Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
0(I
Printed in Great Britain. 1992 Pergamon Press Ltd
T H E MTT C E L L V I A B I L I T Y A S S A Y F O R C Y T O T O X I C I T Y T E S T I N G
IN M U L T I D R U G - R E S I S T A N T H U M A N L E U K E M I C CELLS
Abstract--The MTT cell viability assay is widely used in determining drug sensitivity profiles for
patients with hematological malignancies and in primary screening of potential chemotherapeutic
drugs. Because the multidrug resistance (MDR) phenotype is associated with these malignancies, and
since many vital dyes are effluxed from MDR expressing cells, we have investigated whether the
MDR phenotype interferes with the MTT assay. In CCRF-CEM and K562 human leukemic cell lines
and drug-resistant sub-lines developed from them, comparison of the MTT assay with other cell
viability assays showed significant variation in IC50concentrations, although the resistance relative to
the sensitive parent cell was correlated. Inclusion of verapamil, an inhibitor of drug efflux activity,
had no effect on the MTT assay.
Key words: MTI', multidrug resistance, P-glycoprotein, cell viability assay, cytotoxicity assay,
CCRF-CEM, K562 leukemic cells.
were incubated at 37C for 150 min or for 60 min Time (min)
followed by 90 min in the presence of 9 mM ver-
FIG. 1. Effect of verapamil on MTT assay. Cells (105 well)
apamii and the intracellular drug concentration were incubated in the presence ( ) or absence (. . . . )
measured in an Epics C flow cytometer (Coulter, of 10juM verapamil. (a) CEM U, [~; VLBL00O, (2); (b)
Hialeah, FL) with an argon laser operated at 488 nm. K562 II, D; V8 O, O.
MTT assay in multidrug-resistant cells 1167
fered saline, pH 7.2, at 2.5 mg/ml was added to the blue (0.5%) and the cells excluding the dye were
cells (20 ~tl/well). After incubation at 37C for 2 h, counted in a haemocytometer. Cell viability (%) =
cells were centrifuged at 800g for 5 rain and the average number of cells/average number of cells in
medium aspirated. The formazan crystals were dis- control wells.
solved in 100 ~1 dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and the
A540nm read in a microtitre plate reader. Results were RESULTS
calculated as: cell viability ( % ) = average O.D. of
wells/average O.D. of control wells. Optimisation of M T T assay
(2) Leucine incorporation: after 48 h incubation of Absorbance increased linearly with cell number
cells with drug, the medium was replaced with drug from 104 cells per well to 5 x 105 cells per well
free medium and the plates incubated for 5 h to (r > 0.97). This is within the range of cell growth
allow recovery of surviving cells. Plates were then during a cytotoxicity test. Inclusion of verapamil
centrifuged for 5 min at 700 g, the medium carefully (10 ~tM) in the assay had no effect on the production
removed and replaced with 200 ~tl medium containing of formazan (Fig. 1). However the formazan pro-
0.6 ~Ci L-[4,5-3H]leucine (Amersham, Sydney, Aus- duction was slightly lower in the drug-resistant sub-
tralia). After overnight incubation, cells were washed lines (VLB100 and V8) than in the parental drug-
once with Hank's balanced salt solution (HBSS; sensitive cell lines (CEM, K562). The absorbance
Commonwealth Serum Laboratories, Melbourne, was proportional to MTT concentration up to 5 mg/
Australia), resuspended in 100 ~tl HBSS and 80 ~tl ml for CEM and VLB100 and 2.5 mg/ml for the K562
spotted onto G F / A glass filters (Whatman, Maid- and V8 cells. The optimal incubation time in MTT
stone, England) and the incorporated radioactivity was chosen to give a linear, increase and an
measured as described previously [14]. Cell viability absorbance value of 0.7-1.3 units in control wells.
(%) = average cpm of wells/average cpm of control
wells. Cytotoxicity assays
(3) Dye exclusion assay: cells from triplicate wells Cell viability was determined by the MTT assay
were pooled, mixed with an equal volume of trypan for two unrelated drugs vinblastine (a Vinca alkaloid,
A .A
100 100
50 50
~ A ^ , / x A
>.
[..
10 101 102 10 ~ 10 ~ 102 10 J 10 4
<
7, 100 c 1C d
,-2
,-2
L~
"~Q. ZX
50
,, "O-
........ , ........ i ........ , ........ i
VERAPAMU.
~ 60 ~ CONTROL
Fig. 2a, c) and epirubicin (an anthracycline, Fig. As expected, the highly drug-resistant VLBm0 subline
2b, d). The los0 initially decreased with increasing accumulated much less daunorubicin (approximately
incubation time, however, after 2 days for CEM and one fifth) than the CEM cell line and verapamil
3 days for K562 cells, the ICs0 remains constant. Thus caused a 4-fold increase in drug accumulation (Fig.
times chosen for cytotoxicity testing were 3 days for 4).
CEM and 4 days for K562 cells (indicated by the
solid lines in Fig 2). Comparison of MTT and [3H]leucine incorporation
The Ics0 of any drug was not affected by performing assays
the MTT incubation in fresh media. The addition of The ICs0 for 9 different cytotoxic drugs including
0.1 M glycine in 0.1 M NaCI, pH 10.5 to the DMSO anthracyclines, Vinca alkaloids, antibiotics, epi-
solubilisation of formazan did not have any effect on podophyllotoxins and methotrexate was determined
the Ics0 determination. for the CEM cells and the multidrug-resistant sub-
lines. The Ics0s for the sensitive CEM cells, the
Characterization of drug-resistant cells vinblastine resistant VLB100 and two of the multi-
Figure 3 shows the Western-blot analysis of a series drug-resistant sublines E200 and VE200 which are
of multidrug-resistant cells of increasing drug resist- representative of the E and VE series are shown
ance. The VE series expressed increased levels of in Table 1. The MTT assay generally gave an ICs0
P-glycoprotein which correlated with the level of approximately 3 times higher than the [3H]leucine
resistance to epirubicin and to the level of cross- incorporation assay with some notable exceptions.
resistance to other drugs (not presented). The level For example the lc50 concentrations obtained for
of P-glycoprotein in the VE series also correlated daunorubicin for all cell lines were 10 to 20 times
with the decrease in daunorubicin accumulation by higher by the MTT assay. Although the IC50 values
these cells (Fig. 4). The E series did not express were dependent on the assay used, the relative resist-
detectable levels of P-glycoprotein (Fig. 3), but they ances (compared to the parent cell line) were highly
had similar levels of anthracycline resistance as their correlated by the two assays, as demonstrated in Fig.
VE series counterparts. An example of this is given 5 and P-glycoprotein expression (closed circles) did
for the VE200 and the E200 subline in Table 1. not significantly alter this relationship.
The El00 and E200 sublines also showed a similar
decrease in daunorubicin accumulation over 150 min Comparison of MTT and trypan blue exclusion assay
incubation (Fig. 4). However, this decreased The Ics0 for epirubicin and vinblastine was deter-
accumulation was only partly reversed by verapamil mined in VLBI00 and K562 ceils by M T T and trypan
in the El00 and E200 sublines while reversal was blue exclusion assays. The results (Table 2) showed
more complete for the VE100 and VE200 sublines. that for both cell lines the M T T assay gave an Its0
0
0
0 0
m o 0 0 m
IJ.I LI,I ILl UJ LU
-200kD
- 9 7kD
.... : ~ ,qi!iiiiji~
iiii~ iiii
!i~<i
1169
MTT assay in multidrug-resistant cells 1171
/
r=0.97 0
40
20
30
20
10
0 i i
10 20 30 40 50 10 20
40 80
10 20
o o
0 10 20 30 40 0 20 40 60 80
Z 300 ~,o /
,a~ VINBLASTINE / ACTINOMYCIN
[" r=0.98 /r=0 96
,~LIA 200
;>
~ 100
<
4000
2000
0 ~ i 0 A
2000 4000 6000 8000 Jo 20
RELATIVE RESISTANCE (MTT ASSAY)
FIG. 5. Comparison of ]c5(~of CEM cells and drug-resistant
sublines determined by MTT assay and [3H]leucine incor-
poration assay. Cells were incubated for 3 days in serial
dilution of drug and assayed for cell viability by the two
methods. Correlation coefficients (r) are given; E cell series
( O ) , P-glycoprotein expressing VE cell series ( O ) .
dent on the type of cell viability assay used (Tables it has been demonstrated that daunorubicin is
1 and 2). This may be explained by the drug directly unable to bind ferric iron and cannot produce free
affecting the cell function involved in the viability radicals by this pathway due to the absence of a
assay. For instance, the ]c50 for daunorubicin deter- ketol group present on doxorubicin and epirubicin
mined by the MTT assay was 10-20-fold higher [20]. Thus different anthracyclines while exhibiting
than that determined by the [3H]leucine incor- structural similarities, do exert different effects on
poration assay (Table 1). It is k n o w n that anthra- cell metabolism and this could result in changes in
cyclines interact with the mitochondrial membrane mitochondrial activity involved in the MTT assay.
[19] and also cause free radical formation. H o w e v e r Similarly, the lcs0 for actinomycin D for C E M cells
MTT assay in multidrug-resistant cells 1173
is 28 times higher by the M T T assay c o m p a r e d to 6. Morgan S. A., Watson J. V., Twentyman P. R. &
the [3H]leucine incorporation assay. This could be Smith P. J. (1989) Flow cytometric analysis of Hoechst
33342 uptake as an indicator of multi-drug resistance
due to the fact that actinomycin D inhibits protein in human lung cancer. Br. J. Cancer 60, 282.
synthesis and hence leucine incorporation. It must 7. Endicott J. A. & Ling V. (1989) The biochemistry
be borne in mind that all cytotoxicity assays rely of P-glycoprotein-mediated multidrug resistance. Ann.
on a particular metabolic activity and some of these Rev. Biochem. 58, 137.
activities may be preferentially inhibited by the 8. Yusa K. & Tsuruo T. (1989) Reversal mechanism of
multidrug resistance by verapamil: direct binding of
drug under test. verapamil to P-glycoprotein on specific sites and trans-
The availability of a series of cell lines exhibiting port of verapamil outward across the plasma membrane
different levels of resistance and containing different of K562 cells. Cancer Res. 49, 5002.
amounts of P-glycoprotein (Fig. 3) has allowed us to 9. Mirski S. E. L., Gerlach J. H. & Cole S. P. C. (1987)
compare methods for determining relative resistance. Multidrug resistance in a human small cell lung cancer
cell line selected in adriamycin. Cancer Res. 47, 2594.
Although the M T T assay and the [3H]leucine incor- 10. Ma D. D. F., Davey R. A., Harman D. H., Isbister J.
poration assay gave different I5o values, relative P., Scurf R. D., Mackertich S. M., Dowden G. &
resistance was correlated for both assays (Fig. 5). It Bell D. R. (1987) Detection of a multidrug resistant
is important to note that both methods were able phenotype in acute non-lymphoblastic leukemia. Lan-
to detect the low levels of increased resistance or cet i, 135-137.
11. Foley G. E., Lazarus H., Farber S., Uzman B. G.,
collateral drug sensitivity in these cell lines. Thus the Boone B. A. & McCarthy R. E. (1965) Continuous
MT-F assay can detect the d e v e l o p m e n t of increased culture of human lymphoblasts from peripheral blood
resistance at clinically relevant drug concentrations of a child with acute leukemia. Cancer 18, 522.
(e.g. epirubicin, 16 ng/ml; vinblastine, 6 ng/ml). 12. Beck W. T., Mueller T. J. & Tanzer L. R. (1979)
Therefore use of the M T T assay, which is much Altered surface membrane glycoproteins in Vinca alka-
loid-resistant human leukemic lymphoblasts. Cancer
simpler than other assays for cytotoxicity testing, is Res. 39, 2070.
appropriate for determining the relative resistance of 13. Haber M., Norris M. D., Kavallaris M., Bell D. R.,
cells expressing P-glycoprotein (VE series) or other Davey R. A., White L. & Stewart B. W. (1989) Atypi-
drug efflux mechanisms (E series). H o w e v e r , it is cal multidrug resistance in a therapy-induced drug-
important in the initial screening of drugs to deter- resistant human leukemia cell line (LALW-2): resist-
ance to Vince alkaloids independent of P-glycoprotein.
mine any direct effect the drug may have on formazan Cancer Res. 49, 5281.
production as this could interfere with the cyto- 14. Davey R., Bowen R. & Cahill J. (1983) The analysis of
toxicity assay and may lead to potentially useful drugs soluble galactosyltransferase isoenzyme patterns using
being rejected. It is also important to be aware of high resolution agarose isoelectricfocusing. Biochem.
effects of the drug on Its0 determinations by the Int. 6, 643.
15. Carmichael J., DeGraff W. G., Gazdar A. F., Minna J.
MT-I" assay when screening clinical samples for drug D. & Mitchell J. B. (1987) Evaluation of a tetrazolium-
sensitivity. based semiautomated colorimetric assay: assessment
of chemosensitivity testing. Cancer Res. 47, 936.
16. Twentyman P. R. & Luscombe M. (1987) A study of
REFERENCES some variables in a tetrazolium dye (MTT) based assay
for cell growth and chemosensitivity. Br. J. Cancer 56,
1. Ma D. D. F. & Bell D. R. (1989) Multidrug resistance 279.
and P-glycoprotein expression in human cancer. Aust. 17. Vistica D. T., Skehan P., Scudiero D., Monks A.,
N.Z. J. Med. 19, 736. Pittman A. & Boyd M. R. (1991) Tetrazolium-based
2. Sargent J. M. & Taylor C. G. (1989) Appraisal of the assays for cellular viability: a critical examination of
MTI" assay as a rapid test of chemosensitivity in acute selected parameters affecting formazan production.
myeloid leukaemia. Br. J. Cancer 60, 206. Cancer Res. 51, 2515.
3. Alley M. C., Scudiero D. A., Monks A., Hursey M. 18. Plumb J. A., Milroy R. & Kaye S. B. (1989) Effects
L., Czerwinski M. J., Fine D. L., Abbott B. J., Mayo of the pH dependence of 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-
J. G., Shoemaker R. H. & Boyd M. R. (1988) Feasi- 2,5-diphenyl-tetrazolium bromide-formazan absorp-
bility of drug screening with panels of human tumor tion on chemosensitivity determined by a novel tetra-
cell lines using a microculture tetrazolium assay. Cancer zolium-based assay. Cancer Res. 49, 4435.
Res. 48, 589. 19. Goormanhtigh E., Chatelain P. Caspers J. & Ruys-
4. Mosmann T. (1983) Rapid colorimetric assay for cellu- schaert J. M. (1980) Evidence of a specific complex
lar growth and survival: application to proliferation between adriamycin and negatively-charged phospho-
and cytotoxicity assays. J. Immun. Meth. 65, 55. lipids. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 597, 1.
5. Bucana C. D., Giavazzi R., Nayar R., O'Brien C. A., 20. Zweier J. L., Gianni L., Muindi J. & Myers C. E.
Seid C., Earnest L. E. & Fan D. (1990) Retention (1986) Differences in oxygen reduction by the iron
of vital dyes correlates inversely with the multidrug- complexes of adriamycin and daunomycin: the import-
resistant phenotype of adriamycin-selected murine ance of the side chain hydroxyl group. Biochim.
fibrosarcoma variants. Expl Cell Res. 190, 69. Biophys. Acta 884, 326.