Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Sally Newman, PhD,2 Robert Faux, ABD,3 and Barbara Larimer, MA ME<
As more and more people live longer and health- How are children's attitudes about and percep-
ier lives, and the number of older adults increases, it tions of older adults formed? The answer to this
is incumbent upon society to reflect upon the nature question is complex. Marks, Newman, and Onawola
and genesis of the attitudes and perceptions of its (1985) used the Children's Views on Aging (CVoA)
younger people toward older adults. With their num- questionnaire to demonstrate the complexity and di-
bers increasing, older adults are becoming actively versity of children's attitudes toward older adults.
involved in many aspects of community life (New- They found that, although children's attitudes toward
man, 1985). While their numbers may be large, older the aging process were often negative, their general
adults are often the focus of negative social attitudes, attitudes about older adults were positive. Marks and
which makes them vulnerable to a form of prejudice colleagues concluded that children appear to recog-
known as ageism (Falchikov, 1990; Seefeldt, Jantz, nize the positive and negative aspects of aging. Be-
Galper, & Serock, 1977). Laws (1995) argues that age yond making this distinction, the children displayed
should be studied as a component of a complex appropriate affective responses to each aspect of the
framework of social relations between individuals. aging process and to older people. Based upon their
Ageism can be defined as a set of social practices. research, Marks et al. have suggested the need to
Laws suggests that society has transformed biological look beyond children's attitudes and at the underly-
and chronological age into social and cultural signs. ing components of those attitudes.
Thus, perceived differences between young and old By the time children enter school they may have
people are socially constructed, and are not neces- already developed negative attitudes toward some
sarily reducible to biological causes. How a culture older adults. Research on the development of such
views age, therefore, is often based upon attitudes may help in modifying them before they
socially/culturally agreed upon standards. Re- become well established (Isaacs & Bearison, 1986).
searchers have been interpreting results from chil- Though older adults as a group may be perceived in
dren using adult standards. The question is: is there a a negative light, individual older adults within that
need to be more sensitive to children's socially/cul- aggregate may be perceived either positively or neg-
turally derived standards in the context of interpret- atively. McTavish (1971) has found that negative per-
ing their responses? ceptions can result in an overall rejection of older
adults. McTavish argues that children fear growing
'The authors wish to thank Sandra Harris for her assistance in the prepa- old because of their misconception that aging is
ration of this article, and Valerie Balavage for her assistance in the editing
of the final review of the article.
bad. Children's attitudes and stereotypes develop
2
Address correspondence to Sally Newman, PhD, Director, Generations early and remain fairly constant, guiding their behav-
Together, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260. ior toward others (Klausmeier & Ripple, 1971). As
department of Psychology and Education, University of Pittsburgh, Aronson (1976) reminds us, attitudes are resistant to
Pittsburgh, PA.
'Department of Administration and Policy, University of Pittsburgh,
change, and people will go to great lengths to main-
Pittsburgh, PA. tain them.
84 8 8 89 4 7 Good 60 4 80 0
Pleasant 47 10 64 4
Happy 59 12 68 8
Fast 5 20 7 16
test, slightly more children reported thinking that Pretty 27 29 36 24
the older adults came to their classrooms because Interesting 58 14 72 4
they were lonely, and that they had nothing inter- Kind 55 12 68 4
Loved 52 8 64 8
esting to do.
When asked if they wanted an older adult in their Note: *,+Very Much and Very Little were used as the extreme
classroom as a helper, more children said 'yes' on the values of a five-point rating scale. Not included in the table are
post-test questionnaire. This change reflects an in- counts for intermediate values; we merely wish to describe the
shift. We cannot designate the ends of the scale as either posi-
crease of 6%, from 83% on the pre-test to 89% on the tive or negative because we discovered that the children them-
post-test, indicating a positive reaction of children to selves do not perceive their own ratings in that way.
the interaction with the older adult volunteer.
Section IV of the CVoA addresses children's per-
ceptions of older adults using selected bipolar word
pairs of characteristics drawn from the Osgood se-
mantic differential scale. The children identify along substantially lower and the positive attribution in-
a 5-point Likert-type scale their rating of older peo- creased proportionately. Those who were uncertain
ple's characteristics. In general, there is a marked tended to give more positive descriptions of older
positive shift along a 5-point rating scale in percep- adults after they had participated in the school volun-
teer program.
tion of "old people" after older adults had been
present weekly in the classrooms as school volun-
Summary
teers. Table 3 summarizes the percentage of posi-
tive change in student responses from pre-test to The results of pre-test and post-test administra-
post-test for selected characteristics. tion of the CVoA, including differences between
In general, ratings were more positive after inter- pre-test and post-test, show a shift in childrens'
action with the older adults. In addition, the data feelings about their responses to a more positive
suggest that the descriptions tended toward "very" value. Children who were previously unsure of the
positive on the post-test. For most descriptors, the emotional quality of their responses have shifted
percentage of "very" positive change ranged from from "not sure" in pre-test measures to "good" or
about 10-20%. better in post-test measures. The typical child in this
Some incremental increases in negative descrip- study tends to have positive perceptions of older
tions were also documented. However, the percent- people, but negative feelings about his or her own
age of change as well as the strength of the descrip- aging. They have a realistic and consistent percep-
tions was substantially less than for the positive tion of why older adults work with them in the
results. For example, a small increase (7%) from pre- classroom. There is little change in their under-
test to post-test is observed for the descriptor "bor- standing of the reasons why older adults serve as
ing." At the same time, a 15% increase is observed classroom volunteers between the pre-test and
on the other end of the scale for "interesting." The post-test.
small increases in negative descriptors were in all Children in this study identify physical changes
cases more than offset by change on the positive due to aging, and do not have a negative perception
end of the scale. Other descriptors for which a of them. Previous reports of childrens' negative per-
small increase on the negative side was offset by ceptions of the physical aging process may have
the percentage of positive change were: slow, been prompted more by the attributions and inter-
mean, and hated. It should be stressed that negative pretations of the research than by concrete evi-
increases were incremental and tended to appear in dence gathered from the children themselves. They
the "a little" category. Observed changes were gen- consistently identified positive affective characteris-
erally positive. tics associated with aging, which were clearly de-
In addition to these findings, some other differ- monstrated in their responses to the semantic differ-
ences were noted. For example, when the percentage ential scale. The children accurately and consistently
of students who responded "not sure" decreased identified the reasons why older adults came to
from pre-test to post-test, the greatest corresponding their classrooms, and that they and their classmates
increase was observed in the positive or very positive generally felt good about their presence. The chil-
category. In other words, if the students were "not dren in this study tend to associate their negative
sure" whether they would "describe old people" as feelings with some conditions accompanying the
"good" at the time of the pre-test, the percentage aging process, and they tend to attribute the same
who were "not sure" at the time of the post-test was feelings about aging to the older adults as well.