Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ATHDFCBANK
ADissertationsubmittedinpartialrequirementsfor
theawardofMBADegreeofBangaloreUniversity
By
MsDarshanaPatel
(Regno:04XQCM6021)
Undertheguidanceof
Dr.KVPrabhakar
SeniorProfessor,MPBIM,Bangalore
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement,
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan,
No53,RaceCourseRoad,
Bangalore560001
2006.
EXECUTIVESUMMARY
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 2
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Declaration
Iherebydeclarethatthisdissertationentitled, TOTALQUALITY
MANAGEMENT at HDFC Bank is abonafide study, completed
undertheguidanceandsupervisionofDr. KVPrabhakar,Senior
Professor,M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement,Bangalore,(Internal
Guide) and Mr. Baban Balan, HDFC Bank, Bangalore (External
Guide).
Ifurtherdeclarethatthisdissertationistheresultofmyownefforts
andthatithasnotbeensubmittedtoanyotherUniversityorInstitute
fortheawardofadegreeordiplomaoranydegreeorothersimilar
titleofrecognition.
Place:Bangalore (Ms.Darshana.Patel)
Date:
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 3
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Certificate
I herebycertifythat thisdissertationentitled TOTAL QUALITY
MANAGEMENT at HDFC Bank has been prepared by
Ms.Darshana.PatelundertheguidanceandsupervisionofDr.KV
Prabhakar, Senior Professor, M.P.Birla Institute of Management,
Bangalore. (Internal Guide) and Mr. Baban Balan, HDFC Bank,
Bangalore(ExternalGuide)
Place:Bangalore
Date:
(Dr.NageshSMalavalli)
Principal
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 4
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Certificate
Place:Bangalore
Date:(Dr.KVPrabhakar)
InternalGuide
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 5
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
ExternalGuidesCertificate
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 6
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Acknowledgement
ItissaidAteacheraffectseternity;hecannevertell,wherehis
influencestops.
IamalsogratefultoMr.BabanBalan,Manager,Quality
InitiativesGroup,HDFCBank,forhisguidanceandsupport.Credit
alsogoestomyparents,withoutwhosemoralsupportandinspiration,
thisreportwouldhavebeenincomplete.
THANKYOUONEANDALL.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 7
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Contents
Particulars PageNumber
Introduction 10
IndustryProfile 13
CompanyProfile 17
HDFCandCompetitors 21
Areaofstudy 24
ProblemStatement 29
ResearchObjective 32
ResearchMethodology 34
ResearchGap 38
AnalysisandDataInterpretation 40
Recommendations 60
Annexure 66
Glossary 71
Bibliography 73
Directionsforfurtherresearch 76
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 8
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Listoftablesandcharts
Particulars PageNumber
IndianBankingStructure 15
AccountOpeningProcedure 27
ParetoChart 4146
RootCauseDiagram 47
ServiceSwitchingBehaviour 49
Table1 52
Chart1 52
Graph1 53
Table2 54
Graph2 54
Table3 55
Graph3 56
QualityFunctionDeployment 58
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 9
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER1:INTRODUCTION
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 10
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Banking sector faces lot of challenges. It varies from
improving profitability, reinforcing technology, risk
management, customer orientation to meeting international
standards.Eachchallengefacesasetofstepsandprocedures.
Lotofcareneedstobetakenwhilemonitoringthem.However,
if at the initial steps, the performance deviates from the
expectedstandard,theentireprocesscangohaywire.
HDFCwantstoimplementtheconcepttheTotalQuality
Management (TQM) in the process of account openings. A
processisdefinesasasystematicseriesofactionsdirectedto
theachievementofagoal.Theprocessthereforehastobe:
1 Goaloriented
2 Systematic
3 Capable
4 Legitimate
TQMalsoinvolvesServicesProcessDesignandisdifferent
frommanufacturingprocessdesign.Theyare
1 Outputofserviceprocessesarenotwelldefined
asmanufacturedproducts.
2 Mostserviceprocessesinvolvegreaterinteraction
withcustomer.
3 Customerscannotdefinetheirneedsforservices
until
aftertheyhavesomereferenceorcomparison.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 11
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
In the following pages, we will see how a primary
function of the bank like account opening, even though
perceived simple, undergoes certain procedures. If this
procedureisnotcarriedouteffectivelyinitially,itresultsin
accumulationofdelaysandbringsdowntheefficiencyofthe
bankandfinallyfailstomeetthecustomer'sexpectation.
In the pages to come, Customer Relationship
Management is leveraged to Account Opening Delays at
HDFCBanktogainaninsightintothebanksproblem.This
detailedreportrelatestheissueofaccountopeningdelaysto
thecustomersperceptionofthebank.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 12
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
INDUSTRYPROFILE
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 13
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
TheIndianBankingIndustry,whichisgovernedbythe
Banking Regulation Act of India, 1949 can be broadly
classifiedintotwomajorcategories,nonscheduledbanksand
scheduledbanks.Scheduledbankscomprisecommercialbanks
andthecooperativebanks.Intermsofownership,commercial
bankscanbefurthergroupedintonationalizedbanks,theState
BankofIndiaanditsgroupbanks,regionalruralbanksand
private sector banks (the old/ new domestic and foreign).
These banks have over 67,000 branches spread across the
country.
Thefirstphaseoffinancialreformsresultedinthe
nationalizationof14majorbanksin1969andresultedina
shiftfromClassbankingtoMassbanking.Thisinturnresulted
inasignificantgrowthinthegeographicalcoverageofbanks.
Everybankhadtoearmarkaminimumpercentageoftheirloan
portfoliotosectorsidentifiedasprioritysectors.
ThefollowingchartgivesthestructureoftheIndianBanking
IndianBankingSystem
ReserveBankofIndia
ScheduledBanks NonscheduledBanks
Indian Foreign
PublicSector PrivateSectorBanks
Banks (Old&New)
Industry
Thefactorsthatinfluencethegrowthofbanksarethefollowing
1. Increaseinnationalincome.
2. Increaseinbankinghabit.
3. Expansioninbankingfacilities.
4. InflowsofdepositsfromNonResidentIndians.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 15
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
EventhoughPublicSectorBankingaccountsfor78%of
totalbankingindustry,usetraditionalwaysofbanking,Private
sectorbankshavepioneeredinternetbanking,phonebanking,
ATMsandsoon..
Thebankingindustryiscurrentlydominatedbythefollowingfive
topplayers
1. HDFCBankheadedbyAdityaPuri
2. ICICIBankheadedbyK.V.Kamath(MD&CEO)
3. StateBankofIndiaheadedbyA.K.Purwar(Chairman)
4. CitibankheadedbyWalterWriston(CEO)
5. CanaraBankheadedbyMr.MBNRao(CMD)
Thefollowingpageswillgiveadetailedinsightinto
HDFCBank,itsmaincompetitorsandwhatproblemsthebank
isfacingwithrespecttoaccountopeningdelays.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 16
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER2:PROFILEOFHDFCBANK
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 17
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
TheHousingDevelopmentFinanceCorporationLimited
(HDFC) was amongst the first to receive an 'in principle'
approval from theReserveBankof India(RBI)tosetupa
bankintheprivatesector,aspartoftheRBI'sliberalisationof
the Indian Banking Industry in 1994. The bank was
incorporated in August 1994 in the name of 'HDFC Bank
Limited',withitsregisteredofficeinMumbai,India.HDFC
BankcommencedoperationsasaScheduledCommercialBank
inJanuary1995.HDFCBankbeganoperationsin1995witha
simplemission:tobea"WorldclassIndianBank".
Its awards and accolades for the year 2005 include the
following
inIndia"
Best
AsiamoneyAwards
Domestic
AsiamoneyAwards Commercia "Companyof
lBank
theYear"
HongKongbasedFinance BestCash Awardfor
Manageme
Asiamagazine Corporate
ntBank
EconomicTimesAwards Excellence
India.
"BestBank 200405.
HDFCBankhasbeennamedBestDomesticBankinIndiainThe
AssetTripleACountryAwards2005.
Currentlytheyhaveanetprofitfortheyearquarterended31 stMarch
2006ofRs.870.8Cr.
Background
BusinessObjectives
OrganisationalGoals
VISIONSTATEMENT
TobuildaworldclassIndianbank.
MISSIONSTATEMENT
Use enabling technologies to provide value added products and
servicestocustomersatvalueformoneyprice.
SUBSIDIARIESANDASSOCIATECOMPANIES
1 HDFCBank
2 HDFCMutualFund
3 HDFCStandardLifeInsuranceCompany
4 HDFCRealty
5 HDFCChubbGeneralInsuranceCompanyLtd.
6 CreditInformationBureau(India)Limited
7 OtherCompaniesCoPromotedbyHDFC
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 20
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
HDFCANDITSCOMPETITORS
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 21
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
The immediate competitor of HDFC Bank is ICICI
Bank. ICICI Bank is India's secondlargest bank with total
assetsofaboutRs.1,676.59billion(US$38.5billion)atMarch
31, 2005 and profit after tax of Rs. 20.05 billion(US$ 461
million) for the year ended March 31, 2005 (Rs. 16.37
billion(US$ 376 million) in fiscal 2004). ICICI Bank has a
network of about 573 branches and extension counters and
over2,000ATMs.ICICIBankoffersawiderangeofbanking
products and financial services to corporate and retail
customersthroughavarietyofdeliverychannelsandthrough
its specialised subsidiaries and affiliates in the areas of
investmentbanking,lifeandnonlifeinsurance,venturecapital
and asset management. ICICI Bank set up its international
bankinggroupinfiscal2002tocatertothecrossborderneeds
ofclientsandleverageonitsdomesticbankingstrengthsto
offer products internationally. ICICI Bank currently has
subsidiaries in the United Kingdom, Canada and Russia,
branchesinSingaporeandBahrainandrepresentativeoffices
intheUnitedStates,China,UnitedArabEmirates,Bangladesh
andSouthAfrica.
ICICI Bank's equity shares are listed in India on the Bombay Stock
Exchange and the National Stock Exchange of India Limited and its
AmericanDepositaryReceipts(ADRs)arelistedontheNewYorkStock
Exchange(NYSE)
ThenextcompetitorbankisStateBankOfIndiaor
SBI.SBIisthelargestbankinIndiawithdepositsofRs
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 22
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
3,67,000croreasonMarch31,2005.ItdominatestheIndian
bankingsectorwithamarketshareofaround20%intermsof
total banking sector deposits. The increasing focus on
upgradingthetechnologybackboneofthebankwillenableit
to leverage its reach better, improve service levels, provide
newdeliveryplatforms,andimproveoperatingefficiencyto
counter the threat of competition effectively. Once the core
bankingsolution(CBS)isfullyimplemented,itwillcoverover
10,000 branches and ATMs of the State Bank group, and
emerge as the strongest technology enabled distribution
networkinIndia.
A/COpeningdelaysatvariousbranchesofthe
bank(Southregion)
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 24
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
OneoftheimportantfunctionsoftheBankistoaccept
depositsfromthepublicforthepurposeoflending.Infact,
depositorsarethemajorstakeholdersoftheBankingSystem.
The depositors and their interests form the key area of the
regulatoryframeworkforbankinginIndiaandthishasbeen
enshrinedintheBankingRegulationAct,1949.TheReserve
BankofIndiaisempoweredtoissuedirectives/adviceson
interestratesondepositsandotheraspectsregardingconduct
ofdepositaccountsfromtimetotime.Withliberalizationin
thefinancialsystemandderegulationofinterestrates,banks
arenowfreetoformulatedepositproductswithinthebroad
guidelinesissuedbytheRBI.
Thispolicydocumentondepositsoutlinestheguiding
principlesinrespectofformulationofvariousdepositproducts
offeredbytheBankandtermsandconditionsgoverningthe
conductoftheaccount.Thedocumentrecognisestherightsof
depositors and aims at dissemination of information with
regardtovariousaspectsofacceptanceofdepositsfromthe
members of the public, conduct and operations of various
deposits accounts, payment of interest on various deposit
accounts,closureofdepositaccounts,methodofdisposalof
deposits of deceased depositors, etc., for the benefit of
customers.Itisexpectedthatthisdocumentwillimpartgreater
transparency in dealing with the individual customers and
createawarenessamongcustomersoftheirrights.Theultimate
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 25
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
objective is that the customer will get services they are
rightfullyentitledtoreceivewithoutdemand.
Asweallknow,theprimaryfunctionofabankisto
acceptfundsfrompublicandhenceforth,anaccountneedsto
becreated.Anaccountopeningforacustomeriseasyasit
involvesjustfillinginaformandsubmittingitwithproperid
proofs.However,forabanktheprocessingoftheapplication
forminvolvesasetofprocedureswithcostsincurredatevery
stage.
TheRBIprescribescertainguidelines,whichthebank
hastonecessarilyfollowwhileopeninganaccount.
Thefollowingflowchartgivesthevariousproceduresinvolved
inopeninganaccountwiththeHDFCBank.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 26
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
AOProcess.igx
Customer
Customer No
Sales Pitch decides to
Start walks into
made open
branch
account
Application
form given to Yes A
customer
No No
B
Customer fills
in Account
Opening Form ID Proof Address proof Photograph
PB contacts
customer for
addnl docs
No
Yes Yes No
Existing Satisfac
Satisfactory Satisfactory
customer tory
Yes No No Yes
Customer
A able to Yes
produce
Manager Manager
Yes Yes addnl Docs
Excepti Excepti
on on
No
Valid customer
No No Customer
id provided
submits form
A Verified
Addnl byDoc
PB
Ac not opened.
MC issued to
Funds parked cust for IP
in Dummy A/c Yes funds
No
Satisfac
tory
PB contacts Customer
Clear No customer to able to No Send
Funds Form returned clear clear docs to Yes
available
to PB exception. exception CPU C
Yes
No
PB Auth
Checks
Courier Control
Application Approved
form for Yes Sheet prepared Send
completeness forms to
CPU
Forms DVU
Forms sent to Returns form to
received at Identifies C
DVU Yes branch
CPU exception
No Puts form No
M.P.BirlaIns on hold anagement Doc
satisfactory for
Form iateBharati VidyaBhavan DVU Yes
Branch seeks Yes
sent to
exception
Imaging approval No Addnl Docs No
B
Dept Reqd Yes
Atthepresalestage,thecustomerhasachoiceofgetting
anInstaAccountforanimmediateaccountnumberorcanfill
intheformforanormalone.
Oncetheformisfilledinbythecustomer,itisverified
by the PB (Personal Banker) and is sent to Chennai for
verification. The PB requires all documents relating to ID
proof, photographs and address proof. Once these are
satisfactory,thefundstoopentheaccountaredepositedina
DummyaccountandtheformissenttoChennaiforfurther
verification.
IntheFulfillstep,DVUisDataVerificationUnitthat
islocatedinChennaiforsouthregion(fornorthandwestbeing
Mumbai). Here, it is seen if the application and documents
comply with the rules of the RBI and depending on the
outcomeeithertheaccountisopenedortheformissentbank
to the branch (can even be put on hold) for additional
documentstobesentin.
The main branches wherein such issues reached an
alarmingratewerethefollowing
1 Sarjapur
2 Jaynagar
3 Indiranagar
4 MGRoad
Thefollowingpageswillcontainadetailedstudyonthebranchesand
solutionswillberecommended.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 28
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER4:PROBLEMSTATEMENT
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 29
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
HDFCBank has379branchesand900ATMsin183
cities.Ithasgrownatablisteringpacesince1995,withitsnet
profitgrowingatanannualisedaveragerateof104percent.Its
retailloanshaverisenfromRs845crorein2001toRs7,325
crore in 2004. Its size is now comparable to some of the
smallerpublicsectorbankswhichdominateIndia'slandscape.
Thebankopens,onanaverageatleast2530accounts
perweekforitscustomerscomparedtoitscompetitorswho
haveanaverageofjust1525(forICICI)and1012(forSBI).
However,therecentchangesintheRBIruleswithrespectto
account opening have reduced the efficiency of the bank
therebycausingdelays.
andfacilitiesprovided.Theserecentchangesbroughtinbythe
RBI with respect to account opening have brought in a
problemofdelayinaccountopening.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 31
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER5:RESEARCH
OBJECTIVE
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 32
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Theprojectisundertakenwiththefollowingobjective
1. Identifyingthebranchesthatareavictimtothe
RBIsnewrules.
2. Identifying the main reasons for the delays in
accountopening.
3. Application of various statistical models to
minimizethedelays.
4. Customerexpectationsabouttheirbankthrougha
surveywiththehelpofaquestionnaire.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 33
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER6:RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 34
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
ThebankhasdividedthesouthregionasS1andS2with
branchesunderit.Someofthesebrancheshaveareallyhigh
rateofdelaysinaccountopening.
Themethodologyusedtoconducttheresearchforthepurpose
ofthisdissertationincludes:
1 Samplesurveyofbankcustomerstogaugeanideaon
CustomerSatisfaction
2 Explorereasonsfordelaysinaccountopening.
3 Studythedatabaseofthebanktogetaninsightintothe
workingofthebankanditspolicies.
Tomaketheaboveobservations,thefollowingtoolsofTotal
QualityManagementwereused
Paretoanalysis isabarchartthatillustratesthefrequency
recurrenceofasetofitems.ItisatechniquebasedonPareto
principleof thevitalfewandtrivialmany.Itisalsocalled
the8020rule.
RootCauseanalysisItisadiagramthatgivesthe
relationshipbetweenqualitycharacteristicanditsfactors.Itis
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 35
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
apictorialrepresentationandisalsocalledFishBoneDiagram
orIshikawadiagram.
QualityFunctionDeployment Itreferstothatconceptthat
integratesafirmsTQMeffortsbyunifyingthefourfunctional
strategies
1. Marketing
2. Sales
3. Productdesign
4. Operationsmanagement
Themainqualitycharacteristicischosenandthemajor
causes for the same are listed. Each cause is analysed
thoroughlytofindthemostinfluentialcauseresultinginpoor
qualityofservicedelivery.Thiswillvaryfromplacetoplace
andenvironmenttoenvironment.
SampleSurveyAquestionnairetitledSERVICEQUALITY
LEVERAGEDTOACQUIRINGNEWCUSTOMERS,RETAINING
EXISTINGCUSTOMERS AND REGAINING THE LOST
CUSTOMERS
Thequestionnaireaimsatgettingaperceptionaboutthe
servicesprovidedbythebanktothecustomersandleverageit
to the efficiency of in account opening. The respondents
includedcustomersfromHDFC,ICICI,SBI,Citibank,Canara
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 36
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
bank. A sample questionnaire is enclosed at the end in
Annexure.
TheZtestwasusedtofindanysignificantdifferences
betweenthesamplemeanandapopulationmean.(Thesample
sizetakenwas50.)Itindicateshowlikelyitisthatasample
with a certain mean and standard deviation came from the
populationbeingstudiedthatithasapopulationmean.
Then,aZtestisappliedtoverifythehypothesis
H0:Thereisnodifferencebetweensamplevaluesandthepopulation
values.
H1:Thereisadifferencebetweensamplevaluesandthepopulation
values.
Theconfidenceleveltakeninthisstudyis95%i.e.zis
greaterthan1.96orlessthan1.96,andthedifferenceisstatistically
significant.Thatis,itissounlikelythatthesamplecamefromthis
population(5%chanceorless)thatwerejectthenullhypothesisand
saythatthesampleisdifferentfromthepopulation.
Allthedatawasfedintoanexcelsheetandnecessary
calculationsforZweredone.Itincludedaverage,median,modeand
standarddeviation.TheinbuiltstatisticalfunctionsforaZtestwas
usedtodeterminethevaluesandconclusionsweredrawnbasedon
thesame.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 37
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
RESEARCHGAP
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 38
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Theresearchincludesanalyzingtheprocessofaccount
opening.Thisprocedureitselfisdividedintoseparatefunctionsand
isdistributeintwoplaces(BangaloreandChennai).Hence,thestudy
isfocusedmainlyonproblemsatBangaloreandtheproblemsfaced
inChennairemainundiscovered.
Also, the survey was used to gauge customers
perceptionsabouttheirbanks,thesizeofthesampleisnotverylarge
andhenceanypredictionsmadeonthepopulation,mayattimesbe
inaccurate.
However,despitethegaps,anefforthasbeenmadeto
throwlightontheprocessofaccountopeningandthedefectsrelated
to it. This had been leveraged to the concept of Customer
RelationshipManagement.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 39
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER7:ANALYSISANDDATA
INTERPRETATION
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 40
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Paretoanalysis
ItwasidentifiedthatcertainbranchesinS1andS2werereachinga
highAODRate(AccountOpeningDelay).Onadetailedstudyitwas
found that the following branches in S1 and S2 were the main
brancheswithhighAODs.TheParetochartsaregivenbelowrelated
toS1andS2.
South 1
25 120.00
20 100.00
15 80.00 In numbers
Values
60.00
10 40.00 Cumalative
5 20.00
0 0.00
Himayat Nagar
Nungambakkam
Sanjeeva Reddy
Secunderabad
Begumpet EC
Chanda Nagar
Mehdipatnam
Gaddianaram
Hyderabad
Jagadamba
Nacharam
Hitec City
RA Puram
Guntur
Centre
Salem
Nagar
Branches
SourceFieldInvestigation
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 41
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
South 2
140 120.00
120 100.00
100
80.00 In numbers
80
60 60.00
40 Cumalative
40.00
20 20.00
0 0.00
d m y d la k t ad
a C t
g ar icu
ro
t
o
E C
i o a n o
at c R P
l
a a R
iv B i
a m T C t
ond
t I r
lar
n
po
t
SS ro a a
m al W t h o r
c g
hd P B le r K A
ic e
E
R
n
n
Ba
Branches
SourceFieldInvestigation
Thestudyindepthisdividedinto4brancheswherein
delays had reached an alarming rate compared to its
competitors.
ThebranchesvisitedwerethatofSarjapur,MGRoad,
JaynagarandIndiranagar,fromwhichrelevantinformationhad
tobeextractedfromtheirdatabase.(Thedataisrangesfrom
4thFebruaryto2nd May).Majorreasonswereidentifiedand
tabulatedtogivethefollowingParetochartsforeachbranch
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 42
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
AtSarjapurBranch,HDFCBank.
30 120.00
25 100.00
20 80.00
in numbers
15 60.00 cumalative
10 40.00
5 20.00
0 0.00
d d s c d h d d d d d
e e r / e g e e ie e ie
t t e a d u t t f r f
la
la
i i i i
la la h v o r u r
t
o n e e e
e e O g e q
r r in r e r r v e v
s e
d p t h t r t
e
l
s r o f
o o p m o g o
r
e tu h in n
r
a a sn t
in sn
a y o l
s d
d t g
n N
f
d d o a
ig a n in t in o n
A S e ie o P u
o g F
ic
r
l h i
f r
f C P O
Au
s
n
SourceFieldInvestigation
Observation
At this branch, most of the account holders were employees of
Wipro.AbankofficialfromthisbranchsitsattheWiproofficeand
handles all queries of the account holders through e mails. On
speakingtotheofficialthere,itwasfoundthattheintroductionletter
tothebankwassignedbytheteamlead.Presently,duetochangein
thecompanypolicies,thesignatureofaseniorlevelmanagementis
required. This causes a delay in the bank procedure of account
opening.Itwasalsofoundthatthebankwasunderstaffed.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 43
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
AtMGRoadBranch,HDFCBank
30 120.00
25 100.00
20 80.00
In numbers
15 60.00
Cumalative
10 40.00
5 20.00
0 0.00
Introduction
Co Info not
Signature
letter/ID
Related
Adress
related
related
Others
Name
Reqd
given
SourceFieldInvestigation
Observation
This branch has a lot of corporate accounts and the value of
transactionsisalsohuge.Duetothisitwasfoundthatmostofthe
delays were caused by no proper introduction letter or ID proof
(Refer graph). Either the company information was inadequate or
therewasasignaturemismatch.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 44
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
AtJaynagarbranch,HDFCBank.
14 120.00
12 100.00
10
80.00
8 In numbers
60.00
6 Cumalative
40.00
4
2 20.00
0 0.00
Boardresolution isselfattestedCodedifers(productandLCcode)PermanentaddreqdinAMLform
Name related
Branch codenotindicated
Addressrelated(142&143)Introductionletternotgiven/ID
FD related
Signaturerelated
SourceFieldInvestigation
Observation
Thisbrancheventhoughwaswellmanaged;thewokloadseemedto
beveryheavyonallworkingdaysofthebank.Thehighestrateof
delayswascausedbysignaturemismatch.Theincreaseofworkload
seemedtobethemajorcauseofreducingtheefficiencyofthebank.
Also, the new concept of AML form seemed to cause a lot of
inconveniencetothecustomers(referGlossaryforthemeaningof
AML).
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 45
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
AtIndiranagarbranch,HDFCBank
30 120.00
25 100.00
20 80.00
In numbers
15 60.00
cumalative
10 40.00
5 20.00
0 0.00
s d rs d s d ) d 0 y
D 83
ed e
e
te fer e e 6 r
F
la
t t t
la
t t
fund to m
f
la la h la
g a
i
re e d e rm
t
re d o r r in o
s
nt
t
. s e e s ub /f g
e te s n d
o s n in
co
g t
ici la e si m p d a is
f e r co a o i P
su er
r d N x
d n e
in
A p
o
r
op
n
SourceFieldInvestigation
Observation
Thisbranchwasthemostunorganizedofalltheabove.Thework
loadwasveryhighandthestaffwasunabletocopeuptothework
pressure.Therewasnopropercoordinationbetweentheemployees
andcustomerskeptcomingbackwithcomplaintsthatirkedthestaff
aswellasthecustomers.
TheaboveParetochartsrepresentthereasonsforwhich
theapplicationformswererejectedwiththecontributionsof
each reason indicated in the dotted lines. The meaning of
certainbankingtermsareindicatedintheglossaryattheend.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 46
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
RootCauseAnalysis
This approach was used to analyse, in detail, the reasons that
contribute to the delays in account opening. On observing the
customerdatabaseandworkingofthebanks,thefollowingFishBone
Diagramwasformed.
Employees Training
Customers
4 8
1
5
2
6 9
3 Account
7 OpeningDelays
(AOD)
10
13
11
14
12
External Management
Factors Policies
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 47
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
ThenumbersintheRootCauseDiagramindicatedthefollowingsub
causes.Thesesubcausesarearesultofobservationsandanalysisof
databaseatthe
SubreasonNumber Reason
1 Customersareinhurry
2 Customersareilliterate
3 Customerneedstobeeducatedonbank
needsandrequirements
4 Increaseofworkload
5 Reductioninefficiencydueto
miscommunications
6 Multitasking
7 Communicationgaps
8 Orientation
9 Fundamentalsnotclear
10 ChangeinRBIguidelines
11 Breakdownofsupportsystems
12 Otheruncontrollablefactors
13 Lengthyproceduresforjustaverification
14 Applicationformislabourioustofill
Thesubreasonsidentifiedarearesultofobservingtheprocessthe
bankfollowstoopenanaccount.Themainreasonsaretheparties
involvedinaccountopening.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 48
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
ThefollowingdiagramgivesanotheraspecttoAODthatmayresult
in service switching behaviour that needs to be avoided in any
organisation.
SERVICESWITCHINGDIAGRAM
Inconvenience Responseto
ServiceFailure
Service
Switching
Behaviour
Service Competition
Encounter CoreService
Failures Failures
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 49
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
TheheadInconvenienceincludes
1 Locationortimeslotsallotted
2 Waitingforservice
TheheadServiceEncounterFailureincludes
1 Uncaring
2 Impolite
3 Unknowledgeable
TheheadResponsiveServiceFailureincludes
1 Negativeresponse
2 Reluctantresponse
TheheadCompetitionincludes
Foundbetterserviceelsewhere
TheheadCoreServiceFailureincludes
1 Servicemistakes
2 Processingerrors
3 Servicecatastrophe
Thesurveyconductedwillrevealifthebanksservicessufferfrom
anyoftheabovetraits.Also,itwillaimatmeasuringthelevelof
satisfactionthecustomers havewhenitcomestotransactingwith
theirbank.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 50
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Surveywithquestionnaire
Thehypothesisisframedasfollows
H0:Thereisnodifferencebetweensamplevaluesandthepopulation
values.
H1:Thereisadifferencebetweensamplevaluesandthepopulation
values.
ThefollowingfindingsshowthatH0isaccepted.
Thesurveydone,revealedthefollowingfindings.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 51
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Table1
Thetablewillcorrelatethetimetakenbythethreebanks(HDFC,
ICICIandSBI)toopenanaccount.Thiswillshowtheefficiencyof
thebanksandwillindicatewhichbankhasacompetitiveadvantage.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 52
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Graph1
8
7
6 Instantly
5
4 Within one hour
3 Within one day
2
1 More than 2 days
0
HDFC ICICI SBI
Bank
Canara
Statements HDFC ICICI SBI Citibank Bank
Promptservice 6 6.16 5.83 7.83 6.11
Courteousemployees 6.87 5.83 6.167 7.5 6.17
Caringemployees 5.89 5.5 5.33 7.33 5.67
Servicesatpromisedtime 7 6.167 4.83 8.33 6.11
Visuallyappealing 6.5 6.67 4.83 6.5 5.89
Willingnesstohelp 6.7 5.67 6.167 7.67 6.22
Instillsconfidence 6.78 6.167 5.167 6.5 6.56
Feelsafewhiletransacting 8.11 6.167 7 7.67 7.64
SourceFieldInvestigation
Graph2
time
Perceived
service transacting
levels of Char
10 HDF
customers acteri
8 C
from their stics
6
4
banks
2 ICICI
0 SBI
Citiba
nk
Canara
Bank
SourceFieldInvestigation
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 54
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Interpretation
WeseethatHDFCisperceivedtobethesafestbankwhileCitibank
isperceivedtobethemostpromptbank.ThisisbecauseCitibank
encouragesnet bankingandimposesafineonthecustomer if he
enters the branch for a simple query. ICICI though is a close
competitorofHDFC.However,itwasfoundinthesurveythatthe
traits of courteous employees and caring for customers were
deteriorating. SBI is not perceived to be visually appealing. Old
customersareusedtothebankswaysandaresatisfied.However,the
newcustomersexpectmorefromthebank.
6.78
5.5
6.73
7
6
Table3 SourceField
Overal Investigation
Nameofbank l
HDFC rating
ICICI ofthe
SBI bank
Citibank (outof
CanaraBank 9)
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 55
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Graph3
8
6.78 6.73 7
7 6
6 5.5
5
4
3
2
1
0
HDFC ICICI SBI Citibank Canara Bank
SourceFieldInvestigation
Interpretation
QFDisanexcellentwayofcapturingvoiceofcustomers.It
referstobothdeterminingwhatwillsatisfythecustomerand
secondly,translatingthosecustomerdesiresintothetargetdesign.In
themanufacturingindustry,itisusedearlyintheproductionprocess
todeterminewhatwillsatisfythecustomerandalsowheretodeploy
qualityefforts.
ThetwotermsessentialhereareExpectedqualityandExciting
quality.Expectedqualityinthisresearchreferstothefactthat
customersexpecttheiraccounttobeopenedinadayortwo.Exciting
qualityreferstotraitsthatacustomerdoesnotexpectandenhances
thevalueoftheproductorprocess.
TheQFDprocessislinkedbythefollowingmatrices
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 57
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
TheQualityFunctionDeploymentProcess
4 1
Operating Customer
Instructions Requirement
Planning
Matrix
3 2
ProcessPlan Technical
andQuality Features
Control Deployment
Charts Matrix
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 58
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
In the first matrix of Customer Requirements and Planning
identificationofexpectedandexcitingqualityisdone.Inthesurvey
itwasrevealedthatcustomerswantedtheiraccountstobeopened
instantlyorhardlyinaday.Toprovideforexcitingquality,HDFC
hasofferedschemestoaccountopeningtoaddvaluetoitsservices.
Technicalfeaturesdeploymentcontrolsthecriticalprocesses
withthehelpofqualitycontrolchartsandprocessplans.
Thefinalstepofoperatinginstructionsensuresthatthebankers
contributetothefirmseffortstomeettherequirementssetdownin
theprocessesandservicesparameters.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 59
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
CHAPTER8:
RECOMMENDATIONS
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 60
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Themaincausesofdelaysareidentifiednow.Ifthevery
initialstepoffillingintheapplicationformistakencareof,
the rate of delays will reduce. It resembles the proverb A
battlewellbegunishalfwon.
Hencethefollowingsuggestionsarerecommended
1 Separatetimeslotscanbeallottedinitiallyforaccepting
application forms, or even a separate counter can be
maintainedatthebeginningtofacilitateindividualattention.
Thisassistanceprovidedtothecustomerwillmakesurethat
theformwillbedefectfree.
2 Alldetailsregardingtheidproofcanbeexplainedto
him.Itwasfoundinthesurveythatmanyofthemforgethow
theyhavesignedintheapplicationform.Hence,acounterfoil
canbegiventothecustomerthatcontainshissignaturethathe
canrefertoinfutureifheforgetsthewayhehassigned.Also,
thebankcanexplaintheirinabilitytothecustomertoprocess
theapplicationformifhissignaturediffersfromthedocuments
presentedforidproof.Insuchcases,afreshformisfilledthat
irksthecustomertoo.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 61
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
1 If the bank is not able to do the above, then when the
applicationformishandedover tothecustomer,aseparate
instructiontitledHelpusserveYoubettercanbegiventhat
containsalltherequirementsofthebankwithrespecttotypes
ofidproofsneededandotherrequirementsbasedoncustomer
type(i.e.individual,joint,companyaccountsetc.)
2 ThePersonalBankerneedstoverifythedocumentsbefore
itissenttotheheadofficeatChennai.Ifheisdoubtfulabout
theformbeingaccepted,(yetitissentChennai)hemayaskthe
customertokeepadditionaldocumentsreadyasidproofrather
thanwaittilltheformissentbacktotherespectivebranch.
3 Whenthecustomerisaskedtofillintheapplicationform,it
hastobefoundoutifheisanexistingoranewcustomer.
Existingcustomers detailsarealreadykeyedintothesystem
andhencethebankcantakeadvantageofthisandreducethe
timetakentoprocesstheaccountopening.Separateapplication
forms can be designed for existing customers and the
processingofthesecanbedivertedtoaseparatedepartmentso
thattheDataVerificationUnitandImagingdepartmentscan
concentrate on the forms of new customers. This will also
reduce the work load of the departments and increase
efficiencyandaccuracy.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 62
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
1 In the survey, customers revealed that they found the
fillinginofapplicationformsalabouriousjob.Also,theywere
apprehensive about filling in the form by themselves and
preferredtofillin,inthepresenceofabankofficialtoavoid
mistakes. Hence the bank can encourage net banking or
simplify the application form to reduce the customers
apprehensions.
ItcanbesaidthatHDFCBankisoneofthemostpopular
banks when it comes to customer satisfaction despite its
conventionalmethodofbanking.Itlivesuptoitspunchline
Unmatchedfeatures.Worldclassservices.ItisIndiasleading
privatesectorbank.(Anestablishedbrandinitself.)
Acustomerentersintoabankwithadecisiontoopenan
accountonlyifhefeelsitissafetotransactwithitandifhe
feels that the bank will live up to his expectations. Hence,
account opening procedures can be simplified by the above
suggestionsandpointstoponderonarehighlightedintheRoot
CausediagramandtheServiceSwitchingDiagram.
Macrolevelrecommendations:
1 Providethebankemployeesfirsthandbestcorporate
practices
2 Expose the bank employees to the environment in
whichthebankcustomersusethebank'sservices
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 64
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
1 Constantly retrain the bank staff in the theory and
practiceofTQM
2 Showcasethecustomerquality
3 EstablishacontinuousimprovementcultureintheBank
4 Initiatevigorouslycontinuousprocessimprovementin
theBank.Theprocessimprovementcanbebroughtabout
by;
5 (a)Breakthroughthinking;
6 (b)processstabilization;and
7 (c)Incrementalimprovement.
8 Thefollowingtoolsforcontinuousimprovementinthe
qualityofserviceintheBankarequitehelpful:
1. Brainstorming
2. Processmapping
3. Causeandeffectdiagrams
4. Askingwhy(fivetimes)
5. Checksheets
6. Paretoanalysis
7. Matrixanalysis
8. Consensusbuilding
9. Pairedcomparisons/emphasisoncurveranking
10.Forcefieldanalysis
11.Teampurposeanalysis
12.Cost/benefitanalysis
13.Prioritiesgrid
14.Timecostanalysis
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 65
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
ANNEXURE
Asamplequestionnaireisgivenbelowthatwasusedinthesurvey.
MPBirlaInstituteofManagement
Bangalore
(AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan)
IamastudentofMPBirlaInstituteofManagement,
Bangalore,pursuingmyMBAprogram.Asapartofthe
MBAcurriculum,Ihavetakenuparesearchprojecton
ServiceQualityLeveragedtoacquiringnewcustomers,
retainingexistingcustomersandregainingthelost
customers.InthisconnectionIneedsomeinformationfrom
you.Thequestionnaireis,herewith,enclosed.Kindlygive
yourresponsestothequestions.Isincerelyassureyouthat
yourresponseswillbekeptstrictlyconfidentialandshall
onlybeusedforacademicpurpose.Ishallgreatlyappreciate
yourcooperation.
MsDarshanaPatel
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 66
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
SERVICEQUALITYLEVERAGEDTOACQUIRINGNEW
CUSTOMERS,RETAININGEXISTINGCUSTOMERS
ANDREGAININGTHELOSTCUSTOMERS
(AresearchprojectforHDFCBank,Bangalore)
Name:
Gender:
Age:
Occupation:
NameofyourBank:
Typeofaccountheld:
1 SavingsBank
2 Currentaccount
3 TermDeposit
4 RecurringDeposit
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 67
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Timetakenbyyourbanktoopenyouraccount:
1 Instantly
2 Withinonehour
3 Withinoneday
4 Morethantwodays
Howlonghaveyoubeenacustomer:
1 Lessthanayear
2 Onetotwoyears
3 Twotofiveyears
4 Morethanfiveyears
PARTI
Iwouldliketoknowyourimpressionabouthowwellyourbank
providesservicesrelativetoyourexpectations.Pleasethinkaboutthe
2levelsofexpectationsdefinedbelow:
MinimumServiceLevel:Theminimumlevelofserviceyouconsider
adequate.
DesiredServiceLevel:Thelevelofserviceperformanceyoudesire.
Foreachofthefollowingstatementspleaseindicate
(a)yourminimumservicelevelbyencirclingoneofthenumbers
inthefirstcolumn.
(b)yourdesiredservicelevelbyencirclingoneofthenumbersinthe
secondcolumn
(c)yourperceptionofservicebyencirclingoneofthenumbersinthe
thirdcolumn.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 68
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
When Myminimumlevelof MyDesiredlevel MyPerception
it serviceis: ofserviceis: ofperformance
comes is:
to
1.Prompt 1 23456789 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2345 67
serviceto 9 8 9
customers
2.Employees 1 23456789 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2345 67
whoare 9 8 9
consistently
courteous
3.Employees 1 23456789 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2345 67
dealwith 9 8 9
customersin
caringfashion
4.Provides 1 2 3 45 6 78 9 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2 345 67
serviceat 9 8 9
promisedtime
5.Visually 1 23456789 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2345 67
appealing 9 8 9
materials
associated
withservices
(eg.inbank
signs)
6.Willingness 1 2 3 45 6 78 9 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2 345 67
tohelp 9 8 9
customers
7.Employees 1 2 3 45 6 78 9 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2 345 67
instill 9 8 9
confidencein
customers
8.Making 1 2 3 45 6 78 9 1 2 3 4 5 678 1 2 345 67
customers 9 8 9
feelsafein
transactions
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 69
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
PARTII
1.Howwouldyouratetheoverallqualityofservicesprovidedbythe
bank?
(Circleonenumberbelow)
Extremelypoor Extremelygood
1 23456789
2.Listedbeloware5generalfeaturespertainingtothebankand
servicesitoffers.Iwouldliketoknowhowimportanteachofthese
featuresaretoyou.Pleaseallocateatotalof100pointsamongthe
following5features
Pleasebesurethatthepointsyougiveaddupto100
1.Theappearanceofthebanksphysicalfacilities,Fixtures,
personnelandcommunicationsmaterial__________
points
2.Thebanksabilitytoperformthepromisedservicesdependably
andaccurately__________points
3.Thebankswillingnesstohelpthecustomersandprovideprompt
services__________
points
4.Theknowledgeandcourtesyofthebanksemployeesand
theirabilitytoconveythrustandconfidence__________
points
5.Thecaring,individualizedattentionthebankprovidestoyou
__________points
TotalPointsallocated 100Points
THANKYOUFORSPARINGYOURVALUABLETIMEINGIVING
YOURRESPONSES
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 70
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
GLOSSARY
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 71
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Thestudyincludesfewbankingterminologies.Theirmeaningsare
givenbelow
1 NoPostingFundsthatneedtobeparkedindummy
accountarenotyetdonei.e.notposted.
2 AMLAntiMoneyLaundering.Asetofprocedures,laws
3 Panform60PermanentAccountNumberisanumber
by which the Assessing Officer can identify any person.
PresentlytheIncomeTaxDepartmentisallottingPANunder
the New Series to all assessees which consists of ten
alphanumeric characters and is issued in the form of a
laminated card. The General Index Register Number is a
number given an Assessing Officer to the assessees in the
GeneralIndexRegistermaintainedbyhimwhichalsocontains
thedesignationandtheparticularsoftheAssessingOfficer
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 72
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
BIBLIOGRAPHY
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 73
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Thisresearchprojectiswellsupportedbyfactsfromthefollowing
journalsandwebsites
Books:
1 "Total Quality Management" by Mr. Sridhar Bhatt (7 th
Edition)
2 "BanksandFinancialInstitutions"byMr.LMBhole
,TataMcGrawHillPublications,4thEdition
4 "HowtoLeadYourBusinessBeyondTQM"byMichel
EJoyce,PitmanPublications,1995
WebsitesUsed:
1 www.google.com
2 www.hdfcbank.com
3 www.businessweek.com
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 75
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
DIRECTIONSFORFURTHER
RESEARCH
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 76
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
Basedonourresearchfindings,Igivebelowfertileareasforfuture
research:
1 EnergizingtheCustomerCarethroughTQM
2 Making World Class Performance a Reality through
TQM
3 Bench marking the Best Corporate Practices in the
ApplicationofTQMintheBankingSector
4 CascadingEffectsofTQMonthePerformanceofBanks
5 Using Banking Resources Effectively through Total
QualityManagement
6 TotalQualityControlTheJapaneseWayintheBanking
Sector
7 AppropriateToolsofTQMinBankingOperations
8 FlowChartingtheCustomerServiceOperationsthrough
TQMinBankingSector
Inourview,theaforesaidareasconstitute'greenpasture'forfuture
researchinthisvitalsegmentoftheBankingSector.Perhapstheline
ofthinking,onwhichour researchinvestigationisbased,isquite
helpful.
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 77
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan
M.P.BirlaInstituteofManagement 78
AssociateBharatiyaVidyaBhavan