Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
PII: S0165-5876(16)30081-7
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2016.04.037
Reference: PEDOT 8073
Please cite this article as: Alexandria L. Irace, Eelam A. Adil, Natasha M. Archer, Victoria M.
Silvera, Antonio Perez-Atayde, Reza Rahbar, Pediatric sialoblastoma: evaluation and
management, International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology (2016),
http://dx.doi.org/doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2016.04.037.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service
to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will
undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its
final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could
affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
1
Alexandria L. Irace BAa, Eelam A. Adil MD, MBAa,b, Natasha M. Archer MDc, Victoria M.
a
Boston Childrens Hospital, Department of Otolaryngology and Communication Enhancement,
02115, USA
e
Boston Childrens Hospital, Department of Pathology, 300 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA
02115, USA
Correspondence:
Boston Childrens Hospital, 300 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA 02115, USA. Email
alexandria.irace@childrens.harvard.edu
Page 1 of 21
2
Abstract
Objectives: Sialoblastoma is a rare congenital salivary gland tumor of epithelial origin. The
objectives of this study are to review the literature regarding clinical presentation of
sialoblastoma, evaluate the effectiveness of various treatment methods, and present guidelines
of reported cases were analyzed. We also report an invasive and recurrent case in a pediatric
Results: Sixty-two cases of pediatric sialoblastoma were reviewed. The age at initial
presentation ranged from before birth to 15 years. The parotid gland was the most common
location (n=47). Surgical excision was the primary treatment in all patients. Nine patients
developed metastatic disease of the lung, lymph nodes, or bone. Almost a third of patients had
recurrence and over two thirds of patients were tumor-free for at least 1 year following their last
treatment intervention.
Conclusion: Prompt and complete surgical excision should be recommended to prevent local
and systemic recurrence of pediatric sialoblastoma. Chemotherapy has also shown promise in
several cases, and clinical genomics may shed light on more therapy options. Patients should be
closely followed for at least 12 months following diagnosis, or longer depending on the
Keywords: pediatric sialoblastoma, salivary gland tumor, parotid neoplasm, salivary embryoma,
congenital basal cell adenoma, congenital hybrid basal cell adenoma-adenoid cystic carcinoma
Page 2 of 21
3
1. Introduction
Sialoblastoma is a rare tumor that arises from the primitive duct epithelium of salivary
glands during the perinatal period. Lesions are typically detected by antenatal sonography or by
caregivers within the first few weeks of life. It is estimated that 2 to 5% of all salivary gland
tumors occur in children, with an annual incidence of 0.8 per million, making sialoblastoma
exceptionally uncommon [1,2]. This neoplasm has been reported to be three times as likely to
occur in the parotid gland than the submandibular gland [3]. Sialoblastoma is known to be
locally infiltrative and may metastasize to the lymph nodes or lungs if left untreated [4-6].
Due to the rarity of sialoblastoma, there is little consensus on its management. In this
article, we present a patient with a rapidly growing malignant and recurrent sialoblastoma of the
parotid gland. The patient underwent multiple surgical resections and cycles of chemotherapy.
We also review the literature to summarize patient presentation, management, and outcomes.
Our goal is to propose guidelines for evaluation and management of this rare tumor based on our
2. Methods
A case of a pediatric patient who presented with a large sialoblastoma of the parotid
gland is described. A literature search was performed using the online search databases PubMed,
EMBASE, CINAHL with Full Text, and Cochrane Library on August 1, 2015. Medical subject
headings (MeSH) terms included sialoblastoma, salivary embryoma, congenital basal cell
adenoma, congenital hybrid basal cell adenoma, and congenital hybrid basal cell adenoma-
adenoid cystic carcinoma. The term low-grade basaloid adenocarcinoma, a previously used
name for sialoblastoma, was excluded due to overlapping nomenclature with other salivary gland
tumors, as defined by the World Health Organization [3]. Search results were restricted to those
Page 3 of 21
4
written in the English language describing pediatric patients (under the age of 21 years of age)
and were not limited by year of publication. Separate articles describing the same patient were
3. Results
A 5-month old male was referred to our institution with a left-sided firm facial mass. The
patient was noted at birth to have a 1 cm x 1 cm mass overlying the mandible. This was initially
stable and then rapidly grew to 3 cm x 3 cm by 2 months of age. Ultrasound of the mass at this
point showed a mildly heterogeneous, well-defined predominantly hypoechoic mass within the
left parotid gland with scattered internal hyperechoic foci (Fig. 1) and mild increased vascularity.
The mass was initially believed to be an infantile hemangioendothelioma and was monitored by
a local otolaryngologist in the patients home country. Its continued rapid growth prompted
The mass on presentation was friable and warm to the touch. The patient had dysphagia
and left-sided facial nerve paralysis. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed a large mass
extending intracranially via a widened left foramen ovale into the cavernous sinus. There was
also extension into the left external auditory canal/left middle ear cavity, lower eyelid and
possibly the superolateral orbit. The mass measured 12.1 cm anterior-posterior by 13.5 cm
T1-weighted images (T1WIs) (Fig. 2A). T2-weighted images (T2WIs) showed areas of
intermediate signal intensity, suggesting components of tumor with a high cytoplasm to nucleus
ratio (Fig. 2B) that also corresponded to regions of reduced diffusivity on the ADC map (Fig.
Page 4 of 21
5
2C), and areas of increased signal consistent with high water content or necrosis. Post-contrast
computed tomography (CT) showed heterogeneous tumor enhancement and bony destruction of
the left temporal, sphenoid, pterygoid, maxillary, mandibular, and zygomatic bones, and bony
remodeling/thinning of the squamosal portion of the temporal bone (Fig. 4). No areas of bone
destruction or flow voids were appreciated on MRI or CT. Chest CT revealed no metastatic
disease. Biopsy of the mass was guided by interventional radiology, and pathological
to shrink the tumor to a more easily resectable size. The mass shrank to approximately 3 cm x 4
component of the tumor and total parotidectomy. Pathological examination of the resected
specimen confirmed the diagnosis of sialoblastoma with multifocal tumor necrosis and
etoposide, tumor growth continued. After one cycle of doxorubicin and low-dose
cyclophosphamide, he exhibited a partial but transient response. The regimen was changed to 5-
fluoruracil, cisplatin, and vincristine, as delivered for hepatoblastoma. This treatment was
pursued due to the reported association of hepatoblastoma and sialoblastoma and the belief that
the liver and parotid gland are of similar embryonic origin [7-9]. The patient received 6 cycles of
Page 5 of 21
6
chemotherapy, without the last 2 doses of vincristine to prevent toxicity. Subsequently, a biopsy
Six weeks later, 3 firm, subcentimeter mobile nodules were noted along the left mandible.
MRI showed evidence of sialoblastoma recurrence with extension toward the skull base. The
patient underwent resection of these isolated lesions and neck lymph node biopsy. Small foci of
residual left facial disease progressed rapidly. He began receiving irinotecan and temozolomide,
a second-line therapy for hepatoblastoma. After two cycles, disease progressed at the primary
site. He began daily oral pazopanib (100 mg), a multi-targeted tyrosine kinase receptor inhibitor,
because genetic testing was consistent with a missense mutation in the fibroblast growth factor
receptor 2 (FGFR2) tyrosine kinase gene in the transmembrane domain C382R. This was
suspected to be an activating mutation that could explain the patients persistent disease
progression. FGFR2 p.C382R mutations have been noted in endometrial and gastrointestinal
cancers [10], but have not been reported in sialoblastoma. No known specific FGFR2 inhibitors
had been identified, thus this patient was started on pazopanib, given promising results seen in
both children with solid tumors and adults with head and neck tumors [11,12]. Pazopanib dosage
was increased to 200 mg because of tumor growth. Tumor size then remained stable, but the
patient developed facial swelling. After changing treatment to docetaxel and cisplatin
The patient restarted the 5-fluororuacil, cisplatin, and vincristine regimen, to which he
previously exhibited a good response. Due to hearing loss and a strong response to vincristine,
cisplatin was removed from the regimen. After 5 cycles, MRI demonstrated regrowth of
sialoblastoma in the region of the left parotid gland and surrounding the mandible, retromolar
trigone and medial pterygoid. He received 3 large-fraction doses of local radiation therapy, but
Page 6 of 21
7
developed painful facial swelling. He received daily radiation and one dose of
The family returned to their home country, but shortly thereafter the patients disease
progressed and they returned to our hospital. MRI showed marked increase in the tumor size
involving the left face and orbit, without pulmonary metastasis. There was intracranial
extraaxial tumor within the left middle cranial fossa. The parents opted for aggressive
chemotherapy with ifosfamide and etoposide, which was given on days 1 through 5 every 3
weeks with Neulasta given on day 7. After 3 cycles of this regimen, the tumor continued to grow.
administration, but this resulted in increased pain and tumor growth. His last MRI was performed
at 35 months of age; the tumor extensively involved the left face, skull base, scalp and
intracranial space, left orbit, paranasal sinuses, oral cavity and left neck. No chemotherapy
options appeared to have any potential benefit. The patient was managed by palliative care and
3.2.1 Demographics
The literature search yielded 62 unique reports of pediatric sialoblastoma written in the
English language [1,4-9,13-57]. Forty-four of these results were single case reports. Gender ratio
was almost evenly split, with slightly more males (n=33) than females (n=27) and 2 patients of
unidentified gender. Age at presentation ranged from the prenatal period to 15 years old [25], but
almost half of the cases presented at or before birth (n=30). The earliest clinical presentation of
sialoblastoma, detected on antenatal ultrasound, was in a male fetus at 26 weeks gestation [30].
Page 7 of 21
8
The parotid gland was involved in almost three times as many cases as the submandibular
gland. There was only 1 report of sialoblastoma in the minor salivary glands [52], 1 in ectopic
salivary tissue [39], 1 in an eyelid [40], 2 identified as cheek masses [48,53], and 2 where the
Sixty of 62 patients received treatment, while the other 2 were diagnosed posthumously
[5,8]. In every case, treatment involved partial or complete tumor excision. Thirty-seven cases
were initially treated through surgical excision of the tumor, without removing the affected
salivary gland. The remaining 23 cases involved both tumor excision and sialoadenectomy,
either to prevent recurrence or achieve tumor-free margins. Only 2 patients required sacrifice of
the facial nerve during surgery due to infiltration of the tumor into the nerve branches [18,51].
Facial nerve reconstruction was successful in both patients. Four patients underwent partial
tumor resection and required alternative treatment methods [1,15,34,40]. Chemotherapy was
adjuvant therapy [13,34,40], and 1 receiving both [36]. Radiotherapy was administered to 4
patients [13,15,40].
3.2.3 Recurrence
All initial recurrences occurred within 3 to 17 months from the time of original diagnosis, with
16 cases recurring at or before 12 months. The highest number of recurrences was 6 in one
Page 8 of 21
9
The most common treatment for tumor recurrence was surgical resection without gland
removal, which occurred in 11 of the 20 patients. Six patients underwent surgical resection with
gland removal [6,21,25,49,50,57], and 5 of these operations involved facial nerve sacrifice
[6,21,25,49,50]. The second most common treatment among these reports was chemotherapy,
which was administered to 9 patients. Interestingly, one study reports that just 2 courses of low-
dose chemotherapy were entirely curative for a large recurrent sialoblastoma [1]. Two other case
reports describe similar findings, with chemotherapy completely eradicating recurrent tumor in
these patients [18,46]. In our review, chemotherapy was frequently administered in conjunction
with surgical interventions or radiation treatments. Four patients received adjuvant chemotherapy
[4,48-50], and 2 of these patients also received neoadjuvant therapy [4,50]. A total of 6 patients
brachytherapy [20,51].
3.2.5 Metastases
Two patients presented with metastases prior to initial treatment of sialoblastoma. One
patient, 15 years of age, had evidence of metastatic disease in the lymph nodes and sphenoid,
temporal, and vertebral bones at presentation [25]. One other patient presented at 4 years of age
without any evidence of metastasis and was subsequently lost to follow up for 6 months, after
which she presented with multiple pulmonary metastases [36]. Seven patients had pulmonary or
lymph node metastates after initial treatment [4,5,15,18,20,46,50]. All metastases were seen in
Page 9 of 21
10
Overall, 36 of 51 patients with a reported outcome were tumor-free for at least 1 year
following their last sialoblastoma-related intervention. However, because the duration of patient
follow-up was limited by the date of publication of each reviewed case report, the number of
patients meeting this criterion might actually be much higher. The longest reported follow-up
period was 43 years, during which time the patient remained in good health without any
recurrence of tumor [5]. Long-term complications of surgery are not common in the literature.
Residual facial palsy and paralysis occurred in 2 patients [15,50], and one patient suffered from
4. Discussion
4.1 Background
In 1966, Vawter and Tefft were the first to describe sialoblastoma, naming it an
embryoma because of its predominance in neonates and young children [13]. Since their initial
report, clinicians and pathologists have used a variety of terms to describe this neoplasm:
congenital basal cell adenoma, congenital hybrid basal cell adenoma, low-grade basaloid
[3,16,19,27,35]. In 1988, the term sialoblastoma was introduced to convey both the location
Using a histopathological classification system, perinatal salivary gland tumors can fall
into one of four categories: 1) benign tumors that are analogous to their adult counterparts, 2)
Page 10 of 21
11
hamartomatous tumors with acinar differentiation, 3) tumors that resemble the embryonic
epithelial precursor to the major salivary glands (which includes sialoblastoma), and 4) tumors
that demonstrate malignancy from the onset [58]. There are histological markers for malignancy
in these neoplasms, including anaplasia, neurovascular invasion, and necrosis [19]. Though
sialoblastoma was previously thought to be benign, in 2005 the World Health Organization
reclassified it as a malignant epithelial salivary gland neoplasm [3]. This marked an important
turning point in clinicians understanding of this disease and provided insight on how aggressive
4.2 Imaging
Few reports describe the imaging appearance of sialoblastomas. Typically, these tumors
are lobulated, and can be non-infiltrating or locally invasive into adjacent muscle and bone. On
(Fig. 1) [54,57]. On CT, sialoblastomas are intermediate in attenuation, and similar in attenuation
to muscle [34,57]. On MRI, sialoblastomas are reported as hypointense to brain parenchyma, low
suggesting a high nucleus/cytoplasmic ratio [26,34]. Focal areas of necrosis or hemorrhage may
be present [34]. Tumor may enhance poorly, heterogeneously or intensely [9,34,57]. Diffusion-
weighted imaging shows reduced diffusivity in non-necrotic areas of tumor in keeping with a
high nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratio (Fig. 2C) [34,52,59]. Small satellite lesions adjacent to the
dominant tumor have been noted [26]. The major differential considerations based on imaging
Page 11 of 21
12
intralesional flow voids. Teratomas are typically multiloculated solid and cystic tumors with
calcifications [60].
4.3 Pathology
recapitulates fetal salivary gland tissue. The tumor is composed of solid hypercellular nests,
fibromyxomatous stroma. Nuclear palisading might be present at the periphery of the tumor
nests. The tumor has an infiltrative growth with invasion into adjacent soft tissue and sometimes
nerves (Fig. 5). Mitoses are usually frequent and focal necrosis might be observed. Tumor cells
are immunoreactive for low molecular weight cytokeratins, p63 and S100 protein. The nest
recurrent tumors. Though early surgical resection with clear margins is first line management,
there is no consensus about the most treatment course for aggressive tumors. This is due to the
rarity and variability of clinical presentations [50]. In the past, several authors have
recommended early surgical resection with negative margins as the preferred treatment
[7,19,24,61-63] and claim that radiation or chemotherapy should be considered only if the tumor
returns postoperatively or cannot be fully removed by surgical means [41]. However, others
argue that extensive surgery can be mutilating and leave significant cosmetic and nervous system
Page 12 of 21
13
treatments [7,50]. Furthermore, several authors highlight the finding that sialoblastomas tend to
unfamiliar and unpredictable clinical challenge for most pediatric medical practitioners. In this
report, we present a child with a particularly aggressive case that continued to progress after 2
resections, 10 different chemotherapy regimens, and 3 doses of radiation treatment. The only
regimen that was repeated 2 separate times consisted of 5-fluorouracil, cisplatin, and vincristine,
which eliminated the tumor upon initial administration but did not have a significant effect the
second time. In addition, recurrences of the tumor appeared to develop in different locations on
the head and neck, which made it difficult to localize new growth.
5. Conclusion
At present the best option for children with sialoblastoma seems to be surgical resection.
It is unclear, based on our literature search, how many patients with sialoblastoma have an initial
resection and no further sequelae. It is evident that the role of clinical genomics in more
Page 13 of 21
14
REFERENCES
[3] Barnes L, Eveson JW, Reichart P, Sidransky D, editors. Tumours of the salivary glands.
In: Pathology and Genetics of Head and Neck Tumours. Lyon France: IARC Press;
2005:253.
Sialoblastoma- long-term follow-up and remission for a rare salivary malignancy. Rare
Tumors. 2011;3(2):e13.
[5] Williams SB, Ellis GL, Warnock GR. Sialoblastoma: a clinicopathologic and
[7] Siddiqi SH, Solomon MP, Haller JO. Sialoblastoma and hepatoblastoma in a neonate.
[8] Stones DK, Jansen JC, Griessel D. Sialoblastoma and hepatoblastoma in a newborn
[9] Cheng YK, Chu WC, Law LW, Ting YH, Leung TY. A fetus with a huge neck mass and
Page 14 of 21
15
[11] Glade Bender JL, Lee A, Reid JM, et al. Phase I pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic
study of pazopanib in children with soft tissue sarcoma and other refractory solid tumors:
3043.
[12] Liao RG, Jung J, Tchaicha J, et al. Inhibitor-sensitive FGFR2 and FGFR3 mutations in
[13] Vawter GF, Tefft M. Congenital tumors of the parotid gland. Arch Pathol.
1966;82(3):242-245.
[14] Krolls SO, Trodahl JN, Boyers RC. Salivary gland lesions in children. A survey of 430
[15] Bianchi A, Cudmore RE. Salivary gland tumors in children. J Pediatr Surg.
1978;13(6):519-521.
[16] Canalis RF, Mok MW, Fishman SM, Hemenway WG. Congenital basal cell adenoma of
[17] Roth A, Micheau C. Embryoma (or embryonal tumor) of the parotid gland: report of two
[18] Simpson PR, Rutledge JC, Schaefer SD, Anderson RC. Congenital hybrid basal cell
3):199-208.
Page 15 of 21
16
[19] Batsakis JG, Mackay B, Ryka AF, Seifert RW. Perinatal salivary gland tumours
[20] Taylor GP. Congenital epithelial tumor of the parotid-sialoblastoma. Pediatr Pathol.
1988;8(4):447-452.
[21] Casas LA, Gonzalez-Crussi F, Pensler JM. Monomorphic adenoma of the parotid in a
[22] Adkins GF. Low grade basaloid adenocarcinoma of salivary gland in childhood--the so-
190.
[23] Harris MD, McKeever P, Robertson JM. Congenital tumours of the salivary gland: a case
[24] Hsueh C, Gonzalez-Crussi F. Sialoblastoma: a case report and review of the literature on
[25] Patil DT, Chou PM. Sialoblastoma: utility of Ki-67 and p53 as a prognostic tool and
[26] Som PM BM, Silvers AR, Rothschild MA. Sialoblastoma (Embryoma): MR Findings of
[27] Seifert G, Donath K. The congenital basal cell adenoma of salivary glands. Contribution
1997;430(4):311-319.
[28] Huang R, Jaffer S. Imprint cytology of metastatic sialoblastoma. A case report. Acta
Cytol. 2003;47(6):1123-1126.
Page 16 of 21
17
2000;53(8):697-699.
[31] Green RS, Tunkel DE, Small D, Westra WH, Argani P. Sialoblastoma: association with
gland: report of a case and review of the literature. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol.
2000;53(2):157-161.
[34] Yekeler E, Dursun M, Gun F, et al. Sialoblastoma: MRI findings. Pediatr Radiol.
2004;34(12):1005-1007.
[36] Scott JX KS, Bourne AJ, Williams MP, Agzarian M, Revesz T. Treatment of Metastatic
137.
Page 17 of 21
18
[38] Verret DJ, Galindo RL, DeFatta RJ, Bauer PW. Sialoblastoma: a rare submandibular
[39] Marucci DD, Lawson K, Harper J, Sebire NJ, Dunaway DJ. Sialoblastoma arising in
2007;10(4):309-314.
2008;66(1):123-126.
2008;43(10):e11-13.
[43] Eken M AG, Aydin S, Hardal U, Sanli A. Sialoblastoma of the parotid gland.
[44] Kayahan S GM, Yavuzer D, Karadayi N. Sialoblastoma: case report. Paper presented at:
Page 18 of 21
19
171.
2010;5(47-49).
Otorhinolaryngol. 2010;74(8):942-945.
[51] Shan XF, Cai ZG, Zhang JG, Zhang J, Gao Y, Yu GY. Management of sialoblastoma
[52] Saffari Y, Blei F, Warren SM, Milla S, Greco MA. Congenital minor salivary gland
sialoblastoma: a case report and review of the literature. Fetal Pediatr Pathol.
2011;30(1):32-39.
[53] Brown MM, Walsh EJ, Shetty A, Smidt AC. Sialoblastoma: an unexpected diagnosis. J
[54] Wang L, Chen WL, Chen JF, Pan CB, Zhao XP. Surgical excision of sialoblastoma in the
[55] Sharma J SA, Munghate A. Sialoblastoma of parotid gland: A rare case report and review
[56] Kataria SP, Kumar S, Singh G, Kalra R, Sen R, Garg N. Sialoblastoma. diagnosis by
Page 19 of 21
20
girl with multiple recurrences and long-term follow-up. Head Neck. 2015.
[58] Batsakis JG. Pathology consultation. Nomenclature of developmental tumors. Ann Otol
[59] Papaioannou G, Sebire NJ, McHugh K. Imaging of the unusual pediatric 'blastomas'.
[60] Gezer HO, Oguzkurt P, Temiz A, Bolat FA, Hicsonmez A. Huge Neck Masses Causing
Neonatol. 2014.
[61] Batsakis JG, Frankenthaler R. Embryoma (sialoblastoma) of salivary glands. Ann Otol
[62] Schuller DE, McCabe BF. Salivary gland neoplasms in children. Otolaryngol Clin North
Am. 1977;10(2):399-412.
[63] Kessler A, Handler SD. Salivary gland neoplasms in children: a 10-year survey at the
Page 20 of 21
21
Figure Legends
Figure 1. Ultrasound image shows a circumscribed, hypoechoic mass with scattered hyperechoic
foci (arrow).
Figure 2. A. Axial T1WI shows a large circumscribed mass with areas of dispersed fat (arrow).
B. Coronal T2WI shows tumor characterized by intermediate signal intensity with small foci of
dark signal (short arrow) consistent with hemorrhage and/or calcification. Tumor extends into
the left external auditory canal (long arrow). C. Axial ADC map shows areas of reduced
diffusivity (long arrow) indicating tumor with a high nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratio and areas of
increased diffusivity (short arrow) consistent with tumor components with high water content or
necrosis.
Figure 3. Axial T1W post-contrast image shows intense heterogeneous enhancement of tumor.
Figure 4. CT coronal reformatted post contrast image shows bony destruction of the left
mandible (white arrows), bony remodeling of the left squamosal bone (black arrowheads), and
Page 21 of 21