The following stones were documented by the Fauquier Historical Society following the vandalism of the

Warrenton Cemetery. Some were easily identifiable, while others were face down which made identification
impossible. Efforts were made to identify them based on Nancy Baird and Carol Jordans Fauquier County,
Virginia Tombstone Inscriptions book and imagery from FindAGrave. Names in italics are the believed
identities of the stones. If further identification is made we will update this list.
Name(s) on Damaged Stones Dates
James W. Butler 1855-1923
Mary Butler 1826-
William Burke 1884-1916
Carol Unger 1912-1987
William Strother 1849-1922
Mary White Strother 1852-1936
Ben A. Way (Louisville, KY) None listed
Mable Frost Burgess 1891-1892
Mary Louise Burgess 1885-1967
Horace Turner Burgess 1863-1943
Robert Augustus MacIntyre 1862-1952
Isaac Pennock At-Lee 1890-1938
William Keith Boswell Jr. 1915-
William Keith Boswell 1858-1923
Anna Leftwitch Witmer 1856-1941
T. Gamble Crawford 1860-1905
Eleze F. Henry Crawford Waesche 1867-1977
Constance Hordern Clark None listed
Christian Ross 1843-1913
Christina Ross 1844-1937
Charlie Ross 1881-1903
Fred A. Luke Sprat 1886-1965
Elizabeth Luke -1908
Frederick Arthur Berkley Portman 1867-1907
John Caspar Bartenstein 1883-1912
Eva Holmes Chamberlain Garnier 1876-1962
Helen A. Holmes 1842-1919
Samuel N. Chamberlain 1863-1934
Children of G.C. & L.C. Jolliffe
Marlboro Churchill Jolliffe 1882-1884
Kittie Jolliffe 1880-1884
John Smith 1797-1863
Annie Smith 1801-1881
Infants of John & Annie Smith None listed
George Sumner Smith 1849-1919
Rose Johnson Smith 1858-1931
Mary Keith Neill 1894-1974
Sally Marshall Jefferies 1891-1976

1
Janet Jefferies Reynolds 1898-1990
Enoch Marshall Jefferies 1856-1925
Mary Lovell Jefferies 1863-1948
Elizabeth Jefferies Smith 1888-1976
Susan Jefferies 1818-1890
Enoch Jefferies [CSA marker] 1818-1900
A.M. Brodie 1829-1915
Margaret Brodie 1808-1883
William G. Stepp 1823-1911
Susan Stepp 1819-1905
Rebecca Coke Helms 1886-1912
Charles William Smith 1856-1908
Loulie Sowers Jennings Smith 1849-1936
Francis Washington Jennings 1848-1880
Edmund Henry Hutton [American Legion marker] 1897-1935
Robert Edward Ferneyhough 1914-1936
Jessie Caldwell Walraven 1959-1946
Charles Caldwell 1866-1956
L. Bell Caldwell 1875-1959
William Hamilton Edwards 1875-1957
Helen Walraven 1888-1977
Jessie Walraven Welton 1890-1983
Clare Forsyth Wise 1874-1941
Ella M. Garrett 1843-1910
Mildred Elizabeth White 1849-1934
Agnes Martin Lake 1892-1976
Nellie Button Lake 1897-1946
Alfred M. Heflin 1839-1908
Anna Eliza Heflin 1809-1895
Anton Schwab [CSA marker] 1834-1906
Susan Schwab 1837-1936
John Clatterbuck [CSA marker] 1845-1925
Sarah Clatterbuck 1850-1935

The following graves are those that are difficult to identify.

Location
Obelisk in Bartenstein Family plot
A Holt cross beside George W. Nelson
A cross stone behind a Nelson marker with CSA
marker
A cross stone behind a Nelson marker
Stone beside Hugh Mortimer Nelson
Possible Identity of Gravestone
Thomas Engel Klipstein (1818-1960), Mary
Francis Hampton (1823-1900), Rosa Lee (1863)
Ford Holt (1910)
Reverend George Nelson (1840-1903)
Mary Scollay Nelson (1840-1903)
Mary Nelson Decker (1886-1977)

2
A Fletcher stone to the right of Albert Fletcher (1841) Sallie Withers (1850-1878)
and left of stone below
Fletcher stone to the left of Aunt Nish V.A. Fletcher Manly Fletcher (1873)
(1894)
Stone family obelisk Delia Elizabeth Stone (1908)
To the right of Stone family obelisk Emma G Stone (1883)
To the right of the previous stone (died 190-) Mary Gray Bronaugh (1826-1905)
To the right of the previous stone, left of Ella Stone John T. Bronaugh (1880)
(1829) [CSA Marker]
Stone to the right of Robert Edward Marrow (1988)
and left of Horace Turner Burgess, behind Lawrence
and Dora Hout
Stone beside Samuel C. and behind Gertrude & Mary
Wharton
A Burgess right of Currell Burgess and left of William Pittman Kincheloe
Elizabeth Burgess Kinchloe
Stone beside Ben A. Way and in front of John Webb Susan Throckmortan (Louisville, KY)
Tyler and May Way
Stone to left of Archie Carmichael Hart & Mamie Robert Allison Hart (1840-1909)
Covington [with CSA marker]
Stone to the left of the CSA stone, right of Walters, Isabel Lawson Hart (1843-1912)
below stone for Miles Taylor, Elizabeth Thornton,
Thomas Thornton Hart
Stone to right of Theodore Davisson & Sallie Rogers Julia E. Davisson Hening (1836-1959)
Davisson [JEH footstone]
Read stone (died 1909) to the left of Theodore Mary Read Davisson (1834-1909)
Davisson & Sallie Rogers Davisson
Stone beside Theodore Davisson & Sallie Rogers Dr. John Read (1825-1896)
Davisson, [CSA Marker] in front of stone
Stone to left of Read stone and right of S. Bettie Hugh Nathaniel Davisson (1841-1868)
[CSA Marker]
Stone to the right of James Davisson Chamberlain & Martha Rogers Sowers (1882)
Nannie Sowers
Stone to the right of stone beside Nannie Sowers Sue Ida Fisher (1841-1867)
Stone to the right of William Henry Risdon and left of Lucy Agnes Grant (1859-1919)
Molly Shirley
Stone to the left of Sowers family marker and behind Rose Johnson Smith (1858-1931)
stones for William Sumner, Mary F., J. Richard M.D,
and Catherine Sowers
Stone to the right of John Davenport Blackwell Frances Grayson Smith Blackwell (1848-1924)
Bendall family obelisk Virginius Oldner (1869-1900) Virginia Stone (1840-1927), Corporal Robert T.
is visible. Bendall (1833-1913), Lucy Lee (1867-1941)
A stone in front of Clark and beside Edmund Henry Margaret Ferneyhough (1890-1982)
Hutton

3
A stone in front of Clark and to the right of Edmund Elizabeth Kulp Hutton (1891-1990)
Henry Hutton
Stone to right of Mildred Elizabeth White and left of
G. Hugh Carter Jr.
Stone to the right of Virginia Carter (1907), in front Nelson W. Carter (1892-1918)
of Duncan Beverly Lake (1969)
Stone to the right of previous stone, in front Nellie Harvey L. Carter (1881-1962)
Button Lake (1946)
Stone to the right of Anna Eliza Heflin Joseph A. Schwab (1863-1886)
Stone to the left of James Cotton Corbin, right of William Alexander Corbin (1865-1940), Mattie
William Winston Schwab Leach (1869-1937)
Large Clatterbuck Family Marker
Stone to the left of Price G. and Ruth V. Clatterbuck, William H. Clatterbuck (1870-1910), Fannie B.
behind John M. and Sarah J. Clatterbuck Edwards (1870-1935)
Stone directly in front of Elisah Clatterbuck (1881-
1948) left of John Saunders and Thomas Saunders
Stone directly in front of Mary E. Clatterbuck (1882-
1960), left of Elisha Clatterbuck
Large Cropp Family Marker