer
M. Margaret Knudson, MD, is Director of the San Francisco Injury to qualify for the diagnosis.
Center, University of California San Francisco. All correspondence As part of the programming at San Francisco General
should be sent to the first author at: 10151 East Road, Redwood Valley, Hospital, an art therapy treatment intervention was developed to
CA 95470 or redwood@itsa.ucsf.edu. reduce PTSD symptoms in patients prior to their discharge from
100
CHAPMAN / MORABITO / LADAKAKOS / SCHREIER / KNUDSON 101

the hospital. Though not in a controlled study or systematic version to assess parents reports of their childrens trauma symp-
appraisal, the intervention was implemented over a 10-year peri- toms. The PTSD-I scores are categorized according to the fol-
od with hundreds of hospitalized pediatric trauma patients across lowing breakpoints: raw score 12, doubtful PTSD; score of 12-
the developmental spectrum with results that warranted a con- 24, mild level of PTSD; score of 25-39, moderate level of PTSD;
trolled study. After nearly 10 years of programming, a research score of 40-59, severe PTSD; score 60, very severe PTSD.
proposal was submitted to the San Francisco Injury Center Interviews are repeated 1 week after injury, 1 month after hospi-
(SFIC) for Research and Prevention, one of 10 Injury Control tal discharge, and 6 months after hospital discharge. One year
Centers funded by the National Centers for Disease Control and interviews are currently being conducted for children who con-
Prevention (CDC) in Washington, DC. tinue to demonstrate symptomatology at 6 months. The age
In a collaborative effort with Childrens Hospital Oakland in range for the PTSD-I spans from age 5 to adulthood.
Oakland, California, the project was expanded to include several
specific investigations. The specific aims of the study were: Baseline Measures
To determine the incidence rate of PTSD in pediatric trau-
ma patients following an acute traumatic injury University of California at Los Angeles Post Traumatic Stress
Disorder Index (PTSD-I) Child or Adolescent Version
To determine the outcome of a specific art therapy treat- (Rodriguez, Steinberg, & Pynoos, 1997)
ment intervention in reducing PTSD symptoms in a popu-
lation of hospitalized children University of California at Los Angeles Post Traumatic Stress
Disorder Index (PTSD-I) Parent Version (Rodriguez,
To determine the outcome of the intervention at 1-week, Steinberg, & Pynoos, 1997)
1-month and 6-month follow-up evaluations
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Diagnostic Scale (Foa, 1995)
To examine the ability of parents or caregivers to assess the
childs level of stress Family Environment Scale (Moos & Moos, 1994)
To examine the ability of nursing staff to assess the childs Nursing Checklist (three shifts) (modified version of PTSD-
level of stress RI-Parent Version)

This report features the intervention component of the proj- Postintervention Measures
ect, as other aspects of the study are beyond the limitations of a
brief report. Other publications covering other specific aims of The same measures, with the exception of the Nursing
the project are currently in preparation. Checklist, were administered to all children and parents or
caregivers enrolled in the study at 1-week, 1-month, and 6-
Method month intervals.
Procedurally, all children admitted to the trauma service were
The study is a prospective, randomized cohort design. Sub- screened within 24 hours of admission. The childrens families
jects were children 7 to 17 years old who had been admitted to a were offered a description of the project and an explanation of the
Level I Trauma Center for traumatic injuries. The sustained assessment, treatment, and follow-up procedures. The interviewer
injury must have been of sufficient severity to require the child to obtained permission and proper documentation from child and
remain at the hospital for a minimum of 24 hours. Children were parent or caregiver to participate in the study, and the baseline
excluded if admitted for injuries resulting from burns, child measures were completed by the parent and child. Those children
abuse, and severe head injury. Severe head injury was defined as scoring 12 on the PTSD-I were randomized to a control group
an Abbreviated Injury Scale 3. or the intervention group. The control group received usual hos-
Unlike the adult literature, child PTSD literature indicates pital care. The intervention group received the art therapy inter-
that the type and severity of the trauma may affect the incidence vention from one of two participating art therapists. A group of
of PTSD. Therefore, an attempt was made to create a sample of children with no PTSD symptoms were also assessed and followed
similarly traumatized children. Non-English-speaking children to determine a possible delay in symptom presentation.
and parents/caregivers were not included in the study due to a
lack of non-English-speaking therapists and interviewers. Chapman Art Therapy Treatment
Intervention (CATTI)
Assessment and Follow-up
Tools and Procedures A specific drawing treatment intervention was developed by
the first author as a brief, trauma resolution method. The Chap-
The following assessment measures were used to assess base- man Art Therapy Treatment Intervention (CATTI) is designed for
line measures of PTSD symptoms in all children, parents, and incident-specific, medical trauma to provide an opportunity for the
caregivers enrolled in the study. child to sequentially relate and cognitively comprehend the trau-
The measurement used to pretest and posttest the study matic event, transport to the hospital, emergency care, hospitaliza-
participants was The Childrens Post Traumatic Stress Disorder tion and treatment regimen, and posthospital care and adjustment.
Index (PTSD-I), designed and validated by Robert Pynoos, MD As the literature suggests, in cases of severe PTSD, incident-
(1997) for the assessment of post traumatic stress reactions of specific, individual treatment is indicated (Frederick, 1985;
school age children and adolescents after exposure to a broad Shelby, 2000), and trauma mastery must be incident-specific for
range of traumatic events. The PTSD-I is a self-report measure specific resolution of the problem (Frederick, 1985, p. 93). The
that asks the individuals to respond to a 20-item inventory of CATTI offers developmentally and culturally sensitive trauma
symptoms based primarily on the diagnostic criteria in the resolution therapy to reduce PTSD symptoms, and to facilitate
DSM-IV. The PTSD-I also includes an adolescent and parent the integration of the experience into ones larger, autobiograph-
102 ART THERAPY AND PTSD

ical life narrative (Siegel, 2000). Although children may benefit responses to the traumatic event to universalize their experience
from short-term therapy for incident-based trauma, many chil- and reduce anxiety (Frederick, 1995).
dren can be assisted with very brief, direct intervention (Shelby, The affective expression is often followed by a rapid shift to
2000). In particular, art therapy facilitates the expression and cognitive functioning, evidenced in the childs ability to utilize
exploration of traumatic imagery as it emerges from memory and language and sequentially relate a coherent narrative about the
finds form (Appleton, 2000). event and ensuing medical care. The child is also able to formu-
The CATTI was developed by combining what is known late adaptive coping mechanisms, and in some patients, the
about the resulting neurochemical dysregulation response to orbital prefrontal system is engaged as the childs dialogue
severe stress (van der Kolk, 1996), the formation of images and includes more complex concepts such as consequences, compas-
their relationship to thought and cognition (Bruner, 1964; sion, and a moral imperative.
Horowitz, 1970; Levick, 1984; Lusebrink, 1990), and develop- Inherent in the CATTI is the opportunity for the child to
mental, psychological, and neuropsychological theories on the maintain control over the expression and containment of his or her
storage and retrieval of traumatic memories. The CATTI utilizes graphic and verbal traumatic material. The child is able to express
the integrative capacity of the brain by accessing the traumatic trauma-specific fears (Terr, 1990), perceptions, and misperceptions
sensations and memories in a manner that is consistent with the about the event, medical care, and future. The child is also able to
current understanding of the transmission of experience to lan- relate his or her own unique story in a manner consistent with his
guage (Horowitz, 1970; van der Kolk, 1994 ). By activating both or her level of graphic, perceptual, and cognitive development.
right and left hemisphere activity along with both visual and ver- After completing the drawing and verbal narrative, the child
bal neural pathways, therapeutic potential is maximized as the is engaged in a retelling of the event, using the drawings to illus-
brain creates a visual, nonverbal narrative that is translated to a trate the narrative. During the retelling, numerous issues are
coherent linguistic narrative. Coherent narratives require the par- addressed, including but not limited to: misperceptions, rescue
ticipation of both right and left hemispheres and are created and revenge fantasies, blame, shame and guilt, coping strategies,
through hemispheric integration (Siegel, 1999). treatment and follow-up plans, traumatic reminders, and reinte-
The CATTI is facilitated in a one-to-one session at the gration strategies.
childs bedside in the hospital room. The CATTI is designed to
be completed in approximately 1 hour, with minimal art media.
Preliminary Results
Additional time may be required depending on the severity of the
event and meaning of the event to the child. Optimally, children A total of 85 patients were enrolled in the study: 31 received
would receive ongoing psychological follow-up services, and min- the art therapy intervention, 27 received standard hospital care,
imally, at the time of medical follow-up care. and 27 did not present PTSD symptoms at the baseline inter-
The protocol for this intervention is not described in this view. Hospital care was defined as the normal and usual course of
paper, as some training is required to facilitate the CATTI. The pediatric care including Child Life services, art therapy, social
clinician must have knowledge of the psychological reactions to work, and psychiatric consults.
traumatic physical injuries, the facilitation and containment of Regarding child-specific variables, the average age of the
traumatic imagery, and prior exposure to examples of a variety of child was 10 years (mean 10.7, SD 2.6 years). The average
situations which may be presented (e.g., physical pain, psychobi- length of stay in the hospital was 4.4 days (mean 4.4, SD 5.5
ological reactions) and how to appropriately respond with art days), and average length of stay in the ICU was 1.4 days (mean
media and imagery. The CATTI is currently being prepared for
1.4, SD 3.2 days).
publication, including the theoretical basis and practical applica-
tion for use with hospitalized pediatric trauma patients.
Demographics
CATTI Procedure As illustrated in Table 1, ethnic representation is fairly well
mixed. The finding that 70% of the trauma victims were male is
The CATTI begins with a graphic kinesthetic activity
consistent with adult trauma statistics. The most common mech-
designed to stimulate the formation of images by activating the
cerebellum (Lusebrink, 1990). The motor activity allows for a
release of tension, and the rhythm and motion serve as a method
of relaxation (Lusebrink, 1990) to aid in tolerating the stressors
(Frederick, 1985). The kinesthetic activity is followed by a series
of carefully worded directives to elicit a series of drawings
designed to complete a coherent narrative about the event. Each
drawing in the narrative is followed by an opportunity for the
child to offer accompanying verbalizations related to each image.
The systematic method of accessing the material is consis-
tent with the childs visual and sensory modes of recording trau-
matic experiences (Terr, 1990; van der Kolk, 1994). The draw-
ings, or kinesthetic activity, activate the limbic system, the center
for emotional and perceptual processes. This is most often
expressed behaviorally in tears, or a loud, angry voice. The emo-
tional experience is considered to be essential in order for a cor-
rective emotional experience to occur (Schore, 1994). Childrens Figure 1
emotional expressions are validated by the therapist as normal Patient Groups
CHAPMAN / MORABITO / LADAKAKOS / SCHREIER / KNUDSON 103

anism of injury is primarily from automobile vs. pedestrian or


automobile vs. bicycle accidents. Other injuries represented
include sports, animal, and penetrating injuries and falls. As
shown in Table 2, most of the injuries involved the extremities,
consistent with the high incidence of injuries resulting from
motor vehicle accidents in the sample.

CATTI vs. Standard Hospital Treatment


No significant overall difference in patients PTSD-I scores
was found between those who received the CATTI and those re-
ceiving standard hospital treatment. Table 1 illustrates the de-
crease in symptoms for each group of children from baseline to 1
week and 1 month. Although no statistically significant differ-
ence was determined, examination of individual symptom clus-
ters revealed that intervention produced a reduction in all DSM-
IV PTSD Criteria C (avoidance) symptoms at 1 week and sus-
Figure 2
tained that decrease 1 month. While this finding could be due to
Art Therapy vs. Standard Therapy
regression to the mean, it may indicate that the CATTI may be
effective in reducing acute stress symptoms, and may allow chil-
dren to discuss and process their traumatic experiences more interventions and strategies. This prospective research project
effectively when compared to the standard treatment group. offers one investigation that contributes to that effort.
There are several limitations to the study. First, most of the
Discussion children in the sample suffered mild to moderate injuries, and the
sample size is fairly small. Second, the assessment tools may not be
It is imperative for the art therapy profession to conduct sensitive enough to accurately measure symptoms of hospitalized
controlled studies to measure the efficacy of art therapy treatment acutely injured children. The presentation of post traumatic stress

Table 1
Demographics

Characteristic Percent
Race/Ethnicity
White 35.3%
Black 29.4%
Asian 23.5%
Hispanic 11.8%
Gender
Male 70.6%
Female 29.4%
Mechanism of
MVA/MCA 23.5% Figure 3
Auto/Ped or Bike 47.1% Percent Change in PTSD Scores
Other 29.4%

Table 2
Demographics

Characteristic Percent
Parental Marital Status
Married 41.2%
Single 58.8%
Body Region of Most Severe Injury
Head 17.6%
Chest 5.9%
Abdomen 5.9%
Extremities 58.9%
Multiple 11.8% Figure 4
Percent Change in PTSD Scores
104 ART THERAPY AND PTSD

symptoms in acutely injured children is often idiosyncratic and Hubbard, J., Realmuto, G., Northwood, A., & Masten, A. (1995).
manifested in conjunction with physical injuries, painful medical Comorbidity of psychiatric diagnoses with post traumatic stress disor-
procedures, and hospitalization. The currently available reaction der in survivors of childhood trauma. Journal of the Academy of Child
indices do not entirely describe the observable, often brief and & Adolescent Psychiatry, 34, 1167-1173.
severe stress symptom presentation in acutely injured children.
Levick, M. (1984). Imagery as a style of thinking. Journal of the American
Third, the intervention was designed to be administered as Art Therapy Association, 1(3), 119-124.
a component of ongoing psychological pediatric trauma care, and
previous interaction with the injured child and his or her family. Lusebrink, V. (1990). Imagery and visual expression in therapy. New York:
In the study sample, children were seen without prior interaction Plenum Press.
with the therapist facilitating the intervention. Finally, it is diffi-
cult to ascertain whether PTSD symptoms measured in the fol- Moos, R., & Moos, B. (1994). Family Environment Scale Manual. Palo
low-up data are independent of other traumatic events that may Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologist Press.
have occurred in the childs life since the intervention. Or, as the
literature suggests, children with multiple traumas may have less Pynoos, R., Steinberg, A., & Piacentini, J. (1999). A developmental psy-
chopathology model of childhood traumatic stress and intersection
PTSD, which may be a possible variable in the efficacy of the
with anxiety disorders. Biological Psychology, 46, 1542-1554.
intervention. Perhaps, as suggested in recent literature, anxiety
and depression may be more descriptive of a childs reaction to Rodriguez, N., Steinberg, A., & Pynoos, R (1997). PTSD index for
trauma than PTSD (Pynoos, Steinberg, & Piacentini, 1999; Terr, DSM-IV instrument information: Child version, adolescent version,
1999; Yule, et al., 2000). parent version. Unpublished manuscript.
Further outcome results of 6-month follow-up data are
being compiled. Other data will include the physical and neuro- Schore, A. (1994). Affect regulation and the origin of the self: The neurobi-
logical reactions during the intervention (eye contact, sighs, tears, ology of emotional development. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
mention of pain, autonomic nervous system responses, and psy-
chobiological reactions), and the childs perception of the perpe- Shelby, J. (2000). Brief therapy with traumatized children: A develop-
mental perspective. In H. Kaduson & E. Schaefer (Eds.), Short-term
trator (object, person, etc.). Data related to the drawings will
play therapy. New York: The Guilford Press, 69-104.
include the amount of time spent on each drawing in the narra-
tive, the main focus of the drawing and number of details drawn, Shelby, J., & Tredinnick, M. (1995). Crisis intervention with survivors
and the amount of assistance, if any, required from the therapist of natural disaster: Lessons from Hurricane Andrew. Journal of
to complete the narrative. Additionally, the drawings may con- Counseling, 73(5), 491-497.
tain valuable developmental information about how children per-
ceive traumatic events, medical care, and rehabilitation. It is Siegel, D. (In Press). The developing mind and resolution of trauma:
hoped that the data from this component of the study will con- Some ideas about information processing and an interpersonal neuro-
tribute to the development of the required assessment and treat- biology of psychotherapy. In F. Shaprio (Ed.), EMDR and the paradigm
ment tools to provide the essential psychological component of prism. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association Press.
comprehensive pediatric trauma care.
Siegel, D. (1999). The developing mind: Toward a neurobiology of inter-
personal experience. New York: The Guilford Press.
References
Tellez, M., Mackersie, R., Morabito, D., Shagoury, C., & Heye, C.
American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical man-
(1995). Risks, costs, and the expected complications of re-injury.
ual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
American Journal of Surgery, 170(6), 660-663.
Appleton, V. (2001). Avenues of hope: Art therapy and the resolution of
Terr, L. (1999). A PTSD spectrum: The example of Challenger. In
trauma. Art Therapy: Journal of the American Art Therapy Association
Scientific Proceedings of 46th Annual American Academy of Child &
18(1), 6-13.
Adolescent Psychiatry, Chicago, IL, 90.
Baker, S., & Waller, A. (1989). Childhood injury: State-by-state mortality
Terr, L. (1990). Too scared to cry. New York: Harper & Row.
facts. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Injury Prevention Center.
van der Kolk, B. A., McFarlane, A., & Weisath, L. (Eds.). (1996).
Bruner, J. (1964). The course of cognitive growth. American Psychologist,
Traumatic stress: The effects of overwhelming experience on mind, body
19, 1-15.
and society. New York: Guilford Press.
Deal, L., Gomby, D., Zippiroli, L., & Behrman, R. (2000).
van der Kolk, B. (1994). The body keeps score: Memory and the evolv-
Unintentional injuries in childhood: Analysis and recommendations.
ing psychobiology of posttraumatic stress. Harvard Review of
The Future of Children, 10(1), 4-22.
Psychology, 1(5), 253-265.
Foa, E. (1995). Post Traumatic Stress Diagnostic Scale Manual.
Yule, W., Bolton, D., Udwin, O., Boyle, S., ORyan, D., & Nurrish, J.
Minneapolis: National Computer Systems, Inc.
(2000). The long-term psychological effects of a disaster experienced
in adolescence: The incidence and course of PTSD. Journal of Child
Frederick, R. (1985). Children traumatized by catastrophic situations. In
Psychology and Psychiatry, 41(4), 503-511.
S. Eth and R. Pynoos (Eds.), Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in
Children. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc., 73-99.

Horowitz, M. (1970). Image formation and cognition. New York:


Appleton Century-Crofts.

Você também pode gostar