Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
BREASTFEEDING DURATION
WENDY HAZEL ODDY, PHD, MPH, BAPPSCI, JIANGHONG LI, PHD, MSC, BA,
LINDA LANDSBOROUGH, BSC (NURSING), RN, RM, IBCLC, GARTH EDWARD KENDALL, PHD, MPH, RN,
SARAS HENDERSON, PHD, MED, RN, AND JILL DOWNIE, PHD, MSC, RN
Objective To determine whether maternal prepregnancy overweight or obesity has an independent effect on breastfeeding
duration.
Study design A prospective birth cohort study of 1803 live-born children and their mothers ascertained through antenatal
clinics at the major tertiary obstetric hospital in Perth, Australia, were followed until 3 years of age. Unconditional logistic, Cox
regression, and Kaplan Meier analyses were used to model the association between
maternal prepregnancy overweight and obesity and the duration of predominant or any
breastfeeding allowing for adjustment of confounders (infant factors: gender, birth
weight, gestational age, age solids introduced, and older siblings; maternal factors:
smoking, education, age, race, marital status, pregnancy and birth complications, cesar- From the Telethon Institute for Child
Health Research, Centre for Child Health
ean section, and socioeconomic status). Research, University of Western Australia,
Results Overweight and obese women were more likely to have discontinued breast- PO Box 855, West Perth, Perth, Western
Australia 6872, Australia, School of Public
feeding at any time before 6 months than normal weight women (P < .0005) following Health, Curtin University of Technology,
adjustment for potential confounders. GPO Box U1987, Perth, Western Australia
6845, Australia, South West Health Service,
Conclusion We have shown that prepregnancy body mass index is associated with Health, Department of Western Australia,
reduced breastfeeding duration, and that mothers who are overweight or obese before 4 Royal Street, East Perth, Western Aus-
tralia, Australia, School of Nursing and Mid-
pregnancy tend to breastfeed their infants for a shorter duration than normal weight wifery, Curtin University of Technology,
mothers independent of maternal socioeconomic and demographic characteristics. GPO Box U1987, Perth, Western Australia
(J Pediatr 2006;149:185-91) 6845, Australia.
W.H. Oddy is supported by a Population
Health Research Fellowship from the Na-
tional Health & Medical Research Council
besity is increasing worldwide among women in the reproductive ages.1-3
O Women who are obese have higher rates of amenorrhoea and infertility,4
higher risk of complications during pregnancy such as hypertension and
gestational diabetes, and delivery complications such as higher rates of cesarean
of Australia. The Raine Study is funded by
the National Health & Medical Research
Council of Australia, the Western Austra-
lian Health Promotion Foundation and the
Raine Study Foundation.
sections and prolonged delivery.3 In addition, their obesity may adversely affect the W.H. Oddy developed the hypothesis, un-
dertook statistical analyses, wrote the main
health of their child.5,6 Children of obese mothers have a higher risk for intrauterine drafts of the paper and is correspondent
fetal death, congenital abnormalities, head trauma, shoulder dystocia, fractures of the for this manuscript and requests for re-
clavicle,7 brachial plexus lesions, and increased risk of death within the first year of prints. J. Li contributed to writing of the
main draft, statistical analysis and result in-
life.8 Further, obese and overweight mothers breastfeed their infants less than normal terpretation. L. Landsborough was respon-
weight mothers.9 sible for the literature review and contrib-
uted to interpretation of the results. S.
Research on the determinants of breastfeeding demonstrates a negative association Henderson, G.E. Kendall, and J. Downie
between obesity and, to a lesser extent, overweight on the initiation and continuation of assisted with drafts of the manuscript and
breastfeeding.9-11 Three hypotheses have been proposed to explain this association. First, interpretation of the results.
Received for publication Sep 19, 2005; re-
obese women may have difficulties in initiating and maintaining breastfeeding because of turned for revision Feb 14, 2006; accepted
a different pattern of hormones compared with that of normal weight women.12,13 for publication Apr 4, 2006.
Second, the infants of obese and overweight women may have physical difficulty latching Reprint requests: Wendy Hazel Oddy,
PhD, MPH, BappSci, Telethon Institute for
on to the breast tissue.12 Third, the association between obesity, overweight, and breast- Child Health Research, PO Box 855, West
feeding is confounded by other factors that negatively affect the initiation and duration of Perth, Western Australia 6872, Australia.
E-mail: wendyo@ichr.uwa.edu.au.
breastfeeding, such as pregnancy and birth complications, cesarean section, poor self-
0022-3476/$ - see front matter
esteem and depression, and low socioeconomic status.14 Three major weaknesses of the
Copyright 2006 Mosby Inc. All rights
majority of previous studies include insufficient sample size, nonrandom sampling, and reserved.
lack of adjustment for a range of important covariates likely to confound the observed 10.1016/j.jpeds.2006.04.005
185
association between maternal obesity and duration of breastfeed- age at which other milk was introduced. The infants pre-
ing.12,15 Also, the point at which maternal body mass index dominant source of nourishment was breast milk but the
(BMI) affects breastfeeding duration was not established.2 infant may also have received water and water-based drinks,
Our study aims to overcome these limitations by using fruit juice, vitamin drops, and medicines. Predominant
data from the Western Australian Pregnancy Cohort Study,16,17 breastfeeding was expressed as a continuous variable (in
which provides a sufficient sample size for analysis and data on a months) and as binary variables described above. The mean
wide range of potential confounding factors. Our primary hy- age of introduction to solid foods was 4.35 months with a
pothesis was that maternal prepregnancy overweight and obesity standard deviation of 1.39 months. The age of solid food
has independent effects on breastfeeding duration. introduction ( 4 months) was included in all analyses.
The Association Of Maternal Overweight And Obesity With Breastfeeding Duration 187
Table I. Characteristics of the cohort*
Normal Pearson chi-square
Maternal weight category Total weight Overweight Obese (P value)
% (N)
100.0 (1803) 82.0 (1479) 11.7 (211) 6.3 (113)
Outcome variables
Never Breastfed 8.9 (160) 8.2 (122) 11.4 (24) 12.4 (14) ns
Breastfeeding 2 mo 26.2 (473) 24.0 (355) 33.6 (71) 41.6 (47) .0005
Breastfeeding 4 mo 40.5 (731) 37.9 (560) 50.2 (106) 57.5 (65) .0005
Breastfeeding 6 mo 51.1 (922) 49.0 (725) 59.7 (126) 62.8 (71) .001
Potential confounders
Gender (male) 52.5 (947) 52.5 (776) 54.0 (114) 50.4 (57) ns
Gestational age (37 wks) 7.5 (135) 7.0 (103) 12.3 (26) 5.3 (6) .014
Birth-weight 2500 g 94.8 (1709) 94.9 (1403) 93.4 (197) 96.5 (109) ns
2500 g 5.2 (94) 5.2 (76) 6.7 (14) 3.5 (4) ns
Any older siblings at birth 50.0 (901) 47.8 (707) 58.8 (124) 61.9 (70) .0005
Solids introduced before 4 mo 21.2 (378) 21.0 (307) 21.4 (45) 23.4 (26) ns
Lowest 25th centile SEIFA 19.6 (354) 18.3 (271) 22.7 (48) 31.0 (35) .002
Birth problems 44.5 (802) 45.0 (666) 39.8 (84) 46.0 (52) ns
Pregnancy problems 35.1 (633) 33.5 (495) 43.1 (91) 41.6 (47) .007
Elective or emergency caesarean 20.1 (362) 18.5 (273) 24.6 (52) 32.7 (37) .0005
Maternal age at birth (20 y) 6.2 (111) 6.3 (93) 4.7 (10) 7.1 (8) ns
Maternal race
Caucasian 85.9 (1549) 85.4 (1263) 86.7 (183) 91.2 (103) ns
Aboriginal 2.1 (38) 2.0 (30) 1.9 (4) 3.5 (4) ns
Other (usually Asian) 11.4 (216) 12.6 (186) 11.4 (24) 5.3 (6) ns
Maternal education ( year 12) 39.8 (717) 41.6 (616) 35.1 (74) 23.9 (27) .0005
Maternal marital status
Never married 9.5 (171) 9.3 (137) 7.6 (16) 15.9 (18) .035
Married 71.9 (1297) 71.3 (1055) 76.8 (162) 70.8 (80) ns
De facto 15.7 (283) 16.6 (245) 11.4 (24) 12.4 (14) ns
Separated/divorced/widowed 2.9 (52) 2.8 (42) 4.3 (9) 0.9 (1) ns
Maternal smoking in pregnancy 35.3 (637) 35.6 (527) 34.6 (73) 32.7 (37) ns
*Available for follow-up from birth N 2868 - N Given 1803 where all variables in all multivariate analyses are available
Body mass index (BMI) kg/m2; 25 normal weight; 2529.9 overweight; 30 obese.
The question asked was At what age did you stop breastfeeding? (months) and the results given are cumulative. Each level of breastfeeding is compared with all later times.
Socio-Economic Index for Area.
discontinued any breastfeeding at any time before 6 months time before 6 months following birth than women of normal
following birth compared with normal weight women (Table weight, following adjustment for confounders. Several of
II). The same pattern held true for overweight women, al- these confounding variables were significantly associated with
though to a lesser degree. When combined, both overweight an earlier cessation of breastfeeding. These included maternal
and obese mothers were more likely to have stopped breast- smoking during pregnancy (P .0005), maternal education
feeding at any time before 6 months than normal weight (P .0005), maternal age (P .001), and age solids were
women. The results for predominant breastfeeding were not introduced (P .0005). Less strongly associated with the
different compared to any breastfeeding; therefore, the results duration of breastfeeding was the protective association with
for the association of maternal overweight and obesity with presence of older siblings (P .001).
any breastfeeding are given. In a Cox regression model (Table III), adjusting for the
Table II also presents the results from stepwise logistic identified confounding variables (maternal education, mater-
analysis that adjusted for all possible confounding factors. The nal age, pregnancy problems, older siblings at birth, smoking
association between prepregnancy overweight and obesity during pregnancy, and solids introduced before 4 months),
with breastfeeding duration was strengthened following ad- maternal overweight and obesity (as a dichotomous variable
justment for these factors, although the association with ini- compared with normal weight mothers) remained a signifi-
tiation (never breastfed) was weakened. Overweight mothers cant risk factor for the cessation of any breastfeeding (odds
were more likely to discontinue breastfeeding before 2 months ratio [OR] 1.18; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.05, 1.34; P
than normal weight mothers, as were obese women. Overall, .007). The interpretation of this finding is that those women
the results suggest that women with overweight and obesity as who were overweight or obese compared with normal weight
a group were more likely to discontinue breastfeeding at any women had an 18% increased risk of stopping breastfeeding
Table III. Relation between breastfeeding and prepregnancy overweight or obesity in a multivariate Cox
proportional hazards regression model
Outcome Breastfeeding per Reference Hazard ratio* 95% confidence P
month (n 1803) category (adjusted) limits value
Exposure
Prepregnancy overweight or obese Yes 1.18 1.05, 1.34 .007
Maternal education 12 y 0.77 0.69, 0.85 .0005
Maternal age 20 y 1.27 1.03, 1.56 .023
Pregnancy problems Yes 1.09 0.99, 1.20 .082
Older siblings at birth Yes 0.86 0.78, 0.95 .003
Smoking in pregnancy Yes 1.26 1.13, 1.39 .0005
Solids before 4 mo Yes 1.53 1.36, 1.72 .0005
*Each hazard ratio adjusted for the effect of all other exposures in the table.
with each additional month of breastfeeding duration. A feeding duration at all time points up to 6 months following
Kaplan Meier survival analysis (Figure 1) demonstrates that birth.
mothers who were overweight or obese were more likely to The findings from our study agree with those of a
stop breastfeeding earlier than mothers who were of normal prospective Australian study that examined the perinatal ef-
weight (P .021). fects of maternal BMI.21 Despite adjusting for the effects of
mothers age, occupation, and time of first breastfeed, the
DISCUSSION findings from their study showed that higher maternal BMI
We have shown that independent of maternal socio- had a significant independent impact on breastfeeding cessa-
economic, demographic, and biomedical characteristics, ma- tion.
ternal prepregnancy overweight and obesity reduces breast- Dewey15 found that emergency cesarean section and
The Association Of Maternal Overweight And Obesity With Breastfeeding Duration 189
Rasmussen and Kjolhede13 provided some insights into
possible biological mechanisms. They hypothesized that a
reduced prolactin response to suckling and a higher-than-
normal level of progesterone concentration in the first week
after delivery might compromise early lactation. These au-
thors showed that overweight and obese women had a lower
prolactin response to suckling at day 7, but the concentration
of progesterone did not differ between normal weight and
overweight or obese women at either time point. The finding
that overweight or obese mothers have a lower prolactin
response to suckling suggests a biological basis for the asso-
ciation between prepregnant overweight and obesity and
breastfeeding duration. Because this study was based on just
40 mothers of term infants, larger studies are required to
establish the evidence for biological mechanisms that link
maternal BMI and breastfeeding duration.
A strength of our study was the ability to systematically
adjust for the possible confounding factors identified in the
literature, which included parity, maternal race, marital status,
maternal education, maternal age, the socioeconomic status of
the area (where the mother lived when the baby was born),
obstetric and pregnancy complications, smoking during preg-
nancy, age solids were introduced, a measure of baby blues,
Figure. Kaplan Meier survival analysis for age when breastfeeding birth weight, and gestational age. By such detailed adjust-
stopped, stratified by prepregnancy weight group (overweight and obese ment, we have established the point at which the negative
versus normal weight) (log rank statistic 5.37; df 1; P .021).
impact of obesity and overweight on breastfeeding duration
occurs and further established the independent link between
prolonged duration of labor were significantly associated with maternal body weight and breastfeeding duration.
delayed initiation of lactation with both factors more common A limitation of our study was that approximately 19% of
in overweight and obese women.14 In agreement with women did not answer the questionnaires in relation to
Deweys study, we showed that overweight or obese mothers breastfeeding and therefore these missing cases were excluded
were more likely to have emergency cesarean (elective and from analysis. The nonresponse was significantly correlated
assisted) than normal weight mothers (P .0005) and these with maternal socioeconomic factors, such as no secondary
were more common in obese mothers. education and teenage or single motherhood (P .001).
In our study, we observed a reduced incidence of breast- These factors may have biased our estimated effects in either
feeding initiation in overweight and obese women compared direction. Since obesity is prevalent in low socioeconomic
with normal weight women, which approached statistical groups, the nonresponse to the breastfeeding questions may
significance (P .057). Overweight and obese mothers at- also be significantly correlated to maternal overweight and
tempted to breastfeed but were less successful in continuing obesity. In fact, more mothers in our study who were over-
beyond the first weeks after birth. There is the possibility that weight or obese with education less than 12 years did stop
some overweight mothers made an effort to initiate breast- breastfeeding earlier at each time point (for example, by 2
feeding but were unsuccessful in the milk coming in. In fact, months 27% of overweight or obese mothers had stopped
there may be biological mechanisms that link maternal body breastfeeding compared with 18% of normal weight mothers;
weight to breastfeeding duration. For example, a difference in P .001). This result suggests a downward bias in the
steroid hormones connected to lactation has been observed,12 unadjusted results. The association between maternal over-
and infants of women with a high BMI may have a high weight and obesity and breastfeeding duration would have
demand for energy intake, are less satisfied with breast milk, been stronger if missing cases could be included but would
which in turn may lead to an early introduction of formula not have significantly affected the independent association
milk. Further, babies of obese women may have physical where maternal socioeconomic factors were taken into ac-
difficulty in latching on to the breast tissue or they may not be count.
able to grasp a large breast.12 One prospective study used the Several factors strengthen the confidence in our find-
mother-baby assessment tool developed by Mulford22 to as- ings. First, this is a prospective birth cohort study thus pro-
sess the babys sucking ability and attachment. This study viding precise data on antenatal factors such as smoking,
showed that sucking ability was not associated with breast- delivery mode, and birth and pregnancy complications. These
feeding but that women who were obese had an increased factors have been suggested as potential confounders that may
relative risk of discontinuing breastfeeding. account for the association between prepregnancy overweight
The Association Of Maternal Overweight And Obesity With Breastfeeding Duration 191