Você está na página 1de 6

Freezing/thawing curves and characterization of porous network by a

capacitive sensor based apparatus

Antonin Fabbri, Teddy Fen-Chong & Olivier Coussy

Institut Navier LMSGC, France

ABSTRACT: A capacitive sensor-based apparatus is used to study the ice-water phase change in consolidated
porous media subject to freezing and thawing. This technique relies on the dielectric properties of water, ice,
air, and mineral substrate in the radio-frequency range. A semi-empirical method based on the Lichtenecker
model and on comparison between drying and freezing tests, provides an accurate estimation of the temperature-
dependent liquid water amount in frozen porous materials. This is then analyzed through thermoporometry
concepts to characterize pore size distribution and specific surface area. The results obtained are roughly in the
same order range than those obtained from gravimetric sorption/desorption isotherms.


Damage induced by frost action upon concrete struc-

tures is a source of main concern in cold climates
(Pigeon 1984; Dash, Fu, and Wettlaufer 1995). The
mechanical response of a porous material is cred-
ited to result from the combination of the liquid-solid
expansion, the transport of unfrozen liquid water
through the porous network, and the presence of air
voids (Wang, Monteiro, Rubinsky, and Arav 1996).
A poromechanics-based approach has been recently
worked out to understand and quantify the phenomena
both at the pore scale (Coussy and Fen-Chong 2005)
and at the material scale (Coussy 2005). Whatever the
approach carried out, the freezing/thawing curve, that Figure 1. Schematic diagram of the capacitive sensorbased
is the saturation degree of unfrozen water versus tem- apparatus.
perature, turns out to be the key curve governing the
mechanical behaviour of porous materials upon frost
action. Freezing of cement based materials is usually similar materials have been described in (Fen-Chong,
studied with low temperature calorimetry (Bager and Fabbri, Guilbaud, and Coussy 2004). A preliminary
Sellevold 1986). However, this device only allows to work on freezing and thawing study of cement paste,
test very small specimens (characteristic length round stones, and fused glass beads, has been presented in
the millimeter) which are often crushed. Hence, tests (Fen-Chong, Fabbri, and Gaulard 2005).
on non-crushed heterogeneous materials like mortar The capacitive method is based on the contrast
and concrete (aggregate characteristic length round the between water (about 80) and ice (about 3) dielec-
centimeter) should be difficult to set up. tric constants in the radio-frequency range. A sample
Alternatively, it is possible to use a dielectric is inserted between two plane and circular stainless
method, which is less expensive and allows to test big- steel electrodes connected to a cryostat as sketched in
ger and heavier specimens. This paper presents the use figure 1. These are connected in parallel to a 30 MHz
of a spectroscopic-like dielectric capacitive method 50 MHz oscillator circuit, which forms an oscillat-
for studying the ice/water phase change in cohesive ing circuit. The experimental apparatus measures the
porous media such as cement paste, mortar and con- reduced frequency ( f ), which depends on the sample
crete. The experimental set-up, calibration, and use capacitance. Because a plane capacitance is propor-
for studying the drying (air/water phase change) of tionate to the real dielectric constant of the sample,

Copyright 2005 Taylor & Francis Group plc, London, UK
any liquid water variation inside the porous network
of the material results in resonant frequency variation.



The experimental apparatus gives the f T relation

that can be expressed as a T relation, with T the
electrodes temperature and the dielectric constant
of the sample. To get the freezing curve, a rela-
tion between and the liquid water saturation ratio
Sw must be established. To do so, after a review of
some classical multi-scale schemes (Zakri, Laurent,
Figure 2. Comparison between measured and calculated
and Vauclin 1998; Fen-Chong, Fabbri, Guilbaud, and dielectric constants of a non-saturated porous medium. The
Coussy 2004), the Lichtenecker model was chosen. calculation is made using the three-phase Lichtenecker model
This model comes from the Effective Medium The- with = in (3), thus leading to (4).
ory in which the self-consistent scheme is adopted.
It assumes that the geometrical shape of ellipsoidal
inclusions follows a probability density beta function, 3 TESTED MATERIALS
characterized by a parameter () ranging between 1
and 1. This finally gives (the proof is summarized in Cement paste with water-cement ratio of 0.5 are pre-
reference (Zakri, Laurent, and Vauclin 1998): pared with a 5-liter mortar mixer and cast in cylinder
moulds with a 40 mm diameter and 100 mm high.
Ordinary Portland Cement CEM I CPA 52.5 N CP2
and distilled water is used. One day after casting,
specimens are removed from their mould and stored
in moist condition (relative humidity rh = 95% 5%)
When = 1 the pores (void inclusions) are parallel to during 6 months. Then they are cut in about 15 mm
the external field, while for = 1 they are perpendic- slices before being put in water until testing. Speci-
ular to the external field. The previous expression does mens were saturated with degassed distilled water at
not apply for = 0 for which no particular shape nor 3 kPa air pressure and tested. Before saturation, some
orientation is privileged with regard to the direction specimens (index d) were dried in an oven at 70 C
of the external field. For such a completely disor-
dered medium the Lichtenecker model provides in
the form: 3.1 Freezing-thawing curves
The equation (4) was obtained at = 20 C at which
the matrix and pore water dielectric constants, m and
w , are both known. Actually, the in-situ dielectric con-
stant of in-pore liquid water varies with ionic strength
Let consider the pore volume filled both by liquid (Barthel, Hetzenauer, and Buchner 1992) and adsorp-
water, with dielectric constant w , and by a non wet- tion (Mercury, Vieillard, and Tardy 2001), which in
ting component (ice or air), with dielectric constant turn depends on temperature and saturation. Further-
nw to be an effective medium. If no particular pore more the change in the dielectric constant of non-
shape nor orientation is assumed to be privileged, the evaporable water with temperature will significantly
overall dielectric constant constant w,nw of the porous affect the matrix dielectric constant. As a consequence
material can be expressed from (1) and (2) as: a further relation is needed between w,nw, Sw and .
The in-pore water of cement paste in the range of low
liquid saturation degrees Sw < 0.5 was experimentally
found not to freeze down to 45 C. This was previ-
So as to evaluate , drying test at 20 C were performed ously observed by (Kaufmann 1999). Assuming that
on sandstones, fused glass beads and W/C = 0.5 ordi- no pore water evaporation takes place during cooling/
nary Portland cement paste. As sketched on figure 2, heating cycle on such low saturated samples in the
a linear relation is found between and Sw , which temperature range [0 C; 45 C], it becomes possi-
is well accounted for by letting = in (3), thus ble to experimentally determine the missing relation
we get: between the (initial) liquid water degree saturation, the
temperature, and the sample dielectric constant w,a ,
where index a refers to air.

Copyright 2005 Taylor & Francis Group plc, London, UK
3.2 Dielectric constants of unsaturated cement
The changes in the dielectric constant w,a with respect
to temperature were first determined at liquid satura-
tion degree Sw held constant. Samples with different
liquid saturation degrees Sw were prepared by con-
serving initially dried specimens in an oven at 70 C
during 6 months, within atmospheres at various con-
trolled humidity rh = 12%, 33%, 44%, 85%, and 100%
by using salt solutions (Raoof 1998). This procedure
provided samples with liquid water saturation degrees
Sw = 0.12, 0.17, 0.18, 0.49 and 1 respectively. The
sample dielectric constant w,a was then determined
from 20 C to 5 C for Sw = 100%, and from 20 C
to 40 C for Sw = 0.12, 0.17, 0.18, 0.49. It must be
again stressed out that these temperature ranges were
allowed since primary freezing occurs only at 5 C for
saturated cement pastes, and no freezing is observed Figure 3. Evolution of the apparent dielectric constant and
for unsaturated cement pastes with Sw < 0.5 before its derivation with temperature at a fixed saturation ratio for
45 C. Whatever the porous material tested here, the cement paste P5-1d.
relation between the dielectric constant w,a and the
temperature was found to be linear (see figure 3A for
cement paste P5-1d), so that the corresponding slope
a(Sw ) is a function of liquid saturation only. Further-
more, as reported in figure 3B, a(Sw ) curve was found
to be a line. We finally write:

with a  0.225 C1 and b  0.002 C1 .

Irrespective to the previous experiments the
changes in the dielectric constant w,a with respect to
liquid saturation Sw were then determined at temper-
ature held constant. By varying the relative humidity
rh, drying tests were performed at different tempera-
tures (6 drying tests from 20 C to 5 C). As found
in (Fen-Chong, Fabbri, Guilbaud, and Coussy 2004)
and reported in figure 4A for cement paste P5-1d, all
tests provide a linear relation between the dielectric
Figure 4. Evolution of the apparent dielectric constant and
constant w,a and the liquid saturation degree Sw . As
its derivation with saturation at a fixed temperature for
a consequence, the corresponding slope b is a func- cement paste P5-1d.
tion of temperature only. Furthermore, as reported
in figure 4B, b () is found to be a line. We finally
write: where coefficients a, b, c, d are specific to the tested
porous material. Their determination requires two tests
only: cooling of a fully saturated sample (Sw = 1) down
to the primary freezing, and a cooling test of a dried
with a  0.227 C1 and c  20.158. sample (Sw = 0) down to 45 C.
2 w,a
The Maxwell symmetry-like relation Sw
= Then combining (4) and (7) the freezing/thawing
2 behaviour of porous media can be described by:
a  a = 0.23 so obtained confirms the

existence of a material relation linking w,nw , Sw and

only. This was also observed for stone and fused bead
glass samples. For the tested porous materials, we can
where A = a b(i 1); B = bi ; C = c d(i 1)
eventually write:
and D = di . Once the changes in w,i with
respect to experimentally determined temperature,

Copyright 2005 Taylor & Francis Group plc, London, UK

4.1 Relation between freezing temperature and

pore distribution
Both LMSGC home-made gravimetric sorption/
desorption apparatus (SD) and thawing curve analy-
sis via thermoporometry using capacitive sensor based
device (CS) allow to reach the pore distribution from
20 to 200 . For SD, the pore radius distribution was
obtained from a sorption Sw pc (rh) capillary curve
of a 30 mg crushed sample using the BJH method,
detailed in (Barrett, Joyner, and Halenda 1951). For
CS, it was obtained from a thawing test using thermo-
dynamical and mechanical equilibrium between ice
crystal and liquid water. Thawing test is preferred
to freezing one in this study because metastabil-
ity phenomena occurs in the latter (Scherer 1993).
Thermodynamical equilibrium induces the equality of
their chemical potentials. Neglecting the variation of
ionic concentration of the liquid solution, compressive
heat influence, variation of heat capacity and assum-
ing density of ice and water be equal and constant
Figure 5. Freezing (upper graph) and thawing (lower graph) (i = w = 0 ) basic thermodynamics gives:
of W /C = 0.5 cement paste submitted to different curing

semi-empirical relation (8) gives the means to deter-

mine the thermodynamic state function linking Sw to .
with T0 the bulk melting temperature, pc the capillary
pressure defined as the difference of pressure from the
3.3 Results
less wettable phase to the more wettable (pc = pi pw ),
Figure 5 shows the estimated liquid water saturation Sf = 0 (sw0 si0 ) the entropy of fusion per unit of crys-
ratio variation with temperature during the cooling tal volume Cf = 0 (cp,w cp,i ) the heat capacity differ-
and heating stages of cement paste samples. Satura- ence between water and ice per unit of crystal volume,
tion varies almost linearly with temperature, except and g the function which links univocally pc to T .
around some particular temperatures where the slope From now, pores will be supposed to be cylindrical.
changes significantly. The linear saturation variation is In this case, ice crystal thaws from cylindrical interface
related to the progressive freezing (resp. thawing) of (Setzer 1997). Thus, mechanical equilibrium of the
the water (resp. ice) contained in the connected pores ice/water interface (Young-Laplace law) gives:
which are sufficiently big (resp. small) to freeze (resp.
thaw). The saturation slope change is due to an impor-
tant water/ice phase change. For P5-1d, an important
freezing peak is observed around 8 C and a minor
second one around 43 C. The presence of these two where is the water/ice interface energy, rp the pores
peaks is in good agreement with results reported for radii and e the unfreezable water layer length. Combi-
the same kind of paste by (Kaufmann 1999; Bjaoui, nation of (9) and (10) finally gives the relation linking
Revertegat, and Bournazel 2002). On P5-2, the first the thawing temperature and pore radius in which
freezing peak around 8 C is almost absent while two melting occurs:
others (around 28 C and 43 C) are much more
pronounced. Similar results were obtained on virgin
pastes by (Sellevold and Bager 1980). Our data are then
compared with low temperature calorimetry ones on
the same kind of specimen. Comparison on ice content As Sw is linked to the volume of frozen pores Vi by the
at each freezing peak between our data and (Sellevold relation Sw = 1 Vpores
, (11) allows to easily express
and Bager 1980) ones leads to measured relative dif-
ferences smaller than 20%. Hence, a good agreement the pore radius distribution curve (rp ) = dr
(rp ) from
is found. the Sw T curve. Samples used for comparison are of

Copyright 2005 Taylor & Francis Group plc, London, UK
3 Table 1. Comparison between surface area
values from capacitive sensor based apparatus
Capacitive device
Sorption device (CS), MIP and sorption/desorption test (SD) in
m2 /g.

2 Paste MIP CS SD
dVi /drp [mm3/A/g]

1.5 P5-1d 16.81 82.38 145.46

Sw Sw, min , with Sw,min the volumic proportion
of unfreezable water. Thus, for cylindrical assumed
pores, using (14):
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200
Pore radius [A]

Figure 6. Comparison between pore radius distribution

from thermoporometry using CS and from sorption isotherm
using SD for W /C = 0.5 cement paste. Specific area values from capacitive sensor based
apparatus (CS) experimental data using (15) are com-
the same batch and conserved in the same condition pared with MIP and sorption/desorption test ones for
(P5-1ds conditions). Numerical applications are made an W/C = 0.5 cement paste. The used specimens are
with: Sf = 1, 2 MJ/(Kg.K), Cf 2, 1 MJ/(Kg.K), from the same batch and are cured in the same way.
e = 9 (Brun, Lallemand, Quinson, and Eyraud MIP values are obtained using the Rootare and Pren-
1977) T0 = 270 K (estimated from Raoult Law) and zlow equation (Rootare and Prenzlow 1967). Sorption/
= 36 + 0.25(T T0 ) (Zuber and Marchand 2004). desorption test ones are from BET theory analy-
Results obtained by SD or CS are shown in figure 6. sis (Brunauer, Emmett, and Teller 1938). Numerical
From experimental results, our dielectric device seems applications are made with = 1.62 g/cm3 values
to be precise enough to characterize the fine porous given in 4.1 . Results are reported in table 1.
distribution of a cementitious material. The CS values appear to be strongly higher than
MIP ones. This large gap can be explained by the dam-
4.2 Determination of freezable porous network age caused by the high pressure needed for the MIP
surface area experiment and the inability of the latter to scan finer
porosity. Actually the mercury-injection porosimetry
The specific surface area of an elementary cylindri- technique is known to underestimate the specific area
cal pore with radius rp can be expressed as (Quinson, (Raoof 1998). Furthermore, the lower values provided
Astier, and Brun 1987): by the CS experiment by comparison to the SD exper-
iment can be attributed to the screening effect of
unfreezable water with regard to the roughness of the
internal walls of the porous network. In addition, the
CS cooling test is restricted to 45 C whereas ice
 the dry density of the porous medium and formation is still observed down to 80 C (Jehng,
d wi the ice/water surface per unit of porous medium Sprague, and Halperin 1996).
volume expressed from Laplace Law as:


A spectroscopic-like dielectric capacitive apparatus

Note that (13) assumes that the solid matrix is unde- was set-up in order to experimentally determine the
formable. Combining (12) and (13), the explored thermodynamic state relation relying the ice content
specific surface area can be evaluated by the relation: on the current temperature. This quantitative method
has been successfully applied to centimetric cement
paste samples by combining the results provided
by drying tests and freezing tests. The experimen-
tal results agree well with the data existing in the
Measurable specific area of all freezable porous literature obtained independently on the same kind
network (A in m2 /g) will be the value of for of specimens by low temperature calorimetry. Pore

Copyright 2005 Taylor & Francis Group plc, London, UK
radii distribution and specific surface area are found dielectric constant in porous media by the capacitive
to be consistent with those obtained on similar sam- method. Comptes- Rendus Mecanique 332, 639645.
ples from sorption/desorption isotherms by means of Jehng, J., D. Sprague, and W. Halperin (1996). Pore struc-
a homemade apparatus. ture of hydrating cement paste by magnetic resonance
relaxation analysing and freezing. Magnetic Resonance
Imaging 14(7/8), 785791.
Kaufmann, J. (1999). Experimental identification of damage
REFERENCES mechanisms in cementitious porous materials on phase
transition of pore solution under frost deicing salt attack.
Bager, D. and E. Sellevold (1986). Ice formation in hardened Ph. D. thesis, cole Polytechnique Fdrale de Lausanne,
cement paste - part II : Drying and resaturation on room Ecublens, CH-1015 Lausanne.
temperature cured pastes. Cement and Concrete Research Mercury, L., P. Vieillard, and Y. Tardy (2001). Thermody-
16, 835844. namics of ice polymorphs and icelike water in hydrates
Barrett, E., L. Joyner, and P. Halenda (1951). The determi- and hydroxydes. Applied Geochemistry.
nation of pore volume and area distributions in porous Pigeon, M. (1984). Microstructure et rsistance au gel des
substances. i : Computations from nitrogen isotherms. ciments et btons. Ph. D. thesis, Universit Pierre et Marie
Journal of the American Chemical Society 73, 373380. Curie, Paris 6, France.
Barthel, J., H. Hetzenauer, and R. Buchner (1992). Dielec- Quinson, J. F., M. Astier, and M. Brun (1987). Determination
tric relaxation of aqueous electrolyte solutions. i-solvent of surface areas by thermoporometry. Applied Catalysis
relaxation of 1:2, 2:1 and 2:2 electrolyte solutions. 30, 123130.
Berichte der Bunsen-Gesellschaft Physical Chemistry Raoof, A. (1998). Adsorption distribution et dynamique de
Chemical Physics 96, 988997. leau dans les milieux poreux. Laboratoire Central des
Bjaoui, S., E. Revertegat, and J.-P. Bournazel (2002). Ponts et Chausses, Paris.
Mcanismes de formation de la glace au sein des ptes de Rootare, H. and C. Prenzlow (1967). Surface areas from
ciment et betons. Revue franaise de Gnie Civil 6(78). mercury porosimeter measurements. Journal of Physical
Brun, M., A. Lallemand, J. Quinson, and C. Eyraud (1977). Chemistry 71(8), 27332736.
A new method for the simultaneous determination of Scherer, G. W. (1993). Freezing gels. Journal of Non Crys-
the size and the shape of pores : The thermoporometry. talline Solids 155, 125.
Thermophysica Acta 21, 5988. Sellevold, E. J. and D. H. Bager (1980). Low temperature
Brunauer, S., P. Emmett, and E. Teller (1938). Adsorption calorimetry as a pore structure probe. 7TH Interna-
of gases in multimolecular layers. Journal of American tional Congress on the Chemistry of Cement, Paris 4,
Chemical Society 60(2), 309319. 394399.
Coussy, O. (2005). Poromechanics of freezing materials. Setzer, M. J. (1997). Action of frost and deicing chemicals:
Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids Basic phenomena and testing. In J. Marchand, M. Pigeon,
Submitted to publication. and M. J. Setzer (Eds.), RILEM Proceedings 30, Freeze-
Coussy, O. and T. Fen-Chong (2005). Crystallization, pore Thaw Durability of Concrete. E & FN SPON.
relaxation and cryosuction. Comptes Rendus Mecanique, Wang, K., P. J. M. Monteiro, B. Rubinsky, and A. Arav (1996).
submitted to publication. Microscopic study of ice propagation in concrete. ACI
Dash, J. G., H.-Y. Fu, and J. S. Wettlaufer (1995). The Materials Journal, 370377.
premelting of ice and its environmental consequences. Zakri, T., J.-P. Laurent, and M. Vauclin (1998). Theoretical
Reports on Progress in Physics 58, 115167. evidence for lichteneckers mixture formulae based on the
Fen-Chong, T., A. Fabbri, and F. Gaulard (2005). Freez- effective medium theory. Journal of Physics D: Applied
ing and thawing porous media : Experimental study Physics 31, 15891594.
with a dielectric capacitive method. Comptes-Rendus Zuber, B. and J. Marchand (2004). Predicting the volume
Mecanique, Submitted to publication. instability of hydrated cement systems upon freezing
Fen-Chong, T., A. Fabbri, J.-P. Guilbaud, and O. Coussy using poro-mechanics and local phase equilibra. Concrete
(2004). Determination of liquid water content and Science Engineering 37(268), 257270.

Copyright 2005 Taylor & Francis Group plc, London, UK